HomeMy WebLinkAbout20071023Staff to PAC 1-30.pdfSCOTT WOODBURY
DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
PO BOX 83720
BOISE, IDAHO 83720-0074
(208) 334-0320
ISB NO. 1895
H:=CE!
7flrn (1rT ?'LC,J; '.J!
"" '-- '
t.
, ".
, Iq;~tOT:)?.\~~(, c.U; H_I 1 I.:,,) ',-"Vi,,;.il0W
!jj
NEIL PRICE
DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
PO BOX 83720
BOISE, IDAHO 83720-0074
(208) 334-0314
ISB NO. 6864
Street Address for Express Mail:
472 W. WASHINGTON
BOISE, IDAHO 83702-5983
Attorneys for the Commission Staff
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLI CA TI ON
OF P ACIFICORP DBA ROCKY MOUNTAIN
POWER FOR APPROVAL OF CHANGES TO
ITS ELECTRIC SERVICE SCHEDULES.
CASE NO. P AC-O7-
COMMISSION STAFF'
RESPONSE TO P ACIFICORP
DBA ROCKY MOUNTAIN
POWER'S FIRST SET OF DATA
REQUESTS TO STAFF
The Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission, by and through its attorney of record
Neil Price, Deputy Attorney General, provides the following documents and information in
response to Rocky Mountain Power s First Set of Data Requests to Staff dated October 9, 2007.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23 , 2007
Request No.1: Bryan Lanspery. Please explain how the IRP serves as a guide for
the future acquisition of new resources (page 26, lines 21-23) and provide all documents
relied upon or that reasonably relate to this position.
Answer: The IRP language itself supports the contention that the IRP serves as a guide
for future acquisition of new resources. For example, page 14 bfthe 2007 IRP states "(T)he
preferred portfolio represents the resource plan that has the best balance of cost and risk." The
portfolio analysis results in an action plan that "is used to map out the steps required to acquire
the resources identified in the preferred portfolio.Id at 222. Page 223 ofthe 2007 IRP states
(T)he resources identified in the plan are proxy resources and act as a guide to resource
procurement." (Emphasis added) This language is consistent with the language in the 2003 and
2004 IRPs. See also RMP Response to IPUC Production Request 4, Goodnoe Hills Project.
Note that in the PacifiCorp Energy Expenditure Requisition, under the section entitled "What
alternatives were considered?" the response was "PacifiCorp s most recently published
Integrated Resource Plan established a preferred portfolio that consists of 1 ,400 megawatts of
economic renewable resources, including wind. Alternative resource technologies were
considered via the plan.(Emphasis added) While not verbatim, this is the same response to the
same question for the Leaning Jupiter expenditure requisition and the "Alternatives Considered"
section of the Marengo expenditure requisition. These are projects the Company pursued and
acquired under RFP-2003B.
Request No.2: Bryan Lanspery. Please provide all documents relied upon or that
reasonably relate to your statement on page 26 (lines 23-25) of your prefiled direct
testimony that the "decision to pursue acquisition of new wind generation is based on the
cost and risk analysis included in the Company s IRPs." Which specific IRPs are included
in this statement?
Answer: The past 3 IRPs have preferred portfolios containing wind generation.
Specifically, RFP-2003A and RFP-2003B resulted from the 2003 IRP. The Action Plan states
the Company s intent to issue RFPs for east side and west side wind generation (page 156). On
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST 2 OCTOBER 23, 2007
page 18 , it states
, "
The 2003 IRP Action Plan prescribed the issuance of a renewable RFP (RFP
20O3-B). Given the requirements observed within both control areas, RFP-2003-B will be issued
as planned.
Additionally, see my response to Request No.1 regarding the expenditure requisitions
and the wind facilities procured through RFP-2003B.
Request No.3: Bryan Lanspery. Please quantitatively define the word "consistent"
as used by you in your prefiled testimony on page 27, line 3. What percentage do you
consider "consistent" as that term is used by you on page 27, line 3 of your prefiled direct
testimony?
Answer: Staff does not propose any definitive percentage for "consistent" as found in my
testimony. The concern centers on the fact that the prices being paid for new resources are much
different than those used as assumptions in the Company s IRP. For instance, the IRP assumes a
147 MW west side wind facility to have capital costs of$I 737 per kW. In response to IPUC
Production Request 9, the Company indicated that the capital cost for the 94 MW Goodnoe Hills
facility is closer to $2 096 per kW, the 100.5 MW Leaning Jupiter facility is closer to $1 964 per
, and the140A MW Marengo project is closer to $1 841 per kW. While Staff acknowledges
that recent events have had substantial impacts on construction prices, the 2007 IRP was in the
process of development while these facilities were being procured.
Please see my response to the first request for a reiteration of why Staff believes that the
IRP assumptions are of value in assessing whether a resource acquisition was prudent.
Request No.4: Bryan Lanspery. Please define the word "best" as that term is used
by you on page 27, line 5 of your prefiled direct testimony.
Answer: Staff would consider a resource alternative "best" if it is the most advantageous
most suitable choice given the balance between least-cost planning and risk.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23 , 2007
Request No.5: Bryan Lanspery. Regarding Staff's testimony at page 27 , lines 5-
would such "refreshing" of prices require a full IRP update or be handled in some other
manner? Does Staff maintain the position that the IRP cost assumptions for all new
resource types (wind, coal, and natural gas) should also be "refreshed" if bid prices are
below the IRP assumptions when acquiring new resources? Please explain your responses.
Answer: The Company has traditionally provided annual updates to the IRP, in which
the Company revisits the Action Plan. The Action Plan is "subject to change as new information
becomes available or as circumstances change " and further states
, "
that it is PacifiCorp
intention to revisit and refresh the Action Plan no less frequently than annually." See the 2003
IRP, page 152 , and 2004 IRP, page 180. Staff assumes and believes that the assumptions leading
to the choice of the preferred portfolio and subsequent Action Plan would be revisited at this
time, including cost assumptions, whether too high or low.
Within the context of the testimony, Staff is only trying to suggest that at the time
resource acquisition decisions are made, it is important to have reasonably current and accurate
cost information for all resource alternatives to insure that good decisions are being made. This
is especially true in the case of recent RFPs because those processes took years , not months, to
complete.
Request No.6: Bryan Lanspery. In your prefiled direct testimony at page 10, lines
23-24, you imply that the irrigation curtailment credit is currently priced "at or near
marginal costs." Is your position that the current level of the curtailment credit is
reasonable because it is priced at marginal costs? Please explain your response.
Answer: See Section III: Terms of the Stipulation, subsection 2 of the Stipulation
Regarding Irrigation Load Control Credit Rider (Schedule 72), submitted in Case No. P AC-
05-01. This section specifically states
, "
(P)ricing for these products is based on PacifiCorp
next best alternative to serve east side load; that is, the forward firm energy market at Mona.
" .
The document has been included as Attachment 6 to this response.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST 4 OCTOBER 23 , 2007
Request No.7: Bryan Lanspery. If the irrigation curtailment credit was treated as
a system expense, would it be appropriate to add back the curtailed demand to the JAM
and the cost of service model, as is currently done with Monsanto s load curtailment?
Please explain.
Answer: No. Please see page 10, lines 2-13 in my testimony for an explanation.
Request No.8: Bryan Lanspery. Please explain how you propose Rocky Mountain
Power recover the cost of Idaho demand-side management incentive payments to irrigators
if other states do not agree that the payments should be system-allocated?
Answer: I maintain that the incentive payments ought to be treated as a power supply
expense, and allocated system wide as are other system resources. Recovery of costs allocated to
other jurisdictions is the responsibility of Rocky Mountain Power. If the power supply costs are
disallowed by other jurisdictions, this issue could be presented to the MSP Standing Committee.
Request No.9: Bryan Lanspery. Does Staff believe that Idaho should be allocated
its share of system-allocated costs for demand side management programs similar to
Idaho s irrigation load control program in other states? Please explain.
Answer: Yes. However, similar programs are currently limited. DSM without these
specific characteristics should continue to be situs allocated. Please see page 10, lines 16-19 in
my testimony for an explanation.
