20110222XRG Answer to PAC Motions, and its own Motion.pdf

¡:: tt"~,, ';~.QJ~ATTORNEYS AT LAW
Tel: [phone] Fax: [phone]
P.O. Box 7218 Boise, JD 83707 - 515 N. 27th St. Boise, JD 83702
1un fEB 22 PM 2: 41
Februar 22,2011
Ms. Jean Jewell
Commission Secreta
Idaho Public Utilities Commssion
472 W. Washington
Boise, ID 83702
RE: PAC-E-10-08
Dear Ms. Jewell:
We are enclosing an original and seven (7) copies of the XRG LLCs' ANSWER IN
OPPOSITION TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE
ORDER TO STAY DISCOVERY AND MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT and
XRG LLCs' MOTION TO COMPLETE DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 56(t),
as well as the exhibits thereto, in the above-referenced case.
A copy is also enclosed for your staping and retur to our office.
I" rebLre ry M. Adams
chardson & O'Lear PLLC
Enc: XRG LLCs' 2-22-11 Filing
Peter J. Richardson
Gregory M. Adams
Richardson & O'Lear, PLLC
515 N. 27th Street
P.O. Box 7218
Boise, Idaho 83702
Telephone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
peter(frichardsonandoleary.com
greg(frichardsonandolear .com
R:ECE
ZOIl FEB 22 PM 2: 41
Attorneys for Complainants XRG-DP-7, XRG-DP-8, XRG-DP-9, XRG-DP-I0, LLCs
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
XRG-DP-7, XRG-DP-8, XRG-DP-9, XRG-DP- )10, LLCs, )Complainants, )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
vs.
PACIFICORP, DBA ROCKY MOUNTAIN
POWER,
Defendant.
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
XRGLLCs' ANSWER IN
OPPOSITION TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION
FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER TO STAY
DISCOVERY AND MOTION FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT,
AND XRG LLCs' MOTION TO
COMPLETE DISCOVERY
PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 56(t)
Comes now XRG-DP-7, XRG-DP-8, XRG-DP-9, XRG-DP-lO, LLCs (referred to
collectively as "XRG" or "Exergy"), and pursuat to pursuant to Idaho Administrative Rules
("IDAPA") 31.01.01.57.03 and 31.01.01.256.04, fies ths Answer to Rocky Mountan Power's
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 1
Motion for Protective Order to Stay Discovery and Motion for Sumar Judgment. i XRG
remains committed to entering into a power purchase agreement for each of its 4 wind projects
near Malta, Idaho. XRG has attempted to settle this dispute in good faith to no avaiL. XRG has
diligently responded to Rocky Mounta Power's Production Request Nos. 1 to 50. XRG has
already granted Rocky Mountan Power a 14-day extension to respond to XRG's Production
Requests Nos. 24 to 63, each of which pertin to the highly relevant issue of Rocky Mountan
Power's bad faith negotiations. F or all of these reasons and more, XRG opposes Rocky
Mountain Power's motions, and respectfully requests that the Idaho Public Utilities Commission
("Commission") deny Rocky Mountan Power's motions. XRG alternatively moves the
Commission, pursuat to Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure ("I.R.C.P.") 56(t), to require Rocky
Mountain Power to respond to all pending discovery requests prior to the time XRG must
provide a final response to any motion for sumary judgment.
LEGAL AND REGULATORY BACKGROUND
A. PURP A's Mandatory Purchase Provisions
The mandatory purchase provisions of PURP A require electrc utilities to purchase power
produced by cogenerators or small power producers that obtain status as a "qualifying facilty"
("QF"). 16 U.S.C. § 824a-3(a)(2). Congress's intent "was to encourage the promotion and
development of renewable energy technologies as alternatives to fossil fuels and the constrction
of new generating facilities by electric utilities." Rosebud Enterprises, Inc. v. Idaho Pub. Uti!.
Commn., 128 Idaho 609,613,917 P.2d 766, 780 (1996).
Because the foureenth day afer Rocky Mountain Power's Februar 7, 2011 motions was
the President's Day Holiday, XRG's filing is timely on the fifteenth day, Februar 22,2011. See
IDAPA 31.01.01.17; IDAPA 31.01.01.57.03 and 31.01.01.256.04.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 2
Under Federal Energy Regulatory Commission ("FERC") regulations, the price PURP A
section 21O(b) requires the utilities to pay to QFs in exchange for a QF's electrical output is
termed the avoided cost rate, which must compensate QFs for the utilities' full avoided cost and
not discriminate against QFs. 16 U.S.C. § 824a-3(b), (d); 18 C.F.R. § 292.304(a), (b); see also
Small Power Production and Cogeneration Faci!ities; Regulations Implementing Section 210 of
the Public Utilty Regulatory Policy Act of 1978, 45 Fed. Reg. 12,214, 12,222-12,223 (Feb. 25,
1980). With regard to off-system QFs, "Any electric utility to which such energy or capacity is
delivered must purchase this energy under the obligations set fort in these rues as if the
purchase were made directly from the qualifying facility." 45 Fed. Reg. at 12,220, codifing 18
C.F.R. § 292.303(a)(2).
QFs may select the "avoided costs calculated at the time the obligation (to provide energy
or capacity) is incured." 18 C.F.R. § 292.304(d)(2)(ii). "Whle this may be done through
contract, if the electric utility refuses to sign a contract, the QF may seek state regulatory
authority assistance to enforce the PURP A-imposed obligation on the electrc utilty to purchase
from the QF, and a non-contractual, but stil legally enforceable, obligation will be created
pursuat to the state's implementation of PURPA." JD Wind 1, LLC, "Notice of Intent Not to
Act and Declaratory Order," 129 FERC ~ 61,148, at ~ 25 (November 19,2009).
The Idaho Commission requies utilties in Idaho to make the rates in the published rate
schedule available to QFs that generate less than 10 average megawatts ("aMW"). See US.
Geothermal, Inc. v. Idaho Power Company, Case No. IPC-E-04-8, Order No. 29632, p. 14; 18
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 3
C.F.R. § 292.304(c)(1)-(3).2 When the published rates chage before the QF can obta an
executed contract, the QF is entitled to grandfathered rates if it can "demonstrate that 'but for' the
actions of (the utility, the QF) was otherwse entitled to a power purchase contract." Earth
Power Resources, Inc. v. Washington Water Power Company, Case No. WWP-E-96-6, Order
No. 27231 (1997); see also Blind Canyon Aquaranch v. Idaho Power Company, Case No. IPC-
E-94-1, Order No. 25802 (1994); Snow Mountain Pine v. Maudin, 84 Or. App. 590, 600, 734
P.2d 1366, 1371 (1987).
B. Federal Power Act and FERC's Open Access Transmission Tariff
"Section 205 of the Federal Power Act () prohibits public utilities, with respect to any
jursdictional transmission or sale, from granting an undue preference or subjecting any person to
any undue disadvantage." In Re Portland General Electric Company, 131 FERC ~ 61,224, ~ 8
(June 4, 2010). "FERC acted upon evidence of pervasive discrimination in the transmission of
electric power by completing a massive regulatory revision, culminating in Order No. 888."
Entergy Service, Inc. v. FERC, 375 F.3d 1204, 1205-06 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (citing 16 U.S.C. §§
824(b), 824d and 824e). FERC promulgated "a pro forma Open Access Transmission Tariff
('OATT') that includes the minimum terms and conditions under which transmission providers
may offer service." Id at 1206.
"Par II of the OATT, is transmission service from a specified point of receipt to a
specified point of delivery," and FERC requires utilities to use Par II to serve their own
wholesale and/or unbundled retal load. Id (citing 18 C.F.R. § 35.28(c)(2)). In contrast, "Par
2 As explained below, the Commission reduced the eligibility cap for published rates to
1 00 kilowatts for wind QFs since the time that XRG filed its Complaint in ths case.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMAY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 4
III of the OATT, is a flexible service, which allows the transmission provider to servce a
network customer's load by using multiple receipt and delivery points," and FERC allows
utilities to use Par III (as a network customer) to serve bundled retail loads. Id Thus, FERC
required the utilities themselves to become transmission customers and comply with the terms of
the OATT. To overcome the inerent "incentive to reserve certain capacity simply to prevent
everyone else from using it," FERC "required a network transmission customer (including a
utilty), as a prerequisite to obtaining network transmission service, to designate those 'network
resources' that would generate the power to be transmitted over the reserved capacity." Id at
1207 (internal quotations and alterations omitted). FERC also adopted standards of conduct for
transmission providers. See 18 C.F.R. § 358.5(b)(1) (prohibiting market fuction employees
from conducting transmission fuctions or having access to the system control center); id. at §
358.6 (prohibiting anyone from being a "conduit" of non-public transmission information
between the transmission and merchant fuctions).3
3 Other protections against discrimination include that a transmission provider must
accurately post available transmission capacity on its Open Access Same-time Information
System website. 18 C.F.R. § 37.6(b)(3)(ii)(A); see also In Re Portland General Electric
Company, 131 FERC ~ 61,224, ~~ 12,17 (approving stipulation to fines for inaccurate posting).
And a utilty may not withold the availability of planed transmission lines from open access to
all users solely on account of the utilty's own future plans to use the lines. See Puget Sound
Energy, Inc., 133 FERC ~ 61,160, ~~ 7, 10 (November 18,2010).
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 5
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURA BACKGROUND4
A. XRG's fruitless attempts to obtain 4 PPAs prior to tlling the Complaint
The Complaint in ths case arose from Rocky Mountain Power's conduct which stalled
XRG's development of 4 off-system wind generation facilties near Malta, Idaho, each of which
is a self-certified PURPA QF. XRG DP-7, XRG DP-8, and XRG-DP 9 wil be nameplate 20
MW, and XRG DP-lO wil be nameplate 10 MW. Complaint at ~ 6. XRG has actively
developed these projects since 2006. See, e.g., XRG's Answer to Rocky Mountain Power's
Motion for Summary Judgment Exhibit 1 (hereinafter "XRG Exhibit"), at pp. 1-48 (containing
2007 wind leases); id, at p. 49 (describing XRG's efforts to collect and evaluate wind data and
secure interconnection both beginning in 2006).
On Januar 21, 2009, XRG formally requested that Rocky Mountan Power provide it
with 4 stadard PURP A PPAs for the projects subject to the Complaint, as well as 2 larger QF
wind projects sized over 10 aMW for which XRG requested IRP Methodology rates. Rocky
Mountain Power's Motion for Summary Judgment Exhibit A (hereinafter "RMP SJ Exhibit"), pp.
12-95, 111. XRG proposed to deliver the output of the projects to Rocky Mountan Power's
system at the Brady substation with online dates of December 31,2010. Id at 44,56, 78, 87.
Rocky Mountain Power, however, quickly rejected XRG's request. Beginning Februar
25, 2009, Rocky Mountain Power rejected the request for 4 standard PPAs, and never provided
IRP Methodology rates for the 2 larger projects. Id at pp. 105, 117, 143, 209-10, 299-301.
4 XRG provides background regarding additional factual matters to those in Rocky
Mountan Power's Motion. To the extent Rocky Mountain Power disagrees with XRG's
characterization of the facts, such disagreement only serves to prove the Commission should
hold an evidentiar hearng.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 6
Rocky Mountain Power stated it lacked transmission capacity for the cumulative output such that
Rocky Mountain Power Commercial and Trading ("Rocky Mountain Power C&T") could
designate the projects as network resources and thereby obtain network transmission service
from Rocky Mountain Power Transmission, as required by PacifiCorp's OATT. Id Rocky
Mountain Power stated that it would need to deliver the output to its Utah load, would only be
able to do so for 23 MW delivered to the Brady or Borah substation, and therefore requied XRG
to select only one of its projects for a PP A. Id at p. at 117.
Meanwhile, in March 2009, Bonnevile Power Administration ("BP A") required
completion of $20,000 environmental studies for each of the 4 stadard project's interconnection
- a tota of $80,000. XRG Exhibit 1, at p. 49. Because Rocky Mountan Power had expressed its
resistace to executing PP As for all 4 projects, XRG had to bear the futility of its PPA efforts in
mind when commtting additional fuds to the interconnection process and ultimately lost its
queue numbers for each project which it had initiated in 2006. Id
XRG neverteless persisted in attempting to convince Rocky Mountain Power that
transmission from Brady to the Utah load center would not be a problem, and pointed out that
publicly available information regarding upgrades to the applicable transmission path refuted
Rocky Mountain Power's position. See RMP SJ Exhibit A, at p. 269. From a phone
conversation on November 10,2009, XRG understood Rocky Mountain Power itself to state that
transmission would not be a problem if the projects came online in June 2011, and in light of this
information XRG requested to move the online date to June 2011. See id, at pp. 289, 296.
Yet Rocky Mountain Power consistently and unequivocally relied on the perceived
transmission problem to reject XRG's request for 4 PPAs. See, e.g, id, at p. 209. XRG again
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 7
requested 4 PPAs in March 2010. See id, at pp. 289, 296. On March 12,2010, the Commission
issued Order No. 31021, increasing Rocky Mountain Power's wind integration charge, and then
issued Order No. 31025 on March 16, 2010, which signficantly decreased the published avoided
cost rates. On April 13,2010, Rocky Mountain Power responded to XRG's March inquiries by
letter from Mr. Ken Kaufman. He stated, "PacifiCorp has not offered to purchase net output
from any remaining Exergy project because PacifiCorp lacks the abilty to accept more than
approximately 23 MW of new capacity at either its Borah or Brady substation and XRG has not
offered to pay for system upgrades necessar to accept more than 23 MW." Id, at p. 299.
Rocky Mountain Power disagreed with Exergy's reliance on the November 2010 phone call to
"conclude that PacifiCorp Transmission wil be able to accommodate all Exergy projects after
completion by PacifiCorp Transmission of the upgrade in mid-2011." Id, at p. 300.
B. XRG's Complaint
Left with no other recourse, XRG fied the Complaint in this case on July 29, 2010.
XRG alleged that it attempted to negotiate 4 stadard PPAs in good faith prior to March 12,
2010, but that Rocky Mountain Power refused to fush them on account of its purorted
transmission constraint. Complaint, at ~~ 8, 15-16. XRG alleged that, "By failing to provide
publicly available stadard PPA terms and conditions, and delaying its responses to XRG's
binding offers to enter into four PURP A PP As for its wind QFs near Malta, Idaho, PacifiCorp is
in violation ofPURPA, FERC's implementing regulations, and the Commission's orders." Id at
~ 18. XRG requested that the Commission order Rocky Mountan Power to "execute stadard
PURPA power purchase agreements for XRG's four QF projects at PacifiCorp's avoided cost
rates on file for QFs under 10 aMW prior to March 12,2010(,)" or, "Grant()any other relief that
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMAY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 8
the Commission deems necessar." Id at p. 6.
In its Answer, Rocky Mountain Power "admits it informed XRG in writing on March 23,
2009, May 11, 2009, and October 2, 2009, that available transmission capacity from the
proposed delivery point - Brady substation - was insufficient for accepting more than 23
megawatts of net output from XRG's proposed qualifying facilities." Answer, at ~ 8. It also
asserted as an affrmative defense that it had not acted in bad faith or with undue delay. Id, at p.
6.
C. Rocky Mountain Power's admission that network transmission was available
The paries commenced discovery, and XRG's First Set of Production Requests
(Requests No. 1-15) inquired into the transmission capacity issue. See XRG Exhibit 2, at pp. 1-
24, 34, 36-37. Then, on September 21, 2010, Rocky Mountan Power sent XRG a letter
admitting that transmission was now available for all 4 QFs. XRG Exhibit 3, at pp. 1-10. Rocky
Mountan Power's September 21,2010, letter did not even reference the Complaint case. Id. As
though the litigation were not ongoing, and as though Rocky Mountain Power's perceived
transmission constrait were not a central issue in the litigation, the letter stated:
On July 15,2010, PacifiCorp Transmission designated a new Point
of DeliverylPoint of Receipt for Network Transmission Service
under its Open Access Transmission Tariff called "Path C" . . . The
new Point of DeliverylPoint of Receipt at Patch C effectively
increases avai!able firm transmission across Path C and resolves
PacifiCorp C&T's concerns at this time about the avai!abilty gf
firm Network Resource Transmission Service .m the four QE
projects. . . . If you decide to pursue all four projects, we would
request an update on each project per the attched matrices so that
we can correctly and expediently prepare the draft PP As.
Id, at p. 2 (emphasis added).
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 9
The letter provided no explanation for why Rocky Mountan Power designated a new
point of service on Path C, or why Rocky Mountain Power was unaware prior to this date that
transmission would be available by the time XRG had initially proposed the projects come online
- December 31, 2010. The letter contained, for the first time since XRG contacted Rocky
Mountain Power on Janua 21, 2009, a stadard matrx of additional project information for
each of the 4 QFs that Rocky Mountan Power believed XRG needed to provide in order for
Rocky Mountain Power to prepare standard contracts and complete due dilgence. Id, at pp. 3-
10.
Back in the litigation, in discovery, Rocky Mountain Power then provided internal
communcations between Jim Parouw, a trader in Energy Marketing for PacifiCorp C & T, to
John Younie, a contract administrator for PacifiCorp C & T, regarding Rocky Mountai Power's
investigation into the transmission availability. XRG Exhibit 2, at pp. 1-22,61. On Januar 29,
2009, Mr. Younie had described the projects, including the online date of December 31, 2010,
and that each would be a mandatory purchase PURP A project with an "Idaho Stadard QF Off-
System MAG PPA." Id, at p. 4-7. He asked Mr. Parouw, "Are there any issues with this much
capacity being delivered to Brady?" Id, at p. 3.
On Janua 29, 2010, Mr. Parouw responded, "Import to Utah system on a firm basis is
limited to 23 MW total for these transactions . . .. Another 250 MW exists but APS has first
rights to schedule on the path." Id at pp. 16-19. Mr. Parouw fuher elaborated by stating:
Wil need to request Network Resource status for this resource.
Please notify when you want request for Network Resource status
submitted (wil need to have signed attestation of C&T
commitment). Suggest PPA be contingent upon receiving Network
Resource status. Without Network Resource status for this
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 10
resource, we will need to use PacifiCorp PTP capacity and
schedule the energy to load on the PTP reservation.
Id. (emphasis added).
XRG quickly fied its Second Set of Production Requests (Nos. 16-23), on September 29,
2009, to inquire fuer into the erroneous transmission finding, including information regarding
Rocky Mountan Power's internal procedures for investigating available transmission for off-
system PURP A projects.
D. XRG's renewed attempt to secure 4 PP As without further litigation
Despite the highly suspicious nature the newly revealed facts, XRG entered into
settlement negotiations in good faith in hopes of foregoing fuher litigation and simply securing
PP As for its projects at a rate that would provide it with a reasonable retu. XRG accepted
Rocky Mountain Power's request to stay discovery, and settlement negotiations commenced in
October 2010.
Then, on November 5, 2010, Rocky Mountain Power, along with Idaho Power Company
and Avista Corporation, fied a Joint Motion to Adjust Published Avoided Cost Rate Eligibilty
Cap in GNR-E-1O-04. The utilities requested that the Commission imediately reduce the
eligibilty cap for standard rates contained in PURP A PPAs for QFs from a project size of under
10 aMW to a project size of under 100 kilowatts ("kw") nameplate capacity. See Case No.
GNR-E-1O-04. On December 3, 2010, the Commission issued Order No. 32131, wherein it
declined to immediately reduce the eligibilty cap, but stated that its final decision on the
eligibilty cap issue would be retroactively effective on December 14,2010.
XRG understood settlement negotiations to be ongoing despite the Joint Motion to reduce
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 11
the eligibilty cap. The paries met on December 7,2010. But XRG perceived that meeting to
have been a break down in the settlement negotiations. After that meeting XRG provided Rocky
Mountan Power with a letter contaning updated information regarding the projects, which in
par, responded to the September 21,2010 letter requesting refreshed inormation on the projects
since the time in early 2009 when Rocky Mountain Power refused to negotiate. See XRG Exhibit
3, at pp. 11-15.5 Although XRG's response to the September 21, 2010 letter was delayed by
litigation and settlement negotiations, XRG expressed interest in simply executing contracts. Id.,
at p. 13. In response, Rocky Mountan Power did not provide contracts contaning the rates in
Order No. 30744 or 31025. Indeed, it never responded to XRG's letter at alL. Rather, it re-
commenced litigation.
E. The recently re-commenced litigation
Rocky Mountan Power responded to XRG's Second Set of Production Requests on
December 21, 2010, and Rocky Mountan Power filed its Second Set of Production Requests
(Nos. 26-51) on December 22, 2010. XRG filed its Third Set of
Production Requests (Nos. 24-
63) on Januar 11,2011, asking for detailed explanations for Rocky Mountain Power's failure to
earlier realize that transmission would not be a problem, and its reliance on that non-existent
problem to stal negotiations. F or example, XRG has asked, "please explain why Rocky
Mountain Power did not offer the option to XRG to make the requested PPAs 'contingent upon
receiving Network Resource status,''' Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Protective Order
Because settlement negotiations are confdential for some puroses and Rocky Mountan
Power has objected to discovery requests regarding the settlement negotiations, XRG has
provided only the redacted letter which does not refer to settlement negotiations. As redacted, it
is simply a response to Rocky Mountain Power's September 21,2010 letter, provided by Rocky
Mountan Power outside the context of the litigation.
5
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAI POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 12
Exhibit A (hereinafter "RMP PO Exhibit"), at No. 31(b), which would have enabled Rocky
Mountain Power to make a formal request to its transmission experts to analyze availabilty of
transmission. Id, at Nos. 36-39; XRG Exhibit 2, at pp. 63-64. XRG also asked Rocky Mountain
Power to explain the legitimate use under its OATT for which it held 250 MW ofPTP capacity,
and the reason it did not offer that capacity for XRG's projects. RMP PO Exhibit A, at Nos. 32-
33.
XRG also requested explanation for Rocky Mountain Power's failure to recognze the
publicly available information regarding Rocky Mountain Power's plans to upgrade Path C such
that it would have up to 1600 MW of transfer capacity by the end of201O, and would require no
upgrades for deliveries at Brady. See, e.g., id., at Nos. 42,44. XRG fuher inquired into Rocky
Mountain Power's commitment to the Idaho Commission durng the Mid-American holdings
acquisition in 2005 to upgrade this path, and into its successful request for preferential
transmission ratemakng treatment for the upgrades at FERC in 2008 where it stated that
southwestern Idaho would be "hub" from which its "power will be collected and delivered in
different directions." Id, at Nos. 48, 52. XRG requested explanation into Rocky Mountain
Power's request to rate base the upgrades in its 2010 rate case before the Idaho Commission. Id,
at Nos. 47,49,50. XRG asked whether anyone at Rocky Mountain Power C & T that processed
XRG's PPA requests knew of the proposed upgrades. See, e.g., id., at No. 44(d).
XRG then timely responded to Rocky Mountain Power's Production Request Nos. 26-50
on Janua 12, 2011, without requesting a delay, despite the intervening holiday season. On
Janua 20, 2011, XRG agreed to allow Rocky Mountain Power an additional 14 days to respond
to XRG's Requests Nos. 24-63. See XRG Exhibit 4, at pp. 1. At that time, Rocky Mountan
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 13
Power did not indicate that it planed to fie a motion for a protective order or for sumar
judgment.
Then, on Febru 2,2011, Rocky Mounta Power requested that XRG agree to stay the
response to all of Request Nos. 24-63 pending resolution of a Motion for Sumar Judgment
Rocky Mounta Power now planed to file. Id., at p. 3. XRG rejected ths request. On
Februar 7, 2011, Rocky Mountan Power then filed its Motion for Protective Order to Stay
Discovery on XRG's Production Requests Nos. 24-52, and Motion for Sumar Judgment,
which together with attachments include 381 pages of documents. Rocky Mountain Power
requests expedited review of its request to stay discover, citing the now-expired, extended
deadline for its responses on Febru 15, 2011, which was only 8 days after its voluminous
filing. On the same day, the Commission issued Order No. 32176, in Case No. GNR-E-I0-04,
reducing the published avoided cost rate eligibility cap to 100 kw for wind QFs effective
December 14, 2010. One can therefore infer from Rocky Mountain Power's motions that it
believes XRG canot now even entitle itself to the published avoided cost rates in Order No.
31025. On February 15, 2011, Rocky Mountain Power responded to XRG's pending requests
that do not regard the erroneous transmission constraint finding (Nos. 52-63), but has not
responded to transmission questions (Nos. 24-52).
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAI POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 14
ANSWER
I
Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Summary Judgment should be denied.
A. Legal Standard Applicable to a Motion for Summary Judgment
"Sumar judgment under I.R.C.P. 56(c) is proper only when there is no genuine issue
of material fact and the moving part is entitled to judgment as a matter of law." Ackerman v.
Bonnevile County, 140 Idaho 307, 310, 92 P.3d 557, 560 (Ct. App. 2004). "When ruling on a
motion for sumar judgment, the tral cour must determine whether the evidence, when
constred in the light most favorable to the nonmoving pary, presents a genuine issue of
material fact or shows that the moving pary is not entitled to judgment as a matter of law."
Chandler v. Hayden, 147 Idaho 765, 769, 215 P.3d 485, 489 (2009). "The moving par bears
the burden of proving the absence of material facts." Id. "If the evidence is conficting on
material issues or supports conflcting inferences, or if reasonable minds could reach differig
conclusions, sumary judgment must be denied." Doe v. Sisters of Holy Cross, 126 Idaho 1036,
1039, 895 P.2d 1229, 1232 (Ct. App. 1995). "Should it appear from the afdavits of the pary
opposing the motion that the pary canot for reasons stated present by affidavit facts essential to
justify the par's opposition, the cour may refuse the application for judgment or may order a
continuance to permit affidavits to be obtained or depositions to be taen or discovery to be had
or may make such other order as is just." I.R.C.P. 56(t).
An affrmative defense, such as laches, "must be pleaded and proved by the defendant,"
and the "defendant has the burden of proving every element necessar to establish the
affrmative defense." Hawley v. Green, 117 Idaho 498, 504, 788 P.2d 1321, 1327 (1990); see
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 15
also I.R.C.P. 8(c). The defendant has the burden of supporting a claimed affrmative defense on
a motion for sumar judgment. See Chandler, 147 Idaho at 771, 215 P.3d at 491.
B. The Commission should deny Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Summary
Judgment, or at least stay the Motion until after Rocky Mountain Power responds
to XRG's discovery requests and XRG supplements this filing with the additional
discovery.
1. Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Summary Judgment is not the
appropriate procedural manner with which to process this case.
The Commission's rues do not provide for a Motion for Sumar Judgment. Under
IDAPA 31.01.01.57.03 - a catch-all rule applicable to all motions - XRG must respond by
Answer "with all deliberate and reasonable speed. In no event, is the par entitled to more than
foureen (14) days to answer a motion. .." Because an adverse ruing would be dispositive,
XRG must respond on the merits "with all deliberate speed," and not less than 14 days.
A response to a sumar judgment motion fied in a cour where the rules are
specifically designed to address sumar judgment, however, would not need to be filed so
quickly without advance notice. Under I.R.C.P. 56(c), a response to a motion for sumar
judgment is due 14 days prior to the date set for the hearng on the motion, and no responding
par would agree setting the hearng such that it would have a 14-day tuaround on an
unscheduled, 381-page fiing.6 In Idaho federal cours, a responding pary has 21 days to
respond to a motion for sumar judgment. 7
6 See Local Rules. 2.1, 2.2, District Cour and Magistrate Division for the Fourth Judicial
District ofthe State ofIdaho, available online at http://ww2.state.id.us/fourthjudicial/
FOURTH%20DISTRICT/2011 %20Fourh%20Judicial%20District-Rules.pdf.
7 See Local Rule 7.l(c)(I), (e)(2) United States Distrct Cour for the District ofIdao,
available online at http://ww.id.uscourts.gov/docs/2011 LOCALRULES Clean.pdf.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 16
XRG is clearly prejudiced by having to file a response so quickly to this unexpected 381-
page dispositive filing in such a short time frame. Because the Commission has not requested
motions for sumar judgment in ths case, the typical procedures should apply. The
Commission's rules of procedure provide for two avenues by which to process a complaint case
- either by evidentiary hearing (IDAPA 31.01.01.241 to 260), or by modified procedure with
comments (IDAPA 31.01.01.201 to 204). The complex factual record before the Commission
does not support a finding that it would be in the public interest to process this case without a
hearng. The Commission should therefore process this case by evidentiar hearing. For thei;e
reasons alone, the Commission should reject Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Sumar
Judgment.
2. The Commission should deny Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for
Summary Judgment because it contains no admissible evidence and
therefore fails to comply with I.R.C.P. 56(c), (e).
Although styled as a motion for sumar judgment, Rocky Mountan Power's Motion
fails the basic requirement that it include admissible evidence in support of all material facts.
See I.R.C.P. 56(c), (e); see also Shacocass, Inc. v. Arrington Constr. Co., 116 Idaho 460, 463,
776 P.2d 469,472 (Ct. App. 1989) (holding that where pary submitted exhibits unattched to an
affdavit, those exhbits had no evidentiar value and could not support a motion for sumar
judgment). Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Sumar Judgment fails ths test because it is
supported only by inadmissible exhbits unattched to an affidavit. Rocky Mountan Power
should not be allowed to avail itself of this unscheduled, surrise, dispositive motion called for in
the Idaho Rules of Civil Procedure without actually complying with the rules contaned therein.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 17
For this reason alone, Rocky Mountain Power's motion must be rejected.8
3. Even if the Summary Judgment Motion is appropriate procedurally, the
Commission should deny the Motion because the record overwhelmingly
demonstrates that there are genuine issues of material fact as to Rocky
Mountain Power's bad faith negotiations prior to and after XRG fied the
Complaint, and XRG is entitled to its additional discovery under I.R.C.P.
56(t).
XRG's Complaint alleges that Rocky Mountain Power raised transmission constraint
issues with which XRG disagreed, caused undue delay in negotiations, and thereby deprived
XRG of its right to 4 stadard PPAs containing the rates in Order No. 30744, or any other relief
the Commission deems necessar. XRG's Complaint's request for any other relief the
Commission deems necessar should be read to include an alternative request for an order
entitling it to 4 PPAs contaning the rates in Order No. 31025.9 Because "the record as curently
constituted does not permit an undisputed finding that" XRG failed to attempt to negotiate in
good faith before and after filing the Complaint, or a finding that it was possible to negotiate in
light of Rocky Mountan Power's relentless bad faith, each of Rocky Mountan Power's three
8 Because Rocky Mountain Power has not properly fied affidavits in compliance with the
rue, XRG has no burden to rebut Rocky Mountain Power's inadmissible evidence. See I.R.C.P.
56( e). Should the Commission allow Rocky Mountan Power the right to re-submit its
attchments to its filings with affdavits, XRG respectfully requests the opportunity to do the
same for XRG's supporting exhbits unattached to affdavits.
9 To the extent the Commssion disagrees that XRG's Complaint includes a request for
such alterative relief, XRG hereby requests leave to amend its complaint. Under I.R.C.P. 15(a),
"in the interest of justice, district cours should favor liberal grants of leave to amend a
complaint." Hines v. Hines, 129 Idaho 847, 853, 934 P.2d 20, 26 (1997). Because the
availability of published rates has changed and Rocky Mountain Power has admitted network
transmission is available since the filing of the Complaint, XRG should be allowed to amend the
Complaint to include an alternative claim to entitlement to the intervening rates in effect when it
filed its Complaint if the Complaint canot be read to request such alternative relief.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AN XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 18
asserted bases for sumar judgment faiL. See In the Matter of PacifCorp for an Order
Determining that PacifCorp is not Required to Provide Wheeling Service to Snake River Valley
Electric Association, Case No. PAC-E-01-6, Order No. 28888, p. 13 (2001) (denying
PacifiCorp's motion for sumar judgment).
a. There is a genuine issue of material fact as to whether XRG met its obligation
to attempt to actively negotiate, but was precluded from doing so by Rocky
Mountain Power's bad faith.
The QF's expressed intent and attempts to obligate itself are the critical factors under any
reasonable interpretation of when a legally enforceable obligation is incured under 18 C.F.R. §
292.304( d)(2)(ii). In Earth Power Resources, Inc., the Commission found that "Ear Power
attempted to negotiate and did everyhing in its power to commit itself," but "Water Power
Company . . . either knowingly or through negligence or ineptitude acted so as to prevent Ear
Power from obtaining a contract." Order No. 27231. The QF was therefore entitled to a contract
containing rates in existence when it attempted to obligate itself. Id; see also Snow Mountain
Pine, 84 Or. App. at 600, 734 P.2d at 1371. The Commission's prior decisions also demonstrate
that a QF's intent can be evidenced by the level of matuity of its development of the project and
its knowledge of the standard contract terms.
10
10 See In the Matter of the Application of Idaho Power Company for Approval of a Firm
Energy Sales Agreement with Yellowstone Power Company, Case No. IPC-E-1O-22, Order
32104, at p. 12 (2010) (approving of grandfathered rates despite "the apparent lack of any
written documentation . . . evidencing that the terms of a power purchase agreement were
materially complete (before the rate change)" in par because QF had "familiarity with PURP A
projects and the stadard terms of Idaho Power's power purchase agreements"); In the Matter of
Cassia Wind to Determine Exemption Status, Case No. IPC-E-05-35, Order No. 29954, at pp. 2-4
(2006) (finding wind QF entitled to grandfathered rates when it had merely submitted a
completed application for interconnection study, including the applicable fee, and had pedormed
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 19
XRG meets the legally enforceable obligation test for its 4 QFs. XRG provided very
detailed project specifics for its self-certified QFs in Januar 2009. XRG's parent company,
Exergy Development Group of Idaho, LLC, has developed many Idaho wind QF projects and is
intimately familiar with the unque contract provisions authorized by the Commission for
stadard PURP A wind contracts. Rocky Mountan Power has provided no evidence that any
terms were in dispute. Indeed, Rocky Mountain Power's own internal communications in
Januar 2009 noted that each of these XRG projects would execute an "Idaho Stadard QF Off-
System MAG PPA." XRG Exhibit 2, at pp. 4-7.
XRG and Rocky Mountain Power knew the terms at the times XRG attempted to obligate
itself. XRG also took substatial steps to develop the projects, despite Rocky Mountain Power's
delay tactics. See XRG Exhibit 1, at pp. 49-50. XRG began the interconnection studies in 2006,
and has paid multiple interconnection fees. Id XRG has reinitiated the process afer Rocky
Mountan Power's delay contributed to the loss ofXRG's initial BPA queue numbers. Id XRG
has performed and analyzed wind studies since 2006, has possessed real property rights since
2007, has engaged third paries to complete title and surey work necessar to plan constrction,
and turbine and road layouts. Id, at pp. 1-50. In addition to these activities occuring prior to
Order No. 31025, XRG's continued efforts in 2010 included completion of work to ensure the
projects will not interfere with the governent systems or microwave towers, and wil not afect
endangered species. Id. at p. 50. XRG's projects are much farher along than the grandfathered
wind QF in Cassia Wind. See Order No. 29954.
wind studies, commenced preliminar permitting and licensing activities, and made efforts to
secure sites to place tubines).
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 20
Despite XRG's repeated attempts to execute 4 PPAs, Rocky Mountain Power took one
year and eight months (January 21,2009 until September 21,2010) to respond to XRG with the
Company's standard matrix that it provides to QFs as one of the first steps in QF negotiation and
due diligence. Prior to that time, it provided XRG with no indication that any information XRG
provided was incomplete, even for the one project that Rocky Mountan Power asserts it
attempted to negotiate. Rocky Mountan Power admits that the discovery to which it objects
relates to its actions to evaluate whether it could integrate 70 MW of output at Brady substation.
Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Protective Order, at p. 4. Rocky Mountain Power also
admits XRG "indicated on multiple occasions that it thought the paries should proceed to
negotiate all four PP As and resolve any issue involving transmission constraints on a separate
negotiating path. The Company did not yield to this request." Rocky Mountain Power's Motion
for Summary Judgment, at p. 5. There is no disagreement that the non-existent transmission
constraint precluded any necessar negotiations. i I
As noted above, FERC's regulations require a utility to accept the energy and capacity
ii Rocky Mountan Power asserts that XRG delayed the process towards 4 PPAs. See
Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Summary Judgment, at pp. 14-15. XRG respectfully
submits that an inquiry into the settlement negotiations initiated by XRG shortly afer Rocky
Mountan Power first agreed on September 21, 2010, to provide 4 PPAs for all 4 QFs would
serve to negate Rocky Mountain Power's assertion that XRG was the pary that delayed
progress. IDAPA 31.01.01.272 states that settlement negotiations are confdential, but this rue
should be read in the context of Idaho Rule of Evidence 408, which only excludes evidence of
settlement negotiations if offered for the purose of proving "liability for, or invalidity of, the
claim or any other claim." The rule "does not require exclusion when the evidence is offered for
another purpose," including "negativing a contention of undue delay." I.R.E. 408; Soria v.
Sierra Pacifc Airlines, 111 Idaho 594, 605-06, 726 P.2d 706, 717-18 (1986); see also Athey v.
Farmers, 234 F.3d 357, 362 (8th Cir. 2000); Carney v. American University, 151 F.3d 1090,
1095 (D.C. Cir. 1998). That the settlement negotiations ceased only after the filing of the Joint
Petition in GNR-E-I0-04 only fuher negates Rocky Mountain Power's claim that XRG is the
par that has delayed progress towards 4 executed PP As.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AN
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 21
for an off-system QF just as it would for an on-system QF. See 18 C.F.R. § 292.303(a)(2). For
on-system QF's, PacifiCorp recently asserted in defense of a QF complait that the transmission
and merchant fuctions of the Company had failed to communcate, "PacifiCorp C&T does not
communcate to PacifiCorp Transmission Services regarding a QF's interconnection status
unless authorized by the QF." See XRG Exhibit 5, at p. 26. PacifiCorp stated, "While fuctional
separation is mandated by FERC in order to facilitate open access to FERC-regulated
transmission services, 18 C.F.R. § 358.2, there are other importt reasons to observe fuctional
separation in the context ofQF negotiations. . . ." Id at p. 10 n.7. Rocky Mountan Power does
not deny that FERC's rules apply to its processing ofXRG's PPA requests, see XRG Exhibit 2, at
pp. 38-40, 60, 63-64, and therefore Rocky Mountan Power should not be allowed to abuse its
role as transmission provider and PURP A negotiator to discriminate against QFs.
XRG's pending Production Requests Nos. 24-52 request information very likely,
however, to demonstrate Rocky Mountain Power committed acts of discrimination against XRG
too numerous to detail in this filing. For example, Mr. Griswold stated that necessar network
transmission upgrades "likely would tae four to five years to complete." RMP SJ Exhibit A, at
p. 209. But if Mr. Griswold - who is a market fuction employee - made ths determination
without contacting the transmission fuction employees, he very likely violated FERC's
fuctional separation rules by exercising a transmission fuction of determining transmission
availability for XRG's projects. 12
12 "Transmission" includes "network or point-to-point service." 18 C.F.R. § 358.3(t).
FERC has stated, "it serves no purose to physically separate transmission personnel from the
utility company's merchant personnel without also transferring responsibility for transmission
operations and reliability fuctions to the transmission staff that is charged with the
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 22
Additionally, Rocky Mountain Power's failure to notify XRG of the option to make the
contracts contingent upon receiving network resource status or of initiating the network
transmission request process prior to executing the agreements was very likely an act of bad
faith, about which XRG is entitled to additional discovery.13 Had Rocky Mountain Power C &
T agreed to process the contract negotiation and the transmission requests on different tracts, as
requested by XRG, there is no doubt the transmission fuction employees would have
determined that transmission would be adequate. Furher, Rocky Mountain Power C & T should
have been aware of the ongoing upgrades themselves because XRG discussed the issue with
them on November 10,2009, and the Company had even obtained and requested various forms
of cost-recovery for the upgrades in multiple ratemakng forus.
None of the cases cited by Rocky Mountain Power involved a utilty's complete refusal
to even provide draft contracts on account of a "fatal flaw" perceived by the utilty, which later
proved grossly incorrect. See Cogen Power II, Inc. v. PacifCorp, Case No. UPL-E-94-1, Order
No. 25638 (1994) (stating ''the facts of this case do not demonstrate a pattern of delay,
intransigence or obdurateness on the par ofPacifiCorp"). "(I)t is only after negotiation and/or a
reasonable period for the utilty investigation and response that an otherwse eligible QF can
responsibility of processing transmission requests." Arizona Public Service Company v. Idaho
Power Company, 87 FERC ~ 61,303, 62,225- 62,226 (June 17, 1999); see also Standards of
Conduct for Transmission Providers, Order No. 717-C, 131 FERC ~ 61,045, ~ 15 (April 16,
2010).
