20210311Attorney General Letter.pdf

VIA E-MAIL
Idaho Power Company
Donovan E. Walker
[e-mail]
Idaho Power Company
P.O. Box 70
Boise, ID 83707-007
STATE OF IDAHO
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
LAWRENCE G. WASDEN
March 11, 2021
Michael Darrington
[e-mail]
Idaho Power Company
P.O. Box 70
Boise, ID 83707-0070
PUBLISHED A VOIDED COST RATES FOR ENERGY STORAGE QUALIFYING
FACILITIES; ORDER NO. 34913 IN CASE NO. IPC-E-20-02.
In compliance with Order No. 34913 in Case No. IPC-E-20-02, Staff calculated published
avoided cost rates for new Energy Storage Qualifying Facilities (QFs) using the Company's Peak
Hours. Staff started with the published avoided costs in the Surrogate A voided Resource (SAR)
model approved in Order No. 34683 effective June 1, 2020. Next, Staff separated the avoided cost
of energy and the avoided cost of capacity. Seasonalization Adjustments and Heavy Load/Light
Load Adjustments are maintained for avoided cost of energy. Then, Staff spread the avoided cost
of capacity over Peak Hours as contained in the Company's Compliance Filing per Commission
Order No. 34913. Staff also calculated the levelized avoided cost of energy and the levelized
avoided cost of capacity separately. Consequently, four additional tabs were created in the SAR
model:
Contracts & Administrative law Division/Idaho Public Utilities Commission
P.O. Box 83720, Boise, Idaho 83720-0074 Telephone: [phone], Fax: [phone]
11331 W. Chinden Blvd., Bldg. 8, Suite 201-A, Boise, Idaho 83714
Page 2 of2
March 11, 2021
1. IPCOStorage(Energy)Non-LevelADJ: This tab calculates the non-levelized avoided cost
of energy after Seasonalization Adjustments and Heavy Load/Light Load Adjustments for
Energy Storage QFs.
2. IPCOStorage(Capacity): This tab calculates the non-levelized and levelized avoided cost
of capacity rates for Energy Storage QFs.
3. IPCOStorage(Energy)Levelized: This tab calculates the levelized avoided cost of energy
for Energy Storage QFs before Seasonalization Adjustments and Heavy Load/Light Load
Adjustments, which will be used in the last tab.
4. IPCOStorage(Energy)LevelizedADJ: This tab calculates the levelized avoided cost of
energy after Seasonalization Adjustments and Heavy Load/Light Load Adjustments for
Energy Storage QFs.
Included is an updated copy of the SAR model. Attachment A is a detailed protocol that
documents how Staff modified the model. Attachment B is the final published avoided cost rates
for Energy Storage QFs. Attachment C is an analysis that illustrates the difference in rates between
IRP Method rates and rates produced by the attached SAR model using the example supplied in
the Company's Compliance Filing. Please review these attachments and file a response with the
Commission by March 25, 2021 , stating whether the updates to the SAR model and the
calculations were made correctly.
Staff will update Peak Hours annually when the Company files its annual update to load
forecasts, natural gas forecasts, and contract information for IRP Method rates as required by
Commission Order No. 34913.
Thank you for your cooperation. Please contact Yao Yin ([e-mail]) if you
have any questions.
Sincerely,
~~l(
Edward Jewell
Deputy Attorney General
Enclosures
l:\Legal\ELECTRICIZZZ_CLOSED ELECTRIC\2020\Jdaho Power\lPC-E-20-02\Published Avoided Cost Rates\JPC_Ltr_3. I l.2021.docx
Contracts & Administrative Law Division/Idaho Public Utilities Commission
P.O. Box 83720, Boise, Idaho 83720-0074 Telephone: (208} 334-0300, Fax: [phone]
11331 W. Chinden Blvd., Bldg. 8, Suite 201-A, Boise, Idaho 83714
Attachment A
Protocol for Updating SAR Model in Compliance with Order No. 34913
Current Structure Description
On "A VOID NEW" tab, Column AD contains avoided cost of energy. Column AG contains
avoided cost of capacity after peak capacity factor adjustment, while Column T contains avoided
cost of capacity before peak capacity factor adjustment. Column AH is the sum of Column AD
and Column AG, which then will be seasonalized and adjusted by heavy load/light load hours.
Modification Overview
Separate avoided cost of energy and avoided cost of capacity, spread avoided cost of capacity
over peak hours, and adjust avoided cost of energy for seasonalization and heavy load and light
load hours.
Detailed Steps
Development o{Non-Levelized Rates for Avoided Capacity and Energy
A voided Cost of Energy:
Reference the values in Column AD on the A VOID NEW tab into Column C on the
IPCOStorage(Energy)Non-LevelADJ tab. All technology categories have the same
avoided cost of energy.
A voided Cost of Capacity:
1. Annual value of CCCT in Column D on the IPCOStorage(Capacity) tab is equal to
Column Ton the A VOID NEW tab multiplied by 365, by 24 and then by the chosen
technology's annual capacity factor. All technology categories have the same annual
value ofCCCT.
