20140716IPC to Staff 43-47 .pdf

3Iffi*.
An IDACORP Companyif.ICIi'i'i:i;
?0lE JUL l5 PH 2t 28
iDt\l-lu itu;'-..
uT tLlTt Es 00tu{h{ tss ici"
JULIAA. HILTON
Corporate Counsel
ihi [e-mail]
July 16,2014
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Jean D. Jewell, Secretary
ldaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
Re: Case No. IPC-E-14-04
2013 Demand-Side Management Expenses - ldaho Power Company's
Response to the Second Production Request of the Commission Staff
Dear Ms. Jewell:
Enclosed for filing in the above matter are an original and three (3) copies of ldaho
Power Company's Response to the Second Production Request of the Commission Staff to
ldaho Power Company.
Sincerely,J-LW
Julia A. Hilton
JAH:evp
Enclosures
1221 W. ldaho St. (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, lD 83707
JULIA A. HILTON (!SB No. 7740)
ldaho Power Company
1221West ldaho Street (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, ldaho 83707
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
ih [e-mail]
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
IN THE MATTER OF IDAHO POWER'S
APPLICATION FOR A DETERMINATION
OF 20'13 DEMAND SIDE MANAGEMENT
(DSM) EXPENSES AS PRUDENTLY
INCURRED
fiID I li'ri:. -;
20lq JUL I 6 PH 2: 2B
IDAHO tr';rLiil
uT l[lTl ES Co],11,i I 33 t..'i',
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
CASE NO. !PC-E-14-04
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S
RESPONSE TO THE SECOND
PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE
COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO
POWER COMPANY
COMES NOW, ldaho Power Company ("ldaho Powed' or "Comp?f,y"), and in
response to the Second Production Request of.the Commission Staff to ldaho Power
Company dated July 2, 2014, herewith submits the following information:
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 1
REQUEST NO. 43: ldaho Power's Conservation Potential Assessment appendix
states on page B-10 that the "Behavioral Feedback Tool" measure "models a wide
range of options for providing homeowners with ongoing information on their energy
use, for example via a web portal. These tools are based on the premise that
homeowners will reduce energy use if they better understand how they use energy and
the associated costs. The level of assumed savings is based on isolated behavioral
effects and excludes the technology effects of all other measures listed here." Please
explain which measures were included in the "wide range of options" modeled here,
including the specifics of the web portal.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 43: The following information was provided to
Idaho Power by Applied Energy Group ('AEG').
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting Services (now part of AEG) delivered the
completed potential study report in February 2013. The measure selection process took
place in mid 2012 and the analysis for the study was completed in November 2012.
At the time the measure list was developed (mid 2012), behavioral programs
were relatively new in the industry. There was little information about specific programs
and devices, but some utilities were beginning to include them in potential studies. For
ldaho Power, AEG modeled a single behavioral measure, called "Behavioral Feedback
Tools." This one generic measure was used to represent the types of behavioral
programs delivered by utilities, such as the delivery of energy-use information via direct
mail to customers, which provided a comparison of how the customer's energy
compares with neighbors or a web portal provided to customers to view and leam more
about their energy use.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 2
At the time, AEG reviewed the available evaluation literature to develop
assumptions about measure applicability, costs, savings, and lifetime. These
assumptions are shown in the attachment as the last measure for each housing type
and vintage in Table B-15 through Table 8-26, starting on page B-53 of the appendix.
The tables also show the benefit to cost ratio and levelized cost for each measure in the
first program year (2012).
The response to this Request is sponsored by Pete Pengilly, Customer Research
and Analysis Leader, ldaho Power Company.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 3
REQUEST NO. 44: Please provide all evidence demonstrating that each of the
behavioral feedback tool measures was appropriately assigned a one-year measure !ife.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 44: The following information was provided to
ldaho Power by AEG.
Please see the attachment provided in the Company's response to Staffs
Production Request No. 43. AEG used a measure life of one year for the behavioral
measures because the evidence available at the time indicated that customers respond
to the program as long as they are receiving energy-use information and there was no
evidence that savings would persist when the flow of energy-use information ceases. A
one-year lifetime is appropriate to reflect that the program must be maintained from one
year to the next, which means that measure costs are incurred each year in order to
achieve the energy savings in that year. This is in contrast to other measures, like a
high-efficiency appliance, where measure costs are paid up front and energy savings
are achieved over a five-year to 20-year timeframe, depending on the measure.
The response to this Request is sponsored by Pete Pengilly, Customer Research
and Analysis Leader, ldaho Power Company.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 4
REQUEST NO. 45: Please provide the calculations, energy savings estimates,
and sources (including dates) demonstrating that each of the behavioral feedback tool
measures is not cost-effective.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 45: The following information was provided to
ldaho Power by AEG.
Table 1: Behavioral Measure Calculations for Single-Family Existing Home Segment
MEasure llata
Attrlbrrta:
Basr Saturation
M,easure Cost
Measures
are specified as a usc in each
Behavioral end usas-
lues in red belorar are ted each and sho,tvn for the base
End ttse
Water Heati
lnterior Li
ran<es
Electron ics
M€asure B,enefits
Avoided costs are aoolied to the thc benefits in dollars shovvn bclow.
Values c from vear to as the end-use ener amounts and awoidcd <osts (
Values are calculated for each below.
E rd frre
Vvater H€ati
Electronics
Miscellaneous
BenefiVcoat Results:
ratios are as Measure otal Measure Cost in each
incrcase ovcr timc bccausc ldaho Povrrcr avoidcd
From LoadlVlAP model
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 5
Measure is aoolicableto all homes
arc no trends cln rn€as
am administration costs included in Tota! Mcasure Cost
Table 2: Behaviora! Measure Data
Measure Data
Segment
Single Family
Single Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MH
Limited lncome MH
Measure Savings
Base
Vintage Applicability Saturation
Existing LOO% O%
New lO0% 0%
Existing LOO% 0%
New 1-O0% O%
Existing 100% 0%
New tOO% O%
Existing tOO%o O%
New tOO% O%
Existing tOO% O%
New tOOYo OYo
Existing 7OO% OYo
New LOO% O%
Measure
Lifetime Cost1 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.001 s 40.00
Price ProSram
Scaler Cost
OYo 16.2%
OYo 16.2%
OYo L6.2%
o% L6.2%
o% 16.2%
0% t6.2%
o% 76.2%
0o/o 16.2%
0% 16.2%
0% t6.2Yo
0% t6.2Yo
OYo t6.2Yo
Annual Summer
Savings Peak(Base Demand
year) Savlngs
27.47 0.O3
113.92
46.LL O.OO
74.77 0.OO
49.62 0.01
9.14 0.oo
98.41 0.01
22.81 O.O3
LO5.44
42.t2 0.OO
22.a4 0.OO
32.63 0.OO
8.43 0.OO
94.9L 0.O1
5.18 0.01
25.92
L7.7L O.OO
8.36 0.OO
43.41 O.OO
8.18 0.OO
87.85 0.O1
4.72 0.O1
24.tL
16.20 0.OO
11.OO O.O0
28.55 0.OO
7.54 0.OO
84.98 0.01
Total
Measure
Costs 45.485 +e.aa
S 4G.48
S +0.+s
S as.+s
S +0.+s
S as.+a
S +0.+a
S +0.+e
S ae .+a
S ao.+s
S +s.aa
Setment Vlntage
Single Family ExistinB
Single Family ExistinB
Single Family Existing
SinBle Family Existing
Single Family Existing
Single Family Existing
Single Family Existing
Single Family New
Single Family New
Single Fa mi ly New
Single Family New
Single Family New
Single Family New
Single Family New
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family New
Multi Family New
Multi Family New
Multi Family New
Multi Family New
Multi Family New
Multi Family New
Table 3: Behavioral Measure Savings
Annual 94of 96ol
Savings (% Demand Demand
Enduse of Usage) (S) (W)
Coolin8 t.OO% 1.OO% O.OO%
Space Heating L.OOY, O.OO% t.OOYo
Water Heating t.OO% L.OO% L.OO%
lnterior Lighting t.Ooyo L.OO% L.OOy"
Appliances 1.OO% L.OOYo !.OOYo
Electronics I.OO% L.OOYo I.OO%
Miscellaneous 7.OO% L.OO% t.OO%
Cooling L.OOYo t.OOYo O.OOYI
Space Heating L.OOYo O.OO% 7.OO%
Water Heating L.OOYo l.OOYo t.OO%
lnterior Lighting L.OO% t.OO% 7.OO%
Appliances t.OO% 7.OO% I.OO%
Electronics L.OOYI 1.OO% L.OOYI
Miscellaneous 1.OO% L.OOYo t,OO%
Cooling 1..OO% L.OOYo O.OO%
Space Heating l.OOYo o.Oo% t.OO%
Water Heating L.OOyo 1.OO% 1.OO%
lnterior Lighting L.OO% 7.OO% 7.OO%
Appliances L.OO% 7.OO% I.OO%
Electronics I.OO% t.OO% L.OO%
Miscellaneous I.OO% I.OO% I.OO%
Cooling 1.OO% L.OOYI O.OOYo
Space Heating t.O0yo O.OOyo L.OOyo
Water Heating L.OOyo L.OOyo t.Ooyo
lnterior Lighting L.OO% t.Ooyo 7.OO%
Appliances t.OO% t.OOYo t.OO%
Electronics t.OOYo L.OOY" t.OOlo
Miscellaneous t.OO96 L.OOy" L.OOyo
Winter
Peak
Demand
Savings
o.o7
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.o6
o.o1
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
o.o2
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
o.o2
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 6
Table 3: Behavioral Measure Savings (cont.)