13 FERC's rues allow Rocky Mountan Power C & T to attest that it has the right to a
network resource through a contract that is contingent upon obtaining network resource status.
See Preventing Undue Discrimination and Preference in Transmission Service, Order 890-B,
123 FERC ~ 61,299, ~ 183 (June 23, 2008) (order on rehearing and clarfication). "Network
customers are therefore not required to commit to purchasing a resource prior to submitting a
request to designate that resource." Id..
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMAY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 23
expect to obtain a power purchase contract and a lock-in of avoided cost rates." Id (emphasis
added); see also Island Power Company v. Utah Power and Light Company, Cae No. UPL-E-93-
4, Order No. 25528 (1994) (stating, "PacifiCorp did not refuse repeated attempts to negotiate a
contract"). In the present case, the Commission can find nothg but delay, intransigence and
obdurateness by Rocky Mountain Power.
b. Rocky Mountain Power is not entitled to Summary Judgment on its asserted
basis that XRG's projects are not mature because Commission precedent
does not require the level of maturity asserted by Rocky Mountain Power as
mandatory and because Rocky Mountain Power's bad faith negotiations
precluded XRG's projects' maturity.
The Commission should reject Rocky Mountan Power's assertion that a QF must secure
firm transmission and interconnection rights prior to being able to create a legally enforceable
obligation. Securing firm interconnection and wheeling rights prior to execution of a PURP A
PP A is simply not a requirement in Idaho. The PP As approved in countless orders requie an
off-system QF to obtain transmission and interconnection rights as a condition to achieving first
energy, but not as a precondition to executing the agreement. See, e.g., Application, Case No.
IPC-E-1O-47, Attchment 1, Ars. 4.1.8, 5.7; see also Order No. 32144, at p. 4 (noting QF had to
reapply for transmission rights afer execution and approval of PP As). Rocky Mountain Power
itself has very recently entered into such agreements With QFs. See, e.g., Application, Case No.
PAC-E-11-01, § 2.2.4 (Janua 10, 2011) (merely requiring QF to provide Rocky Mountain
Power with executed interconnection agreement ''ten days prior to delivery of energy"); see also
Application, Case No. PAC-E-1O-05, § 2.2.3 (August 20,2010) (same); Order No. 32084.
These most recent Commission orders are consistent with long-standing Commission
precedent. In the seminal Idaho PURA case, Idaho Power argued that Afton Energy, Inc. - an
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 24
off-system QF located in Wyoming - was not entitled to a PURP A contract because it "ha( d) not
demonstrated that it can or will deliver its power generated at its facilty to the (Idaho Power) for
the ful 35-year term." Afton Energy, Inc. v. Idaho Power Company, Case No. U-1006-199,
Order No. 17478, at pp. 14 (1982). The Commission acknowledged that there was risk with the
proposed wheeling arangement, which does not appear to have provided Afton with irrevocable
wheeling rights. Id But in ordering Idaho Power to execute a PP A, the Commssion stated that
''the risk of BP A's exercise of the cancellation clause of the wheeling agreement is one that can
reasonably be borne in bringing ths project on line." Id at 15. Furher, "(t)his is paricularly so
in light of the fact that Afton itself has borne the risk of increased costs of transmission and
interconnection as well as a major portion of other transmission or interconnection risks by virte
of its agreement to the liquidated damages provision." Id, affrmed by Afton Energy, Inc. v.
Idaho Power Co., 107 Idaho 781, 693 P.2d 427 (1984).14
The facts of the present case demonstrate that, in addition to long-stading precedent,
common sense also dictates that a QF should not be required to secure firm transmission and
interconnection rights prior to being able to obligate itself to a PP A. First, the costs to proceed
through those processes are substatial. Each interconnection application for each of XRG's 4
QFs requires a $2,500 deposit, and each system impact study deposit is $5,000. See XRG Exhibit
1, at p. 53. Each Facilities Study deposit is $7,000. Id XRG understads that the deposit each
QF must submit to secure wheeling rights is $2,600, which would be a tota of $10,400.
14 Like XRG, Afton alleged that the utility had "'intentionally and deliberately protracted
the negotiation for the purchase of its power' and had 'continualy employed delaying tactics
designed to discourage Jones and destroy his efforts to complete the financing of this plant.'"
Order No. 17478, atpp. 1-2.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 25
Combined, the processes could tae several months to complete, at which point the QF wil
begin incurrng very substatial expenses for necessar construction. A QF canot be expected
to commit the time and resources to complete each process with no assurance of which rates will
be available to its project, or that it will even receive a contract.
Furher, XRG has been engaged in the interconnection process for these QFs since 2006,
and lost its initial queue positions on account of reluctace to incur additional expenses at a time
when Rocky Mountain Power refused to execute PPAs. See XRG Exhibit 1, at pp. 49-50, 53-55.
XRG has also investigated availability of transmission from the projects to the Brady substation
at varous times since 2006 and is comfortable with its feasibility from a techncal and cost
perspective. RMP SJ Exhibit A, at p. 44, 56, 67, 78, 87; XRG Exhibit 3, at p. 12. Rocky
Mountain Power's speculation that XRG may be unable to compel BPA to wheel the output to
Brady is unounded because BPA operates under an OATT.I5 In light of the delays in securng
PPAs, XRG recently attempted to commit to a revised online date of Janua 1,2013, and XRG
has committed to a $45/kw delay default liquidated damages provision, which would require it to
post $3.15 milion as a guarantee that it will achieve the projected online date. XRG Exhibit 1, at
p. 55; XRG Exhibit 3, p. 12-14. XRG is aware of this damages provision because it is included
in several PPAs entered into by companies managed by its parent company, Exergy
Development Group of Idaho, with Idaho Power. XRG Exhibit 1, at pp. 51-52.
In a case not cited by Rocky Mountain Power, the Oregon Cour of Appeals approved of
15 Furer, Rocky Mountain Power's speculation that XRG will need three wheels to get the
output to Brady is unounded. XRG is engaged in securng a single wheel over lines operated by
BP A or for which BP A possesses transmission rights, and XRG is confdent in its ability to
deliver the output to Brady.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 26
the approach long used by the Idaho Commission and advocated by XRG in this case. See Water
Power Co. v. PacifCorp, 99 Or.App. 125, 127, 132, 781 P.2d 860, 862, 864 (1989) (approving
of PUC ruing that, after the QF filed a complaint in October 1983, "Pacific had to sign a power
purchase agreement at 1982 rates, if Water Power would submit a written plan for transmitting
power to Pacific's grid,,).16 Moreover, Rocky Mountain Power's reliance on Empire Lumber
Company v. Washington Water Power, 114 Idaho 191, 755 P.2d 1229 (1987), is misplaced. In
that case, the Cour merely held that a QF is not entitled to "obtain an option to sell some amount
of electrcal power to be generated at some plant of unown size or capacity." Id, 114 Idaho at
194, 755 P.2d at 1232. XRG did not request an option. It requested 4 stadard contracts for 4
self-certified QFs of known size, capacity, and location, and for which it had expended
substatial sums in developing. Rocky Mountain Power is therefore not entitled to judgment as a
matter of law because XRG's projects were mature at the time of the rate change in Order No.
31025, and were even more matue at the time of the drop in the eligibilty cap in Order No.
32176.
According to Rocky Mountan Power, XRG would have had to submit non-refudable
deposits of tens of thousands of dollars for interconnection and transmission rights to entitle
itself to PP As, all at a time when Rocky Mountain Power refused to even provide a responsive
inquiry on due dilgence for any of the projects, or so much as a draf PP A for 3 of the projects.
But Rocky Mountan Power canot have it both ways - if it will require an onerous delay default
16 The Commission should therefore reject Rocky Mountain Power's reliance upon
Portland General Electric Co. v. Oregon Energy Co., OPUC Docket No. 98-055, 1998 Ore.
LEXIS 131, recons. denied, Order No. 98-238, because it is a non-binding, out-of-state
commission order and it imposes a requirement never utilzed in Idaho.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 27
liquidated damages provision to more than protect it and its ratepayers from financial risk, it
canot also require the QF to complete the expensive and time consumng interconnection and
transmission processes prior to PP A execution.
c. Rocky Mountain Power is not entitled to summary judgment on its asserted
basis of a delay by XRG in fiing the Complaint.
i. The pre-fied complaint rule does not compel summary judgment.
Rocky Mountan Power asserts incorrectly that the "pre-fied complaint rule" should
apply to this case, where the QF had almost no notice of the change of rates in Order No. 31025
and filed its Complaint prior to the change in the eligibility cap in Order No. 32176. Rocky
Mountain Power's arguent fails for many reasons.
First, the pre-filed complaint requirement arose from a procedure where the utility fied a
petition to change existing rates well in advance of the effective date of the rate change. See
A. W. Brown Co., Inc. v. Idaho Power Co., 121 Idaho 812, 814, 816, 828 P.2d 841, 843, 845
(1992) (noting that utility fied petition to change rates in Januar 1985, and rates did not go into
effect until late April 1985); In the Matter of the Application of Idaho Power Company for New
Cogeneration/Small Power Production Rates, Case No. U-I006-248, Order No. 19745, at pp. 1,
3 (1985) (noting that utility fied applications to lower rates in "sumer 1984" and Januar 25,
1985, but cut-off date for filing a complaint for grandfather status at April 29, 1985). Without
such advance notice, the pre-filed complaint rule makes no sense, and the rate change in Order
No. 31025 occured with almost no advance notice to XRG or other QFs.
Second, in A. W. Brown, the Cour merely approved of this grandfather test and did not
compel it as the Commission's only available way to test whether a QF had effected a legally
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 28
enforceable obligation. Third, the Commission has not requied ths pre-filed complaint test
consistently. See, e.g., Blind Canyon Aquaranch, Order No. 25802; Earth Power Resources,
Inc., Order No. 27231. Fourh, even if the pre-fied complaint rue applied to two rate changes at
issue in XRG's Complaint, XRG fied its Complaint many months before the rate change
regarding the eligibilty cap in Order No. 32176. And the Complaint has now proven highly
meritorious in light of Rocky Mountain Power's subsequent determination that it had been
incorrect, and XRG had been correct, regarding the transmission capacity issue.
ii. Rocky Mountain Power has not proven the elements of laches.
As noted above, laches is an affirmative defense which the defendant must prove. The
elements are: "(1) defendant's invasion of plaintiffs rights, (2) delay in asserting plaintiffs
rights, the plaintiff having had notice and an opportunity to institute a suit, (3) lack of knowledge
by defendant that plaintiff would assert his rights, and (4) injur or prejudice to defendant in
event relief is accorded to plaintiff or the suit is not held to be bared." Huppert v. Wolford, 91
Idaho 249, 257, 420 P.2d 11, 19 (1966). Rocky Mountain Power itself notes that, "Whether a
par is gulty oflaches primarily is a question of fact. . . ." See Rocky Mountain Power's Motion
for Summary Judgment, at p. 20 (internal quotation omitted). That admission alone warants
rejecting ths arguent at sumar judgment. Aside from the lack of evidence, however, Rocky
Mountain Power does not even have a colorable argument for the second and four elements.
XRG engaged in no delay in asserting its position or its claims. As documented above
and admitted by Rocky Mountan Power, XRG attempted at all times after March 2009 to
convince Rocky Mountain Power to negotiate PPAs for delivery of all 4 QFs at Brady substation.
That XRG waited until July 2010 to file a Complaint only demonstrates that XRG filed a
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 29
Complaint as a last resort afer giving Rocky Mountain Power ample time to recognze what
ultimately proved tre - that it would have the capacity to accept more than 23 MW all along.
Furher, Rocky Mountan Power has not even provided any clearly ariculated basis for
how it was prejudiced by the July 29, 2010 filing of the Complaint. It took Rocky Mountain
Power over a month to even respond to XRG's last correspondence on March 12,2010, with a
letter dated April 13,2010. In several cases arising out of the rate change in Order No. 31025,
the Commission approved of PP As with grandfathered rates entered into after the rate change.
See Order Nos. 32024,32025,32026, 32027, 32068, 32104, 32138. It was reasonable for XRG
to wait to see if Rocky Mountai Power would resolve the transmission constraint XRG believed
to be wholly non-existent all along prior to filing the Complaint. Indeed, Rocky Mountain
Power ultimately discovered XRG was correct about transmission - the crucial issue in this case
- after XRG filed the Complaint.
II
Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Protective Order to Stay Discovery should be denied.
Rocky Mountan Power's request for protective order and stay of discovery is governed
by IDAPA 31.01.01.221, and I.R.C.P. 26(c). "The discovery rules are to be used as a means of
eliciting unprivileged information that appears reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of
admissible evidence." Rosebud v. PacifCorp, Case No. UPL-E-92-6, Case No. 25784 (1994).
A tribunal may issue a protective order to protect a pary from, inter alia, "undue burden," but
only "for good cause shown." I.R.C.P. 26(c). "If the motion for protective order is denied in
whole or in par, the cour may, on such terms and conditions as are just, order that any pary or
person provide or permit discovery." Id Rocky Mountan Power is incorrect that a protective
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAI POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 30
order is justified.
As explained above, the discovery requests stil outstading (Nos. 24-52) pertn to the
crucial issue in this case - Rocky Mountain Power's bad faith investigation into available
transmission capacity. XRG's Motion to Complete Discovery under Rule 56(t) should be
granted on that basis alone. Doe, 126 Idaho at 1044, 895 P.2d at 1237 (holding cour erred in
denying Rule 56(t) motion seeking an opportity to conduct discovery on relevant points before
disposition of the sumar judgment motion).
17
Additionally, Rocky Mountain Power has over broadly characterized each and every one
of XRG's Production Request Nos. 24-52 as "burdensome." Some that it lists as "paricularly
burdensome in both depth and scope" are anytng but burdensome. See Rocky Mountain
Power's Motion for Protective Order, at p. 4 & n.lO (listing Production Requests Nos. 44-52).
Those questions inquire into highly relevant issues, such as an explanation for why Rocky
Mountain Power stated in publicly available documents in early 2010 that imports to Brady for
bidders into a request for proposal would require $0 in upgrades, while at the same time tellng
XRG it could not deliver to Brady without XRG paying for upgrades. See RMP POD Exhibit A,
at No. 44. Some can be answered with a single word. See id. at No. 45(a) (asking if Rocky
Mountain Power ever provided XRG with IRP Methodology rates). Even if some requests could
17 Rocky Mountain Power's cited cases are so distinguishable that they do not merit serious
discussion. See Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Protective Order, at p. 3 (citing Selkirk
Seed Co. v. Forney, 134 Idaho 98, 105,996 P.2d 798,805 (2000) (holding that cour's protective
order was appropriate where the plaintiff sought discovery on an "alleged fraud on the cour"
which "was not par of a 'case or controversy' properly before it" and none of applicable
documents were evidence of such fraud); Avi!a v. Wahlquist, 126 Idaho 745, 749, 890 P.2d 331,
335 (1995) (holding trial cour properly granted sumar judgment without additional discovery
because plaintiff failed to fie notice of tort claim act within applicable statute of limitation).
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMAY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 31
be considered unduly burdensome, Rocky Mountain Power's recourse is to object to individua
questions rather than refuse to answer any questions regarding its investigation into transmission
a"ClilalJilit;y.I8
Rocky Mountain Power has served, and XRG has individually responded or objected to
50 production requests in a timely fashion. For the Commission to grant sumar judgment
without a procedural schedule in ths case, and without allowing for XRG to receive the
responses to these highy relevant production requests on account of a massive, sophisticated
utility's complaint that the requests are "unduly burdensome" would be patently unair. The
Commission should deny Rocky Mountain Power's Motion for Protective Order.
CONCLUSION
XRG remains committed to enterig into a stadad power purchase agreement for each
of the 4 QFs, and maintans it has the right to 4 contracts containing stadard provisions and the
published avoided cost rates. XRG respectfully requests that the Commission require Rocky
Mountain Power to respond to all pending discovery requests prior to the time XRG must
provide a final response to any pleading or motion addressing the merits of the allegations in
XRG's Complaint. Furer, without waiving its right to the full relief requested in the
Complaint, XRG alternatively requests that the Commission simply order Rocky Mountain
Power to accept XRG's reasonable settlement offer and execute 4 stadard contracts. XRG
stads wiling to provide whatever evidence or arguent the Commission may request regarding
18 Ironically, Rocky Mountain Power cites Rosebud v. PacifCorp, where the Commission
not only ordered a pary to respond to discovery requests but also painstangly itemized the
various appropriate bases upon which the pary may object to individual questions. See Order
No. 25784.
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMRY JUGMENT AN XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 32
the settlement negotiations.
)
Respectfully submitted this l: day of Febru 2011.
CHARDSON AND O'LEARY, PLLCU-
eter J Richardson (ISB No: 3195)
or ry M. Adams (ISB No. 7454)
Attorneys for the XRG LLCs
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 33
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
,)
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 'l-i day of Febru, 2011, a tre and correct copy
of the within and foregoing XRG LLCs' ANSWER IN OPPOSITION TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER TO STAY DISCOVERY
AND MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, and XRG LLCs' MOTION TO
COMPLETE DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 56(t) was served in the maner shown
to:
Jean Jewell
Commission Secreta
Idaho Public Utilities Commission
472 W. Washington
Boise, ID 83702
jean. j ewell(fpuc. idaho. gov
L Hand Delivery
_ U.S. Mail, postage pre-paid
Facsimile
lL Electronic Mail
Mark C. Moench
Rocky Mountain Power
201 South Main Street, Suite 2300
Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Mark.moenchCfacificom.com
_ Hand Delivery
X- U.S. Mail, postage pre-paid
Facsimile
lL Electronic Mail
Danel E. Solander
Rocky Mountain Power
201 South Main Street, Suite 2300
Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Daniel.solanderCfacificorp.com
_ Hand Delivery
lL U.S. Mail, postage pre-paid
Facsimile
lL Electronic Mail
Jeffey S. Lovinger
Kenneth E. Kaufman
Lovinger Kaufman LLP
825 NE Multnomah, Suite 925
Portland, OR 97232
lovinger(fLKLaw.com
Kaufman(fLKLaw.com
_ Hand Delivery
.. U.S. Mail, postage pre-paid
Facsimile
-. Electronic Mail
By:
or a M. Adams
RICHARDSON & O'LEARY PLLC
Attorneys for Complainant
ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND XRG LLCS' MOTION TO COMPLETE
DISCOVERY
PAGE 34
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
ftf:CE:
20" FEB 22 Pr¡ 2: 48
XRG LLCs' ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR
SUMRY JUGMENT
EXHIBIT 1
Excerpts ofXRG LLCs' Responses to Rocky Mountain Power's
Production Requests
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 1
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
~ONRlQlNo. 24
OD~.1$,2()ì~.dW X1G ~ al oftb pr ri ae to ~ _ ~..th D.O ~ fot..yW inlu pr riahts to eo.cløpatal re~fa1i~on ac nøb, an ónínwi~? ~.pr~ ofsu pr ri...
XRIITO.UQ NO. 24Se................
Xl... Ílbc~ 24Pø.JI~..
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 2
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
J.nr
.... Pi lI~ ll ..........hI....l!
..14. .. ll... .li..Di.... "lIsSln .ifl _..tit C...." ri.
-~u.e......1 '....01"'('111.. i.antnne..........,............
"'81
A. l.-C
-....II...dirO'
Cc. l)........an..~.....ii -, r r RAr.nf......?f.plfl,
s; lIs.......into....PRP...........1.._411.............~...utuli.t_'II_.....,ønIi~.
c. lJSI...I.....IDL....I..~........11'......
D. L..se._......D~..,.,._........._....tø......,. ....Illl_ MW... ...
~."..1 I. ,..lALtdll/l.'............1............ Im..r..
i i Ril ". I~ ...L......s su11.UAIIIMail..øf.......Iii.) f".n-.fl....ttPQer...IPI.lli..i...r....dlip...'I....ef..,.................II...øiwi.........inls ..~. ...IUCM..~.II.~
NO. ~..a_II...ØClid.I....~..~-wl....IM...d:.... LI..er..LIiI....... .~:
~"'___L Ai
1. . i-' ...if..... ....Leis.... PNiø.....lÐ............. ..,.....-lN.... ...,.s....id _..
.reiip.. .... -....,m. ..... Îllie..,.......Wf......11....-.-..._ ul ÎI ..... I.t... ti"..-..ci. f)... an.._rr.p...""....lIill.. ..el__~an........ __ or__.I... Of iI._~ .'.ill. .lIlided iP
18111..._ Nuie .. egs8 .......Pt.I'.. ",u.idin...3.1...
1.11.101 !Ifni.W' rl n. l.ls........PØ.......
.1d ......,........_... Ni IS. .___ ....1 Iilim..
'''', ~~il._.,l.~'!":.''?:..?!~.''',~),:--,.:n~,::': ';1~~:- 'c. ).GlBM XlG-4e
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 3
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
... i...l. .,............d!fI...cti. ..........1....... I......'.....,....II.........,........U.U...
......).. LtI..ULef....II..P'Il....................................................
2. II
"1 i.n........~.......,.. .......
.......... .....__..,......30L.nli.se..hif
01131'.'''_. wi L...*C.Ji...O'.....Ii.Di............,......................"iIR..'. As........-Ciiii L...Gf....ì~..._.._...di.......8f......."'.t...._ .......... ...1......... en ..Pr..,..
... ..,..._....'.)n:.Il...ln'....ofWli...
..'* li ..EAtl..n De... Ter In'" ew le..._ to
.....Ca....()....,..ìtl'...II~.. tt 1.1.... in"
~).....(3.,..._~... Le........,1h
.... _...... Li.ii... ,..fL to "' tU.
3..!tllt.t l'ttlll""". ttr. ,.. '.nll ,. ................."'~i...... .£..n'--...ll
a.1tr8C90' ,=. t.tr.i~"t .DUN1...111.........1:;:....... ..IiJln.n:~.._....... .....'1...1....,...... Pr'''' ....,...-'
*"" II......... '"' i."r~ . L.s... d.im.._ Is Sa ...ilin...
.. CIlI......iiaiLI.......JI$) Wi.......... .,...1,1.._~i.1"'jitl...WI'I.'1\ ~ _.._
....11.... ..I' '.fl.ra..ÌI'" MCeliuUaryør'-. th..II"CI.. ......... tn..IM..... ..~....Iti.... '...lIs'III..'II..... ..Ifa.n~
'.C....U II. ...... ....alin'-1.... .......... in -.......... Ì1..11...I~.......rs M.I~".."'wi
m........ ..\I. uJ8 ...... ...... s. ....,.)1. en
fill"." .n....".......in...... ;t ins......_d..,......,.'.."_reli........ L..iii...i,ii...._.........~......Ii.lnJIR....iAlI.......l,..LIII....._..lls......q..~......c.........'Y.. ....... 0....- Ft.....(llO._..1." .ii..._.. Nlli.It";....... of ....,.....1)..............L....r'...Wf..... In adlt....... ........... lIes,I"" iRdi. ..__.......
_.....1..... . Lu... .. ....iry ...si.... in Cl........1~i....,........,......11,......... ~l.lllr"... ..blt it. Lii..... ",_l.II.'-" .. l.....wi ....
_..... ..............'.i..I..., Lei... ..........
S.i.1'Ppså' "......" 121:. i(.....--..~.........................1.....--.............,..l1..'."'.....IIIA 5)1....... Liii.......
2Gf- LP~XIDP_
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 4
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
............... ........... ...... IMcr,tat .nn....lWu..... ....LUIIl...,..__., mii'
l.2 . .... !nsnlf¡tur tp'? t...e . . ilL............BII....._......lllt-....IEI...II..'......,......_..dii.......ndilliulin.....,ufin......'.'..id..L..._....... Ji.lflliflll..ILlI........'UI_I..III........
_1"'1011."11"11..111. t.. llhì.fa... ....LN.....
..,.ù......ct....ta.iiul............uJJ ii..,søøf
--fMlnrGl.lu,ia...W."I.1 .... II' .11..................".... lNrI.....,.....llin..on..... Li..ee Cl lÐ ...1.. aI ill. en... on t.-.. pr"....
3.3 "rrl.ef.nnl'"aner..Luu'..~..,..slv......111... ~i1... .... ft "PNe.,_..._lllli.............1., ....-ac..Pl..I'....Ii.....
CJe" -..... ...... .
Less., .,~"'''tO.'' ,.~ør"'.'" ..pRM-..t.,.~.(14)fe....~ L_....~-..,.I.I......RØuplh~-..I'.N~.ape.......I.¡ . .-1..,......., Le. Lee..e"~
WI. L..lM8i C'.. ,. ., lMs II...... ...... hi"
lI..p"" øt....... wtlPp.. .. MI" UR110l1l~......... hit..... Pr...or.. "ci~
... Su........ ...... at l!" Lui.....
,. _... ..,....1... .......'111. ~........
3.4"'~£lmle.*''' Llllee..IO....,....IIR_...nl$.,."ll4~Ar....il'..at...IO...II..~.
............"................... LelSllif
..ta........ CUi. ....... ..çlrn.-øfwi..........'.11.11............:1..1.,.,.. GCØl.....s.................I.._......ce..EI.ri....111_1..... .........1.181..~i..,.... tl .iiib"'~
LIs,,"..EU epi'......_ ..p.rt. le..DI.....__ pI......
.......,........,..% w.. ........1'..IQ".II'..~.jf............In_....Gfan.......1i1l
-1111121. ."'..11. _.u or ..._nt to li lfildi It .~ Ql ."~øt...........is.....Ir_.,..~orf.di............_..II..J..__._.~..
.., ...wi...lni............ ...'.. fm...~
............. 1111 E 1.'......"i_..ll.Dt.........,..11'.........
~.$...11''' , "" ?t....l&utlnl..fh..'....,
1.........11.11.....1......... ...... .... ........
PllJepWof Liiii." .. li..,.. 1' leu.. at.. "'lliiu~t tolll.3...
4. ,.111 ppy.
4.1 eir.1.""'.0.? zngfç "'O:P 3M?R.
3.e - L! AO nG-on..
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
PageS
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
....1..........0. ..ci.d...... c..âeOlllil.il DI
i .u.. .."'_"1".' _., _."0f DlUiindFM ....I....rstM...............Jl1..,....,..-........
".2. '5'=1.....'1' lIinI1tl..I".................,...... ._"'_""'.II.I"Dk.JI$~"'''fl
'1111111 ...IJI .U.I,...("Rl~ ,...012 ui ...
OP.l..........",.,....... r Iltt............"1l..~...._. if.,.... lU.U.........Ii~....
().ll....,.'.... i..,. .... ..__in.I.... Ul .. ......
,...,."....1....11.... .._.n .111111'.,._..__.."""''(i-i..... lR1i..(a" L.......i.. .lii".........L.............,. ..ft.............,....1......" ...............1... .... (l) "...-_(1)~ra.t'" ...Cee......Qp.. Lii.l..lI sh,. Leiiia a,..J.....Ii..'".Ul'*.....,.lN....~o,..lan 0* ........is...i 1st IR eaye ..11-Qi.._..i.n................... lR......
L..... iula...eln..........IR.on..PJ... L..........,~.
...... 0."' r. II DJ ..,.00.01..,.. .. _fQ .s'''1I .. "._II... (N.........i'..,......lIi......repn........ i .IIIR_ ...u=....,....._.. an ...ID"" .,"'.eaIIU'n.........I-... ,...T.... ..1.-. In.......................A..(lor.........._....o.Llin.......,..,S.' U." Leiiii'" if ....1\i. . ..sli ii.. tWA..,,..,.. -.iiIn'. 0l J1.. Di($1.-." ...... wltØ.. -- CIlalltl "" .1I1l"""
.."... .Atll..lln..~.__L...Il..S.....ld-f ,.nA........_85...,. 1_..__(l_si.~.".""'iI'el
.. 0..."111,,.. ("111 rnlirli"'U.Ae.Fo.. n.ilssi tf 1........... ..........iils.._.................
""'niiry ............ ,...1.. fM. th NITeref
...~ 1l.....'.....ønR8_T..ill..I"" Li....
'C..... ....,..... .... .,..
4.l Dld'7 ..1Ft . if"''' T..fl.. ..1iAt ".fl
....1 ...I.........,......III...d~............"11......11......,..., c..n.r.,.......
'.ili- ...r"llil.....c...n.IF)W, L.............,......I.....1... ..1..a........._...,..Wi..l'..............C..ii.,..
..... n F 'sn.'rørrwnmr,p..:o'! .-.11tl...... ..fIIJi'I.I...._...IIl..(2~in,.1.......1fCi II.'.. pi, . ............ ....(3",) irJ8 ...... Wlf
C. 1...._......._.........lll.ftlif.yi11....l5Gf
OI...il.,........._......li..lln,... ..in.-.11 r r ,iint.,..... _,ii.1l8f........"...... ....:......'&...IIIr.. ..li....
..,.........aI...........wi .._raenfli..........
-4.,..laÄ..~ UI.1i XJ._
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 6
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
....,............i..ir..' ...,in..............ee2).......... ut a_'.. . .......111 i........
....IIiIi..hllll.....Il....ln..,.......... . ........._,.,.....i.,..........,........rto
..11 ".AI..It................._......Llfd n...._....".
................,... ....t............. "G.,.....
......di..'..s i.. l).... ............. .ii._....~2J....._....Ir......Íl....Ib..._.,...............,.........................
øø.iua............. ,...... ".1* __if .Juies.en""
....... ...IIl........... ".. ".IIIA"..I; ot....;
..t.... ...~ .... ....,...ut.............._.. ÌI C8ra..11i "Lii...'. ....øn.. Pler5)--".11.. ..fawh ... 'llared._ AØ......ft(illnø.
...a.in...toa....,... JUdlal.r.. ex..,......__.l!:ll"lI pe en anddllJld....au ~ar ~
,... ll PIIi. ...... le". ..... disiltw-'.",__
ut... orfr th... .. ør __ 1I1l11'" of _of Leeiiie'søt
lm.dl.. tr.... ....l .... ì.. i._Jiii; 7) .... re. ~
,.,........,. re.MI "Y Li.... in ei fO Le.......I...
.,~i". GI... ....... or an.. ofLlsiSI. in lI L.tel)'"
ofilet*.. gea...,..... .. .._s no lo.ed ......ii,;orl)........lvdllLI.....IM.......liilalæn. po._~.
4.4.f L.........tcLe.....Ii.........øfel-" .._d ...M_........ ca fI..s~re1i.....,......r.1I III ~. "'''.(1'' __-. .,.....,..
e."d.. J8te.. _'I. ...- Leiiii', ,.....'..~..Le..tW.. sti...... th ,.1",. Liilli_lhle.. kesi ~
..11$1'I~.......... tt Net.dI tø..1h l8 wiL11Iee'S fØ.¥ICØ."
4.S. .t: t ("""i..e 1.."7Ptt. n.~~_...
...........,..........'..'7' .4.1 It..I..............
li ....uNs... "lesSII" in.. ep... wi .....
..ut. 8~ GfTWé.(2lM on th PI\1l.~.. TI P_....~..
..th.... IMIdi II ,., .......,.or te.. 20 lM. llPr
....i.....e.........wi .........Pf'e... .MWis..
... N.... iUs" tc88.. PPA(Rf RøMG.Aai.......
-=I".""".8I1r. I Lis. II ill." ....... ..............-
iÐ....)...L........l.".... ....in.....C1I...d.il.. ~..Mam_fIcll....fGif..PMl-
~ cMfl
5_1Y..I.A~DG-_
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 7
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.... $sIFICI"..
..I~....1 .~.'1.....
Ce:J 2........,.........e....Ef*l.. UlOp."'"CG..li...~.
".I i.........lU tAl .'d OM Fe...... .t-"
i..Mn St.'II1M In......,...~-.__ fo.~.£I.""d,.Qldi$2ØO.-e'd Op..;..in~fN ,.....fi.....ldIR Re .1.~S"'OR ÑØ."¡..lof..
T~I'IQfl..1.GØ."...Nt...Re ....Je..ii lAiiønol..ee..d.n....un..:I lwallJ....~_.~......,..'CG'-T...ILi.¡.lJ .~~..ii Ii Iind.
....3 --..~If~Ar..Pe.._c...ofoi..eo......Of....AIlI4.i)
If ow.to ..
Cllin d..,.......8h "'Ií ..IiSblIi.n.nl
s. lrsaoiwrrnrnf. Lllll........Ii_Mc...L.uCl.i:." "S ."lJ Ef~
5.1 C..p....i.. I................ .,........
f....wI........._.... ...II...M___-_."
1Ø.'1 ..M ....._.1..1.. Lissi.~s.."_ en...........,....
5.2 _ .1ZO "1,.. S.. Ql21..11 .Lii... ......I..8Ie..I...,.....m .............iin__ I'p.it ..lílll..L.......
60t- LB ~ XlG-
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
PageS
Case No. PAC-E-10-OS
irllllhn"ln '....II.""' ....._....... ..._.li........ '"U.IiUI.................I.m ....
._.1 .1.11_....11...111 ,...u~....._I._.."n_..lI
,..........'..'.....1'1,.. Liiiii...................,
......i.i.'....i .t'.I.IIi...........i" .1...11.. In....''
,.-._.......... __, ....lir.......si....LI..n."Pr..",.
$.3 u. 1..... ....l.i..........."...."'.......................--....,....._....111111.
.'.1. ..................""1.'" inC...c..1I.. Lun......,..,.1,..
5.. .. Ui trlSi'" Fl.. _. ...........WØt an.. it.....'...liEIEi..-..I....i" "Lis...d. ..........~~ tt ør..111"..,.."........ .in. .....-.ida.iorhl.nerehi.." I...... ..IÄI.I n. ,....... Stili_.... dalü. a.. ..Ill..... "ei' .... __ne", ..11. "t ....
...... .. ,..... in.. ..1..le fill.... .. or Ir ta. at ('
QUII.ac OR or un" ""11M). lN Se .nø~ .~._.."~.I,pli"'."I5""" mlJ8.. Clc:..,....5.
5.5 . .".0"'.. Le...... 1n.....""..eol.1Slfl'....L....rJ.... _Ii IUILIIIIr'~. pa... ..i.e.........,I.s.....i.~..~..lllt.,~...........di.II..... el'..ses..iøl...U.... ..ør....-~.....iR ....Cl...l.nl..dl..si....~? ~..,ne...nt.... nll...........llÐflelil.or.... ~.iR **-- fÐlessei.. Ci 'llJd........ Lees.. 1'~
.... th ..:i*1.......~ Th in'Biliiáfsh aø...
.......IS.di ................__.-ltqp;lsI~_..ul. .,....lIill........,ÜI...dPa.
$., .. kW_.I"II........~ti~...-
N...SOf..,.,. _.....ll...~.... ....$l............~_..In..MdT..MlDø
(.,.....~ .~ li ........ lI.".llGfa
Ii.."",
~....BI8I. Lees.. .llll...lM..............ii øf......l.lØ'lr'II..,~
5.7 . g..nnrll'tpnr...' E ..in................ Qcl.,......_.... ...I..........,lI.........c..l. ...lO.,..i....r........u.............,....,.Qt..
".l....L"n.......,..~1i .........,L..~,...-_su _II... __1M.." ø..Ql _0*,1 ..-...,......................liWI..
re.......ii.....da.i..... or "1st ..... if.....
1f.........................~ ..all... Pa,......'" l.i....._ fl...."I.=-_ Us.
7427v. LI AGI XlGD.k
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 9
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
$.1" , ... U......... ..........Ut..llll..
.....13...nlil........"... Lin........,...............lil.........II."'..L.I..I....' .......,.........".,........11...........1. ill....."'il..._prlnl.I'tl,.IiIU..
...infi. ...~:..:~II;:;:I=.~::~-:=::~I==~ef.....1...' .,..._... _..... ..m...li
".Fi? nnntS Cr 1 iin.,."' ..,.......ânlilll....
111;1.... ..............111.111. ..llllll...... .....
...............1 ill' cll..'''..OIuni...q.....
.......lli.'.8......... l..lliwI......oRl............ "W"""""'LII..r ......llck ........~.
~i~i.." .......1.111........ ....1,...... .....
5.tt ,.'alIORU., L.a... .,..if......_.~'..r........e...........,.....QRLI...ot....'lrlW"....I.._....to-.~..e_..bo...,..
5.ta. t't::.. i........no... ù..Diå uecill..'IIl.Tl~.. .... ..............~_............'.hli "'II...... CI.....wmli....l¡...lD..,.......,._i..ùs..._..............Ia....in ..._............lpeef... ."an
.... ......u.if.... ..lIit....
d. .' .nrCW:: i.... . . .11-- ....... ............fGl....,II=-t-1)
8.1 ,pm re tet ti.l..... --er....II........__.I...Il....~1ò 11......6I....
..2 'ifnrtJnupli. ..1...............,'ttIÇ....
_.__..EE..*'in.....I..,.RI......~., ...it..... E.lr_~..W..t... ..,........__....,.... ..._..inc.CG. ..øh..... Pt._i....
.... ,.... ....'III.R"L.............. .......ulils......... ia.lu t ... t4 ..,..... ~.__..
.1'..,.........1.. ...... lI,uatliiWI c..."..... is
in nl....._......,.. .... in EM ç_ no....f.,II......rd.... Ile_Iilal... .._AO..~....
..'.... ........ lì1l_..I.. ftil...............
mup.i.........r'..._. 1111..... Pnp ..... .......~i ir Ià C
1.1....... li.....................,......PI,.tl...$plc.ld.ÌlettnC.lli.ee..~IBI......II.................. d.riltl......ß...I8Qf..Ç....~....,....._.......1.... ....T.....-......IIIØl.. ....JI...... ""...,....- uø
_l....... ..........1~i.....,....." L.....
......t.AØ.xiQ._
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 10
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
..I.....II...............=:. . ...... ... ,..Ual OL.II. .......ilui....
_......".....~... ..... ... ..iaii_in; .......11..). ..F..........................G8......føel.......PrI'1'....T..........III.......1.. ...n.,..... L...ii....l.llll.....(1...,llil1.It....,.....,....&._..lI........11.711..11111.........................(1"...,...iea 'lin '" Lui II
U rt" 1 ,.......~..Olf. ............111iRk' p... '1IlliLIiIU...........l........
........ ..¡.,.".. ..Il ........ '.1........ Pnlf.. lS..,.................".. ...ii~d "ki"'~"" ,.CIIIUiì,..l.' llllllll..me........
Pn.... ..~i.. ....... Gr....aldl..S...II..~IJÏÅIlrl'.1.1,~._...ru~..~._..~~......._.,1.i1...,ir~....Gl..~ i.....~.......~fo_.........ac.. ..WI..IFIUIMp.... .llSnls us øflh ~ -f* ~-~er~in"Wfil""''''wf''__''Pr.Le" ..~ ..... .... ol ri Wi reto.ll. Pf-... ..iR "Lu....s ....1_ .1O.... _følif..ll.......lIsø ....CØ.1o wi ~ sw......
.. ..... ,.... "..... sh.... ri to I... SC...",....,..,..1,..... ......QO.....,
iiR$..utv~to.. ..._ pe.
..3.1Q&".'"rRrm i Ii i.~. ...........lD....~_........'..raleu.~............by
pi. "'1I1'IBU"'R.llD~~.. ~"'ls..toami.....1_~..U..I.......~..Ne......l.1S.8.$
us of'" Piq....... iÑ \t pu at......... dLllii...,.lIu....'ie
1.3.2 .1'.. .1.5"... ....i......ì__..t8l11n...,..,..'.dJ..~re!l.......~..~.."""110 .,...__.. iR-... "'''_leI~l;llillli.iR..''PP
l. .tt UP altn . . Le..-... MeShin.~LII.I.i81¡l..,...lll.bJ¡Il~_..,~,.,I.l.....~,Gl.~'..~
".lthal . ..................." us......lIe.......,.
r its In...PUIL ...,a_illl'_ ...S...... ..Ii.............
"..lFa .'...1111", ".....iii.....,..., ....Dl..IrW."t.~..
.. ..~. " aRE ........ 'pplc..tefl......II¡...
................ Th Sdi8MiiR...lrHhe.......'...1 Ii .".c.....".i......i..ol..... "'I.US...
