Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSANDP-IDACORP-APR-27-2012t.pdfSummary: IDACORP Inc. Credit Rating: BBB/Stable/ A-2 Rationale Standard & Poor's Ratings Services bases its 'BBB' corporate credit rating (CCR) on Idaho Power Co. (IPC) and its parent IDACORP Inc. on our view of the company's consolidated credit profile. This profile consists primarily of integrated regulated electric utility operations at IPC, and reflects an II excellent II business risk profile and II aggressive II consolidated financial risk profile under our corporate risk profile matrix. IPC's electric utility normally provides more than 99% of IDACORP's earnings and most of its consolidated cash from operations. IPC serves retail electric customers in Idaho and Oregon, which account for about 95% and 5% of regulated assets, respectively. IDACORP's and IPC's excellent business risk profile reflects our view of fully regulated monopoly utility operations, featuring both a low-cost hydroelectric generation base and a credit-supportive regulatory climate in Idaho. Hydro generation provides about one-half of total generation needs under normal water conditions, but we expect that the proportion will lessen as loads grow and as non-hydro generating resources are added. The utility has some of the lowest average retail customer rates in the U.S. as a result of its abundant hydroelectric generation. This exposes the company to substantial replacement power price risk when low water flows lead to reduced generation, although the risk will partially abate in 2012 as the Langley Gulch facility begins to supply IPC. Idaho regulators have authorized a robust power cost recovery mechanism to assist in absorbing variations and limiting financial exposure. IPC's revised annual power cost adjustment (PCA) mechanism in Idaho supports credit quality and reduces the undercollection of power costs. The most significant credit-supportive components of the annually filed PCA are a sharing provision that reduces the company's exposure to 5% of undercollected power costs, and a forecast cost methodology designed to reduce deferrals and collection lag. In exceptionally low water years, deferrals can materially weaken cash flows and credit metrics, but Standard & Poor's generally views such collection delays as temporary because we anticipate that the company will collect 95% of costs above base rates over 12 months, with a carrying charge. The PCA has a long history of support and no instances of material disallowances. Furthermore, in March 2012, IPC was permanently permitted a revenue decoupling mechanism, governing weather-normalization on residential customers and other small customers. The II aggressive II financial risk profile of IDACORP and IPC reflects our view of low cash-flow-based credit metrics and above-average adjusted debt leverage, based on our indicative corporate financial ratios. Credit metrics bottomed out in 2007, but have rebounded somewhat over the past few years because the company has taken steps to stabilize returns and bolster cash flows with updated base rates and a modified power cost mechanism. Slower expense growth, robust hydro output in the past few years, and tax benefits have also helped cash flows. We do not consider load loss stemming from the company's significant energy efficiency spending a significant risk due to a fixed-cost adjustment (FCA) mechanism in Idaho that decouples certain costs from energy usage by residential and commercial customers. However, the Idaho commission decision to continue to allow IPC to use the FCA--but not permanently--highlights our uncertainty about how energy efficiency spending affects credit. Standard & Poor's I Research I April 27, 2012 © Standard & Poor's. All rights reserved. No reprint or dissemination without Standard & Peer's permission. See Terms of Use/Disclaimer on the last page. 2 951355 I 300542s92 Summary: IDACORP Inc. For the 12 months ended Dec. 31, 2011, IDACORP's consolidated adjusted funds from operations (FFO) to total debt was 15.1 %, slightly higher than the previous year, supported by higher base rates and increased deferred taxes. (We adjust credit metrics to include the debt equivalent of leases, purchased power obligations, and postretirement benefit obligations.) We believe that the company should maintain average adjusted FFO to debt of at least 12 % to sustain the ratings but the metric is likely to trend higher as pending rate cases take effect. The company's consolidated adjusted debt to total capitalization was 54.3% as of Dec. 31, 2011. Adjusted debt leverage remains aggressive, while reported debt leverage trended down to 48%. The company appears to be targeting a balanced unadjusted capital structure and has taken steps to maintain it, even while executing an ambitious capital investment program. We expect capital expenditures to decrease when company completes the Langley Gulch plant this year. Capital spending