Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20040624Responses of Avista to CAPAI Part IID.pdfTriple- E Report January 1 , 2003 to October 31, 2003 f2g~ ll /itl Jt D A vista Demand-Side Management Team J on Powell Renee Coelho Chris Drake Catherine Bryan Tom Kliewer Rob Gray Eric Lee Tom Lienhard Mike Littrel Bruce Folsom Lori Hermanson b 5 rY\ 1JlJ K.p eLf if Table 1E Electric Utility Costs Aggregated by Programs and Customer Segments SEGMENTS Agricultural $ Govemmenf $ Food Service $ Health Care Hospitality $ Limited Income Manufacturing $ Office $ Residential $ Retail $ GENERAL General (Implementation) $ OTHER EXPENDITURES NEEA3 $ OTHER PROGRAMS Rooftop program Residential CFL promotion Non-residential CFL promotion Enhanced incentive program Exit Sign Promotion Residential water heater program EMS Re-Commissioning $ TOTAL $ BROKEN OUT BY CATEGORY Total assigned to segments Total assigned to general Total assigned to other Total assigned to temp. programs TOTAL $ CATEGORY AS A PERCENT Total assigned to segment Total assigned to general Total assigned to other pgms. Total assigned to old programs TOTAL Total non-regional utility cost Incentives lementation 330 275 362 203 604 888 653 95,867 13,371 239,615 604 377 319 63,077 293 86,440 227 605 936 85,077 517 50,329 815 491,48711 $ 001 97311 $ 493,525 794,752 TOTAL 27,605 396,808 19,540 109,238 249 219 440,396 136,733 254 541 85,594 75,144 491 ,487 001,973 288,277 1,493 525 301 293 794 818 491 487 491 ,487 001,973 001,973 493 525 794,752 288,277 45.54. 14.14. 30.30. 45.54./~1 100. 1 ,493,525 792,77911 $286,304 NOTES: 1) Incentives are accounted for on a cash basis and will not match de-rated incentive expenditures amounts. 2) The Govemment segment includes educational institutions as well as federal, state and local governments. 3) Costs associated with membership in NEEA are included in this table, but are excluded from all other tables. 4) Incentives attributable to emergency programs have been allocated to the appropriate customer segment Table 1G Gas Utility Costs Aggregated by Programs and Customer Segments SEGMENTS Agricultural $ Govemmenf $ Food Service $ Health Care Hospitality $ Limited Income Manufacturing $ Office $ Residential $ Retail $ GENERAL General $ OTHER EXPENDITURES Regional3 $ OTHER PROGRAMS Rooftop program Residential CFL promotion Non-residential CFL promotion Enhanced incentive program Exit Sign Promotion Residential water heater program EMS Re-Commissioning $ TOTAL $ BROKEN OUT BY CATEGORY Total assigned to segments Total assigned to general Total assigned to other Total assigned to old programs TOTAL $ CATEGORY AS A PERCENT Total assigned to segment Total assigned to general Total assigned to other pgms. Total assigned to old programs TOTAL Total non-regional utility cost Incentives 1 Implementation TOTAL 641 101,223 115 161 066 217 496 204 265 80,245 124 746 209,380 26,446 65,115 193,738 128,623 65,115 193,738 92.94. 92.o;~1 100. 106,548 87,191 II $193,738 Ptt Z- NOTES: 1) Incentives are accounted for on a cash basis and will not match de-rated incentive expenditures amounts. 2) The Govemment segment includes educational institutions as well as federal, state and local governments. 3) Costs associated with gas programs in support of regional initiatives appear in this table but are excluded from other tables. 4) Incentives attributable to emergency programs have been allocated to the appropriate customer segment 641 100,395 828 115 161,066 217,349 147 202,272 993 392 853 122,441 305 209,187 193 26,446 65,11511 $ II $ 106,548 191 106,548 $ 106,548 $ 22,076 $ 115 $ 87,191 Table 1 Electric Utility Costs Aggregated by Programs and Customer Segments Incentives Implementation TOTAL SEGMENTS Agricultural 330 916 29,246 Govemmenf $462,598 35,433 498 031 Food Service 888 768 656 Health Care 256,932 13,371 270,303 Hospitality 456,964 751 466,715 Limited Income 579,590 65,070 644 660 Manufacturing 117 685 99,293 216,978 Office 350 046 242 379,288 Residential $294 264 710 294,974 Retail 775 24,815 101,590 GENERAL General (Implementation)556,60211 $556,602 OTHER EXPENDITURES NEEA3 $001 97311 $001,973 OTHER PROGRAMS Rooftop program Residential CFL promotion Non-residential CFL promotion Enhanced incentive program Exit Sign Promotion Residential water heater program EMS Re-Commissioning TOTAL 600,073 881,943 482,016 BROKEN OUT BY CATEGORY Total assigned to segments 600,073 323,368 923,441 Total assigned to general 556 602 556,602 Total assigned to other 001 973 001,973 Total assigned to temp. programs TOTAL 600,073 881,943 482,016 CATEGORY AS A PERCENT Total assigned to segment 58.65. Total assigned to general 12.12. Total assigned to other pgms.22.22.4% Total assigned to old programs TOTAL 58.42.o;~1 100. Total non-regional utility cost 600 073 879,970 II $480 043 NOTES: 1) Incentives are accounted for on a cash basis and will not match de-rated incentive expenditures amounts. 2) The Govemment segment includes educational institutions as well as federal, state and local governments. 3) Costs associated with membership in NEEA are included in this table, but are excluded from all other tables. 4) Incentives attributable to emergency programs have been allocated to the appropriate customer segment . '",- :;; '2.. 'ft" (I) CJ) (I)::s (I) (I) :--. ~ B21-en 111eniD-111 e :I:19 t?- 't:I CD ene 0.2' 0en 'en E ~ ~ 111 . t?- E Iii(I) =-- enU ~e u '6 't:I 19 8. LL. '" ... 2! 111 en... 0~ U 't:I Iii . e-o.EoE 01;:: 0CDa-CUU ;; Q) CI Iii c..!2 :s ::'iii CDUJ .... OMNUJMCDCD ~~~~~~~~ rsj 10" m N ..; 0 N m ..: ..:ION~~""MO10 ....N~NM........ flit flit 409 flit flit flit CIt 409 CIt 409 CIt ~:g ;;:~;i;fD~iO~:; CD N UJ ... M UJ N an M ~" 0 M" on 0 on on on UJ " .... """'NMOUJ~N ... .... 409 flit flit flit flit flit 6ft flltClt flit flit 409 409 409 flit flit flit flit fit 6ft flit flit IOCD OCDQ)UJM....~..,. OO""M...Q)M~Q)~ .... CD CD 10 N N M ~ an 10 ... CD ~g~gf'?j~~"i:g;e ~... N ~ .... N ":..... flit fit flit fit flit fit fit flit flit flit flit ~:g;;:~;i;fD ~iO~:; CD N C\I UJ ... M UJ N an M ~a:;cMonoonononcD .... - M""""NMOUJ..,.N .... .... . Q) ~~ CD e 't:I UQ) .5 21 E :g ~ flltfltWflltflltflltflltflltflltflt fit flltflltM flit flit flit flit flit flit flit 6ft flit flit M flit flit flit flit flit CIt fit 6ft't:I e CD 0 en e':; 8111 .r:. =-- E ;:: u -CD a-!::: E 1e(!;;;:(!;I::~~~~ ~UJ UJ M UJ 0 Q) an CD N~t:f~mgg~ ~ flit fit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit e' 8CU GI.r:.::o ~ E ;::~- u ee ,- g8:g fD~~~:gl::ro ~CDUJ MNUJOM ' ..; on ai 1:::" 0 ' ~ ' .n 0' M~ Q)gJM ~CDIO .... flit flit flit flltClt flltflltflltCltfllt flit .!! ..c"OJ !! 'E ::I CD .~ E ~::I E GI fJ) ... ::- ~ :i: 0 0 C) LL. t!!~~.~~s "'= 0. .=o~a:== III - U - iii 0 't:I .!!! III CD :I: CD ::I :I: :I:: e oS ~ (I) CJ) (I) ::s (I) (I) :--. (I) e 001 uin iiieniD-111 e :I:iii CD t?- 't:I-CD :g5.0in .en E ~ ~ 111 . t?- E =-- en;:: cnU 0t!! u'6 't:I 19&LL.0'" -to- 2! (I)(I) :s ::'iii ... an .... an 0 .... ~ N UJ ,... UJ CDOCD....MIOQ)Q)CDM MM"" .... MCDQ)""NN":M~N cOgg~g g~ ~N ~ ............ flit flit flit flit flit flit flltClt Cltfllt flit (!;~~~~~:gg ....... t\!.e.UJOUJNCD~ .... ... 0.... ~' N rD ai rD M .n .... flit 6ft flit flit flit flit flit flit 6ft flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit .... ManCDCDlOlOCDOCD;i;~::~~~~i!~;..: ..: N ..: ,.: ..; 0 ~ai 0 CD....O CDNON... ...NN ....N flit flit CIt flit CIt flit flit CIt CIt flit flit (!;~mf8~~~~:gg ... ... N, e. co 0 CD N CD ~ ....... 0.... ";NcOairDM ... CU en... 0~ u 't:I III . ' a-EoE 01- 0CDa-CU:t; CD CI in III Ec( - cilDUi~ 0s1iu ~ g e ~21 EIII 01 .!2 a- iacn e':; 8CU - 15 i::-. E ;:: ~ c. is . e' 8CU ID.r:. ~ - ~=c:c( u ~ -t!! , flltflltCltflltflltflltflltCltflltfllt fllt flit flit CIt flit flit flit flit flit flit flit flit .... CD 10..,. N .... CD CD ......: N flit flit flit flit flit flit flit 6ft flit flit flit ,... MIOMano .... Q)CDM....":NN .... flit 6ft flit flit flit flit flit flit 6ft flit flit ... co Q) N N .... ,... co ;1j ..: ,... ' N ,...- N m rD cO.... 0 CONO .... N N .... N .... flit flltflltflltflltClt flit flit 6ft flit flit :is ... iii 'E ID ::; CD .s.?~ E ~::I e iD en ... ::0 ~Jl 0 0 C) LL. ID ::-. ... = ~ CU iii (5 := us:. a- eIII -iii 0 't:IQI :I: ID:I: ~ :::i r . 01 ID iii- ;:: :: 'E Gi'=0 IDa: 1iJ ~ /P. a:; .... . iiien ca ,:; e ... N N N~ 888N N N iii 0"3 't:I 't:I ::;ID ~ 't:Iiii en cu 't:I11I.Q III .Q 'E , !::: iii~ 1i ff 01 cu u 5r~ ~ ~ iD GI ,.. E 0 ~ "'- ~ .EUi~ G e 0 ..r:.1! 'E 13 1iJ III .r:. ::I OIO-- E 't:IIII't:Ii Cl SiD ~ 5. QI .E.2I'in~ u.E ::! :a1! ::! III a!i~215 g.:g I1I 't:I1iJCD1!-5 III III.-~en E!'Ec lIIg e Cil8"E-8'6 Q.~~~lD't:I "",ClCU.. ID ~ "'" ID U U01 CU 't:I:ij !!!.. III s:.o.lD s3:88 ~!!!! "-5'-~iii'-5't:1i;;III ~ s iii ID c.c. :g~' ~.soSe u 0 III ::! 't:I 't:I ::! .Ei:8 OlCls:. !! Ui :g CD Iii Iiiu1:l11 111u cuu E ID a ID ~~~Ui ::--- u-'iii l1l t!!a-'E .r:. ::-. '6,E QI i ~:6:5 ::1= ~~~ :g'5'58~i~~~oiiiIIICll ... ::I ::IClleniiia-o.Ql ::I /P. /P. f3. f3. C!J f3. ~ f3. rii ...--- LL.:I: ::I::I ::I ::I ::I ::I ::I ::I ::I III ... ::I .r:. iii iii ... 't:I iii CII IIICii ::I III ::!: ::I ...:. . Ta b l e 3 E Al l o c a t i o n o f I n c e n t i v e a n d N o n - In c e n t i v e ( N o n - io n a l ) E l e c t r i c U t i l i t Co s t s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o ie s As s l s l l v e Co m p r e l S e d In d u s t r i a l Re s o u r c e Su s t a i n a b l e ,," o f Ap p l l a n c e l Te c h n o l o g i e s Ai r Co n t r o l l HV A C Pr o c e l l Llg h l l n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r l Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e l Ma n a g e m e n t Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g TO T A L $ Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l 18 5 75 9 55 5 28 , 49 8 Go v e r n m e n t 68 , 92 5 23 3 . 26 9 35 , 88 1 19 5 31 5 70 5 53 5 , 09 8 23 . Fo o d S e r v i c e 89 0 $ 50 2 28 , 99 5 15 , 08 8 10 , 33 6 59 , 81 1 He a l t h C a r e 70 5 $ 17 , 80 6 S 76 , 15 8 26 2 12 2 , 93 0 Ho s p i t a l i t y 21 2 75 5 S 58 , 21 6 S 40 4 00 8 $ 27 4 38 3 12 . LIm i t e d I n c o m e 11 9 , 43 2 33 9 , 29 0 $ 42 1 62 0 $ 47 0 , 76 2 20 . Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 22 0 , 04 5 13 9 15 , 48 2 (4 4 , 72 8 ) $ 36 3 24 2 , 37 6 10 . Of f i c e 96 0 40 $ 55 , 19 0 $ 21 4 , 65 0 $ 80 0 $ 46 4 30 . 