2. Subsequently, values in Column Don the IPCOStorage(Capacity) tab are spread over the
total number of Peak Hours in a year.
Development o{Levelized Rates for Avoided Capacity and Energy
A voided Cost of Energy:
1. An intermediate tab of IPCOStorage(Energy)Levelized is created to contain levelized
rates before seasonalization and heavy load and light load adjustments.
2. IPCOStorage(Energy)levelizedADJ tab shows the seasonalization and heavy load and
light load adjustments.
A voided Cost of Capacity:
1. The levelized avoided costs of capacity included in Column G on the
IPCOStorage(Capacity) tab are the result of dividing the $/MW in Column F by the
number of peak hours in the year included in Cell L8.
Attachment A
2. The contract period for levelized avoided costs of capacity starts after the first deficit
year. The formula in Column A on the IPCOStorage(Capacity) tab reference the "Input -
Load and Resource" tab, where the capacity deficiency data is contained.
AVOIDED COST OF CAPACITY FOR ENERGY STORAGE (IPCO)
Years of
Levelized Levelized Avoided
Avoided Cost Non-levelized Avoided Cost of Capacity
of Capacity Cost of Capacity during during Peak Hours
Payment Online Year Peak Hours ($/MWh) ($/MWh)
0 2021
0 2022
0 2023
0 2024
0 2025
1 2026 427.79 427.79
2 2027 434.07 430.81
3 2028 440.44 433.77
4 2029 446.91 436.68
5 2030 453.47 439.53
6 2031 460.13 442.33
7 2032 466.89 445.06
8 2033 473.75 447.74
9 2034 480.71 450.36
10 2035 487.78 452.92
11 2036 494.95 455.42
12 2037 502.23 457.86
13 2038 509.62 460.24
14 2039 517.12 462 .56
15 2040 524.73 464.82
16 2041 532.46 467.02
17 2042 540.30 469.15
18 2043 548.26 471.23
19 2044 556.34 473.24
20 2045 564.54 475.20
21 2046 572.86 477.10
S.HonalluiCion Factor•
......,, ......,,
IN.sons
7UO% ~toMatc:h•Mloy)
1211.00% ~to.,,_,,,,~NowMMlr,sndO.e.Mlllr)
100,00% ~toJanuary,Februsry, June, Sepk,Mlllr,andOdlllber)
--..._,"'klntcn.s,r.1
IOAHO POWER
AvotOED COST MlEI OF ENERGY FOR ENERGY STORAGE PROJECTS
IDAHOPOWER
NON-UVEL.IZED MTES
S..-:tl"fklntl1:tft) ..._,l"tk .. 11to"JI.I -------------------------..... vy. '7.ll __ .__ ------ll------+------+-------ll------+------+-------11--------+--------<f------◄I
202\
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
202,
202,
2030
203\
2032
2033
2034
"'' -2037
2036
"'' 2040
2041
2042
2043 -2045
2046
°""'9fllW 11.24 (14.04)
.... HMv)tLAM UafllLAM - -27.07
27.1-4
28.17
,0,27
33.54
36.75
'9.1-4
"·" -41.88
-42.22
-42.90
44.19
-45.111
-47.31 .....
-49.87
52.02
53.7-4
55.04
56~7
57.64
59.10
60.80
52.117
6-4.51
68.92
19.79
19.8(1
20.119
22.99
26.26
29.-47
3\.16
3U1
"·" .....
35.62 ,.,,
38.53
40.03
-41.28
-42.59
-4-4.7-4
-46.-48
-47.76
"·" 50.36
51.82
53.52
55.59
57.23
59,ll-4
-17.52
17.57
18.32
19.87
22.27
2-4.13 ,~,.
27.87
211.-40
211.65
29.15
30,10
31.29
32.39
33.31
3427
35.115
37,12
38.07
39.05
39.99
-41.06
-42.31
-43.113
-45.03
-46.IIO
l"nc:•IK• ----NA 19.90
NA 19.95
NA 20.70
NA 2225
NA ,. ..
