20141121Initial Comments.pdf

SEffi*.
An IDACORP Companv
fii-r1 l- j\. -ii.:r.'r:i.
?illtl l{0Y 20 Pl,l 5: 0l+
l [),,i :-ii.r ' .- , - ,1r'iil l"i't!-:' f.r'll,i' lri,,tr; r iLi ii,--.,; r../r--il ,r:,.\r,-.1-,,
DONOVAN E. WALKER
Lead Gounsel
dwal ker@i dahopower.com
November 20,2014
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Jean D. Jewell, Secretary
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
Re: Gase No. IPC-E-14-36
Orchard Ranch Solar, LLC - Idaho Power Company's lnitial Comments
Dear Ms. Jewell:
Enclosed for filing please find an original and seven (7) copies of ldaho Power
Company's lnitial Comments in the above matter.
DEW:csb
Enclosures
1221 W. ldaho St. (83702)
PO. Box 70
Boise, lD 83707
Yeryffily youls,
Onovan E. Walker
DONOVAN E. WALKER (lSB No. 5921)
ldaho Power Company
1221West ldaho Street (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, Idaho 83707
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
dwalker@ id ahopower. com
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION
OF IDAHO POWER COMPANY FOR
APPROVAL OR REJECTION OF AN
ENERGY SALES AGREEMENT WITH
ORCHARD RANCH SOLAR, LLC FOR THE
SALE AND PURCHASE OF ELECTRIC
ENERGY.
FIlli;1
?cll, FiOi 20
il^rl ,
I i-irr l'iti,-i: -
Irl,? 5: firr.
r1tr,.,..,
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
CASE NO. |PC-E-14-36
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S
INITIAL COMMENTS
Idaho Power Company ("ldaho Powe/' or "Company") hereby respectfully
submits the following lnitial Comments to the Idaho Public Utilities Commission
("Commission") in the above-referenced matter:
1. The Comments of the Commission Staff ("Staff') from Case No.
IPC-E-14-19 (Grand View Solar) and Case No. IPC-E-14-20 (Boise City Solar)
recommended that the rates contained in the Energy Sales Agreement ("ESA") between
ldaho Power and each solar qualifying facility ('QF') be revised to account for energy
cost computation issues identified by Staff. Staff recommended two modifications,
related to assumptions about the fuel forecast and assumptions about displaceable
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S INITIAL COMMENTS - 1
resources, to the computation of avoided cost rates utilized by the approved
Incremental Cost lntegrated Resource Plan Methodology. ldaho Power incorporated
Staffs recommended adjustments into the model, and submitted replacement pricing for
each ESA. Each QF agreed to replace the pricing in its respective ESA with the
replacement pricing that incorporated the revisions recommended by Staff. The
Commission then subsequently approved each modified ESA containing the
replacement pricing. Order No. 33179 (Grand View Solar); Order No. 33180 (Boise City
Solar).
2. Orchard Ranch Solar, LLC, has requested that ldaho Power re-run the
pricing contained in its ESA to incorporate Staffs recommended adjustments from the
Grand View Solar and Boise City Solar cases. ldaho Power has revised the rates in
Orchard Ranch Solar, LLC's ESA to incorporate Staffs recommended adjustments.
ldaho Power has generated a Replacement Appendix E to the ESA which contains the
revised prices. The Replacement Appendix E is submitted herewith as Attachment 1 in
both clean and redlined format. Additionally, included as Attachmenl2, in both clean
and redlined format, is a replacement page of the ESA that contains a correction to
reflect the proper county location of the project.
3. For comparison purposes, the 2O-year levelized rate for the ESA as
originally submitted is $62.67/megawatt-hour ('MWh') and the rate from the
Replacement Appendix E is $62.21lMWh. The estimated 2O-year contractual obligation
based upon the originally submitted prices is $63,565,295 and the estimated 2O-year
contractual obligation with the revised prices is $63,325,585. The levelized integration
charge contained in the ESA is the same in both instances at $5.05/MWh.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S INITIAL COMMENTS - 2
4. ldaho Power is not cunently aware of whether Orchard Ranch Solar, LLC,
agrees to adopt the Replacement Appendix E which incorponates Staffs rccommended
changes to the pricing model.
Respectfully submitted this 20h day of November 2014.
DONOVAN E. WALKER
Attomey for ldaho Power Company
IDAHO POWER COMPAT.IYS INITIAL COMMENTS - 3
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 20s day of November 20141 served a true and
conect copy of IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S lNlTlAL COMMENTS upon the following
named parties by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following:
Commission Staff
Kristine A. Sasser
Deputy Attomey General
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington (83702)
P.O. Box 83720
Boise, ldaho 83720-007 4
Orchard Ranch Solar, LLG
Ron Williams
Williams Bradbury, P.C
1015 West Hays Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
Ben Fairbanks
Director, Development
First Wind
X Hand Delivered
_U.S. Mail
Overnight Mail
FAXX Email [e-mail]
Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
_Hand Delivered
U.S. Mail
Ovemight Mail
FAXX Email [e-mail]
Christa Bearry, Legal Assistant
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S INITIAL COMMENTS - 4
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES GOMMISSION
GASE NO. IPG-E-I4-36
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
ATTACHMENT 1
GLEAN FORMAT
E-1
REPLACEMENT APPENDX E
SOLAR FACILITY ENERGY PRICES AND INTEGRATION CHARGES
(Prices based upon the energy shape and capacity specified in Appendix H)
Base Enerev Purchase Prices - For all Base Energy received during Heavy Load Hours Idaho
Power shall pay the Base Energy Heavy Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge
specified below and for all Base Energy received during Light Load Hours Idaho Power shall pay
the Base Energy Light Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge specifred below. All
of these prices are subject to revision as specified within paragraph7.4.