68 8 $ 31 9 , 79 3 14 . Re s i d e n t i a l 26 , 82 5 95 , 78 1 49 5 13 1 , 12 8 Re t l l l 20 , 63 4 76 , 91 7 92 8 10 1 52 8 4" . TO T A L S 15 1 , 15 6 22 0 , 04 5 40 S 82 5 , 10 6 72 , 23 5 57 4 63 9 17 9 , 15 9 49 0 19 5 , 31 5 68 , 12 0 S 2 , 28 6 , 30 4 10 0 . -; . o f p o r t f o l i o 3& . 1- ; . 25 . 0- ; . 10 0 . 0- ; . NO T E S : In c e n t i v e s a r e d e - r a t e d l o r d e g r e e 0 1 p r o j e c t c o m p l e t i o n t o m a t c h r e c o g n i t i o n 0 1 k W h a n d I h e r m c l a i m s . Co s t s a s s o c i a t e d w i t h r e g i o n a l p r o g r a m s a r e e x c l u d e d f r o m t h i s t a b l e , a n d a r e e x c l u d e d f r o m a l l c o s l - e " e c l i v e n e s s c a l c u l a t i o n s . DT a b l e 3 G Al l o c a t i o n o f I n c e n t i v e a n d N o n - In c e n t i v e No n - io n a l Ga s U t i l i t Co s t s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s As s l s l l v e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Re s o u r c e Su s t a i n a b l e %o f Ap p l l i n c e l Te c h n o l o g i e s Ai r Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e s s LI g h t i n g Mo n l t o r f n g Mo t o r s Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e s Ma n a g e m e n t Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g . T O T A L S Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l 64 7 87 3 22 5 74 5 Go v e r n m e n t 93 5 67 , 19 2 39 , 30 2 13 , 97 3 12 1 , 40 1 10 . Fo o d S e r v i c e 05 2 28 1 38 5 He l l t h C a r e 16 0 , 4 1 0 16 0 , 41 0 13 . Ho s p i t a l i t y 71 9 17 7 39 1 44 , 02 1 22 2 , 13 1 18 . LI m i t e d I n c o m e 12 5 12 3 , 4 5 9 80 , 77 3 $ 20 6 , 35 7 17 . Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 56 0 $ 85 , 86 3 $ 46 9 89 2 Of f i c e 88 , 67 8 45 , 31 8 13 3 , 99 8 11 . 2'" 1 . Re s i d e n l i l l 82 5 $ 18 0 , 70 2 40 , 66 0 $ 22 & , 18 7 18 . 9" . Re t a i l 15 , 10 7 $ 94 9 17 9 30 , 23 & 5'" 1 . TO T A L S 23 , 71 1 64 7 , 63 0 87 , 73 6 16 0 , 46 2 39 , 30 2 23 4 , 89 8 S S 1 , 19 3 , 73 8 10 0 . % o f p o r t f o l i o 00 / . 54 . 3" . 13 . 0" . 19 . 7" . 10 0 . NO T E S : In c e n l i v e s a r e d e - r a t e d l o r d e g r e e 0 1 p r o j e c t c o m p l e l i o n t o m a t c h r e c o g n i l i o n 0 1 k W h a n d t h e r m c l a i m s . Co s t s a s s o c i a t e d w i t h r e g i o n a l p r o g r a m s a r e e x c l u d e d I r o m t h i s t a b l e , a n d a r e e x c l u d e d f r o m a l l c o s l - e " e c l i v e n e s s c a l c u l a t i o n s . Ta b l e 4 E All o c a t i o n o f E l e c t r i c D i r e c t I n c e n t i v e s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s Al l l s l l v e Co m p r e s s e d In d u l t r l l l Re s o u r c e Su s t a i n a b l e %o f Ap p l l a n c e l Te c h n o l o g i e s Air Co n t r o l l HV A C Pr o c e s s LI g h t i n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r l Ne w T e c h Re n e w l b l e l Ma n a g e m e n t Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g TO T A L $ Po r t f o l i o Ag r l c u l l u r a l 32 1 33 0 0" . Go v e r n m e n t 46 , 65 5 15 7 . 89 9 28 7 13 2 , 20 8 15 4 36 2 , 20 3 24 . 3" . Fo o d S e r v i c e 36 8 36 9 23 3 84 5 88 8 3" . He a l l h C a r e 21 , 60 6 13 , 88 6 59 . 39 0 98 4 95 , 86 7 Ho s p i t a l i t y 18 5 , 79 6 50 , 83 9 35 3 62 7 23 9 , 61 5 16 . 0" . LI m i t e d I n c o m e 95 . 72 5 $ 2 7 1 , 94 2 74 2 90 9 37 7 , 31 9 25 . 3.' " Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 45 , 65 9 21 3 (9 , 28 1 ) 10 . 65 8 29 3 4" . OH l c e 81 9 39 , 28 0 15 2 , 77 2 10 . 53 4 33 0 21 , 84 2 22 7 , 60 5 15 . Re l l d e n t l a l 40 5 62 , 14 4 51 2 85 , 07 7 7" . Re t a i l 10 , 22 9 38 , 12 9 94 7 50 , 32 9 TO T A L $ 11 6 , 04 5 45 , 65 9 $ 8 3 8 , 05 1 90 3 40 8 , 21 9 10 5 , 22 9 34 7 13 2 , 20 8 41 , 83 6 49 3 , 52 5 10 0 . 0" . % o f p o r t f o l i o 8,. . 42 . 27 . 10 0 . 0" . NO T E S : In c e n t i v e s r e p r e s e n t e d i n t h i s t a b l e a r e c a l c u l a t e d o n a c a s h b a s i s Ta b l e 4 G All o c a t i o n o f G a s D i r e c t I n c e n t i v e s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o ie s Au l s l l v e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Re s o u r c e Su s t a i n a b l e ". o f Ap p l l a n c e l Te c h n o l o g i e s Ai r Co n t r o l l HV A C Pr o c e s s LI g h t i n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r s Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e s Ma n a g e m e n t Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g TO T A L $ Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l 0" . Go v e r n m e n t 77 3 55 , 56 5 32 , 50 1 11 , 55 5 10 0 , 39 5 1" . Fo o d S e r v i c e He a l l h C . r e 16 1 06 6 16 1 , 06 6 14 . 6, . . Ho s p i t a l i t y 70 4 $ 1 7 3 . 57 3 43 , 07 3 21 7 , 34 9 19 . Llm l l e d I n c o m e 08 3 12 1 , 01 5 79 , 17 4 20 2 , 27 2 18 . Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 43 5 66 , 59 4 36 4 67 , 39 2 Of f i c e 03 1 41 , 41 0 12 2 , 44 1 11 . Re s l d e n l l a l 48 2 16 7 12 0 37 . 60 4 20 9 , 18 7 18 . 9, . . Re t a i l 13 , 21 4 95 3 27 9 26 , 44 6 4, . . TO T A L $ 21 , 23 5 $ 6 0 5 , 69 2 86 , 59 4 16 1 , 06 6 32 , 50 1 21 9 , 46 0 10 6 , 54 8 10 0 . 0. " ,. . o f p o r t f o l i o 54 . 8.0 % 14 . 0,. . 2. 9 % 19 . 10 0 . NO T E S : In c e n t i v e s r e p r e s e n t e d I n t h i s t a b l e a r e c a l c u l a t e d o n a c a s h b a s i s Ta b l e 5 E Al l o c a t i o n o f E l e c t r i c b . . " . n g s A t t r i b u t a b l e t o E l e c t r i c P r o ra m s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s A.s l s l l v e Te c h n o l o g l e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Re s o u r c e Su s t a i n a b l e %o f Ap p l i a n c e s Air Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e s s Llg h l l n g Mo n l l o r l n g Mo t o r s Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e s Ma n a g e m e n t Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g TO T A L k W h Po r t f o l i o Ag r l c u l l u r a l 34 3 53 2 03 0 90 5 Go v e r n m e n t 05 5 , 89 2 57 3 , 55 3 54 9 , 67 2 99 2 , 11 0 26 , 12 6 19 7 , 35 2 28 . Fo o d S e r v i c e 35 . 52 2 17 9 , 68 5 15 7 . 23 1 60 2 , 20 1 41 2 , 53 1 38 7 , 17 0 He a l t h C a r e 18 2 , 92 5 11 7 , 56 3 50 2 , 82 4 33 5 81 1 , 64 7 Ho s p l l a l l t y 15 6 60 6 31 6 , 47 9 19 5 16 , 35 3 49 1 , 63 4 Ll m l l e d I n c o m e 45 6 , 67 2 29 7 , 34 6 13 , 08 1 32 , 96 1 80 0 , 06 0 20 / . Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 68 5 , 25 4 58 8 40 0 , 00 7 (1 , 15 5 , 63 9 ) 32 7 , 05 5 96 7 26 2 , 23 0 21 . Of f i c e 47 , 90 1 47 9 66 7 , 52 8 59 6 , 20 7 17 9 , 01 3 60 7 37 1 , 17 9 86 7 , 91 4 13 . 30 / . Re s l d e n l l a l 55 2 . 17 8 97 1 56 6 54 6 17 4 86 1 69 9 , 15 2 Re t a i l 75 0 31 7 , 85 8 18 4 , 87 5 60 , 51 0 56 3 , 99 4 40 / . TO T A L k W h 09 3 02 2 68 5 , 25 4 47 9 83 3 , 33 9 60 8 , 77 0 24 8 , 31 9 56 1 , 78 8 15 3 99 2 , 11 0 10 4 82 4 29 , 13 4 , 05 8 10 0 . % 0 1 p o r t f o l i o 0" ' " 19 . 50 / . 23 . 24 . 9" 1 . 10 . 3" 1 . 80 / . 10 0 . NO T E S : Th e s e s a v i n g s i n c l u d e d e r a t e d k W h s a v i n g s I r o m t h e c o n t r a c t e d a n d c o n s t r u c t i o n p h a s e s . Ta b l e 5 G Al l o c a t i o n o f E l e c t r i c S a v i n s A t t r i b u t a b l e t o G a s P r o ra m s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s A.s l s l l v e Te c h n o l o g l e C o m p r e l s e d Ap p l i a n c e s I Air Co n t r o l l HV A C In d u l t r l a l Pr o c e l l Llg h l i n g Mo n l l o r l n g Mo t o r l Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e l Re s o u r c e Ma n a g e m e n t Sh e l l Su s t a i n a b l e Bu i l d i n g T O T A L k W h Ag r i c u l t u r a l Go v e r n m e n t Fo o d S e r v i c e ;: t : : ) He a l t h C a r e Ho s p l l a l l t y LI m i t e d I n c o m e \ M a n u f a c t u r i n g -- . j Of f i c e Re s i d e n t i a l Re t a i l TO T A L k W h % o f p o r t f o l i o (1 8 ) (1 8 ) .'" o f Po r t f o l i o O." , 10 0 . 00 / . 0" 1 . 00 / . 10 0 . 00 / . 00 / . O." , 00 / . (1 8 ) 10 0 . 00 / . 00 / . 00 / . (1 8 ) 10 0 . NO T E S : Th e s e s a v i n g s i n c l u d e d e r a t e d k W h s a v i n g s ' r o m I h e c o n t r a c t e d a n d c o n s t r u c t i o n p h a s e s . Ta b l e 6 E Al l o c a t i o n o f G a s S a v i n g s A t t r i b u t a b l e t o E l e c t r i c P r o ra m s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s Al s l s t i v e Re l o u r c e Te c h n o l o g l e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Ma n a g e m e n Su s t a i n a b l e TO T A L ." . o f Ap p l l a n c e l Ai r Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e s s LI g h t i n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r l Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e l Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g th e r m s Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l Go v e r n m e n t (1 7 87 9 ) (1 7 , 87 9 ) 45 . Fo o d S e r v i c e (1 , 49 S ) (2 0 5 ) 70 1 ) He a l t h C a r e (S 9 8 ) (7 8 6 ) (1 , 48 4 ) Ho s p i t a l i t y (1 4 0 ) (2 , 57 0 ) (2 , 71 0 ) 0." . LI m i t e d I n c o m e Ma n u f a c t u r i n g (1 1 0 ) 83 3 72 3 -9 . 6" 1 . Or t l c e (1 4 ) (4 . 64 7 ) 49 9 ) (1 2 , 16 0 ) 31 . 2 % Re l l d e n l l a l 0" 1 . Re t a i l 76 5 ) (6 , 76 5 ) 17 . TO T A L k W h (1 , 51 0 ) (5 , 59 5 ) (3 1 , 87 2 ) (3 8 , 97 8 ) 10 0 . k o f p o r t f o l i o 3. 9 % 0" 1 . 14 . 00 / . 81 . 80 / . 00 / . O" ! . 00 / . 0" - ' 10 0 . 00 / . NO T E S : Th e s e s a v i n g s i n c l u d e d e r a t e d k W h s a v i n g s I r o m t h e c o n l r a c t e d a n d c o n s t r u c t i o n p h a s e s . En e r g y s a v i n g s c l a i m s m a d e i n t h i s t a b l e a r e g a s t h e r m s s a v i n g s a t t r i b u t a b l e t o e l e c l r i c p r o g r a m s ( a r i s i n g I r o m j o i n l o r i n t e r a c t i v e s a v i n g s e l l e e t s ) . Ta b l e 6 G Al l o c a t i o n o f G a s S a v i n g s A t t r i b u t a b l e t o G a s P r o g r a m s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s Al i l l t i v e Re s o u r c e Te c h n o l o g l e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Ma n a g e m e n Su s t a i n a b l e TO T A L 0/. Ap p l l a n c e l Ai r Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e l l LI g h t i n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r s Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e s Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g th e r m s Po r t f o l i o A r l c u l t u r a l 02 0 74 0 04 9 12 , 80 9 Go v e r n m e n t 80 2 12 9 , 58 3 75 , 79 6 94 8 23 4 , 12 9 31 . Fo o d S e r v i c e 57 9 22 6 92 4 14 , 72 9 0( ) He a l t h C a r e 61 3 ) (7 , 61 3 ) Ho s p i t a l i t y 17 4 42 , 94 9 10 , 65 8 53 , 78 1 10 / . LI m i t e d I n c o m e 25 0 14 , 52 5 50 3 24 , 27 8 Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 49 7 76 , 21 9 41 6 77 , 13 2 10 . 