Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout200312011st Response of Qwest to Staff.pdfSTOEL ~~, F\ECEIVEO FI! r.. d- L. PM ~: 23 101 S. Capitol Boulevard. Suite 1900 Boise, Idaho 83702 main 208.389.90002003 NO\! fax 208.389.9040 ATTORNEYS AT LAW U t'u8LJC UTILITIES COMi'lISSION www.sloel.com November 26, 2003 MARY S. HOBSON Direct (208) 387-4277 mshobson(fj)stoel.com VIA HAND DELIVERY Jean D. Jewell, Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission 472 West Washington Boise, ID 83702-5983 RE:Docket No. GNR-O3- Dear Ms. Jewell: Enclosed for filing with this Commission is an original and three (3) copies of Qwest Corporation s Responses to First Production Request of the Commission Staff in the above- ~ referenced matter. " ,'. Cf:) :" Attachment A to Response to Request No. 12 i~)10t c~nsidered confidential but is voluminous and is therefore being provided on compact dIsc. Attachments to Responses to Request Nos. 18 and 31 are considered confidential and proprietary and are being filed under separate cover with this Commission. Copies of the confidential attachment(s) will be provided to those individuals who execute Exhibit A to the Protective Agreement. Attachments to Responses to Request Nos. 1 , 15, 17 and 35 are considered Highly Confidential and Use Restricted per Protective Order No. 29384 and are being filed under separate cover with this Commission. Copies of these Highly Confidential attachments will be provided to those individuals who execute Exhibit B to the Protective Agreement. If you have any questions, please contact me. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Very truly yours Enclosurescc: Service List; Tina Colvin 0 reg 011 Washington California U I a h Boise-I 64764.1 0029164-00097 Idaho Mary S. Hobson (ISB #2142) Stoel Rives LLP 101 South Capitol Boulevard - Suite 1900 Boise, ill 83702 Telephone: (208) 389-9000 Facsimile: (208) 389-9040 mshobson~stoel.com OR' G H\lQL\L RECEIVED FiLED II) ZOU3 MOV 29 fM~: 23 .u LJ t,U8LiC UTiliTIES CGr'iMISSIUN Adam L. Sherr (WSBA #25291) Qwest 1600 ih Avenue - Room 3206 Seattle, WA 98191 Telephone: (206) 398-2507 Facsimile: (206) 343-4040 adam.sherr~qwest.com Attorneys for Qwest Corporation BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF IPUC RESPONSE TO FCC ORDER ON REVIEW OF SECTION 251 UNBUNDLING OBLIGATIONS OF INCUMBENT LOCAL EXCHANGE CARRIERS (CCDOCKET NO. 01-338) Case No. GNR-03- QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF NINE-MONTH REVIEW OF ECONOMIC AND OPERATIONAL IMPAIRMENT REGARDING ACCESS TO SPECIFIC UNES Qwest Corporation ("Qwest") pursuant to Rule 225 of the Rules of Procedure of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission and Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 34 hereby submits the following responses to Staffs Request for Production. QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF - Page Boise-164762,1 0029164-00097 Respectfully submitted this 26th day of November, 2003. Qwest Corporation Ho fa--.- ~ary S. H son Stoel Rives LLP Adam L. Sherr Qwest Attorneys for Qwest Corporation QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF - Page 2 Boise-I 64762,1 0029164-00097 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this 26th day of November, 2003, I served QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF as follows: Jean Jewell, Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission 472 West Washington Street O. Box 83720 Boise, ill 83720-0074 Phone: (208) 334-0300 Fax: (208) 334-3762 i i ewell~puc. state.id. us Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Wayne Hart Idaho Public Utilities Commission 472 West Washington Street O. Box 83720 Boise, ill 83720-0074 Phone: (208) 334-0300 Fax: (208) 334-3762 whart~puc.state.id. us Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Weldon Stutzman, Deputy Attorney General Idaho Public Utilities Commission 472 West Washington Street O. Box 83720 Boise, ill 83720-0074 Phone: (208) 334-0300 Fax: (208) 334-3762 wstutzm~puc.state.id. Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Marlin D. Ard, Esq. O. Box 2190 Sisters, OR 97759 Telephone: (541) 549-1787 Facsimile: (541) 549-4537 Maratty~qwest.net Attorney for Verizon Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF - Page 3 Boise-I 64762.1 0029164-00097 Charles Carrathers Verizon Northwest Inc. 1800 41 st Street Everett, W A 98201 Telephone: (425) 261-5691 Facsimile: (425) 261-5262 chuck. carrathers~verizon. com Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Dean J. Miller McDevitt & Miller LLP 420 West Bannock Street O. Box 2564 (83701) Boise, ill 83702 Telephone: (208) 343-7500 Facsimile: (208) 336-6912 i oe~mcdevitt -miller .com Attorney for MCImetro, Time Warner Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Robert M. Pomeroy, Jr. Holland & Hart 8390 East Crescent Parkway - Suite 400 Greenwood Village, CO 80111 Telephone: (303) 290-1622 Facsimile: (303) 290-1606 bpomeroy~ho llandhart. com Attorney for AT&T Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Adam L. Sherr Qwest 1600 ih Avenue - Room 3206 Seattle, W A 98191 Telephone: (206) 398-2507 Facsimile: (206) 343-4040 adam.sherr~qwest.com Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Clay R. Sturgis Moss Adams LLP 601 West Riverside - Suite 1800 Spokane, W A 99201-0663 Telephone: (509) 747-2600 Facsimile: (509) 624-4129 c1ays~mossadams.com Attorney for ITA Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF - Page 4 Boise-164762.10029164-00097 Brian Thomas Time Warner Telecom 223 Taylor Avenue North Seattle, W A 98109 Brian. Thomas~twtelecom.com Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Mary B. Tribby Letty S. D. Friesen AT&T Communications of the Mountain States, mc. 1875 Lawrence Street- Suite 1575 Denver, CO 80202 Telephone: (303) 298-6475 Facsimile: (303) 298-6301 lsfiiesen~att.com Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email Conley E. Ward Givens Pursley LLP 277 North 6th Street - Suite 200 O. Box 2720 Boise, ill 83701 Telephone: (208) 388-1200 Facsimile: (208) 388-1300 cew~gi venspursley .com Attorney for ITA Hand Delivery U. S. Mail Overnight Delivery Facsimile Email At Iv yff I/o t-z--- Mary S. Hfjson QWEST CORPORATION'S RESPONSES TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF - Page 5 Boise-164762,10029164-00097 Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-001 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:001 Mass Market Switching For each wire center in your territory in Idaho , please provide the number of business voice-grade equivalent lines that you directly serve. RESPONSE: Please see Highly Confidential Attachment "A" which contains the number of business voice-grade equivalent lines served by Qwest by wire center. Respondent:Maryann Klasinsi , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-002 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:002 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho , please provide the number of business voice-grade equivalent lines that CLECs are serving through resale. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U. S. C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of theProtective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information, see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for the number of business voice-grade equivalent lines by wire center that CLECs are serving through resale as of 9/30/03. Respondent:Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-003 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:003 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho , please provide the number of business voice-grade equivalent lines that CLECs are serving through UNE- RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U. S. C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information, see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for the estimated number of business voice-grade equivalent UNE-P lines in service as of 9/30/03 by wire center.Since Qwest cannot directly track the number of UNE-P lines CLECs are using to serve business customers, Qwest has identified the quantity of UNE- telephone numbers appearing in the residential section of the Qwest White Pages database , and subtracted those quantities from the total UNE- quantities in service. The remainder is identified for this purpose as being business UNE-P lines in service. Since only a fraction of all business lines in service actually appear in the White Pages, a simple reporting of UNE- business listings understates the actual number of UNE-P lines being used for business purposes. Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-004 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:004 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho, please provide the number of business voice-grade equivalent lines that CLECs are serving through the CLEC's own facilities. RESPONSE: Information regarding quantities of customers , by type of service, being served by CLECs via CLEC-owned facilities is highly confidential information that is proprietary to the CLECs. Qwest does not have access to these linecounts. Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-005 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:005 For each wire center in your terri tory in Idaho, please provide the number of residential voice-grade equivalent lines that you directly serve. RESPONSE: Please see Highly Confidential Attachment "A" which contains the number of residence voice-grade equivalent lines served by Qwest by wire center. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-006 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:006 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho , please provide the number of residential voice -grade equivalent lines that CLECs are serving throughresale. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U.C. 222(a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Once Qwest has received information , see HIGHLY residential voice-grade resale. a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for the number of equivalent lines that CLECs are serving through Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03 - STF 1-007 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:007 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho, please provide the number of residential voice-grade equivalent lines that CLECs are serving through UNE - P . RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U.C. 222(a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of theProtective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information, see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for the number of UNE- lines Qwest believes are being used by CLECs to serve residential customers. UNE-P is not identified in Qwest systems as being used for residential or business purposes - these services are generic, wholesale services provide by Qwest to CLECs. To estimate the number of residential UNE-P lines inservice, Qwest compared the telephone numbers associated with UNE-P lines in service against the current White Pages listings database, and identified the quantity of UNE-P telephone numbers shown in the residential section of thatdatabase. This is the only means Qwest has of approximating the number of UNE-P residential lines in service, and the results of this analysis are reflected in HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT " Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-008 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:008 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho , please provide the estimated number of residential lines that CLECs are serving through their ownfacilities (complete bypass) . RESPONSE: Information regarding quanti ties of customers , by type of service , being served by CLECs via CLEC-owned facilities is highly confidential information that is proprietary to the CLECs. Qwest does not have access to these line counts. Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-009 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:009 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho, please provide the number of in-service collocation arrangements that you have, and for each collocation arrangement , please indicate the type of collocation that you are providing. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U.C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information ) and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information , see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for the number of in-service collocation arrangements for all collocation types by wire center. Respondent:Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-010 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:010 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho, please provide the number of provisioned collocation arrangements that you have in place that have yet to be activated , and for each collocation arrangement , please indicate the type of collocation. RESPONSE: Qwest does not monitor when a CLEC activates their facilities to provide services to their customer and so Qwest has no knowledge regarding the information sought in this request. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1- 011 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:011 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho , please provide the number of pending collocation arrangements that you have , and for each collocation arrangement, please indicate the type of collocation. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U. S. C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information ) and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of theProtective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-012 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:012 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho, please provide a list of restrictions on equipment, cross-connects between CLEC collocation cages, or other restrictions or limitations that you place on a CLECs use of collocation space. RESPONSE: The following language from applicable SGAT sections defines the type of equipment that can be placed in collocation space: Collocation of Switching Equipment. CLEC may collocate any equipment that is necessary for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements. Digital Subscriber meet this legal standard. Line Access Multiplexers (DSLAMS)always Asynchronous Transfer Mode (ATM) or Packet Switching also meets this legal standard when used for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements for purposes of providing Advanced Services such as xDSL. Equipment used predominantly to support DSLAMs and ATMs, such as routers and concentrators , as well as testing and network management equipment also meet this legal standard. Before any equipment that includesswitching functionality is installed CLEC must provide a written inventory to Qwest of all switching equipment and how it will be used for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements. Once CLEC establishes that it will use certain type of equipment for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements, Qwest will allowfuture Collocations of similar equipment without requesting a written justification unless and until Qwest can establish to the state Commission that such equipment is not intended for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements. However , Qwest will complete the Collocation within the appropriate interval unless granted relief by the Commission. 1.2.Remote Switching Units (RSUs) also meet this legal standard when used for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements for purposes of providing Local Exchange Service. Except as provided for in Sections 8.1 through 8.above, CLEC may not collocate equipment that is not necessary for Interconnection or access to Unbundled Network Elements. All equipment shall meet and be installed in accordance with Network Equipment Building System (NEBS) Level l safety standards. Qwestshall provide standard Premises alarming pursuant to Qwest TechnicalPublication 77385. Qwest shall not impose safety or engineering requirements on CLEC that are more stringent than the safety or engineering requirements Qwest imposes on its own equipment located on its Premises. Also , Qwest Technical Publication 77386 addresses the type of can be placed in collocation space. ATTACHMENT "A", provided contains Technical Publication 77386. This document also can following url: http:j jwww.qwest.comjtechpubj . equipment that on a CD be found at the Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-O3- STF 1-013 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:013 For each wire center in your territory in Idaho, please identify whether or not collocation space is currently available to CLECs. For each wire center where collocation space is currently not available to CLECs, please include an explanation of why space is not available in those wire centers. RESPONSE: Please see ATTACHMENT "A" which lists the wire centers in Idaho indicating whether space is available or not. This information is available at the following url: http: / /www. qwest. com/wholesale/notices/ collo/ spaceAvail. html A wire center is at exhaust when there is no space to place one standard bay of equipment for cageless collocation. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-014 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:014 Swi tching With respect to the voice-grade equivalent lines being provided to (a) residential customers; (b) business customers to whom you provide between 1- voice-grade equivalent lines at one location; (c) business customers to whom you provide between 4-24 voice grade equivalent lines at one location; and (d) business customers to whom you provide 24 or more voice-grade equivalentlines (in one location), state the current average total monthly revenues earned per line served in Idaho by LATA and by MSA and specify the source of those revenues by service type. RESPONSE: Qwest is in the process of gathering the information necessary to respond to this request and will supplement its response as it completes its review and analysis of thl information. Respondent:Qwest Legal Department Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-015 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:015 For each switch (e.g. circuit, packet , soft switch , etc.) currently used, or those that have been used, or that could be used to provide local service in Idaho (this would include switches located in other states that provide or have the ability to provide local exchange service in Idaho), state the initial cost of that switch, including installation and engineering costs, and the number of initial equipped lines. RESPONSE: Please see Highly Confidential Attachment "A" which contains the Engineered, Furnished and Installed (liE, F , and I ") cost for switches purchased in 1999 to present and the initial line counts for these switches. A special study would be required to provide information for those switches purchased prior to 1999. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03 - STF 1-016 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:016 Describe in detail any instances in which your company is using, through a wholesale, lease , or resale arrangement , the switch of any entity unaffiliated with Qwest (e., another competitive local exchange carrier) to provide local exchange service to end users in Idaho. Include in your response the rates , terms, and conditions under which you are obtaining swi tching on a wholesale , lease, or resale basis. RESPONSE: Qwest is not using, through a wholesale , lease, or resale arrangement, the switch of any entity unaffiliated with Qwest (e.g., another competitive local exchange carrier) to provide local exchange service to end users in Idaho. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03 - STF 1-017 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:017 State whether your company is providing, or plans to provide , through a wholesale, lease or resale arrangement, capacity on any swi tches you own or operate in Idaho , or that you own or operate in another state and that you use to provide local service in Idaho, to an unaffiliated entity. For any such instances, identify the rates, terms, and conditions under which you are making that switch capacity available. For each switch on which you are currently leasing or selling capacity to an unaffiliated entity, identify: a. The make , model , age, and current software upgrades of each switch; b. The geographic location of the switch; c. The footprint or geographic area served by the switch , including a list of each exchange served by the switch;the features and functions (including software upgrades) available in the switch; d. Provide the capacity of each switch , including: (i) (ii) percentage of switch capacity in use; percentage of switch capacity reserved for your company own use and future use; and (iii) percentage of current and future capacity of each switch that will be made available for CLEC use. e. For each switch identified , please state in detail: (i) (ii) the anticipated service life of the switch; and whether your company intends to utilize the identified switch for the full anticipated service life. RESPONSE: Qwest provides access to its facilities, including switches in accordance with all state and federal statutes and to all entities as required by law. Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-023 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:023 List each task that is part of the batch hot cut process described in the answer to the above request regarding a batch process. Provide the average time it takes to complete the task , the typical occurrence of the task during the process, the labor rate for the task , and the common overhead loading associated with the labor rate. Indicate the source of the data , i. e. time/motion studies, SME analysis , etc. RESPONSE: Qwest is in the process of preparing a detailed overview of the new Batch Hot Cut Process ("BHCP") in anticipation of a collaborative meeting with the CLECs. The overview was filed with the Commission on November 12 , 2003 , with the Joint Forum scheduled to take place on December 1st - 3rd. The information provided at that time, as well as the information that will be developed during the forum process will address the issues raised in this data request. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-024 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:024 List each task that is part of the batch hot cut process that is not included in the current hot cut process. RESPONSE: Please see Qwest I s Response to Staff Set 1, Data Request No. 22. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-025 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:025 List each task that is part of the current hot cut process that is not included in the batch hot cut process. RESPONSE: Please see Qwest I s Response to Staff Set 1, Data Request No. 22. Tasks in Qwest r s current hot cut process but not in Qwest I s proposed batch hot cut process include, but are not limited to, the following:a. The Central Office Technician ("COT") performs the central office wiring and appropriate tests on Design, Verify, and Assign date. The COT documents the start time of the "lift" and the end of the "lay" process; b. The COT notifies the Qwest Customer Care Center ("QCCC") that the work is complete and provides , the QCCC with: the "lift" and "lay" time and the testresults;c. The QCCC documents the stop time of the cut and phones the CLEC that the work is complete providing test results. If the CLEC has purchased Cooperative or Performance Testing, the test results are also forwarded to the CLEC via e-mail within two business days of order completion; and d. CLEC does not accept the loop, the QCCC enters a jeopardy code on the order and notifies the Service Delivery Coordinator ("SDC") and the Recent Change Memory Administration Center ("RCMAC") that the order will not be completed due to customer reasons. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-026 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:026 On a monthly basis, provide the total number of residential lines served and the number of residential lines served using integrated digital linecarriers. Provide separately for every wire center the number of Qwest retail residential lines, UNE served residential lines, and Wholesale served residential lines. Provide this information for the period of time since the FCC approved Qwest' s Application for 271 authority in Idaho. Provide the information on a region-wide basis in addition to Idaho specific data. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U.C. 222(a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of theProtective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested infor~ation. Qwest has not compiled region-wide data , nor has it compiled the requested data for all of the states in its 14-state region. Region-wide data is not relevant to the mass market switching case in the nine-month proceeding, nor does Qwest believe that region-wide data is necessary for the Commission participation in the Batch Hot Cut forum. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information, see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for the number of residential lines served by Qwest in Idaho and the percent of these residential lines using integrated digital line carrier, HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "B" for the total number of CLEC residential resold lines (characterized in the request as "wholesale" served residential lines), and HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "C" for the number of UNE-P lines Qwest believes are being used by CLECs to serve residential customers. Neither UNE-P nor UNE-L are identified in Qwest systems as being used for residential or business purposes - these services are generic, wholesale services provided by Qwest to CLECs. To estimate the number of residential UNE- lines in service, Qwest compared the telephone numbers associated with UNE- lines in service against the current White Pages listings database , and identified the quantity of UNE-P telephone numbers shown in the residentialsection of that database. This is the only means Qwest has of approximating the number of UNE-P residential lines in service. and the results of this analysis are reflected in HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "C." Since UNE-L has no associated telephone number in Qwest switches (the telephone numbers associated with UNE-L lines are provisioned from CLEC switches) Qwest is unable to compare UNE-L telephone numbers to the Qwest White Pages database. In the Idaho Section 271 proceedings , Qwest attributed 100% of UNE-L lines in service to business. For consistency, the same approach will be applied in this proceeding in developing Qwest I s response to this discovery question. To the extent CLECs provide information in their discovery responses showing some proportion of their UNE-L lines are now being used to serve residential customers, Qwest will reflect that information in its direct testimony. Respondents: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-027 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:027 For each wire center , on a monthly basis, provide the total number of business mass-market lines served and the number of business mass-marketlines served using integrated digital line carriers. Provide separately for every wire center the number of Qwest retail business mass-market lines, liNE served business mass-market lines, and Wholesale served business mass-marketlines. Explain how Qwest determined which business lines were mass-market lines and which are enterprise lines. Provide this information for the period of time since the FCC approved Qwest' s Application for 271 authorityin Idaho. Provide the information on a region-wide basis in addition to Idaho specific data. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U. S . C. 222 (a) ( "Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Qwest has not compiled region-wide data, nor has it compiled the requesteddata for all of the states in its 14-state region. Region-wide data is not relevant to the mass market switching case in the nine-month proceeding, nor does Qwest believe that region-wide data is necessary for the Commission ' participation in the Batch Hot Cut forum. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for a report of all business access lines served on a DSO level in each wire center in Idaho, and the percent of these business lines served using integrated digital carrier. Qwest does not track lines using integrated digital carrier by service; therefore, the percent is the same for residence and for business. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "B" for the number of resold DSO-Ievel business lines in service (characterized in the above request as "wholesale" served business lines) . Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information , see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "C" for the estimated number of DSQ-level business UNE-P lines in service by wire center. Since Qwest cannot directly track the number of UNE-P lines CLECs are using to serve business customers, Qwest has identified the quantity of UNE-P telephone numbers appearing in the residential section of the Qwest White Pages database , and subtracted those quantities from the total UNE-P quantities in service. The remainder is identified for this purpose as being business UNE-P lines in service. Since only a fraction of all business lines in service actually appear in the White Pages, a simple reporting of UNE- business listings understates the actual number of UNE-P lines being used for business purposes. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information, see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "D" for a report by wire center of all DSQ-level UNE-L lines in service. At this time, Qwest has no way to differentiate whether UNE-L lines are used by CLECs to serve residential or business customers , and represents for purposes of this response that all UNE-L lines are being used to serve business customers. However, as CLECs provide discovery responses in this proceeding identifying the proportion of UNE-L lines actually used to serve business customers, Qwest will reflect that information in its direct testimony to be filed in December. For purposes of this response, Qwest has defined all business lines served at the DSQ level as "mass market" business lines. In fact, the FCC has directed the state Commissions to determine the point at which CLECs can efficiently and reasonably serve multi-line business customers with DSl loops , and the Commission will base its findings in this regard on all evidence supplied by the parties through discovery responses and direct testimony. Qwest does not yet know where this "break" point is, but will submit its recommendation to the Commission as to where it recommends the break point to be in its direct testimony to be filed in December. Respondents: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-028 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:028 If the tasks related to the hot cut process for lines served using integrated digi tal line carriers differs from the process used for other lines , discuss how the process is different and list the tasks that must be added specifically