Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20160526Thies Exhibit 2.pdfDAVID J. MEYER VICE PRESIDENT AND CHIEF COUNSEL FOR REGULATORY & GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS AVISTA CORPORATION P.O. BOX 3727 1411 EAST MISSION AVENUE SPOKANE, WASHINGTON 99220-3727 TELEPHONE: (509) 495-4316 FACSIMILE: (509) 495-8851 DAVID.MEYER@AVISTACORP.COM BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION ) CASE NO. AVU-E-16-03 OF AVISTA CORPORATION FOR THE ) AUTHORITY TO INCREASE ITS RATES ) AND CHARGES FOR ELECTRIC SERVICE ) Exhibit No. 2 TO ELECTRIC CUSTOMERS IN THE ) STATE OF IDAHO ) MARK T. THIES ) FOR AVISTA CORPORATION (ELECTRIC) Standard & Poor's Moody's Last Upgraded Credit Outlook A+A1 A A2 First Mortgage Bonds Secured Medium-Term Notes A-First Mortgage Bonds A3 Secured Medium-Term Notes BBB+Baa1 Avista Corp./Issuer rating BBB Avista Corp./Corporate credit rating Baa2 Trust-Originated Preferred Securities BBB-Baa3 INVESTMENT GRADE BB+Trust-Originated Preferred Securities Ba1 BB Ba2 BB-Ba3 (1 The Company received an upgrade to its Corporate credit rating in March 2011 and to its First Mortgage Bonds in August 2011 Stable Stable AVISTA CORPORATION Long-term Securities Credit Ratings March/August 2011(1)January 2014 Exhibit No. 2 Case No. AVU-E-16-03M. Thies, Avista Schedule 1, Page 1 of 4 Percent of Component Amount Total Capital Cost Cost Total Long-term Debt 1,543,000,000$ 50.0%(2)5.67% 2.83% Common Equity 1,593,310,328$ 50.0%(2)9.90%(1)4.95% Total 3,136,310,328$ 100%7.78% Percent of Component Amount Total Capital Cost Cost Total Long-term Debt 1,493,000,000$ 50.7% 5.41% 2.74% Common Equity 1,454,612,499$ 49.3% 9.50%(3)4.68% TOTAL 2,947,612,499$ 100%7.43% (1)Proposed return on common equity (2) (3)As approved by the Commission in Case AVU-E-12-08/AVU-G-15-01 The Company's actual percentage of debt and equity is 49.2% and 50.8%, resectively. The Company is proposing a capital structure of 50% equity and 50 % total long-term debt. AVISTA CORPORATION Cost of Capital December 31, 2015 AVISTA CORPORATION Proposed Cost of Capital December 31, 2016 Exhibit No. 2 Case No. AVU-E-16-03M. Thies, Avista Schedule 1, Page 2 of 4 Principal Line Coupon Maturity Settlement Principal Issuance SWAP Discount Loss/Reacq Net Yield to Outstanding Effective Line No.Description Rate Date Date Amount Costs Loss/(Gain)(Premium)Expenses Proceeds Maturity 12/31/2016 Cost No. (a)(b)( c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(g)(h)(i)(j)(k)(l) 1 FMBS - SERIES A 7.530%5/5/2023 5/6/1993 5,500,000 42,712 - - 963,011 4,494,277 9.359%5,500,000 514,744 1 2 FMBS - SERIES A 7.540%5/5/2023 5/7/1993 1,000,000 7,766 - - 175,412 816,822 9.375%1,000,000 93,747 2 3 FMBS - SERIES A 7.390%5/11/2018 5/11/1993 7,000,000 54,364 - - 1,227,883 5,717,753 9.287%7,000,000 650,114 3 4 FMBS - SERIES A 7.450%6/11/2018 6/9/1993 15,500,000 120,377 - 50,220 2,140,440 13,188,963 8.953%15,500,000 1,387,715 4 5 FMBS - SERIES A 7.180%8/11/2023 8/12/1993 7,000,000 54,364 - - - 6,945,636 7.244%7,000,000 507,064 5 6 Trust Preferred*1.858%a 6/1/2037 6/3/1997 40,000,000 1,296,086 - - (1,769,125) 40,473,039 1.816%40,000,000 726,428 6 7 FMBS - SERIES C 6.370%6/19/2028 6/19/1998 25,000,000 158,304 - - 188,649 24,653,047 6.475%25,000,000 1,618,863 7 8 5.45% SERIES 5.450%12/1/2019 11/18/2004 90,000,000 1,192,681 - 239,400 88,567,919 5.608%90,000,000 5,047,001 8 9 FMBS - 6.25% 6.250%12/1/2035 11/17/2005 150,000,000 1,812,935 (4,445,000) 367,500 152,264,565 6.139%150,000,000 9,208,605 9 10 FMBS - 5.70% 5.700%7/1/2037 12/15/2006 150,000,000 4,702,304 3,738,000 222,000 - 141,337,696 6.120%150,000,000 9,179,674 10 11 5.95% SERIES 5.950%6/1/2018 4/3/2008 250,000,000 2,246,419 16,395,000 835,000 - 230,523,581 7.034%250,000,000 17,585,926 11 12 5.125% SERIES 5.125%4/1/2022 9/22/2009 250,000,000 2,284,788 (10,776,222) 575,000 2,875,817 255,040,618 4.907%250,000,000 12,268,615 12 13 3.89% SERIES 3.890%12/20/2020 12/20/2010 52,000,000 385,129 - - 6,273,664 45,341,207 5.578%52,000,000 2,900,581 13 14 5.55% SERIES 5.550%12/20/2040 12/20/2010 35,000,000 258,834 - - 5,263,822 29,477,345 6.788%35,000,000 2,375,887 14 15 4.45% SERIES 4.450%12/14/2041 12/14/2011 85,000,000 692,833 10,557,000 - - 73,750,167 5.340%85,000,000 4,538,871 15 16 4.23% SERIES 4.230%11/29/2047 11/30/2012 80,000,000 730,833 18,546,870 - 105,020 60,617,277 5.868%80,000,000 4,694,533 16 17 4.11% SERIES 4.110%12/1/2044 12/18/2014 60,000,000 425,188 (5,429,000) - - 65,003,812 3.650%60,000,000 2,189,882 17 18 4.37% SERIES 4.370%12/1/2045 12/16/2015 100,000,000 561,757 9,383,299 - - 90,054,944 5.015%100,000,000 5,014,858 18 19 Forecasted Issuance b 4.500%10/1/2046 10/1/2016 140,000,000 1,400,000 e 138,600,000 4.562%140,000,000 6,386,118 19 20 1,543,000,000 86,889,230 20 21 .21 22 Repurchase c 7.74%12/31/2017 6/30/2006 6,875,000 483,582 6,391,418 8.721%d 70,127 22 23 Repurchase c 5.72%3/1/2034 12/30/2009 17,000,000 1,916,297 15,083,703 6.661%d 159,446 23 24 Repurchase c 6.55%10/1/2032 12/31/2008 66,700,000 3,709,174 62,990,826 7.034%d 324,360 24 25 1,543,000,000 87,443,163 25 26 26 27 Adjusted Weighted Average Cost of Long-term Debt 5.667%27 28 a Var. Rate Long-Term Debt, interest rate information comes from Exhibit No. 1 Page 4 28 29 b 29 30 c The coupon rate used is the cost of debt at the time of the repurchases 30 31 d The amounts are calculated using the IRR function 31 32 e The Company forecasts issuance expenses of 1% based on historical costs 32 This is a projected issuance, whose maturity date and coupon rate may change depending on market conditions. Forecasted Rates are based on forward rates from Thomson Reuters analysis tools plus an estimated credit spread AVISTA CORPORATION Forecasted Cost of Debt Detail - Idaho December 31, 2016 Exhibit No. 2 Case No. AVU-E-16-03 M. Thies, Avista Schedule 1, Page 3 of 4 1 Dec-15 Jan-16 Feb-16 Mar-16 Apr-16 May-16 Jun-16 Jul-16 Aug-16 Sep-16 Oct-16 Nov-16 Dec-16 Avg of 2 (a)(b)(b)( c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)(j)(k)(l)(m)(o) 3 Trust Preferred*$40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 $40,000,000 40,000,000$ 4 5 Number of Days in Month 31 31 29 31 30 31 30 31 31 30 31 30 31 6 Forecasted Rates Trust Preferred** 1.2892% 1.2892% 1.2892% 1.5898%**1.7240%** 1.7240%** 1.7240%**1.8213%** 1.8213%** 1.8213%** 1.9322%** 1.9322%** 1.9322%** 7 Trust Preferred Interest Expense 44,406$ 44,406$ 41,541$ 54,760$ 57,467$ 59,382$ 57,467$ 62,734$ 62,734$ 60,710$ 66,554$ 64,407$ 66,554$ 743,119$ 8 9 10 Coupon Maturity Settlement Principal Issuance Gain/Reacq Net Yield to Outstanding Effective 11 Description Rate Date Date Amount Costs Expenses Proceeds Maturity 12/31/2016 Cost 12 (a)(b)( c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)(j)(k) 13 Trust Preferred 1.86% 6/1/2037 6/3/1997 40,000,000$ 1,296,086$ (1,769,125)$ 40,473,039$ 1.816% 40,000,000$ 726,428$ 14 15 *Original issue principal amount was $50 million. The Company repurchased $10 million of the securities outstanding. 16 **Forecasted Rates are based on forward rates from Thomson Reuters analysis tools plus the 87.5 basis points pursuant to the debt agreement. AVISTA CORPORATION Cost of Long-Term Variable Rate Debt Detail December 31, 2016 Exhibit No. 2 Case No. AVU-E-16-03M. Thies, Avista Schedule 1, Page 4 of 4 Exhibit No. 2  Case No. AVU‐E‐16‐03  M. Thies, Avista  Schedule 2, Page 1 of 1  CONFIDENTIAL subject to Attorney’s Certificate of Confidentiality Company’s planned capital expenditures and long-term debt issuances by year Pages 1 of 1 Exhibit No. 2  Case No. AVU‐E‐16‐03  M. Thies, Avista  Schedule 3, Page 1 of 9  CONFIDENTIAL subject to Attorney’s Certificate of Confidentiality Interest Rate Risk Management Plan Pages 1 of 9