1.5 lltldn........,~~......_..ml'.LI............ . Ih..I.'I....L.u......lJ..~
...'..... ...-....1'....,..... ai...n. ...n..ii.PI
I424 - LI AO Xl
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 11
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
J.............O ..1, .I.ìl.... .....,..........11..1.....
.............,........ ..Liu.r....".,........,...........'-51.. ............Liinr......... ."i.......u-. .ll......dtef....It.."u....
lNi ',i..ulsn...._ ",..".Iin ..... "f
...21....,.........11111'... 1111. 2 '1IT.'.n.......lilI...
.iu.................n'.....ordl..,.ad.. 11'll1n.....
.,..1.1.... ...~i..,....
l. .:1.1 "1.1.1 n..... ..~. ...:::.=. . ...iI...A.dlll. ... ........... ..... ... ... .. 'lOr...... c,,' id
.Ch.. Diii 11 (l.l1". . ........lM..lRlI..
..¡s......isir.... ....................0.......1.
...0........ ,..111_ tt...I..'....... ...,.eftll..Ö
.. lI.n....... ind."" Leiiie .... ' .1.1 is inn 118i&l. F....DG(l.-~
7. FM ..p......." g..a z-
7.1 .. fil1r l 'n.L...........ri .*'"'Ull"l'..
...... ,.. ,...PI'.,...... ...Ln............_.._...l1........~. 1..,_pø:r..1.1I..itJ......1an1.. i I.... ...l............m.ilrw..dJ......
,..........,.... diiid: 1f.. Ir UJ L.i.or......
...........Pi...i......... Leii..""" 8U NI"..1111................. ........,.Wi.Lu.lil.......-
1.2 Cz $ =f:flll!:~.. ...L........t..anot..i.....d.._d..~V¿;:._ Lune _I .......1.1..-
Dslii., ............8f.. UI",,,les llfG:
(4. ..,............................ri...øf.._...8....'I1,..... __._
...UII.t.' ....d 111-
M. ~'''d' .1.............-...........,..lI.,LIIUI .........._ ...............,.$1..........'1'. ........it.,-........."'Ln.......
M IfLt.............tt"..........it.......iilf..._Ll.'...i.......n................................."...-.............,..,....................d.....iei.ir.~............ ì..ifLI....~......... ..li...~ u...... -..th,...:1............ .....to..SU.........~ ff..øf..Ii.I.liof.....~lf..
....... __.. li ..IJV,inl.....pctlb..efa ...1...........
L......L..nr_..".......III....n... ..,..,......u.................iPL.......prlp.rt. ~..
104X7", LItslDrtD()._
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 12
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
........I...i.........I..ttf..........r. ........................,..11....11 b ..5..t..........~i...........__...........,1......_..........._.........IiTJnn.............
.....,.'...111 ...................,.........".........-U...,....AlíMt..,ti....I,..._W.............r_..1..........,........
.... ... .......... .........I..lnLUI..1111....1............_..........'.......,.1011..'...........l._LI......lI... Li...r .".............
........ ..............Mf_...... 1I1d)fr..........ii ..in................ne...................,......be~..........._.......føiR...... ~llL.II.....
....11 Bill fl. ,ed.... pftothailicwaR de'oUhe..........
(.) 1'.......lsf.r.,_..~iR.....by.8f
.. MG)1gTI...... ...U.......,1I1S.....I.ofLIIIIUlljan if........ ..'..... ...l\clor...ltiø~,;
8. PI.'TN ,. ..
8.1 D'" .........11.............D........,... ..... li 'er 77.2.... lD" lIl..-.
,..II... ..,..it..,......._ ..nii.... ..Idale.....
.~ -n,...ti.II...,....lo,....~.
..li ...r.....1f .....Flsh_l1 ooi"..~("_......._--~(I ,.......iilI.."'........ ........_...... ...,..~_._...ir_...__.......i..n..ø.a....'*(3.............UlI.....
.....,....cw ...... ...111.. i.....fa Ðr ends.'m C811......._.......(3_~....ne.....
..fL (I
(a ",..... ,.ich or .lUiil.tilln&ø......._.,...Un....._..juiI..._an~.p......~
.....I....."'I.......,._.......Bi_lan..1W .,
11...11........__..._... si lI .....
U .11" I. ,; ."". .II......ØI_..............__...ûii.r.....(l"'...'............'_. IIM_"'''.''..' la ,......ilr.,...~iR wN....nat..........._".I.U....(J.....,.~.....rI ~.._...s..~..............faiI... _"IIl_-nt.... ..",lelilOef."eu ...... ~ ..IS.fl.... .............111~i.......11....,.. -li. lf
....... t "18' .... .ii...is" .nlSl.' ..1.tMllD18I1....
114241 - LE AGR XlG-
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 13
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.......,............,.............if'e ..11..I.........inl.....("T........,....
...1 dJ .niiii....._...ir .......,..EI'.l£it ..IFLI........
JR. l" .....L.Ui" -..... ~i.1..11.... ..... ..$3.......1.'.. ........,Llll..."....Io.III.'.. .........
'tit ... ~....... T. il...' I....... _... II"..... it 11t81114l'....I..............if ....lTl.18t.hlitl..
1. . ..=.".." mil, .Up...it 1.........llof..... L......""I1II.1;......_I.1 ..'........4.,
...if... .mil..... de. ..-....0.1...........
.......... .............. L..... ........._.....-~.........ip..............."..._...,¡ .",11-'1,~i'" .............IiP."'.......b.I....'............_..($iN........................liei('.....mn........IMi.n.........atL..ll.r..._....Iri If............Sl.. .........180daof....IIDfof.............. .....1...... .... .Ülto..IICl" r;'........ilr..II'...,...In....,......... Leliii. ..L...........1U PJwiøn~. ei(11Q.......ll...n......... It.... lIânalPJ
.........".,,""........ .....(1....... pe... _...:d iil.,'ii" .UI..i.I..... .....DJlqUi8f.............g....no..au...I.........L-.......... 11 a........ lJ
1.4 . 'rEI fIr .. If". .1... L........i'... -...........".P.ttIlN..... _....tO~....fc.. ..... _...1 ...11... .... II....... elallllt., ".of..............fI."'L......
t. . .. ..... ..... ... ... ..11I...........l.n .ai...,..Il.............1 llJU.... "'...m.nRC. ....~....o..r,.............."...01.............
,...... '....n.,.. PrP..... __...._ L....'sUl. .........11.1. ....n.II........"........ Al.....11...... .iil_Of__.......Ii_.._...be.....~~.,.. L..........".......,.. ..to"Nln..I.~_r.. nil.,.. fi.. ..4..1......... L.n...... ..,..... an_
..__........."...L..... ...orisi....nø..._..............."'Lniii 1.....1.1..1111..
JI.......... ..,.............. L....IlAD
........ iag ..........................
...... l¡...III.W ......
'M. PI l' rn.
ai "'1'1).-0 t p......._-......
......... ,.in.' ....lI..,....II.....'ed I) fll.....,"" ec
fI-...... .... ........., tose ftitii.. "'..
12.....i...AØØD.Q...
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 14
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
..................1.... ...............,........,Ii..............,. ...........,.....
n.lbl..II....lI........fI....... 13 tfl..¡¡.'...i....Ilillan.....
tU J' , Up......_..ntøf~."..UI...............'..iii.ir.........................
.... ......."Ibi.id, II_ __, ......... ...rs.........., ......................._-,......*...................to......11
.."....._..........le................... Ìl....L.u...... ....... ....Lllnl8hre a.,uir.. ....'I.......IaIJA.- tU..........q...l.....I............~..Il~.WI.re.to..i..i..ii,........._........ii.: (i ....~Shnø..~...,.. d"~-.......... ....,,-.åUWålGflh
... ..........,.ltar (iM asi.......va.. *cI .....~i.. ....,Ì1 ia.... ..laf1O Le._...... ..........lIec... ....cf...... l....øi $l...... ...8I~. or....,.orål._....__........"..tt ......_.~..Iri_.._i.erer....~.
..3 . . Itt! î .1 ..NA h..C..... ~l' otped...in.."..III...I1III1S.... un..'... ~~..if~ ..."..,.... de....~~..._
àY'eist.re....".. .NI..~ _past... Pf..IISJII.1llo"Pa..satli~" ISIII:
I..."gt...R.....~AI.~.._yP.O."27........1...18 I$
I.' 71(1,.
XA- DP LLCde Ew De ili,n-- LL
8& W." .ø. ..120
Id B .,--..c.
411n titXR - DP LlCfi Aïi .in I; oi Pl
51S .. 'Z II..10 om
Al Pe Ai..
1342 - LB AGI XlG-.iø
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 15
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
.......,1..111'.........................................'......1..11.. .....IkIÌ... ...11......l'lml... ................lNtl......... ..__.........~.....,.r .1.....11............,...........................~i.........'7 S ..
... .,.'tn..Ea....................,1._......,,_........""1.........11;....
...,... ..."5............... ""IU"t8'" .lu'...I..
....,..,.........__..... ....'nnfr......................11.....' ...sl__.................
.. £l'........ ....111,... ..1_"'., MI.........,..
........ ...... '.UUtil".'" Pt .rt $0 ....is...__1f1I.,..,...Aiil............... JI......I.... ..(~~..Jlliptfl... ......~.81.e 1.. (a.pn.~....fe............n_..........GI...pø..
......,..............__~to ............PM
..~...I.."¥.. I~..1. .lJ.......I..~.._lf..~
_........ ..........'1... ..11(1 fo.,......"~...".."" _,.,~i.... .......faLI....'s....lll'..~..ef..".II........l.IICl "Y-~
...1. '=l~I ..,..........................t......_ . ..(1f.,.....~_....
...I..I.....uh ....................pe..lI....i__...... "'112 ardll......... In U fUanel(e "'sd.........I..I.I$),N__.M1...........~.....-..........................".....
11.....'.. -..-.Ji................,..........iß....&..IP..,...I'.....II"'-.............~..........""_II...At.........4....."'.....
11.., QPIJØf mAr, ..,.......ci.,..r.......... ....Ó.II.IiI-.-....I..-., ~.. ...ir.Il.,!..
_... ..1..1... .."...1. II.. RO Mil......"".. or
...... ,............,....,..
1.. :'..."..lin.9' .,....~.IsI.I.....I.
Cl.... ....... ,........Pl..... ".,1
iet .....1..................111..................01...
.....,.1.. .ti-... ......., ...orel Me ."..""or
m..a .Int........."...".... .......'" ......... ..fÐ............,....IB
..t ... ..r fl.. .,....,..1..,............................_.....,.....'11_.......................llIFa'.........".
'.lip..."............In...., tl." .,. "..en"
144J.. UlA~ XJ.d
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 16
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
......Ill... ........faC1 e...ld.....__....._..1................
1'.101' itS 11..............,.1.1_.,..
~....J... ................c......_...-_................ .'.....~.
10.11..._ sa . ...,..orll.rsa"_..~...1.'I..lln........I....Ii.......,.............,..1 "....1. ,....,,,.. ,.lllor..Ip..I~øf....or.......,.....i...'I.............iUs "'iF-..iia......-ll..... .....fI......,..oøøf
.. .........'\.. lIr.e.11 toN UI~""tlbJ 1t.
'1:1'2 ..eg .,. ......~li~iI_.QIKl
UI.........øi...... deem ...c:...... tI'M................~........~
10.1$ ....fw lb,.....paiR..aeør~fo....... p..I--....I_..._dM"riør......~or."."" IaI.løf..~......ldtoJebn!.s~..
..........ìu~ wi su... ÐrI'IBlltø............ .
...11 lh?',m. .lbPa.I....I__~.~of..Le~in......lch..._B.
.Wt~. Le....Lesle "._.Il...~. øf..fh.....
l I.lar:J.R ..,let ce..
.". 3à~Laa..Prl lill _ CE
111~i..:XR-ÐNLLC_......-..."
~
15CM - I. AO XlG-.åe
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
rOZ6
..C.I.11OFne .....t
l... "".".i.."".. '" .."-.i." ".1.,17. E"8E" lul.._..." I! "WI'" ,.,,. ".....ft., T... 1'1.., ~ 2J EMCl"
.. Miil Ii n....ca 0I. ..
1.4Ø.-~AOU.lT~
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 18
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
Errf 16..1;. st.,.,,.1R
;¿tl!
"
?~\ ~
~.."-.~-::;.....',..,.'"
:./1..:.
,...
. ".."-~--~~,r.. - --.\
!s"
.... ..J"
;.'-.._.r-"/
'\
\(: -'
..:;~,- :
i
......'....... ._._. !
!..'
..,'#',
~...
.i~,~.-tn,'..
'. .)'.
r'Tlf.
. ;....?i.. ..-:.... ..". ¡..'
0-.'
~:~~..tI~
,:t.
.'~.' .."
~
..__..__....., .f;; ..
'.
/XI...w:"'"
'fi;;:~. :~::.
(0
"
.l'.~'"r.~/ ',..~,.
:117.v
.._.......-1,.....-
t:"'
-.-4,. :6
f; ......
..- /~'~,,~'~_~~ t
l~' "
I
¡
~,~' ~,...l
\:':
.'-
,¡~ ~/....
. -'.'~..~(
..
~.lt
~..--'.
,
.: ",~
~l~.!¡-: ~.
.i
..
.1
..,
.i..:
1,J '.
~..iø_~~-~..I~_.....Ø..'
11417v - I. AO ao.de
31.4846
~î1f'~ lJ Exhibit 1
NSS ¡;~~.i'A,G-E-l0-08
:L1R~.ì-A, --MJü~~:=tE::N
e;...~t-:(¡.'ttt).t:? ~... .. .... . ... .. ......... ... ...~~r l-~ u: ~UTT ..rt:..,' "',' ',", , _' ..4JE....'IO......CQ..1D tt~7 APR 2 fiR 9 18
....øu.cii¡¡.lt..~l.Pl'....... --.....-=......I.n
~_. '. ,. -" ¡ ;"" I;.. ~ l:/~""AI gF~dlÎû1;a..lj ~ø
.......w.,"'..........
".zrea'.'..uswr.' MM MiTlla:
'f~ .ØI..Wl PMI LI ~iíi.. .....-.... ...1.......~ -""Ulll. J. ll "'CèlAf~.
-- -.... li........... ri i....,.
u~, ~'~l ir ,_ ~~_
..:
A. .. øø..........................Nku.............irfli.. we................,.....
....,.. ......lIn.... ._111 illS 1 I.. io..... on I.........
--....8i...........i1..~..I_ediR' ttrA......... .....,........1$".. (f~:I.. n....,........"T_'l.....~....oø-.........~,.fI_.~ef~Op...., ..ir......Op....II'a.') ......., ..su.. ~........JJ......"&,¡ ..n.,.M........
-0...... Opiii.lin.............. --.....4l.en.. .....l...........eiii.. .IU" .OR" ..1............. ..,.....................ef..~SI.... lill&lIJI_." T... ...ll....... th L.iiW"'..
.......... ........it.... ...L..oI......t1.tl.lM....i....u.........C.,............ue.,.d.........
,............11.."..........,.. __...
..........,....... ...."ne.... At...
.11J14""."'6Mw.MR J 1I-'"
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 20
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
..""........ ..111......... ."'II"."PI.......'.II.fi..........
Lee.ii.
J. 1I$i."I..CIlIR
~ s"~~....s...
PMsh'l.. ..ce
Liill1lll:
XR..DP.M........,CD8A
~¿?!.~'d4..'l~'.
G
.1l11.........'MK 1ll...AlI'''_''Z
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 21
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
1mNMtM em SD
___ Dr.C.._..)
)
)
..
L"':ìi4.. .. . ...a.."".....,...:::~=-J.J'4..l'j'~~i:~~=
np 1 ..,1_....'1.......1.,...."... ..... bt.....",_..~Il.....__. .........nlcilladl.....lø.....R(l)........pe.). ..........fI..,æ~.....IU.I.d..~i4.\t''t L. Si-~~ ~ ~ p:r(~.d, ~O'fAll" ~d- S'~
,. ..
\\ Pt1B\.,'
~~~Õ~$''1..
"If ::i:))
BAt:
Of Ik~;t 'J .1107. ...... ......rei.....
.......-1_ -"_ -- /l L ti'UI. .. ~.es. Jhc~LJt~( . ...it.... -._..... .......,II.LrU.." .....ne. be..,.)..
..., "''*iifi Ul.....if.'.._ adculll,- _1M......111.. ..11..........c..l............................,.øn..Qr...eR ...lløf....~..,in'..d..~
1..1,
Ce."
)
)
)
IS.
_llfU_.....l..1U1P 'EIT -..3
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 22
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
mRC'
DRC...OPTH..Ml
. ,,,.,, ""S"'.14."'''''IE''8en 17, E"."III..n1....NE"-E~_"-W~."...."lI. T..,. ,........Vl8fl.... ,.uiil.n. CtUIIi Cø,..
1I11(l.."""JlMl 1...II.Ir...-.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Pàgéîj'J,
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
n TE.TOr m PC"."".,t
¿/!
."';l-~r'".t~..-:..." 'c,.
/./;--/\ -l
\
!#'.*..-./.t\~,.-/.
.,: .
i....
...-
J . ,).\~.. ',~
..'_.'..~....... .l~~ ,..-
.. - - "~:.'!~"'".._~..~1:~_..',..
,\.-
~ il "',..~~, -
,.' ,';0,"~.,.
(p
,;......u., -
fi...~t:..J ."",.
v
..1 ,
,J
:~
....:"'..(
.,:1
0Ì~"lt
~
."" '.~"'j-",.
...-....;
~"...'"."..
J
.-....,
I
..
l-"':.--~'- -",~:r"" .;
~~...~:.I. ..-~
~...4~C"~~",""'.U .....'..
11.111............. MFE 1.11-""
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 24
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08"',..i.JYK A~ IXSI
TlWi PI!M "Ilia. n Ex.iii. II ..... etfíiel.lJ......1. R. Så ,le C..,., (" _XRG-, LLC ~e"~,_
... Clft l'1I._....lMth......iW.t1 i.. vr...i... 111....1i1h....M8I4,2e:
Th,..... a Wi PI i. AlI'8.en.. ..14,. CltwOs ...OptiAi........".efitMl i",*,,~Ði Th,. ....,-..... ..._of.... C_L..Of....,........
..ii.._ ......, .-1h. leili. fe ad.. C.i~ Oi...11...-
B~u.....~....S1tll.i..C....-..w..mi,2010.(:. ... ...0,..... .f__llllIhCO"'ef~oflh
....-..C.......is.tl asfolkn:.l) thde ofi ~Poworhtd .1.._Wiau'.cubutityl2)tb~ot'~~~.'II,. a,... lP- MR de th ~al ~ da3) ~dc~..II ..i.a da."._. ~toCOiet th llje4)tñ llofoÎI
~.. fWdøee..,.ee,.ietoCOi..ll .~-,Sl._"_U11.. ef~_ imlat.Oltåsi.
NOWTlOR fo.~-wJc~. ..~_$ì~.of
Yl_.....w~l... Le~..to~tb VinP..i......iit.t J\yI, .18, ~ to~c ~if_"'''CGdibave
lIli".ey ....
1N~ 'f,.lM _ I. ea _tA~asoftbda........LI
1.I.S"..lIt('1P '/¥~ ß ø ~
.1)r...111: l """U' '.""1.
.
i.øs:
~LLC..~~4£
lu: ~.û.
NG A..wh "in =_. ~..:
xi(), LLCP.u.....__
Paa1&f2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page2S
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Wl.PMK Wli.MMIM
.....f'LflØ.. ......, (t .~.....II.I\I...8lef
..,...,.. ........, _....$..flJ~lt.$'h. .00,..n'IUii"~"LL..."'''._''If1nUU.'', i._Luul.....111..........._..11..
8E6t
A... .LI.I.f ~............l\lc..iid" ~~.lI..............II..._.~ iRM,rAr.r~"" (l'" if'.
S,. . ............ .~... hlPÅ..in...'ot
LI..........I". ir....,.....
.......,.111.. (-..... ..... tuill..~.
C. ~.....to.._ Lai.. "'''lflOB............._.....
o. ... Lii.i......, ..M.wi.... lø ~,..._.....~Î'...,...........'.._....a(2IMWGfWØ....
.. ........ Lii.tN ...'.nd.. .iA......... ..-.t... .._.........l;,..~ ~..
........ .. ç ., 7 iRQf,...~ flOQr . . Jr.Po
....... 0 t.. q ()eC) _.......... IYM........... ....."...Nt .~.llGfye.
NØ.1M......i.lt.. ....ill.~...... ~d
.._...¥IiS.~..eAØ1...~..L.u.e he......;!ß
1. .... L....r....I....L....D.."8l.,.~lø......
""Ins ...-..........,."'.8.- f8..............
".'i,nunt ......,...,.,._ .....II...lsi...l~ .......illi_.-- ............ "'1f 3.:....CI ...lI-....__..__......_.,..ilOi.R......Il~..~....
.................1.... OtIl""'''...I, _._lurie. if
..."&2.... ...II....lOøfrll Pt... .lIesded.,"r..U...
t.1.. 'Ii." 5JlnJl...Wrw" iL......,.....,......
it" .... "iuliR" ........... AS.. .... JI.'UISfl er
1.....LE.AGlD(i..
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 26
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
w,a'u.i.,.i.i ..iil...........,....... R ..... 'Us
.. '.N111'" ......l.l.ll.i..in......."'i' Irt.."l..'III_
.....11 I. ..IJl_..\...,.... .... _Is III.......,................_...1..'.. -....'iirt.1 J.
11 . i. ,....,..,....,~...........Di............(I,.....CGSI...I_L11fCit . 1....Ol.I...._"O.Ii.I....Op..._~GI..__...
..,...............,¡ IIIA~. ,.........._....~ll..,..........~i__.,..........-........Ii-$U..........liPt.......-i.....iif. ....,......''11........... .VM..~.. fal1 lI.....D8Ol..Temlì....Lliu. ....tolØI$U..OII...o,..lfllf.....ld ~...~t.SlI. fA"~....PJ)W.._~ -. Lei...........
....... PØE ltit 4 lei... ..... ...,1.3.
3. Pw 7"VS _.ei $X. Th..dn..~..J*14..Ii.
.. ..... PI ",.._ae ff. .. an no øI
3.1'.0 BY tin '7311 Q.r!PræertU...fWur.o.1h
T..Liii.... .......It... ..to... ........ce......
.....,.........."'.1...... ""'lrlóin _.. Of..lIplllla........,,.Lr..l. .dWl$... ....i..~fO..lJ.e..al.,......l.U.li¡n..PPA(S~WI.....~lf..føu..8......a1..........'....~....._....ii.in_...._ ....IR..~fl.s.....llfø......in.... .......ri. .inlNøø ...........st..... .._..d..I... .cM....'....'.....es.....n. ..iDII_" '''...fI.......es to ..."I..ElIA ~....lWi. ..1 , Ii.... ...ml.....tø....wi
mluUEIIElCe....'.. __IM.ii.. _.._.., .....yR~..J'_...1 ....fplZ..W.. noin"~. .I.....R.-..~......fer~'llijl.... ......lI~..........1... ø.. _.-.... ~ge.lrm.,II'I..lfil...n...l..............l...R.............~,..eí.........Ii.. Pl.I...0n~Fi..fI(1.,d......'111.......'..111... ..&tll..... lUl'II,"..
IIRIIRd.CR.......... Wll" ~s pi....,...."- .....l................._...it$PI_..~.._sp...~.,..
".UII". in...... "'."ØJ'_. MÇlIS.-- de.il itliin~._...... .Rt.............,.........,..,.. .....LIs.........tess.....,. Le........,..'e.......OR...
......... ÎRlc8....I..lIl. iie. ..1m lit ....._...
2.. -llìi\ AG:x.4
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 27
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
......JJ........................... ......-........,..lI....it"'i...............,. 'I'Z
U . 117$ilf:,.ror!nfli'MsrCl\OJI. in.......................11,........130......_....
.'ut.......ildl.lldi..nili......II...........1 lui
floz..1 _..... ¡.'¡IIL" ....."...... a..........1.....'....10....... .u....Le..........ì..nii............. iISilrt...I.........lii.II.."'...UI fi1...I.r...ll'fI~.l.................P...,. ....if__-............. .....,............................ ........1... U.I ..... ...1. ..... L...lir'JR'..
,
3-~3 'ann.larm Jil t 1 en $ LlI.......... ..~rief....~~Ir.. .... .... ."fi"'~ ...,.....an."'11,,""1.- ~........~_m..n$~_li......,............... L..e'i.. ~.fr"IQ_. ..Th
.........lIP.....IJ..C'l)fefAwi. Linii.._.... ..... i .. II,. ,... ....,........ to be ...il
.. ....... ............,... iyL..,or.l...iee_._...iA_..ef....ØRLI...rs~...L........,......11... f1..~.. "".,p ..... li un"'-!." ..... .'11.i..,.....lti.. en" PR,I.. ..,~i1. ot.,.'.II~..I:U".......................l..ll.....I."........_..i'i.........iire..,~.~.
...:ì~..=~ER5::...-:.:~':m:==....tr..Il.....~ll....__.. tlMdCGMn.LeiiieifA
..fi .............. Le.....ceofWi....................'.......D.....'.,..................Ii...I...R......sb_al~.."1111111.. ..........,..1&.."..........
L..nr. .. IIiUlll. ......l.s..... .,..ptlllfwØ
..".....Ih .... ..llrUIlI.fIl.al........SLI..4.....
....In...........I...n."".lI.c1ai... ........
.,111. ".11111"".U ... ...IM.............en...Pl..........-........PI................or.outttiii....,...... ..... ci ..1O..a..lM............ ......... ....,....., ...._fR..
"......... lIII...... eiillinc Lis."" ......'-Ili .....,.. ...,...
1.1 9 p 1'1f' t n ."'1 *.M,.lfl Ì1...U...........r\ '"U...,.....I'........... '.._,.ar...........p:1.....Le.............. ..h...L.lii.llll .....id. .. U...
... Pr'.'..1 UP",
4.1 M?lpt OM_Ita? FE 7 tFttfÇM'.2s . , ..
3....J.~~_
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 28
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.......S...............c.....O'..lln..L............i-.......o.n.II..FM....... ..($1.-'''_._''_ ....Jl ,. fi.... ,..l".. fR...
4.2 . n' .8i __.p1ilIdiMIII'.lrtei........
L.......,....La... __" Fø""lllnd Oøllfl(l._,._éf.,.1... ...I_..L..lfl..('..~. Me...c...9I....ti....llllp. ."lId"".' , n". ......._...,.................,...L..I....."'......~
o.'1rl..,....IIa.,...,. .-...11.11.11' "...'-..,... r-llølFl8 ... (l pe lM _¡....ul CIl.dl....
...1 IlUIL."" r. .. ..,.. piiiA". llQNalle...eRi'etsthAtii..le......,... ...laRM...__..dfe..,.,.lndw8øn...IIÎi-.....lh..~~1..MßQ_..
_(1)......~. 21'" or...Dl.t.as.....P!L......lA...,.....I....... ,.....th~0.... (J"''' ..fc ~ 1stlneaYf~"c.IfUllàl~ ÐI...l. RerlUÑltJ pM~.lnth......in..I_..Iliå_Jll..n...~.t.$J........ ..~ an~onTlS..f'.~ (I'.-.O€ ....,.. .... foP..Qn....SIS*"Øi rlUl.I.R.. Fe" _~""'."~.....be_...if...an...IR.... ......onor..~tO.føea..$J.....,......r........T..of..~In.........L.............IJ i8f(t.,........__rÐ
...lll............ ..3.__.i..I~..Ji....d..._l.la_il.liaR.it fi -II NA _II... "'ti.. d.o. ~ ~($1.01.10....... .1U..____'sd~~.......fe. '.&lin1M'" c......iid __ Lesfl 1I.I.ib en_A... --il a........ ..,(1.. -.~.-....d.d.".i.-.....rt....nil.i...Re. FG....h_....r~...W_~.....i_llI1M..~d_.d..fi~..twør
.._11." ..............,....._.re¡...Ter of
ti ..1l l'...... Re.. T....iss¡IRl. Rè..clillll ... .....1Ì RI.
4.3 .. i.re.eapnJl .....t..ofll........Pe.ri...(d......,..... ..~~.....................1111... _ li ........._ Clllnd,...II...
~Aln"lnlt....f:tl _,......,...~e...t....... ".a_MI .....II..,.;R.... _,..,... .....lì....,.........(.n...,..
4.4 A n tin"'.'PI., en ...=-.., . ....l1..~Pe_lill...-..-..~(2-iin,.1 ~...,eø...,.,cl Of........-. ........ ~(3~)in,. 'lW.tl1lfi
Cøiiu..Opit ..l ....... WlIf4.Ø)in ,...11..~ 1$.
ea... OIlI..llll.. ........ (5.ft) in ye1l..in EI1.1I1'.lIl1nt,._......d..~
...............:""CI re'........i.._i....._tl...._..._......._.........ii_..~.
..0f. i. AG XIGÐÂ8
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 29
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
....,.... .0111111 il'b'-illlcl..IU... .,lr.....tc:....'..d..~.._.,..lR.JC .1.....11I...........1.3'1....
..... ....11...........11..,......11.......0.....
........1..1... . ui..............,1..IUI.........d.r.IU.'I 111111.1.._.'..................,..........
..........i.m..i.. ...111.1..'1.........,.__
.... ¡ç ....IIIUilo: It...... ue.f1ua.._.liraMt...ilrllllí............................._......._.4...C.......I).13I.. ...................._......1 2..f..II......*II"..........__..
....,.....1 i.' 1111. ..,,*a .......Iiin .....:..) ,.1.-0........1.....'......,...........,..."I'UI.II'..I.I.IIlI.. LII.......iiUI.....PP..S)......._...i.....'hl.'....._,....~....... nl".........."'.....ier~~......
". ..q.."..,.IA.'ld..I,.~.........--.1R
.....;-....Id.......""..... ....-. cI... or....au.....U Fl..". ............nøt..øtll.IN....
.,.-- .......ll. or an ~..ç 7).....ir$'..n.lit
,...........PlllU...-_dlR 1...... iA .._ Li...i......._It" 1111...." ........... ø._ i., of 1.eli.........: I)...,........1. ..11.... ....-...1_. ....1"1f.._....s relih...Le....... ..ii. 1_ .._â'.
......1 l..s.e.,........lia..II..nøf....~8l
... ...1.. ..1l........"".......er...,... FR"'Ni"'''
""- ,......,...... ~t.. si (l."" ......... CJ ee
c"in.,._ ......" .1_.. leiie'" pn....on. Le......1011....... llllerttAleiiee ."leIS."''' SI ...
....... ....li............. ..,.. ~wi le...if..........
4.1.1 "fim '.'....e.. TMht..".ftlI'"
........,......,.II..WiR 't r . .tl,27C1ii.. AI'.I"'WI........'I..hll...L.......lr....I...........ií .,... .................,.1... Th..I1I1.........
........ lAn n II til'."". AW_. -. 20 MW. Th Pa.... Lli......... ..tfwi po'" on" ~ . aotl iell.........I.......PPA(.,l' Ro~ Po...._..oatti,..i.r. ILIII.I'"II.....me.... J...of~"""""
.... ......'1.._.. L..... ..Re ...8J...lllid.. fit........... ......._ef....1I cdfoiRll..
f8l4Cllr dlM..i
I4M...I.AIIA~~.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 30
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
4.6 SPrn ÇhOf Pant
Se 4.1 Paym Pr to $1.5O Beinng wi thCocetofEffDaanCoEndinUpoOpeCocet of CoODeonsseon4.2 la Re $4,OO Install One Time Fee(Stao)caøa
Land Re $1 ,5f in$tale Anuaian
(Anua)ca fo firs Commiit of
year ~$2.00 irttaled O~8;ØE.in~$Vryye quaraffiYeSuRent$1,~ta AluaaferinitofconTrali$1 ,OO aø Anua afrRefotrioinitof
Hoe coctn
MinimlJ..Rø.:;Anual aft
LancJReAnnU8.CQcentof~taRet &.eørdalTramionWne()ra orR.t initonóf~.Sê 4.3 Royty Paymet ffRoit Anl .,Perot Comencnt ofGroReueCOI~the QPtart
Miirm . Rent (s4.2~)aPbieto suecaleryea.Les shall paysi.êX toLe.adltl ret
5.. ~ kØVI1l. .t, cona. re ardwarttltøLeä$
fo as.ofthe Efcte Date:
5.1 . .~Yl l.l.L.shaUat all titncoil'atl mal
re$wilhaJlvaidlå. orc:. rule,reulåon and sttu Of any
~ntå ~. apicbl to L~$Ofôn$onâíi usôf the Plpe.
5.2 . PaYftet'rapancfOtr nb.. L.~sJ1I be~_ft
an inc in rel p~l$ le again th Prpeatbuto i.'s
64248v - LEAE AGRE XRG-P9.do
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
J?åge 31
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
inn.. ..lì4fn..".Ii.......'i......Ja. "'.... CG...."L......
..å..........fllII.I......."...... ..........rbl..) _i.... .i..n.......... ........_ it..'_
L........ m 1I._PuI,". Lii........................!
......., d.....¡iI'..'lln.........IJaI.le..... Lii..i.....
,....... -... -...., ...ct.......... ,.Lniilt en......,
.... ~.. L......... L.......,....... "....,.__..
.........................,.. ......ru.i..nu,..._.,.,...._I,.._ .."'...... iI ..d1.wlL....ì~.....f'".
IA Hi....1..'I.... ,................_......
.Lê..' d tll..-il'IIIU,.iIUII tI.."..~..t..Of, ......_.....lftl............,..øI .................t. 11........_..IiCIl1ln .. ""'en of........ whis till.. . 8
".pn. ....1..'....,1.1..... _I..... .. "'.l'. "t _...".,
....."""......if..__.all..fI... ........'......_.. ....PI.il.'l. 'Tie i$no.......,.,.........'..1. ..!,.c.'_.,I...,...,.bor~...~tø
he, U.
1.. .. .ktr. ... r Li............. .ei....l'ldiL II.".L....... ......d... Lt....".......... ...f.........,lILI" .a.............. .. '1i1.,r in....dhøI '..,.. II
tU.... _...s. ..ei'.".iis......... ..nm or.. GU ti.
..... il.. (I., lillÐfLISluon lePlIi...CIan ne...nt
..............- Il.. . lsi... or 8f _..in do
wøfe Les..e. ør(l.... of..~.. Le.... Th if&lei~..~.._.....Of_~ llirldRlhO""-
tel....UU.,Ii,.. .IIIIMIi..... ............._......_ini. ". ... .aø. ..iii" en"""" Le....d...
I.. tt7n1tLlllI......_..Ì1I_.Il~~....... ..............1..........1'...111"-.... ""......~.......'*¥.*_I.I..___In_I.lßfA.T.,..............,..se ii.lI .....II_.....Ade.,._ '1IllldDapd__......III...L............ ..........11.
...d....,.......Leiur..,..IIi.... ....1st
$:1 .n::=~??I7rl=:? ........1......'.......
.....1. .i..u.ny¿~... ii~ ........................,..L....................... ..... .....11'.._ en"PfI'....Liu.....n -".Le- 1A...,.. ....~.~
........... ............ ISI-'CI. fi........,............................I.i...r.....
........ ".._.. ...... ...lti.ck.. ".lfuq.
IS". "1S,.fl ................., ..d erdiiii..... ..........1..... ....(3.... no, ff L...ir.
74....J1..A...lIlCDØ.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 32
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
..1 m 3. tA.... ....eii ..........n........
-.1.. ......il....,..Pt...I............il....
.. .... .... ....Iin.... Pt..... an ~..I.. ..... '.1'...........
... Pti,." ...... .'1_ ...... _JII ''''Ufiillll aGl
.lIiun..... II.... JL
I.t. ., L¡...IlI.ln....._'...~le Lt".,.
.1....lb..11 .:1.. .., ..i.inm........"u... in..........1. . II....... ............ .1i1.."
5.10 F. .1.. Ct In....... M""I".. "'iM..lJsi~....nllIl.... -.. ...._.I.I.l....FS prlI"'......li............*12 . ca..II"'.............".....1f ......,.ilr....... ....Pftl\. L...........nE.le.."...-øp...........LeI...IiI.......Ní.....lIli""....., L........,. _.-..1 llIElS .......
5.11 "... ftlf'tqtl¡'LLellll.............:111...or............II..........
......."..11... "'.........._... rlfetbbGllPlel
5.12. .." 5 IF LA...ilh ne in.. L...ote _...
PNpllft. n. ......... __."1.. .,.1l if... tJ.,...
.-"'-' ....it...... ..ti........iøilll.., ..............._.. _.lUI......"............._.. in... .,..... iì....... ...,... LuSlst......
.... ......irl....i:.. iriii.oø...
l. .. .. .l 211Ft". ..i..'.n.....__...LU.......Slll....... DI
1.1 .. inuia...." ~iS._..(J""""it,,,,,(l..........."'1......... ..'i:."" tI..~
1.2 . I b...! C i.ii 1i1r..'he_f!g.IiGf
..,........_1_ .il...pz..J..,...di......~lt
bW.1i.... _.........,..:t..1.~...........-......-Le.c.~.....(J...I!...~....,....u....J..m.LIi... ..........._...
rll..I..LI..il.... 1111"".."')11'.._. .........1....
....,.............,.. .._w..tdC4IIIf.¡"'.\liS
'.li......II..CI'.I:......ini I.'.'.........."'..............108..... _.. ~...II.S._rlll...-.....-...iP.. _..fJ_....~ør..r..."...1........... .. ..t'.,..PI....,...,.... .&bCrlr""". ....ISE......................,...."'... *p.."..lltIC.Le..ee.. .1........I..III..ld
..... LIl.I. ..~r ....11111... ie 11I..,......lI9.....
....P'plfl. i............ ....T..I............., ..... Pm......,.......-..
.. ......lI.. .UlCidl.......".II..llÙliSI.
IG4 ~ LB Aall .n XlDP_
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 33
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
...................~..........n..' LoIl.III''' .iia ....,_....Li...'a........"iI.I"..~..Jl. ..an......
,.111 a.'.............................,....-....tl'....!"T...."tJ .."..lllf"'.n....
......III.....I_Ul... ..L..... ....ttl...........U...I._.....,.......................
'..11 .11 ;,....u.."u...iI..i..........'..llSf,...II.lftliti.IU.
..1 .Jet. ... ..... .-.......O..L1(.........~....
-'1'1 mi.......i.i........................ .. lJ................. ...,..11_....4........... pii............_..I1..ll_.....,Ii.._.....__or~...__.,..Li............i.. """'...or.leFl""
""............... oI...pu"..... _.I.ciiR
IInr1'.t, ..1......_'itorS... ....... or.."- ...li,h.~.nllii 11.,,'I . Q'. ...foIJ.a..IiJ.I.........lM............Pn--_or............,.. .-.,is ..111.,. . ,¡.., .....II'S UI.90" ,... ,.n_.8d ti..~...lI_........wn..__...~.lM........-. J.... er...wi~-..Pr.,....¡It............,... .Ini.. Ma.2......... ........................i..Ud......'....nllu' __. or..
...... ... ""1I. n.PwI.. .. ,...ii....*....
b."!tllI" "..........',. i_III...... CG.....ù2jl..lill¡...............
1...1. QI~..,~R.'I..~i:la....,..................~.._...__À.,hn..llllllnlJ
.... ."..11'1.".:4 ii..llls. or.............. 11-....
.le"JI. ..1.1i.nr.-.....AI.. ....... N eii.. ... ...........
__.. Pn.fW........ .. wi pu at _.. je ..-.. fAL..............
1.1. . ,.,=ltt,. ... ..", ...... it....~ YeI...ur,_ __w %qr.lA..................I iliiI.Rai............._'" _III øf..~.."...ii.."'....
i.". .ll.... . .., .. .. .................... Ifitc_..
.........Il.II....\l...¿..lMEl~........ t.....ui..... ...
...' 'ulMhl ......,.... ..........'...1111.....
".ila..i..III.....II...m........_., Mil... .........,. idi..........,.... .....i1III&....lnl..............
...........11.1..... ...s,p't................
... _..w ........... 1' Se is.. iøJI.........
_in..'" .,pli,'sßeflûil.".toiilJ." ..........
u. her' pt. ....in..ii.a. .... ..flUI1.....1 i'.tii..........ii Ii.ii......_i....... ......~ lI.
