20141223Reply Comments.pdf

SEffi*.
An TDACORP ComoanvIii:fiIit'rl'i'
?!lt"t 0[C zit PH lr: 2l
DONOVAN E. WALKER
Lead Gounset , , .,. , ,
i,'rl,-i'll.- ,-: -;,,i ;.i , li S,iC , ,[e-mail] ij i ili I i-' 'i
December 23,2014
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Jean D. Jewell, Secretary
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
Re: Case No. IPC-E-14-28
Clark Solar 1, LLC - ldaho Power Company's Reply Comments
Dear Ms. Jewell:
Enclosed for filing please find an original and seven (7) copies of ldaho Power
Company's Reply Comments in the above matter.#reDonovan E. Walker
DEW:csb
Enclosures
1221 W. ldaho St. (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, lD 83707
DONOVAN E. WALKER (lSB No. 5921)
ldaho Power Company
1221West Idaho Street (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, ldaho 83707
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
dwal ker@ id a hopower. com
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION
OF IDAHO POWER COMPANY FOR
APPROVAL OR REJECTION OF AN
ENERGY SALES AGREEMENT WITH
CLARK SOLAR 1, LLC FOR THE SALE
AND PURCHASE OF ELECTRIC ENERGY.
r-, !:i:*
,)n I 1 F:-!r
!q: !:-\J
t--,. ii_' 1r r-_ I I l',''1 -
t-l : ii i: ii--
,a,l-l,i, i'
^.r h,,r t . a-lt' j i-tl \'{l
::: I
:: ..,'.-.;.. ..,- -,r -"'
BEFORE THE !DAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
CASE NO. !PC-E-14-28
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S
REPLY COMMENTS
ldaho Power Company ("ldaho Powed'or "Company"), in response to the Notice
of Application and Notice of Modified Procedure issued in Order No. 33164 and in
response to the Comments of the ldaho Public Utilities Commission ("Commission")
Staff ("Staff') and Clark Solar 1, LLC ("Clark Solar 1") filed on December 19,2014,
hereby respectfully submits the following Reply Comments to the Commission. With
these Reply Comments, ldaho Power submits, as Attachment t hereto, a "Second
Replacement Appendix E' that incorporates Staffs additional recommended rate
adjustments consistent with those from ldaho Power's Response to the Third
Production Request from Staff. With these Reply Comments, ldaho Power also
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 1
requests that the Commission affirm that the avoided cost rates contained in this
contract correctly utilize a first capacity deficit of July 2021.
I. STAFF'S RECOMMENDED RATES ADJUSTMENTS
1. On November 20, 2014, ldaho Power filed lnitial Comments in this matter
which submitted a "Replacement Appendix E" reflecting the Commission-approved rate
adjustments from the Grand View Solar and Boise City Solar cases. Order No. 33179
(Grand View Solar); Order No. 33180 (Boise City Solar).
2. On December 19, 2014, Staff filed Comments recommending the
incorporation of additional price adjustments consistent with those made in ldaho
Power's Response to the Third Production Request from Staff. Idaho Power submits
herewith as Attachment 1, in both clean and redlined format, a "second Replacement
Appendix E" that incorporates Staffs additional recommended rate adjustments
consistent with those from ldaho Power's Response to the Third Production Request
from Staff.
3. On December 19, 2014, Mountain Home Solar, LLC; Pocatello Solar 1,
LLC; Clark Solar 1, LLC; Clark Solar 2, LLC; Clark Solar 3, LLC; and Clark Solar 4, LLC,
filed lnitial Comments. In those Initial Comments, Mountain Home Solar, Pocatello
Solar, and Clark Solar 1, Clark Solar 2, Clark Solar 3, and Clark Solar 4 each accepted
Staffs recommended adjustments to the contract pricing. (Staff recommended approval
of pricing from ldaho Power's Response to the Third Production Request of Staff for
Mountain Home Solar, Pocatello Solar 1, Clark Solar 1, and Clark Solar 2. Staff
recommended pricing from ldaho Power's lnitial Comments for Clark Solar 3 and Clark
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 2
Solar 4.). The projects also provide argument that a 2016 capacity deficiency should
be used as opposed to ldaho Power's 2021 capacity deficiency.
4. For comparison purposes, the 20-year levelized rate for the Energy Sales
Agreement ('ESA") as originally submitted is $61.71G/megawatt-hour ('MWh') and the
rate from the Second Replacement Appendix E is $59.97/MWh. The estimated 2O-year
contractual obligation based upon the originally submitted prices is $249,756,516 and
the estimated 20-year contractual obligation with the revised prices is $242,380,161.
The levelized integration charge contained in the ESA is the same in both instances at
$4.1s/MWh.
5. Should the Commission determine to accept the additional recommended
rate adjustments, ldaho Power recommends incorporation and approval of the Second
Replacement Appendix E with the approval of the ESA, rather than incorporating the
same through a contract amendment.
I!. CAPACITY SUFFICIENCY
6. ldaho Power maintains that the correct capacity sufficiency period for
purposes of calculating the appropriate avoided cost rate for this contract is July of
2021. This is the capacity sufficiency period included in the rates set forth in Appendix
E, Replacement Appendix E, and the Second Replacement Appendix E. Clark Solar 1
maintains its strained argument that the Commission should adopt and approve a
capacity sufficiency period of July 2016 for the associated rates in its contract. The
2016 capacity deficiency is included in the alternative Appendix F, which should be
rejected by the Commission.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 3
7. The Commission has already decided this issue, and determined that
ldaho Power's 2021 capacity deficiency is appropriate for use in determining avoided
costs pursuant to the lncremental Cost lntegrated Resource Plan Methodology ("lRP
Methodology") used for the determination of rates in this contract. "We find that ignoring
the Company's demand response contribution in calculations under the IRP
methodology would unjustly inflate avoided costs paid to QFs and harm ratepayers by
requiring them to pay for capacity provided by a QF that the utility does not need."
