20170224REVISED Staff Testimony Exhibits 103, 110, 113-117.pdf

Idaho Public Utilities Commission
P,0. Eox &1720, gobe, l0 83720-{nT 4 q
0tbr,Gmu
, C.ommlssioner
Rapcr, Commissioner
TO
RE
ErfiqSn&rson, Com missioner
. ,.. 1lrl'l:r \,.-t*'ir
February 24,2017
Commission Secretary
Parties of Record
Exhibit 103, ll0, ll3, ll4,l75,116,ll7
Case No. INT-G-16-02
Please find enclosed the Revised Exhibits 103, 110 and ll3-ll7 in INT-G-16-02. The following
are summaries of the revisions:
L Revised Exhibit No. 103 (2124117), updates Revised Exhibit No. 103 (2/8117), sponsored by Staff
witness Joe Terry. The earlier version of the exhibit did not properly account for ITCs in its
income tax calculation. The Company, in its original Application, made an effor in its treatment
of ITC by not amortizing it and by capturing the benefit in a single year. The Company corrected
this error through its Amended Response to Staff Production Request No. 178. Staff audited the
ITC amortization and accepted the Company's revision but did not include the effect of the
change in Revised Exhibit No. 103 (2l8ll7). The attached Revised Exhibit No. 103 (2/24117)
captures this change to Staff s proposed revenue requirement;
2. Revised Exhibit No. I 10 (02124117), sponsored by Staff witness Mike Morrison, updates original
Exhibit No. I l0 (l2l16l16) to reflect Staff witness Terry,'s updated revenue requirement; and
3. Revised Exhibits Nos. I13,114,115, I16, I l7 (all 2l24ll7), sponsored by Staff witness Bentley
Erdwurm, update the corresponding original exhibits to reflect revisions necessitated by Staff
witness Terry's final updated revenue requirement.
Specific details are provided in the enclosed Revised Exhibits 103, I l0 and 113-117.
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions regarding these changes.
Sincerely,
Z
Sean Costello
Enclosure
472 West Washington Street, Boise lD 83702
Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone]
cc
[Certificate of S ervice]
aa
:{a*aqolqn
xxqo:
)s:R*)s
Ee E..tE r -,ii;EEE3E;OE;FO
3853&E
(+€<c4
4
-t sr.=!a!
:EEEE
a
.i
)q
.qI
:t
i
a
i
:t
q(?
a
i
)!
q9
ir
i
s
i
*
q?
:l
{
t
q
Revised Exhibit No. 103
Case No. INT-G-16-02
J. Terry, Staff
02/24117
n
q
.,i
q
E
I
S
.a'
I
iE
O
..
.'
6t
"
riE
o_
=q
is
siE
eEE
;E
6o
$q
cici!
* 66o
SBBq
.i$G
o?o
s3E9-
I
Fd.i
F
8.
o-
N.s
q
F
G
G
e
oNo
tsd:aN- o,q
OO-6O?
'j6cir;ooio+NOFN-NE
N
Io-
.,i
ri
q
d
3
&
\
q
r.1
o6
8gs86e
@- .Y
F
E
s
^tEI8o-t c
9l-
.l=
sl5
t"
-t-o-t c
o-l !
t"
EEUP
EaiE
5EEo
tsz
6c
N- 6-
6o
8F
drtgo
o- o- N-
ooNt
6a6F6ooOhio?dotui;J
N-ro-O-Fa6.G @o PN
N
F-
N.
c,i
N
E
6\
oFoots-
FFOOI-lo6dN6
o-F--_o-F_q
8.
gr
o-
c9
OO-t6OiOOFtsO
ddN'aits..idot+6oO6OoF
i doi Jri
@-
6"
ci
il
6
@-
6'
o-@-
@- o-
rj6idd.i
g
P
6iiEE9.EEEO
o!FEc -EE 39@c Eb-9.9e<A.E(5.AeEbgEEEEE.
