Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20191108Supplement to Application.pdfNovember 8,2019 RECEIVED iSiSliCI -8 Plt 2:09 r'. '..t.,':li,i'lVIA OVERNIGHT DELIVERY RE: CASE NO. PAC-E-19-16 PACIFICORP'S APPLICATION FORACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF THE 2OI9 INTEGRATED RESOURCE PLAN Dear Ms. Hanian: PacifiCorp identified corrections within the 2019 IRP, Volume - Appendices A-L and one correction in Volume I - Chapter 5 that are summarized in the table below. Enclosed as a second supplement to the 2019 IRP are replacement pages incorporating the corrections. Regarding the work papers that were filed October 25, 2019, PacifiCorp also seeks to replace certain files listed below with those provided in this second supplement filing. Note, the identified corrections and replacement files do not affect the analysis, preferred portfolio, inputs or outcomes of the 2019 IRP, and do not affect any other materials provided. rConections are incorporated in the publicly posted version ofthe 2019 tRP available at: httos://www.nacifi com.cont tontenVdamheom/documents/en/pacifi corp/energy,/integrated-resourcc- PacifiCorp 20l9IRP Volume Il Apperdices A-L and Volume I Chrpter 5r Reference Update Page Appendix L 248-253 Appendix L Replacement page conects the data in Table L.55 to reflect initial cases P-16 through P-20 under social cost ofcarbon. This oble was inconectly populated with initial cases P-45CP through P-53CP. 264 Appcndix L Replacement page corrects the data in Table L.59 and l able L.60 to conect total PVRR.266 Appendix L Replacem€nt page corrects graphic ofwinter system capacity trends olan./2019_lRP VolumeJl Aooendices_A-L.pdf httos:/1www.nacifi com.com/content/dam/ncom/ plani2o | 9 IRP_Volume_l.pdf uments/edoacificoro/enersv/inteerated-resource- ROCKY MOUNTAIN POVT'ER A OVTS|ON OF iACTFTCORP 1407 Norlh Temple, Suite 330 Salt Lake City, Utah 84116 Diane Hanian Commission Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission 1 1331 W Chinden Blvd Building 8 Suite 201A Boise, Idaho 83714 Rcplacement pages correct the data in thc standard dcviation column and the upper tail column ofTables L.1l through L.23. Replacement page corrects the data ir Tablc L.65 to conect total PVRR for the P70-P74 cor irmation cases.269 Chapter 5 120 ldaho Public Utilities Commission November 8,2019 Page 2 Delcte from lst SuDDlement 2019 IRP Data Disc or Drive Location ReDlace with Tbl L. l-L.64 Stochastic Simulation Results.xlsx \Public\Chapten + Appendices\Appendix L - Stochastic Simulation Results Tbl L. l -L.65 Stochastic Simulation Results 2nd Supp.xlsx Irolder and contents: P_|19- P26CNW.MMR CONF \Confi dential\Plannirg & Risk_CONFtGateway and No Gas Cases_CoNF.zip\Gateway and No Gas Cascs CorlflModcl Input + Output CONF\P II9-P26CNW-MMR CONR Folder and Contents: P_I19- P26CNW-MMR_CONF 2nd Supp \Conlidcntial\System Optimizer OutpuLCONRGateway and No Gas Cascs_CoNF,zip\Gateway and No Gas Cases_CONF\lvlodel Input + Ouptut CONF\I 19. P26CNW-MMR CONF\ Fold€r and contents: II9-P26CNW- MMR CONI 2nd Supp PaR Stochastic Summary P_ll9- P26CNW-MMR 1909300244 CONI'.xlsm \Conlidential\Planning & Risk_CONF\Gateway and No Gas Cases CONF.zip\Cateway and No Gas Cases ConflPaR Summary RcDon CONF\ PaR Stochastic Summary P_l l9- P26CNW-MMR 19100t1720 CONl 2nd Supp.xlsm PaR_Detail-Report_P_l I 9- P26CNW- MMR 20l9l0l CONF.xlsm \Confidential\Plaoning & Risk_CONF\Gatewa), and No Cas Cascs_CONF,zip\Gateway and No Gas Cases ConflPaR Detail Rcpon CONF\ PaR_Detail_Repon_P_l I 9- P26CNW-MMR_2019 r 03 CONF 2nd Suop.xlsm \Confi dential\System Optimizer Output_CoNF\Gateway and No Cas Cases_CONF.zip\Gateway and No Cas Cases_CONF\SO Summalv Report Pre- Reliabilit_v CONF\ SO Portfolio Il9-P22CNW- MM_1909290011 CONF znd Supp,xlsm SO Portfolio I l9-P23- MM 1909261445 CONF-xlsm \Confi dential\System Optimizer Output_CoNtlcateway and No Gas Cases_CONF. zip\Gateway and No Cas Cases_CON F\SO Summary Repon Pre- R€liability CONF\ SO Portfolio I l9-P23CNw- MM_l909290013 CONF 2nd Supp.xlsm SO Portfolio I19-P25- MM 1909251201 CONF.xlsm \Confi dential\System Optimizer Output CoNncatelvay and No Gas Cases_CONF.zip\Gateway ard No Gas Cases_CONF\SO Summar)' Repon Pre- Reliability coN[\ SO Portfolio I l9-P26- MM 1909251203 CONF.xlsm \Confi dential\System Optimizer OutpuLCONRGateway and No Gas Cases_CoNF.zip\Gateway and No Gas Cases CONF\SO Summar,' Report Pre- Reliability CONn SO Portfolio Il9-P26CNW- MM,1909290025 CONF 2nd Supp.xlsm SO Ponfolio Il9-P29- MMR 1909261504 CONF.xlsm \Confi dential\System Optimizcr Output_CONF\Gateway and No Gas Cases_CON F. zip\Gateu ay and No Gas Cases_CONF\SO Summar)' Report Reliabiliry CoNF\ SO Portfolio 119-P26CNw- MMR_I910021007 CONF 2nd Supp.xlsm Please find enclosed two data discs containing the second supplement confidential work papers and second supplement non-confidential work papers outlined in the table below. Please replace the files as described in the table below that were previously provided on October 25, 2019 with the files provided in this second supplemental filing. Replacements for confidential files remain confidential. Confidential information in the 2019 IRP will be provided to any party who has intervened in this case and signed a non-disclosure agreement. PacifiCorp requests that interested parties contact the state manager at the number listed below for a copy of the non-disclosure agreement that must be executed and submitted to the Company prior to obtaining a copy of the confidential information. Folder and cont€nts: ll9- P26CNW-MMR SO Portfolio I19.P22. MM 1909251 150 CONF.xlsm SO Portfolio Il9-P25CNW- MN4_1909290020 CONF 2nd Supp.xlsm Idaho Public