_....... ..'....'1;......... II' ......ili:L1lI.""
.""-l".Â.BI~_
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 34
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
taJ1tV ri ai1o, dam,c:ims. ex an ot liail telJ~
sole fror añing soouöf (i) any QPöf leøon th Prort. (¡¡)any
grol1l~ae or grnelltfalur to ac on th pa of Les or anøiels eI in dong wo fo Le, or (ãi) any brch of this Agret by L..
This innica sh surv th tena of th Agrent Th
inJl shano ap to lo, da,c:m&,expseanotli$lit
caus ei whol or in pa by any nelg or delib ac or orlonon th pa
of any Leee Indif Part.
6.5.1L.$~tøitmtif l.... U.~6.§ isca
at OrMiIIi~($1,QO,OO.0Q),.un .80. insuce po Í$.lnpta..wh.
Pfvi fogreta cøe. In th ev oiL, gas. minel exüonorexactes. COmeOlthPt byLeorotpa.~ ça.of.~$Ø$rêpötir1hCem lé$UrrSe6.5is¡n~.tcF"~MllQ ~rS
($5,OQ,OQ¡OQ).
7. En~;ReNot to~.
7.1 Biht to En. Lesee shl. haveth riht at ll. tietø~to any en (h. a 'Vag") all or any pa of leee's intre unthSAgte wl. th co of l.es. l. sh be pI. coofallsucagrnt be Lean ~ and all suchmaiBnadfo th
piof Slrily~no.deinsg7'.¡(Q). Les 8Qrethat suc
docnt ar th profL$$ end 1batl.~ll(eesuel'lrec
eoentiát$hH l"ot.~$Uc: retqal"Y tbPf ~llS$le'spror
wrn cot.
7.2. .. . ~føMoBé Shlé~~anyófit
inhøhd..pt.. insPQf!7.1 ~, i.~8h l.ese~agre
~n ~..at fo the beneofanY.Mort_as~:
(a) Th .PaWU nocaCè or ni thisA;remet't the
pri wt co of éa of th Moee, Which coshllhO beu~lyWihlldordØJa.
(t/. Ea...~stl..~.....fhl'httø cfOãô~..or..tbin
re1Jretobe~ by Leee un th Agnt. an Lerstacany
sue.ac.orttin peom by a MO.uhderth Ag~asjfsuc aetorthng
W8dØby L~it.
(cYIfi.esorihllb$e~toterrnaeih$Ag..lTcl"'tøål"unere deulby.t.~.i.Will notettAQ~nt~ ltli.fi.givwt no ofSUurire deul anofitintotein th$ Agrenttö~Ch~WhiC tiYere an gNe l.Ø$ Per$,.nøiOfMr~... in in i.ee'$~an ha givn eac$uc~$t~th
(ao) êlon da.. to curelldeult to prt such teti øfthi$~.
(d) . .In cae of th teinati of th ~mefasareltofanyde.lJotthb$~.inscyar ap~ otare Inbåøi for~, L.~lg..pr f'.toal(MØ~Whic ~ reandorgiv L. pef$n$riofthir..re ~lnL~'$pr. ~maYl
10
424.LEBAGRU XRG-DP9.dQ
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 35
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.... ..1..."'.. ,¡..alS .11....1.,...._..,..,..'1...
...,.'......Ull.......... ...._...__L...........~i.................11111'.2...........
.................11.. IE .~....I....I!... .........Nnttulfllfl, ruC. ............m.... "'elti "-li"'.
".I..L ...ss.,........"....arlf.II.......Ii.........._...._...lílr.,_.,.._.~_....__....u....... ZSlI...._........Jt......... ui1h..1.....11...._.......... ........1.. ...... lJ..I......_1........L..llr..L..IiI. _,.Lin.r.. .....II_~............tl........................_..."....I.fA...,..........,.................. .....or.....,.....,....
.......-........if...... .p.m..llli.....to..~..L.U..lí....._.. to.. ei..tiii,,'" _.............
.le. n-........raf....in..,...iwan
....61111................. WdCDOftelar;an r..110.......... .n.... AOtIdtor.......
I. g l"Ia. t ,$?!,
.1.1 n! ..&a............shco ....i:et
De" .."................U.. ....... ........
.... iJ ..1..,......_............. ....... ..11..1.".CI~
c. lMfø. iiiiiuii..liei... pe.... to,.......r...........or~_...~._..(3di........... l!
lI ,.....iulOìl .,...,.100...... ....,....,........._I.....__...........su
.... . shu".. .......(J-.fGSU..R1lun..ls..
....._......... _uian. r.. fa .øa.i.. QlPI .......... .....Ht.(3..pe..Wl ........Plor (c. A......'..il=i..¡...r....n....I.n......"-UØ ..'..... .11- .... ..if ""..lllit -ik_.,.,..llIle.Ill.å5k." efa .'''ii II iine It ..... ~lt'1i.lm.......lllrJill... _ (l.".....
1.2. Jr.', t i." 3 D.LI......Ii.I.......II.lnt_...._....l..nr .....(3 .........-..1..tIh5liJ iil.......... ."-ÜkRe ."i,,'ar." ,.in.._.. ...,..........".c.......Pl......._.-1'."'" ....IIIlI.......Ii...nla'...ar.u... .....
II I... ..il.......... ..1..... ff. ...5.. ..ûtW.,,, .111.......1.................11..1.._....'11...01......
......Li.... 'IIm. 11"....1 ..tn...I.-piflll.....
1141.~.l.~Øi._
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 36
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
df at th wi enfaHt, wh fo pelt, érMme ototetco, Le ma te th Le (" Terinan")beth~ofco. In 1h ev of su Ea T~.~Wlll
~ le. fQ L.s. us, . any wind rn de an.an.fa p$it
d~ de. by Le.seeas of th teinda. Wdhirrni(901days
folQany su. Ea. Terna, Les wi re.it. J,.. an inlla
fr th Le prrt, incing it nil(1 mwrs.
8.3 $wr of Pm.Upo th exor..teof1h
Ag. Lesee sh pe an qu Iè.sur' and rêth Pt
to Le In th .CO in whic it wa SU at theornoe atlfi$~ unlé ot ag to by Le. Lesag"-at.~
co todi ao.re .i1eqipm. imvet'Ot8, fb.an oter
pr ~.O( i~ by L.- or it afflite on tlPro (prviedithtallfQn fond sh be to a de of th (3) fet bethsur of the
gnind an covered
wi .sol) wiin on hureeiti (180) dafromtt i:of
te,åÐ of Which .$h beat L.ee'sso.CO an~. If.Lêfal$tòremoStWind ~.felitwiin 180. daysof~ofttA9~
L;rrndosø,inwh çaLeseesh rersL.førebJe C(. of
re..n ~ incrr by Le. In adon to any ot reie avie
to Le. sh Le fal to re su prrt \M on hundre ei(180)da fr th exon or ea tein of this Ag an arall prrelng on thPtbe su on hun eiht (180) dl nøl peod
sh be de ab to Le and Leee he ag to renquianaraØ rihts to an su pr. it be noes un anagre thl.
shll be unde no Oblig to ac su abndrr
SA. I~ otJb rm. .l.~thrihttoit~lt
~to9Q.upo th.~at reJ1.eo.pr.tfrnloins th sa fO
thpuotde.th fh Agre is beng pio 0b Elndtlall .of.the f$flârbêng!æ and .pê by l..
9. .. COem. Sh ti or po of al of thPrøbe~ in~. prngs bya gome ag. go.~ or ot
prte pø un thex of th ri of emnedomin. or shd apatltaki
re1hre~. po of th Prpe wh .ul'bi fQleu's U$, thn th~ntshl ~at up th ve Of ti or tangof pO~ Allpa inon~ofanta by ernect shbe ì'tol.,excetthle shbtentoaraw lTefo th~ lEr'lamd
reCOof anrø prthtLee ha1hrihtto iemo. an foth IO al1~to anSUp~thLe.eior is reuil'otto
A!,an4 folhiootusof th ~by Løse. Itisearetl LesShàl~thriht to pepat.in anY ~ntpringanath le shallnoent.r intoany.biiri ~t~~tWi()thpi WI~ of ~~which $hii nobeunreeblywil.ld.
10. Ui~:
1.0.1 For Ma .. Qe. If ~no of$'$: .,.Ui bYthÎS
Agreto be pe by elpa is prvent or del by ~ot ar .
12
4248v.. I.i.AGRB DG..DP9òdø
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 37
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.,..~ .n.'......" hi llli-_.............==.i:::':::':::'.-::p.-:.::..:::-::-
.UlI.... ..tli.... _. .......,...... ....iiz"..p.'.................
....i:.=~d.M=.==..':-:::~:=.;~-::=:-.
...UIl......U..II$u..-. h........_ .....Ile'...
...1'1 i .........1.......... ....... ...".....,,_
""1."..Jl ,....................................,..
.....SJl,....,..JlU.,.....L.....IiII.. ..._...........in....Ltln.......o...............n.......... '.....i..I....ln.II."..""'llR".O U....... ~.
.....In_l_if.....rl.au.I__........ Wlre.p.i:.~..................s..t..._............~._
...,....tI (I...... ....111y fn su~.._.........__.......d:af(ino..i..._wt...wi..... ....llli'....lnli:UIe.if.. na.~ ...ifi...~.......,..._..GI.....~...."......Id-Iiior.............................
.is.............,. ...11.... "illta..ii"&........ Ii .r......JDI"'.
1'.' ttmlll.......CX.........._....~...11.1It..II........ .............. .... ..lJ$cI~...~if......'...n........d....rei..~~.or..
"""111111 CI ._cd ..l're n!lstl'. .. ,... .., ... .iid...,.........ii..iddtnses:
...'U? .J...'..t~lL..M1 ~".ii..,".0."21__...1_..0.,
UJ:.u.
=':~E.~ì~C....,.,NM.-CI...Ia-..-~ LLC..... "IPI & cn PLC......"....10..Mn......
13....J.I..~øm~._
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 38
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Not pe ~Shl be. dH giVthäayéode. NoeøgiVbY~çO$h.be tlemedgi ontlfQ.bu .$i. fo.~
1l_; ..No male as prhe shQ be deegiV on thtbrd
bu. da folo th ma date. No Of ch of address shal be giVn bywrn ..nø. in th ma dele in th Se 10.3.
10.4 Fyr As. Ea ~1h Part loUiis Ag~taito
pe all su ac ("in bu notliit to ex anddeliiia$l suaiins and do) as reSCbl.1' be ne 10 fuefeaCh
an allofthe pu aoin of th Agre les eireagrethit Will
fr
ti
to time eninrèablhótisee.El~.WlånMoaøwhictrreui~ suChanagre~tprih9tl ~$hU ~jzu-rltrQfth
~ari tiotdisb..ft.po of.th Pr$( ~asjtisno.ind.ult ofanofthprioofth.Agnl Lesragrelñtwinthirt(3Q) day.af
reiptofa Wl reue by .Le itsh: Calgra I'-w and ie. fOeleandotpuli uti1anfaanany.ot elpo~
incUding an ~r~ h on.te acta to Le.anc~tl ~tlttshal. denery or øerabf for Leee's ~enan. ~øf.tñPr;
an4 (b) cote with l.. in ~wi retJforanandalf_in
cha or oth land us peit anor ap18 nec fO LeSE'S
dev an us of th Prer. co bythfsAgte
10.5 . ..El ce. Eìcl pa~rethitshall.attlriticlUlrithTeroftllsAgtwi te (10) øa af. awn reue by lhQtpa. exe..~.anddeNè lothreuepaawñt~
eengththis,.rn Is unrnand in fuH toanef(ormo ..an
statl tnifri). th daøn WhiC the plymts an4 any otclrgeshave_npad, anc.lh ~arnodetlt ex$ÜC) tltd~eX .at. stng .lh
na of such deult.
10.6NÓWmv. No weofanyrightunth~shabeefedfuanpuun .iOwr. Sinøbythp$hRto~th
riht. ..l) Sh any su wa be .cø 10 be a niv of.anySt~ rihtt. or prøftlisAgre
10~7 .~fi'.ThPartesagthatthootêntsoUfûS.~arl.óth.fn eXèng.R øol'en..år~txpt81 reui by law,Shll
bel~ePtstøt ~nt. St(í in90i~ll't~l:~toariy~C)cony wi priwr c;..øf th ot p$rt.
10~8gDIrJ A$rB ThsAg. toth with it åttex.tQl1lli1he eh~~ .be.th Pår .~.~.repe tøth$tbj
mattr her: and any prr agrets, d~() u~if.wrttor or.l,
.R supeec by th Agreementanc $hbe of no for oref. No ad or
inifca of an termorptotooUhis Agre shH be ef unlesetforth
in Wrng andsiiiedby éa.Oflhe Par.
10.~GptnYr... Tt te.åndpiofth Agrøtshallbeiorein~nc wl..i.tn.ila.of tn_teof....kJ...~ble.fQ.Ç(rdci
madeanlobepewi su Stte an with refetoth chofle.
14
4248 -LEA~ XlG-DP9.do
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 39
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
"11...Ui.,....................... 111111.1 -..Ift'"..1....lØ.............c:.~........._.........11..............
11. ..I.W.1l?........................:iill...,...........4.."...............1................
....Si.................- IILf", .....
..1=-"'57Ir ...II...............,....nt....l ntli i..nq......,.,. .....1.. ...11....... ør..11 .'Ù....d. ..r_............o"ii.i.n."......"'.IIR.Jl.....,. OI.......... l.il hi"""
un.. ..IU...'...... ......,... ....lIil..... lRdlhn"
.. ............. lll.... ti...... ...... .. la.
..12 NI .111 .,~r-li..dlntwor...1..' ...,.....II......._....alOfWl.....-II.....................
...1l f='ra., ....J... peiIUll... or......_..
...il':"" '7.& YL..It.I......Of.......-..dy ........1.
.,.....I.fl...IIO .,.......... ..lltol' ....1.-...II..~-....in..J._..IU..or~.....,pøs......
10.14 ..... ....I.LU.. re. ..Il......,......1.1.........1........0*"1.1N.....EROF.....l.el..............1...-..
L.iierJ.Fl_.a.,.."
IJ ;r. ~~~..'1........Pl.llihii8R CE
L.I.U~"._tø..u...............
~4!
15...._.r.Al..~~..
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 40
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
mETA
iiier... ,...PR8R
ll "Mi". 12".......2, 3.. -t. E ~$W" fl. .Ift _an "'1, 2.3..
if, E KNWK f E "'.". 811111 3t. -rI ...11.... 21 Ea......MlJ'Il'" 0. ce. ..
1.4i - i. AG XJGÐ.-
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 41
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
7T77,1"'9s r 71......,y.
:;.
: ~;~_.)
.f :;,,~~~~~~_;.~
~...';'
;......\..,.r.. !.~~':- :w~,,~l; , i
:,',.._...........'...
.....
..:,..".
.~"..'"
.
~
i
i
...or
..,~!..:.......~:.....-l ..~.- ¡
-.;
~.l.:,~:,
'I.1
i
i
~'),', r "
· ~-t,,;, ".. ¡,...~ '\ ;r '~ "
,-g,"'
~
~Il
i
;~...
-.~:=I \."
"\..,'.
"...--..'i
.¿_..~..
~l~~;
'"_.t-.4....,. .... '" .;:~.,-$" ".,\
~..li).\.\i.~
'il--'~~,'.'.
",'"-"'l~,~lIf
".
. ; 'l
. _ f:.......~
...r.....:~=-\
~,
:~ ",~ '-l
~,.' ..","'l~
..
~i-",
..
~§~...,.. '".'
~.-..;;..~~i
.:1
.. '~~'
~..m~i_'...... ..'....-.-
11G4" IMNa -- XI.4e
3.14l48
~~Sl"" SJ Exhibit 1tlage il2
CAS¿;'. ,~lse'ïø.AAC-E-l0-08
i.:'!¡::.'f A. l.tt;ji:::LS~NRECO~PER ~
~i:i: I~ u: PU'rY ~ . ....... ..-
~ø...."'IWNe....t: NT 10 lG:7 RPR 2 Rtl9 19
W..gpu.....Ii.,&~.PUc......;...."II....
-= .....~i.
~ . ""i-" "~""Jli1 ~t:'¿~~Î1i~7
...................en
7.np??F'".,ZC'W.,t.tS rna1' ... OF ¥I PAlE AØ is... ..... -.....14. ... by ""..ien J.1' s.".ee.... ~t.. Xf - DP.MIl IR .. CC _" (iiiee").
WH:
A. OR....... ..fl.....-.._aWiP8......1...."....1.,.... _.. ".,iill. _.. ..",._",._nIBii..... i..I........ .11.1' . lIsn.....__.....-_I.._..-....IIÎl..~..ìt_A
........ _I", at It "'ti,ef (t ~
It. 1'.............."T..")_~OR.....fW...........l3,."".......-Qa~ot..II...."O.......Op......O'7);Øß........Ml.....,.....""..1. ...t........5 UlftÐa"l.As........"....Op...I....-.w~....er....or
.....,...... ._..1.... or .S..ll-~."'''..............'lIle.n...~..ef_~........'11*2......,. T..._._ ....,........,...~ef.iiimllllløf_.~.,..ii'ii iilhn øf...... ìt..lløf...15*...._......
c. .. ll..............annI.................M......._.. .....,....ON.. ..'..111 .."'l'of"..."....... _øf...sû...__......
...-.'~LE...II...,...1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 43
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
....._.J....ll...ll.tdlll_......~..Wl..i..... ..._..........
L....r.
J. a .111 i ii'" 0IMW
~ ~~· . Gi;;.iiL _...i.....æø
buia:
JØ:DP_.........~i111
.....~.cZ
~. L"", , ' ,,,*Ab " Š
.......'_I..It'j._..~..2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 44
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
ll"'_rm
.... lit.~.....)
)
)
ss.
~~
..., -:\~ )i\ ) ss.C..øi M'('llL )
o.UAie,k. 2.'1 .20l)7.~"..h~
=~T~~ 76l~ Cv!H~~ ..Ø*soNlI)t...-........_........llbcD.Å.lnceto....~)..~..... _i.a.ii ......1n .......ad.lD.......Il 11.:l..'....it....~J....._.........J. ...iM..~s~ .tReA...........~..........~
£~~,~~
.§.¿gl7.
...,......,......LI.AWIl..-....
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 45
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
DrZSA...0....._....."'
""NlK. li"Il" '..1.3.....1". ,......n. .....úi 1.2.3.4,1".,"..1'.".....0".1..11....21 .."......_\e.~.""
in 'Mì.""_-'''" .......B1..,..
XRG Answer 8J Exhibit 1
Page 46
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
, P"IA..Qg t Ptd
1M8F..1R
¥.~l....ß' .';, ',;;'..'.:L ; ;-f',\~)'/
~
¡
ì
If
tiJ
.-..u..'... :"
(t
""~;\ ¡...
i. ¿~...'~..F
"\'.. ),. ,\._",
.. '"
-iar . :~.
lq
~
..if
v,',
~'r. '.
~, .Ji, .
.-Z,c.....rR
l t~:
l1;,~::.'
~..,
l
~~=-1~......,..".
..
,,'....
.
)'
'_...........i~F..\~~.:..
l'~~:1.t..i .~.t'-_: r'.-,.0- .....~ ¡ .'.~". tSeru!'-" . t
\"
"
!
- ",,\4,
'S"
~..~" ,,";' 'I'~~.:
..' ""-l.
':.
~'
~.. ~"".~,,, ~~
"""~
1
~"l,=-l_~,l~"",. ,.lIi.,..'.oi
......."MILI..11I -,..
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 47
.,'..LI_....,~e No. PAC-E-10-08
.¡, . , ,ll
"fi
) SI.0. _....lr..l.l...J~".. .11.., ~....,..... ...... ... .......)..Il.)WM_IU.....'" Ii 111.."" ..._l..il..._~.ei..i."ii...lif... .....Il.IIt..).......,.~ ~l)."......rr... .aI.- ....Yi 1h J*I)..~. th
. .....Y:8ß
_øf...::~a~.f'. ~
..o...~£.11. . .~~...th......~..~,.In.l1).....~ê:..( .Z ~1r"J ... ..lIJr~.._..~._.....'h£iiu...rr e;i.."....~a)~-.l)
.,1.'...11..... ill..£IIUÇ... Mlil.ldto_..ti....I...Ii.......1.....1... .....ltMi.... .,~~s,er"
Ï81I.lili ..,.Ii.L........li..wàtI ~s)....aliiu..i.....
)
)II
)
:all,d ¿¡~-~....Pu.I_
XIo-. LL..iiiii...._"2".1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 48
Case No. PAC-E-10-08~...II.. AG""' IX
1lwwr.i..'\. i 1I..1rili..iI.._.tf~.i..,....._J.llSi.'hIC... IS riuli""DG-,UC('.IUI"".III,,,"
.,. ea................ l ..........iA1hWWhii..........,........ 14,"':
-...._llyt.... 1. _.lllnl.....l~..eåfoC.....i~~.....,..ieMl 14,it,~.~~...~........IIJI..IfI..C RlI.........Ii...........
.........,.-..,.... ..... ftaß."C.IiRer~.~
DG-, LtC wi,. "..,......ii ~ ORØfWO Je.l,a¡ø
wiOE . 1:__ 0,...... ..'l--..I.,....c.lRlll_ofcl.~on oftk.. Mii uiialCiiRllI11 ....~: l).~efa~'OW,.. nl...1rlrt t ,. ti l)ai ~yofl'..1..~..........a....Mn_....fJ.~().._;3)...~olal..e.~'q*tdlQ..__pr4)_.iÌYer ofbi..-alnl.I._._I..,..I'..tQco.c6e~anElS)BclÇQII.R'lIof......ì..l1ad.i.dæ si.
NOW'l fo .. .. vain.. 00Cl 1M no ai nffilof
wh In.. ..wlll.... i... i...... G1 lb W"øl PI Le..IBlIB~ Ju i, 28.., ~ eo _1m tIin ¡fth.. CO ha---"Y."--IN WlWl, i... i..........~&$ief.,.fl."wra1.LI:1.~..~ .~..1ls..,."J.. ~:' ;.. 'Tem..hs: 1....1" $ $' 'tnt
..
I.a:
XlG-,LL~~
hi tZ.."....
.~l..A.u¡.I...L.I.,.."....:~ ..
~
-.,;¡...., ,."
. .,,'"
XlG-. u.
ix..¡. .Â11.'."lof2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 49
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
UQEalriuaNlj3i
DiX1wo.~ofdaXlG ~..Ol.th thPPA~200 JfÎQ..USall'ii_ (q. eo ~ ~ co. pe~et.lre totb*G.~.".~Ìl200.
X& l_rQJlIQ. 31
......iirits~()ftk~.ia200..toR.M~Pow. ..to..iiit PPA$~bafisuttBPA ~ôD
~ OINøvel,20 (BAQu NoOOS. 0046, 004', GØ). XRO .pa f.,
.~-lü"'Øi ~200, an ~ûi th iistypr.~.... qu iiUD1U lâ200, wh.. SPA ~1(O'$~ ~_tol~.dna~JI~ ()f.adnaS2~OOfo.adot
~ .-..totEpr-a tö ofS80~OO. At th ti.~.~-~~
W.,e...d it~ to .~ PrAs f01'8114 pr~.an.nOhaiø btth tùilofilPPA..et ia mi.... ~tt áC. tU.iø th ~0I pr.~ M~Po'$ e:y .-coya faii D.O's inliiø ~ ii._qu..thpr~ie...
I:lt~Po$~ tôPrAs in 200,XRO did cotô wcöi th~iaio. 1' ~ in~
· E..e4m..~ armaneXRO'saOstón ìt~.· ~aîb pu to ~.di. an su woon th i-_ fA plm~tI_aøiö layø
. ~..:w" ~aM aD whch wu inly coJui20
..eion of_1ø'M.· ~ So~-8DOfwiWh~Uitjia208.
· ~ ~on~ to SPA -QuNos. G0388 (XG-DP7~ lllO),OO9S(XO DP subt i 1l2310).
XRO LL' REPONSES TO ROCY MOUNAI POWER'S SECON SET OF
PIODUCTON REUEST - PACoE-l()
PAG 7
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 50
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
IJEftriODlÇf NQ.i22
Di DG wo..on..~. of1h XRO pr od1b th PPA..du 20101 Ifsopl....lialmi (e.g. co awa l!&ine cope .~et,)~to
th no pr th oc in 2010.
X&QJWNSE TO RE NO. 32
De Ro MoUDaiiPowv's co re to execg PrAlin 2010, XRO.dK~to wo__ priin2010. n.woin~:
. E.~ 'tpa ~ ~.wlCO1èmvepton $likly~..~~.· F.iin ~neon1 an iDintineXRG's.gøo..úioøit le.
· ~ widà :ntoananyss. whh waiiøø~ Ju1200
wit1erofme toWel.
. .~ So mot0 an anys ofwi wmch ~iitiîn200.
.Rettln nq to BPA - 001 1 (DG..Dl'.~ 3/1ill0),
ani.Q(12QCG-DPIO su 3/12110). DutollPA'$.~iiÐftN~_
XRG~bmthieuetoçæiy wiBPA's eø. BPAaetl
.~ for xiG-DI, WI mw lîa.Qi..No.OOSefveonl216110..Xl0
issûawlÏ~ fr BPA.or 1h.suan desìfo tlUG-DPl.O
~ii ..wt it iši _.mtøBPA Øî i 1124flO..RêWda~.~.sy..ùn.st.îrBPA fòQuiNos.
(j8S(XG.DP7,Ø09SQCG 1)l') an ex~ F~tiStt.Ag~fosa
· Eiath pa øøto~anii~beaiutudyfOt aU4 prj~ttoeö. th prlCwl.ii_fêe\\than,miet~toêt.~
. Bii atb pa ~ttoooast co!'withth NaT~it.Øt.ItoiØîAdjn_øn.tØi.~ al4.~.wl aVOd
in~ wilhgovert~.· ~~nk~ in or to~aB~AtnQn~P$niai.~in~witlØPA ttS$ÐÖ~~itg f'tr$Str thUa.prj.-to Øny __on
XRO LLCs' R.SES TO ROCKY MOUNAI POWE'S SECOND SE OF
PRODUCTON REQUE - PAC.E-l ()S
PAGES
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 51
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.B1 r...cmkUH iuH
ø.~ '-61 ~... ~ totlpoit ob OIør..jty.. PPAIwil..pI in 200 P..liea pico, an PlAex da.
ØG.lgpIBTOUQ.NQí34
XI..__..lh..eáfo~infoli_oi. Vad W81h
~XR..... ..fb
Bu..~..tI fø.QWi ~totb po offu~PPAit20:
. -r*ø C_Wil"~~.Pø Q.y" ~11912Q0
. Cø~W'md M wWldP(lCo"..~ ?~. ~"s Fln W"UI Pa 'W. IdiPaw Q.y, ~. 71912
no LLs" REPOSES TO ROCY MOUNAI POWE"S SEC SET OF
PRODUCT REUE - PAC-E-lo-
PAGE 10
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 52
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
BEQU FOI PR.OPQ.QN NO. 35
HolD pi di.Eø de to th po it oboaor ii fWyex PPAs
wi acoun in 201 O? Pl lis.. prec COUDpa, an PPA ~_.
XBGUSPOSE 10 RE NO. 35
~G ôl.......thftca1sfoimiev~W"~ MùVn...th
~Xltl.. aslõoW$.
Eø ~..~.~. totl pooffny~PJAÙl.i()lo:
· BigBIuW"ui Far wi N~ StPOWè ~dla Xe~,eXec
in ill 0 an apve by th PUC 0181010
.. DoCre Win PB wi Id Powe eoy,.ex~12l10l10
.. Cotwo WiD Pa wi kW Pow ~,_~ 12110110
· Sa.Ct. Wìn ,ar wi Id Powe Coi,ex~ 121101010
.. ~!'W'md Pa W'.ldù Pow Com,.,O'~ 121101010
XR LLs' RESE TO ROCK.Y MOAI POWER.'S SECOND SET OF
PRODCTON REQUSTS - PAC-E-IO-8
PAGE 11
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 53
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.JIPmfO BORClWt 37
DoDG_...~ ....tø.~ tb XRGpr to ~iPO\
A-.....'s (BPA")~? If,. di XRO oonttiSUri~ ~ 14.20101
OaMl 1S:~2010? 0ì~. 10, ..20 On Oc 2, 200 On Jem21,200~.__..lImr.ca.da
JBllS¡ tOUQtæTN~i7
Xlß~~dilJth~ eas foimev inot XRO ~.itrit( Ol¡"'~lØ 1'A$lØ*,rili iltb .prtoseiico
ri.1Dsa~" fo 1iea ou. Ref, e.g., IPC 0r l4Q. 32144.
Xl(J ~~... ~tI_l'is aibipuastø th in of~."Wlut ~.. Ob~ DO". foll
S..XlG'$.~..toReNo. 31.32 for XRO'set_ ri~~~Thtìi_øf"..~pi.wi.th PPAptli be.
di~..hu"''' DO eâ by..Ro Moun Pø'ste~tø..ec PI"iw...pmecøe _ PP.A ieGi. ~. Jai 21,200. DO haiDti an,.fo-..~.~an.stsi200. .~.~
~~'$2~ -_.~ ~sty desi is ".00. EaFacSt..t isS'M)(.BPA l&ony~aS20lOO"t fo..
~ ~ .fo... Jl in Ja 200,wb wod..habeæiSl,OOdeatatime Wh. Roc Mo Pow.it it eøul.O! ~di ou. ofll..pr.llO" ii~ ~st COai laily asa reofth
.de ùi se PPAa~. ha .be..bu QUof its. inq-. .po fo t1Ptec~ DGln~tø ~thup BPA'si~on;p.ai hacu.~.to .~~11: BPA's.sty~.
It~ tb.,.XROdiâ'ld ~ wi. BPAno~in
XlG~I..li ~to~ NO.6. DG ha oitt co st iD for.
1' ee"in.O's~ to Re No.49.XRG 1)y p1ri tbâd~.XRG .Abm toRM Re No. 37.
xa0l.' R£~ TO RQCYMOAIPOWE'S SECNP SET OFPROOCTON REST -- PA£..£.I()
PAGE 13
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 54
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
BET FOR PRODUCTION NO. 38
Doe JOG curtly have Fin righ as defi in the trssion sece prvídet's OAITto
deliver all outut from the XRG prjec ac th trssion seces provider's syst to
Rocky Mounta Power at Bray for the ful 20-yea tem reue in the PPAs? ffyes, pl~
descbe the spific trmion providers) and did XRG contrl suh rights on Decber 14,
20101 OìiMarh 15, 2010? On Novembe 1O,2oo9? On Oc()be ~,2009? OnJanUl~l,
2009?Pleaanwer setely for each dae. Ifno, pleaexplainctistof~i()n
sece reues) wìththe 1:sr,ssi()l' seceprovider(s).
XRO RESPONSE TO REUEST NO. 38
XRO objects on the grund ths reuestcas for irlevantiiöriation.XR.Gniaitaios its righ
to oblìgåltslfto PPAs, and the riskinerent th~th pr()to serøginteonnecon
righ an ttssion righ for the enti outut. Reerce, e.g., IPC Or No. 32144.
Witliiwavig ths objecon, XROstte as follows.
See JOO's R.esponse to RequestNo. 32 for XRG's effort an rights to P'trmissoriA$
ëKpl'setoR.ocky M0unPowermay túes proUS1Y'anui0$tfeçt1yatthemee&
heeetheJ)es onDeber 7, 2010 andinXRG's. lettiandatfuep.tsMte .~ber
14,2010, XRGisçønf4etthattrionto Ro Mountain Powerwilbeaclievale.and
cost-effective.
(Redted reference to settement negotiations.)
XRG LLCs' REPONSES TO ROCKY MOUNAI POWER'S SECOND SET OF
PRODUCTION REQUESTS - PAC-E-) 0-08
PAGE 14
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 1
Page 55
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Bi FQ PIOWCDOl NQ. 39
Wh is di ei _ at wh fi tri8$ fo th no pr to Ro MOUPo's l) 'W be av? Pl exla
xi lÐfTO Bil\. 39
As sall in DO's.. t& R. MO Pow on De 14,2010, no ha J'
au 0I ci of J.. 1, 2013. àD ri wi be av at th ti.
XR LL' REPOSES TO R.OCKY MOAI POWE'S SECND SET OF
PRODUCTN RETS - PAC.E-I0-8
PAGE is
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
RE(~Ef
iO!! FEB 22 Pi"l 2: Its
XRG LLCs' ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR
SUMY JUDGMENT
EXHBIT 2
Excerpts of Rocky Mountain Power's Responses to XRG LLCs'
Production Requests
PtC,,E..l()81R~kyMounta Powe
Septbe 21, 2010
XRG ~ :R~uesi 1
ØC; n.taR."lles i
pie~ide _ Jl(l al1donts (ìllhidìng eoes,~ly
or externally dibut), and allstes rega XR6's teuefor PURPA
PPAs.an inteonnecon with R.ky Mountan Power's syem in Idao for the
XRGQl projects referecedin the Complaimin this ca. pieaor~ize
docaits chrnologicaly.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 1
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
f
,
-.poe to :XRGD.~Reqll.t.l
R.ocky MÖU1Wi ~ obj toXRO' $oaReq\lst 1 totñextettbàt it.ca
fQltJJdaçuments .an$tl(i~on tiegruntbatitisunulyburns,overy
br~anmayseimdevant and or privileged ìnfonnatC$.N()tw~
l1d witbat waivi tl fQlloingobjeçpns, R.oçky MounPowerespti
asfo1lo.ws.
Plea refer to Attbnen XRG 1.
R.eclder:
Sponsr:
Brue Grswold
To Be Detin
t_,;",
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 2
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
RO~kyMou.taili Power provided two att~h..e..ts bire$PoiiøetoXRG
Reques No.1.
.A pages 7..301 of Exhibit A to Rocky Mountain. Power~s.Moti()n forSnøiinar
Judgmeiit, Roeky MoolitainPowersubinited olily"AttclaXRG 1 Part i~"
.Ia¡ela contains correpondence between XRG and Rocky Mountain Power.
XRGbefeby Ìlicludes fortbeCollltissÎØllonly "AttehXRG1Part 2," which
Ro~kyMollntainP()werprovded ilirepGlI$eto XRG~si-li_f()t aU
internally generate corrpondence and documents.
XRG Answer SJ ~xhibit 2
Page 3 ag løll
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
(J~'"" (M Funl
tt .
Fr YOUnl JOn
.. Frl.~.23._10:2NATo: ~. ~l'~l.~i::.e-.~
Jl 181e.
"'Po, Ji
- Fr, JI~,2O 1:24AMTCKV"" Jo.~.~: ex~
e...~..ld .~..it~. an Bn th.. ne i8ues"8rde~. WeÇUhl2$
MW fi PT lmpoQ8bifrSr..bo_h8..$ô an op to APS to us th~lO ~ \V. ~
....av Weco do a 1ø1J reir to ge en adê8paføOO of 0.. ~
UI(20MW). WeOQ UI$ho-k re to hae da ca fo ot Unlbuth wo bênoIo~ tt ltwiUbe av.
Jl
fr_;Y~ Jo
..~, ~...:z _U:l1PM...~,JINdln .Pi
Ji tì is a sunM of 8prWind pÌ to .~23lI.Th pr pontd
ch ..,, Br Su Ioin so .1d. Ar th any is wi thismucñ t:bede" ør ThkJfo yohi.
Younie, John
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2Page 4 Pap lof 1
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
fro: Younie.Jon
.. ~,Janu.29.20 12:2.PMTo: _C&T PrTraAp
$Ub,XRG-p-i (Sipi) -PipóQFTra
F'Aeis~thfo stnd Idah OF WÏd trsa Jo ne Ma Idah. ThprYl be
c:nn tøth ePA sy an wi deiv to PAC at th Br Suba. 8f is theprsurn.
. Bu
. seller:
. PO:
. Tenn:. Pr. Qu
. Prce:
. LO:. Ag.-. Cr.8t~
. Nona Va:
PAC
XRG-P-7. LLC (Simpl)
BnJy Subsn, 10
20 yer1, Decmbe 31, 2010 through. Dern30.2030
FirmQFpu~
19.8 Mt. .pproXima 50,00 MWH lfnLlallyldahQfb(fj lJVO~Ç(PrlReplace Pow on annualizbasiif.MAGisritaqhie
IdahôSt.rdQFOfem MAG PPA
TBDObligon to purQF Po
$77 rnlOnove 2Qye te
You John
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 5 P.l Qfl
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
F'l' You.Jo
ll ~,JaUl29._ 12.~PlTo: _~T~T~" Ap.~.~..,().Llç ~Wut ..PrQFTra
PAC ie~,ilJ"'fO .~.ldho QFwf~ Io rtMa Id. ThpR'W be
COto th SPA." at Wldeivtø PAÇ at th Br Subs. Be IS th. pt~.
. Bu. a.. PO
. Ter:. Pr. 0...)'. Pr:. IJ.~. CN. 8l-.. No Va
PAC
XR..10. LLC (Ne We)
Br Substi 10
20 ye, De 31, 200 th Ðebe 30,2030FI OF pu19.8 lM ~ 54.8OMW annuId fi av co prRe Po on an bais If MA is no ac
Id Sl QF Of-8 MAG PPA
TB
0b to pu QF Po18." mlfo ov 20 ye te
XRG Answer SJl'¡Tgf
Page 6
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08Yoiin.,. John
Frø: YournJo
se lb. Ja29. 2Q 12:02 PM
To: _C&TPrT~ Apl
Søbje:XR... LLC (Nemb Ea) - PrQF Trans
PAGil~thfo.lQng ~.kthoQF.WI hiielo ~..Ma.Id. .l" prwlbê
Q)r'1athBPA lYanWldew to PAC at th Bt SObl. Be"thprsurn;
. Bu. Ie
. PO:
. Ter:. Prct. Qu:. Pr:. LO.~. Cr
· 8I*t. No Va:
PAC
XRP-9. LLC.(N Ea)
Br SObl. 10
20 ye. Debe 31. 200 tth De 30. 2030FI QF.pu
19.8MWépat56.31S. MWanal
Id.flav co pr~.Po.o,iannu balf MA Is notae
IdStndQf Qf~ tAGPPA
TBD
Obaeto.~ Qf Po
$t.7 mi1K ov 20 ye te
You. Jo
XRG Answer SJ Exii.ibit 2Page 7 Pap i of!
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Fr: yoi. ..I
-= ~.""Ula..~ fZ,'ÒPfTo: ..ClT PrT~Ap..~.LLC(P) ...PrQFTrt
PAÇ faØQII", ..~~. kk QFWi tr lQneM8 "bo. ". prWi be
~ to thBPAIY ai wideto PAC at th Br Subs. Be is ..~ $Urnry.
· hJ. a.. PO. Têr. Pn.~. Pr:. LD· Aø. Cn
· "ilier. Na Va:
PAC
XR-8, LLC (Pl)
8r SUbl. 10
20 ye Debe 31. 200 th De 30. 20FI QF pu
19.8 MW ap 67.507 MW anly
Id ft aved CO prR8 Po on ari8 be if MA is no ac
Id SI QF OI.. MA PPA
TBO
0b to pu QF Pc
$8.5 miio tM 20 ye te
Yøunle, John
XRG Answer SJÆxhibit 2Page 8 Pagi ofl
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Fto: Wesim. Naie
.se Th, ~29. 20 12:3 PM
To: YOU, JoCo ..Pa Ch
~/RE:XRG.p..7 (Simpl) .. Pr QF Tr8
~Plthex Je na of th cont an th da ne to ru,rth PPE.
wn.aii. wøoothls? We wa to en we ån co-'fr .crstndlntøn th IdQFs gø
~. NolKl' if we srStprde fr..Qett critse.
.,.v~ Jø. ... ..... . . ... .. .... .....
1e.~,Ji29,.~ 12:02 PMi.=_Cl" ""~Ap"lt~7(Sl)"PrQPTmn
PA.Cil~thdoilo _id Id QF wi tr lo .,.Mã..fd. . TnplWi be
COMí..to.th SPA sy an wi de to PAC at th Br&a. Be.th tisu.