Order No. 331 59, p. 8.
lnclusion of ldaho Power's demand response produces a
more accurate avoided cost and, therefore, more closely
aligns with the intent and requirement of PURPA and FERC
regulations. Therefore, we find it just and reasonable to
include the capacity provided by ldaho Power's demand
response programs in calculation made under the IRP
methodology. We further find that the capacity provided by
demand response is sufficient to meet the Company's needs
until July 2021.
lT lS HEREBY ORDERED that Idaho Power's Application is
approved. We confirm July 2021 as the Company's capacity
deficiency period for use in the incremental cost !RP
methodology.
Order No. 33159, p.9.
8. On July 30, 2014, the Commission issued Order No. 33084 that directed
ldaho Power to utilize July 2021 as its first capacity deficit to be used in the Company's
surrogate avoided resource methodology for the determination of published avoided
cost rates. Case No. IPC-E-13-21, Order No. 33084, p. 5. The Company's 2013 IRP
contained a first capacity deficiency of 2016. However, subsequent to the filing of the
2013lRP, the Company entered into a stipulation requiring the acquisition of up to 440
megawatts ("MW") of demand response ("DR"). ldaho Power subsequently enrolled
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 4
over 400 MW of DR program participants for the 2014 season. Case No. IPC-E-13-21
examined and established that the appropriate capacity deficiency period for
determining published avoided cost rates is July 2021 with the inclusion of ldaho
Power's DR programs.
9. On August 13, 2014, ldaho Power filed an application with the
Commission seeking an order confirming the use of a July 2021 capacity deficiency
period in the approved IRP Methodology. Case No. IPC-E-14-22, ldaho Power's
Application, incorporated herein by this reference. As referenced and quoted above,
the Commission approved ldaho Power's Application and confirmed July 2021 as the
Company's capacity deficiency period for use in the IRP Methodology. Order No.
33159, p.9.
10. Because Clark Solar 1 is unable to establish any legally enforceable
obligation under ldaho law to avoided cost rates using a 2016 capacity deficit, See,
ldaho Power Co., v. ldaho Public Utilities Comm'n., 155 ldaho 780,316 P.3d 1278
("Grouse Creek'), it now argues ineffectively that the contract in this matter, which was
signed by the parties on October 13,2014, was "binding between the parties" prior to
the Commission's final order confirming use of the 2021 capacity deficit in the IRP
Methodology. lnitial Comments of Clark Solar 1, et al., pp. 4-5. This contention is
absolutely incorrect. Under this Commission's implementation of the Public Utility
Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 ("PURPA") for the state of ldaho, the Commission
utilizes a case-by-case implementation where it requires that each separate contract
and/or obligation for purchase be separately and distinctly approved by the Commission
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS.5
prior to its effectiveness. !n fact, Clark Solar 1 acknowledges that its contract contains
the provision in Article 21.1 which states:
Idaho Power shall file this Agreement for its acceptance or
rejection by the Commission and resolution of the disputed
Solar Facility Pricing Schedule as described in paragraph
7.1. This Agreement shall only become finally effective upon
the Commission's approval of all terms and provisions
hereof without change or condition and declaration that all
payments to be made to Seller hereunder shall be allowed
as prudently incurred expenses for ratemaking purposes.
11. Contrary to Clark Solar 1's assertions that the parties' signatures on the
contract make it "binding between the parties" the parties' signatures on a PURPA
contract simply means that both parties have reached agreement as to the terms and
conditions contained therein. However, it is of no binding effect and is not "finally
effective" unless and until it is reviewed and approved by the Commission. Additionally,
in the case of this particular contract, the parties agreed to terms and conditions that
expressly state that there is not agreement upon the proper capacity sufficiency period
to be used in the contractual rates, and the parties agreed to abide by what the
Commission would decide with regard to that matter. Contrary to Clark Solar 1's
argument that a subsequent Commission decision could not affect the determination,
the agreement expressed in the contract itself anticipates and specifically provides that
the Commission will decide the matter, subsequently, and that the parties will abide by
that decision. Article 7.1 provides:
The Solar Facility Pricing Schedule to be included in this
Agreement is disputed by the Parties. ldaho Power believes
Appendix E is the appropriate Solar Facility Pricing as it
includes an ldaho Power capacity deficit period beginning in
2021. The Seller believes Appendix F is the appropriate
Solar Facility Pricing Schedule and it includes an ldaho
Power capacity deficit period beginning in 2016. Both of
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 6
these pricing schedules were calculated using the
Commission approved lncremental Cost IRP Avoided Cost
Methodology, with the only difference being the starting date
of the ldaho Power capacity deficit period. The Parties have
agreed to a!! other terms and conditions of this Agreement
and hereby agree to submit this Solar Facility Pricing
Schedule dispute to the Commission for resolution. The
Parties may submit to the Commission written argument or
Comments in support of their respective positions, in
accordance with a procedural schedule mutually agreeable
to the Parties and the Commission. The Parties agree to
abide and be bound by the Commission's decision on this
issue. The final Order of the Commission resolving this
dispute will be included and become an integral part of this
Agreement, which the Parties agree to support and uphold.