NA 27.01
NA 211.76
NA JO.OS
NA 30.78
NA 31.03
NA 3\.53
NA "·" NA 33£7
NA 3-4.78
NA 35.69
NA 36.65
NA 36>3
NA 39.50
NA "·" NA -41.-43
NA -42.37
NA 43.44
NA 44.69
NA 462\
NA -47.-41
NA -49.19
----........ ---- - ------NA 14.55 NA 28.60 NA
NA 1-4.60 NA 28.68 NA
NA 15.35 NA "·" NA
NA 16.90 NA 32.44 NA
NA 19.30 NA "·" NA
NA 21.615 NA .,,, NA
NA 23.-41 NA 43.00 NA
NA 2-4.70 NA -45.111 NA
NA 25.-43 NA -46.37 NA
NA 25.6' NA -46.711 NA
NA 26.111 NA -47.59 NA
NA 27.13 NA -49.15 NA
NA ,.,, NA 51.08 NA
NA 29.-42 NA 52.89 NA
NA J0.34 NA .. .,. NA
NA 3\.30 NA ..... NA
NA 32.118 NA 511.53 NA
NA 3-4,15 NA 60.60 NA
NA 35.10 NA 62.18 NA
NA 36.00 NA 83.76 NA
NA >l.f12 NA .. ,. NA
NA 36.09 NA '7.04 NA
NA 39.34 NA "·" NA
NA "·" NA 71.55 NA
NA -42.06 NA 73.52 NA
NA -43.113 NA 78.-41 NA
--....... l"lic:•IK• ------------ - ---.... -.... ---..... -32.-49 NA 23.75 NA 2'.113 NA 27.07 NA 19.79 NA
32.57 NA 23,113 NA ,,.., NA 27.1-4 NA 19.86 NA
33.60 NA 25.07 NA 2-4.93 NA 211.17 NA 20.89 NA
36,32 NA 27.59 NA 27.03 NA ,.,, NA 22.99 NA
-40.2-4 NA 31.51 NA JO.JO NA 33.5-4 NA ,..,. NA
44.10 NA 35.36 NA 3351 NA ,us NA 29.-47 NA ..... NA 36>3 NA 35.00 NA 39.1-4 NA ,, ... NA
"·" NA 40.33 NA 37,&5 NA -40.89 NA 33.81 NA
50.26 NA -41.53 NA 36.64 NA 41.111 NA "·" NA
50,87 NA -41.93 NA 36.98 NA -42.22 NA ..... NA
51.-411 NA -42.7-4 NA ..... NA -42.90 NA 35.62 NA
53,03 NA 44.30 NA 40.95 NA -4-4.19 NA 36'1 NA
S..97 NA 4624 NA -42.57 NA -45.81 NA "·"' NA
56.78 NA 48.04 NA 44.07 NA -47.31 NA 40.C, NA
511.28 NA ..... NA 45.32 NA .... NA -41.28 NA ..... NA 51.11 NA 46.63 NA -49.87 NA 42.59 NA
62.-42 NA ,,.., NA -48.78 NA 52.02 NA 44.7-4 NA ..... NA 55.76 NA so.so NA 53.7-4 NA 46.46 NA
"·" NA 57.31 NA 51.IK) NA 55.04 NA -47.76 NA ,,.., NA 511.91 NA 53.13 NA 56.37 NA 49.09 NA
89.17 NA 80.-43 NA "·" NA 57.64 NA 50.36 NA
7012 NA 62.19 NA "·" NA 59.10 NA 51.82 NA
n.'6 NA 6423 NA 57-'6 NA '°·" NA 53.52 NA
75.44 NA 86.70 NA ..... NA 82.117 NA ..... NA
n.◄1 NA "·" NA 81.27 NA 64.51 NA 5723 NA
"·'° NA 71.57 NA "·" NA 66.92 NA 59.64 NA
..._, n.lO% ~loMattl•M9J)
Season2 1J0.00% ~loJ41lf,Auguat,NcwemNr,•nd~)
'"-1 100.00"4 ~loJuMary,F~,,A111o1,Seplember,Nid~)
IDAHO,owa
AVOIDE0 e0aTfltATH O, -y 1'0111.BeflOY STOltAOE ~KTS
Elglblltytor._.., ...... .,...1o_".,•"ot-c:u100 __ °'__._·
IDAHO,.._
L<VIUZE) .. ,..
l'ftOJICT otM.N .. 2021
..... ,l'l'lc .. (7U"Jlot .._, ..... 11wt.1 .... J ....... 11WIC.I
......,.... 11.21 1'111 ......,..._...... Ui!Mi....11.._ 1'111 MNwyLNIINNf LJalllLMfMliw 1'1111 ......,. ..... .._. Uiilll.._...._ __ ..... ------ll-------+------+----------11-----------1---------1-------111-----------1---------1-------11
........ 11.M !MM)
,,..,
23.17
24.19
202
25.75 ,. ..
27.12
21.74 , .. ,
10 30.17
30.73
31.27
31.71
14 32.29
15 32.71 ,e 33.21 ,,.,
18 :M,11 ,..,
27.07 19.71
27.11 1t.13
17.43 20.15
21.06 20.71
2U9 21.71
30.04 22.79
31.08
31.97
32.78
33.41
33.97
)4,51
35.03
35.53
3U0
311.45
3U1
37.35
37.TT
38.US
23.71 ,.., ,.,.
28.13
21.69
27.23
27.7S
2125 21.n
29.17
29.63 ,.., ,.,. ,. ..
_.,, .... ---17.52: NA
17.54 NA
17.71 NA
11.24 NA
11.93 NA
11.70 NA ,. ...
21.12
21.70
22.11
"·" ,,_,.
"·" 23.73
24.08
2-4.41
24.74
25.07
25.31
25.U
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
------1UO NA
11.12 NA
20.11 NA
20.12 NA
21.31 NA
22.08 NA ,,.,
23.50
2◄.08 ,. ..
2◄..1 ,..,.
25.74
21.11 ,. ...
28.71
27.13
27.45
27.7t!I
28,05
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
...... 1Nc .. f7l.AI
-­.... ---14.55 NA
14.57 NA
14.81 NA
15.27 NA
15.M NA
11.73 NA
17.41
11.15
11.73
19.21
1U2
20.01 ,..,.
