Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20130102order_no_32697_errata.pdfOffice of the Secretary Service Date January 2, 2013 BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE COMMISSION'S ) REVIEW OF PURPA QF CONTRACT ) CASE NO. GNR-E-11-03 PROVISIONS INCLUDING THE ) SURROGATE AVOIDED RESOURCE (SAR) ) AND INTEGRATED RESOURCE PLANNING ) ERRATA TO (IRP) METHODOLOGIES FOR ) ORDER NO. 32697 CALCULATING AVOIDED COST RATES. ) On December 18, 2012, the Commission issued final Order No. 32697. Avoided cost rates calculated based on the Commission's findings in the Order and provided as Attachments A, B and C incorrectly incorporated transmission and line loss in the calculations. Pursuant to the Commission's findings, energy payments are not to be discounted by transmission and line loss. Order No. 32697 at 16. The corrected avoided cost rate calculation sheets are attached. DATED at Boise, Idaho this 2 day of January 2013. Jn D. Jewell () Commission Secretary bls/O:GNR-E-1 1-03—Errata 32697 IDAHO POWER COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR WIND PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED RATES (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR 1 30.53 30.35 33.12 36.25 37.33 38.48 2012 30.53 2 30.44 31.68 34.62 36.77 37.88 39.13 2013 30.35 3 31.27 33.09 35.45 37.29 38.48 39.88 2014 33.12 4 32.37 34.02 36.12 37.86 39.16 40.49 2015 36.25 5 33.21 34.78 36.75 38.49 39.76 41.43 2016 37.33 6 33.93 35.47 37.41 39.05 40.60 42.55 2017 38.48 7 34.59 36.15 37.99 39.83 41.62 43.67 2018 39.84 8 35.24 36.75 38.74 40.75 42.64 44.68 2019 41.56 9 35.83 37.49 39.61 41.69 43.59 45.60 2020 42.64 10 36.52 38.33 40.50 42.57 44.45 46.48 2021 46.00 11 37.31 39.17 41.33 43.38 45.28 47.38 2022 49.71 12 38.10 39.97 42.11 44.16 46.13 48.25 2023 52.58 13 38.86 40.72 42.86 44.97 46.96 49.06 2024 54.52 14 39.56 41.44 43.62 45.74 47.73 49.86 2025 56.18 15 40.25 42.18 44.36 46.48 48.49 50.65 2026 58.48 16 40.95 42.88 45.07 47.20 49.24 51.42 2027 61.63 17 41.62 43.56 45.76 47.91 49.97 52.17 2028 64.00 18 42.26 44.22 46.43 48.60 50.69 52.94 2029 66.03 19 42.88 44.86 47.09 49.28 51.42 53.73 2030 68.69 20 43.50 45.50 47.74 49.97 52.17 54.48 2031 71.49 2032 74.37 2033 77.18 2034 81.63 2035 86.29 2036 88.46 2037 92.22 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case' at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. - - ATTACHMENT A ERRATA ORDER NO. 32697 CASE NO. GNR-E-11-03 IDAHO POWER COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SOLAR PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMVVIi Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH ___________________________ CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 38.62 63.05 64.52 66.06 2012 30.53 2 30.44 34.32 50.35 63.76 65.26 66.91 2013 30.35 3 32.96 43.16 54.71 64.47 66.05 67.85 2014 38.62 4 39.62 47.88 57.22 65.21 66.92 68.65 2015 63.05 5 43.85 50.97 59.02 66.02 67.69 69.77 2016 64.52 6 46.86 53.26 60.51 66.76 68.71 71.07 2017 66.06 7 49.20 55.12 61.73 67.70 69.90 72.37 2018 67.83 8 51.14 56.65 62.99 68.79 71.09 73.55 2019 69.96 9 52.75 58.13 64.29 69.90 72.20 74.63 2020 71.46 10 54.29 59.58 65.55 70.93 73.23 75.68 2021 75.24 11 55.79 60.95 66.71 71.90 74.22 76.74 2022 79.38 12 57.19 62.21 67.78 72.84 75.23 77.76 2023 82.67 13 58.47 63.36 68.80 73.79 76.20 78.73 2024 85.06 14 59.64 64.44 69.80 74.71 77.12 79.68 2025 87.16 15 60.74 65.50 70.77 75.59 78.03 80.61 2026 89.91 16 61.80 66.50 71.68 76.44 78.91 81.52 2027 93.53 17 62.81 67.44 72.56 77.29 79.78 82.41 2028 96.37 18 63.76 68.35 73.42 78.11 80.63 83.32 2029 98.86 19 64.66 69.22 74.26 78.91 81.48 84.24 2030 102.01 20 65.53 70.07 75.07 79.73 82.36 85.11 2031 105.30 2032 108.67 2033 111.99 2034 116.94 2035 122.12 2036 124.82 2037 129.11 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.govloiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. IDAHO POWER COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR HYDRO PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $/MWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ON-LINE YEAR CONTRACT LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 34.98 45.33 46.54 47.83 2012 30.53 2 30.44 32.58 39.95 45.91 47.16 48.55 2013 30.35 3 31.84 36.50 41.98 46.50 47.83 49.36 2014 34.98 4 34.83 38.72 43.27 47.13 48.57 50.03 2015 45.33 5 36.82 40.27 44.30 47.82 49.22 51.03 2016 46.54 6 38.31 41.50 45.24 48.44 50.13 52.22 2017 47.83 7 39.54 42.58 46.03 49.27 51.20 53.39 2018 49.33 8 40.63 43.50 46.96 50.25 52.28 54.47 2019 51.19 9 41.56 44.48 47.98 51.25 53.28 55.44 2020 52.41 10 42.54 45.53 48.99 52.18 54.20 56.37 2021 55.91 11 43.57 46.55 49.93 53.04 55.09 57.33 2022 59.77 12 44.57 47.51 50.81 53.88 55.99 58.25 2023 62.78 13 45.50 48.39 51.65 54.73 56.87 59.12 2024 64.87 14 46.37 49.24 52.50 55.56 57.69 59.97 2025 66.68 15 47.19 50.08 53.31 56.34 58.50 60.80 2026 69.13 16 48.01 50.89 54.09 57.11 59.30 61.62 2027 72.44 17 48.80 51.65 54.84 57.86 60.08 62.42 2028 74.97 18 49.54 52.40 55.58 58.60 60.83 63.24 2029 77.15 19 50.26 53.12 56.30 59.32 61.61 64.07 2030 79.98 20 50.96 53.82 57.00 60.06 62.40 64.86 2031 82.95 2032 86.00 2033 88.98 2034 93.59 2035 98.43 2036 100.78 2037 104.72 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case at http:l/www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. IDAHO POWER COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR CANAL DROP HYDRO PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 34.98 81.30 83.03 84.85 2012 30.53 2 30.44 32.58 57.23 82.13 83.91 85.83 2013 30.35 3 31.84 47.56 65.16 82.97 84.82 86.90 2014 34.98 4 42.79 55.41 69.52 83.84 85.81 87.82 2015 81.30 5 49.62 60.41 72.47 84.76 86.71 89.07 2016 83.03 6 54.40 64.00 74.75 85.62 87.85 90.49 2017 84.85 7 58.02 66.82 76.57 86.68 89.16 91.90 2018 86.89 8 60.94 69.09 78.31 87.89 90.47 93.21 2019 89.30 9 63.34 71.16 80.00 89.10 91.69 94.40 2020 91.08 10 65.52 73.10 81.58 90.25 92.82 95.56 2021 95.14 11 67.54 74.89 83.03 91.32 93.92 96.73 2022 99.57 12 69.40 76.51 84.34 92.36 95.04 97.86 2023 103.17 13 71.08 77.97 85.58 93.41 96.11 98.94 2024 105.85 14 72.59 79.33 86.79 94.43 97.13 99.99 2025 108.26 15 74.00 80.63 87.94 95.41 98.14 101.02 2026 111.32 16 75.34 81.86 89.02 96.36 99.12 102.02 2027 115.25 17 76.59 83.00 90.06 97.29 100.07 103.00 2028 118.40 18 77.76 84.10 91.07 98.20 101.01 104.00 2029 121.22 19 78.88 85.15 92.04 99.09 101.96 105.01 2030 124.69 20 79.93 86.15 92.97 99.98 102.91 105.96 2031 128.32 2032 132.03 2033 135.68 2034 140.99 2035 146.52 2036 149.58 2037 154.23 Note: A "canal drop hydro project" is defined as a generation facility which produces the majority of its generation during the irrigation season and is located on a man-made waterway that conveys water primarily intended for irrigation or that primarily conveys irrigation return flows. Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. IDAHO POWER COMPANY AVOIDED COST RATES FOR OTHER PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. CONTRACT 111 lig ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED RATES (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR 1 30.53 30.35 32.48 55.91 57.27 58.72 2012 30.53 2 30.44 31.37 43.73 56.57 57.97 59.51 2013 30.35 3 31.07 38.92 47.90 57.23 58.71 60.40 2014 32.48 4 36.57 42.98 50.29 57.92 59.52 61.15 2015 55.91 5 40.08 45.65 52.00 58.68 60.25 62.22 2016 57.27 6 42.61 47.65 53.41 59.38 61.22 63.47 2017 58.72 7 44.59 49.29 54.57 60.28 62.37 64.72 2018 60.38 8 46.26 50.65 55.77 61.32 63.51 65.86 2019 62.40 9 47.65 51.98 57.02 62.38 64.58 66.90 2020 63.78 10 49.00 53.32 58.23 63.38 65.56 67.90 2021 67.45 11 50.34 54.59 59.34 64.30 66.51 68.92 2022 71.48 12 51.61 55.75 60.36 65.20 67.48 69.90 2023 74.66 13 52.77 56.82 61.33 66.11 68.41 70.83 2024 76.92 14 53.84 57.82 62.30 66.99 69.29 71.74 2025 78.91 15 54.84 58.81 63.22 67.83 70.16 72.63 2026 81.54 16 55.82 59.75 64.10 68.65 71.01 73.50 2027 85.03 17 56.75 60.64 64.94 69.46 71.84 74.36 2028 87.75 18 57.63 61.49 65.77 70.25 72.65 75.23 2029 90.12 19 58.47 62.31 66.57 71.02 73.48 76.11 2030 93.13 20 59.28 63.11 67.34 71.80 74.31 76.95 2031 96.29 2032 99.54 2033 102.71 2034 107.53 2035 112.57 2036 115.13 2037 119.28 Note: 'Other projects" refers to projects other than wind, solar, hydro, and canal drop hydro projects. These "Other projects" may include (but are not limited to): cogeneration, biomass, biogas, landfill gas, or geothermal projects. Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. AVISTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR WIND PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $/MWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ON-LINE YEAR CONTRACT LENGTH _______ CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 30.25 33.34 34.38 35.49 2012 30.53 2 30.45 30.30 31.73 33.84 34.91 36.12 2013 30.35 3 30.39 31.24 32.54 34.34 35.49 36.84 2014 30.25 4 31.04 31.93 33.19 34.89 36.15 38.13 2015 33.34 5 31.60 32.53 33.80 35.49 37.25 39.46 2016 34.38 6 32.12 33.10 34.43 36.46 38.43 40.85 2017 35.49 7 32.64 33.70 35.34 37.52 39.68 42.14 2018 36.81 8 33.18 34.52 36.33 38.64 40.87 43.29 2019 38.48 9 33.92 35.43 37.38 39.74 41.94 44.30 2020 42.69 10 34.74 36.39 38.40 40.73 42.90 45.26 2021 46.04 11 35.61 37.34 39.35 41.64 43.82 46.22 2022 49.76 12 36.48 38.21 40.21 42.50 44.73 47.12 2023 52.62 13 37.29 39.02 41.03 43.36 45.59 47.98 2024 54.56 14 38.04 39.80 41.85 44.18 46.41 48.80 2025 56.22 15 38.77 40.57 42.63 44.95 47.19 49.60 2026 58.52 16 39.49 41.31 43.37 45.70 47.96 50.38 2027 61.68 17 40.18 42.01 44.08 46.43 48.71 51.14 2028 64.05 18 40.83 42.68 44.78 47.14 49.43 51.91 2029 66.07 19 41.47 43.34 45.45 47.82 50.16 52.70 2030 68.74 20 42.09 43.98 46.11 48.52 50.91 53.43 2031 71.54 2032 74.42 2033 77.23 2034 81.68 2035 86.34 2036 88.51 2037 92.27 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. - ATTACHMENT B ERRATA ORDER NO. 32697 CASE NO. GNR-E-11-03 AVISTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SOLAR PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ON-LINE YEAR iY - CONTRACT LENGTH ________ CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 30.25 33.34 34.38 35.49 2012 30.53 2 30.45 30.30 31.73 33.84 34.91 36.12 2013 30.35 3 30.39 31.24 32.54 34.34 35.49 36.84 2014 30.25 4 31.04 31.93 33.19 34.89 36.15 44.56 2015 33.34 5 31.60 32.53 33.80 35.49 42.17 49.80 2016 34.38 6 32.12 33.10 34.43 40.38 46.68 53.84 2017 35.49 7 32.64 33.70 38.56 44.27 50.33 53.87 2018 36.81 8 33.18 37.22 41.98 47.55 50.68 54.08 2019 38.48 9 36.21 40.22 44.94 48.06 51.10 54.37 2020 71.88 10 38.86 42.89 45.56 48.61 51.55 54.75 2021 75.67 11 41.25 43.54 46.17 49.14 52.05 55.25 2022 79.81 12 41.91 44.18 46.77 49.70 52.63 55.78 2023 54.14 13 42.54 44.79 47.36 50.31 53.21 56.32 2024 56.11 14 43.15 45.40 48.00 50.92 53.79 56.88 2025 57.79 15 43.75 46.03 48.62 51.51 54.38 57.46 2026 60.11 16 44.36 46.65 49.22 52.11 54.97 58.05 2027 63.29 17 44.96 47.25 49.82 52.71 55.57 58.64 2028 65.69 18 45.54 47.83 50.41 53.30 56.16 59.26 2029 67.73 19 46.11 48.41 51.00 53.88 56.78 59.92 2030 70.42 20 46.66 48.98 51.57 54.49 57.43 60.55 2031 73.25 2032 76.16 2033 78.99 2034 83.46 2035 88.15 2036 90.35 2037 94.13 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. AVISTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR HYDRO PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $JMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ON-LINE YEAR CONTRACT CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 30.25 33.34 34.38 35.49 2012 30.53 2 30.45 30.30 31.73 33.84 34.91 36.12 2013 30.35 3 30.39 31.24 32.54 34.34 35.49 36.84 2014 30.25 4 31.04 31.93 33.19 34.89 36.15 40.31 2015 33.34 5 31.60 32.53 33.80 35.49 38.92 42.97 2016 34.38 6 32.12 33.10 34.43 37.79 41.23 45.25 2017 35.49 7 32.64 33.70 36.43 39.81 43.29 48.70 2018 36.81 8 33.18 35.44 38.24 41.66 46.36 51.49 2019 38.48 9 34.70 37.05 39.94 44.40 48.90 53.79 2020 52.58 10 36.13 38.59 42.41 46.72 51.06 55.79 2021 56.08 11 37.52 40.81 44.53 48.71 52.95 57.62 2022 59.94 12 39.52 42.75 46.39 50.49 54.69 59.26 2023 76.60 13 41.28 44.46 48.06 52.13 56.27 60.74 2024 78.89 14 42.86 46.02 49.61 53.63 57.70 62.11 2025 80.91 15 44.29 47.46 51.03 54.99 59.02 63.39 2026 83.57 16 45.64 48.80 52.32 56.26 60.27 64.60 2027 87.09 17 46.88 50.02 53.53 57.45 61.44 65.74 2028 89.83 18 48.03 51.17 54.67 58.57 62.54 66.85 2029 92.23 19 49.11 52.25 55.74 59.62 63.61 67.95 2030 95.28 20 50.12 53.26 56.75 60.66 64.67 68.97 2031 98.47 2032 101.75 2033 104.96 2034 109.81 2035 114.88 2036 117.48 2037 121.66 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See 'Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaflaeo/tablebrowser/. AVISTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR CANAL DROP HYDRO PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. - CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH _________ CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 30.25 33.34 34.38 35.49 2012 30.53 2 30.45 30.30 31.73 33.84 34.91 36.12 2013 30.35 3 30.39 31.24 32.54 34.34 35.49 36.84 2014 30.25 4 31.04 31.93 33.19 34.89 36.15 48.93 2015 33.34 5 31.60 32.53 33.80 35.49 45.53 56.84 2016 34.38 6 32.12 33.10 34.43 43.06 52.29 62.68 2017 35.49 7 32.64 33.70 40.75 48.87 57.58 61.21 2018 36.81 6 33.18 39.05 45.83 53.61 56.82 60.29 2019 38.48 9 37.76 43.49 50.09 53.28 56.38 59.70 2020 91.77 10 41.67 47.31 50.04 53.14 56.14 59.39 2021 95.84 11 45.09 47.43 50.10 53.12 56.08 59.32 2022 100.28 12 45.30 47.62 50.24 53.22 56.18 59.38 2023 49.31 13 45.57 47.85 50.46 53.44 56.38 59.52 2024 51.21 14 45.86 48.14 50.77 53.72 56.62 59.74 2025 52.82 15 46.18 48.49 51.11 54.03 56.92 60.02 2026 55.07 16 46.56 48.87 51.47 54.38 57.26 60.36 2027 58.17 17 46.95 49.25 51.85 54.76 57.64 60.73 2028 60.50 18 47.34 49.66 52.25 55.16 58.04 61.16 2029 62.46 19 47.75 50.07 52.67 55.57 58.49 61.64 2030 65.07 20 48.16 50.49 53.10 56.03 58.98 62.11 2031 67.83 2032 70.65 2033 73.41 2034 77.80 2035 82.40 2036 84.52 2037 88.22 Note: A canal drop hydro project" is defined as a generation facility which produces the majority of its generation during the irrigation season and is located on a man-made waterway that conveys water primarily intended for irrigation or that primarily conveys irrigation return flows. Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowserl. AVISTA AVOIDED COST RATES FOR OTHER PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ON-LINE YEAR CONTRACT LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 30.25 33.34 34.38 35.49 2012 30.53 2 30.45 30.30 31.73 33.84 34.91 36.12 2013 30.35 3 30.39 31.24 32.54 34.34 35.49 36.84 2014 30.25 4 31.04 31.93 33.19 34.89 36.15 42.84 2015 33.34 5 31.60 32.53 33.80 35.49 40.86 47.05 2016 34.38 6 32.12 33.10 34.43 39.34 44.48 50.38 2017 35.49 7 32.64 33.70 37.70 42.47 47.49 53.09 2018 36.81 8 33.18 36.50 40.47 45.18 50.03 55.32 2019 38.48 9 35.60 38.95 42.92 47.51 52.16 57.19 2020 64.11 10 37.76 41.16 45.08 49.51 53.98 58.85 2021 67.78 11 39.75 43.13 46.96 51.25 55.61 60.40 2022 71.81 12 41.55 44.87 48.61 52.81 57.13 61.81 2023 74.99 13 43.15 46.41 50.10 54.27 58.52 63.10 2024 77.26 14 44.58 47.82 51.50 55.61 59.79 64.31 2025 79.25 15 45.90 49.15 52.79 56.84 60.98 65.45 2026 81.89 16 47.14 50.37 53.98 58.00 62.10 66.53 2027 85.39 17 48.30 51.50 55.09 59.09 63.17 67.56 2028 88.11 18 49.36 52.57 56.14 60.12 64.18 68.58 2029 90.48 19 50.37 53.57 57.14 61.10 65.17 69.60 2030 93.50 20 51.32 54.52 58.09 62.06 66.15 70.54 2031 96.67 2032 99.92 2033 103.10 2034 107.92 2035 112.97 2036 115.54 2037 119.69 Note: "Other projects" refers to projects other than wind, solar, hydro, and canal drop hydro projects. These "Other projects" may include (but are not limited to): cogeneration, biomass, biogas, landfill gas, or geothermal projects. Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR WIND PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. I. CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 33.05 36.19 37.26 38.41 2012 30.53 2 30.44 31.65 34.56 36.70 37.82 39.07 2013 30.35 3 31.25 33.05 35.39 37.23 38.42 39.82 2014 33.05 4 32.34 33.98 36.06 37.80 39.10 40.43 2015 36.19 5 33.18 34.74 36.70 38.43 39.69 41.37 2016 37.26 6 33.90 35.43 37.35 38.99 40.55 42.50 2017 38.41 7 34.56 36.11 37.94 39.77 41.57 43.62 2018 39.78 8 35.21 36.72 38.69 40.70 42.60 44.64 2019 41.49 9 35.80 37.45 39.57 41.65 43.55 45.56 2020 42.58 10 36.50 38.30 40.46 42.53 44.41 46.44 2021 45.93 11 37.29 39.15 41.30 43.35 45.25 47.35 2022 49.64 12 38.09 39.96 42.08 44.14 46.11 48.23 2023 52.51 13 38.85 40.71 42.84 44.95 46.94 49.05 2024 54.45 14 39.57 41.44 43.62 45.74 47.73 49.86 2025 56.10 15 40.26 42.18 44.37 46.48 48.50 50.66 2026 58.40 16 40.97 42.90 45.08 47.21 49.26 51.44 2027 61.56 17 41.65 43.59 45.78 47.93 50.00 52.20 2028 63.93 18 42.30 44.26 46.46 48.64 50.73 52.98 2029 65.95 19 42.93 44.91 47.14 49.33 51.47 53.79 2030 68.61 20 43.56 45.56 47.79 50.03 52.23 54.55 2031 71.41 2032 74.29 2033 77.10 2034 81.54 2035 86.20 2036 88.38 2037 92.13 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. ATTACHMENT C ERRATA ORDER NO. 32697 CASE NO. GNR-E-11-03 PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR SOLAR PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ON-LINE YEAR CONTRACT LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 58.89 62.41 63.86 65.40 2012 30.53 2 30.44 44.08 60.58 63.11 64.60 66.25 2013 30.35 3 39.21 49.72 61.59 63.81 65.39 67.18 2014 58.89 4 44.36 52.86 62.44 64.56 66.25 67.98 2015 62.41 5 47.69 55.00 63.24 65.36 67.02 69.10 2016 63.86 6 50.10 56.66 64.07 66.10 68.05 70.40 2017 65.40 7 52.01 58.07 64.82 67.05 69.24 71.70 2018 67.16 8 53.64 59.27 65.73 68.14 70.44 72.88 2019 69.28 9 55.01 60.49 66.77 69.25 71.55 73.97 2020 70.77 10 56.36 61.75 67.82 70.29 72.58 75.02 2021 74.54 11 57.70 62.96 68.81 71.26 73.57 76.09 2022 78.67 12 58.98 