Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20230417IPC Direct Brady_Exhibits.pdf BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF IDAHO POWER COMPANY FOR AUTHORITY TO IMPLEMENT POWER COST ADJUSTMENT (“PCA”) RATES FOR ELECTRIC SERVICE FROM JUNE 1, 2023, THROUGH MAY 31, 2024. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CASE NO. IPC-E-23-12 IDAHO POWER COMPANY DIRECT TESTIMONY OF JESSICA G. BRADY RECEIVED Monday, April 17, 2023 3:46:07 PM IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION BRADY, DI 1 Idaho Power Company Q. Please state your name, business address, and 1 present position with Idaho Power Company (“Idaho Power” or 2 “Company”). 3 A. My name is Jessica G. Brady. My business 4 address is 1221 West Idaho Street, Boise, Idaho 83702. I 5 am employed by Idaho Power as a Regulatory Analyst in the 6 Regulatory Affairs Department. 7 Q. Please describe your educational background. 8 A. In May of 2016, I received a Bachelor of 9 Science degree in Economics and a Bachelor of Arts degree 10 in Spanish from the University of Idaho. I have also 11 attended “The Basics: Practical Regulatory Training for the 12 Electric Industry,” an electric utility ratemaking course 13 offered through New Mexico State University’s Center for 14 Public Utilities and “Electric Utility Fundamentals & 15 Insights,” an electric utility course offered through the 16 Western Energy Institute. 17 Q. Please describe your work experience. 18 A. In September 2021, I was hired as a Regulatory 19 Analyst in Idaho Power’s Regulatory Affairs Department. As 20 a Regulatory Analyst, I provide support for the Company’s 21 regulatory activities, including compliance reporting, 22 financial analysis, and the development of revenue 23 forecasts for regulatory filings. I am also responsible for 24 the Company’s power cost filings in both Idaho and Oregon. 25 BRADY, DI 2 Idaho Power Company Prior to Idaho Power, I worked for five years at 1 Clearwater Analytics, a provider of investment accounting 2 and reporting software. I held various roles at Clearwater 3 Analytics but was primarily focused on customer success and 4 relationship management. I gained a breadth of knowledge in 5 investments and the use of proprietary software to 6 streamline the operations of a company’s finance and 7 accounting teams. I spent my last year at Clearwater 8 developing a training program focused on providing new 9 hires with the technical skills to be successful in an 10 operations role. 11 Q. What is the Company requesting in this case? 12 A. The Company is requesting approval of its 13 2023-2024 Power Cost Adjustment (“PCA”) rates to become 14 effective June 1, 2023. If approved, the 2023-2024 PCA 15 will result in an increase in total billed revenue of 16 approximately $200.2 million, or 14.68 percent. 17 Q. How is your testimony organized? 18 A. My testimony consists of four sections. In the 19 first section, I provide an overview of the PCA. In the 20 second section, I detail the 2023-2024 PCA amount in 21 comparison to last year’s PCA amount, identify and discuss 22 the main factors contributing to this change, and present 23 the quantification of the 2023-2024 PCA rates to become 24 effective June 1, 2023. In the third section, I discuss 25 BRADY, DI 3 Idaho Power Company the additional PCA component related to revenue sharing. In 1 the final section, I detail the net customer impact of the 2 2023-2024 PCA rates if approved as filed. 3 I. PCA OVERVIEW 4 Q. What is the purpose of the PCA? 5 A. The PCA is a rate mechanism that quantifies 6 and tracks annual differences between actual Net Power 7 Supply Expenses (“NPSE”) and the normalized or “base level” 8 of NPSE recovered in the Company’s base rates, resulting in 9 a credit or surcharge that is updated annually on June 1. 10 The PCA mechanism uses a 12-month test period of April 11 through March (“PCA Year”) and includes a forecast 12 component and a Balancing Adjustment, formerly referred to 13 as the “true-up” and the “true-up of the true-up”. The 14 forecast component represents the difference between the 15 Company’s NPSE forecast from the March Operating Plan and 16 base level NPSE recovered in the Company’s base rates. The 17 Balancing Adjustment includes a backward-looking tracking 18 of differences between the prior PCA Year’s forecast and 19 actual NPSE incurred by the Company, and also tracks the 20 collection of the prior year’s Balancing Adjustment. 21 Q. How does the PCA mechanism function? 22 A. With the exception of Public Utility 23 Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (“PURPA”) expenses and 24 demand response incentive payments, the PCA allows the 25 BRADY, DI 4 Idaho Power Company Company to pass through to customers 95 percent of the 1 annual differences in actual NPSE as compared with base 2 level NPSE, whether positive or negative. With respect to 3 PURPA expenses and demand response incentive payments, as 4 actual annual expenses deviate from base level NPSE, the 5 Company is allowed to pass 100 percent of the difference 6 for recovery or credit through the PCA. The PCA is also 7 the rate mechanism used by the Company to provide customer 8 benefits resulting from the revenue sharing mechanism 9 approved by the Commission in Order No. 34071. 10 Q. Does the revenue collected from customers 11 through the annual PCA rate contribute toward the Company’s 12 earnings? 13 A. No. The PCA mechanism provides for the annual 14 collection or refund of net power supply cost differences 15 between actual costs incurred by the Company and the base 16 level NPSE component of base rates. Aside from the 95 17 percent to 5 percent sharing component I just described, 18 the PCA provides for a one-for-one collection or refund of 19 actual net power supply expenses incurred, or to be 20 incurred, to provide safe, reliable electric service to 21 customers. 22 Q. What are the components of the PCA base level 23 NPSE? 24 BRADY, DI 5 Idaho Power Company A. The PCA base level NPSE includes the following1 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (“FERC”) accounts: 2 Account 501, Fuel (coal); Account 536, Water for Power; 3 Account 547, Fuel (gas); Account 555, Purchased Power; 4 Account 565, Transmission of Electricity by Others; and 5 Account 447, Sales for Resale (typically referred to as 6 surplus sales). 7 The PCA base level expense component for FERC 8 Account 555 includes costs of both PURPA and non-PURPA 9 (market) purchases. Per Order No. 32426, the Company 10 adjusts FERC Account 555 to also include demand response 11 incentive payments that the Company provides to customers 12 who participate in any of its three demand response 13 programs. 14 II. 2023-2024 PCA15 Q. What is the total PCA collection that would16 result under the 2023-2024 PCA rates proposed by the 17 Company in this case? 18 A. The 2023-2024 PCA rates would result in total19 PCA collection of $408.2 million. This represents an 20 increase in total billed revenue of $200.2 million for the 21 upcoming year, an increase of 14.68 percent. 22 Q. Have you prepared a table that details the23 $200.2 million revenue impact by component? 24 BRADY, DI 6 Idaho Power Company A. Yes. Table 1 presents a separation of the 1 $200.2 million increase into each component included in the 2 Company’s proposed rates. 3 Table 1 Revenue Impact by Component  Line  No. Rate Component 2022‐2023 PCA 2023‐2024 PCA Difference  1 PCA Forecast   $           169,966,873  $        218,005,217   $      48,038,344   2 PCA Balancing Adjustment   $             38,583,273    $        189,924,254   $    151,625,231   3 PCA Total   $           208,550,146  $        408,213,721   $    199,663,575   4 Revenue Sharing   $                (568,435)   $                  0     $            568,435   5 Total Revenue Impact   $           207,981,710  $       408,213,721   $    200,232,011   4 Q. What are the main factors driving the revenue5 change requested in this case? 6 A. The increase in this year’s PCA is driven by7 an increase in both the forecast component and the 8 Balancing Adjustment. The increase in this year’s forecast 9 component is attributed primarily to higher forecast market 10 energy and natural gas prices, combined with a limited coal 11 supply. 12 As can be seen on Table 1, the Balancing Adjustment 13 accounts for over 75 percent of the overall PCA revenue 14 change, indicating that last year’s actual power costs were 15 greater than forecast. Similar to the forecast component, 16 the increase in the Balancing Adjustment is largely 17 attributed to high natural gas and market energy prices 18 during the 2022-2023 PCA Year, combined with a limited coal 19 BRADY, DI 7 Idaho Power Company supply. In addition, hydro generation was 9 percent lower 1 than forecast. 2 The price increases in both the natural gas and 3 energy markets, as well as the limited coal supply, will be 4 discussed in more detail later in this testimony. 5 A. PCA Forecast. 6 Q. How is the PCA forecast amount determined? 7 A. As described previously, the PCA forecast 8 component represents the difference between the Company’s 9 forecast of NPSE for the upcoming April – March test year 10 and base level NPSE recovered in the Company’s base rates. 11 Q. What is the Company’s determination of the 12 system-level difference between currently approved base 13 level NPSE1 and the forecast of NPSE for the 2023-2024 PCA 14 Year? 15 A. The system-level forecast of NPSE for the 16 2023-2024 PCA Year is $541,499,384, which is $235,814,515 17 higher than the currently approved base level NPSE of 18 $305,684,869. Table 2 presents the system-level 19 differences between currently approved base level NPSE and 20 the forecast of NPSE for the 2023-2024 PCA Year by FERC 21 account. 22 23 1 In the Matter of the Application of Idaho Power Company for Authority to Establish a New Base Level of Net Power Supply Expense, Case No. IPC-E-13-20, Order No. 33000 (March 21, 2014). BRADY, DI 8 Idaho Power Company Table 2 2023 ‐ 2024 PCA FORECAST (Total System)            Line No. FERC Account Base NPSE Forecast Difference    95% Sharing Accounts      1 Account 501, Coal   $           108,503,180    $     130,090,026   $        21,586,845   2 Account 536, Water for Power   $               2,380,597    $                         0    $       (2,380,597)  3 Account 547, Other Fuel   $             33,367,563    $     134,492,688    $     101,256,077   4 Account 555, Purchased Power Non‐PURPA   $             62,606,593    $     123,485,717   $       60,886,095   5 Account 565, 3rd Party Transmission    $               5,455,955    $         7,964,649    $         2,508,694   6 Account 447, Surplus Sales    $         (51,735,153)   $    (84,191,539)   $    (32,456,386)         $          160,578,735    $    311,979,464    $    151,400,729               100% Sharing Accounts      7 Account 555, PURPA   $          133,853,869    $     218,535,412    $      84,681,543   8 Account 555, Demand Response Incentives   $            11,252,265    $     10,984,508    $         (267,757)  9 Total   $          305,684,869    $   541,499,384      $    235,814,515   1 Q. What is the basis for the forecast of NPSE for 2 the 2023-2024 PCA Year? 3 A. The forecast of NPSE for the 2023-2024 PCA 4 Year is based on the Company’s March 2023 Operating Plan. 5 Q. How is the NPSE forecast developed for the 6 Company’s Operating Plan? 7 A. The Operating Plan is prepared monthly and 8 represents a forecast of the Company’s monthly NPSE for the 9 following 18-month period; however, for the PCA, the 10 Company includes only the 12 months that correspond to the 11 PCA Year. The Operating Plan is developed by simulating 12 the dispatch of the Company’s generation resources for each 13 month, segmented by heavy load and light load hours. The 14 dispatch considers a current forecast of forward market 15 BRADY, DI 9 Idaho Power Company energy prices, available hydro generation, coal and natural 1 gas prices, and any existing hedge transactions. The 2 system load forecast is then analyzed against the resulting 3 monthly heavy load and light load dispatch to determine a 4 monthly load and resource balance. Any identified resource 5 deficiency is assumed to be filled with market energy 6 purchases or natural gas to fuel the Langley Gulch power 7 plant (“Langley Gulch”), based on economics and available 8 generating capacity at Langley Gulch. Economically 9 dispatched generation above the system load forecast 10 represents surplus energy sales. The forecast of monthly 11 NPSE and generation for the 2023-2024 PCA Year, as 12 determined in the Company’s March 2023 Operating Plan, is 13 provided in Exhibit No. 1. 