E€EEEE*czFooo@
H: gE
FEEssg
qo.
ogE&Eg E,'IB EEAdE EE9g& eEq8E!88=
q EE,9EEidEBEFE;EE.EEEBPaOUiOOOO
n666tt(
E
E s E€E*E !Es 4.EEEsHg.E i.:gi9EP
:ESEIPEEiI
$cIgEgiE$ERNRRSHHMSN
oil
s
6tsFOOFO@
rx**oooooN6+oorooNoNod+q-qdvitr
6; rjc;
e
-.u-nE*EE.EX!F?EEE-3U8.o=rE60
BFAEECOdCE:F
6
52
.,i ai88
s .'i
E
eec
6
EE Fq9 d
2<
8S@.q
E rg
=it B=
6'a
I:
B
PE5
5EE
EEb-6<
z
<.:al!
@
o
En
Ei
ET
o
3E,!383: sI oeE*;
3o
* EB-
o 9FEB65p
es Hd6
.B
EEB
E-3 E3Sdz<
6frd
=![
*iE5
i3
!
Z
66E
E
!-o
e
.s
6
5r
EOo
Normalized Test Year Revenue at Current Rates
Base Rate Gas Operating
Base Rate Fraction Revenue
510,953,290 0.128473 529,292,269
43,290,919 0.507768 738,209,206
20,158,015 0.000307 76,770,782
26,149 0.235438 97,025
1,891 0.000022 6,791
407,862 0.004784 2,852,315
833,7L3 0.009779 79t,L75
8,909,434 0.104501 8,364,283
675,936 0.007928 649,238
Staff Allocation of Revenue to Existing Classes
Test Year Ending December 3L,zOtG
Staff Allocation of Revenue to Proposed Classes
Test Year Ending December 31, 2016
Revenue Requirement
Class
RS-1
RS-2
IS-R
GS-1
ts-c
LV-1
T-3
r-4
T-5
Base Rate
511,622,935
45,937,573
27,748
2L,390,4O5
2,007
432,797
884,683
9,454,726
717,260
Total 585,257,209 1.000000 5256,962,485 s90,469,534
Revenue Requirement
Base Rate
s57,560,509
27,748
27,39O,4O5
2,O07
432,797
884,683
L0,77L,386
s90,469,534
Class
Normalized Test Year Revenue at Current Rates
Base Rate Gas Operating
Base Rate Fraction Revenue
554,244,209 0.636242 St67,q91,ql6
20,158,015 0.000307 75,770,182
26,L49 0.236438 97,025
1,891 0,000022 6,797
407,862 0.004784 2,852,3L5
833,713 0.009779 791,L75
9,585,370 0.772429 9,01.3,521
585,257,209 1.000000 5256,962,485
RS
IS-R
GS.1
IS.C
LV-1
T-3
T-4
Total
Notes:
L. Base rate revenues exclude PGA costs of gas.
2. 590,469,534 revenue requirement from Witness Terry's Exhibit 103.
3. Base Rate Revenue requirement obtained by multiplying Revenue Requirement
by Class Base Rate Fraction.
Revised Exhibit No. 1 l0
Case No. INT-G-16-02
M. Morrison, Staff
02/24117
RS-l Bill Comparison - Apr through Nov - Current v. Staff Proposed
Staff-
Proposed
Currentl Bill Bill
Excluding Excluding
cu rrentl Blll
Staff-
Proposed
Bill including
Gas Cost5 s.so
s 12.77s 2o.os
5 27.32S so.sos 34.s9
$ 47.87
s 49.14
$ so.qz
s 63.59s 70.95
5 78.24
5 s6.42
s 114.60