. Bur:. 8e
. POD:. Ter:. Pi. Qu:. Pr:
. LD:. Agrme
. Creit. Stat
. Honat Value:
PAC
XRø.P..7. LLC (Simpl)~SubsnllD2Oyel'. Debe31.2010throh De11J" aQ. 203FiJ ÇlF JK
19.8. MWapproxlma 5O,OO.MW 'rt"~IY
Jdati 1ñèd iavQ eø pri
ReplacementPoronannuall baiS If MAG is no aCh
Idah Stlu QF OtY$ MAG PPA
TaD
Oboatt( pua. QFPow$71.rnllin. 0_20 yn..te
XRG Answer SJ~xhif~
Page 9 ap
Case No. PAC-E-10-08yøuJon
F..: W~.~
.e. T'¡ JI29.20 12:37 PM
TOt YOú.. JoCO P8..Ch.......XR..1().LtØ(~W.)..~QFT~
~pr..~..naofthcoln th da ne to ru thPP,
,. Yau.Jo
..1l,..l 29,20 12mPMM...caT..~..~
l'lrl ~io, LJCf7CpI111:HN.) ..~Qf rl1lS
PAÇ.i.~if..tb~ .i'. ~ QFWi~io ne Mald.ThprØjechYi be
~tothlPAsyln Wi.. d8l9 PAqat thBI1Suti. .EJI$ tlprau.
· 8u. ... PO. T..:. Pr
. QI J ii)":. Pr. 1.:.~. ÇI. 8t1l. No VII:
PACXR-10. Lie (Nb Wes)
Br Su. 10
20 ye De 31.2010 th Dl 30.20Fi QF pu
19.' li .proxlma", 54.80 MW m'ld.fi av co pr
Re Po on an bail If MA Is no ac
Id8 St QF 0I-8 MAG PPA
TIDObig to pu OF Po
$&.4 mUton av 20 ye te
Yo.ul'le, Jotn
XRG Answer SJExhibit 2Page 10 Pag loft
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Fro: WeIn, Naie
.Se Tl, JaY8 29. 2O 12:38 PM
To: Yót. Jo
CO: PI-' Ch
SU REXR-...LLC (NbEal..~ QFT~
PIpne th ex .1èn8meóftheoht an th da ne to runihPP.
~YØlleJon
.se. ~,Ja 29, 20 12:02 PMJO;..ClT PrT~ApiSU..XR,LLC (NalCnbEa)... .Pr.QFTra
PA.Cls~thfOriSfIdQFWfnd~~ riMa'de. ..prwfb.lXie to thBPA iysten'laiWlI.deto PACatthBrSU. 8ø. IIth prsu.
. Bu. Ie. PO. Ter. Pr. GuIt. Pr
..:,LD:. Agit:. Cn. 8tat
. No Value:
PAC
XR-D-8. LLC (Neb Ea)
Br Su. 10
20 ye Debe 31, 2010 th De 30.20FI QF pc19.8 MN ap 68316 MW anId fi av oo prRe Po on an ba If MA is no adie
Ida Stnd OF Of-$ MAG PPA
TBO
Oblg to puse OF Po
$8.7 miio ov 20 ye te
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2Page 11 Pql On
Case No. PAC-E-10-08Younl.Jo
Fro: ~..~
.. 1b,Ja2t,2012:38 PMTo: Y~Jo...: REXRG--e. U.C~. ~QFjl1
..~......naôfthCOntan thdàl'tonm th PÆ.
4"" ,,4, " ;r 4. _Z!.~ ¥ô-.....~,~~,_12:02PM,.l...Q.TPr~~ .....~u.(PI).. Pr QFTl1
PAC"~lh~ ~ktQF Vllr lo ,. MakJ. ThprWi be
conato1h SPA Nt atWI de to PAC. th Br Subs.Be is th.pr~.
· II. 8I. PO. T_:
. PfDcl
. Clb.':
· JI. LD.~. Ql
· 8l1lr-. ..Ya:
PAC
XR. LLC (P)
Br Su. 10
20 ye Debe 31, 2010 th Debe 30; 2030Fi QF pu
18.8 MW lIat 61$7 MW arId fi av co prRe Po on ania..11 MA is no ad
id St QF 0f MAG PPA
TBO
0b to pu OF Po
$8.5 milio ov 20 ye te
V'ounle, John
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2Page 12 Pag i ofl
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
Fro: HeI1, Da
le Th, Jan 29,.20 3:2 PM
-rOt Yøu. Jo; _C&T PrTra Ap
.SuRE: XR..7 (Si)- ~ OF Trans
Pr ae deûioø:
Lea 8C Not a le as tl pd is eo fiDe ~~ No si ti CO 1a a ii
~1': VOl"ie/Jcihn
~ Tb, Jl29,20 12:02 PM1'.:._ÇlT..~..Ap$lld~1(Sipkl"Pl QF Tr
PAC l$~" fCkM.ai .1d QF wi t1 lo ne Ma kJho.thprwl.l)
co~ tou. SPA .$Y..8r WIL deiV to PAC at th Br SUbl. Be isttprec SU.
. Buy
. 8e1er:. PO:
. Ten:. Pruc. Quant. Pr~
. LO:
. Agrwnt:. Crit. Staty:
. Nomin Value
PAC
XRG-..7, ltC (Simplt)
Bra$l;bsn, 10
20 ye. Oer31, 2010 thh Dembr 30,203FiQF~.19.8 Mlapxi 50.00 MWannually
Idaho fied aVOid ..cø pr
Rep Po on anliz baiS if MAGis not aChieve
ldahStai QF Of-8ys MAG PPA
TBD
Oblgatonto puid.QF Power
$71miHiQ over~OYcta
XRG Answer SJlxhi~iUi
Page 13 .
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08You. Joh
Pr: He. Dl
e. lb. Ja 29. 20 3:3 PM
To: You. Jo _CAT PrTI' Ap
...at FE: XR10, U.C (N Wes) . Pr QF Tra
.."....,......... ..~
lI.Il..lø Noa... tl pr ÎI CØ fi~-_: 'Niwa.. ti oo la aii
4....Yø.JQ
.."n' ~ ~,i0ii~Pll':_aT~~IUIJ ~ioLL~Wt).. Ph~ QF~
PACil.~;..~~..kI.cø..wJ. nn lo neMakf. 'T.~wi be
~tolh .A~ li wi deto PAC...Br Su. .Bø 18l1prSl~.~. 8e. PO. T.... Pr.... Pr. LD.~. Cr· --.. No Vii
PAC
XR10. LLC (Nco Vl)
.. Su. ID20 ye De 31. 2010 th Debe 30. 20
Fi QF pt
18.8 MW ap 54 MWH 8IId fl av co prRe Poon ~ balf MA Is no ac
1d8tid QF ~ MA PPA
TBOb to pu QF Po
$8.4 mil ov 20 y. tl
XRG Answer SJ ~xhi~itliPage 14 a¡
Case No. PAC-E-l0-08Younle,Joh
Fr: He..Oe
e. Th. Ja29. 20 3:33 PM
To: yopie. Joh";3~&TPrTI' Ap
.llREXß...LtC(NbEa) - ~op QF Tra
~~deb h'iae:
Le.~ Not iii..tlpd is co fiDe¡,1f8Ciu~ så th c:'" a DO
$....Pr: You Jo
le lh, Ja 29, 20 U:02 PMTo: 3:4T PrTr ApSubj XR, u. (Nenb Ea) - Pr QF Tre
PAC ia oolIig lh fo st Id QF wi tr lo ne Ma Id. Th pr wi be
ci to th SPA sy an wi de to PAC at th Br SUbs Be ia th pr iumme.
. Bu. Se. PO. T-.. Pr. Qu. Pr. LO. Ag. Cr. 8bal
. NOlIlliai va:
PACXf-9, LtC (Ne Ea)
In Su JD
20 ye De 31. 200 th De 30, 2030FI QF pu19.8 WI ap 56,315 MW anId fi av co pr
Reacen Po on ar be if MAG ia no acie
Id Sl QF Ol-6 MA PPA
180
Ob to pu OF Po$8.7 ml ov 20 yø te
You,John
XRG Answer 8J Exhibit 2
Page 15 laplOfl
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Fr-: He,; ',Ql
.. ~, ..a.203:35PM
TO: Y~Jo3~&T PrTI' Ap.~..AE~,L.C(Pf) ..~QF"FI
PøÌlii4l ICclinfnti:
i-..... Noa...... pi is cc1en fi
ÐI ...';1. Nø'l IÌ th CC la aDO
:d'..:;Q;
..you .1..~t~29t2O ii:QPM,..JT~,~ll1!...~W:.~._~QF~
PAC 1S~.Ii"fo_lCldQFwl"'au..etto to.. M8 Id.Thptwl be
~ to".A~ .,wi..detq. PAC at th Br SUbs. Be.1I thprsumiiåI.
· II. 8e
. POD:
. Ter:. Pr
. au81l:...:
. LD. Ag. Cr. ad..:. ....Va:
PACXR-a LtC (Pi)
Br Su, 102Ô ye De 31, 2010 ho Debe 30, 20Fi QF pu
19.8MW 8Pox57.607 MW Rl
Idfl ev co prRe Po on 8l ba if MA Is no acId .8l QF 0I MA PPATI
Q) to ~ QF Po
$8.6 ml rN 20 ye te
XRG Answer SJ ll~ilJi
Page 16
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
GI', 8Iøe (MktFun)
44Fro: Po. Jin
8e Tt..Ja29. 203:56 PM
To: Yount. .J;__C&T PnTraAp
~: FæXRG-"7($impJ).. Pr QFTran
Tr'l1i$Imp to lJ~ on.fi~ li to 23 MW to fo th tr (WO 4olfOf~
.Bø re.. to 8n to fail.tr). An 25 MW ex bu APShafh.ri. to ~onth pathIfAP scUl fr Br we cold an8fllpt to wh lhgh BO.. bu th'Mbe~.
Imp to GøÎl po~ bu wi be li by Go ar lo an .~ba. Tl wlbehors
woen Go IOqm ll ussooraJ Ofthre.A stWi be.~.toPtnu"Of
1ir11ô Wi bl iri. Th prem may be exacerb bY SPA .lO$Mlo Thee"KnI.
Wi neto~.~.~stfothré'....~....~.wtYW..wa~fo.Nê~$l~ $UbmJt(Wil'to ~tlatOf~Tcol1)~S~PPAbeøoiqQpn~..~~... Wf"-tw~atfóti~...Wl.~..to..UIPa.PTcø.Mdscutth~tolQad ønth.PT.f8on.
PI: Youle Jo
81. 'Trs, Jaua 29, 20 12:02 PMToi _caT PnTnt Ap~XR-7 (SI) -Pr QF Tl1ns
PAC 1$ co th. fo~ ld OF wind tr~JøneMáldä.."".~iWibecorito thBPA~nWl.dé 10 PAC.th Br SU.8eISthPrsull.
. Bu. Se
. POD:. Ten:. Pruc. Qu:D._.. ..IRØ.
. LO:. Ag. Cre
· Stat:
. Nomina Val
PAC
XRG.."7'.LLØ (Simplt)ElraySubtinllO ... . . . . . .
20 ye Demb 311 2010 through De 3(, 2030FirnaF~
is.8MW 8ppXilé 50.00 MWHll
kjah fbed ..~. co pr
Re ..Po.on..annUiIl...ba ¡fMAe.1$ nQtachldåti St(ilt QF Of-8em MA13PPA
taD
Oljgtò PYrc"QF .PQ
$77 mil ove 20yertenn
XRG Answer SJ/;xhifgrlPage 17 ·
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
GrId. Br (Mid Funcon)
Fr: Po, JI
le Th, Ja 29, 20 ~56 PM
To: Youie Jo; _c&T PrTra Ap
8U RE: XRGÐ-10. LLC (Nb Wes) - Pr QF Tra
TnmJl
Imp to Ut sy. on a fi ba Ji to 23 MW to fo th tr (wo do re of exBo nt to 8n to Wlte tr). An 25 WI .. bu AP ha fi ri to scon th pa. If Nl scUl fr Br we co at to wh th Bo bu th wo be na.
Ii 4:. "Il
ImPtc~ Î$polM Wlf.llby Gø.. lø lI..rcba.. Th wi beho
WhGO lo. C8no OM $OOf. of tlre. A stdy Wil be nelo ~ m.ofhofoWlbein Thpn rtbe~by BPA.loe shiål ~ _ l(,
Wl....\O~~~..foth ~.P1e1nøWbyo wa~føNeRè..~ (wI~tcbMsiat ofC&T c:). Su PPA be~up ..re Nè~st. Wi Nc Re 8ttí fo th .~. we Wi r. to_Pa PT~ ari SCtt ene to lo on th PT re.
..y~.)...~t~~I_U:02PMT.._C.T..~.~
...~101 U,CNe1Q W.)-.~.q:.Tt
PACil~.thfo~1c OF Wi ~IQC.ne Ma ~Tt~Wl
btCØ1ltoltBPAJY 8l. de to PAC at1h BrSU. Be IS th pr su.
. 8u...
. PO:. . Ter:. Pl. Qu:. Pr:
. LD:.~
. CNd· 8t1D
. Nomin Yaue
PACXR..10,L.(~b we8r~1Ø
2Oyu. De3'l, 200 th Debe 30, 20FiQF~1EUtMW ~54.øMWH8I
kl.fb.. co pr~en~on ll11.il:ifMAGîsoq~Ida $tQF()MAGPPA18~tc ~.QF.F'$8.4 mi Ø'20 yete
XRG Answer S~xhibAlì
Page 18 p
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
G1',.Br(Mkt Func)
!i " iØ .
Fr; Po,.n
Se. ~,Jan 29,20 3:5 PM
To; You~, Jo; _CAT PrTra Ap
~ .RE XRG--e, LLC (Ne .Ea) - Pr QF Tr.lI88ctlo
TrarnisnIrpotO Wa sy ona fibe ii to 23. MW to fo th tr (woddOreöf éXng
Boh I' to Br to fa trlS). An 25Ø MWexst bu AP.firltsto sc
on th pa. If APS scOles fr .Bt we co atmplto wttJgf Bch buth\N benonrm.
Imtoi~j$pObu wilbelimft.by Gcn.øilOanretcba. 'TWilbehö_n~l0 caiius soorall ofthre; AsbYl' be ~topnl'be of
hoJoe.1 bei~ Th'$~.lTbe.~ by aPA IPsluto Th Mile Knoll.
\WnMtoni.i.Nel~."fo.th.I'.PlnowhYØ .1I~1ø~
~. st$\'"it (Wi ne to ha.. sig attesation ofQlT coml). S~t PFAbe CQ1G
upo re .Ne Re $i. Wi Ne Reræslfo thr'rowe wil needtousPa PT ca an sce th en to lod on th PT l'.
FI YOU~ Jo1e~,Ja;i,2012:QZ PMTO.~tAT.Pr~~1U~,.u.(N Ei.. PrQF Tra
PAC tsconglIfolO.~ldi QF Witr\oneMa Id. ThprWi
becototh BPA .sy. ån Wi.deto PAC at1hBhISU Beisthprje su.
. Buy. Se
. PO:. Ttu. Pr. Qu:. Pri:. LO. AQen. Cr. Sbate
. No.. Value:
PAC
XR, LLC (N Ea)
Br Su 1020 ye De 31, 2010 th Debe 30, 20Fi QF pu
19.8 MW apat 56,315 MW anIda fi av co pr
Re Po on annu ba if MAG is no ac
Ida strd QF Ol MAG PPA
TaDOb to pu OF Po
$8.7 mllo ov 20 ye te
XRG Answer SJlxhiri~liPage 19 ~
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Gr Br (Mid Func)t ¥bFr: Po. Ji
le Th, Ja 29, 20 3:57 PM
To: Youni. Jo _C&T PrTI' Ap
"ifliet RE JC UC (P) . Pr QF TraT~Jmtø.Ul ~Qt. fi.bI hhdtø23 MW tøfolh~(wC)ulcfdO ~c:~Bo~tø8n lf~~). An 2SMWéX bu AP "1lt"'lfi~
on th Ød. IfAP âc fr Biwe cold 8tpttø 'l lh 80buthla WObeii.
lmtc~ils ~..bQWil)ljltby Go...k)'an.~~. 1'~b.~'Wh .Gó.Iò_no....sø.øralof...I1. A $lWI be.n8.to pI..~.tR
hol'löWi bein. Th prma be'~ bYBPA lo $hto1' MD. Kn.
WI titø~~.~...fotf~. Pl. no Whnyo'wi ~for~~il~.(W' neto.i..$i'~ ofC&T oomi).SOPPAbe~
.lI~NeRlst..Wl Ne ReR: -".fo tt.~ we wil ne to us.Pa.PT ~ andSCuJth en tt _(ton th PT re. '.
4....~.J
...~, 3l29, .2Q.t2:02,"""-ClT".~~Nd..~, u.(Pl.~QFTr
. .PAi$CQt8klefIlQ ...~~ IØClWI ~ Jó.. Mlldo Th~.be~ totlBPA $y an..de to PAC atth Bn~o Bé.la1l ~1W.
. Bu. 8e. PO
. Ter:. Pr.~. Pr
. LO:.~. Cr. St8t. No V8l
PAC
JC. LLÇ(~)
1n.$ybø JD
20 ye. D8be31,2010thtt De30. 2030Fl(,.~1'.JMW.~.57.507 MW ii
Idfi.1l co.. pr~t.~..Of""m.lz be. lft#is riadId $t.QFOfMASPPA
TS
Obigto pu QF Pp$8.5 miioov20ye te
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 20
Cas-e No. PAC-E-IO-08
a
_......._....,.~.....;.'iI
R.-~... ~..,--
'-1l~~,..~...~~
~.-,.....'....~....
....~~....--'..".. ~
;k'U.. .~...~i._~..~..,~~~,._,,~~~.,'. .. ,." ',. ,.. ~..."$ ......~--..~~.....-.-..-.. ..~_....
...~~.._-¡¡
....~;'....~.........,..',.......-..-..:_:..;;-'~~
:_~;...............----._..~~~~~~~'~
....:~~..-~-..~:..~....~.--,--"'~
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 21
Case No. PAC-E-10-08... . . . ....
.... -.4..t\a..~.. ~ L .....,.70 . ':.:.._......__... ....... . '"
'-~~. ~~..:~~~J..~,... ""~. .... "'=-_. ,
.::-~ , :'...... ...=~::ßbAi ,. Byte:" '.;~'~ ~ ff~J;:~..::
\
..
._.._.... :=._~j._.._~~:+::..~j¡~J\¿~¡J;:::
-.. ......--_.. .-...........__........._... .. ..._._.....,~..,..--.-.......-...- -~ ..,...~ .,......-...-
.. .~". ..:~...,'..'...:..,. ."'.., .,.;~....~:.'-'....,--,---.. .......:'-... ....,...,.....:..'.',.......,;.;'..:.'. '..,,.'..", "i.'.. ", .....'......,...._:.,..:::..'. "'"":...*!
. .......-"~~~~?l.~_~trC-_.__6~'4f"__J)~ .._~__._..........
.~--._._- --~~~---æJ ..:'....~fA .... ~+~\it~ ~_ ...~._.. ___-~
_.:.._~_",:.~ ..2:"~-~-;Ll:~. =2dd~.~~lp~"~i9
--_." --~~~.~-~.~~,.6blt ~=.
¡h~~....'.........:......_ .,...__..__.._..~..._~_ _~."............_~~....,.. .. ...:.......~.~~:_...~._..
---..-.....-....._,....~,~.,
-~~..
"jf ..----
-.--.._..':.~....
...,,......-.--- .....',,.~--.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 22
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
QJ~~la ll\l' - +~
-- -,.. .. ¡ -. . _.- ..lJ~~. _'00 .~A.~~.~~.
~:~d/ ~~~~N'. -
.. -_..:~.- .. ~-~ '"¡~ 'b~
0,',-
\...
. ."..".~:. ',.. ,- '- ....."" "'' ..~'---.:--'...
. .,.,...., ..~...... '. -.
~~~~-~~_.... _:.~_... ~~~.. ..
.'.. -.:., '....' .., "..."" ..~-~-.'-~....,..',,N.'..''! t.....,',;..l,..'...'..............'...'..
~...._... .._~'.......~..'..,..........
,-...__....'.;,".,,'.
. 4...'~.._;'.;'.,,'..
..~.~. ...; -.'_ _... ;. .Ò¡.;...;....~..:.
t.~~...'....__..~..__.... ..,..,...... -....~._.
"
.. ;.',.':',_:..
..
~-.~.-=~~:_~:.- ..~-~~:.'~.." .~~ -~.:..".'!~~~.,
PAC-E-l Q-8/Roc Mountan Powe
Sebe 27.2010
XRO Dat Request 2
XRG Data Reque 2
Refere Ansr, , 9. Plea explain why Rocky Mountan Power delivere a
PPA for only one of th XRO prjec? Did Rocky Mounta Power reive
reuets for PPAs for all four XRO prjec?
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 23
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
l.poastoXRGDataa.uest2
Rocky MOWltain Power objects to XRO's Dat Request 2 to the extent th it
seks an expe opinion, a lega opinion, or legal art an to th extet it
cals for Rocky Mountan Powe to ste an opinion not prviously wrtten.
See IPUC Rule 225. Notthdin an without waving the foregoing
objecons Rocky Mounin Pow rends as follows.
Yes Rocky Mounta Powe did reive reuests frm XRO for four PPAs for
the XRO projec.
Rocky Mowi1a Power previously explaied why it pred only one PP A, in an
e-mal frm Bruce Oriswld to James Cakulis da Octobe 2,200, an in a
letter frm PacifCorp's lega col, Ken Kauf to XRO's atrney.
Peter Richadson, on Apnl13, 2010. Plea refer to Exhbits A-19 an A-2S to
Roc Mounta Power's First ~w:tion Request to th XRO LLCs. atthe as
par of Atthment no 1, , "~ T' ,
Furore, even ¡fth wer no issueS with any of th four PPAs reuested.
Paciforp intily would have set XRG a single PPA, an th pr
invidua PP As at th end of the neotiati. afer all te and condtion ha
be fuy negotiated.
Rerdlde:Spor:
".1 ,,-Bru Grlq. ;
To Be Detered;-,
PAC..E- i 0-81R1c'MountaPoWe
Septebe 27, .2010
XRG Data Request 5
XRG Data Request.5
Refece Anser, 1 8. Plea pi:vi~ surt docnts orstes
estlishg th tron cait:v for nO more th 23NfW of net ol.ir ~
availaòle at the time peod frm Jan 200 to Marh 2010. Please provide
suning.doWTents or stes eslishg tht trmission çaity. for no
more th 23MW w()uId beavaiiaòleat aU proposed online date discus by
XRO~.inçluding.June201J .
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 24
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Response to XRG Data Reuet 5
Rocky Mounta Power objec t9 XRG'sData Request 5 to th exent tht it cals
for all douments and studes on the grtis th it is unduly burensome. overly
brad. an may sek irrlevant and or privileged informaton. Notwth
an withut waiving the foregoing objecQl. Ro Mouta Power responds
as follows.
Pleae refer to Atthmnt XRO 1. whch inludes emais from Jim Portouw to
Bru Grswold daed Janua 29, 200 an Atthment XRO 5, a let frm
Rocky Mounta Power to XRO da Sembe 21,2010.
Recordlder:
Sponsr:
Brue Grswold; ;.l .t
To Be DeterieJ . i i i, l
~: .1' n"
J
,I'
10 PAC-10-
XRG5
XRG Answer 8J Exhibit 2
Page 25 A.metXR 5
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
~eslElf2 ¡815 Mu St 60
Po ot ",31
~il,20io
~.~_r,..Ca1424~Ave
llei-.MTS961
at DQp.7~)(G.N,1(H, :ø1'..iø.uCs
De W.Cais:
Ol. .JyIS,2QiO, hd~1's8oDde~a~poüofôovc~ ofl""lbNtt ~Séce..iØOp~ T~øn Tarcald~C'.P_fl~&l'~tPlO1iCoQiT" ~awa.of1himofth~toXRO'8plje~ 0J~ i~, 2010.
Th... poiqøf.J:veomotklCat PatCefwiy~~tefl
.~..~.. ~"c.l'ivePaeCò C&T's coat tb"'a1tb
~ty()ffi~"Øl~T""iS8io SefQf1fo QFpi-, ab~
.~. byD.G.to dctò PallBr,Ida. Tlre th 1-. pr.XRG-DP.,
7LL,D.G-DP..8LL,XRQ.j)P-9 Ll;anXRG-pp.,iO LL.nocetbPacfiCoC&TisØØJ:lP-to eiio a 2O)' ~~~Wiudofthprjec at.~avøi4~ ..... .mt. in OPC Or No. 31025 (orsusu:rasi:ybf in~ OI .tltl~.~~~pu~foth pr):
'iø..~.toN__.R.Tnmia..Sect.&\paic Yrnbf~ll
PeCoT~onafi~. fiSé ba JfyO\iWC Ubtoøt'VfoWidt
yopìiOCpleomeatS0-113-Sillal l0 lS.PQõle IfyøudeØètopuålfbpr~ weWè~an ~OJC!ipmjepetlatma_ ÌOthwe..~y ..~Y p&o ci PPAs is inicp crticapij_sp~~QF ~lapt..ai buth~ maIlbCâl inclusve Adtional inmabe . lswepiep"'~dr.
&cO$:XRG-DP7-R.CqIi~ XRG-D$I.~ ~Ol X"O-DP
ReIøon XRG-))Pto.Re~OJ
CC PwllcbDåêlSöJlfBt1.~~T~ao~tl~'l""wi..Nll~~
Så1O iinßPrec. lI~Pa.C4T is Dê..l awa()an Ji fa flw1h WO~~T~1ì"".SI.ie
At XRG 5.pd Pag. 1 of9
10 PAC-E-1Q.
XRG5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 26 AttachmentXRG 5
Case No. PAC-E-1O-08
DC - Dn Of PPA InfOlOJ
Note: .~tin r~st~ in lii" 1J11.isiWl to he CQtidertl inclLtil'e4mliN.ii.fiHforPPA
pre/jonitJ ho/ipartic-s age em fllli1lfòrmtltiem.
Prear by Pae -91211Q
XRO-Dr7 - ReIafol'tiD
(a) Detion abili to
obt QF stat
(b) Degn cacit (MW).stion sc rel1.
an ne am of poer
delive to th Comy's
elecc 8Vem
(c) Geon teclog another reated teclo
atl1ícable to th site
(d) pr site locion
(è) SChedul ofiny
JKwcr deliveres
(1) Callati or
dolron of minimu
an iniudmu aiiualdees
(g) Motve for or tì pIa
(h) pr onli date andot $ignic dles ni
to comlet mileone
Pl"ided - January 2 i, 20
Prde FEC For 556 ~
QF Sef Cerifcation
Ten OcWin D8.2. 2MW
tu totling 19.8 MW
DcWind D8.2. 2MW tuine
Cas Count,lD
Prvided ma ofturine
locions
Prde i 2X24 geti
for Ves V90 i.8 MW \\'TG
No Inortion Prvi
Prvide 12X4 geti
for Ves V90 1.8 MW WT
p. En - i 21111 0
Additionai Infortin
reQuesed by lacCol1:
Pr QF nu whe
Form 556 aclledge by
PERC
Ese stion sece for
ea tune; wil serae
station sece be requi
Ar the st the seèeed
turbnes? Prvie tuin
S'ficaion
Provide cooes of prec
and tax lot num. Prvide
loction of subsation. Map
shs 13 turbin rcleinforion prde in
(b);(c). tel, an (g)Rec dinc inture maufac in (b)
and (e) and (e) prucon
foret. hovide the co
i 1X4 for tb seeced tur.
lnlue th me in exce
formt.
Pride Càlcuion ofmi ma and
av anual geemion
Con da is stll valid.
Prode win sty fo
P1ec.Prvide up sce to
acev the daes includng
interio ancoon nieson(i) pr coct ter and~vW
(j) Status of intetion ortr$Slon art
20 ye, non-Ievlí. non-
fuel
Inion is thugh
BPA
Prvide.. of Seller'sinerecionapeaion
wit BfA; prdè date
Seller's aplicaion was
de colee by BPA;
provide co of SIS an ot
stes if available; prvid
doumon of avaibiity
of tr for Prie to
Att XRG 5.pd Pag2of9
10 PAe--1Q-
XRG5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 27 AtfrnXRG 5
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Ug - nrJ Of UA ID&21Nt: l11mi m¡sM in the nw Is 11 to be COJ'lSuk inclushv (1d is Mt fina/for PPA
~ im INJr pa 6f on aD hiomiotJ.
Prar by Pac - 9121/10
(k) pont of dcive Bry Substtion
Bry. If a\"alabJe; prde
scedule of reinng
ineron wor.Identify ~t lea-
tim for majorinterion com
an incae wheiJl suh
inerio eqpm babe or
Prode st ofBPATrassn ScAg to BraSubstPrvi doaton thatSeer ba obed ng to
wi at prec site (ie. la011_Spe prer fon of
sety to be prde fordeay se (leer of cr~ea or
Plea list all pets.
lice an le ri an
eo (e.g. iiio
agt) reuire to opeprjec; prvide st of ea'S reuire facilitdoPlea prde Je na an
2 ye of auted fi
for the QF dew0p or then prvig cr suto th QF deop so th
PacifiCor ca colee
crorll reew.
(I)Win Righs
(m) Fon ofSety to be
prvide
(n) Requit FacilitDos
(0) Cre
2
At XRG 5.pd P8 3Of9
10 PAC--10-
XRG5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 28 At XRG 5
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
BG _.PPlOfPPA.IiOlNote.: l1fion reet bi ti maT Is no to be Ct illlini,." and is lffiforPPA
ptpillYio until bo paes ag OI all ilfrmat.
Pteby Pac - 9121110
XRG-DP8 -Requir Prvied -January ii Addl Infonsio,JlÚormaoD 109 reqes by P.dfCorp:
(a)Demontion iibi1ity to Provided PERC Fonn 556 -Proide QF num wheobtanQFstusQFSelfCerficationFc: 556aewlèdge.py
PERC
(b)Desgn cåty(MW)~1'en DeWind n8..~~2MW estesiori.âece..fòtstaiönseCetuinestøtaUns 19 8 MW eatUiì;wm..mtereG~eìtS, iu.nt;statoi~(l~~uir?
amount ofwwt'tJe1ivered
to theCorrPA$ei~csYS
(el Géretn teclogy DeWin 08.2. 2M\ Ar.~$tiltheseeetedaDotherrelledtuestqil1?P1Vietuetelogyapliletothee~catiQJsite
((l)propo$e siieiocol1 CûSaCöUtty~ 10 Pr~~~.o:tprJ~tPfuVideni~oftuin and t8Klotn~.PI~
loction locion ()sub$ation Mapsli$13t~~le
lDØTiODJ'vidcin
Cb).(c).(e);ii (a)
(e)Scledl.ileôf inthy PrVided 12X4 georon R~di~Ì1
power delveres rorVe$V9()1 .8 MW tim~.ni~fuO!)
WTG an(c)ii (e)prI.ÎØfQre. Prde~~
i.2Xifor.thc..$e~...tu~.
lneb.tQf'ìle Íløicel
fonn.
(t) CøiCUatønpr No InrotiønPrVìded PrvicilCUn ofd.etøminin.ofJ:niui ~nììflndan~uiian av~antigentiOD
deveres
(øMOte f0or lù PtØYÍde i2X24ge~n Còii di1åis iî'I¡ålidplanrorV'~fa V90L,$MW PtvK...Wi sty for
WTG Prøf;.(h)prpo øn-linedat tllEnet ==i2/3 1IlO PrVideupld~ui~tQ
and otetSigrfiCâtdâes acb_...tl...~te..inciini
reuire to complete mterion an
miesones ~mileson
(ilpr cotrct ter 20 ye.non~levli.non-
and ÐJçigørvi$ions ful
(j)Staus. ê)inteønecn Iriterecon is throug P~videst~ot~etiiôt..ttmon.argee1t BPA int~lPn~pp1iGaiøP
withBPA;proe~te
Seller's lllicatiwe
decOlete bvBPA;
At XRG 5.pd Pag 4 019
10 PAe--1D-S
XRGS
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2Page 29 ~x.5
Case No. PAC-E-1O-08
XßG - pea Ql rfA lItDl
Note: l1fon rellH in tie 1'tr is 1W 10 be c:onsrter indu.'IÎl'e tmd is not filor pp II
pratiDii unlJ bm pøies ~ (1 011 infrmatun.
Pr by Pae ~ 9/2 111 0
(k) po of deive Br Subston
provide copy of sis an ot
stes, it avalabl provi
doclimeniaÛO of ~i.biil
oftriiS$ion for Prjce to
Br. If available; prdescedule of rening
interecon WO.
Ide pr lead-
tim for maorin compsan incate whe suinlerion eq ba
be oiPrvi st of al
Trasson Prvider's
Trassion SerceA¡t to BraSubon
Prvide docation th
Selle ha obt rits to
wi at projl site (ie. la
or le Spey pmer fo of
se to be prvied fordeay se (leter of crt,
caesw. or-teel
Plea lis al pennit
licen. an land rights aneos (e.g. inmxinonag) reui to opte
prec prvide st of eahsuc re fadot
Plea prvide leg na an2 ye of aud fina
for th QF delop or thentity prvidi cr surt
to th QF develop SO th
PacifCor can coletcrtwor re.
(nWin Rights
(m) For of Se to be
prvied
(n) R.ui FaeiltyDots
(0) Crtw
2
At XR 5.pd Pa 5019
10 PAC-E~1 ()
XRG5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 30 AtththtXRG 5
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
XB(;-- in OF PPA.lati.1W~. lnftionrested in the Iftr is 1U tQ be ''ØlIidn-d jndU$'rdw:jg1ltfinQforPPA
Pr'JX1"dI inil bøthpal1e$ ~(l till itiømQn.
~byPRç ~ 9121110
XRGoDP9 .. Requir Provide -Jan....ryZl,A4diti..litol1UonInfonitlii20req"esegbyPatiCorp:
(a) Demc:on ablity to Prvide PEC Form SS6-PrVide QF iiwli
obtan QF sttu QF SelfCerficaon Foi SS6 acge by
FERC
(b)OèSign caty (MW),Ten OeWin 08.2.2MW Esmate stonMrce forstonsecetunestotain19.8 MW ee tu wil ii~reujrents an net iiøn secebc l'iiit?
an0un of power øeliverto the CØtPânts elecc
smet
(CrGêJØnteøoI~&Y PeWindDS.i,~MW At'~$tUthSelécød
and Qtreate tues t~? Prvidetume
~()loiy 1i1i~letøthe sptb()
sìte
(d)ptseSite location Casa County,ID Prvide ~()fpti~Prded ni oftuine an ta lot nube.Prviloconsloetioiofsublton.M~sb 13 turin,reriile
írifortioll¡)ovided iii
(b),Ce),. O~). ..li (g
(e)SohedUI'of nrntly Pivic;ed 1~4 gflwaon R#;:o~itdi~ii
powerdelivores forVe8tas V90 i.$MW ttiin.~~in.(b)
WTO aiile)~ (e)PtUc9t
f~,. Pryjdetlcomt12X4 for thsøeÇedtii~
Irlude the fie in ~lfann
(f) Cl1çplationoi'Nolnronnôn Prded Precakfation.øfd~enìnonof minium inui_~anamtnwmumänuaaYe~anuä~
delVlê$
(j) MqtÌve ft.oJ'ñi Prvideø t2~4 g$~tion Cønfl datâis stl\lUd.
plan for VC$tå V901.8 MW hoyj~CliWmø Jtu(lfot
WTO prj~.
(h)ptopedon-lindae l!il2ergy:=121II10 PrvitJeupted. søece tQå.dotlerSignfteliit dåtes acíevthtJé$ínud
æqui..tø..eoPlete íiit~íim ann:~.~Ot i:êåór
(llpr .eoqt te 20ye.î1-levelize.nol1-~ørcigPiViiOl fu
QJ,Stl of'ìlerrtneco!I Int~eçon .istlugh PrQvide~Qf$eiler'$otttisSiQî ålseent BPA il't~a¡liçaíon
with BPA; pryjedat.e
Sellêr'sappHean WlJ
de colie bYBPA;
1
AtXRG5;pd PaS of9
10 PAC-E-10-
XRG$
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 31~~xRG $
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
X89 - Dr? Ot: l7Â lD'1tiNo: ~ ~ in tM1ftr i. 1W to be c'oner fiiclush'l an is ltt,tilUllø PPA
JW1o unl bóth pain ag on all ~.
Prepaed by Pae - 9121/10
(I) poin of delive Bray Subtion
prvie co oralS an othestes if avalale predoation of avilalnoftrøsion fo Prjec to
Bra. If aville; prvide
scede of reiniinternnon worIdeif pr le.
tim fo maor
inion compne
ancUndcate whed suh
internnion eqt ..be or
Prde st of anTflon Prvide' sTrasson SeceAgr to BraySubtiPrde dotion that
Sele ha obtined rilh to
wind at prec site (ie, laorleu tsl
Spfy prer fo of
se to be ptvided fordelay sety (leter of cr
ca esw orPlea lis all pe
lic an la risJ anco (e.g. in
agree) re to ope
proec prde st of easu re falitdo
Plea prde lep na an
2 ye of auite fiia
for th QF delop or thenty prdin crt su
to th QF delo so th
PacfiCor ea colete
crworbi miew.
(l)Win Righ
(m) Pon of Se to be
prvided
(n) Require Facility
Docuents
(0) Crtwrtes
2
Att XRG 5.pd Pa7of9
10 PAC--10-
XRG5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 32 Atme XRG 5
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Dg~.vtiqOfWW"'''N~:l1tN refMet in t~_tr is Mt to be cøøsti ilK:lusÌl'f andisllØt,~.fP:IM~ un bo pe ag di til i1f
Pr by Pac- 9121110
XRG-DPI0 -Reuir Prvied -Janua 21 Addlüori Jllonili,Inform 200 reueed by PaCo:
(a)Oeontion ablity to Prvi FERC For SS6 -ProVide QF'num whe
Obtain QF sts QF Self Cerfication Fon 556 aeJecae bYFElC
(b)Dø¡neaty (MW),Five DeWmd D8.2,2MW 'NO'tE:f'EltCS56slI5Sttionsecetuinestotaing10MWDeWin niin~totld lOMW
reuireents and net and.12X4Wìsetion
aiount ofpòercm1ive showsl9,8MW USVC$
to tlw Cqty's eleçç ttUines Estitesttioll
system ~eefóteah t~..il~t~$tQl.~..~
?(ê) .aeeronteology DeWin D8.2,2MW N . FæC$5~~s5
anöther mated tuines DeWìaniInt9tâlOMW
tecolo&y aplicable to the an 12X4\V~ticm
site S~19.8MWUsmi""
tuin At. th..tin thøselli tiin?PrvìdetllSDCâoii
(d)~site 10ßon C~aCoUlty,ID P1"vìd4Q(~tesofpijec
Prvided ma oftuine anitulotnt.PløYdeloconloc9f~tiOt. Map~..lltuii,~neUe~tioipnvj in~ahfltl..
(e)Sd"fileofnionthy Provide 1 2X4gencrti ~.Ul
pQwed€livees fOr Ves V90 1.8MW tiiùi~Ctin..(b)
WTO ii(c).lr (è)pitìf~. lìýÌdethé~f~4fo~..~ed..~
Inel~the tl~ÍIeiee
.eaJcøøof(f)Caleuå1oßor No ~C)n PI".videddet~onofrrinìtui Ilii.Ji~1QatmlXmiun~ave~ àI~tion.
deliveres
(¡ MøtivcfQt Otfuel Prvided 12X24gèEløn Córimdà.i,)lln..."ßd,pla fot VêSta V90 L.8MW PrvideWú tfy lò
WT ptojee.
(h) prpo on..hi date tllEncrgy -12/1Ii 0 PtWt upsçoto
and other signficat date ac~da~tidin
reuireto ~nilete in~~ii1'IC$~~
(iJpîpôèontt ter 20 ye~non4evClìiea,nC)n..
fl micinir muvions fuel
m Si.tuofinternneçon Internnecon is tb~pr\'léltU$øfSeêt'l
At XRG 5.pd Pa 8 Of9
10 PAC-E-1()
XRG5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 33 AtrrXRG.5
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
:uç- aeig OF UÃ àfNo: I~cm tw1l in lit mlW Is IWlo be coid inclu.moe an is 1t1:fùuil Jor PP A.
pl' ii bø/i pt ag IJ utI iiion.