14 Q. Did the Company make any adjustments to the 15 March 2023 Operating Plan, for purposes of quantifying 16 forecast NPSE for the 2023-2024 PCA Year? 17 A. Yes. Forecast NPSE in the March 2023 Operating 18 Plan includes the addition of a new power purchase 19 agreement (“PPA”), Black Mesa Solar. For purposes of 20 quantifying forecast NPSE for the 2023-2024 PCA Year for 21 this filing, the Company removed the forecasted expenses 22 associated with Black Mesa Solar, because Micron 23 Technology, Inc. (“Micron”) will be paying for 100 percent 24 of Black Mesa Solar’s generation according to the 25 BRADY, DI 10 Idaho Power Company provisions of a new Energy Sales Agreement (“ESA”)2 between 1 Idaho Power and Micron. 2 Q. Please provide more information on the Black 3 Mesa Solar PPA and its treatment in the PCA forecast. 4 A. Black Mesa Solar is a 40 MW alternating 5 current solar photovoltaic generation facility, expected to 6 come online in June 2023. The PPA was negotiated in 7 conjunction with the Micron ESA, which states that Idaho 8 Power will procure renewable resources to assist Micron in 9 meeting a portion of its annual energy requirements with 10 energy generated by those resources. While the renewable 11 resource, Black Mesa Solar in this case, will not serve 12 Micron directly, and rather will be connected to the 13 Company’s system, Micron will pay for all of the output 14 through its ESA. 15 Because Micron will be paying for 100 percent of 16 Black Mesa Solar’s generation, the cost of the PPA was 17 removed from the Company’s calculation of forecast NPSE. 18 As recommended by Commission Staff in Order No. 35482, the 19 Company has provided Black Mesa Solar’s forecast generation 20 and expenses, as well as Micron’s monthly load forecast, as 21 Confidential Exhibit No. 4. 22 2 In the Matter of the Replacement Special contract with Micron Technology, Inc. and Purchase Agreement with Black Mesa Energy LLC, Case No. IPC-E-22-06, Order No. 35482 (August 01, 2022). BRADY, DI 11 Idaho Power Company Q. How will the excess generation and renewable 1 capacity credit payments, as detailed in Micron’s ESA, be 2 incorporated into this year’s PCA filing? 3 A. In the event that Black Mesa Solar’s 4 generation exceeds Micron’s load in a given hour, the 5 Company will compensate Micron for the excess generation 6 according to the methodology approved by the Commission in 7 Order No. 35482. However, for the 2023-2024 PCA year, the 8 Company does not expect Black Mesa Solar’s generation to 9 exceed Micron’s load in any hour. As a result, no excess 10 generation payments are included in this year’s PCA 11 forecast. 12 In addition, as stated in Order No. 35482, the 13 Company will not begin renewable capacity credit payments 14 until July 1, 2026. As a result, no renewable capacity 15 credit payments are included in this year’s PCA forecast. 16 Q. How does the Company’s forecast of system-17 level NPSE for the 2023-2024 PCA compare to the system-18 level forecast included in last year’s PCA? 19 A. Table 3 below compares this year’s 2023-2024 20 PCA forecast of NPSE to last year’s PCA forecast by FERC 21 account. As detailed in this table, the PCA forecast on a 22 total system basis for the 2023-2024 PCA year is 23 $541,499,384, which is $52,004,084 higher than last year’s 24 forecast amount of $489,495,300. 25 BRADY, DI 12 Idaho Power Company Table 3 PCA Forecast Comparison Expenses  (Total System)            Line No. FERC Account  2022‐2023      Forecast  2023‐2024  Forecast Difference    95% Sharing Accounts      1 Account 501, Coal   $      151,179,160    $        130,090,026    $     (21,089,135)  2 Account 536, Water for Power   $                          0    $                            0    $                         0    3 Account 547, Other Fuel   $        79,067,982    $        134,623,640    $       55,555,657   4 Account 555, Purchased Power Non‐PURPA   $        98,482,808    $        123,492,688    $       25,009,880   5 Account 565, 3rd Party Transmission    $          5,149,239    $            7,964,649    $         2,815,409   6 Account 447, Surplus Sales   $     (65,085,848)   $       (84,191,539)   $    (19,105,691)       $     268,793,342    $       311,979,464    $       43,186,122               100% Sharing Accounts      7 Account 555, PURPA   $     212,586,058    $        218,535,412    $         5,949,354   8 Account 555, Demand Response Incentives   $          8,115,900    $          10,984,508    $         2,868,608          $     220,701,958      $        229,519,920    $        8,817,962             9 Total PCA Forecast     $    489,495,300     $        541,499,384    $      52,004,084   1 Q. What general conclusions can be drawn from the 2 information contained in Table 3? 3 A. When viewed by category, the 95 percent 4 sharing accounts have increased approximately $43.2 million 5 from last year’s forecast, while the 100 percent sharing 6 accounts have increased approximately $8.8 million over 7 last year’s forecast. 8 Q. What factors are contributing to the major 9 differences presented in Table 3? 10 A. Forecast expenses included in the 95 percent 11 sharing accounts are expected to increase by 16 percent as 12 compared to last year, from $268,793,342 to $311,979,464. 13 Due to the limited coal supply, the Company expects to rely 14 BRADY, DI 13 Idaho Power Company more on natural gas generation and purchased power to serve 1 load in the 2023-2024 PCA Year. 2 Q. Please explain the circumstances that led to 3 the Company’s limited coal supply. 4 A. Global natural gas supply and demand 5 disruptions over the last several months, stemming from the 6 Russian invasion of Ukraine and sabotage of the Nord Stream 7 pipelines, have caused price escalation and volatility in 8 the natural gas and energy markets. 9 As the same time, the U.S. has been ramping down its 10 coal production, limiting the supply of coal available to 11 the electric utility sector. Similarly, production 12 capabilities at Bridger Coal Company (“BCC”) have decreased 13 as a result of the closing of the underground mining 14 operations at the end of 2021. 15 As a result of the price escalation and volatility 16 in the natural gas and energy markets throughout 2022, 17 Idaho Power increased its reliance on coal-fired generation 18 to serve load. Actual coal-fired generation for the first 9 19 months of 2022 was 50 percent higher than the same period 20 in 2021, and 30 percent higher than the 5-year average for 21 the period. 22 The increase in coal-fired generation in 2022, 23 combined with the closure of the underground mine at BCC, 24 has resulted in a limited supply of coal available for use 25 BRADY, DI 14 Idaho Power Company in 2023. Coal availability is expected to improve in 2024, 1 however, when Bridger Units 1 and 2 are converted to 2 natural gas fired units, thus reducing Idaho Power’s coal-3 fired fleet from 5 units to 3 units. 4 Q. How is Idaho Power working to limit the 5 customer impact of the current coal constraints at the 6 Bridger plant? 7 A. Idaho Power plans to use 100 percent of the 8 available production capacity from BCC through 2023. Idaho 9 Power is actively working with its operating partner at 10 BCC, PacifiCorp, to identify opportunities to maximize coal 11 production with existing infrastructure, resources, and 12 equipment. 13 In addition to utilizing 100 percent of available 14 production capacity at BCC, the Company has secured all 15 available coal from its primary third-party supplier, Black 16 Butte Coal Company, through 2023. 17 Idaho Power has also recently secured rail 18 transportation that will allow for approximately 200,000 19 tons of spot coal to be delivered from the Powder River 20 Basin (“PRB”) to the Bridger plant beginning in May 2023 21 through December 2023. While PRB coal has not been utilized 22 at Bridger as a base fuel supply source to date due to its 23 high propensity to spontaneously combust, the plant is 24 capable of consuming PRB coal on a limited scale. Idaho 25 BRADY, DI 15 Idaho Power Company Power intends to rely on as much PRB coal as can be 1 delivered and burned safely at the plant in 2023. 2 Q. Has the Company and its partner considered 3 increasing the capacity to produce coal at BCC? 4 A. Yes. However, no feasible, cost-effective 5 methods of increasing coal production capacity in the short 6 term have been identified. Increasing coal production at 7 BCC to levels that would completely fill the shortfall in 8 supply would require new permits and additional investment 9 in capital infrastructure. Because the current coal supply 10 constraints are not expected to persist after the 11 conversion of Bridger Units 1 and 2 to natural gas, 12 additional investment to fill the near-term temporary 13 shortfall in coal supply would not provide a benefit to 14 customers in the long-term. 15 Q. What is Idaho Power doing to address coal 16 constraints at the Valmy plant? 17 A. At Valmy, Idaho Power is actively working to 18 secure additional coal supply for 2023, 2024, and 2025. 19 Solicitations made in a June 2022 Request for Proposal 20 (“RFP”) seeking 2023 coal volumes from spot coal suppliers 21 indicated minimal Western coal available and higher coal 22 prices. 23 As a result of the knowledge gained from the June 24 2022 RFP, Idaho Power, and its co-owner of Valmy, NV 25 BRADY, DI 16 Idaho Power Company Energy, commissioned an independent engineering firm to 1 evaluate the performance capabilities of the current dry 2 sorbent injection system and feasibility of installing 3 activated carbon injection systems that would enhance 4 controls to allow Valmy to burn higher mercury and sulfur 5 coals. Based on information provided by the engineering 6 firm, Valmy plant specifications for mercury and sulfur 7 were refined. 8 In November 2022, NV Energy and Idaho Power issued a 9 new RFP seeking coal for 2023. Idaho Power has scheduled a 10 test burn for a new fuel source from this RFP, and a 11 contract is being negotiated with the supplier pending 12 finalization of rail transportation. Idaho Power expects 13 that this volume of additional coal, combined with existing 14 stockpile inventory, will provide fuel to operate Valmy 15 during the summer months of 2023, as well as the winter 16 months of 2023–24. 17 Q. Please elaborate on the changes in the 95 18 percent sharing accounts for this year’s forecast as 19 compared with last year’s forecast as presented in Table 3. 20 A. For the 2023-2024 PCA year, the average 21 forecast market purchase price is $76.01 per megawatt-hour 22 (“MWh”), compared to $49.11 per MWh last year, an increase 23 of 55 percent. In addition, the per-unit cost of natural 24 gas for the 2023-2024 PCA year is $41.27 per MWh, an 25 BRADY, DI 17 Idaho Power Company increase of 33 percent compared to last year. As a result 1 of the limited coal supply, the per-unit cost of coal 2 generation has also increased from last year. The average 3 per-unit cost of coal-fired generation for the 2023-2024 4 PCA year is $36.95 per MWh, an increase of 24 percent 5 compared to last year. Accordingly, expenses from non-PURPA 6 purchased power are expected to increase 25 percent as 7 compared to last year’s forecast, natural gas expense is 8 expected to increase 70 percent, and coal fuel expense is 9 expected to decrease 14 percent. 10 The increase in forecast market energy prices is 11 also resulting in higher surplus sales revenue. Surplus 12 sales revenue is expected to increase 29 percent compared 13 to last year, from $65,085,848 to $84,191,539. For the 14 2023-2024 PCA Year, the average forecast market sales price 15 is $82.96 per MWh compared with $51.73 last year, a 60 16 percent increase. 17 Q. What factors are contributing to the change in 18 the 100 percent sharing accounts? 19 A. As can be seen in Table 3, forecast expenses 20 included in the 100 percent sharing accounts are expected 21 to increase by 4 percent as compared to last year, from 22 $220,701,958 to $229,519,920. Forecast PURPA costs 23 increased by $5.95 million as compared to last year’s 24 BRADY, DI 18 Idaho Power Company forecast and forecast demand response incentive payments 1 increased by $2.9 million as compared to last year. 2 Q. Is the increase in forecast PURPA costs 3 related to increased generation output from PURPA projects? 