Request No. 10: Bryan Lanspery. Please provide all documentation or other
evidentiary support for Staff's position at page 7 , line 13 that Staff's allocation proposal for
the irrigation load control program is not contrary to the guidelines of the Revised
Protocol.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23, 2007
Answer: See Appendix A of the Revised Protocol for definition of "Special Contracts
Also, see Appendix D for explanation and numerical treatment of Special Contract With
Ancillary Service Contract Attributes. It is evident from the example in Appendix D that
revenues are treated situs, while the energy and demand related costs are allocated using the
system energy and system capacity factors, respectively. Since the irrigators have no option to
buy through the curtailment, references in the Revised Protocol to adding load back prior to
determining the Load-Based Dynamic Allocation Factors are moot.
Also, see pages 6-15 of my testimony for Staff s position on the Irrigation Load Control
Incentive payment and Revised Protocol.
Request No. 11: Bryan Lanspery. Please identify all parties to whom you would
expect to participate in a new docket on line extension policies if the Idaho Public Utilities
Commission accepted your recommendation to open a subsequent docket to address this
issue.
Answer: Staff does not propose a list of specific parties that would participate, merely
that line extension modifications should be addressed in a separate docket as the Commission
traditionally has done. This affords the opportunity to send notice to any potential party, whether
it is the Building Contractors Association of Southeast Idaho, other hom~ builders associations
bordering municipalities, etc. that would not participate in a general rate case where line
extension policies are marginalized due to larger issues.
Request No. 12: Bryan Lanspery. Would you agree that one reason why the
irrigation load should remain situs is because there is no loss of revenue to the company,
because load is simply shifted to off-peak times? If no, please explain.
Answer: The fact that there is no loss of revenue associated with the irrigation load
program has little bearing on Staff s position that the resource payments should be system
allocated. What matters is that the program is reflective of a contract purchase that the Company
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST 6 OCTOBER 23 2007
has entered into. If anything, there is no loss of revenue associated with contract purchases
another similarity with the Program.
Request No. 13: Bryan Lanspery. Please explain what an adequate sample load
consists of as referenced by you on page 16 of your prefiled direct testimony.
Answer: An adequate sample load reflects the population load within a level of
acceptance. This level is somewhat subjective, but Staff would consider a 5% or 10% level as
adequate. The sampling data obtained through lIP A Data Request 1.7 demonstrates that the
sample data fails to meet the 10% criteria more than half the time (19 out of36 months for
Schedules 1 , 36, and 10). It is in the Company s interest to have the sample load accurately
portray the population load.
Request No. 14: Bryan Lanspery. Regarding your testimony at page 4, lines 1-4, is
Staff's position that an increase in Monsanto s rates should change the credit provided to
Monsanto for interruptibility? Please explain your response.
Answer: No. The change in the credit results from changes in the inputs used to valuate
the Monsanto curtailment products. It is no surprise that marginal costs, which form the basis of
the credit valuations, are rising along with embedded costs, which form the basis of the rate
Increase.
Request No. 15: Bryan Lanspery. Please specifically identify the "methods of
valuation" approved in Order No. 30197 which Staff used to determine the increase in
economic curtailment and system integrity components of the Monsanto credit in this case.
Please provide any documents from this case which reflect Staff's position on these
methods of valuation and any calculations of the Monsanto credit using these methods.
Answer: See pages 7-8 of Order No. 30197 for explanation of the methods employed by
Staff to calculate the economic curtailment and system integrity components.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23, 2007
See Attachment 15 for calculations performed by Staff. Values are found under the tab
named 'pv800.
Request No. 16: Bryan Lanspery. Please provide all workpapers for Staff's
proposed increase of 14% for the Monsanto credit in this case.
Answer: See response to Data Request 15.
Request No. 17: Bryan Lanspery. What additional information would have been
required to calculate the operating reserve component? Why does Staff believe that a 14%
increase is conservative, as indicated on page 5, line 15 of Staff's testimony?
Answer: To calculate the operating reserve component, it would be necessary to know
the highest cost economically viable generating unit that is being held offline for each hour as a
result of the product offered by Monsanto, as well as the cost per MW and associated
transmission expense for that unit.
The 14% is considered conservative as it equals the lower of the increases for the
economic curtailment and system integrity components. With market prices increasing since the
credits were negotiated in 2006 and new generating resources that may qualify as the highest
cost economically viable generating unit that is being held offline not available until the latter
quarter of 2007, it is reasonable to assume that the 14% is conservative.
Request No. 18: Bryan Lanspery. Regarding Staff's testimony at page 5, lines 17-
22, please explain the relationship between increases in the forward price curve and the
valuation of the Monsanto credit. Is Staff's position that increases in the forward price
curve should always result in a corresponding increase in the Monsanto credit?
Answer: See response to Data Request 15 regarding the relationship between the forward
price curve and the Monsanto credit.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23 , 2007
, Staffs position is not that increases in the forward price curves should always result
in a corresponding increase in the Monsanto credit. Increases in the price curves only should
affect the credit in the proper forum. Monsanto is a tariff customer, and as this is a general rate
case, this is the proper forum to address the credit value.
Request No. 19: Joe Leckie. Please explain why you are viewing the company
incentive pay in the short term as opposed to the long term. How is this position consistent
with your position on page 9 of your testimony that over the long term customers benefit
from meeting budgets, but viewed in short run the immediate benefits go to shareholder?
Answer: Staff looked at the incentive pay that was being paid to the employees during
the accepted test year used to determine rates. It would not be appropriate to view incentive pay
in the long term and use that view as the basis for determining a test year expense. This is
consistent with the position that over the long term customers benefit from meeting budgets. In
making this assertion, I assume that the Company s budgets over a long term would reflect
financial performance that would ensure the Company s financial health, that would show the
Company earning its authorized rate of return, and that the Company would embrace greater
efficiencies in its expenditures. If the Company, through the meeting of its budgets over an
extended period of time, is able to achieve these assumptions, there may be fewer rate cases; the
operating expenses would not increase, as quickly, and there can be less pressure for increased
rates. These are benefits to the customers. On the other hand, any action by the Company that
increases the bottom line financial results are an immediate benefit to the shareholders and
meeting budgets should result in increasing the bottom line financial result of the Company.
Request No. 20: Joe Leckie. Do you agree that operating within budget is an
essential element of achieving financial objectives that benefit customers? Please explain.
Answer: Yes, over time but not necessarily in a single year. The Company must be a
financially viable entity if it is to be a reliable and reasonably priced provider of power to its
customers. The use of budgeting is an essential management tool to keep the Company a
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST 9 OCTOBER 23 , 2007
financially viable entity. A financially healthy Company is able to keep expenses lower than if it
is not healthy, and lower expenses benefits customers over time.
Request No. 21: Patricia Harms. Please indicate the policy you are referring to on
page 9 of your testimony when you indicate that Staff's recommendation regarding major
plant additions is consistent with policy used for major plant additions in other cases.
Please identify any and all supporting documentation for this policy.
Answer: It is Staffs policy to attempt to be consistent with various utilities on similar
issues. As noted in the referenced testimony,
this methodology was developed under the supervision of Staff witness Carlock
Deputy Administrator of the Utilities Division, to ensure annualizing or adding
major plant additions such as this as if it were in service for the entire test year is
consistent with the policy used for major plant additions in Idaho Power and
Avista rate cases (Case Nos. IPC-03-13 and A VU-04-1).
Request No. 22: Pactricia Harms. Please provide workpapers, analysis, documents
used for preparing Exhibits 108-113.
Answer: When these exhibits and the corresponding testimony were filed on September
, 2007 the workpapers supporting them were contained in three separate e-mails to the parties
in the case. Notably the regulatory and jurisdictional (RAM and JAM) models were sent in two
separate e-mails due to the size of the spreadsheets. These electronic spreadsheets were on the
Revised Protocol methodology and were the basis of Exhibit Nos. 109 and 110. Exhibit No. 111
is the same RAM and JAM switched to the Rolled-In basis. Exhibit No. 112 identifies the
revenue requirement increase or decrease associated with Staffs adjustments. The amounts on
this exhibit were derived from review ofthe RAM and JAM with various adjustments "switched
off." The workpaper supporting Exhibit No. 113 was e-mailed to parties in the case on
September 28 2007. These exhibits as a whole result from Staffs review of the Company
response to audit and production requests. Exhibit No.1 08 calculates the "Capped Revised
Protocol Revenue Requirement" and the inputs to this exhibit are from the RAM and JAM. The
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNT AIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23 2007
electronic spreadsheet supporting this exhibit has been e-mailed to the parties in the case
contemporaneous with this production request response.