s 1s0.97
5 223.7L
s 296.44
s 369.18
S ss1.o2
s 732.86
Therms
0
10
20
30
35
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
125
150
200
300
400
500
750
1000
Gas Costs 2.s0
S s.67
S 8.84
s 12.00
s 13.s9
S 1s.17
s 18.34
s 21.51
5 24.67
5 27.84
s 31.01
s 34.18
s 42.10
s s0.02
s 6s.85
s 97.s3
S 129.2L
s 160.89
s 240.09
s 319.28
Gas CostS s.sos 7.21
S s.ss
s 10.64s 11.s0s 12.35s 14.07S rs.zgs 17.s0
5 L9.22
s 20.93
5 22.65S zo.ss
5 gt.zz
s 39.79
s s5.94
s 74.09
5 91.24
s 134.10
s 176.97
$ changeS s.oos 1.ss
S o.oss (1.36)s (2.0s)s (2.81)
5 @.27l,S (s.72)
s (7.17)
s (8.62)s (10.08)s (11.s3)s (1s.15)s (18.80)
s (26.05)
s (40.ss)
S (ss.12)
s (5s.66)
s (10s.e8)
s (142.31)
% Change
120%
27%
T%
-11%
-15%
-19%
-23%
-27%
-29%
-31%
-32%
-34%
-36%
-38%
-40%
-42%
-43%
-43%
-44%
-45%
lncluding
Gas Cost
2.50
Lt.23
19.95
28.68
33.04
37.47
45.13
54.86
53.59
72.3L
81.04
89.77
111.58
133.40
L77.03
264.30
351.57
438.84
557.00
875.t7
S changeS 3.oos 1.ss
S o.og
s (1.36)s (2.0e)
s (2.81)
5 (4.27l,
s (s.72)
5 0.17l,
S (8.62)
s (10.08)s (11.s3)
s (1s.15)
s (18.80)
s (25.06)
s (40.ss)s (ss.12)
s (6s.66)
s (1os.s8)
s (142.31)
% Change
L20%
L4%
o%
-5%
-6%
-8%
-9%
-to%
-LI%
-L2%
-t2%
-13%
-t4%
-14%
-t5%
-t5%
-t6%
-76%
-76%
-16%
', S,, s
.l S
.li.l S
::S.S
r.Srrt Sta,, St. s
,,S
'.t S
,a: st,,t 5..s
., S,. S'tsi:. S'$
RS-1 Bill Comparison - Dec through Mar - Current v. Staff Proposed
Staff-
Proposed
Current Bill Bill
Excluding Excluding
Therms
0
10
20
30
35
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
L25
150
200
300
400
500
750
1000
Gas Costs 5.s0
S 8.s4
s 10.s8
s 12.63
s 13.6s
5 14.67
s 16.71
s 18.7s
s 20.80
5 22.84
s 24,88
s 26.92
s 32.03
s 37.13
5 47.34
5 67.77
s 88.1es 108.61
s 1s9.67
s 2L0.72
Gas Cost SS s.so $
5 7.2t Ss e.se ss 10.64 ss 11.s0 ss rz.s6 ss 14.07 ss 1s.7s ss 17.s0 ss 79.22 ss 20,s3 ss 22.6s ss 26.s3 s5 31.22 5s sg.zg sS s5.94 Ss 74.0e ss s1.24 ss 134.10 s
5 L76.s7 S
% Change
-15%
-L6%
-16%
-16%
-76%
-76%
-76%
-76%
-L6%
-L6%
-L6%
-L6%
-16%
-t6%
-16%
-t6%
-L6%
-t6%
-t6%
-16%
Current Bill
lncluding
Gas CostS s.sos 14.10
5 2t.70
S 2e.30
S gs.ro
s 36.90
s 44.s1S sz.rrs s9.71s 67.31s 74.91
s 82.s1s 101.s1s 120.s2s 1s8.s2
s 234.s3s 310.s4s 385.s5
S szs.ss
5 766.67
Staff-
Proposed
Bill including
Gas CostS s.so
5 t2.77S zo.os
