20170503Stipulation and Motion.pdf

<Em*
An loAcofP company
?il l.l Ftti
IVED
P 5lLISA D. NORDSTROTTI
Lead Counsel
[e-mail]
LDN/KKt
Enclosures
X,r*d@
Lisa D. Nordstrom
May 3, 2017
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Diane Hanian, Secretary
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
Re: Case No. IPC-E-16-24
Recovery of Costs Associated with North Valmy Power Plant
Settlement Stipulation and Motion to Approve Seftlement Stipulation
Dear Ms. Hanian:
Enclosed for filing in the above mafter are an original and seven (7) copies of a
Settlement Stipulation and Motion to Approve Settlement Stipulation.
Very truly youfti,
LISA D. NORDSTROM (!SB No. 5733)
ldaho Power Company
1221West ldaho Street (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, ldaho 83707
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
I no rd strom @ ida hopower. co m
Attomey for ldaho Power Company
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION
OF IDAHO POWER COMPANY FOR
AUTHORIry TO INCREASE ITS RATES
FOR ELECTRIC SERVICE TO RECOVER
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE NORTH
VALMY PLANT
CASE NO. !PC-E-16-24
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND
MOTION TO APPROVE
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION
a. rlu,' .,1 I
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
ldaho Power Company ("ldaho Powe/' or "Company") requests that the ldaho
Public Utilities Commission ("Commission") approve the settlement stipulation
("Settlement Stipulation") contained in this filing. The Settlement Stipulation contains
the following provisions related to the Company's North Valmy power plant ("Valmy"):
(1) a levelized ldaho jurisdictional revenue increase of $13,285,285 effective June 1,
2017, to recover Valmy related revenue requirements through 2028, (2) a balancing
account to track the incremental costs and benefits associated with the accelerated
Valmy end-of-life date, (3) regulatory accounts, including regulatory assets, to facilitate
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles ("GAAP"), (4) a process to review the
prudency of expenditures following the closure of each generation unit, and (5) the
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 1
settlement of all issues in ldaho Powe/s pending depreciation docket, Case No. IPC-E-
16-23.
The Settlement Stipulation is entered into between ldaho Power, Commission
Staff ("Staff'), the ldaho !nigation Pumpers Association, !nc. ('llPA'), Micron
Technology, !nc. ("Micron"), the U.S. Department of Energy and Federa! Executive
Agencies ("DOE'), the ldaho Conservation League ("lCL") and Sierra Club, and the
Industrial Customers of ldaho Power ("lClP"), hereafter jointly refened to as "Parties."
I.
1. The terms and conditions of this Seftlement Stipulation are set forth
herein. The Parties agree that this Settlement Stipulation represents a fair, just, and
reasonable compromise of the dispute(s) between the Parties, and that this Settlement
Stipulation is in the public interest. The Parties maintain that the Settlement Stipulation
as a whole and its acceptance by the Commission, if it is accepted, represent a
reasonable resolution of all issues between the Parties identified herein. Therefore, the
Parties hereby respectfully move the Commission, in accordance with RP 56 and RP
274-76, for an order approving the Settlement Stipulation executed between the Parties
and all of its terms and conditions without material change or condition, and closing the
cunent proceeding.
II. BACKGROUND
2. On October 21, 2016, ldaho Power Company filed an Application in this
case requesting Gommission authorization to accelerate the depreciation schedule for
Valmy to: (1) allow the plant to be fully depreciated by December 31 ,2025i (2) establish
a balancing account to track the incremental costs and benefits associated with the
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 2
accelerated Valmy end-of-life date, and (3) adjust customer rates to recover the
associated incremental annual levelized revenue requirement of $28.50 million with an
effective date of June 1, 2017. The result of this Application would have resulted in an
overall increase of 2.51 percent.
3. The Company concunently filed an Application in Case No. !PC-E-16-23
asking the Commission to adopt revised depreciation rates for its electric plant-in-
service and correspondingly adjust ldaho jurisdictional base rates, also with an effective
date of June 1, 2017. The result of that proposed adjustment would have resulted in an
overal! rate increase of 0.59 percent.
4. In November 2016, the Commission issued an Order providing Notice of
the Application and setting a deadline for interventions. Order No. 33650.
Subsequently, the Commission granted Petitions to lntervene from !lPA, Micron, ICL
and Sierra Club, DOE, and lClP. Order Nos. 33660, 33671 ,33672,33674, and 33746.
5. The Parties met on February 2,2017, and April 12, 2017, for settlement
discussions regarding rate issues related to the Gompany's North Valmy power plant.
Based upon these settlement discussions, as a compromise of the respective positions of
the Parties, and for other considerations as set forth below, the Parties agree to the
following terms:
III. TERMS OF THE SETTLEMENT STIPUI.ATION
6. ldaho Jurisdictional Revenue Requirement. The Parties agree to an ldaho
jurisdictiona! revenue increase of $13,285,285, to be recovered from all customer classes
through a uniform percentage increase to all base rate components except the service
charge effective June 1, 2017. lf this Settlement Stipulation is approved by the
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 3
Commission, the amount all Idaho customer classes pay for electric service will increase
by $t3.3 million which equates to an overall increase of 1.17 percent as set forth in
Attachment 1. This levelized adjustment incorporates cunent Valmy investments,
prcjected additions to the Valmy plant for Unit 1 in 2017 through 2019, cunent and future
non-fuel operations and maintenance ('O&M') savings (difference between costs
embedded in base rates and actuaUforecasted costs) beginning June 1 , 2017, until Valmy
operation is no longer reflected in base rates, and the projected decommissioning costs
(exclud ing contingency estimates).
7. Accountinq Order. To accomplish a levelized revenue requirement
collection period beyond the operational Iife of the plant, the Parties agree to support the
issuance of an accounting oder that allows ldaho Power to make all needed accounting
entries, including establishing regulatory asset accounts, that would allow for the matching
of GAAP revenue recognition with the actual monthly pattem of the Valmy revenue
requirement from 2017 through 2028. These adjustments will not have any future effect
on customer rates for the existing Valmy capita! investment but will a!!ow the Company to
match revenues with the costs that it is incuning over the next 11 years. Attachment 2
contains illustrative examples of the regulatory accounts and estimated adjustments based
on the analysis agreed to in this Seftlement Stipulation.