Setment Vintate
Mobi le Home Existi ng
Mobi le Home Existing
Mobi le Home Existing
Mobi le Home Existing
Mobi le Home Existing
Mobi le Home Existing
Mobi le Home Existing
Mobile Home New
Mobile Home New
Mobile Home New
Mobile Home New
Mobile Home New
Mobile Home New
Mobile Home New
Limited lncome SF Existing
Umited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF Existing
Li mited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF Existing
Li mited lncome MF New
Limited lncome MF New
Limited lncome MF New
Limited lncome MF New
Li mited lncome MF New
Li mited lncome MF New
Umited lncome MF New
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Li mited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited I ncome MH Existi ng
Umited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Annual
Savinas (96
Enduse ofusate)
Cooling L.OO
Space Heating L-OOYo
Water Heating L-OO
lnterior Lighting L-oo
Applia nces L.OO
Electronics L.OOYo
Miscel la neous L-OO
Cooling L.OO
Space Heating t.OO
Water Heating l-OOYo
lnterior Ughting l-OO
Appliances L.OOY"
El4tronics t-OO
Miscel la neous t-OO
Cooling L-OOY"
Space Heating L.OO%o
Water Heating L-OOYo
lnterior Lighting L.OOY"
Applia nces L.OO
Electroni cs L-OO
Miscel la neous L.OOY"
Cooling L-OO
Space HeatinB L.OOY"
water Heatin8 L.OO
lnterior Lighting L-ooyo
Appliances L-OOYo
Electronics L-OOY"
Miscel la neous l-Ooyo
Cooling 1.OO%
Space Heating L.OO
Water Heating 1.OO%
lnterior Lighting L-OO
Applia nces L-OO
Electronics t-OO
Miscellaneous l-OOYo
Cooling L-OOYo
Space Heating L.OOY"
Water Heating 3,.OO
lnterior Lighting L-00
Appl ia nces 1-OoYo
Electronics 1"-OOY"
Miscellaneous L.OOY"
Cooling 1,-OO
Space Heating 1,-oO94
water Heati ng L.oOYo
lnterior Ughting L.OO
Appliances L.OO
Electronics L.OO
Miscel la neous ]--OO
Cooli ng L-oOYo
Space Heating L-OoYo
Water Heating L.OOY"
lnterior Lighting L.OOY"
Appliances \.OOY"
Electronics L-OOY,
Mi scel la neous L-OOY"
Annual Summer
Savints Peak(Bas Demand
year) Savings
14.()9 0.O4
96.1()
30-aa o-oo
16.44 0.OO
45.48 0.OO
a.1a o.oo
86.1"0 O.O1
L4.O7 0.O4
84.90
24.23 0.OO
2()-s6 ()-oo
29.9L O.OO
7 -54 0.OO
82-43 0.O1
15.30 0.O2
101.61
42.56 0.OO
19.65 0.OO
45.48 0.OO
4.49 0.oo
49.91 0.O1
t2.49 0.o1
94.O43a.aa o.oo
23.99 0.OO
29.9L 0.OO
7.42 0.OO
46.45 0.o1
7.97 0.O1
28.5!
t7.7t o.oo
4.36 0.oo
43.4T O.OO
a.1a o.oo
45.37 0.O1
6.40 0.o1
25-42
L6-20 0.OO
11..OO O.OO
24.56 0.OO
7 -54 0.OO
82.OO O.O1
7 -25 0.O2
6().3()
27.02 0.OO
L8.7t O.OO
43.4t O.O1
7.8t O.OO
44.61 0.o1
6.07 ().O2
53.27
24.70 0.OO
22.84 0.OO28..ss o.oo
7.21, O.OO
45.53 0.O1
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF
of ofDemand Demand(s) (w)
t_ooyo o.ooyo
o-ooyo t.ooy"
L.OOv" 1".OO
1-OO 1-OOv"
l.OOy" 1,.OOyo
1,.OO t.OOy"
t.oo L.00%,
l.OOy" O.OOyo
o.oo 1,.oovo
t.oo l.oov"
1.OOv" L.00
L.OO 1,.OOyo
L.OOy" 1,.OOyo
l.OOy" 1,.OOyo
1.OO% O.OOyoo.oov" 1,.oo
L.OOyo t.OOy"
1,.OO t_OOy"
\.OOy" 1,.OOy"
L.OOyo l.Ooyo
1,.OOyo L.OOy"
1,.OO O.OO
o.ooy" L.ooyo
t.ooy" L.00
1,.OOv" \.OOv"
L.OOv" L.OOv"
1_OOv" 1.OOt.oov" \.oov"t.oov" o.oov"o.ooy" 1,.ooyot.oov" 1,.oov"
L-OOv" L.00
7-OOv" L.00
L.OOyo L.OOy"
l.OOYo I.OOY"
t.ooyo o.ooy"o.oov" 1,.oo
L.OOy" 1,.OOyo
L.OOyo 1,.OOyo
L.OOy" 1,.OOyot.oov" 1,.oo
L.OOy" 1,.OOyo
t.oov" o.oo
o.oov" t.oov"
t.oov" L.oo
L.OOy" L.OOy"
L.OOvo t.OO
t.oo t.ooyo
L.00 r.OOv"
7.OOv" O.OOy"
o.oo t.oov"
1,.OOy" L.OOyo
t.ooy" L.ooyo
L.OOyo 1,.OOyo
1,.OOyo t.OOy"
7.OOv" L.OOv"
TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 7
lllrinte r
Peak
Demand
savings
o.o6
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.o5
o.o1
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
o.o6
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.o6
o.o1
o.oo
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
o.o2
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.o2
o.oo
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.()4
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
o.o3
o.oL
o.oo
o.o1
o.oo
o.o1
Segment
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Famlly
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Single Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Famlly
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Family
Multi Famlly
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
Mobile Home
2.96s 2.97 s E.Oa2.845 2.82 S g.Oz
L.43 s 1.42 s 1.s2
o.77 s O.zSs O.zA1.19s r.rZ5 L.2L0.28s O.ZSs o.2e
3.22 s S.ZO s 3.44
12.70 s 12.s9 s 13.35
L.32 s 1.32
0.6s s o.es
0.s2 s o.sr
O.37 S o.sS
1.05 s 1.04
0.26 s O.Zs
2.89 s Z.gg
7.06 5 t.oz
s 3.03 s 3.26s 3.41 s 4.75S r.os S 2.20s 0.81 s 0.e7s 1.2e s 1.63s o.sz s o.+s$ t.tt s s.os
s 14.28 $ rg.S+
1.40 s 1.43
o.8s s 1.20
0.63 s O.eS
0.28 s O.Sz
1.s9 s 1.81
o.32 s O.aZ
3.57 s 4.93
8.54 $ 10.94
s 3.36 s :.+Ss s.rz s s.sos 2.34 s 2.s1s o.eg s o.gss 1.73 s r.sas o.as s 0.4es s.as s s.93
$ rg.rg S 20.89
5 t.42 $ t.qzs 1.31 s r.+ss o.sa s o.g+s 0.29 s 0.31s L.74 s 1.71s o.+s s o.+ss s.++ s 6.00s 11.s3 s rZ.zg
s 1.38 s r.+rs 1.22 s 1.32s 0.88 s o.s+s 0.41 s O.a+s 1.ss s 1.6ss 0.41 s O.++s s.rr s s.szs 11.1s 5 rZ.OS
s 3.54 s S.0Ss 4.83 s S.zgs r.sg s 1.69s o.ez s 0.58s 1.78 s 1.7ss 0.4s s o.aes 4.87 s s.23$ rz.zg $ rs.zs
s c.oz s +.raS 4.2s S +.sgs r.ss s 1.59s o.so s o.ses 1.60 s r.zoS o.+r S o.++s 4.82 5 S.zZ
s 17.47 $ rS.eS
Table 4: Behavioral Measure Benefits
Vintate End Use 2012 2013 2014 2015 2O2O 2025 2030
Existing Cooling S a.sZS S.agS g.S+S S.sSS 3.84S 3.845 S.gO
Existing SpaceHeating S S.OS S S.O+ S g.er S S.zO S 5.19 S S.SZ S S.gS
Existing WaterHeating S r.ss S 1.52 S 1.61 S 1.75 S 2.26 S 2.36 S Z.sr
Existing lnteriorUghting S 0.53 S O.er S 0.64 S 0.65 S O.Z+ S O.0g S O.ZS
Existing Appliances S r.zl S 1.65 S L.lL S 1.s1 S 2.03 S 1.92 S r.eg
Existing Electronics S O.erS 0.31 S O.SgS O.gsS 0.47S O.sOS O.SS
Existing Miscellaneous S S.SZ S :.aO S 3.53 S 3.86 S S.rs 5 S.Sr S S.gr
Existing Total s 14.13 s 13.92 s 14.55 $ 15.70s 19.68 s 20.40$ Zr.lg
New Cooling S
New Space Heating SNew Water Heating SNew lnterior Ughting $New Appliances SNew Electronics SNew Miscellaneous SNew Total $
Existing Cooling S
Existing Space Heating S
Existing Water Heating S
Existing lnterior Lighting S
Existing Appliances 5
Existing Electronics S
Existing Miscellaneous S
Existint fotal S
New Cooling S
New Space Heating SNew Water Heating SNew lnterior Ughting $New Appliances SNew Electronics SNew Miscellaneous SNew Total S
Existing Cooling S
Existing Space Heating S
Existing Water Heating S
Existing lnterior Ughting S
Existing Appliances S
Existing Electronics S
Existing Miscellaneous S
Existing Total S
New Cooling SNew Space Heating SNew Water Heating SNew lnterior Lighting $New Appliances SNew Electronics SNew Miscellaneous SNew Total S
3.s7S s.ss$ s.sz
2.s9 s z.sz s 2.801.04s r.ozs 1.08o.s6s o.sss o.s81.s9s 1.s3s 1.s70.28s O.zzs o.zs
2.9r s Z.Ag s 3.10
t2.54 s 12.38 s 12.99
3.61 s g.eZs 3.562.29$ 2.27 s 2.480.96s O.Sss 1.020.69s O.O0s O.zO1.09s 1.08s 1.11
o.2s s o.2s s o.z0
2.79 s 2.78 s 2.99
11.69s11.61 3LZ.ZZ
s 1.32 s 1.36s o.zg s 1.12s o.er s o.szs 0.39 s 0.46s 1.16 s r.+es o.zs s o.ssS s.as 5 4.79s 7.se s 10.39
$ s.sz s e.szs r.r+ s +.+sS 1.17 S r.szs o.ss s o.ozs r.ezs 1.88s o.sz s o.+zs s.:s s 4.ss
S 13.84 $ 17.14
s s.es s s.ga5 2.78 S r.gSs 1.11 s 1.48s 0.73 s O.ezs r.rs s 1.sos 0.29 s 0.38s 3.28 s +.+s$ 13.05 s 16.s4
L.42 S 1.40 S
0.70 s 0.69 s
o.s6 s o.ss s
0.28 5 0.27 S
1.s4 5 L.47 S
0.28 s O.Zt s
3.oo s a.oo s
7.77 s 7.66 s
L,4L
0.76
0.s8
0.28
1.51
o.29
3.24
8.06
L.34
0.70
0.55
0.37
1.09
o.26
3.13
7,J,4
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY. S
Table 4: Behavioral Measure Benefits (cont.)