20 / . Or t l c e 71 , 02 6 36 , 29 7 10 7 , 32 3 14 . 2. k Re l l d e n t l a l 16 0 15 5 , 79 4 35 , 05 6 19 5 , 01 0 25 . Re t a i l 21 , 97 1 11 , 56 1 10 , 44 0 43 , 97 2 TO T A L k W h 28 , 35 7 43 3 , 53 4 84 , 95 9 (7 , 38 7 ) 75 , 79 6 14 0 , 29 1 75 5 , 55 0 10 0 . 00 / . % o f p o r t f o l i o 57 . 11 . -1 . 0. 1 . 10 . 18 . 0." . 10 0 . NO T E S : Th e s e s a v i n g s i n c l u d e d e r a t e d k W h s a v i n g s f r o m t h e c o n t r a c t e d a n d c o n s t r u c t i o n p h a s e s . En e r g y s a v i n g s c l a i m s m a d e I n t h i s t a b l e a r e g a s t h e r m s a v i n g s a t t r i b u t a b l e t o g a s p r o g r a m s . Ta b l e 7 E Al l o c a t i o n o f E l e c t r i c N o n - En e r g Be n e f i t s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s Al l l l t i v e Re l o u r c e Te c h n o l o g l e C o m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Ma n a g e m e " Su s t a i n a b l e '" / . o f Ap p l i a n c e s Air Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e l l LI g h t i n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r l Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e l Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g TO T A L S Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l 30 4 29 1 63 0 2'" / . Go v e r n m e n t 90 , 47 6 16 3 , 26 5 42 6 03 4 26 7 , 20 2 13 . Fo o d S e r v i c e 82 9 10 2 12 7 , 79 6 60 6 08 6 14 3 , 42 0 He a l t h C a r e 29 9 18 , 87 7 24 , 17 6 Ho s p l t a l i l y 12 2 , 69 1 24 1 , 82 1 34 8 85 4 36 6 , 71 4 18 . Ll m l l e d I n c o m e 0'" / . Ma n u f a c t u r i n g 27 1 , 69 9 27 9 15 , 24 3 (4 9 , 74 4 ) S 23 7 , 56 6 11 . Of t l c e 16 , 28 6 92 , 74 2 52 8 , 55 9 49 , 25 4 68 6 , 84 2 34 . 3'" / . Re s i d e n t i a l Re h l l l 34 5 18 4 , 38 3 87 2 27 3 , 59 9 13 . 7'" 1 . TO T A L k W h 18 , 11 5 27 1 , 69 9 39 8 , 96 8 14 7 , 34 3 09 0 , 76 7 06 5 69 , 18 9 00 4 , 14 7 10 0 . '" I . o f po r t f o l i o 13 . 19 . 54 . 00 / . 00 / . 10 0 . 00 / . NO T E S : Th i s l a b l e d o e s n o l i n c l u d e n o n - e n e r g y b e n e l i l s w h i c h w e r e n o l s u H i c i e n l l y q u a n l i f i a b l e 10 b e c l a i m e d a s p a r t o f l h e p r o j e c l b e n e f i t s . Ta b l e 7 G Al l o c a t i o n o f G a s N o n - En e r Be n e f i t s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e me n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s As i l l t i v e Re s o u r c e Te c h n o l o g l e C o m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Ma n a g e m e n Su s t a i n a b l e '" I . Ap p l l a n c e l Air Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e l l LI g h t i n g Mo n i t o r i n g Mo t o r l Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e l Sh e l l Bu i l d i n g TO T A L S Po r t f o l i o Ag r l c u l l u r a l 79 3 15 , 47 0 85 7 25 , 12 0 60 / . Go v e r n m e n t 97 6 04 2 68 , 08 6 11 0 , 10 4 Fo o d S e r v i c e 02 1 19 , 37 0 21 , 39 1 He a l l h C a r e Ho s p l l a l l t y 57 6 56 , 55 6 17 , 62 3 74 , 75 5 LIm i t e d I n c o m e Ma n u f a c l u r l n g 00 6 , 58 6 55 4 00 7 , 14 0 65 . 7'" 1 . Of t l c e 18 9 , 00 4 45 , 76 3 23 4 76 8 15 . 3'" 1 . Re s i d e n t i a l 0'" 1 . Re t a i l 29 , 10 0 10 , 80 8 20 , 17 2 60 , 08 0 TO T A L k W h 65 1 30 8 , 22 5 02 2 , 05 6 17 2 , 42 5 53 3 , 35 7 10 0 . 0'" 1 . % o f p o r t f o l i o 0'" 1 . 00 / . 20 . 10 / . 88 . 0'" 1 . 00 / . 00 / . 11 . 0- / . 10 0 . 00 / . NO T E S : Th i s l a b l e d o e s n o t i n c l u d e n o n - e n e r g y b e n e f i t s w h i c h w e r e n o l s u " i c i e n l l y q u a n l i l i a b l e t o b e c l a i m e d a s p a r t 0 1 t h e p r o j e c t b e n e f i t s . Ta b l e B E All o c a t i o n o f E l e c t r i c C u s t o m e r C o s t s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s As s l s l l v e Re s o u r c e Te c h n o l o g l e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r I a l Ma n a g e m e n Su s t a I n a b l e /. o f Ap p l l a n c e l Ai r Co n t r o l l HV A C Pr o c e l l Llg h l l n g Mo n i t o r I n g Mo t o r s Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e s Sh e l l Bu i l d I n g TO T A L S Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l (2 1 15 2 ) $ 67 5 (2 0 , 47 7 ) 2'Y . Go v e r n m e n t 25 8 99 1 33 4 , 37 1 19 8 57 2 25 8 80 6 , 39 0 20 . Fo o d S e r v I c e 52 5 33 , 96 0 08 0 00 0 53 , 21 1 12 3 01 9 29 7 , 71 5 14 . He a l t h C a r e 13 4 , 74 9 46 , 74 4 12 2 , 56 9 26 3 30 7 32 4 5'Y . Ho s p l t a l l l y 44 3 , 47 7 19 0 , 94 3 64 1 36 9 64 0 , 45 0 LI m i t e d I n c o m e 11 3 , 42 5 41 7 , 71 4 97 1 24 , 42 1 58 1 , 53 1 4'Y . Ma n u f a c t u r i n g $ 1 61 2 , 39 2 94 8 11 3 , 34 9 (3 5 0 , 84 0 ) S 50 9 , 12 7 46 2 88 5 , 43 7 21 . 7'Y . OH i c e 34 , 81 0 24 3 23 4 , 99 7 56 5 , 07 6 39 , 75 0 19 , 78 8 21 2 , 96 0 12 7 , 62 3 13 . 0'Y . Re s l d e n l l a l 92 , 80 0 42 4 , 21 9 73 4 27 , 16 1 54 6 , 91 4 3'Y . Re t a i l 29 1 , 25 5 23 1 , 61 9 30 , 45 9 55 3 , 41 4 TO T A L k W h 24 8 , 64 0 61 2 , 39 2 24 3 24 0 , 31 0 17 2 , 19 6 09 7 , 09 6 77 1 , 96 0 22 , 52 1 98 , 57 2 44 2 , 39 1 70 6 , 32 1 10 0 . ". o f p o r t f o l i o 18 . 25 . 13 . 5" . 24 . w . 10 0 . Ta b l e B G Al l o c a t i o n o f G a s C u s t o m e r C o s t s A c r o s s C u s t o m e r S e g m e n t s a n d T e c h n o l o g i e s As s l s l i v e Re s o u r c e Te c h n o l o g l e Co m p r e s s e d In d u s t r i a l Ma n a g e m e n Su s t a i n a b l e %o f Ap p l i a n c e s Air Co n t r o l s HV A C Pr o c e l l Ll g h l l n g Mo n I t o r i n g Mo t o r s Ne w T e c h Re n e w a b l e s Sh e l l Bu i l d I n g TO T A L S Po r t f o l i o Ag r i c u l t u r a l 47 , 99 1 28 8 54 , 27 9 Go v e r n m e n t 12 , 37 5 05 1 , 92 9 45 , 42 6 23 0 , 27 6 34 0 , 00 8 31 . 8'Y . Fo o d S e r v i c e 25 , 95 8 58 3 33 , 49 7 61 , 03 8 4. / . He a l t h C a r e (1 0 , 62 1 ) (1 0 , 62 1 ) Ho s p l t a l l l y 98 0 24 1 , 07 6 73 , 18 5 31 6 , 24 1 5'Y . LI m i t e d I n c o m e 73 8 70 , 23 3 56 , 74 8 13 6 , 71 9 2'Y . Ma n u f a c t u r I n g 59 0 49 5 49 4 86 3 50 1 , 94 7 11 . \: / OH i c e 51 8 , 42 4 26 8 , 33 5 78 6 75 9 18 . Re s l d e n l l a l 60 0 59 7 11 7 17 0 89 7 79 5 , 61 4 18 . Re l a l l 90 , 18 5 63 , 4 2 1 79 , 53 0 23 3 , 13 6 TO T A L k W h 14 1 , 87 8 57 1 , 74 8 54 3 , 48 6 (9 , 03 8 ) 45 , 42 8 92 1 , 62 0 21 5 , 12 2 10 0 . 0'Y . % o f p o r t f o l i o OO Y . 61 . 12 . 9'Y . -0 . 2'Y . O'Y . O'Y . 1'Y . 21 . 10 0 . Table 9E Electric Cost-Effectiveness Statistics by Customer Segment Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Agricultural (0.30)(0.63) Government Food Service . Health Care 1.73 Hospitality 1.00 Limited Income Manufacturing 1.06 Office Residential Retail 1.70 PORTFOLIO NOTES: Cost-effectiveness calculations do not include costs or benefits associated with regional programs. NiAN is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. Table 9G Gas Cost-Effectiveness Statistics by Customer Segment Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Agricultural Govemment Food Service Health Care 32. Hospitality 1.52 Limited Income Manufacturing 1.74 Office Residential 1.72 Retail PORTFOLIO NOTES: Cost-effectiveness calculations do not include costs or benefits associated with regional programs. N/A" is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. \ \ Table 1 Electric Cost-Effectiveness Statistics by Technology Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Appliances 0.45 Assistive Technologies Compressed Air Controls (0.41)-0. HVAC Industrial Process 1.53 Lighting 0.46 Monitoring Motors New Tech Renewables Resource Management Shell Sustainable Building PORTFOLIO NOTES: Cost-effectiveness calculations do not include costs or benefits associated with regional programs. N1A8 is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. Table 1DG Gas Cost-Effectiveness Statistics by Technology Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Appliances Assistive Technologies Compressed Air Controls HVAC Industrial Process Lighting 32. Monitoring Motors New Tech Renewables Resource Management 12. Shell Sustainable Building PORTFOUO NOTES: Cost-effectiveness calculations do not include costs or benefits associated with regional programs. N/N is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. roo Table 11 Electric Net Benefits by Customer Segment Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Agricultural 707 715 41,821 (17 114) Government 89,997 901,651 026,086 (1,964 798) Food Service 805,087 690,789 475,328 (673,670) Health Care 15,920 272,782 187,230 (173,206) Hospitality 039 489 312 387 858 (388,931) Limited Income 201,372 201,372 205,054 (1,003,682) Manufacturing 124 321 1 ,455,386 669,215 (538,933) Office 139,434 804 926 315 817 189,570) Residential 629,454 091,147 376 734 (747 280) Retail (76 264) $364 493 306 487 (397 105) PORTFOLIO 957,066 288 572 991,631 094,288) NOTES: Costs and benefits included in each cost-effectiveness test are detailed in Table 13. Costs associated with regional programs are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. Table 11G Gas Net Benefits by Customer Segm~nt Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Agricultural 657 584 65,790 (44 133) Government 277 614 031,913 618,260 (340 652) Food Service 591 78,090 539 (31,948) Health Care (16,642) $(27,263) $(34 951) $309 Hospitality 167,069 249,604 314 527 (147,458) Limited Income 36,117 36,117 200 931 (164 814) Manufacturing (87,100) $185,486 202,969 (290,068) Office (6,905) $503,823 297 281 (304 186) Residential 584 976 171 502 039,371 (454,395) Retail 43,937 134,103 190 092 (146,155) PORTFOLIO 083,315 3,405,959 988,809 (1,905,500) NOTES: Costs and benefits included in each cost-effectiveness test are detailed in Table 13. Costs associated with regional programs are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. POo \3 Table 12E Electric Net Benefits by Technology Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Appliances 47,899 148,389 435,024 (390,165) Assistive Technologies Compressed Air (19,634) $089,277 600,022 (619,656) Controls (360) $(250) $(110) HVAC 987,061 422,867 146,132 (2,160,669) Industrial Process 650,275 552,584 042.185 (391 909) lighting (251,626) $533,496 200,306 (2,507,017) Monitoring Motors 326,011 682 604 605,852 (277 842) NewTech Renewables (19,977) $052 (18,348) $(1,630) Resource Management 121 637 220 209 556,007 (434 370) Shell 113,762 437,024 424 701 (310,920) Sustainable Building PORTFOLIO 957,066 288,572 991 631 094 288) NOTES: Costs and benefits included in each cost-effectiveness test are detailed in Table 13. Regional program costs and benefits are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. Table 12G Gas Net Benefits by Technology Total Non- Resource Utility Cost Participant Participant Cost Test Test Test Test Appliances (387) $19,636 119,149 (119,536) Assistive Technologies Compressed Air Controls HVAC 530,539 416,571 523 373 (992,840) Industrial Process (88,354) $204 515 231,865 (320,219) lighting (17,416) $(26,454) $(35,182) $766 Monitoring Motors New Tech Renewables Resource Management 55,046 100,473 140,238 (85,192) Shell 603,867 691,218 009,367 (405 479) Sustainable Building PORTFOUO 083 315 405,959 988,609 (1,905,500) NOTES: Costs and benefits included in each cost-effectiveness test are detailed in Table 13. Regional program costs and benefits are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. PO\ Table 13E .. . - Summary of Electric Cost-Effectiveness Tests and Descriptive Statistics Regular Income Limited Income Regular Income Limited IncomeTotal Resource Cost Test portfolio portfolio Overall DOrtfolio Utility Cost Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Electric avoided cost 520 588 811 885 $ 10,332,473 Electric avoided cost 520,588 811,885 10,332,473 Non-Energy benelits $287 006 287 006 Natural Gas avoided cost (163,313) $(163,313) Natural Gas avoided cost (163,313) $(163 313)UCT benefits 357 276 811,885 10,169,160 TRC benefits 644 281 811.885 $ 11 456,166 Non-incentive utility cost 743.797 48,982 792,779 Non-incentive utility cost 743,797 48,982 792,779 Incentive cost 526,278 561.531 087 809 Customer cost $144,790 561,531 706,321 UCT costs 270,075 610 513 880,588 TRC costs 888,587 610,513 9,499,100 UCT ratio TRC ratio Net UCT benefits $087,200 201,372 288,572 Net TRC benefits $755 694 201,372 1 ,957,066 Regular Income Limited Income Participant Test portfolio portfolio Overall cortfolio Electric Bill Reduction $ 12,341 119 $ 1 205,054 $ 13,546,173 Gas Bill Reduction $ (223,036) $ $ (223,036) Non-Energybenefits $ 1 287 006 $ $ 1 287,006 Participant benefits $ 13,405,089 $ 1 205,054 $ 14,610 143 Customer project cost 144 790 561 531 706,321 Incentive received $(2,526 278) $(561,531) $(3,087 809) Participant costs 618,512 618.512 Participant Test ratio Net Participant benefits $786 577 1 ,205,054 991 631 Regular Income Descriptive Statistics cortfolio Annual kWh savings 27 333,998 Annual thenn savings (38,978) Levelized TRC cost per kWh $ 0.0376 $ Levelized UCT cost per kWh $ 0.0138 $ Regular Income Limited Income Electric Non-Participant Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Electric avoided cost savings $ 9 520,588 $ Non-Participant benefits $ 9,520,588 $ 811 885 $ 10,332,473 811 885 $ 10,332,473 Electric Revenue loss 12,341 119 205,054 13,546,173 Non-incentive utility cost 743,797 982 792,779 Customer incentives $526,278 561 531 087 809 Non-Participant costs 611,195 815,567 17,426 762 Non-Part. ratio Net Non-Part. benefits $(6,090,606) $(1,003,682) $(7,094,288) Limited Income portfolio 800 060 Overall portfolio 134,058 (38,978) 0372 0152 0337 $ 0337 $ NOTES: Costs associated with membership in regional programs are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. N/A" is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. p~ IS Table 13G Summary of Gas Cost-Effectiveness Tests and Descriptive Statistics Regular Income Limited Income Regular Income Limited IncomeTotal Resource Cost Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio UtIlity Cost Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolioElectric avoided cost (9) $(9)Electric avoided cost (9) $(9)Non-Energy benefits $573,854 573,854 Natural Gas avoided cost 636,146 175,637 811 783 Natural Gas avoided cost 636 146 175,637 811 783 UCT benefits 636,137 175 637 811 774TRC benefits 209,991 175,637 385,628 Non-incentive utility cost 389 802 191Non-incentive utility cost 389 802 191 Incentive cost 181 906 136,719 318 625 Customer cost $078,403 136,719 215,122 UCT costs 266,295 139 521 1,405,815TRC costs 162.792 139,521 302,313 UCT ratioTRC ratio Net UCT benefits $369,842 117 405,959Net TRC benefits $047,199 36,117 083 315 Regular Income Limited Income Participant Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Electric Bill Reduction $ (15) $ (15) Gas Bill Reduction $ 5.110,537 $ 200 931 $ 5,311,468 Non-Energy benefits $ 573 854 $ $ 573,854 Participant benefits $ 5 684 376 $ 200,931 $ 5,885 307 Customer project cost 078,403 136,719 215,122 Incentive received $181,906) $(136 719) $(1,318,625) Participant costs 896,497 896,497 Participant Test ratio Net Participant benefits 787,878 200,931 988,809 Regular Income Descriptive Statistics portfolio Annual kWh savings (18) Annual therm savings 731 272 Levelized TAC cost per therm $ 0.559 $ Levelized UCT cost per therm $ 0.170 $ Regular Income Limited Income Gas Non-Participant Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Gas avoided cost savings $636 146 175,637 811 783 Non-Part benefits $636 146 175,637 811,783 Gas Revenue loss $110,537 200,931 311,468 Non-incentive utility cost 389 802 191 Customer incentives $181 906 136,719 318 625 Non-Part costs 376,832 340,452 717 283 Non-Part. ratio Net Non-Part. benefits $(1,740,686) $(164 814) $905,500) Limited Income portfolio Overall portfolio (18) 755,550 559 183 24,278 564 $ 564 $ NOTES: Costs associated with membership in regional programs are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. N/A" is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. p~ IlP Table 13EG Summary of Combined Gas and Electric Cost-Effectiveness Tests and Descriptive Statistics Regular Income Limited Income Regular Income Limited IncomeTotal Resource Cost Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Utility Cost Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Electric avoided cost 520,579 811,885 $ 10,332,464 Electric avoided cost 520,579 81 1 885 10,332,464 Non-Energy benefits $860,859 860,859 Natural Gas avoided cost 472 833 175,637 648,471 Natural Gas avoided cost 472,833 175,637 648,471 UCT benefits 993,413 987 522 14,980,935 TRC benefits 15,854 272 987 522 $ 16,841,794 Non-incentive utility cost 828,186 51,784 879 970Non-incentive utility cost 828,186 784 879,970 Incentive cost 708,184 698,250 406 434 Customer cost $12,223,193 698,250 12,921 ,443 UCT costs 536,370 750,034 286,404 TRC costs 13,051,379 750 034 801 413 UCT ratio TRC ratio Net UCT benefits $457,043 237,488 694 531 Net TRC benefits $802,893 237,488 040,381 Regular Income Limited Income Gas and Electric Non- Regular Income Limited IncomeParticipant Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Participant Test portfolio portfolio Overall portfolio Electric Bill Reduction $12,341 104 205,054 $ 13,546 158 Gas avoided cost savings $636,146 175,637 811,783Gas Bill Reduction $887 501 200,931 088 432 Electric avoided cost savings $520,588 811 885 10,332,473 Non-Energy benefits $860,859 860,859 Non-Part benefits $156 734 987 522 15,144 257 Participant benefits $19,089,465 405,985 $ 20,495,450 Gas Revenue loss $110,537 200,931 311,468 Customer project cost 223.193 698,250 $ 12,921,443 Electric Revenue loss 12,341,119 205,054 13,546,173Incentive received $(3,708 184) $(698,250)(4,406,434)Non-incentive utility cost 828,186 51,784 879 970 Participant costs 515,009 515 009 Customer incentives $708,184 698,250 406 434 Non-Part costs 988,026 156,019 144 045Participant Test ratio Net Participant benefits $ 10,574,456 405,985 $ 11,980 441 Non-Part. ratio Net Non-Part. benefits $831,292) $(1,168,496) $(8,999 788) Regular Income Descriptive Statistics portfolio Annual kWh savings 27,333,980 Annual therm savings 692,294 Limited Income portfolio 800,060 24,278 Overall portfolio 29,134 040 716,572 NOTES: Costs associated with membership in regional programs are excluded from all cost-effectiveness calculations. N/A" is listed for segments with benefits, but no costs. po\ Ta b l e 1 4 E G Ta r i f f R i d e r B a l a n c e s Ja n u a r y WA S H I N G T O N E L E C T R I C T A R I F F R I D E R Ac t u a l W A R e v S 4 1 2 , 22 7 S 3 6 9 50 2 S 3 7 7 90 3 S 3 5 5 , 83 7 S 3 3 7 , 83 3 S 3 3 8 27 9 S 3 3 0 , 81 8 S 3 8 5 , 86 5 S 3 5 9 19 5 S 3 3 5 , 98 7 S 3 , 56 3 24 8 Ac t u a l W A E x p S 3 0 7 , 27 0 S 1 8 7 27 0 S 2 5 9 , 54 2 S 1 9 0 13 5 S 1 8 4 , 24 7 S 3 8 2 , 23 3 S 4 9 1 , 45 7 S 1 1 8 , 18 0 S 2 9 3 54 7 S 1 5 5 43 8 S 2 54 9 31 9 Ad j u s l m e n l a S 5 8 , 38 5 S S 5 8 38 5 Ba l a n c e r e d u c l l o n S 1 0 4 , 95 7 S 1 8 2 , 23 2 S 1 1 8 38 1 S 2 2 4 , 08 7 S 1 5 3 , 58 8 S ( 2 3 95 4 ) S ( 1 8 0 , 83 9 ) S 2 4 7 , 48 5 S 8 5 , 84 8 S 1 8 0 54 9 S 1 , 09 2 , 31 2 Fe b r u a r y Ma r c h Ap r . Ma y Ju n e Ju l y Au g u s l Sa p t e m b 8 f Oc l o b e r 03 1 0 1 0 . 31 . St a r t i n g b a l a n c e en d i n g b a l a n c e (5 , 93 8 60 3 ) S 83 1 , 84 8 ) S (5 , 83 1 84 8 ) S ( 5 , 84 9 , 41 4 ) S ( 5 , 53 1 05 3 ) S ( 5 30 8 96 6 ) S ( 5 , 15 3 36 0 ) S ( 5 , 17 7 , 33 4 ) S ( 5 , 33 7 , 97 3 ) S ( 5 , 09 0 48 8 ) S ( 5 02 4 , 84 0 ) 84 9 , 41 4 ) S ( 5 53 1 05 3 ) S ( 5 , 30 8 , 86 6 ) S ( 5 , 15 3 , 38 0 ) S ( 5 , 17 7 33 4 ) S ( 5 33 7 97 3 ) S ( 5 , 09 0 48 8 ) S ( 5 02 4 , 84 0 ) S ( 4 84 4 , 2 8 1 ) ID A H O E L E C T R I C T A R I F F R I D E R Ac l u a l l D R a v S 2 4 7 47 4 S 2 2 1 1 50 0 S 2 2 4 47 2 S 2 1 1 , 99 3 S 1 9 3 , 40 3 S 1 9 8 , 03 6 S 2 2 8 58 6 S 2 4 1 55 9 S 2 3 9 , 83 1 S 2 2 5 07 4 S 2 . 