Request No. 23: Terri Carlock. Please provide copies of all work papers, analyses,
documents, or other references/citations used by Ms. Carlock in preparing Exhibit 120.
Answer: Attachment No. 23 provides copies of documents/work papers used to prepare
Staff Exhibit No. 120. Some of this information received from the Company may be
Confidential , so is marked accordingly. In addition Staff used 2007 IRP documents and its
participation in IRP Public Input Stakeholders Meetings for background and understanding.
These documents are not attached as they are Company filed documents and available on the
Company website.
Request No. 24: Terri Carlock. Please provide Ms. Carlock's imputed system
revenues on a $/MWh basis for each referenced project in Exhibit 120.
Answer: See Attachment No. 23.
Request No. 25: Terri Carlock. Please provide the energy (in MWh) on a per
project basis associated with Ms. Carlock's imputed system revenues in Exhibit 120.
Answer: See Attachment No. 23.
Request No. 26: Terri Carlock. Please identify the reference for each of Ms.
Carlock's calculation assumptions in preparing Exhibit 120.
Answer: See Attachment No. 23 and Staff Exhibit No. 120.
Request No. 27: Terri Carlock. Please provide copies of all work papers, analyses,
documents, and other material relied upon or that Staff anticipates relying upon in support
(including electronic with active formulas) of its REC adjustment.
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23 2007
Answer: Attachment No. 27 provides copies of documents/workpapers to calculate
Staffs REC adjustment.
Request No. 28: Terri Carlock. In your REC adjustment, what review was done on
the need for the pro forma REC adjustment? Was the pro forma adjustment caused by
additional sales related to the new wind plants, and does doing both adjustments cause a
double count?
Answer: The need for the proforma REC adjustment was evaluated in this case and will
continue to be evaluated in future proceedings based on the overall PacifiCorp system
generation, use of RECs in various states, the number and availability of RECs to sell, and the
actual sales. This will most likely also continue to be an MSP issue until resolved. Additional
sales included the sale of RECs from new wind plants. However, the inclusion of both
adjustments does not create a double counting in this case. It could be a double counting in other
situations depending on the time line for the generation and sale of the RECs, but as indicated
previously, that is not the situation in this case. This adjustment should not be a standard
adjustment that the Company would include in its Results of Operation because it must be
evaluated based on the specific circumstances in a test year and proforma period.
Request No. 29: Terri Carlock. Please provide copies of all work papers, analyses,
documents, and other material relied upon or that Staff anticipants relying upon in
support (including electronic with active formulas) of its return on equity
recommendations.
Answer: Staff relied on Company documents and documents from various Company
sponsored processes that will not be attached to this response because the documents were
Company developed and are voluminous. These documents include the following: the
Company s testimony, exhibits, work papers, production requests, audit requests, IRP filings
IRP public input and stakeholder documents and meetings, MSP documents, Revised Protocol
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23 , 2007
Interjurisdictional Cost Allocation Methodology and workgroup documents, Standing
Committee and workgroup documents. Staff also relied on The Value Line Investment Survey
and Energy Central Professional. Attachment 29 provides copies that Staff printed and may not
have been available to Company witness Hadaway s work papers. Electronic work papers are
provided in the folder "TCarlock wp P AC-07-
Request No. 30: Please produce any and all documents that Staff expects or
reasonably anticipates introducing into evidence at a hearing in the above-captioned
docket.
Answer: Staff anticipates introducing all exhibits accompanying its direct testimony.
Staff will consider the necessity of further exhibits with and following the scheduled filing of
rebuttal testimony in this matter.
DATED at Boise, Idaho, this;).~~ day of October 2007.
Deputy Attorney General
Technical Staff: Bryan Lanspery
Joe Leckie
Patricia Harms
Terri Carlock
i:umisc:prodreq/paceO7,5npbljlphtc prod response!
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO ROCKY
MOUNTAIN POWER'S DATA REQUEST OCTOBER 23, 2007
ATTACHMENT
(8 PAGES)
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'
FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS
CASE NO. P AC-O7-
James F. Fell
STOEL RIVES LLP
900 SW Fifth Avenue, Suite 2600
Portland, OR 97204
Telephone: (503) 294-9343
Fax: (503) 220-2480
Emai1: jffellCfYstoeJ.com
Bar Number: 2274
\'EO
, ,
,- J C. .
'1 ~-:-n: l,-
'..,
I..!
'i\Jf)~1 nCT \ 1 M~ 9: ~ 3
i)~ 0 PUGUC
SIOi1\:c:, CO~'\~'l\S u; l\- \ , IC..
~ ,
Lisa Nordstrom
PacifiCorp Office of the General Counsel
825 NE Multnomah Street, Suite 1800
Portland, OR 97232
Telephone: (503) 813-6227
Fax: (503) 813-7252
Email: lisa.nordstromCfYpacificorp.com
Bar Number: 5733
Attorneys for PacifiCorp dba Utah
Power & Light Company
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
IN THE MATTER OF THE
APPLICATION OF P ACIFICORP DBA
UTAH POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
FOR AUTHORITY TO INCREASE ITS
RATES FOR ELECTRIC SERVICE
TO ELECTRIC CUSTOMERS IN THE
ST ATE OF IDAHO
CASE NO. PAC-O5-
STIPULATION REGARDING
IRRIGATION LOAD CONTROL
CREDIT RIDER (SCHEDULE 72)
This stipulation ("Stipulation ) is entered into by and among PacifiCorp, doing business
as Utah Power & Light Company ("PacifiCorp" or the "Company ), and the Idaho Irrigation
Pumpers Association ("lIP A") (collectively referred to as the "Parties
). ,
I. INTRODUCTION
The terms and conditions of this Stipulation are set forth herein. The Parties agree that
this Stipulation represents a fair, just and reasonable compromise of the issues raised in this
STIPULA nON - Page 1
PonlndJ-15J0490, I 0020017-00072
---,-- -,,- --- --,-- "_'_m_,__
_____'_'~
proceeding and that this Stipulation is in the public interest. The Parties, therefore
recommend that the Public Utilities Commission ("Commission ) approve the Stipulation and
all of its terms and conditions. Reference IDAPA 31.01.01.272, 274.
II. BACKGROUND
On July 22 , 2005, the Commission issued Order No. 29833 partially approving
a Stipulation dated June 10 2005 ("Stipulation ). The Stipulation stated in paragraph 11:
The Company agrees to meet with lIP A and other interested parties
regarding the calculation of credits under the Company
Schedule 72, the Irrigation Load Control Credit Rider. The initial
such meeting shall occur no later than August 31 , 2005. In the
event the parties reach agreement on such calculation, the
Company shall prepare a stipulation setting forth the agree-upon
terms and file such stipulation with the Commission no later than
September 30, 2005.
The Parties have met and have agreed upon a revised Schedule 72 for the
irrigation season commencing June 1 2006 and ending September 15, 2006. The terms of this
agreement are incorporated in this Stipulation.
Based upon the settlement discussions between the Parties, and as a compromise
of their positions, the Parties agree to the following terms:
III. TERMS OF THE STIPULATION
Product . From June 1 , 2006 to September 15,2006, PacifiCorp will provide a
credit to Idaho Schedule 10 customers who sign up to physically curtain their load associated
with one of three different predetermined timeframes. These timeframes, all falling between
the hours ending 1400 and 1900 Pacific Prevailing Time (2:00 pm to 8:00 pm Mountain
Prevailing Time), are as follows:
(a)Option 1 : Two six-continuous hour blocks per week
(Monday & Wednesday or Tuesday & Thursday);
Option 2: Two three-continuous hour blocks per week
(Monday & Wednesday or Tuesday & Thursday); or(b)
(c)Option 3: Four three-continuous hour blocks per week
occurring Monday through Thursday.