5 zt.szs 30.96S sa.sg
S 41.87
s 49.14S so.+z
s 63.59
s 70.96
5 78.24
s 96.42
s 114.60
s 1s0.97
5 223.71
5 296.44
s 369.18
s ss1.02
5 732.86
$ changes (1.00)s (1.33)
s (1.66)
s (1.s8)
s (2.is)s (2.31)s (2.64)
5 Q.s7ls (3.2s)
S (3.62)
$ (3.ss)
5 {.4.27l,s (s.oe)S (s.sr)s (7.ss)
s (10.83)
s (14.10)
s (17.37)
s (2s.s6)
s (33.7s)
Change % Change
-t5%
-9%
-8%
_7%
-6%
-6%
-6%
-6%
-6%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-5%
_4%
_4%
_4%
Revised Exhibit No. I 13
Case No. INT-G-16-02
B. Erdwurm, Staff
02t24/17
(1.00)
(1.33)
(1.55)
(1.e8)
(2.1s)
(2.31)
12.641
12.s7l
(3.2e)
(3.52)
(3.ss)
(4.28)
(s.0e)
(s.s1)
(7.ss)
(10.83)
(14.10)
(17.38)
(2s.s6)
(33.7s)
Note 1: Based on Gas Costs in Company's Application
RS-2 Bill Comparison - Apr through Nov - Current v. Staff Proposed
Staff-
Proposed
currentl Bill Bill
Excluding Excluding
Therms
0
10
20
30
35
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
725
150
200
300
400
500
750
1000
Gas CostS z.so
5 4.465 o.qzS a.saS s.se
S 10.34S rz.so
s 14.265 L6.22
S rs.rg
S 20.L4
5 22.10
s 27.00S sr.so
s 41.70
s 51.30
s 80.90s 100.s0
s 149.s0
s 198.s0
Gas Costs s.so
5 7.2L
s 8.s3
s 10.54
s 11.s0
s 12.36
s 14.07
s 1s.79
s 17.s0
s L9.22
S zo.g:
s 22.6s
s 26.s3
5 3t.22s 3s.7s
S s6.94
s 74.09
S 91.24
s 134.10
5 L76.97
ange
3.00
2.75
2.5L
2.26
2.14
2.02
t.77
1.53
r.28
1.04
0.79
0.55
(0.07)
(0.68)
(1.s 1)
(4.35)
(6.81)
(e.27l.
(1s.40)
(21.s3)
% Change
L20%
62%
39%
27%
23%
20%
t4%
Lt%
8%
6%
4%
2%
o%
-2%
-5%
_7%
-8%
-9%
-10%
-7L%
currentl Bill
lncluding
Gas Cost
2.50
9.62
16.74
23.86
27.4L
30.97
38.09
45.2t
s2.33
59.45
66.57
73.69
91.48
109.28
L44.87
216.05
287.24
3s8.43
536.39
714.35
Staff-
Proposed
Bill including
Gas CostS s.so
5 12.37s 19.2s
5 26.t2s 29.s6s 32.99S ss.ez
s 46.74$ ss.srs 60.49
s 67.35
5 74.23
S 91.42
s 108.60
s L42.96
5 2L1.70
s 280.43
5 349.16
s s20.99
s 592.82
3.00
2.75
2.51
2.26
2.14
2.02
7.77
1.53
1.28
L.04
0.79
0.55
(0.07)
(0.68)
(1.e1)
(4.36)
(6.81)
(s.27)
(1s.40)
(21.s3)
% Change
120%
29%
t5%
9%
8%
7%
5%
3%
ao/z/o
2%
L%
t%
o%
_7%
-7%
-2%
10/'z /o
-3%
-3%
-3%
S Cft
s
s
S
s
s
s
s
5
S
s
S
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
ChangeS
s
s
s
s
S
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
',. s,S
l, S
',, S
S.s', s.l s
l,i' sl. S.
5.,;, s., s,., S;.