Pr by Pac - 9121110
or trison ememt SPA
(k) potofdeliver Bmdy Substion
interon aplieaøn
with BPA; prvi date
Seer's aplictio was
d= colete by SPA;
prvide coy of SI an otstdies if avlabl pr\iddoti of .vabilit
oftrsio for Prec to
Sra.lfavilable: prvide
lCheule ofreinteii woIdenfy pmt Jead-
tim fo majorin: co
an inca wher NChiner eqt habe oiPr stus ohllTmi Prvi's
Trass SeceAgs) to BidySubonProvide dcwnon th'
Seler ba obt ri¡hl to
wind at prjt li (ie. lan
. art_
Spfy pr fo ofsety to be iø fodey sety (leter of crt.
ca es Plea li all pe.
lice an 1a n¡ anco (e.g. iDte:
agr) re to opc
proec prde st of eah
suc re falitdot
Plea prvide 1e¡ na an
2 yea of au ñiials
for the QF de or th
enty prdi crt su
to th QF deop so thPacCoi ca coi~crtwøt re.
(I)Win Rights
(m) For ofSecty to beprde
(n) Requi FacliDoen
(0) Crtwoiincss
2
Att XR 5.pd Pag9of9
PAC-E-l ()8lRocky Mounta Powel'
Septbe 27,2010
XRODa Reauest 6
XRG Data Request 6
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 34
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
. ,; :,
Do it app at ths date th trssion capaity will exis for over 23 MW at
th propose point of interonnection for th XRG projects at any point pror to
the end of 20 i i? If so, plea identify an provide supportng documents
esblishi when Rocky Mounta Power firs beame awa of ths possibilty
of additiona trssion capaity.
Response to DO' Data Reques 6
'1
Rocky Mounta Powerobjec to XRO's Data ReqC$ 6totb exil tl itças
for q1/dourents an stdies On the gtun tht ¡tis unduly bureíme,overly
broa an ni~yseekireievant and ot prVieged iiiføraton~RQCky r\auntan
Powç.ppjøÇ to XR(l'sPataReqt 6 to.th~ent dit it~ksanexpe
O))ìnon, a.1egopilÛon, or legal lUguenandtotlexteltitcalsfot RÒØKy
~PuntaPo~lostan opitonnot pre"io~IYwil''SeelPI.C RUle2iS.
Nptw1ltading an withut waving th f~oing objecons, Rocky MOunWn
Powe respnd as follows.. ';
.~ 1:"Yes. It now. appe th trSsi~cait exists sucient to acomodte
70 MW otcaity frm XRO's four ptoposec prjects deIivetgnet outputto
Rocky Mounta Power's Bray Substn in Idao.
Rocky Mouta Power bee aware of adtional trission capaity acrss
Pat C on July is, 20lo- dat PacifCorp Trassion Servces declar a
new Point ofDeJiverlPoint of Recipt caled "Path Co.. On Septmbe 14,2010,
Roclc Moun Power firs regniZed that the July 15, 20 i 0 ch elimina
al identified baer to accngall;70 MW output from th XRO projects at
Bra Subson. On Sepembe2\j 2010, Rocky Mountain Powe notified XRG
tht it is able to pur out ftri alJour prpose XRO prjec at the Bray
Substion Poin of Delive at th p\1bli$ avoided co rate in efec on th
date th paes execute PPAs for such projects. Plea refer to Attent XRO
5 for a copy of the Sembe 21, 2010 letr.
Recrdolder:
Sponso:
Bnie Grswold
To Be Deteinec
,f
~;,.1- ,
~.', ..
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 35
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08PAC-Bot o-08JRoc Mounta Powe
Sepbe 27, 2010
no Data Request 9
DG Da Request 9
Referce Ânsert FIT AFFI tr DEFENSE. Plea explain how XRO
could execute PP As when Rocky .M9Uø.n Power did not prvide XRO's
reue PPAs. Plea identi ai;pr~de th communcaon from Roy
Mou Powe inorming XRO th thè one PPA prvided fo one of the four
XRO prjecs shoul be us fo th reaing XRO projects.
Repo to XRG Data Reuest 9
Rocky Moun Powe objects to XRO's Data Requet 9 to th ext th it
see an expe opinon, a legal opinion, or legal arguent and to th extt it
cals for Rocky Mowiwn Power to stte an opinon not previously wrtt.
Se ¡PUC Rule 225. Notwtb~ and Witbout waiving th foregoing
objections, Rocky Mountan Powrre.snds as follows.
XRO could not execute PPAs beus XRO did not negotiat PPAs to completion
with Roc Mounta Power pnor to th Mah 15, 2010 rate change.
Roc Mounta Power did no exlan to XRO in wrg th the one dr PPA
provied by Rocky Mou Powe on" May i i. 200. shuld be us for the
reai XRO projec. XRO.~l~:i a July 6. 2009 e-mail, an again in a
Mah I 1, 2010 e-mail to anice Or~oi~ tht it would tak the dr PPA
prvide by Rocky Mountan POWCpn)Aay i 1. 200 an replicat it to crete
PP As fur its oth th prjec pi~refer to Exhbits A- 17 an A-23 to
Rocky Mouta Powe's Fir Pructiòn Reuest to th XRO LLCs, at as
pa of Atthm no 1. XRO al delar on Marh 11. 2010, tht it would
pr Roky Mowitan Powe with ree maup of thse four dr pp As for
Roc Mounta Power's review an apval. XRO ha never prted the
dr to Rocky Moun Power.
Recrdlde:Spor:Bru Gnswlèf ..~.
To Be Deteinel',", t/
\':
l
I
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 36
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08PAC..E-IO-Q3/Roky Mounta Power
Septmber 27, 2010
XRQ~ ReqlJe$tll
XRG DataR~..est 11
Refeiçe .Ansr, THll AFFlRATIEPEFENSE. WOldR.ockyMounta
Powe consider action in contrcton with FERCinteecontues to be ba
fath? Would Roky Mounta Powe consde it to.~ ba fai to refu.to
pross reues for PPAs on th gruns th trsmission caity is perceived
to be lackig at a ti whe Rocky Mountan Power knew., or could reanably
anticipate, tht trsnission caity would not be a problem on the prpose
online date in th PPAs?
Repö_to DGDat Req..estU
Rocky Moimtä.úiPowetobjectstö XR6's DataRequest i 1. ort.tliWöUn thåtit
~KSeKpê .Qpimon, a Iegalopinon,or legatargueritandonttcrgrOl.ds tbatit
cals for Rocky Mow: Power to St an opinon not previously wrtt. See
!PUC Rule 225.
Recrdlder:
Sponsor:
8niceOrswldTriBe Detêd
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 37
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08PAC-E- i o-08IRocky Mounta Power
Sebe 27, 20 i 0no Da Reuest 12
DG Datà Request 12
Do PacitiCorp or any of its afliat cons tr upgr that ar
likely to occur whn it commts itlf an' its ratepyers to utty-own
geon reures? If so, pleae: 'C?Plam how Roc Mounta Powe
pres XRO's re for intercOilec an PP As on a nondiscmiorbas ~pa to otr cume, ì'iìludng utlity-owned generon reures.
Refernce 18 C.F.R. § 292.306(a).
Rocky Móunta Power adinisterXRO's QFPPAteues in acrd With
itsPt.AobligationsaiIÔ1b() Coiiioii ii.e.sand ordet. N"on..QF
iresós would bcadster .~~.COm~y-iS$~ed ReauestFot
Ptpo~l (RP) prS Whe.~.~url,inludiiniany inepede
devel0lJ(itie1ud¡ in~ QF*).~.ù,iit-0wn$enonre\Uee who
cJiose to bid into th R., .ar tl~li a non-discriory mantwith
indetevaluaov~i¡h onlieproçesa. andcommuncatIpii.Rocky
Moimta Power's RFP Proe$San doçumeit ar post on its website.
If th QF is not selec un th RF pro, the QF ca stll re a PPA
frm Rocky Moutan Powe un PUR A obligaons. Rocky Mountan Powe
trts all QFs reuesting a PPA Ulde PÜk A obligaon in the sae non-
discminator man. . .,
Reerdolder:
Spons:
Bru GrswoldTo Be De
tf.,
PAC-B..io.08IRoc Moun Power
Debe ilt 2010XRGDa Requ 16
- XRGData Reues 16
Plea prvide Roc Moui Po's poli by whch tho.~ ai
tr ar of th Co re infon re trsson ai
reue ne re st ft th trssioi side of th Compy for
PPAs. lith policy is difft for PUR A PP As or for off-sýs PPAs, plea
prvide the seartêpolícyìes).
. XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 38
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Resøs to XRG Data Reques 16
Ro Moun Power's Coer an Tra bus un rees
inonti re.trsson an ne reur rees thugh
PacfiCorp Trasson th wholes tnamison busine unt ofPacCo.
PacColp's wholese trsmiss sece ar re by th Fed Ener
R.Co (PRC) wei co-ba regulation subject toPacCoi's Op Ac Trasson Tarff, whch ha be on file at th
PERC si 1989. PacfiCots tmission bus op inntly an
in it trsson sece on a noat bass usin th public
Op Accss Same-tie Inon Sys (OASIS). Plea refer to
Att XRO 16 for a coy of Trasson' s BUs Prce #9: NetorkLo and Reur Addtion an Ch.
Rede Bt' Grswold lDesDeSp -Biu Grold
10 PA~-10.8
XRG16~~XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 39~~XRG 1l
Case No. PAC-E-10-08r~.".,,.~
Bu.....Pl'~",: :Nno..k l.lind. a...reAddtióJs fld ClåDg.
pfJ:MåY23,~001Katt~Y23,2()B~N(): 0.0
Not to aD Enties:
niQA.ITplVidetiu~ta iraîssiônCusmeriny see its Nerk Lo utilzingNotQitIn~n. Trasnissioo Ser'i~. 'I.NetQrk Trasiision Custme mus
submit a Cørleted Apli~iQnp'lrst to Setion 29 for all New. Netrk Lö
(SeQn 31.2).
Se~n 31,~Qfth~OATT rellÎtS a Netork Cusme to submit ...~. lQl an
l'(LR)fO ûPdatt~ for
it :Netork. Lo and keSQurce.PaifiCôrpusetbe$efø_tbrtrÎSionplang. inchidingbut not. limited totr~ion
~italloctin a1iti expaion plans to asist PacifiCQI. in~lia1ly
seÙJ it C\tnet løa.CuntteYeaL&R.infonntionisre'lird to be stbrit
at lea on..pe yeaûöm eah Netork Cl1mer. Netork Ctistoiar .alSQ
reuiretosubrit timely wrtt nQtiçe of material ehangestoany infoitionprovid
in,. Cöniple Application relatg tQ the Netor Custer's NetwórLös, Netrk
lesø~,it trsmissonsyst or oter 8S.()f its failtie$or opeQnsafg
th TraiQtiPrvider'sabilty tQplvide . reliabJeserviçe. Th Netk Cusoner
$luIdcleay .
idetify . any chages to the an'llsubnission in aU inir"yea
submisions. ~ifiCQ t.i.si() willrev~,sty. and. açmmodte int-yea
clip$ts SQ aspraticaleonceteived.
1Iis~ineprticeappli($.to aU trission C\ltomer unless explicitly contrcte
bY Cötttes.
Netork Lod Additi
1IisbQsîiss ~cWifies whPaciñCorp considers to bea~íiew" load or re'I,
öt)a~lnat chage" in load.
tbfoUowig atootiider "' loa. anreuirasepa Cømplet Applicaon
put to ses 29 and 31 of the OA'l:
· In~ji .1Qå no alrey aeunte for in th. L&k,tothe disbusystm
(qo JcV)aioneslof2MW or gr~
· In~in lo nQt al..aeunte for in tbL&R. to tbtrissioii
.sy (~ leV) atör.sit of S MW or grer.
1IefcilQwing arCQnsidere "matrial. çhage" an reuir tirelywren 110ticetothe
trsmissiotproviderput to 31.6 ôfth QA IT:
Pa Bu.. Pr
Att XRG 18,pd
1
Pag1Of2
10 PAc--10.
XRG16
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 40 AtXRG16
Case No. PAC-E-1O-08~~Tra",~~
· Inl'inlOl t1otalraceounted (or in tñ.L&R,to ti dbtri1:onsysi
(~O.kV) atone sit grr tll MWbiit le$stI 2 MW.
· Incr. in ioa nøt aladaclJte fotintheL&llto the iiiSion
syste (:;.40kV) at one sit gr th I MW but lestl 5 MW.
· Reuction in 10lnot al acun (or in th L&Il atoisÎt oneit the
distrbuton or trsmision syst of S MW or gr.
Lo inres unde 1 MW ar consid oranic grwt and do no reqit tiely
wrtt nøtice or a Complet Applion.
NemOl Relure Adtu
Mew Network ltures or cbagetø the naeplae ()çøiiiingsorlKis!NetWøt~W'rean e~~ ineçonagmetpumto PaIV or
Vqftñ OA.Tt and .. Coniplet Appliønpuuat to.seon29and 30 oftb
OA.Tt. Reue for ne Netor Reur deignon shaH be madt1ag searte
OASIS .reque for service tø .ilow PacifCor. the opit to reie and respnd
accoin to Setin 32 oftheOA.1T.
Cô._'Qr~: busj~.co
I.F~ IDa':.o.o:~:i~~
Pacor Sune Pr 2
Ath XRG 16.pd Pag2of2
PAC~B-lo-ky Mountan Power
Debe 21, 201 ()
XRO Da Reue 17
XRG Data Reue 17
Plea exp how the Coy's two aI coply with PE's m¡tth th tw not cou. regag trssion rets.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 41
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
Res to XRG Data Reue i 7
Plea reer to Atthm XRO 17, a coy of PacfiCo's Sta of CoColian Pr. Th Fed En Reg Comon
Stada of Cond fo ttsnion prvi ar avaable on PafiCo
Tnusson's OASIS webite.
~old BriGnold/.J..DesS~ Bni Grswold
10 PAC.E..1ß.8
XRG17
~.~!flf~RP
Standards
of Conduct
Compliance
Procedures
Att XRG 17.pd Pag 1 Of 18
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 42 Atthm XRG17
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
PO M8 1. 2010
3I10
10 PAC-E-10.
XRG 1tABLE OF CONTENT
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 43~AAG17
Case No. PAC-E-1O-08
St or Conuc Coplia Pr
Att XRG 11.p Pag2of18
ro PAe-.10-
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 4+.me XRG 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08¡'Ai IFICORP
I. Introucton
1he leer~ .En~tnCoIle'FB1~.c')St$Of omd.uctfoUr~
plvìdéi ("StådaOf COdtid')ai de to proæføfudai prle;
1. AtrOñpródemusttreanil trsioo aito,åf~anri,
onanoundl1ydiry bas, an mus no ma or grt any unuep~ Qt
advan to any pers or Sl any pe to undue prdiæ or didvata With
reto any tra.on of elec en in inte co,01' wi~. roth
whle8sae of elec er in iiilest comm.;L Å ~ÍQprdeist:onfuoneilny inU$ ftgjii~ently
frm itslIfuemployeerexcas pettinthruor~
pett byFECorr,3. A trï'óiprovide mdlts eml'l()~C0ttåc, cötats lidagets at~tefrincU~pruslilLt(dut"Ü)~, :rb1ic~tpfuOll iitmontothtr~ ptOde~s ìMkefumtemp~..4. Atraniiionprd.eimuspreqac to nopublic.tninon~on
innntin to al itstt cu afte an noteexce in th
ca. of co cutome inti or crtica en inasetreirortion
Ii~ of th ob PE ha prulte ru th.govetlir~çí
ar.((Jtuncati ben ce employee wi Pacrp, anwi .rei.toeert
inAl employee ofPaØ.ar PacCo's afte mus çomplywìth. the
Stof Coucttues. '1St.ofCouct Copli ~ulexli
FBC'stuan th pturPaciCorpan its aftèwi fol.owin orgrÜ)ÇOply
With th tu
2.C:hlefC:orianeéOteer
PaCor hadegn ColfNoas thclexJiofffor$t of~(~13.5$).M: Not~~fo~otC01latolaflite((mpli is..wi .MiRed, leal c: arèOliäriOfær
(S(.l3-.81~),
3. Key Definits
Th ru go inon be tranion fuon emplo and mâ
fu emloyee, inud sittins wh an emploee who doe no fa with eith
cà ac asa couit fo non-pblic tr fu inti Al of th tehave sp mean uner th ru, so ca un of FEaC's de is ke
to copliæ.
2
Staar of Cond Coia Preó
At XRG 17.pdf Page30f18
to PAc-.10-
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 4$\n'tXR17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
I'A(IFI((JRP
A. Traon Pn
'1anio pro me any puli utiit tht own opate or cotrls fad1
us for th tr of elc en in inte co. PadCo is a
tr prede
I. Trisn Fuon Em
."' £uct emloyee me an employe cotrct cotat or ag
of a tron prer who actly an pe en on a day-ty ba in
tr fucton Tron fuon inude the pla dir or
or ca out ofday-toy tr ope, indi th grantig and denyi oftrss se re.
Ce Pa Powereiloyee ar tr fuon emloy (fo exple
QPlo, scul an emloye tht wor on tron sece aninte re).
C. Ma func Em
"M fu em" me an emloyee, ~ cotat or a¡t of a
t: p:r or of an afte of a trss prde who acvey and
pey en on a day-to ba in mllke ft, which geery meanth sae fo re of elc en or c:
CeipadfCåt.~..~åfd...tt.oilo.mabt~.,~..ForaliofPad(J$ ~fuempIQY.pl.retpPa~s
~ web.orìl:Op~~nmeJntitiSys (OAS) website:
htt://ww.0aÍ$.padftotp.c1 oa/Pf/~unctpIQyeLiH'
PaCo'IÍ ~£ucton employeam al beid by e-addi
~tiof"llFundil"tøiiOWei~. fuonemloyecsnae.
D.Afiau Al" of a sp en me an pe wh oo)s is ooll
by or is uner co co with th sp enty. An afte
in a divion of th sp enty tht opte as a funa unt
Paàñ ba seer af indi but no lite to:Padf EnCo &i Tr
82 NE Multnma Sui 60
Por OR 9'
Fo a ro li of PadCors afte, pleas re to Pacors Intet web site or its
OAS we site: htt//ww.oa.pacorp.co/oa/ppw I afte.doc
3
Sta of Co Co Prre
At XRG 17.pd Pa.4of18
10 PAe-..10-o
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 46 Atnt XRG 11
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
P'ACIIIC()ßJ*
...I..pedent Fqnctønini Rule
Padfot'$~on fuon empioy mus fu indeently of Pacior!s
makeÍ1 employee. Make fu emloy ar prit fr
conduÇt tron sy option or iety fu, an make nucton
empløyca have ac to a tranon cotr cer or ot t:onfaties
or inatisytern th differ in any way fr th atpïdé tn.ii~
tton~. ~flcton empioye arptotefr.cxuct~.£u.
.A.Phøi ~WorkSltiót!ót ~..fUónemplóyeofP~...at.Ph:y$~y..~~
.&o..th.oimake .fuat~ploy, an atis.~et
Pac's tranon fu emloy ~ locte in two pla (1) at th Portan
Cotr Cete at 9951 SE Any, an (2) at PadfCo's hedquar in th Lld Ce
Towe on th 16t floo. No ~ fuon emploee ar stti at th Pord
Col Cete or on th Uoyd Cete Tow 16t floo an ac to th trmin
fati an fl is rect as describe in se 4.B. beow.
Ma fu employ in Por ar lote on th 6t fl of th lloyd Cete
Tow. No tr fuon employ ar stti on th 6t fl an tr
fu employ do no have badge acc in the ar of th 6t fl wh matig
fuon emploee ar locte. A vito log is mata at th lotion.
8.Acces Reons
Visito lo ar ma at th Port Cotrl Cete. Notæ of any vits to th Porlan
Conl Ce by maket fu emplo ar al pote on Pac's In we
si or its OAS, alon wi a depton of th pu for th viit
Th ll Ceter Tower budig is sh wi ot copa tl acc is l'trct
by floo In th sitution any emlo who is no stlior on a pacu fi mus eithha a bage pett ac to th floa or must cota an employee on th fl to es
th dur any flr acc. Badge for markeg fuon employee do no alow su
emloye to acc a tr fu facity or floor With a pers esrt fr
a tranon fuon or ot no-ma fucton employee. F1 badge fo
tr fu employee do no al such em to have ac to ar
hoin maketigfuon employ witht a pers esrt
4
Ath XRG 17.pd
Sti of Co Co Pr
Pag50f18
10 PAe--1Q-a
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2Page 47~.)G.11
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
PAçifl(-()RI'
S.No Couit. RulP~js~itefn ~~yoasa codUi fothdiofno-pilic
~~oninlitoilS makefUonemp~. Anem~~cotr~øn.tWagafP~Wit$aftei$~teft~1lpt(~~onintoany of th tranPtQtler~$ .n\~ftd'emplö)t
N()..littronÑl()~ti~Ude.infoon:rti to tlp~~.~gQ1 ~out otday..tøayoptiönindithgrtilt
denyi of ~sec;ie,.tlt jsnptavaßle tothpubIic() on th
tr pr\1'sOA$.
~no CQnltrn aPi~totûemloye,whè() no anemplee.isdéSte as atränmifu()()m~
fuoneipioyeEmploy~ini-venOr..pulicOt coential
tranfudioniiritionbUtth arptte fr sh
such inal; w;th~fuempioyee thgh any
rtA-puC01' off..ASIS èocati.
lnadditithnocouiiu1eapP to eourcation~
PadRCQl'eiPloye Elø maft eJptyeof PacÇa
af*Mi~..Bn.coy.iSan afæd el
~ pryi. P~Cqcash~() with Mierca.En Coinpany
with on øcc:Qn.Mi~an ~Coparseledìktr~ c:lamafuet1oYee.Nonopublict: fuon Wonntieith~t Mita~CoiyOtpaâforp,shd be Sl. wi themloee.
LiinoMi~am En Copay J.pili.tr f1ln()shcl be ~ wi.Padfi$~.lt trc1make fueipIo.
SiiL~ Nót Natu Ga aIcl Ke. Riwraæafli gt tnsion prvide,
Ce MidACland PaQCorpSas S1pply anunte re sece eiploye
en in.1l ftdionthNOt Nå~ Ga or Ke Rive ~ No no
pilic~()fictinnnati otNor or Ker $hdbeshw;th th
èiiplòyéè
5
St of Conct Coe Pr
At XRG 17.pd Pag6of18
10 PAe--1()
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 48Atme XRG 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Pi\(lfl(()RP
6. Trancy RuleA.Co~ DI$O$re.R.ll'me
If atr~Qtpreipiøyeedios.nøn-publi ttanftoitinrmtioninanl COtò tlSta of Col1cttheip1oyee .is..retø ~y
CQctith.Re Coli R~at 5013-,.pr. 6, Øt801-22,pr.6,oranycoplæøfñce.IntiOh dîos in vîotation oftlStarof CQtdllct
mus be ~tey po on th ln web si~ orOAS.
i. Expt fo Cusme Infon an Cri Ener 1~c;reInftinUnd tl exem ttan prvîder al retøpøiiceof dios,l:t.nQ.
it noafte. ct inrmtiQtor.çrti en fut1búritiOhonitslnetweb siæ6r OAS. 'lexeiptOrwialSaplyt6 lXy.() în~n.~Ca~is$Ubjtolite~tiQt.
il.TI' ..5p. Ex..ptonUnciei tlexenpt~oiiprvid. donø ha'Yetø~yd*løeinti tht maie sole toa tr fucts sp ~fó~
ae. Th expt pe di of te inQt~iñ..~
sy ;,d prct. option of th tron sy if ælafew.tlrnk.fucts tranon rees
il.Vourt Cose EX
Anø-aftetUst.lXY vø~taçøtin wititØaUQWthe~Oh
prvidetto..sh..su.ctLö'S intionWi~~OhenpJQ)ee.Jn.()idtø~~.alnøinIQiia~ly p~to'Uvol~y"CQt,FEC~
tltranfiioprdê t( pø noæóftloonst!l'fórits In web site. orOASlS,aløt
with a~ thtìt did no prvieanyprce/eiiñøpøti;ie:m~in
exchfó th votttcot.
Iv. Reiait ~ toplEX
Attprdé'sttònftOr and Inar.fuem~ mayexçlintipetocopUai\(::ewithRetyi~$Uch.~
mus betKed ex inemqr ci W'.ai:ld mus be rne Ûl'
a$plctca. 'Ixetdsh bemadeavaUableto FECQ.po re'l ~ rny~is.()fha"Wrtt.ør.ty.no. elcresumas&mar ttines,
or rerdediteexcl. The~r4mU$tbe.il: l9l'fteye
Y. Exn. Ihfon NecêSto MåRln or ltÐpêl
Thexemptøn aIows t:~prvils ~fuc:..i()_eø
~fu emIoyeto.exdtin ne to iiorIáre
6
SW1 of Cout Colice Prure
At XRG 17.pd Pag 7ot18
10 PAe--1()
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2Page 49 ~1'~17
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
lA1lfrcQHP
opti of th tran syst or ge unts or inon th ma af thdi of geat unts Such ex mus be æc ext in em
ci whe a re mus be made as so as prctle. Th
re sh be mae available to FERC up rees Th re may
ço of had-wrtt or ty no, elc æcrd such as e-in
an te in or reed teho exch, Th re mus be
re for five ye.
I.Ac to Traisson Funeon Sp InfnPacCo ha stct its inimti ac sy to en
ma £u emlo of PadCor an its affli do not
have ac to inimti prbite un th Stda of Coduct
PadCorp's inrmti te gr ha implemte cotrls,
whdi ar rewed on a rear ba, to en acc re ar incoliæ.
7. i..." Web ..~. Rt4ui,.entIn~~~no~trprcerFEC~PaçCo
topo~ intiQi Oi itli ~..Si. p~CQ's.lite we. si cube~ alWW~df.am. lroitionpoon th Intert websi is ~ fo
fiVêyefot FBCau.di..Pa.l1 posudi inrmtiOn on itsOASlS.
A. Ge Re annmin, of Poft
i. A tranon provide mus upte te intion on its litet we site
wi se bu days of any chge, an pot the date on whch th inrmti
was update
ii.In thevenat~sudiasanea~ l100 fiorhu.ca, ~y~pta~ptdet'$nørbu..opl:, the poti/reuiénts
may be SUpe bythtlantn()prde If tldîpt la.m~ th on
.~øn the~ion prvidtnttus.nQt l"C andlfy sek a fu exemptonfrinth..po.~ts.
iJi.A1repotil1Usf besuffcitlyprtllastobe readily accib1e.
..W'ri.P~
PadECotp po~ wrltpr for ii1etati of th $bø ofQmuçt
on its InwebsiteandOAS.
7
Sta d Co Coia Pr
At XRG 17.pd PagSOf18
10 PAe--10.
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page SO AtmeXRG 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
I'A(lfl(ORf'
c.o..~.~
PaciÇotpPQ .~ÍQl1owm~ti inti() on its ~'Welslte
· Th naeS an ad ofPaåfCos .ite tlt ~pl or remalæ
fuct emloye;
· A li Of faciti sh by tr fu eilq aninfict
emploee, includi th ty Of fati sh an th addi; an
· Th job titl an jo despt Of tTon fuon erp~.
I) ~ .""nnn
PacCotp ù:...po.itimtior~ip(lW.~.~ias..åffiiateWith
seend4Y$a£thepø~ti..~ iS~.PaciCottn$t.altrt ~pøtial
tr påasAA afate.
E. E""Tl"Eimay tran be. ~~ønfuonantl
in ftcm so lon as SU ttiS1\uslaç:eit
thStoi Couct N~ ofanyempløyttfmbéèeth
~ fucton and th ma (u Win bepoteon the
htte web site an OAS and inude the. £oinOrón:
· NaiOf trfegerployæ;
" 1hievetit:es held at the pror anci ne potion;anci
· 1heff date of th tt.
Employee tr sh not be us as a couit for im
inrmtion sh (i.e., no "cycl ba and fo beee th
t: fu and th make fuct in orer to evad th inrmtion
dios pr1)tión). Employ tr intion mus te po on th Inet
web site an OAS fo ni days.
8. Separ Bo and Records
PacCo ma it bo of ac and rerd setey fti th of its aîte
tht emlo or re ma fuon employ. paås bob an rerd aravaile fo FEC inon at PacCos he 82 NB Multn por
Or 972.
8
Sta of Co Coia Pred
Att XRG 17.pd Pa9of18
10 PAc.-10.8
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 5~l'.x11
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
PAClfIC()f\P
9. Sands of Cond TraniniA... ofCoTrain Rere
Th Stda of Coct ie, an PadfCo pr, tr for al trfuon emplye marke fu emloy, ofce di su employan any ot empl li to be pr to tron fu inrm Th
emloee mus :æve the Sta of Conduct prur in wrtt fo an mus
re Stdar of Coduct tr with th fit th days of emplym
ø.AnTrani., P..PadCoprde an tr on th St of Co ru to al emplo
an cotrct with asgn P-num An ex mus be apprved by th
compli of.
'l.trtnbe live Otetc. oncötion of bo EmpoyWi be ti
.tothav~.a¡5(he(bJlingofsudi tiUûngby bu\Ut mageorth~ai Oltoftpli~
c. .c.CaAlemplothtpardpinSt ofCònct trft'U šignaæion
$ttithtithh.e.~. l:, In th.~of~c tr~emploE!~
be ~ toceé~øitNtth have ~in th tr;MalU tr
aucatiOfaæmallbyth~. ~fîn a 6ldot FECaudit.
10. Ope Ac:c:esTra.lon Tar Implemnton
~.~onptvideinus apiyal.opacc.~ ta (ØATT).~ré~ foth puor $å of~on se (inUd butnoJitefo, ùiofprçe/~, sc~pr~ .an seCl or baina fa li~anno~ rn.Th ~on ptvidetmupt alsi
~secereint:sa ~ancl with th sa t:efr~.
A..5t. ~ ofT Pl'~~iopiermWòtstdd:yen alOATTpr tht 40rt ~
prde fò th usofdion.
9
Sta of Couci Co Prre
At XRG 17.pd P910of18
10 PAc--10-
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 51AmeXRG 11
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
PALlflCORP
I I. Oter InformnShnl Resrls
Inadtiorrtoth inrm shre01.re bythS~ofeodt1ctFEC's seate Ma-B Ra Af Re en tht HmairtiøJ.'
is no pa beee PadfCo En employe or its cotrac an .aneinployee
of a in-ite powe sa afte such as Corova En Coy;d:yor
indiy. "M in" is bry def by FERCtome acouneaonbeeeautityanitsafte poer ma COth utitys, órhafte
powetmarke's, powerortranioI\ bu, inuding:· PosliveiUdneliveitlionstch as saórpuSé thtWiårWi.rIbe made¡
· Prt or Ñtuittlo,· C~otpoli mf:itionw
" Iiti ofSicaL or slt value.
Th Afæ Reon al pre tht PaåCo wi not dùy or in.prade
to any afte powe make peel no-puHc intiOl æggtr~avaty term or rate on Pacor's tron SYte unf$sichin:ition
· Is prvided in re to a tees by a poer tra.tefQr~Olgeiæ
uner PaciCorp's op-acc tron ta;
· Per to thiese and
· Iscopååbleto hinontion prdedfu nofafteMttitiiintMeoletåfth~fc~ÎSon~æ.
PacCorp wi po on its OASIS th dition of any re fo
trmiion sece by any poer makeg.afte in h sama
as it wou po inrmtion fo a ret fo sece by an no-aJiate
elle entity.
12. Quesons and Inquiries
Any queson or co reate to Staar of Couc compli
or an copli ret des here shd be addr
to Colt Nor at 503-13-554. In addition any emloye revig
coplicerete inqu fr exte pa, includi but no
limited to pa rerenti FEC, otr retory boes, copa
or copetitors, shoud re sad pa to th nu..
10
Stda of Codu Copl Prcedun
Att XRG 17.pd Pag 110118
10 PAC--1Q-
XR17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 5~rrXRG11
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Atth XRG 17.pd Page 12 of 18
10 PAC-E-1o-OS
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 5Init~G 17
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Attach XRG 17.pd Page 13 of 18
10 PAe--10-
XR17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 5imeXRG17
Case No. PAC-E-l0-08
Ath XRG 17.pdf Page 14 of 18
ID PAC-E-10-
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page ~riènXRG17
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Attch XRG 17.pd page 15 of18
10 PAø.-1Q;
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page SRttritXRG 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Atth XRG 17.pd Page 16 of 18
10 PAe--10-
XRG17
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page ~me XRG 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
At1h XRG 17.pdf Page 17 of 18
10 PAe-.10-
XRG17
3/10
Atth XRG 17.pd
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page ~metXRG 11
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
~~!.!!lRP
Pa.18of 18
PAC.,E40-lRocky Mounta PoWer
~be21~~OlO
XRGData R.uet18
:QGDjtReq1H18
Plea explai how-th Coy coplied with th pøcìe di inresp to pron re i 6 an i 7 in its negoaton with XRO for th
PPAs at issue in th Complo
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 60
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Res to XRG Data Reque 18
Th Coiy~smerbatfictonut1ìztrissió~infoinpubliciy
avai1lbleonth P~cifiCør Tnuion OASISw~site,fol1owingthe
Stada øtCOduct pr prvide in AttentXRO.17,
Reclde Biie (Jold / Des DesSpo Bro Grswold
PAC-E- io-8Iocky Mou PoweDe 21,2010
XRO Da Reue 19
XRData Reque 19
R.ef Roc Mou Pow's Re to no's Fir Pron
Recst Att XRO 1, Par 2. Pl prvide th job titl an detionfor th followig invis dur th ti fr of the corr
prvide by Roky Mounta Pow.
XRG Answèr SJ Exhibit 2
Page 61
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
a. John Youne
b. Bruce Grswold
c. Nae Weslingd Chs Pa
e. Jim Portwf. DaHei
Resnse to DC Data Reques 19
Nam, poitn, de buses un
a. Joh Youne, Co Admstr, Coeral an Trg. P8fiCor
b. Br Orld,Di, ShorTen Orgion an QF Cotr,Comer and Tra, PafiCo Engy .
c. Nat Weslin Maag, Cret, Cret, PacifiCoi
d Chs Papusk, Dior, :R isk M8Dagent, Cret, PacfiCor
e. Jim POluw, Tra, Engy Mang, Coial an Traing, PaeifiCo
f. Da He, Anys FinAcctig, Comia an Trag,
PacfiCo
b:lde; Br Grswold lDe DeS~ Bru.Grswøld
PAC-E-1O..08IRky Mounta Power
Deceer21,2010
XRGData Requet 20
XRC Data R.eques io
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 62
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Did Rocky Mou Power inor XRO dur a telopho COYétiønonor
ab\Ú Novembe 10, 200, th ttsson may be avle for all f01 XRO
projects if the prjec cae on on or aftr JuneZOII? If so,. plea idetify
anprovidesigdoentseslisngWheRöCkfMòuntaPowetfut
Qee awar of ths possibilty of adtiøna1:Ì$iøn çaìt.
Resonse to XRG Data Reues io
Nø. Tbe~~ di$ÇU$trsioncon$Ilts.4ug aNov~rlO,2Q0
coiierecaUdurng which XRGsiiggestha.~a Jun20U
CØercial ønin_ foritsprostprjeçis niightlltletn$$ion
contrt issue. Rocky Mounta Pøwerdidnot.ag tbta June 2011 one
date wod aØly ad th trsmisson ooI't issu.
Du the Novembe 10, 200 coce cal, the paes di th Rocky
Mounta Power's trsson fution ("PacfiCoi Trasson Serces" or
"PTS") is Kheduled to complet a sees of trsson sy impryements
beee Popus Subston and Ter Subtion by Janua 2011.
However, the paes also dise the fa th Ro Moun. Power's
me fucton ("Comm an Trag" or "C&T') do not cotrol the
PTS cons schee rega suh trsson sys imprvemts and
tht C&T ha no asur tht suc imroemts will be available in Janua
20 i i or at any tie in 20 i 1. Moreer, copleton of th Populus- Ter
upgr likely would not alevate constrnts acs Path C sucitly toacmm all 70 MW ofXRG's propo output at Bray without cain
Rock Mountan Power to cu a corrndg amou of fi imrt fr
Network Reoures utizng the lim Path Ctrsmission caity.
ReldeSpor:Bruce Grswold
Bruce Grswold
PAC-E..io-08Iooky Mountain Power
Debe 21, 2010
XRO Da Reue 21
DO Data R.ue 21
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 63
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Refeiai Rocky Moun Pow's. Resns to XRO's Fiø Pron
Reques Att XRO S.
a. Plea exlai bow PacfiCorp C&T bee awar of Pa Con
Sepbe 13,2010.
b. Plça explai wh PacfiCo Traion fi be awa th Path
C wonld exist.
R.llsetonG.J) Requestlt
a. PaefiCoip C&Treewedtb availetrSsion caty~on for
patCq:n P~ifiGorp Tnission'sOASIS weite.
b. paçifCqrp. Tl'usrisoi.fideitwou1ddeiptPai C as. Poi
ofServee(for:netoit reat()) qtt OASIS afew week$.PJ() to 1uly 15,
2010, 'W itd.ver tbldi Powehasplîtits OASIS po naed
"IlBR,"wlebisaaacenttq Pat C,into sean dièt$Ccdg
PQintSna "Bonn" an .~ray:' PaeifiCor Traionimplen~
theebaon July 15,2010.
PAC.E-l ()8/ocky Mouta Powe '
Debe 21 t 201 0
XRG PaRequc$t 21
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 64
Case No. PAC-E-10.08
e. Neitb. PacfiCo Trasmisson wa no awa, at th tie it øegn,
Path C as a Poi of $~ce, th th cha would have any efeç() the
ability to prvide futu t:ssîonseceto XRO.
d. ThedirefetooiiJulylS, iQIOwaii . new ~~ pa
.po'..butin Wa årting .()ftliahY'exîsti~PatCpo.
e. (î) Yes, PacfiCo Tron êoidepr'.pa' iø.redigto
rets fortrSTissøi sece.
(ii) Yes,PaçifiCo Traon prde aplicæts fo. trD$ii$iOl sece
withiirmon abut fl trssøi .sy up~thtmaYi:lCan
aplicatsabiltyto seur trSSon sece. HO'evr~th July 15, 2010
inodêåontø path C$a PoiøtofSece W8iiota ~on systeim~
(il) No, as of De 20, 20 1 0 ther ha be no trss seee
reest for the XRG prec.
f. PacfiCo Trasmisson deign Pa C as a Poin of Se (for neor
reaton) 00 July 15, 2010. Th cha prvide adti fischeul flexbil, wi th un ret tht mo reur using
differ fi pat to Pat C Poin of Sece coul be scheuled usg th
sa fi pa fr Pat C Point of Sece to Ut loa even though no
phyica upgr ocur Beus thre was no physic upgr rela to
the July 1 S, 2010 ch, an beau th in in scheg flexiilty
tht rete fr th .July 15, 2010 chage wa not ex C&T did nø
look for or diver new flexibilty acs Pat C unti XRO's Firt Dat
Reque caus C&T to review Pat C OASIS de in Sebe 2010.
g. No, PaeifCor C&T ba no knwlede of avaable caty ac Pat C
prior to Setebe 13, 2010. Pnorto Septebe 13, 2010, C&Tbelieved thal Pat C available caacty ha be reed an ba no exon tb
caity wod be avable. In re to XRO diver re
PafiCor C&Tmad OASIS inqes on Setebe 13,2010 an
discver the &Yaile cacity. C&T immedly reque all avaable
caty fr PacfiCo Traion an reuested th PacfiCoi
Traisson alocte th caty to C&T as Networ t:ion to deiver
Network reur to Network loa
Recolde: Grold I Desmas
Spor: Bre Grswld
PAC-E- i 0-81Roc Mounta Power
Debe21, 2010
XRG Da Rees 22
XRG Data :Reques ii
Refen Ro Mouta Powe's Re to XRO's Fir Pi
Re æqt No.7.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 65
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
a. Do Roc Mountan Pow adt tbt it did not provide its deptn
of th ''p flws an omss in XRO's aplicaon maals" ua itsSep 2 i, 2010 let
b. If no plea idtify an prvide th code ft Roky
Moun Power describing su "pt flaws and omssons~' eaier.
c. Is it Roc Mou Pow's policy in PURA negotion to wat
apxily 1 ye and g month (Jan 200 to Sebe 2010) af aPPA re to prvide Ro Moun Power's detin of th "patet flws
an omission" in a PUR A PPA aplion în a ma sutialy simla to
tht at to the Sein 21, 2010 let.
do If no plea explain why Rocky Mounta Power waite appxily
1 ye an 8 month to re to no's reue at isue in th Complabit.
