20180516Reply Comments.pdf

38ffi*@
An IDACORP Company
RECEIVED
?$r$F1AY 16 P?{ h:32
DONOVAN E. WALKER
Lead Counsel
[e-mail]
i:-''::'r- ' l-'El-lQ
-r ,: '=."r :, : 1';,,1;JiilSSl0N
May 16,2018
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Diane M. Hanian, Secretary
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
Re Case No. IPC-E-18-02
Fixed Cost Adjustment Rates for June 1,2018, through May 31 ,2019
ldaho Power Company's Reply Comments
Dear Ms. Hanian
Enclosed for filing in the above matter please find an original and seven (7) copies
of ldaho Power Company's Reply Comments.
Very truly yours,
Donovan E. Walker
DEW/KKT
Enclosures
P.O. Box 70 (83707)
1221 W. ldaho St.
Boise, lD 83702
tu
DONOVAN E. WALKER (!SB No. 5921)
ldaho Power Company
1221West ldaho Street (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, ldaho 83707
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
dwalker@ idahopower. com
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
REC T IVED
tfil$Fl.$Y l6 PH lr:32
.'\fl\Ji{
i :''.,, .rtu$LICl':,l '-1ilh{}'{lSS
IN THE MATTER OF IDAHO POWER
COMPANY'S APPLICATION FOR
AUTHORITY TO IMPLEMENT FIXED COST
ADJUSTMENT RATES FOR SERVICE
FROM JUNE 1,2018, THROUGH MAY 31,
2019.
CASE NO. IPC-E-18-02
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S
REPLY COMMENTS
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
On March 15,2018, ldaho Power Company ("ldaho Power" or "Company") applied
to the ldaho Public Utilities Commission ("Commission") for an order allowing the
Company to decrease its Fixed Cost Adjustment ("FCA") rates for electric service
provided from June 1,2018, through May 31 ,2019. The Company respectfully submits
the following Reply Comments in response to Comments filed by the Commission Staff
("Staff') on May 10,2018.
CORRECTED DEFERRAL BALANCE
As identified on page 2 of Staff's Comments, subsequent to filing its application in
this case, the Company identified a formula error in the spreadsheet used to produce
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 1
Exhibit No. 4 of Company witness Mr. Goralski. With these Reply Comments, the
Company is providing corrected exhibits which remove the inadvertent double-counting
of the year end adjustment in the previously submitted Exhibit No. 4. The error from
Exhibit No. 4 impacted Exhibit Nos. 5 and 6; therefore, all three corrected exhibits are
included with these Reply Comments. The proposed FCA deferral balance, FCA rates,
and billed revenue impact in Exhibits No. 4-6 match the "Updated" column values in the
side-by-side comparison cited in Attachment A included as part of Staff's comments. As
corrected, the total FCA balance the Company is proposing to collect from the Residential
and Small General Service customers is $15,606,711, a decrease of $19,405,331 from
the current FCA deferral balance. The resulting rates are .2923 cents per kilowatt-hour
('kwh") for Residential customers and .3679 cents per kWh for Small General Service
customers.
REQUEST FOR RELIEF
The Company requests that the Commission approve the corrected FCA balance
of $15,606,711 and resulting corrected rates of .2923 cents per kWh for Residential
customers and .3679 cents per kWh for Small General Service customers to become
effective June 1 ,2018.
Upon receipt of a Commission Order, the Company will submit a compliance filing
with an updated Schedule 54.
Respectfully submitted this 16th day of May 2018.
DO E R
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 2
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 16th day of May 2018 I served a true and correct
copy of IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS upon the following named
parties by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following:
Commission Staff
Edith Pacillo
Deputy Attorney General
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington (83702)
P.O. Box 83720
Boise, ldaho 83720-007 4
Hand Delivered
_U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
Kim T
o
Executive Assistant
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 3
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
GASE NO. IPC.E.18.02
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
GORALSKI, DI
TESTIMONY
CORRECTED EXHIBIT NO.4
CORRECTED
Exhibit No. 4
Case No. IPC-E-18-02
P. Goralski, IPC
Page 1 of2
ooo
o
o
ciN.!