STIPULATION - Page 2
Portlnd3-1530490,\0020017-00072
, - -- ----~--
Pricing. Pricing for these three products is based on PacifiCorp s next best
alternative to serve east side load; that is, the forward finD energy market at Mona. All three
products represent super peak prices for the timeframes involved. The monthly credits, on a
$/KW -month basis, for the three timeframes is as follows:
(a)Option 1:((FPC Mona M - Thurs HE 14-19 PPT $IMWh - FPC Mona M -
HE 20-13 PPT) * 6 Hrs/Day * 2 DaysfWeek * # WeekslMonth) + 1000
Option 2: ((FPC Mona M-Thurs HE 16-18 PPT $IMWh- FPC MonaM-
HE 19-15 PPT) * 3 Hrs/Day * 2 Days/Week * # WeekslMonth) + 1000
(b)
(c)Option 3 : ((FPC Mona M - Thurs HE 16-18 PPT $IMWh - FPC Mona M-
HE 19-15 PPT) * 3 Hrs/Day * 4 Days/Week * # WeekslMonth) + 1000
Appendix A shows the difference in prices for these Options for 2005 compared to 2006.
III. GENERAL TERMS
The Parties agree that this Stipulation represents a compromise in their positions
on the issues covered. Other than the above referenced positions and any testimony filed in
support of the approval of this Stipulation, and except to the extent necessary for a Party to
explain before the Commission its own statements and positions with respect to the Stipulation,
negotiations relating to this Stipulation shall not be admissible in evidence in this or any other
proceeding regarding this subject matter.
The Parties submit this Stipulation to the Commission and recommend approval
in its entirety pursuant to IDAPA 31.01.01.274. Parties shall support this Stipulation before
the Commission , and no Party shall appeal any portion of this Stipulation or Order approving
the same. If this Stipulation is challenged by any person not a party to the Stipulation, the
Parties to this Stipulation reserve the right to cross-examine witnesses and put on such case as
they deem appropriate to respond fully to the issues presented, including the right to raise
issues that are incorporated in the settlements embodied in this Stipulation. Notwithstanding
this reservation of rights , the Parties to this Stipulation agree that they will continue to support
the Commission s adoption of the terms of this Stipulation.
STIPULA nON - Page 3
Portlnd3-1530490,l 0020017-00072
- -~-'--
In the event the Commission rejects any part or all of this Stipulation , or
imposes any additional material conditions on approval of this Stipulation, each Party reserves
the right , upon written notice to the Commission and the other Party to this proceeding, within
IS days of the date of such action by the Commission, to withdraw from this Stipulation. In
such case, no Party shall be bound or prejudiced by the terms of this Stipulation , and each
Party shall be entitled to seek reconsideration of the Commission s order, file testimony as it
chooses , cross-examine witnesses, and do all other things necessary to put on such case as it
deems appropriate. In such case, the Parties immediately will request the prompt reconvening
of a prehearing conference for purposes of establishing a procedural schedule for the
completion of the case. The Parties agree to cooperate in development of a schedule that
concludes the proceeding on the earliest possible date, taking into account the needs of the
Parties in participating in hearings and preparing briefs.
The Parties agree that this Stipulation is in the public interest and that all of its
terms and conditions are fair , just and reasonable.
No Party shall be bound, benefited or prejudiced by any position asserted in the
negotiation of this Stipulation, except to the extent expressly stated herein, nor shall this
Stipulation be construed as a waiver of the rights of any Party unless such rights are expressly
waived herein. Execution of this Stipulation shall not be deemed to constitute an
acknowledgment by any Party of the validity or invalidity of any particular method, theory or
principle of regulation or cost recovery. No Party shall be deemed to have agreed that any
method, theory or principle of regulation or cost recovery employed in arriving at this
Stipulation is appropriate for resolving any issues in any other proceeding in the future.
findings of fact or conclusions of law other than those stated herein shall be deemed to be
implicit in this Stipulation.
STIPULATION - Page 4
Portlnd3-1530490, I 0020017-00072
The obligations of the Parties under this Stipulation are subject to the
Commission s approval of this Stipulation in accordance with its tenns and conditions and upon
such approval being upheld on appeal by a court of competent jurisdiction.
Respectfully submitted this /2- y of October, 2005.
lli
Jame
Stoel Rives LLP
Attorneys for PacifiCorp
TIC L.
Racine, Olson, Nye, Budge & Bailey, Chartered
Attorney for Idaho Irrigation Pumpers
Association, Inc.
PacifiCorp
STIPULATION - Page 5
Portlnd3-!530490,10020017-00072
-,--- -______, ,- -----~---
Option: 1
2 days per week , 6 hrs per day
2005 Credit
2006 Proposed Credit
Percent Change
Option:
2 days per week, 3 hrs per day
2005 Credit
2006 Proposed Credit
Percent Change
Option: 3
4 days per week, 3 hrs per day
2005 Credit
2006 Proposed Credit
Percent Change
Jun-
$2.
$3.
17%
Jun-
$1.
$1.47
17%
Jun-
$2.
$2.
16%
Jul-
$2.
$3.
27%
Jul-
$1.41
$1,
28%
Jul-
$2.
$3.
27%
Aug-
$2.
$3.
29%
Aug-
$1.
$1.
29%
Aug-
$2.
$3.
29%
-" ,-,------
APPENDIX A
Page 1 of
Sep-
$0.
$1.
48%
Sep-
$0.
$0.47
50%
Sep-
$0.
$0.
50%
'--,----
PROOF OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this 14th day of October, 2005 I caused to be served, via
Federal Express, a true and correct copy of the Stipulation regarding Irrigation Load control
Credit Rider (Schedule 72).
IDAHO IRRIGATION PUMPERS
ASSOCIATION, INC;
Eric L. Olsen
Racine, Olson, Nye, Budge
Bailey, Chartered
201 E. Center
O. Box 1391
Pocatello, ill 83204-1391
MONSANTO
Randall Budge
Racine, Olson, Nye, Budge
Bailey, Chartered
201 E. Center
O. Box 1391
Pocatello, ill 83204-1391
Scott Woodbury
Idaho Public Utilities Commission
472 W. Washington
Boise, ID 83702-5983
Kira Pfisterer
Idaho Public Utilities Commission
472 W. Washington
Boise, ID 83702-5983
James R. Smith
Monsanto Company
Highway 34 North
Soda Springs, ID 83276
Anthony Yankel
29814 Lake Road
Bay Village, OH 44140
Conley E. Ward
Givens Pursley LLP
601 W. Bannock St.
Boise, ID 83702
Dennis E. Peseau
Utility Resources, Inc.
1500 Liberty St. SE, Suite 250
Salem, OR 97302
Timothy J. Shurtz
411 S. Main
Firth, ID 83236
Brady M. Purdy
Attorney At Law
2019 N. 17th Street
Boise, ID 83702
- ------- -- -____- -- -,
R. Scott Pasley
Assistant General Counsel
R. Simplot Company
999 Main Street
Boise, ill 83702
David Hawk
Director, Energy Natural Resources
R. Simplot Company
999 Main Street
Boise, ill 83702
Katie Iverson
17244 W. Cordova Court
Surprise 85387
Joe Lecki
Idaho Public Utilities Commission
472 W. Washington
Boise, ill 83702-5983
Peggy R
Regulatory Operations Coordinator
ATTACHMENT
(17 PAGES)
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'
FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS
CASE NO. P AC-O7-
PERIOD
2007/07/02:03:00:00PM
2007/07/03:03:00:00PM
2007/07/05:03:00:00PM
2007/07/06:03:00:00PM
2007/07/09:03:00:00PM
2007/07/10:03:00:00PM
2007/07/11 :03:00:00PM
2007/07/12:03:00:00PM
2007/07/13:03:00:00PM
2007/07/16:03:00:00PM
2007/07/17:03:00:00PM
2007/07/18:03:00:00PM
2007/07/19:03:00:00PM
2007/07/20:03:00:00PM
2007/07/23:03:00:00PM
2007/07/24:03:00:00PM
2007/07/25:03:00:00PM
2007/07/26:03:00:00PM
2007/07/27:03:00:00PM
2007/07/30:03:00:00PM
2007/07/31 :03:00:00PM
2007/07/02:04:00:00PM
2007/07/03:04:00:00PM
2007/07/05:04:00:00PM
2007/07/06:04:00: OOPM
2007/07/09:04:00:00PM
2007/07/10:04: 00:00PM
2007/07/11 :04:00:00PM
2007/07/12:04:00:00PM
2007/07/13:04:00:00PM
2007/07/16:04:00:00PM
2007/07/17:04:00:00PM
2007/07/18:04:00:00PM
2007/07/19:04:00:00PM
2007/07/20:04:00:00PM
2007/07/23:04:00:00PM
2007/07/24:04:00:00PM
2007/07/25:04:00:00PM
2007/07/26:04: 00: OOPM
2007/07/27:04:00:00PM
2007/07/30:04:00:00PM
2007/07/31 :04:00:00PM
2007/07/02:05:00:00PM
2007/07/03:05:00:00PM
2007/07/05:05:00:00PM
2007/07/06:05:00:00PM
2007/07/09:05:00:00PM
2007/07/10:05:00:00PM
2007/07/11 :05:00:00PM
2007/07/12:05:00:00PM
2007/07/13:05:00:00PM
BUBBLE
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
Pal
PRICE SUM HULL
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132,88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132,88 HLH
132.88 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132,26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
132.26 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130,12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
$/MWH Economic Value
67 8902.96 $5,735,485.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902.