23 8 , 72 8 Ac l u a l i D E x p S 1 3 1 88 7 S 8 0 25 9 S 1 1 1 , 23 2 S 8 1 , 48 8 S 7 8 , 98 3 S ( 1 9 8 , 36 8 ) S 2 1 0 , 62 4 S 5 0 , 84 9 S 1 2 5 80 5 S 8 8 81 7 S 7 3 1 1 , 95 8 Ad j u s l m a n l a S 1 5 8 38 5 ) S S ( 5 8 , 38 5 ) S 1 1 5 78 7 S 1 4 8 , 24 1 S 1 1 3 24 0 S 7 2 , 12 2 S 1 1 4 , 44 0 S 3 9 4 40 2 S 1 7 , 98 2 S 1 9 0 91 0 S 1 1 3 , 82 8 S 1 5 8 , 45 7 S 1 43 9 38 7 Sta r t i n g b a l a n c e En d i n g b a l a n c e 75 8 , 25 8 ) S (1 , 64 2 48 9 ) S 84 2 , 48 9 ) S ( 1 49 4 22 8 ) S ( 1 38 0 98 8 ) S ( 1 30 8 86 8 ) S ( 1 19 4 42 6 ) S (1 , 49 4 , 22 8 ) S 38 0 98 8 ) S ( 1 30 8 86 6 ) S ( 1 19 4 42 6 ) S ( 8 0 0 02 4 ) S (8 0 0 , 02 4 ) S (7 8 2 06 2 ) S (7 8 2 08 2 ) S (5 9 1 15 2 ) S (5 9 1 15 2 ) S (4 7 7 32 8 ) S (4 7 7 32 6 ) (3 1 8 88 9 ) CO M B I N E D E L E C T R I C T A R I F F R I D E R S Ac l u a l R e v 65 1 1 70 1 59 8 , 00 2 60 2 , 37 5 58 7 83 0 53 1 23 8 53 4 , 31 5 55 9 , 40 4 60 7 , 22 4 59 8 , 82 8 56 1 06 1 Ac t u a l E x p 43 8 , 95 7 28 7 , 52 9 37 0 77 4 27 1 82 1 26 3 , 21 0 16 3 , 86 7 70 2 08 1 18 8 , 82 9 41 9 , 35 2 22 2 05 5 Ad j u s t m e n t s Ba l a n c e r e d u c l l a n 22 0 , 74 4 33 0 47 3 23 1 , 60 1 29 8 , 2 0 9 26 8 , 02 8 37 0 44 8 (1 4 2 , 87 7 ) S 43 8 , 39 5 17 9 47 4 33 9 00 6 81 9 , 97 4 28 8 , 27 5 53 1 69 9 Sta r l i n g b a l a n c e En d i n g b a l a n c e (7 , 69 4 85 9 ) S 47 4 11 5 ) S (7 , 47 4 11 5 1 S ( 7 14 3 84 2 ) S ( 8 91 2 , 04 1 1 S ( 8 81 5 63 2 ) S ( 8 , 34 7 , 80 8 ) S ( 5 , 87 7 35 8 ) S ( 8 12 0 03 5 ) S ( 5 88 1 , 84 0 ) S ( 5 50 2 , 18 8 ) 14 3 84 2 ) S ( 6 81 2 , 04 1 ) S ( 8 81 5 83 2 ) S ( 8 . 34 7 , 80 6 1 S ( 5 , 97 7 , 35 8 ) S ( 8 12 0 03 5 ) S ( 5 , 88 1 , 84 0 ) S ( 5 50 2 , 18 8 1 S ( 5 , 16 3 , 18 0 1 WA S H I N G T O N G A S T MI F F R I D E R Ac t u a l W A R e v 81 , 22 5 82 , 21 9 84 , 59 3 47 9 07 8 27 , 04 1 89 5 13 , 2 2 7 74 7 28 0 51 7 , 88 2 Ac t u a l W A E x p 89 5 11 2 , 95 8 49 7 88 2 17 1 , 58 3 14 3 , 34 9 58 , 44 0 28 , 00 8 13 5 33 8 SO , 78 1 11 1 1 , 58 7 Ad j u s l m e n t s 11 1 , 24 9 11 1 , 24 9 Ba l a n c e l e d u c l l o n 23 0 (3 0 73 7 ) S 09 6 08 8 (1 2 5 , 50 7 ) S (1 1 6 , 30 8 ) S (4 0 44 5 ) S (1 2 , 78 1 ) S (1 0 1 , 58 9 ) S 51 9 (2 8 2 . 45 6 ) Sta r t i n g b a l a n c e (8 4 2 , 29 3 ) S (8 1 5 08 3 1 S (8 4 5 80 0 ) S (8 2 1 70 4 ) S (7 3 8 63 8 ) S (8 8 2 , 14 5 1 S (9 7 8 45 3 ) S ( 1 , 01 8 89 8 ) S ( 1 , 03 1 87 9 ) S ( 1 13 3 , 26 8 ) En d i n g b a l a n (8 1 5 , 0 8 3 ) S (8 4 5 80 0 ) S (8 2 1 70 4 1 S (7 3 6 63 8 ) S (8 6 2 14 5 ) S (9 7 8 , 45 3 ) S ( 1 01 8 , 89 8 1 S ( 1 , 03 1 87 8 ) S ( 1 13 3 , 26 8 ) S ( 1 12 4 , 74 9 ) ID A H O G A S T A R I F F R I D E R Ac l u a l l D R e v Ac l u a l l D E x p Ad j u s l m e n l s . . ! 39 , 05 1 24 9 S 42 8 S 41 0 S 11 , 82 5 S (1 3 18 1 ) S (1 7 8 5" " ) S (1 8 4 96 3 ) S (1 8 4 , 98 3 ) S (1 7 1 1 , 12 4 ) S 34 , 52 2 S 2 8 11 0 S 1" , 20 8 S 1 1 76 1 S 7 44 1 S 8 06 7 S 7 . 12 1 S 9 87 2 S 1 9 5 40 0 92 7 S 3 8 "5 5 S 7 3 53 6 S ( 4 7 09 2 ) S 2 4 18 9 S 1 1 , 14 8 S 5 " 00 1 S 2 1 75 5 S 2 " 2 , 15 3 S ( 1 1 1 , 24 9 1 S S ( 1 1 1 . 24 9 ) 59 5 S ( 1 2 3 , 99 4 ) S ( 5 5 , 33 0 ) S 5 6 "5 3 S ( 1 8 , 74 " ) S (5 , 07 9 ) S ( 5 0 88 0 ) S ( 1 1 68 3 ) S ( 1 9 8 00 2 ) St a r l i n g b a l a n c e En d i n g b a l a n c e (1 7 8 12 4 ) S (1 8 9 , 52 9 ) S (1 6 9 , 52 9 ) S (2 9 3 52 3 ) S (2 9 3 52 3 ) S (3 4 8 85 3 ) S (3 4 8 85 3 ) S (2 9 0 , 00 0 ) S (2 9 0 00 0 ) S (3 0 8 , 74 8 ) S (3 0 8 , 74 " ) S (3 1 1 82 7 ) S (3 1 1 , "2 7 ) S (3 8 2 70 7 ) (3 8 2 70 7 ) (3 7 4 , 59 0 ) CO M B I N E D G A S T A R I F F R I D E R S Ac t u a l R e v 13 0 27 8 S 11 7 , 48 " S 11 9 11 5 S 58 9 28 2 S 38 , 80 2 S 23 , 43 8 S 29 4 86 8 S 15 2 Ac l u a l E x p 91 , 42 1 18 1 , 36 8 S 42 4 12 9 51 7 S 24 5 11 9 S 25 7 S 82 9 S 37 . 15 4 19 3 33 7 S 72 , 51 6 S Ad j u s l m e n l a Ba l a n c e r e d u c U o n 38 , 85 5 S (4 3 89 8 ) S 32 , 81 1 1 (3 8 92 8 1 S (1 8 0 , 63 7 1 S (5 7 45 5 1 S (5 7 19 3 1 S (1 7 , 88 0 ) S (1 5 2 . 48 9 ) S (3 , 38 4 ) S 71 3 28 2 18 3 74 0 (4 8 0 45 8 ) Sta l l i n g b a l a n c e En d i n g b a l a n c e (1 , 01 8 88 1 ) S (9 8 0 02 8 1 S (8 8 0 02 8 1 S ( 1 , 02 3 , 82 4 1 S ( 8 8 1 , 23 3 ) S ( 1 , 03 0 18 1 ) S ( 1 , 21 0 99 8 ) S ( 1 28 8 45 3 ) S ( 1 , 32 5 84 8 1 S ( 1 , 34 3 50 8 1 S ( 1 , 49 5 97 5 1 (1 . 02 3 92 4 1 S (8 8 1 , 2 3 3 ) S ( 1 03 0 18 1 ) S ( 1 21 0 , 99 8 ) S ( 1 , 2 8 8 , 45 3 ) S ( 1 32 5 84 8 ) S ( 1 , 34 3 50 6 ) S ( 1 , 49 5 , 97 5 ) S ( 1 49 9 33 9 ) CO M B I N E D G A S A N D E L E C T R I C T A R I F F R I D E R S Ac t u a l R e v S 7 8 9 , 97 7 S 7 1 5 47 0 S 7 2 1 49 0 S 6 5 8 41 8 S 5 9 5 51 8 S 5 7 3 11 7 S 5 8 2 , 84 0 S 6 2 8 , 51 8 S 6 3 9 , 89 4 S 83 0 21 3 S 8 , 53 3 25 8 Ac t u a l E x p S 5 3 0 , 37 8 S 4 2 8 89 5 S 4 5 7 , 19 8 S 4 0 1 13 8 S 5 0 8 , 32 9 S 2 8 0 12 4 S 7 8 2 , 71 0 S 2 0 5 , 98 3 S 8 1 2 , 88 9 S 2 9 4 , 57 1 S 4 48 2 , 01 5 Ba l a n c a r e d u c l i o n S 2 5 9 , 59 9 S 2 8 8 , 57 5 S 28 4 , 2 9 2 S 2 5 7 , 28 1 S 8 7 , 18 9 S 3 1 2 , 99 3 S ( 1 8 9 , 87 0 ) S 4 2 0 53 5 S 2 7 , 00 5 S 3 3 5 84 2 S 2 , 05 1 , 2 4 1 Sl8 r t l n g b a l a n c e En d i n g b a l a n c e (8 . 71 3 , 74 0 ) (8 , 45 4 14 1 ) S (8 , 45 4 , 14 1 ) S ( 8 16 7 58 8 ) S ( 7 , 90 3 27 4 ) S ( 7 , 84 5 , 99 3 ) S ( 7 , 55 " , 80 4 ) S ( 7 24 5 81 1 ) S ( 7 , 44 5 , 61 1 1 ) S ( 7 , 02 5 , 14 8 ) S ( 8 , 99 8 14 1 ) 16 7 58 8 ) S ( 7 , 90 3 , 27 4 ) S ( 7 , 84 5 99 3 ) S 55 8 80 4 ) S ( 7 , 24 5 , 81 1 1 S ( 7 44 5 . 88 1 ) S ( 7 , 02 5 14 8 ) S ( 8 99 8 , 14 1 ) S ( 6 , 66 2 , 49 9 ) NO T E S : Th e A p r l a d j u s l m e n l l e p l e a e n t s a j u r i s d l c t i o n a l l r a n s l e r r e s u l l i n g f r o m p e r i o d i c Ir u . u p s b e t w e e n p r o j e c t e d an d a c t u a l j u r i s d i c l l o n a l e " P e n s e a l l o c a l i o n s . -cble 15EG Calculation of Energy Savings vs. Utility Expenditure Proportionality Proportionality (kWh and therm Proportionality (mmbtu Adjusted Proportionality Calculation Unadjusted Proportionality Calculation Electric Gas Electric Gas 288,277 193,738 288,277 193,738 493,525) $106,548) 087 809 318.625 882.561 1,405,815 288,277 193,738 (335,306) $ 547 255 1,405 815 288 277 193,738 819,974 713 282 819.974 713,282 78%197%56%167% 29,134,058 755,550 29,134,058 755 550 33.333,333 200,000 33,333,333 200,000 87%378%87%378% 112%192%155%226% 136%179% Actual 1/1/03 to 10/31/03 cash expenditures Less cash incentives Add in derated incentives Adjusted (for incentives) utility expenditures Normalize NEEA expenditures Total adjusted utility expenditures DSM revenues 1/1/03 to 10/31/03 Adjusted utility expenditures divided by actual revenues Energy savings from Triple-E Report Tariff goal % of goal achieved NOTES: (1) Adjustments for the difference between cash incentives and those accrued as projects move through the "pipeline" (contracted to construction tocompleted) remove the effect of scheduling cash payment of incentives to future dates. (2) NEEA revenues have been adjusted to equal our annual maximum contractual obligation. Regional energy savings are not reflected in this calculation. 1; IC( Workpapers Associated with Calculation of Demand-Side Management Calculations 2004 Idaho GRC J on Powell 2/5/04 1/1 / 9 9 1 0 7 1 3 1 / 9 9 Ele c t r i c 81 1 / 9 9 10 1 1 1 3 0 1 9 9 E l e c t r i c 12 1 1 / 9 9 1 0 3 1 3 1 1 0 0 E l e c t r i c 41 1 / 0 0 10 71 3 1 1 0 0 El e c t r i c 81 1 1 0 0 10 1 2 / 3 1 / 0 0 E l e c t r i c 1/1 1 0 1 1 0 8 / 3 1 1 0 1 Ele c t r i c Re a u l a r I n c lim ~ e d t n c TO T A l Re a u l a r ' n c Li m H e d I n c TO T A l Re a u t a r I n c lIm H e d I n c TO T A l Re a u l a r I n c lim H e d I n c TO T A l Re a u l a r I n c llm H e d I n c TO T A l Re a u l a r t n c lI m H e d I n c TO T A l El e c t r i c A C 83 2 , 50 8 32 0 38 9 25 2 90 7 30 3 , 69 7 45 7 79 0 $ 4 78 1 48 7 $ 2 , 06 8 87 7 59 9 88 0 $ 2 , 86 6 75 7 $ 3 , 26 6 32 7 53 2 . 75 1 $ 3 79 9 07 8 $ 2 , 25 9 69 5 64 1 , 68 1 $ 2 90 1 37 8 $ 2 1 30 5 80 6 82 7 , 67 8 $ 2 2 13 3 48 4 NE B 85 0 78 , 85 0 77 5 46 1 77 5 48 1 $ 2 , 00 1 , 68 2 $ 2 , 00 1 68 2 33 1 , 85 9 33 1 , 85 9 18 2 , 77 2 18 2 77 2 Ga s A C (5 5 85 2 ) $ 18 5 38 5 ) $ 25 1 23 7 ) (8 5 9 42 4 ) $ (6 3 44 3 ) $ (9 2 2 , 88 7 ) (2 0 9 83 2 ) $ (1 3 8 41 3 ) $ (3 4 8 24 5 ) (2 8 8 01 8 ) $ (3 5 3 47 0 ) $ (8 4 1 48 6 ) 47 9 46 0 (5 6 3 44 8 ) $ (8 3 88 8 ) $ 2 9 89 9 88 0 (7 2 4 , 39 7 ) $ 2 8 97 5 28 3 TR C B E N E F I T 87 8 85 8 12 5 01 4 00 1 67 0 $ 3 , 52 1 . 12 3 39 4 34 7 $ 3 81 5 , 47 0 $ 3 , 83 2 , 50 6 48 3 48 7 09 5 , 97 3 97 8 , 87 3 17 9 , 2 8 1 15 9 , 2 5 4 $ 4 07 1 , 01 4 23 3 $ 4 14 9 , 2 4 7 $ 5 1 , 18 8 , 25 8 10 3 28 1 $ 5 1 , 2 9 1 53 9 Na n I n c U I c o a l 87 0 , 63 5 21 1 , 2 7 5 88 1 , 91 0 90 5 45 7 58 9 93 5 02 8 08 0 78 2 85 , 2 2 7 17 8 00 9 08 3 83 2 83 2 12 9 48 4 17 3 48 8 80 8 27 3 09 7 $ 2 , 2 4 9 87 8 25 0 , 07 8 49 9 85 4 CU R t c a s t 42 2 , 13 0 63 7 74 7 05 9 , 87 7 $ 2 , 27 3 , 33 9 29 1 37 7 56 4 , 71 8 $ 2 . 10 3 31 1 41 4 49 2 $ 2 , 51 7 , 80 3 $ 2 , 57 2 , 19 9 36 5 50 4 93 7 70 3 $ 3 , 27 8 03 7 83 7 74 7 $ 3 , 91 3 . 78 4 $ 3 5 , 13 1 83 7 98 9 , 47 5 $ 3 8 , 12 1 . 31 2 TR O C O S T 09 2 , 78 5 84 8 02 2 84 1 78 7 $ 3 17 8 79 8 32 0 94 8 $ 3 , 49 9 74 2 $ 3 , 18 4 , 09 3 50 9 71 9 $ 3 , 89 3 , 81 2 $ 3 , 85 8 , 03 1 41 1 , 13 8 $ 4 06 7 18 7 $ 4 44 9 , 52 5 73 7 , 35 8 18 8 , 88 1 $ 3 7 , 38 1 71 3 23 8 55 3 $ 3 8 , 82 1 . 2 8 8 NE T T R C (2 1 8 , 10 9 ) $ (7 2 4 , 00 8 ) $ (9 4 0 11 7 ) 34 2 , 32 7 40 1 41 5 72 8 44 8 41 3 (4 8 , 2 5 2 ) $ 40 2 , 18 1 32 3 94 2 (2 3 1 , 85 5 ) $ 09 2 , 08 7 (3 7 8 , 51 1 ) $ (8 5 9 , 12 3 ) $ ( 1 , 03 7 . 83 4 ) $ 1 3 80 8 54 5 $ ( 1 , 13 8 , 2 7 2 ) $ 1 2 , 87 0 , 27 3 TR C B f C 1.2 3 El e c t r i c A C 93 2 , 50 8 32 0 39 9 25 2 80 7 $ 4 , 30 3 69 7 45 7 . 78 0 76 1 48 7 $ 2 06 8 87 7 59 9 , 88 0 $ 2 , 88 8 75 7 $ 3 28 6 32 7 53 2 , 75 1 $ 3 . 79 9 07 8 $ 2 , 25 9 89 5 84 1 68 1 $ 2 , 90 1 37 8 $ 2 1 , 30 5 80 6 82 7 , 87 8 $ 2 2 , 13 3 , 48 4 Ga s A C (5 5 85 2 ) $ (1 . 