8. lncome Tax Accountino. lncome tax calculations for this settlement reflect
the new recovery period through 2028 and maintain compliance with the lntemal Revenue
Code ("lRC") normalization rules for accelerated depreciation. Because the Company
does not cunently track accumulated defened income taxes ('ADIT') and reversing flow-
through dffierences by specific plant, such as Valmy, the Company used a tax accounting
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION .4
system generated estimated amount of ADIT for the numbers included in the 2011 test
year for Valmy, as well as for the beginning balance of ADIT for rcvenue requirement
computations in the original filing and this Settlement Stipulation. The Parties agree that
acceptance of the income tax calculations in this settlement also rcquires the recognition
that the balance of ADIT and reversing flow through related to the thermal plant tax
accounting group, after removing Valmy, will be used in future rate proceedings for the
other thermal plants (mainly the Jim Bridger plant), including general rate cases.
9. Additional Reoulatorv Accounts. While the actual target shutdown date is
estimatedtobeattheendof 2019 forValmyUnitl andend of 2O2SforValmyUnit2,the
Parties agree to treat the shutdown year of both units as the end of 2028 for ratemaking
purposes. Because GAAP and IRC rules, including normalization, will require the
Company to make income tax filings and accounting entries consistent with the economics
that actually occur rather than the 2028 assumption the revenue requirement is based on,
the Parties support authorization of regulatory accounts to adjust the financial statement
impacts resulting from the timing of Valmy-related depreciation and income tax and GAAP
results as compared to the 2028 ratemaking assumption. Attachment 3 contains
illustrative examples of the regulatory accounts and estimated adjustments based on the
analysis agreed to in this Settlement Stipulation.
10. Continued Evaluation of Unit Closures. ldaho Power will conduct ongoing
analyses to evaluate the economics of a Unit 2 retirement and submit the results as part of
its lntegrated Resource Plan.
11. Unit Closure Neqotiations with NV Enerov. The parties agree that ldaho
Power shall use prudent and commercially reasonable efforts to accomplish the following:
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 5
a. Reach an agreement with Valmy @-owner NV Eneryy to amend the
North Valmy ownership and operating agreement to provide that (i) North Valmy Unit 1
shall permanently cease buming coal on or before December 31,2019, and (ii) North
Valmy Unit 2 shal! permanently @ase buming coalon or before December 31,2025;or
b. ln the absence of pamgraph 11.a above, ldaho Power will end its
participation in the operation of Valmy Unit 1 by December 31 ,2019, and Valmy Unit 2 by
December 31,2025.
12. Status Report on Neqotiations. ldaho Power Gompany shall file with the
Commission and parties in this proceeding a status report on the results of negotiations
described in paragraph 1 1 with NV Energy on or before December 31, 2017. Parties
agree to file comments in response to the above-referenced 2017 year-end report no later
than March 31,2018.
13. Unit Closure Prudence Reviews and Cost Recoverv. ldaho Power agrees to
the following:
a. 2020 Adjustment to Base Rafes: On or before December 31,2019,
ldaho Power shallfile an application with the Commission that seeks a prudence review of
the actions taken to date by the Company in pursuit of the rcsults listed in paragraph 11
including, if applicable, any future ongoing operating, maintenance, and fuel costs
associated with the operation of North Valmy Unit 1 beyond 2019. Absent an earlier
review, ldaho Powerwill seek a2020 adjustmentto base ratesthat includes: (1) Unit 1
prudence review and forecast-to-actual adjustment of 2017-2019 incremental investments,
(2) Unit 2 prudence review and potential inclusion of 2017-2019 incrementa! investments,
(3) Unit 1 and Unit 2 forecast-to-actual adjustmentot 2017-2019 (base v. forecasted) O&M
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 6
savings, and (4) Unit 2 closure validation study to evaluate a least cosUleast risk closure
date and potential inclusion of forecasted 2O2O-2O25 incremental investments. ldaho
Power acknowledges as a provision of this Settlement Stipulation that the Commission
may, as a result of its prudence review, conclude that the future operating costs of North
Valmy Unit 1 are no longer recoverable through customers' rates beyond December 31,
2019, other than such costs as the Commission shall determine are necessary and
prudent in order to obtain the results described in paragraph 11 and for the continued
provision of reliable power to ldaho Powe/s customers; and
b. 2026 Adjustment to Base Rafes: On or before December 31, 2025,
Idaho Power shall file an application with the Commission that seeks a prudence review of
the actions taken to date by the Company in pursuit of the results listed in paragraph 11
including, if applicable, any future ongoing operating, maintenance, and fue! costs
associated with the operation of North Valmy Unit 2 beyond 2025. Absent an earlier
review, following the closure of Valmy Unit 2 at the end of 2025, ldaho Power will seek a
2026 adjustment to base rates that includes: (1) a Unit 2 prudence review and forecast-to-
actual adjustment of 2020-2025 incremental investments, (2) a forecast-to-actual
adjustment of 2020-2025 (base v. forecasted) O&M savings associated with Valmy, and
(3) a Unit 1 and Unit 2 prudence review and forecast-to-actual adjustment of
decommissioning costs to the extent actuals are available. ldaho Power acknowledges as
a provision of this Stipulation that the Commission may, as a result of its prudence review,
conclude that the operating costs of North Valmy Unit 2 are no longer recoverable through
customers' rates beyond December 31, 2025, other than such costs as the Gommission
shall determine are necessary and prudent in order to obtain the results described in
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 7
paragraph 11 and for the continued provision of reliable power to ldaho Powe/s
customers.
c. The exclusion of North Valmy costs in subparagraphs (a) and (b)
above shall not prevent ldaho Power from seeking to re@ver in rates the depreciation
@sts, applicable decommissioning @sts, and the then cunent authorized retum on
unrecovered asset balances associated with prudent capital expenditures that are incuned
at North Valmy Unit 1 prior to December 31, 2019, or at North Valmy Unit 2 prior to
December 31,2025, as well as any prudently incuned costs required to modify and/or
terminate the ownership and operating agreements between Idaho Power and NV Energy.
14. Asset Retirement Obliqations. Valmy-related Asset Retirement Obligations
('ARO') balances will continue to be accounted for using the defenaltreatment required by
Oder No. 29414, such that the recorded Valmy-related ARO liabilities will be fully offset by
the rclated regulatory assets at the time of decommissioning. Revenues collected as a
result of the Seftlement Stipulation, including future adjustments based on changes in
decommissioning estimates and actual costs, will cover the estimated asset retirement
costs and decommissioning.
15. True-up of Expenditures. Because the Settlement Stipulation includes
estimates of future capital, decommissioning and O&M expenditures as part of the
levelized revenue requirement, the Parties agree that (1) those future expenditures should
be trued up to actual and the forecast of expenditures updated, (2) the analysis of the
required revenue to be collected from customers and non-levelized revenue requirement
should be recalculated using the same methodology agreed to in this Settlement
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 8
Stipulation, and (3) the levelized collection adjusted up or down based on those actual
results, if material.