8902,
8902,
8902.
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861 .42
8861.42
8861 .42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861 .42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8861.42
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718,
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
2007/07/16:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/17:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/19:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/23:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/24:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/25:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/26:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/27:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/30:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/31 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:03:00:00PM Pal
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
130.12 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
125.68 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123,99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123,99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8718.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8420.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307,
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
2007/08/24:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/02:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/03:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/05:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/06:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/09:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/10:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/11 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/12:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/13:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/16:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/17:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/19:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/23:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/24:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/25:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/26:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/27:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/30:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/31 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/02:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/03:06:00:00PM Pal
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.99 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
123.42 HLH
122.97 HLH
122,97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122,97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122,97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
122.97 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8307.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269,
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269,
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8269.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238.
8238,
8238.
8238.
8238.
8102.
8102,
2007/07/05:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/06:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/09:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/10:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/11 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/12:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/13:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/16:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/17:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/19:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/23:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/24:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/25:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/26:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/27:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/30:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/31 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:06:00:00PM Pal
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120,94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
120.94 HLH
118.HLH
118.6HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.6HLH
118.HLH
118.6HLH
118.HLH
118.6HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118,6HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
118.HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
115.2 HLH
115.HLH
115.HLH
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102,
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102.
8102,
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.2
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.2
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946.
7946,
7946.
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
2007/08/15:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/0,1 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/08:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/14:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/22:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/25:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/26:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/27:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/28:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/29:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/02:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/03:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/06:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/07:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/08:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/09:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/10:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/13:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/14:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/15:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/16:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/17:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/20:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/21 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/22:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/23:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/24:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
115.2 HLH
113,56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113,56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113,56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113,56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
113.56 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111,38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7718.4
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7608.
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
2007/08/27:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/28:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/29:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/30:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/31 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/06/01 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/08:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/14:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/22:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/25:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/26:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/27:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/28:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/29:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/02:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/03:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/05:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/06:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/09:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/10:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/11 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/12:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/13:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/16:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/17:01:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/19:01:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/23:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/24:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/25:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/26:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/27:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/30:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/31:01:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/01 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:06:00:00PM Pal
111.38 HLH
111,38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.38 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.37 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111,04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111,04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111,04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111.04 HLH
111,04 HLH
111.04 HLH
110,03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7462.46
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7461.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439,
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7439.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
2007/06/08:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/14:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/22:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/25:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/26:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/27:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/28:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/29:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/02:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/03:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/05:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/06:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/09:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/10:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/11 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/12:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/13:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/16:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/17:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/19:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/23:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/24:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/25:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/26:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/27:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/30:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/31:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21 :02:00:00PM Pal
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110.03 HLH
110,03 HLH
110.03 HLH
109.98 HLH
109.98 HLH
109.98 HLH
109.98 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109,2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
109.2 HLH
108.16 HLH
108.16 HLH
108.16 HLH
108,16 HLH
106.91 HLH
106.91 HLH
106.91 HLH
106.91 HLH
105.97 HLH
105.97 HLH
105.97 HLH
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7372.
7368.
7368.
7368.
7368.
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7316.4
7246.
7246.
7246.
7246.
7162.
7162,
7162,
7162.
7099.
7099.
7099.
2007/07/28:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/04:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/11 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/18:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/25:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/04:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/11 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/18:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/25:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/01 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/08:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/14:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/22:03:00:00PM Pal
105.97 HLH
105.53 HLH
105.53 HLH
105.53 HLH
105.53 HLH
105.46 HLH
105.46 HLH
105.46 HLH
105.46 HLH
105.34 HLH
105,34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.34 HLH
105.31 HLH
105.31 HLH
105.31 HLH
105.31 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105,12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105,12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105,12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
7099.
7070.
7070.
7070.
7070.
7065.
7065.
7065.
7065.
7057.
7057.
7057,
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057.
7057,
7057.
7057.
7057,
7057.
7057.
7055.
7055.
7055.
7055.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
2007/06/25:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/26:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/27:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/28:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/29:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/04:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/11 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/18:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/25:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/04:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/11 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/18:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/25:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/02:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/03:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/05:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/06:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/09:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/10:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/11 :12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/12:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/13:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/16:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/17:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/19:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/23:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/24:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/25: 12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/26:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/27:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/30:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/31 :12:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/01 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/08:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/14:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/22:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/25:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/26:07:00:00PM Pal
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.12 HLH
105.11 HLH
105.11 HLH
105.11 HLH
105.11 HLH
104.56 HLH
104.56 HLH
104.56 HLH
104.56 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104,38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
104.38 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7043.
7042.
7042.
7042.
7042.
7005.
7005.
7005.
7005.
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46 '
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6993.46
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
2007/06/27:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/28:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/29:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/14:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/21 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/28:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/07:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28: 12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31:12:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/01 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/04:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/08:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/15:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/22:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/29:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/04:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/05:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/06:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/07:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/10:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/11 :03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/12:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/13:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/14:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/17:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/18:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/19:03:00:00PM Pal
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
103.29 HLH
101.38 HLH
101.38 HLH
101.38 HLH
101.38 HLH
100.75 HLH
100,75 HLH
100.75 HLH
100.75 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98,15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.15 HLH
98.02 LLH
98.02 LLH
98.02 LLH
98.02 LLH
98.02 LLH
98.02 LLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97,85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
6920.43
6920.43
6920.43
6792.46
6792.46
6792.46
6792.46
6750.
6750.
6750.
6750.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576,
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6576.
6567.
6567,
6567.
6567.
6567.
6567.
6555,
6555.
6555,
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
2007/09/20:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/21:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/24:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/25:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/26:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/27:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/28:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/04:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/05:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/06:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/07:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/10:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/11 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/12:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/13:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/14:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/17:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/18:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/19:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/20:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/21 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/24:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/25:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/26:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/27:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/28:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/01 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/04:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/08:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/15:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/22:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/29:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/01 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:08:00:00PM Pal
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.85 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97,52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.52 HLH
97.29 HLH
97.29 HLH
97.29 HLH
97.29 HLH
96.97 LLH
96.97 LLH
96,97 LLH
96.97 LLH
96.97 LLH
96.97 LLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96,59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96,59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96,59 HLH
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6555.
6533.
6533,
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533,
6533.
6533.
6533.
6533.
6518.43
6518.43
6518.43
6518.43
6496.
6496.
6496.
6496.
6496.
6496.
6471.
6471,
6471.
6471.
6471,
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
2007/08/23:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/01 :04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/04:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/08:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/15:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/22:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/29:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/04:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/05:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/06:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/07:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/10:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/11 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/12:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/13:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/14:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/17:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/18:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/19:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/20:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/21 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/24:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/25:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/26:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/27:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/28:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/04:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/11 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/18:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/25:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/05:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/12:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/19:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/26:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/04:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/05:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/06:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/07:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/10:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/11 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/12:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/13:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/14:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/17:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/18:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/19:05:00:00PM Pal
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96.59 HLH
96,59 HLH
96.29 LLH
96.29 LLH
96.29 LLH
96.29 LLH
96.29 LLH
96.29 LLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15HLH
96,15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
96.15 HLH
95.96 HLH
95.96 HLH
95.96 HLH
95.96 HLH
95.42 LLH
95.42 LLH
95.42 LLH
95.42 LLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6471.
6451.43
6451 .43
6451.43
6451.43
6451.43
6451 .43
6442,
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442,
6442,
6442.