Utilities Commission November 8,2019 Page 3 All formal correspondence and data requests regarding this filing should be addressed as lbllows: By e-mail (pref'errcd):datarequest@pacifi com. com irp@pacificom.com ted.weston@.oacificorp.com wome. ho gle@pacifi corp.com By regular mail Data Request Response Center PacifiCorp 825 NE Multnomah Street, Suile 2000 Portland, Oregon, 97 232 With copies to:Ted Weston Idaho Regulatory Affairs Manager Rocky Mountain Power 1407 North Temple, Suite 330 Salt Lake Cily, Utah 84116 Yvorure R. Hogle Assistant General Counsel Rocky Mountain Power 1407 North Temple, Suite 320 Salt Lake City. Utah 84116 Informal inquiries may be directed to Ted Weston, Idaho Regulatory Affairs Manager, at (80r)220-2963. Sincerely. Joelle Steward Vice President, Regulation Enclosures CC: $^r^-C Jim Yost, Idaho Govemor's Office (without enclosures) Benjamin Otto, Idaho Conservation League (without enclosures) Mark Stokes, Idaho Power Company (without enclosures) Teri Carlock, Idaho Public Utilities Commission staff (without enclosures) Randy Budge, (Bayer,Monsanto) (without enclosures) Nancy Kelly, Westem Resource Advocates (without enclosures) 2019 IRP Second Supplemental PACIFICoRP _ 20I9 IRP Table L.l1 - Stochastic Risk Results Initial Develo ment Cases - Low Gas No COz Table L.12 - Stochastic Risk Resul Initial Develo ent Cases - H Gas COr Table L.13 - Stochastic Risk Results Initial Develo ment Cases - Social Cost of Carbon PVRR($n)Stsnderd Devistion sth p€rcentilc 90th percentile 95th percertile Uppcr Teil (nean of 3 Highcst) No Fircd Costs Pt6 |2 t9,295 19,555 tq 501 8,955 Pl7 86 20,892 zt,t02 2t,t6t Pl8 22,315 ,r 50,22,623 6,856 103 20,318 7 ,471 94 20,702 20,913 6,962 Initid Cases High Grs, High CO2 PVRR($m)Strndsrd Devirtion 5th percentile 90th percentile 95th percentile Upper Tail (mean of 3 Highest) No [ired Costs 30,056 30,202 Pl7 r36 28,657 29,014 29,069 15,67 6 Pl8 27,947 28,030 12,249 28,9',70178 29,407 29,539 16,665 P20 28,151 28,700 Initiel Cescs Sociel Coct ofCerbon PVRR($m)Stendsrd Deviation sth p€rcentil€90th percentilc 95th percentile Uppcr Teil (mean of 3 Highest) No Fired Cosh Pl6 212 40,000 40,096 29,355 Pt7 156 36,173 36.63536,605 23,280 PIE t6l 35,050 35,433 3s,491 19,747 Pt9 193 38,1 l5 25,807 P20 184 37,76r 37,881 23,79r AppENDrx L - STocHAsrrc SIML'I-,ffioN REsuLTs Initirl Crses Low Ges, No CO2 7,7 59 lll 20,052Pl9 70,296 H!0 20,952 P16 200 29,555 19,534 27,57s'149 P19 163 28,575 14,677 39,365 38,642 38,752 37,236 248 PACITTCORP. 