16. General Depreciation. Parties to the pending depreciation docket in Case
No. IPC-E-16-23 agree or do not object to the terms set forth in the Seftlement Stipulation
filed simultaneously in that docket which would result in the new depreciation rates going
into effect June 1,2017, with no associated change in retai! rates.
17. The Parties submit this Settlement Stipulation to the Commission and
recommend approval in its entirety pursuant to RP 274-76. The Parties shall support
this Settlement Stipulation before the Commission and shall not appea! a Commission
order approving the Settlement Stipulation or an issue resolved by the Settlement
Stipulation. lf this Settlement Stipulation is challenged by anyone who is not a party,
then each Party reserves the right to file testimony, cross-examine witnesses, and put
on such case as they deem appropriate to respond fully to the issues presented,
including the right to raise issues that are incorporated in the settlements embodied in
this Settlement Stipulation. Notwithstanding this reservation of rights, the Parties agree
that they will contlnue to support the Commission's adoption of the terms of this
Settlement Stipulation.
18. lf the Commission or any reviewing body on appeal rejects any part or all
of this Settlement Stipulation or imposes any additional material conditions on approval
of this Settlement Stipulation, then each Party reserves the right, upon written notice to
the Commission and the other Parties to this proceeding within 14 days of the date of
such action by the Commission, to withdraw from this Settlement Stipulation. ln such
case, no Party shall be bound or prejudiced by the terms of this Settlement Stipulation
and each Party sha!! be entitled to seek reconsideration of the Commission's order, file
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 9
testimony as it chooses, cross-examine witnesses, and do all other things necessary to
put on such case as it deems appropriate. ln such case, the Parties immediately will
request the prompt reconvening of a prehearing conference for purposes of establishing
a procedural schedule for the completion of Case No. IPC-E-16-24, and the Parties
agree to cooperate in development of a schedule that concludes the proceeding on the
earliest possible date, taking into account the needs of the Parties in participating in
hearings and preparing briefs.
19. The Parties agree that this Settlement Stipulation is in the public interest
and that all of its terms and conditions are fair, just, and reasonable.
20. No Party shall be bound, benefited, or prejudiced by any position asserted
in the negotiation of this Settlement Stipulation, except to the extent expressly stated
herein, nor shall this Settlement Stipulation be construed as a waiver of rights unless
such rights are expressly waived herein. Except as otherwise expressly provided for
herein, execution of this Settlement Stipulation shall not be deemed to constitute an
acknowledgment by any Party of the validity or invalidity of any particular method,
theory, or principle of regulation or cost recpvery. No Party shall be deemed to have
agreed that any method, theory, or principle of regulation or cost recovery employed in
aniving at this Settlement Stipulation is appropriate for resolving any issues in any other
proceeding in the future. No findings of fact or conclusions of law other than those
stated herein shall be deemed to be implicit in this Settlement Stipulation. This
Seftlement Stipulation sets forth the complete understanding of the Parties, and this
Settlement Stipulation includes no other promises, understandings, representations,
arrangements, or agreements pertaining to the subject matter of this Settlement
Stipulation, or any other subject matter, not expressly contained herein.
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 1O
21. The obligations of the Parties are subject to the Commission's approval of
this Settlement Stipulation in accordance with its terms and conditions and upon such
approval being upheld on appeal, if any, by a court of competent jurisdiction. All terms
and conditions of this Settlement Stipulation are subject to approval by the Commission,
and only after such approval, without material change or modification, has been
received shall the Settlement Stipulation be valid.
22. This Settlement Stipulation may be executed in counterparts and each
signed counterpart shall constitute an original document.
IV. PROCEDURE
23. Pursuant to RP 274, the Gommission has discretion to determine the
manner with which it considers a proposed settlement. In this mafter, the Parties have
reached agreement on a final resolution to this case. This Settlement Stipulation is
reasonable and in the publlc interest. Pursuant to RP 2O1 and 202, the Parties believe
the public interest does not require a hearing to consider the issues presented by this
Motion and request it be processed as expeditiously as possible by Modified Procedure
to effectuate a June 1, 2017, rate effective date, without waiving the right to a hearing
on the previously disputed matters in this proceeding should the Commission reject the
settlement.
V. REQUESTED RELIEF
NOW, THEREFORE, the Parties respectfully request that the Commission
process this Settlement Stipulation using Modified Procedure with less than a 21-day
comment period and then enter its order approving the Settlement Stipulation without
material change or condition.
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 11
DATED this 3d day of May 2017.
ldaho Power Company Commission Staff
Attomey for Company
Daphne Huang
Aftomey for IPUC Staff
ldaho lnigation Pumpers Association, lnc. Micron Technology, lnc.
By By
Eric L. Olsen
Attomey for Idaho lnigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attomey for Micrcn Technology, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of Idaho Power United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
By By
Peter Richardson
Attomey for lndustrial Customerc of ldaho
Power
Steven Porter
Attomey for US Department of Energy
ldaho Conservation League Siena Club
By By
Benjamin J. Otto
Aftomey for ldaho Gonservation League
Travis Ritchie
Attomey for Siena Club
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 12
DATED this 3d day of May 2017.
ldaho Power Company Commission Stafr
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Attomey for ldaho Power Company
hfYlt C)atristet*Attomeyfor Staf
ldaho lnigation Pumpers Association, lnc. Micron Technology, lnc.
By By
Eric L. Olsen
Attomey for ldaho lnigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attomey for Micron Technology, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
By By
Peter Richardson
Attomey for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
Steven Porter
Attomey for US Departnent of Energy
ldaho Conservation League Siena Club
By By
Benjamin J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
Travis Ritchie
Attomey for Siena Club
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPUI.ATION . 12
td
By
DATED this 3d day of May 2017
ldaho Power Company
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Attorney for IPUC Stafl
, lnc. Micron Technology, lnc.
By
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attorney for Micron Technology, lnc
United States Deparfinent of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
Steven Porter
Attomey for US Department of Energy
Sierra Club
Travis Ritchie
Attorney for Sierra Club
L.
Attorney for ldaho lrrigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
!ndustrial Customers of ldaho Power
By By
Peter Richardson
Attorney for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
ldaho Conservation League
By By
Benjamin J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 12
ldaho lrr[ation Pumpers Association, lnc. Micron Technology, lnc.
By By
DATED this 3d day of May 2017.
ldaho Power Company
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
Eric L. Olsen
Attorney for ldaho lrrigaUon Pumpers
Association, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power
By By
Peter Richardson
Attorney for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
ldaho Conservation League
By By
Beniamin J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 12
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Attomey for IPUC Staff
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attorney for Micron Technology, lnc.