Case No. IPC-E-14-22, seeking the Commission confirmation that 2021 was the correct
capacity deficiency to be used in the IRP Methodology, was pending at the time Clark
Solar 1's contract was signed by the parties. lntermountain Energy Partners, LLC
(managing member for Mountain Home Solar, Pocatello Solar, Clark Solar 1, Clark
Solar 2, Clark Solar 3, and Clark Solar 4) directly participated in Case No. IPC-E-14-22
advocating for a 2016 capacity deficiency determination that was denied.
12. As stated above, the Commission has already decided this issue, and
determined that ldaho Power's 2021 capacity deficiency is appropriate for use in
determining avoided costs pursuant to the IRP Methodology used for the determination
of rates in this contract. ldaho Power asks that the Commission affirm that July 2021 is
the proper first capacity deficit for the calculation of avoided cost rates for Clark Solar
1's contract.
Respectfully submitted this 23d day of
DONOVAN E. WALKER
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS. T
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTTFY that on the 23'd day of December 20141 served a true and
correct copy of IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS upon the following
named parties by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following:
Gommission Staff
Kristine A. Sasser
Deputy Attomey General
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington (83702)
P.O. Box 83720
Boise, ldaho 83720-007 4
Clark Solar 1, LLC
Dean J. Miller
McDEVITT & MILLER, LLP
420 West Bannock
Boise, ldaho 83702
/
Mark van Gulik
Clark Solar 1, LLC
P.O. Box 7354
Boise, ldaho 83707
X Hand Delivered
X
U.S. Mail
Overnight Mail
FAX
Email [e-mail]
Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
_Hand Delivered
U.S. Mai!
Overnight Mail
FAXX Email mvanoulik@sunerq\,vorld.com
Bearry, [egalAssistant
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S REPLY COMMENTS - 8
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIG UTILITIES COMMISSION
GASE NO. IPC-E-14-29
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
ATTACHMENT 1
CLEAN FORMAT
SECOND REPLACEMENT APPENDIX E
SOLAR FACILITY ENERGY PRICES AND INTEGRATION CHARGES
(Prices based upon the energy shape and capacity specified in Appendix I)
E-l Base Enerqy Purchase Prices - For all Base Energy received during Heavy Load Hours Idaho
Power shall pay the Base Energy Heavy Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge
specified below and for all Base Energy received during Light Load Hours Idaho Power shall pay
the Base Energy Light Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge specified below. All
of these prices are subject to revision as specified within paragraph 7.5.
Base Energy Heavy
Load Purchase PriceMonth/Year (Mills/kWh)
Base Energy Light
Load Purchase Price
(Mills/kWh)
s29.72
$30.0r
$30.30
$30.s8
$30.87
$3 I .16
$31.45
s31.73
$32.02
$32.31
$32.60
$32.88
$33.17
$33.46
$33.74
$34.03
$34.32
$34.61
s34.89
$35.18
$3s.47
$35.76
$36.04
s36.33
$36.62
$36.90
s37.19
Solar Integration
Charge
(Mills/kWh)
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
s3.20
s3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
Jan-16
Feb-16
Mar-16
Apr-16
May-16
Jun-16
Jul-16
Aug-16
Sep-16
Oct-16
Nov-16
Dec-16
Jan-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
Apr-17
May-17
Jun-17
Jul-17
Aug-17
Sep-17
Oct-17
Nov-17
Dec-17
Jan- I 8
Feb-I8
Mar-18
$31.98
$32.28
$32.59
$32.89
s33.20
$33.51
$33.81
s34.12
$34.42
$34.t3
$3s.03
$35.34
$3s.64
$35.95
$36.25
s36.s6
$36.86
$37.17
$37.47
$37.78
s38.08
$38.39
$38.69
$39.00
$39.30
s39.6r
$39.92
47
Apr-18
May-18
Jun-l 8
Jul-18
Aug-18
Sep-18
Oct-I8
Nov-18
Dec-l8
Jan-19
Feb-19
Mar-19
Apr-19
May-19
Jun-19
