20210527Bulkley Exhibit 12.pdf

Case No. PAC-E-21-07
Exhibit No. 12
Witness: Ann E. Bulkley
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER
Exhibit Accompanying Direct Testimony of Ann E. Bulkley
Constant Growth DCF Model
May 2021
Rocky Mountain Power
Exhibit No. 12 Page 1 of 3
Case No. PAC-E-21-07
Witness: Ann E. Bulkley
6loNJ(') F
9F-j6-9.z(Oj lf)o-=6 tf).6=Eotrlo=E!!='i6.=c>.c>o>+e+=EN
olN6-:6.o6':E-6'
d6o=EEE g EEE -e =rtA' = FE SeE ee , IE xY C x o (O.x o(L(L o E -:o lo66 'q "' E 6'u? c;bb ?.E1r =?-+oo+J-.6+h-,EEses-E*E'=??9-9- xEE 6 e x=Fc0dl=5'>>N?5.&u.. .. .. \ - o oO(DaoOOOoo=-pp'ff'ffpEsf;trsg
=: f f = = f :,: crcr88trtr888fi,r99
------O FFclrrttfr@t-@Or--
@ooz
sa/,\tt
sroo
d,
sro(Do
soq(o
so)
to
stslo
ao
s(o
G?la
sNl\o
saoq
aq
coo
=
$eH$$$$$$$$tei"$$*$
P o, 99 I : d o, ot : S d d S d : P o;
$$h$*s$$$$55$*"$s$E
P <i d d cr, P d oj d P = F- d : d : d o;
sssss{sssssssfssss(') CD cO F- - X sl t - N (O (C, (D ): (O CD l"\ No) t\ cD \t o) "1 (\ (o e l0 0) lr) o) qa F (o @ oo, d d d + P d oi F- oj oj <i d P F- F- F- ot
sssssssssssssssf":esO F- r, N (O O 6l (O (O (\l (O al F- O O !--: O l\q q o? r of q ol q q u? o,.o o o o :': o F
<o ri <ct d $ N d d t @ ai rj $ d <'i P'r, <ci
=assssssssssss=esXsS";ooooooooooooe-oYoo
= @ (o F- O) CD F- N F CD @ \r' t :\ * Y. O Nz rri F- rj d d d rj d d r- + + z rj 3 ri @
sssssssssssssssxssO O O lf) O (I, r() O) O l() <D f- O O O Y o) OO t- tf) - O) e O O) (, <, l.) lr) @ O rr, -. !t (?,
F- d l- <j <, F- d +'d d d s rj o, <.j I c, d
ssssssssssxsssssssoooooooooo:loooooooorl)ooo60000qiooo6060
G, d <, @ J il tc; d a, cd
=
c,i + F- + + d d
sssssssssssssssssst O) O @ (D t <f rr) 'rt (D l'- (') (', O) N O O olO) 6l O N O) F O O - @ F O F (O O @ $ Ori ri <.i ri r.i ai c'i + + t.i c.i + ri d + ri r ri
ssssssssss*sssssssN O O @ (D d) t tf r(, N O - CD r(' CD F CD (O@ N O) (O @ <) r+ (! O F- O O O rO N (O (\,1 O)rj r; Gi rj c.j c) rj .r $ c.j ci + d (.j + (.j + 6i
{ N Go o <.: t.- I ro o o) @ - o F (r, F F, qo (o cD ao rt (') Y o o, i- o @ @ o (?, F @ t<r, d d ci <.i F- ^@ ; d tri + - - <'i N rri d e.i(o |r) N @ t |r) - o, (D ro ta @ (o rt N <f tr) (oe 6 e e, e, @ b e4 e+ g, @ @ @ @ o @ q g,
(! F o @ o) $ !t @ o $ t o r (o at (') (o G)u? q c! ol q \ c? oq q - u? <t q u? c? q u? q
6l F (! Or - F t (O (') Ol F N r F r, F (\l Fe, 4, e, @ o e, et e, e e a e, @ o @ @ o @
i=uQ*3HXfr*sEHE?ps*
Ei EH8 EFE.5 - c g8.E E E 6 Es 6ed>E>E(!E--
.18* € EssE ;.t$Egt g,
E E5E BHFB5e.Hfi Pgg.g9 P
iEcEggg:gggEgEEf;;E
!UJ.sroTT,
EB>t
EEJ&
g, sso.! B6E9afio
*psEE9*,8 o
HgEii,fro
EEr
,r'3 t
ESoEO>;o
Eg6d.