United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
Steven Porter
Attorney for US Department of Energy
Siena Club
Travis Ritchie
Attomey for Siena Club
ldaho lrrigation Pumpers Association, lnc. Micron Technology, lnc.
By By
DATED this 3rd day of May 2017
ldaho Power Company
By
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
Eric L. Olsen
Attorney for ldaho lrrigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power
By By
Peter R n
Attorney for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
ldaho Conservation League
By By
Benjamin J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 12
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Attorney for IPUC Staff
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attorney for Micron Technology, lnc
United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
Steven Porter
Attorney for US Department of Energy
Sierra Club
Travis Ritchie
Attorney for Sierra Club
DATED this 3rd day of May 2017
ldaho Power Company
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
ldaho lrrigation Purnpers Association, lnc.
By
Eric L. Olsen
Attorney for ldaho lrrigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power
By
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Attorney for IPUC Staff
Micron Technology, lnc.
By
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attomey for Micron Technology, lnc.
United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
Steven Porter
Attorney for US Department of Energy
Sierra Club
Travis Ritchie
Attorney for Sierra Club
By
Peter Richardson
Attorney for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
ldaho Conservation League
By By
Benjamin J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION - 12
ldaho Inigation Pumpers Association, !nc. Micron Technology, lnc.
By By
DATED this 3d day of May 2017.
ldaho Power Company
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
Eric L. Olsen
Attorney for ldaho lnigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power
By
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Attorney for IPUC Staff
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attorney for Micron Technology, lnc.
United States Department of Energy and
Federa! Executive Agencies
By
Steven Porter
Aftorney for US Department of Energy
Sierra CIub
Travis Ritchie
Attorney for Sierra Club
Peter Richardson
Attorney for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
Idaho Conservation League
By By
J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 12
By
DATED this 3d day of May 2017.
ldaho Power Company
Lisa D. Nordstrom
Aftorney for ldaho Power Company
ldaho lrrigation Pumpers Association, lnc.
Eric L. Olsen
Attorney for ldaho lnigation Pumpers
Association, lnc.
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power
Peter Richardson
Attorney for lndustrial Customers of ldaho
Power
ldaho Conservation League
By
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Attorney for IPUC Staff
Micron Technology, lnc.
By
Thorvald A. Nelson
Attorney for Micron Technology, lnc.
United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
By
Steven Porter
Attorney for US Department of Energy
Sierra Club
By
By 6-Tfu
Benjamin J. Otto
Attorney for ldaho Conservation League
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 12
Travis Ritchie
Attorney for Sierra Club
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 3d day of May 2017 I served a true and conect
copy of the SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT
STIPULATION upon the following named parties by the method indicated below, and
addressed to the following:
Commission Staff
Daphne Huang
Deputy Attomey Genera!
!daho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington (83702)
P.O. Box 83720
Boise, ldaho 83720-007 4
Micron Technology, lnc.
Thorvald A. Nelson
Frederick J. Schmidt
EmanuelT. Cocian
Brian T. Hansen
HOLLAND & HART, LLP
6380 South Fiddlers Green Circle, Suite 500
Greenwood Village, Colorado 80111
Pete Bennett
Micron Technology, lnc.
8000 South FederalWay
Boise, ldaho 83707
ldaho lrrigation Pumpers Association, lnc.
Eric L. Olsen
ECHO HAWK & OLSEN, PLLC
505 Perching Avenue, Suite 100
P.O. Box 6119
Pocatello, ldaho 83205
Anthony Yankel
12700 Lake Avenue, Unit 2505
Lakewood, Ohio 44107
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 13
X Hand Delivered
_U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail_FAXX Email [e-mail]
[e-mail]
etcocian@hol land hart. cqm
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
kmtrease@holland hart.com
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
[e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail
FAX
x Emai! [e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
lndustrial Gustomers of ldaho Power
Peter J. Richardson
RICHARDSON ADAMS, PLLC
515 North 27h Street (83702)
P.O. Box 7218
Boise, ldaho 83707
Dr. Don Reading
6070 Hi!! Road
Boise, ldaho 83703
United States Department of Energy and
Federal Executive Agencies
Steven Porter
Office of the General Counsel (GC-76)
The United States Department of Energy
1000 lndependence Avenue, SW (Room 6D-033)
Washington, D.C.20585
ldaho Gonservation League
Benjamin J. Otto
ldaho Conservation League
710 North Sixth Street
P.O. Box 844
Boise, ldaho 83701
Sierra CIub
Travis Ritchie
Sierra Club
2101 Webster Street, Suite 1300
Oakland, Califomia 94612
SETTLEMENT STIPULATION AND MOTION
TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT STIPULATION . 14
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
Ovemight Mai!
FAX
x Email [e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Ovemight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
Ovemight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
_Hand DeliveredX U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mail
_FAXX Email [e-mail]
Executive AssistantKi
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
GASE NO. IPG-E-16-24
IDAHO POWER GOMPANY
ATTACHMENT 1
aoo
6oFEo66ocoll-
ao
o(\l
(",
6
=t\
o(\t
oc,a
ra
I
ieS:esor@o)o)-I-I
si\I
(!(n(o@rrolc!N6'O-lo rl lo lo
Fri@FNCDI.)NCDO)6Nr--dddOFNN(g-FrOoer66
FF(Ot\u?qo?q
-OOOlotlr)to
q
o
(oo(t
.l'o!trit-O
roo6.I)oNdi
c)
ga
G,o
o('tctN
{-o-O
attoarlo
I'rioC'd
6troC'NNI)
OlONNoattlo@ (1, ((, o)d<tdc\iI'OC"N@ri@(oatotddNglFrfg gg
ro
+6
(n(\t(0-
1r)6rO
ro-o)o-
q
(a
lodt\
ari
o
t\
rio
lo
dNodoo-
o
rl)t(?r_
aort
1o-l(}ort
o)\to-NNl.'