4 A. In part. Table 4 details changes between last 5 year’s PCA forecast and this year’s PCA forecast with 6 respect to forecasted generation in MWh. As shown in Table 7 4, PURPA generation is anticipated to increase by 19,189 8 MWh, or less than 1 percent. The 3 percent increase in 9 PURPA expense is largely the result of price escalation in 10 PURPA contracts, for which the average cost is $71.47 per 11 MWh, compared to $69.96 last year. 12 Table 4 PCA Forecast Comparison Generation (Total System‐MWh)           Line No. FERC Account 2022‐2023 Forecast  2023‐2024  Forecast Difference  1 Hydro                5,972,743                 6,487,995                   515,252      95% Sharing Accounts      2 Account 501, Coal                5,083,043                 3,520,905                 (1,562,138)   3 Account 547, Other Fuel                2,556,322                 3,261,784                     705,462   4 Account 555, Purchased Power Non‐PURPA                1,580,326                 1,695,683                     115,357     95% Sharing Accounts              15,192,435               14,966,367                  (226,068)                100% Sharing Accounts      5 Account 555, PURPA                3,038,613                 3,057,802                     19,189     100% Accounts                3,038,613                 3,057,802                      19,189              6 Total Generation              18,231,048               18,024,169                  (206,879)                95% Sharing Accounts      7 Account 447, Surplus Sales                1,258,195                 1,014,817                     (243,978)   8 Total Load              16,972,853               17,009,352  36,499   13 BRADY, DI 19 Idaho Power Company Q. What other general conclusions can be drawn 1 from the information in Table 4? 2 A. Compared to last year’s forecast, hydro 3 generation is expected to increase from 5,972,743 MWh to 4 6,487,995 MWh, or 9 percent. Due to the limited coal 5 supply, coal-fired generation is expected to decrease from 6 5,083,043 MWh to 3,520,905 MWh, or 31 percent. To offset 7 the reduction in coal-fired generation, natural gas 8 generation is expected to increase 28 percent compared to 9 last year. In addition, non-PURPA purchased power is 10 expected to increase 7 percent from last year. This 7 11 percent increase is due to an increase in PPA generation, 12 more specifically, the increased forecast generation from 13 Jackpot Solar, which came online in December 2022. 14 Q. What is causing the 9 percent increase in 15 expected hydro generation? 16 A. The increase in expected hydro generation is 17 mainly due to higher projected inflows into Brownlee 18 reservoir. The March Operating Plan used in this year’s 19 PCA forecast projects April through July inflows into 20 Brownlee of 4.3 million acre-feet (“MAF”) as compared to 21 2.9 MAF used to determine last year’s PCA forecast, an 22 increase of 69 percent. Expected inflows into Brownlee are 23 higher than last year’s PCA forecast as a result of better 24 snowpack conditions, which provide for sustained runoff and 25 BRADY, DI 20 Idaho Power Company increased hydro generation during the spring and summer 1 months. Snowpack conditions used to determine this year’s 2 PCA hydro forecast are 117 percent of normal, compared to 3 76 percent of normal last year. 4 Q. How are the forecasted NPSE differences 5 presented in Table 2 used to determine the 2023-2024 PCA 6 forecast component to be collected from Idaho customers? 7 A. The 2023-2024 PCA forecast component reflects 8 the Idaho jurisdictional share of the forecasted NPSE 9 differences presented in Table 2, adjusted for the PCA 10 sharing provisions. The Idaho jurisdictional share of the 11 forecast NPSE differences is determined by applying a ratio 12 of forecast firm Idaho jurisdictional sales to forecast 13 firm system-level sales to the system-level NPSE 14 differences. 15 Q. Were any changes made to the Idaho 16 jurisdictional sales and system-level sales to account for 17 the portion of Micron’s load met by Black Mesa Solar? 18 A. Yes. The portion of Micron’s load forecast to 19 be met by Black Mesa Solar was removed from the total 20 forecast Idaho jurisdictional sales and system-level sales 21 and was not used in the derivation of the PCA rate. 22 Q. What is the Company’s forecast of system-level 23 firm sales and Idaho jurisdictional firm sales, net of the 24 BRADY, DI 21 Idaho Power Company portion of Micron’s load met by Black Mesa Solar, for the 1 2023-2024 PCA Year? 2 A. For the 2023-2024 PCA Year, Idaho Power has 3 forecast system-level firm sales to be 15,684,447 MWh and 4 Idaho jurisdictional firm sales to be 14,982,736 MWh, or 5 95.52 percent of the system level. 6 Q. What is the Company’s determination of the 7 2023-2024 PCA forecast component to be collected from Idaho 8 customers? 9 A. The 2023-2024 PCA forecast component to be 10 collected from Idaho customers is $218,006,526. Table 5 11 presents the determination of the 2023-2024 PCA forecast 12 component by individual PCA expense and revenue category. 13 14 Table 5 2023‐2024 PCA FORECAST            Line No. FERC Account Difference from Base  Difference After  Sharing Idaho Allocation    95% Sharing Accounts (From Table 1)     1 Account 501, Coal   $     21,586,845    $      20,507,503   $       19,588,713   2 Account 536, Water for Power   $     (2,380,597)   $      (2,261,567)  $       (2,160,243)  3 Account 547, Other Fuel   $   101,256,077    $      96,193,273   $       91,883,560   4 Account 555, Purchased Power Non‐PURPA   $     60,886,095    $      57,841,790   $       55,250,325   5 Account 565, 3rd Party Transmission    $       2,508,694    $        2,383,259   $         2,276,483   6 Account 447, Surplus Sales      $  (32,456,386)   $   (30,833,566)  $    (29,452,141)         $   151,400,729    $    143,830,692   $     137,386,697               100% Sharing Accounts      7 Account 555, PURPA   $     84,681,543    $     84,681,543   $       80,887,586   8 Account 555, Demand Response Incentives   $        (267,757)   $        (267,757)  $          (267,757)  9 Total   $   235,814,515    $   228,244,478   $     218,006,526   15 BRADY, DI 22 Idaho Power Company B. Balancing Adjustment. 1 Q. What is this year’s quantification of the 2 Balancing Adjustment? 3 A. The Balancing Adjustment is detailed in the 4 PCA deferral report, attached hereto as Exhibit No. 2. This 5 report compares actual NPSE amounts to actual power cost 6 collections monthly, with the differences accumulated as a 7 deferral balance. The balance at the end of March 2023, 8 with interest applied, was $190,205,569 as shown on row 100 9 of Exhibit No. 2. The approximate $190 million represents 10 an increase to customer rates in this year’s PCA Balancing 11 Adjustment. 12 Q. To what factors do you attribute the 13 accumulation of the approximate $190 million deferral 14 balance? 15 A. The approximate $190 million deferral balance 16 was primarily driven by a decrease in actual hydro 17 generation from expected as well as higher than forecast 18 market purchases and natural gas generation, due to a 19 limited coal supply. 20 Actual hydro generation for the 2022-2023 PCA year 21 totaled 5,458,343 MWh, a 9 percent decrease from last 22 year’s forecast of 5,972,743 MWh. Actual purchased power 23 totaled 4,297,723 MWh, a 172 percent increase from last 24 year’s forecast. Actual natural gas generation totaled 25 BRADY, DI 23 Idaho Power Company 2,716,835 MWh, a 6 percent increase from last year’s 1 forecast. Lastly, actual surplus sales volumes totaled 2 1,455,119 MWh, an increase of 16 percent from last year. 3 Actual natural gas and market energy prices were 4 also higher than forecast, driving a 126 percent increase 5 in natural gas fuel expense and a 318 percent increase in 6 purchased power expense. 7 In addition, due to the limited coal supply, the 8 Company began optimizing its coal-fired generation dispatch 9 in October 2022. At a high level, this dispatch 10 optimization process involved reducing coal unit dispatch 11 during lower market price conditions to ensure the plants 12 were available to operate during high load and/or high 13 market price conditions. As a result, actual coal-fired 14 generation totaled 3,265,218 MWh, a decrease of 36 percent 15 compared to last year’s forecast. 16 Q. Please elaborate on the changes in actual 17 versus forecast generation and expense for the 2022-2023 18 PCA Year. 19 A. Last year’s PCA forecast included an average 20 market sales price of $51.73 per MWh. The actual average 21 market sales price for the 2022-2023 PCA year was $116.98 22 per MWh, a 126 percent increase. As a result of the 23 difference in forecast and actual market sales prices, as 24 well as economic opportunity during the spring and winter 25 BRADY, DI 24 Idaho Power Company months of the 2022-2023 PCA year, actual surplus sales 1 volumes were 16 percent higher than forecast. Surplus sales 2 revenue totaled $170,224,982, which was 162 percent higher 3 than forecast revenues of $65,085,848. 4 As mentioned above, actual coal-fired generation for 5 the 2022-2023 PCA year was 36 percent lower than forecast. 6 Actual coal fuel expense totaled $94,955,998, which was 37 7 percent lower than forecast. Coal-fired generation was 8 lower than forecast due to the limited coal supply, as 9 discussed earlier in testimony. 10 Natural gas generation totaled 2,716,835 MWh for the 11 2022-2023 PCA Year, which was 6 percent higher than 12 forecast. Due to the increased natural gas prices, actual 13 natural gas expense totaled $178,317,313, which was 126 14 percent higher than forecast. While natural gas prices were 15 higher than forecast, the Company’s reliance on natural gas 16 generation increased 6 percent as it was needed to meet 17 load, as well as make off-system sales when it was 18 economic, as noted previously. 19 While both purchased power and surplus sales 20 increased, surplus sale volumes were highest in off-peak 21 spring and winter months, and purchased power was highest 22 in summer months, where hot temperatures caused 23 continuously higher than forecast peak loads. 24 BRADY, DI 25 Idaho Power Company Q. Were there any items included in this year’s 1 Balancing Adjustment in addition to actual NPSE incurred 2 during the April 2022 through March 2023 period? 3 A. Yes. Per Commission Order No. 34100, Idaho 4 Power included its actual costs of Western Energy Imbalance 5 Market (“EIM”) participation for April 2022 through March 6 2023 in the Balancing Adjustment. Benefits associated with 7 EIM participation are embedded in actual NPSE experienced 8 over that same period. 9 Q. Please summarize the conditions of Order No. 10 34100 as they pertain to EIM cost recovery through the 2022 11 PCA. 12 A. Per the terms of the settlement stipulation 13 (“EIM Stipulation”) approved by Order No. 34100, Idaho 14 Power agreed to include an EIM-related monthly revenue 15 requirement in its monthly PCA deferral calculation based 16 on actual EIM participation costs commencing April 1, 2018. 17 The Company also agreed to apply a soft cap to EIM-related 18 revenue requirement included in the PCA deferral equal to 19 annual EIM benefits as reported by the California 20 Independent System Operator (“CAISO”) for the corresponding 21 period. 22 Q. Is the EIM-related revenue requirement 23 included in the April 2022 through March 2023 PCA deferral 24 BRADY, DI 26 Idaho Power Company under the soft cap of annual CAISO-reported benefits for 1 that same period? 2 A. Yes. For the April 2022 through March 2023 3 period, the EIM-related revenue requirement totaled $2.5 4 million, while CAISO reported EIM benefits for Idaho Power 5 of approximately $37.7 million from April through December 6 (CAISO’s first quarter 2023 report has not yet been 7 published). Therefore, the Company’s EIM-related revenue 8 requirement is less than the soft cap agreed to in the EIM 9 Stipulation. 10 Q. Does Idaho Power believe the EIM has provided 11 net benefits to customers since joining in April 2018? 12 A. Yes. While Idaho Power believes the CAISO 13 benefit calculation overstates estimated benefits to Idaho 14 Power’s system, the Company believes customers have 15 realized significant net benefits since the Company’s entry 16 into the EIM in April 2018. As discussed in the Company’s 17 May 24, 2019, Report of EIM Benefits and Costs of 18 Participation, filed in Case No. IPC-E-16-19, Idaho Power 19 has developed a more precise methodology for determining 20 EIM benefits that uses inputs specific to the Company. 