Base Energy Heavy
Load Purchase PriceMonth/Year (Mills/kWh)
Jan-16 $33.38
Feb-16 S33.37
Mar-16 527.11
Apr-16 52352
May-16 $26.12
Jun-16 $26.18
Jul-16 $37.82
Aug-16 $39.99
Sep-16 $33.43
Oct-16 $30.31
Nov-16 $35.31
Dec-16 $35.45
Jan-17 $34.11
Feb-17 $33.14
Mar-17 $30.03
Apr-17 524.47
May-17 $23.72
Jun-17 S20.13
Jul-17 538.10
Aug-17 S41.45
Sep-17 $32.88
Oct-17 $33.49
Nov-17 537.15
Dec-17 $38.21
Jan-18 534.62
Feb-18 $37.78
Base Energy Light Solar Integration
Load Purchase Price Charge(Mills&Wh) (Mills/kWh)
$32.23
$3 I .13
$25.15
$18.49
$19.63
$1s.82
$33.67
s36.22
$28.77
$29.01
$34.s r
$35.31
$30.3s
$32.98
$19.94
$8.43
$15.6s
s8.08
$33.60
s37.s7
$31.71
s33.66
s37.07
$37.9s
$35.04
$31.71
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.0r
$4.01
s4.01
$4.01
$4.01
s4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.2s
$4.25
50
Mar-I8
Apr-I8
May-18
Jun-18
Jul-18
Aug-18
Sep-18
Oct-18
Nov-18
Dec-18
Jan-19
Feb-19
Mar-19
Apr-19
May-19
Jun-19
Jul-19
Aug-19
Sep-19
Oct-19
Nov-19
Dec-19
Jan-20
Feb-20
Mar-20
Apr-20
May-20
Jun-20
Jul-20
Aug-20
Sep-20
Oct-20
Nov-20
Dec-20
Jan-21
Feb-21
Mar-21
Apr-21
May-21
Jun-21
Jul-21
Aug-21
Sep-21
Oct-21
Nov-21
Dec-21
Jar22
$31.04
$26.s7
s27.02
$27.50
$40.s7
$44.66
$36.69
$37.t7
$40.89
$42.15
$37.40
s40.96
s34.93
s24.78
$23.99
s26.97
$41.78
s45.43
$39.07
s39.34
$43.s0
$44.73
$43.rs
$40.23
$24.41
s23.s7
$22.61
$26.t4
$43.72
$47.37
$38.20
$39.79
s46.13
$47.48
$46.06
$44.00
$33.r2
$26.38
$26.37
$29.20
$71.r7
$74.90
$6s.84
$66.s0
$74.30
$76.00
s'73.34
szt.60
$26.48
$26.4s
$12.60
$40.13
$39.s8
$36.16
$37.78
$40.31
$41.91
$32.3s
s29.6r
$27.10
$24.31
$23.0s
s23.10
s40.02
s40.80
s38.33
$39.28
$43.08
$44.64
$38.41
s30.3 r
$23.86
$23.40
$2 r.98
s23.80
s42.s3
$41.62
s32.03
$39.35
$4s.16
$47.48
$43.64
$35.21
s29.24
s2s.sl
s25.5r
$26.00
$68.s9
s68.80
$63.28
s65.91
$73.45
s76.00
$69.25
$4.2s
s4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
$4.38
s4.38
s4.51
s4.s1
$4.s1
$4.s1
s4.51
$4.s1
$4.s1
$4.51
s4.sl
$4.s1
$4.51
s4.sl
s4.64
s4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
s4.64
$4.64
84.64
s4.64
$4.64
s4.78
5l
Feb-22
i&'dar-22
Apr-22
May-22
Jwr-22
Jd-22
Aug-22
Sep-22
Oct-22
Nov-22
Dec-22
Jan-23
Feb-23
Mar-23
Apr-23
May-23
Jun-23
Jul-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
ivday-24
hn-24
Jul-24
Att'g-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Jan-25
Feb-25
Mar-25
Apr-25
May-25
Jun-25
Jul-25
Aug-25
Sep-25
Oct-25
Nov-25
Dec-25
s75.21
$60.78
$s8.21
$56.42
s59.32
$73.86
s78.27
$69.33
$68.76
$78.86
$80.45
$75.40
$78.30
$66.1I
$s8.47
ss7.72
$s9.60
$76.83
$81.31
$71.91
$70.34
$83.16
$84.61
$8s.21
$82.36
s67.49
$s9.31
$s8.72
$59.14
$81.8 r
$90.8s
s72.81
s7l.75
$86.73
$88.40
$89.30
$87.37
$79.12
$58.s2
$62.92
$64.r6
$86.66
$94.30
$7s.34
$73.48
$90.28
s92.99
s71.83
s59.e0
$ss.39
sss.31
$53.14
$72.76
$71.82
$67.61
s68.76
$78.s9
$80.64
$70.78
$71.7s