Jul-19
Aug-19
Sep-19
Oct-19
Nov-19
Dec-l9
Jan-20
Feb-20
Mar-20
Apr-20
May-20
Jun-20
Jul-20
Aug-20
Sep-20
Oct-20
Nov-20
Dec-20
Jan-21
Feb-21
Mar-21
Apr-21
May-21
Jun-21
Jul-21
Aug-21
Sep-21
Oct-21
Nov-21
Dec-21
Ja*22
Feb-22
Mar-22
s40.22
$40.53
$40.83
$41.14
$41.44
$41.7s
$42.0s
$42.36
$42.66
s42.97
s43.27
$43.58
$43.88
$44.19
M4.49
$44.80
$45.r0
$45.41
Ms.72
$46.02
s46.33
$46.63
s46.94
$47.24
s47.5s
$47.8s
s48.16
$48.46
$48.77
$49.07
$49.38
$49.68
$49.99
$50.29
$s0.60
$s0.90
$s 1.21
$5 r.s l
$s 1.82
$52.13
$s2.43
$52.74
$s3.04
$53.35
$s3.6s
$53.96
$s4.26
$54.57
$37.48
$37.t7
$38.0s
$38.34
$38.63
s38.91
$39.20
$39.49
$39.78
$40.06
$40.3s
$40.64
s40.93
$41.21
$41.s0
s41.79
$42.07
s42.36
$42.6s
M2.94
$43.22
$43.51
s43.80
$44.09
944.37
$44.66
$44.9s
s45.23
s4s.s2
$4s.81
$46.10
$46.38
$46.67
$46.96
$47.24
947.s3
s47.82
$48.11
$48.39
$48.68
$48.97
949.26
$49.s4
$49.83
$50.12
$s0.40
$s0.69
$s0.98
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
s3.39
$3.39
$3.39
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
s3.49
s3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
s3.49
$3.49
s3.49
$3.60
s3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
s3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.71
s3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
s3.82
$3.82
$3.82
48
Apr-22
May-22
Jtm-22
Jul-22
Aug-22
Sep-22
Oct-22
Nov-22
Dec-22
Jan-23
Feb-23
Mar-23
Apr-23
May-23
Jwr-23
Jul-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
lan-24
Feb-24
Mar24
Apr-24
May-24
Jvn-24
hl-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Jan-25
Feb-25
Mar-25
Apr-25
May-25
Jun-25
Jul-25
Aug-25
Sep-25
Oct-25
Nov-25
Dec-25
Jan-26
Feb-26
Mar-26
$54.87
$ss.r8
$55.48
$55.79
$s6.09
$s6.40
$56.70
$s7.01
s57.31
$57.62
ss7.92
$58.23
$58.s4
$58.84
$s9.15
ss9.4s
$s9.76
$60.06
$60.37
$60.67
$60.98
$61.28
$6r.59
$61.89
$62.20
$62.50
$62.81
$63.1I
s63.42
$63.72
s64.03
$64.33
$64.64
s64.9s
$65.2s
$6s.s6
$6s.86
$66.17
$66.47
s66.78
$67.08
$67.39
$67.69
$68.00
$68.30
$68.61
$68.91
s69.22
$s 1.27
s5l.ss
s51.84
$52. l 3
ssz.42
$52.70
$s2.99
$s3.28
$53.56
$s3.8s
ss4.l4
$54.43
$s4.71
sss.00
$55.29
$55.57
$ss.86
$s6. l s
$s6.44
$s6.72
$s7.01
$s7.30
$57.59
$s7.87
$s8. l 6
$58.4s
$s8.73
$59.02
$s9.31
$s9.60
$s9.88
$60.17
$60.46
$60.7s
s61.03
$61.32
s6l.6l
$61.89
$62. l 8
$62.47
s62.76
$63.04
s63.33
s63.62
$63.90
$64.r9
$64.48
s64.77
$3.82
$3.82
s3.82
s3.82
s3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.93
$3.93
$3.93
$3.93
s3.93
$3.93
$3.93
s3.93
$3.93
$3.93
$3.93
$3.93
$4.0s
$4.05
$4.0s
s4.05
$4.05
s4.05
$4.05
$4.0s
s4.05
s4.0s
$4.0s
$4.05
$4.17
$4.17
$4.17
$4.17
s4.r7
$4.17
$4.17
$4.r7
s4.17
v.t7
s4.r7
s4.17
$4.30
s4.30
s4.30
49
Apr-26
May-26
Jun-26
Jul-26
1otg-26
Sep-26
Oct-26
Nov-26
Dec-26
Jan-27
Feb-27
Mar-27
Apr-27
May-27
Jun-27
Jul-21
1otg-27
Sep-27
Oct-27
Nov-27
Dec-27
Jan-28
Feb-28
Mar-28
Apr-28
May-28
Jun-28
Jul-28
Aug-28
Sep-28
Oct28
Nov-28
Dec-28
Jan-29
Feb-29
Mar-29
Apr-29
May-29
Jun-29
Jul-29
Aug-29
Sep-29
Oct-29
Nov-29
Dec-29
Jan-30
Feb-30
Mar-30
$69.s2
$69.83
s70. l3
$70.44
$70.75
s71.05
$71.36
$71.66
$71.97
s72.27
s72.58
$72.88
$73.r9
$73.49
s73.80
$74.10
$74.41
$74.7t
$7s.02
s75.32
$7s.63
$75.93
$76.24
$76.s4
$76.85
$77.16
$77.46
$77.77
$78.07
$78.38
$78.68
$78.99
s79.29
$79.60
$79.90
$80.21
$80.51
s80.82
$8 l. r2
$81.43
$8 r.73
$82.04
$82.34
$82.65
$82.9s
s83.26
$83.s7
$83.87
$6s.05
$65.34
$65.63
s6s.92
$66.20
$66.49
$66.78
$67.06
$67.35
$67.64
s67.93
$68.21
$68.50
s68.79
$69.07
$69.36
$69.65
s69.94
$70.22
$70.s 1
s70.80
$71.09
$71.37
$71.66
$71.9s
$72.23
s72.s2
$72.81
$73.r0
$73.38
fi73.67
$73.96
$74.2s
$74.s3
974.82
$7s.1l
$7s.39
$7s.68
s7s.97
$76.26
$76.s4
s76.83
$77.12
s77.40
$77.69
$77.98
$78.27
s78.ss
$4.30
$4.30
$4.30
s4.30
$4.30