ReBS to DC Data Reque 22
llocyMountanl'ower objeçtoX'G'sDa Reqv,22 to tli~~tbit
Sêlcàl expopinon~ iåtepopinonörleg areItan to th extet it
calsfor R.()Mou Power to s..an QPiinii .pre()lywrtw
~irUC Rte22S. No an witb
waiVig th fotgoing
øbjøønR.ockyMount. power re as foiiows.
a. No.
b. Pactl()nQted~O of potetial "f tl"ne~XR(l's
coon it fuer due digen onOçbe 2,200,an.gln () Apri13, 2~10. Thse wrtiwer prvidedasEXbitA..19andEXhbitA-2S,
revely, inEXhbit A, to Rocky Mounta Power's Fi. Pron
.Req to XRO.
c. No.
d. As.discit Rocky Mouta Power's R~toXR.rl'sFir
PJuÇ() R.~t,:oRees No.7, Rocky MOun Power seXRG a
dr PPA anasedJorcomments on May III 20Q. XRG4id iitrean.c.
wicoelts,reionsoradtiøn inormtirept thdrPPA.
Rocky Mounta Powerreite itsret for couuenonthe dr. lPA
on Oc~2, 2QQ9. Apin,XRG 4idnot re Neenextste in
PAC-E-I0-lRky Mounta Power
Debe .21,2010
ARGData R.es 22
netig th dr PPA ar th rebilty of XRO. XROneetoverfy
tbtthinon0n prvide by it in Janua 200 is stU cot (as RÔky
Moun~in Powerre in Ocbe 200 and Apr i3~2010).XROnee
to. tellR()ky MO\ Power if any of th te.pfthe P.PA arnøt
~lean 'Proaltetive lague, ifany. XRGålsOIleetoIIe
Chceinth drPPA, suh as eleçwbafc of~layaefatítsety
it will prvide an wli it Wi prvi fiial inon in aida!
Ro Mouta Power's crtwort review. Unt XRG prvide siß
informon Rooky Moun Power cat dee.with cety.wh
prjec-spfic iion is misug, wh inoron is in or wbâ
adtion inoration may stll be reui As dius in th ~ns to
ARGDataR.t No. 10, thpt of deel()inaR~sa
inftîonforan Ida PPA is iteve. Any faJurwdelopsut
ii~in~öt Wìtl .te.to.XRG'srefotPPAsiibetJtetofncr'srefu to~dto,orcøeJt.qi tldrPPA~
by Roky ~oanPowet.lietiecXRG ha boyethe)~and
Roc MoutaiiPower ~ be left to ~veadialogWìthil$lf.'llK-
excltisive lits ofii inortion prvide by Roky Moun Power on
Sebe 21, 2010 wer a ¡o fath ef by Ro Moun Power to
ma pr noth no's lac of coon Roc Mounta
Power dees tht its Sebe 2 l, 2010 let wa th fi ti it
councate with XRG rega ne inoo.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 66
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Reclde: Bru Grswold
Sponsr: Broe Grswold
PAC..E-l Q.08l Mounta Power
Debe 21, 2010
XRO Da Reque 23
XRG Data Reques 23
Refer Ans FOURTH AFTIV DEFESE. Ple idetify an
provi al dots or evden sn th ason th no's prjCG
wer not suciently ma.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 2
Page 67
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Jl to DG Data Req 23
Roc Mouta Power obec to XRO's Da Reque 23 to th cxæt th it
ca for all doents an stu on th grun th it is unuly buen.overy br an may se irlevant and or pnvieg infoon Rtl
Mol, Poweobec to XRO's Da Reque 23 to the exte it se ex
opti a leg opon or le argu an to the exte th it cals for Ro
Mou Power to st an opinon not prviouy wrtt See IPUC Rule 225.
Notthing an withut wavig th forein obecon Roky Mounta
Power resp as fonows.
Rqçky M9U1t$in Pow$" baaJYprvide XRO with ail.non-pvilcF
dourrespiveto XRG'sDa.llt ~3.
ReldSp Bru Grswold I Des Des
Bnie Grswold
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
,"'-r1lJL.ì
11'.... q eEB. ')? P"A 2~ 49,Jjli \ _,~,' Lf- ,1.
XRG LLCs' ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR
SUMY JUGMENT
EXHIBIT 3
Rocky Mountain Power's September 21, 2010 letter regarding transmission
a'failabilit)
and
XRG,LLCs' December 13,2010 letter -- REDACTED
!!Adams
i:gt:
."m:
To:
CO:IUbj:..me:
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 1
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Jef 1.,.(I~.lkl.C(lT~l~2tl2010 5:43PMPetRicrd
Kerf Kaufmann; Gr. Ad
Re:XRGPecCQ No ofavai'bltrnsmi$$iO 21$e010.póf; ATT02188.tx
Pete:
SOnds goo. It. attaçhing atøpy of ,letter that Bruce Griswold just sent to i,.,Clrkt.lis. ....r41nl -traiisødssiOra\llililbility.
Thanks,
Jef
1
~~~fe XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 2
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08lis MiJh,st 600Por. 0r9n32
Seembe 2 I, 2010
Mr. Jim T. Cas
1424.Po A.ve.
HeleaMT 5961
Rø XRG-Dp..7, XlG-DP-, XRG-DP-9, XRG-P-ltJ, LL,
De Mt.Cais:
OtJuly i St 2010,iPâCCo TraisSol'.(If1iptt a .Re.Poiøt ofOelivelPoint ofR~tfutNetot Tiansson$er~ undeits.Op Acc Trasson TadCåed
"Pat C".PacfiCo Coal &: Trag ("PacfiCoi C&'rbeeawaofthîi of
tl~to XJG's prj~ alve,on~be 13,.2010.
Tl.nePoiofDeVelPointøflùptatPatCetecveY.inavaablefi
~().lCPatC an
relve PacfiCo C&T's COl'ce$ attbstiC' abuttiav~offi~oi Resur Tanissol' Sen~for theÍ(urQFptee,ab~
pr by XRGtotWverto PaefiCoip at Bry, lda.. Ther~' .tl..ICer prvideXRG..OP"7LLC XRG~DP..8LL, XRG-DP..9 LL, an XRG~DP-IOL.LC 11ti~tmPacñCoC&Tis
iiw~toen_intoa 2()yellwe J'ur apâlt Wie8 ofthes~~,atii
cut avode QO..t'se fort in OPIJC or. NQ.310ZS (or..su sn~ taasmabein
et ol'.the da th paes execpowè puagreits foth~jec). i
Fit c:tyfo Netpt Res 'lissonSCceac Pat C Wil beal.~y
Pacfteo Trasmison 00 a fi cot%ñr seed.bais. i.lfyou WQuld ~tomoveføa:with
yourpiêê~co~ meat.SO~813-52i8.as son as poible. If you dedeto pu. aU
fourpree we woud rees an up on eaèb ptjecpett.~~S(tbweça
C0:Yaiexely.pr..~PPAs.Eah~rel$. crcat'ecspinon. roQF PPA prtionbmtheinmaynotbeal i~ve. AdditiotW inonir beaswe~aiexch dra.
~: XJCìDir..lequi1aIIionn; XRG-OP8..leqlÛed hûon; XR~DP9
ReqIntion XRG~DPio-Req Iinnon
co: P_R.~n
Danel SolarJetEr
i Pac CAT do no gø th PaCo T~ wi lt N. Re TransDisø
Se to th XRO Prje. Howeve Paciñ CAT is no lon awa of any lily fa flw th wo
pt Pa Tmn8S ftm gr su a re
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 3
P.Sì-l1P7OlWAllÛimdM . .. . . . ..... Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Nø~; hJmtlirre~ Ihtliemtixis:noi to Jwc()idmd inclu.'fil'tQldisnot,tnul lt PPA
p.ralJtilltilbølhP(rtiesagQn n11 inlOttatiQ17.P~by Pac- 9121110
XRG-DP7 - R.equ
InformtioD
(a) DemnstiÓ1 abilty to
obai OF stat
(b) Desig capaci (MW).stion se res.
and ne amt of power
delive to th Comy's
electrc svem
(e) Getion teclog another reed technlog
aolicable to th site
(d) pr site locion
(el ScClule of moly
power devees
(1) Calti ordeion of in
an maimum annal
deivees
(g) Moti\'e for or fu pbln
(h) pred onlin da an
ot signficat daes reir
to colete miesones
Pro'Vded - Januar 21, 209
Prde FERC Fen S56 -
QF Self Cerification
Ten DeWin 08.2. 2MW
tu totali 19.8 MW
DeWind 08.2. 2MW tures
Casia Coun, ID
Provided ma of turine
lociOD
Prvided i2X4 gen
for vesta V90 i.8 MW Vt'T
No Iiormtion Prvided
Prvided 12X4 getion
fo Ve$ V90 1.8 MW WTG
1$r Ener = 1211110
Addiolln(ormatin
reauesed by PatiCotv:
Prvide OF nube when
Fonn 556 ackwleded by
FERC
Esimte sttion sece for
ea turb; wil serae
statio seice be reuir?
Ar these still the ~leced
turin? Prvide tuine
snficaon
Prvide cool1tes of prjec
and tax lot numer. Prde
loctio of suation. Map
shos 13 turin. rcile
infomtion prvided in
(b).(c), eeL. an (2)
Recnce diy in
turin mafacture in (b)
an (c) and (e) prouctionforet. Prvide th corr
12X24 for the se0ced turne.
Include the file in excel
formt.
Prd~ calcuatio of
mini maini and
averge anua geertion
Conin data is stll valid.
Provie wind stud for
nroiec.
Prvide upted sce to
acheve th da inlud
interon and
cotrct milesone(i) pr cont ter and. viion
(J) Staus of intertion ortrion art
2Q ya~ qo-lev non-
fuel
Internnecon i. thgh
BPA
Prvide $tatu of Seller' s
interion applicaion
with BP A; provide date
Seller's aplicaion was
dee colete by BPA;
provide co of SiS and oth
stes. if avilable; prvide
documtaton of avilabilty
of tron for Priec to
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 4
BC-PM QFPPl)Ol1d01l. ... Case No. PAC-E-IO-ØS
i¥Q1e: Inforation reue,tI,d in thèmtitr.is not to be,'onsdtmi iiit1usiveond is tlot.fiulfor PPA
prerotiollUltil both ptttes aplon (i1 in/ormation.
Prear by Pac - 9/21/10
(k) poin of deive Bray Subsation
Brady. If available; prvide
schede of reining
interecion work
Idenify prourt lead-
time for majorinterion co
an inicate whethe suh
interion eqpinent hasbee or
Provide sts ofBPA
Trasmsson Serce
Agt to Brady
Substion
Prode doation tht
Seller ha obtined ngh to
wid at prjec site (ie-landour or lea s)
Spefy prer fon of
securty to be prided for
delay secty (leter of cred~
cash esow. or ee)
Plea list all pets.
lice. and land nghts an
contrct (e.g. internntion
agrt) reuied to opte
project; prvide stus of each
such reuired faclitydocum
Please prvide leg na ai1d
2 yem of audited fineia
for the QF devlop or th
enty prviding crt support
to th QF dever SO that
PacifiCor ca complete
credtwornes reew.
(l)Win Rights
(tn). Fól' of Secty tò be
prvide
(n) Req FaciltyDots
(0) Crìwortbies
2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 5.G~pPlgitlAW.rJ .. . CaseNo. PAC-E-10-08
Nnté,' ~Øl~i&tM-."ti..ll"l to be C(~tW i1l1ith't aNt Lsrrfflll.f(d PPA
~JJtipniatilbn.j14t1if!,t~(Q1l.tillinrm(llion.
~reb.Y Pie -9121110
DG-ON -R.eqil"PJoVk ...JlJllar 21,Atlnal InformationlAfo....ti.200 ..uesec.l)PadfCorp:
(a) Domononabì1ty tó PtôvidedFERC Pot 556-l'yietcQF ~.Wb
obtain QF SttQ OF $ef Cerficaon FoS.S6øcledle by
PEC(1) ~ìgn~ty (M\V,T~OøW"ìn .08.2,2MW Esimate stonsece fOtsttion seCe tuines totllìng 19.8 MW eacl tuin; wil1&qte
re1,irel'ÇIt8 aid Ilet $tation aaeeber~llir
amountofpowet deliver
to the ÇOfPity's eltçc
smem
(ø)(ì~er(ion t.olosy DeWin D8.2,2MW At tlistll the seloced
an. other telated tuines tu1ines?Prvie tuin~lolymliÇable tothe Spfication
site
(d)prosositè1ocation C.Coum,ID Prvide.COrdte. of prjec
Prövide n.p of t\ine and wflot numbe. .Prvide
locaons 1QCtiondf sublltiøn.. ~ap
slws .13. tuin.~llile
infonnlion l'vi~in
(l)).(ø). Ce)..ån(g)
(e)$c1iikl\de ofmontlly Prvide 12X24 genertion R.ec1edián in
pòwedeliveres forV~V9()1 .8MW"turine måfåin (b)
WTG an (cl ~ (e) praon
for. Prvide t1COrr
1.2 forthseeøed tuine,
Inclqdethefie in exel
formt
(f). C'a1It1onor No Infòon Prvided PtvidewCUon ofdeterûon ofmium tnnimi~r:ur ånanriumanuaavi;ge imua ~Qn
døJvees
(J)MOtve ..fo or fuel Pt'lded 12X24.g~ertìon Con dlta is stil "Italid.
1'1$1 for Ves. V90 1.8 MW Prvide wind styfor
WTG projec.
(h) pr~on-1ine date 1st È,etgy=1211fl0 Provide ~ed seleto
ändother si¡iCät dãtès aclev th. dåtes including
reui~tOCQirplete interon and
1liesnes c~on míld$es
(i) pt$ec ÇQtrGt ter 20 ye. non..ieve1ized,non~
ändPrCÙgørvisions fuel
(j S.9finterecon biterecon is throug Prvide $laM ofSeIletts ortrassonammgeert BFA iitetec01.aplication
WithBPA~prde dae
Seller'sapücatiOll WK
deeççUlleteby llP.A
1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 6
XR - DPS OF PfA Infgrn Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Note: In.foatio"1W/.ested ¡nthe matr is not t() be t:onsderedinê/u.ûl'eandis not fina/for PPA
preion U7ti both parties uge on al/ i1ffo17tion.
Prep by Pac - 9/2 i 110
(k) point of delive Brady Substatiôn
provide copy of sis and other
stes, if available; provide
documtation of avaabilty
of trnsission for Prect to
Brady. If availble; provide
schedule of reinng
interecon work.
Idenif prt lead-
tim for majorinteecio conets
an incate whether such
inerecion equipm habe or
Prvide st of all
Trassion Prvider's
Trasson Serce
Agrt to Brady
Subtion
Provide doctation that
selle ha obtaed rights to
wi at prject site (ie.lad
nur or lea .
Spe prfer fonn of
securty to be prvided for
delay seurty (leer of crit.
ca esw. or llte)
Pleae li all pets,
licees and lad rights an
contrs (e.g. inerecon
agt) reui to opte
prject; prvide st of eachsu reUire facitydo
Plea prvide legal na an
2 ye of audite financls
for th QF devop or th
entity prviding crt surt
to the QF devlop so tht
PacfiCoi can coletecretwores recn.
(l)Wind Rights
(m) Fon ofSecunty to be
provided
(n) Requi Facilty
Douments
(0) Credtwornes
2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3. Page 7
BG-mQ1rtAln0i; .. Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
NfIe:.' ...lr~nre~lt.Ì1ilrelJri;r: i.t1lt.,o bq(:01Lfidø:ed iltc1u.fÎl'EQnt .1$. nøfimil.for PPA
prratkn ltil /)1tparti~siieo.n all inll)rm~tiøn.~QYP.c- 9/21110
XRG-DP9 - Require
liifonutioD
(a) Demon abilty to
obta QF sttu
(b) Dei¡n cacity (MW),
sttion sece
reirents, and net
amunt of power deiveed
to th Compay's elecc
SYem
(e) Genertion tehnology
and ot related
telogy aplicale to the
$ite
(d) propo site location
(e) Schedule of monthy
powe delivees
(f) Cacuation ordeteraton of mium
and maimum anua
delveres
(g) Motive forc or fuel
plan
(h) propose on-line dae
and other sil1ficat dates
reui to completemiesnes
(i) prse contrct teran prcig prviions
(j Statu of internnectonor trisson amemt
Prvided -Januar 21,
100
Prvided FERC Form 556 -
QF Self Cerfication
Ten OeWin 08.2, 2MW
tues totain 19.8 MW
DeWind D8.2, 2MWtwes
Cassia County, ID
Provided map of tuin
loctions
Prvided 12X24 generation
forVesV90 1.8 MW
WTG
No InlòJ'oli Prvided
Provided 12X24 generon
forVèsas V90 1.8 MW
WTG
1 Sl Energy = 12.31110
20 yet, non-leveJized, non-
fuel
1nterC()liiec is thugh
SPA
AddoDal Inormtin
requesed by Patior:
Provide OF num when
Form 556 acw1edge by
FERC
Esimae stion sece for
each turbine wi sete
station sece be reuir
Ar th stil the seleced
turine? Prvide tuin
spificaion
Prvide cordnaes of prjec
and tax lot num. Pride
loction of substion. Map
shows 13 tuin, reile
inomtion prvided in
(b),Ce), (el, an (g)Recile dicran inturin mact in (b)
and (e) an (e) pronfor. Prvie th co
12X4 for the seeced tue.
Inlude th fie in exce
font.
Prvide calation of
mimu maimum an
averge anua gention
Con daa is st vad.
Prvide wi stdy for
projec.
Prvide up scede to
achiev thes dates includin
inteion and
conson mileon
Prvie status of Seller's
internn applicaion
with BPA; provide date
Seller's aplication was
dee complete by BP A;
1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 8
XR- DP9 OF PPA 1J0IPt.g. Case No. PAC-E-10-08
NQte.- .1'1fomi(lti()lf1tliest~initht!mntrx tsllot to lJ(.òl'sietinclush-eáM is not fiMlfprPPA
Prerl1ti(J/luntil/)liparJi~sagre t:n all ilffOJ11faiføn.
P~by Pac.. 9/21110
(k) point of deliver Bray Substtion
prvide copy of SIS an otherstudes, if avalale; prvi
docon of avalability
of trsson for Prjec to
Brady. If avalable; prvide
sce of reining
inerec wor
Idenify proemt lea-
ti for major
interconnecion coens
and inicte whe su
internecon eqipmt hasbe orer
Prvide sta of all
Trasmon Provde's
Trasson Seice
Agrt to Brady
Subtation
Provide doumention that
Seller has obtain ngh to
wind at projec site (ie, lan. orlease - ,
Speif preer for of
seurty to be prvided fo
dely sety (leter of crt.
cash esw, or
Plea list all pets,
lic., an la ngh andcon (e.g. inerneionaart) reui to ope
projec; -procl sttu ofea
suh reoo facilitydo
Plea provide legl na an
2 ye of audoo fincls
for the QF deelop or th
enity providi crt supp
to the QF develop so th
PacifiCor can complete
crtworne review.
(l)Wind Rights
(m) Form of Secty to be
prvided
(n) Requi Facility
Docuents
(0) Cretwortines
2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 9
~G..,pi(lQrlälafl1tl... .... ....... Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
Nol: i~nrrfllßtltfU1 th€~ isnØt t(1 #1Cfn.'riderälinclu.nl't a'ljs nø/imiføllM:
premliOl'!lii bqtn ptesagret on gil l'!fomutio.ll. .
~byPac- 9121110
DG.J)PlO -R.eqJÛre Provide -Jaø.uar 11,A~"tion~D
lafonnQøn.1009 r~l,1l_" byPaØfCoi';
(a) 0~strti()11 ability tö Prvided PERC Fonn 556 -ProvideQF utn .\VIl
obtamQF sttu QF $elfCeriffcation Fon SS6acknwleded by
FERe
(t)Degncaty(MW),FiyeOeWind D8.2.2MW NOTE:FERC S56 shws 5
staon sece tunes totaing 1 0 MW DeWintutótal 10MW
~llireøts.aid net and 12.~4 Wind pntian
amount øfpowe deliver shows 19.8ti usÌ1g Ves$.
to theCotpany'selectç tur~.Esesttìon
sY$ei seree fOlea tuine;wil
septe Sttiönseìcebe. -.,
(c)Geertion tecol0aY DeWin(l 08.2.2MW NOTE:FERCS56 shv..sS
and othettelåte tues De'\ìndtwljnes totallQMW
teehnlogy applicable to the and 1 m4 win getion
site shows 1 9.8MW usin Vešs
tuinei.Ar th. still th
selecedtuin?Prvide
ture: infieaon
((I)ptØPQ$(site lpctipn CQsiC'oul'ty.ID Pmvi4ecotesøfpt(j~
Providedinåp oftiìne and tax lOt numbe. Prvide
locons locofsusttiór Map
shos 13 turrreriile
inrition prvided.in(bHc)' leL.anCiù
(el Seieie pfinonthy Prvide 12X4 geertion Recnçie~m
powerdelivmes for Ves V90 1.8 MW tue ~ in (b)
WTO and (è) an (e) Pr\1nnfore.Prdø the co.-t
12X4 fQJ t1e~e4tujI1;Inludethe fie in excelfoni.
(f)Caløula.tion or No Information Prvided Ptde èåculloJ1öfdetnaonofn:íni1m 1'il ~hnum,an
aniiædniuianual aVerge 8luill getion
dêliveies
(g)Møtiveforcof fuel Prvidedl2X4 genation Conf daa is stiUvälid.
plan førV'esas V90 1 .8 MW PmVidewi ltudy for
WTO prjeçt.
(l)prpO$e öi4íp.edae 1
ti
Ene,gy ""12/31110 Prvideuptescede to
andoth$ignficantdates ache.~..daøsinludin
tøqlJìre tøcøinlete mt.eciöJ.and
nùlelnes conson milesone
()) prpoed Cónù1ct ter 2Qyea,non..leveiized.non..
andorcilZm-visions fuel
.m.$ta~ofintern.eøon Inteiiieeton is throu2ñ Prvide sttus øfSel1cr's
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 10
ØG - ppl0 Of 'FA lnor9!tin Case No. PAC-E-10-08Note: 'nfrmon 1Yue:edinrhe 11tr is not 10 be('()l1sid~dÌ1clu.m't'an;s notfllfor PPA
prt!paation unl bøth parte.' ap' .onQ/l irrformution.
Prear by Pac - 9121/10
Qr trsisson arement BP A
(lc)point ofdClliver BradySubstoIl
interecon apHcaon
with BPA; provide date
Seller's aplication was
dee colete by BPA;
pnvide cop of SiS and other
stes. if available; pro, ide
docmentation of availabilty
of trmissio for Projec to
Bray. If available; prde
schedule of rein
interecion workIdentify pr lea-
limes for maorintertion conen
an indcae wheer suhinterecon eqmen ba
be ot
Provide status of aU
Traon Prvider' s
Trasson Serce
Agr(s) to Brady
Subtion
Prvide docmentation tht'
Seller ha obtned rights to
wind at projec site (ie. lanour or lea aarens)
Spefy preer fon of
sec to be prvided for
dely secty (letèr of cret.
cash esw, or
Plea li all pets,
lice, an lan righs ancontct (e.g. intion
agt) reui 10 opteprojec; prvide stat of eah
su reui falidoct
Pleaii prvide legl na an
2 yers of aUdie fiei
for the QF âe0per or theenity pmvi crit su
to the QF delop so tht
PacifCor ca compete
crtwortess reew.
(!)WindRights
(m) Form of Secunty to be
prvided
(n) Requí Facility
Douments
(0) Creitwrthiess
2
.!Adms
Fro:Se
To:
eo:IuAthmnl:
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 11
Çase No, PAÇ-E-1Q-08
GreAcms
Mo, Der 13. 20101:45 PM'Ke Kaufmann'; Jef LorPe Ricar; Bru Ort; 1eultsxermet.com'
XRG OP7, XRG OP8, XRG OP9, and XRG OP10Meum of Recing - Raf River Ran (XRG-DP8).pd Meorndm of Recin -
XRG:OP7 (XRG:OP9).pd Memondm of Recing - XRG-P8 (XRG-P7)pdMemum of Rerding - XRG-0P (XRG-DP7).pd Mendm of Recin - XRG-
OP10 (XRG-P10).pd 12 x 24 - XRG-DP7.x1x; 12 x 24 - XRO-DP.xI 12 x 24 - XRG
OP9.xlsx; 12 x 24 - XRG-P10.xfsx; Malt Compl Ma.jpg; 12-13-10 Lett to
Kaufmann.pd XRG Da Refrh 12-13-10(2).doc
Ken and Jeff,
flleiøsethe ._hl letter .nd dOCument, Wearøplaclnc.papercopies ln the mail toay.
'lease confirm recipt.
Thanks.
GrAdaRi & O'Le PLLC
SIS N. 27th S1. 83702
P,O. Bo 7218. 83707
Boise, Ido
Voice: 208.938.2236
Facsimile: 208.938.790
lnformtionçontanèd in thiseletirnicmesse and in anyattçhrnents hero rnyçQttRin lnfunna.tionthat is çonfidelthd.proeted
by the attorney/clieniprvilege and/or attorney work proucrdocne. This email is intended only for the. use of the indivìdual. or
entity named abve. Inadverent disclosure of the contents of this email or its attçhments to unintended recpients is no intended to
and doe not constitue a waiver oftheattmey/ciient privilege and/or attorney work prodUct doomne. This trsmission isfirter
cøvered by the Eletttnic Commllnicatiotl Privacy Act, i 8 U.S.C. §§ 2510-252 L
If you håVê received this emailih errr, immediately notify th sender of the errneous receipt and destroy this email and any
attchmen of the same eiter electronic or prite. Arty disclosure. dissmination. distrbution, copymg otuseofthe col1tentsor
infonon reeived in error is strctly prohibited.
Thank you.
1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 12
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
.......'1'10".1'1' .T ...."
T.I,201.9".7,. ...1 i.......,.,..
ao.. m. .. io." . m N. 2M.... lO Ø7
~13,20io
..u................
r.i.e i l~i..LL.Jll.a~Stfi~.~.rm2O$,:~~."lSFa:~..i
..Jl.....P4e.....xa, XI ~,.. xap.i.
0. Mr. K.;
~it..Wk.......~io_..yøwi...wr..........~ to.1l~ wi be~ Hø.Blao-
bd............i.. CD oftbPPAs .. .""Ib_al..çø.~...,r....__~...__....po..y~.i.__îtJs4itê~.PMiIl$~~n,l ~PlA....lCØo,.li......lU~.å~.~.of.PPl.
Mr. ~mn6:,K.rl1Ð
De.il3. 200"2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 13
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
As Bxergy sucted as eay as November 200 from a telephone conversation with
PacillCorp Traission and as confied v.;th PacifiCorp' s Septembe 21, 20 to let,
trission capity is not an issue. Exerg)' maintains that PacifiCorp's refusal to negotiate
PPAs in 200 wa entirely unjusified. Furer, th reman unwered quesions in the
complait tløt regaring PaeifiCotp Comereial and Trading's process for investigatg
ne ~. designtin on Excq~s behalf in this ca, inluding bow tha pross faile
to __ røiz th tiS$ion would not be a prblem an whPacifiCorp~. . s. .
shoud no tae long to complet the reuested PP As.
Can we ex euute PP As
to yo re.
01 We look for
Mt....K~~i3.,2010"3
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 14
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
v..tM...,.
1?~'-....~..()IA, PL
Cc: Bn 0r Pa--Ca.. ~Grof~ LLC~:
mti....pø ..XJ, XRG-P8.XlG-,âDRO.DP.I0
!!Ad
Fro:Se:
To:
Cc:SUbj:
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 15
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
Ke Kannlk~nt._.ooi
t.nø; ~ber13,20101:54 PMG~A($
Jeft.oYfng P.-rRlarn; Bru GrlWkI; ~rkullsx~elencoRl: ~RGDP1,~RG DPa, XRG DP,end XRG OP10
,.....
i cQnfi...recl1pt.
Thlnls..
ken
on oe..13.. 2919.. at 12:44 PM"Ghe Ad..s wrote:
~. .ken.nd~~f 1
)
) Please Sift. the attached letter and dócuiients. weareplac;lllpatJrcapies in the_it
tocey.
)
~.Pl'a$e corrtrt re.1pt.
,.
.)Thanks.
,.)Gre . ..A
)llchards().l( O'Leary PLi.C
)lUSH. 21thStreeti 13192
), P.O. 90x 721., 83107
,.~l$e¡ Idah9
,. Vt~i(.: 2.. '~..~~36,. Facsi.11e: 288.9.38.'7
,.)inf~lon c()tain-ain thisel.ectroic .sseae and lnanyattedlllnt$ heret:o.ycont:alnlnf()l"t1onthetlsc()nfidentl~1Ipr-ected by the attorneylclientprivi1eie .\'d/()r attorney
Iirk prouct ØØctrine. Tl'is..n is intended.only for the use of the indivldual or entity
nll .boVe. Inadvertent dlsdosureøf the contents of thiS èlHor itsåttachits to
unintende recipiénts is' not intende to and does nO constitute a waiver'. of the
.itorny/clientprivilele andlor. attorney WQrk prouct doctrine.. This transliiss10n is . fi.('her
coyeredby the ElectronicConunicatic)O Privacy Act, 11 U.S.C. §§ 2S1fl..2S21.
)0
)1'f yôu haverecelVed thisélU in erro ..i-.diatelynotifythesencler O' theêrroneøi.$
receiptanddestrøythis emil and any attachnints of the same èither electroic: or pl'ntèd.
Anydisclos\lre.diss.ination. diStribution.. copying or use of the contents or infol"llti()
received in error is str1ctlYProib1ted.
,. ttønkYou..)
~.(~ran\Jøf. ltecordinc - ltaftRiverRarich (XJG-DP8). pdfHMeniranUlofRecol"in,-XRG,.
pp"7(XRG",DP) .pdf)(Merandl.llO' Recording - XRG-DP8 (XRG-DP"7) .pdfHMerandl.Of Rec()rdinC ,-
X.RG..J: (XRG-OP7).pdf)(Menirandum of Recording - XRG..DPiø (XRG..DPiø) .pdfH12 x 24 - XRG-
DP'l.xlsx)(12 x 24 - XRG-DP8.xlsx)(12 x 24 - XRG-DP9.x1sx)d2 x 24 ,. XRG-DP1Ø.xl$xHMalta
COilexMap.jpl)(12..1l-1Ø Letter toicauTânh.pdf)(XRG Dâta Refresh 12-13-19(%) .dOc)
K.nnethKaufunn
Lovlnør ic.u-nnlt.P
82SNE MultnOlh¡Suite92S
Portland" OR 97232-21S9
($l~Jiiø..nis (()lce)
1
(503) 912-29~1 (fax)
[phone] (direct)
ww.LKLaw.com
k¡ufmanQlLKtaw. com
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 3
Page 16
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
THISCCfICATION MAY CONAIN CONFIDENTIAL INFOTION AND MAY BE SUBJECT TO ATTORNEY"CLIENT
PRIVILEGE, THE ATTORNEY WOK PRODCT DOTRINE, THE JOINT DEFENSE PRIVILEGE, AN/ORO"lER
pRIVllEGiS.If you are no the intended recipient(s), or theeiloyee or\igentrespon$ibl,
for delivery of this message to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified "that any
dissemination, distribution or copying of this e-lIi1 inssage is strictly proibited. If you
have received this message in error, please imndiately notify the sender and dèlete thise:.
IRaU lI!isage fro your comuter.
2
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
REeF
ZOU FEB 22 PM 2: 49
XRG LLCs' ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR
SUMY JUDGMENT
EXHBIT 4
Correspondence regarding response time for XRG, LLCs' Production Requests
Nos. 24-63
!!
Adams
Pro:le
To:
Cc:~
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 4
Page 1
Case No. PAC-E-10-08 .
Gr Adms
Thursy. Janua 20. 2011 10:00 AM.., Lovnger; Pet Ric
Kr Sa Ke Kaufn
RE: XRG v. PII, IPUC Cas No. PAe-E-10-e
Conf1f' !
&r....Ad.II$RtchålsOl & o~ ieary PLl"C
SlSN... 21thStre.t,8~1ê2
P.O. 8()( 7218.. ø~7ø7
klsl.. :td.ho
Vole.: iea. .3Ii.223S
Facsiml.: 288.938.798
X.nfl'tlO1cQntainedìn thbeleetl"ic _s5age and in.anyattachantshlMito .-..c()rrlln
lnføntiQO thcJt i~cQOfidentiai,Prøtected by the attorney/client priv1.i.eleand/orattom~
"01'1( prouct doctr1.ne. Th:i enil is intended only for the use of the individual or entity.
n"' abv.. Inadvertent d1sdosureof thé col"tentsof this èmU or its attachlntsto
uninten red.pients is not. intendød.t~ ana does not constitute a waiver ofth~
it'ttorney/c1ientpr1vilege and/or ëtttorney wo.rl( prouct doctrine. This transiiiss10n blurther
covered by tlH Electroi.c C()unication Pri vilcy Act, 18 U. S.C. §§ 2510- 2521.
If you have received this email in er"ror.. i-.iatel~not1fy .the sender of tl'e er'roeos
receipt and destroy this emil and any attachønts of the same either electroic or printed.
Anydl$c1os\,re, dis$e11oatioil di,stribution, copying or use of the contents or :informtion
rleived in error 1$ strictlyproh:ibited.
Tlankyou.
..........Or:i.sinai..ss..e.. -....-
Fr':Jef l,ovl",ier r ntllto: lovin¡erjlklaw. com)
Slnt: Thursd.y., .'.n...ry28, 2eU . :45 AMTo: peter Richlr"son;Gre Ad.s
Cç:kr'is · S.sser; Ken KåUnn
SUf.jeet:XlGv. PltifiCqrPI IPU C.seHø. PAC-E-1'-e8
Peter & Gre:
Th.nkyou føragreeinstoaJ extens:ion of ti. for PacifiCorp to ...:ise objections and respod
to XRG's third set of cti$çovery requests in PAC:. E-1e-ø8. Per our conversation.. both
objections .nd responses .re no due February 15, 29U. Pleaseconfil".
Jef
Jeffrey S. l"ovinier
Loviner kaman LLP
825 HE Multnoh , Suite 925
Portland, OR 97232-2159
(583) 2lØ-7715 (office)
[phone] (fax)
[phone] (direct)
ww. LKlaw. çQJ
lov1ngenlKlaw. Com
1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 4
Page 2
THXS COMICATION MAY CONAIN CONFIDENTIAL INFOMATION AN MAY sease No. PAC-E-10-08
SUBJECT TO ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE" TH ATTORNEY WORK PROD
DOTRINE" THE JOINT DEFENSE PRIVILEGE" AN/OR OTHER PRIVILEGES. if you
are not the intended recipient(s)" or the employee or agent
reSpOnsible for deli very of this me$Sage to the intended recipient ( s) "
you are hereby notified that any dissemnation" distribution or
copy~ngof tliise-maU message isstrictiyprohibited. If you have
received thiSmessageirt error, please illdiately notify the sender
and delete this e-ntil Ilssage fro your comuter.
i
.2Ada
Fro:te
To:
Cc:Sub
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 4
Page 3
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
Je Lovin (Ionglk.oo)
Wed. Febar 02. 201112:18 PMP9 RicrdGre Adms; Ke Kaufmn.
XRG v. Pacor, IPUC ca no. PAC--1o-
Pete:
RøçkyMøn.tëlIn Por intends to fUea IItion for sUJIry judgrnt. .. donit thtn.ktbeMlttøn
iJiicëltesany .bsueonwhich XRGseeks dlscov.ry tn the pending third set of discoveryrequests. Forèfic1ençy we rec~nc:astay of discoverypendil1sresolution of the
dlspcsj,ive Jlion.C:an XRG agre to stay discovery? We would be happy to cliscuss.
.If tttpart1es cannoreachaireemtit.. Wêllyllve to stay discovery Peoding resoluti.ønor
the dispositive iitiön.
IAresPQnse by non. . tOlrro would be ..chappreiated.
Thanks,
Jef I Ken
Jefrey S. Lovinger
Lovinaer Kaunn LlP
825 HE Multnoh, Suite 925
Porlindi OR 97232-2158
(5$3) 238-7715 (office)
[phone] (fax)
[phone] (direct)
ww. LKLaw. çom
10vingeriKLaw. C9f
TlI$ C~iCATi:ON .MAVCOlArCONFtDENti:L ItlFORTiON AN MAYBE SuBJECT TQ. IATTQKEV~CUENT
PRIvtLEGE, THE ATT~NEY WOK PROPCT DOTRINE1 THE JOINT DEFENS.E PRIVILEGE, AN/OR OTHER
PltiVIUGE$. if you are not the intended recip:lent(s)i or the employee or agent respOnsiblefor dellveryQf this_ssage to the intended recipient (5), you are hereby notifi~el . tb.-any
di5semination1distributioo orcopyiiigof thise-iiail message 1$ strlçtly prohibit.c.. l'fypu
havereceived this me 5 s..ge in error, please i.ediately notify the sender an delete thb e..
1111.$$.lle fl" YO\.rcOIuter.
l 51G: 4d9b17a6956857832992l
1
n"'('
r~'~",~ - ,
Ca~e'No. PAC-E-IO-08
...."" 'ì?')t\\' t- tJ) L,..L.v .
.._ i,. nL6 io; J
XRG LLCs' ANSWER TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S MOTION FOR
SUMY JUDGMENT
EXHIBIT 5
Excerpts of Testimony and Brief of Rocky Mountain Power in
Energy Recovery Group, LLC v. PacifiCorp, dba Pacific Power
Oregon PUC Docket No. UCB 44
Lo I KAUI UP.. Nl N\ l .. 92..Oa91iSO
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 1
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.ol..(l ...,15-(S.m.
Jt£
Ap .26, 2010Jl.....,.IIf/JI
Pu Utty~ilØ ()f~A..: fie-
JOBOil48
s..0I t72141
k DEG\' UOVl\'GROtJ. LLÖ,Co vaP~ll"lAC POWß~OPC~No. t144
AtIFit.Ce
BulttUii"~doetar åtorbå __ eøof.P~tfM!llPSMIl.,..
Â8...øoolths__ ..ùenlosPlda st th ex coaoieitto
-il-.~ prde.
'1.yo.ii.~fø.y()U1...
CQ: UCI44SCcc Li~
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 2
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
BEORE TH PUBC UT COMMION 01' OREN
UCB44
ENGY REVEY GROUP LL,
Colat,PAcmCORP"S.MOTON..JOltSUY lVME
VI
PACICORP dbaPACDC POWE~
1 Pu to OAR 86013-031, Pa dIaPac .Po~ly
2 i:ves th Puli Ut Co of Or ("ssoi") fo an orgrai
3 s:judgmen in th abca ma, ~thre~ by~.
4 Rever Oi.UC ("G"ar. diQis..ElO~s COWiptUd ERG
5 fi its pr. se Colaiton Novem iO,200asth c... to øn
6 PaCo to en itapowe puag("PA,?WitlrthavOidO cø..
7 inef pr to Sebe 9, 200. .At de wh ERG SOieø..I\lOJ
8 åi th i-. un. di, th Mii..~ l... ..J.. fol ~.. .~
9 or th pa to fi dive II by Ap 26, 201 O.$le Må ~, 2010
10 Riil Deb 44 812. PaCo~. sø.t.lJøiin~of..
1 i Ap26dealme
12
13
L .STAN.A OF RE
14
15
Oiunoû.tO sujuet, th .Co
vi
th tãaøaUitbtii th may be drlitt
il fa of th novi pu... .1 v. Gø Mo Co., 325
UCB 44 - PacCo's Mo fo Sum Ju 1
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 3
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
1 Or., .40 (1lt. ..1' t1'jud. vr ... if... . íli .._..'f~.._...~.pa..~.to~
3 .... ofJa.() 47 C.
4 y.....,,~ ai~¥".t_ c.'I347 or 44,451 (i (."'I".JI_
S _.l';III.pe.tr.~I..of. TIJI~.