$62.3s
$s7.r4
$s6.61
$s6.76
s74.s4
$7s.02
$70.s9
$70.34
$82.28
$84.7s
$81.70
s77.66
$68.02
$57.33
$ss.s3
$57.36
$80.14
$77.74
s73.43
$71.7s
$85.31
s88.40
$89.1 5
$80.33
$67.r7
$s5.71
ss9.77
$s7.ss
$80.s6
$79.27
$73.69
s73.48
$90.23
$92.32
s4.78
$4.78
s4.78
s4.78
$4.78
$4.78
s4.78
$4.78
$4.78
s4.78
$4.78
$4.93
s4.93
$4.93
s4.93
s4.93
$4.93
$4.93
$4.93
$4.93
$4.93
$4.93
s4.93
$5.07
$s.07
$s.07
ss.07
ss.07
$s.07
$s.07
$s.07
$s.07
$s.07
ss.07
$s.07
$s.23
ss.23
$5.23
$s.23
$5.23
$s.23
$s.23
$s.23
ss.23
$s.23
$s.23
$s.23
52
Jarr26
Feb-26
Mar-26
Apr-26
May-26
Jun-26
Jul-26
Aug-26
Sep-26
Oct-26
Nov-26
Dec-26
Ja*27
Feb-27
Mar27
Apr-27
May-27
Jvn-27
Jul-27
Ang-27
Sep-27
Oct-27
Nov-27
Dec-27
Jan-28
Feb-28
Mar-28
Apr-28
May-28
Jun-28
Jul-28
Aug-28
Sep-28
Oct-28
Nov-28
Dec-28
Jan-29
Feb-29
Mar-29
Apr-29
May-29
Jun-29
Jtrl-29
Aug-29
Sep-29
Oct-29
Nov-29
$92.67
$91.13
$67.10
$62.73
s63.92
s64.64
$88.87
$9s.2s
s78.52
$75.54
$94.s7
$97.83
$94.99
$93.99
$8r.s7
$69.00
s65.50
$70.32
$91.4s
$99.04
s81.46
$77.97
$97.88
sl01.43
$99.90
$97.7t
$72.s6
$68.63
s77.67
$74.98
$9s.71
$102.10
$84.97
$80.70
$103.s9
$r07.30
$101.76
$101.54
$77.5s
s7l.l8
$79.63
s71.13
$96.07
$r05.86
$90.07
$83.16
s10s.99
$91.62
$87. l 5
$60.r7
$60.38
$s9.61
$62.26
s82.42
$82.2s
$77.|s
$75.54
$91.71
$97.34
$90.r4
$88.9s
$68.45
s62.82
$65.12
$67.54
$84.98
$86.26
$79.84
$77.90
$97.06
$r02.1I
$89.26
$91.84
$72.7s
$68.43
$77.82
$72.12
$88.79
$89.42
$83.76
$80.58
$10r.64
$r0s.8r
$93.78
$97.24
$70.92
$66.39
$78.26
$65.18
$89.61
$91.27
s87.09
$83.06
sl06.l9
ss.38
$s.38
$s.38
$s.38
ss.38
ss.38
$5.38
ss.38
s5.38
$s.38
$s.38
ss.38
$s.s5
$5.55
$s.s5
$s.s5
$s.5s
$5.55
$s.ss
ss.ss
$5.ss
$5.5s
ss.ss
ss.5s
ss.71
$5.71
ss.71
ss.71
$5.71
ss.71
$s.71
ss.71
$5.71
$5.71
$s.71
$s.71
ss.88
$s.88
ss.88
$s.88
ss.88
s5.88
ss.88
$s.88
$s.88
$5.88
ss.88
53
Dec-29
Jan-30
Feb-30
Mar-30
Apr-30
May-30
Jun-30
Jul-30
Aug-30
Sep-30
Oct-30
Nov-30
Dec-30
Jan-31
Feb-31
Mar-31
Apr-31
May-31
Jun-31
Jul-31
Aug-31
Sep-31
Oct-31
Nov-31
Dec-31
Ja*32
Feb-32
Mar-32
Apr-32
May-32
Jun-32
Jul-32
Aug-32
Sep-32
Oct-32
Nov-32
Dec-32
Jan-33
Feb-33
Mar-33
Apr-33
May-33
Jun-33
Jul-33
Aug-33
Sep-33
Oct-33
$r 10.91
$10s.41
$104.15
$80.75
$65.8s
$66.60
s78.r5
$e9.5s
$r07.21
$93.89
$86.19
$110.25
$114.61
$112.43
$r09.72
$9s.19
s7 r.87
s78.82
s86.7s
s109.0r
$113.45
$106.79
s91.94
$117.91
$128.92
$117.02
s114.90
s86.65
$82.21
$90.73
$90.38
sl 14.31
s1r7.86
$109.00
$95.27
$r26.18
$131.01
$l19.94
$117.76
$88.66
s84.08
$92.86
$92.50
$117.1s
$120.81
$1 r 1.68
$97.s4
$108.21
$99.s0
$e8.99
$77.09
$64.35
$64.16
$77.5s
$9s.37
$9s.8s
$91.80
$85.98
$r07.26
s112.06
s102.04
$99.70
$8s.89
$68.18
$70.39
$83.42
$99.86
$103.00
$r00.46
$89.36
$116.42
9122.29
$106.07
$102.36
$81.75
$8 1.12
$87.61
$90.23
$10s.09
$r07.42
$103.62
$93.62
$124.93
sr26.74
$108.66
$104.84
s83.62
$82.97
$89.6s
s92.35
$107.66
$r r0.05