$4.30
$4.30
$4.30
$4.30
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
s4.56
$4.56
$4.56
$4.56
$4.56
$4.s6
$4.56
$4.s6
$4.s6
$4.s6
$4.56
$4.s6
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
s4.69
$4.69
s4.69
$4.69
$4.69
M.69
s4.84
s4.84
$4.84
50
Apr-30
May-30
Jun-30
Jul-30
Aug-30
Sep-30
Oct-30
Nov-30
Dec-30
Jan-3 I
Feb-31
Mar-31
Apr-31
May-31
Jun-3 I
Jul-31
Aug-31
Sep-3 I
Oct-31
Nov-31
Dec-31
Ia*32
Feb-32
Mar-32
Apr-32
May-32
llurr-32
Jul-32
Aug-32
Sep-32
Oct-32
Nov-32
Dec-32
Jan-33
Feb-33
Mar-33
Apr-33
May-33
Jun-33
Jul-33
Aug-33
Sep-33
Oct-33
Nov-33
Dec-33
Ja*34
Feb-34
Mar-34
$84.18
$84.48
$84.79
$8s.09
$8s.40
$8s.70
$86.01
$86.31
$86.62
$86.92
$87.23
$87.53
$87.84
$88.14
$88.45
s88.75
$89.06
s89.36
$89.67
s89.98
$90.28
$90.59
$90.89
s91.20
$91.50
$91.81
$92. r 1
$92.42
$92.72
s93.03
s93.33
$93.64
s93.94
$94.25
$94.5s
$94.86
s95.r6
$95.47
$9s.78
se6.08
s96.39
$96.69
$97.00
$97.30
$97.61
s97.91
$98.22
$98.s2
$78.84
$79. l3
s79.42
$79.70
$79.99
$80.28
$80.s6
$80.8s
$81.r4
$81.43
$81.71
s82.00
$82.29
$82.s8
$82.86
$83.1s
$83.,14
$83.72
$84.01
$84.30
s84.s9
s84.87
$8s. l 6
$85.45
s8s.73
$86.02
$86.31
$86.60
s86.88
s87. r 7
$87.46
s87.75
$88.03
$88.32
$88.61
$88.89
$89. l 8
s89.47
$89.76
$90.04
seo.33
s90.62
s90.91
$9 1. l9
$9r.48
991.77
$92.0s
$92.34
$4.84
$4.84
$4.84
$4.84
$4.84
s4.84
s4.84
$4.84
$4.84
s4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
s4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$s.13
$5.13
s5.13
$s.13
$5.r3
$5.1 3
$s.1 3
$s.1 3
$s.r3
$s.13
$s.1 3
ss.r3
$5.28
$s.28
$s.28
$s.28
$5.28
$s.28
$s.28
$s.28
$s.28
$s.28
$s.28
$s.28
$5.,14
$5.214
$5.,+4
51
Apr-34
May-34
Jun-34
Jul-34
Aug-34
Sep-34
Oct-34
Nov-34
Dec-34
Jan-35
Feb-35
Mar-35
Apr-35
May-35
Jun-35
Jul-35
Aug-35
Sep-35
Oct-35
Nov-35
Dec-35
Jan-36
Feb-36
Mar-36
Apr-36
May-36
Jun-36
Jul-36
Aug-36
Sep-36
Oct36
Nov-36
Dec-36
$98.83
$99.13
$99.44
$99.74
sl00.0s
$100.35
$100.66
$100.96
$101.27
$101.s7
$101.88
s102.r9
sr02.49
s102.80
$103.10
$103.41
$103.71
s104.02
$104.32
$r04.63
$104.93
$105.24
$10s.55
$l0s.8s
sl06.l6
$106.47
$r06.78
$r07.09
$107.41
$107.72
$108.03
s108.35
$108.67
s92.63
$92.92
$93.20
$93.49
$93.78
$94.06
$94.3s
$94.64
s94.93
$9s.2r
$9s.s0
$95.79
$96.08
$96.36
$96.65
$96.94
$97.22
$97.s 1
$97.80
$98.09
$98.37
s98.66
$98.95
s99.24
$9e.s3
$99.82
sr00.r l
$100.41
$100.70
$r01.00
$101.29
s101.59
$101.89
ss.44
s5.44
$5.214
$5.,{4
$s.44
$5.,14
$s.44
$s.44
$5.44
ss.61
$5.61
s5.61
$5.61
$s.61
$5.61
$s.61
$s.61
$s.61
$s.61
$s.61
$5.61
s5.77
$s.77
ss.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
ss.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
52
REDLINED FORMAT
SECOND REPLACEMENT APPENDIX E
SOLAR FACILITY ENERGY PRICES AND INTEGRATION CHARGES
(Prices based upon the energy shape and capacity specified in Appendix I)
E-l Base Enerey Purchase Prices - For all Base Energy received during Heavy Load Hours Idaho
Power shall pay the Base Energy Heavy Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge
specified below and for all Base Energy received during Light Load Hours Idaho Power shall pay
the Base Energy Light Load Purchase Price less the Solar Integration Charge specified below. All
of these prices are subject to revision as specified within paragraph 7.5.
Base Energy Heavy
Load Purchase PriceMontMYear (Mills/kWh)
Base Energy Light Solar Integration
Load Purchase Price Charge(Mills/kWh) (Mills/kWh)
Jan-16
Feb-16
Mar-16
Apr-16
May-16
Jun-16
Jul-16
Aug-16
Sep-16
Oct-16
Nov-16
Dec-16
Jan-17
Feb-17
Mar-17
Apr-17
May-17
Jun-17
Jul-17
Aug-17
Sep-17
Oct-17
Nov-17
Dec-17
Jan- I 8
Feb-18
Mar-18
$31.98$W1
$32.28$B,136
s32.s9$32Se
s32.89$33+r
$33.20$3s3
$33.51$33=66
$33.8 1$33,98
$34.r2$v;e
$34.42$g4
$34.73$3t.95
$35.03$3#
$3s.34$m
$3s.64$3s?