20.71
21.11
21.44
21.n
2210
2241
22.70
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
-·-----2UO NA
21.M NA ,.., ....
21.71 NA
,... NA
U.11 NA ,,.,.
34AI ,...,
3620 ,. ..
:U.52
31.14 ... ,.
3U1 ,. .. ..... .. .., .,..,
41.11
....
NA ....
NA
NA
NA
NA ....
NA
NA ....
NA
NA ....
l».HO,OWM
LrVIUZEO M Tel
l"M>JICTOfrM.JNEIN2022
"·" 32.53
32.92
33.117
:M.79 .....
37.27 ,.,,
39.31 .....
40.77
41.41
'2.03
"·" '3.20
43.74 ..... .. ., .. .,, .. ...
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
..... ,,,... .. ,1 ...
23.75 NA
23.79 NA
24.18 NA
,... NA
21.05 NA
27.32 NA
21.13
"·" ,. .. ,,.,.
32.03
32.17
'3.30 ,, .. ,.,,
35.01
35.55 ..... ,. ...
37.06
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
-23.&3
23.&7
24.11
24.12
25.15
2e.eo
27.12
28.74
"·" 30.17
30.73
31.27
31.79
32.2t
32.71
33.21
33.17
:M.11
"·" "·"
-­....
~
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
27.ll7
27.11
27.<3
21,ot ,. .. ,. .. ,, ..
31.17
32.71
33.41
33.97 ,.., ,...,
35.53 ,. ..
30.45 ,..,
37.35
37.n
31.16
---~
NA .... ....
NA
NA
NA
NA .... ....
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
...... , ...... 11...,,,
_ ... , .... -'"'" -19.79 NA
1U3 NA
20.15 NA
20,78 NA
21.71 NA
22.TII NA
23.71 ,. .. ,. ...
26.13 ,. ..
27.23
27.75 ,.,,
21.72
29.17
"·" ,.., .....
'°·"
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
....,,... 17,a .... MuWW"a........ IJIMLA,alNM, .... ..._,.a........ .....a........ .... ~'---I.... IJIM'--INM, __ ..... ------11-------+------+--------!l--------<-------+-------<ll--------<-------+-------<I
........ 1"4 1$4.kl
,, ..
24,40 ,.,,
21.33
2756
21.18
"·" ,.~,
31.111
31.77
27.14 19.81
27.'3 20.35
21.44 21.11
28.57 22.28
30.79 23.51
31.112 24.14
32.82 25.14
J.J.71 26.<la
34.43 27.15
35.01
17.57 NA
17.93 NA
11.53 NA
19.35 NA
20.25 NA
21.08 NA
21.12 NA
22'3 NA
22,93 NA
23.35
-·-----19.95 NA
20.31 NA
20.11 NA
21.74 NA
22.63 NA
23.41 NA
24.20 NA
24.11 NA
25.31 NA
-­.... -'"'"-14.80 NA
14.96 NA
15.5a NA
11,31 NA
17.21 NA
11.11 NA
tU5 NA
18.4fl NA
19.91 NA
-·-----21.11 NA
21.27 NA
30.25 NA
31.10 NA
,,.. NA
34.42 NA
35.12 NA
3U2 NA
37.43 NA
32..57 NA
33.11 NA
:M.13 NA
35.49 NA
3''5 NA
30.31 NA
39.51 NA
40.51 NA
41.32 NA
......... .... ---23.13 NA
24.43 NA
25,0 NA
M.75 NA
21.21 NA
21.57 NA
30.77 NA
31.71 NA
32.58 NA
-'"· ----2,,0 NA
24.40 NA
25.21 NA
29.ll NA
27.55 NA
28.18 NA
21.18 NA
30.52 NA
31,19 NA
J1.n
27.14 NA
27.13 NA
21.44 NA
21.57 NA
30.79 NA
31.12 NA
32.12 NA
33.711 NA
:M,43 NA
-­.... --· -19.16 NA
20.35 NA
21.111 NA
22.29 NA
23.51 NA
24.64 NA
25.64 NA
21.41 NA
27.15 NA
12 32..15
1-4 33M
15 3-4.ll
11 3-4.79
17 35.25 .....
HI 311.08
_!2.,_ 3U9
35.51 ,._.,
38.11
37.10
37.51
38.03
38.-49
38.92
39.33
39.73
21.21
28.11
29.33
29'2
30,S
30.75
31.21
3UI
32.0S
32-"
23.75
2◄.15
2-4.53 ,. .. ,.,,
25.57
25.91
2U3
"·" ,..,
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
26.13
21.53
28111
27.27
27.11
27.95
21.29
21.11
21.Slt
29.,.
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
20.78
21.11
21.51
21.91
"-"
"-'' 22.9-4
"-" 23.51
23.85
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
31.71 ,.,, .... .. ..,
-41.18
-41.75
'2.30
-42.12 .. ,,,
-43.71
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
l>AHOl"OWEft
L.eVE..IZEDMTH
P'ftO~ OfrMJNE IN 202'
42.17 .,,,
-43.93
44.51
-45.07
"·" ◄I.HS
-.a.71 ..,.,.