for the lines served using integrated digital line carriers. Include the time required to accomplish those tasks. RESPONSE: If a UNE-P loop is currently provided over IDLC and the CLEC requests conversion to an Unbundled Loop, Qwest will first look for an alternative which could include, but is not limited to, metallic facilities (copper pair) or a Universal Pair Gain. If neither of these alternatives is available as a temporary solution , Qwest will hairpin the circuit and issue a job to provision a Central Office Terminal (COT) and will convert the hairpin onto the COT when it becomes available. Hairpins are dedicated time slots between two DSO ports in the same Integrated Digital Carrier Unit (IDCU). If a UNE-P line provided over IDLC is converted to a UNE-Loop using a hot cut process, a new jumper must be run on the DSO distributing frames where the OSP pair appears. The OSP pair is connected by jumpers to the CLEC switching equipment. It may be necessary to place voltage protection coils or continui ty coils at the OSP pair appearance or UDLC pair appearance. The IDLC channel formerly used is modified by translations and then becomesavailable for reuse. The time needed to accomplish these tasks will vary, based on the size of the office (number of floors, etc.) and the number and location of distributing frames involved. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-029 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:029 On a monthly basis, provide the average time a customer s service was disconnected due to the hot cut process. Provide this information for the period of time since the FCC approved Qwest' s Application for 271 authorityin Idaho. Provide the information on a region-wide basis in addition to Idaho specific data. RESPONSE: Qwest does not track the exact data point identified in this request; however, Qwest does track "the time actually involved in disconnecting the loop from Qwest network and connecting/testing the loop.See Purpose of Measure OP-7 available at the following URL: http:\\www.qwest.com\wholesale\results\roc.html The audited data under PID OP-7 shows that the amount of out of service time plus testing time is approximately three minutes. However , the amount of time a customer is out of service is only the time it takes Qwest to disconnect the loop from its frame and reconnect it to the CLEC. While testing occurs thereafter, the customer is almost always in service during the testing phase. While Qwest does not track the true out of service time , Qwest estimates that this time is almost always less than 30 seconds, and would average approximately 15 seconds. Qwest has not compiled region-wide data, nor has it compiled the requested data for all of the states in its 14-state region. Region-wide data is not relevant to the mass market switching case in the nine -month proceeding, nor does Qwest believe that region-wide data is necessary for the Commission ' participation in the Batch Hot Cut forum. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-030 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:030 On a monthly basis , provide the number of technicians during each month who have transferred a line from an ILEC switch to the CLEC facility as part of the hot cut process. Count only those employees who perform the manualprocess. Provide this information for the period of time since the FCC approved Qwest' s Application for 271 authority in Idaho. Provide the information on a region-wide basis in addition to Idaho specific data. RESPONSE: Qwest does not track this information in Idaho or on a region-wide basis. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-031 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:031 On a monthly basis , provide the number of technicians trained and capable of transferring a line from an ILEC switch to the CLEC facility as part of the hot cut process. Count only those employees who can perform the manual process. Do not include management or supervisory personnel who can perform these tasks but do not do so as part of their regular work effort. Provide this information for the period of time since the FCC approved Qwest' s Application for 271 authority in Idaho. Provide the information on a region-wide basis in addition to Idaho specific data. RESPONSE: Qwest does not track this information on a monthly basis. However Confidential Attachment "A" contains the number of technicians. trained capable of transferring a line from a Qwest switch to CLEC facility as of Qwest I s current hot cut process currently working in Idaho. andpart Qwest has not compiled region-wide data , nor has it compiled the requested data for all of the states in its 14-state region. Region-wide data is not relevant to the mass market switching case in the nine-month proceeding, nor does Qwest believe that region-wide data is necessary for the Commission' participation in the Batch Hot Cut forum. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-032 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:032 On a monthly basis for every wire center , provide, in an electronic format the number of hot cuts performed. Provide this information for the period of time since the FCC approved Qwest' s Application for 271 authority in Idaho. Provide the information on a region-wide basis in addition to Idaho specific data. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U.C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Qwest has not compiled region-wide data, nor has it compiled the requested data for all of the states in its 14-state region. Region-wide data is not relevant to the mass market switching case in the nine-month proceeding, nor does Qwest believe that region-wide data is necessary for the Commission ' participation in the Batch Hot Cut forum. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-033 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:033 Provide a list of all carriers with which Qwest has an interconnection agreement for the provision of local service in Idaho. RESPONSE: See Attachment "A" for a list of all carriers with which Qwest has an interconnection agreement for the provision of local service in Idaho. Respondent:Susan Van Putten, Qwest Manager Sam Radetsky, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-034 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:034 Provide a list of all carriers to which Qwest has sold collocation services in Idaho. For each carrier , list the wire centers where the carrier is collocated. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U.C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. Once Qwest has received a Commission Order or CLEC permission to release information , see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHMENT "A" for a list of all carriers that have active collocations as of 11/17/03. Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-035 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:035 Provide a list of Qwest wire centers with indicators that identify whether the office is unstaffed, has a technician on duty but the technician cannot perform hot cuts , or has a technician on duty and the technician can perform hot cuts. For unstaffed offices and offices where the technician cannot perform hot cuts, specify the number of miles that the technician must drive and driving time to reach that office from the closest office where a technician who can perform hot cuts is normally on duty. RESPONSE: Please see Highly Confidential Attachment "A" which lists the Qwest wire centers in Idaho , whether there are technicians in the office who can perform hot cuts, and , if the office is unstaffed , the nearest wire center with staff and the distance from that wire center. Qwest did not provide the time between offices due to factors such as weather , traffic, and workload that could influence travel time. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-036 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:036 If a batch cut process is developed , does that make it more or less likely that an electronic loop provisioning process will be implemented? RESPONSE: Qwest does not intend to implement an electronic loop provisioning ("ELP"process. The FCC recognized in the Triennial Review Order ("TRO") that an electronic loop provisioning proposal would cost by one estimate "more than 100 billion dollars"TRO at Para. 491. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-037 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:037 For each technician identified as trained in the hot cut process , when did that training occur? RESPONSE: On the job training was conducted in advance of the first live hot cut and continues today in the form of weekly audi ts conducted by management employees. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03 - STF 1-038 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:038 For each technician identified as trained in the hot cut process, is that training documented or posted? If so , where is that training documented or posted? RESPONSE: The training is not documented or posted. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-O3- STF 1- 03 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:039 For each technician identified as trained in the hot cut process , how often does that technician get trained in the hot cut process? RESPONSE: Hot cut training is provided as on the job training using Qwest Central Office job aids. Qwest management employees audit non-management employees on a weekly basis to ensure compliance to processes. Coaching sessions are provided to bring employees back into compliance if necessary. Training is an ongoing process. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-040 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:040 For each technician identified as trained in the hot cut process , is there a refresher course for that technician? If so, how often is the refresher course offered? RESPONSE: Please see Qwest I s Response to Staff Set 1 , Data Request No.3 9. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-041 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:041 For each technician identified as trained in the hot cut process, is the technician required to take the refresher course if one is offered? RESPONSE: Each technician is required to attend refresher training. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-042 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:042 Does Qwest I s UNE-L loop always provide CLECs with DSO capacity? RESPONSE: Qwest is in the process of gathering the information necessary to respond to this request and will supplement its response as it completes its review and analysis of thE information. Respondent:Qwest Legal Department Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-043 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:043 If Qwest I s UNE-L loop does not always provide CLECs with DSO capacity, identify by customer and wire center all instances where it does not provide DSO capacity. RESPONSE: Qwest is in the process of gathering the information necessary to respond to this request and will supplement its response as it completes its review and analysis of the information. Respondent:Qwest Legal Department Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1- 044 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:044 For each Qwest central office or wire center at which loops and transport are connected at collocation arrangements to form EELs, please provide the following information: (a) the CLLI code , street address , and V&H coordinates of the Qwest central office or wire center where such EELs are created; (b) the CLLI code, street address, V&H coordinates , and owner(s) of the switch (es) to which such EELs are connected; (c) number of such EELs that comprise DS-O/voice grade transport connected to DS - O/voice grade loops; (d) number of such EELs that comprise DS-1 transport connected to multiplexed DS-O/voice grade loops; (e) number of such EELs that comprise DS-1 transport connected to multiplexed and concentrated DS-O/voice grade loops, and the loop-to-transportconcentration ratio; (f) number of such EELs that comprise DS-3 transport connected to multiplexed DS-O/voice grade loops; (g) number of such EELs that comprise DS-3 transport connected to multiplexed and concentrated DS-O/voice grade loops , and the loop-to-transportconcentration ratio; (h)number such EELs that comprise DS-transport connected DS-loops; (i)number such EELs that comprise DS-transport connected to multiplexed DS-loops; (j) number of such EELs that comprise DS-3 transport connected to multiplexed and concentrated