for the 12 months ended Dec. 31, 2011, totaled $327 million, down from $340 million in 2010. The Idaho commission preapproved this investment after new legislation in 2009 granted preapproval authority. If slow growth rates continue over the next few years, the size of IPC's planned capital expenditures and expected internal cash funding ability should increase cash flows, limiting the need for external capital. If major transmission proposals in the Northwest move forward, IDACORP may need more external equity to support the credit rating. Such investments are uncertain and are unlikely to occur until after 2013. Liquidity The short-term rating on IDACORP and IPC is 'A-2'. Liquidity is strong, based on an analysis of sources and uses, absent access to capital markets. Companies with strong liquidity should be able to withstand substantially adverse market circumstances over the next 24 months while still having sufficient liquidity to meet their obligations. Our analysis results in coverage that is above 1.5x for the upcoming 12 months. Even when measured over the next 24 months, it remains above lx. On Oct. 26, 2011, IDACORP and IPC individually entered into a second amended and restated credit agreement. The credit agreements mature on Oct. 26, 2016, and provide as much as $125 million at IDACORP and $300 million at IPC. At Feb 17, 2012, IDACORP had no amounts outstanding under its credit facility and $51.5 million of commercial paper outstanding, and IPC had no amounts outstanding under its credit facility and no commercial paper outstanding. Each credit agreement contains a covenant requiring a leverage ratio of consolidated debt to consolidated total capitalization of no more than 65% at the end of each fiscal quarter. At Dec. 31, 2011, IDACORP and IPC were compliant with all facility covenants. Recovery analysis We rate IPC's first mortgage bonds (FMB) 'A-', two notches higher than the issuer credit rating, with a recovery rating of '1 +'. We assign recovery ratings to FMBs issued by U.S. utilities, and this can result in issue ratings being notched above the CCR on a utility, depending on the CCR category and the extent of the collateral coverage. We base the investment-grade FMB recovery methodology the ample historical record of nearly 100% recovery for secured-bond holders in utility bankruptcies and our view that the factors that supported those recoveries (small size of the creditor class and the durable value of utility rate-based assets during and after a reorganization, given the essential service provided and the high replacement cost) will persist. Under our notching criteria, we consider the limitations of FMB issuance under the utility's indenture relative to the value of the collateral pledged to bondholders, management's stated intentions on future FMB issuance, and the regulatory limitations on bond issuance when assigning issue ratings to utility FMBs. FMB ratings can exceed a utility CCR by as much as one notch in the 'A' category, two notches in the 'BBB' category, and three notches in speculative-grade categories. IPC's collateral coverage of more than 1.5x supports a recovery rating of '1+' and an issue rating of 'A-', two notches www.standardandpoors.com © Standard & Poor's. All rights reserved. No reprint or dissemination without Standard & Peer's permission. See Terms of Use/Disclaimer on the last page. 3 951355 I 300542s92 Summary: IDACORP Inc. above the CCR. Outlook The stable outlook reflects our expectation of sufficient operating cash flows to support financial metrics that are adequate for the ratings, the ability to internally fund a significant portion of capital expenditures, and adequate management of regulatory relationships. In our base case we expect FFO to debt of 16% and debt to EBITDA of 4. 7x in 2013, declining to 4.5x in 2014. We could lower the ratings if the company does not carefully manage costs and investments to ensure full recovery and the maintenance of credit metrics, including FFO to debt of at least 12 % . We could raise the ratings if the company is able to consistently achieve significantly stronger financial metrics, including adjusted FFO to debt of 20% or more and adjusted debt to capital of 50% or less, in addition to solidly managing regulatory relationships. However, higher ratings are unlikely in the near term, although we expect some credit improvement. Related Criteria And Research • Liquidity Descriptors For Global Corporate Issuers, Sept. 28, 2011 • Business Risk/Financial Risk Matrix Expanded, May 27, 2009 • Analytical Methodology, April 15, 2008 • Changes To Collateral Coverage Requirements For '1+' Recovery Ratings On U.S. Utility First Mortgage Bonds, Sept. 6, 2007 Standard & Poor's I Research I April 27, 2012 4 © Standard & Poor's. All rights reserved. No reprint or dissemination without Standard & Peer's permission. See Terms of Use/Disclaimer on the last page. 951355 I 300542s92 The McGrow·Hi/1 Companies I-