$r06.14
$9s.84
$s.88
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
s6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
s6.06
$6.24
$6.24
$6.24
$6.24
s6.24
$6.24
$6.24
$6.24
$6.24
86.24
$6.24
s6.24
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
s6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
96.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
54
Nov-33
Dec-33
Jan-34
Feb-34
Mar-34
Apr-34
May-34
Jun-34
Jul-34
Aug-34
Sep-34
Oct-34
Nov-34
Dec-34
Jan-35
Feb-35
Mar-35
Apr-35
May-35
Jun-35
Jul-35
Aug-35
Sep-35
Oct-35
Nov-35
Dec-35
Jan-36
Feb-36
Mar-36
Apr-36
May-36
Jun-36
Jul-36
Aug-36
Sep-36
Oct-36
Nov-36
Dec-36
$129.37
$134.3s
$r22.90
$120.64
$90.67
$85.96
$9s.00
$94.63
$120.02
s123.79
sl r4.39
$99.82
s132.61
$137.73
st2s.94
s123.62
s92.75
s87.89
s97.20
$96.82
$122.97
$r26.86
sl r7.17
sl02.l7
$13s.94
gr4t.22
$129.01
$126.62
s94.83
$89.82
$99.4r
$99.02
$125.96
$129.96
s119.98
$104.s3
$139.32
$144.7s
$128.09
$129.95
$rrt.27
$r07.34
$8s.48
$84.8r
$91.69
$94.47
$110.24
$112.70
$r08.68
$98.07
$131.28
$133.20
sr r3.97
s109.92
$87.40
$86.71
s93.79
$96.66
s112.90
$r 15.44
$1 I r.29
$100.37
$134.57
$136.ss
$r r6.68
$1l2.sl
s89.32
$88.61
s95.90
$98.86
$11s.s8
$l18.20
$r 13.93
$r02.68
$137.91
$139.9s
$6.62
$6.62
$6.82
s6.82
s6.82
s6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
s6.82
s7.02
$7.02
$7.02
s7.02
$7.02
$7.02
$7.02
s7.02
s7.02
$7.02
$7.02
s7.02
$7.24
87.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
s7.24
$7.24
s7.24
$7.24
55
REDLINED FORMAT
E-1
REPLACEMENT APPENDIX E
SOLAR FACILITY ENERGY PRICES AND INTEGRATION CHARGES
(Prices based upon the energy shape and capacity specified in Appendix H)
Base Enerey Purchase Prices - For all Base Energy received during Heavy Load Hours Idaho
Power shall pay the Base Energy Heavy Load Purchase Price less the Solar lntegration Charge
specified below and for all Base Energy received during Light Load Hours Idaho Power shall pay
the Base Energy Light Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge specified below. All
of these prices are subject to revision as specified within paragraph7.4.
Base Energy Heavy
Load Purchase Price
Month/Year (Mills/kWh)
Jan-16 $33.38$29*3
Feb-16 $33.37$e$2
Mar-16 $271$ru
Apr-16 $23.52W#
May-16 $26.12$2#
Jun-16 $26.18$2+S3
Jul-16 $37.82$3+t2
Aug-16 $39.99$4e5e
Sep-16 $33.43$3t5+
Oct-16 $30.31$3}35
Nov-16 S35.31$3Bl
Dec-16 $35.45$34S8
Jan-17 S34.ll$+t39
Feb-17 $33.14$+t$5
Mar-17 530.03$29*3
Apr-17 524.47$PJl8
May-17 523.72W
Jun-17 $20.13$23Je
Jul-17 $38.10$385s
Aug-17 $41.45$++31
Sep-17 $32.88$+1.58
Oct-17 $33.49$35'e7
Nov-17 $37.15$6}f
Dec-17 $38.21$36-62
Jan-18 534.62$33SJ
Feb-18 $37.78$35'53
Base Energy Light Solar Integration
Load Purchase Price Charge(Mills/kWh) (Mills/kWh)
$32.23$Mr
$31.r3$28J0
$25.15$25=t9
$18.49$23+4
$19.63$13++
$1s.82$19+m
$33.67$3*2
$36.22$ts1#
$28.t7$3e9?