oo@@NOCOat)NG'FF
'rt of 6i do@l\<(o d) ra, Na;otctdNgFto qo
OFNONO6l.}
-NIOO)dddJ@tftlf,)l.)NaOFdt 6i ot sito)oloIOFNCt)
@CDON$ld)
ooflt
=6oEoEog
G
oF
(D
Iog
6l cEI ELIEl .oot oool -s 8.El c.E U,'Ql Porrr=
,ElgSgE
+rr)@l\O
8*aaeSSSSSSaeS(A(,)SI,)NO-rFr(OaOAleeZ-ONGTNNNNN
-; ;--;;;J-;
EseEEBQeePfiPHe;sSRH$eBEdI
=
EusRENEgaPqsE5E$$sHuedEe
(r,
E
N(\tOt(OOOOTr,O)StOsl O(l)O r@Lrtti ()NOr Ft(irNto- Jild dJJ(r) 6t(r,!l
eG)rrroNoPPNgE$Oi
E Szt
ol5lEIol>totEI
=ob9edOEo.()
oE-otEEgEI.o ?i a0 ;l-uag&l
EIs=l
=&l
=loool
gEB
'dl
EI.olcI'Elolat
EI
EIa!lFI
Eo=loo
Elo
cl
=l:lLIolo.t
lostoNoaDocr(r(o(od,@Oglrt@rl(t@Osl(\lNlO@ @tO-c)-O(O$lalJo- 6i+dot6idddc;(,)(otoloLro|frcoo)t' c)o)(\t(9(l)oo@-l.,? NrONFoo-689D- N g'Or l'l Cr)(nlr, cr' 6t6 0 94EHfldetrl
O(v,O-(()@FNFOFotNlrtl\FNr@N(ONl\(rO -6!tg)(DC{rt-Fdd t.j6t<'tdd-je.idciaO|' N<r(DestClesiClll\ ar'-N''r')@god 'tai JJq o oo
NOOFSONIOT@6OFlOglt\+NNCDdr+rr,O)O)O (ON<t$F(O-OO
dd dd6isid+dotailoo @(,)rato)oN(DoNFtf (ONCDNFO(D(D-
d' (e c\idGtdoo-otC,di(,er)Fi\Gr'Ort elo ar, ste g gaEHH
o)Cirot\N@1() 1()((,tFoNt @LOFO)(9 lt (DONss O-OONOOOOdFi J+c\iJdJ+criJ(DLt NF(O@OO)O- OFOsDls-stoJs- +rtf ddl.j JN-c.iSl 6l (O F (O F C.,lO eN (\IOd d cf i
E -el
E Eg
o5
o
oG,E
-oO=toEToP
=Ebeeo.c,9Eer.EE9EOEGdE
E
CoE,(,
o5
Ta\6
>F! f, 6E- oFE b =oBEoii.EE€TE
: EE i€r.9.gio
€E'ES! c EtroE
5o6(,
E€agBe o
t BE o o o E f
H*EEEEt;cE=5t
gEgg;$EHeEf,EE
6lol6lEIel'El6ll-l
EI€lclfl
-Nd){rrlroNcoo)P=SPotrJ2t
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES GOMMISSION
cAsE NO. IPC-E-16-24
t
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
ATTACHMENT 2
r_,,., $8F3gSg8SEs88pgFggES8SgE8p8Eg8E89EAS5ggtABg$8$89988S$839$93E88Frtas99E8AgSSFA90tE EsEgshBE;tg9:g$frEEEEtFg$HsEB*:$HEs:$IEFEg;IE:!il$ilpgrrF$;NEEFEge;HrilqEp$sgtggEEa
-----rJ:dddddddddddddodddiiiiriid6dd66dddddddoFFFFnNEodoo6ddoooddod
*
8e3
5t
l!
$!
Tat3
g
TII
r_t!p'
grat6A
I!
T!
J
€pt
E
e
:
t_
#
tr35!rII
.8il
JTt-'
t
E
38gS95SFFg8gs83$e$FFspEEFF3sAg3S98A39$S8F$qA8sA$5849$A$A$Sg$i:SEg$gFSFgSAa$EF5-=ddliieLide:!eeiesfinR6siBiHiENris;ss;griS$rcaie5i$iiriri*B'dfriddidSidErfpraiiiisiSe
RF'E,FFF666€€F6€€FggOSFgFgggCSFFS6F666F8666F6s-FFFS,FFF66F6FFF€€€€6F€6gFFFEFgFFO€FFFc-d---c-o-qqqqqqqqq6.6.o.qq6.qq6.qqqo"o-qqqq6-qqqo.qo-qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqo-qqqqqqqqqqqq4qqqqq6-6-q6"q
EEEAEEEEEEEEEE AEAEEE AEEAEEEEEEEEEAEEEEEE EE EE E E EAEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEA AE EEEEEEEEEEEEEE
FEEEFFFFFFEEFFFFFFEFFiEnEaFEFFFEFFFFHHSSHH$HSHSE$EH$HHHHHHHHCHHHH$$HSSSHPEHSHHHHH$$$SnnnnnannanDBBBnBDDnDDnDadaadnaaaanDnand-aaDaDDaBDDnnnaDBDDdnBBtsnDntsinlBBnnnanDnaaDdnBs;55;EF5;;=;=555;6S;;;-.F:F;;;;S;;5:5=F;5;5i5;5:5:5;5;;S5:::S:55S;;F;;5:5=F55;;S;;;=F=
FEEEEEEEFFFFFEEEFFEeeeTFiKFhKihiihhhhEIiiiiiiiIiH}i558}iHIiHHEHEESHEEEHHHHHEHHHHiiH}:iIHiHiHHHiiHiiiiiHnnDnnianB6nnDdDdnnDDBaaandafiDanildaaDndBaaaDDanndaDaDaDnnndannnnnaDfiinnaaianaanBiBnBnB:5;i;6F5tE:5S555;EF;;;:5Ss;=;;F;;3si=5;5;EF55E:<FS5S5;5F;5!:!SF;5;;=;;E=F=it:;EF55E:!=
ggEgSEsSBggESBssggBgEEEggggEEEEgEgggHH$$H$H$$$ggBgH$HHB$gHBHHBH$$H$BH$Hfi$BHBBgfi$Hs$BH
:i;5;;=5;;:F:F;:;5S;;;:5:;;:;;S;;;:5=ii5;5S55;:FSF;:;;S5;;SS:S5;;;=;;5-<;=F5;;EF;;5:F=
ilt
s888888888888899938SS89SS8888888888888::a::::::aa:393939933333888888888888hjidddddddddddd{iijjia{jiiiddddddildddddJddJJildJddddd;ddddd;dddddddddddd;ddddsSsNNssIsNfl.s.t*.EBEEB8.qqqqSEEqqqqe8.8.8.8.8.q\5-85_Eq\EEh.EE:.I.I.:.E-I-r.{.:.x-I-I.6-66-6-6-6-6_6-6.6_6-6-?ddddddddddddddddddd6ododdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddNa{(o(Nso
3
e9
I
gesggEgB*ggsgsggBBBEgsggggggssge*sggH$$H$HHH$flflHHHHHH$H$H$$HHHHfiHH$HHHHHHHHHHHfi$HHHHfl
>nariai-aa>N:nlfDaFiaa>n>Na>;Di;aB>n>N.iaaia-a>n>nBlaDF-aE>N>n;+;ai-;a>n>-;]BaFala>N>
6a666AGa66aA6afr 6e=6a606e66
! I a!. o-6-6-N-N-N-N-6 q N q e aaaaao r a 9
q a 6-6 N o- q o. N^ q i.4 6-q a- q - N-r. r. ! t r-.- I !