6442,
6442.
6442.
6442.
6442.
6429.
6429.
6429.
6429.
6393,
6393.
6393.
6393.
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
2007/09/20:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/21 :05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/24:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/25:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/26:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/27:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/28:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/05:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/12:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/19:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/26:03:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/02:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/03:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/05:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/06:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/09:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/10:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/11 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/12:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/13:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/16:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/17:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/18:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/19:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/20:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/23:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/24:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/25:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/26:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/27:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/30:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/31 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/01 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/04:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/08:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/15:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/22:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/29:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/05:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/12:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/19:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/26:04:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/07:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/14:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/21:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/28:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/01 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/04:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/08:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/15:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/22:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/29:06:00:00PM Pal
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95,23 HLH
95.23 HLH
95.23 HLH
9523 HLH
95.23 HLH
94.4 LLH
94.4 LLH
94.4 LLH
94.4 LLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.34 HLH
94.09 LLH
94.09 LLH
94.09 LLH
94.09 LLH
94.09 LLH
94.09 LLH
93.78 LLH
93.78 LLH
93.78 LLH
93.78 LLH
93,03 HLH
93.03 HLH
93.03 HLH
93,03 HLH
92,74 LLH
92,74 LLH
92.74 LLH
92.74 LLH
92.74 LLH
92.74 LLH
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6380.41
6324.
6324.
6324.
6324.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320,
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6320.
6304.
6304.
6304.
6304.
6304.
6304.
6283.
6283.
6283.
6283.
6233.
6233.
6233.
6233.
6213,
6213.
6213.
6213.
6213.
6213.
2007/09/04:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/05:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/06:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/07:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/10:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/11 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/12:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/13:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/14:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/17:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/18:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/19:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/20:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/21 :06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/24:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/25:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/26:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/27:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/28:06:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/05:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/12:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/19:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/26:05:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/05:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/12:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/19:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/26:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/01 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/08:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/14:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21 :08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/22:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/25:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/26:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/27:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/28:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/29:08:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/05:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/12:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/19:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/26:07:00:00PM Pal
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92,HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92.HLH
92,HLH
92.57 LLH
92.57 LLH
92.57 LLH
92.57 LLH
92.23 LLH
92.23 LLH
92.23 LLH
92.23 LLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92,02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92,02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
92.02 HLH
91.76 LLH
91.76 LLH
91.76 LLH
91.76 LLH
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.2
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.
6204.2
6204,
6204.
6202,
6202.
6202,
6202.
6179.41
6179.41
6179.41
6179.41
6165.
6165.
6165,
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165,
6165,
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165,
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165.
6165.
6147.
6147.
6147.
6147.
2007/08/04:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/11 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/18:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/25:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/09/04:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/05:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/06:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/07:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/10:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/11 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/12:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/13:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/14:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/17:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/18:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/19:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/20:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/21 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/24:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/25:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/26:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/27:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/09/28:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/01 :01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/04:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/08:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/15:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/22:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/07/29:01 :OO:OOPM Pal
2007/08/01 :09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/02:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/03:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/06:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/07:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/08:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/09:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/10:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/13:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/14:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/15:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/16:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/17:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/20:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/21 :09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/22:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/23:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/24:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/27:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/28:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/29:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/30:09:00:00PM Pal
2007/08/31 :09:00:00PM Pal
91.73 HLH
91.73 HLH
91.73 HLH
91.73 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91,56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91,56 HLH
91,56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
91.56 HLH
90.73 LLH
90.73 LLH
90.73 LLH
90.73 LLH
90.73 LLH
90.73 LLH
90,5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90,5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90,5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90,5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90.5 HLH
90,5 HLH
6145.
6145.
6145.
6145.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134,
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134,
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6134.
6078.
6078.
6078.
6078.
6078.
6078.
6063,
6063.
6063,
6063.
6063.
6063,
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063,
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063.
6063,
2007/07/01 :07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/04:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/08:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/15:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/22:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/07/29:07:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/01 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/04:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/05:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/06:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/07:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/08:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/11 :02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/12:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/13:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/1jt:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/15:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/18:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/19:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/20:02:00:00PM Pal
2007/06/21 :02:00:00PM Pal
90.1 LLH
90.1 LLH
90.1 LLH
90.1 LLH
90.1 LLH
90.1 LLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89,84 HLH
89,84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
89.84 HLH
6036.
6036.
6036.
6036.
6036.
6036.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.
6019.28
Month HL$LL$on-peak hours Average on-peak price
1/1/2007 50.40.45.416 20800 68.
2/1/2007 50.40.45.384 19392
3/1/2007 51.39.46.432 22032
4/1/2007 54.35.46.400 21800 120.
5/1/2007 64.39.53.47 416 26624
6/1/2007 75.45.62.416 31200 System Integrity Value
7/1/2007 94.55.77.400 37630 $98,185.
8/1/2007 92.54.76,432 39873,
9/1/2007 79.53.68.384 30672
10/1/2007 65.51.59.42 432 28317.
11/1/2007 67.53.46 61.400 27048
12/1/2007 73.57.66.400 29532
68.sum:912 334 921
ATTACHMENT
(1 PAGE)
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'
FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS
CASE NO. PAC-O7-
Page 1.
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER
STATE OF IDAHO
Normalized Results of Operations
12 Months Ended December 2006 with Known and Measurables
(1) December 2006 Rolled-In Revenue Requirement
(2) Rate Mitigation Cap
(3) Capped Revised Protocol Revenue Requirement
(4) Normalized December 2006 General Business Revenues
(5) Capped Revised Protocol Price Change
(A)(B)
Case Proposed
OriQinal FilinQ by Staff
194 215 986 187 104 796
101,67%101,67%
197 459,393 190,229,447
178,992 843 178,992 843
18,466,550 11,236,604
Line
No,
Revised Protocol
(6) Filed Revised Protocol Revenue Requirement
(7) Normalized December 2006 General Business Revenues
(8) Revised Protocol Price Change
(9) Capped Revised Protocol Price Change
(10) Reduction to Revised Protocol Revenue Requirement
201 020 661
178,992 843
027 818
18,466,550
(3,561,268)
193 808 268
178,992 843
815,425
236,604
(3,578,821 )
Capped Revenue Requirement Increase as a Percentage of Line 7 10,32%28%1
Staff witness Harms
PAC-07-
Capped Revenue Requirement Exhibit and WP
NON-CONFIDENTIAL
TT A CHMENT
(5 PAGES)
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'
FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS
CASE NO. P AC-O7-
PAC-07-05/Rocky Mountain Power
September 13 , 2007
IPUC Production Data Request 56
IPUC Production Data Request 56
Please provide a summary of all green tag or Renewable Energy Credit (REC)
purchases or sales for the Wolverine Creek, Marengo, Leaning Juniper and
Goodnoe Hills projects. For each project and for each purchase or sale, list the
date of the transaction, the quantity of green tags or RECs purchased or sold, the
price and the term of the purchase or sale. Please compare the actual purchase or
sale price of the green tags or RECs to the price assumed in the economic analysis
for the project.
Response to IPUC Production Data Request 56
Please refer to Attachment IPUC Production 56.
(Paul 1. Johnson prepared this response and is the recordholder. It has not been
determined who will sponsor this response at hearing. Please contact Brian
Dickman at 801-220-4975 to discuss this response.
At
t
a
c
h
m
e
n
t
I
P
U
G
Pr
o
d
u
c
t
i
o
n
5
6
Le
a
n
i
n
g
J
u
n
i
p
e
r
12
/
2
8
/
0
6
Sa
l
e
01
/
2
4
/
0
7
Sa
l
e
04
/
0
6
/
0
7
Sa
l
e
Wo
l
v
e
r
i
n
e
G
r
e
e
k
01
/
1
8
/
0
7
Sa
l
e
04
/
0
6
/
0
7
Sa
l
e
07
/
0
2
/
0
7
Sa
l
e
07
/
0
5
/
0
7
Sa
l
e
Ma
r
e
n
g
o
No
R
E
G
t
r
a
n
s
a
c
t
i
o
n
s
50
,
00
0
00
0
00
0
$4
,
$3
,
$2
,
04
5
60
,
00
0
00
0
50
0
$1
.