-47.17
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
33'3
3"7
35.19
35.78
31.3< ,. ...
37.-45
3U7
38.◄7
31.M
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
32.32 ,, ...
3W
33.M
3'.32 ,.._,.
35.25
35.U .....
31.-49
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
..... ,. .. ,..,
37.10
37.S,
31.03
31,◄lil
31n
39.33
311.73
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
..... , ...... tw"A.I
28.28
21.11
29.33
29.12
3021
30.75
31.21
3U◄
32.05
32.'5
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
.....,._. tf.21 "'°MfVLNIINNr L.Jaltll.NIINNr .....,.LNIINNr L.Jaltll.NIINNr 1'1111 .....,.LNIINNr .... .__.,._ -,: -----➔t------+------+--------11--------,1--------t------t1-------+------+------a1 .......,. .,.,. 1'4.64)
2-4..93 ,. ...
27.21
2UI
29.llil
30 ..
3UO
32,-47
33 ..
10 33.51
11 3-4.12
12 3-4,5-4
1-4 JS.SO
15 31.08
11 31..5-4
17 31.llil
37.-41
37..11
~ 38.20
21.17 20.U
29.11 21..lilO
30.52 23.2-4
31.lilO 2-4.62
33.13 25.15
3-4.11 26.lilO
35.04 27.71
35.71 28.-43
38.21 29.00 ,...,
37.311
37.al
31.37
31.M
31U2
"·" -40.23
"·" -41.05
-41.44
295'
30.01
30.00 ,, ... ,, ... ....
32.00 .....
33>7
33.n
3-4.11
11.32
19.01
20.05
21.01
21.117
22.7-4
23.37
23.17 ,..,.
m•
"·" 25.-445
25.12
21.11 .... ,
2UI
21.19
27.50
27,79
21.06
_ ... , ---NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
....... ----20.71> NA
21.-45 NA
22.-43 NA
13.-4-4 NA
2-4.35 NA
25.12 NA
25.75 NA
21.25 NA
2t.87 NA
27.0I
21M ,, ....
21.20 ..... .....
29><
29'7
29,a
30.17
30.-41
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
15.35 NA
11.10 NA
17.0I NA
11.0lil NA
1lil.OO NA
11.n NA
20.«I NA
20-" NA
21.32 NA
21.71
22.11
22.◄lil
22.85
23.19 ,, ..
"" ,..,,
2-4.53
2-4.12
25.11
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
29n
31.13
32.73
"-" "·" 37.13
38.11
31-" "·" <0.30 ...... ..,.,.
-42.15
◄2.n .,.,. ..... .. .,, ....
'5.31 .......
........ -~
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
l>AHO l"OWEft
UVIUZIDMTH
,ttOJECTOfrMJNEINZO?A
------33.10 NA
35.01 NA
311.82 NA
38.28 NA
31.75 NA
-41,02 NA
-42.05 NA
-42.85 NA
<1.5< NA
-4-4,19
'"' "·" ....... .... oo
-47.18
-47,7-4 ....,,
-445,78 ... ,,
"·"
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
25.07 NA
2t.21 NA
27..19 NA
29.5< NA
31.02 NA
32.28 NA
33.31 NA
3-4.12 NA
3',0 NA
35A5 ,. ..
311.72
37.31
37..17
3'M
3'.00 ,. ....
"·" ..... ....
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
2-4.93 NA
25.... NA
27.21 NA
21.M NA
29.H NA
30.IM NA
31.10 NA
32.-47 NA
33.0-4 NA
33.51
3-4.12
"·" 35.13
35.SO
"-" 31.5< ,...
37.-41
37.11
31.,.
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
....... ----21.17 NA
29.18 NA
30.52 NA
31.lilO NA
33.13 NA
3-4.11 NA 35.. NA
35.71 NA
38.21 NA
31'2
37.31
37M
31>7 ......
39.32
38.78
<023 ......
◄1.(15
-41.44
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
...... , ...... in ..... 1 .._, ...... ,~ .._,,...."'""I
------20.tlil NA
21.lilO NA
23.2-4 NA
202 NA
25.15 NA
M.lilO NA
27.71 NA
21.-43 NA
29.00 NA
29.M
30.0I
30.00
31.0lil
31.56
32.0<
32.00
32.95
3337
33.n
3-4,16
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
ltlaw-" 17,11 "'°MfVLNIINNr IJlll,ILNIINNr PIii. .._,,,.LNIINNr UptLNIINNr 1'111 MN,,y-LNIINNr IJlllltl.NIIMNr E-,-,.,.---,.,-M-1➔1----:,"':,.="'cc,+-----,-=_,,....,=-+----,-=c_"'...,=-it----,,.,.cc.:,."''"',,-,t------=-=••,,.-t----,.,.cc..,.°',...,=-➔l-----=-=...,,,.-t----,-=_,,....,=-+----,-=c_"''"'=-il =M---=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
"
"
27.03 30.27 22.tlil 19.17 NA 22.25 NA 11.90 NA 32.-4-4 NA 31.32 NA 27.59 NA 27.Gl NA 30.27 NA 22.ilil NA
21.10 31,M 2-4.51 21.02 NA
30.11 33.35 21.07 22.13 NA
31.39 3-4.63 27.35 23.07 NA
32.-45 35.19 21.-41 23.15 NA
33.29 38.53 29.25 2-4.-47 NA
33" 37.17 2fl..U 2◄."4 NA
3-4.◄e n.ro J0.◄2 25.33 NA
3-4.tl 31.22 30.9-4 25.71 NA
35.50 31.7-4 31.4& 21.0SI NA
311.01 39.25 31.97 21.-47 NA
36.-49 39.73 32.-45 21.12 NA
23.-40
2-4.51
25.◄5 ,.,, .....