19 5 38 5 ) $ (1 , 2 5 1 , 2 3 7 ) (8 5 9 , 42 4 ) $ (8 3 44 3 ) $ (9 2 2 , 88 7 ) (2 0 9 83 2 ) $ (1 3 8 41 3 ) $ (3 4 8 24 5 ) (2 8 8 01 6 ) $ (3 5 3 47 0 ) $ (8 4 1 48 6 ) 47 9 46 0 (5 6 3 44 8 ) $ (8 3 98 8 ) $ 2 9 69 9 88 0 (7 2 4 39 7 ) $ 2 8 97 5 , 28 3 UC T B E N E F I T 87 6 65 8 12 5 01 4 00 1 67 0 $ 3 , 44 4 , 27 3 39 4 34 7 $ 3 , 83 8 62 0 85 7 , 04 5 46 3 48 7 $ 2 32 0 51 2 $ 2 , 97 8 31 1 17 8 , 2 8 1 $ 3 , 15 7 58 2 $ 2 73 9 15 5 23 3 $ 2 , 81 7 38 8 $ 5 1 00 5 48 8 10 3 , 28 1 $ 5 1 , 10 8 78 7 Na n I n c U t C a s t 87 0 63 5 21 1 , 2 7 5 88 1 , 81 0 80 5 45 7 56 9 93 5 , 02 8 08 0 78 2 22 7 17 8 , 00 9 08 3 , 83 2 45 , 83 2 12 9 , 46 4 17 3 48 8 60 9 1,2 7 3 09 7 $ 2 , 24 9 87 8 25 0 07 8 49 9 , 95 4 In c a n t U t C o s t 57 8 81 8 63 7 74 7 21 6 66 5 59 5 29 3 29 1 37 7 88 8 87 0 50 6 20 9 41 4 49 2 92 0 70 1 82 4 05 7 38 5 50 4 18 9 58 1 74 5 97 9 83 7 74 7 38 3 72 8 $ 9 , 98 5 81 0 98 9 , 47 5 $ 1 0 , 95 5 28 5 UC T C O S T 24 9 55 3 84 9 02 2 09 8 57 5 50 0 75 0 32 0 94 8 82 1 , 69 8 58 8 99 1 50 9 71 9 $ 2 , 09 6 , 71 0 90 7 86 9 41 1 , 13 8 $ 2 , 31 9 , 02 5 91 9 46 7 73 7 35 6 $ 2 65 6 82 3 $ 1 2 , 2 1 5 68 6 1, 2 3 9 55 3 $ 1 3 45 5 , 23 9 NE T U C T 82 7 10 3 (7 2 4 00 8 ) $ 90 3 , 09 5 94 3 52 3 40 1 $ 2 01 8 , 92 4 27 0 05 4 (4 8 , 25 2 ) $ 22 3 , 80 2 07 0 42 2 (2 3 1 85 5 ) $ 83 8 58 7 81 9 88 8 (8 5 9 12 3 ) $ 16 0 , 56 5 $ 3 8 78 9 , 80 0 $ ( 1 , 13 8 , 2 7 2 ) $ 3 7 85 3 52 8 UC T 8 I C Bil l r e d u c t i o n E 94 8 50 7 91 1 53 4 88 0 , 04 1 $ 4 47 1 02 0 45 8 , 50 5 $ 4 82 7 52 5 $ 4 , 08 7 , 57 3 1, 2 7 8 03 8 34 3 80 8 87 8 , 95 7 85 8 , 2 6 9 $ 8 53 8 22 8 76 2 13 7 86 8 , 07 8 $ 3 , 43 0 , 2 1 3 $ 8 1 , 76 9 , 17 8 $ 1 2 . 72 1 , 2 6 3 $ 8 4 , 49 0 43 9 Bi l l r e d u c t i o n G NE B 85 0 85 0 77 5 48 1 77 5 48 1 00 1 86 2 00 1 , 68 2 33 1 . 85 9 33 1 85 9 18 2 77 2 18 2 77 2 PA R T B E N E F I T 84 8 50 7 81 1 53 4 86 0 , 04 1 $ 4 54 7 87 0 45 6 50 5 00 4 , 37 5 84 3 03 4 1, 2 7 8 03 8 $ 7 . 11 8 , 07 0 68 1 81 9 85 8 , 2 8 9 $ 8 , 53 9 88 8 $ 4 09 3 99 8 86 8 07 8 $ 4 , 78 2 , 07 2 $ 8 1 95 1 , 94 8 $ 1 2 , 72 1 28 3 $ 9 4 87 3 , 2 1 1 CU R t c o s t 42 2 13 0 83 7 74 7 05 9 87 7 $ 2 , 2 7 3 33 9 29 1 37 7 56 4 71 8 $ 2 10 3 31 1 41 4 49 2 $ 2 51 7 80 3 $ 2 , 57 2 19 9 3& 5 , 50 4 $ 2 , 83 7 70 3 $ 3 , 2 7 8 , 03 7 83 7 , 74 7 $ 3 91 3 78 4 $ 3 5 13 1 , 83 7 98 9 47 5 $ 3 8 12 1 31 2 tn c r e c e i v e d (5 7 8 91 8 ) $ (8 3 7 74 7 ) $ (1 , 2 1 8 86 5 ) (5 9 5 29 3 ) $ (2 9 1 , 37 7 ) $ (8 8 8 67 0 ) (5 0 6 20 9 ) $ (4 1 4 , 48 2 ) $ (9 2 0 70 1 ) (8 2 4 05 7 ) $ (3 8 5 50 4 ) $ ( 1 18 9 56 1 ) (7 4 5 , 97 9 ) $ (6 3 7 74 7 ) $ ( 1 , 38 3 72 6 ) $ ( 9 96 5 81 0 ) $ (9 6 9 , 47 5 ) $ ( 1 0 95 5 , 28 5 ) PA R T C O S T 84 3 21 2 84 3 21 2 67 8 , 04 8 $ 67 8 04 8 59 7 , 10 2 59 7 10 2 74 8 , 14 2 74 8 14 2 $ 2 , 53 0 , 05 8 $ 2 53 0 05 8 $ 2 5 18 8 , 02 7 $ 2 5 16 8 , 02 7 NE T P A R T (8 9 4 , 70 5 ) $ 91 1 53 4 82 9 $ 2 , 86 9 82 4 45 8 , 50 5 $ 3 32 8 32 9 $ 4 , 24 5 83 2 27 8 03 8 $ 5 , 52 1 , 98 8 93 3 47 7 85 8 26 9 $ 8 , 79 1 , 74 8 56 3 83 8 18 8 07 8 $ 2 , 2 3 2 . 01 4 $ 5 8 78 5 92 1 $ 1 2 . 72 1 , 2 8 3 $ 6 9 50 7 18 4 PA R T 8 1 0 II D I V I O I ' 1 . II D I V l O ! II D I V I O I II D I V I O I liD / V I O l II D I V I O I Ele c t r i c A C 93 2 , 50 8 32 0 39 9 25 2 , 90 7 $ 3 44 4 , 2 7 3 39 4 34 7 $ 3 , 83 8 , 62 0 $ 2 , 06 8 87 7 59 9 88 0 $ 2 , 86 8 75 7 $ 3 28 6 32 7 53 2 75 1 S 3 79 9 07 8 $ 2 , 73 9 15 5 78 , 2 3 4 S 2 , 81 7 38 9 $ 2 1 30 5 80 8 82 7 87 8 S 2 2 , 13 3 48 4 RIM B E N E F I T 93 2 50 8 32 0 , 39 9 25 2 80 7 44 4 27 3 39 4 34 7 83 8 , 62 0 S 2 , 06 8 , 87 7 59 9 88 0 S 2 , 68 6 75 7 S 3 , 28 8 , 32 7 53 2 , 75 1 S 3 , 79 9 07 8 S 2 , 73 9 15 5 78 , 23 4 S 2 81 7 38 9 S 2 1 , 30 5 , 80 8 82 7 87 8 S 2 2 . 13 3 48 4 EI r e v l o s s 94 7 99 8 40 3 , 88 1 35 1 87 9 S 8 , 27 4 49 1 81 9 , 88 7 $ 8 89 4 37 8 S 4 53 7 68 1 53 5 , 98 1 S 8 , 07 3 84 2 12 5 82 2 33 5 17 1 48 1 , 09 3 $ 2 , 78 2 13 7 88 8 , 07 8 S 3 , 43 0 21 3 S 4 4 87 8 18 4 $ 1 3 79 8 48 5 S 5 8 , 87 2 , 82 9 No n . 1n c u t c o s t 67 0 83 5 21 1 , 2 7 5 88 1 , 91 0 90 5 , 45 7 56 9 93 5 02 8 08 0 78 2 22 7 17 8 00 9 08 3 83 2 83 2 12 9 , 46 4 17 3 48 8 80 8 1,2 7 3 09 7 S 2 , 24 9 , 87 8 25 0 , 07 8 $ 2 , 49 9 85 4 In c c a R l 57 8 , 91 8 83 7 74 7 21 6 66 5 59 5 , 2 9 3 29 1 37 7 88 8 87 0 50 6 20 9 41 4 49 2 92 0 70 1 82 4 05 7 3& 5 50 4 18 9 58 1 74 5 97 9 83 7 74 7 38 3 72 8 98 5 , 81 0 96 9 47 5 $ 1 0 , 95 5 , 28 5 RI M C O S T 19 7 55 1 2, 2 5 2 , 90 3 45 0 , 45 4 $ 7 , 77 5 , 2 4 1 94 0 , 83 3 71 6 , 07 4 $ 8 12 4 87 2 $ 2 , 04 5 88 0 17 0 35 2 03 3 , 81 1 74 8 30 7 76 0 11 8 88 1 , 60 4 40 5 , 43 2 $ 8 , 08 7 , 03 8 $ 5 7 . 09 1 85 0 $ 1 5 , 03 6 01 8 $ 7 2 , 12 7 86 8 NE T R I M 35 3 59 0 88 2 85 2 03 8 24 2 S 2 , 84 8 98 0 10 2 , 97 0 $ 2 , 95 1 , 95 0 58 0 . 86 8 18 5 38 8 74 8 05 6 $ 2 , 44 2 , 27 0 18 7 24 7 80 8 51 7 99 3 17 8 (5 5 9 51 3 ) $ 43 3 86 3 $ 1 1 33 9 , 98 8 (1 8 1 , 79 7 ) $ 1 1 , 17 8 19 9 RI M B f O kW h s 15 , 2 0 0 39 8 83 3 66 5 83 4 06 1 04 9 40 0 15 2 , 38 4 14 , 2 0 1 76 4 38 3 23 7 95 7 , 03 4 12 , 32 0 27 1 15 , 21 4 , 18 1 73 8 03 5 95 2 19 8 10 , 56 2 32 0 72 7 , 81 9 28 9 93 9 11 8 85 8 39 3 48 4 64 8 12 0 14 1 , 04 1 Th e r m s (1 8 , 2 2 6 ) (2 4 0 27 8 ) (2 5 8 50 2 ) (2 2 9 94 5 ) (1 8 77 9 ) (2 4 8 , 72 4 ) (8 3 10 2 ) (5 3 , 41 9 ) (1 3 8 , 52 1 ) (9 1 , 89 4 ) (7 4 12 7 ) (1 & 5 , 82 1 ) 53 , 60 0 (1 1 4 , 22 3 ) (8 0 62 3 ) 90 7 . 51 0 (1 4 5 , 29 1 ) 76 2 , 21 9 9/ 1 1 0 1 10 12 / 3 1 1 0 1 Ele c t r i c T a b l a 1 3 E 11 1 1 0 2 1 0 1 2 / 3 1 1 0 2 e l e c t r i c T a b l a 13 E 1/1 1 0 3 1 0 1 0 / 3 1 1 0 3 e l e c t r i c R8 d u l a r I n c tin n e d I n c TO T A L Ra o u l a r I n c Li m n e d l n o TO T A L Ra a u l a r l a c Lim n e d I n c TO T A L R8 d u l a r I n c Li m n e d l a c TO T A L Ele c l r i c A C 69 7 , 02 8 37 8 09 5 07 5 12 3 70 1 , 2 8 9 79 1 , 72 4 S 1 0 49 2 , 99 3 52 0 58 8 81 1 , 88 5 $ 1 0 33 2 47 3 60 , 05 3 79 5 38 1 , 88 3 S 8 6 41 5 87 8 NE B 03 3 94 3 03 3 94 3 89 1 , 58 2 89 1 , 56 2 28 7 , 00 6 1, 2 8 7 , 00 6 38 1 11 5 38 1 11 5 Ga s A C (1 7 0 17 7 ) $ (2 7 4 55 7 ) (4 4 4 , 73 4 ) $ ( 1 49 8 39 1 ) S (3 9 0 01 8 ) S ( 1 88 8 , 40 9 ) (1 8 3 , 31 3 ) $ (1 8 3 , 31 3 ) 93 4 13 5 (3 , 70 1 13 1 ) S 2 3 23 3 , 00 4 TR C B E N E F I T 56 0 7s . t 10 3 , 53 8 68 4 , 33 2 89 4 44 0 40 1 , 70 6 S 1 0 , 2 8 6 14 8 S 1 0 84 4 28 1 81 1 88 5 S 1 1 45 6 18 6 36 9 04 5 68 0 75 2 S 9 9 02 9 , 79 7 No n l a c U t c o s t 86 1 , 83 2 (2 7 00 9 ) S 83 4 82 3 04 7 07 7 13 8 12 3 , 21 5 74 3 79 7 48 , 98 2 79 2 77 9 61 6 , 77 6 82 9 50 1 S 1 0 44 6 27 7 Ou s t c o s t 25 1 , 2 8 6 70 0 26 9 95 1 , 55 5 37 7 02 9 42 5 58 2 80 2 61 1 14 4 , 79 0 56 1 , 53 1 70 6 32 1 55 1 95 8 02 3 , 72 4 S 7 8 57 5 , 68 2 TR C C O S T 91 3 11 8 67 3 , 26 0 56 6 37 8 42 4 10 6 50 1 . 72 0 92 5 82 6 88 8 , 58 7 61 0 51 3 49 9 10 0 16 8 , 73 4 85 3 , 2 2 5 $ 8 7 , 02 1 , 85 8 NE T T R C $ ( 2 , 35 2 32 4 ) $ (5 8 9 , 72 2 ) $ 82 2 , 04 6 ) 47 0 , 33 4 (1 0 0 01 4 ) $ 37 0 32 0 . 75 5 69 4 20 1 37 2 95 7 06 6 15 , 20 0 31 1 18 2 47 3 ) $ 1 2 , 00 7 , 83 8 TR C B l C 1.2 1 Ele c t r i c A C 69 7 02 8 37 8 , 09 5 07 5 . 12 3 70 1 , 2 6 9 79 1 . 72 4 S 1 0 49 2 , 89 3 52 0 58 8 81 1 , 88 5 $ 1 0 33 2 , 47 3 05 3 , 79 5 38 1 , 88 3 $ 6 8 41 5 67 8 Ga s A C (1 7 0 17 7 ) $ (2 7 4 55 7 ) (4 4 4 , 73 4 ) $ ( 1 49 8 39 1 ) $ (3 8 0 01 8 ) $ ( 1 , 88 8 , 40 9 ) (1 8 3 , 31 3 ) $ (1 8 3 , 31 3 ) 83 4 , 13 5 70 1 13 1 ) $ 2 3 , 23 3 00 4 . UC T B E N E F I T 52 6 85 1 10 3 , 53 8 83 0 38 9 20 2 , 87 8 40 1 . 70 6 60 4 58 4 35 7 , 27 5 81 1 88 5 $ 1 0 18 9 , 16 0 86 , 96 7 , 83 0 66 0 75 2 $ 8 8 64 8 , 68 2 No n I n c U t e a s t 68 1 . 83 2 (2 7 , 00 9 ) $ 83 4 , 82 3 04 7 07 7 13 8 12 3 21 5 74 3 78 7 98 2 78 2 , 77 9 61 6 77 6 82 8 50 1 $ 1 0 , 44 6 27 7 In c a n t U t C o s t 11 0 , 34 4 70 0 , 26 9 81 0 61 3 07 6 73 4 53 9 , 50 1 61 6 23 5 52 8 27 8 58 1 , 53 1 08 7 , 80 9 92 9 82 2 13 7 64 3 $ 2 4 , 06 7 , 2 6 5 UC T C O S T 77 2 , 17 6 67 3 , 2 6 0 44 5 , 43 8 12 3 81 1 81 5 83 8 73 9 . 45 0 3, 2 7 0 , 07 5 61 0 51 3 88 0 , 58 8 54 6 39 8 96 7 14 4 $ 3 4 . 51 3 54 2 NE T U C T 75 4 , 87 5 (5 8 9 , 72 2 ) $ 18 4 , 95 3 07 9 06 7 (2 1 3 83 3 ) $ 88 5 , 13 4 08 7 , 20 0 20 1 . 37 2 6,2 8 8 , 57 2 58 , 44 1 , 53 2 30 6 39 2 ) $ 5 5 , 13 5 14 0 UC T B l C BR I r e d u c t i o n E 16 0 83 4 85 9 , 12 2 $ 1 0 , 01 8 , 95 6 S 1 4 , 18 4 01 6 1,3 3 8 81 3 $ 1 5 50 0 , 82 9 $ 1 2 , 34 1 , 11 9 1, 2 0 5 05 4 $ 1 3 54 6 , 17 3 $ 1 3 5 38 4 33 9 20 , 2 9 2 47 2 $1 5 5 85 8 , 81 1 Bil l r e d u c t i o n G 41 0 29 5 (4 2 0 32 8 ) (1 0 03 3 ) S ( 1 71 3 17 5 ) $ (4 9 5 53 8 ) $ ( 2 , 2 0 8 , 71 3 ) (2 2 3 03 8 ) (2 2 3 03 6 ) 52 5 91 6 ) (9 1 5 , 86 8 ) $ ( 2 44 1 , 78 2 ) NE B 03 3 94 3 03 3 94 3 69 1 56 2 69 1 58 2 28 7 00 6 1,2 8 7 00 6 38 1 , 11 5 38 1 11 5 PA R T B E N E F I T $ 1 0 , 80 5 07 2 43 8 78 4 $ 1 1 . 04 3 , 86 8 S 1 4 14 2 , 40 3 84 1 07 5 $ 1 4 98 3 47 8 $ 1 3 . 40 5 08 9 1.2 0 5 05 4 $ 1 4 , 61 0 14 3 $ 1 4 3 , 21 8 53 8 18 , 37 6 , 60 6 $1 8 2 , 59 6 14 4 Ou s t c o s t 25 1 , 2 8 6 70 0 , 2 6 9 85 1 55 5 37 7 , 02 9 42 5 58 2 60 2 , 61 1 14 4 79 0 58 1 , 53 1 70 6 , 32 1 55 1 95 6 02 3 72 4 $ 7 6 57 5 61 2 In c r e c a i v e d S ( 2 . 11 0 34 4 ) $ (7 0 0 , 2 8 9 ) $ ( 2 81 0 , 61 3 ) $ ( 1 07 6 73 4 ) $ (5 3 9 50 1 ) $ ( 1 61 6 23 5 ) S ( 2 , 52 6 , 2 7 8 ) $ (5 6 1 53 1 ) $ ( 3 08 7 , 60 9 ) (1 8 , 92 9 82 2 ) $ 13 7 64 3 ) $( 2 4 , 06 7 26 5 ) PA R T C O S T 14 0 84 2 14 0 , s.t 2 30 0 , 2 9 5 (1 1 3 91 8 ) 18 6 37 6 61 8 , 51 2 61 8 , 51 2 52 , 82 2 , 33 6 (1 1 3 , 81 8 ) $ 5 2 , 50 8 41 7 NE T P A R T 48 4 13 0 43 8 78 4 8~ , 82 4 84 2 10 8 85 4 89 4 79 7 10 2 78 8 , 57 7 20 5 05 4 89 1 , 63 1 59 7 , 2 0 2 49 0 52 5 $1 1 0 08 7 72 7 PA R T B l C flD l V l O ! fl D I V / O ! -1 7 0 . Ele c t r i c A C 68 7 02 8 37 8 09 5 07 5 12 3 70 1 28 9 79 1 , 72 4 $ 1 0 49 2 99 3 52 0 58 8 81 1 , 88 5 $ 1 0 , 33 2 47 3 05 3 79 5 38 1 , 88 3 S 8 8 , 41 5 , 87 8 RI M B E N E F I T 89 7 . 02 8 37 8 , 09 5 07 5 , 12 3 70 1 , 2 6 9 79 1 72 4 $ 1 0 , 49 2 , 99 3 52 0 , 58 8 81 1 88 5 $ 1 0 , 33 2 , 47 3 80 , 05 3 , 79 5 38 1 , 88 3 S 6 8 , 41 5 87 8 EI r e v 1 0 . . 16 0 83 4 85 9 12 2 $ 1 0 . 01 8 95 6 $ 1 4 18 4 01 8 33 8 81 3 $ 1 5 50 0 62 9 $ 1 2 , 34 1 11 9 1,2 0 5 , 05 4 S 1 3 54 8 17 3 $ 1 0 1 19 0 38 2 22 , 76 0 , 2 3 0 $1 2 3 95 0 59 2 No n - in c u t c a s t 68 1 , 83 2 (2 7 , 00 9 ) $ 83 4 , 82 3 04 7 , 07 7 13 8 12 3 , 21 5 74 3 , 79 7 96 2 79 2 , 77 9 81 8 77 8 62 9 50 1 $ 1 0 44 8 27 7 In c c o s t 11 0 34 4 70 0 , 2 8 9 81 0 81 3 07 8 73 4 53 9 50 1 81 8 23 5 52 8 27 8 58 1 , 53 1 08 7 80 9 11 1 92 9 , 82 2 13 7 , 84 3 $ 2 4 06 7 28 5 RI M C O S T $ 1 1 , 93 3 01 0 53 2 36 2 $ 1 3 48 5 39 2 $ 1 8 28 7 82 7 95 2 , 2 5 2 $ 1 1 1 24 0 07 9 $ 1 5 81 1 19 4 11 1 5 , 56 7 $ 1 7 42 8 , 78 1 $ 1 2 9 , 73 8 , 78 0 21 1 72 7 37 4 $1 5 8 , 48 4 , 13 4 NE T R I M 58 6 11 8 4 (3 2 2 , 17 4 ) $ 2, 2 8 4 51 0 82 4 53 5 25 2 , 2 2 3 11 7 8 75 8 99 4 31 0 25 0 35 4 24 4 , 86 4 41 , 12 4 , 17 3 22 4 24 0 S 4 2 , 34 8 41 3 RI M B l C kW h . 