$3s.9s$3sr
$36.2s$3#
$36.s6$3#
s36.86$3+r
937.17$31-54
$37.47$#"€,6
$37.78ffi
$38.08$38-+r
$38.39$38*3
$38.69$3H
$39.00$39++8
$39.30$9*e
$39.61$40-B
s39.92$4444
$29.72$3e56
$30.01$eJs
$30.30$3{-25
s30.s8$+s
$30.87$3-l=&t
$3 1.1 6$34=t4
$31.4s$9_.Z+3
$3r.73$+231
$32.02$3*2
$32.31$3s
$32.60$33-g
$32.88$33J+
$33.17$3t.20
$33.46$+t.50
$33.74$343s
$34.03$3#
s34.32$3538
s34.61$3#
s34.89$35"97
$3s.18$3#+
$3s.47$3#
$35.76$36,86
$36.04$3#
$36.33$3++l5
$36.62V#
$36.90$38+4
$37.19$3834
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
s3.20
s3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.20
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
s3.29
93.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.29
$3.39
s3.39
$3.39
47
Apr-18
May-18
Jun-18
Jul-18
Aug-18
Sep-l 8
Oct-18
Nov-18
Dec-l8
Jan-19
Feb-19
Mar-19
Apr-19
May-19
Jun-19
Jul-19
Aug-19
Sep-19
Oct-19
Nov-19
Dec-19
Jan-20
Feb-20
Mar-20
Apr-20
May-20
Jun-20
Jul-20
Aug-20
Sep-20
Oct-20
Nov-20
Dec-20
Jan-21
Feb-21
Mar-21
Apr-21
May-21
Jun-21
Jul-21
Aug-21
Sep-21
Oct-21
Nov-21
Dec-21
Jan-22
Feb-22
Mar-22
$40.22$4Q3+
$40.53$4#
s40.83$4{"4}
$41.14$4{-%
s4t.44WA6
$41.75$42-38
$42.0s$+23+
$42.36$4S3
$42.66$4?'35
s42.97W#
s43.27$m
$43.58$44-32
$43.88$445s
$44.19$44+7
$44.49$4s
$44.80$4#
$4s.r0$4s
$4s.4tw
$4s.72$4#
$46.02$469+
s46.33$/,-/#
$46.63y1-56
$46.94$47+8
s47.24$484
$47.ss$48#
s47.85$48*5
$48.16,$49?++
$48.46$4eS
$48.77$/p+2
$49.07$5e,+4
$49.38Sse++
$49.68$sB
$49.99$++r
$5Q2gSS+-++
$50.60$+H
$50.90$54=08
$5r.21$*r+
$s 1.51$#3
$51.82$S=05
$52.13$53,38
$s2.43$m
$s2.74$s4+Z
$s3.04$rBs
$s3.3s$AnS+
$s3.6s$s4J9
$53.96$55=3+
$s4.26$s#r
s54.s7$5g
s37.48$38#
$37.77$4893
s38.0s$s2
w$3es2
$38.63$39-8+
$38.91$40,1+
$39.20$40J0
$39.49$40Je
$39.78$4e99
$40.06$4{-29
s40.35$4H
$40.64$4S
$40.93$43#
$4r.2r$+2+7
$41.s0$42+6
$41.79$43$6
$42.07$M
$42.36$43'65
$42.6sW54
$-P4$4424
$43.22$44s4
$43.51$44=83
$43.80$H3
$44.09$45'/p-
$44.37$4531
$44.66$46e+
$44.95$4er
s4s.23$4ffi
$4s.s2$46Je
s4s.at$++-+g
$46.10$+7-44^
$46.38$4++8
$46.67$48$8
$46.96$48?3+
s47.24Ws
$47.s3$4s=96
s47.82$M
$48.11$495s
$48.39$493s
$4E 0gssg'++
$4E.qZSss++
$4926$se+4
$49.s4$5r+3
$49.83$583
$s0.12$+w
$50.40$+g
$s0.69$#+
$s0.98$#r
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
$3.39
s3.39
$3.39
$3.39
$3.3e
$3.39
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
$3.49
s3.49
$3.49
s3.49
s3.49
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
s3.60
s3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.60
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.71
$3.7r
$3.71
s3.71
$3.71
$3.71
s3.71
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
48
Apr-22
May-22
Jwr-22
Jul-22
Aug-22
Sep-22
Oct-22
Nov-22
Dec-22
Jan-23
Feb-23
Mar-23
Apr-23
May-23
Jun-23
Jul-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
May-24
Jrur-24
Jul-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Jan-25
Feb-25
Mar-25
Apr-25
May-25
Jun-25
Jul-25
Aug-25
Sep-25
Oct-Z5
Nov-25
Dec-25
Ja*26
Feb-26
Mar-26
$s4.87$ss
$s5.18$s6'6r
$551E$s6r3
$55.79$s++6
$56.09$5+58
$s6.40$#J0
$s6.70$s8+3
$57.01$585s
$s7.31$s8*+
$s7.62$sH