@ul
oc
-9
oq
F
N"
tso-
F
s
@co
qo
ts-
Fq
o-oN
tsq
N@@-
o-
oqo@o-N@
oq
I
oq
@o-
F
.i@o
;e
@co
q
o f,
o-c?
ts
Nq
FNqo@U?
@
c?ooc!tsoq
octsN1
a
oq
@.
o
oN.
oDE
oo@
oq
ry
oq
oqoq
oqoNN-
@6-
@-
s
@qo
\
N"
@
ts
@o{-
@No-
oq
FoF.oo
oq
q
oqo@o"
N@
@q
@
s
oco
@a 6i@o
6iNa?
@
tsol
@N\
@q
@:NNry
ts
oqoq
@@@
oco
@-
o
No-
o
lo
oqoq
Na
eoo
o
oq
q
ooq
c!
@
o
s
6qo
oc!
@NF.o@
aN
ooo_
oq
Fo@-o@o
oqoo
N
ocNoN.o
I s
@qo
q?
oN
@q
@
@
@q
I
o
oq
@
$-oo
6l
@@c,lo
6
oqooao@
oqoo
N
\
o-
.:-
oq
N\
Na
oq
oq
oIoq
tsa
u?o
6-
so
6qo
tsq
o
q
o
o!
ots"
69"
oc
oo-
@oN
oq
q
oq
F
@-
q
o
s
oqo
q 6i o;
o?
c?
N\oq
Nc
<2oq
oc
o
o!
o oloo
@_
I c
oq
@
ryoq
oq
NN.
N!-
r:
F
s
6qo
@
$-
q?o
@-
ul
@o-o
s-
@
oqo
o-
@@
oq
\
oq
oo-
oN
ts
@
s
oqo
oe@
Noq
o
oqN6
do
@a?
N\@N\@
Nr:ooq
o
oc@
o,lo@c2
oc6
F.oo
N\oo@-
o
oq
N
c!
Nq
oq
N
c!
..,{
oqoNu2
e?
-
No_
s
@co
oq
@
\N \@@@-
6
oqo
@-o
oqo\
o:
o-
@
ts
@
s
6q
o
qo
Fc o1
@a!
@@
q
Nts
u?
oa
oa
c?
oq
N@c!
@ry
oco
F.
@@
oa
6v-
o
oq
No
oq
@
.2
ocN
IN@q
@N.
N
s
qo
ts
N
<i
o_
@.qoNN.o
q
o-o
oc
N
oco
@-o
ts
N
s
@qo
oqo ts
N@
o.!
@
ao
tsFq6N
ts
^l@ts\
q?
oq
a@Fc?
oo
@.ots
\
q
q
n
oq
0q
oq
ocl s
o@co
o
@-
a
N.@o-
@
oq
N
N.
No
q
r!
N
@
N
s
@qo
\N
oq
@Nq
@oq
oq
NoN.
N
@ao
o_o@ F
C
aG
ooL
o
N
o
o
N:
o
q
N-
so
@co
oc?
o
o
o
o
N
o-
NN-
N
oq
q
oq
r!
N
o
N
N.
No
s
ci
@
N N
alo@q
Fo
@qts
ryoN
.i
@cFtsu1
ory
oc6Na
.:
oc
d.
ts
@
N
o
aofco
o
o.
oo-
oq
6.
N
o.
s
@q
oq
r
o-
oq
q
aq
o-
so
@co
q
c2
oo
oqo
q
oq
ou1
F
o-
oq
@
o_
@
E
oaod>
o
=
oE
!
E
oo
E
,!r
F
o
o
EooooEooco
Go
oc
tor
E
coE
od
o
go@
c'-
.=do@
o
ooo
c,oe
o
6@
,EEcU
!
o
os
Eco
o
r5
i6
s
G)c
o
Gd
Eo
;Ec
ou!