27.32
27.71 .....
21.◄ 7
2US
29.20
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
18.05
19.11
20.10
20.aa
21.50
21.117
22.36
22.7-4
23.12
23.50
23.15
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
"" 36.13
37.U
31.M
39.95
«1.71
''-'' -41.lil7
'2.00 .,,, .,_,.
NA
NA
NA
NA ..
NA ..
NA
NA
NA
NA
,.,,
.0.02
-41.55
42.13 .. ....
... oo
◄5.2◄ ......
-445.◄lil
◄7.10
-47.61
NA
NA
NA
NA ..
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
29A1
31.28
"-" ......
JS.10 ....
3UI
37.13
37.75
31.36
31.M
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
2UO
30.11
l1.3lil
32.-45
"-" 33'3
"·" ,.. ..
35.50
31.01
31.-49
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
31.1-4
33.35
"·" 3 .. ,
3'-53
37.17
37.70
31.22
31.7-4 ,,.,,
Jlil.73
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
2-4.56
2'.07
27.35
21.-41 ,..,.
"-'' 30.-42
30 ....
31.-445
3U7
32.-45
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
,,
" " " " " " ........l!_
.....
37M .,., ,.,, ..... ,.,, ..... .....
40.20 ,,., 21.17 NA ,..,
-10.U 33.40 27.52 NA ,. ...
41.11 33M 27.87 -30,S
◄1.11 ,...,, ,.,. -,. ..
42.04 34.71 21.52 NA 30.00
◄2,45 35.17 21.12 NA 31.20
◄2.8-4 .... 29.11 NA 31.49
43.23 .... ,._,. -31.77
NA 2'.20 NA -24.55 --24.90 --2523 --"·" --25.15 NA -211.14 --211.42 -
.. .,, NA .. ., NA .... NA .... NA .... NA ., ... NA
'7.52 NA
'7.01 NA
ICIAHOl"'Owat
liVIUZEDMTU
l"RO.-cT~ .. 2021
... ,. NA ,..,. NA ..... NA .. ,, NA ... .., -..... NA 37.44 -.... NA .. .,. NA '40.15 -37.92 -41.11 NA .. .., NA 41.19 NA 3U7 -41.11 NA ..... NA ◄1,71 NA .. ... -.... NA ..... -'2.20 NA 39.21 -42.45 NA
51.41 NA 42.17 NA ..... -., .. NA
51.87 -43.13 NA ..... -.,,, ..
u.,.._.~ ..... ,,.. ... ~ ..._,,._.._,'IJftl ..._,...,...111"'1
32.92 NA .... NA
33.le -,...,, -..... NA
35,17 NA ..... -"·" -
Maeww-..,. 17.2' PIii .....,.Lellll..._ UIMLNIII..._ 1"111 MlonrW.Nea UfNLNIII..._ 1"111 HHv\lLNII'-"' ....... I.NII .... __ ._ ------H----~-=..,=-l------:c..,.cc,-,c..,,,--+----,-=~..,=-ll----~..,.~,""'"',,--+-----=~•n,,--+----,..,.=,~..,=-l, 1------=c-=..,,,--tl----..,.=,~-,,..+---~...,=-=,I
....... ,,.,. ($4.MJ ...... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... -~=.=~-~-=-~~-~-=~I-=-=-=-=-=-=---=-=
12
" ,.
30.30 33.S4 M.21 22.27 NA 24.65 NA 19.30 NA ll.31 NA 40.24 NA 31.51 NA 30.30 NA 33.54 NA 2l.2t NA ,, ..
33.09
)UO ,..., ,..., ,. .. ,.,, ,. .. ,,.,.
37.83 ,.,.
"·n ,.,.
311.71
<t0.14 .... ..... .,.,.
JS.oe
31.33
37.34
3&.11
31.U
39.1◄
39.11
40.10 .....
41.07 .,..,
42.01
42.AII
42.95 .,.,.
27.10
29.05
30,0, ,.., ,,.,. ,, ... ,,,,
32.82
33>2
33.7' ,..,.