$57.92$59,#
$s8.23$s+&r
$s8.s4$60;H
$58.84$60Jt9
$s9.1s$6+er
$s9.45$6H
$59.76$6K
$60.06$6H8
$60.37$6+r+
$60.67$e41
$60.98$62+s
$61.28$AS8
$61.59$63+tO
$61.89$#
$62.20$6{.05
$62.s0$w7
$62.81$Anig
$63.r r$6#2
$63.42$s
$63.72$6#
$64.03$6S
$64.33$66+r
$64.64$6#
$64.9s$6#6
$6s.2s$g
$6s.56$s6e
$6s.86$6+J3
$66.17$6&2s
s66.47$68=#
$66.78$68*9
$67.08$6H2
$67.39$6954
$67.69$6q86
$68.00rep
$68.3o$+esr
$68.61$+0*3
$68.91$+M
$ag.zz$4+4&
$51.27$W
$51.ss$#
$s1.84$s339
$s2.13$s#
$52.42$53'98
$52.70$tt.28
$s2.99$s4#
$s3.28$AtJ7
$53.56$55=16
$53.85$s5+t6
$s4.14$s5#5
$s4.43$s#s
$54.71$ssr
$ss.00$563r
sss.29$sg
$ss.s7$#3
$5s.86$#S
$s6.ls$w
$56.44158-p
$s6.72$s84+
$57.01$58-7r
$57.30$s9Se
$s7.s9$593e
$57.87$s959
$s8.16$s9i9
$58.45$60,+8
$s8.73$50J8
$s9.02$60+7
$s9.31$6W
$s9.60$6H
$s9.88$6K
$60.17$6s
$60.46$#
$60.7s$es4
s6r.03$62*4
$61.32$eB
$61.6r$#3
$6r.89$#3
$62.18$eLe2
$62.47$WZ
$62.76W#
s63.04$An.4t
$63.33$6s30
s63.62$6H
$63.90$65=79
$64.19$6s
s64.48$6#
$64.77$6ffi
s3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
$3.82
s3.82
$3.93
$3.93
$3.93
$3.93
s3.93
$3.93
$3.93
s3.93
s3.93
$3.93
s3.93
$3.93
s4.0s
$4.05
$4.0s
$4.0s
$4.05
$4.0s
$4.0s
$4.05
s4.0s
$4.05
$4.05
$4.0s
$4.17
$4.17
$4.17
$4.17
s4.r7
M.17
$4.17
$4.17
$4.17
94.t7
94.17
$4.17
s4.30
$4.30
s4.30
Apr-26
May-26
Jun-26
Jul-26
A.tg-26
Sep-26
Oct-26
Nov-26
Dec-26
Jan-27
Feb-27
Mar-27
Apr-27
May-27
Jvr-27
Jul-27
Ang-27
Sep-27
Oct-27
Nov-27
Dec-27
Jat-28
Feb-28
Mar-28
Apr-28
May-28
Jun-28
Jul-28
Aug-28
Sep-28
Oct-28
Nov-28
Dec-28
Jan-29
Feb-29
Mar-29
Apr-29
May-29
Jur-29
Jul-29
Aug-29
Sep-29
Oct-29
Nov-29
Dec-29
Jan-30
Feb-30
Mar-30
$69.52$+H0
$69.83$++B
$70J3$72,4s
$70.449+23+
$70.75$++r0
$71.05$+3+t2
s7r.36$1334
s7r.66$14+7
v).91$143e
$72.27$14-+L
$72.s8$+s;04
s72.88$+536
$73.19$+sS8
s73.49$+#r
$73.80$H3
s74.10$+#
$74.41W
s74.7r$14
$7s.02$.,4#
$7s.32$F185
$75-6lS+e+7
$75.93$+859
$76.2451892
$76.s451924
$76.8s$7956
$77.16$+9*9
$77.46$8e+r
$77.77$fps1
$78.07$8e*6
s78.38$&H
s78.68$srj0
s78.99$&s
s79.29$82-t5
$7q.00$82+7
$79.90$82ie
$80.21$83.p
$80.51$83+14
$80.82$83J7
$81.12$84S9
s8r.43$&[4r
$81.73$8+7r
$82.041$8536
$82.34$H
$82.6s$8#r
$82.9s$86$3
$83.26$863s
$83.s7$86S8
$83.87$8+S0
ffi.85$66J+
$6s.34$H7
s6s.63$6756
$6s.92$6+i6
$66.20$68-15
$66.49$68;t5
$66.78$68+r
$67.06$69++
$67.35$6933
$67.64W#
$67.93$6BJ2
$68.21$+012
$68.s0$+0s2
$68.79Wr
$69.07$++r
$69.36$+re
$69.65$+He
s69.94$+p9
s70.22$#W
s70.51$+258
$70.80$+2,88
$71.09$+3rg
v)]7t*1347
s7r.66$1334
$zt.qs$74.o6
$72.23$##
$72.s2$14{5
$72.8$1ry
$73.10$++24
$73.38S#
$73.67$+#3
s73.96$7#
$74.2s974+Z
$74.s3914+Z
$74.829714+
$75.1r$+?3-t
$zs.39q7+5e
s7s.68$7+J0
$75.97$+8=+9
$76.26$184{^
s76.s4$+8+8
$76.83$+9S8
$77.12$19+7
$77.40$1941
$77.6e$W
$77.98$89
$78.27$8e5s
$78.ss$8e*s
$4.30
s4.30
$4.30
s4.30
$4.30
$4.30
s4.30
$4.30
s4.30
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
$4.43
s4.43
$4.43
$4.43
s4.43
s4.43
$4.43
$4.43
s4.43
$4.s6
$4.s6
s4.s6
s4.s6
$4.s6
$4.s6
s4.56
$4.s6
s4.s6
s4.s6
$4.56
$4.s6
$4.69
s4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
$4.69
s4.84
$4.84
s4.84
50
Apr-30
May-30
Jun-30
Jul-30
Aug-30