64.09 69.74 72.20 74.59 77.12 2023 81.95 13 60.16 65.13 70.65 73.16 75.56 78.09 2024 84.32 14 61.25 66.12 71.56 74.09 76.50 79.05 2025 86.42 15 62.28 67.11 72.45 74.97 77.41 79.99 2026 89.16 16 63.28 68.05 73.29 75.84 78.30 80.91 2027 92.77 17 64.24 68.94 74.12 76.69 79.18 81.81 2028 95.60 18 65.15 69.80 74.93 77.52 80.04 82.72 2029 98.08 19 66.02 70.64 75.73 78.34 80.91 83.66 2030 101.21 20 66.86 71.46 76.51 79.16 81.79 84.54 2031 104.49 2032 107.86 2033 111.16 2034 116.10 2035 121.27 2036 123.96 2037 128.23 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaflaeo/tablebrowser/. PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR HYDRO PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMVVh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. - rrH CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH ______________________________ CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZEO (YEARS) YEAR RATES 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 1 30.53 30.35 41.81 45.07 46.28 47.56 2012 30.53 2 30.44 35.86 43.38 45.65 46.89 48.28 2013 30.35 3 33.95 38.70 44.27 46.24 47.56 49.09 2014 41.81 4 36.42 40.38 45.00 46.86 48.30 49.76 2015 45.07 5 38.10 41.61 45.69 47.55 48.96 50.76 2016 46.28 6 39.39 42.62 46.40 48.18 49.87 51.95 2017 47.56 7 40.47 43.55 47.05 49.01 50.94 5313 2018 49.06 8 41.45 44.36 47.85 50.00 52.03 54.21 2019 50.91 9 42.31 45.26 48.79 51.00 53.04 55.19 2020 52.13 10 43.23 46.24 49.73 51.94 53.96 56.13 2021 55.63 11 44.21 47.22 50.62 52.81 54.85 57.09 2022 59.48 12 45.17 48.14 51.46 53.65 55.76 58.02 2023 62.49 13 46.08 48.99 52.27 54.51 56.64 58.89 2024 64.57 14 46.92 49.81 53.09 55.35 57.48 59.75 2025 66.38 15 47.72 50.63 53.88 56.14 58.30 60.60 2026 68.83 16 48.53 51.42 54.64 56.92 59.10 61.42 2027 72.13 17 49.31 52.18 55.38 57.68 59.89 62.23 2028 74.66 18 50.04 52.91 56.11 58.43 60.66 63.06 2029 76.84 19 50.76 53.63 56.83 59.16 61.45 63.91 2030 79.66 20 51.46 54.33 57.52 59.90 62.25 64.71 2031 82.62 2032 85.67 2033 88.64 2034 93.25 2035 98.08 2036 100.44 2037 104.36 Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.govloiaf/aeo/tablebrowser/. PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR CANAL DROP HYDRO PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $IMWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. - oil CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH ________________ CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED RATES (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR 1 30.53 30.35 76.49 80.26 81.98 83.78 2012 30.53 2 30.44 52.54 78.30 81.08 82.84 84.75 2013 30.35 3 44.63 61.08 79.43 81.91 83.76 85.82 2014 76.49 4 52.54 65.72 80.40 82.78 84.74 86.74 2015 80.26 5 57.56 68.80 81.32 83.70 85.63 87.98 2016 81.98 6 61.14 71.12 82.26 84.56 86.78 89.40 2017 83.78 7 63.90 73.03 83.12 85.62 88.08 90.82 2018 85.81 8 66.19 74.63 84.15 86.82 89.39 92.12 2019 88.20 9 68.09 76.18 85.29 88.04 90.62 93.32 2020 89.96 10 69.88 77.72 86.45 89.19 91.75 94.48 2021 94.01 11 71.60 79.18 87.54 90.26 92.86 95.65 2022 98.43 12 73.20 80.52 88.57 91.31 93.97 96.79 2023 102.00 13 74.67 81.76 89.58 92.37 95.05 97.87 2024 104.67 14 76.01 82.93 90.59 93.39 96.08 98.92 2025 107.06 15 77.27 84.08 91.57 94.37 97.09 99.96 2026 110.11 16 78.48 85.17 92.50 95.33 98.08 100.97 2027 114.02 17 79.63 86.20 93.42 96.27 99.05 101.96 2028 117.16 18 80.71 87.20 94.32 97.19 99.99 102.97 2029 119.96 19 81.74 88.16 95.20 98.09 100.95 103.99 2030 123.41 20 82.73 89.09 96.06 99.00 101.92 104.96 2031 127.02 2032 130.71 2033 134.35 2034 139.63 2035 145.14 2036 148.18 2037 152.81 Note: A 'canal drop hydro project" is defined as a generation facility which produces the majority of its generation during the irrigation season and is located on a man-made waterway that conveys water primarily intended for irrigation or that primarily conveys irrigation return flows. Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.govloiaf/aeo/tablebrowserl. PACIFICORP AVOIDED COST RATES FOR OTHER PROJECTS December 18, 2012 $/MWh Eligibility for these rates is limited to wind and solar projects 100 kW or smaller, and to non-wind and non- solar projects smaller than 10 aMW. ?_ CONTRACT ON-LINE YEAR LENGTH CONTRACT NON-LEVELIZED (YEARS) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YEAR RATES 1 30.53 30.35 52.01 55.42 56.78 58.21 2012 30.53 2 30.44 40.77 53.65 56.07 57.47 59.01 2013 30.35 3 37.09 45.28 54.61 56.73 58.21 59.89 2014 52.01 4 41.16 47.83 55.41 57.43 59.02 60.64 2015 55.42 5 43.82 49.60 56.17 58.19 59.74 61.71 2016 56.78 6 45.78 51.00 56.95 58.88 60.72 62.97 2017 58.21 7 47.36 52.22 57.66 59.78 61.87 64.22 2018 59.86 8 48.73 53.26 58.53 60.83 63.02 65.36 2019 61.88 9 49.89 54.36 59.52 61.89 64.09 66.40 2020 63.26 10 51.07 55.50 60.53 62.89 65.07 67.41 2021 66.92 11 52.26 56.62 61.48 63.82 66.03 68.43 2022 70.94 12 53.42 57.66 62.37 64.73 67.00 69.42 2023 74.11 13 54.49 58.63 63.24 65.65 67.94 70.36 2024 76.37 14 55.47 59.55 64.12 66.54 68.83 71.27 2025 78.34 15 56.41 60.47 64.97 67.38 69.71 72.17 2026 80.97 16 57.34 61.35 65.78 68.21 70.56 73.06 2027 84.45 17 58.22 62.19 66.57 69.03 71.41 73.92 2028 87.16 18 59.06 63.00 67.35 69.83 72.23 74.80 2029 89.52 19 59.87 63.79 68.11 70.61 73.07 75.70 2030 92.53 20 60.66 64.56 68.86 71.40 73.92 76.55 2031 95.68 2032 98.92 2033 102.08 2034 106.89 2035 111.92 2036 114.48 2037 118.61 Note: "Other projects" refers to projects other than wind, solar, hydro, and canal drop hydro projects. These 'Other projects" may include (but are not limited to): cogeneration, biomass, biogas, landfill gas, or geothermal projects. Note: The rates shown in this table have been computed using the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)'s Annual Energy Outlook 2012 released June 25, 2012. See "Annual Energy Outlook 2012, All Tables, Energy Prices by Sector and Source, Mountain, Reference case" at http://www.eia.gov/oiaflaeoltablebrowser/.