20 19 IRP AppENDIx L - STocrrAsrrc SrMrJr.ATroN REs(rLTs Table L.14 - Stochastic Risk Results C Cases - Medium Gas Medium COz Table L.15 - Stochastic Risk Results CP Cases - Medium Gas Medium COz PVRR($m) C Casrs Strndard Devirtion 5th percentile 90th percentile Upper Tail (mean of 3 Highest) No Fixed Costs P3l C 99 23,233 23,s07 23,s36 10,353 P36C 146 23,677 10,27 5 P45C 23,131 104 23,t25 23,4s8 9,864 P46J23C 106 23,445 23,506 9,856 P47C r03 23,045 23,333 23,371 P48C 103 23,073 23,396 9,933 P53C 23,185 23,5t8 P53J23C 107 ?3,?35 23,52s 23,580 P54C 23,547 10,21 I PVRR($m)Strndsrd Devietion Sth percentile 90th percentile 95th percendle Upper Tril (mean of 3 High.st) No Fixed Costs P36CP 142 23,194 23,65',7 P45CP 23,367 10,061 P46CP 104 23,143 P46J23CP 23,144 23.456 23,492 9,850 23,067 23,393 P48CP 104 23,051 23,327 P53CP r05 23,199 23,52t 9,892 P45Cr{W 23,062 95th percentile 23,213 23,574 99 23,409 23,449 t0,072 P46C 23,404 23,160 10,023 23,342 105 ?3,466 9,92t 9,915 102 23233 23,s09 CP Cases Medium Gas, Medium CO2 23,56r 10,241 100 23,043 23,322 23,426 23,464 9,844 109 P47CP 103 23,349 10,040 23,374 9,963 23,4',76 98 23,348 17.1'71 10,338 249 Table L.16 - Stochastic Risk Results CP Cases - Low Gas Low COz Table L.17 - Stochastic Risk Resul CP Cases - Hi Gas CO: PVRR($m) CP Ceses Low Gas, No CO2 Standrrd Devietion 9(hh percentile 95th pcrcentile Uppcr Tril (men of 3 Highat) No Fired Cods P36CP l0l 20,229 20,485 20,515 7,103 P45CP 68 20,001 ?0,t87 20,216 6,895 P46CP 72 20,387 P46J23CP 79 20,195 20,412 6,802 P47CP 72 20,0'10 20,268 20,293 6,862 P53CP 20,228 6,800 67 19,878 20,085 7,029 CP Cescs High Ges, High CO2 5th percentlle 90th percentile 95th percentile Upper Teil (mean of 3 Ilighest) No Fired Costs PVRR($m)Stendard Devietior 28,091 28,193180 P45CP 27,971 t4,44313927,596 28,067 P46J23CP 142 28,008 134 14,696 27,528 27,893t37 27,990 14,571 140 28,051 28,t44 14,508 P45CPNIW 133 28,121 250 PACIFICoRP_2019 IRP AppENDrx L - STocHASTTc STMULATToN RESTJLTS 5th percentile 20,187 20,409 6,771 20427 72 20,030 20,223 20,264 6,883 P48CP 73 20,428 20,450 P45CPNW 20,052 27,612 t4,782P36CP 133 27,585 27,947 28,039 t4,733 P46CP 27,595 28,059 14,409 P47CP 27,596 2',7,9s',1 28,060 P4ECP 27,672P53CP ?7,748 28,190 l5,l5l PYRR($m)Standerd Deviation Sth percentile 90th percentile 95th perccntile Uppcr Tail (mcan of 3 Highest) No Fired Costs 187 36,278 36,808 36,887 23,413 P45CP 36,713 37,141 153 36451 P46J23CP 153 36,296 36,75s P47CP t53 37,139 37,150 36,567 3'7,007155 t55 3'1,075 P45CPNW 152 36,877 37,303 24,302 PACIFICORP.2OI9IRP Table L.18 - Stochastic Risk Resul CP- Social Cost of Carbon Table L.19 - Stochastic Risk Results, FOT Risk Assessment Crses - Medium Gas, Medium COz PYRR($n) FOT Ceses Standsrd Deviation 5th percentile 90th percentile 95th percentile Upper Tail (mean of 3 Highest) No Fixed Costs IM 23,9t7 108 23,867 24,t93 r0,923 P46CP 24,239 24,296 109 23,83s 24,130 P48CP 23,927 24,293 P53CP 23,986 24,305 251 AppENDrx L - STocHAsrrc SrMuLArroN REsuLTs CP Cases Social Cost of Carbon P36CP 152 37,13',1 23.870 P46CP 36,897 36,923 23,327 36,784 23,151 36,699 23,8t9 P4ECP 37,020 23,620 P53CP 36,576 37,M3 23,436 37,292 P45CNW 24,2t2 