$29.0r$+Hs
$34.51$33,00
$35.31$3S
s30.3s$295s
$32.98$3P+
$19.94$23"79
$8.43${642
$1s.65$?136
$E.0E$+4'48
s33.60$34s
$37.57$38-p
$31.71$3+19
$33.66$+t.65
$37.07$3#3
$37.9s$3S
$3s.04$3S
$31.71$+Kr
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
s4.01
s4.01
$4.01
$4.01
s4.01
s4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.01
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
$4.13
s4.13
$4.13
s4.13
s4.2s
$4.2s
50
Mar-18
Apr-18
May-18
Jun-18
Jul-18
Aug-18
Sep-18
Oct-l8
Nov-18
Dec-18
Jan-19
Feb-19
Mar-19
Apr-19
May-19
Jun-19
Jul-19
Aug-19
Sep-19
Oct-19
Nov-19
Dec-19
Jan-20
Feb-20
Mar-20
Apr-20
May-20
Jun-20
Jul-20
Aug-20
Sep-20
Oct-20
Nov-20
Dec-20
Jan-21
Feb-21
Mar-21
Apr-21
May-21
Jun-21
Jul-21
Aug-21
Sep-21
Oct-21
Nov-21
Dec-21
Jan-22
$31.04$+H
s26.s7$HZ
$27.02W-&
$27.50$28-35
$40.57$4+-++
$44.66$44.8+
$36.69$38S8
$37.77$?q#
$40.89$38S2
$42.15$#
$37.40$He
$40.96$3+54
$34.93$3+9+
$24.78$2#3
$23.99$2e
$26.97$p#2
$41.78$WZ
$4s.43$4#
s39.07$9*e
s39.34$#
$43.s0$3H
s44.73$95
$43.15$3H
$40.23$38-53
s24.41$Wt
$23.57$23=Sr
s22.61$23+r
$26.14$263e
$43.72$WZ
$47.37W=5+
$38.20$3H
$39.79$4g4e
$46.13$40S
$47.48$40S
$46.06$4W
$44.00$39*s
$33.r2W
u6.38$2++0
$26.37$2#Z
$29.20$,932
$71.1791+,75
$74.90$+#
$6s.84$#
$66.s0$#r
$74.30$6+5+
$76.00$#
$73.34$6950
$27.60$28,t+
$26.48$2#s
$26.45$26+18
$12.6_0$+9,8+
s40.13$4t-+t
$39.58$483
$36.16$3++t+
$37.78$3144
$40.31$38S2
$41.91$38.1+
$32.3s$ts*
$29.61$34*8
$27.10w26
$24.31$2+2
$23.05$23$s
$23.1o$"ffi
$40.02$4t=+e
$40.80$4-l-29
$38.33$3F2
$39.28$39+$
$43.08$39S
$44.64$3947
$38.41$37s
$30.31$32J+
$23.86$24=68
$23.40$23#
$21.98#l-98
$23.80$23=88
$42.s3W4
$41.62$4{-9r
$32.03$3t.98
s39.3s$40++
$45.16$44F6+
$47.48$40:58
s43.64$4++7
$3s.21$3#
s29.24W*t
$2511$2s,se
s2s.sl$2#r
s26.00$2ffi
s68.s9$69S
$68.80$gr
s63.28$6sJs
s6s.9l$ere
$73.4s$6114
$76.00$6+s+
$69.25$68-73
$4.2s
$4.2s
$4.25
94.2s
s4.2s
$4.2s
s4.2s
$4.2s
$4.2s
s4.25
$4.38
s4.38
$4.38
s4.38
$4.38
s4.38
$4.38
s4.38
s4.38
$4.38
s4.38
$4.38
s4.51
$4.s1
$4.51
$4.s1
$4.51
$4.s1
$4.51
$4.51
s4.51
$4.s1
$4.51
$4.51
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
94.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.64
$4.78
5I
Feb-22
Mar-22
Apr-22
May-22
Jtm-22
Jul-22
Aag-22
Sep-22
Oct-22
Nov-22
Dec-22
Jan-23
Feb-23
Mar-23
Apr-23
May-23
Jun-23
Jul-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
May-24
Jtn-24
Jul-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Jan-25
Feb-25
Mar-25
Apr-25
May-25
Jun-25
Jul-25
Aug-25
Sep-25
Oct-25
Nov-25
Dec-25
s75.21$7H3
$60.78$6p5
$5&21$se54
$s6.42$#
$59.32$6e.:t8
$73.86$7S
$78.27$79S9
$69.33$+r*+
$68.76$+t"e5
$78.86$+m5
$80.4s$+l+r
$7s.40$+p0
$78.30$73+3
$66.1 l$6#
$58.47$59Js
$s7.72$s848
$59.60$s9+7
s76.83$7H
S81.31$82+t0
$71.91$7s#s
s70.34$1454
s83.16$7tr5+
$84.6r$1449
$&5.21$+652
$82.36$+#
$67.49$ffi
s59.31$6e,15
$58.72$5939
$s9.14$s
$81.81$8+r{}
$90.8s$9256
$72.8r$++J-r
s7r.7s9113+
$86.73ffi3
$88.40$+?J9
$89.30$+9+t5
$87.37$+8J9
g79.t2$;6jA.