$2
,
$5
,
$5
,
Go
o
d
n
o
e
H
i
l
l
s
No
R
E
G
t
r
a
n
s
a
c
t
i
o
n
s
At
t
a
c
h
I
P
U
G
Pr
o
d
u
c
t
i
o
n
5
6
,
xi
s
Pa
g
e
1
o
f
1
va
l
u
e
a
ss
u
m
e
d
I
n
t
h
e
~c
o
n
o
m
i
c
a
n
a
l
y
s
i
s
f
o
r
t
h
e
p
r
o
j
e
c
"
,
($
/
R
E
G
)
$1
,
97
/
M
W
h
d
u
r
i
n
g
t
h
e
l
i
f
e
o
f
t
h
e
pr
o
j
e
c
t
(
\
e
v
e
l
i
z
e
d
v
a
l
u
e
o
f
$
5
/
M
W
h
fo
r
5
-
ea
r
s
Sa
m
e
a
s
a
b
o
v
e
Sa
m
e
a
s
a
b
o
v
e
$1
,
95
/
M
W
h
d
u
r
i
n
g
t
h
e
l
i
f
e
o
f
t
h
e
pr
o
j
e
c
t
(
I
e
v
e
l
i
z
e
d
v
a
l
u
e
o
f
$
5
/
M
W
h
fo
r
5
-
ye
a
r
s
)
Sa
m
e
a
s
a
b
o
v
e
Sa
m
e
a
s
a
b
o
v
e
Sa
m
e
a
s
a
b
o
v
e
MW
h
d
u
r
i
n
g
t
h
e
l
i
e
o
th
e
pr
o
j
e
c
t
(
I
e
v
e
l
i
z
e
d
v
a
l
u
e
o
f
$
5
/
M
W
h
fo
r
5
-
ye
a
r
s
)
Ja
n
u
a
r
y
t
o
J
u
n
e
2
0
0
6
Ju
l
y
t
o
D
e
c
e
m
b
e
r
2
0
0
6
Ja
n
u
a
r
y
t
o
J
u
n
e
2
0
0
7
Ju
l
y
t
o
D
e
c
e
m
b
e
r
2
0
0
6
Pr
e
s
e
n
t
v
a
l
u
e
r
e
v
e
n
u
e
r
e
q
u
i
r
e
m
e
n
t
of
$
0
i
f
t
h
e
v
a
l
u
e
o
f
R
E
G
s
o
r
t
h
e
co
s
t
o
f
c
o
m
p
l
i
a
n
c
e
w
i
t
h
r
e
n
e
w
a
b
l
e
po
r
t
f
o
l
i
o
s
t
a
n
d
a
r
d
s
r
i
s
e
t
o
ap
p
r
o
x
i
m
a
t
e
l
y
$
6
,
37
/
M
W
h
,
Rocky Mountain Power
New Generation Resource
Idaho GRC Revenue Requirement Impact
Leaning Juniper
Resource:
Additional Capacity :
In-Service Date:
Months In Test Period:
eaning Juniper Page Ref.
100,5 MW Nominal Rating
Sept 14, 2006 8,
Twelve
Maintenance Costs:304 000
Net Power Cost Savings:( 14 000 000)
Depreciation Rate
Annualized Depreciation Expense:
00%
017 370
Property Taxes:320 377
Capital Investment :11A.5.b (/ft.\r.l 175 434 259
Weighted for Months In-Service 100%
Monthly Weighted Investment 175 434 259
Depreciation Reserve:532 052)
Accumulated DIT Balance:736 234)
Net Rate Base 164 165 973
Interest Synch 045 904)
Renewable Energy Tax Credit 922 846)
Rev. Req. on Interest Exp / Tax Cr (12 650 176)
CWC and Bad Debt Impact (214 290)
Return on Investment 571 542
Test Period Revenue Requirement 348 823
Idaho Revenue Requirement 463 450
Idaho ECD Impact 773
Total Impact to Idaho 485 223
(1) Estimated based on -771 499 from page 8.6 annualized for 12 months
10.
estimate
estimate
(1 )
ROCK;! i"lountain Power
Exhibit No, 13 page 3 or
CASE NO, PAC-07-
Witness Steven R, McDougal
Rocky Mountain Power
New Generation Resource
Idaho GRC Revenue Requirement Impact
Marengo
Resource:
Additional Capacity:
In-Service Date:
Months In Test Period:
Maintenance Costs:
Net Power Cost Savings:
Depreciation Expense:
Property Taxes:
Capital I nvestment :
j ~
I AI I ?I~).I"'V //L\N
Weighted for Months In-Service
Monthly Weighted Investment
Depreciation Reserve:
Accumulated DIT Balance:
Net Rate Base
Interest Synch
Renewable Energy Tax Credit
Rev. Req. on Interest Exp Tax Cr
CWC and Bad Debt Impact
Return on Investment
Test Period Revenue Requirement
Idaho Revenue Requirement
Idaho ECDlmpact
Total Impact to Idaho
Marengo Page Ref.
140.4 MW Nominal Rating
August 1 , 2007 8,8.4
Five
168 000
(11 100 000)
309 023
822 796
258 541 351
41,67%
107,725 563
154 512)
270 634)
102 300,417
144 367)
(3,406 502)
(7,424 073)
(191 330)
065 510
649 926
167 116
516
174 632
10.
estimate
estimate
8.4
Rock;! Mounlain Power
Exhibit No, IJ page 2 of 5
CASE NO, PAC-07-
Witness Steven R, McDougal
Rocky Mountain Power
New Generation Resource
Idaho GRC Revenue Requirement Impact
Goodnoe Hills
Resource:
Additional Capacity :
I n-Service Date:
Months In Test Period:
Maintenance Costs:
Net Power Cost Savings:
Depreciation Expense:
Property Taxes:
Capital Investment:t z. 0;7 J ,1-0 /IL \H
Weighted for Months In-Service
Monthly Weighted Investment
Depreciation Reserve:
Accumulated DIT Balance:
Net Rate Base
Interest Synch
Renewable Energy Tax Credit
Rev, Req. on Interest Exp Tax Cr
CWC and Bad Debt Impact
Return on Investment
Test Period Revenue Requirement
Idaho Revenue Requirement
Idaho ECD Impact
Total Impact to Idaho
Goodnoe Hills Page Ref.
94 MW Nominal Rating
Nov 15 2007 8,4
One and a half
154 121
300 000)
982 862
187 675
196 572,406
13%
571 551
(491,431)
(746 012)
334 108
(717 211)
(546,454)
321 280)
(29 788)
208 258
881 847
613
700
313
10.