6 ii APUC.."UW1 i.Jl1~...IF.ii~~.....Ae~Â")
I ii U.S.CIt a.a "_""to ~ ~ ... of... .~
9 PlAR 201 .. 210 (....,, 16 OS.C. If M,. ~3) .. ....10..dt__~of~aø.....~lJ
11 .... ..~. .ea. .~,~ t'.øiPUAf210(')12 ..... "....a-. ....e-i.. ~ . ~..
1 ""....li....-lPa.c~tO....._if ,.sof~(l.......
...... ~dî . It.'" .. ~~l&~..........
w: p., Pøw Co., 71 fIC 1 61,153,61,495 (I'"); t1~.. Co., 72l"'
61.0l$,'lAS(l"~
UC44-PaCo'sMø fot~..fpe 2
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 4
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
1 On Jl 23, 199, th Go si SB i 149, th el ii
2 ~ bil .pu by th 1999 OrOlLoshttve Aa. On
3 F~.S,20iJt1~OI prga rem.~ SB .1149.
4 OPUC Or No~ 01..154, sl OJ at i (OPC Do No. AI390,lt 1h~of l
S Pr R.1e1å to Im th Co of Co Ag an.AJl~
6 of FlI). Th.re ex Pa II Po 0e BJeft
7 Oron PtA (aU 768.50 tb 7S8.SSS) an th ~'sP0A
8 reot(.ri29 or th OMAclistratiivJl...). .Seê opue ~:No..o.S..
.9 S8atS7.
10 In 200, th CoiSlOl ov it PUAre2Ct-. ...
1 i ured th Co to COde at 1b ti wh.u ho to rJDi..2lò
12eJ whch niif aD,lJy toele ut TI~~..it
.13 .Wo. ~te_otÐivi29 "Wb it ~.... UN 1i2?~.. 0l
14 OtNo. Os.S8.âtsl. Thugor iI..biUMlI29,th .~.~..
is ~.pr.ro.im1e PUAfo" QFs, ~iifaøi
16 l) ..~ utility an in l se of S'PPAs.~. _.ap tt..
17 ~ tI 1129.~ PiO; ~ Tar ~ 37
18 ~ 3'7. Wlprdêi~fWQ'pløf 10 MW. otik\ t..~ppA$19 lI~~
20 Oi lun6,20(, ~ Bil 838 ~ la, an d~ .. ~/ii
iisl 1149~~ ~'tì Oròl PUA. ..~ot~
22 R.øe OPCDóNo. ARS~9 (Ap 1~,20). Th CoiaM tøløwe
2 8M OPUC Or No. OS-S8 (OPU Do No. UM i 129. lnve Ro to Blio Ut
Pu..1t QuiI Faclit).
UCB44..PaCo.sMöfbr ~~3
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit S
PageS
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.. Th c...i..i. ""çi. th. a QP Ì$1ì oll.th.aW..it
S.........1Ma Pl.l it ~. th QP _..m .... ..._a, .. .."."...... .ihQ' es___ ut....
7 1i.fa..~ 1'., .~. v..~, OPOati. ...at
a "ÐI..~.Nø.UMi4Ø~4,2O.
9 m. AlPI.I'ACT
10 Bk it.. ..ofa...QP,toÑ _8I..lClM NkOiI.-.
11 ..,.._-... 10.. t'. QFi.. UlMW.... to
12 .. ... ..~.. ..sa... 37. BRO ..iDlh ....
13 ...Iå~..ii ~ wdSd3'1by...
14 ..lncøtOl a¡li wi l'. T.. s. _ ~ 17,
U 20. Pa. BØWt 101. IJ Apl 20. !RO's .... Di, Mi16 ~,._~ T~ Se IIP'fIiIlLa ll.
17 P~l_"'.Il..A _.t.Ms. ~.vc Mr.~_ JI
18 ........ ()f~~.. TtåraT"nií.eJtI.. wm
19 'Y.. ld ...1 ... ~..~ Mr. CafM th ~Cø ~
20 ~.... adPPAJ .. tb heii to c. Mr. Y_e. .. ..
ii ~.tli. Wg(a PPA.ll.
lAl............ _~ ... ÌlN~ -".lI.lInÖlt'"
..,... '.'.by_Coki il Al S2l...llyl il efMorc .onNO. ..ll6(lIamQF ~ ruwit.. Aup26, 200~_).
UCB 44.;-Paeol Mofolu J1..4
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 6
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
i In Ju 20. Mr. ~. co PIICAT to.ÍJ ~tl
2 pr for ne a PPA. PacCo. 0r. PaCo CtT ~.
3 ERO th ne of a PPA wa go by $c37 ai th EI.iØi
4 ad iD01on at PacCo's cu geat Mbte. 14 at 4-3;
5 PaCoEXbit 201.8R0 wa en to ~ lh in~ ~by
6 $c37îfaiWlBR.G4oidetoii1iattb$c37 ~fo~
7alPA. .P~. (ìldl,"3.
8 Oi .Jy9.200. PaCO fied .~ Nø. ~1~\Vtl .t1. C~
9 se to.re PøifCo's pU Sc. 37 av co ra m~
10 wi OPUC ~No. OSS84 (Coon af a tWYet cye1olUavoid
11 0Q ra)aim ~Wi OAit~) (~a:ut .,iiøe
12avideCO_ inor~at ieaQJ:.ft:tw ,.). ...li.t,.ActNo. 0912,
13 PaCo iafire_ :~ CO .~ ..1u1y .12.20.
14 ~OPUCAd~Nq.~i2,.Ii Utity fWnaa 1 (Jn~..io.Oi ..~.
15~(). PaCo.sne~.3.7.avde...co ia.\V....in..~.
16 Mr. ~øiwi. Ra"on~ 16. .Ath....17 ..tebtapa .~iion~t4_ a~ ~
18PPA føBlO'$ ~ prje~toø~. MtRarOldê
19 _.A"~OoC&tby.~tmth"da. ld .~Co.hadö
20 .J*. ii~ tl~PPA.DØ waita:waN th.OWoba .1I
l Th inCOui ~ wa fùly ex by Pa Tnis Se ei lMef en Se 17, 20. Paoo. ~ To" El ba pu PITrais s... to ofS10,03330 to re PI Trwis Se's ae Oòto
co a ~ im si aa a fa 1Q. Pa Exib 102 (ø.683.0); PIEx 103 (S6SO.2). ElG.. DO ma an pa to Pa c.l'. ~.GrId.
UCB 44 - PacCo's Moton fo Su Judpi 5
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 7
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
1 PPA "~áD.~.1O ~ it 14.; Pa00, tl4. .1'te
2 _da ........fi Wr_ ...hc8l PaCoC&T l' ...
I ...d,.Of. lPA wc bê .~J' to tI ~..Wi.hcl ia
9 ~";(3) ti ER .ii.io ..~ .Pa.. C£T .Witl \1
10 .... ~ by SI(B)() ofSC31; am(4) ... Pa.I
11..37i-W'h"7..d~..9,20. ..~ 1...
12 Oa.~ 10, 2l, th Comh.OI sePa wi. BRlll.
13 ô....... ().~ 13,200, im ii PeCAT""
14 QP ..tct.. it Md .be..1J ii tM ..ma IRUl to Pe OI
15 1*,11'... 16,.. âö lo vibeof ~~. BRO',,,
16 P. .lS204. BRO ùiea tbit Wòd, .iD ... ~.
11 ~... fi po pâls tatb paatto dualax
18 ... 14. PjØCQe.T_.~. to wo diHp WiEROto......_
19 ~~~_toOOJctl Sc 31 ptii. fo .ioti...
20 ",A~,~. Toc.,EROhl_ prPl e.wi
21 ell of th ~on~.by 8eii (8)(2) of$C. 37. 14. at 6.Tl ~..
22 ha DO ..eX . PP.A or an .~ fC th ~ of. lcp
23 ~.ob""ilil.at6.
UCB 44 - PaCø'.1 Mo fo~ Ju 6
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 8
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
1 IV. ARUM
2 ERG's re 10 "or th ut 10 hoth fee. sc Qfinth
3 or¡i Sc 37 in fo an in pl pror to Se 1,20 sI be d'"
4 1:.U,O "nøa, fa 'Wêb ittiwo ~ .a'-.øfla,tJ
5 øø¡S"'olio_~it~
6 .,A lBGjfut.ltl1""w=!.. .._...
7 UìidØ" th Co'ø reor. a QFis entl to a. ~.....av....CO
8 ra cmifth QF_ th ut haèXawr PPAotif_ bave~in
9 wr 1b a.Je enoblion ai Se OAR &6~3)_
10 OAR 86g.10(29). lñ .~...th rc~ ..th Coi.¡øi. hi .~
II ~thlÎ~~eoWl'uia.fU ~PPÃOIlÎwi
12 ~. re th exlimc of a leg W~ obon
13OPUCOr No. 0939 at. 6. How, th Co8lal .ao1l it ...
14 detb a Ie .ror 0b ha bà ii..... mtb~..of
lSa.wrtt...-iftb..Co ~.tIa1J~. .11_
16 or wi im cW. .1à."
S DO iiÎ1 a mmfl" dl do DO ei.... re wh DO MB it is lI 11
.. roW it re EIO" be re by col fo ove th mo.... DO cb 11..pI it CoIa PI is ki in 1l po ofmt Ba.s.. ti it 'f.OoIIi.. to qu ør _ cl ha DO re to lltto ,. (... du :E paÎReÐC cø to Pa 'I Sw) .. Pa do .... .. ..
he Th on poll ret aI se fa il th Co .. to ER', aU
-- ofdi ra ch_ Pa'1 aU falu to prvi no
'In OPC Ol 0939. th ('ig l1:
Pa is l' bo by Cois nd .. by .. ow Sc 38 (1l ..
Qf .. to Sc 37J 11 Jl il ao" It PI ... in ii
fada or wi DI tW. a QF ma ti a oola wi 1l eoil _ it di
CoÎl fi ba fa or UD de. we ma CO th a (J crOlleobJiJ wa ÌI in di -. of a wr ..__ be th pa.
UCB 44 - Pac's Moon fo Summa Ju 7
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 9
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
12 .. fr di ÎI fa ofBI al tI PIC ha DO acia bi fØ or wi
13 lI de ..:nO is DO Cl to \w pa Pa's ~ 9
14 øo co..
is .. ...%1...... ....'...Cli .....16 _lZl!liilW
1' \" .~ap__.f9 st. _lQPPP~.PaçCQ i9Uo
18 1M pr.", ..___ tò ÌI. ~~1. Th.~~.
19 WI_31ia OPUQ ~ 1'0'-iiø. ..~ 37~." _QF.~.
20 $o31 avela___ mu.. ii. bo .~ ~...
21 PPA.wi.~. ~.37.atl. ,,'øf~.37pr.~øf
22 ...~.~
23 .......... ........ ,....- .......~.....24 ... .......C..,.. ..~....s2S .(l.._~iø i. ~)...1. --
26 Co'.tin_¡sâ . fb (PCö T....issi 8e)27 ~.. .~. ..,....~ ...he by _ Co's28 ~..t\~~ anTtI.
UCB 44-. Pa', MofoS., .J .
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 10
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
I Sc 31. at 8 (emph ad. Th _pa"Í$ieti~ oi
2 Pae lO. Pae lO al ~tb PacCo Tra ~.ai Pa
'3 OtT ar ... fùon. ~ PaCorp ..~... .øf ~.$O~
4~Cä11by th,ecBi~~~ Idat 10.
S Movaby reanlilD of fe law. II wi. th ~øf .tl
6 Commisson Pa adist th ii. prm ttcompke
7 seon 1ì th PPA.prfor QFs.' hcCo c.t _.spio PICo
8 trasson Sece ie.wlêh QFshatoue~~
9 P.~, ~Idld. WPaCo T~on Se_dønø~tø
10 J-.m.0I1 ~. ta ofits PlA.~loø.~..3. ~di
i i seon ma _ be ii it is cly exai ~inSc37.
12 If Mr. Ca wa no al ~. of ...~31, ..Pø.. ir
13 Mi. ..Ca ~.of ~.. 37 in th sp. of 20. Mr. .~.me 'Wth
14 ~if~TJ'.on~~elnit.w;LaRa inAp200tø~
IS.G.s ~..t.~ PaCøtOOt~I..2. At th
"l1îl.~_~. Îl '1-1J PDC.. ~1D~Cl~..tø.~"'ÌI~ 18.C.f..§3SI.2....tiÛI~.~~..,...il. tl ÇØof9F ~aa Sc 37. F.... QF.~ia._~..QI.....,A ~~i: ....1) dI_..~_ ..JM...Qf..". ma ....loOl..a FB~wl....,ÌD'l.ai....~1..it ~ofPEC'..~ ofCo\\c..... 8l.~~ii
popt m.- lJ to" ei a QF ot . Wh"" ...._.. mi Jl .....êl di liJof"~ it is~tto ~.tø ol .~ ~.. F8C~of~ln if.ìlHi po pnintiSt1D..~_..~.a QF. ~ if ~ ~.. .ap. OItOmtc.~ WbIe....
~.... 1D..jb~IQF..s8d..it1l bôdi _ ..r*..toeølo ~in~'s"" .. ..ia.. lO~" CCrt$ii~e'Wth rn ~~aI""_"" -..-40 IQ. A$..~
... COB8wi røÇS.. ofCois ..~.__ if~*'~ti.."~.. bø DCF ...... .. QP .... ........ dieo---eois Sá....8Dap..:n.~..4...PlQ)!~tùJlCtlse. iDdi CO ofQF.... ... Sa op Øn. No.07..120(~Sd
37) .. al Sd Re Ad No. 0619 (M 2. 200 (~ lb di ~apScl131).
UCB 44 - Pals Moûæi for 8rWI Judgm t
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 11
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08
1 ..a..y,.Ot...r ...... .. .~ wk he coul ..lØfoa PPAld.
2 ....... .tø Mr. ~ th~Co T~ ..._-
3 ..WulPAll kL ... ~th.. _~""øf~
4. QlTQf(:c.JJ.~"" y..........ot_of........
., _..l.._toMr.~laøto lû to aûlWr. YOU....aPPA.lJ.
6 kt.Jv.it Mr.~" ...Plif caT. P"~~.
'1 i... ~Cl1øc........ JelYOU. -.Mr.C4..... ....3....:l ~
10 ir is th.liö to '-CO~.s ~I~ ~ n. Of
11 ,......... .... ..~ -'OO...pt.. of or (*) ~
12 ~37. Lcøi kJifyou have atY~
13 PaCo BxWt201. Mt.~_Mr. YOU ~iùe. th
14 .. ...dare.. th 00 wl lii toSc 31. Pac lbli202
IS Mr. ~ "_Mr. Y" aahlidtlcollMr. YOU fu.ltOn.h
16 23. Mt. ~. cl. .~ otT an .ieth .~. ofQP ~
11 JkGiJ4wh Wå ~ fO Jo. Yo_ wh Mr. YOuto~
11 ~it~.ht ~ witl Ids -ld ..~Mt. Gr$'
19 .~Mr. ..~ to th ~~._.. to re Se.37~ ~.
20MI. .~to-. Wi lI.~- ~l4. ..~ fC~a
21 wr ~tb .PPA~..... ni .1J~.7.14 .2..3.
-At" ~.MI ~hI 8D~ 1bPlwo.. a..1' ._2O.~-~.
UCB44 -~lsMofoSu Jv 10
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 12
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
i Olmilai"artb. pi apay-e orlitoPaCø TraissOl
1 i sece..o
12 Althiilbano dutødø ..,PaCo ~ss i.s. p:pt
13 forth pay~utPP.A tøPa.Co Oct. liJWh~ c.T
14reveERG'spa exPP.Aittredtøhep Mr~ Ca..by.te. lûwh
iSh.ne tocl tofoUowth Sc 31.piusi them... pr~im
1I Se B() OI paes l an 9 otSe 31 prvi:
ID or to ob a prje sp dr po pu .. di ow mupr ÎI Miti to ti eo. .. pr ia I8 fo th
cole of a po pu.. ia bu no Ji 10:
(a) dc of 8bili 10 ob fJP _:
(b) de ca (M st se re, an no am of po to bedeli to th Co~ oI sy.
(e) .... te. an.... tlJo ariOlto th...
(d) pi si lo
(e) scedul ofmo po deer(I) calan or de ofmiim an ma ID dler(ø mo fo or 1\l pll;(I) pr oa1i .. an od siif.. re to CO th milo;
(i) pr COIr te an pr prviio (Le. ~.. iD;(j",of~ortria~
(I) POin of 40iv or ii.
10 Mr. Ca.. ai a co of th ~bc 9 ve of Sd 31 to tb plly "lte
PPA su Se 16, 200. Paif00 Grold.
UCB 44 - PaCorp's Mo fo Sum 1u 11
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 13
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
1 ..,.i, ~PI" M". YØt.. Mr. .~.. lI ...... ..
2 _.'IIl.klt 1'1,/2O..... ..of.O'.PPA. ØI .~.BR."
3 ~.... ..fOdl'PA ~..m .~...37,"" sa.-4 __...~Il_~"".(I)().ot~37,.~."
S........._"A7..irW.~byDOW..~.,
6 ll.~ .~_n....',20. .Pa Exõi203. Pí. ti .. it
1 ~_'. .._17, 20. ~ ~ tb Sc.37 PPAì*IUI.
I "Jì." ...... ......_ .~.£RG'. pe.. ~ ...~.
, C&l'_.~"m dU.. ~ I1 ti :(. to. ..pi Ðl'$ "1\
10 ...i..f""U ..or....~....ia~..~.....
12 .. ,.~4i_..~37fKMr.~..itl'...it_ld.
13 .. *I~d. ~ to OIMr.You Mr. YCM'... ..~
14 Mr. ~l"to"Îd ..~. 37, ~i Mr. Or's .- .~. ..
is .~~Cô4i_""Mt..~.. it~.to"'~.
16 ~.PlCo.dM""'..~ 37 ..itW..... tô~.PPA
17 ..... .Çl.........8D ìl1W ~ ...wr~ to ht....
11 ~.tt......by,.laa90f~.37.
19 .~ CAT .. ~ .. ~i7, .20, ~. ..~
20 1'.__.~""N to it. .çøfpø ~PPA""_ il.
21 .. ~ .~.Gr4. .~ClT..4i-.._PPA;
22 .di. ....fP .pe_.. toBRG;ar 4k no bo Ø1 ab.. QP
23 ....ibeii .PPA- .. ~hcit .r.Co CAT . fi di ømc
UCB 44-~"Mo.fc.~h""12
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 14
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
1 ev spking wi Mr. Cate lIut his pI QF preø 1d Wh a~()
:2 itredire th hcCo CeT spe with Mr.Caii.l _,~
3 ~....~ un. ld. PaCo C&T.~. ~ ~
4abPP.A at th aplion pr th do DO euimt in awr~fø
S a PPA Id at 3. Of ca mely re a bl PPA u pe of¡nbrpi
6 plamng. Id. PaCo C&T reve ca frm jo. polDko$, .~
7 ~.Gd .~. in ad~ to ~. ~ 14. ~_..
8 .~. .:w....~ ~iil P~do. op a,Øl.or .be pi..~
9 coUDøø wi aQF un1ilPaifCo ear reawi ~.fø..
lOPPA. 11 IdMr. Ca ha noce of th Sc 37 ta aø eifo totø
i 1 it orch to ig it Ha he sutt to PaCo a ."Wie.- fo a ppA.in
12 _ 200.heWlli leab th pera -"m_~. wi
i3hcCl CÂT fi. ttd_'øBRO's .pd ~lPi. it ~tW
14 ~.. '.WJ¡_~for.piM,. miSc37,aøpve Mr. ~
is ~. of. sl oIQF.aw CO ia th .. da. It/ at 4-S.
16 Pa. ... wi Mr. ~s ~ .th... Pa
17 T~"'Se_diii.ùi hi of Pals_ ..~_..
18 r. wa . th re.ofW fa ~ caT,...it~3ii ..,.
i9apby.~ dø_teP~T~~.Wh ti
20 Co, re ne..... ~.didno 1m.Wh .. me ..
21 Mr.~m.Ap 20. ti. ~ C&Twoul Ø:a....l"m
22 Jul 20. PaCotoo, la. i. tà Ms. ..~.. :f i. 'l
II Se Se 31. at 8 ("le ot di by th Co. aU collic to di Co
te QF popu ..- sh be din m wr to ~F Co).")
UCB 44 - PadCo's Moon for &i .f 13
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 15
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
1~~. ..~.. _ .,. w. oied ft Mr. ~.m
2 ...,. r.2Ø.U 14 .w-... 8Qin .po.fa in Api1Obf ..
3 Ii~. c.iø..wiMt. y~. iatw reenedbiiø sc31.
" G ... ...".....md.......dr..r5 ii'" .-.ila .'11~ Ob.tø-.......'~6 ..O_~...~~...bl_~ot~ck-
1 ....~~or..'d~ERøt.~~9., ii,.""
a ..w_~_ot..deJl_la.~.fli.. tl ~.
, ~.. 9. 20. ~ DO hû ~ 37 ,PA .~. .
10 PlCO otTóI ~ 16. 20 -.. $i .. tJ ..~ 9 ...
U ~37" .. aaan ii 1:ot OCaf u.~ ...
12 ~oø ~bc 16.20. woc. no p\t ri. to .. le .~.
13 ~to~'~20...
14 v.. COCLUSION
is D.G is ei.to. PP.....Sebe 9. 200avoU.__ _if
16 ElO." ..tø..~on.s sa tb~~.w
17 fithot"" it~... thde ER.Gofa.fu ~ lPAot a
18 Wr. ~.. roth .aiof .. lepy ~leobOli..be
12~......tiltdi..iaOf.,nI~....OPC
.00No. 0939 ..~4. 20ia OPCDo No. tI 1449. ~ CATii p*
Jl of ..._ ...ôI ... on it CIer aacn .. .ll ...e-",JJW~Cf.htn.Atit..lI~ we...ui I~..~ to QP.... _~..... (..li;llw.paif~...- Pl,.__~..~-~...~~tMil~..-jlIO~.._..~~....pØ~~1Ola~T8
....~... fOøoofll pe.lpli~. ~.1Omi~ 00l'ia~. ~_Qø...'s iP in ..Qr No.ø.39 "'~at'".. at ~ iD...... ca. _Shld nö bè aplk ~ .. ..bà ro Wi..-~."'.iD li ft
uæ44..~'$~ fo~.._7 Jvi 14
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 16
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
i Sè 9, 20. For th ie cf abve,tIfa in ths C8 (am ål
2 releii to be dr ft 1h fa), ev. wbé view in thlilh__
3 fae ito ERG, do iisu a fi th PaCo .ae. in ibefath or With
4 ~delay.,
5 ~ORE,P8C(re re.tltlCOon fb th
6 thaino ge is of ma fa an th Pais en tø~
7 ju.as.a ii of law, an re th diCoon .tl ERG's ~
8 wi prce.
Date th 26th da of Apr 2010.Re su
By
,OS96147Ke . Kantì 088 98672
Lo Xaan LLP
Of Att for PacCo82 N.H. Mu SU 92
Pó Or 9722
(503) 23o-mS~miC
Jor A. Whte, OSB 0970Se CoPaftCo82 N.R. Mul Sui 180
Potl Or 972
(S03) 813.5613lo~
UCB 44-- PaçCç!sMøti forS1 ~15
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 17
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
CETICATE OF SERVICE
i~ _ _00 ApI26, 2010. I sea f;. _..cø..coøf#J ~p~',JlfoSIl ~ on th fOllwm.iupeeD byf1eiMå:
MI CAMAAGIG DIR
BNY UCVEY GlOUP LL
POBOX 21420
SALOR9'07
ED DURERGER
PUUC UT COMMSION OFOREN
PO BOX 2148
SAL OR 9708-2141
I ~ce"'oDAp26, 2010, 1$C .tr. CO co of"~P~',Mofø ~~ 0J tbftii peeø by~.ma:
.JAlA .\V. (\OREGClN~ll
SENCOSEL PAClORPOREN J:
'~eiCPOWJ~ LIaHT 82NE MUTNOMA JT STB200
140 W NOltnl'IST32Ø POk'I 01.9132
SALT LACl1U'UU6 -..""1ø.
THOM HNEON (W
PO.IiX:iiilWE.01.:971..121 I...,.-.....iil_
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 18
Case No. PAC-E-I0-08
1A I KAtJ LL
as HE w. _. Su 92
PoOl ""21~
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 19
Case No. PAC-E-10-08
.~..1'iS_.91
i-
A.26,2010
MI". lib""" U.. JI
Pu Uti CoMf ofOn
At Yt1iD Ce
POll214l
s. ott 972148
It: BNOY REVERY GROUP, LLC, Cola vi.PACJCO dbPACI POWE Ra
OPUC Doet No. UC 44
~FiJ.Ca..b~hi_~......Qf_lvecøoltbDh
r~ ...E: øfLn Ri (paeltJlOJ) an th Di T~..!i1Ø t11k Gr(PacQ10f2fU).
Al... co.oftl ccleisenlø l'dast th.ex .colJRlitto
"Ùltl-~ ¡)'\decl.
iiY' Ùl~foYO\~.
SiDy.
:/-
cc: uæ 44 Se LiEn
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 20cas~"f.
BgoRE TH PUC UT COMMON OJ' OREN
UCB44
ENGY REVEY GROUP LL
Compt.
va
PAClOOIt dIJPACDCPOWE
R.t.
DIRTINYor
BRUCE GRIOLD
ON.IØJ'OF
PÂ.ClCORP
Ap 26 2010
i Q.
2 A.
3
'"
4 0-
s A.
6
1 Q.
8 A-
t
10
11
12
13
14
is
16
17 Q.
18 A.
19
io
21
22 Q.
23
24
,,''''....,;'.'..,......,
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5Page2~oo
Case Nò'~Y~UD8
,...,............
Bn Cìld. ~. 825NH M~,Sak ~.p~. ~
9132
WØ..,..................î..~
lam emoy" by Paêo fWtiîi tb~.t Tl'de1I
.. ~.øfSbT.. Qr.ai Ql. 'ac.t'. Co..........,...........e.......
lba. aa.s." M.S.... ~ ~ Io Me.. ..
t1 auOtSt l1ìi, reve. lbaw be.,. Wi
~o_~ye in va pootlêbim ieeD
.~ ...~. ma.i'. an.-w .CI .~I. ia. al
wo.ùi~ .ii.alwi .. ~ fiii apt'1ol'.
I.. Cû~ we. in .. ee.... Tta ..bu UI.of.~
~r,.Coc.'rM'..Di._... QF- ..,..~. ..... ~.... ...tb...._~...~.DIwi.....~.........,,....,..?ll ~of.~.tD l'la _~ wi...R.
Ot1.MD"i.. .... wrCO.. ..~
~_SlG,_ dåhO ~.ii..~ fr
..QF$tòJ'PØch ~("Aspvto...31.,........,........ii'. ...il........~
c.T....... ØG" ..1I.aPPA for Q.G'. ...... .. .,.....Xh...l'..o...(......~
i A-
2
3
4
S Q.
6
7 A-
S
9 Q.
10 A.
11
12
13
14
is Q.
16
17 A.
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2S
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 22CaseNo.~GrJd
i pa.in ce councdon bo SIO an .Pae.T.. As
Di of QF Cæ an suso to J"Y~ QF .~
.A, I wa gey awa of coUD beBRG _
PaCo C&T.
Ar yo... of al CO "'_ERG 0.... np.........ay..pi. of..dl.rpC... Piwto..........nO'.:rJ-'
No, to .thbe.of ..inknwlede ERG ba no co wi aiieieeof
PaCo QtT~its:Pjepr to Ji200.
WlcJ ERG 1i...CO wi~e.Tt
Mi Ca,on be of ERG, ca Mr. YOU fo tbifi _ot or
abut Jun 3, 200. AJ 8$ Exõi ~lan £x.
~02Î&tñ exNiOfembeiMr". Y~..Mt.i~
on lun 3 in..wh. Mr. YOUidiMt..~toPâC'$.~
seillot'Wpq.
Di )'011a lI eo wi ERG .. .i 2I? If,.,. ......ti.. ofyfM....
Yes i sp wi Mi Ca, Ma Di of lio. t. ph on a
Ju 23, 200 ph ca. No, Mr. You 1l ha .. suh a
phca bu he wa on va My re ,. Wb !I to
po aps fo a Sc 31 PPA is to em_ poi. de If.a
co ofSd 37, iq tb ap to.u wi an ~ .. iu th
ap to sv a wr te fo a PPA COII th iaiiilon
re by SC 31 if he de to se a PPA. Mr. Ca to me
ab hi prje aa to me th i. ta ~ wiMr. Y01. i_
code th I as Mr. Ca if Mr. YOU se him à li to See37,
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5Page~~fi~caseNõ~8
i ....if.i.. -4~- tøbi todita. ......
2 PJA ~ fb....~ ~ by .Se..31itii.dilfl. ...
3 PIA.
.. .Q. .... .,...IlØ......,Q.'. I..... "'... _.S ..Cl.,~...tttd QI ....,
6 A. 1' .J ..2O... ~we ~ ~CO ~T .~...
'1 ~...pp.A__~i"øçessJbat. no Cltm in wn
I ie. to a PPA. Ma ca mely l'a 'bla :PAIi ..pa of
9 ,.imiMt tm- ..PJ .PI CåTRC_ ca tr jo..iOpo~ Il ~_ l's in ad. to seIt ~
12 0." .~CaT.", ..0. DO .... DC', Jø.2813 .....,ø.."....
i..A. NCll~.~Tdi:n opaflon æO..bUonth.. 2OCO
15 As aOìt_ ~tø th .pr qU Pa elT .~
16 ~ ~l~. It is bO PaCo ..pt....f( ap ...ti OI .
17 ~l.QP 1ØJ th~QPsutsa wr .l'fo ..WA .~
II .~31.
19 Q.. 1'0_'" .'1... fi DC CèP"" Cl'l....20 ..i3....$......I',21?
21 Ã.. No, it_-.
22 .Q. ..............1',*"
23 Ã. ~CåT .~..wl .1ø. tik a st.. P'A tb .wu ~
2.. lI..Wl~~ tl PrecansibymtG.
1 Q.
2
3 A.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14 Q.
15 A.
16
17
is
19
20 Q.
21
22 A.
23
24
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 24CaseNo.~Grkl4
w. Paer CAT ap.'." ,1' 8ebe 11, aø. PPA ,.
ERG? U..t, wlaot
PaCo C&T wa DO ex th PPA an wa DO awa tI .!RO..wu
~a PPA. . Pa 8 an90fSde37~it.~$.PKJ_
thQF,~lplJ* ..tb .:f di. of 't PFA. .T, is~sø'"
~Cø cabe eetbih PPAiS.~ tøìt~ PPAgtve
by th Coi$Søn Th 8e17,.20 PPA~tlfi~~
PaCo C&T ~ iiBRG tb it ~.å ~. 37 PPJ\
Pa C&T .hø no pa .Î1 .pi th ~c ~Oí ij
ERq's~ 17.200PPA,ii wa it _. tlBRO .ha. ..~ a
štnd PPA te _ha .~. to~¡t. .Mr. 'Y~ anuwle
at fidid DO re ev ~ with Mr. Caabhi ~.Prj_
ui we reew our re
w...s... 17, io.PPAeøpl..?
No. it co so bu DO al of th jnfon re by Seon (B)() at
pa 8 an 9 of ~ 37.. Al. it con1aiiiec avo co ra IS we IS a
co of th Sc 37, th we in ef pr to Sebe 9. 200 bu DO
lo efve wh ERG su th maal re by Pa C&T
on Se 17, 200~
Bow di Padf.. lD :E'. .... 11,'" PPAsùlB
A1 ERG di DOt foll Sc 31, PaCo ..st hi su
oftb PPA on ~ 11. 20 to be a wr re to bq th Sc
37 pr. Th sa da, loh You sa Mr. Ca an eml (at
1
2
3
4
S
6
1 Q.
i A.
9
10
11
12
13
14 Q.
15 A-
t6
11
11
19
20
21
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5Page~~caseNõ~j'8
am Pa) ia (1) .. Pa CAT .. iø øc el
EIO'. So 16 pr PPA; (2) tJ ne of a PPA wo be
~ pu to th pm csHi in Sc 31; (3) th ERG
8I to pr Pa CeT wi th wr iiOl f8 by
Se (8)(2) of Sc 37; an (4) th PaCoqts Sc 31 ia ha
cli ef Se 9, 20.
.. ...di .,1W Pacor to tI la.
Bx'b Pa is a No 13, 20 ci fì Mr. Ca to Mr.
YOU an myin wI he in Pa caT th lå BI Prje 8$
it be ... Jf in di matuia ie by Pa CAT OD Sebe
11, ie .. no .. Wa .. of ~ co at" Prt,
_. In.. _..I, D. ... pm' to eoie it ap .PI fi
,. pI gat I.... ,...'CW to du am t.
WI...Nø__13,.....1M....D.'...
Fo_ .. it ...,. fh DO W_col.'pi~
~foth~4. ~ I1t20lWl¥t.~~
tò 1Ç Patoasa.PPA. MØI deVi.. it tO l'1l
si a io.. PPA Wi ~for ~ uitilthli ~ ti
th prptlC ..... ~f..b1. Al,it-.~... to
~SlG ev .hi. or ii.... ecfele .pict .. ol4
Sc37.pr or thcti'- ~e 37 ~
i Q.
2
3 A.
4
S
6
7
8
9 Q.
10
11 A-
12
13
14
is Q.
16 A.
17 Q.
18 A-
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 26CaseNo.~Grld6
au ER ..,.. lD.. .. ue... il di 8......1'7,__"A
aa eopl tie Sc 37 pr te obta aPPA?
Pa C&T ba coue to wo di wi Bla to up th prec
inlQly. ØØpletlbSde31 .prfo ~ .
PPA. Toø. iRQ_ no prvide Pa C&Twitb a1.ofth iJ
æqbySe (BX2) of Sc 37. 'loi thple$ have ii
exec a PPA or an aa ie th eslisbof ..a lep
enle oblon
Plbri ex .. Padorp QtT aa P~or ~..8ent...1a1'
PaC&T .do. nb~ea to PtCo .T1's. Se
re a QF's iD st UD au by thQF. BRa di
no au su CC UD SC i7~ 1iit pi
PaCo wi wr au aU to thSe 17, 200PPA.
...hcorcaT........ orre.........G?
NOtPaC&Tbari.~øo~.mottER.
Do......,..te.Bý
Yes.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 27
Ca.
G.. ....... ..ij. -¡fis· ... ... l'Cl
ØJTGPl~ tJCOIOl or ORJlf
tIeD"
ENY IlVD Gllot LL,
e."i,
Y&
p.ACDcoar AaPACI PO
1t1l..
uiu TlONY or
LtlJ ltD11
ONJJ OJ'
PACØOOll
Apr2l 208
.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 28CaseNo.~R.l
i Q. Pie ltle.Y"UÖeaa .... ad
2 A.
3
4 Q.
S A.
6
7 Q.
8
9
10
.LaRa PådCo. 82 NE ~ SUi 160, 'Poi~()
97232.
Wlt II ye oc...... "'.. ..y.. _plci?
I am emloy by PaCo fu-t in th TraiMon. de
(P'transssonSece) asa 'trass~
.. cl ,....ilri..wi E.. ...., C.. ...l..'
(".G~..ID~ wi P.df...T....~~..ilOERG'. .pto .. ..ti tã .. IO"'FaI. .or
("Proje
11 A. 1 have be PacCo Tf8ss Se's pr ... WiERG..fO
12 tn. ~Ùl ERG's. iion refoitP: .si.Ocbe ...16.
13 201, Wh lWå .coby BRO's Ç(ta (B Wojszk) .Wl
14 quOD 0J~1et thapCâfom for 1I~ofth
is ~øifàity.
16 Q. ,Je...EüPMierp0i tetlteoay.
17 A. E,mbit.PåCo101 is th fi pae an sillplc ..0£ di...a~
i8~on .rc fOrERO's Prjesu~ by U,(l to 'lCCo
19 TiiissØli~onNovebe .11, 2001. l,y sa1Wgtb.re.- El
20 intlp. foine an~on..~
21 Q. :DY" reeverèl..apoerpur.. .._ (~'PA.,.22 ERGpri''' Sl.. .t"lflO~""øp
23 A. 'Yes Irela coon tht i ha withMI. ~tbl'ble_p_
24 inA.200, wh I me wi Mr. Ca~ .~on
2S~ap~an.exQ1of thFacJiQes .$t.. ~.. I
1
2
3
4
$
6
7
I Q.
9
10 A.
11
12
13
14
IS
16
17
11
19 Q.
20 A.
21
22
23
24 Q.
2$
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
~:;:~~8..k_......~Mi.~.._...øo
....a"Àtl.~lW....~T.....Il..~_.,
"'riJl". BAs i ~ th ... ..~ ~.!.~
~-'T""~ GlTj .1.lllhL"..i 'Y"."
_ ... ti....... .. ... __.. .... ~, _tohl hi.
.... ~..... tOcaMr. yØtf4 cl1l.,.. ..~_
....pp,A
.,.......,....PPA.........t....... ..........
Yes X_witl .Mr...~..~....~.U)J2QQ. At thtiliJ'._..wi.a~~.~on..~._a....~
It. fi ."', fijlrl I.... toM'. ~ '.'''.. ..~
1"_....~.. ii.hath ~ ..arfl-.øIWÂl
_'1.1I...ft"~." ~. caT i.....i.. iøh
V-u. 1l..~Wk.....~ li.. to 4ø.. OI....
_~l."" ....A.. .Mi. Y01~. ~ .-.Ot.
.~. .,Ihptii.. .17,., PJCo~'" ~..~...--...
....,...1.......... $eIRI..i.. 2Ø ..... ....
Møl\V" ..ti..l'A. PaT~~Ii nOrole
"Pt...... ".(.11 "8). i.ll~ _1l wo........ii_ ... ."".\\ ...... ~ .... ~
.n...
...,...........,. ...paeTn... .....~.C..T........?
1 A.
2
3
4
5
6
7 Q.
8
9
10 A.
11 Q.
12
13 A.
14
15
16 Q.
17 A.
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 30 ~~.. .....! 1.RP
Case No. r ft'i~
Pa Tl'on Se do DO c: wi Pa..c.T
re .di~on of .. ge...ta ~.. th ~._
prvi.. volll cons no to PlñØnt~$$Sece
au su o(.Ulica To ti be øfmy.~ ø.Øba.ii
pr su ..re fo Pa Tiwis .SlCl tø di..
Prec with Pa C&T.
Attle lÙleöf101lApr2lJ ..ee di .ERG, ...,. .....tIpNforp...... *"øiè .... ...c_... .. tb...l'ld UlIee....OfOria.J....2I
No~ I wanøflthPaCo W0fill_C~.-_ÍJJu2(.
wi... ia di YOB ... awtU daeSe 37 avld.....Iadi..'
I ñr ie th hcCo~s.Sc 31 av0cc_ba ebll wJ.
Mr.~inudni.in lQ-'to ai ~:kQÍPl~ e.'l m
0e..200treiiOl....W8..~ÎO~_pp.A
wit.. .-ofIRG'liateuOl'....
PaOa'l..i.. Se CO bo .~ ~...~ .. ..
fatyst re iiimon of ElG'.~. BlQ _~ ÎO
pay a de towaPac TrIlOl~ts__ .~ ~
st. ..bø iea 1t.. ...be .. ..~ ~.. ..eo. ... ....
~..EkG ...ul. .pa. $10,033.30 to ~.. ..I*Co
Tl'i_on Sece's cøto .ev... tl ..ap_ ..stth
~ ôfBR's~ J'je JlCo ,.¡.. .~
bal1fn:ui EROto pa aaadtiOJ cobeOJth.S1Q~Ø3:l.3(~
to..buth ..... .c=~1Oc:_ .tt ~_..
i
i
3 Q.
4 ~
S
6
7 Q.
i A.
9
10
ii Q.
12 A.
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
~:::~~8~"SJ""an~() ~.IoER(r. Pt
...,bl17,20.
.........i..Oleato..~.
s-biPlCol02Î$ ... let .da May 21. 2O1hm ~
T.._.. s...tø BI... pndi .. ac. of th .ae. eoto
CO- it~ÎI st.
.. ....XthMPMiorl3to th...,.~~ioi lal li()be 6,. ~. _ ~.
r..ØI ~tø.ø..pr . ..~ of tt. __ _.lø
eoi.ttf'list...........,.....
Yes
XRG Answer SJ Exhibit 5
Page 32
Case No. PAC-E-IO-08