24,258 I1,032 P45CP 24,160 ll3 )7 074 10,'162 P47CP 24,t56 10,829 lll 24,241 10,904 ll5 24,357 10,828 PAOFICORP _ 2OI9 IRP AppENDtx L - STocHAsrrc SIMULATToN REsuLTs Table L.20 - Stochastic Risk Results, Gateway and No Gas Cases - Medium Gas, Medium COz Table L.2l - Stochastic Risk Result Sens Cases - Medium Ga Medium COz Table L.22 - Stochastic Risk Results DSM Rebundled Cases - Medium Gas Medium COz PVRR($m) Grtewry rnd No Grs Studies Standard Deviatlon Sth percentile 90th percentile 95th pcrcentile Upper Tail (meen of 3 Eighest) No Fired Costs P-22CI\l.w 23,470 23,733 10,057 P-23CNW 24,037 24,307 24,3s8 9,625 98 ?4 00?24,4t4 9,958 P-26CI\rW 23,162 23,4s4 P29 23,467 23,503 10,256 P2gPS t23 23,439 23,777 23,803 10,509 Sensitivity Studies PVRR($m)St ndard Devirtion 5th percentile 90th pcrcentile 95th percentile Upper Teil (mean of 3 Highest) No Fired Cosls 96 21,939 22,208 22,248 9,646 s02 I l3 24,t82 1l <11 11,270 s03 103 ,1 )1<23,514 23,550 10,594 s04 100 23,161 23,442 23,480 10,527 s05 99 22,827 23,102 95 23,902 24,183 24,207 I 1,1 l9 s07 98 )) oo7 23,301 t0,346 s08 23,039 23,313 23,372 PVRR ($m) DP Studies St ndsrd Devietion 5th percentile 9fth percentile 95th percentile Upper Tail (mean of 3 Highest) No Fixed Costs P45DP 10t 22,956 23,248 t0,026 P46DP 23,012 23,321 23,344 P53DP 23,070 9,687 252 96 1111) t00 P-25CNW 24,372 99 23,479 t0,255 98 23,182 s0l 24,475 23,134 10,23 I s06 23,?54 9',7 23,350 10,187 P45CPfrw 98 23,062 23,348 10,338 23,268 106 9,639 107 23,38t 23,401 PACIFICoRP - 2019 IRP APPENDIX L - SToCHASTIC SIMULATIoN REST,]I,TS Table L.23 - Stochastic Risk Results P70 Cases - Medium Gas Medium COz Table L,24 - Stochastic Risk Ad usted Table L.25 - Stochastic Risk Ad usted PVRR Price Scenario 24,806 P70 Studies Standerd Deviation 5th pcrcentil€95th pcrcentile Upper Tail (mean of 3 Highest) No Fixed Costs P70 99 ?3,882 10,457 P7t 95 23,859 24,139 24,t65 10,384 P7Z 95 23,969 )L )1\10,5 t7 P73 98 24,100 P74 96 24,075 24,364 24,381 10,604 Nrme PVRR($m)Name PYRR($n)Namc PVRR ($m) P0l 25,319 Plz 24,873 Pl326,1'14 P31 24,667 25,022 Pt4 Pl5 25,506 P33 2s,010 Pl6 P34 ?5,146 Pt7 P35 24,858 P08 25,081 Pl8 2s,602 24,710P45 P19P0924,960 25,211 P46 24,s93 P10 24,848 P20 26.385 P53 24,650 Pll 24,966 P28 24,879 P54 PVRR($n) Name Med Ges, Med COz High Gas, Hlgh COr Socid Cost of Cerbon 20427 2s,097 3r,357 41,7 t7 22,07t 25,400 30,312 38,24',7 29,187 2t,209 25,2t I P20 21,881 26,385 29,832 39,421 253 Initial Cases Initial Cases PVRR($m)90th perccntilc 24,161 24,204 24,238 24,391 24,426 10,502 Med Gas, Mcd CO2 P30 24,928 P02 25,226 P03 24,987 P32 24,947 P04 24,974 25,t39P06 25,097 P07 25,021 25,400 Low Ges, No COr Pl6 Pt7 P18 23,587 25,602 37,051 P19 30,701 40,334 :lal U 2 € oa q) U(J q) tr U U & I ra FI 6F ! U U 9a U d € q) v)o q) U (, I I|ara F]o F FJ- sl 2C J =9 a 8!