22 , 42 5 48 9 84 8 68 4 07 2 , 15 3 32 , 51 7 11 5 3 36 4 52 8 11 8 2 , 38 1 33 3 99 8 80 0 06 0 13 4 , 05 8 28 3 32 3 22 7 50 4 , 83 7 28 5 82 7 88 4 Th e r m s (8 3 74 1 ) (6 0 76 3 ) (1 2 4 50 4 ) (3 1 2 , 70 8 ) (8 4 53 8 ) (3 9 7 , 2 4 4 ) (3 8 97 8 ) (3 8 87 8 ) 12 2 71 8 (7 9 1 41 4 ) 33 1 , 30 2 Me a s u r a l i f e !I ~ I ! I I ~ ~ t ~ l i : 15 . Dis c o u n t r a t e La v e l i z e d T R C c o s t $0 . 03 1 1 $0 . 03 1 $0 . 03 8 Le v e l i z e d U C T c o s l $0 . 01 3 $0 . 03 1 m ~ m m m n i J q : g f 4 : n 95 - 9 6 G a s 11 1 1 0 1 1 0 8 1 3 1 1 0 1 Ta b l e 1 3 G 9'1 1 0 1 1 0 12 / 3 1 1 0 1 Ta b l e 1 3 G 1/1 / 0 2 1 0 12 / 3 1 1 0 2 Ta b l e 1 3 G 1/1 / 0 3 1 0 1 0 1 3 1 / 0 3 T a b l e 1 3 G Re o u l a r I n e li m i t e d l o a TO T A l Re g u l a r I n e LI m i t e d I n e TO T A L Ra o u l a r I n e lim i t e d I n e TO T A l Re g u l a r I n e lim i t e d I n e TO T A l RA n u l a r l o a li m i t e d I n c TO T A l Re o u l a r I n e lim i t e d I n e TO T A l Ele c t r i c A C 92 0 92 0 30 6 30 6 28 7 28 9 28 7 28 9 (9 ) S (9 ) 34 9 50 6 34 9 50 6 NE B 30 , 26 5 28 5 43 2 80 , 43 2 04 2 80 9 04 2 80 9 57 3 85 4 57 3 , 85 4 72 7 36 0 72 7 36 0 Ga s A C 17 9 71 5 85 , 62 5 1,2 6 5 34 0 48 8 28 5 48 8 , 28 5 85 1 , 08 3 47 , 42 5 89 8 , 50 8 54 5 , 40 0 24 1 , 85 8 78 7 , 25 6 83 6 , 14 8 17 5 83 7 81 1 78 3 S 1 3 70 0 , 62 9 55 0 , 54 3 $ 1 4 25 1 17 2 TR C B E N E F I T 17 9 , 71 5 62 5 26 5 34 0 56 7 , 47 0 56 7 , 47 0 94 4 82 1 42 5 99 2 , 24 6 87 5 , 49 8 24 1 85 6 11 7 35 4 20 9 99 1 17 5 83 7 38 5 , 62 8 $ 1 5 77 7 , 49 5 55 0 . 54 3 $ 1 8 32 8 03 8 No n I n e U I c o a l 14 1 77 8 11 , 79 3 15 3 , 57 1 08 7 81 . 08 7 39 2 11 2 16 , 50 4 58 7 44 9 79 , 03 8 84 , 38 9 80 2 19 1 37 8 , 2 3 3 15 6 39 7 38 9 Cu s l e o s l 70 8 46 5 77 , 89 6 78 6 36 1 40 1 67 8 40 1 67 8 76 2 , 57 2 92 2 83 4 , 49 4 03 7 35 9 30 8 59 9 34 5 , 95 6 07 8 40 3 13 6 71 9 21 5 12 2 S 1 2 , 00 8 , 47 7 57 5 13 6 S 1 2 , 58 3 61 3 TR C C O S T 85 0 , 24 3 89 , 68 9 93 9 , 93 2 46 2 , 76 5 46 2 78 5 79 8 , 98 4 52 , 03 4 85 0 99 8 11 1 , 94 6 31 3 04 8 42 4 99 4 16 2 , 79 2 13 9 . 52 1 30 2 , 31 3 $ 1 2 , 38 8 71 0 59 4 , 29 2 $ 1 2 , 98 1 , 00 2 NE T T R C 32 9 47 2 06 4 ) S 32 5 40 8 10 4 70 5 10 4 70 5 14 5 , 85 7 60 9 ) $ 14 1 , 2 4 8 78 3 55 2 (7 1 , 19 2 ) S 69 2 , 36 0 04 7 19 9 11 8 08 3 , 31 5 39 0 , 78 5 (4 3 74 9 ) $ 34 7 , 03 6 TR C B f C /lD I V I O I 1.6 2 1.1 9 1.1 6 12 5 12 7 Ele c t r i c A C 92 0 48 , 92 0 30 6 30 6 28 7 , 28 9 28 7 28 9 (9 ) S (9 ) 34 9 50 6 34 9 , 50 6 Ga s A C 17 9 71 5 85 , 62 5 1, 2 6 5 , 34 0 48 8 , 28 5 48 8 , 28 5 85 1 08 3 42 5 89 8 50 8 54 5 40 0 24 1 , 85 6 78 7 , 2 5 6 83 8 14 6 17 5 , 83 7 81 1 , 78 3 S 1 3 , 70 0 , 62 9 55 0 , 54 3 S 1 4 25 1 . 17 2 UC T B E N E F I T 17 9 71 5 85 , 62 5 1, 2 6 5 , 34 0 53 7 20 5 53 7 , 2 0 5 88 4 38 9 42 5 91 1 , 81 4 83 2 , 66 9 24 1 , 85 6 07 4 54 5 83 6 13 7 17 5 83 7 81 1 , 77 4 $ 1 4 05 0 , 13 5 55 0 54 3 $ 1 4 60 0 87 8 No n I n e U I C o s l 14 1 77 8 11 , 79 3 15 3 57 1 08 7 61 , 08 7 39 2 11 2 50 4 58 7 44 9 03 6 84 . 38 9 80 2 19 1 37 8 23 3 19 , 15 6 39 7 38 9 In c e n l U I C o s l 48 1 77 0 75 6 56 2 52 6 59 2 , 69 5 59 2 , 69 5 96 1 , 42 1 92 2 01 3 34 3 20 6 68 2 30 8 , 59 9 51 5 28 1 18 1 90 6 13 8 71 9 31 8 , 62 5 42 4 , 47 4 57 7 , 99 8 00 2 , 47 2 UC T C O S T 62 3 54 8 92 , 55 1 71 6 09 9 65 3 , 78 2 65 3 78 2 97 7 , 81 3 52 , 03 4 02 9 , 84 7 28 1 , 26 9 31 3 04 8 59 4 31 7 26 6 29 5 13 9 . 52 1 40 5 81 8 80 2 . 70 7 59 7 , 15 4 39 9 86 1 NE T U C T 55 6 18 7 92 6 ) S 54 9 24 1 88 3 42 3 88 3 , 42 3 88 6 , 57 6 60 9 ) $ 88 1 98 7 55 1 42 0 (7 1 , 19 2 ) $ 46 0 22 8 36 9 84 2 36 , 11 6 40 5 95 8 9, 2 4 7 , 42 8 (4 6 61 1 ) $ 20 0 , 81 7 UC T B f C /lD I V / O ! 12 6 Bi l l r e d u c t i o n E 09 3 29 , 09 3 30 6 , 78 8 30 6 78 8 (1 5 ) S (1 5 ) 33 5 86 8 33 5 86 8 Bil l r e d u c t i o n G 92 9 , 47 8 17 2 , 72 0 10 2 , 19 8 05 1 38 0 05 1 , 38 0 21 4 06 2 11 7 27 8 , 17 9 79 5 , 26 7 26 5 79 2 06 1 05 9 11 0 , 53 7 20 0 93 1 31 1 . 46 8 $ 1 5 10 0 72 4 70 3 56 0 S 1 5 , 80 4 , 2 8 4 NE B 26 5 30 , 2 6 5 43 2 43 2 04 2 , 80 9 04 2 80 9 57 3 , 85 4 57 3 85 4 72 7 36 0 72 7 36 0 PA R T B E N E F I T 92 9 , 47 8 17 2 , 72 0 10 2 , 19 8 08 1 84 5 08 1 , 84 5 32 3 58 7 11 7 38 7 70 4 14 4 88 4 26 5 79 2 41 0 , 65 6 68 4 37 6 20 0 93 1 88 5 30 7 $ 1 7 , 18 3 , 95 0 70 3 , 56 0 $ 1 7 . 86 7 51 0 Cu s l e o s l 70 8 46 5 89 6 78 8 36 1 40 1 , 67 8 40 1 67 8 76 2 57 2 51 , 92 2 83 4 49 4 03 7 35 9 30 8 59 9 34 5 , 95 8 07 8 , 40 3 13 8 71 9 21 5 12 2 S 1 2 , 00 8 47 7 57 5 , 13 6 S 1 2 , 58 3 , 61 3 In c r e c e i v e d (4 8 1 . 77 0 ) S (8 0 75 8 ) S (5 6 2 , 52 8 ) (5 9 2 69 5 ) S (5 9 2 , 69 5 ) (9 6 1 42 1 ) $ (5 1 92 2 ) S ( 1 01 3 34 3 ) S ( 1 20 6 68 2 ) S (3 0 8 59 9 ) $ ( 1 , 51 5 , 28 1 ) S ( 1 , 18 1 , 90 6 ) S (1 3 6 71 9 ) $ ( 1 31 8 , 62 5 ) S ( 4 42 4 47 4 ) S (5 7 7 , 99 8 ) $ ( 5 , 00 2 , 47 2 ) PA R T C O S T 22 8 89 5 88 2 ) S 22 3 , 83 3 80 8 , 98 3 80 8 , 98 3 82 1 , 15 1 82 1 15 1 83 0 87 7 83 0 87 7 89 6 49 7 89 8 , 49 7 58 4 00 3 (2 , 86 2 ) 58 1 14 1 NE T P A R T 70 2 , 78 3 17 5 58 2 87 8 , 36 5 27 2 , 66 2 1, 2 7 2 , 66 2 50 2 , 43 6 11 7 56 6 55 3 31 4 18 7 26 5 79 2 57 9 97 9 78 7 87 9 20 0 93 1 96 8 , 81 0 57 9 94 7 70 6 , 42 2 $ 1 0 , 2 6 8 36 9 PA R T B f C 60 . /lD I V l O I /lD I V l O I /l D I V l O I /lD I V l O I -2 4 5 . Ga s A C 17 9 71 5 85 , 62 5 1,2 6 5 34 0 48 8 26 5 48 8 28 5 85 1 , 08 3 42 5 89 8 50 8 54 5 , 40 0 24 1 85 6 78 7 , 2 5 6 83 6 14 6 17 5 83 7 81 1 . 78 3 S 1 3 70 0 62 9 55 0 , 54 3 S 1 4 , 2 5 1 17 2 RI M B E N E F I T 17 9 71 5 62 5 26 5 34 0 48 8 , 26 5 46 8 , 2 6 5 85 1 08 3 47 , 42 5 89 8 50 8 54 5 40 0 24 1 85 6 78 7 , 2 5 6 83 6 14 6 17 5 83 7 81 1 , 78 3 $ 1 3 70 0 62 9 55 0 , 54 3 $ 1 4 , 2 5 1 17 2 Ga s r e v l o s s 92 9 47 8 17 2 , 72 0 10 2 19 8 88 8 91 5 88 8 91 5 2,2 1 4 06 2 11 7 2,2 7 8 17 9 79 5 26 7 26 5 79 2 06 1 05 9 11 0 , 53 7 20 0 93 1 31 1 46 8 S 1 4 93 8 25 9 70 3 58 0 S 1 5 84 1 81 9 No n - in c u l e o s l 14 1 77 8 11 , 79 3 15 3 57 1 08 7 61 , 08 7 39 2 11 2 50 4 56 7 44 9 03 6 84 , 38 9 80 2 87 , 19 1 37 8 23 3 19 , 15 6 39 7 38 9 In e e o s l 48 1 , 77 0 75 8 56 2 , 52 8 59 2 69 5 59 2 69 5 96 1 , 42 1 92 2 01 3 34 3 1 , 2 0 6 68 2 30 8 , 59 9 51 5 , 28 1 18 1 , 90 6 13 6 71 9 31 8 , 62 5 42 4 , 47 4 57 7 , 99 8 00 2 , 47 2 RIM C O S T 55 3 02 6 26 5 27 1 81 8 , 2 9 7 54 2 69 7 54 2 89 7 19 1 87 5 11 8 15 1 30 8 02 6 07 6 53 6 57 8 84 0 65 5 37 6 37 6 83 2 34 0 , 45 2 71 7 , 2 8 4 $ 1 9 . 74 0 , 96 8 30 0 71 4 $ 2 1 . 04 1 , 66 0 NE T R I M 89 7 94 5 68 7 70 2 81 2 89 5 59 0 89 5 59 0 68 9 68 2 49 7 ) $ 68 5 , 16 5 33 8 71 8 (6 8 74 3 ) $ 27 1 97 5 45 4 24 0 91 8 49 3 , 15 8 9, 2 7 6 , 15 5 (2 7 45 5 ) $ 24 8 , 70 0 RIM B f C /l D l V f O l kW h s 75 0 75 0 53 2 53 2 73 3 66 7 73 3 , 86 7 (1 8 ) (1 8 ) 81 8 93 1 81 8 93 1 Th e r m s 33 4 60 1 45 6 36 1 . 2 5 7 25 4 , 92 0 25 4 , 92 0 46 8 89 8 18 9 47 8 06 5 81 7 , 16 6 81 7 85 3 98 3 73 1 , 2 7 2 24 , 2 7 8 75 5 55 0 40 7 05 5 72 0 50 1 77 5 Me a s u r e l i t e l:i ~ ~ ! ~t~ l l : f ~ ~ r f ~ ; ' 15 . Dis c o u n l r e l e le v e l i z e d T R C e o s l $0 . 41 8 $0 . 34 6 le v e l i z e d U C T c o s l $0 . 13 3 $0 . 42 0 w : m ~ ! U ! n $ g : ~ t SU M M A R Y O F E L E C T R I C A N D G A S P R O G R A M S kW h s Th e r m s Ele c t r i c p r o g r a m s Ga s p r o g r a m s Re g u l a r Re g u l a r i n c o m e li m i t e d i n c o m e To t a l in c o m e l i m i t e d i n c o m e 26 3 , 32 3 22 7 22 , 50 4 63 7 28 5 , 82 7 , 86 4 81 8 , 93 1 12 2 , 71 6 (7 9 1 41 4 ) 33 1 30 2 40 7 , 05 5 94 , 72 0 28 5 , 82 7 86 4 k W h s fr o m e l e c t r i c p r o g r a m s o n l y :i m : m ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ; 7 : ~ ~ m kW h s f r o m E & G p r o g r a m s 1/ 1 / 9 9 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 1/ 1 / 9 9 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 32 . 72 a m W To t a l 81 8 93 1 50 1 77 5 El e c t r i c a n d g a s p r o g r a m s Re g u l a r in c o m e l i m i t e d i n c o m e 26 4 14 2 15 8 2 2 50 4 63 7 52 9 . 77 1 ( 6 9 6 , 69 4 ) To t a l 28 6 64 6 79 5 83 3 , 07 7 50 1 77 5 t h e r m s fr o m g a s p r o g r a m s o n l y mm m : m m : ~ ; i j ~ ~ i Q Z l r ~ i i r th e n T 1 s f r o m e l e c t r i c an d g a s p r o g r a m s 3/ 1 5 / 9 5 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 3/ 1 5 / 9 5 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 g a s p r o g r a m s a n d 1 / 1 / 9 9 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 e l e c t r i c p r o g r a m s Gas Avoided Cost Calculations Gas Avoided Costs Modified Gas Avoided Costs Year Annual Winter Annual Winter 1 01/02 553 675 2002 501 581 2 02/03 505 593 2003 477 539 3 03104 0.496 568 2004 441 500 04105 457 510 2005 436 502 5 05/06 0.425 0.490 2006 457 526 6 06/07 446 513 2007 480 551 7 07/08 468 538 2008 503 577 8 08/09 491 563 2009 527 604 9 09/10 514 590 2010 553 633 10 10/11 540 618 2011 580 663 11 11/12 566 647 2012 609 695 12 12/13 594 678 2013 638 728 13 13114 623 711 2014 669 763 14 14115 653 745 2015 702 800 15 15/16 685 781 2016 737 838 16 16/17 719 818 2017 773 878 17 17/18 754 857 2018 811 921 18 18/19 791 899 2019 851 965 19 19/20 830 942 2020 893 011 20 20/21 871 987 2021 937 060 21 21/22 914 035 2022 983 112 22 W23 959 085 2023 032 166 23 23124 007 138 2024 083 222 24 24/25 056 193 2025 136 282 25 25/26 109 251 2026 192 344 26 26/27 163 312 2027 252 409 27 27/28 221 375 2028 314 478 28 28/29 282 442 2029 378 550 29 29/30 345 513 2030 447 625 30 30/31 1.412 587 2031 518 704 . .. 31 31/32 482 1. 