Segment
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome SF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
limited lncome MF
Limited Income MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Limited lncome MF
Vintate End Use 2Ol2
Existing Cooling S 1.96
Existing Space Heating 5 2.74
Existing Water Heating S 1.43
Existing lnterior Lighting S 0.66
Existing Appliances S 1.55
Existing Electronics S 0.29
Existi ng Miscel la neous S 3.05
Existing Total S 11.66
2013 2014 201s 2020s r.g+ s 1.97 s 2.00 s 2.13s 2.7L s Z.ge s 3.31 s 4.55s r.+o s 1.4e s 1.61 s 2.09s 0.64s O.ezs o.oss o.zas 1.48 s r.sa s 1.63 s 1.8ss o.zs s o.so s o.s: s o.+as s.og s g.ze s 3.s7 s 4.83$ rr.so s 12.18 s 13.13 $ 15.78
202s 2030s 2.13 s 2.15s s.o4 s s.44s 2.19 s 2.33s o.ze s o.zss 1.7s s 1.73s 0.47 s 0.s0s s.22 s s.66s 17.s3 s rg.sr
New
New
New
New
New
New
New
New
Exi sti ng
Exi sti ng
Exi sti ng
Exi sti ng
Exi sti ng
Exi sti ng
Exi sti ng
Existing
New
New
New
New
New
New
New
New
1.01
o.77
0.56
o.27
1.45
0.28
2.90
7.24
1.00
0.76
0.5s
0.25
1.39
0.28
2.88
7.t2
L.7t
2.75
1.40
0.81
1.08
o.27
3.16
11.19
1.01
0.83
0.s8
o.27
t.43
0.29
3.09
7.5L
t.7L
3.06
1.53
0.8s
1.15
0.30
3.48
,,2.07
r.02
0.94
0.53
0.27
t.52
0.32
3.39
8.08
1.09 s
L.33 s
0.83 s
0.31 st.76 s
o.42 s
4.ss s
10.28 $
1.09 s
1.4s s
0.88 s
0.28 s
L.70 s
0.4s s
4.8e s
10.74 $
1.11
1.58
0.94
0.30
1.69
0.49
5.27
11.38
Cooling S
Space Heating S
Water Heating S
lnterior Ughting S
Appliances S
El ectroni cs S
Miscellaneous STotal S
1.68 s 1.68 s
2.s4 5 2.52 S
L32 s 1.31 s
0.81 s O.tt s
1.06 s 1.0s s
0.26 s 0.26 s
2.94 s Z.gq s
10.50 s 10.s2 $
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
$
S
s
s
s
S
s
S
s
S
s
s
s
S
$
s
s
s
s
s
S
s
s
S
s
s
s
s
s
S
s
S
S
s
s
s
s
s
$
1.84s r.SSs r.Se
4.29 s 4.54 s s.02
2.O4 s Z.rS s 2.33
L.Oz s 0.93 s 1.00
L.47 s 1.s5s 1.65o.4os o.+zs o.+s
4.7s s S.rg s s.e 0
1s.81 s16.81 srS.OZ
Cool i ng
Space Heati ng
Water Heating
lnterior Lighting
Appl i a nces
El ectroni cs
Mi scel I a neo us
Total
S
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
Cooling S
Space Heating S
Water Heating S
lnterior Lighting SAppliances S
El ectroni cs S
Miscellaneous S
Total S
0.83 S 0.83 5
0.70 s 0.69 s
0.s2 s o.sr s
0.37 s 0.3s s
1.00 s o.ge s
0.26 s O.zS s
2.79 5 218 S
6.45 s e.cO $
0.84 s 0.84 s
0.76 s 0.8s so.sss o.ers
0.37 S o.ss S
1.03 s r.ro s
0.27 s o.2s s
z.ss s 3.28 s
6.80 s 7.3s s
0.91 s 0.93s 0.97
L.20 s r.sr s 1.430.82s 0.88s 0.940.4ss o.sss o.+z
L.4L s 1.49 s 1.s90.38s 0.41 s 0.44
4.4s s 4.83 5 s.24
9.62 s 10.2s s 11.02
s 1.so s 1.e3s E.Oz s Z.zts r.ss s 1.48S 0.69 S o.zss r.sr s r.zss 0.44 s 0.47s 4.83 s s.rr5 u.oz S rc.zg
$ t.tq s r.zss z.Gt s z.gss 1.38 s 1.48s 0.88 s O.gsS r.eo S 1.69s 0.39 s O.qzs 4.83 s s.rzs 13.50 s 14.39
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
$
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Limited lncome MH New
Cooling S 1.84
Space Heating S 1.62
Water Heating S 0.91
lnterior Lighting S 0.63
Appliances S 1.64
Electronics S 0.26
Miscellaneous S 2.99
Total S 9.89
Cooling S
Space Heating S
Water Heating S
lnterior Lighting SAppliances S
El ectroni cs S
Miscellaneous STotal S
1.83 s r.S+
1.61 s 1.76
0.89 s O.g+
0.51 s 0.0+
t.s7 s 1.62
0.26 s O.Zg
2.96 s S.r0
9.74 s 10.2s
1.8s s 1.91
L.97 s 2.79
r.o2 s 1.33
0.64 s O.za
L.7L s r.Sr
0.31 s 0.41
3.4s s 4.s6
10.9s s 13.53
1.s8s 1.s9s 1.70
1.s6 s t.74s 2.460.89s O.szs 1.300.78s 0.81 s O.gz
1.L4 s 1.21 s 1.s10.2s5 o.zt S o.s63.09s 3.38s 4.s29.29s 9.98s12.83
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
1.s5 S 1.s6 S
L.44 s 1.43 s
0.84 S o.sE S
0.77 s O.z: st.L2 s 1.11 s
0.24 s O.z+ s
2.90 s z.as s
8.87 s 8.78 s
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 9
Table 5: Behavioral Measure Benefit-Cost Ratios
Source
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
Computed from above
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
From LoadMAP Model
Segment Vintage
Single Family Existing
Single Family New
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family New
Mobile Home Existing
Mobile Home New
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF New
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH New
Single Family Existing
Single Family New
Multi Family Existing
Multi Family New
Mobile Home Existing
Mobile Home New
Limited lncome SF Existing
Limited lncome SF New
Limited lncome MF Existing
Limited lncome MF New
Limited lncome MH Existing
Limited lncome MH New
20L2 2013 2014
0.30 0.30 0.32
0.27 0.27 0.29
o.L7 0.15 0.t7
0.15 0.15 0.16
o.27 0.27 0.28
0.25 0.25 0.26
0.25 0.25 0.25
0.23 0.23 0.24
0.16 0.15 0.16
o.L4 0.14 0.15
o.21 0.21 0.22
0.19 0.19 0.20
201s 2020 202s 2030
o.34 0.42 0.44 0.46
0.31 0.39 0.42 0.45
0.19 0.24 0.25 0.26
0.77 0.22 0.24 0.26
0.30 0.37 0.38 0.40
0.28 0.36 0.38 0.40
0.28 0.36 0.38 0.40
0.26 0.34 0.35 0.39
0.77 0.22 0.23 0.24
0.15 0.2r o.22 0.24
0.24 0.29 0.30 0.32
o.27 0.28 0.29 0.31
0.30
o.27
o.77
0.15
o.27
0.25
0.25
0.23
0.15
0.14
o.2t
0.19
0.30
o.27
0.16
0.15
o.27
0.25
0.25
0.23
0.15
0.14
0.27
0.19
0.32
o.29
o.t7
0.16
0.28
o.26
0.26
o.24
0.16
0.15
0.22
0.20
0.34
0.31
0.19
o.t7
0_30
0.28
0.28
o.26
o.17
0.16
0.24
o.27
0.42
0.39
o.24
0.22
o.37
0.35
0.36
0.34
0.22
o.2l
0.29
0.28
o.44
o.42
0.25
0.24
0.38
0.38
0.38
0.36
0.23
o.22
0.30
o.29
0.45
0.45
o.26
0.25
0.40
0.40
0.40
0.39
0.24
o.24
0.32
0.31
The response to this Request is sponsored by Pete Pengilly, Customer Research
and Analysis Leader, ldaho Power Company.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 1O
REQUEST NO. 46: ldaho Powe/s Conservation Potentia! Assessment
Appendix states on page F-1 that "The market adoption rates for the ldaho Power study
were developed using the ramp rates from the Northwest Power and Conservation
Council's Sixth Plan as a starting point. The ramp rates were then adjusted based on
actual ldaho Power program history and information from program evaluations."
Please provide the assumptions, calculations, and sources (including dates)
used to develop the final ramp rates for each measure in Appendix F. Please provide
all workpapers in executable format.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 46: The following information was provided to
ldaho Power by AEG.
AEG started with the Northwest Power and Conservation Council's Sixth Plan
ramp rates and, based upon its expertise, adjusted them to align with ldaho Powe/s
program accomplishments lor 201V2012 and projected savings lor 2013. AEG does
not have any work papers that support the process. Appendix F presents the results of
the process.