21 Based on this methodology, the Company believes benefits 22 achieved between April 2022 and December 2022 are 23 approximately $9 million (benefits for the first quarter of 24 2023 are not yet available). This level of EIM benefits 25 BRADY, DI 27 Idaho Power Company compared to the Idaho-jurisdictional EIM costs of $2.5 1 million, demonstrates a net benefit to the Company and, 2 ultimately, its customers. 3 C. PCA Rate Determination. 4 Q. How is the rate for the forecast portion of 5 the PCA for April 2023 through March 2024 determined? 6 A. The rate for the forecast portion of the PCA 7 is equal to the sum of (1) 95 percent of the difference 8 between the non-PURPA expenses quantified in the Operating 9 Plan and those quantified in the Company’s last approved 10 update of NPSE, divided by the Company’s forecast of system 11 firm sales for June 1, 2023, through May 31, 20243 (“System-12 level Sales Forecast”); and (2) 100 percent of the 13 difference between PURPA-related expenses quantified in the 14 Operating Plan and those quantified in the Company’s last 15 approved update of NPSE, divided by the Company’s System-16 level Sales Forecast; and (3) 100 percent of the difference 17 between the Idaho jurisdictional demand response incentive 18 payments quantified in the Operating Plan and those 19 quantified in the Company’s last approved update of NPSE, 20 divided by the forecast of Idaho jurisdictional firm sales4 21 for June 1, 2023, through May 31, 2024. 22 3 System-level and Idaho jurisdictional firm sales used in the calculation are net of Black Mesa Solar’s forecasted generation for the June 2023 – May 2024 time period. 4 Id. BRADY, DI 28 Idaho Power Company Q. What is the rate for the forecast portion of 1 the PCA for April 2023 through March 2024? 2 A. The rate for non-PURPA expenses is 0.9183 3 cents per kilowatt-hour (“kWh”), which is calculated by 4 multiplying $151,400,729 from Table 2 by 95 percent and 5 then dividing it by the System-level Sales Forecast, net of 6 Black Mesa Solar generation, of 15,662,267 MWh 7 (($151,400,729 * 0.95) / 15,662,267) = $9.183 /MWh = 0.9183 8 cents/kWh). The rate for PURPA expenses is 0.5407 cents 9 per kWh, which is calculated by dividing $84,681,543 from 10 Table 2 by the 15,662,267 MWh ($84,681,543 / 15,662,267 MWh 11 = $5.407/MWh = 0.5407 cents/kWh). The rate for demand 12 response incentive payments is negative 0.0018 cents per 13 kWh, which is calculated by dividing the negative $267,757 14 from Table 2 by the forecast of Idaho jurisdictional firm 15 sales, net of Black Mesa Solar generation, of 14,960,556 16 MWh (-$267,757 / 14,960,556 MWh = -$0.0180/MWh = -0.0018 17 cents/kWh). The forecast portion of the PCA rate is 1.4572 18 cents per kWh, which is calculated by adding the non-PURPA 19 expense of 0.9183 cents per kWh to the PURPA expense of 20 0.5407 cents per kWh to the demand response incentive 21 payment of negative 0.0018 cents per kWh (0.9183 + 0. 5407 22 + -0.0018 = 1.4572 cents/kWh). 23 Q. How did you compute this year’s Balancing 24 Account rate? 25 BRADY, DI 29 Idaho Power Company A. As shown in Exhibit No. 2, this year’s 1 Balancing Adjustment of the PCA is approximately $190 2 million, which, when divided by the Company’s forecast of 3 Idaho jurisdictional sales, net of Black Mesa generation, 4 of 14,960,556 MWh, results in a rate of 1.2714 cents per 5 kWh ($190,205,569 / 14,960,556 = $12.714/MWh = 1.2714 6 cents/kWh). 7 Q. What is the resulting PCA rate when you 8 combine all the PCA components described previously? 9 A. The uniform PCA rate comprises (1) the 1.4572 10 cents per kWh for the 2023-2024 projected power cost of 11 serving firm loads under the current PCA methodology and 95 12 percent sharing, and (2) the 1.2714 cents per kWh for the 13 2022-2023 Balancing Adjustment of the PCA. The sum of these 14 two components is a 2.7286 cents per kWh charge for all 15 rate classes. 16 III. ADDITIONAL PCA RATE ADJUSTMENTS 17 A. Revenue Sharing. 18 Q. When was the revenue sharing mechanism 19 originally established? 20 A. The revenue sharing mechanism was originally 21 established in Case No. IPC-E-09-30 and approved in Order 22 No. 30978, effective for the years 2009-2011. Since then, 23 the revenue sharing mechanism has been modified and 24 BRADY, DI 30 Idaho Power Company extended three times.5 Most recently, the revenue sharing 1 mechanism was extended indefinitely, with modifications, in 2 Order No. 34071 in Case No. GNR-U-18-01. 3 Q. What are the provisions of the current revenue 4 sharing mechanism? 5 A. In Case No. GNR-U-18-01, the Company filed a 6 motion to approve a settlement stipulation (“2018 7 Stipulation”) extending the sharing mechanism indefinitely, 8 with modifications. The Commission approved the 2018 9 Stipulation in Order No. 34071. 10 Per the terms of the 2018 Stipulation, if the 11 Company’s actual year-end Return on Equity (“ROE”) for the 12 Idaho jurisdiction exceeds 10 percent, all amounts up to 13 and including a 10.5 percent ROE will be shared between 14 customers and the Company on an 80 percent and 20 percent 15 basis, respectively, to be provided as a rate reduction to 16 become effective at the time of the subsequent year’s PCA. 17 If the Company’s Idaho jurisdictional ROE exceeds 10.5 18 percent, all amounts in excess of 10.5 percent will be 19 shared 55 percent with Idaho customers as a rate reduction 20 to become effective with the subsequent year’s PCA, 25 21 percent will be shared with Idaho customers in the form of 22 an offset to amounts in the Company’s pension balancing 23 account, and 20 percent will be apportioned to the Company. 24 5 Order Nos. 32424, 33149 and 34071. BRADY, DI 31 Idaho Power Company With regard to the amortization of Accumulated 1 Deferred Investment Tax Credits (“ADITC”), the 2018 2 Stipulation allows the Company to accelerate the 3 amortization of ADITC, in an amount up to $45 million, to 4 achieve a maximum 9.4 percent Idaho jurisdictional ROE if 5 the Company’s year-end actual results fall below that 6 amount for any year beginning January 1, 2020. Idaho Power 7 may use up to $25 million of additional amortization of 8 ADITC per year, provided the total, cumulative amount of 9 ADITC does not exceed $45 million. Per the 2018 10 Stipulation, once the Company has fully amortized the $45 11 million of ADITC, revenue sharing will cease; however, 12 Idaho Power may at any time request to replenish the total 13 amount of ADITC it is permitted to amortize, and if 14 approved by the Commission, revenue sharing would continue. 15 Q. What have been the results of the revenue 16 sharing mechanism since it was implemented through 2021? 17 A. The Company’s earnings in each year from 2011 18 through 2015, as well as 2018 and 2021, resulted in revenue 19 sharing with customers totaling $126.7 million, either as a 20 direct rate offset in the PCA or as an offset to amounts 21 that would have otherwise been collected in rates. The 22 Company’s earnings in 2016, 2017, 2019, and 2020 were below 23 the revenue sharing threshold. These amounts are detailed 24 in Table 6 below. 25 BRADY, DI 32 Idaho Power Company Table  6 2009‐2022 Revenue Sharing  Line  No. Revenue Sharing Component 2009‐2011 2012‐2014 2015‐2019 2020‐2022    1 Available ADITC For Use $45 Million $45 Million $45 Million $45 Million    2 Customer Benefits ($ Millions):           3 Reduction to Rates $27.1 $22.8  $8.2  $0.6  Total  4 Offset to Pension Balancing Account $20.3  $47.8  $0.0  $0.0  2009‐2022  5 Total $47.4  $70.6  $8.2  $0.6  $126.7              1 Q. Did the Company’s year-end 2022 financial 2 results warrant any action related to the existing sharing 3 agreement per the terms of the 2018 Stipulation? 4 A. No. The Company’s year-end 2022 financial 5 results yielded an actual Idaho jurisdictional ROE of 9.8 6 percent, falling below the 10 percent ROE threshold for 7 revenue sharing, and thus resulting in no revenue sharing 8 with customers. 9 Q. Did the Company use the same methodology to 10 determine the Idaho jurisdictional 2022 year-end ROE that 11 was used in prior PCA filings? 12 A. Yes. The methodology used to determine the 13 Company’s Idaho jurisdictional 2022 year-end ROE is 14 consistent with the methodology used for the year-end ROE 15 determinations since the inception of the mechanism. 16 Q. Do you have an exhibit demonstrating the 17 application of this methodology? 18 BRADY, DI 33 Idaho Power Company A. Yes. Exhibit No. 3 provides a step-by-step 1 calculation of the Idaho jurisdictional ROE based on year-2 end 2022 financial results utilizing the Commission-3 approved methodology from previous PCA filings. 4 IV. NET CUSTOMER IMPACT 5 Q. What is the revenue impact of the requested 6 PCA rate when compared with PCA rates currently in effect? 7 A. Attachment 2 to the Application filed 8 contemporaneously with my testimony provides a detailed 9 description of the overall revenue impact of this filing on 10 each customer class. As shown in Attachment 2, applying 11 the requested PCA rates to expected customer sales for the 12 June 2023 through May 2024 test year6 results in a PCA 13 increase of $200.2 million. 14 Q. Given the magnitude of the increase for the 15 2023-2024 PCA, did the Company consider proposing any rate 16 mitigation options? 17 A. Yes, though after careful consideration it was 18 ultimately decided to not propose any rate mitigation 19 measures in this case. While the Company is sensitive to 20 the financial impact the proposed increase will have on its 21 customers, it believes the potential longer-term downside 22 6 Expected customer sales for the June 2023 – May 2024 test year are reduced by the amount of Micron’s load forecast to be met by Black Mesa Solar generation for the reasons explained herein. BRADY, DI 34 Idaho Power Company risks outweigh the near-term relief of deferring all or a 1 portion of the requested increase. 2 Q. What concerns does the Company have with 3 proposing rate mitigation measures in this case? 4 A. First, the Company believes that customer 5 interests are generally best served by matching cost 6 recovery as closely as possible with the period in which 7 power supply costs are incurred. Additionally, mitigating 8 rate impacts by spreading recovery over multiple years 9 creates the possibility that the deferred collection will 10 result in “rate pancaking” with potential future rate 11 increases, essentially deferring an increase in the current 12 year to create an even larger increase in the future. 13 Q. Is the Company’s decision not to propose any 14 rate mitigation measures in this case consistent with 15 Commission precedent? 16 A. Yes. In considering the use of rate mitigation 17 measures in prior PCA cases, the Commission has repeatedly 18 declined to spread recovery of amounts into subsequent 19 years citing concerns surrounding rate pancaking, 20 appropriate matching of costs and recovery, and the overall 21 intent of the PCA mechanism.7 22 7 See, e.g., Order Nos. 28722, 29026, 30563, 30828, and 32821. BRADY, DI 35 Idaho Power Company Q. Would Idaho Power be amenable to implementing 1 rate mitigation measures for the 2023-2024 PCA if the 2 Commission determines such measures are appropriate? 3 A. Yes. While both Idaho Power and the Commission 4 have expressed concerns with rate mitigation measures in 5 the past, the Company would be amenable to discussing such 6 measures in the current filing. A two-year recovery period, 7 for example, would reduce the rate impact from the proposed 8 $200.2 million, or 14.68 percent increase, to an 9 approximate $100 million, or slightly more than 7 percent, 10 annual increase in collection spread over two years. 11 Q. Have you prepared a revised Schedule 55 that 12 includes the proposed PCA rates? 13 A. Yes. Attachment 1 to the Application is a 14 revised Schedule 55 and includes the proposed PCA rates in 15 clean and legislative formats. 16 Q. Please summarize the Company’s request in this 17 filing. 18 A. If approved, the 2023-2024 PCA will result in 19 an increase in total billed revenue of approximately $200.2 20 million, or 14.68 percent. The Commission should approve 21 the Company’s computation of the PCA rates, the calculation 22 of which follows the methodology that was approved in Order 23 Nos. 30715, 33307, and 34071. 24 Q. Does this conclude your testimony? 25 BRADY, DI 36 Idaho Power Company A. Yes, it does. 1 // 2 // 3 // 4 // 5 // 6 // 7 // 8 // 9 // 10 // 11 // 12 // 13 // 14 // 15 // 16 // 17 // 18 // 19 // 20 // 21 // 22 // 23 // 24 BRADY, DI 37 Idaho Power Company DECLARATION OF JESSICA G. BRADY 1 I, Jessica G. Brady, declare under penalty of 2 perjury under the laws of the state of Idaho: 3 1. My name is Jessica G. Brady. I am employed 4 by Idaho Power Company as a Regulatory Analyst in the 5 Regulatory Affairs Department. 