S
s
s
s
s,s s
s
RS-2 Bill Comparison - Dec through Mar - Current v. Staff Proposed
Staff-
Proposed
Current Bill Bill
Excluding Excluding
Staff-
Current Bill Proposed
lncluding Billincluding
Gas CostS s.sos 12.37s 19.2s
5 26.72s 29.s5
5 32.99
s 39.87
5 46.74
s s3.61
s 60.49
s 67.36
5 74.23
s 91.42
s 108.50
s 142.96
s 211.70
s 280.43
5 349,16
s s20.99
5 692.82
% Change
-15%
-7%
-4%
-3%
-2%
_2%
-7%
-t%
-7%
0%
o%
0%
0%
0%
t%
7%
7%
1%
t%
t%
Revised Exhibit No. I l4
Case No. INT-G-16-02
B. Erdwurm, Staff
02124117
Therms
0
10
20
30
35
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
125
150
200
300
400
500
750
1000
Gas Costs 5.soS s.rzS s.zs
s 11.37
S 12.18
s 12.99
s 14.62
s 16.24
5 t7.87
s 19.49
s 21.11
5 22.74
s 26.80
s 30.86
S 38.97
s ss.21
s 71.4s
S az.og
s 128.28
s 168.87
Gas CostS s.so
5 7.2Ls 8.s3
s 10.64s 11.s0s 12.36
5 t4.07
s 1s.79
s 17.s0
s 19.22
s 20.93
5 22.6s
s 26.93
s 31..22s 39.79
s s6.94
s 74.09
5 91.24
s 134.10
5 L76.97
nge
(1.00)
(0.s1)
(0.82)
(0.73)
(0.68)
(0.64)
(0.s4)
(0.4s)
(0.36)
10.271
(0.18)
(o.os)
0.14
0.37
0.82
1.73
2.64
3.55
s.83
8.10
% Change
-L5%
-Lt%
-8%
-6%
-6%
_5%
_4%
-3%
-2%
-L%
-L%
0%
L%
t%
2%
3%
4%
4%
5%
5%
Gas Cost
6.50
13.28
20.06
26.85
30.24
33.63
40.47
47.19
53.98
60.76
67.54
74.32
91.28
108.23
L42.t4
209.97
277.79
345.61
515.17
684.72
S changes (1.00)S (0.e1)
5 (0.82)
s (0.73)
S (0.68)
S (0.64)s (o.ss)
S (0.4s)
s (0.36)
S (0.27)
s (0.18)s (o.oe)S o.r+S o.se
S 0.82
s 1.73
5 2.64S s.ss
S s.82
S 8.10
$ Cha
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
S
s
s
S
S
s
s
s
.t; s,iS;ii S:.,, S
s
'.rl sr;S,'S
,,S:S
s
s
s
S
s
'S,s
::, s,,i, s:i' s
Note 1: Based on Gas Costs in Company's Application
General Service Bill Comparison - Apr through Nov - Current v. Staff Proposed
Therms
currentl Bill
Exclu ding
Gas CostS z.oo
5 7.44
s 12.88
s 18.31
s 23.7sS :+.oss 4s.s0S ss.zgS os.osS a+.oo
5 104.24
s 1s3.18
s 202.13
s 48s.29
5 922.L9
s 1,3s9.09
s 1,79s.99
s 3,s43.s9
S s,zgr.rs
s 7,038.79
Staff-
Proposed
Bill
Excluding
Gas Costs e.so
s 14.06
S 18.61
5 23.L7
5 27.72S so.ss
S 4s.94s s3.89s 61.84
5 77.73
s 93.63
s 133.36
s 173.10
s 400.30
s 747.s2
s 1,082.7s
5 L,423.97
s 2,423.97
s 3,423.97
5 4,423.97
S changes 7.s0
5 6.62s s.74s 4.8ss 3.97S z.ztS o.q+s (1.40)
s (3.24)
s (6.s3)
s (10.61)s (1s.82)s (2s.02)s (84,se)
s (180.66)
5 Q76.341s (372.01)
s (1,11s.61)
s (1,867.21)
s (2,614.81)
% Change
375%
89%
45%
26%
L7%
6%
L%
-3%
-5%
-8%
-ro%
-L3%
-t4%
-18%
-20%
-20%
-2t%
-32%
-35%
-37%
currentl Bill
lncluding Gas
CostS z.oo
5 20.23
s 38.46
S so.ogS 74.92
s 111.38
5 147.84