The response to this Request is sponsored by Pete Pengilly, Customer Research
and Analysis Leader, ldaho Power Company.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REOUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 11
REQUEST NO. 47: Page 49 of the DSM Report states that the third party
evaluation of Heating and Cooling Efficiency recommended that ldaho Power "develop
a brand for ldaho Powe/s energy efficiency programs [at the portfolio level] to increase
customer awareness." Does ldaho Power plan to implement this suggestion? Please
explain why or why not.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST NO. 47: No, all of ldaho Poweds energy efficiency
programs are consistently branded to align with the overall Company brand. The ldaho
Power brand is aligned with the Company's vision and mission. The intent of the ldaho
Power brand is to make all of the Company's materials consistent and recognizable.
The response to this Request is sponsored by Pete Pengilly, Customer Research
and Analysis Leader, ldaho Power Company.
DATED at Boise, ldaho, this 16th day of July 2014.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 12
Attorney for ldaho Power Company
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 16th day of July 20141 served a true and correct
copy of IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY upon the
following named parties by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following:
Gommission Staff Hand Delivered
Idaho Public Utilities Commission _FAX
4T2WeslWashington (83702) X Email [e-mail]
P.O. Box 83720
Boise, ldaho 83720-007 4
lndustrial Customers of ldaho Power Hand Delivered
D. Neil Price
Deputy Attomey General
ldaho Conservation League
Benjamin J. Otto
ldaho Conservation League
710 North Sixth Street
Boise, ldaho 83702
_U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mail
_U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mail
_U.S. Mail
_Overnight Mai!
FAX
Peter J. Richardson
RICHARDSON ADAMS, PLLC
515 North 27th Street (83702) FAX
P.O. Box 7218
Boise, ldaho 83707
Dr. Don Reading
6070 Hill Road
Boise, ldaho 83703
X Email [e-mail]
Hand Delivered
X Email [e-mail]
Hand Delivered
U.S. Mail
Overnight Mail
FAXX Email [e-mail]
IDAHO POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO THE SECOND PRODUCTION
REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO IDAHO POWER COMPANY - 13
BEFORE THE
IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
GASE NO. IPC-E-14-04
IDAHO POWER COMPANY
RESPONSE TO STAFF'S
REQUEST NO.43
lnsulation - Ceilint 36.1X 90.0t6 2A ss94.00 375.8 0.19 S0.139
lnsulation - Ductlnt 0.0x 9.5*25 S3so.m 52E.1 o.58 s0.045
lnsulation - lnflltiatlon Control 24.2%100.0*72 s265.00 1,070.9 o.77 s_0.92e
So.1s4lnsulatlon - Radlant Batrler 5.096 90.016 t2 s922.68 705.3 o.t7
Ductint - Repalr and seallng 11.8%90.0,6 20 s375.00 r,877.2 1.55 50.018
wlndows - Hith Etficiency/ENERGY
STAR 61.3,6 100.0%25 s7,5m.00 2,558.5 0.09 50.23s
windows - lnstall Reflecuve Film s.096 45.0,6 10 s89s.39 943.4 o.67 50.125
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.096 100.()96 12 s320.00 144.8 0.10 s0.260
Roofs - Hlgh Reflectivlty 5.0,6 10.0'6 15 s1,s49.61 211.1 0.r0 s0.7s3
Attlc Fan - lnstallatlon t.8x 50.0t6 18 s115.80 15.8 0.10 s0.680
Attk Fan - Solar 0.0x 0.0t6 0 So.oo 1.00 s0.mo
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - lnstallation 13.0%100.016 19 s3so.00 15.8 0.04 52.001
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 7.7%23.O%18 s20o.0o 415.6 1.77 So.042
CeilinB Fan - lnstallation 20.616 1m.0%10 s160.00 277 -A 1.10 s0.077
Thermostat - Clod(Programmable s2.0%85.0%L2 5111.42 1,t160.5 3.15 s0.009
Home Energy ManaSement System 2.0%40.016 20 s500.00 L,277.9 0.54 s0.041
Central AC - Early Replacement o.4%80.0%15 s2,89s.@ 274.7 0.07 s1.081
Central AC - Malntenance and Tune-Up 47.W 100.016 4 s12s.00 27t.O 0.78 50.t27
Cerltral Heat Pump - Maintenance 2s.wr 100.0t6 20 s430.31 794.9 o.74 So.oaa
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.016 100.0%5 s7s.o0 393.4 4.30 50.043
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators L2.OX 90.0'6 10 s12.70 744.2 2.L6 s0.011
water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 48.O9$100.0,6 10 527.OO 675.L 4.il s0.00s
Water Heater - Plpe lnsuladon 12.W 38.116 15 s180.00 26t.7 0.32 So.o71
Wate. Heater - Timer L7.O%1m.016 10 s194.@ 1L9.7 0.40 s0.062
water Heater - Oesuperheater 0.0x 0.016 0 So.oo 1.m So.mo
Water Heater - Solar System s.g%50.096 zo S6,sm.oo 3,458.2 0.13 So.156
lnterio, UghUnt - Occupancy Sensors 24.4X 50.0%15 97so.00 457.4 o.1?S0.164
Exterior LiShting - Photosensor Control 24.Or$100.0%8 s90.00 26.4 0.03 s0.s41
Exterior Lightlng - Photovoltaic
lnstallation 10.016 45.0X 15 $2,97s.00 38.s 0.00 57.927
Exterior ughthg - Tlmeclock
lnstallation 10.0t6 100.0%8 s72.00 26.0 0.04 s0.433
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 0.0x 100.0'6 13 s1,203.m 136.8 0.02 s0.983
s0.071Refri gerator - Maintenance 17.O%100.0,6 4 s39.18 151.9 0.38
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0%85.0%9 s130.00 1.062.3 1.35 s0.018
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.Wo 85.096 5 s130.00 7L4.6 0.95 to.036
Freezer - Eady Replacement 0.0,6 100.0%13 s484.00 L07.2 0.04 s0.sos
Freezer - Maintenance 37.0%100.096 4 s15.57 L25.7 0.78 s0.034
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1,4%100.016 4 s21.00 9L.4 0.43 So.063
Pgorlllne - rlmel
Pool Heater - Solar System
-59.0%
0.0%
100.096
0.0%
15 $150 qo
9q.oo
l'1 1 o.32 to,077
0 r.00 So.ooo
Behavloal Feedback Tools 0.0x 1m.0%7 540.00 353.4 0.30 s0.110
Eesidential Energy Efficiency Eq,uipment and Measure Data
Tabb E-75 aGrgy Etlwct.y Norr-Equlqrcnt Da*gryb Family, ilsdttg Wt bgtG
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-53
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
Table 8-76 EnctgyEllbbncyNon-&ulpncntOAAndc FamW llcrVln@o
lnsulation - C€iling s4.2%90.096 20 s415,80 568.5 o.42 s0.06s
lnsulation - Ductlng 3.096 9.596 25 s3y).00 s77.2 0.s2 s0.049
lnsulatlon - Radlant Banler 25.0%100.0%t2 s922.58 210.5 0.07 so,s15
Ductir8 - Repair and Seallng 50.0%90.0%20 s37s.00 L,707.s 1.40 so.or9
Windows - Hlgh Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 92.9%100.0%25 s2,2m.00 3,O70.4 0./O So.os7
Windows - lrstall Reflective Film 2.0%45.O%10 ssn.67 558.1 0.63 So.13s
Doors - Storm and Thermal 13.096 100.016 L2 s180.00 209.9 0.30 So.1o1
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.016 90.016 15 ss16.s4 218.1 0.32 50.243
Attic Fan - lnstallatlon 3.8X 50.096 18 s96.s0 14.7 0.12 s0.611
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0%0.096 0 s0.00 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - lnstallation 4.O,(25.O%19 Szoo.oo 14.7 0.06 s1.233
Whole-Hous€ Fan - lnstallatlon 7.7%25.0%18 s200.00 t102.8 1.58 s0.045
CeilinB Fan - lnstallation 20.6%1m.0%10 s160.00 292.9 1.18 50.073
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 743%85.0t6 L2 S114.42 970.4 2.49 so.014
Home Energy Management System 2.0%60.4x 20 s600.00 t,2to.6 0.54 s0.044
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 4r.o%100.0r5 4 s12s.00 225.O 0.56 s0.1s3
Centaal Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.Vn 100.096 zo s430.31 674.8 0.63 s0.0s6
Water Heater- Faucet Aerators 3.096 90.016 10 s7.12 135.1 3.5s so.ooz
water Heater - Lorr-Flow Showerheads 50.0t6 1m.0%10 s27.0O 616.8 4.40 so.006
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42.Wo 47.3%15 Sso.oo 234.7 1.11 So.o21
Water Heater - Timer 5.096 100.016 10 s194.00 392.1 0.39 s0.065
Water Heater - Oesuperheater o.016 0.0%0 s0.(n 1.00 so.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0%50.016 zo s5,s00.00 3,158.9 0,72 So.182
lnterior LlShtinS - Occ1tpancy 5enso6 24.0%30.0%15 ss00.00 37,-.7 0,23 So.oeo
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control t3.a%100.016 8 s90.00 27.5 0.04 So.srr
Exterior Lightlnt - Photovoltaic
lnstallaUon 10.0%43.Ar5 15 52,975.@ 4t.4 0.m s7.356
Exterior Lighting - Iimeclock
lnstallatlon t6.gv"lm.096 8 s72.00 27.5 0.05 So.4o9
Refrigerator - Malntenance 24,0%L@.O%4 s39.r8 83.0 0.22 s0.130
RefrlSerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0%85.096 9 s130.00 667.4 0.92 s0.028
Freezer - Remove Second Unit ?.o%85.096 5 S13o.oo 419.8 o.44 s0.061
Freezer - Maintenance
Electronics - Smart Power Strips
24..0%
L.4%
100.016
100.0%
4 s15.57 73.8
84.3
0.49 So.os8
s0.0694s21.00 0.39
Pool Pump - Timer 55.0%100.096 15 s160.00 _ _2|6:
129.2
o.?2
1.00-* tn
s9:176
_$0.r9
s0.122Behavioral Feedback Tools
_* 0.M
0.0%
o.a%
100.096 1
s0.P_
s40.00
B-54 ***."nirnoc.co.