-.a IJ X a ig,e>Fi\ r'..1 at o $-c\ a.l t--ry cl N o, c.l a.lc{ a..t N o\ c..t a.l .€,! > ;O. lEi ., C8:dud o\ \o o\ F. \oc.l$^ o\c-c-\o a'lo{ ci \o sgilha,aEti Nc-al \oa-o\ al taE.E -B E;ai,, o \ooo oa.-o\ \o Olo:o F.o:cro:g t-o:g o o o.o.o, ! i E F. o r\ a-al a-F. a-o, ar Eo td o,N N at t-r s a-.1 a] 1.. o\ (\l \o 6l Fg r.E =,q Fr o,t-r o\\o o.!o Ea: al a.l a.l a.l E & n o aftr tlt! 9 F \o\oal o. o. o o F.a.l o taz Q U U€s U al \c QF,Q (J i1Ft \o \oc-e.l o\r-c] c.- t--E.t 3 U E€ F.sgiaactqA o t. t\ q! E.E -g:s adla t-- a..l t- al za a.t t'- ^ 'iD & o\ c^.1F-- ol c rrl N Ol FI,.c); cn! 5s F- ssE o\ c && 0. n ar) f- 4l t-r aala^lo, s r--c- z F' c.. OlOl o o\e \ot.- at N a! N ol N \o N o (,)(,U c] F o\\o oF'a. a- ...oa.lo \ocl a.l t.. \oa.lF- F t--\o -\o-o\ o Or tr 6\o o\ al I ooEo tu \o N U A Q U Uil I \o F] q,F U I 6l(.J U EoE Q oQ && I l.a J] 6F F,.1 It 2oF J:za(J tr U Fa IJ Xoz$ q\ al I oO U -d ,o> \o o\o,t-- .E=EE;o.tr xd c3 "Ed(J ar NFr \oo\c.l F- sEiaeale! .rI c.l ..1 a.l c.l E.H- BE# c.l t--o,F-a{g zo \oo \o o a E & N F-o\ar E Ii c-F.\o \o rac 9EEEQ{):IF EU (\o\ FE: F-a.l N o,c.lat &I q qlA 9 ti ql F.cr. o\oo\1..ira.l Ol !t z U\o U o UF {(.) ta U z U n1€l c-c.l \o a.'F.a,l tal a.,l t'--N t-N t-N -!5iE; ,9836I N F o\\o a.lt--o\F. taa E EE3,t eaneaIt ai \o \o b,E.E -E E*aE" o\r-\o zat-l t--o,co.oOl i \ot-. \o t*t-r \oo\t-- o EJ o\ ."I a.lo o\ c.l tr Fe.0; Hi oN oFr FEE a.l o a.r e E cc i 9 th tuAFr <o c..l a.l \o ...l .\l al Edz U U ()tr(JF Q3 \o tr\o \o rr al (\Fal t--o\6.o\o.o. t.. a.l No N ch o.o\ c.l o\F.. U \o o\a- \o F.a- Ir c-o\ \o \ot*\o l-.\o al t-- r- c.l t-- N \o a.,l U \o a z O 6U (, d a c.l l- o. 0) -(DI o) (! zU sf, o 0)!) 0) o 0) €' o d() .o o0 b0ID (.) E (D E (.) E I (,)o iL) -{) I (B q) o F* & U 6! E o! 6 rl I\o\orl (l] F U I 2 d o 2 U F. E E U oUc F I|a F]o F !(c EI iu E 5.E EEEEA t'- c-c-a t-. ,,llAa& ao cU (J ett th 3 !o EE EE F- ! c t.r (.l \oU q! c Aq! E !c EE€EE EE a.l al ,,t{ c\(..l \o U EaE a. !t E E ! t.e EEEE o o !qd&r'.et a al e\ !t E a& Eo (J d E B!nl I l. -s L) z rl 'o 3 qo f;EfE F E BzU F Q Ci U at \o LIFs U€U =4:3d.o>F ilr a.l N N a.l \oc\ .l o a\ c.l EoEEeS;l3a \o E Ei9,.8 !aalEAi oa.to,O'o\ E.H - BEd o. e'l cl, a.a o.o\ o\ o\ o o\o' B A & \oF.'\oc-' Ol (-.F-\oF. rr) \o \o o-F- ur 9 Qo:rF 5U F-\oF.t_-t* oH EEE o\a.l a-.1 c.l c.l c.l G Ic eE a EL F t--E z F a-6lt.- FJf !',1dzoIJ5 Utr U Fa I ,1x z -t! a.-c.l \o \o F c.l Q\o crc\l tr F. c.t o t-t* t- o\ al o U PACITICORP_20I9IRP Figure 5.7 - Winter System Capacity Position Trend l2,mo I t,0q) Wctt Erirtirt RGtourc6 un0 2@l 2gn ,frB 2@a 2o,s ztx 2027 ,at t02, aBo 2(B1 ,032 203 ,Gra 2(B5 20s5 ,rE? 2@t E:-W..t &tltdnt R.!d...1 I l...l Ei.dE R.tdrI.d U!..!drd l.OT'. L ...1 r,t]rdol[3 X..a +Otaldar + llf,i Pl.Dltt R..aatt --.-Ollkilan l3% R..crvcr Eut Exirtbg Rerouroer 120 CHAPTER 5 - LoAD AND RESoURCE BALAICE ta,mo r0,000 6,0d) a.0() 2,0a,0 0