Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20091223UWI to Staff 169-183.pdfMcDevitt & Miller LLP Lawyers (208) 343-7500 (208) 336-6912 (Fax) Via Hand Delivery Jean Jewell, Secreta Idaho Public Utities Commssion 472 W. Washigton St. Boise, Idao 83720 420 W. Bannock Street P.O. Box 2564-83701 Boise, Idaho 83702 Re: Case No. UWI-W-09-01 General Rate Case Fili Dear Ms. Jewell: HECEI f) L009 DEC 23 Pr1 l: 40 Chas. F. McDevitt Dean J. (Joe) Miler December 23, 2009 Enclosed for fig, please fid thee (3) copies of United Water Idao's First Response to Commssion Staffs Eighth Production Request Nos. 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178,179, 180, 181, 182, and 183. Kidly retu a fie staped copy to me. DJM/hh Encl. Very Truy Yours, McDevitt & Mier ll~LDean J. Mier ORIGINAL Dean J. Miler (ISB No. 1968) McDEVITT & MILLER LLP 420 West Banock Street P.O. Box 2564-83701 Boise, Idaho 83702 Tel: 208-343-7500 Fax: 208-336-6912 joe(imcdevitt -miller .com Attorneys for United Water Idaho Inc. BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF ) UNITED WATER IDAHO INC., FOR ) AUTHORITY TO INCREASE ITS RATES AND ~ CHARGES FOR WATER SERVICE IN THE )STATE OF IDAHO ) ) CASE NO.UWI-W-09-01 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC'S FIRST RESPONSE TO COMMISSION STAFF'S EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUESTS United Water Idaho Inc, ("United Water") by and through its undersigned attorneys, hereby submits its First Response to the Commission Staffs Eighth Production Request Nos. 169,170,171,172,173,174,175,176,177,178,179,180, 181, 182, and 183. DATED this1-1. day of December, 2009. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. BY:~ il ean J ~ Miler ' McDevitt & Miler LLP 420 West Banock Boise, Idaho 83702 P: 208.343.7500 F: 208.336.6912 Attorney for United Water UNITED WATER IDAHO INC'S FIRT RESPONSE TO COMMISSION STAFF'S EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUESTS. 1 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on thedêay of December, 2009, I caused to be served, via the methodes) indicated below, tre and correct copies of the foregoing document, upon: Jean Jewell, Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission 472 West Washington Street P.O. Box 83720 Boise,ID 83720-0074 j j ewell (ipuc. state. id. us Hand Delivered U.S. Mail Fax Fed. Express Email Brad M. Purdy Attorney at Law 2019 N. 17th Street Boise, ID 83702 bmpurdy(ihotmail.com Hand Delivered U.S. Mail Fax Fed. Express Email u:~'- ~'- ~'- ~'- ~'-)(~'- ~'- ~'- ~. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC'S FIRST RESPONSE TO COMMISSION STAFF'S EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUESTS- 2 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W -09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Kevin Doherty REQUEST NO. 169: Please calculate the change to the Company's fied revenue requirement that occurs as a result of the updates to actuals for Plant in Service requested in Production Request Nos. 160 to 166. Please identify and include within your response all amounts that would change as a result of updating Plant in Service forecasts to actuals. If an amount such as taxes (deferrals or expenses) does not change, please provide a detailed explanation as to why the amount would not change as a result of updating Plant in Service forecasts to actuals. RESPONSE NO. 169: Based on discussions between Commission Staf and United Water representatives, the Paries have agreed that the updates requested by the above referenced Production Requests may be provided after the close of the calendar year December 31,2009. United Water has agreed to provide the requested updates not later than Januar 8, 2010. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W -09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Kevin Doherty REQUEST NO. 170: Please provide all workpapers and underlying documentation supporting the Company's response to the preceding request. RESPONSE NO. 170: Based on discussions between Commission Staf and United Water representatives, the Paries have agreed that the updates requested by the above referenced Production Requests may be provided after the close of the calendar year December 31, 2009. United Water has agreed to provide the requested updates not later than January 8,2010. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W -09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF TH COMMSSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Kevin Doherty REQUEST NO. 171: Please provide the files in Excel format with formulas intact for all items in response to the preceding two requests. RESPONSE NO. 171: Based on discussions between Commission Staff and United Water representatives, the Paries have agreed that the updates requested by the above referenced Production Requests may be provided after the close of the calendar year December 31, 2009. United Water has agreed to provide the requested updates not later than January 8,2010. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Charles E. Loy REQUEST NO. 172: Please prepare Adjustment 1 (Exhibit 11, Schedule 1, Adjustment 1: Adjustment to Payroll Chargeable to Operations and Maintenance) based on pay rates and employee coùnts as of December 31, 2009. Include the pro forma workpapers 11.1.1, 11.1.2, 11.1.3. If there are any other adjustments afected by this adjustment, please include those affected adjustments and workpapers with this response. RESPONSE NO. 172: The Company has updated its Exhbit 11, Schedule 1, Adjustment 1 and all associated workpapers with the latest known inormation as requested. The Exhibit and associated workpapers are included in electronic format with this response. Gross payroll drops $30,371 from $5,587,860 to $5,557,489. The net payroll chargeable to Operations and Maintenance decreases $22,280 from $4,099,254 to $4,076,974. The reasons gross payroll is decreasing are enumerated as follows: 1. The Company filed the Accounting Manager position on August 03,2009 at a salar of $67,891 or $2,891 more than the $65,000 estimated in the initial filng. This also impacts the 2010 pro forma increase by an additional $116. 2. The Company hired a new Accounting Clerk on November 11,2009 to fil a short term vacancy. The gross pay impact is a decrease of $1,237. 3. The Company is in the process of hiring a new Customer Service Representative to fil a recent vacancy. The differential between the old salar and the new is expected to be a decrease of $9,532. 4. The Company filed a Utilty Person position on December 7, 2009 to fil an existing vacancy. The original filng contained an inaccurate pro-forma hourly rate of $18.30. The correct pro-forma rate per the Bargaining Unit contract is $19.20, a $1,872 increase. 5. The Company filed a vacant outside Customer Service position from within on October 3,2009. The pay differential from the old to the new employee is $0.45 per hour or an anual increase of $936. 6. Due to an internal transfer indicated above, the Company has chosen an internal candidate (Meter Reader) to fil the vacant Utilty Person position. This transfer wil become effective as soon as the hiring process is completed on a new Meter Reader. The pay differential from the old incumbent employee to the new candidate is a decrease of $11,690. 7. An existing outside Customer Service employee has elected to retire Januar 1,2010. It is anticipated this position wil be filed by a new employee early in the new year. The differential between the retiring employee and the new employee is anticipated to be a decrease of $12,688. 8. The new Meter Reader indicated in #6, above, wil replace the prior Meter Reader at a savings of $0.50 per hour or an anual total decrease of $1,040. Other adjustments that are afected by the change to payroll are as follows: Exhibit 11, Schedule 1, Adjustment NO.4: Adjustment of Employee Health Care Expense and Benefits. When the Company prepared its direct case, pricing data from late 2008 was utilzed and the aray of employee medical, dental and vision coverage choices from November 2008 was used. To compensate for the stale information, the Company used a price escalator of 10%, as provided by Human Resources, to increase pro forma medical costs. The Company now knows actual Company and employee costs for 2010 as well as employee coverage choices. As a result pro forma Health Care Expense & Benefits are increased from $831,250 to $887,966, an increase of $56,716. Exhibit 11, Schedule No.3, Adjustment No.1, FICA taxes, decreases due to the downward adjustment in payroll. Pro Forma FICA taxes as filed were $420,071 and are updated to $417,747. This represents a decrease of $2,324. Exhibit 11, Schedule No.3, Adjustment No.3, SUTA taxes actually increases despite the small downward change in payrolL. The case was fied with base SUTA wages of $33.200 and a tax rate of 0.447%. The Company has recently learned from the Deparment of Labor (see attached fax from IDOL) that base wages for 2010 are increasing to $33,300 and United Water Idaho's tax rate wil be 0.96% in 2010. This increase SUTA expense from an as filed $14,695 to an adjusted $31,568, an increase of $16,873. Exhibit 11, Schedule 1, Adjustment NO.6: Adjust Payroll Overheads Charged to Balance Sheet . Accounts incorporates the above changes. The net change is a $21,160 increase to expense. f- í2/22/2009 18: 12 FAX 12083348301 10 DEPT OF LABOR 19001/001 TX11 0000035505 FEIN 820101565 PROD LEC0760PREV FEIN 000000000 EMP SSN . 