6 2. On behalf of Idaho Power, I present this 7 pre-filed direct testimony and Exhibit Nos. 1-4 in this 8 matter. 9 3. To the best of my knowledge, my pre-filed 10 direct testimony and exhibits are true and accurate. 11 I hereby declare that the above statement is true to 12 the best of my knowledge and belief, and that I understand 13 it is made for use as evidence before the Idaho Public 14 Utilities Commission and is subject to penalty for perjury. 15 SIGNED this 14th day of April 2023, at Boise, Idaho. 16 17 Signed: _________________________ 18 BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION CASE NO. IPC-E-23-12 IDAHO POWER COMPANY BRADY, DI TESTIMONY EXHIBIT NO. 1 Line No. FERC Accoun April May June Jul Augus Septembe Octobe Novembe Decembe January February March Annua 95% Sharing Account 1 Hydroelectric Generation (MWh 669,893 815,724 668,995 589,237 459,802 469,487 410,852 376,407 417,821 500,561 511,721 597,496 6,487,995 Account 536, Water for Power 2 Total Expense -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$ Account 501, Coa Jim Bridge3 Energy (MWh)32,400 33,480 52,800 345,000 389,280 368,000 291,648 301,087 397,342 248,168 224,151 198,028 2,881,385 4 Total Expense 927,519$ 944,093$ 1,583,803$ 11,771,641$ 13,302,239$ 12,531,704$ 9,823,994$ 10,124,985$ 13,479,776$ 9,093,109$ 8,224,823$ 7,120,278$ 98,927,967$ North Valm 5 Energy (MWh)0 0 0 92,982 93,606 90,587 (0) 90,586 93,606 93,606 84,547 (0) 639,520 6 Total Expense 281,244$ 281,244$ 281,244$ 4,036,122$ 4,112,417$ 4,091,354$ 281,244$ 4,346,310$ 4,494,603$ 4,527,474$ 4,147,553$ 281,244$ 31,162,058$ Account 547, Other Fuel Langley Gulc 7 Energy (MWh)139,733 217,400 207,136 210,784 211,056 173,533 104,419 215,505 227,040 226,896 209,272 219,721 2,362,496 8 Total Expense 4,057,080$ 5,606,759$ 5,549,706$ 6,062,379$ 6,297,359$ 5,184,195$ 2,768,811$ 8,521,863$ 11,667,835$ 11,483,215$ 9,621,781$ 8,050,424$ 84,871,408$ Danskin 9 Energy (MWh)- - 107,536 120,760 121,032 17,920 16,072 - 48,608 91,656 - - 523,584 10 Total Expense 188,260$ 188,260$ 4,834,354$ 5,856,346$ 6,077,534$ 1,087,306$ 880,963$ 188,260$ 4,036,946$ 7,322,223$ 188,260$ 188,260$ 31,036,972$ Bennett Mountai11 Energy (MWh)53,120 24,600 29,792 123,504 117,792 - 26,896 - - - - - 375,704 12 Total Expense 2,730,132.99$ 1,136,502.99$ 1,372,887.23$ 5,862,220.99$ 5,798,229.63$ 92,724.99$ 1,258,935.55$ 92,724.99$ 92,724.99$ 92,724.99$ 92,724.99$ 92,724.99$ 18,715,259$ Account 555, Purchased Power Non-PURP 13 Energy (MWh)142,847 191,051 259,425 196,337 112,350 68,143 152,585 101,420 99,244 122,682 106,225 143,375 1,695,683 14 Total Expense 7,687,629$ 9,415,073$ 13,232,753$ 18,203,695$ 14,155,915$ 4,935,489$ 9,776,664$ 7,118,508$ 8,565,313$ 11,905,097$ 9,371,986$ 9,124,566$ 123,492,688$ Account 565, 3rd Party Transmission15 Total Expense 288,871$ 555,684$ 995,003$ 1,295,183$ 1,374,340$ 678,713$ 627,107$ 442,821$ 475,985$ 476,827$ 531,126$ 222,991$ 7,964,649$ Account 447, Surplus Sale 16 Energy (MWh)(164,104) (233,311) (50,588) (57,706) (29,711) (77,912) (18,744) (23,789) (3,189) (43,366) (130,716) (181,682) (1,014,817) 17 Total Expense (11,881,670)$ (11,175,499)$ (2,179,620)$ (7,279,357)$ (6,124,246)$ (12,126,073)$ (1,354,165)$ (2,053,469)$ (389,477)$ (5,433,721)$ (13,001,139)$ (11,193,102)$ (84,191,539)$ 100% Sharing Account Account 555, PURP 18 Energy (MWh)294,581 304,873 315,285 293,178 276,769 254,323 228,028 184,726 193,395 208,290 248,034 256,321 3,057,802 19 Total Expense 15,926,928$ 16,207,313$ 22,389,867$ 24,148,708$ 23,196,742$ 17,877,565$ 16,195,226$ 16,041,536$ 17,320,985$ 16,103,838$ 18,694,874$ 14,431,830$ 218,535,412$ Account 555, Demand Response Incentive 20 Total Expense -$ -$ 283,373$ 3,219,549$ 4,926,370$ 1,339,151$ 185,519$ 59,448$ 971,098$ -$ -$ -$ 10,984,508$ 95% Sharing Account 4,279,066$ 6,952,118$ 25,670,130$ 45,808,231$ 44,993,789$ 16,475,415$ 24,063,555$ 28,782,003$ 42,423,706$ 39,466,950$ 19,177,114$ 13,887,387$ 311,979,464$ 100% Sharing Account 15,926,928$ 16,207,313$ 22,673,240$ 27,368,257$ 28,123,112$ 19,216,716$ 16,380,745$ 16,100,984$ 18,292,083$ 16,103,838$ 18,694,874$ 14,431,830$ 229,519,920$ 21 Total Net Power Supply Expense 20,205,994$ 23,159,431$ 48,343,370$ 73,176,488$ 73,116,901$ 35,692,131$ 40,444,300$ 44,882,987$ 60,715,789$ 55,570,787$ 37,871,988$ 28,319,217$ 541,499,384$ 22 Total Generation (MWh) 1,332,575 1,587,128 1,640,969 1,971,781 1,781,687 1,441,992 1,230,500 1,269,731 1,477,055 1,491,859 1,383,951 1,414,941 18,024,169 23 Total Load (MWh) 1,168,471 1,353,817 1,590,381 1,914,075 1,751,976 1,364,081 1,211,755 1,245,943 1,473,866 1,448,493 1,253,235 1,233,259 17,009,352 APRIL 1, 2023 - MARCH 31, 2024IDAHO POWER PCA FORECAS Exhibit No. 1 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 1 of 1 BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION CASE NO. IPC-E-23-12 IDAHO POWER COMPANY BRADY, DI TESTIMONY EXHIBIT NO. 2 Power Cost Adjustment Highlighted cells need to be updated prior to the June and July PCA entries April 2022 thru March 2023 April May June July August September October November December January February March Totals Idaho Jurisdiction Net Power Supply Expense (Non-QF) Actual Non-QF Fuel Expense-Coal 10,847,106.68 7,386,836.10 4,111,571.46 11,388,060.41 12,934,149.36 10,862,858.85 4,311,322.69 7,381,229.78 8,669,673.61 7,626,241.65 7,359,669.84 2,077,275.31 94,955,995.74 Fuel Expense-Gas 5,526,950.57 4,507,824.70 1,959,307.24 10,394,443.73 6,195,389.72 11,777,878.94 8,000,984.36 21,045,163.64 36,970,792.16 27,818,545.94 19,969,889.01 24,150,144.27 178,317,314.28 Non-Firm Purchases 11,864,206.44 14,536,346.52 12,238,491.62 32,596,901.52 38,083,529.37 53,257,026.95 18,727,713.66 28,902,479.00 76,331,498.00 71,159,607.64 20,756,484.69 26,483,985.39 404,938,270.80 Third Party Transmission 590,965.52 1,005,756.94 1,365,288.83 1,915,820.21 1,790,013.35 1,018,981.81 884,839.05 682,107.44 822,136.83 875,468.43 962,712.15 905,086.65 12,819,177.21 Surplus Sales (3,054,903.66) (8,394,562.48) (2,261,691.94) 116,995.03 (227,238.62) (37,093,105.64) (5,653,754.73) (9,143,789.20) (42,268,447.57) (41,177,195.12) (14,320,861.02) (6,746,427.22) (170,224,982.17) Water for Power (Leases)- - - - - - - - - - - - - Total Actual NPSE $25,774,325.55 19,042,201.78 17,412,967.21 56,412,220.90 58,775,843.18 39,823,640.91 26,271,105.03 48,867,190.66 80,525,653.03 66,302,668.54 34,727,894.67 46,870,064.40 520,805,775.86 Idaho Allocation 95.6%95.4%95.7%96.0%95.9%95.8%95.7%95.3%95.2%95.3%95.6%96.0% Net Idaho Jurisctional Actual Non-QF $24,640,255.23 18,166,260.50 16,664,209.62 54,155,732.06 56,366,033.61 38,151,047.99 25,141,447.51 46,570,432.70 76,660,421.68 63,186,443.12 33,199,867.30 44,995,261.82 497,897,413.14 Base Non-QF Fuel Expense-Coal $7,525,242.00 7,487,643.00 9,019,153.00 11,385,255.00 12,185,412.00 10,796,845.00 7,781,442.00 7,302,324.00 8,455,019.00 9,553,773.00 8,912,994.00 8,098,078.00 108,503,180.00 Fuel Expense-Gas $2,314,209.00 2,302,646.00 2,773,625.00 3,501,263.00 3,747,333.00 3,320,312.00 2,392,997.00 2,245,656.00 2,600,139.00 2,938,035.00 2,740,979.00 2,490,369.00 33,367,563.00 Non-Firm Purchases $4,342,083.00 4,320,388.00 5,204,073.00 6,569,319.00 7,031,012.00 6,229,805.00 4,489,910.00 4,213,459.00 4,878,566.00 5,512,549.00 5,142,819.00 4,672,610.00 62,606,593.00 Third Party Transmission $378,398.00 376,507.00 453,517.00 572,494.00 612,729.00 542,907.00 391,281.00 367,189.00 425,151.00 480,400.00 448,179.00 407,203.00 5,455,955.00 Surplus Sales $(3,588,093.00) (3,570,166.00) (4,300,402.00) (5,428,577.00) (5,810,099.00) (5,148,019.00) (3,710,251.00) (3,481,805.00) (4,031,418.00) (4,555,312.00) (4,249,784.00) (3,861,227.00) (51,735,153.00) Water for Power (Leases)$165,106.00 164,281.00 197,883.00 249,796.00 267,352.00 236,886.00 170,727.00 160,216.00 185,506.00 209,613.00 195,555.00 177,676.00 2,380,597.00 Idaho Base NPSE $11,136,945.00 11,081,299.00 13,347,849.00 16,849,550.00 18,033,739.00 15,978,736.00 11,516,106.00 10,807,039.00 12,512,963.00 14,139,058.00 13,190,742.00 11,984,709.00 160,578,735.00 Idaho Allocation 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0% Net Idaho Jurisdiction 95% Items $10,580,097.75 10,527,234.05 12,680,456.55 16,007,072.50 17,132,052.05 15,179,799.20 10,940,300.70 10,266,687.05 11,887,314.85 13,432,105.10 12,531,204.90 11,385,473.55 152,549,798.25 Idaho Jurisdiction Change From Base $14,060,157.48 7,639,026.45 3,983,753.07 38,148,659.56 39,233,981.56 22,971,248.79 14,201,146.81 36,303,745.65 64,773,106.83 49,754,338.02 20,668,662.40 33,609,788.27 345,347,614.89 Sharing Percentage 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0% Net Power Supply Expense Deferral ①$13,357,149.61 7,257,075.13 3,784,565.42 36,241,226.58 37,272,282.48 21,822,686.35 13,491,089.47 34,488,558.37 61,534,451.49 47,266,621.12 19,635,229.28 31,929,298.86 328,080,234.16 Idaho Jurisdictional Qualifying Facility NPSE Actual QF (Includes Net Metering, Raft River 100% & Liquidated Damages)$14,958,605.05 16,068,219.34 18,990,400.71 21,624,166.85 20,132,150.98 16,190,054.78 13,070,143.71 16,510,351.76 17,309,716.19 15,523,875.98 18,000,196.38 14,949,609.43 203,327,491.16 Idaho Allocation 95.6%95.4%95.7%96.0%95.9%95.8%95.7%95.3%95.2%95.3%95.6%96.0% Idaho Jurisctional Actual QF $14,300,426.43 15,329,081.25 18,173,813.48 20,759,200.18 19,306,732.79 15,510,072.48 12,508,127.53 15,734,365.23 16,478,849.81 14,794,253.81 17,208,187.74 14,351,625.05 194,454,735.78 Base QF $9,283,440.00 9,237,057.00 11,126,388.00 14,045,307.00 15,032,413.00 13,319,420.00 9,599,498.00 9,008,440.00 10,430,450.00 11,785,917.00 10,995,427.00 9,990,113.00 133,853,870.00 Idaho Allocation 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0% Idaho Jurisdictional Base $8,819,268.00 8,775,204.15 10,570,068.60 13,343,041.65 14,280,792.35 12,653,449.00 9,119,523.10 8,558,018.00 9,908,927.50 11,196,621.15 10,445,655.65 9,490,607.35 127,161,176.50 Idaho Jurisdiction Change From Base $5,481,158.43 6,553,877.10 7,603,744.88 7,416,158.53 5,025,940.44 2,856,623.48 3,388,604.43 7,176,347.23 6,569,922.31 3,597,632.66 6,762,532.09 4,861,017.70 67,293,559.28 Sharing Percentage 100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%QF Deferral ②$5,481,158.43 6,553,877.10 7,603,744.88 7,416,158.53 5,025,940.44 2,856,623.48 3,388,604.43 7,176,347.23 6,569,922.31 3,597,632.66 6,762,532.09 4,861,017.70 67,293,559.28 Idaho Revenue Adjustment (SBAR Actual Idaho Jurisdictional Billing Month Sales MWh 1,005,246 1,053,812 1,178,710 1,548,306 1,721,691 1,581,973 1,118,643 1,050,588 1,227,997 1,269,362 1,221,424 1,168,371 15,146,122 Normalized Idaho Jurisdictional Billing Month Sales MWh 947,192 953,286 1,131,686 1,370,142 1,428,766 1,300,608 1,045,495 957,864 1,081,014 1,177,663 1,101,149 1,004,027 13,498,892 Sales Change MWh 58,054 100,526 47,024 178,164 292,925 281,365 73,148 92,724 146,983 91,699 120,275 164,344 1,647,230 % of Prior Period Billings at Old Rate -$ 0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000% % of Current Period Billings at New Rate-effective 6/2015 26.72$ 100.000%100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% Sales Adjustment Prior To Sharing @ $(1,551,202.88) (2,686,048.71) (1,256,481.28) (4,760,542.08) (7,826,942.72) (7,518,072.80) (1,954,514.56) (2,477,585.28) (3,927,385.76) (2,450,197.28) (3,213,748.00) (4,391,267.63) (44,013,988.98) Sharing Percentage 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0% Idaho Revenue Adjustment (SBAR) ③$(1,473,642.74) (2,551,746.27) (1,193,657.22) (4,522,514.98) (7,435,595.58) (7,142,169.16) (1,856,788.83) (2,353,706.02) (3,731,016.47) (2,327,687.42) (3,053,060.60) (4,171,704.25) (41,813,289.54) Idaho Jurisdcitional Demand Response Incentive Payments Idaho Actual Demand Response $ - - 163,366.82 2,073,169.22 2,843,974.65 2,121,623.76 628,735.75 479,437.58 1,020.00 14.35 85.35 101.34 8,311,528.82 Idaho Base Demand Response $780,401.00 776,502.00 935,327.00 1,180,702.00 1,263,682.00 1,119,681.00 806,970.00 757,284.00 876,823.00 990,769.00 924,317.00 839,807.00 11,252,265.00 Change From Base $(780,401.00) (776,502.00) (771,960.18) 892,467.22 1,580,292.65 1,001,942.76 (178,234.25) (277,846.42) (875,803.00) (990,754.65) (924,231.65) (839,705.66) (2,940,736.18) Sharing Percentage 100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0%100.0% Change From Base ④$(780,401.00) (776,502.00) (771,960.18)892,467.22 1,580,292.65 1,001,942.76 (178,234.25) (277,846.42) (875,803.00) (990,754.65) (924,231.65) (839,705.66) (2,940,736.18) Idaho Miscellaneous Revenue System Emission Allowance Sales Credit $- - - - - - - - - - - - - System Renewable Energy Credit Sales $(1,168,040.31) 809.96 171.78 181.81 (1,183,377.60) 669.95 (83,462.81) 218.59 (738,019.94) (3,294,293.02) (4,123,273.82) (63,679.79) (10,652,095.20) Revenue Subtotal $(1,168,040.31)809.96 171.78 181.81 (1,183,377.60)669.95 (83,462.81)218.59 (738,019.94) (3,294,293.02) (4,123,273.82) (63,679.79) (10,652,095.20) Idaho Allocation 95.6%95.4%95.7%96.0%95.9%95.8%95.7%95.3%95.2%95.3%95.6%96.0% Sharing Percentage 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%Miscellaneous Revenue Deferral ⑤$(1,060,814.21)734.07 156.17 165.81 (1,078,116.16)609.72 (75,880.21)197.90 (667,465.23) (2,982,488.19) (3,744,757.28) (58,075.97) (9,665,733.58) # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 1 of 25 Idaho EIM Participation Costs Return on EIM Capital Investment $ 33,103.18 32,402.30 31,701.42 31,000.54 30,299.65 29,598.77 28,897.89 28,197.01 27,496.13 26,795.25 26,094.37 25,393.49 350,980.01 Operating Expenses $196,675.42 205,717.68 167,186.10 167,362.06 196,300.92 166,352.29 176,893.06 143,446.00 179,859.42 225,077.65 195,294.16 214,835.67 2,235,000.41 Revenue Subtotal $229,778.59 238,119.98 198,887.52 198,362.60 226,600.57 195,951.07 205,790.95 171,643.02 207,355.55 251,872.90 221,388.53 240,229.16 2,585,980.43 Sharing Percentage 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0% EIM Revenue Requirement ⑥$218,289.66 226,213.98 188,943.14 188,444.47 215,270.54 186,153.52 195,501.40 163,060.87 196,987.77 239,279.26 210,319.11 228,217.70 2,456,681.42 TOTAL DEFERRAL (Sum of ①-⑥) $15,741,739.75 10,709,652.01 9,611,792.21 40,215,947.63 35,580,074.37 18,725,846.67 14,964,292.01 39,196,611.93 63,027,076.87 44,802,602.78 18,886,030.95 31,949,048.38 343,410,715.56 PCA Forecasted Revenues Actual Idaho Jurisdictional Billing Month Sales MWh 1,005,246 1,053,812 1,178,710 1,548,306 1,721,691 1,581,973 1,118,643 1,050,588 1,227,997 1,269,362 1,221,424 1,168,371 15,146,122 % of Prior Period Billings at Old Rate 6/1/2021 7.83$ 100.000%100.000% 60.185%1.389%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000% % of Current Period Billings at New Rate - 6/1/2022 8.79$ 0.000%0.000% 39.800% 98.600% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000%Forecast Rate Revenues ⑦(8,839,128.20) (9,266,166.94) (11,441,018.36) (17,409,566.17) (19,407,095.97) (17,972,798.81) (12,708,913.52) (11,935,736.88) (13,951,273.90) (14,421,225.91) (13,876,598.56) (13,273,861.21) (164,503,384.43) PCA Balancing Account Balance Monthly Interest Rate (Annual 1% for 2022, 2% for 2023)%0.0833%0.0833% 0.0833% 0.0833%0.0833% 0.0833% 0.0833% 0.0833% 0.0833% 0.1667%0.1667%0.1667%1.2500% Beginning Balance 38,669,525.55$ 46,832,766.34 49,603,036.48 47,089,846.29 65,914,170.36 77,522,098.47 74,442,372.54 73,918,880.54 98,574,262.10 144,614,010.89 172,012,445.47 174,207,820.07 38,669,525.55 2022-2023 Incremental Deferral (Sum of ①-⑥ above 15,741,739.75 10,709,652.01 9,611,792.21 40,215,947.63 35,580,074.37 18,725,846.67 14,964,292.01 39,196,611.93 63,027,076.87 44,802,602.78 18,886,030.95 31,949,048.38 343,410,715.56 2022-2023 PCA Forecast Revenues (Collections) ⑦ above (8,839,128.20) (9,266,166.94) (11,441,018.36) (17,409,566.17) (19,407,095.97) (17,972,798.81) (12,708,913.52) (11,935,736.88) (13,951,273.90) (14,421,225.91) (13,876,598.56) (13,273,861.21) (164,503,384.43) 2022-2023 PCA Prior Balance Revenues (Collections) 1,228,404.64 1,287,757.76 (153,917.98) (4,021,298.93) (4,619,978.77) (3,897,375.54) (2,840,905.80) (2,667,092.56) (3,118,199.40) (3,223,965.64) (3,100,745.20) (2,967,784.99) (28,095,102.41) Revenue Sharing - Order No. - - (571,381.92) - - - - - - - - - (571,381.92) DSM Rider Forecasted Surplus Funds - Order No. - - - - - - - - - - - - - 2022-2023 Ending Balance Without Current Month Interest 46,800,541.74 49,564,009.17 47,048,510.43 65,874,928.82 77,467,169.99 74,377,770.79 73,856,845.23 98,512,663.03 144,531,865.67 171,771,422.12 173,921,132.66 189,915,222.25 188,910,372.35 Current Month Interest 32,224.60 39,027.31 41,335.86 39,241.54 54,928.48 64,601.75 62,035.31 61,599.07 82,145.22 241,023.35 286,687.41 290,346.37 1,295,196.272022-2023 Ending Deferral Balance 46,832,766.34$ 49,603,036.48 47,089,846.29 65,914,170.36 77,522,098.47 74,442,372.54 73,918,880.54 98,574,262.10 144,614,010.89 172,012,445.47 174,207,820.07 190,205,568.62 190,205,568.62 Tab is 100% locked down, with no manual inputs. Idaho Billed Sales MWh 1,005,246 1,053,812 1,178,710 1,548,306 1,721,691 1,581,973 1,118,643 1,050,588 1,227,997 1,269,362 1,221,424 1,168,371 15,146,122 Oregon Billed Sales MWh 46,427 50,553 53,082 63,743 72,727 68,968 50,421 51,906 62,339 62,037 56,639 49,302 688,143 Total MWh 1,051,673 1,104,364 1,231,792 1,612,049 1,794,417 1,650,941 1,169,064 1,102,494 1,290,336 1,331,399 1,278,063 1,217,673 15,834,266 Idaho % Billed Sales 95.6%95.4%95.7%96.0%95.9%95.8%95.7%95.3%95.2%95.3%95.6%96.0% Oregon % Billed Sales 4.4%4.6%4.3%4.0%4.1%4.2%4.3%4.7%4.8%4.7%4.4%4.0% Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 2 of 25 Power Cost Adjustment Input Sheet April 2022 thru March 2023 Source April May June July August September October November December January February March Total Actual Idaho Jurisdictional Billing Month Sales (Mwh) NCUST - Fin Accntng 1,005,246 1,053,812 1,178,710 1,548,306 1,721,691 1,581,973 1,118,643 1,050,588 1,227,997 1,269,362 1,221,424 1,168,371 15,146,122 Actual Idaho Jurisdictional Calendar Month Sales (Mwh)NCUST - Fin Accntng 1,030,080 1,151,009 1,309,649 1,770,115 1,656,873 1,267,327 1,022,769 1,159,427 1,297,005 1,255,296 1,120,338 1,156,785 15,196,672 Actual Oregon Jurisdictional Billing Month Sales (Mwh)NCUST - Fin Accntng 46,427 50,553 53,082 63,743 72,727 68,968 50,421 51,906 62,339 62,037 56,639 49,302 688,143 Surplus Sales (447) Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem (3,054,903.66) (8,394,562.48) (2,261,691.94) 116,995.03 (227,238.62) (37,093,105.64) (5,653,754.73) (9,143,789.20) (42,268,447.57) (41,177,195.12) (14,320,861.02) (6,746,427.22) (170,224,982.17) Total Purchased Power Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 12,191,275.94 14,772,851.86 12,670,837.76 32,482,332.00 37,703,740.06 53,511,436.21 19,164,182.26 29,443,672.31 76,511,844.14 71,435,626.01 21,313,471.02 26,579,956.71 407,781,226.28 Less Raft River Geothermal 100% PCA Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 421,475.64 406,842.04 527,600.39 589,330.74 528,975.59 464,130.18 527,125.14 699,354.59 724,962.11 614,089.57 559,327.26 452,143.91 6,515,357.16 Net Non-Firm Purchases - Including Telecaset & Raft River 95%(Acct 555000)11,769,800.30 14,366,009.82 12,143,237.37 31,893,001.26 37,174,764.47 53,047,306.03 18,637,057.12 28,744,317.72 75,786,882.03 70,821,536.44 20,754,143.76 26,127,812.80 401,265,869.12 Purchased Power Transmission Losses (555050)Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 92,639.60 168,488.10 92,879.25 696,566.17 894,801.42 199,583.40 85,663.16 155,437.39 541,970.00 335,938.83 265.59 354,785.32 3,619,018.23 Oregon Solar Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 1,766.54 1,848.60 2,375.00 7,334.09 13,963.48 10,137.52 4,993.38 2,723.89 2,645.97 2,132.37 2,075.34 1,387.27 53,383.45 Total Non-Firm Purchases 11,864,206.44 14,536,346.52 12,238,491.62 32,596,901.52 38,083,529.37 53,257,026.95 18,727,713.66 28,902,479.00 76,331,498.00 71,159,607.64 20,756,484.69 26,483,985.39 404,938,270.80 CSPP Expense (555070)Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 14,537,129.41 15,661,377.30 18,462,800.32 21,066,477.95 19,603,175.39 15,725,924.60 12,556,172.32 15,810,957.17 16,803,693.41 14,690,847.08 17,440,869.12 14,622,620.54 196,982,044.61 Net Metering (555101) Order No. 29094 Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem - - - - - - - - - - - - - Raft River 100%Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 421,475.64 406,842.04 527,600.39 589,330.74 528,975.59 464,130.18 527,125.14 699,354.59 724,962.11 614,089.57 559,327.26 452,143.91 6,515,357.16 Liquidated Damages (555080)Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem - (31,641.84) (13,153.75) 40.00 (218,939.33) 218,939.33 - (125,155.02) (169,910.61) Total QF 14,958,605.05 16,068,219.34 18,990,400.71 21,624,166.85 20,132,150.98 16,190,054.78 13,070,143.71 16,510,351.76 17,309,716.19 15,523,875.98 18,000,196.38 14,949,609.43 203,327,491.16 Demand Response Incentive Payments Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem - - 163,366.82 2,073,169.22 2,843,974.65 2,121,623.76 628,735.75 479,437.58 1,020.00 14.35 85.35 101.34 8,311,528.82 Third Party Transmission (565000)Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 590,965.52 1,005,756.94 1,365,288.83 1,915,820.21 1,790,013.35 1,018,981.81 884,839.05 682,107.44 822,136.83 875,468.43 962,712.15 905,086.65 12,819,177.21 Fuel Expense - Coal (Account 501)Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 10,847,106.68 7,386,836.10 4,111,571.46 11,388,060.41 12,934,149.36 10,862,858.85 4,311,322.69 7,381,229.78 8,669,673.61 7,626,241.65 7,359,669.84 2,077,275.31 94,955,995.74 Fuel Expense - Gas - Capacity & Fuel (547101 - 547103. 547105) Purchases and Sales Sheet-Christy Van Paepeghem 5,526,950.57 4,507,824.70 1,959,307.24 10,394,443.73 6,195,389.72 11,777,878.94 8,000,984.36 21,045,163.64 36,970,792.16 27,818,545.94 19,969,889.01 24,150,144.27 178,317,314.28 Water Lease Expense (Acct 536003)Peoplesoft query - Cathy Campbell - - - - - - - - - - - - - Emission Allowance Sales Peoplesoft query - Cathy Campbell - - - - - - - - - - - - - Renewable Energy Credits Christy Van Paepeghem (1,168,040.31) 809.96 171.78 181.81 (1,183,377.60) 669.95 (83,462.81) 218.59 (738,019.94) (3,294,293.02) (4,123,273.82) (63,679.79) (10,652,095.20) True-up Revenues YYYY PCA from Data Warehouse - Fin Accntng (1,228,404.64) (1,287,757.76) 153,917.98 4,021,298.93 4,619,978.77 3,897,375.54 2,840,905.80 2,667,092.56 3,118,199.40 3,223,965.64 3,100,745.20 2,967,784.99 28,095,102.41 Forecast Revenues YYYY PCA from Data Warehouse - Fin Accntng 8,839,128.20 9,266,166.94 11,441,018.36 17,409,566.17 19,407,095.97 17,972,798.81 12,708,913.52 11,935,736.88 13,951,273.90 14,421,225.91 13,876,598.56 13,273,861.21 164,503,384.43 Tab is 100% locked down, with exception of inputs, which have been traced to source Normalized Idaho Jurisdictional Billed Sales (Mwh)947,192 953,286 1,131,686 1,370,142 1,428,766 1,300,608 1,045,495 957,864 1,081,014 1,177,663 1,101,149 1,004,027 13,498,892 Normalized Idaho Jurisdictional Calendar Month Sales (Mwh)911,298 1,108,897 1,213,542 1,521,656 1,379,463 1,113,295 955,414 980,350 1,177,700 1,169,731 990,746 982,290 13,504,382 Base Non-QF Fuel Expense-Coal 7,525,242.00 7,487,643.00 9,019,153.00 11,385,255.00 12,185,412.00 10,796,845.00 7,781,442.00 7,302,324.00 8,455,019.00 9,553,773.00 8,912,994.00 8,098,078.00 108,503,180.00 Fuel Expense-Gas 2,314,209.00 2,302,646.00 2,773,625.00 3,501,263.00 3,747,333.00 3,320,312.00 2,392,997.00 2,245,656.00 2,600,139.00 2,938,035.00 2,740,979.00 2,490,369.00 33,367,563.00 Non-Firm Purchases 4,342,083.00 4,320,388.00 5,204,073.00 6,569,319.00 7,031,012.00 6,229,805.00 4,489,910.00 4,213,459.00 4,878,566.00 5,512,549.00 5,142,819.00 4,672,610.00 62,606,593.00 Third Party Transmission 378,398.00 376,507.00 453,517.00 572,494.00 612,729.00 542,907.00 391,281.00 367,189.00 425,151.00 480,400.00 448,179.00 407,203.00 5,455,955.00 Surplus Sales (3,588,093.00) (3,570,166.00) (4,300,402.00) (5,428,577.00) (5,810,099.00) (5,148,019.00) (3,710,251.00) (3,481,805.00) (4,031,418.00) (4,555,312.00) (4,249,784.00) (3,861,227.00) (51,735,153.00) Water for Power (Leases)165,106.00 164,281.00 197,883.00 249,796.00 267,352.00 236,886.00 170,727.00 160,216.00 185,506.00 209,613.00 195,555.00 177,676.00 2,380,597.00 Net 95% Items 11,136,945.00 11,081,299.00 13,347,849.00 16,849,550.00 18,033,739.00 15,978,736.00 11,516,106.00 10,807,039.00 12,512,963.00 14,139,058.00 13,190,742.00 11,984,709.00 160,578,735.00 Base Demand Response Incentive Payments 780,401 776,502 935,327 1,180,702 1,263,682 1,119,681 806,970 757,284 876,823 990,769 924,317 839,807 11,252,265 Base QF 9,283,440 9,237,057 11,126,388 14,045,307 15,032,413 13,319,420 9,599,498 9,008,440 10,430,450 11,785,917 10,995,427 9,990,113 133,853,870 Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 3 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Mar‐22 Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 205803.1395 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4152990.097 Net Electric Plant in Service 3792037.002 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 38996.09787 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,753,041$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 158,056$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (38,822)      State Income Taxes (11,800) Total Operating Expenses 146,051$                 Operating Income ‐146051.1616 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (146,051)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐3.89% Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 170633.5795 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 229,779$                 # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 4 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE May‐22 Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 211302.1158 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4187956.646 Net Electric Plant in Service 3751571.476 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 77992.19575 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,673,579$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 167,098$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (40,607)      State Income Taxes (12,342) Total Operating Expenses 152,766$                 Operating Income ‐152765.948 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (152,766)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐4.16% Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 176827.8923 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 238,120$                 # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 5 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 216801.0921 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4222923.196 Net Electric Plant in Service 3711105.951 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 116988.2936 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,594,118$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 128,567$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (33,001)      State Income Taxes (10,031) Total Operating Expenses 124,152$                 Operating Income ‐124152.3972 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (124,152)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐3.45% # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 6 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 147693.8678 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 198,888$                 Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 23,541$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 31,701 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 124,152 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 167,186 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 198,888$ # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 7 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 222300.0684 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4257889.745 Net Electric Plant in Service 3670640.425 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 155984.3915 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,514,656$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 128,743$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (33,035)      State Income Taxes (10,041) Total Operating Expenses 124,283$                 Operating Income ‐124283.0649 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (124,283)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐3.54% # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 8 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 147304.0619 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 198,363$                 Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 23,021$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 31,001 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 124,283 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 167,362 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 198,363$ # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 9 of 25 Idaho Power Compan Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requiremen RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                  Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 227799.0447 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4292856.294 Net Electric Plant in Service 3630174.9 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 194980.4894 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,435,194$             NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 157,682$                     Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (38,748)      State Income Taxes (11,777) Total Operating Expenses 145,773$                Operating Income ‐145773.0579 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (145,773)$               Rate of Return as filed ‐4.24% Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 168273.5813 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 226,601$                Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 22,501$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 30,300 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 145,773 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 196,301 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 226,601$ # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 10 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 233298.021 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4327822.843 Net Electric Plant in Service 3589709.374 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 233976.5872 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,355,733$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 127,733$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (32,836)      State Income Taxes (9,981) Total Operating Expenses 123,533$                 Operating Income ‐123533.2124 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (123,533)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐3.68% Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 11 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 145513.2622 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 195,951$                 Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 21,980$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 29,599 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 123,533 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 166,352 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 195,951$ # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 12 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 238796.9973 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4362789.392 Net Electric Plant in Service 3549243.849 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 272972.6851 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,276,271$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 138,274$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (34,917)      State Income Taxes (10,613) Total Operating Expenses 131,361$                 Operating Income ‐131360.7815 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (131,361)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐4.01% # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 13 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 152820.3576 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 205,791$                 Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 21,460$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 28,898 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 131,361 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 176,893 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 205,791$ # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 14 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1153936.874      Transmission Plant 1204191.691      Distribution Plant 0      General Plant 0 Total Electric Plant in Service 8150830.238 Less: Accumulated Depreciation 244295.9736 Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4397755.941 Net Electric Plant in Service 3508778.324 Less: Customer Adv for Construction 0 Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 311968.783 Add: Plant Held for Future Use 0 Add: Working Capital 0 Add: Other Deferred Amounts 0 Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,196,810$              NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues 0      Other Operating Revenues 0 Total Operating Revenues ‐$  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 104,827$                      Depreciation Expenses 5,499      Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967      Taxes Other Than Income 3,429 Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment 0      Federal Income Taxes (28,314)      State Income Taxes (8,606) Total Operating Expenses 106,523$                 Operating Income ‐106522.9996 Add: IERCO Operating Income 0 Consolidated Operating Income (106,523)$                Rate of Return as filed ‐3.33% Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 15 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 7.86% Earnings Impact 127462.1021 Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.347 Monthly Revenue Requirement 171,643$                 Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 20,939$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 28,197 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 106,523 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 143,446 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 171,643$ Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 16 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,701.67                Production Plant 1,153,936.87                Transmission Plant 1,204,191.69                Distribution Plant ‐       General Plant ‐  Total Electric Plant in Service 8,150,830.24           Less: Accumulated Depreciation 249,794.95              Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4,432,722.49           Net Electric Plant in Service 3,468,312.80           Less: Customer Adv for Construction ‐  Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 350,964.88              Add: Plant Held for Future Use ‐  Add: Working Capital ‐  Add: Other Deferred Amounts ‐  Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,117,347.92           NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues ‐       Other Operating Revenues ‐  Total Operating Revenues ‐  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 141,240.14                   Depreciation Expenses 5,498.98       Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,966.55                     Taxes Other Than Income 3,429.02  Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,277.88)                      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment ‐       Federal Income Taxes (35,502.25)                    State Income Taxes (10,790.96)               Total Operating Expenses 133,563.60              Operating Income (133,563.60)             Add: IERCO Operating Income ‐  Consolidated Operating Income (133,563.60)             Rate of Return as filed (0.04)  # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 17 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 0.08  Earnings Impact 153,982.23              Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.35  Monthly Revenue Requirement 207,355.55              Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 20,418.63 Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 27,496.13 Start-up Costs Amortization - Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs - Other Operating Expense 133,563.60 Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 179,859.42 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 207,355.55 # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 18 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,701.67                Production Plant 1,153,936.87                Transmission Plant 1,204,191.69                Distribution Plant ‐       General Plant ‐  Total Electric Plant in Service 8,150,830.24           Less: Accumulated Depreciation 255,293.93              Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4,467,689.04           Net Electric Plant in Service 3,427,847.27           Less: Customer Adv for Construction ‐  Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 389,960.98              Add: Plant Held for Future Use ‐  Add: Working Capital ‐  Add: Other Deferred Amounts ‐  Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,037,886.29           NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues ‐       Other Operating Revenues ‐  Total Operating Revenues ‐  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 186,458.36                   Depreciation Expenses 5,498.98       Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,966.55                     Taxes Other Than Income 3,429.02  Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,277.88)                      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment ‐       Federal Income Taxes (44,428.32)                    State Income Taxes (13,504.05)               Total Operating Expenses 167,142.66              Operating Income (167,142.66)             Add: IERCO Operating Income ‐  Consolidated Operating Income (167,142.66)             Rate of Return as filed (0.06)  # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 19 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 0.08  Earnings Impact 187,040.81              Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.35  Monthly Revenue Requirement 251,872.90              Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 19,898.16 Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 26,795.25 Start-up Costs Amortization - Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs - Other Operating Expense 167,142.66 Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 225,077.65 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 251,872.90 # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 20 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,701.67                Production Plant 1,153,936.87                Transmission Plant 1,204,191.69                Distribution Plant ‐       General Plant ‐  Total Electric Plant in Service 8,150,830.24           Less: Accumulated Depreciation 260,792.90              Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4,502,655.59           Net Electric Plant in Service 3,387,381.75           Less: Customer Adv for Construction ‐  Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 428,957.08              Add: Plant Held for Future Use ‐  Add: Working Capital ‐  Add: Other Deferred Amounts ‐  Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 2,958,424.67           NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues ‐       Other Operating Revenues ‐  Total Operating Revenues ‐  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 156,674.85                   Depreciation Expenses 5,498.98       Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,966.55                     Taxes Other Than Income 3,429.02  Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,277.88)                      Investment Tax Credit Adjustment ‐       Federal Income Taxes (38,549.05)                    State Income Taxes (11,717.04)               Total Operating Expenses 145,025.44              Operating Income (145,025.44)             Add: IERCO Operating Income ‐  Consolidated Operating Income (145,025.44)             Rate of Return as filed (0.05)  # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 21 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 0.08  Earnings Impact 164,403.12              Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1.35  Monthly Revenue Requirement 221,388.53              Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 19,377.68 Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 26,094.37 Start-up Costs Amortization - Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs - Other Operating Expense 145,025.44 Gross-up factor 1.35 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 195,294.16 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 221,388.53 # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 22 of 25 Idaho Power Company Western EIM Participation Costs Idaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement RATE BASE Mar‐23 Electric Plant in Service      Intangible Plant 5,792,702$                   Production Plant 1,153,937                     Transmission Plant 1,204,192                     Distribution Plant ‐       General Plant ‐  Total Electric Plant in Service 8,150,830                Less: Accumulated Depreciation 266,292  Less: Amortization of Other Plant 4,537,622                Net Electric Plant in Service 3,346,916                Less: Customer Adv for Construction ‐  Less: Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes 467,953  Add: Plant Held for Future Use ‐  Add: Working Capital ‐  Add: Other Deferred Amounts ‐  Add: Subsidiary Rate Base TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 2,878,963                NET INCOME Operating Revenues      Sales Revenues ‐       Other Operating Revenues ‐  Total Operating Revenues ‐  Operating Expenses      Operation and Maintenance Expenses 176,216       Depreciation Expenses 5,499       Amortization of Limited Term Plant 34,967       Taxes Other Than Income 3,429  Regulatory Debits/Credits      Provision for Deferred Income Taxes (5,278)       Investment Tax Credit Adjustment ‐       Federal Income Taxes (42,407)       State Income Taxes (12,890)  Total Operating Expenses 159,537  Operating Income (159,537)  Add: IERCO Operating Income ‐  Consolidated Operating Income (159,537)  Rate of Return as filed (0)  # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 23 of 25 Annual Authorized Rate of Return 0  Earnings Impact 178,394  Net‐to‐Gross Tax Multiplier 1  Monthly Revenue Requirement 240,229  Components of Monthly Revenue Requirement Return on Rate Base 18,857$ Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Return on Rate Base 25,393 Start-up Costs Amortization 0 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Start-Up Costs 0 Other Operating Expense 159,537 Gross-up factor 1.347 Total Monthly Rev Req for Other Operating Exp 214,836 Total Monthly Revenue Requirement 240,229$ # Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 24 of 25 Power Cost Adjustment Calendar Month Accrual Calculations 2015-2019 2020 Total 2021 Total 2022 Total Total Cumulative Total January February March April May June July August September October November December All Years Sales Based Adjustment Prior New (Effective 6/1/15)Actual Idaho Jurisdictional Calendar Month Sales Mwh 68,807,570 14,160,172 14,720,217 15,127,055 1,255,296 1,120,338 1,156,785Normalized Idaho Jurisdictional Calendar Month Sales Mwh 67,494,460 13,498,892 13,498,892 13,498,892 1,169,255 990,343 981,891 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 107,991,136 Sales Change Mwh 1,313,110 661,280 1,221,325 1,628,163 86,041 129,995 174,894 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (107,991,136) % of Prior Period Billings at Old Rate 0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000%0.000% % of Current Period Billings at New Rate 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% 100.000% Sales Adjustment Prior To Sharing @ 26.72$ $(35,086,299.20) (17,669,401.60) (32,633,804.00) (43,504,509.03) (2,299,003.13)(3,473,460.32) (4,673,164.93)0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (128,894,013.83) Sharing Percentage 95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%95.0%Calendar Month Sales Based Adjustment $(33,331,984.24) (16,785,931.52) (31,002,113.81) (41,329,283.58) (2,184,052.97) (3,299,787.30) (4,439,506.68)0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (122,449,313.15) Billing Month Sales Based Adjustment (from PCA Worksheet)$(31,321,930.20) (15,344,094.93) (31,319,972.25) (40,271,037.70) (2,327,687.42) (3,053,060.60) (4,171,704.25)0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (118,257,035.08) Net Calendar Month Deferral / Accrual $(2,010,054.04) (1,441,836.59)317,858.44 (1,058,245.88)143,634.45 (246,726.70) (267,802.43)0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (4,192,278.07) Accounting:Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr)Dr (Cr) 799 X00001 999 182326 (2,010,054.04) (1,441,836.59)317,858.44 (1,058,245.88)143,634.45 (246,726.70) (267,802.43)0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (4,563,172.75) 693 M30108 441 557001 2,010,054.04 1,441,836.59 (317,858.44)1,058,245.88 (143,634.45)246,726.70 267,802.43 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 4,563,172.75 2023 \\dallas\Reg_Pricing\Employees\Brady\PCA\2023\March\Filing\Exhibit No. 2 - PCA Deferral Report - Balancing Adjustment.xlsx Exhibit No. 2 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 25 of 25 BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION CASE NO. IPC-E-23-12 IDAHO POWER COMPANY BRADY, DI TESTIMONY EXHIBIT NO. 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 TOTAL TOTAL 8 SYSTEM IDAHO IDAHO %SYSTEM IDAHO IDAHO % 9 * * * SUMMARY OF RESULTS * * * 10 TOTAL COMBINED RATE BASE 3,816,760,459 3,659,529,896 95.881% 11 12 DEVELOPMENT OF NET INCOME 13 OPERATING REVENUES 14 RETAIL SALES REVENUES (Incl 449.1 Rev)1,048,578,872 1,003,074,365 Direct Assign 1,372,758,056 1,312,548,812 Direct Assign 15 OTHER OPERATING REVENUES 167,118,182 160,109,387 95.8%264,369,926 253,282,475 95.8% 16 TOTAL OPERATING REVENUES 1,215,697,054 1,163,183,751 1,637,127,982 1,565,831,287 17 18 OPERATING EXPENSES 19 OPERATION & MAINTENANCE EXPENSES 793,265,607 755,302,382 95.2%1,105,868,787 1,052,945,345 95.2% 20 DEPRECIATION EXPENSE 120,425,620 115,582,841 96.0%163,581,418 157,003,177 96.0% 21 AMORTIZATION OF LIMITED TERM PLANT 3,510,742 3,369,427 96.0%4,852,904 4,657,563 96.0% 22 TAXES OTHER THAN INCOME 25,015,497 23,226,349 92.8%28,701,676 26,648,887 92.8% 23 REGULATORY DEBITS/CREDITS 1,249,451 1,022,156 81.8%1,753,318 1,434,363 81.8% 24 PROVISION FOR DEFERRED INCOME TAXES (7,519,188) (7,114,821) 94.6%(10,828,285) (10,245,961)94.6% 25 INVESTMENT TAX CREDIT ADJUSTMENT 3,334,345 3,199,107 95.9%5,825,740 5,589,454 95.9% 26 FEDERAL INCOME TAXES 26,089,683 25,397,531 97.3%42,187,659 41,068,433 97.3% 27 STATE INCOME TAXES 9,757,987 9,513,728 97.5%1,940,619 1,892,042 97.5% 28 TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSES 975,129,745 929,498,701 1,343,883,837 1,280,993,303 29 30 OPERATING INCOME 240,567,309 233,685,051 293,244,145 284,837,983 31 ADD: IERCO OPERATING INCOME 6,559,424 6,269,611 95.6%8,782,042 8,394,028 95.6% 32 33 OPERATING INCOME BEFORE OTHER INCOME AND DEDUCTION 247,126,732 239,954,662 302,026,187 293,232,011 97.1% 34 ADD: AFUDC EQUITY 37,285,494 35,749,526 95.9% (L 10) 35 ADD: OTHER INCOME AND DEDUCTIONS 4,596,024 4,462,201 97.1% (L 33) 36 37 INCOME BEFORE INTEREST CHARGES 343,907,704 333,443,738 38 LESS: INTEREST CHARGES 89,041,036 85,373,011 95.9% (L 10) 39 40 NET INCOME 254,866,668 248,070,726 41 42 ACTUAL YEAR-END RESULTS - BEFORE ITC ADJUSTMENT 43 EARNINGS ON COMMON STOCK 254,866,668 248,070,726 44 COMMON EQUITY AT YEAR END 2,631,661,816 2,523,251,118 95.9% (L10) 45 46 RETURN ON YEAR-END COMMON EQUITY 9.68%9.83% 47 48 EARNINGS ON COMMON STOCK @ 9.40 ROE 250,007,873 237,185,605 (L44 * 9.4%) 49 EARNINGS ON COMMON STOCK @ 10 ROE 263,166,182 252,325,112 (L44 * 10%) 50 EARNINGS ON COMMON STOCK @ 10.50 ROE 276,324,491 264,941,367 (L44 * 10.5%) 51 52 53 ACTUAL YEAR-END RESULTS - AFTER ITC ADJUSTMENT: 54 INVESTMENT TAX CREDIT ADJUSTMENT (12,014,483) (L48-L43) / (1-9.4%) 55 ADJUSTED EARNINGS ON COMMON STOCK 236,056,244 56 ADJUSTED COMMON EQUITY AT YEAR-END 2,511,236,635 57 ADJUSTED RETURN ON YEAR-END COMMON EQUITY 9.40% 58 59 IF IDAHO RETURN ON COMMON EQUITY (Line 46) <9.4% 60 ADDITIONAL ITC ADJUSTMENT (Annualized) If L 54 is negative, then 0; if positive, then smaller of L54 or $25,000,000 0 61 62 IF IDAHO RETURN ON COMMON EQUITY (Line 46) >10% 63 IDAHO EARNINGS GREATER THAN 10% ROE BUT LESS THAN 10.5%0 (L43-L49)/(1-10%) 64 65 IF IDAHO RETURN ON COMMON EQUITY (Line 46) >10.5% 66 INCREMENTAL IDAHO EARNINGS GREATER THAN 10.50% ROE 0 (L43-L50)/(1-10.5%) 67 68 Per Order #34071:After Tax Tax Gross Up 69 ROE between 10%-10.5% --CUSTOMER SHARE - 80% (Reduction to rates)0 - 70 ROE between 10%-10.5% --COMPANY SHARE - 20% 0 71 ROE greater than 10.5% (Incremental) -- CUSTOMER SHARE - 55% (Reduction to rates)0 - ROE greater than 10.5% (Incremental) -- CUSTOMER SHARE - 25% (Offset to Pension balance)0 - 72 ROE greater than 10.5% (Incremental) --COMPANY SHARE - 20% 0 73 0 74 Prepared by: Kelley Noe Reviewed by: September Allocations/Ratios IDAHO POWER COMPANY ADDITIONAL INVESTMENT TAX CREDIT ANALYSIS For the Twelve Months Ended December 31, 2022 Actual September 30, 2022 Actual December 31, 2022 Exhibit No. 3 Case No. IPC-E-23-12 J. Brady, IPC Page 1 of 1 BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION CASE NO. IPC-E-23-12 IDAHO POWER COMPANY BRADY, DI TESTIMONY EXHIBIT NO. 4 CONFIDENTIAL