diddiddtdddididdiddddddddia= 3 = 3 = =s= eg g g g g s g g g 9.99 g g. g g
ASSSAets9AeAEABFg'ASSs s I s I s I
$a ii iir r r iiiraiiiiiN^iN ri N ris
839e!8s9t1B
_=993995
, aeaaBF9*. gd jsie
EEEEEEEE
8r^-J338i$iDisiB
6t6
!33
988iis
666
EEE
8gE000
BEB
n-." a- q i".- q ! q q q q q - q a I q q e - 4 q q - n q a. o- q o o_ q q q 6- q q
iiiiididiiddiidddsooddddidiii!iidddiii
r. 6 o- q q o- q r- o- - q E- q q - q N- 6_ a- - a F- c- e 6- 6- 6- d- q o- a .- i- -- N- r- 6- N_
t83888888388APA8&A8AAAA8eg939S5AS3e353
sIit333338s88;;;;;;6;6;;;d3d33333333dd
B s- I ? ? I I ? q ? q q t E a a a E a E E E E E E h h a E h h. h. h h- h. E h. 8. 8. E E E E E € E 8- 8- 8- EdddddiddddddiidiiidNNN
Pg8:tsjidddqqr_8.b-
Nea=4666-6r5EE:NIH:!HEsEi{!Bi;:.H.EEE&EE:.&EEEiEEeEEiEil€!.ih.P.a5.gEEE![:.il.S.;EEEEBqilEpEEESE*HqEEEfldiosg!es':8$EP3b:9i!EgifrfrFF;EE5frBHBflE[[U3i333EggtgrSr';;;;EgBEEHSRR*FEHSEFFFnfflIS
. o=33:9956PtBBBp5ts!i.hI5tP93Ft:SABN8&89:99:8E88888t88393-PPENg5333D3Bei$EBBgEFS&
- j j jj jdddddddddddddddoddoddodddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd
r.aeeaegrrrrrrrrrs.rs.EEErEEEE!.qqEtegtgtteegeagterf,tteetttetSSgeaeee9gegEgggg.gs.gggENs99ge3!!!!!!!!!:S::::::!!!!:::e999999s999s99ss9ssssss99sss99se9seeeseseesegeegg
q o a q a a a q e { q e o- q d- q o- I d- 6- 6- 6- 6- 6- 4 6- 6- 6- q q q----"--93::93e99999$NNNNNNNNNSN
,;, ., ,3.,.,9R
6n6 aF66 h x - 6 - 6 6 6aeN-Fa-6e-a6t6eia66 a6aa6aA6edtiB8386EthBggaah83tE8r88gRgBgX95B3tsCE9383:895:93:g85rS9SE-6$B!B95ie5C8g3SB
FEgf;Hit3illi88$:fli$:qE"H:$83.E"s:8s.f,$:8:a.s.E!iE$:r.EE:n:S.EEE"E6E3Ef;tu.A.N.5.ilF.C.c.{fl.p.B.B.r.Ei{fl.8fl.A8
=a--- _r_riddddddddddddddJdddddrjir ---jjjjigddiggiiiiijjj3jiidii
aa6Aaa66 6 o o 6 6 G o d 6 aaeFaaa6ea6e66666eaee666eaA65
-io.co\6._q-4.N6-o-6-6-q6-i.-r--6--qq.-r-q6-q6-n-N-6-D-d-o-q1N-6-o-6-ro-6-eo-qd;dildd-iddildJddildidhEo
lr8<
grai6O
l!i!
3t
i;
II3
:
lr3<
P3aiJ6
!r
}I
I.fidI
EEEEe E 8qSBEAAAESASE rAH gSEgEeggeeAsIt$$$Atr qEEEEgEEEE Egi;A;a;;AeA;;rErSs eetttes eddJddd;ddddddddddddddilddddddddjJjj;JjJjjJjddddddddddddj999999=======LL!==gggggggggggg99gg9g9999ge99cec9999999g999999999g9gg9Cg99egg_--
ET
o 66a6a6aaaaa6eAeeAe6ee666aaaAAaaaa666666666ee66a6e
- - =========a==gggggggggggg======:===9===3====3s====
8S
E6I
T
'
.
'
:'
I
eoPTB$
==
'8.
E
!"
e
dq
gn8tt
e
t88t8t
B;iB
!ntt
Iai;,Il*$
I3I
6
r
F9rid3
dJidddddddtddi
ddddddiJddddda
9rE$SBqE$erAEt:.!EqpEE-8p9iiEpF:
tig!i!i!i!iE.NNNNNS$sN
s
i
t
85;L3?
fl
t
6NENNNLNLxNxLa
dt't't'i{{sf,f,{tad
P2
gaagaa;
8FTIEIE
I
Tg'
cg
I
f
j
3dI
i
t.
E
B
tIg
E;*8efr[
ccgSgsg
s33333gggggg
p3.*;
RU8;
8r5
E8:
Eqfl
833
j
F.83BgB
f,;abt
t3f,Bg
3eE3
r6Q6F9oFE
ddddddddi
Eaa t
3t
58
S
IEER;I
46. o n o - 6 F -. d 6 - 6 r 6 - a d 6 6 6 a i E 6
Isli$dNF'E'E 8jEt!:9:n j jts!iddddf iddddddi
S EEggEEEEIEAAEEEEEAEAEABEEEEEEEEEEEEEErtrEatiitttiI8r888EEEEEEEEEEEEEEaEEE
E, taaaIlEEEgSq9qgqgqFeaEaIgEa$[EE3$[Ee[$ggeasaaqaefl gE$$f s[$30
Ei i E 3.a.AAl qqEBll;E:" 5.3.f H $.5.!.p.E RE e.l I ggAggEgEtg8BAgggBggEESSEgrsoI ddddilddddd-'JJ..