9o-
=Pf
i 5,8
R.,NCE€d:=Eo
o):otr
cc,CLEoo
ltoorF
=otoFz
F@zoo
oo(o
Rocky Mountain Power
Exhibit No. '12 Page 2 ol 3
Case No. PAC-E-21-07
Witness: Ann E. Bulkley
C!o(\t;: =E9Ni(U_S4
aoi tr)
89Eotr=dl=cEE=9 Eic=+h+=(, l.-B =6.o6'-:s =Ect|r)o=E6EA
oF!3=F.Ejees.IE;I X O (OXdoEao6o q,,E 6'u? c;6 ?.Ei! =?-+lt + J -i o + to'-
^e a'= e E -9 P=f'Y5rxf;€Hb"**dlFF;'>>N?6'JE.'...\HOOCD66CD(DO66==Y(E(6YYY(!(!=JJ 5 f f : = 5 = UOo Er cr o o o (, oul ul@|JJ|JJr,(,(,lJJw^-
----O
FN(Oel.)(ON6(DFF
(Ec.9oooo(L
oooz
st\\o
s@@o)
so)(o
ao
sooq(o
so)
d
sFro(o
s(o
a?
ro
so6o
so)(oc,
c6o
=
E g * n* n- $ $ n S $ * e* $ $ ** $ $ S
= ot I : = P oi oi d S l "j ot S d, : P oi
$$$kNR$$X$Et*k$I$$E
P cd oj oj oi P o, d d 3 :.d oj : d : o; o;
fssssssssssssXssssyi @ cD t o cD F N (o t @ @ <, = o <) (') (f,Y F- o) + 6l CD o o o) @ @ F O) - t- @ @ O,
P d d oi d oi oj d d o, oj <j d P F- F F- d
sssssssssssssssfsso N (, (\,t (Y) o ol (o r, 6l (o N F- o o :-: o t\tr) (O O, r O) $l Ol O o rr, O) @ O O @'': O F<r'ri d d + F- ri d .r d d ri $ d <'i e'ri <i
.e S S S ;e }e S :e ;e ;e ;e ;e }s.e ;e X }e }eoio00000000000ro=oo> oc o? \ ol ol \ o! r ol oq -t.c > a i c c!
- ro N (, @ (o ro r.c) (, lr) t- t t - (, - rr) <)
sssssssssssssssxssO O O rr) O O) tr) o) O rO CD t'- O O O = o) OO t\ lr) F <D F O Ct, rf) (O r{) r() @ O tr) -. r(' F)
F- rj F <ci ro F- <i + rri rrj o * aj d rj I d <ci
ssssssssssxsssssssooooooooooxoooooooo 6 o ro o lf, o o o o': rr) o o rr) o ro o<j rj d @ ; il <c,'r, aj d I c.i $ r- r + c'i <j
ssssssssssssssssssO @ O () CD O) F (7, O) - CD F F- O{ - F- (O (7)r q q \c\! q q c? ol q q o? r cC o? o? c? o?t (a (O (Y) $ (O (o !t (o \t 6l \t rr) (o t (.) $ N
ssssssssssssssssssN o o (., O cO F N O @ O (., (O t- C., (O (O 14)O) - O) (O F O) rr) N (D @ O N O (O 6l N Ol @r, <'j 6i d + c.i <'j r c.i ci cri t'ri <'i + d + c.i
6 (O l',- lr, O Ol P rO - e N N CD - CD - N F-t r' @ t <t c.r': !' 3 - cD <O F- 6 $ - F N
<'i ci ri - d co I? J ?- ri d a; - c.i d d d s(o ro F- @ t (l - o, CD (, ts rO (O $ N t @ (06 V' @ O @ q b@ 6 A 6 e' e' q @ q o e
N F O (O CD $ !t (O O \l t @ F (O c-,1 (o @ (?)u? (q ol ol q \ F? oq q r u? -t q q c? q u? oq
N F N N e - t d) (') c.,t F (\ F - (., - O{ F606si6@A@@O600@e,OOO
i=uQ*EHXtr*UEHEire*
.Ea EHE EFE-s . 38E ; E E Es 6e
gtEeeest :.iEEg* a=
iEEESgEgHFEEflEEEEE
t.9-u.loE.
EBJE
EE
=(r
g, ss!8.= =dE9
A,S o
trgEN O.n
-sgpE
FEEI
9o-
;3E
i,r 6
Bxe
E$up.!u
o
Eg6d.