estimate
estimate
8,4
8.7
1'.ocky ,YlouniJin powe"
Exhiblc No /J page 4 0
CASE NO, PAC-O7-Witness Steven R, McDougal
ATTACHMENT
(3 PAGES)
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'
FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS
CASE NO. P AC-O7-
Rocky Mountain Power
Idaho Results of Operations December 2006
Impute Green Tag Revenue
PAGE
Adjustment to Revenue:
Miscellaneous Other Revenue
Miscellaneous Other Revenue
TOTAL IDAHO
ACCOUNT COMPANY FACTOR FACTOR %ALLOCATED REF#
456 SG-t 306%217 291445533
456 825 390 SG 306%053
270 923 269 344
Description of Adjustment:
This IPUC adjustment imputes revenue associated with the Company s Green Tags as discussed in Staff witness Carlock's testimony,
20
0
5
20
0
5
45
6
2
0
0
0
O
T
H
E
R
E
L
E
C
T
R
I
C
R
E
V
(
E
X
C
L
U
D
I
N
G
W
H
E
E
L
I
N
G
)
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
15
5
,
20
0
5
20
0
6
45
6
2
0
0
0
O
T
H
E
R
E
L
E
C
T
R
I
C
R
E
V
(
E
X
C
L
U
D
I
N
G
W
H
E
E
L
I
N
G
)
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
10
7
,
7
8
4
,
20
0
5
20
0
6
45
6
2
0
0
0
O
T
H
E
R
E
L
E
C
T
R
I
C
R
E
V
(
E
X
C
L
U
D
I
N
G
W
H
E
E
L
I
N
G
)
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
23
2
,
20
0
5
20
0
6
45
6
2
0
0
0
O
T
H
E
R
E
L
E
C
T
R
I
C
R
E
V
(
E
X
C
L
U
D
I
N
G
W
H
E
E
L
I
N
G
)
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
10
3
20
4
,
20
0
5
20
0
6
45
6
2
0
0
0
O
T
H
E
R
E
L
E
C
T
R
I
C
R
E
V
(
E
X
C
L
U
D
I
N
G
W
H
E
E
L
I
N
G
)
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
11
5
28
0
,
20
0
5
20
0
6
45
6
2
0
0
0
O
T
H
E
R
E
L
E
C
T
R
I
C
R
E
V
(
E
X
C
L
U
D
I
N
G
W
H
E
E
L
I
N
G
)
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
59
9
,
39
3
94
5
,
20
0
6
20
0
7
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
32
9
,
20
0
6
20
0
7
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
61
7
,
20
0
6
20
0
7
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
10
9
98
7
,
20
0
6
20
0
7
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
17
1
00
0
,
20
0
6
20
0
7
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
35
3
98
7
,
20
0
6
20
0
7
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
16
9
86
2
,
89
5
78
4
,
20
0
7
20
0
8
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
43
9
20
0
,
20
0
7
20
0
8
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
62
8
07
5
,
20
0
7
20
0
8
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
20
6
,
4
7
5
,
20
0
7
20
0
8
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
i
t
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
17
6
,
4
6
2
,
20
0
7
20
0
8
45
6
2
3
0
0
M
I
S
C
E
L
L
A
N
E
O
U
S
O
T
H
E
R
R
E
V
E
N
U
E
S
30
1
9
4
5
G
r
e
e
n
C
r
e
d
~
S
a
l
e
s
R
e
v
e
n
u
e
11
9
6
N
e
t
P
o
w
e
r
C
o
s
t
10
8
38
6
86
2
,
83
7
07
5
,
At
t
a
c
h
I
P
U
C
3
0
,
xl
s
Page 1 of
Terri Carlock
From: Dickman , Brian (Brian,Dickman~PacifiCorp,comJ
Sent: Thursday, September 13 2007 3:11 PMTo: Terri Carlock; Joe Leckie; Patricia Harms
Cc: Brown , Justin
Subject: On-site audit follow-up
A couple of follow-up items:
1 - The company booked $1 011 684,20 of green tag revenue (non-blue sky) received in 2006, The revenue is
booked in account 456,23 and allocated on an SG factor.
2 - The process to begin the auction for the Cottonwood coal lease is underway. It appears the auction will take
place at the end of September or beginning of October.
Brian
0 0 ,~ C
0 0
(.\J ~ 007 0 '
:;? , '
i' c:;
", ,
~ r 'J,
~ ., " .
-ry ;),0010 i i: ;
' .' ';, -
C) 1!r'5- 8 f. 5 J :3 ) (
! ,
rro~'r)()-
10/18/2007
ATTACHMENT
(1 PAGE)
STAFF'S RESPONSE TO
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'
FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS
CASE NO. PAC-O7-
Energy Central-Printer Friendly http://pro,energycentral. com/professionaJ/news/power/news -printer
.....' '" ,
:'10
.,,
' r
'" "'" '" "' (', "
~oj;'NER(:.","Y' "I~NrRAl,
' '
SS,,O'
, "..":,_
: E
~..
NAL
S&P: MidAmerican Energy Holdings Coo's Proposed $1 Billion Bonds Assigned
BB8+' Rating
SAN FRANCISCO Aug, 24, 2007--
Standard & Poor s Ratings Services today assigned its 'BBB+' rating to MidAmerican Energy Holdings Co.
(MEHC) $1 billion proposed senior unsecured bonds, due 2037. The outlook on MEHC's '' corporate credit
rating is stable,
The company s corporate credit rating incorporates its strong business risk , fairly aggressive financial profile
and both explicit and implicit support from Berkshire Hathaway," said Standard & Poor s credit analyst Anne
Selting. "The company s strong business profile reflects the significant diversity of its businesses, the continued
stable operations of its regulated businesses , a limited exposure to unregulated ventures , and our expectation
that its future acquisitions will be in the regulated utility segment"
Proceeds from the 144A issuance will be used to pre-fund $450 million and $550 million of senior unsecured
notes coming due in May and September 2008, respectively. Standard & Poor s expects that the proceeds will be
invested in U.S. Treasury securities or applied to payoff borrowings under MEHC's working capital revolver until
they are used to retire debt Although the proceeds are not scheduled to be used immediately, MEHC doesn
have other significant capital expenditure plans where these funds could be employed. Capital requirements at
MEHC's subsidiaries, such as PacifiCorp and MidAmerican Energy Co., will be funded at the subsidiary level.
TOP
Copyright ~ 1996-2007 by CyberTech, Inc,All rights reserved,
Energy CentralCID and Energy Central ProfessionalCID are registered trademarks of CyberTech , Incorporated, Data and
information is provided for informational purposes only, and is not intended for trading purposes. CyberTech does not
warrant that the information or services of Energy Central will meet any specific requirements; nor will it be error free or
uninterrupted; nor shall CyberTech be liable for any indirect, incidental or consequential damages (including lost data
information or profits) sustained or incurred in connection with the use of, operation of, or inability to use Energy Central.
Other terms of use may apply, Membership information is confidential and subject to our privacy aqreement
1 of 1 8/30/:2007 :2::2:2
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE THIS 23RD DAY OF OCTOBER 2007
SERVED THE FOREGOING COMMISSION STAFF'S RESPONSE TO PACIFICORP
DBA ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER'S FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS TO
STAFF, IN CASE NO. PAC-07-, BY MAILING A COpy THEREOF, POSTAGE
PREPAID, TO THE FOLLOWING:
JUSTIN BROWN
BRIAN DICKMAN
ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER
201 S MAIN ST STE 2300
SALT LAKE CITY UT 84111
MAIL: justin.brown~pacificorp.com
brian. dickman~JJacificorp. com
DATA REQUEST RESPONSE CENTER
ACIFICORP
825 NE MULTNOMAH STE 2000
PORTLAND OR 97232
MAIL: datarequest~pacificorp. com
(ELECTRONIC COPIES ONLY)
JAMES R SMITH
MONSANTO COMPANY
PO BOX 816
SODA SPRINGS ID 83276
MAIL: iim.smith~monsanto.com
ERIC L OLSEN
RACINE OLSON NYE BUDGE & BAILEY
PO BOX 1391
POCATELLO ID 83201-1391
E- MAIL: elo~racinelaw .net
CONLEY E WARD
MICHAEL C CREAMER
GIVENS PURSLEY LLP
PO BOX 2720
BOISE ID 83701-2720
MAIL: cew~givenspursley.com
KATHERINE A. McDOWELL
McDOWELL & RACKNER
520 SOUTHWEST SIXTH AVE STE 830
PORTLAND OR 97204
MAIL: katherine~mcd-law.com
RANDALL C BUDGE
RACINE OLSON NYE BUDGE & BAILEY
PO BOX 1391
POCATELLO ID 83201-1391
MAIL: rcb~racinelaw.net
MAURICE BRUBAKER
KATIE IVERSON
BRUBAKER & ASSOCIATES
1215 FERN RIDGE PARKWAY STE208
ST LOUIS MO 63141
MAIL: mbrubaker~consu1tbai.com
ki verson~consul tb ai. com
ANTHONY Y ANKEL
29814 LAKE ROAD
BAY VILLAGE OH 44140
MAIL: ton v~yanke1.net
DENNIS E PESEAU, Ph.
UTILITY RESOURCES INC
1500 LIBERTY ST SE STE 250
SALEM OR 97302
MAIL: dpeseau~excite.com
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
BRAD M PURDY
ATTORNEY AT LAW
2019 N 17TH STREET
BOISE ID 83702
MAIL: bmpurdy~hotmail.com
KEVIN B HOMER
ATTORNEY AT LAW
1565 SOUTH BOULEVARD
IDAHO FALLS ID 83404
MAIL: kbh~khomer1aw.com
TIMOTHY SHURTZ
411 S. MAIN
FIRTH ID 83236
MAIL: tim~idahosupreme. com
f/ibrY'-SECRET Y
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE