Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20180516final_order_no_34062.pdfOffice of the Secretary Service Date May 16,2018 BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE ANNUAL UPDATE ) TO PUBLISHED AVOIDED COST RATES )CASE NOS.AVU-E-18-04 BASED ON THE UPDATED NATURAL GAS )IPC-E-18-05 PRICE FORECAST OF THE U.S.ENERGY )PAC-E-18-02 INFORMATION ADMINISTRATION (EIA)) )ORDER NO.34062 Pursuant to the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA)and the implementing regulations of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC),the Idaho Public Utilities Commission (Commission)has approved a Surrogate Avoided Resource (SAR) methodology for calculation of the published avoided cost rates at which PURPA qualifying cogeneration and small power production facilities (QFs)are paid by Avista,Idaho Power and PacifiCorp.Avoided cost rates are the purchase price paid to QFs for purchases of QF capacity and energy.The release of the Annual Energy Outlook by the U.S.Energy Information Administration (EIA)triggered an updated calculation of SAR avoided cost rates. EIA UPDATE TO THE NATURAL GAS PRICE FORECAST The surrogate resource is based on natural gas plant pricing,therefore one of the key input variables in the computation of published avoided cost rates is the long-term natural gas price forecast.In accordance with the methodology approved in Order No.32697,and subsequent orders,the "reference case"natural gas price forecast for the Mountain Region's Electric Power sector included in EIA's Annual Energy Outlook serves as the basis for computing published avoided cost rates.In Order No.32697,this Commission stated that each year the final release of the Annual Energy Outlook should automatically trigger a re-calculation of the published avoided cost rates.In Order 32802,the Commission clarified that an update should occur on June 1 or within 30 days of the final release of the Annual Energy Outlook, whichever is later.This clarification was to accommodate the possibility that the final release of EIA data does not occur in time to meet the June 1 effective date. UPDATED PUBLISHED AVOIDED COST RATES Commission Staff recomputed published avoided cost rates for Idaho Power,Avista, and PacifiCorp using EIA's most recent annual natural gas price forecast.Staff provided Avista, ORDER NO.34062 1 Idaho Power,and PacifiCorp with worksheets on April 5,2018,for review and comment, showing the computation of the updated avoided cost rates. Both Avista and PacifiCorp acknowledged that the rates computed by Staff as presented are correct.Idaho Power concurred that the calculations provided by Staff are consistent with the SAR methodology approved in Commission Orders Nos.32697 and 32802. Idaho Power Response Letter at 1.However,it expressed concerns with the use of the reference case natural gas price forecast for the Mountain Region's Electric Power sector included in the EIA's Annual Energy Outlook.Id. Idaho Power argued that while Commission Order No.32697 generically requires the use of the EIA forecasts in the SAR methodology,it does not specify which data series must be used.Id.Idaho Power disagreed with the use of the Mountain Region sector forecast,claiming that it is not a representative forecast for natural gas prices because it represents pricing that is higher than historical and expected natural gas transactions specific to Idaho Power.Id. More specifically,Idaho Power claimed that the use of the Mountain Region sector forecast unreasonablyinflated the SAR avoided cost prices and its customers should not have to pay inflated costs.Id.Instead,Idaho Power suggested Commission Staff use the EIA's natural gas spot price at Henry Hub:High Oil and Gas Resource and Technology forecast,adjusted for Sumas and Idaho City Gate,which was also utilized in Idaho Power's 2017 Integrated Resource Planning process and Incremental Cost IRP methodology.Id.' Idaho Power stated that it undertook a comparison between Staff's proposed avoided cost rates and its suggested methodology and found that "[w]hen the Natural Gas Spot Price at Henry Hub forecast is applied as the basis in the SAR methodology,the approximate decrease in 20-year levelized avoided cost prices across all resource types,assuming an online year of 2018, is $10.99 per megawattshour."Id.at 1-2. Idaho Power further stated that it is experiencing increased development of new PURPA QFs that are eligible for published avoided cost rates over the next several years.Id.at 2.These QFs must enter into new or replacement energy sales agreements where,according to Idaho Power,use of the Mountain Region natural gas price forecast results in higher avoided costs.Id.In order to rectify this,Idaho Power suggested that each applicable Idaho utility *Staff disagreed