=oo
;
-co
o
!o
oJ
o
ooc
<()r
E
p
d
d
oF
toI
o,9Ioo
o
oo
Geo
ooc
-go@
E
6o
Eo
ooo
C
oe
o
!6@o,EEcU
!
c
co
=,-
E
Gf
s
6fcC
ooE
oos
t
o
U
Bs
ooc
.>cco
o
G
!ol
ooc
<oro.9too
o
oo
Eo
oF
oE
6f
6
o!o.Ir
EoF
o
c
No
N
No
6
ooo
ooooxoo
ooo
ooo
ooooxoo
o
N
ooo
oo
ox
o
o
oo
N
ooo
ooooxoo
€C c c o c G o
CORRECTED
Exhibit No. 4
Case No. IPC-E-18-02
P. Goralski, IPC
Page2 ol2
toF
6(,
oq
NNo_
o@_
q
NF6"
o
q
l-
N.
oqo
a
@
a
Nr:
@a
.,1oN6
oI\@oq
octsNo!
oq
oo{-
@
o
oo
o
oq
FNo-
o
@_
ocNNo-
o@-
@.!
o-N@
s
@Io
@a?
@
N.
N
q
Ntso-
o
qoot-
@@F.
oqo
s-
@
oqo
s-
o
o-co
a@N
@1Nr\
@a
.!o
6
q
@
ol
N
@
@
o-
N
F
oq
F
o-
o@-
ocN
o-
o@-
@oq
oo-ots
s
@eo
@c?
@
N.
@6l
o_N@
@6!
@N.
FF.
oqo
l-
@
o
oi
s_
6
oq
t_
s
@qo ts@
o
oo
o
o
q
@
q
N
@
N
a E
oqtsNo-
@-
oqtsNo-
@-
ovl
F
@-N
s
o@qo
@
6i
N-
q
o
o
@q
NNo-
N.
oqo
9-
@
oqo
s-
ts
N
N.
s
@co @
oq
a
oq
oq
q
@q @
o-
a
tol
oI
oq
No-
o@-
oq
N
o-
o@-
N:o
@-
s
@qo
@
d
N.
N
oql
F
@-
N
oq?
@ts"o
F-
oqo
$-
@
oIo
l-
@
\6
o-
s
@qo
.qots
r
N\
N-@N
<;
@
q
@
ot
N
@
@
o
N
ao
o
oq
N
o-
o
@-
oqN
o"
o@_
Nc;6
o
s
@co
6
d
N.
N
N
oi
@-
6
oc
@
oqo
{_
@
c?o@o-
s
o@
c;
a@F@
\@
ai
\tsoaN
@
6
@
N
a
ocNNo-
o@-
oq
NNo-
o@-
\o6o-
r:o
o-
\No
6N\
oqoo9
@
oqo
9-
@
o@
N
o
c'l
C?o
oq
@
@
crN
N
o-
cts
o"
oF
o-
o
oqo
t-
@
q
@ts-
o
coE,
oq
tso-
@@o-
oq
q
oq
FNo-
o@-
s
@co
oqoN@^
@
oqo
oqo
s_
@
s
6qo
oqoi-
@
o
<i@o"
@o6-
o
o_
o
oq
o_
No
oqo@o
2
o!
Eo
@o
oc
N
o-
@
oq
q
I
oq
ro-
o-
o?o
o-
N
s
oqo
F\
@s-
N
\o@
o
oq
N
d
@
ocN
N
N
ocoNoq
@cNq
s
qo
N
@
e?o@c?
o
N.
@
q
@-
6
s-
oqN
l-tsoN.
oq
N@@-
@-
oq
F
N.r@
oc@oa6
ooEooz
oIN
N.
tso-
q
I
q
oc
N@o-6
Fq
o-o
s
6co
o
Nq
No!o
o-
Fo!
o!
ool
o
@q
F
oc
6iN
oq
N
ci
@
o?
@c?
so
@qo
o
<iF
q
@-
@q
No-ts
@
o
@o':
@"
o!@@
6iNo-
oq
@e-
oo"
o
Nts
c c (q €o C c o
I
d
l
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
GASE NO. IPC-E -19-02
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
GORALSKI, DI
TESTIMONY
GORRECTED EXHIBIT NO.5
CORRECTED
Exhibit No. 5
Case No. IPC-E-18-02
P. Goralski, IPC
Page 1 of 1
xstq
(!.)
a(oto.Robo=sgsro{.^ d,oodo
oao
oot0l!
co
oolo-Catoii>coGJCELo8pi5s3GT!6 Go=v=3<o
or
rr1(r1
rnotoiH{/}
tY!tY! o.gOE,11
LooOIO otl- t!
^gELOo,HT Eo-o9d5EPEoE()roic
fiEEcog E.=odE 3iX L(Jurrr
Nd$dON.'i ddOo. (o.rn Lnmd14 lli
>RF-nm
oqo
o
F\.do\ort
@
@\o.o
cnF\@
e.io.s@
@(f)o.
l\'F\o.
cno(f)r)
o-
N<io\ort
a+
o.9
?ov1
ELE ttE.E P8=r.;qEotsoOE ttt l)
60)N l'\
NOoo
<i ci.J\ <rt
xlRFF.1 nfftm
1-Sqqco@NNco@c'i c.i
(.) (t@8
@N9aF\ (,N@e) c)o.doo
-tOr:' s+
-@
\o-\oo.o(]oon@o.@o..d ril'\ -$t46
N.oo(r)
-@c.i utr)N(f).ori F-.O(f)
r)'
.<f.o9aCN-CN-3N.d ctcoNl.\ CO+t+
-q
tl,
oe,
Eg*ocdot-uEb9L5
tUtE=
ll,
o
irO(,o{,
il8
0,oPsfl
!!a9bEELqoz
3-9
E,EP<Ur
tl9l6lc,l-ItrloJ
El#.E lEE IEE13rlEo lEEls
L'II!L
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIG UTILITIES COMMISSION
GASE NO. IPC-E-18-02
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
GORALSKI, DI
TESTIMONY
CORRECTED EXHIBIT NO.6
Nqo
so\o
@@9\
ON
o$O\t$_ o-NO
o- o-SNN-q@
noaiN@
@NN@riooo
$@oo@- o-@oN@N_ O-ON
q
ss-.s.6'* 6'q\5\
oocoE(-)
cooo(I
tsetE3;b
N$OOoo6No- -- @-$@oO-@
o
@@@NNONriciq-oooo
ONONNO@No- @- N-NNONNNosN
-_6 N
o@
orHl.lEpl
olrlclol
ol
ozl
<l
BI
-tolo-l
Eg
m
o
E*dl
oq
No
@$-N@o-
so
@
@No-oN
Nodo
Nood
N.i@
€
orNo.iodl
6@
vo@-o
$oa-o$$
@ooo@oe*ONo'j ^i
Je oiN66
tE sr
tsE gI
i.odl
Ic- ol
Eg#EI-3e&l
rl
BI
-tolo_l
*aloool
EE PI
rsEl
o5
o
od,t
-g9=8oEtt!ooP
oYao.d,9?o>EE9EOEt;E
o
to:(,
EG>9 =C E .LOo- 9-ooFocfo-N65€3.;? A ! e-:
:E;EEa- E i!o-o.96uIEl o.,::6! x:-Ef;i*
Eo
oftro
otrEg
in
o
o
EcEt()
oE'6
troo
oo-
N@ooF@
NOONo@rtN@o
o
o*ooo@NN- o- otooNN$N-NOair .jON
o
oo =t= oi
E E5I6 ru :lz
-OOO@NONN
$-s
NN
$N
NN
@N
oo
oFEo
6
o
o
o
oN
6
moN.iocl
3
N o,cao,U)Eoco(,
oEo c')OE';c
bocD .g6cb*bc,o&
6Gtro.DF
o@
:<r!9>rooo=o
= >oiEd,oPEEtUFoooo.9>.9.92sllooooura@o
ooo6E=EE
o-.Looagp!
o-Q o ou>dt
clolql
ol8l ElEl 6lhl dl
FI tsI,EI
6lFl
trlEIol
=tsl
o;6 o!ltazl
CORRECTED
Exhibit No. 6
Case No. IPC-E-18-02
P. Goralski, IPC
Page 1 of 1
oc:olzl