Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20170705Link Exhibit 24.pdfCase No.PAC-E-17-07 Exhibit No.24 Witness:Rick T.Link BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER Exhibit Accompanying Direct Testimony of Rick T.Link June 2017 O Rocky Mountain Power Exhibit No.24 Page 1 of 2 Case No.PAC-E-17-07 ..a.,a2..co-.24- Witness:Rick T.Link (Benefit)/Cost PYRRúh 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 203[2032 2033 2034 |2035 |2036 CustofPro.iects $1.174 50 $0 50 $17 $103 5129 $l33 5140 5144 5147 $151 $167 $171 $172 5181 $185 $186 $187 $190 5198ChangeuiNPC(53][]50 50 $l ($14)(548)($49)(SSI)(548)(548)($46)($47)($40)(542)(525)(520)(522)($29)($28)($27)($22) ChangeuiEmissions so 50 $0 $0 50 50 So 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50ChangelnOSM(570)50 (50)(Sl)($2)(54)(56)(57)(SS)(59)(19)($l0)($12)(510)(510)(511)(Sl])(Sil)(Sil)(511)(SII) ChancemSvstemFixedCost (5672)50 SU 50 (50)(531)(557)(559)(564)(567)(568)(570)(5871 (590)(5132)(5116)(siso)($159)(5167)(5143)(SIS3) Net(BenclityCost $12)SU 50 (50)50 $20 517 $16 Sl9 520 524 523 128 $30 55 $33 SI (513)($l9)$N Sll Ëo(ÑatarmtGas.Media-CO2mPelkyScenario (Benefit)/Cost PYRRtd;2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 |2035 |2036CustofProjects51.174 SU 50 50 517 5103 5129 5133 $140 $144 SIA7 StS]5167 $171 $172 SIBI Sl85 $186 5187 5190 5198ChangemNPC($$l])50 50 50 (516)(549)(552)(555)(552)(554)($53)(154)(549)(553)(569)(564)(570)($l00)(5106)(5158)(5136)CliangeinEtnismons (529)$0 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 (54)($5)(55)(55)(59)($2)(Sl)($2)($5)(19)($13)(516)ChangeinOSM (526)50 (50)(50)(50)(SI)(52)(52)(52)($2)(52)(54)(54)(54)($4)($6)($6)(56)(S6)(56)(56)ChangeinSvstemFixedCost ($536)50 $0 50 (50)($3])(557)(159)(564)(S67)(568)(570)(588)(588)(598)(590)(Sil5)(590)(589)(561)($$9) Net(henelltvCust 573 50 50 $0 SI $21 519 SIN $22 517 519 518 $21 517 ($1)Sl9 (58)($14)(523)(548)(SIV) MNN&lGÑHigh CO2 PrkePolicy Scener¾ (Benefit)fo4 PVRRid;2019 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 |2035 |2036CostofPnycets$1.174 10 50 50 517 5103 5129 5133 5140 5144 5147 5151 5167 Sl71 $172 1181 5185 5186 5187 $190 $198 ChangeulNlf (5361)50 50 50 (St6)(552)(555)($57)(551)(556)(554)(544)($17)(516)(526)(535)(560)(59)(524)(587)($101) ChangentEnnssions (5239)50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 (54)(512)(533)(556)(564)(571)($88)(595)(539)(560)(540)(565) ChangentDSM ($6)50 50 10 10 (51)($1)(51)(11)till (51)(SI)(SI)(SI)(SI)(SI)(SI)(SI)(SI)(II)($3)ChanecinSvstemFixaiCost (165|}50 50 50 (50)(53[)(557)(559)(564)(567)(56N)(570)(5102)(5105)(5125)(599)(SSN)(5188)(516l)(5179)(577) Net(Beneli17Cost (584)SU 50 $0 $1 $20 Sl7 517 523 517 $ll $2 ($l0)(515)(550)(542)(558)(550)(559)($117)(548) 4ÑChaaraldas&Ñ¢Otrrhe-Evacysemarte (Benclit)Cost PPRRun 2017 2(Ils 