with the Company changing its forecast away from EIA's Mountain Region sector forecast to EIA's "High Oil and Gas Resource and Technology Case"forecast in the 2017 IRP.See Comments of the Commission Staff in Case No.IPC-E-17-11. )R l)ER NO.34062 2 should utilize its own natural gas forecast stream in terms of computations made under the SAR methodology.Id. Staff recommended that its proposed updated rates be approved,effective June 1, 2018 (per Order No.32697),but that the Commission find that Idaho Power's suggestion may be raised in a generic docket,brought of its own volition,related to the revision of the Commission's methodology for updating published avoided cost rates to reflect updated natural gas price forecasts.In such proceeding,all electric utilities and interested parties would have the opportunityto provide comment so the Commission can more fully understand the impact of Idaho Power's proposal. FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS The Idaho Public Utilities Commission has jurisdiction over Avista Corporation dba Avista Utilities,Idaho Power Company,and PacifiCorp dba Rocky Mountain Power and the matters considered in this case pursuant to the authorityand power granted it under Title 61 of the Idaho Code and the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA).The Commission has authority under PURPA and the implementing regulations of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)to set avoided costs,to order electric utilities to enter into fixed-term obligations for the purchase of energy from qualified facilities,and to implement FERC rules. Pursuant to its authority,the Commission has reviewed and considered the filings of record.The annual update to the SAR methodology's avoided cost rates is a relatively simple arithmetic re-calculation.We find that the accuracy of the calculations and the resulting rates disseminated by Staff based upon EIA's most recent annual natural gas price forecast have not been challenged.The "suggestion"made by Idaho Power concerned the particular EIA forecast Staff used to update published avoided cost rates.We would note that,while Order No.32697 may not explicitly adopt the "reference case"natural gas price forecast for the Mountain Region's Electric Power sector,we have explicitlyapproved its use for the past five years in our final orders addressing the annual EIA update.See Order Nos.32817,33041,33305,33538,and 33773.It is currently the natural gas price forecast that this Commission approves for determination of SAR avoided costs. We acknowledge the Company's suggestion that it would like the existing SAR methodology altered to allow each utility its own natural gas price forecast stream but find that ORDER NO.34062 3 Idaho Power may address its suggestion in a dedicated docket in which the other utilities and any interested parties can provide comments to fully inform the Commission about the issue. We fmd the updated published avoided cost rates are fair,just,and reasonable. ORDER IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the updates to published avoided cost rates for Avista,Idaho Power,and PacifiCorp are approved,effective June 1,2018. THIS IS A FINAL ORDER.Any person interested in this Order may petition for reconsideration within twenty-one (21)days of the service date of this Order.Within seven (7) days after any person has petitioned for reconsideration,any other person may cross-petition for reconsideration.See Idaho Code §61-626. DONE by Order of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission at Boise,Idaho this day of May 2018. PAUL K I AÑ ,PRESIDENT KRI TINE RAPER,C SSIONER ERIC ANDERSON,COMMISSIONER ATTEST: Diane M.Hanian Commission Secretary AVUEl804 IPCE1805 PACE1802 se ORDER NO.34062 4 3. 8 . En e r g y Pa c e s by Se c t o r an d So u r c e JO U do l a s pe r mi on St u , un l e s s ot h e r w i s e no t e d ) Mo u n t a i n 0 Se c t o r a n d s o u r c e 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 ec t n c Po w e r 8/ Di s t u ï b 12 . 0 7 14 . 0 5 14 . 5 8 15 , 7 6 19 . 2 8 21 . 0 6 21 . 9 2 22 . 6 2 22 . 7 9 22 . 9 1 ie al a Du 3, 4 0 4. 0 3 3. 9 3 5. 1 7 8. 4 3 10 . 0 8 11 . 0 4 11 . 8 8 11 . 9 7 11 . 9 8 Na t u d C 2. 7 7 3. 5 2 3. 6 3 3. 9 9 4. 2 3 4. 2 0 4.2 3 4. 3 7 4. 5 0 4. 6 5 Me am f or 1. 8 6 1.8 4 1. 8 3 1. 8 1 1. 7 9 1. 8 0 1. 8 0 1.8 0 1. 7 9 1. 7 9 0. 6 5 0. 6 5 0. 6 5 0. 6 5 0. 6 5 0. 6 5 0.6 5 0. 6 6 0. 6 6 0. 6 6 Pn c e s m No m m a l Do l l a r s eu u. Po w e r 8/ 11 . 8 6 14 . 0 5 14 . 9 1 16 . 4 9 20 . 6 9 23 . 1 7 24 . 6 9 26 . 1 1 26 . 9 5 27 . 7 3 3.3 5 4. 0 3 4. 0 2 5. 4 1 9. 0 5 11 . 0 9 12 . 4 4 13 . 7 2 14 . 1 5 14 . 5 1 Ut u : a a t e 2. 7 3 3. 5 2 3. 7 1 4 . 1 8 4. 5 4 4. 6 2 4.7 7 5. 0 5 5. 3 2 5. 6 3 un to 1.8 3 1. 8 4 1. 8 7 1.8 9 1. 9 2 1. 9 8 2. 0 3 2. 0 7 2. 1 2 2. 1 7 Ur a n i u m 0. 6 3 0. 6 5 0. 6 6 0. 6 8 0. 7 0 0. 7 2 0.7 4 0. 7 6 0. 7 8 0. 8 0 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 20 3 1 20 3 2 20 3 3 20 3 4 20 3 5 20 3 6 20 3 7 20 3 8 20 3 9 20 4 0 20 4 1 23 . 0 6 23 . 2 8 23 . 5 5 23 . 8 2 24 . 0 2 24 . 4 0 24 . 6 0 24 . 9 0 25 . 1 5 25 . 2 7 25 . 4 1 25 . 9 1 26 . 0 6 26 , 2 9 26 . 5 1 26 . 7 4 12 . 2 1 12 . 4 2 12 , 5 8 12 . 8 8 13 . 0 6 13 . 3 4 13 , 4 8 13 . 6 8 13 . 8 5 14 . 0 4 14 . 1 1 14 . 4 8 14 , 6 2 14 . 8 1 14 . 9 7 15 . 1 3 4. 7 0 4. 7 7 4. 7 9 4. 8 5 4. 8 6 4. 8 5 4. 8 8 4. 8 7 4. 8 9 4. 8 9 5. 0 1 5. 0 2 5. 0 8 5. 1 3 5. 1 8 5. 2 3 1. 7 8 1.7 9 1. 7 8 1. 7 9 1. 8 0 1. 8 0 1. 8 1 1. 8 2 1. 8 3 1. 8 5 1.8 7 1. 8 8 1. 9 0 1.9 1 1. 9 2 1. 9 3 0. 6 6 0. 6 6 0. 6 6 0. 6 6 0. 6 7 0. 6 7 0. 6 7 0. 6 7 0. 6 7 0.6 7 0. 6 8 0. 6 8 0. 6 8 0. 6 8 0. 6 8 0. 6 9 28 . 5 6 29 . 4 8 30 . 4 7 31 . 4 8 32 . 4 1 33 . 6 5 34 . 6 6 35 . 8 7 37 . 0 4 38 . 0 7 39 . 1 5 40 . 8 4 42 . 0 2 43 . 3 6 44 . 7 2 46 . 1 8 15 . 1 3 15 . 7 3 16 . 2 7 17 , 0 2 17 . 6 3 18 . 3 9 18 . 9 9 19 . 7 0 20 . 3 9 21 . 1 5 21 . 7 4 22 . 8 3 23 . 5 7 24 . 4 2 25 . 2 5 26 . 1 2 5. 8 3 6, 0 4 6. 2 0 6. 4 1 6. 5 5 6. 6 9 6. 8 8 7. 0 2 7. 2 1 7. 3 7 7. 7 2 7. 9 1 8. 1 8 8. 4 6 8. 7 4 9. 0 2 2. 2 0 2. 2 7 2. 3 1 2.3 6 2. 4 2 2. 4 9 2. 5 5 2. 6 2 2. 7 0 2. 7 9 2. 8 8 2. 9 7 3. 0 6 3 15 3. 2 4 3. 3 3 0. 8 2 0. 8 4 0, 8 6 0. 8 8 0. 9 0 0. 9 2 0. 9 4 0. 9 7 0. 9 9 1. 0 2 1. 0 4 1. 0 7 1. 0 9 1. 1 2 1. 1 5 1. 1 8 20 4 2 20 4 3 20 4 4 20 4 5 20 4 6 20 4 7 20 4 8 20 4 9 20 5 0 26 . 8 0 26 . 8 5 26 . 9 4 27 . 0 6 26 . 9 9 27 . 1 1 27 . 3 4 27 . 3 3 27 . 4 4 15 . 2 1 15 . 2 7 15 . 2 7 15 . 3 1 15 . 2 0 15 . 2 4 15 . 4 1 15 . 4 1 15 . 6 1 5. 2 9 5. 3 5 5. 4 2 5. 4 7 5.5 2 5. 5 8 5. 7 1 5. 7 8 5. 8 9 1. 9 4 1, 9 4 1. 9 5 1. 9 5 1. 9 6 1. 9 7 1. 9 8 1. 9 8 1. 9 9 0, 6 9 0. 6 9 0. 6 9 0. 6 9 0. 6 9 0. 7 0 0. 7 0 0. 7 0 0. 7 0 47 36 48 . 5 9 49 . 9 4 51 . 3 9 52 . 5 2 54 . 0 5 55 . 9 0 57 . 2 8 58 . 9 7 26 . 8 9 27 . 6 4 28 . 3 1 29 . 0 8 29 . 5 8 30 . 3 9 31 . 4 9 32 . 3 0 33 . 5 6 9. 3 5 9. 6 8 10 . 0 4 10 . 3 9 10 . 7 4 11 . 1 4 11 . 6 8 12 . 1 1 12 . 6 5 3. 4 3 3, 5 2 3. 6 1 3, 7 1 3. 8 1 3. 9 2 4. 0 4 4. 1 5 4, 2 8 1. 2 1 1. 2 5 1. 2 8 1. 3 1 1. 3 5 1. 3 9 1.4 3 1. 4 7 1. 5 1 AVISTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR WIND PROJECTS June 01,2018 $/MWhNewContractsandReplacementContracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects 100 kW or smalle LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZEDARS)2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 3tS7 34,47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.13 33.12 34.77 35,61 37,16 39.18 2019 3L87 3 31.46 33.73 35 20 36,42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32,27 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 41.74 2021 35.09 5 32.94 34.95 36.62 38.15 40.45 42.94 2022 36.18 6 33.66 35.67 37.41 39.38 4L59 43,91 2023 38.22 7 34.40 36.43 38.51 40,44 42.54 44.77 2024 40.22 8 35.16 37,44 39,48 41.34 43.39 45.52 2025 42.46 9 36.12 38.35 40.32 42.16 44.14 46.19 2026 47.15 10 37.00 39.16 41.11 42,90 44.81 46.81 2027 48.76 11 37.78 39.91 4081 43.56 45.44 47.39 2028 50.021238.52 40,59 42.44 44,17 46.02 47.94 2029 51.61 13 39.18 41.21 43 04 44.74 46.57 48.46 2030 52.721439.79 4L79 43.59 45.29 47.09 49.01 2031 53.811540.36 42.33 44.12 45.80 47.63 49,53 2032 55.221640.89 42.85 44,62 46.32 48.14 50.05 2033 56.34 17 41.40 43,33 45.13 46.82 48.65 50.57 2034 57.79184L8743.82 45-61 47.32 49.15 51.07 2035 59.061942.35 44.29 46.09 47.80 49.64 51.57 2036 6L652042.81 44.75 46.55 48.28 50.13 52,07 2037 63.12 2038 65,18 2039 67.26 2040 69,35 2041 71.53 2042 73.99 2043 76.44 Note:These rates will be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration(EIAfs Annual EnergyOutlook2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3 8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eía.govíoutlooks/aeo/tables ref.php AVISTAPage 1 /d5TA AVOlDED COST RATES FOR SOLAR PROJECTS June 01 2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is hmited to projects 100 kW or smaller LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENGTH __CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED(YEARS 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 \EAR RATES 1 28,51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.13 33.12 34,77 35.61 37,16 39.18 2019 3L87 3 3L46 33.73 35.20 36.42 38.10 40,19 2020 34.47 4 32.27 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 42.07 2021 35,09 5 32.94 34.95 36.62 38.15 40.71 43.48 2022 36.18 6 33.66 35.67 37.41 39.59 42.02 44,58 2023 38.22734.40 36.43 38,68 40,79 43.09 48.90 2024 40,22 8 35.16 37.58 39.77 41.80 46.85 52.26 2025 42.46936,24 38.60 40.72 45.11 49.88 52.51 2026 48.65 10 37.22 39.50 43.65 47.85 50.27 52.82 2027 50.28 11 38.08 42,13 46,12 48.31 50.67 53.13 2028 51.56 12 40.46 44.38 46,61 48.76 51,05 53.46 2029 82.991342.52 44.89 47.09 49.19 51.45 53.81 2030 84 551443-06 45,39 47.55 49,62 51.84 54.20 2031 55.421543.57 45.86 47.99 50.03 52.26 54,60 2032 56.861644.05 46.31 48.41 50.48 52.68 55.01 2033 58.001744.51 46.74 48.86 50.91 53.11 55.43 2034 59.471844.95 47.19 49,29 51.34 53.54 56.80 2035 60.771945.40 47.62 49.72 51.77 54.82 57.20 2036 63.382045.83 48.05 50-15 52.97 55.23 57 62 2037 64.88 2038 66.97 2039 69.07 2040 106.19 2041 73.39 2042 75.88 2043 78 36 Note:These rates will be further adjusted with the applicableintegration charge. Note:The rates shownin this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy Information Administration (EIAfs Annual EnergyOutlook2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/tables ref.php AVISTA Page 2 A VISTAAVOIDEDCOSTRATESFORNON-SEASONAL HYDRO PROJECTS June 01,2018 $,MWo New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaller than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS)2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.13 33.12 34.77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 31,46 33,73 35.20 36.42 38.10 40-19 2020 34.47 4 32.27 34,27 35,87 37.26 39.07 43.61 2021 35,09 5 32,94 34.95 36.62 38.15 41.89 45.95 2022 36 18 6 33.66 35.67 37.41 40.53 44,00 47.69 2023 38,22 7 34.40 36,43 39.46 42.42 45.65 51,32 2024 40.22 8 35.16 38.24 41.14 43.95 48,88 54.16 2025 42.46 9 36,80 39,77 42,55 46.85 51.50 54.86 2026 55.58 10 38.22 41.08 45.14 49.25 52.29 55.52 2027 57 31 11 39.46 43.43 47.34 50.07 53.02 56.14 2028 58.70 12 41.60 45.44 48.16 50.83 53.69 56,73 2029 79.94 13 43.47 46.26 48.92 51.52 54.33 57.28 2030 81.46 14 44.27 47,01 49.62 52,18 54,92 57.87 2031 62.87 15 45.02 47.71 50.27 52.79 55.54 58,43 2032 64.42 16 45.71 48.36 50.88 53.41 56.12 58.99 2033 65.67 17 46.35 48.96 51.49 53.99 56.69 59.54 2034 67.26 18 46.95 49.57 52.07 54.57 57.25 60,70 2035 68.67 19 47.55 50.14 52.64 55.12 58.35 61,22 2036 71.40 20 48.11 50.69 53,19 56.17 58.87 61.74 2037 73.01 2038 75.22 2039 77.44 2040 102.61 2041 82.02 2042 84.63 2043 87.24 Note:These rates wiß be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainat https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/tables ref.php AVISTA Page 3 ALSTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SEASONAL HYDRO PROJECTS June 01 2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full capacity Payments Ehgtbility for these rates is limited to projects smaller than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZEDtYEARS:2016 2019 2020 2021 2027 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28,51 2 30,13 33.12 34.77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.67 3 31.46 33,73 35.20 36.42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32.27 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 41.02 2021 35,09 5 32.94 34.95 36.62 38.15 39.90 41.77 2022 36.18 6 33.66 35.67 37.41 38.94 40.66 42.44 2023 38,22 7 34.40 36,43 38.14 39.67 41.33 49,06 2024 40.22 8 35.16 37 13 38.83 40.33 46.99 64.16 -2025 42.46 9 35.86 37.80 39.46 45.23 51.50 53.85 2026 43.90 10 36.53 38.42 43.75 49.24 51.42 53.70 2027 45,46 11 37.14 42.21 47.33 49.31 51.43 53.64 2028 46.67 12 40.54 45,44 47.49 49.43 51 50 53.66 2029 101,29 13 43,46 45.67 47.69 49.59 51.62 53.74 2030 103.121443.75 45.92 47,90 49 78 51.78 53.91 2031 50.31 15 44,04 46-17 48.13 49.98 52.01 54.11 2032 51.671644.33 46.43 48.37 50.24 52,25 54,35 2033 52.731744.62 46.70 48.65 50.52 52.52 54.62 2034 54.131844.91 47.00 48.94 50.81 52.81 66.59 2035 55.351945.23 47.30 49.24 51.11 54-63 56.85 2036 57,88 20 45,54 47.61 49.55 52.80 54.92 57.14 2037 59.30 2038 61.30 2039 63,32 2040 127.68 2041 67,47 2042 69.87 2043 72.27 Note:A "seasonal hydro project"is defined as a generationfacility which produces at least 55%of its annual generationduring themonthsofJune,July,and August.Order 32802. Note:These rates will be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy Information Administration (EIAfs Annuaî EnergyOutlook2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eia.gov/outioaks/aeo/tables ref.php AVISTA Page 4 AVOIDED COST RATES FOR OTHER PAOJFCTS June G1,2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaler than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED201820192020202120222023YEARRATES 1 28.51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30,13 33,12 34.77 35.61 37,16 39,18 2019 31.87 3 31.46 33.73 35.20 36,42 38,10 40,19 2020 34.47432.27 34-27 35.87 37.26 39,07 46.01 2021 35.09 5 32,94 34.95 36.62 38.15 43.73 49.81 2022 36.18633,66 35.67 37,41 42.01 47.08 52.54 2023 38.22734.40 36.43 40.67 44,95 49.63 54,69 2024 40.22835,16 39.25 43.27 47,30 51.71 56.42 2025 42.46937.67 41.58 45.40 49,26 53.43 57,87 2026 66.361039.79 43.54 47,22 50.91 54.89 59.14 2027 68.251141.60 45.24 48.78 52.33 56.17 60.26 2028 69.791243.19 46,71 50.14 53.59 57.31 61.27 2029 71.681344.59 48,01 51 36 54.72 58.34 62.19 2030 73.07 14 45.83 49,18 52.45 55.74 59.28 63.09 2031 74.471546.96 50.24 53,45 56.68 60..19 63.93 2032 76.191647.98 51,21 54.37 57,58 61.04 64.73 2033 77.611748.91 52,09 55.25 58.42 61.85 65.50 2034 79.371849.78 52,95 56.07 59.22 62.62 66.24 2035 80.961950.61 53,75 56.85 59.98 63.36 66.95 2036 83.872051.38 54,50 57.59 60,71 64.07 67.64 2037 85.67 2038 88,06 2039 90.47 2040 92,91 2041 95.43 2042 98.24 2043 101,06 Note:"Otherprojects"refers to projects other than wind,solar,non-seasonal hydro,and seasonal hydro projects.These "Otherprojects"may include (but are not limited to):cogeneration,biomass,biogas,landfili gas,or geothermal projects. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the IJ.S.Energy Information Administration(EIA)'s Annual EnergyOutlook2018,releasedFebruary 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.ela-gov/outlooks aeo/tables _ref.php AVISTA Page 5 IDAHO POWE COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR WIND PROJECTS Jane 01.2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Fun Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects 100 kW or smaller LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED (YEARS)2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38,22 2018 28.51 2 30,12 33.12 34.77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 31.46 33.72 35.20 36.42 38,10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32.26 34.27 35.87 37 26 39.07 41,77 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34,94 36,61 38.14 40,47 42.98 2022 36.18 6 33.65 35.66 37.40 39,39 41.61 43.96 2023 38.22 7 34.38 36.41 38.51 40.45 42.57 44.83 2024 40.22 8 35.13 37.43 39.48 41.36 43.43 45.58 2025 42.46 9 36.10 38.34 40.33 42.18 44.18 46,25 2026 47,31 10 36.98 39.15 41.11 42.92 44,85 46.87 2027 48.92 11 37.76 39.90 41.81 43.57 45.48 47,45 2028 50.18 12 38.49 40.58 42.45 44.19 46.05 47.99 2029 51.77 13 39.16 41.20 43.04 44.76 46.60 48,51 2030 52.88 14 39.76 41.78 43.59 45.29 47.11 49.05 2031 53.97 15 40.33 42,31 44.11 45.80 47.65 49.57 2032 55.39 16 40.85 42,82 44.60 46.32 48,16 50.08 2033 56.51 17 41.35 43.30 45,11 46,82 48.66 50.59 2034 57.96 18 41.82 43,78 45.58 47.30 49.15 51.09 2035 59.24 19 42.29 44.25 46.05 47.78 49.63 51.57 2036 61.82 20 42.74 44,70 46,51 48.25 50-11 52.06 2037 63.30 2038 65.36 2039 67,44 2040 69.54 2041 71,72 2042 74.17 2043 76.64 Note:These rates wif be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/tablesref.php IDAHO POWER COMPANY Page 1 IDAHO POWER COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SOLAR PROJECTS June 01,2018 5 MWh New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects 100 kW or smaller. LEVELIZED NOULEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENGTH XH HAC I NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS)2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31,87 34,47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33.12 34,77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 31.46 33.72 35.20 36,42 38,10 40,19 2020 34.47 4 32,26 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 48.72 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34.94 36.61 38.14 45.81 54,17 2022 36.18 6 33.65 35,66 37.40 43.65 50,56 58,02 2023 38.22 7 34.38 36.41 42.01 47.79 54.12 60,99 2024 40 22 8 35.13 40.37 45,63 51.04 56.97 63.34 2025 42.46 9 38.60 43.58 48.57 53.71 59 29 65 28 2026 78.74 10 41,49 46.25 51-03 55.93 61.24 66.95 2027 80.81 11 43.93 48,53 53.13 57.83 62.93 68.40 2028 82.54 12 46.05 50.49 54.93 59.49 64.41 69.70 2029 84.61 13 47.90 52.21 56.53 60.95 65.74 70,87 2030 86.19 14 49.52 53.74 57,95 62,27 66,94 71.98 2031 87.78 15 50.98 55.10 59.23 63.46 68.07 73,00 2032 89.69 16 52.29 56,34 60.40 64.59 69.11 73.97 2033 91.31 17 53,49 57.47 61.50 65.62 70,10 74,89 2034 93.27 18 54.58 58.54 62.51 66.60 71.02 75,76 2035 95.07 19 55.61 59.52 63.47 67.52 71.90 76.59 2036 98.18 20 56 57 60.45 64.37 68.39 72.73 77.39 2037 100.19 2038 102.79 2039 105.42 2040 108,08 2041 110.82 2042 113,85 2043 116.90 Note:These rates win be further adjusted with the applicableintegration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s AnnualEnergy Outlook 2018,released February 2018,See Annual Energy Outlook 2018,Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainat https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/tables ref.php IDAHO POWER COMPANYPage 2 IDAHO POWER COMPANYAVOIDEDCOSTRATESFORNON-SEASONAL HYDRO PROJECTS June 01,2018 $MWh New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Fun Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaller than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVEUZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED201820192020202120222023YEARRATES 1 28,51 3L87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28,51 2 30.12 33.12 34.77 35,61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 3L46 33.72 35.20 36.42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32.26 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 48.05 2021 35,09 5 32.93 34.94 36.61 38.14 45.29 53.09 2022 36.18 6 33,65 35.66 37.40 43-24 49.69 56.66 2023 38,22 7 34.38 36.41 41.67 47,08 53.00 59.42 2024 40.22 8 35,13 40.08 45.04 50,10 55.65 61.62 2025 42.46 9 38.36 43,07 47.77 52.59 57.82 63.43 2026 75.69104LO545.56 50.07 5467 59.65 6500 2027 77.72 11 43,33 47.69 52.03 56.44 6L24 66.37 2028 79.401245.32 49.53 53.72 58.00 62.63 67.59 2029 81.42 13 47.05 51.14 55.22 59.38 63.88 68.70 2030 82,96 14 48.58 52.58 56.56 60.62 65.01 69.75 2031 84.50 15 49 95 53.86 57.76 61.74 66.09 70.73 2032 86,36 16 51.18 55 03 58.86 62.81 67.08 7L65 2033 87.931752,31 56 09 59.91 63.80 68.01 72.53 2034 89.851853.34 57 11 60.87 64.73 68.90 73,36 2035 91.591954.32 58 04 61.78 65.60 69.74 74,16 2036 94.652055.22 58.92 62.63 66.43 70.54 74,93 2037 96.61 2038 99.16 2039 10L73 2040 104.34 2041 107.022042110.00 2043 112.99 Note:These rates will be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration (EIA)'s AnnualEnergyOutlook2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps:Hwww.eia.govioutlooks/aeoltables ref.php IDAHO POWER COMPANY Page 3 IDAHO POWe?COMPANYMO!OED COST RATES FOR SEASONAL HYDRO PROJECTS June 01 2016 $1W New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is Ilmited to projects smaller than 10 aMW LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-UNE YEAR LFNGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED A EARy 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28,51 3087 34,47 35,09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33.12 34.77 35,61 37.16 39.18 2019 3L87 3 31.46 33.72 35.20 36.42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32.26 34.27 35,87 37.26 39.07 52.78 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34,94 36.61 38.14 48.92 60.70 2022 36,18 6 33,65 35.66 37.40 46 14 55.77 66.23 2023 38.22 7 34.38 36.41 44,05 52.08 60.86 70.41 2024 40,22 8 35.13 42.08 49.23 56.69 64.87 73-70 2025 42.46 9 40.06 46.64 53,37 60.43 68.11 76.39 2026 97.08 10 44.12 50.39 56.82 63.52 70.80 78.67 2027 99.42 11 47.53 53.56 59.73 66.14 73.12 80.63 2028 101.42 12 50.46 56.28 62.22 68.41 75.12 82.36 2029 103.76 13 53.00 58,63 64.40 70.40 76.91 83.91 2030 105.63 14 55.22 60.71 66.32 72.17 78.50 85.35 2031 107.50 15 57.20 62,56 68,05 73,76 79.98 86.67 2032 109.70 16 58.97 64 23 69.61 75.24 81.34 87.91 2033 11L61 17 60.57 65.74 71.06 76.60 82.60 89.06 2034 113.87 18 62.02 67,15 72.39 77.86 83.78 90,15 2035 115.97 19 63.38 68.44 73.62 79,03 84.89 91 18 2036 119.39 20 64.63 69.64 74.78 80.14 85.93 92.16 2037 121.71 2038 124.63 2039 127.58 2040 130.56 2041 133,63 2042 137.00 2043 140.38 Note:A "seasonal hydro project"is defined as a generationfacility which produces at least 55%of its annual generationduríng the months of June,July,and August.Order 32802, Note:These rates will be further adjusted with the applicableintegration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/tables ref.php IDAHO POWER COMPANY Page 4 AVOIDED COST RATES R OTHER PROJECTS June 01,2018 5 Mvvr New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaller than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS)2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34,47 35.09 36.18 38,22 2018 28,51 2 30,12 33.12 34.77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 3LS7 3 3L46 33,72 35,20 36.42 38.10 40,19 2020 34.47 4 32,26 34.27 35.87 37.26 39,07 46,21 2021 35,09 5 32.93 34,94 36.61 38.14 43,88 50.14 2022 36.18 6 33.65 35.66 37.40 42.11 47.33 52.95 2023 38.22 7 34.38 36,41 40.75 45.14 49,95 55.16 2024 40.22 8 35,13 39,31 43,42 47.55 52.09 56.94 2025 42.46 9 37.70 41.69 45.60 49.55 53.84 58.42 2026 67.41 10 39.86 43.69 47.46 51.24 55.33 59.71 2027 69.31 11 41.71 45.42 49.05 52.69 56.64 60.85 2028 70.87 12 43.33 46.92 50.43 53.97 57.79 61.87 2029 72.77 13 44.75 48.24 51.67 55.11 58.84 62.81 2030 74.18 14 46.00 49.42 52.77 56.15 59.79 63.71 2031 75.59 15 47.14 50.49 53.78 57.09 60.71 64.56 2032 77.32 16 48,17 51.47 54.70 58.00 61.56 65.36 2033 78.76 17 49.11 52,36 55.59 58.84 62.37 66.13 2034 80,54 18 49.98 53.22 56.41 59.64 63..14 66.86 2035 82.15 19 50.81 54.02 57.19 60.40 63.87 67.57 2036 85,07 20 51.58 54.77 57,93 61.13 64,58 68,26 2037 86.89 2038 89.30 2039 91.73 2040 94.18 2041 96.72 2042 99.55 2043 102.38 Note:"Other projects"refers to projects other than wind,solar,non-seasonal hydro,and seasonal hydro projects.These "Other projects"may include (but are not limited to):cogeneration,biomass,biogas,landfill gas,or geothermalprojects. Note:The rates shown in this tabîe have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration(EIA)'s AnnualEnergy Outîook 2018.releasedFebruary 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainat https://www.ela.gov/outlooks/aeoltables ref.php IDAHO POWER COMPANY Page 5 PACIFICORP AVOIDED GOST RATES FOR WîND PROJECTS June 01,2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects 100 kW or smaller. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED YEARS)2018 2019 2020 2021 202?2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33.12 34,77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 31.46 33.73 35.20 36,42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32,27 34.27 35,87 37.26 39.07 41.02 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34.94 36.61 38.15 39.89 41.77 2022 36.18 6 33.66 35.66 37.41 38.93 40.65 42.91 2023 38.22 7 34,39 36.43 38,14 39.66 41.71 43.89 2024 40.22 8 35.15 37.13 38.83 40.65 42.65 44.73 2025 42.46 9 35.85 37,80 39.73 41.53 43.46 45.47 2026 43.901036,52 38<65 40.56 42.31 44.19 46.15 2027 45-46 11 37.33 39.43 41.29 43.01 44.85 46.76 2028 50,10 12 38.09 40.14 41,96 43.66 45.46 47.35 2029 51.69 13 38.78 40.78 42,58 44,25 46.04 47.90 2030 52.801439,40 41.38 43.15 44.81 46.59 48.47 2031 53.89 15 39.99 41.93 43.70 45.34 47.14 49.02 2032 55.311640.53 42.46 44.21 45.88 47.67 49.55 2033 56.43 17 41.05 42.96 44.73 46.40 48.20 50.08 2034 57.881841.53 43.46 45.22 46.90 48,71 50.60 2035 59,15 19 42.02 43.94 45.71 47.40 49.21 51,11 2036 61.74 20 42,48 44.40 46.18 47,88 49.70 51.61 2037 63.21 2038 65.27 2039 67.35 2040 69.45 2041 71.62 2042 74.08 2043 76.54 Note:These rates wm be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge, Note:The rates shown in this table have been cornputed using the U.S.Energy Information Administration (EIAfs Annual EnergyOutlook2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018,Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eia.gov/outlookslaeo!tables ref.php PACIFICORP Page 1 PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SOLAR PROJECTS June 01,2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects 100 kW or smaller. LEVELIZED NOULEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE VEAR LENGTH C 3NT RAC N3N LEVELIZE3DEARS*2018 2~19 2020 2021 2022 2023 vFAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34,47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33.12 34.77 35,61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 31.46 33.73 35,20 36.42 38,10 40,19 2020 34.47 4 32.27 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 41.02 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34.94 36,61 38.15 39.89 41.77 2022 36.18 6 33.66 35,66 37,41 38,93 40.65 47.23 2023 38.22 7 34.39 36,43 38,14 39.66 45.26 51.33 2024 40,22 8 35,15 37.13 38.83 43.63 48.89 54.54 2025 42.46 9 35,85 37.80 42.27 46.85 51.82 57.14 2026 43.90 10 36-52 40.83 45.14 49.51 54.25 59.33 2027 45.46 11 39,24 43,42 47.56 51.76 56.33 61.20 2028 81.77 12 41.59 45,63 49.64 53,72 58,13 62,85 2029 83.82 13 43.63 47.56 51.47 55.43 59.73 64.31 2030 85.40 14 45.42 49.27 53,08 56.96 61,16 65.68 2031 86.97 15 47.03 50.79 54.53 58.34 62.49 66.92 2032 88.87 16 48,46 52.17 55.84 59.63 63.71 68.07 2033 90.48 17 49.77 53.41 57.08 60,80 64.84 69.16 2034 92.44 18 50.96 54.59 58,21 61,90 65.90 70.17 2035 94.22 19 52.08 55.67 59.26 62.93 66.90 71.13 2036 97.32 20 53.11 56.68 60.25 63.90 67.84 72.05 2037 99.31 2038 101.91 2039 104.52 2040 107.16 2041 109 89 2042 112 92 2043 115 95 Note:These rates wifî be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shownin this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration (EIAfs Annual Energy Outlook 2018,released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeotables ref.php PACIFICORP Page 2 PACŒlCORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR NON-SEASONAL HYDRO PROJECTS June 01,2018 $M½r New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaller than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LINE YEARLENCTH C NTRA T NON-LEVELIZED WEARS)2018 20 9 2320 2021 2022 2023 V EAR RATES 1 28,51 31.87 34.47 35.09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33,12 34.77 35.61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 31.46 33,73 35.20 36.42 38.10 40 19 2020 34.47 4 32.27 34.27 35.87 37.26 39.07 41,02 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34,94 36.61 38.15 39.89 41,77 2022 36.18 6 33.66 35.66 37.41 38.93 40.65 46.81 2023 38.22 7 34.39 38,43 38.14 39.66 44.92 50.61 2024 40.22 8 35.15 37.13 38.83 43.34 48.29 53.58 2025 42.46 9 35,85 37.80 42.02 46,33 51.01 56.00 2026 43.901036.52 40.62 44.69 48.81 53 27 58,05 2027 45.46 11 39.05 43.03 46.95 50.91 55.22 59,80 2028 78.69 12 4L25 45.10 48.89 52.74 56.90 61.35 2029 80.711343,16 46.90 50.61 54.35 58.40 62.72 2030 82,231444,84 48,50 52.12 55.79 59.74 64.01 2031 83.76 15 46,34 49,93 53.48 57.08 61.00 65.18 2032 85.621647.69 51 22 54.71 58.29 62.15 66.28 2033 87.18 17 48,92 52.40 55.88 59.41 63.22 67.30 2034 89.081850,04 53.51 56,94 60.45 64.23 68.27 2035 90.81 19 51.10 54.53 57.95 6L43 65 18 69-19 2036 93.862052.08 55.49 58.89 62.35 66.08 70.06 2037 95.81 2038 98.35 2039 100.91 2040 103,50 2041 106.18 2042 109.15 2043 112.12 Note:These rates wiß be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shownin this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration (E!Afs Annual EnergyOutlook2018,releasedFebruary 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018 Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps:/www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeollabîes ref.php PACIFICORP Page 3 PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SEASONAL HYDRO PROJECTS June 01,2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaller than 10 aMW. LEVELIZED NON-LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-LîNE YEARLENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVEUZED :YEARS 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28,51 31.87 34.47 35 09 36.18 38.22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33.12 34.77 35,61 37.16 39.18 2019 31.87 3 3L46 33.73 35.20 36.42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32.27 34,27 35.87 37.26 39,07 41.02 2021 35.09 5 32.93 34,94 36,61 38.15 39.89 41,77 2022 36.18 6 33,66 35.66 37,41 38.93 40.65 49.75 2023 38.22 7 34.39 36.43 38.14 39,66 47.33 55.67 2024 40.22 8 35.15 37 13 38.83 45.36 52.53 60.26 2025 42.46 9 35.85 37.80 43,75 49,95 56.69 63,94 2026 43.901036.52 42,11 47,81 53.71 60.12 67.02 2027 45.46 11 40.35 45.75 51.22 56,87 63,02 69.63 2028 100 24 12 43.63 48.84 54.12 59,59 65.52 71.89 2029 102.57 13 46.46 51.52 56.65 61.96 67.71 73.88 2030 104.42 14 48.94 53.87 58,87 64.05 69.66 75.71 2031 106.27 15 51.13 55,96 60,85 65.92 71.44 77,36 2032 108.45 16 53.09 57.83 62.63 67.64 73.06 78.88 2033 110.35 17 54.85 59,51 64.28 69,21 74 55 80,28 '2034 112.591856.45 61.08 65.78 70.65 75.93 81.59 2035 114.67 19 57,94 62.51 67.17 72.00 77.22 82.81 2036 118.072059.31 63,84 68.46 73.25 78..42 83.97 2037 120.37 2038 123.27 2039 126.20 2040 129.16 2041 132.22 2042 135.57 2043 138.93 Note:A seasonal hydro project"is defined as a generation faci ity which produces at least SS%of its annual generationduringthe months of June,July,and August.Order 32802. Note:These rates will be further adjusted with the applicable integration charge. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S.Energy information Administration (EIA)'s Annual EnergyOutlook2018.released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018.Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainat https://www.eia.gov outlooks/aeo/tables ref.php PACIFICORP Page 4 PAGI,CORPAVOIDEDCOSTRATESFOROTHER PROJECTS June 01,2018 New Contracts and Replacement Contracts without Full Capacity Payments Eligibility for these rates is limited to projects smaler than 10 aMW LEVELIZED NOb LEVELIZED CONTRACT ON-UNE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 YEAR RATES 1 28.51 31.87 34.47 35,09 36.18 38,22 2018 28.51 2 30.12 33.12 34,77 35.61 37.16 39,18 2019 31,87 3 31 46 33.73 35.20 36,42 38.10 40.19 2020 34.47 4 32 27 34.27 35.87 37.26 39,07 41,02 2021 35,09 5 32 93 34.94 36.61 38.15 39,89 41.77 2022 36.18 6 33 66 35.66 37.41 38.93 40.65 45,67 2023 38,22 7 34 39 36.43 38.14 39.66 43,98 48.65 2024 40.22 8 35 15 37 13 38,83 42.55 46.64 51.00 2025 42,46 9 35 85 37,80 41,35 44.93 48.81 52,93 2026 43,90 10 36 52 40.05 43,49 46.91 50.62 54.58 2027 45.46 11 38 55 41.98 45,30 48.61 52.19 56,00 2028 70.3512403343.65 46.87 50.09 53.56 57,26 2029 72.24 13 41.88 45,12 48.26 51 40 54.79 58.39 2030 73,65 14 43.25 46.42 49.50 52 58 55.90 59,47 2031 75.051544.49 47.60 50.63 53 65 56.96 60.46 2032 76,77 16 45.60 48.67 51,65 54 67 57.93 61,40 2033 78.21 17 46.62 49.64 52.62 55.61 58.84 62.28 2034 79.98 18 47.56 50.58 53.52 56.50 59.70 63.12 2035 81.581948.45 51.44 54.37 57.33 60.52 63,91 2036 84.49 20 49.28 52.26 55.18 58.13 61.30 64.68 2037 86.30 2038 88.70 2039 91.12 2040 93.57 2041 96.10 2042 98.91 2043 101.74 Note:"Otherprojects"refers to projects other than wind,solar,non-seasonalhydro,and seasonal hydro projects.These "Otherprojects"may include (but are not limited to):cogeneration,biomass,biogas,landfill gas,or geothermal projects. Note:The rates shown in this table have been computed using the lJ.S.Energy Information Administration(EIAys Annual EnergyOutlook2018.released February 2018.See Annual Energy Outlook 2018,Table 3.8 Energy Prices by Sector-Mountainathttps:www.ela.gov outlooks aeo/tables_ref.php PACIFICORP Page 5