DS-1 loops, and the loop-to-transport concentration ratio. RESPONSE: Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/ carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U. S . C. 222 (a) "Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or 2) permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. (a) Please see Highly Confidential Attachment "A" which contains the CLLI code, street address , and V & H coordinates of the Qwest central offices that have EELs. (b) Qwest does track the information requested. (c-j) Qwest does not track the information requested. Please see HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL ATTACHEMNT "B" for the EEL in service by wire center as of 9/30/03. Respondent: Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-045 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:045 For each Qwest central office or wire center at which loops and transport are connected to form EELs wi thout using collocation , please provide the following information (a) the CLLI code, street address, and V&H coordinates of the Qwest central office or wire center where such EELs are created; (b) the CLLI code , street address , V&H coordinates , and owner(s) of the switch(es) to which such EELs are connected; (c) number of such EELs that comprise DS-Ojvoice grade transport connected to DS-Ojvoice grade loops; (d) number of such EELs that comprise DS-1 transport connected to multiplexed DS-Ojvoice grade loops; (e) number of such EELs that comprise DS-1 transport connected to multiplexed and concentrated DS-Ojvoice grade loops, and the loop-to-transportconcentration ratio; (f) number of such EELs that comprise DS-3 transport connected to multiplexed DS-Ojvoice grade loops; (g) number of such EELs that comprise DS-3 transport connected to multiplexed and concentrated DS-Ojvoice grade loops, and the loop-to-transportconcentration ratio; (h)number such EELs that comprise DS-transport connected DS-loops; (i)number such EELs that comprise DS-transport connected multiplexed DS-loops; (j) number of such EELs that comprise DS-3 transport connected to multiplexed and concentrated DS-1 loops, and the loop-to-transport concentration ratio. RESPONSE: Qwest does not track if the EELs used by CLECs are used with or withoutcollocations. Respondent: Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-046 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:046 For each CLEC and other carrier collocation arrangement in each Qwest central office or wire center in Idaho, please provide the following information reported by CLLI code and street address: (a) name of CLEC or other carrier; (b) type of collocation arrangement (e.g. caged , cageless , virtual , etc. (c) size of collocation arrangement; (d) amount of power (including both "A" and "B" DC feeds and AC power) supplied to the collocation arrangement; (e) number of 2-wire cross connects currently provisioned from the MDF to the collocation arrangement; (f) number of 4-wire cross connects currently provisioned from the MDF to the collocation arrangement; (g) all equipment installed in the collocation arrangement, including make, model , and total installed capacity for each piece of equipment; (h) type (s) of Qwest transport connected to the collocation arrangement (e., special access , UNE transport , etc. (i) capacity (ies) of Qwest transport connected to the collocation arrangement (e., DS-, DS-3, OC-3, etc., and number of circuits at each level of capaci ty) ; (j) all non-recurring and recurring charges for the collocation arrangement; (k) name (s) of other collocating carrier (s) to which this collocation arrangement is connected in this central office or wire center. RESPONSE: with regard to subparts (a), (b), and (c), Qwest has compiled the Idaho data in its possession that is responsive to this request. However , this request seeks CLEC/carrier specific information that may be protected under 47 U. S. C. 222 (a) ("Privacy of Customer Information") and/or other federal privacy laws. Qwest will provide the requested CLEC information to those that have signed Exhibit B of the Protective Order (Commission Order No. 29384) upon receiving either: (1) a Commission order requiring production of the information; or permission from the CLEC to release the requested information. (d)Qwest does not track this information. (e)Qwest does not track this information. (f)Qwest does not track this information. (g) Qwest does not track this information. (h)Qwest does not track this information. (i)Qwest does not track this inf orma t ion. (j) Recurring and nonrecurring rates for collocation may be located in the SGAT, Exhibit A from the pull down menu at the following URL: http://www.qwest.com/who1esa1e/c1ecs/sgatswire1ine.htm1 (k)Qwest does not track this information. Respondent:Maryann Klasinski , Qwest Manager Elaine Garley, Qwest Manager Steve Nelson, Qwest Manager Idaho Case No. GNR-03- STF 1-048 INTERVENOR:Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission REQUEST NO:048 Please explain whether you currently have in place electronic systems that can accomplish each of the following migration types on a automated flow-through basis (i. e., no human or other manual intervention is required for completion of the migration) (a) from UNE-P voice only, or UNE-P voice plus data , to CLEC switch-based voice only; (b)from UNE - P voice only,or UNE-voice plus data,Qwest voice only; (c)from UNE-voice only,or UNE-voice plus data,Qwest voice plus data; (d) from UNE-P voice only, or UNE-P voice plus data, to one CLEC linesplitting; (e) from UNE-P voice only, or UNE-P voice plus data, to two CLEC line splitting; (f) from UNE-, or UNE-P voice plus data , to CLEC line sharing with CLECsplitter; (g) from UNE-, or UNE-P voice plus data , to CLEC line sharing with Qwestsplitter; (h) from CLEC switch-based voice to any of the above; (i) from one and two CLEC line splitting to any of the above; (j) from one and two CLEC line sharing to any of the above. RESPONSE: Qwest is in the process of gathering the information necessary to respond to this request and will supplement its response as it completes its review and analysis of tht information. Respondent:Qwest Legal Department GNR- T -03- N ov. 26 , 2003 Attachment A to Response Request No. 12 is voluminous - (3 copies of compact disc) for case file / Legal / Wayne