Sep-30
Oct-30
Nov-30
Dec-30
Jan-3 I
Feb-31
Mar-31
Apr-31
May-31
Jun-3 I
Jul-31
Aug-31
Sep-3 I
Oct-31
Nov-31
Dec-31
lan-32
Feb-32
Mar32
Apr-32
May-32
Jun-32
Jul-32
Aug-32
Sep-32
Oct-32
Nov-32
Dec-32
Jan-33
Feb-33
Mar-33
Apr-33
May-33
Jun-33
Jul-33
Aug-33
Sep-33
Oct-33
Nov-33
Dec-33
Jan-34
Feb-34
Mar-34
$84.18$8H
$84.48$8?5s
$84.79$8+97
$8s.09$88+9
$8s.40$8852
$85.70$8&ry1
$86.01$89J6
$86.31$8959
$86.62$89+r
$86.92$9e33
$87.23$9es6
$87.53$9eJ8
$87.84$980
$88.14$+H
$88.4s$+Hs
$88.75$92,9
$89.06$9+se
$89.36$92*2
$89.67$93.14
$89.98$93++7
$90.28$9s
$90.sg$ryl+r
$90.89$94.44
$91.20$9414
$91.s0$9s
$91.81$9s+t1
$92.1l$9#3
$92.42$W
$92.72$W8
$e3.03$9m
$93.33$9+€2
$93.64$9+34
$93.949914+
$94.2sw7s
$94.55$9Br
g_36$983r
$9s.16$98J6
$9s.47$99J8
$9s.78$995r
$96.08$e9J3
$96.3g$+eHs
$96.69$+Oe58
$97.00${00se
$97.30$]{}H2
$97.61$r+H
$97.91$+{)]=8+
$98.22$+e2=r9
$98.52$l€29
$78.84$8+-+4
$79.13$SH4
W#+33
$79.70$82S3
$79.99$82-32
$80.28$82#
$80.56$82+r
$E0.E5$83,2+
$81.r4$83s+
$81.43$$-8e
$8r.71$&rs
$82.00$&139
$82.29$&159
$82.58$e+98
$82.86$8#
$83.uSS557
$83.44$85?8+
$83.72$8#
S84.01$86++6
$84.:gSs6Js
$84.59$&7-05
$84.87$8+34
$8s.r6$8+54
$85.4s$8+J3
$8s.73$88+3
$86.02$88#
$86.3r$88*2
$86.60$89-t+
$86.88$89+l+
$87.r7$8+r
$87.46$90$e
$87.7s$9H
$88.03$9+59
$88.32$90*9
$88.61$9H
$88.89$+H
$89.18$9rJ7
M$e2S7
$89.76$9236
se0.04$9256
$90.33$92J5
$e0.62$93+s
$90.91$93"54
$91.19$93*4
$91.48$ry1J3
$91.77$9+B
992.0s$9432
s92.34$9.#2
$4.84
$4.84
s4.84
s4.84
s4.84
$4.84
$4.84
$4.84
$4.84
$4.98
s4.98
$4.98
$4.98
s4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$4.98
$s.13
$5.13
$s.r3
$s.13
$s.13
$s.r3
$s.1 3
$s.1 3
$s.1 3
$5.13
$s.13
s5.1 3
$s.28
$5.28
$s.28
ss.28
ss.28
s5.28
$5.28
ss.28
s5.28
ss.28
ss.28
s5.28
ss.44
$5.44
s5.44
Apr-34
May-34
Jun-34
Jul-34
Aug-34
Sep-34
Oct-34
Nov-34
Dec-34
Jan-35
Feb-35
Mar-35
Apr-35
May-35
Jun-35
Jul-35
Aug-35
Sep-35
Oct-35
Nov-35
Dec-35
Jan-36
Feb-36
Mar-36
Apr-36
May-36
Jun-36
Jul-36
Aug-36
Sep-36
Oct-36
Nov-36
Dec-36
$9E E3$+e2*4
$99.13$+€3={6
$99.44$lO3+9
$99.74$+€3=8+
$100.05${o4,r3
$100.3s$++rJ6
$100.66$J+t.+8,
$100.96$10++0
$101.27$l05rl3
$101.57${Os+s
$10r.88$W
$102.19$lS6rK)
$102.49$]{)#
$102.80${4+Szt
$r03.10$+€+=3+
$103.41$+0759
$103.71$+es+r
$104.02$+e8'34
$104.32${O866
$104.63$+€8J8
$104.93$ro9+r
$105.24${e9#
$r0s.ss${09J6
sr0s.8s$+-rc+8
$106.16$+r+6+
$r06.47$4-rc+l
$106.78$+{l-+7
$107.09$l+1#0
$107.41$++{-93
$107.72$++2%
$108.03$+r+59
$108.35$++2J3
$108.67${-rs
$92.63$9#r
$92.92$9#
$93.20$9sJe
$93.49$9640
$93.78$9ffi
$94.06$96#9
$94.3s$97S9
$94.64$9H
$94.93$9?58
$9s.21$9+97
s9s.s0$98*+
s9s.79$9856
$96.08$98*6
$96.36$9H
$96.65$99*+5
wse4$ry34
$97.22$-rce,gt
$97.sr$#3
$97.80$+e0#
$98.09$+{092
$9t.:zs+e+-ee
$98.66$+OH
$98.9s$++*+
$99.24$+€+r+
$99.53${02+++
$99.82${02-at
$100.1l${43+r
$r00.41$+03J+
$100.70$te3-6t
$101.00$lg=9?
$101.29$.r-&p2
Sl0l.59$+0zH
$10t.89$++t-83
$5.44
$5.,+4
$s.44
$5.,14
55.,14
s5.44
$s.44
s5.44
$5.44
$5.61
$s.6r
$5.61
$s.61
$5.61
$s.61
$5.61
$5.61
$5.61
s5.61
$s.61
$5.61
$5.77
$5.77
$s.77
s5.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
$s.77
ss.77
$s.77
$s.77
52