s 183.21
s 218.s8
S 289.33S 360.07s s36.93
s 713.80
5 1,764.46
s 3,480.s4
s s,195.51
s 6,912.69
5 13,776.99
s 20,64L.29
s 27,s0s.s9
Staff-
Proposed Bill
including Gas
Cost
S s.so
s 26.8s
s 44.19
s 61.s4
s 78.89
s 113.58
s 148.28
s 181.81
s 21s.34
5 282.40s 349.45
5 stt.tz
s 684.77
5 t,679.47
s 3,299.87
5 4,920.27
S 6,s40.67
$ t2,6s7.37
5 18,774.07
5 24,890.77
S changes 7.s0S s.ozS s.zss 4.8ss 3.s7S z.zoS o.+a5 (1.a0)
S (3.24)s (6.s3)s (10.61)
s (1s.82)
s (2s,02)
s (84.ss)
s (180.55)
5 (276.34)
s (372.01)
s (1,11s.61)
5 (1,867.21)
s (2,614.81)
% Change
375%
33%
L5%
9%
5%
2%
0%
_L%
-L%
_2%
-3%
_4%
-4%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-5%
-8%
-9%
-10%
0
25
s0
75
100
150
200
250
300
400
500
750
1000
2500
s000
7s00
10000
20000
30000
40000
General Service Bill Comparison - Dec through Mar - Current v. Staff Proposed
Therms
Current Bill
Excluding
Gas Costs e.so
S 13.67
S 17.83
s 22.00
5 26.t7s 34.s0s 42.83S so.rrS sz.se5 tt.gzS ao.azs 722.84S r.s9.2o
s 367.16
S ozg.e eS sgz.ro
s 1,304.65
5 2,ss4.66
s 3,804.66
s s,0s4.66
Current Bill
lncluding Gas
CostS s.so
5 26.46
s 43.42
s 50.37
s 77.33
s 111.2s
s 14s.17
s 178.02
s 210.88
5 276.59
s 342.31
S soo.sg
S oto.st
s 1,546.34
s 3,238.01
s 4,829.59
S o,+zr.ss
s 12,788.06
s 19,154.76
s 2s,s2L.46
Staff-
Proposed Bill
including Gas
Cost
S s.so
s 25.8s
s 44.19
S 61.s4
s 78.89
s 113.s8
s 148.28
s 181.81
s 21s.34
s 282.40
s 349.46S srz.rz
5 684.77
s 1,679.47
s 3,299.87
5 4,920.27
s 5,s40.57
5 L2,6s7.37
5 18,774.07
$ 24,890.77
S Change
sS o.sgS o.zs5 t.tts 1.sss 2.33S s.rrS s.zes 4.46s s.81s 7.15s 10.s3s 13.e0
s 33.14
s 61.86s 90.s9
s 119.31s (130.6e)
s (380.6s)s (530.6s)
Staff-
Proposed
Bill
Excluding
Gas Cost S cs s.so ss 14.06 ss 18.61 s
5 23.L7 Ss 27.72 ss 35.83 ss 4s.e4 ss s3.8s s
S 61.84 Ss 77.73 ss sg.6s ss 133.36 ss 173.10 ss 400.30 s5 74L.s2 S
s 1,082.75 s
5 1,423.97 S
$ 2,423.97 s
s 3,423.97 s
5 4,423.97 S
hange % Change % Change
o%
L%
2%
2%
2%
2%
2%
ao/z/o
ao/z/o
2%
2%
2%
2%
2%
aolz/o
2%
2%
-t%
-2%
-2%
Revised Exhibit No. I l5
Case No. INT-G-16-02
B. Erdwurm, Staff
02t241t7
0
25
50
75
100
150
200
250
300
400
s00
750
1000
2500
s000
7500
10000
20000
30000
40000
0.39
0.78
t.t7
1.56
2.33
3.11
3.78
4.46
5.81
7.L6
10.53
13.90
33.14
61.86
90.59
119.31
(130.6s)
(380.6s)
(630.6s)
0%
3%
4%
5%
6%
7%
7%
8%
8%
8%
8%
9%
9%
9%
9%
9%
9%
-5%
-10%
-72%
Note 1: Based on Gas Costs in Company's Application
Proof of Revenue
Line No
Billing
DeterminatesClass
RS-1
Annual Bills
Therms
Total
RS-2
Annual Bills
Therms
Total
Annual Bills
Therms
Total
GS-1.