Residential Energy Efficigncy Equipment and Measure Data
Table 8-77 EfigUEflrc*n ytlon-qulpnarrtDaHlald Familn Erffing Wn@e
Refriterator - Early Replacement
Refrigerator -Maintenance
Refri8e6tor -Remove Secord Unit
Freeler - Remove Second Unft
Freezer - Earlyi:?|.":I:ll
Freezer - Maintenance
Electronics - Smart Power Strips
P:olPump-Timer _- -
Pool Heater - Solar System
5160 00
So.oo
Eehavioral Feedback Tools
rnerrlOC UtitltV Soiuiions Consulting
lnsulatlon - Ceilint 27-S%40.096 20 s21s.00 150.3 0.25 s0.126
lnsulatlon - Ducting 0.0x 9.516 25 S3so.oo 15.3 0.03 SL838
lnsulation - lnfiltration Control 7A.t%100.096 t2 _i_T5.90
5922.68
10_-31
239.0
o23
0.09
$0.103
So.4s4lnsulation - Radlant Barrier 5.0%40.096 L2
oucting - Repalr and Sealht 11.816 90.096 20 s37s.00 4t8.4 0.28 So.o79
Wlndows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR
60.s96 100.096 25 s2,s00.@ s48.1 0.08 s0.365
Windows - lnstall R€flective Film s.0%tts.0%10 s186.32 155.1 1.G)so.160
Doors - Storm and Thermal t7.o%1m.016 t2 s320.0O s0.mo
Roofs - Hlgh Refl€ctivity 3.0%10.0%15 51.549.61 54.3 0.05 S2.931
Attic Fan - lnstallation 0.0%0.096 18 So.oo 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Solar o.o%0.0%0 So.oo 1.(n s0.000
Attlc Fan - PhotovoJtaic - Installatlon 0.0%0.016 19 s0.00 1.00 s0.m0
whole-House Fan - lnstallation L.6%23.O%18 51s0.00 63.3 0.66 s0.220
Ceillnt Fan - lnstallation t2.t%1m.or6 10 S80.oo s2.4 0.85 90.203
Thermostat - Clock/Protrammable ?.A.6%85.016 L2 s73.33 179.6 1.00 So.o48
Home Energy Manatement System 2-O%N.0%20 s600.00 1,080.0 0.58 s0.049
Central Ac - Eady Replacement 0,0%80.096 15 s2,89s.00 81.3 0.02 s3.6s3
Central AC - Malntenance and Tune-Up ?3.O%1m.096 4 51@.00 80.3 o.78 s0.344
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 2s.o%100.0t6 zo Sroo.oo 21t.t 0.89 s0.042
Room Ac - Removal ofsecond Unit o.ffi 100.0%5 S7s.oo 195.9 2.31 50.087
Water Heat€r - Faucet Aerators 8.096 90.0'6 10 s12.70 79.6 1.10 50.021
Water Heater - Lorr-Fiow Showerheads 24.O%100,0t6 10 527.00 t63.2 2.35 s0.010
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42.0%38.714 15 s180.()()1@.2 0.12 S0.184
Water Heater - Timer 5.016 100.016 10 s194.00 t6L.2 0.15 So.15o
Water Heater - Desuperheatet 0.096 0.0t6 0 s0.m 1.00 s0.m0
water Heater - Solar System s.o%50.016 10 s6,s00.00 7,532.7 0.04 s0.s64
lnterior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 6.O%20.o%15 s2s6.00 2(x).O 0.15 s0.126
Exterior Lightint - Photosensor Control 7.0%1m.0x I s90.00 15.9 0.02 S0.888
Exterior Lightlnt - Photovoltalc
lnstallation 10.0%45.0%15 s2,975.00 4t-7 0.00 s7.430
Exterlor Llghting - Timeclock
lnstallation 6.0%100.0%8 572.O0 15.9 0.03 s0.711
2.7%100.096 13 t1,203.00 119.7 0.02 s1.124
27.O%1(x).0t6 4 S39.18 132.9 o.32 50.081
3.0%85.016 9 s130.00 929.5 1.18 So.o20
sooar2.0%85.0t6 5 s130.00 625.3 0.64
2.7%100.096 13 s484.00 93.8 0.04 s0.577
27.0%100.0%4 s1s.57 110.0 o.77 s0.039
L.4/"100.0%4 s21.00 81.8 0.38 s0.071
1991
0.0,6
100.0%15
1.00
s0.000
so.00o0.0%0
0.0,6 100.0%I 196.6 o.t7 So.2o3s40.00
B-55
Residentlal Energy Efflclency Equipment and Measure Data -
Table B-18 Encry Elfrcbrry tloa-EqulptnntM- Malti FamW tew Wnbgo
lnsulatlon - Cellln8 4L.3%40.096 20 s1so.50 190.1 0.51 s0.070
lnsulation - Oucting 3.0%9.5%25 s3s0.00 10.5 0.02 s2.668
ln$lation - Radiant Ba.rier 5.096 1m.0%t2 S922.68
s37s.m
67:r_
385.2
0.02 -- _S1.6u
So.086DuctinS - Repair ard Sealing a).0%90.0%20 o.25
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 93.0X 100.0%25 s2,200.m 978.?0.15 So.180
wlndows - lnstall Reflectlve Fllm 2.O%1?roT
tm.0%
10 s218.97 131.5 0.81 50.222
ooors - Storm and Thermal 19-O9(L2 5180.m s0.0m
Roofs - High Reflectivaty 0.0x 90.0%15 s516.54 3s.9 0.11 5L.474
Attic Fan - lnstallation 0.0%0.0'6 18 So.m 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0%0.0%0 50.m 1.00 So.ooo
Attic Fan - Photovohaic - lnstallation 0.0%0.0%19 So.oo 1.00 So.ooo
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 1.5*25,0%18 s150.m 50.000
Ceiling Fan - lnstallatlon 12.7%199i1
85.0,6
10 s80.00 50.5 L.O2 so.175
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 40.8,6 10 573.13 111.8 0.58 So.osz
Home EnerSy ManaSement System 2.0%60.016 zo s6m.00 8SO.O o.s7 50.062
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 33.0,6 1@.0x 4 s1m.m 65.7 o.24 So.42o
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.O%100.0%20 s100.00 t82.4 0.75 so.o+e
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 4.0%90.096 10 57.t2 72.8 1.88 so.o13
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 30.096 1m.0%10 527.U 332.3 2.26 so.011
Water Heater - Plpe lnsulaflon 42.O%41.3%1S ss0.00 9r.7 0.41 so.0s6
Water Heater - Timer 5.0x 100.0%10 s194.00 150.9 0.14 $0.u1
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.016 0.0%o so.oo 1.00 so.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.OX s0.0%10 56sm.00 t,416.7 0.04 So.6u
lnterior Lightin8 - Occupancy Sensors 5.0%10.096 15 s2s6.0o 275.1 o.2L $0.09s
Erterior Ughtlng - Photosensor Control t.0%100.0%I s90.00 20.0 0.03 s0.703
Erterior Lightlng - Photovoltaic
lnstallation 10.0x 45.0X 15 52,97s.00 54.3 0.00 s5.522
Exterior Llghthg - Timeclock
lnstallation 11.0%100.0x 8 s72.@ 20.0 0.04 s0.s52
Refrigentor - Malntenance 9.0%100.096 4 539.18 72.6 0.19 S0.149
Refri8erator - Remove Second Unit 1.Wb 85.096 9 s130.00 58/t 0 0.80 s0.032
Freezer - Remove Second Unlt 2.O%85.016 6 s130.00 ?67.3 0.38 s0.069
Freezer - Malntenance 9.0%100.0r 4 s1s.s7 64.6 0.43 s0.066
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4%100.0%4 s21.00 75.4 0.35 50.077
Pglllume,- rimel _
Pool Heater - Solar System
3s 91
0-0%
100.0t6 15 _L!0.9
So.m
So.ooo
0.0%0 1.00 So.ooo
Behrvioral Feedback Tools o.o%100.0%7 540.oo 177.7 0.15 50.225
B-55 www.enernoc.com
TaHa B-19
,Re_sidential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
ErptlU Elllclcncy llot-@aiprent Wr&ilc lbrrq Hfrrg Wnbgc
lnsuhtion - Ceiling 36.1%95.0%20 s707.00 299.1 0,14 so.209
lnsulation - Ducting 0.0%9s%25 s3s0.00 569.8 0.51 s0.049
Insulation - Infilt.ation Control 30.0%100.0%*t2
t2
s266.00 _r91.1
577.O
0i"1
0.15
50.03s
lnsulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0%95.0%s922.68 s0.188
Ductint - Repalr and SealinB 10.0%90.0%m 537s.oo 1,703.5 7.37 50.019
Windows - HiSh Efficiency/EilERGY
STAR s6.596
s.ox
100.0x 25 s7,s00.00 2,096.8 0.08 S0.287
Wndows - lnstall Rerlective Film 45.096 10 s788.06 484.0 0.75 So.2L7
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.0r 100.ox t2 s320.00 118.0 o.09 S0.319
Roofs - High Reflectivlty s.0x 10.0q6 15 s1,s49.61 108.3 0.10 51.468
Attic Fan - lnstallation 23%50.0,6 18 s11s.80 8.1 0.10 s1.325
Attic Fan - Solar 0.096 0.0%0 So.oo 1,00 So-ooo
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - lnstallation 13.0%100.096 19 s3s0.m 8.1 0.03 53.eoo
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 5.9%25.O%18 s1s0.00 228.5 2.25 s0.061
Ceiling Fan - lnstallation 77,9%100.0%10 S80.oo L42.5 2.14 s0.075
Thermostat - clock/Programmable 12.4%85.0%10 s73.33 1,L65.4 4.06 s0.008
Home Energy Management System 2.O%10.o%20 s600.00 1,313.4 o.58 s0.040
Central AC - Eady Replacement 0.096 80.0x 15 S2,89s.m 22t.3 o.05 S1.342
Central AC - Mahtenance and Tune-Up 25.0%100.0x 4 s100.00 218.3 0.78 so.126
Central Heat Pump - Malntenance 25.O%100.0%20 s393.m 705.1 0.69 s0.049
Room AC - Removal ofSecond Unit 0.096 1m.096 5 S7s.oo 880.3 9.53 so.019
Water Heater - Faucet Aeators L2.0%90.016 10 572.7o 99.2 1.45 50.017
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 33.4%1m.096 r0 527.00 452.L 3.11 50.oo8
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulatlon 42.4X 38.196 15 S180.oo L74.8 4.22 So.106
Water Heater - fimer L7.016 100.0x 10 t194.00 147.4 o.33 s0.074
Water Heater - Desuperheater o.a%0.0%0 So.oo 1.00 50.000
water Heater - solar system 5.0%s0.0}6 r0 S5,soo.oo 2,3L5.8 o.07 s0.373
hterlor Li8hting - Occupancl Sensors 67.W 80.0%15 5750.00 42L.1 0.11 S0.183
Exterior LightinS - Photdensor Control 23.0%100.0%8 s90.00 23.4 o.03 s0.601
Exterior Lightint - Photovoltaic
lnstallation 10.096 13.W 15 $2,97s.0o 34.7 0.00 58.808
Exterior Lightint - Timeclock
lnstallation 10.016 100.096 8 s72.00 23.4 0.04 s0.481
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 4.9%100.0%l3 S1,2o3.oo L?5.4
139.3
0.02
o.34
s1.073
RefriSerator - Maintenance 35.0e6 100.0%4 S39.18 So.o78
RefriSerator - Remove Second Unil 3.0%85.096 9 S13o.oo 973.8 t.24 s0.019
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0%85.096 6 s130.00 555.1 0.65 So.o3e
Freezer - Early Replacement 4.9%100.0%13 9484.00 98.3 0.(x 50.ssl
Free2er - Maintenance 35.0%100.0x 4 $ 1s.57 115.2 o.7z So.o37
Electronlcs - Smart Power Strlps 1.4%100.096 4 S21.oo 81.8
194.3
0.38 s0.071
PooL!:me lrilel
Pool Heater - Solar System
50.0,6 100.0%15 s160.00 o.z9
1.00
so.08s
So.oooo.0%0.0%0 So.oo
Behavioral Feedback Tools o.0x 1@.4%1 S4o.m 297.7 o,z7 So.134
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting a-57
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
labh 8-m EncryyElllcbncy tlon-EqulptnntbbMoffilc Honq MuWnEgc
lnsulation - Celling 54.2%95.0%20 s494.90 440.6 0.35 so.099
lnsulation - Oucting 3.0%9.SX L5 s3s0.00 497.O 0.45 So.oso
lnsulation - Radiant Barrier 5-ffi
s0.0x
100.0x t:
20
s922.68 158.9 0.0.'8
7.20
so.!9,
So.o22DuctinS - Repai. and Sealing 90.016 s37s.00 1,485.3
Windows - High Efflciency/ENERGY
STAR 88.0,6 100.096 25 52,200.00 2,40/9.6 0.38 So.o73
Wndows - lnstall Reflective Fllm ?:M
13.0%
45.O%10 s575.18 350.5 0.77 s0.219
So.130Doors - Storm and Thermal 100.0x L2 518o.oo 163.0 0.29
Rooft - Hl8h Reflectivity 5.0x 90.096 1S 5s16.s4 134.6 0.38 S0.394
Attic Fan - lnstallation 2.3%50.0%18 s96.s0 9.1 0.14 s0.ee1
Attic Fan - Solar o.w 0.0%0 So.m 1.m 50.ooo
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - lnstallatlon 4.4%25.O%19 s200.m 9.1 0.07 s1.e98
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 5.996 25.O%18 51s0.m 248.5 2.56 50.0s6
Ceillng Fan -,nstallatlon 77.9%100.0%10 s80.00 180.7 2.47 So.os9
Thermostat - Clock/Protrammable 46.3%85.0%10 573.33 740.2 3,67 s0.013
Home EnerSy Management System 2.0%50.0%20 s600.m 1,332.0 0.64 s0.040
C€ntral AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 25.0%100.0%4 s100.00 176-8 0.55 $0.1s6
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance E.O%1@.0%zo 5393.m sTt.5 0.s9 s0.060
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 3.W5 90.0%10 57.72 90.6 2.46 So.o1o
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 35.0%100.0%10 s27.00 413.4 2.96 s0.009
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42.O%413%1S 5s0.00 150.0 0.75 s0.032
Water Heater - Timer 5.0%1m.0%10 S194.oo 328.5 0.33 So.o79
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.016 0.0%0 s0.00 1.00 50.m0
Water Heater - Solar System s.0x 50.0%10 $6,s00.00 2,LL7.Z 0.06 50.409
lnterior LiEhtinB - Occupancy S€nsors 67.0%80.0x 15 5500.00 514,0 o.2L 5o.1oo
Exterlor Llthting - Photosensor Control t3.o%100.0%8 s90.00 24.8 0.04 50.558
Exterior Lightin8 - Photovoltaic
lnstallation 10.096 45.0X 15 s2,97s.00 37.3 0.00 s8.185
Exterior Lightlng - Tlmedock
lnstallatlon 16.0%100.0%8 s72.00 24.4 0.05 So.4ss
RefriSerator - Malntenance o.o%100.0?6 4 S39.18 76.1 0.20 50.142
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0%85.0%9 s130.00 611.8 0.84 s0.030
Freezer - Remove S€cond Unil 2.Oyo 85.0%6 s130.00 384.8 0.40 So.066
Freezer - Maintenance 0.0%
t_4%
100.0%!
4
s15.57 67.7
75.4
0.45
0.3s
s0.063
So.o77Electronics - Smart Power Strips 100.0,6 s21.00
Pool Heater - Solar System
3s.0%
0_0%
100.0%15 lAoo
50.00
-1%.,0.29
1.ft{}
- *P-:
so.000o.o%o
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0%100.0%1 S4o.oo 267.6 0.2s s0.149
B-58 www.enernoc,com
Residentlal Energy Efficienca Equipment and Measure Data
Et Gryf EfiHcrW lbn-qafurcnt Dat>Limlbd fitcoar $ngb Family, ffinglailc D-21
Wt@c
enerluOi uiiiiiy sotutions Consulting
lnsuhtion - C,elllnB 36.196 90.095 20 ss94.00 317.0 0.14 So.res
lnsuhtion - Ducting 0.0x 9.596 2S s3s0.m 602.5 0.54 So.o47
lnsulation - lnflltration Control ?4.2%r00.0%12 s266.00 945.1 0.65 s0.033
lnsulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0x 90.0%t2 _ !:12.58
s37s.00
619js
1,801.3
0.14 S0.178
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 2.O*90.096 20 1.45 s0.018
Wlndows - High Efflclency/ENERGY STAR 67.3%1(x).016 25 s7,s00.00 2,2L9.7 0.07 s0.271
windows - lnstall Reflective Film 5.0%$.49{t0 s89s.39 525.6 o.37 so.227
DooR - Storm and Thermal 38.0%100.0%t2 s320.@ 125.0 0.08 s0.301
Roofs - High Reflectlvlty 5.0%10.096 15 l':f111
$us.80
tL7.6 0.05 S1.3s2
Attic Fan - lnstallation 3.8%50.016 18 8.8 0.06 51.227
Aftic Fan - Solar 0.0%0.0r 0 5o.oo 1.00 So.ooo
Attlc Fan - Photovohaic - lnstallation 13.0,6 1m.ox 19 s350.00 8.8 o.0z S3.591
Whole-House Fan - lnstallatlon 7.7%25.016 18 s200.00 248.3 0.9s so.07s
Ceiling Fan - lnstallatlon n.6%100.096 10 Srso.oo 154.8 0.61 so.138
Thermostat - ClocVProgrammable 52.096 85.096 10 Srt4.42 1,235.1 2.19 So.orz
Home Energy Man4ement System 2.O%rto.096 20 5500.m 1,139.9 0.216 so.046
Central AC - Earh Replacement o.4x 80.0%15 s2,89s.00 234.t o.06 s1.269
Central AC - Malntenance and Tune-Up 4t.w 100.0x 4
20
slT m
s430.31
231.0
745.6
0.56 So.149
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 2s.0x 1m.096 0.57 So.osr
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit o.0%1m.0%5 s7s.00 335.3 3.67 so.os1
Water Heater - Faucet Aeratoc L2.Ar$90.0%10 s12.70 136.8 2.00 5o.orz
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads lt.7%1m.096 10 S27.m 523.1 4.28 So.006
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42.O9t 38.196 15 s180.m 24t.O 0.30 5a.o77
Wate. Heater - Tlmer tt.o%1m.0%10 s194.00 387.5 0.37 So.o57
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0x 0.0x 0 9o.m
1,t92.2
1.00
0.(D
s0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0%50.096 10 s6,500.00 s0.271
lnterior Lighting - Occupancy Senso6 24.M 50.0%15 s7s0.00 491.2 0.13 So.rsz
Exterior LiShtlng - Photosensor Control 24.9%100.0%8 s90.00 27.3 0.04 so.s1s
Exterior Lithting - Photovoltaic
lnstallatlon 10.096 45.O%15 s2,97s.00 q.4 0.00 s7.549
Exterlor Llghtlng - Tlmedock lnstallatlon 10.0%100.0%8 572.N 77.3 0.05 9.412
Refriterator - Early Replacemem 0.096 100.0x 13 s1,203.m t25.4 0.02 s1.073
Refrige6tor - Maintenance 37.O%1@.0*1 s39.18 139.3 0.34 s0.078
Refrige6tor - Remove Second Unit 3.096 8s.ofr;9 5130.m 973.8 L.24 s0.019
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.OrS.8s.096 6 S13o.oo 655.1 0.6s So.039
Freeze, - Early Replacement 9t1
37.0%
100.0%13 s484.00
s15.57
98.3
115.2
0.y_
0.72
So.ss1
Freezer - Maintenance 100.0%4 s0.037
Electronlcs - Smart Power Strlps t-4*1m.0%4 521.m _v?