12/22/2009 EMPLOYER-NAME ~ ALPHA KEY UNITE 15: 04: 02 : 73 DBA-NAME UNITED WATER OF IDAHO DBA-CD 0 PHONE 208-367-7304ADDRESS-1 PO BOX 66744 ST LOUIS MO 631666744ADDRESS-2 8248 W VICTORY RD BOISE 10 837090000 ADDR-I-CD 4 SPEC-HNDLG 0 TYPE-COV-CD 00 CONTRIBUTOR-CD 0 ADDR-2-CD 9 TYPE-OWNER 2 WAGE-REPORT 0 DELINQUENCY-IND 0 494150SIC/OWNERSHIPCOUNTY-CD 001 NAICS CODE 221310~ FLO-REP-NO RATE ~ FOR YEAR 2010 FLD-ASN-NO LIABILITY-DATE 01/01/1936 PRED SUCC 00/00/000000/00/000000/00/0000 o01/01/1936 .00 BANKRUPT -DATE STATUS-ISSUE-DTE REINSTATEMENT -DATE ACCT -STATUS-CD ACCT-STATUS-DTE CURR-ACCT -BALANCE 045 AUDIT-ASSIGN 00/00/0000 00000000 AUDIT-COMPLETE 00/00/0000AUDIT-ERROR 0 0000000000 0000000000 INSTALLMENTSDUE-DATE 00000000PMT-CD 0PMT-AMT .00ANT-DUE .00PMTS-REM 00BALANCE .00 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/SponsoringWitness: Gregory P.Wyatt REQUEST NO. 173: Please provide the United Water Idaho specific parameters for the Short Ter Incentive.Plan (STIP). Please separate out the objectives into financial and personal objectives. Please provide any and all criteria upon which the incentive and bonus plans are based. Please break out each objective or. criteria by its percentage weight. RESPONSE NO. 173: Attached is the UnitedW'ater ShortTerm Incentive Plan (STIP), which explains the pareters for the Plan. Also attached is the STIP Incentive Weight Char which provides the weightings allocable for financial and personal objectives. The Idaho section has been highlighted. United Water Short Term Incentive Plan (STIP) I. PURPOSE The Short Term Incentive Plan (STIP) is an annual compensation plan that supports United Water's business objectives by: · Providing an annual incentive strtegy tht drives performance towards objectives ctitical to creating shareholder value. · Offering competitive cash compensation opportnities to all eligible employees. · Awarding outstanding achievement among employees who can directly impact United Water's results. · Providing cash awards for both qualitative and quatitative results. · Providing cash compensatioiiopportnities for making sound business decisions that impaCt the company's financial performance and the overall succes of Suez. II. ELIGfflLITY All active exempt employees in salargrades12and above inc1udingexpatrates are eligible to participate in STIP ifnot covered.byanother annual incentive plan. Employees must be hired or promoted into STIPeligible positions by the first pay period of the fourt quarer of the plan year, iii order to be eligible for a STIP award for that plån year.. III.AWAR OPPORTUNITIES Employees are assigned a target award based on their job/salary grade; Target awards for expatrates wil be based on their Suez compensation plan unless otherwise agreed to by Suez. The tagetawa~d. is established at market competitive levels and is expressed. as a percentage of base salary. Target awards wil be prorated for part.time employees. Paid awards may range from 0% to 200%ofthe target award based on achievement of financial objectives and personal objectives. Should any events occur during the performance year that in the opinion of the management of United Water materially affect the performnce targets set, then United Water may recommend tothe Compensation Advisory Committee and Suez that an adjustment be made to any final payment. IV. PERFORMCE MEASURES The STIP program is based on two different measures of performance that are critical to United Water's success, financial and personal performance. Page 1 UnitedWater 1('.. ' Financial Each year, Suez Environment and United Water's Compensation Advisory Committee determine financial measures and target performance levels that wil form the basis fór measuring success under STIP. Each objective is assigned a weight based on the employee's job/salary grade. Personal As a part of the Performance and Development Review (PDR) process, employees have specific annual objectives that support the attainment of departental or organizational objectives. These objectives form the basis for the personal. objective porton of STIP. Managers. have the flexibilty to set the weight of each personal objective in accordance with the plan's guidelines. v. PAYOUT SCALES Every level of company, business segment/departent and individual performance earns a different STIP payout. As United Water and its employees meet or exceed their objectives the payout will grow as shown on the below payout scales. Financial Objectives No incentive wil be paid for results at or below 80% (theshold) of an objective. An incentive payment equal to two times the target can be earned for results equal to or grater than 120% of objective. A linear progression applies for determining the payout % between theshold and maximum. Personal Objectives 0% 1%-90% 91%,.110% 111% -150% 151%- 200% At the end ofthe performance year, managers wil evaluate their employee's personal objectives and assign a payment percentage based on the level of performance achieved. Personal objectives that are financial indicators should be measured using the scale for financial objectives. Page 2 UnitedWater *"-. .k Sample Award Calculation Key Assumptions: Base Salary = $82,000 Individual Target = 15% or $12,300 Corporate Financials weight 30% and Personal Objectives weight 700/. EBITDA Free Cash Flow Net Current Income Total Financial (% Total STIP) Personal Ob'ective #1 Personal Ob'ectve #2 PersonalOb" ective #3 Personal Ob'ectve #4 Peronal Ob'ective #5 Total Personal % TotalSllP 100.0% 120.()% 110.0% 70.0% 100.0% 34% 33% 33% 100% 30"1 25% 20% 20% 20% 15% 100% 70% 25.0% 24.0% 22.0% 14.0% 15.5% 100.50/. Total Earned Award Calculatin Earned STIP Objective A!X Weight Total Finanèial 73.1%30°/í 21.9% Personal 100.5%70%70.3% Award Payment Calculation --Individual Target (15%) Total Earned AWard~. "!' STIP Award Payment $12,300'X; mv. $11,341 Vi. PLAN PAYOUTS Employees who are on the active payroll on December 3 i st of the pedormance year wil be eligible to receive an award. Employees who are terminated for' cause or gross misconduct or who vo1untan1y resign pnor to the end of a plan year wil not receive a STIP award. STIP awards wil be prorated for eligible new hires based on the number of days on payroll the year of hire. Employees whose target award may have changed dunng a plàn year due to a job change wil receive a prorated award based on number of days in each job. Page 3 United Water 1('.. . . , Employees who are eligible and choose to retire prior to the end of any plan year wil receive an award that is prorated to reflect the number of days actually worked during the plan year. This also applies in the event of death, disability (defined as any consecutive absence of 60 days or more), leave of absence, inter-company transfers or a reduction in force. In the event of disability the pro-ration wil apply to financial targets only and not personal objectives. Payments wil be made when normally paid in the 1 sl quarter of the year following the performance year. STIP awards are based on year-end salary. and are paid in lump sum during the first quarter following the end of the performance year. STIP award payments cannot be deferred. STIP awards are treated as ordinary income for tax purposes. Taxes wil be withheld and are owed in the year awards are paid. VII. ADMIISTRTION United Water's Compensation Advisory Committee, Suez Environment and the CEO of United Water admjnisterthe STIP program. The interpretation ofthe application of the plan doctnent is at the sole discretion of the company and the CEO's decision wil be binding. United Water's Compensation group manages program administration. Important Neither STIP, nor any action taken in conjuncton with this plan, shall be constred as giving to any emloyee the right to be retained by United Water.. The statements in this document do not consttute a contract relative to compsation treatment and are not intended to create any contractual rights, either expressed or implied, between United Water and its employees. Cerain situations may require compesation treatmt different thanthe practices expressed here. The policies, practices, and procedures descbed in this document tny be changed, altered, modified or deleted at any time, with or without prior notice by United Water. The STIP may be modified or terinated at any time. These actions may affect present and future eligible employees. Page 4 UnitedWater .- .. ."* Tj ; A - H o Al l U n i t e d W a t e r EB I T D A 10 % 10 % 5% 5% Fr e e C a s h F l o w 10 % 10 % 5% 5% . 10 % Ne t C u r r e n t I n c o m e 10 % 5% 5% No n - F i n a n c i a l Pe r s o n a l O b j e c t i v e 50 % 60 % 40 % 50 % Bu s i n e s s S e g m e n t / D e p t F i n a n c i a l s 20 % 10 % 20 % 10 % Pr o j e c t F i n a n c i a l s - - 25 % 25 % , UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF PreparerlSponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 174: Please provide the United Water Idaho specific parameters for the Bargaining Unit Incentive Plan. Please separate out the objectives into financial and personal objectives. Please provide any and all criteria upon which the incentive and bonus plans are based. Please break outeach objective or criteria by its percentage weight. RESPONSE NO. 174: Attached is the United Water Non-Exemptlnion Bonus Plan which explai the parameters and objectives criteria for the Plan. The Plan description separates out the objectives into financial and non-financial objectives, which are 50% financial and 50% non-financiaL. Non-ExemptlUl1l' Bonus Plan Regulated Segment 2007 ;),~.Q United Water. -s'-ez .'. Non,-ExempWnion Bonus Plan 2007 PURPOSE: For the 2007 performance year, a bonus program has been designed for non- exempt/union employees in the Regulated Segment The program support United Water's business ideals by recognizing the efforts of non-exempt employees in contributing to the ,stl~~'d()ltI. 8tlsines$Uniftl' finane~réSll~custom.,serice satisfactoii,..wate,.qualiltlcompliance and,safe~. initiatisoM EUf3IBltJ: All. acte non-exempt/unioo regular employees, part-time and full-time, are eligible to partcipate in the Bonus Program. Employees must be hired by the first pay period of the fourth quarter of the plan year, in order to be eligible for an award for that plan year. AltABD.O&lÐ.1'UNl~: Thetargta\Y.fØ~ntnx.mPWniòn.mPfoy..i.iSi't.5%... B~s~d ,on the, percentage achieved for each of the measurements, .R8Y_:;~.G'~'1'~'~:Qtlh_..tlfet (as in attched Payout Spal&). Payment is calculat8Ø based on bonus accomplishment multiplied by the employee's total productve earnings for the calendar year. PI'~¡iimJìrat.'defl_.Mì Earnings for all hours an employee is paid for (ineluding regtJlar time, overme, rest time; stand-by, emergencYt holidays (incl... ,floaters),. vacation, bere~vement, andie jury duty) excluding' sick time (PaiQlunpaid), STD, LTD, ,WOrkets Compensation; personal time (unpaiq): .and FMl time. PERfORMANCE MEASURES: perf0nnanc Measures are subject to change from one plan year to the next and .are at the discretion of senior management and the,.planCldniinistratci. ,All p~orClnce...is.t~ be measured against proposed business unit targets, on a,~."i:~II;'¡f1â$l.fõ b~.dptrpo.l.. The program is based .on the following measurements for each Business Unit: o EBtl'DA~ 50,. o SAfllV GOAES 25% o CUSl'OMERSERVlCe;OOAI"S&. 25~ Business Unit EBITDA - is the financial indicator used by United Water for all bonus programs. EBITDAi = Earnings (Revenue - Expenses) before Interest, Taxes, Depreciaton and Amortzation. EBITDA is a commonly used metrc to evaluate profitability. Safety Goals: (Each weighted equally) Recordable ancl. Fteuency. Rates Severity Rate Trainil1g.HoursPer Employe, Page 1 of5 .. Non-ExempVUnion Bonl,S Plan 2007' Customer Service. Goals: (Each weighted equally) For business units that cannot currently measure and report on ASA and abandoned calf rate, the remaining two customer service meties wil be weighted equally.Av~ersfilløfanswrçalls Abandon...ca,ratê RegYlatQf,ÇQglaint$,~.Q; t pelil.('QQ~t9mElr; Act~vrEl¡a9Jl~ COMlllNcariOIlEll BusinèsS Unit Modifier. This mocfi;ca;ad.~ølit~aPnfÎi,l.RJQ,,\Q~6~lto the bonus target, based o~the cornPJiance results. Iarg.,isQ~'.lQQ~~9mQU~i;ce in sampling and testing. Thecompllanceperformance measures are: .... .. . Processl Pênnit.Violations under operatíonal control samplir\lolatlón$ ReportingViolätlons Notifiation Violations ArV¡orãliJiI.'rftiatJlt~llt.sûreM¡ñfcr¡téì'iwæ'affçttht:bu~iMSsc~mø_~i~: CompU¡ance Bonus Violations Target Modifier 0 +0.5% 1 -0.25% 2 or more -0.5% PAYOUTS: Et~...,)lidJ~3..lf,9Dk1llJ~fl~Xl."P..,*fQl.iilialbø'3't~Ql;_'PI~y.af,.WiUbeii,Elli9i~l'ii~.rEl.~lt.aØlrawal' Employees who ..are terminated for caU$8 or gross misconduct wil' not recive an award regardless. of when.' termination occurs. ErnploYEle~Vl~(). voiunt~ril! resig~priorto.. the. end., of~epian~:~r ,'WiU n~t r;cei;e ,an award. et~...li._,ma~.Wbefl.....nmIl¡.... ~,initth_,1~!,....qLllt...QI.the!....year followingt, the; pElrtanee YElClrt,.' Awards are treated as ordinary income for tax purposes. Taxes win be withheld and are owed in the year awards are paid. PA'lOUT SCALE: %01 Payment AcmDlishment % 90%0% 95%50% 100%100% 105%112.5% 110%125% Page 2 of5 l ., ,. Non-Exempt/Union Bonus Plan 2007 AWARD EXAMPLES: I.Productive Earnings Target Modifier (+1-) 0 violations Modified Tar et $50,000 $ 750 +$ 250 $1,OC)O EBITDA Customer Service Safe Total Earned Award. Totat Payout $ (Modified Target X Award % 110.0% 110.0% 110.0% 125.0% 125~O% 125.0% 50% 25% 25% 62.5% 31.25% 31.25% 1250/0 $1,250 II.Productive Earnings Targ.. Modifier (+1-) 1 violatio Mödifl.Tar et $50,000 $ 750 -$ 125 $ 62$ $625 II.Prodlctve Earnin. Targ,. Modifier (+1-) 2violations MOdified'Tar et $50,000 $ 750 -$ 250 $ SOc) EBlTDA Customer ServiCè Safe Total Earned Award Total Payout $ (Modified Target X Award % 95.0% 95.0% 95.0% 50.0% 50.0% 50.0% 50% 25% 25% 25.0% 12.5% 12.5% 50.0% $250 Page 30f5 ~. .'"., NOlExemptlUnion Bonus Plan 2007 ADMINISTRATION: United. Watet$ Human Resources departent with the Compensation department and the Executive Management Team wil administer this program. The interpretation of the application of the pla.n document is at the sole discretion of the company and the Chief Operation Offcer's... decision will be binding~ United Water's Human Resources departent manages program administration./ Bonus payments are not considered eligible earnings for calculation of pension benefit or 401 K deferrals and company match as per plans' provisions. Page 4 of5 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 175: Please provide the United Water Idaho specific parameters for the Non-Exempt Bonus Plan. Please separate out the objectives into financial and personal objectives. Please provide any and all criteria upon which the incentive and bonus plan are based. Please break out each objective or criteria by its percentage weight. RESPONSE NO. 175: Attached is the United Water Non-Exempt Bonus Plan which explains the parameters and objectives critera for the Plan. The Plan description separates out the objectives into financial and non-financial objectives, which are 50% financial and 50% non-financiaL. Non-Exempt Bonus Plan Regulated Segment 2007 ')4~7QUnited Water.f. _..~.__..____...._M. -s""ez l' Non-Exempt Bonus Plan 2007 PURPOSE: For the 2007 perfrmance year, a bonus program has been designed for non-exempt employees in the Regulated: Segment. The program supports United Water's business ideals by recognizing the, effort of non~exempt employees in contributing to the succs~Qf~,",.' eU$lnèØlJllif'I,"ffñäncial;resullS;i,custØnl'.$eNicEtsatiÅ¡faCton;' wate, qLJalityl~~i.nçEt andsafe~ initiatives.:. ELIGlSII.D!:.¡" All active non-exempt regular employees, part-time and full-time, are eligible to partcipate in the Bonus Program. Employees must be hired by the first pay period of tle fourt quarter of the plan year, in order to be eligible for an award for that plan year. AW.R.,OPPÐFl"~~l'!,:,:".,.,:":::":.,,.,, The.targ.~awaf(),no".exePf!ènlPJÐY¡~;il~. Based'on.thEt perce~tage achieved for each of. the ',measurements, paYQU1;csft b.tl;~,12S.:pe~'QI:tt.;;i.rget (as in attched Payout. Scale).. Payment is .calculãted based on bonus accomplishment multiplied by the employee's total productive eamingsfor the calendar year. fr9~H~tlßllln.,";,dêtm.a$: Eamings forallhoursanemployee is paid fei (including regular time, overtime, rest time, stand..by. emergency, holidays (inct. "floaters), vacation., bereavement, '. and jury duty) excluding' sick time (paid/unpaid), STD, L TO, Worker's Compensation,., personal time (unpaid) and FML time. PERFORMANCE MEASURES: Performance Measures are subjeçt,to change from one plan year to the next andare"at theidiscretion of senior management and the plan administrator. ,~l perfrm~nce is tobe measured against proposed. business unit targets on aa.uláWØiC'ßD'bJsi~tq l;Ql'.::øti~es. The program is based on the following measurements for each Business Unito ESl41'.. aOllio SAF'E1"GÖÂLSi 25~" o CUSl"OMER;,SfERVlÇ~ GOALS 25% Business Unit E81TDA - is the financial indicator used by United Water for all bonus programs. EBlTOM = Eamings (Revenue - Expenses) before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization. EBITDA is a commonly used metric to evaluate profitabilty. Safety Goals: (Each weighted equally) Recordable' and Frequency Rate$' Severi Rate TrailiingHours per Ernployee Page 1 of 5 ..' Non..Exempt Bonus Plan 2007 Customer Service Goals: (Each weighted equally) For business units that cannot currently measure and report on ASA and abandoned call rate, the remaining two customer service metrics wil be weighted equally. Averåg.s~of'an$we..caii~'~ At)àndonec~~'ratEl RêgulalorycornpJaints 0.1 pefl' 1, 000 customersActalreadta. COMPtlANelaMODlllERJ BUsiness Unit Modifier:. ThismQdifieF'cali.aØdqr"sQl;trlçt.up;tø¡a:&~ to the bonus target, based on the compliance results. Targelil'Q:Q~100%. COO1PUãnGf in sampling and testing. The compliance performance measures are: Process! Permit violations under operational control Sampling. ViolatiOl\' Reporting Violations NotiflcatlonViolations A violation in anyoftfe: compliance measurement critria will aff th buine_ø ccnnpuanea, mo_outll-' beJo . . . Compliance Bonus ViolâtionÅ¡ Target Modifier . 0 i.'. +0.5% 1 -0.25% 2 or more -0.5% PAYOUTS:e~"WÐôar.éÆ.m.r.a$tý.På:il'.j~Øl.PI;~i..i~Qt~.~..IlØW. b.;eligi.ble(..lQ;reçiva¡..aQJ~Wa~tl~"':.,.Employeeswho are t~rminated fOr cause or gross misconduct will not receive" an award regardless of . when termination occurs. Employees who VOlUntarily resign prior to the end of the plan. year wil not receive an award., Pa~(lneat$;¡wll'.~¡m..¡tWl)~'n()mílll~, p~i¡;jig'i.t~\t..!