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 21130 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects 11.174 50 Su 50 517 5103 5129 5133 Sl40 Sl44 1147 5151 5167 5171 5172 $181 $185 1186 Sib7 5190 5198ChangeinNPC($492)50 50 50 ($17)(557)(562)($64)(565)(564)(Shi)(563)(557)(SSI)(556)(574)(5106)(567)(575)529 (195) ChangelnEnnssions 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 91 50 50 $0 50 50 $(I $0 50 50 50 50 50 50ChangeulDSMSl6505050SISISI52525252525252535353$3 53 5)54 ChangeinSvstemFixedCost (S7]7)50 $0 50 (50)($31)($57)($59)(564)(567)(568)($70)($107)(Sl20)(5173)(5122)(580)($143)(5142)($266)($172) Net(BenclitVCos1 ($19)SU 50 50 SI $15 512 512 Sl3 $15 520 520 56 ($27)(564)($13)$1 ($20)(527)($46)($66) Medium Natural Öss,Medima CO2 Prici oscy senarts (Hencfl1)fos1 ITRgid¿2017 2018 2019 2020 202]2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 202W 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036Cos10fPnycets5Ll74505050SI75103$129 $)33 5140 5144 5147 Sl>]$167 5171 Sl72 5181 SINS Slb6 5187 5190 $198CliangeinNif(snis)50 50 50 (Sl6)(556)($64)(567)(567)(565)(562)(565)(558)(573)(556)(Slas)(Sl38)(Sl37)($149)($148)($82)Changetal.nnssions (546)su 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 (19)(510)(Sil)(510)(57)(SS)(Sill (513)(58)(58)(59)(58) ChangeinOSM $27 10 50 50 $0 50 50 $2 52 52 12 53 $3 $5 $6 57 57 57 57 57 57 CbangeinsvstemFixedCos1 (5626)50 50 50 ($0)($31)($57)(560)($64)($67)($68)($71)($107)(5110)($178)($120)(554)($92)($91)(599)($1WA) Net(lienefit)/(os1 ($NS)$0 50 $0 $1 $16 $9 $9 510 55 $9 $7 ($5)($14)($64)(548)(514)($43)(554)(560)(569) Mediam Naturs1 Gaa HilkCO2 Poiky seenario O (Benetit)(os1 |PrRRed,2017 20:N 2019 2020 2021 2022 |202)2024 2025 2026 2021 2028 2029 2030 203]2032 2033 2014 2035 2036 CustofPreiects SLI74 50 SU 50 Sl?$103 5]29 5133 5140 5144 $147 5151 1167 5171 5172 5181 SINS 5186 $187 $190 SIVE ChangeinNIT (5454)$0 §0 SI (516)(555)(§62)($64)(564)(562)(560)(56N)(548)(566)($35)($24)(533)(597)(5107)(526)(§67)Changemhmissions ($208)50 SU 50 50 50 50 $0 50 (Sil)($22)(523)(53N)(550)(54N)($60)($55)(543)(548)(5NG)(SS2) Changeinl)SM (g4c)50 50 (Sl)(SI)(52)($2)(53)($3)(54)(54)(54)(55)(55)(56)($7)($8)($9)(sil)(513)(516)ChangeinSys1milixedCost (SA2W)50 50 $0 ($0)(53[)($57)(559)(564)($67)($68)(570)($90)(585)(5131)(5137)($139)($[33)($131)($102)($99) Ne1(Benclit)Cost ($156)50 $0 (50)50 515 SS $7 $9 (50)(56)(514)($15)($34)(547)($47)(550)(596)(5109)(531)(565) IIIgh Natural Gas,Eere CO2 Price.Pelky Scenarie ifBenefittfost PrRRrd;2017 2015 2019 2020 2021 2022 |2023 2tl24 2025 2026 2027 2025 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2tl35 20% CustofPtojeels SI,I74 50 50 50 517 5103 Sl29 $l33 5140 Sl44 5147 5151 5167 $171 $172 5151 5185 5186 SIN7 5190 Sl98ChangemNif($775)50 50 50 (522)(574)(591)(587)(594)(592)(588)(591)(SNY)521 (5123)($104)(5129)(5198)(5202)(5132)(Sl68) Changeinhmissions 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 10 50 50 50 $0 50 $0 50 50 50 50 SilChangeinOSMSl3$0 ($0)(50)(10)$1 51 $1 $1 51 $1 51 50 $1 $2 $2 $2 $4 $$57 57 ChanteinSvstcmFixedCost ($716)50 SU $0 ($0)($3|}($57)(567)(571)($74)(576)($7N)(594)($226)(5104)(5132)(5115)(5115)(5127)($167)($149) Net(llenefit)/tos1 ($304)$0 50 50 ($6)($2)(SIN)($19)($25)($22)(516)($17)($15)($32)($53)(553)(557)(5122)(Sl37)($lul)($113) HighNatural Gee,Me:ManCO2 Price-PoneyScenario (HenetitMos1 |PYRRid;2017 20th 20l9 2020 2021 2022 |2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 202k 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 |2035 |2036CustofPruiectsSLI74505050Sl75103$129 5133 $140 $144 St47 SIS[Sl67 Sl71 5172 5181 5185 $186 Sls7 Sl90 5198 ChangcuiNPC (5¾04)50 50 SI (521)(572)(588)(590)(597)($94)($90)(592)($90)(5102)(5129)(SN6)(5166)($121)($143)($156)($170)ChangcinEmissions ($31)50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 ($4)($5)(56)(55)(56)(57)($4)($10)($$)(59)($7)($10)ChangcinOSM (561)50 ($0)(51)($2)(54)(54)(54)($5)($6)($6)($7)(58)(59)(510)($12)($13)($13)($13)($13)($13) ChanacinSvslemlixedCost (5597)50 $0 50 (50)($3))($57)(559)($64)(567)(568)($70)(587)(586)(188)(5145)(556)($138)(5127)($125)(5126) Net(Bene11tWCost (5318)50 $0 (50)(57)(54)($20)($20)(526)($27)(522)($25)($23)($31)($61)(566)(561)(S93)(5105)(5111)(512] HighNaturelGas,RigbCO2PriesPeacy8emark (Benelit)osi |PrgRid,2017 20Ib 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 |2035 |2036Cos10fProjectsSt.I74 50 50 50 517 5103 5129 5133 5140 S]44 5147 515]5167 5171 Sl72 5181 SISS $186 $187 $190 $198 ChangcinNlf (5605)50 50 $0 (523)(576)(592)(593)(598)($97)($93)(585)$7 (587)(576)($49)($78)(563)(560)($58)($1l7)ChangeinEmissions ($122)SU 50 50 50 50 50 $0 $0 ($5)($11)(528}($11)($41)($35)(533)($37)($28)($23)($31)($36) ChangeinOSM ($18)$0 50 ($0)(50)(50)(50)(SD)($2}($2)(52)(53)(54)(54)(54)($4)($4)($4)($4)($4)($4)ChaneemSystemFixedCost (582A)SU 50 $0 (50)($31)(557)(559)(164)(167)(568)(570)(5197)(588)($126)(SISS)(5141)(5196)($214)($219)(5264) Net(Hencli1VCost (5396)50 50 50 (56)(14)(520)(520)(524)(527)($27)(535)(537)(548)(570)(594)(575)(Sl05)($115)(5122)(5223) O Rocky Mountain Power Exhibit No.24 Page 2 of 2 Case No.PAC-E-17-07 Witness:Rick T.LinkOlawhaturalGaaZereCO2PolicyScenario (Bencfit)/Cost PYRRtd)2017 20]R 2019 2020 202]2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 203[2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects $1174 $0 50 50 $17 $103 5129 Sl33 Sl40 $144 5147 SIS)5167 $171 $172 518]Siss $186 Sis7 Sl90 5198 ChangeinNPC ($340)50 50 51 (515)(554)(555)(554)(550)(553)(550)(551)(544)(544)(522)(518)($19)(538)($36)(532)($31) Change in Emissions $0 50 50 10 $0 50 50 50 $0 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 