684 2032.594 787 32 32/33 555 745 2033 673 874 33 32/34 632 830 2034 756 966 34 32/35 713 919 35 32/36 798 012 09% Discount rate 09% Year EIAC PV Levelized cost Levelized Annual Levelized Winter 2004 03372 $0.0312 $0.034 $0.501 $0.581 2005 03506 $0.0612 $0.034 $0.489 $0.561 2006 03649 $0.0901 $0.035 $0.474 $0.542 2007 03820 $0.1181 $0.036 $0.466 $0.533 2008 04244 $0.1468 $0.037 $0.464 $0.532 2009 04598 $0.1757 $0.038 $0.466 $0.534 2010 05010 $0.2047 $0.039 $0.470 $0.539 2011 05297 $0.2332 $0.041 $0.476 $0.545 2012 05535 $0.2607 $0.042 $0.482 $0.552 2013 05739 $0.2870 $0.043 $0.489 $0.560 2014 05828 $0.3118 $0.044 $0.496 $0.568 2015 06020 $0.3354 $0.045 $0.503 $0.576 2016 06263 $0.3582 $0.046 $0.511 $0.585 2017 06487 $0.3801 $0.046 $0.519 $0.594 2018 06541 $0.4004 $0.602 2019 06728 $0.4198 $0.048 $0.535 $0.611 2020 06919 $0.4382 $0.048 $0.543 $0.621 2021 07032 $0.4556 $0.049 $0.551 $0.630 2022 07125 $0.4718 $0.049 $0.559 $0.639 2023 07571 $0.4878 $0.050 $0.567 $0.648 2024 07796 $0.5030 $0.051 $0.575 $0.657 2025 08029 $0.5175 $0.051 $0.584 $0.666 2026 08271 $0.5313 $0.052 $0.592 $0.675 2027 08544 $0.5445 $0.052 $0.600 $0.684 2028 08860 $0.5572 $0.053 $0.608 $0.693 2029 09143 $0.5693 $0.053 $0.616 $0.702 2030 09440 $0.5809 $0.054 $0.624 $0.711 2031 09750 $0.5919 $0.054 $0.631 $0.719 2032 10076 $0.6025 $0.054 $0.639 $0.728 2033 10414 $0.6126 $0.055 $0.647 $0.736 10756 $0.654 $0.745 $0.662 $0.753 $0.669 $0.761 $0.665 $0.756 $0.661 $0.752 Ex h i b i t x x x x x x x To t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t T e s t S u m m a r y - G a s DS M P r o g r a m s 1 9 9 5 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 Re g u l a r i n c o m e Li m i t e d i n c o m e To t a l D S M po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i 34 9 , 50 6 $ $ 3 4 9 , 50 6 72 7 , 36 0 $ $ 1 72 7 , 36 0 13 , 70 0 , 62 9 $ 5 5 0 , 54 3 $ 1 4 25 1 , 17 2 15 , 77 7 , 4 9 5 $ 5 5 0 , 54 3 $ 1 6 , 32 8 , 03 8 To t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t T e s t S u m m a r y - E l e c t r i c DS M P r o g r a m s 1 / 1 / 9 9 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 Re g u l a r i n c o m e Li m i t e d i n c o m e To t a l D S M po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i o $ 6 0 05 3 , 79 5 $ 6 , 36 1 88 3 $ 6 6 , 4 1 5 , 67 8 $ 9 , 38 1 , 11 5 $ $ 9 , 38 1 11 5 J 2 6 , 93 4 , 13 5 ~ ( 3 , 70 1 , 13 1 ) ~ 2 3 , 23 3 , 00 4 $ 9 6 , 36 9 , 04 5 $ 2 , 66 0 , 75 2 $ 9 9 , 02 9 , 79 7 El e c t r i c A v o i d e d C o s t No n - En e r g y B e n e f i t s Ga s A v o i d e d C o s t To t a l R e s o u r c e B e n e f i t s El e c t r i c A v o i d e d C o s t No n - En e r g y B e n e f i t s $ Ga s A v o i d e d C o s t To t a l R e s o u r c e B e n e f i t s $ No n - Ut i l i t y I n c e n t i v e C o s t 61 6 , 77 6 82 9 , 50 1 10 , 4 4 6 , 27 7 No n - Ut i l i t y I n c e n t i v e C o s t 37 8 , 23 3 19 , 15 6 39 7 38 9 In c r e m e n t a l C u s t o m e r C o s t 55 1 , 95 8 02 3 , 72 4 76 , 57 5 , 68 2 In c r e m e n t a l C u s t o m e r C o s t 12 , 00 8 , 4 7 7 57 5 , 13 6 58 3 , 61 3 To t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t 16 8 , 73 4 85 3 , 22 5 02 1 95 9 To t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t 12 , 38 6 , 71 0 59 4 , 29 2 12 , 98 1 00 2 Ne t T o t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t 15 , 20 0 , 31 1 (3 , 19 2 , 4 7 3 ) $ 12 , 00 7 , 83 8 Ne t T o t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t 39 0 , 78 5 (4 3 , 74 9 ) $ 34 7 , 03 6 To t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t B e n e f i V C o s t R a t i o 0. 4 5 To t a l R e s o u r c e C o s t B e n e f i V C o s t R a t i o kW h s a v i n g s 26 3 , 32 3 , 22 7 22 , 50 4 , 63 7 28 5 , 82 7 86 4 Th e r m s a v i n g s 2, 4 0 7 , 05 5 94 , 72 0 50 1 , 77 5 15 - ye a r l e v e l i z e d u t i l i t y c o s t p e r k W h 03 6 03 1 03 6 15 - ye a r l e v e l i z e d T R C c o s t p e r t h e r m 60 5 73 7 61 0 Ut i l i t y C o s t T e s t S u m m a r y - E l e c t r i c DS M p r o g r a m s 1 / 1 / 9 9 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 , , Re g u l a r i n c o m e Li m i t e d i n c o m e To t a l D S M po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i o El e c t r i c A v o i d e d C o s t $ 6 0 , 05 3 , 79 5 $ 6 , 36 1 , 88 3 $ 6 6 , 41 5 , 67 8 Ga s A v o i d e d C o s t $ 2 6 , 93 4 , 13 5 $ 70 1 , 13 1 $ 2 3 , 23 3 , 00 4 Ut i l i t y B e n e f i t s $ 8 6 , 98 7 , 93 0 $ 2 , 66 0 , 75 2 $ 8 9 , 64 8 , 68 2 Ut i l i t y C o s t T e s t S u m m a r y - G a s DS M p r o g r a m s 1 9 9 5 t o 1 0 / 3 1 / 0 3 Re g u l a r i n c o m e Li m i t e d i n c o m e po r t f o l i o po r t f o l i o 34 9 , 50 6 $ 70 0 , 62 9 $ 5 5 0 , 54 3 $ 14 , 05 0 , 13 5 $ 5 5 0 , 54 3 $ El e c t r i c A v o i d e d C o s t Ga s A v o i d e d C o s t Ut i l i t y B e n e f i t s $ No n - Ut i l i t y I n c e n t i v e C o s t 61 6 , 77 6 82 9 , 50 1 1 0 , 4 4 6 , 27 7 No n - Ut i l i t y I n c e n t i v e C o s t 37 8 , 23 3 19 , 15 6 Ut i l i t y I n c e n t i v e C o s t 18 , 92 9 , 62 2 13 7 64 3 24 , 06 7 , 26 5 Ut i l i t y I n c e n t i v e C o s t 4, 4 2 4 47 4 57 7 , 99 8 Ut i l i t y C o s t $ 28 , 54 6 , 39 8 96 7 , 14 4 34 , 51 3 , 54 2 Ut i l i t y C o s t 80 2 , 70 7 59 7 15 4 Ne t U t i l i t y C o s t 58 , 4 4 1 53 2 (3 , 30 6 , 39 2 ) $ 55 , 13 5 , 14 0 Ne t U t i l i t y C o s t 24 7 42 8 (4 6 , 61 1 ) $ Ut i l i t y C o s t T e s t B e n e f i V C o s t R a t i o 0. 4 5 Ut i l i t y C o s t T e s t B e n e f i V C o s t R a t i o kW h s a v i n g s 26 3 , 32 3 , 22 7 22 , 50 4 , 63 7 28 5 , 82 7 , 86 4 Th e r m s a v i n g s 40 7 , 05 5 94 , 72 0 15 - ye a r l e v e l i z e d u t i l i t y c o s t p e r k W h 01 3 03 1 01 4 15 - ye a r l e v e l i z e d u t i l i t y c o s t p e r t h e r m 23 4 74 1 To t a l D S M po r t f o l i 34 9 , 50 6 25 1 , 17 2 60 0 , 67 8 39 7 , 38 9 00 2 , 47 2 39 9 , 86 1 20 0 , 81 7 50 1 , 77 5 25 4 Ex h i b i t x x x x x x 1/ 1 / 9 9 t o 7/ 3 1 / 9 9 Su m m a r y o f E l e c t r i c a n d G a s E n e r g y S a v i n g s Re g u l a r I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o Li m i t e d I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o To t a l P o r t f o l i o Th e r m S a v i n g s D e r i v e d f r o m G a s - Ef f i c i e n c y P r o g r a m s 8/ 1 / 9 9 t o 12 / 1 / 9 9 t o 4/ 1 / 0 0 t o 8/ 1 / 0 0 t o 1/ 1 / 0 1 t o 11 / 3 0 / 9 9 1 3 / 3 1 / 0 0 1 7 / 3 1 / 0 0 1 1 2 / 3 1 / 0 0 8/ 3 1 / 0 1 25 4 92 0 3/ 1 3 / 9 5 t0 1 2 / 3 1 / 9 6 25 4 92 0 Re g u l a r I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o Li m i t e d I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o To t a l P o r t f o l i o ~. . i I I I I 8 1 . Ad d i t i o n a l t h e r m s s a v i n g s d e r i v e d t h e E l e c t r i c a n d G a s D S M P o r t f o l i o 8/ 1 / 9 9 t o 12 / 1 / 9 9 t o 4/ 1 / 0 0 t o 8/ 1 / 0 0 t o 1/ 1 / 0 1 t o 11 / 3 0 / 9 9 3/ 3 1 / 0 0 7/ 3 1 / 0 0 12 / 3 1 / 0 0 8/ 3 1 / 0 1 (2 2 9 , 94 5 ) ( 8 3 10 2 ) ( 9 1 69 4 ) 5 3 , 60 0 90 7 , 51 0 18 , 77 9 53 , 4 1 9 7 4 12 7 1 1 4 , 22 3 1 4 5 , 29 1 (2 4 8 , 72 4 ) ( 1 3 6 , 52 1 ) ( 1 6 5 , 82 1 ) ( 6 0 , 62 3 ) 4 76 2 , 21 9 Re g u l a r I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o Lim i t e d I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o To t a l P o r t f o l i o 3/ 1 3 / 9 5 t0 1 2 / 3 1 / 9 6 33 4 80 1 26 , 45 6 36 1 , 25 7 3/ 1 3 / 9 5 1/ 1 / 9 9 t o t0 1 2 / 3 1 / 9 6 7/ 3 1 / 9 9 Re g u l a r I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o 1 5 , 20 0 , 39 6 Li m i t e d I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o 5 , 63 3 , 66 5 To t a l P o r t f o l i o IJ I I i I l l l l f l 3/ 1 3 / 9 5 t0 1 2 / 3 1 / 9 6 1/ 1 / 9 9 t o 7/ 3 1 / 9 9 To t a l T h e r m S a v i n g s D e r i v e d f r o m t h e E l e c t r i c a n d G a s D S M P o r t f o l i o 8/ 1 / 9 9 t o 12 / 1 / 9 9 t o 4/ 1 / 0 0 t o 8/ 1 / 0 0 t o 1/ 1 / 0 1 t o 11 / 3 0 / 9 9 3/ 3 1 / 0 0 7/ 3 1 / 0 0 12 / 3 1 / 0 0 8/ 3 1 / 0 1 (2 2 9 , 94 5 ) ( 8 3 , 10 2 ) ( 9 1 69 4 ) 5 3 , 60 0 5 , 16 2 , 43 0 18 , 77 9 53 , 4 1 9 7 4 , 12 7 1 1 4 22 3 1 4 5 29 1 (2 4 8 , 72 4 ) ( 1 3 6 , 52 1 ) ( 1 6 5 , 82 1 ) ( 6 0 , 62 3 ) 5 , 01 7 13 9 El e c t r i c k W h S a v i n g s D e r i v e d f r o m E l e c t r i c - Ef f i c i e n c y P r o g r a m s 8/ 1 / 9 9 t o 12 / 1 / 9 9 t o 4/ 1 / 0 0 t o 8/ 1 / 0 0 t o 1/ 1 / 0 1 t o 11 / 3 0 / 9 9 3/ 3 1 / 0 0 7/ 3 1 / 0 0 12 / 3 1 / 0 0 8/ 3 1 / 0 1 13 , 04 9 , 40 0 10 , 36 3 , 23 7 1 5 , 21 4 , 16 1 1 0 , 56 2 , 32 0 1 1 6 , 65 6 , 39 3 15 2 , 36 4 1 , 95 7 , 03 4 1 , 73 8 , 03 5 2 , 72 7 , 61 9 3 48 4 , 64 8 12 0 , 14 1 04 1 Ad d i t i o n a l E l e c t r i c k W h s a v i n g s d e r i v e d t h e E l e c t r i c a n d G a s D S M P o r t f o l i o 8/ 1 / 9 9 t o 12 / 1 / 9 9 t o 4/ 1 / 0 0 t o 8/ 1 / 0 0 t o 1/ 1 / 0 1 t o 11 / 3 0 / 9 9 3 3 / 3 1 / 0 0 3 7 / 3 1 / 0 0 3 1 2 / 3 1 / 0 0 8/ 3 1 / 0 1 36 , 75 0 Re g u l a r I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o Li m i t e d I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o 36 , 75 0 3/ 1 3 / 9 5 t0 1 2 / 3 1 / 9 6 Re g u l a r I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o Li m i t e d I n c o m e P o r t f o l i o To t a l Po r t f o l i o ~ . 1/ 1 / 9 9 t o 7/ 3 1 / 9 9 15 , 20 0 , 39 6 63 3 , 66 5 20 , 83 4 06 1 9/ 1 / 0 1 t o 1/ 1 / 0 2 t o 1/ 1 / 0 3 t o 12 / 3 1 / 0 1 12 / 3 1 / 0 2 10 / 3 1 / 0 3 TO T A L 46 8 , 89 6 61 7 16 6 73 1 , 27 2 40 7 05 5 16 9 36 , 81 7 27 8 94 , 72 0 47 6 06 5 65 3 , 98 3 75 5 , 55 0 50 1 , 77 5 1/ 1 / 0 3 t o 10 / 3 1 / 0 3 (3 8 , 97 8 ) (3 8 , 97 8 ) 1/ 1 / 0 3 t o 10 / 3 1 / 0 3 69 2 29 4 27 8 71 6 57 2 9/ 1 / 0 1 t o 1/ 1 / 0 2 t o 1/ 1 / 0 3 t o 12 / 3 1 / 0 1 12 / 3 1 / 0 2 10 / 3 1 / 0 3 TO T A L 22 , 4 2 5 , 46 9 51 7 , 85 3 33 3 , 99 8 26 3 , 32 3 , 22 7 64 6 , 68 4 36 4 , 52 8 80 0 , 06 0 22 , 50 4 63 7 24 , 07 2 , 15 3 88 2 , 38 1 29 , 13 4 , 05 8 28 5 , 82 7 86 4 9/ 1 / 0 1 t o 1/ 1 / 0 2 t o 1/ 1 / 0 3 t o 12 / 3 1 / 0 1 12 / 3 1 / 0 2 10 / 3 1 / 0 3 TO T A L 48 , 53 2 73 3 , 66 7 (1 8 ) 81 8 , 93 1 48 , 53 2 73 3 , 66 7 (1 8 ) 81 8 , 93 1 To t a l E l e c t r i c k W h S a v i n g s D e r i v e d f r o m t h e E l e c t r i c a n d G a s D S M P o r t f o l i o 8/ 1 / 9 9 t o 12 / 1 / 9 9 t o 4/ 1 / 0 0 t o 8/ 1 / 0 0 t o 1/ 1 / 0 1 t o 9/ 1 / 0 1 t o 11 / 3 0 / 9 9 3/ 3 1 / 0 0 7/ 3 1 / 0 0 12 / 3 1 / 0 0 8/ 3 1 / 0 1 12 / 3 1 / 0 1 13 , 04 9 , 4 0 0 10 , 36 3 , 23 7 1 5 , 21 4 , 16 1 1 0 , 56 2 32 0 1 1 6 , 69 3 , 14 3 22 , 47 4 00 1 15 2 , 36 4 1 , 95 7 , 03 4 1 , 73 8 , 03 5 2 , 72 7 , 61 9 3 , 4 8 4 64 8 1 , 64 6 68 4 14 , 20 1 , 76 4 1 2 , 32 0 , 27 1 1 6 , 95 2 , 19 6 1 3 28 9 , 93 9 1 2 0 , 17 7 , 79 1 2 4 , 12 0 , 68 5 1/ 1 / 0 2 t o 12 / 3 1 / 0 2 33 , 25 1 , 52 0 36 4 52 8 35 , 61 6 , 04 8 No t e s 1 G a s D S M p r o g r a m s w e r e n o t f u n d e d d u r i n g t h e 1 9 9 7 t o 20 0 0 ti m e p e r i o d . 2 T h e 9 5 / 9 6 i m p a c t o f e l e c t r i c D S M p r o g r a m s u p o n n a t u r a l g a s s a v i n g s h a s b e e n i n c o r p o r a t e d i n t o p r e v i o u s r a t e c a s e s . 3 T h e A v i s t a D S M p o r t f o l i o w a s r e s t r i c t e d t o g a s p r o g r a m s d u r i n g t h i s t i m e . 1/ 1 / 0 3 t o 10 / 3 1 / 0 3 27 , 33 3 , 98 0 80 0 , 06 0 29 , 13 4 , 04 0 TO T A L 26 4 , 14 2 , 15 8 22 , 50 4 63 7 28 6 64 6 79 5