$s8.s2$6059
$62.92W#
$64.1ffi*2
$86.66$8&fl
$94.30$H9
$75.3z+{E&t$6
$73.48$+9199
$90.28$8e+8
$92.99$&H
$71.83$6ry4
$59.90$s959
susss*+
$55.31$55+t2
$s3.r4$r+J+
$72.76$1356
$71.82$7+18
$57.6ts+s++
$68.76$7eJ8
$78.s9$+S
$80.64$+2*4
$70.78S70*1,5
$71.7s$+0€+
$62.3s$#8
$s7.14$s8S6
$s6.61$s#
$s6.76$s#2
$74.s4$;1s39
s75.02911-+4
$7059$73=67
$70.34$+{a38
$82.28$++40
$84.7s$q452
s8l.70$+5:74
$77.66$X3,*7
s68.02$6el9
s57.33$58=r+
$s5.53$#+
$s7.36$#r
$80.14$8s
$77.74$;79*8
973.43$,W
$7t.7sv+2
s8s.3lrer
$88.40$++Je
$89.1s$+g*s
$80.33$-7644
$67.17$Fgl4
$ss.7r$ss*2
$59.77$s9+r
$s7.ss$sry3
$80.s6$8256
$79.27$fp"J6
$73.69$7&e3
$73.48$8e$8
$90.23$8e=r3
$92.32$SH
$4.78
s4.78
$4.78
s4.78
$4.78
$4.78
$4.78
s4.78
$4.78
s4.78
s4.78
$4.93
$4.93
s4.93
s4.93
s4.93
$4.93
s4.93
$4.93
$4.93
$4.93
s4.93
$4.e3
$5.07
ss.07
$s.07
ss.07
ss.07
ss.07
$s.07
ss.07
$s.07
$s.07
ss.07
$5.07
$s.23
ss.23
$s.23
$s.23
$s.23
$s.23
$5.23
ss.23
$s.23
$5.23
$5.23
$5.23
52
Jan-26
Feb-26
Mar-26
Apr-26
May-26
Jun-26
Jul-26
htg-26
Sep-26
Oct-26
Nov-26
Dec-26
Jan-27
Feb-27
Mar-27
Apr-27
May-27
Jrn-27
hl-27
Aug-27
Sep-27
Oct-27
Nov-27
Dec-27
Jan-28
Feb-28
Mar-28
Apr-28
May-28
Jun-28
Jul-28
Aug-28
Sep-28
Oct-28
Nov-28
Dec-28
Jan-29
Feb-29
Mar-29
Apr-29
May-29
Jun-29
Jul-29
Aug-29
Sep-29
Oct-29
Nov-29
$91.62$823e
ffissoaa
$60.17$6&+r
$60.38$6054
$59.61$sH3
$62.26$65$9
$82.42$8#3
$82.25$8#
$77.1s$83i4
$2514$83J+
$91.71$82+r
$97.34$€#S
$90J_4$83++
$88.95$8?/+0
$68.4s$69+r
$62.82$W
$6s.12$6#
$67.549H
$84.98$Ssg
$!6.26$8Br
$79.84$8H
$77.90$8s
$97.06$89
$102.1 l$9H
s89.26$&Le5
$91.84$&1.,96
s72.7sgq2++
$68.43$68*8
$77.82$+8S2
972.12$41+5
$88.79$90+t3
$89.42$9+18
$83.76$90+15
$80.s8$89$s
$101.64$90J7
$105.81$ry-rQ
wE$8+3s
$97.24$89$7
$70.92$+eS6
s66.39$#2
$78.2691954
$65.18$68S8
$89.61$92-?+
$91.27W*
$87.09$9438
$83.06$92#
$106.19$92*9
$92.67$&Z#
$91.13$82S7
s67.10$6sr
wJ3$&+7
$63.92$6#
$64.64$M
$88.87$9156
s9s.2s$+1-r2
$78.s2$&6
$7s.54$83+K)
$94.s7$83+t5
S97.83$8s+ts
$94.99$&t.95
$93.99$&l=+8
$81.s7$+95s
s69.00$+0{9
S65.50$663,+
s70.32$1359
$91.4s$ryH
$99.04$le0J7
$E-1.46$8+32
$77.97$86-r+
$97.88$86J3
$101.43$89=++
$99.90$883s
$e7.71$8+*s
$72.569125+
$68.63$69J+
s77.675;+784
$74.989192+
$9s.71$97+l
st02.l0$+03J+
$84.97$9W
$80.70$89++2
$103.s9$9e*6
$107.30$ry1€8
$101.76$90J2
$r01.54$9eJe
$77.ss$+#r
$71.18$72+0
$79.6391952
$zr.rr$+125
$96.07$9936
s105.86$+e8-75
$90.07$9sJe
$83.16$925s
s105.99$92,85
$s.38
$5.38
$s.38
$s.38
$s.38
$s.38
$s.38
$s.38
$s.38
$5.38
$s.38
ss.38
$s.55
$s.ss
$s.s5
$s.ss
$s.s5
ss.5s
$s.ss
ss.ss
$s.ss
$s.ss
$5.55
ss.ss
$s.71
s5.71
$s.71
$s.71
$s.71
$s.71
$5.71
$5.71
$s.71
$s.71
$5.71
$s.71
$s.88
$s.88
$s.88
$5.88
$s.88
$5.88
ss.88
ss.88
$5.88