Annual Bills
Rate
ss.so
50.77t47
ss.s0
50.L7t47
ss.so
so.L7L47
s0.043s6
s0.01733
s0.00408
Revenue
1
2
3
4
5
5
7
8
2L
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
807,488
32,972,374
2,893,307
184,003,6s8
1,008
L37,397
31,992,665
52,346,235
26,785,787
54,44r,L84
ss,6s3,763
s10,0s4e47
s15,913,189
s31,LOl551,
9
10
11
12
ts-R
s47,464,296
ss,s44
s23,sss
13
14
15
16
\7
18
19
20
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
385,791 ss.s0
0.t822t
0.15895
0.13649
0.10000
770,524,687
702 S9.so
0.L8221,
0.15895
0.13649
0.10000
15,010
2t7 No Charge
450,360 s0.20000
5959
$t,077
s1,08s
s447
So
Sz,eog
S3,s78
ieo,o72
s275,193
s35s,26s
Revised Exhibit No. I l6
Case No.INT-G-16-02
B. Erdwurm, Staff
02/24/17 Page I of 2
s29,103
s3,55s,01s
ss,829,383
s8,320,434
S3,s74,098
SO
Therms - Tier 1
Therms - Tier 2
Therms - Tier 3
Therms - Tier 4
Total Therms
Total
Annual Bills
Therms - Tier 1
Therms - Tier 2
Therms - Tier 3
Therms - Tier 4
Total Therms
Total
Annual Bills
MDFQ
Therms - Tier 1
Therms - Tier 2
Therms - Tier 3
Total Therms
Total
s
517,723,916
21,388,930
rs-c
LV-1
5,911
6,823
3,276
6,317,560
0
s275,L93
So
So
6,317,560
Line No.
40
4L
42
43
44
45
46
47
Proof of Revenue (cont.)
Class
T-3
Annual Bills
Therms - Tier 1
Therms - Tier 2
Therms - Tier 3
Total Therms
Total
T-4
Annual Bills
MDFQl
Therms - Tier 1
Therms - Tier 2
Therms - Tier 3
Total Therms
Overrun
Total
T-5
Annual Bills
MDFQl
Therms - Tier 1
Therms - Tier 2
Therms - Tier 3
Total Therms
Total
Total (excludes Gas Costs)
Billing
Determinates Rate
72 No Charge
Revenue
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
58
69
70
44,776,25L
7to,747,535
85,960,750
67,928,377
8,308,080
3,4L9,023
33,049,148
s0.01897
50.00772
s0.0028s
s0.04948
50.0L747
so.0os37
No Charge
So.zo
s0.04948
50.0t747
so.oo537
1,t49 No Charge
L4,66L,480 So.2o
s1s7,604
s25,39s
s94,190
s278,189
s278,189
52,932,296
5s,479,788
s1,s01,734
5364,775
s7,346,298
510,278,s94
s131,954
s32s,343
s87,s2o
s21,8s8
s434,72L
s566,585
S90,489,587
Revised Exhibit No. 116
Case No. INT-G-16-02
B. Erdwurm, Staff
02/24117 Page2 of 2
264,636,672
4,L20,808
659,820
6,575,248
5,009,713
4,070,392
15,655,352
Residential & General Service Rates - Current & Staff Proposed
Company
Current Proposed Staff Proposed
Current to Staff
Change
Current to Staff %
Change
Residential RS-1
Customer Charge
Apr-Nov (8 months)
Dec-Mar (4 months)
Weighted Avg
Commodity Charge
Apr-Nov (8 months)
Dec-Mar (4 months)
Residential RS-2
Customer Charge
Apr-Nov (8 months)
Dec-Mar (4 months)
Weighted Avg
Commodity Charge
Apr-Nov (8 months)
Dec-Mar (4 months)
General Service GS-1
Customer Charge
Apr-Nov (8 months)
Dec-Mar (4 months)
Weighted Avg
Commodity Charge
Apr-Nov (8 months)
1st block
2nd block
3rd block
4th block
Dec-Mar (4 months)
1st block