34.73 ,.,,
35.97
:M.10 ,...,
-NA = NA = NA -NA -NA -NA -NA -NA = NA -NA ~ NA = NA ~ NA = W. = NA ~ NA = NA -NA
-NA -NA -NA -NA -NA -NA -NA -NA -NA = NA -W. -W. = NA = W. -NA -NA = NA -NA -.. = .. -.. -.. -.. ~ .. = .. -.. = -~ NA = NA -W. -W. -NA = NA ~ W. = NA -NA 28.73 NA 29.11 NA 23.7& NA ◄US NA 47.53 NA 3U0 NA Je.37 NA 39.11 NA 32.33 NA
-NA -NA = W. -W. = NA -NA -W. -NA = NA
-NA -W. ~ W. = W. ~ W. -W. ~ W. -NA = W.
-NA -W. -NA -W. = NA -NA = NA = NA = NA = NA -NA = NA -NA -NA -NA -NA = NA = NA
-NA -NA -NA = NA -NA ~ NA = NA -NA = NA
-NA = NA -NA = NA -NA = NA = NA = NA = NA
-NA -NA = NA ~ NA = NA -NA ~ NA -NA -NA
-NA = NA -NA = NA -NA = NA -NA = NA ~ NA
-NA = NA -NA -• = NA = NA -W. -NA -NA = NA = NA = NA = NA -NA -NA -NA = NA -NA
-NA = NA = NA -NA = NA = -= NA -NA = NA .___1!!__ 41.74
.....
'4.20 ..... .....
,..,
37.31
37,70 -• -NA = NA -NA -NA = NA = NA ..... 37.70
...... , ..... .._p~ ..__,.,...._,1,..,.. ...... ,Ncl-a~
.....,._. 11.21 .... ................. lJllltLNII.... ....., ..... ..._ U.,.LNII._ 1"11111 ..._,..,_.._ UIMLNII..._ ---------11----~-= ... =,-+----~ ... "',""-,,--t----,-=~-=-ll----~ ... ~.""-,,--t-----=~ •• ,,..+---~ ... = .... ~. 1------=c-=0n=,-+-----=~-,,..+---~-=-=-;1 ........ $U4 jk.MJ .... .... w1H ..... w1H ...i __, wlN .... -~~.=~-c-=-~~-~-=~1-=-=-=-=---=-=-=-=
10
..
" "
33.51 36.75 2tA7 24..13 NA 27.01 NA 21.M NA 40.21 NA 44.10 NA 35.H NA 33.51 NA 38.75 NA 29.47 NA
MM 37.89 30.61 25.47 NA 27.15 NA 22.50 NA 41.58 NA <t5.47 NA 31.74 NA 34.M NA 37.U NA 30.11 NA
35.511 3&.11 31.53 28.15 NA 11.53 NA 23.11 NA 42M NA 48.58 NA 37.8-4 NA 35.58 NA 3&.t1 NA 31.53 NA
38.25 39.49 32.21 26.65 NA 29.03 NA 23.M NA 43.51 NA 47.39 NA 31,H NA 36.25 NA 39.49 NA 32.21 NA
311.n 39.N 32.68 26.99 NA 29.37 NA 24.02 NA 44.N NA 47.95 NA 39.21 NA 36.72 NA lt.N NA 32.M NA
37.12 40.3& JJ.N 27.21 NA 29.M NA 24.31 NA 44.54 NA 48.<43 NA 39.69 NA 37.U NA 40.36 NA 33.08 NA
37.55 '40,71 33.50 2UO NA 29.18 NA 24.13 NA 45.0S NA O .M NA 40.21 NA 37.55 NA «>.71 NA 33.SO NA
31,01 41.25 JU7 27.t,4 NA 30.32 NA 207 NA 45.62 NA 49.50 NA 40.77 NA l&.01 NA 41.25 NA lJ.97 NA
31.50 41.74 34M 21.29 NA 30.U NA 25.32 NA 46.20 NA 50.0I NA 41.35 NA 31.50 NA 41.74 NA 34.46 NA
31.M 42.20 34.92 2U4 NA 31.02 NA 25.87 NA 46.7ll NA 50.14 NA 41.111 NA 31.N NA 42.20 NA 34.92 NA
39.42 42.M 35.31 215.97 NA 31.35 NA a.oo NA 47.30 NA 51.19 NA 42.45 NA 39.42 NA 42.M NA 35.Je NA
39.91 43.15 35.17 29.33 NA 31.71 NA 2ll.J6 NA 47.19 NA 51.71 NA 43.04 NA Jt.91 NA 43.15 NA JS.17 NA
40.39 43.1,J Je.35 29.U NA 32.07 NA 2'.n NA 41.47 NA 52.Je NA 43.fi2 NA 40.Jt NA 43.IJ NA J&.JS NA
40Mi 44.10 Je.12 JO.OJ NA 32.41 NA 27.0fi NA 49.0J NA 52..92 NA 44.18 NA 40..M NA 44.10 NA 35.12 NA
41.31 44.54 37-26 J0.36 NA 32.74 NA 27.39 NA 49.57 NA 53.45 NA
41.73 44.97 37.69 J0.17 U.05 NA 27.70 NA 50.ot NA 53.N NA
44.72
45-23
NA NA 41.31
41.73
NA NA
.. .. .. ., NA NA 37-26
37.69
NA NA
w .