r qa iq e a9Egtq aE t egEf,Eqeqg$sE9g$qIE[[qEta6aeE a[8a8a[[Eqe88aE5[gEI N i E i3 sitt JrS! S 9!9 I ji9 e e SS= i9 EE€ssggccgsgsgijijdidgdegjjid---
I!i;iliiltilil;*ilFFEFFFFFFFFFii;iitiSitItcpEggpsgggstsIIIIIIIIIIIIIIrrsB'ra'iB't!rrtddri$BB'ssBBd3d;i;rr*;*fff;i;(*$e$e$e$$e$eesiiiiriddciic'
I I -E$.tItffiffiiIggp.gE[[[!u.tqqqEEt!!!.!!.!!B.qqs.Es.qEs.B.qE6.Ie8flfl[[fiflefiq iI r s s jis'iiditiiiE'iiiE'6diidrirtdrida's'riB'da'iiiiiSc'ddiidaririririririririririiiI----------
EI!E;FE3rEp38pCfl !!SE!3F8trpIE:e
33d I 8[ MAil*q 3EE
=
E 3 ! P 0 ;s gtsE d ri
dddddjiiJ;j-j;jiJi
5Bt3
HHH$HHHHH$HHHf; HHHH$$$$$$$HHB$$HH$$HEH$$$$$$$$$$$$i=;;5;5=;;E-<5=i55;5S5i5;<5=F55;5F;55-<5-=555;;F55!:!EH5:$EH$H$XH;;:;;=5;
FqEgltetSI*oS:!TgE8E!EEddJ({dd{d{j
9i939999999446-q6-a-q6-qa-6-
EtEr_3-t-3_r-3-3-r-
=:9 3=9 =5 = 9a
$$HHHHH$HHEHHHHHHHHH$Hfl H$H$$$fi $$$$HHBE&BBBHHHBEH$ff fl $$$$$$8$fi ; 5 ; t s 55 F : F s F 5 5 ; 5 s 5 5 F : F-< S ; 5 ; rF i5 E : S s ; 5S E;S 5 ; s s 5 : S iS fi E S 5 t p : F
- eFa=a&=e6asata6ea6e6a
i;FaEE;Ei!f, 5EH: EaT[EEgEraddr;;J;ddddddddddaa jiE =====================
I E[$BEItEEtqAgeqECBggtgStrtElEEttl9:99!9E8E8Fg
eQs e
SEgB
.Er
=FFE; gE
qIP
I
E
r " EEE EE EEE[[[!. f, 0 gEEEEE gi E rlrlrlrlr.i.r d dE r i i,r t r g E g gtI r -------- -
I.,rl
I r,,.,.
TI
gEEhEE!qBE[88:qEIISETEFEIE:3!iIESIT:iE8$iq!E:UOgtI5B88PE3t5hts999nC8i8!=t8t88IRRR38E69.t.tE!e6
!iEif !!i!!!:!!!!!!!:::sEt!:EErErEEtts!sEEisres?o
teeteeeeeeeaeeeeeeeeeeteeeetteeeteeeetaeIeteeta6ddddddd6dddddddddd666666666dd6d6dddd6066656566: : : : : r,af;I3
fiEiisFFI riii
$HH$HHHHHHHHHHHHH$HH$HH$ff $HHH$HH$H$fi HHB$$$H$F$E$fl $H$$$8$HB$
F ;5 ; E S ;5 i : ! : S ;: ; E: 5;! :i : 5;5; 5 F 5 i! = 5 = F ;5 ;;i< ; r E : F = F ; 5 ; 5 F :;E :E
Er
=F5r;il
Hfi $$ff ff $$HHHHHHHH$HHH$$HHH8Hff I$H$8fl fl Bfi B$$FH$$HBB$f; B$F$H$$$B$555;EF5EE:E=555;;S;tE:FsS5i;rS5:E:;=;55;sF5;E=F=555;E=5;i:F
f;c
E
E
eee999tteggg
il*99[Nt38S:3TFE$FfiNiHiEH
EE!!.8.EErIgeE
ST
agjg
3g
ri ii
g
ItI
6_t!e
,F8at36liIi
f5tT
rt
T
I
=i'
r_
TX3<
?3
5t
il
,}S
grs
5.
I
!eI6I
T
I*iIiI
I8:8*s
r- 38FSF$F9Eg83$lgFEAgSgFS9!! g liiE i ['fl Bt s.8 i ['fl q g e. :.E 5.E !. :i.
I a89Et8[EtBaPtEsIassqoaiiaIt6s8t333b3NrFR8g8;88t888:o u ------------------_-==9=
I E i; E i i i i E E E E 6 6 fi t F t t i. $ R' s' fi 8.
r "eeeaeeeEet{880888e{840e .
;g il't !i!i$'f,$.f;f;f,lig i r'$ u ggE $ Eg$.! f, ---------r
8C
E aEi$EIiEqgqEe;Ee.atEEEaEEEsEittttfi "
H B. H t: i Fi a. i. t d E $. i E : 8l p t g i $ E' t I E $: ! i I i ; ! E] 3
-' -o6oo..o-d-FtsNd--ddjjidddddJJJ--
aiiiiiaseseIqqriss$sasEeEEreaEErria"ggggE8s3533EB8EE3rEUE5!L:EeaEEsE: 3ce
s 8.!.s.qq {aaq{qqqqqs.t gE g { [ { g uquqqq qqqq
EE9!E!99!E?E!€EqES!€$!Sf qt!!!!t9S!5
t-,t
FFii
E-
FF
iI
f, f, af, af, af, af, aaNEANSnNN[trEN8i3B
!!E!TEE!!I!88Tfl fl fl 3[3ITfl T!{EBddddddddddddjj;jiji -----IIeE
!E
tEils$f,EsE["D38.fltgtF:o
IE
s3iiItaaar!
$agF.$Fs'tit't:pj
tqfie$Ie!x!![!!
$aEga$$geggssr
p
F
p
at
g8;AIa
E':'!'$$i
xt IiNriFi[i
88EPE.
666
scE
ga8
SQN
3.$.3.i.E
ri
r. B.
3f
888
;*t
R
I
93
ri 8t
g?
a8
?.3
I
I
a3
E
t
R
i
358iit
8EE
riiiN
g8g
gEE
g
uE
s$jj$isi
8t93
85Fh
g
E
T
u
eeE
ggg
:!Hi. RiE839C
RFf,8
i$h['
eeeB9!99gggg EAAggt
AFG888
333
E3$3!trrrrrprEf,glsSg
R n e e e,.5.q F i [[F i &N t[R[&{s.t
:prt
$
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
cAsE NO. IPC-E-16-24
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
ATTACHMENT 3
s Eq E ES fl S h E R ! p E i tI E E : E I fl EEfl g.e E E q A.8"F *.p S.E F S fr p.Af; C 5 ; E
U$31135!i$$$$!!$!33!5!3ii:3!3::i$egq$qgggl$gcggsi
EaEBESEEEEEE$s$ss$$$$$$sss8s$$ssssssssss$s$Essgse
ilInf, Befr fl fr 8B$pppSrptppppl[[[p[[[[[[[[EssEaEEEEEBddd ddd$ d d d s- 0a s I d c d B's d I I I $dB I ds dB d$sd$i ,, t i J s ' '
j j
[[p.s.at 0 [ $.( tE s"r.qEE {EEs.E u.r.qfl$.fl flf,fl.8.$.fl.48.{[ * e I.i r.E I.I.Ig gs sf s s s s d s'B r s s 5 5 5 s d f, i St'E'E'ii iiiidE E 5 I I s E i i i i i g i
QE gr3$Ii3 !B$8ft E$I gp3hil g.p E nlUgi tis $ B Es E E i.q.E :.E EE h g.fi. E e. d:E ! 3.3.r:jiJ jji;iddilddddddddddddaaaiis
3 E 3 E eEEeiqsE i € 5 5 qE i.qi"E e.5.5 5.5 5.5 5 5aBR8i385;;;;5;;;e5;;;E;5E58;5;;
i E p il EEEEItIs s E g [8 f; q!! ! !E ! qE!!!"!.