194.3
0.lo s0.068
Pool Pump - Timer s9.0%100.0%15 5150.00 0.29 5o.o8s
Pool Heater - Solar Svstem 0.0x o.o%0 So.oo 1.m So.ooo
Eehavloral Feedbac* Tools o.o%100.0%1 s40.00 323.O 0.25 S0.124
lllirlliT _c!il!T
lnsulation - Ducting
s!.]!
3.M
e9.ry
9.s%
20 941s.80 477.4 0.32 So.077
25 53s0.00 527.4 o.47 s0.0s3
lnsulatlon - Radlant Banier 25.0%100.096 12 s922.58 169.3 0.0s S0.641
Ducting - Repair and Seallng
wi"dod- Htsh
* -
Efficlencv/ENERGY STAR
- 1lffi
92.9%
?9:oI
100.096
19
23
s37s"m I,577.1 1.26 s0.021
s2,200.00 2,629.7 o32 So.o57
Windows - lnstall Reflectlve
Film 2.Wo 45.O%10 5577.67 lzr.2 0.36 s0.239
Doors - Storm and Thermal 11.O%100.0%72 S180.m 776.7 o.21 So,120
Roofs - High Reflecttuity 5.0%90.0%15 s516.s4 123.3 0.18 s0.430
Attic Fan - lnstallaffon 3.8X 50.016 18 596.s0 8.3 0.07 s1.081
Attlc Fan - Solar 0.0%0.0t6 0 s0.00 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Photorohalc -
lnstallation 4.O%25.0%19 s200.00 8.3 0.03 s2.181
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 7.7%25.OYn 18 5200.m 2?7.7 0.89 s0.082
Ceiling Fan - lnstallation 20.6%100.0%10 5160.00 155.6 o.67 S0.129
Thermostat -
Clock/Prosrammable 743%85.0%10 s114.42 794.7 1.63 s0.019
Home EnerSy Management
Svdam 2.O%60.0%2A s600.00 1,083.0 0.45 s0.049
Central AC - Maintenance and
Tune-Uo 47.O%100.0%4 s12s.00 79t.7 0.56 So.180
Central Heat Pump -
Maintenance 2s.o%
3.0%
100.096 20 s430.31 533.5 0.57 5o.oeo
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 90.096 10 57.12 124.t 3.38 s0.008
Water Heater - Low-Flow
showerheads 50.0%100.0%10 s27.@ 569.3 4.O7 So.oo5
Water Heater - Pip€ lnsulation 42.0%47.3%15 Sso,oo 220.4 1.O3 So.o23
Water Heater - Timer 5.0%100.0,6 t0 S194,oo 362.0 0.36 50.071
Wat€r Heater - Desuperheater 0.0%o.@6 0 s0.00 1.00 s0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0e6 s0.0t6 10 55,soo.oo 2,915.9 0.09 S0.297
lnterior Lightlng - Occupancy
Sensors 24.O%30.0%15 ss00.00 599.6 o.24 so.086
Exterior Lightint - Photosensor
Control 13.0%100.096 8 s90.00 28.9 0.(x So.+ez
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
lnstallation \o.o%45.W6 15 s2,97s.00 43.5 0.00 s7.016
Exterior Lighting - fimeclock
lnstallatlon 16.0%100.0%8 572.00
s39.18
28.9 0.06 s0.390
RefriBerator - Maintenance 24.4%100.096 4 76.r 0.20 so.142
Refrigerator - Remove second
9qi!
Freezer - Remove Second Unit
3.O95 85.@6
85.0%
9
5
s130.00 611.8 0.84
0.i10
s0.030
2.O%s130.0O 384.8 s0.055
Freezer - Maintenance 24.O%100.0%4 s1s.s7 67.7 0.45 50.063
El€ctronics - Smart Powet
Itrlps-- __
Pool Pump - Timer
t.4%
5s.096
100.096
100.0%
4
15
s21,00
-fiooo
78.2
796.7
0.35
o.29
So.o74
s0.083
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0%__;*
rm.0%
0 50.00 1.00 So.ooo
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0%1 S4o.oo 294.4 o.23 S0.135
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
Tabla 8-22 Encryy Eltlciency lWr-Equlpmnt ht*Llmibd Inonc Slagtc Family, Ittew
UlnbgE
B-60 www.enernoc,com
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
tucrgy EllWttcy Mn-Equlpncnt WLtmlEd frcoap Uafti FamW etulnglailcB-Z)
WnEgp
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting
lnsulatlon - Ceiling 27s%40.0%20 S21s.oo t72.8 o.24 So.11o
lnsulatlon - Ductlng 0.0%9.5%25 s3s0.00 15.3 0.03 51.838
lnsulatlon - lnfiltration Control 10.1%100.0%12 s266.00 335.7 0.24 s0.093
lnsulatlon - Radiant Barrier !:o%
2.O%
4g'01
90.0%
t2
20
s922.68
s37s.00
277,S
418.4
0.08
0.28
si.rs1
So.o7eDuctiE - Repair and Sealing
Windows - HiBh Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 60.5%100.0%25 s2,SOO.m 627.2 0.o8 So.320
Windows - lnstall Reflective Film 5.0e6 45.0r 10 s186.32 238.7 o.79 So.1o4
Doo6 - Storm and Thermal L7.gX 100.0%12 9320.00 so.m0
Roofs - High R€flectivity 3.OX r0.0%15 s1,s49.51 83.s 0.04 51.904
Attic Fan - lnstallation 0.096 0.016 18 s0.m 1.00 So.ooo
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0x o.o%0 So.oo 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - lnstallation 0.0x 0.0,6 19 So.m 1.00 So.mo
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 1.6%25.O%18 s150.00 So.o@
Ceiling Fan - lnstallation 72,7%100.096 10 s80.00 80.5 0.52 So.13z
f hermostat - Clock/Programmable 28.6%85.0%10 s73.33 272.3 o.79 So.046
Home Energy Maoa8ement System 5.0%40.09(20 s6m.00 1,2L4.4 0.55 So.044
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.016 80.0*i 15 52,8e5.m 81.3 o.02 s3.6s3
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 1-3o%
23.0%
1@.016 4
20
s1m.00 80.3 0.28 $o.raa
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 100.016 s1m.00 zr1'.7 0.94 So.o42
Room AC - Removal ofsecond Unit 0.096 100.0%5 s7s.m 195.9 2.31 so.o87
Wrter Heater - Faucet Aerators 8.0%90.0%10 5L2.70 79.5 1.r0 so.o21
Water Heater - [ow-Flow Showerheads 24.4X 100.0%10 s27.OO 363.2 2.35 so.0t0
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42-0'6 38.1%15 s180.00 100.2 o.12 s0.184
Water Heater - Timer 5.016 100.0%10 s194.00 L6L.2 o.1s 50.150
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0%
5.O%
0.0%0 s0.00 1.00 s0.000
io.;iWater Heater - Solar System s0.o%l0 56,soo.oo 1,512.9 o.o4
lnterior LiBhtin8 - Occupancy S€nsors 6.0%20.4%15 s2s6.00 209.0 0.15 So.rzo
Exterior Ughting - Photosenso, Control 7.0%100.0%8 s90.00 15.9 0.02 so.888
Exterior Lighting - Photovohaic
lnstallation 10.0%45.0%15 s2,975.00 4!.7 0.00 s7.430
Exterior Lighting - ifimeclock lnstallation 6.OX 7m.o%8 572.N 15.9 0.o3 90.7u
Refrlgerator - Eady Replacement 2.7%1m.096 13 51,203.00 119.7 0.02 5r.724
Refrigerator - Maintenance 27.4%1m.096 1 s39.18 732.9 o,12 so.081
RefriBerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0x 85.0%9 s130.00 929.5 1.18 s0.020
Freezer - Remove Second Unll 2.OX 85.0%6 s130.m 62s.3 0.64 So.041
I"":i E11l!"pl:':T*j
Freezer - Maintenance
2.7%19-0?6
100.096
13 5484.m 93.8
110.0
9.-o,
o.7t
, ig5ll
So.03927.0%4 S1s.s7
Electronics - Smart Power StriPs 1.4%100.0%4 s21.00 81.8 0.38 so.07r
Pool Pump - Timer 50.0%100.0%15 s160.00 $0.000
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.o%0.0%0 5o.oo 1.00 So.ooo
Behavioral Feed back Tooh 0.096 100.0%1 -JfP _ le:1 0.16 So.2oo
lnsulation - Ceiling 4t.3vr N.O%20 Slso.so 270.7 0.43 s0.063
lnsulation - Ductin8 1.O%9s%25 53s0.m 10.5 0.02 s2.66E
lns:lltjon : lad'::t-1?Ttl -
Ductlng - Repair and Sealing
5.0%100.0r :?
20
5922.68 72.8
376.6
0.02
0.25
s'.i:1
So.o88s0.0%90.0%s37s.00
Windows - High
Effic|encY/ENERGY STAR 93.0%100.0x 25 s2,200.m 1,068.0 0.14 So.16s
wndows - flstlll R"fl:I1,r--" Il,
Doors - Storm and Thermal
2.A6 45.096 10 s218.97 L78.2 0.52 So.154
19.0%100.0%t2 S180.m s0.0q)
Roofs - Hlgh Reflectlvlty 0.0%90.0,6 15 Ss16.s4 48.7 0.o7 s1.088
Attk Fan - lnstallation 0.0%0.0%18 s0.m 1.00 So.mo
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0%0.0,6 0 s0.00 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic -IllBlEllgn _
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation
0.0'5 0.0%19 50.00 1.00 So.mo
1.696 25.0%18 S15().oo So.mo
Ceilint Fan - lnstallation 12.7%100.0%10 S80.oo 82.1 0.55 s0.130
Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable 40.8%8s.0%10 S23.33
s600.00
127.3
932.5
0.s1 5o.ozz
So.os7Home Energy Management
Svstem 2.016 50.096 20 0.rt8
Central AC - Maintenance and
Tune-Up 33.096 100.0%4 s100.00 65.7 o.24 So.42o
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0%100.0%20 s100.00 182.4 o.78 so.o48
Water Heater - Faucet AemtoB 4.O%90.096 10 57.12 72.A 1.88 So.o13
Water Heater - Low-Flow
Showerheads 30.0%100.0%10 S27.oo 332.3 2.26 So.ou
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42.016 4t3%15 5s0.00 9r.7 0.41 so.oso
Water Heater - Tlmer 5.096 100.0%10 s194.00 150.9 0.14 So.rzr
water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0%0.0%0 So.oo 1.00 s0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.096 50.0%10 s5,s00.00 1,399.1 0.04 50.618
lfierior LiShtint - Occupancy
Sensors 6.Ovr 10.0%15 s255.00 275.7 o.27 So.09s
Exterlor Lighting - Photosensor
control L.A%100.0%8 Sso.m 20.0 0.03 5o.zoE
Exterior Llghting - Photovoltaic
lnstallation 10.0%45.0%15 52,97s.00 54.3 0.m 9s.622
Exterior Lighting - Tlmec-lock
lnstallation 11.O%100.0%8 s72.m 20.0 0.04 s0.s62
Refriterator - Maintenance 9.0%100.0%4 s39.18 72.6 0.19 S0.149
Unit 1.O%8s.0,6 9 s130.m 584.0 o.80 so.o32
I::'"_1: l:-::" second Y1t
Freerer - Malntenance
2.W"85.0%
1m-0,6
6
4
513-om
s1s.s7
357.3
64.6
0.38 50.069
9.0%0.43 50.066
Electroni6 - Smart Power Strlps
Pool Pump - Timer
1.1%
35.0%
100.0x
100.0%
4
15
S21.m
S1Go.00
75.4 0.35 s0.917
s0.000
So.oooPool Heater - Solar System o.86 o.o%0 $o.oo 1.00
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.o%100.0%1 S1o.m 777.5 0.14 50.22s
Residentjat Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
Tafu 8-24 AHgU Afubncy llon-@uipnnt W UmiN fitcotno lluld Funfu tlcu Wabge
s-62 www,enemoc.com
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
Encrgy Elfl&ncy tbn-Equlptttctrt OM.lmiM fncone lloffile Hoare, &ifrttgTablc E-25
Ylnbgc
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting
lnsulation - Ceiling 36.1%95.096 20 s707.00 184.5 0.08 50.338
lnsulation - Ductint 0.096 9.5%25 S3so.oo 174.4 0.35 s0.07s
lnsulatlon - lnflltratlon Control 30.096 100.096 72 s266.00 565.1 o.44 s0.oss
lnsulation - Radlant Barrler :.v
10.0%
95.096 t2 s922.68 3S8.7 0.09 So.3o3
Ouctint - Repair and S€aling 90.0%20 s37s.00 1,118.5 0.96 So.o3o
wlndow: - HLqh Efllciency/ENERGY srAR
Windows - lnstall Reflectlve Film
55.596
5.0%
19o:ffi,
45.C%
23 s71soq:00
s788.05
1::0{t8
249.4
9:91
o.39
i0:461
S0.42110
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.O9$100.016 L2 s320.00 73.3 0.0s s0.514
Roofs - Hi8h Reflectivity 5.016 LO.016 15 s1,549.61 55.7 0.05 s2.8s4
Attlc Fan - lnstallatlon 23%50.096 18 s11s.80 1-2 0.05 52.577
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0%0.016 0 s0.00 1.00 s0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - tnstallation 13.0X 1m.ox 19 s3s0.00 4.2 0.02 S7.s81
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation 5.9X
17.9%
_ 2s!r6
1@.0%
18 s1s0.0o t17-6 1.15 So.u8
Ceiling Fan - lnstallatlon 10 s80.00 73.3 1.13 s0.145
Thermostat - ClocVProgrammable 12.4%85.0%10 573.33 719.5 2.?S s0.014
Home Energy Management System 2.O%N.016 20 s600.00 911.1 0.38 s0.058
Central AC - Early Replac€ment 0.096 80.096 15 s2,$s.00 182.1 0.0s s1.630
Central AC - Malntenance and Tune-Up 25.0%100.096 4 s100.00 179.8 0.64 so.153
Cental Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0%100.0%20 s393.00 1184.4 0.52 so.o72
Room Ac - Removal ofsecond Unit o.g%100.0%5 s7s.00 725.O 7.93 so.o24
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators L2.0%90.0%10 slz.7O 85.8 1.27 90.019
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads ,3.4%100.0%10 s27.00 395.5 2.72 So.oo9
Water Heater - Pipe lnsulation 42.O%38.1%15 s180.00 153.0 0.19 s0.121
Water Heater - Tlmer L7.O%1m.0x 10 5194.00 303.9 0.29 so.08s
water Heater - Desuperheater 0.096 o.096 0 s0.00 1.00 5o.om
Water Heater - Solar System 5.015 50.0e6 20 s5.s00.00 2,026.3 0.08 s0.283
lnterior Lighting - Occupancy Sensorc 67.O%80.0%15 s7s0.00 457.4 o.72 S0.164
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 23.0%1@.0,6 I s90.00 26.O o.o3 So.s41
Erterior liShting - Photovoltaic
lnstallatlon 10.0%4s.096 15 52,97s.00 38.5 0.00 s7.927
Exterior Lightlng - Timeclock lnstallation 10.0%100.0'6 8 s72.@ 26.0 0,04 s0.433
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 4.9%100.0,6 13 91,203,00 1L9.7 o.02 S1.124
Refrigerator - Maintenan@ 35.0%100.0%1 s3e.18 t?2.9 o.33 so.o81
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.Vo 8s.096 9 s130.00 929.5 1.18 50,020
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.Ov"85.0%6 s130.00 625.3 0.62 So.o41
Freezer - Early Replacement 4.9%
35.096
100.0%t
4
5484.m 93.8 0.04
o.69
so.s77
Freezer - Maintenance 100.096 S15.57 110.O So.o39
Electronlcs - Smart Powet Strips 7.4%1@.0%4 S21.oo 78.t 0.37 -JgITs0.08sPool Pump - Timer 50.0%100.0x 15 s160.00 194.3 o.29
Pool Heater - Solar system
Behavioral Feedback Tools
0.0%
0.0%
0.o%
100.0%1
50.*_
s40.00 253.1
1.00
o.2L
_ llooo
So.1s8
Residential Energy Efficiency Fluipment and Measure Data
Trblc B-26 Ercrgy Elllchncy Non-Equipnent h*llmlbd Incottrc llofilc lbnc, Ncw
VInfuo
lnrulaU:n_- Ce'llnS
lnsulation - Ducting
54.2r$
3.0%
95.0%20 s494.90 25S.S 0.18 So.164
9.5%25 s3s0.00 325.5 031 so.086
lnsulation - Radiant Banler 5.0x 100.096 t2 s922.68 92.8 0.(N s1.159
Ducting - Repalr and S€aling 50.0x 90.016 20 S37s.oo 912.7 9-81
0.21
So.o34
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 88.0%100.096 25 s2,200.00 L,477.6 90.120
windows - lnstall Reflective Film - ?o%
t3.o%
-1s:9%,
100.0%
1o 5576.18 1:_13
98.4
o.33
-,.- Sosoz
So.21sOoo.s - Storm and Thermal t2 $18o.oo 0.1s
Roofs - HlSh Reflectivity 5.0%90.0%15 s516.54 58.0 o.r7 50.913
Attic Fan - lnstallation 2.?%50.096 18 s96.sO 3.9 0.(E s2.296
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0%o.or'0 50.00 1.00 50.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - lnstallatlon 4.Wo 25.Wo 19 5200.00 3.9 0.03 54.532
Whole-House Fan - lnstallation s.9%25.O%18 s1so.00 707.2 1.11 $0.130
CeilinB Fan - lnstallation 17.9%1(x).0%10 s8O.00 !!.?
438.0
L.24 i! 13i
So.o2oThermostat - Clock/Programmable 463%85.0%t2 s73.33 2'o2
Home Ener8y Manatement System 7.Wn fi.o%20 s600.00 933.4 0.lo s0.0s7
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune Up 25.Or$100.0x 4 s100.00 145.6 0.54 So.190
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance zs.wo 1m.0%20 5393.00 396.3 o.44 s0.087
Water Heat€r - Faucet Aerato6 3.0%90.0%10 57.t2 79.3 2_75 So.o12
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 35.0%100.0 10 S27.oo 361-7 2.59 $o.oro
Water Heat€r - Pipe lnsulation 42.O%17.3%15 Sso.oo 140.O o.65 So.o37
Water Heater - Timer 5.0x 1m.0%10 s194.00 287.4 0.29 s0.090
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0%0.0%0 s0.00 1.00 s0.0m
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0%50.o%20 s5,s00.00 1,852.6 0.07 So.310
lnterior Li8hting - Occupancy Sensors 67.O%80.ffi 15 s500.00 s7t.l 0.23 s0.090
Exterio. Ugilting - Photosensor Control L3.0%100.0%::
15
ll0o
s2,97s.00
,r.s_
47.1
o.04 So.srr
Exterior Lighting - Photovohaic
lnsta llation 10.096 45.0r$o.oo s7.356
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock lnstallation 16.0%1m.016
100.095
8 s72.00 2f .5 0.0s So.4o9
Refrigerator - Maintenance o.o%4 S39.18 72-6 0.19 S0.149
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0%85.0%9 s130.00 584.0 0.80 s0.032
Freezer - Remove Second Unit z.o%85.0%6 s130,00 367.3 0.38 s0.069
Freezer - Maintenance o.o%100.0x 4 S1s.s7 54.6 0.43 s0.065
Electronics - Smart Power Strips t.4%1m.0%4 s21.00 72.r 0.33 s0.080
Pool Pump - Timer 35.0%100.0%15 s150.00 196.7 0.29 s0.083
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0%o.o%o So.oo 1.00 So.mo
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0%100.0%1 S4o.m 228.3 0.19 s0.17s
B-64 www,enernoc.com