2nd block
3rd block
4th block
Sz.so
Ss.so
Ss.as
s0.31678
50.20422
Sz.so
Se.so
s3.83
50.19600
s0.16237
Sz.oo
Sg.so
54.so
50,2t7st
S0.19s78
50.17476
N/A
s0.16556
S0.14546
s0.12s00
N/A
s10.00
S1o.oo
s10.00
S0.1126s
s0.1126s
s10.00
s10.00
s10.00
s0.1126s
s0.1126s
S3s.oo
s3s.00
S3s.oo
S0.11076
s0,0s662
s0.08297
s0.07s00
S0.11076
s0.09662
s0.08297
s0.07s00
Ss.so
Ss.so
Ss.so
50.t7147
50.17147
Ss.so
Ss.so
Ss.so
50.t7t47
50.!7!47
Ss.so
Sg.so
59.s0
50,t822t
s0.1s89s
S0.13649
s0.10000
s0.1822 1
So.1s89s
s0.13649
s0.10000
(So.r+sar1
(So.oszzsl
53.oo
(S1.oo)
Sr.oz
Ss.oo
(s1.00)
S1.67
r20%
-75%
43o/o
-46%
-L6%
720%
43%
375%
0%
Ttto/o
-L6%
-L9%
-22%
N/A
9%
9%
9%
N/A
Revised Exhibit No. I 17
Case No. INT-G-16-02
B. Erdwurm, Staff
02124117
t5%
(So.oz+sa1
So.oogro
S7.so
So.oo
Ss.oo
(So.o3s3o)
(S0.03683)
(So.osazzl
N/A
s0,01sss
S0.01349
So.ou49
N/A
13%
6%
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE THIS 24TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2017,
SERVED THE FOREGOING REVISED EXHIBITS OF THE COMMISSION STAFF,
IN CASE NO. INT-G-16-02, BY MAILING A COPY THEREOF, POSTAGE PREPAID,
TO THE FOLLOWING:
MICHAEL P McGRATH
DIR _ REGULATORY AFFAIRS
INTERMOLINTAIN GAS CO
PO BOX 7608
BOISE ID 83707
E-MAIL: [e-mail]
BRAD M PURDY
ATTORNEY AT LAW
2OI9 N 17TH STREET
BOISE TD 83702
E-MAIL: [e-mail]
CHAD M STOKES
TOMMY A BROOKS
CABLE HUSTON LLP
1OO1 SW 5TH AVE STE 2OOO
PORTLAND OR 97204-1136
E-MAIL: [e-mail]
tbrooks@cablehuston. com
BENJAMIN J OTTO
ID CONSERVATION LEAGUE
710 N 6TH STREET
BOISE ID 83702
E-MAIL: [e-mail]
RONALD L WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS BRADBURY
1015 W HAYS ST
BOISE ID 83702
E-MAIL : [e-mail]
EDWARD A FINKLEA
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
NW INDUSTzuAL GAS USERS
545 GRANDVIEW DR
ASHLAND OR 87520
E-MAIL: [e-mail]
ELECTRONIC ONLY
MICHAEL C CREAMER
GIVENS PURSLEY LLP
E-MAIL: mcc@ givenspursley.com
F DIEGO RIVAS
NW ENERGY COALITION
1101 STHAVENUE
HELENA MT 59601
E-MAIL: [e-mail]
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
PETER RICHARDSON
GREGORY M ADAMS
RICHARDSON ADAMS PLLC
5I5 N 27TH STREET
BOISE ID 83702
E-MAIL : [e-mail]
gre g@richardsonadams. com
KEN MILLER
SNAKE zuVER ALLIANCE
PO BOX 1731
BOISE ID 83701
E-MAIL : [e-mail]
LANNY L ZIEMAN
NATALIE A CEPAK
THOMAS A JERNIGAN
EBONY M PAYTON
AFLOA/JA-ULFSC
I39 BARNES DR STE I
TYNDALL AFB FL 32403
E-MAIL: lannv.zieman. I @us.af.mil
Natalie. cepak.2 @us. af.mil
Thomas j erni gan. 3 @us. af.mil
Ebony. payton. ctr@us. af.mil
SCOTT DALE BLICKENSTAFF
AMALGAMATED SUGAR CO LLC
195I S SATURN WAY
STE 1OO
BOISE ID 83709
E-MAIL : [e-mail]
ANDREW J UNSICKER MAJ USAF
AFLOA/JACE-ULFSC
139 BARNES DR STE I
TYNDALL AFB FL 32403
E-MAIL : Andrew. [e-mail]
u,4/*,^secnrrAni/
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE