20200117Public Hearing Transcript Vol I.pdf

I
I
I
I
T
I
T
t
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
T
T
I
RECEIVED
'0i0 JAti I 7 PH l: 55
In The Matter Of: ,'.,', ,.,,,,,,ii1lsr0ru
MORNING VIEW WATER COMPANY APPLICATION FOR
AUTHORITY TO INCREASE ITS RATES AND CHARGES
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING
Januory 8, 2020
T&T Reporting, LLC
477 Shoup Avenue, Suite 105
Idaho Falls, Idaho 83402
DDD D-D-DD-COPY
Reported By: DiAnn E. Prock CSR, RPR' CCR
I
T
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
!
I
T
I
T
I
T
1
2
3
4
5
5
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
L4
15
16
L7
18
19
20
2L
22
23
24
25
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5495 FAX
1
*****
rN TEE I.TATTER OF MORNING \rIEW
ITATER COMPAIflT I S APP].IC;LTION IPR
ATITEORITY TO INCRE'LSE TTS RAEES
E}ID CEARGES FOR ITATER SERVICEIN IDAEO
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
CASE NO.:
MN\/-rg-19-01
REPORTER'S TRJA}ISCRIPT OF PUBI,IC IIEARING
Ifednesday, January 8,2O2O; 1: OO o'cJ-ock p.a.
BE IT REMEMBERED that t}'e pubJ-ic trearing inthe above-captioned matter rras taken at theilefferson County Idaho Courthouse, 21O Corrrttrouse
Way, Suite 24O, Rigby, Idaho, before DiArtn Erdna.nProek, CSR SRL 953, CCR, RPR, Court Rel)orter andNotary h:b.Iic, in and for ttre State of Idaho, in theabowe-entitled matter.
off ice@ttreporti n g.com
ttreporting.com
T
E
n
T
T
I
BEE1oRE THE IDA.EO PUBI..IC IITILTTIES COMMISSION
E
I
L]
I
n
T
u
E
E
T
T
I
E
I
T
t
t
I
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
T
T
t
I
T
T
T
T
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
I
9
10
11
L2
13
14
15
16
77
18
19
20
2t
22
23
24
25
T
T
I
I
I
T
I
T
T
I
T
I
t T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5495 FAX
2
APPEARANCES
Comissioners Present:
PAT'I.. KJELLENDER
ERIC A}IDERSON
KRTSTINE R.APER
For the Uti].itiee Coumission:
OI'FICE OF :rHE ATTORNEY GENERJAI
BY: I4IATTEEW C. ET NIER
P. O. Box fJ3720Boise, rdaho 43720(2O8) 334-0318
E-nai1 : aatt, Lrunter@puc. ida.ho. gow
INDEX OE. WI:rNESSES
.IARED GUNDERSON.7
9}IIILIAM STERLING CLE'TENTS .
BRETT EELTIIAN.L2
offi ce@ttre porti n g. com
ttreporting.com
NAME PAGE
I
T
T
T
T
I
T
I
T
I
T
I
T
T
I
T
t
T
I
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
10
11
72
13
L4
15
15
t7
18
19
20
2!
22
23
24
off ice@ttreporti n g.com
ttreporting.com
3
(The pubJ.ic trearing' proceeded at.
7: OO p.m. as fo1J.ows: )
MR. ATiIDERSON: Good eweningr, 1adies and
gentJ.enen. IIow are you?
Thank you for waiting and being patient
for us sitting up here. And we did say
7:0O o'cJ.ock, and by th.e record we probaloJ-y shouJ-d
start at 7:00 o'cJ.ock in case som'ebody eIEe came in.
And so we are Lrere for this Lrearing, and
we want to thaak ewerybody for being trere.
Today is lilednesday, t.he 8th of Janrrary,
2020, and thiE is the tine and pJ-ace for pr:bJ.ie
hearing before the Idaho PubJ-ic UtiJ.ities
Com'ission, Case Nuu.ber !4IW-W-19-O1.
ft's furtl.er identified as In the l'Iatter
of App].ication of Morning View l{ater Coupany for
Arrtl'orization to Increase lt.s Rateg and Wate,r
Serwice in Idaho .
lYerre goingr t'o take pubJ-ic t'esti-mony
from the custoherg this eveningr, and that,'s what the
purpose of this trearing is.
tqf na.ne is Eric Anderson. I wiJ.J. be
cl.airing th.j.s hearing, and to ttre left is
Comissioner Kristine Ra.1>er, and to my rigiht' is25
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
T
T
t
T
t
,l
2l
:l
,l
.l
,l
.l
,l
I
3
T
I
I
T
T
I
I
t
T
I
T
I
t
I
I
t
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
T
T
T
T
T
T
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
I
9
10
11
L2
13
L4
15
16
L7
18
19
20
21-
22
23
24
25
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.54s6 FAX
Coamissioner PauI KjeJ.J-ander. We al-so l:a.we orrr
court reporter here. IIer nalne is Di*enn Prock.
we]-come,
Ttre intent of these proceeding:s is for
the three commissioners to take your testi'nony at]'d
to compJ.ete the buiJ.ding of a reeord. Once the
record is compJ-ete -- coEpJ-eteJ-y buiJ-t, the case
wi].]- be c.I.osed.
The three como.issioners wil]- then
de1i]cerate based on a]-]- the ewidence and a.].]. t'he
matters t,hat are part of the official. record of this
case,
We serwe as a three paneJ. jurli cial-
comoittee, and our roJ-e again this ewening is just'
to ensure that your testi"'ony is treard and it
becomes part of the record appropriateJ-y.
Ttre rray we wiJ.J- opelate this evening is
t,hat f wiJ-J- caJ.J. the naaes of the peopJ-e ttrat have
sigmed
I ca]-]-
up to testify, and
name and sit
if you'Il come forward as
youx at this tabJ.e here, our
attorney wiJ-J- swear you in.
Orrr attorneyr s from the attorney
gieneral-'s office, and he wiJ-J- ask you a few
questions to identify you and your residency,
t,he prrrpose of ttre fora of tlris record.
and
office@ttreporti ng.com
ttreporting.com
4
T
u
T
T
T
T
I
I
t
T
T
t
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
off i ce@ttreporti ng. com
ttreporling.com
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5495 FAX
5
Then you ltray proceed with your
stateoeDt, brrt remember if yor: hawe a1ready
submit'ted written counents in this case, they are in
tl..e record al.so a1ready, amd so yort donr t' need to
repeat them, but if yorr're hear and you wish t'o,
yorr're uore than we]-coD'e to.
If you hawe sou.e additiona]- reu.arks to
make, that's fine, and any previous testifier that
has al-ready addressed ttre i-ssue, you don't need to
go over it agrain if you donrt wish to. You can just
say you agree
are we1come to
Ttre
with the prewious test,inony, but you
go over it agrain if you wa.nt to.
comnissionrs decision in the case
has been based utr>on the substantial- and comp)-ete
of ourewidence in tl.e record whieh is why aJ-J.
proceedings are transcribed by a court
are awaiJ-ab1e for pub1ic inspection.
Before we start the pubJ.ic
reporter and
testinony, we
wiJ.J- now take the a1>peasances of, part.ies 1>resent at
the hearing.
Is there a.nybody here representing
Morrntain view lfater?
MR. RE;ADING: Morning' View.
COMMf SS IONER aIIDERSON: Excuse Ee,
Morning View lfater .
,l
,l
,l
.l
sl
,l
,l
8l
,l
,ol
11 I
,ri
131
,rl
1sl
15 I
1? I
"l,rl
201
211
*l
,rl
24 I
,51
T
!
I
T
I
I
T
T
n
t
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
T
t
T
I
I
I
I
I
t
T
I
I
T
T
I
T
T
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
10
11
12
13
!4
15
16
77
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.s29.5496 FAX
Ca.n you ident.ify yourseJ-f?
MR. REjADING: My na.ae is Dawid Rea.ri ngI.
Irm the bookkeeper.
COM!fI S S IONER AIIDERSON: Thank you. And
eoumission staff?
MR. HITNIER: l.Iatt' Ilunter. I'e Deputy
At'torney General serving as 1ega1 counseJ. for
corm.ission staff.
COM!4[ S S IONER AIIDERSON: Thank you.
Artd J.astJ.y, a reninder, this is not a
question-and-answer period for the comissioners uP
ofhere. It's you! opportunity t'o test,ify
the commission, and once you're com1>Lete
there nay be some ol)I)ortunity for us to
questions if we see fit.
ask you
l'or the court' re1>olt,er's
and don't be offeadedspeak clearJ-y,
stotr> you for some c1arification or
quickJ.y. That happens to a 1ot of
front of ttrese trearings.
So with ttrat, I beJ.iewe
in front,
with that
sa)<e, pJ.ease
if she has to
if you speak too
rrs when we're in
that we are
ready to gto atread a.nd start the testieony, and f
wouJ.d caII Jared Gunderson up.
Thank you.
. MR. HUNTER: Mr. Gr:nderson, wiJ-l yor:'25
[e-mail]
ttreportang.com
'i
,l
,l
,l
tl
,l
6l
,l
'l
el
E
T
T
I
t
T
t
T
I
T
I
I
T
T
t
I
I
I
T
I
t
T
T
t
T
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
s,
52
T&T Reportin
208.
LLC 208.529.5491
9.5496 FAX
1
raise your rigrht hand.
Do you swear or affira that the
tes tiDony you
correct to the
are abotrt to 1>rovide wiJ-J- be true and
best of yorrr knowJ.edge.
TEE WITNESS: Yes.
ITHEREUPON,
JARED GUNDERSON, Lrawing been first duJ'y
sworn t,o te1J. t'he trut,tr, t,tre wtroJ.e truth and not.tring
but the truth, testified as foJ-J-ows:
******
MR. HITNTER: Thank you. I'm g'oing to
ask you a coupJ.e quick hotrsekeeping questions.
IIiIJ- you state your first and J.ast naoe
and spe11 your J-ast name for the record.
MR. GTINDERSON: Jared Gunderson.
G-u-n-d-e-r-s-o-n.
MR. IIUNTER: And what is your residence
address?
MR. GITNDERSON: 191 North 3990 East,
Rigby.
MR. IIITNTER: Ihank you. And are you a
cus tomer of Morning View.
MR. GUNDERSON: Yes.
MR. HITNTER: Thank you.
off ice@ttreporti n g. com
ttreporting.com
'l
21
,l
.l
'l6l
,l
'l9l
10 I
111
1'I
13 I
trl
,ul
16 I
I,ri
,t]
"i
20
,rl
,rl
231
24l
,51
I
t
t
I
T
I
I
t
I
I
I
T
I
T
t
I
I
t
I
T
T
I
I
I
I
I
COMMIS S IONER ANDERSON: M!. Gunderson,
couJ.d w€: have you -- thank yorr very much,
TEE IIITNESS: Ttrank you.
I was jrrst rewiewing this staff re1>ort
that I just receiwed tonigtrt, and was going' throug'h
here, and IrE reading tltrougtr rewenues, mirrd you I
just g'ot this just' a few Einutes ag'o. It was very
quiek, but one 1>oint stood out' it De that I worrJ-d
ask that the board trawe their staff reevaluate wou].d
be the connection fees that are ctrargred for new
connections of forty-fiwe doJ-J-ars .
That is not even c].ose to what it costs
to buy ca1>acity into a water systen for a deveJ-oper
to add a new hone. I know this becarrse of my
experience working for municil)a1ity.
I'we work for cities that cl.arge
anywhere from sewenteen trrrndred doJ-1ars to
thirty-fiwe hun&ed doJ.J-ars connection fees just to
buy into ttre system for a^ new connection.
So I made ot,her rnent.ion, I gron't' restate
it alcout the tiered syst'en. I aa.de my counent's to
you. That was uy on].y coEDent, is I rf,anted to ask if
you couJ-d ask the staff to reewal.uate t,laat, and J-ook
at that cost. That shou].d be increased and ttrat
wou].d --
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
10
11
72
13
L4
15
16
L7
18
19
20
2L
22
23
24
9,52
T&T Reportin
208.
LLC 208.529.5491
9.5496 FAX
25
office@ttre porti n g.com
ttreporting.com
1I
,l
:l
'i
t
I
I
I
T
T
I
T
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
t
T
I
T
I
I
T
t
I
I
I
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
I
9
10
11
!2
13
14
15
15
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
office@ttreporti n g. com
ttreporting.com
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
9
COMIiIfSSIONER AIIDERSON: Ttra.nk you,
Mr - Grrnderson .
Wi].]-i-- C].ements .
MR. HIrIilfER: l4r. C1enents, p1ease raise
your right hand.
Do you srear and affirm that the
testimony you are aborrt t,o prowide wiJ-J- be true and
correct to the best of your know1edgre?
MR. CLEMENTS: Yes.
WHEREUPON
WILLI}I\T STERLING CLEMENTS ,
first duJ-y sworn
and nothing but
to teJ.J- the trut'h,
ttre t,rrth, test,ified
hawing been
the wlro].e truth
as fo].]-ows:
******
MR. Iilrll:fER: Ttran} you.WouJ.d you
the ]-ast namerplease state yorrr
for the record.
fi.:11 nane and speJ-J-
MR. CLEMENIS: IIiI].i='r' St,er].ing'
Clements, C-1-e-n-e-n-t-s.
MR. HUNTER: And lrhat' is your residence
add:ess.
MR. CLEMEIiIIES: 18O North 3988 East.
MR. IIUNTER: And are you current1.y a
customer of Morning View.25
T
I
t
t
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
t
T
I
I
I
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
t
T
10
I
t
I
T
t
T
!
T
T
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
5
1
I
9
11
L2
13
L4
15
16
71
18
19
20
27
22
23
24
T
office@ttreporti n g.com
ttreporting.com
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
10
5:OO o'cJ-ock one, brrt I ha.we
not being: here a.t the
a. few concerrrs t.hat I
taJ-ked to some people that J.eft before, and they
st.ated t'hat they rli 6;1 tg belierre that t}.e new
MR. C],EMENTS:
I apoJ-ogize for
houses
into this
that are being' buiJ-t l.awe been
assessment.
since the we].]. wa.s -- the new we].].
and ewer''1'thi ng e].se, heIs probabJ.y
that to me
Yes,
built.
spoke
in the
trous ing'
broug:ht
Now,
was estab]-ished
trad about fourteen new honers And
is increased rewenue, and he a].so in his 1n
ttre letter that we receiwed maiJ- , that the
water usage has declined.
owerhead declines. More
Iilater usage decJ.ines ,
hones are buiJ.t, owerhead
deeJ-ines. fhatrs ttre rray I 1ook at it.
And I can say for one thinq I know for
srrre, if there's a rf,ater increase, the thirty
I>ercertt of dr1' lawns ttrat we hawe now wi]-]- doub.].e
becarrse people -- some of these peopJ-e just can't
afford to pay the water, so they just a1J-ow t.heir
Iawas to g,o dr1r.
And right in where I 1iwe, tl.erers forrr
homes around me. No. Ttrey don't -- ttrey donrt ewen
trlr to water. I can understand a sma]-]. increase if
it was showrr in the records, the financia1 records25
I
I
t
I
t
T
T
I
I
I
T
T
I
T
t
t
I
T
I
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
72
13
L4
15
76
77
18
19
20
2L
22
23
24
T
T&T Reporting, LLC 208-529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
11
that it was justified, but so far r have not, -- hets
a.n open recordutiJ-ity, I hawe never seen
states his income, what
repairs he has had to pay
a pubJ.ic
book ttrat
and wtrat
his overhead is,
for. And ttrat' I s
just' a few of my cotrccrrtrs.
Thank you very nrrch.
COMIII S S IONER AIIDERSON: lhank you,
Mr. CJ-enertts. Thank you very uuch.
Do re trawe another sign up sheet'?
MR. EI,N:PER: No one else has signed
r:P.
COMMfS S IONER AIIDERSON: We're groing
t,o -- wlrat re're going to do, since rto one e]-se is
signred u1> to speak rigrht norr, I think we're just
going to go off the record for fiwe minutes and see
if someone does deeide they wish to say sometl. ing'.
Since vrerve come this way, we want to
make srrre ewerybody l.as an opportsunity to s1>eak. So
we'J-J- be off the record for fiwe Dinutes, and then
we wiLJ- come back and hopefi:I1y somebody eJ-se wishes
to spea} .
Thank you.
(A brief receas was had. )
COMMI S S IONER NIDERSON: Why donrt we go
atread and go back on the record. I9e hawe Brrd.25
office@ttreporti n g. com
ttreporting.com
t
t
I
T
I
T
I
I
T
I
t
I
I
t
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
I
t
I
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
5
1
8
9
10
11
L2
13
L4
15
15
L7
18
19
20
2t
22
23
24
25
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
12
MR. FEI.IIIAN: Brett.
COMMISSIONER AIIDERSON: Brett.
MR. EEfJMAII: Yes.
COM!4ISSIONER AIIDERSON: Fe1tna.n?
MR. f'ELIlrlAlI : Yes .
COMI'ISSIONER ANDERSON: thank you,
Brett. P.]-ease.
MR. tlulflIER: Mr. FeJ.toan, cou1d you
raise your right hand.
MR. EELII*IAII : Yes .
MR. HITNIER: Do you swear or affirm ttrat
the tes tinony you are al)out to prowide wiJ.J- be true
and eorrect' to t'he best of your knowJ-edge.
MR. EELrMAN: Yes.
WHEREUPON,
BRETT EELTT'IAII, hanring' been first du]-y
srrorn to te]-I the truth, the wtro].e truth and nothing
buts the trutl', testified as foJ-l-ows:
******
MR. HUNTER:Thank you. I{orr3.d you
na.me and speJ-J- your 1ast namepJ.ease state your fuJ-l
for the record.
MR. IELTI'IAN: It's Brett Fe]-tnan, and
J.asts na.De is spe1.J.ed F-e-1-t-m-a-n.
off ice@ttreporti n g. com
ttreporting.com
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
T
I
T
I
t
I
T
t
I
T
I
T
I
T
I
T
T
T
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
10
11
12
13
t4
15
16
L7
18
19
20
2t
22
23
24
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
l4!R. HUI{IIER: Okay. ,Jllst a corrp.]-e oore
questions.
Iltrat is your residence address?
MR. EEIIIiIAII: 3980 East 2O0 North in
Rigby.
MR- EUNIER: And are you presently a
custooer of Morning View Ylater Company.
MR. FELIIVIA}I: Yes, sir.
MR. EUNIER: Thank you.
PJ.ease proceed.
MR. EELII4IAN: Just a few concerns about
rate increases .
Yorr know, I rrnders tand businesses need
to cover t'heir costs. I know that a 1ot of tl.e
peopJ-e or tlre neighbors in ttre area a.re concerned
about not just wtrat the rate increases wi]-l do to
t,heir pocketbook as far as month to lnonth, but you
st,a.rt J-ooking at the fact, as the grry stated before
me, you know, 1>eopJ-e are J-etting: ttreir yards die.
And if you -- if you foJ-J-ow the I Love
Riqby 1rage/ for exaopl"e, if you just GoogJ-e Morning:
View Water on ttrere -- or, excuse E'e, you']-]- see
peol)].ers concerns that are actua]-].y shopping in that
neighborhood tl.at trawe ta1ked to 1>eopJ.e in the area
a.bout, you know, wha.t do you J-ike, or what' do you25
[e-mail]
ftreporting.com
I
I
T
I
T
T
I
T
T
T
,l
"l
3l
.l
5
.I
,l
8l
,l
13
I
t
T
I
t
t
T
T
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
T
t
T
I
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
8
9
10
11
L2
13
74
15
15
L7
18
19
20
2L
22
23
24
office@ft reporting.com
ttreporting.com
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
L4
don't ]-ike?
And it has
water priees are hig'h
came rrp, act'ual-J-y, that t'he
enough that it's chased peop].e
It's something ttra.t I'maway from tl.at
concerned about
IIe!e
I went
I)rotr)erty orrrrer ,
got a new sclroo1
what's going to
t,oo.
coming in
happen when
area.
just a
we've
right by us. You know,
tlae a.rea starts to not J.ook so gleen anymore, and
here theyrre t'rying to 1>ut a brand new sctlool and
errerything up in this area
And, again, I understand they need to
cower their costs, but as far as watelr usage
decJ-ine, f can see certainJ.y why it
as far as instalJ-ingf mean,
systeBs
weattrer
wou1d dec].ine.
smart rrater
that connect t,o Ey WII'I . It connects to t.he
so if it starts raining, it' wiJ-J- rr.ot water-
It t a.t'ers in sequences that make it efficient.
And I did al-I this just because my water
bi1-J-, frankJ.y, in the gummertime, itrs more tlra.n my
gas and water biJ-J' coubined. I mean, itrs ;>ret,ty
outrageous,
Irve J.ived other pJ-aces where I'we had
to pay for water, and there's rrnders tandabJ.e costs
and t,hen therers extrene. And I think -- I think we
were pustring' extrene before, and now Lrere we are25
T
I
I
T
I
T
I
T
T
T
T
I
t
I
t
T
I
I
I
I
asking for uore.
coopromise
especialJ.y
That's soDe
At what' point do you say there's a
there between your customers and that.,
if they hawe no other option to tr>ay it.
of the things I'm a J.ittJ-e eoncerned
owDe! of 1rro1>erty there.
COMMI S S IONER AIIDERSON: Thank you,
alcorrt as an
Brett.
MR. fELTttAlI: Yup, thank you.
COMMTSSTONER ANDERSON: Oh, wait. We
hanre a question here.
MR. IELT!{AN: Yes.
COMI-IISSIONER KJELLANDER: Brett, just
for cJ.arification, if you couJ-d l.eJ-p ne understand,
do you know about the awerage size of J-ots in the
Morning' View subdiwision .
MR. IELTIBN: f think most of then
around De are att acre. I think some of the -- some
of those that are in trai1er park and tl.at are
around a ha].f an acr€!.
Arrd I am compa.ring -- I mowed from a J-ot
ttrat was an acre previously. It was, yorr know, in a
different count and that, but I paid a fJ-at rate,
and t,hat was that for the rrater usagfe. So ha].f an
acre to an acre.
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
I
9
10
11
t2
13
L4
15
16
L7
18
19
20
27
22
23
24
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
25
off i ce@ttreporti n g.com
ttreporting.com
1sI
T
T
I
I
T
T
T
I
I
t
T
T
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PUBLIC HEARING - January 8,2020
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
t2
13
74
15
t6
l7
18
19
20
[e-mail]
ttreporting.com
COM!,ISSIONER K,IELLA]iIDER: Thank you
COMMI S S IONER AIiIDERSON: Thank you very
mrreh.
Ttrank you.
MR. E'ELIt!AN: Tl'ank you EFrys.
COlnfi S S IONER NiIDERSON: Do we ha.wer
anyone eJ.se who wislres to testify?
(No audibJ.e response. )
COMI.ISSfONER A]IDERSON: Last ca]-]-.
(No arrrr i L.1s response . )
COMMISSIONER AIIDERSON: YlelJ- , ttrank you
wery muclr for your attenda.nce this ewening - I'm,
g'J-ad you erere a.bJ-e to testify and yor: had the
freedoo to do so.
At this point in time, t,lris record wiJ-J-
be cJ-osed and sulunitted, and we wiJ.J- deJ.iberate on
ttris and draft a final. order at the eompJ-etion of
orrr de].iberation.
So thaak you alJ. for being' here for bottr
of t'heae meetings today. Appreciate it.
And we are now adjourned.
(Yflhereupon, the proceedings conc1trded a.t
7:17 p.m. )
******
25
T&T Reporting, LLC 208.529.5491
208.529.5496 FAX
T
I
T
I
I
T
T
T
16
,rl
22
,tl
,nl
I
t
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
t
t
I
I
T
I
T
I
T
L7
1
2
3
4
5
5
7
I
9
REPORTER I S CERTIFICATE
STATE OF IDAIIO
COT'NTY OF BONNEVII,I,E
I, DiArtn Erdnan Prock, CSR, CCR, RPR, a
duJ.y couurissioned Notary Public in and for the Stateof ldaho, do hereby certify:
Thats I took down in Stsenots1pe all of theproceedinge had in the before-entsitled matster ats the
time and place indicated, and that thereafter said
StenotlT)e noteE were tranecribed into tslpewriting at
and under my direction and auperwieion, and tsheforegoing transcript conetitutee a fuII, true and
accurate record of the proceedinge had.
I further certify that I have no interestin the events of tshe action.
WITNESS my hand and EeaI tshie
'January, 2020.
10th day of
)
)
)
10
11
72
r-3
L4
l-5
15
t7
18
Ita,,^h OD
19
20
2t
.,)My corurission expireB November 26, 2025.
23
24
DiAnn Erdman ProckIdaho CSR SRL, 963, CCR, RPRNotary Public in and forthe State of Idaho
LLC 208.529.5491
9.5496 FAX
s,
52
T&T Reportin
208.
DIA'{N ERDMAN PROCK
coMMtsstoN No. 5r352
NOTARY PUBLIC
STATE OF IOAHOMYCOt UtSStOt{ EXPTRES .rr,26/19
25
off [e-mail]
ttreporting.com
t
T
I
I
I
I
T
t
T
I
I
T
T
I
I
T
T
I
I
T