8oNCEgz.>Eo
oxotr
cGo.Eoo
o
d
LLooIF3oEoFz
FU)zo(,
ooo)
Rocky Mountain Power
Exhibit No. 12 Page 3 of 3
Case No. PAC-E-21-07
Witness: Ann E. Bulkley
6loN
oF!:9i-'-E-9
Z(E|j so-=o9ovEoFo=E(o=ib=,G;.c=(E>+e+=ENoF---6'.9, 6' -:s:6'
6]f'o=E
oo ! coo F x99, a eE Eeg 99 . IE xC y x (J !o.x o(L(L o ! -:o ()oo q ^, E 6'u? c,bb o.Eir =?-+.o ll + J -. o + ;1'-EEo=gE*E=i;-9-9-xttE0x=e.d)d)=6'>>N;5.r-......\HOOO (D o o O o o o o==I9EE g I g6C 5 5J f f:, J = 3 = f ctctoouqoQo9ollJtuu)u)|JJ|.JJ(/')(,urwUJ--
---O rr({(')$tr}@F-@o)FF
@ooz
sNqo
s!ttl
ar,
srt\o
soqo
so
to
s
r.l
ao
saoq[)
slaoq
FI
sr?F
FI
troo-
$$$$$$s$gs$stEh$E=: d P P : I d d ot $ S d d P cr, : = o,
d +* * r" * $ s * s h" t* s s E s I N f
- (O @ i- $'. (O lf) tl':'. CO N -: O t. rO O)P d otd d P o, oj d : : d oj : d : oi d
fssssssssssssXssssX{ F- o rl) (() @ o (Y) (o ro rr) co (o :. @ ot o o': (o O) (Y) t @ (') \t @ <) CD O) O) v: (O O CD cO3 d d d d d d ot <i oi oi <, d P F- d N cci
sssssssssssssssfsso F- (') at (.) o 6l (o c) 6t (o $t t- o o Ll o F-rr, (O O) r O) (\r O) O rr, rr, O) @ O O cO''! O -@ d <t to.r r.- rrl d * @ o c.i $ d <'i P'r; d
,e S ;e de ;e ;e ;e ;e ;e S ;e ee S =s ;e X ;e ae--oooooooooooo--o=oo:S @ (') F- o) (D F- N r o @ tt t :S st r. o srz d F- d ci d ri ri rri rri r.'. s.r z c.j P ri <t
sssssssssssssssxsso o o tr) o o) rr) (D c) r.) o) N o o o = o oO F- tO - O) F O O, rO (o rO l.) @ O |r) r. t (v)
F- ri r- @ d N <ci + rri rri o s c.i d <.i 3 d <,
ssssssssssxsssssssooooooooooxoooooooo rr, o u) o o o o o o -i lr) 0 0 ro o lo o
G, ri G, d ; il d d c, .d 3 c,i i F- + + c.j <i
sssssssssssssssss;sO) @ N (O O cO O tf O r (O - (O @ O) * N OO F O) (O lr) O, (O \f @ O F r) F O) N r 6 @
;;;;;;;;;.;;;.;;;c! q oq u? a oq u? e? oq oq c s c e c! q.c \{ (t N (f) \t N (.) * (?) G) (\l * r() (O t r) { N
NFNFooI?s-NtoNoooN@(") F o (7) o { r'! o co o * o co t- @ $ o Noj c.i d rj d ci 5 oi d d + d - d d ; cd F-rt) r() F- @ (.) @ - cO CD t() t- .O c) q F- S lr) (Oe, 4, @ @ g, a b e4 e9 @ et @ e, @ q e, @ a
N F O (O Ct, sf \l (O O rl !t O - (O (\l O (O Oq q q q e \ c? q oq r u? a q q c? q u? qN F N (\l F F \l (., rrN - N F F r) r Ot roo@ggog60qge60@@4q
i=HQr3H=tr*ElHr?rs*
o
=-a 5H
E f F E Es s.E
at * € 8FBE :.i$EgE a,
E 8,qt B ilF f s"E,H fi ilg i,g p lq
iEEEESH:gggEUEEE;E
IUot
E.s,I
e8Jd
EB>E
9,8,=!E.E }6E9A,So
9?EdE9N (!.n
a89=o c.= a
FEEI
9o-
;S;
B;s
E$op .!9.z>o
Eg6d.
!,OENCEg
..>€o
oIotr
EC'CLEoo
q
@
E
(o
lr)
t
Ll-ooIF
=otoFz
FU'zoo
oo@
(')
N