8388883555555EE85E53t3t3333833!
99999AA3ttE3E333E3t3tg8888tt8a a a a aF E-N-N- L- \- \- N- E- F-\\ qq qq q q q qq qqq
s.3
$r
}E
Ir
r!
t.:TI!
IE
*t
E
BI
T
IE
t$
,9
fg
T,E86
53=988gsiitgi
aFtaasqqqqc.&38J3;e
TTFFFF
BIlt
f,3*
!::!},:!::::::3:339pe3999999:99999993AR888R888R888E66&6neEEE6S$NSBNBBB8SB838888883888E
BgBggB$gggBBSggSgBBBBgBBBgggBBgBEggBESggSSBBBBEBSE$g$*B*ggggBEEEgSgEBBgBEEsggBBEg$8$Ess5=tis5i5ss:55:;5S;;5sF=555;;=;r;=55S;;;5s5;5:isi;s;E=5tE=E:555;5F5;E!ESF5s;;:;5E:i:
[.
3.
a
3
q ! q 3- ! 3- 3- ;- r- 3- 3- 3- 5-rrs3r3883888:ji;-_jjjji-'jjj
SEFEFEEiTi!i;iiiriiiisiii.i[553EEi;ii;.;l:.;.;ElElEI.!.s.!!.1r.:.:":.:"i.i:::
5:EliliE6HEEE;.;.;. HH"EE;.EE f; H.;.;:H.H.H:;.;.;.;.fl tAAf;B H. H.t fl.Hf,:H.U [fr.fr.fr.fr.r"*.*.fril.n E.i6.s.5.E E E
sii::sHqEqeqEEssqssqqqesqqqqqqqilftfl$ffftflfls$fl$E8E$g$EEBEqEu.qqEEa.EEEi[.83.4434;;3;3s.3.E
EEfr$$[Ed$s$$!sq{qq.Esq$.$.qqe.ss.t!s.!q$!!qq!"q!!.!.{qqs.qs.qs"s.s.qq3.3.t$$33i$19].$ $sst$$$t$!
lidddddd6ooo
FEEFFEEFEsEFEHHEEfEHFHfrHfrEfrfrfrfifrfrfrfrfE$ffi$$fiff$$ffFEFffEEEEHEHEEEBB$g$$$$$$$$fl$$$E$EEEfEflfi
=SS5;i==ii=F=SF5;;FE;i:!=;5:;E;;tESiss;5;E:5;E:E:5;5;;s;5!:ESs;s;5F;;E:F:E;5;;FEEE:is
Tg
u3t_
lr
I
I
ddd{dddd-'d
jjjjidd;dd
EEfeseefrefi'
dddddddddd
=:3=3=5=53
J
3ri
$3€
$tE
666939
3. S.
$fi
666959
Naats
E s.H!.83E3E3
33Agq
fl.9. g.
t g.F.
gBe
CIg!:
eaa338t333
E:Eg:g:
I. S.
t3
3;
ts:
tR.
ttt$
38589tC5Riii:5isiu
3E
{l
ry
i!!E383.!!E!!!ri!
q
gINEN
E!!!!
ft
}I
M=rddJ0
g
TRPI r ts nEtf;E iEE iE ? E E i.3 EIi. e.t Et tiqitIl!.tlt[ffi It r a E ! r.E E E F E Ar aA3.r.un qiql; EN.E EdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddJ;Jjj
f; f; tittti$nif, ttfi 8s8$88$a$$$ttEffi tEtsssssssesssee6 tEEuEt Et ! E3EEE5E0E50
rtI
Eg
3
$Eii!ttHtEtEt'-ii!EIltlxlnlst
$frfrsfrfrs [[STITTTITITITTsEEtttttttttttl
it
it
888888
tEttEt
E5E6EE
$HH$E$5;5i55
I. I.R88t fr[r.Itt ItIt ttu fl H fl qaqqsqililp t: ts.ttptttttrrtrrrrtt555555E5
rr.....,..8.d$t
I t9 tI lltt llltta Itlltt It
ttrEi$IIIsild ITdt
$$H
=is
I5
H$5;88F5 H8$$$$$$$$$$$$$8BEE$$88888t8888ilt88s F =F 55 55F 55ESFSF55;5F55;-=F =5;5 ;5FaiE
g8
s5
i- i r F E e Er [pt 3 ! EeEE !N [fl F : i E r ] E r r
=
{! 5 tE Ee : fl iil ! r r 3 ! t gitqi!.lI i*!.-tt i56c airtlN a{mErtEFtrs[ptrtnsrep!il1t18 qEe[! t I r I IEiiiF p.l lt1tr 3 I 8 3 I 3 E i A B A i t t t t t t t t i i t a a a 6 a t 3 ? ? g 3 t D a t g t a F o rE N E I > : : ! : o . . + o -
ecaactaacacFF6a6FFF6aaFaaaaaatctaacaaaaaaaaatctaatFFtctcttE't!IItrqu-tquIttREtEttEtttEt?!?!!!-!!-:-:-:-:-!-i!!i!!:-:-:-i!-:-!i!:-=-:-::-------tl sEsssEEsEEEggggggggggggqE g B"q Eq8,E E !.gqqq q q8E 8.!"qq 8.aqqE0.!.0.!.aqaE
FT PIPP
3::.:aaq q8 q E 8. i I g E E E E E: E e q E q E E q q { f g g q' g d q q d g f, q q { q q 8. E a q q. $
ie.iiE EEIagP T TTT I.I. t
H$H$E$$$$$fi $fi fl $BHEE$FEHHBHES$$8$8$B$$$BE=5:S55[5SiE5=5=i55fi 5EI:5F5FF5:E5F5i5SF$$;5 H$H5Fa $$$SFS H
5
HHH5Fi