ChangeinVOki (519)50 50 50 (50)(51)($1)(Sl)($2)(S2)(52)(52)($1)(SI)(59)(Slo)($10)(Sl)($0)($0)($1) ChangeroDSM (576)50 (50)(51)(52)(55)($6)(57)($9)(59)(510)($11)($12)($10 ($11)(512)($12)($12)($12)($12)($13) ChangeinDeficiency (52}10 50 (50)50 50 50 (50)50 ($0)50 50 ($0)(50)(50)(51)$0 50 ($3)(S))($2) ChangeinSystemFixedCos1 (5660)$0 50 50 ($0)($31)($56)($58)($63)($65)($66)($69)($85)($87)($130)($114)($147)(5157)(5165)(5141)(5151) Net(Benefit)/Cost 577 50 (50)(Sl)(Sl)Sl2 $ll $12 Sl7 515 519 519 $25 $28 (50)526 (54)($21)(530)53 $I lawNar.ralC.x,MudiumcG2 Poucybecamrso (Benefit)/Cost PYRRid)2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects $1,l74 50 50 SO $17 5103 5129 5133 Sl40 5144 5147 5151 1167 5171 5172 518]5185 SlN6 5187 5190 5198 ChangemNPC (5536)$0 50 50 ($17)(557)(558)(557)(553)(560)($57)(558)(551)($54)(566)(564)(567)(5103)(5112)(5156)($144) ChangeinEmissions (540)50 50 SD 50 50 50 50 50 (55)(56)(57)(510)(511)(52)(52)(54)(59)(51])($19)(522) ChangeanVOM (515)50 50 50 (50)(SI)(51)(Sl}(52)(Sl)(Sl)(51)($1)(52)(57)(56)(57)$1 50 (Sl)(51) ChangeinDSM (528)50 (50)(50)($0)(52)(52)($2)($2)(52)(S3)(54)($4)(54)(55)($6)(56)($6)(56)(56)(57) ChangeinDeficiency (50)50 SO 50 50 50 ($0)(50}50 (50)50 (50)(50)(50)$0 $0 $1 50 51 (SG)(53) ChangeinsysternFixedCos1 (5523)50 50 SD (50)($31)(555)(558)(563)($65)(566)($69)(565)(586)(595)(587)(5113)(588)(587)(558)(557) Net(BenefityCost 532 50 (50)(50)(50)513 $13 St5 520 510 513 51]515 514 (53)$15 (512)(518)($27)(550)($35) Jaw Naural Gas.High CO2 Sceaarte (Benefit)/Cost PF7tRuli 2017 2018 20]9 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects 51.174 50 50 $0 517 $103 5129 5133 5140 5144 $147 $151 5167 5171 $172 5181 5185 5186 5187 $190 $198 ChangemNPC (5446)$0 50 $0 ($17)(557)(558)(558)(554)(561)(560)(558)(544)(539)(551)(562)(583)(523)(543)(585)($102) ChangemEmissions ($195)SU 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 (58)(Sls)(531)(542)(549)(550)(561)(571)($31)(544)(538)(571) ChangeinVOM ($18)$0 50 50 ($0)(Sl)($1)($1)($2)($1)($1)(SI)($2)($2)(54)($3)($4)($2)($3)($12)(56) ChangeinDSAf (57)50 50 50 50 (Sl)(51)($1)(51)(51)($1)(51)(Sl)(51)(51)(51)($1)($1)(Sl)($1)(53) ChangemDeficiency (53)50 50 50 50 50 (50)(50)50 50 50 (50)(50)(50)(50)(52)(51)50 ($5)52 ($2) ChangeinSystemFixedCost (5638)$0 50 50 (50)($3])($55)(SSS)(562)(565)($66)(568)(5100)(5103)($123)($97)(585)($185)(SlÅ 9)(Sl76)(575) Net(BenefityCost ($133)SG 50 SD (50)$14 513 SIS $21 SS SI (59)($22)(523)(556)($45)(561)(555)(567)($120)(560) (Benefit)/Cost PIRRid;2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 203l 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CustofProjects $1174 50 50 50 517 Slu3 5129 5133 5140 5144 5147 5151 5167 5171 5172 5181 5185 5186 5187 5190 Sl98 ChangemNPC (5519)50 SC (50)($17)(560)(563)(566)(569)(575)(570)(572)(566)(582)(556)(572)(598)(573)(577)527 (594) ChangernEmissions 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 SU 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 ChangeluVOM (525)50 50 (50)(50)(51)($2)(52)(52)(52)($2)(52)(Sl)(55)(59)(510)(Sil)(52)(52)(50)(53) ChangeinOSM $17 50 50 50 51 $1 Si $2 52 52 52 S2 52 52 53 53 53 53 53 52 54 ChangeinDeficiency 50 $0 50 (50)($0)$0 50 (50)$0 $0 50 50 ($0)Si SI SD 50 (SI)(SI)(50)SI ChangemSvsternFixalCost (5704)50 50 50 (50)(531)(555)(SSS)(563)(565)(566)(569)(5104)(Sll7)(5171)($120)(178)(5140)(5140)(5264)($170) Net(BenefityCost (557)50 10 50 $0 512 5]O 59 59 54 510 $10 (53)(530)(560)(517)51 (526)(530)(546)(564) (acuefitWCost PYRRidi 2017 20lk 20t9 2020 2021 2022 2013 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects $1.174 50 50 50 517 5103 5129 5133 St40 Sl44 Sl47 SISI St67 5171 $172 518]5185 $166 5157 5190 Sl9N O ChangeinNPC ($629 50 (50)(50)(518)($63)($67)($69)($69)(574)($69)(572)(566)($72)(554)(599)($132)($135)(5143)($135)(566) ChangeinEmissions (551)50 50 50 50 50 SU 50 $0 (56)(57)(58)(59)(58)(59)($12)(516)(Sl3)($15)(Sl7)(514) ChangeinvOM (527)50 50 (50)(50)(51)(52)(52)(52)($2)(52)(52)(11)(52)(SID)(510)(Sil)(53)(54)(54)(53) ChangeinDSM $29 50 50 50 50 50 50 52 52 52 52 53 54 55 56 57 57 57 57 57 58 ChangeinDeficiency si 50 50 (50)Stl 50 50 50 50 50 $0 50 50 10 50 50 (50)(50)(50)Si 50 ChanecimSystemFixedCost (5613)50 50 50 (50)($31)(556)(558)(563)(565)(567)(569)($105)($108)($[75)(5117)(552)(589)(588)(597)($182) Net(BenefityCost (S]II)50 50 50 (51)SS 55 $6 SS (52)54 53 (Sil)(514)(569)(551)(SIS)(547)($56)(553)(559) (BenefityCost PIRRid 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 203]2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects SL]74 50 50 50 517 Sl03 Sl29 $133 sl40 Sl44 5147 515]$167 5171 Sl72 Sis]$185 $186 5187 $190 5198 ChangeinNFC (5495)50 50 50 (517)(562)(566)($66)(566)(571)($68)(571)(556)(566)(§47)(543)(541)($92)($101)($27)(576) ChangeinEmissions (S2f9)SU 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 (59)(SIX)($28)($43)(560)(550)(55l)(560)(553)(558)(585)(578) ChangeinvOh1 (521)50 50 50 (50)($1)(52)(52)(52)(52)($1)($2)(52)(52)(52)($2)(52)(Slo)(510)(53)(53) ChangeinDSN1 (543)So 50 (51)(St)($2)(52)(53)(53)(54)(54)(54)($5)($6)(56)(57)(SS)(59)(Sil)(514)($17) ChangeinDeficiency (55)$0 50 (50)50 $0 50 50 (50)50 50 50 (50)50 50 ($1)($1)(53)(53)(SS)(52) ChangeinSystemFixedCost (5615)50 50 50 (50)($31)(555)(558)(563)(565)(566)($68)(SSS)(583)(5129)(5134)(5137)(5]31)(5129)(Sl(Xl)(597) Net(Benefithfost (5224)50 50 (50)(51)57 54 14 55 (57)(Sil)(522)(526)(544)(562)($58)(563)($]Il)(Sl24)($47)(574) HighNaturs!Gas,EeroCO2P Scensrto (Benefn)Cost PYRRid;2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects 5]174 50 $0 50 517 5103 Sl29 5133 5140 5144 Sl47 5151 Sl67 5171 5172 5181 5]S5 5186 $187 5190 5198 ChangeinNPC (5724)50 $0 SU (522)(578)(188)(583)(582)(589)(584)(587)(580)52 ($112)(593)(Sil5)($172)(5175)(5120)($147) ChangeinEmissions 50 50 $0 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 $0 50 ChangeinvOM (521)50 50 (50)(50)(51)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(50)(52)(52)(52)(58)(58)(57)(57) ChangeinDSM Sl3 50 (50)(50)(50)51 51 51 St $1 51 Si $1 $2 52 52 53 54 56 57 57 ChangeinDeficiency 51 50 50 50 50 50 51 (50)50 51 50 50 50 50 51 St (50)(51)52 (53)(53) ChangeinsystemFixedCost (5703)50 50 50 (50)(531)(555)(565)(570)(573)(574)(576)(592)(5224)(5101)(5130)(Sil3)(5112)($114)($164)($147) Net(BenefityCost (5260)50 (50)(50)(56)(56)(SIS)(Sl6)($14)(SIS)($12)(SIA)(56)(549)(541)($41)(543)(5102)(5113)(597)(598) mal.N.s.r.I a...m..n..co2 v.acy s....rs. |(BenefityCost PYRRid;2017 20lb 2019 2020 2û21 '022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects $1.174 SO SU $0 $17 Si03 Sl29 5133 $!40 5144 $147 SlSI Sl67 $171 $172 5181 5185 5186 5187 5190 $198 CliangeinNPC (5740)50 So 50 ($21)($76)($85)(583)($82)($88)($83)(585)(579)($92}($121)($75)($145)($117)($131)($134)(Sl49) ChangeinEmissions (544)50 SO 50 50 50 50 50 Sfi (56)(57)(58)(57)(58}(SS)(56)(512)(St])(512)($¡4)($16) ChangeiuVOM (SIS)50 50 50 (50)(51)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(53) ChangeinDSM (565)SO (50)(51)(53)(54)(54)(54)($6)(56)(57)(58)(59)(29)(Sil)($12)($14)($14)(514)(514)($14) ChangeinDeficiency $2 So 50 50 50 50 50 (50)$0 $1 SU $1 $1 $l $1 50 $1 ($1)(51)(50)(Sl) ChanceinSvstemFixedCost (5584)50 50 50 (50)(53l)(155)(558)(563)(165)(166)(568)(585)(583)(586)(5142)(554)($135)(Sl25)($122)($124) Net(BenefityCost (5272)50 (50)(51)(57)(59)(Sl7)(514)($13)(S23)($18)(520)(Sl5)(522)(555)(556)(542)(594)($99)($96)($109) (BenefityCost PVRRfd;2017 2018 2019 2020 202]2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 203l 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 CostofProjects $1174 50 $0 50 517 5103 5129 5133 St40 Sl44 Sl47 Sl51 St67 Sl7l $172 5181 5185 5186 $187 $190 5198 ChangeinNPC (5585)50 50 50 ($22)(578)(587)(585)(584)(591)(587)(591)53 (584)(581)(550)(578)(568)(563)($55)(Sl03) ChangeinEmissions (5151)50 $0 50 50 W 50 50 50 (SS)(Sl6)(525)(Sl0)(546)(543)(543)(54N)(535)(533)($35)($54) ChangeinVOM (514)50 50 50 (50)(51)($2)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(Sl)(52)(52)(52)(52)(52)(St)(Sl)(55) ChangeinOSM ($19)50 50 (50)(SD)(50)(50)(50)(52)($2)($2)(53)(54)(54)(54)(54)(54)(54)(54)(54)(54) ChangeinDeficiency ($1)50 50 50 50 50 50 (50)50 SI So 50 50 50 50 ($2)(Sl)(54)(52)(SI)St ChaneeinsystemFixedCost ($813)50 50 50 (50)(53l)(555)(558)(563)(565)(566)(568)(5195)(586)($124)(5186)(5139)($194)($212)($217)(5262) Net(BalefityCost (5409)50 50 ($0)(56)(57)($16)($12)(511)($24)($27}($38)($38)(550)(581)($106)(588)(5119)(5130)(Sl23)($229) O