' 20
~-14
42.55 ., ... .,.,.
45.38
45.79
48.19
48.58
38.10 , .. , , .. , ,,.,.
30.97
31..27
31.57 ,. ...
NA
NA
NA
NA
,,.,.
33.65 ,, ... ,.,.
NA
NA
NA
NA
28.00
28.30
28.60 ,. .. NA
NA
NA
NA
5057
51.08 ..... ,,.,
NA
NA
NA
NA
...... .....
55.43 .....
NA
NA
NA
NA
45.72 .. ,,
4U9
47.18
NA
NA
NA
NA
42.14
42.55
42.95 .,,.
NA
NA
NA
NA
.. .,.
45.711
46.1'1 ....
NA
NA
NA
NA
38.10
38.51
38.91
39.30
NA
NA
NA
NA
Staff Published Rate Analysis• Difference between IRP·based Rates and
Published Rates using Company's IRP-based calculations from Compliance
FIiing. The capacity Price comparison Is for year 2029.
l Surroaate
2 Annual Peak Hours -IPC Complia~ Filing (hrs)
3 Ulpita1 Cost {$/kw/month)
4 Fixed O&M j$/kw/month}
5 Cost of Surrogate ($/kw/month)
6 Cost of Surrogate ($/kw/year)
7 Nameplate Capacity (kW)
8 Peak-hour Ca ad Factor
9 Effective capacity at peak (kw)
11 Annual Avoided Cost ($/year)
12 QF Generation during Peak Hours (kwh)
13 Year 2029 Capacity Price ($/kwh)
14 Difference between Scenario 2a and Scenario 2
15 Difference between Scenario la and Scenario 1
16 Difference between Scenario lb and Scenario 1
17 Difference between Scenario 2 and Scenario la
18 Total Difference between IRP and SAR (Difference between Scenario 2 and Scenario l)
19 Percent contribution of the total difference
Scenario 1: IRP-based Scenario -Scenario la: !RP-based Scenario lb: IRP-bued Scenario 2: SAR-based Scenario 2■: SAR-based
Example from Company's Scenario • Replilce 2017 IRP Scenario • Replace QF Annu•I Scenario -SAR-bas@d cccr Scenario -Published Rate
Compllance Filing for Year 2029 SCCT Surrogate with SAR-based Generation durfn1 Peak Hours Surrogate -QF Generation CCCT Surrogate• Different
(SCCT Surrogate from 2017 IRP • CCCT Surrogilte
QF Generation during Peak Hours
based on aeneratlon profile)
seer
434
8.64
2.04
10.68
128.16
20000
0.84
16800
2,153,088
8339000
$
Is o.2s82 is
Is
for genen1t1on based on during Peak Hours calculated Peak-hour Capadty Factor.
generation profile with value using Nameplate Capacity,
calculated using Nameplate Peak Hour Capacity Factor, and
Capacity, Peak Hour Capacity Annual Peak Hours.
Factor, and Annual Peak Hours.
CCCT SCCCT CCCT CCCT
434 434 434 434
14.32 8.64 14.32 14.32
1.84 2.04 1.84 1.84
16.16 10.68 16.16 16.16
193.95 128.16 193.95 193.95
20000 20000 20000 20000
0.84 0.84 0.84
16800 16800 16800 20000
3,258,378 $ 2,153,088 $ 3,258,378 $ 3,879,022
8339000 7291200 7291200 8680000
o.3907 is 0.2953 1 $ 0.4469 1 $ 0.4469 1
0.1325 I$
0.0371 1~ 0.0562 1
0.1887
'"" 30%
NOie I The Qf .,...•lion durlncpe•k houn lor tN lRP-memod (Sun•rio I •nd h)UMS tM •mount of -•lion duri"I peak hours,., lhe,.._•llon profile t,....,, the lb.I,..,,.. 11..d ;., tile Cotnp&r,y",c«npla""• fill,,.;
Hol•2: TI,eQF....-•llondurln&PHkHourslr\Sc-rlolb,2and2•1tcalculatadbymul!lplyl,.lheNamaplai.Capo,ciTybythePnk-hourcal)Kltyfac1orandbylheAnn,..IPNkHoun.
Nola 3: n.. S,U...,.t:hod Cal)Klty Pnc<II Jn Scanarlo 2 don not chantt ,..-rdlt-uol tht paak-tk>ur capacity lac1or whk:h IJ •lustratad by lhed(ffwenc:a i..a.,..,.. Sc ...... rlo 2 and la. n.. puk-ft<>Ur capad!y IKl<>f ca""ail out whan dat«mr.,!n1Clpacl!yPtlul Jlnca II: is uMd •• • mult!pliat tod•*min• lhe Annu•l Avoided Cos! (Ina nu....,•10< of the Clpaclt-.
Prk:• lf'Qllflion) •"d IJtllC u..d Ha multlpUer to detatmin• lh•CIF JeM<•tlon durln1Pnk Houn (tha"-<>m!nalor of!M Capaaiy Prtu equaliclf>).
Att.lchmentC
IPC-E-20-02