~l~¡'\~o...;th.;(y,.r folJoWing,.the. perforance.!.yel~ Awards are treated as ordinary' income for. tax purposes. Taxes wil be withheld and are owed in the year awards are paid. PAYOUT SCAlE~.. % of Payment Accomplishment % 90%0% 95%50% 100%100% 105%112.5% 110%125% Page 2 of5 1 Non-Exempt Bonus Plan 2007 AWARD EXMPLES: i. Productive Earnings Tårget Modifer (+1.) 0 violations Modified Tar et EBlTDA Customer Service Safe Total Earned AWard TotalPaxout $ (Modified. Target X Award'* 110.0% 110.0% 110.0°/0 125.0% 125.0% 125.0% 50% 25% 25% 62.5% 31.25% 31.25% 125% $2,187.50 II.Producte Earnings Target Môdifier(+i.) 1 violation Modified Tarat' $50,00 $ 1,500 -$ 125 $ 1375 EBlTDA Custoni Service. Safe Total Earned Award Total Payout $ (Modified Target X Award % $1,375 m. ProdUcte Earnings Tål'get.. Modifer (+1-) 2. violations MódifiedTar et EBITDA Customer Service Safe Total Earned Award Total Payout $ (Modified Target X Award % 95.0% 95.0% 95.0% 50.0% 50.0% 50.0% 50% 25% 25% 25.0% 12.5% 12.5% 50.0% $625 Page 3 of5 , " Non-Exempt Bonus Plan 2007 ADMINISTRATION: United Water's Human Resources department with the Compensation departent and the Executive Management Team wil administer this program. The interpretation of the application of the plan document is at the sole discretion of the company and the Chief Operating Offcer's decision wil be binding. United Waters Human Resources departent manages program administration. Bonus payments are not considered eligible earnings for calculation of pension benefit or 401 K deferrals and company match as per plans' provisions. Page 4 of5 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W -09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 176: When are each of the bonus or incentive plans paid? Please break down the response by each plan tye. RESPONSE NO. 176: The Short Term Incentive Plan (STIP), the Non-Exempt Bönus Plan and the Non-Exempt/nion Bonus Plan are generally paid closely together in March. In 2009, the STIP and the Non-Exempt Bonus Plan payments were paid March 11,2009. While the Non-Exempt/nion Bonus Plan payments were paid March 19,2009. In 2008, the STIP was paid March 3, 2008 while the Non- Exempt Bonus Plan payments and the Non-Exempt/nion Bonus Plan payments were paid March 12,2008. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 177: What is the time period that each incentive or bonus plan covers? Please break down the response by each plan type. RESPONSE NO. 177: The Short Term Incentive Plan, the Non-Exempt Bonus Plan and the Non-Exempt/nion Bonus Plan all cover a calendar year period. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Charles E. Loy REQUEST NO. 178: What is the amount of bonus or incentive plan that is included in the test year (June 1,2008 through May 31, 2009)? Please break down the response by each plan type. RESPONSE NO. 178: The test year contains Short Term Incentive Plan payments of$157,873; Non-Exempt Bonus Plan pàyments $13,538.80 and Non-Exempt/Union Bonus Plan payments of$40,571.16. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Pteparer/Sponsoring Witness: Charles E. Loy REQUEST NO. 179: What is the amount of bonus or incentive plan that is included in the Pro Forma Adjustment 1 outside of the test year? Please break down the response by each plan type. RESPONSE NO. 179: Pro Fonna Adjustment 1 contains the following amount of bonus or incentive plan compensation: Short Term Incentive Plan payments of$162,873; Non-Exempt Bonus Plan payments of$14,538.80 and Non-Exempt/nion Bonus Plan payments $41,571.16 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI- W -09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 180: Please provide details on future milestones and goals for individual conservation programs; include both supply side programs and customer demand side programs. RESPONSE NO. 180: The milestones and goals for the individual conservation programs as approved by the Idaho Public Utilties Commission are found in the Conservation Plan itself and the Commissions' Order No. 30305 and 30305 ERRATA. UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 181: In a preliminar review the spreadsheet provided in response to Production Request No. 136 regarding the United Water Shares program indicates that some customers may have been provided more than the $50.00 maximum. Please provide complete financial detail on the United Water Shares program on a monthly basis for the years 2006 - 2009 to date in an electronically executable format with formulas intact. Please provide fuher explanation of the program details including: how customer contrbutions were distrbuted among recipients, maximum amount of benefits, any changes to the program since initiated and when the change was initiated. RESPONSE NO. 181: The response to Production Request No. 136 contained data gathered from two different sets of data; the fuding data and the customer data. Accounting maintains the funding data and it is reported on a fiscal calendar month with a cutoff typically around the 22nd of each month. Customer Service maintains the customer data and it is reported on a tre calendar month. There are no other data files in electronically executable format other than what the Company already provided in its response to Production Request No. 136. In accordance with the original program guidelines, the maximum amount of benefit a customer can obtain is $50.00 each year. No individual customer has received a UW Cares benefit in excess of $50.00 in any year. The varance in timing of the two sets of data mentioned above account for the apparent discrepancy referenced in this Request. There have been no changes in the program since it was initiated. Customer contrbutions are rolled in to the total Company contrbutions and are not distrbuted directly to customers. They serve to offset Company contrbutions. ~ UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer: Patrcia Foss Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 182: Please provide a sample copy of a bil for those legacy customers for which the Company stil collects the Leakguard fee. Provide additional detail regarding the number of customers being billêd for Leakguard, how those transactions and the monies collected are handled, and how the Company processes the accounts. RESPONSE NO. 182: A water bill with the LeakGuard charges is attached. Customers who have the LeakGuard coverage biled on their water bils ar only those who were enrolled in the program prior to its sale to Home Service. No new LeakGuard customers have been added to United Water Idaho's biling since the sale. The LeakGuard charge is a flat-rate fee every two months and is biled as a separate line item. It is described as "LeakGuard" on the water. bil. As customers pay their bils, monies are applied to the separate bil componerlts. The water portion ofthe bil is always satisfied first, then taxes, and finally LeakGuard. At month-end, reports are generated that identify how much was received and booked against the LeakGuard bil component. That amount is moved via ajouma1 entr from United Water Idaho to United Water LeakGuard. Home Service is then paid from the United Water LeakGuard business unit. United Water Idaho currently bils 3,570 LeakGuard accounts. '" ,/ USAGE HISTORY UNITEDWATE Bi-Monthly usage in hundred cubic feet Billng Date: Account Number: 10/19/09 06000999341402 9 Previous Balance Payments Through 10/19/09 Thank You Balance Forward Current Charges Due 11/08/2009 $219.52 $221.00CR $1.48CR $158.67 12 Aug-oct Oct-Dec Dec-Feb Feb-Apr AfJr~un Jun-Aug Aug-Oct SERVICE TO:SERVICE ADDRESS 047683339 08/18/09 10/15/09 58 399 490 91 CCF ACTUAL EQUIVALENT TO 68,068 GALLONS SAFE DRINKNG WTR FEE LEAKGUARD I TOTAL CURRENT CHARGES W18 25.7586 CCFê $1.2112 65.2414 CCF ê $1.5141 WATER CHARGE SUBTOTAL CUSTOMER CHARGE $31.20 $98.78 $129.98 $16.21 $0.50 $11.98 $158.67 SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR IMPORTANT ACCOUNT INFORMATION "*Donateto UW Cares, and help those in our community who need assistance paying their water bills. Contributions are taxdeductible, and 100 percent of your donation goes to helping families meet their most essential need - water. United Water will match all customer donations up to $20,000 annually. Donations can bemailedtoUWCares.P.O.Box190420.Boise.ID 83719-0420. Thank you for your generosity."" Save a stamp and go paperless today! Log on to ww.unitedwater.com or call Customer Service to find out more information and to enroll in eBiling. "For a small convenience fee, you can now pay your bill any time by calling 888-608-6690." 1 200 RE 1600 PLEASE DETACH HERE AND RETURN THE BDTIOM PORTION WITH YOUR PAYMENT IN THE RETURN ENVELOPE PROVIDED. 060 1308 MAROa 091209 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------õã-1308 MARO0921200 Account Number: 06000999341402Balance Forward $1.48CR Current Charges Due 11/08/2009 $158.67 UNITED WATER8248 West Victory Road Boise, ID 83709 SERVICE ADDRESS:5354 SilVER SPUR ST BOISE 10 D Please check this box if you have made any changes to the information on the reverse side. _.__ ~K::~ L UNITED WATER IDAHO PAYMENT CENTER PO BOX 371804 plnSBURGH PA 15250-7804 EBPP 129 BOISE 10 83709-5956 UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. CASE UWI-W-09-01 EIGHTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF Preparer/Sponsoring Witness: Gregory P. Wyatt REQUEST NO. 183: Please provide the total number of conservation kits distrbuted in 2006 thrugh United Water Shares andE1.;Ada. RESPONSE NO. 183: The anwer to this Request has already been provided in the Company's response to Production Request No. 135.