ss.88
s5.88
53
Dec-29
Jan-30
Feb-30
Mar-30
Apr-30
May-30
Jun-30
Jul-30
Aug-30
Sep-30
Oct-30
Nov-30
Dec-30
Jan-3 I
Feb-31
Mar-31
Apr-31
May-31
Jun-31
Jul-31
Aug-31
Sep-31
Oct-31
Nov-31
Dec-31
Jan-32
Feb-32
Mar-32
Apr-32
May-32
Jun-32
Jul-32
Aug-32
Sep-32
Oct-32
Nov-32
Dec-32
Jan-33
Feb-33
Mar-33
Apr-33
May-33
Jun-33
Jul-33
Aug-33
Sep-33
Oct-33
sl10.9r$9+5s
$105.41$93-76
$104.15$9#8
$80.75$8e5r
$65.8s$6+#2
$66.60$6++ts
$78.15$82+2
$99.ss${-02#0
$107.2r$l€933
$93.89$99#2
$86.19$9#7
$l10.2s$H
$l14.0t$gr-++
$l12.43$te3-+l
sr09.72$99*r"
$95.19$98?
$7r.87$7444
$78.82$eB7
$86.75$8+-r5
s109.01$H+-?t
$113.45$1-14-88
$106.79${08,30
$91.94$10+-+9
$l17.91$]{l-+7
$r2892$+21*+
$l17.02$reB3
sl14.90${s}5s
$86.65$87Sr
$82.21$83+r
$90.73$9+r3
$90.38$9Fr
$l14.31$r-l9s+
$l17.86$]{959
$109.00$+{-l-13
$9s.27$10#
sr26.18$-r+H
$r3l.0l${30$2
$l19.94$1r3+r
$r17.76$re#
$88.66$89S3
$84.08$8*r
$92.86$ry80
$92.s0$92*4
$1r7.ls$+2?6r
$r20.81$s2J9
$111.68$113#
$97.54$+079s
$108.21$925e
$99.s0$90Js
s98.99$9+18
$77.09$m
$643s$AL+r
s64.16A1427
$77.s5$82++3
$95iZSq8Ja
s9s.8s$98*6
$91.80$98-t9
$8s.98$9s5r
s107.26$9+J8
$l]2-a_6$e#
$102.04$9pr
s99.70$925e
$85.89$&H
$68.18$68,16
$70.39$+e5e
$83.42$s#
$99.86$+02-rc
$103.00$r+#
$100.46$r++J3
s89.36$995+
$l r6.42$re#2
$r22.29$+2+56
$106.07$+€0*r
$r02.36$9#
$81.75$8J+ts
s8 l. r2$&s
$87.61$8++6
$90.23$905e
$r05.09$r€75r
$107.42$re83+
$103.62$+e83,lt
s93.62$++Le2
$r24.93$+-lH
sr26.74$+263!
$108.66$g=3+
$104.84$9+33
$83.62$83-3e
s82.97$83=0+
$89.6s$89*0
$92.35$92#
$107.66$]{{Ll4
$110.05$l-rJ#
$106.14$++s
$9s.84$+e#5
$5.88
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
s6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
$6.06
s6.06
$6.06
86.24
s6.24
$6.24
$6.24
$6.24
s6.24
s6.24
$6.24
$6.24
$6.24
s6.24
$6.24
$6.43
$6.43
s6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
$6.43
s6.43
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
$6.62
54
Nov-33
Dec-33
Jan-34
Feb-34
Mar-34
Apr-34
May-34
Jun-34
Jul-34
Aug-34
Sep-34
Oct-34
Nov-34
Dec-34
Jan-35
Feb-35
Mar-35
Apr-35
May-35
Jun-35
Jul-35
Aug-35
Sep-35
Oct-35
Nov-35
Dec-35
Jan-36
Feb-36
Mar-36
Apr-36
May-36
Jun-36
Jul-36
Aug-36
Sep-36
Oct-36
Nov-36
Dec-36
$129.37$+2457
$134.3s${3333
sr2290$++432
w$1e850
$90.67$99
s8s.96$8+#+
$95.00$96+18
$94.$$ry57
$120.02$t25-et
$r23.79$E#
sl14.39$11653
$99.82$+r+s4
$132.61$+e756
s137.73$r3ffi
$125.94$1-l+J2
$123.62$++t=+t
$92.7s$9+r3
$87.89$8#s
$97.20$9#
$96.829+7+7
$122.97$+,836
$126.86$148-14
$l 17.17$++9++8
$r02.17${-13++
$135.94$-r30*r
$r4r.22$+44+1
$129.0r$s03r
$126.62$+13#
$94.83$9#2
$89.82$9+-+4
$99.41$+€0J8
$99.02$9H
$125.96$l+pr
$129.96$-r+S
$l19.98$.W
$104.53$1+5Je
$139.32$1+l-06
sr44.75$+4?4?
$128.09$rr*5
$129.9s$13g+r
$111.27$+e5*3
$107.34$995r
$8s.48$8#
$84.81$er$r
$9r.69$9Hs
$94.47$9+16
$110.24${r3*O
$r r2.70$1{#r
$108.68$-rJ3#
$98.07$rOHe
$131.28$+2#
s133.20$r3s
sr 13.97$+eH5
$109.92$++pr
$87.40$8+S6
$86.71$8#l
$93.79$93Js
$96.66$e6es
$112.90$+{#
$l15.44${-16++8
$l l1.29$++84
$100.37$#2
$134.57$l+8+A
$136.ss$+3ffi
$l16.68${+0Je
$ll2.5l$+0/t30
$89.32$88J6
$88.61$8#r
$9s.90$w
$9E3_6$e+rs
$l ls.s8$++€+9
$118.20$+{ry
$r r3.93$+-rq3
$102.68$1{4-36
$137.91$-r+K
$139.9s$+4e$0
s6.62
$6.62
s6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
$6.82
s6.82
s6.82
$7.02
$7.02
97.02
$7.02
s7.02
$7.02
s7.02
s7.02
s7.02
s7.02
s7.02
$7.02
s7.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
s7.24
$7.24
$7.24
$7.24
87.24
$7.24
s7.24
55
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
cAsE NO. IPC-E-14-36
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
ATTACHMENT 2
CLEAN FORMAT
APPENDX B
FACILITY AND POINT OF DELMERY
Project Name: Orchard Ranch Solar. LLC
Project Number: 25 57 3998
B-I DESCRIPTIONOFFACILITY
(Must include the Nameplate Capacity rating and VAR capability (both leading and lagging) of
all Generation Units to be included in the Facility.)
Orchard Ranch Solar. LLC is a 20 Mril/ AC: 26.19 MW DC single-axis tracking photovoltaic
facilitv to be located on aooroximately 160 acres near Orchard in Ada County. Idaho. The
Project consists of l0 (ten) x 2.0 MWac SMA inverters (or equivalent) and 85.880 x JA 305w dc
panels (or equivalent).
Nameplate: 20 MWac
Var Capability (Both leading and lagging) I*ading is 0.95 Laggrng is 0.95.
B-2 LOCATION OF FACILITY
Near: Orchard.ID
Actual or nearest physical street address: Orchard Road Ada County, Idaho 83716
GPS Coordinates: Latitude Decimal Degrees: 43.332139
Longitude Decimal Degrees: -116.029743
State: Idaho County: Ada
Description of lnterconnection Location: 34.5kV line near Orchard Road
B-3 SCHEDULED FIRST ENERGY AND OPERATION DATE
Seller has selected September 15e. 2016 as the Scheduled First Energy Date.
Seller has selected Decernber I't. 2016 as the Scheduled Operation Date.
In making these selections, Seller recognizes that adequate testing of the Facility and completion
of all requirements in paragraph 5.2 of this Agreernent must be completed prior to the project
being granted an Operation Date.
39
REDLINED FORMAT
APPENDX B
FACILITY AND POINT OF DELIVERY
Project Name: Orchard Ranch Solar. LLC
Project Number: 2557 3998
B-I DESCRIPTION OF FACILIry
(Must include the Nameplate Capacity rating and VAR capability (both leading and lagging) of
all Generation Units to be included in the Facility.)
Orchard Ranch Solar. LLC is a 20 MW AC: 26.19 MW DC sinele-axis tracking photovoltaic
facility to be located on aporoximatelv 160 acres near Orchard in Ada County. Idaho. The
Project consists of 10 (ten) x 2.0 MWac SMA inverters (or equivalent) and 85.880 x JA 305w dc
panels (or equivalent).
Nameplate: 20 MWac
Var Capability (Both leading and lagging) Leadingis|.95 Lagging is 0.95.
8.2 LOCATION OF FACILITY
Near: Orchard.ID
Actual or nearest physical street address: Orchard Road Ada County, Idaho 83716
GPS Coordinates: Latitude Decimal Degrees: 43.332139
Longitude Decimal Degrees: -116.0297 43
State: Idaho County: Pe,'rrerAda
Description of Interconnection Location: 34.5kV line near Orchard Road
B-3 SCHEDULED FIRST ENERGY AND OPERATION DATE
Seller has selected Seotember 15ft. 2016 as the Scheduled First Energy Date.
Seller has selected December I't. 2016 as the Scheduled Operation Date.
In making these selections, Seller recognizes that adequate testing of the Facility and completion
of all requirements in paragraph 5.2 of this Agreernent must be completed prior to the project
being granted an Operation Date.
39