20130717IPC Attachment 2-Final Report.PDF

IDAHO POWER ENERGY EFFICIENCY POTENTIAL STUDY
Appendices

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting iii

This report was prepared by
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting
500 Ygnacio Valley Blvd., Suite 450
Walnut Creek, CA 94596

I. Rohmund, Project Director
J. Borstein, Project Manager

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting v
CONTENTS
A MARKET PROFILES ............................................................................................... A-1
B RESIDENTIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE DATA .............. B-1
C COMMERCIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE DATA .............. C-1
D INDUSTRIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE DATA................ D-1
E IRRIGATION ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE DATA ............... E-1
F MARKET ADOPTION FACTORS .............................................................................. F-1
G ANNUAL SAVINGS ................................................................................................. G-1

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting vii
CONTENTS

LIST OF TABLES
Table A-1 Single Family Market Profile, 2011 ........................................................................ A-2
Table A-2 Multi Family Market Profile, 2011 .......................................................................... A-3
Table A-3 Mobile Home Market Profile, 2011 ........................................................................ A-4
Table A-4 Single Family Limited Income Market Profile, 2011................................................. A-5
Table A-5 Multi Family Limited Income Market Profile, 2011 .................................................. A-6
Table A-6 Mobile Home Limited Income Market Profile, 2011 ................................................. A-7
Table A-7 Small Office Market Profile, 2011 .......................................................................... A-8
Table A-8 Large Office Market Profile, 2011 .......................................................................... A-9
Table A-9 Restaurant Market Profile, 2011 ........................................................................... A-10
Table A-10 Retail Market Profile, 2011 .................................................................................. A-11
Table A-11 Grocery Market Profile, 2011 ............................................................................... A-12
Table A-12 College Market Profile, 2011 ................................................................................ A-13
Table A-13 School Market Profile, 2011 ................................................................................. A-14
Table A-14 Hospital Market Profile, 2011 ............................................................................... A-15
Table A-15 Lodging Market Profile, 2011 ............................................................................... A-16
Table A-16 Assembly Market Profile, 2011 ............................................................................. A-17
Table A-17 Warehouse Market Profile, 2011 .......................................................................... A-18
Table A-18 Miscellaneous Commercial Market Profile, 2011 .................................................... A-19
Table A-19 Manufacturing Food Market Profile, 2011 ............................................................. A-20
Table A-20 Agriculture Market Profile, 2011 ........................................................................... A-21
Table A-21 Water and Waste Water Market Profile, 2011 ....................................................... A-22
Table A-22 Electronics Market Profile, 2011 ........................................................................... A-23
Table A-23 Other Industrial Market Profile, 2011 ................................................................... A-24
Table A-24 Irrigation Market Profile, 2011 ............................................................................. A-25
Table B-1 Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment Measure Descriptions ................................B-2
Table B-2 Residential Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Measure Descriptions .........................B-7
Table B-3 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data —Single Family, Existing Vintage ....................... B-11
Table B-4 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data —Single Family, New Vintage ........................... B-14
Table B-5 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — Multi Family, Existing Vintage ....................... B-18
Table B-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — Multi Family, New Vintage ............................ B-21
Table B-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — Mobile Home, Existing Vintage ...................... B-25
Table B-8 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Mobile Home, New Vintage ................ B-28
Table B-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, Existing Vintage B-32
Table B-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, New Vintage ..... B-35
Table B-11 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Multi Family, Existing Vintage .. B-39
Table B-12 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Multi Family, New Vintage....... B-42
Table B-13 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, Existing Vintage B-46
Table B-14 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, New Vintage ..... B-49

viii www.enernoc.com
Table B-15 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Single Family, Existing Vintage................. B-53
Table B-16 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Single Family, New Vintage ..................... B-54
Table B-17 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Multi Family, Existing Vintage .................. B-55
Table B-18 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Multi Family, New Vintage ...................... B-56
Table B-19 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Mobile Home, Existing Vintage ................. B-57
Table B-20 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Mobile Home, New Vintage ..................... B-58
Table B-21 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, Existing VintageB-59
Table B-22 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, New VintageB-60
Table B-23 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Multi Family, Existing VintageB-61
Table B-24 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Limited Income Multi Family, New VintageB-62
Table B-25 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, Existing VintageB-63
Table B-26 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, New VintageB-64
Table C-1 Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment Measure Descriptions .............................. C-2
Table C-2 Commercial Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Measure Descriptions ....................... C-5
Table C-3 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Small Office, Existing Vintage ......................... C-11
Table C-4 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Small Office, New Vintage .............................. C-15
Table C-5 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Large Office, Existing Vintage ......................... C-19
Table C-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Large Office, New Vintage .............................. C-23
Table C-7 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Restaurant, Existing Vintage ........................... C-27
Table C-8 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Restaurant, New Vintage ................................ C-31
Table C-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Retail, Existing Vintage ................................... C-35
Table C-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Retail, New Vintage ........................................ C-39
Table C-11 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Grocery, Existing Vintage ................................ C-43
Table C-12 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Grocery, New Vintage .................................... C-47
Table C-13 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— College, Existing Vintage ............................... C-51
Table C-14 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — College, New Vintage ................................... C-55
Table C-15 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— School, Existing Vintage ................................ C-59
Table C-16 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— School, New Vintage ..................................... C-63
Table C-17 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Hospital, Existing Vintage .............................. C-67
Table C-18 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Hospital, New Vintage ................................... C-71
Table C-19 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Lodging, Existing Vintage ............................... C-75
Table C-20 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Lodging, New Vintage ................................... C-79
Table C-21 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Warehouse, Existing Vintage ......................... C-83
Table C-22 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Warehouse, New Vintage .............................. C-87
Table C-23 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, Existing Vintage ................. C-91
Table C-24 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, New Vintage...................... C-95
Table C-24 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, New Vintage...................... C-99
Table C-23 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Miscellaneous, Existing Vintage ..................... C-103
Table C-24 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Miscellaneous, New Vintage ......................... C-107
Table C-25 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Small Office, Existing Vintage ................ C-111
Table C-26 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Small Office, New Vintage .................... C-113
Table C-27 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Large Office, Existing Vintage ............... C-115
Table C-28 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Large Office, New Vintage .................... C-117
Table C-29 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Restaurant, Existing Vintage ................. C-119
Table C-30 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Restaurant, New Vintage ...................... C-121

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting ix
Table C-31 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Retail, Existing Vintage ......................... C-123
Table C-32 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Retail, New Vintage.............................. C-125
Table C-33 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Grocery, Existing Vintage ..................... C-127
Table C-34 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Grocery, New Vintage .......................... C-129
Table C-35 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— College, Existing Vintage ...................... C-131
Table C-36 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— College, New Vintage ........................... C-133
Table C-37 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— School, Existing Vintage ....................... C-135
Table C-38 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— School, New Vintage ............................ C-137
Table C-39 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Hospital, Existing Vintage ..................... C-139
Table C-40 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Hospital, New Vintage .......................... C-141
Table C-41 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Lodging, Existing Vintage ..................... C-143
Table C-42 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Lodging, New Vintage .......................... C-145
Table C-43 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Warehouse, Existing Vintage ................ C-147
Table C-44 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Warehouse, New Vintage ..................... C-149
Table C-45 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Miscellaneous, Existing Vintage ............. C-155
Table C-46 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Miscellaneous, New Vintage .................. C-157
Table D-1 Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment Measure Descriptions ................................. D-2
Table D-2 Industrial Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Measure Descriptions .......................... D-4
Table D-3 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Agriculture, Existing Vintage .......................... D-10
Table D-4 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Agriculture, New Vintage ............................... D-14
Table D-5 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Electronics, Existing Vintage .......................... D-17
Table D-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Electronics, New Vintage ............................... D-20
Table D-7 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Manufacturing Food, Existing Vintage ............. D-23
Table D-8 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Manufacturing Food, New Vintage ................. D-26
Table D-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Water and Wastewater, Existing Vintage ........ D-29
Table D-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Water and Wastewater, New Vintage ............ D-32
Table D-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Other Industrial, Existing Vintage .................. D-35
Table D-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Other Industrial, New Vintage ....................... D-38
Table D-13 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Agriculture, Existing Vintage .................. D-41
Table D-14 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Agriculture, New Vintage ....................... D-43
Table D-15 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Electronics, Existing Vintage ................... D-45
Table D-16 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Electronics, New Vintage ....................... D-47
Table D-17 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Manufacturing Food, Existing Vintage ..... D-49
Table D-18 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Manufacturing Food, New Vintage .......... D-51
Table D-21 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Water and Wastewater, Existing Vintage D-53
Table D-22 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Water and Wastewater, New Vintage ..... D-55
Table D-21 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Other Industrial, Existing Vintage ........... D-57
Table D-22 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Other, New Vintage .............................. D-59
Table E-1 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Irrigation, Existing Vintage ............................... E-2
Table E-2 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Irrigation, New Vintage .................................... E-3
Table E-3 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Irrigation, Existing Vintage ....................... E-4
Table E-4 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Irrigation, New Vintage ............................ E-5
Table F-1 Residential Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors ...... F-2
Table F-2 Residential Non-Equipment Measures— Achievable Potential Market Adoption FactorsF-3
Table F-3 Commercial Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors ..... F-5

x www.enernoc.com
Table F-4 Commercial Non-Equipment Measures — Achievable Potential Market Adoption FactorsF-7
Table F-5 Industrial Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors ...... F-10
Table F-6 Industrial Non-Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors F-11
Table F-7 Irrigation Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors ....... F-13
Table F-8 Irrigation Non-Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors F-14
Table G-1 Annual Electric Energy Savings, All Sectors (1,000 MWh) ....................................... G-1
Table G-2 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Residential (1,000 MWh) ....................................... G-3
Table G-3 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Commercial (1,000 MWh)...................................... G-5
Table G-4 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Industrial (1,000 MWh) ......................................... G-7
Table G-5 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Irrigation (1,000 MWh) ......................................... G-9

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-1
APPENDIX A
MARKET PROFILES
Market profiles describe electricity use by sector, segment, end use and technology in the base
year of the study (2011). The market profiles are given for average buildings and new vintages.
As explained in Chapter 2 of the study report, a market profile includes the following elements:
 Market size is a representation of the number of customers in the segment. For the
residential sector, it is number of households. In the commercial sector, it is floor space
measured in square feet. For the industrial sector, it is number of employees.
 Saturations define the fraction of buildings with the specific technologies. (e.g., homes
with electric space heating, commercial floor space with natural gas furnaces, etc).
 UEC (unit energy consumption) or EUI (energy-use index) describes the amount
of energy consumed in the base year by a specific technology in buildings that have the
technology. We use UECs expressed in kWh/household for the residential sector, and
EUIs expressed in kWh/square foot or kWh/employee for the commercial and industrial
sectors respectively.
 Intensity for the residential sector represents the average energy use for the
technology across all households in the base year. It is computed as the product of the
saturation and the UEC and is defined as kWh/household. For the commercial and
industrial sectors, intensity, computed as the product of the saturation and the EUI,
represents the average use for the technology across all floor space or all employees in
the base year.
 Usage is the annual energy use by a technology/end use in the segment. It is the
product of the market size and intensity and is quantified in GWh.
This appendix presents the following market profiles:
 Residential market profiles by segment (Table A-1 through Table A-6)
 Commercial market profiles by building type (Table A-7 through Table A-18)
 Industrial market profiles (Table A-19 through Table A-23)
 Irrigation market profiles (Table A-24)

Market Profiles
A-2 www.enernoc.com
Table A-1 Single Family Market Profile, 2011

UEC Intensity Usage UEC Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/HH)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/HH)
Cooling Central AC 76.7%2,185 1,675 357 84.3%2,090 1,762 -4.4%
Cooling Room AC 3.2%313 10 2 2.7%308 8 -1.5%
Cooling Air-Source Heat Pump 6.1%2,141 131 28 7.0%2,069 145 -3.4%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.8%1,428 11 2 0.9%1,345 12 -5.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 1.8%1,576 28 6 1.9%1,629 31 3.4%
Space Heating Electric Room Heat 4.3%9,379 403 86 4.1%8,878 363 -5.3%
Space Heating Electric Furnace 9.2%10,317 949 202 9.2%9,549 879 -7.4%
Space Heating Air-Source Heat Pump 6.1%7,503 458 98 7.0%7,215 507 -3.8%
Space Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.8%5,005 40 9 0.8%4,706 38 -6.0%
Water Heating Water Heater <= 55 Gal 36.0%3,455 1,245 265 36.0%3,158 1,138 -8.6%
Water Heating Water Heater > 55 Gal 3.6%3,901 139 30 3.6%3,564 127 -8.7%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1,134 1,134 242 100.0%1,252 1,252 10.4%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%146 146 31 100.0%166 166 13.4%
Interior Lighting Specialty 100.0%591 591 126 100.0%841 841 42.4%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%260 260 55 100.0%276 276 5.9%
Appliances Clothes Washer 99.3%117 116 25 99.3%62 61 -47.0%
Appliances Clothes Dryer 93.4%877 820 175 96.2%622 599 -29.1%
Appliances Dishwasher 92.5%444 411 88 98.1%209 205 -52.9%
Appliances Refrigerator 100.0%836 836 178 100.0%457 457 -45.4%
Appliances Freezer 73.8%655 484 103 81.2%385 313 -41.2%
Appliances Second Refrigerator 40.7%974 396 84 44.8%612 274 -37.2%
Appliances Stove 77.6%502 389 83 79.9%502 401 0.0%
Appliances Microwave 101.5%143 145 31 101.5%143 145 0.0%
Electronics Personal Computers 98.8%289 285 61 108.6%295 320 2.2%
Electronics Monitor 98.8%57 57 12 108.6%56 61 -2.9%
Electronics Laptops 100.0%124 124 26 110.0%125 138 0.9%
Electronics TVs 236.6%180 426 91 272.0%117 320 -34.8%
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier 80.0%44 35 8 92.0%42 39 -4.5%
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR 333.2%118 392 84 383.1%107 410 -9.0%
Electronics Devices and Gadgets 100.0%55 55 12 120.0%55 66 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 4.9%1,650 81 17 5.9%1,650 97 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 1.2%5,479 67 14 1.5%5,041 74 -8.0%
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa 3.3%1,045 35 7 4.3%1,019 44 -2.5%
Miscellaneous Well Pump 5.0%617 31 7 5.5%617 34 -0.1%
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan 76.4%319 243 52 76.4%313 239 -1.9%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%394 394 84 100.0%512 512 30.0%
13,045 2,780 12,354 -5.3%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-3
Table A-2 Multi Family Market Profile, 2011

UEC Intensity Usage UEC Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/HH)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/HH)
Cooling Central AC 52.3%1,073 562 14 65.4%1,060 693 -1.3%
Cooling Room AC 14.7%196 29 1 17.7%189 33 -3.7%
Cooling Air-Source Heat Pump 3.5%1,052 37 1 4.5%1,022 46 -2.8%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%702 - - 0.0%661 - -5.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 1.2%684 8 0 1.2%751 9 9.9%
Space Heating Electric Room Heat 33.7%3,888 1,309 33 32.0%3,807 1,217 -2.1%
Space Heating Electric Furnace 15.9%4,277 680 17 15.9%3,978 633 -7.0%
Space Heating Air-Source Heat Pump 3.5%3,110 108 3 4.5%3,142 142 1.0%
Space Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%2,075 - - 0.0%1,951 - -6.0%
Water Heating Water Heater <= 55 Gal 61.8%1,694 1,048 26 61.8%1,550 958 -8.5%
Water Heating Water Heater > 55 Gal 0.0%2,485 - - 0.0%2,271 - -8.6%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%584 584 15 100.0%714 714 22.3%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%67 67 2 100.0%86 86 27.6%
Interior Lighting Specialty 100.0%228 228 6 100.0%331 331 45.1%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%113 113 3 100.0%143 143 26.6%
Appliances Clothes Washer 84.6%105 89 2 87.2%56 49 -47.0%
Appliances Clothes Dryer 89.1%790 704 18 91.8%560 514 -29.1%
Appliances Dishwasher 86.3%400 345 9 94.9%188 179 -52.9%
Appliances Refrigerator 100.0%752 752 19 100.0%411 411 -45.4%
Appliances Freezer 23.5%590 139 3 24.2%346 84 -41.3%
Appliances Second Refrigerator 16.1%876 141 4 16.6%551 91 -37.2%
Appliances Stove 81.6%452 368 9 84.0%452 379 0.0%
Appliances Microwave 99.0%129 127 3 99.0%129 127 0.0%
Electronics Personal Computers 58.3%270 157 4 64.1%276 177 2.2%
Electronics Monitor 58.3%54 31 1 64.1%52 33 -2.9%
Electronics Laptops 88.3%116 103 3 97.2%117 114 0.9%
Electronics TVs 179.9%161 290 7 206.9%105 218 -34.8%
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier 47.2%41 20 0 54.3%40 21 -4.5%
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR 253.3%110 279 7 291.3%100 292 -9.0%
Electronics Devices and Gadgets 100.0%52 52 1 120.0%52 62 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%1,500 - - 0.0%1,500 - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%4,981 - - 0.0%4,583 - -8.0%
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa 0.0%950 - - 0.0%926 - -2.5%
Miscellaneous Well Pump 0.0%556 - - 0.0%556 - -0.1%
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan 52.7%112 59 1 52.7%110 58 -1.9%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%307 307 8 100.0%399 399 30.0%
8,737 220 8,216 -6.0%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-4 www.enernoc.com
Table A-3 Mobile Home Market Profile, 2011

UEC Intensity Usage UEC Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/HH)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/HH)
Cooling Central AC 59.6%1,120 668 12 62.6%1,066 668 -4.8%
Cooling Room AC 16.8%445 75 1 16.8%428 72 -4.0%
Cooling Air-Source Heat Pump 2.4%1,097 26 0 2.6%1,048 27 -4.5%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 1.7%732 12 0 1.8%689 13 -5.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 7.2%713 51 1 7.2%837 60 17.4%
Space Heating Electric Room Heat 1.2%8,932 106 2 1.1%8,266 93 -7.4%
Space Heating Electric Furnace 57.6%9,949 5,727 100 57.6%9,208 5,300 -7.4%
Space Heating Air-Source Heat Pump 2.4%7,236 172 3 2.6%6,830 179 -5.6%
Space Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 1.7%4,826 80 1 1.7%4,538 75 -6.0%
Water Heating Water Heater <= 55 Gal 75.6%2,573 1,944 34 75.6%2,352 1,778 -8.6%
Water Heating Water Heater > 55 Gal 0.0%3,774 - - 0.0%3,448 - -8.6%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%964 964 17 100.0%1,065 1,065 10.4%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%124 124 2 100.0%141 141 13.4%
Interior Lighting Specialty 100.0%502 502 9 100.0%715 715 42.4%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%221 221 4 100.0%234 234 5.9%
Appliances Clothes Washer 97.2%106 103 2 100.2%56 56 -47.0%
Appliances Clothes Dryer 98.5%798 786 14 98.5%566 557 -29.1%
Appliances Dishwasher 84.3%404 340 6 92.7%190 176 -52.9%
Appliances Refrigerator 100.0%760 760 13 100.0%415 415 -45.4%
Appliances Freezer 84.0%596 500 9 86.5%350 303 -41.3%
Appliances Second Refrigerator 31.8%885 282 5 32.8%556 182 -37.2%
Appliances Stove 91.3%456 416 7 94.0%456 429 0.0%
Appliances Microwave 93.6%130 122 2 93.6%130 122 0.0%
Electronics Personal Computers 74.6%262 196 3 82.0%268 220 2.2%
Electronics Monitor 74.6%47 35 1 82.0%46 37 -2.9%
Electronics Laptops 69.8%113 79 1 76.8%114 88 0.9%
Electronics TVs 215.8%141 304 5 248.2%92 228 -34.8%
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier 60.4%40 24 0 69.5%38 27 -4.5%
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR 304.0%107 325 6 349.6%97 340 -9.0%
Electronics Devices and Gadgets 100.0%50 50 1 120.0%50 60 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%1,500 - - 0.0%1,500 - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%4,981 - - 0.0%4,583 - -8.0%
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa 0.0%950 - - 0.0%926 - -2.5%
Miscellaneous Well Pump 15.0%451 68 1 16.5%451 74 -0.1%
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan 76.7%296 227 4 76.7%290 222 -1.9%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%263 263 5 100.0%341 341 30.0%
15,553 273 14,299 -8.1%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-5
Table A-4 Single Family Limited Income Market Profile, 2011

UEC Intensity Usage UEC Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/HH)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/HH)
Cooling Central AC 51.2%2,029 1,039 102 61.5%1,941 1,193 -4.4%
Cooling Room AC 16.6%291 48 5 16.6%286 48 -1.5%
Cooling Air-Source Heat Pump 5.3%1,988 105 10 5.8%1,921 111 -3.4%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.3%1,326 3 0 0.3%1,249 3 -5.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 2.9%1,464 43 4 3.2%1,513 48 3.4%
Space Heating Electric Room Heat 8.8%9,379 828 82 8.4%8,878 745 -5.3%
Space Heating Electric Furnace 7.5%10,317 777 77 7.5%9,549 719 -7.4%
Space Heating Air-Source Heat Pump 5.3%7,503 395 39 5.8%7,215 417 -3.8%
Space Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.3%5,005 13 1 0.3%4,706 12 -6.0%
Water Heating Water Heater <= 55 Gal 57.8%3,455 1,997 197 57.8%3,158 1,825 -8.6%
Water Heating Water Heater > 55 Gal 0.0%3,901 - - 0.0%3,564 - -8.7%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1,078 1,078 106 100.0%1,190 1,190 10.4%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%139 139 14 100.0%157 157 13.4%
Interior Lighting Specialty 100.0%561 561 55 100.0%799 799 42.4%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%247 247 24 100.0%262 262 5.9%
Appliances Clothes Washer 96.3%112 107 11 99.2%59 59 -47.0%
Appliances Clothes Dryer 95.2%838 798 79 98.1%594 583 -29.1%
Appliances Dishwasher 71.6%424 304 30 85.9%200 171 -52.9%
Appliances Refrigerator 100.0%798 798 79 100.0%436 436 -45.4%
Appliances Freezer 84.9%625 531 52 93.4%367 343 -41.2%
Appliances Second Refrigerator 34.4%930 320 32 37.8%584 221 -37.2%
Appliances Stove 90.5%479 433 43 90.5%479 433 0.0%
Appliances Microwave 99.6%136 136 13 99.6%136 136 0.0%
Electronics Personal Computers 89.0%270 241 24 97.9%276 270 2.2%
Electronics Monitor 89.0%54 48 5 97.9%52 51 -2.9%
Electronics Laptops 78.2%116 91 9 86.0%117 101 0.9%
Electronics TVs 200.3%161 323 32 230.4%105 242 -34.8%
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier 72.0%41 30 3 82.8%40 33 -4.5%
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR 299.8%110 331 33 344.8%100 346 -9.0%
Electronics Devices and Gadgets 100.0%52 52 5 120.0%52 62 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%1,500 - - 0.0%1,500 - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%4,981 - - 0.0%4,583 - -8.0%
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa 0.0%950 - - 0.0%926 - -2.5%
Miscellaneous Well Pump 5.0%561 28 3 5.5%560 31 -0.1%
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan 76.4%290 221 22 76.4%284 217 -1.9%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%327 327 32 100.0%425 425 30.0%
12,390 1,222 11,690 -5.6%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-6 www.enernoc.com
Table A-5 Multi Family Limited Income Market Profile, 2011

UEC Intensity Usage UEC Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/HH)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/HH)
Cooling Central AC 45.8%651 298 8 48.1%642 309 -1.3%
Cooling Room AC 45.3%196 89 2 49.8%189 94 -3.7%
Cooling Air-Source Heat Pump 0.0%797 - - 0.0%774 - -2.8%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%532 - - 0.0%501 - -5.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%414 - - 0.0%455 - 9.9%
Space Heating Electric Room Heat 43.5%2,592 1,129 32 41.4%2,538 1,050 -2.1%
Space Heating Electric Furnace 19.3%2,851 551 15 19.3%2,582 499 -9.4%
Space Heating Air-Source Heat Pump 0.0%2,073 - - 0.0%2,095 - 1.0%
Space Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%1,383 - - 0.0%1,300 - -6.0%
Water Heating Water Heater <= 55 Gal 66.4%1,463 972 27 66.4%1,338 889 -8.5%
Water Heating Water Heater > 55 Gal 0.0%2,146 - - 0.0%1,962 - -8.6%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%511 511 14 100.0%625 625 22.3%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%55 55 2 100.0%70 70 27.6%
Interior Lighting Specialty 100.0%152 152 4 100.0%221 221 45.1%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%91 91 3 100.0%115 115 26.6%
Appliances Clothes Washer 71.5%84 60 2 89.4%44 40 -47.0%
Appliances Clothes Dryer 96.9%630 611 17 99.8%447 446 -29.1%
Appliances Dishwasher 69.2%319 221 6 86.5%150 130 -52.9%
Appliances Refrigerator 100.0%600 600 17 100.0%328 328 -45.4%
Appliances Freezer 20.0%470 94 3 20.6%276 57 -41.3%
Appliances Second Refrigerator 10.5%664 70 2 10.8%417 45 -37.2%
Appliances Stove 93.2%342 319 9 93.2%342 319 0.0%
Appliances Microwave 95.8%104 100 3 95.8%104 100 0.0%
Electronics Personal Computers 56.4%223 126 4 62.0%228 141 2.2%
Electronics Monitor 56.4%44 25 1 62.0%43 27 -2.9%
Electronics Laptops 99.0%96 95 3 108.9%97 105 0.9%
Electronics TVs 152.0%125 190 5 174.8%82 143 -34.8%
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier 47.2%34 16 0 54.3%33 18 -4.5%
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR 253.3%86 217 6 291.3%78 227 -9.0%
Electronics Devices and Gadgets 100.0%40 40 1 120.0%40 48 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%1,125 - - 0.0%1,125 - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%3,736 - - 0.0%3,437 - -8.0%
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa 0.0%713 - - 0.0%695 - -2.5%
Miscellaneous Well Pump 0.0%528 - - 0.0%528 - -0.1%
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan 52.7%112 59 2 52.7%110 58 -1.9%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%99 99 3 100.0%129 129 30.0%
6,788 190 6,231 -8.2%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-7
Table A-6 Mobile Home Limited Income Market Profile, 2011

UEC Intensity Usage UEC Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/HH)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/HH)
Cooling Central AC 46.7%1,302 608 18 56.0%1,240 695 -4.8%
Cooling Room AC 18.2%518 94 3 18.2%497 90 -4.0%
Cooling Air-Source Heat Pump 6.4%1,276 82 2 6.7%1,219 82 -4.5%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.8%851 6 0 0.8%801 6 -5.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 14.0%829 116 3 14.0%974 137 17.4%
Space Heating Electric Room Heat 4.2%8,668 361 11 4.0%8,022 318 -7.4%
Space Heating Electric Furnace 44.3%9,535 4,222 123 44.3%8,825 3,908 -7.4%
Space Heating Air-Source Heat Pump 6.4%6,934 444 13 6.7%6,545 440 -5.6%
Space Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.8%4,625 35 1 0.8%4,349 33 -6.0%
Water Heating Water Heater <= 55 Gal 80.9%2,316 1,873 54 80.9%2,117 1,712 -8.6%
Water Heating Water Heater > 55 Gal 0.0%3,396 - - 0.0%3,103 - -8.6%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%930 930 27 100.0%1,027 1,027 10.4%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%120 120 3 100.0%136 136 13.4%
Interior Lighting Specialty 100.0%473 473 14 100.0%673 673 42.4%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%208 208 6 100.0%220 220 5.9%
Appliances Clothes Washer 95.8%96 92 3 98.6%51 50 -47.0%
Appliances Clothes Dryer 100.0%718 718 21 100.0%509 509 -29.1%
Appliances Dishwasher 56.5%364 205 6 73.5%171 126 -52.9%
Appliances Refrigerator 100.0%684 684 20 100.0%374 374 -45.4%
Appliances Freezer 65.0%536 348 10 67.0%315 211 -41.3%
Appliances Second Refrigerator 20.2%797 161 5 20.8%501 104 -37.2%
Appliances Stove 88.4%410 363 11 88.4%411 363 0.0%
Appliances Microwave 99.0%117 116 3 99.0%117 116 0.0%
Electronics Personal Computers 70.4%236 166 5 77.4%241 187 2.2%
Electronics Monitor 70.4%44 31 1 77.4%43 33 -2.9%
Electronics Laptops 55.8%102 57 2 61.4%103 63 0.9%
Electronics TVs 186.9%133 249 7 214.9%87 187 -34.8%
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier 60.4%36 22 1 69.5%35 24 -4.5%
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR 304.0%96 293 9 349.6%88 306 -9.0%
Electronics Devices and Gadgets 100.0%40 40 1 120.0%40 48 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%1,125 - - 0.0%1,125 - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%3,736 - - 0.0%3,437 - -8.0%
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa 0.0%713 - - 0.0%695 - -2.5%
Miscellaneous Well Pump 15.0%428 64 2 16.5%428 71 -0.1%
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan 76.7%296 227 7 76.7%290 222 -1.9%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%177 177 5 100.0%230 230 30.0%
13,585 395 12,699 -6.5%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-8 www.enernoc.com
Table A-7 Small Office Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.2%6 0 0 0.2%5 0 -14.8%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.0%6 0 0 0.1%5 0 -13.8%
Cooling Roof top AC 49.7%5 3 87 56.3%4 2 -15.9%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 20.4%5 1 35 23.2%4 1 -23.2%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%3 - - 0.0%3 - -16.8%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%4 - - 0.0%3 - -15.3%
Cooling Other Cooling 16.4%4 1 22 18.5%3 1 -15.5%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 20.4%5 1 32 20.4%4 1 -10.5%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%3 - - 0.0%3 - -10.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 2.1%7 0 5 2.1%6 0 -9.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 18.8%7 1 43 18.8%6 1 -9.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1 1 41 100.0%1 1 -16.0%
Water Heating Water Heating 67.6%1 1 21 67.6%1 1 -6.9%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%2 2 55 100.0%2 2 -1.4%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 10 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%3 3 88 100.0%2 2 -13.6%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 5 100.0%0 0 -40.0%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 27 100.0%1 1 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 2 100.0%0 0 -4.7%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 5.1%- - - 10.2%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 5.1%0 0 0 15.3%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 5.1%- - - 7.1%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5.1%- - - 7.1%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.1%0 0 0 10.2%0 0 -9.9%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 5.1%0 0 0 10.2%0 0 -29.8%
Food Preparation Oven 3.6%0 0 0 10.9%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 3.6%- - - 5.1%- - 0.0%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 3.6%1 0 1 10.9%1 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 3.6%- - - 5.1%- - 0.0%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%1 1 32 140.0%1 1 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 5 140.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%1 1 23 140.0%1 1 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 6 140.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 8 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 20.5%0 0 1 24.6%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 22.0%1 0 10 30.8%2 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1 1 28 100.0%1 1 10.0%
18 590 17 -3.4%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-9
Table A-8 Large Office Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 33.0%5 2 15 37.4%4 1 -16.9%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 23.0%5 1 11 26.0%4 1 -19.6%
Cooling Roof top AC 19.3%4 1 7 21.9%3 1 -17.4%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 10.0%4 0 4 11.3%3 0 -28.8%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%2 0 0 0.6%2 0 -18.2%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%3 - - 0.0%3 - -14.4%
Cooling Other Cooling 0.5%3 0 0 0.6%3 0 -15.5%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 10.0%4 0 3 10.0%3 0 -3.5%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%2 0 0 0.5%2 0 -4.3%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.0%5 - - 0.0%4 - -12.6%
Heating Electric Furnace 36.2%5 2 19 36.2%5 2 -12.6%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%3 3 31 100.0%3 3 -19.5%
Water Heating Water Heating 65.8%1 1 7 65.8%1 1 -4.0%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 13 100.0%1 1 -1.4%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%4 4 35 100.0%3 3 -13.6%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -39.9%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%0 0 5 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 -4.7%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 44.9%- - - 62.9%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 44.9%0 0 0 62.9%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 44.9%0 0 1 62.9%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 44.9%0 0 0 62.9%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 44.9%0 0 0 62.9%0 0 -12.2%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 44.9%0 0 0 62.9%0 0 -12.8%
Food Preparation Oven 43.1%0 0 1 60.3%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 43.1%0 0 1 60.3%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 43.1%0 0 1 60.3%0 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 43.1%0 0 0 60.3%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%2 2 23 140.0%2 3 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 4 140.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 3 140.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 4 140.0%0 1 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 2 100.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 12.7%0 0 0 13.9%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 89.6%1 0 5 125.4%1 1 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1 1 7 100.0%1 1 10.0%
21 205 21 -1.4%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-10 www.enernoc.com
Table A-9 Restaurant Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.2%6 0 0 0.2%5 0 -11.8%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.0%6 - - 0.0%5 - -15.5%
Cooling Roof top AC 49.4%6 3 18 54.4%5 3 -20.8%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 10.2%3 0 2 11.2%5 1 38.0%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%4 - - 0.0%3 - -18.3%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%5 - - 0.0%4 - -15.7%
Cooling Other Cooling 16.3%5 1 5 19.5%4 1 -15.0%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 10.2%5 1 3 10.2%3 0 -50.5%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%4 - - 0.0%2 - -48.3%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.8%6 0 0 0.8%5 0 -8.6%
Heating Electric Furnace 7.0%6 0 2 7.0%5 0 -8.6%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%3 3 14 100.0%2 2 -21.0%
Water Heating Water Heating 33.6%7 2 13 33.6%7 2 -4.6%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%5 5 29 100.0%5 5 -3.5%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1 1 6 100.0%1 1 -25.9%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -34.1%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%2 2 10 100.0%1 1 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 9.0%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 97.3%5 4 25 107.0%2 2 -56.3%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 97.3%1 1 4 107.0%0 0 -49.8%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 97.3%3 3 16 107.0%3 3 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 97.3%1 1 7 107.0%1 1 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 97.3%1 1 4 107.0%1 1 -10.8%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 97.3%1 1 4 107.0%1 1 -27.9%
Food Preparation Oven 52.5%6 3 19 73.5%6 5 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 52.5%9 5 28 73.5%9 7 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 52.5%7 4 21 73.5%5 4 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 52.5%2 1 6 57.8%1 1 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 2 110.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 100.0%0 0 0 120.0%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 20.0%5 1 5 28.0%5 1 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 10.0%
44 249 43 -3.8%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-11
Table A-10 Retail Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 7.7%4 0 11 8.1%3 0 -13.6%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 1.9%4 0 3 2.0%3 0 -15.2%
Cooling Roof top AC 43.8%4 2 67 48.2%3 2 -16.2%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 16.3%4 1 27 18.0%3 1 -32.8%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%3 - - 0.0%2 - -18.9%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%3 - - 0.0%3 - -13.2%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.3%3 0 3 2.3%3 0 -15.0%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 16.3%4 1 23 16.3%4 1 -2.1%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%3 - - 0.0%3 - 5.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 1.4%6 0 3 1.4%5 0 -12.6%
Heating Electric Furnace 12.7%6 1 27 12.7%5 1 -12.6%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1 1 41 100.0%1 1 -13.6%
Water Heating Water Heating 65.5%1 1 22 65.5%1 1 -5.0%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%3 3 112 100.0%3 3 -1.1%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 16 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%2 2 90 100.0%2 2 -11.8%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 23 100.0%1 1 -12.0%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%0 0 13 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.7%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 52.4%1 0 10 62.9%0 0 -56.3%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 52.4%0 0 2 68.1%0 0 -50.0%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 52.4%0 0 6 68.1%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 52.4%0 0 3 68.1%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 52.4%0 0 3 68.1%0 0 -12.2%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 52.4%0 0 3 73.4%0 0 -29.8%
Food Preparation Oven 39.6%0 0 3 55.4%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 39.6%0 0 5 55.4%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 39.6%0 0 7 55.4%0 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 39.6%0 0 2 49.5%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 6 125.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 9 125.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 100.0%0 0 2 120.0%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 40.2%0 0 2 48.2%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1 1 27 100.0%1 1 30.0%
15 571 14 -7.0%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-12 www.enernoc.com
Table A-11 Grocery Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.7%2 0 0 1.7%1 0 -14.1%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 1.7%2 0 0 1.7%1 0 -15.7%
Cooling Roof top AC 56.9%2 1 5 62.5%2 1 -17.0%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 13.5%5 1 4 14.9%1 0 -75.0%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%1 0 0 0.5%1 0 -16.9%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%1 - - 0.0%1 - -14.1%
Cooling Other Cooling 4.3%1 0 0 4.3%1 0 -15.0%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 13.5%2 0 1 13.5%4 1 186.5%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%1 0 0 0.5%3 0 177.8%
Heating Electric Room Heat 1.3%6 0 0 1.3%5 0 -9.4%
Heating Electric Furnace 11.2%6 1 4 11.2%6 1 -9.4%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%2 2 11 100.0%2 2 -12.7%
Water Heating Water Heating 49.1%2 1 6 49.1%2 1 -4.0%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%3 3 16 100.0%3 3 -2.7%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%6 6 32 100.0%5 5 -10.2%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -43.4%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 5 100.0%1 1 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.5%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 98.9%7 7 38 108.8%3 3 -56.2%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 98.9%0 0 2 108.8%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 98.9%14 13 69 108.8%12 13 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 98.9%6 6 31 108.8%6 6 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 98.9%0 0 1 108.8%0 0 -12.2%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 98.9%0 0 2 108.8%0 0 -29.8%
Food Preparation Oven 54.9%1 0 2 76.8%1 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 54.9%1 1 3 76.8%1 1 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 54.9%1 1 4 76.8%1 1 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 54.9%0 0 1 68.6%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 0 125.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 0 125.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 100.0%0 0 0 120.0%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 34.6%1 0 2 41.6%1 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1 1 3 100.0%1 1 50.0%
47 246 42 -11.0%
New Units
Compared to AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-13
Table A-12 College Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 36.1%4 1 14 37.9%3 1 -16.6%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 9.0%4 0 3 9.5%3 0 -18.8%
Cooling Roof top AC 21.3%4 1 7 23.5%3 1 -17.4%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 8.1%6 0 4 8.9%3 0 -54.1%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%2 0 0 0.5%2 0 -15.2%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%3 - - 0.0%2 - -14.5%
Cooling Other Cooling 0.0%3 - - 0.0%2 - -15.5%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 8.1%3 0 2 8.1%5 0 54.0%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%2 0 0 0.5%4 0 61.7%
Heating Electric Room Heat 1.0%11 0 1 1.0%9 0 -12.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 9.4%11 1 10 9.4%10 1 -12.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%2 2 14 100.0%1 1 -12.2%
Water Heating Water Heating 42.2%2 1 8 42.2%2 1 -6.9%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%2 2 16 100.0%2 2 -0.3%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 2 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%3 3 27 100.0%3 3 -8.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -58.1%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 6 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 4.4%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 26.6%0 0 0 34.6%0 0 -56.4%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 26.6%0 0 0 34.6%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 26.6%0 0 0 34.6%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 26.6%0 0 0 34.6%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 26.6%0 0 0 37.2%0 0 -9.9%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 26.6%0 0 0 34.6%0 0 -23.5%
Food Preparation Oven 21.0%0 0 1 27.4%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 21.0%0 0 1 27.4%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 21.0%1 0 1 27.4%0 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 21.0%0 0 0 26.3%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 3 125.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 2 125.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 20.8%0 0 0 24.9%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 88.8%0 0 1 106.6%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 4.9%0 0 0 5.8%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 1.2%0 0 0 1.2%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%0 0 4 100.0%1 1 30.0%
14 130 13 -7.7%
New Units
Compared to AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-14 www.enernoc.com
Table A-13 School Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 26.4%3 1 19 26.4%2 1 -16.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 6.6%3 0 5 6.6%2 0 -19.0%
Cooling Roof top AC 18.2%2 0 12 21.0%2 0 -17.4%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 10.7%5 0 14 11.8%2 0 -61.2%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%1 0 0 0.5%1 0 -11.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%2 - - 0.0%1 - -14.5%
Cooling Other Cooling 0.0%2 - - 0.0%2 - -15.5%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 10.7%2 0 6 10.7%4 0 86.9%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%1 0 0 0.5%3 0 96.2%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.5%8 0 1 0.5%7 0 -12.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 4.3%9 0 10 4.3%7 0 -12.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1 1 25 100.0%1 1 -12.2%
Water Heating Water Heating 38.2%1 0 13 38.2%1 0 -6.9%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 35 100.0%1 1 -0.3%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 6 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1 1 26 100.0%1 1 -8.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 2 100.0%0 0 -58.1%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 15 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 4.4%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 65.7%0 0 4 92.0%0 0 -56.4%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 65.7%0 0 1 92.0%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 65.7%0 0 3 92.0%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 65.7%0 0 1 92.0%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 65.7%0 0 2 92.0%0 0 -9.9%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 65.7%0 0 1 85.4%0 0 -23.5%
Food Preparation Oven 52.3%0 0 2 62.8%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 52.3%0 0 4 62.8%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 52.3%0 0 6 62.8%0 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 52.3%0 0 2 73.3%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 6 140.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 1 140.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 6 140.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 1 140.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 2 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 4.2%0 0 0 5.1%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 43.7%0 0 1 43.7%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 1.2%0 0 0 1.2%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.3%0 0 0 0.3%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%0 0 8 100.0%0 0 30.0%
9 239 8 -6.9%
New Units
Compared to AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-15
Table A-14 Hospital Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 14.6%9 1 15 15.3%8 1 -14.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 51.2%10 5 56 53.8%9 5 -11.0%
Cooling Roof top AC 24.3%9 2 24 25.5%7 2 -16.7%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 2.4%9 0 3 2.6%7 0 -26.2%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%5 0 0 0.5%5 0 -12.7%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%7 - - 0.0%6 - -13.7%
Cooling Other Cooling 1.1%7 0 1 1.2%6 0 -15.5%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 2.4%8 0 2 2.4%8 0 -3.1%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.5%5 0 0 0.5%6 0 8.8%
Heating Electric Room Heat 1.0%16 0 2 1.0%14 0 -13.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.7%17 1 17 8.7%15 1 -13.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%5 5 51 100.0%4 4 -12.1%
Water Heating Water Heating 25.2%5 1 13 25.2%4 1 -2.0%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%2 2 22 100.0%2 2 -2.7%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%4 4 49 100.0%4 4 -10.1%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 -51.9%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 6 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 5.1%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 70.8%0 0 3 92.0%0 0 -56.2%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 70.8%0 0 0 92.0%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 70.8%0 0 2 92.0%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 70.8%0 0 1 92.0%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 70.8%0 0 1 92.0%0 0 -11.4%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 70.8%0 0 1 92.0%0 0 -27.9%
Food Preparation Oven 42.0%1 0 4 52.5%1 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 42.0%1 1 6 52.5%1 1 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 42.0%2 1 9 52.5%1 1 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 42.0%1 0 3 58.8%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 5 140.0%0 1 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 1 140.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 2 140.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 1 135.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 5.5%0 0 0 6.1%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 74.1%1 1 8 88.9%1 1 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.9%0 0 0 0.9%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.2%0 0 0 0.2%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%3 3 38 100.0%4 4 10.0%
31 345 29 -4.7%
New Units
Compared to AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-16 www.enernoc.com
Table A-15 Lodging Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 4.2%2 0 1 4.8%1 0 -10.9%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 17.0%2 0 3 19.2%2 0 -12.4%
Cooling Roof top AC 7.7%3 0 3 8.8%3 0 -16.0%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 23.7%3 1 8 26.8%3 1 -6.7%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 1.0%2 0 0 1.1%2 0 -15.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%3 - - 0.0%2 - -28.3%
Cooling Other Cooling 26.3%3 1 8 28.9%2 1 -15.5%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 23.7%3 1 8 23.7%2 1 -25.8%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 1.0%2 0 0 1.0%2 0 -30.7%
Heating Electric Room Heat 3.8%4 0 1 3.8%3 0 -9.8%
Heating Electric Furnace 34.0%4 1 14 34.0%3 1 -9.8%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1 1 13 100.0%1 1 -10.2%
Water Heating Water Heating 28.2%4 1 12 28.2%4 1 -8.9%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%5 5 51 100.0%5 5 -5.2%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 1 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1 1 6 100.0%0 0 -19.6%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 3 100.0%0 0 -46.8%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 5 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 -0.9%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 58.9%0 0 3 73.6%0 0 -56.2%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 58.9%0 0 0 73.6%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 58.9%0 0 2 73.6%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 58.9%0 0 1 73.6%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 58.9%0 0 1 73.6%0 0 -11.1%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 58.9%0 0 1 76.6%0 0 -27.9%
Food Preparation Oven 30.0%0 0 1 37.5%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 30.0%0 0 1 37.5%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 30.0%1 0 2 37.5%1 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 30.0%0 0 1 33.0%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 0 120.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 100.0%0 0 0 120.0%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 91.3%0 0 4 109.5%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 39.5%0 0 0 39.5%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 9.9%0 0 0 9.9%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1 1 9 100.0%1 1 10.0%
16 166 14 -7.8%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-17
Table A-16 Assembly Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 6.9%2 0 3 8.2%2 0 -16.1%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 4.6%2 0 2 5.5%2 0 -18.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 52.4%2 1 23 62.7%2 1 -16.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 12.7%3 0 8 15.3%2 0 -50.6%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%1 - - 0.0%1 - -18.9%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%2 - - 0.0%2 - -13.1%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.7%2 0 1 3.2%2 0 -15.0%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 12.7%2 0 5 12.7%3 0 33.0%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%1 - - 0.0%2 - 43.8%
Heating Electric Room Heat 1.3%4 0 1 1.3%4 0 -5.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 11.3%4 1 9 11.3%4 0 -5.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1 1 11 100.0%1 1 -14.8%
Water Heating Water Heating 47.0%1 1 10 47.0%1 1 -4.0%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 26 100.0%1 1 -0.6%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 3 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%2 2 43 100.0%2 2 -10.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 4 100.0%0 0 -10.8%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 19 100.0%1 1 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 -0.9%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 30.2%0 0 1 37.8%0 0 -56.3%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 30.2%0 0 0 37.8%0 0 -50.7%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 30.2%0 0 1 37.8%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 30.2%0 0 0 37.8%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 30.2%0 0 1 37.8%0 0 -12.2%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 30.2%0 0 0 39.3%0 0 -27.9%
Food Preparation Oven 30.7%0 0 1 38.4%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 30.7%0 0 1 38.4%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 30.7%0 0 2 38.4%0 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 30.7%0 0 1 33.8%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 4 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 1 120.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 2 110.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 1 125.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 30.5%0 0 0 36.6%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 59.9%0 0 0 71.9%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 4.3%0 0 0 4.3%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 1.1%0 0 0 1.1%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1 1 17 100.0%1 1 30.0%
11 203 10 -5.6%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-18 www.enernoc.com
Table A-17 Warehouse Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.0%2 - - 0.0%2 - -17.9%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.0%2 - - 0.0%1 - -19.2%
Cooling Roof top AC 11.1%2 0 8 13.3%2 0 -15.9%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%7 0 17 9.0%2 0 -76.9%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%1 - - 0.0%1 - -18.9%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%2 - - 0.0%1 - -13.0%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.5%2 0 1 3.0%1 0 -15.0%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%2 0 5 7.5%5 0 184.5%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%1 - - 0.0%4 - 207.5%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.9%8 0 2 0.9%8 0 -5.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.1%8 1 23 8.1%8 1 -5.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%0 0 9 100.0%0 0 -12.7%
Water Heating Water Heating 55.3%0 0 5 55.3%0 0 -4.0%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 20 100.0%1 1 4.8%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%0 0 4 100.0%0 0 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%2 2 59 100.0%2 2 -9.4%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 -42.9%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 17 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.2%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 15.1%2 0 8 18.8%1 0 -56.3%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 15.1%- - - 18.8%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 15.1%- - - 18.8%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 15.1%- - - 18.8%- - 0.0%
Refrigeration Icemaker 15.1%0 0 0 18.8%0 0 -12.2%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 15.1%0 0 0 19.6%0 0 -23.5%
Food Preparation Oven 2.3%0 0 0 2.8%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 2.3%- - - 2.8%- - 0.0%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 2.3%- - - 2.8%- - 0.0%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 2.3%- - - 2.5%- - 0.0%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 3 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 0 120.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 4 110.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 1 110.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 0 125.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 1.9%0 0 0 2.3%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 49.9%0 0 5 59.8%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 0.0%- - - 0.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%0 0 11 100.0%0 0 10.0%
6 205 5 -9.3%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-19
Table A-18 Miscellaneous Commercial Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Sqft.)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 3.0%2 0 1 3.9%2 0 -16.2%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 11.9%2 0 4 15.5%2 0 -18.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 24.7%3 1 9 32.1%2 1 -16.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 12.1%4 1 7 15.7%2 0 -56.4%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%2 - - 0.0%1 - -18.9%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%2 - - 0.0%2 - -13.1%
Cooling Other Cooling 3.5%2 0 1 4.6%2 0 -15.0%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 12.1%2 0 4 12.1%4 0 50.7%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%2 - - 0.0%3 - 62.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 1.4%5 0 1 1.4%5 0 -5.1%
Heating Electric Furnace 12.2%6 1 9 12.2%5 1 -5.1%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1 1 11 100.0%1 1 -15.4%
Water Heating Water Heating 44.5%2 1 9 44.5%1 1 -4.6%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 16 100.0%1 1 -0.6%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%2 2 29 100.0%1 1 -50.6%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1 1 10 100.0%1 1 -13.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%0 0 4 100.0%0 0 -11.2%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1 1 8 100.0%0 0 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 4 100.0%0 0 -0.9%
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 21.6%0 0 1 27.0%0 0 -56.4%
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 21.6%0 0 0 27.0%0 0 -48.8%
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 21.6%0 0 1 27.0%0 0 -9.7%
Refrigeration Open Display Case 21.6%0 0 0 27.0%0 0 -9.3%
Refrigeration Icemaker 21.6%0 0 0 27.0%0 0 -12.2%
Refrigeration Vending Machine 21.6%0 0 0 28.1%0 0 -27.9%
Food Preparation Oven 15.4%0 0 0 17.0%0 0 -1.2%
Food Preparation Fryer 15.4%0 0 1 17.0%0 0 -0.6%
Food Preparation Dishwasher 15.4%0 0 1 17.0%0 0 -24.1%
Food Preparation Hot Food Container 15.4%0 0 0 17.0%0 0 -39.9%
Office Equipment Desktop Computer 100.0%0 0 2 110.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Laptop 100.0%0 0 0 120.0%0 0 -0.7%
Office Equipment Server 100.0%0 0 2 110.0%0 0 -4.7%
Office Equipment Monitor 100.0%0 0 0 110.0%0 0 -2.8%
Office Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax 100.0%0 0 0 125.0%0 0 -6.1%
Office Equipment POS Terminal 30.5%0 0 0 36.6%0 0 -15.6%
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors 59.9%0 0 2 71.9%0 0 5.1%
Miscellaneous Pool Pump 4.3%0 0 0 5.1%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Pool Heater 1.1%0 0 0 1.1%0 0 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%9 9 123 100.0%10 10 5.0%
20 262 19 -5.9%
New Units
Compared to
AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles
Market Profiles
A-20 www.enernoc.com
Table A-19 Manufacturing Food Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 2.5%9,431 236 3 2.5%8,330 208 -11.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 2.5%9,025 226 3 2.5%5,495 137 -39.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 6.7%10,436 698 9 6.7%5,104 342 -51.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%9,435 712 9 7.5%5,881 444 -37.7%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%6,293 - - 0.0%4,152 - -34.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%7,827 - - 0.0%2,202 - -71.9%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.5%8,234 209 3 2.5%7,633 193 -7.3%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%29,900 2,257 30 7.5%26,696 2,015 -10.7%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%19,943 - - 0.0%18,962 - -4.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.9%36,809 330 4 0.9%34,963 314 -5.0%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.1%38,649 3,121 41 8.1%36,711 2,964 -5.0%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1,182 1,182 16 100.0%942 942 -20.2%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1,543 1,543 20 100.0%1,065 1,065 -31.0%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%328 328 4 100.0%165 165 -49.8%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%4,495 4,495 59 100.0%4,300 4,300 -4.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%3 3 0 100.0%2 2 -42.7%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1,204 1,204 16 100.0%- - -100.0%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.2%
Motors Pumps 100.0%13,360 13,360 176 100.0%13,356 13,356 0.0%
Motors Fans & Blowers 100.0%9,609 9,609 127 100.0%9,606 9,606 0.0%
Motors Compressed Air 100.0%5,415 5,415 71 100.0%5,414 5,414 0.0%
Motors Matl Handling 100.0%8,187 8,187 108 100.0%8,185 8,185 0.0%
Motors Matl Processing 100.0%11,626 11,626 153 100.0%11,623 11,623 0.0%
Motors Other Motors 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Process Process Heating 100.0%7,938 7,938 105 100.0%7,938 7,938 0.0%
Process Process Cooling and Refrig 100.0%31,154 31,154 410 100.0%31,154 31,154 0.0%
Process Electro-Chemical Processes 100.0%277 277 4 100.0%277 277 0.0%
Process Other Process 100.0%993 993 13 100.0%993 993 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%5,248 5,248 69 100.0%5,248 5,248 0.0%
110,351 1,454 106,888 -3.1%Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles New Units
Compared
to AverageSaturation
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-21
Table A-20 Agriculture Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 2.5%9,813 245 1 2.5%8,668 217 -11.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 2.5%9,391 235 1 2.5%5,717 143 -39.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 6.7%10,859 727 2 6.7%5,311 355 -51.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%9,817 741 2 7.5%6,120 462 -37.7%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%6,548 - - 0.0%4,321 - -34.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%8,145 - - 0.0%2,291 - -71.9%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.5%8,568 217 1 2.5%7,942 201 -7.3%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%31,112 2,348 7 7.5%27,778 2,096 -10.7%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%20,752 - - 0.0%19,731 - -4.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.9%38,301 344 1 0.9%36,380 326 -5.0%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.1%40,216 3,247 9 8.1%38,199 3,084 -5.0%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%1,229 1,229 3 100.0%981 981 -20.2%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%2,472 2,472 7 100.0%1,706 1,706 -31.0%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%526 526 1 100.0%264 264 -49.8%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%7,201 7,201 20 100.0%6,890 6,890 -4.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%5 5 0 100.0%3 3 -42.7%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%1,929 1,929 5 100.0%1,261 1,261 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1 1 0 100.0%1 1 0.2%
Motors Pumps 100.0%18,667 18,667 52 100.0%18,662 18,662 0.0%
Motors Fans & Blowers 100.0%14,933 14,933 41 100.0%14,930 14,930 0.0%
Motors Compressed Air 100.0%3,733 3,733 10 100.0%3,733 3,733 0.0%
Motors Matl Handling 100.0%3,733 3,733 10 100.0%3,732 3,732 0.0%
Motors Matl Processing 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Motors Other Motors 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Process Process Heating 100.0%3,733 3,733 10 100.0%3,242 3,242 -13.2%
Process Process Cooling and Refrig 100.0%25,200 25,200 70 100.0%25,200 25,200 0.0%
Process Electro-Chemical Processes 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Process Other Process 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1,867 1,867 5 100.0%1,867 1,867 0.0%
93,334 258 89,357 -4.3%Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles New Units
Compared
to AverageSaturation
Market Profiles
A-22 www.enernoc.com
Table A-21 Water and Waste Water Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 2.5%3,483 87 0 2.5%3,077 77 -11.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 2.5%3,333 83 0 2.5%2,029 51 -39.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 6.7%3,854 258 1 6.7%1,885 126 -51.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%3,485 263 1 7.5%2,172 164 -37.7%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%2,324 - - 0.0%1,534 - -34.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%2,891 - - 0.0%813 - -71.9%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.5%3,041 77 0 2.5%2,819 71 -7.3%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%11,043 833 3 7.5%9,859 744 -10.7%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%7,366 - - 0.0%7,003 - -4.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.9%13,594 122 0 0.9%12,913 116 -5.0%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.1%14,274 1,153 4 8.1%13,558 1,095 -5.0%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%436 436 1 100.0%348 348 -20.2%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%622 622 2 100.0%429 429 -31.0%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%132 132 0 100.0%66 66 -49.8%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1,811 1,811 6 100.0%1,733 1,733 -4.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 0 100.0%1 1 -42.7%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%485 485 2 100.0%317 317 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.2%
Motors Pumps 100.0%31,264 31,264 98 100.0%31,256 31,256 0.0%
Motors Fans & Blowers 100.0%6,663 6,663 21 100.0%6,662 6,662 0.0%
Motors Compressed Air 100.0%2,665 2,665 8 100.0%2,665 2,665 0.0%
Motors Matl Handling 100.0%7,996 7,996 25 100.0%7,994 7,994 0.0%
Motors Matl Processing 100.0%6,717 6,717 21 100.0%6,715 6,715 0.0%
Motors Other Motors 100.0%7,330 7,330 23 100.0%7,328 7,328 0.0%
Process Process Heating 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Process Process Cooling and Refrig 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Process Electro-Chemical Processes 100.0%- - - 100.0%- - 0.0%
Process Other Process 100.0%3,194 3,194 10 100.0%3,194 3,194 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1,887 1,887 6 100.0%1,887 1,887 0.0%
74,080 233 73,038 -1.4%Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles New Units
Compared
to AverageSaturation
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-23
Table A-22 Electronics Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 2.5%4,337 108 1 2.5%3,831 96 -11.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 2.5%4,150 104 1 2.5%2,527 63 -39.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 6.7%4,799 321 4 6.7%2,347 157 -51.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%4,339 327 4 7.5%2,705 204 -37.7%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%2,894 - - 0.0%1,910 - -34.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%3,600 - - 0.0%1,013 - -71.9%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.5%3,787 96 1 2.5%3,510 89 -7.3%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%13,750 1,038 13 7.5%12,277 927 -10.7%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%9,171 - - 0.0%8,720 - -4.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.9%16,927 152 2 0.9%16,078 144 -5.0%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.1%17,774 1,435 18 8.1%16,882 1,363 -5.0%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%543 543 7 100.0%433 433 -20.2%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%342 342 4 100.0%236 236 -31.0%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%73 73 1 100.0%37 37 -49.8%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%997 997 13 100.0%954 954 -4.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 0 100.0%0 0 -42.7%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%267 267 3 100.0%175 175 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.2%
Motors Pumps 100.0%484 484 6 100.0%484 484 0.0%
Motors Fans & Blowers 100.0%484 484 6 100.0%484 484 0.0%
Motors Compressed Air 100.0%242 242 3 100.0%242 242 0.0%
Motors Matl Handling 100.0%145 145 2 100.0%145 145 0.0%
Motors Matl Processing 100.0%726 726 9 100.0%726 726 0.0%
Motors Other Motors 100.0%968 968 12 100.0%967 967 0.0%
Process Process Heating 100.0%1,583 1,583 20 100.0%1,583 1,583 0.0%
Process Process Cooling and Refrig 100.0%1,470 1,470 19 100.0%1,470 1,470 0.0%
Process Electro-Chemical Processes 100.0%276 276 4 100.0%276 276 0.0%
Process Other Process 100.0%1,389 1,389 18 100.0%1,389 1,389 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1,246 1,246 16 100.0%1,246 1,246 0.0%
14,818 188 13,890 -6.3%Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles New Units
Compared
to AverageSaturation
Market Profiles
A-24 www.enernoc.com
Table A-23 Other Industrial Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/Empl.
)
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 2.5%4,118 103 3 2.5%3,637 91 -11.7%
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 2.5%3,941 99 3 2.5%2,399 60 -39.1%
Cooling Roof top AC 6.7%4,557 305 9 6.7%2,229 149 -51.1%
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%4,120 311 9 7.5%2,568 194 -37.7%
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%2,748 - - 0.0%1,813 - -34.0%
Cooling Evaporative AC 0.0%3,418 - - 0.0%961 - -71.9%
Cooling Other Cooling 2.5%3,595 91 3 2.5%3,333 84 -7.3%
Heating Air Source Heat Pump 7.5%13,055 985 28 7.5%11,656 880 -10.7%
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump 0.0%8,708 - - 0.0%8,279 - -4.9%
Heating Electric Room Heat 0.9%16,072 144 4 0.9%15,266 137 -5.0%
Heating Electric Furnace 8.1%16,875 1,363 39 8.1%16,029 1,294 -5.0%
Ventilation Ventilation 100.0%516 516 15 100.0%412 412 -20.2%
Interior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%522 522 15 100.0%360 360 -31.0%
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures 100.0%111 111 3 100.0%56 56 -49.8%
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%1,520 1,520 44 100.0%1,455 1,455 -4.3%
Exterior Lighting Screw-in 100.0%1 1 0 100.0%1 1 -42.7%
Exterior Lighting HID 100.0%407 407 12 100.0%266 266 -34.6%
Exterior Lighting Linear Fluorescent 100.0%0 0 0 100.0%0 0 0.2%
Motors Pumps 100.0%996 996 29 100.0%996 996 0.0%
Motors Fans & Blowers 100.0%1,196 1,196 35 100.0%1,196 1,196 0.0%
Motors Compressed Air 100.0%967 967 28 100.0%967 967 0.0%
Motors Matl Handling 100.0%412 412 12 100.0%412 412 0.0%
Motors Matl Processing 100.0%1,634 1,634 47 100.0%1,634 1,634 0.0%
Motors Other Motors 100.0%34 34 1 100.0%34 34 0.0%
Process Process Heating 100.0%1,685 1,685 49 100.0%1,685 1,685 0.0%
Process Process Cooling and Refrig 100.0%885 885 26 100.0%885 885 0.0%
Process Electro-Chemical Processes 100.0%170 170 5 100.0%170 170 0.0%
Process Other Process 100.0%185 185 5 100.0%185 185 0.0%
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous 100.0%1,016 1,016 29 100.0%1,016 1,016 0.0%
15,660 452 14,619 -6.6%Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles New Units
Compared
to AverageSaturation
Market Profiles
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-25
Table A-24 Irrigation Market Profile, 2011

EUI Intensity Usage EUI Intensity
(kWh)(kWh/SP)(GWh)(kWh)(kWh/SP)
Motors 5 HP 100.0%645 645 12 100.0%623 623 -3.4%
Motors 10 HP 100.0%1,914 1,914 36 100.0%1,847 1,847 -3.5%
Motors 15 HP 100.0%1,385 1,385 26 100.0%1,342 1,342 -3.1%
Motors 20 HP 100.0%1,732 1,732 32 100.0%1,688 1,688 -2.5%
Motors 25 HP 100.0%2,031 2,031 38 100.0%1,981 1,981 -2.5%
Motors 30 HP 100.0%2,161 2,161 40 100.0%2,109 2,109 -2.4%
Motors 40 HP 100.0%3,727 3,727 70 100.0%3,655 3,655 -1.9%
Motors 50 HP 100.0%3,771 3,771 71 100.0%3,703 3,703 -1.8%
Motors 60 HP 100.0%2,905 2,905 54 100.0%2,861 2,861 -1.5%
Motors 75 HP 100.0%4,489 4,489 84 100.0%4,443 4,443 -1.0%
Motors 100 HP 100.0%6,571 6,571 123 100.0%6,480 6,480 -1.4%
Motors 125 HP 100.0%4,926 4,926 92 100.0%4,878 4,878 -1.0%
Motors 150 HP 100.0%5,781 5,781 108 100.0%5,718 5,718 -1.1%
Motors 200 HP 100.0%9,690 9,690 182 100.0%9,601 9,601 -0.9%
Motors 250 HP 100.0%6,006 6,006 113 100.0%5,941 5,941 -1.1%
Motors 300 HP 100.0%6,659 6,659 125 100.0%6,579 6,579 -1.2%
Motors 350 HP 100.0%5,507 5,507 103 100.0%5,450 5,450 -1.0%
Motors 400 HP 100.0%5,534 5,534 104 100.0%5,470 5,470 -1.1%
Motors 450 HP 100.0%3,613 3,613 68 100.0%3,550 3,550 -1.7%
Motors 500 HP 100.0%3,510 3,510 66 100.0%3,439 3,439 -2.0%
Motors 600 HP 100.0%3,799 3,799 71 100.0%3,722 3,722 -2.0%
Motors > 600 HP 100.0%8,051 8,051 151 100.0%7,890 7,890 -2.0%
94,407 1,769 92,972 -1.5%
New Units
Compared
to AverageSaturation
Total
End Use Technology Saturation
Average Market Profiles

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting A-26

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-1
APPENDIX B
RESIDENTIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE
DATA
This appendix presents detailed information for all energy-efficiency measures (equipment and
non-equipment measures per the LoadMAP taxonomy) that were evaluated as part of this study.
Several sets of tables are provided.
Measure Descriptions
Table B-1 and Table B-2 provide brief descriptions for all equipment and non-equipment
measures that were assessed for potential.
Measure Data
Table B-3 through Table B-14 list the detailed unit-level data for the equipment measures for
each of the housing type segments — Single Family, Multi Family, Mobile Home, Limited Income
Single Family, Limited Income Multi Family, and Limited Income Mobile Home — and for existing
and new construction, respectively. Savings are in annual kWh per household, and incremental
costs are in $/household ($/HH), unless noted otherwise. The B/C ratio shown in the tables are
for the first year of the potential analysis (2012), although the B/C ratio is calculated within
LoadMAP for each year of the forecast. The B/C ratio in the tables is 1.00 if the measure
represents the baseline technology, and zero if the technology is not available in 2013. The final
data item in these tables is the levelized cost of conserved energy, which is defined as the cost
of the measure divided by the cumulative amount of energy savings accrued over the measure’s
lifetime ($/kWh).
Table B-15 through Table B-26 list the detailed unit-level data for the non-equipment energy
efficiency measures for each of the housing type segments and for existing and new
construction, respectively. Because these measures can produce energy-use savings for multiple
end-use loads (e.g., insulation affects heating and cooling energy use) savings are expressed as
a net percentage of all the relevant, combined end-use loads. Base saturation indicates the
percentage of homes in which the measure is already installed. Applicability is a factor that
accounts for whether the measure is applicable to the building. Cost is expressed in $/household.
The detailed measure-level tables present the results of the benefit/cost (B/C) analysis for the
first year of the analysis (2012) although the B/C ratio is calculated within LoadMAP for each
year of the forecast. These tables also contain the levelized cost of conserved energy, which is
defined as the cost of the measure divided by the cumulative amount of energy savings accrued
over the measure’s lifetime ($/kWh).

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-2 www.enernoc.com
Table B-1 Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment Measure Descriptions
End Use Technology Measure Description
Cooling Central AC
Central air conditioners consist of a refrigeration system using a direct
expansion cycle. Equipment includes a compressor, an air-cooled
condenser (located outdoors), an expansion valve, and an evaporator
coil. A supply fan near the evaporator coil distributes supply air through
air ducts to the building. Cooling efficiencies vary based on materials
used, equipment size, condenser type, and system configuration. CACs
may be unitary (all components housed in a factory-built assembly) or
split system (an outdoor condenser section and an indoor evaporator
section connected by refrigerant lines and with the compressor either
indoors or outdoors). Energy efficiency is rated according to the size of
the unit using the Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating (SEER). Ductless
systems with Variable Refrigerant Flow further improve the operating
efficiency.
Cooling Room AC
Room air conditioners are designed to cool a single room or space. They
incorporate a complete air-cooled refrigeration and air-handling system
in an individual package. Room air conditioners come in several forms,
including window, split-type, and packaged terminal units. Energy
efficiency is rated according to the size of the unit using the Energy
Efficiency Rating (EER).
Heating/Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump
A central heat pump consists of components similar to a CAC system, but
is usually designed to function both as a heat pump and an air
conditioner. It consists of a refrigeration system using a direct expansion
(DX) cycle. Equipment includes a compressor, an air-cooled condenser
(located outdoors), an expansion valve, and an evaporator coil (located in
the supply air duct near the supply fan) and a reversing valve to change
the DX cycle from cooling to heating when required. The cooling and
heating efficiencies vary based on the materials used, equipment size,
condenser type, and system configuration. Heat pumps may be unitary
(all components housed in a factory-built assembly) or a split system (an
outdoor condenser section and an indoor evaporator section connected
by refrigerant lines, with either outdoors or indoors. A high-efficiency
option for a ductless mini-split system is also analyzed.
Heating/Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump
Geothermal heat pumps are similar to air-source heat pumps, but use the
ground or groundwater instead of outside air to provide a heat
source/sink. A geothermal heat pump system generally consists of three
major subsystems or parts: a geothermal heat pump to move heat
between the building and the fluid in the earth connection, an earth
connection for transferring heat between the fluid and the earth, and a
distribution subsystem for delivering heating or cooling to the building.
The system may also have a desuperheater to supplement the building's
water heater, or a full-demand water heater to meet all of the building's
hot water needs.
Cooling Evaporative AC Evaporative air conditioning, sometimes called swamp cooling, uses the
cooling effect produced when water evaporates to provide space cooling.
Heating Electric Furnace
Resistive heating elements are used to convert electricity directly to heat.
The heat is then delivered by a supply fan and duct system to the regions
that require heating.
Heating Electric Room Heat Resistive heating elements are used to convert electricity directly to heat.
Conductive fins surrounding the element or another mechanism is used
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-3
End Use Technology Measure Description
to deliver the heat directly to the surrounding room or area. These are
typically either baseboard or wall-mounted units.
Water Heating Water Heater
For electric hot water heating, the most common type is a storage heater,
which incorporates an electric heating element, storage tank, outer
jacket, insulation, and controls in a single unit. Efficient units are
characterized by a high recovery or thermal efficiency and low standby
losses (the ratio of heat lost per hour to the content of the stored water).
A further efficiency gain is available through a heat pump water heater
(HPWH), which uses a vapor-compression thermodynamic cycle similar to
that found in an air-conditioner or refrigerator to extract heat from an
available source (e.g., air) and reject that heat to a higher temperature
sink, in this case, the water in the water heater. Electric instantaneous
water heaters are available, but are excluded from this study due to
potentially high instantaneous demand concerns.
Interior Lighting Screw-in
Infrared halogen lamps are designed to be a replacement for standards
incandescent lamps. Also referred to as advanced incandescent lamps,
these products meet the Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA)
lighting standards and are phased in as the baseline technology screw-in
lamp technology to reflect the timeline over which the EISA lighting
standards take effect. Compact fluorescent lamps are designed to be a
replacement for standard incandescent lamps and use about 25% of the
energy used by standard incandescent lamps to produce the same lumen
output. They can use either electronic or magnetic ballasts. Integral
compact fluorescent lamps have the ballast integrated into the base of
the lamp and have a standard screw-in base that permits installation into
existing incandescent fixtures. Light-emitting diode (LED) lighting has
seen recent penetration in specific applications such as traffic lights and
exit signs. With the potential for extremely high efficiency, LEDs show
promise to provide general-use lighting for interior spaces. Current
models commercially available have efficacies comparable to CFLs.
However, theoretical efficiencies are significantly higher. LED models
under development are expected to provide improved efficacies.
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent
T8 fluorescent lamps are smaller in diameter than standard T12 lamps,
resulting in greater light output per watt. T8 lamps also operate at a
lower current and wattage, which increases the efficiency of the ballast
but requires the lamps to be compatible with the ballast. Fluorescent
lamp fixtures can include a reflector that increases the light output from
the fixture, and thus make it possible to use a fewer number of lamps in
each fixture. T5 lamps further increase efficiency by reducing the lamp
diameter to 5/8”. Light-emitting diode (LED) lighting has seen recent
penetration in specific applications such as traffic lights and exit signs.
With the potential for extremely high efficiency, LEDs show promise to
provide general-use lighting for interior spaces. Current models
commercially available have efficacies comparable to CFLs. However,
theoretical efficiencies are significantly higher. LED models under
development are expected to provide improved efficacies.
Interior Lighting Specialty Lighting
Bulbs that the DOE does not consider conventional and are not covered
by federal efficiency standards. These include: appliance bulbs, heavy-
duty bulbs, dimmable bulbs, three-way bulbs, G shape (globe) lamps,
candelabra base, and others.
Exterior Screw-in Infrared halogen lamps are designed to be a replacement for standards
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-4 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Measure Description
Lighting incandescent lamps. Also referred to as advanced incandescent lamps,
these products meet the Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA)
lighting standards and are phased in as the baseline technology screw-in
lamp technology to reflect the timeline over which the EISA lighting
standards take effect. Compact fluorescent lamps are designed to be a
replacement for standard incandescent lamps and use about 25% of the
energy used by standard incandescent lamps to produce the same lumen
output. They can use either electronic or magnetic ballasts. Integral
compact fluorescent lamps have the ballast integrated into the base of
the lamp and have a standard screw-in base that permits installation into
existing incandescent fixtures. Light-emitting diode (LED) lighting has
seen recent penetration in specific applications such as traffic lights and
exit signs. With the potential for extremely high efficiency, LEDs show
promise to provide general-use lighting for interior spaces. Current
models commercially available have efficacies comparable to CFLs.
However, theoretical efficiencies are significantly higher. LED models
under development are expected to provide improved efficacies.
Appliances Refrigerator
Energy-efficient refrigerators/freezers incorporate features such as
improved cabinet insulation, more efficient compressors and evaporator
fans, defrost controls, mullion heaters, oversized condenser coils, and
improved door seals. Further efficiency increases can be obtained by
reducing the volume of refrigerated space, or adding multiple
compartments to reduce losses from opening doors.
Appliances Second
Refrigerator
Energy-efficient refrigerators/freezers incorporate features such as
improved cabinet insulation, more efficient compressors and evaporator
fans, defrost controls, mullion heaters, oversized condenser coils, and
improved door seals. Further efficiency increases can be obtained by
reducing the volume of refrigerated space, or adding multiple
compartments to reduce losses from opening doors.
Appliances Freezer
Energy-efficient refrigerators/freezers incorporate features such as
improved cabinet insulation, more efficient compressors and evaporator
fans, defrost controls, mullion heaters, oversized condenser coils, and
improved door seals. Further efficiency increases can be obtained by
reducing the volume of refrigerated space, or adding multiple
compartments to reduce losses from opening doors.
Appliances Clothes Washer
High efficiency clothes washers use superior designs that require less
water. Sensors match the hot water needs to the size and soil level of the
load, preventing energy waste. Further energy and water savings can be
achieved through advanced technologies such as inverter-drive or
combination washer-dryer units. MEF is the official energy efficiency
metric used to compare relative efficiencies of different clothes washers.
MEF considers the energy used to run the washer, heat the water, and
run the dryer. The higher the MEF, the more efficient the clothes washer.
Appliances Clothes Dryer
An energy-efficient clothes dryer has a moisture-sensing device to
terminate the drying cycle rather than using a timer, and an energy-
efficient motor is used for spinning the dryer tub. Application of a heat
pump cycle for extracting the moisture from clothes leads to additional
energy savings.
Appliances Dishwasher
High efficiency dishwashers save by using both improved technology for
the primary wash cycle, and by using less hot water. Construction
includes more effective washing action, energy-efficient motors, and
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-5
End Use Technology Measure Description
other advanced technology such as sensors that determine the length of
the wash cycle and the temperature of the water necessary to clean the
dishes.
Appliances Stove
These products have additional insulation in the oven compartment and
tighter-fitting oven door gaskets and hinges to save energy. Conventional
ovens must first heat up about 35 pounds of steel and a large amount of
air before they heat up the food. Higher efficiency options include
convection ovens, halogen burners, and induction burners.
Appliances Microwave Appliance that heats food with microwave radiation. No high efficiency
option is modeled.
Electronics Personal
Computers
Improved power management can significantly reduce the annual energy
consumption of PCs and monitors in both standby and normal operation.
ENERGY STAR and Climate Savers labeled products provide increasing
level of energy efficiency.
Electronics Monitor High efficiency electronics use efficient components and employ
sleep/powersave modes.
Electronics Laptops High efficiency electronics use efficient components and employ
sleep/powersave modes.
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier High efficiency electronics use efficient components and employ
sleep/powersave modes.
Electronics TVs
In the average home, electronic products consumed significant energy,
even when they are turn off, to maintain features like clocks, remote
control, and channel/station memory. ENERGY STAR labeled consumer
electronics can drastically reduce consumption during standby mode, in
addition to saving energy through advanced power management during
normal use.
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets
High efficiency electronics can use efficient components and employ
sleep/powersave modes.
Electronics Set-top Boxes/DVR High efficiency electronics can use efficient components and employ
sleep/powersave modes.
Miscellaneous Pool Heater
Efficient pool heaters can make use of heat pump technology to achieve
significantly higher coefficients of performance in the COP=5.0 range.
Gas pool heaters have a burner to heat water in a loop. Efficiency
improvements can include: exhaust fan controls, electronic ignition (no
pilot light), compact size and lighter weight to reduce cycling losses, and
sealed combustion. Very high efficiency units, or condensing units,
condense the water vapor produced in the combustion process and also
use the heat from this condensation.
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High-efficiency motors and two-speed pumps provide improved energy
efficiency for this load.
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan
In homes heated by a furnace, there is still substantial energy use by the
fan responsible for moving the hot air throughout the ductwork.
Application of an Electronically Commutating Motor (ECM) ensures that
motor speed matches the heating requirements of the system and saves
energy when compared to a continuously operating standard motor.
Miscellaneous Hot Tub/ Spa High-efficiency motors provide improved energy efficiency for this load.
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-6 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Measure Description
Miscellaneous Well Pump
Existing well pumps can achieve efficiency improvements by using
optimized system components and more efficient motors. Efficiencies:
Baseline 40% EF, High Efficiency 60% EF
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous
The miscellaneous category within the miscellaneous end use accounts
for energy consumed by a wide range of plug loads including countertop
appliances, power tools, and hair dryers. No efficiency measure is
modeled for these uses.
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-7
Table B-2 Residential Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Measure Descriptions
End Use Measure Description
HVAC (All) Insulation - Ceiling
Thermal insulation is material or combinations of materials that are used to
inhibit the flow of heat energy by conductive, convective, and radiative transfer
modes. Thus, thermal insulation above ceilings can conserve energy by
reducing the heat loss or gain into attics and/or through roofs. The type of
building construction defines insulating possibilities. Typical insulating
materials include: loose-fill (blown) cellulose, loose-fill (blown) fiberglass, and
rigid polystyrene.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Ducting
Air distribution ducts can be insulated to reduce heating or cooling losses. Best
results can be achieved by covering the entire surface area with insulation.
Several types of ducts and duct insulation are available, including flexible duct,
pre-insulated duct, duct board, duct wrap, tacked, or glued rigid insulation, and
waterproof hard shell materials for exterior ducts. This analysis assumes that
installing duct insulation can reduce the temperature drop/gain in ducts by
50%.
HVAC (All) Insulation -
Infiltration Control
Lowering the air infiltration rate by caulking small leaks and weather-stripping
around window frames, doorframes, power outlets, plumbing, and wall corners
can provide significant energy savings. Weather-stripping doors and windows
will create a tight seal and further reduce air infiltration.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Radiant
Barrier
Radiant barriers are materials installed to reduce the heat gain in buildings.
Radiant barriers are made from materials that are highly reflective and have
low emissivity like aluminum. The closer the emissivity is to 0 the better they
will perform. Radiant barriers can be placed above the insulation or on the
roof rafters.
HVAC (All) Ducting - Repair and
Sealing
Leakage in unsealed ducts varies considerably because of the differences in
fabricating machinery used, the methods for assembly, installation
workmanship, and age of the ductwork. Air leaks from the system to the
outdoors result in a direct loss proportional to the amount of leakage and the
difference in enthalpy between the outdoor air and the conditioned air. To
seal ducts, a wide variety of sealing methods and products exist. Each has a
relatively short shelf life, and no documented research has identified the aging
characteristics of sealant applications.
HVAC (All)
Windows - High
Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR
High-efficiency windows, such as those labeled under the ENERGY STAR
Program, are designed to reduce energy use and increase occupant comfort.
High-efficiency windows reduce the amount of heat transfer through the
glazing surface. For example, some windows have a low-E coating, a thin film of
metallic oxide coating on the glass surface that allows passage of short-wave
solar energy through glass and prevents long-wave energy from escaping.
Another example is double-pane glass that reduces conductive and convective
heat transfer. Some double-pane windows are gas-filled (usually argon) to
further increase the insulating properties of the window.
Cooling Windows - Install
Reflective Film
Reflective films applied to the window interior help reduce solar gain into the
space and thus lower cooling energy use.
HVAC (All) Doors - Storm and
Thermal
Like other components of the shell, doors are subject to several types of heat
loss: conduction, infiltration, and radiant losses. Similar to a storm window, a
storm door creates an insulating air space between the storm and primary
doors. A tight fitting storm door can also help reduce air leakage or infiltration.
Thermal doors have exceptional thermal insulation properties and also are
provided with weather-stripping on the doorframe to reduce air leakage.
Cooling Roofs - High
Reflectivity
The color and material of a building structure surface will determine the
amount of solar radiation absorbed by that surface and subsequently
transferred into a building. This is called solar absorptance. By using a living
roof or a roofing material with a light color (and a lower solar absorptance), the
roof will absorb less solar radiation and consequently reduce the cooling load.
Living roofs also reduce stormwater runoff.
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-8 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
Cooling Attic Fan -
Installation
Attic fans can reduce the need for AC by reducing heat transfer from the attic
through the ceiling of the house. A well-ventilated attic can be several degrees
cooler than a comparable, unventilated attic. An option for an attic fan
equipped with a small solar photovoltaic generator is also modeled.
Cooling Attic Fan - Solar
Cooling
Attic Fan -
Photovoltaic -
Installation
Attic fans can reduce the need for AC by reducing heat transfer from the attic
through the ceiling of the house. A well-ventilated attic can be several degrees
cooler than a comparable, unventilated attic. An option for an attic fan
equipped with a small solar photovoltaic generator is also modeled.
Cooling Whole-House Fan -
Installation
Whole-house fans can reduce the need for AC on moderate-weather days or on
cool evenings. The fan facilitates a quick air change throughout the entire
house. Several windows must be open to achieve the best results. The fan is
mounted on the top floor of the house, usually in a hallway ceiling.
Cooling Ceiling Fan -
Installation
Ceiling fans can reduce the need for air conditioning. However, the house
occupants must also select a ceiling fan with a high-efficiency motor and either
shutoff the AC system or setup the thermostat temperature of the air
conditioning system to realize the potential energy savings. Some ceiling fans
also come with lamps. In this analysis, it is assumed that there are no lamps,
and installing a ceiling fan will allow occupants to increase the thermostat
cooling setpoint up by 2°F.
HVAC (All) Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable
A programmable thermostat can be added to most heating/cooling systems.
They are typically used during winter to lower temperatures at night and in
summer to increase temperatures during the afternoon. The energy savings
from this type of thermostat are identical to those of a "setback" strategy with
standard thermostats, but the convenience of a programmable thermostat
makes it a much more attractive option. In this analysis, the baseline is
assumed to have no thermostat setback.
All Home Energy
Management System
A centralized home energy management system can be used to control and
schedule cooling, space heating, lighting, and possibly appliances as well. Some
designs also allow the homeowner to remotely control loads via the Internet.
Cooling Central AC - Early
Replacement
CAC systems currently on the market are significantly more efficient that older
units, due to technology improvement and stricter appliance standards. This
measure incents homeowners to replace an aging but still working unit with a
new, higher-efficiency one.
Cooling
Central AC -
Maintenance and
Tune-Up
An air conditioner's filters, coils, and fins require regular cleaning and
maintenance for the unit to function effectively and efficiently throughout its
life. Neglecting necessary maintenance leads to a steady decline in
performance, requiring the AC unit to use more energy for the same cooling
load.
HVAC (All) Central Heat Pump -
Maintenance
A heat pump's filters, coils, and fins require regular cleaning and maintenance
for the unit to function effectively and efficiently throughout its life. Neglecting
necessary maintenance ensures a steady decline in performance while energy
use steadily increases.
Cooling Room AC - Removal
of Second Unit
Homeowners may have a second room AC unit that is extremely inefficient.
This measure incents homeowners to recycle the second unit and thus also
eliminates associated electricity use.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Faucet Aerators
Water faucet aerators are threaded screens that attach to existing faucets.
They reduce the volume of water coming out of faucets while introducing air
into the water stream. This measure provides energy saving by reducing hot
water use, as well as water conservation for both hot and cold water.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - Low-
Flow Showerheads
Similar to faucet aerators, low-flow showerheads reduce the consumption of
hot water, which in turn decreases water heating energy use.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - Pipe
Insulation
Insulating hot water pipes decreases energy losses from piping that distributes
hot water throughout the building. It also results in quicker delivery of hot
water and may allow the lowering of the hot water set point, which saves
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-9
End Use Measure Description
energy. The most common insulation materials for this purpose are
polyethylene and neoprene.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Timer
These measures use either a programmable thermostat or a timer to adjust the
water heater setpoint at times of low usage, typically when a home is
unoccupied.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Desuperheater
A desuperheater can be added to an existing geothermal heat pump system
(typically installed with the primary function of space heating and cooling) in
order to draw off a portion of the geothermal heat for water heating purposes.
The system can either supplement the building's water heater, or be a full-
demand water heater that meets all of the building's hot water needs.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - Solar
System
Solar water heating systems can be used in residential buildings that have an
appropriate near-south-facing roof or nearby unshaded grounds for installing a
collector. Although system types vary, in general these systems use a solar
absorber surface within a solar collector or an actual storage tank. Either a
heat-transfer fluid or the actual potable water flows through tubes attached to
the absorber and transfers heat from it. (Systems with a separate heat-
transfer-fluid loop include a heat exchanger that then heats the potable water.)
The heated water is stored in a separate preheat tank or a conventional water
heater tank. If additional heat is needed, it is provided by a conventional
water-heating system.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Occupancy Sensors
Occupancy sensors turn lights off when a space is unoccupied. They are
appropriate for areas with intermittent use, such as bathrooms or storage
areas.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Photosensor Control
Photosensor controls turn exterior lighting on or off based on ambient lighting
levels. Compared with manual operation, this can reduce the operation of
exterior lighting during daylight hours.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Photovoltaic
Installation
Solar photovoltaic generation may be used to power exterior lighting and thus
eliminate all or part of the electrical energy use.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Timeclock
Installation
Lighting timers turn exterior lighting on or off based on a preset schedule.
Compared with manual operation, this can reduce the operation of exterior
lighting during daylight hours.
Appliances Refrigerator - Early
Replacement
Refrigerators/freezers currently on the market are significantly more efficient
that older units, due to technology improvement and stricter appliance
standards. This measure incents homeowners to replace an aging but still
working unit with a new, higher-efficiency one.
Appliances Refrigerator -
Maintenance
This measure includes repairing and recharging refrigerant lines, cleaning
condenser coils, and replacing the oil. This reduces energy consumption by
improving the rate at which the system can compress and cool refrigerant as it
moves through the system.
Appliances Refrigerator -
Remove Second Unit
Homeowners may have a second refrigerator or freezer that is not used to full
capacity and that, because of its age, is extremely inefficient. This measure
incents homeowners to recycle the second unit and thus also eliminates
associated electricity use.
Appliances Freezer - Remove
Second Unit
Homeowners may have a second refrigerator or freezer that is not used to full
capacity and that, because of its age, is extremely inefficient. This measure
incents homeowners to recycle the second unit and thus also eliminates
associated electricity use.
Appliances Freezer - Early
Replacement
Refrigerators/freezers currently on the market are significantly more efficient
that older units, due to technology improvement and stricter appliance
standards. This measure incents homeowners to replace an aging but still
working unit with a new, higher-efficiency one.
Appliances Freezer -
Maintenance
This measure includes repairing and recharging refrigerant lines, cleaning
condenser coils, and replacing the oil. This reduces energy consumption by
improving the rate at which the system can compress and cool refrigerant as it
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-10 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
moves through the system.
Electronics Electronics - Smart
Power Strips
Representing a growing portion of home electricity consumption, plug-in
electronics such as set-top boxes, DVD players, gaming systems, digital video
recorders, and even battery chargers for mobile phones and laptop computers
are often designed to supply a set voltage. When the units are not in use, this
voltage could be dropped significantly (~1 W) and thereby generate a
significant energy savings, assumed for this analysis to be between 4-5% on
average. These savings are in excess of the measures already discussed for
computers and televisions.
Miscellaneous Pool Pump - Timer A pool pump timer allows the pump to turn off automatically, eliminating the
wasted energy associated with unnecessary pumping.
Miscellaneous Pool Heater - Solar
System This measure replaces a conventional pool heater with a solar system.
All Behavioral Feedback
Tools
he behavioral feedback tool measure models the wide range of options for
providing homeowners with ongoing information on their energy use, for
example via a web portal. These tools are based on the premise that
homeowners will reduce energy use if they better understand how they use
energy and the associated costs. The level of assumed savings is based on
isolated behavioral effects and excludes the technology effects of all other
measures listed here.

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-11
Table B-3 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data —Single Family, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 166.96 $294.04 20 0.99 $0.16
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 218.29 $735.11 20 0.93 $0.30
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 261.47 $771.86 20 0.93 $0.26
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 298.42 $2,591.25 20 0.71 $0.77
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 625.20 $2,499.36 20 0.77 $0.35
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 27.92 $2.18 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 32.92 $35.75 10 1.04 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 44.56 $109.59 10 0.96 $0.33
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 55.34 $183.43 10 0.90 $0.44
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 163.62 $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 213.93 $0.00 20 0.91 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 256.24 $0.00 20 0.91 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 292.45 $0.00 20 0.71 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 797.28 $439.85 20 1.05 $0.05
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,210.66 $1,864.06 20 1.03 $0.14
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 2,002.04 $1,938.54 20 1.07 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 182.00 $700.75 12 0.96 $0.45
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 464.69 $3,503.73 12 0.74 $0.89
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 497.45 $439.85 20 1.00 $0.08
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 864.72 $1,864.06 20 0.91 $0.19
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,133.00 $1,938.54 20 0.91 $0.15
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,320.59 $5,686.79 20 0.71 $0.38
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 1,032.54 $334.91 20 1.05 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,653.04 $893.10 20 1.03 $0.05
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 3,288.22 $2,009.47 20 1.07 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-12 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 167.89 $67.00 15 1.00 $0.04
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,939.72 $1,614.00 15 0.70 $0.09
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 204.75 $26.80 15 1.03 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,529.62 $2,865.00 15 - $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 22.45 $164.66 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 810.35 $164.66 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 1,010.65 $69.77 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 1,097.69 $1,971.07 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,184.74 $632.13 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 13.70 -$4.37 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 23.17 $792.64 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 41.04 $34.95 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 41.62 $59.94 10 0.62 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 44.75 $519.51 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 169.06 $220.01 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 519.98 $220.01 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 609.19 $93.23 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 647.96 $2,633.69 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 686.73 $844.63 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 33.85 $41.15 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 209.45 $41.15 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 241.78 $16.40 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 261.19 $353.88 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 295.18 $144.72 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 29.62 $80.00 14 - $0.29
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 36.51 $75.00 14 - $0.22
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0)
41.62 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.30
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-13
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 41.62 $115.00 14 - $0.30
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 44.70 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.50
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.72 $52.00 14 0.93 $0.83
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 32.11 $75.00 14 - $0.25
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 71.90 $175.00 14 - $0.26
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 14.93 $42.00 12 - $0.33
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 29.84 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.32
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 100.58 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.30
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 43.33 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 62.37 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.06
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 86.59 $218.00 20 - $0.22
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 111.47 $695.00 20 - $0.55
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 43.40 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 94.61 $198.00 22 1.07 $0.18
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 95.64 $198.00 22 - $0.17
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 119.29 $352.00 22 - $0.25
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 58.05 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 83.54 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 115.99 $218.00 20 - $0.17
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 149.31 $695.00 20 - $0.41
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.44 $121.00 20 0.91 $7.42
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.75 $580.00 20 0.67 $10.78
Appliances Stove Induction 26.65 $898.00 20 0.58 $2.97
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 292.57 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 14.48 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 49.49 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 101.97 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 109.34 $0.03 11 1.07 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-14 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 13.54 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 123.99 $11.04 5 1.03 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 170.10 $85.00 15 0.99 $0.05
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 680.41 $579.00 15 0.80 $0.09
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 4,383.28 $2,550.00 15 0.86 $0.06
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 156.75 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.20
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 209.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.17
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 220.39 $110.00 10 0.93 $0.07
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 54.82 $769.00 18 0.28 $1.30
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Table B-4 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data —Single Family, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 174.31 $144.51 20 1.03 $0.07
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 217.89 $361.28 20 1.00 $0.15
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 252.96 $379.34 20 1.00 $0.13
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 283.79 $1,273.49 20 0.84 $0.40
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 630.38 $1,228.34 20 0.95 $0.17
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 29.79 $2.18 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 35.09 $35.75 10 1.05 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 47.47 $109.59 10 0.97 $0.31
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 58.89 $183.43 10 0.91 $0.41
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 172.01 $180.51 20 1.03 $0.09
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 213.96 $764.98 20 0.98 $0.32
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 249.62 $795.55 20 1.00 $0.28
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 280.04 $1,489.40 20 0.85 $0.47
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 272.60 $135.60 20 1.09 $0.04
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-15
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 303.29 $361.61 20 1.09 $0.11
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 782.92 $813.61 20 1.23 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 190.08 $344.39 12 1.01 $0.21
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 485.30 $1,721.94 12 0.89 $0.42
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 523.68 $216.16 20 1.03 $0.04
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 960.67 $916.09 20 0.98 $0.08
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,319.72 $952.69 20 1.00 $0.06
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,611.33 $2,794.75 20 0.85 $0.15
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 955.65 $164.59 20 1.09 $0.02
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,463.40 $438.92 20 1.09 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 3,000.78 $987.57 20 1.23 $0.03
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 167.89 $67.00 15 1.00 $0.04
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,939.72 $1,614.00 15 0.70 $0.09
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 204.75 $26.80 15 1.03 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,529.62 $2,865.00 15 - $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 25.50 $187.07 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 920.65 $187.07 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 1,148.21 $79.27 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 1,247.10 $2,239.35 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,346.00 $718.17 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 15.56 -$4.97 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 26.33 $900.53 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 46.62 $39.70 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 47.29 $68.10 10 0.62 $0.19
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-16 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 50.84 $590.23 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 211.32 $275.01 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 649.98 $275.01 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 761.49 $116.54 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 809.95 $3,292.11 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 858.41 $1,055.79 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 38.46 $46.75 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 237.95 $46.75 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 274.69 $18.63 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 296.74 $402.05 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 335.36 $164.42 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 73.02 $4.00 14 - $0.01
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 131.12 $198.00 14 - $0.16
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 137.26 $198.00 14 1.07 $0.15
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 160.91 $352.00 14 - $0.23
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 44.70 $0.00 14 0.97 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 64.77 $19.47 14 0.93 $0.03
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 115.65 $43.00 14 - $0.04
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 187.88 $218.00 14 - $0.12
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 14.93 $42.00 12 - $0.33
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 29.84 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.32
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 100.58 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.30
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 43.33 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 62.37 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.06
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 86.59 $218.00 20 - $0.22
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 111.47 $695.00 20 - $0.55
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 43.40 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 94.61 $198.00 22 1.07 $0.18
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 95.64 $198.00 22 - $0.17
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 119.29 $352.00 22 - $0.25
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-17
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 58.05 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 83.54 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 115.99 $218.00 20 - $0.17
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 149.31 $695.00 20 - $0.41
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.44 $121.00 20 0.91 $7.42
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.75 $580.00 20 0.67 $10.78
Appliances Stove Induction 26.65 $898.00 20 0.58 $2.97
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 292.57 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 14.48 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 49.49 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 101.97 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 109.34 $0.03 11 1.07 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 13.54 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 123.99 $11.04 5 1.03 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 170.10 $85.00 15 0.99 $0.05
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 680.41 $579.00 15 0.80 $0.09
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 4,383.28 $2,550.00 15 0.86 $0.06
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 156.75 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.20
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 209.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.17
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 220.39 $110.00 10 0.93 $0.07
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 54.82 $769.00 18 0.28 $1.30
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-18 www.enernoc.com
Table B-5 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — Multi Family, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 81.91 $582.92 20 0.92 $0.63
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 160.35 $1,457.30 20 0.82 $0.80
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 226.22 $1,530.16 20 0.82 $0.60
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 282.24 $5,136.97 20 0.53 $1.61
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 416.91 $4,954.80 20 0.55 $1.05
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 17.49 $6.48 10 1.05 $0.05
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 20.61 $106.50 10 0.91 $0.69
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 27.93 $326.46 10 0.72 $1.56
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 34.62 $546.41 10 0.59 $2.10
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 80.33 $729.59 20 0.94 $0.80
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 157.14 $3,092.00 20 0.77 $1.74
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 221.72 $3,215.55 20 0.77 $1.28
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 276.73 $6,020.05 20 0.53 $1.92
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 147.29 $135.54 20 1.06 $0.08
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 169.94 $361.45 20 1.04 $0.19
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 426.92 $813.26 20 1.09 $0.17
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 78.92 $1,226.41 12 0.88 $1.83
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 201.51 $6,132.06 12 0.58 $3.58
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 206.20 $1,073.36 20 0.94 $0.46
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 358.43 $4,548.90 20 0.77 $1.12
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 469.64 $4,730.66 20 0.77 $0.89
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 547.40 $13,877.58 20 0.53 $2.24
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 428.00 $138.82 20 1.06 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 685.20 $370.20 20 1.04 $0.05
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 1,363.00 $832.95 20 1.09 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-19
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 82.24 $67.00 15 0.97 $0.08
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 950.94 $1,614.00 15 0.48 $0.17
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 130.29 $26.80 15 1.02 $0.02
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 973.89 $2,865.00 15 - $0.30
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 11.39 $86.61 4 - $2.10
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 411.01 $86.61 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 512.60 $36.70 6 1.64 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 556.75 $1,036.80 15 0.25 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 600.90 $332.50 15 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 6.30 -$2.09 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 10.66 $378.00 20 0.13 $3.13
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 18.87 $16.67 10 0.77 $0.12
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 19.14 $28.59 10 0.61 $0.20
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 20.58 $247.75 20 - $1.06
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 63.97 $86.33 4 - $0.37
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 196.75 $86.33 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 230.50 $36.58 6 1.13 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 245.17 $1,033.49 15 0.12 $0.43
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 259.84 $331.44 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 15.65 $19.73 4 - $0.35
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 96.83 $19.73 4 - $0.06
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 111.77 $7.86 6 1.74 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 120.75 $169.67 15 0.30 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 136.46 $69.39 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 26.65 $80.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 32.86 $75.00 14 - $0.24
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 37.46 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.33
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-20 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 37.46 $115.00 14 - $0.33
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 40.23 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.56
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.05 $52.00 14 0.92 $0.92
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 28.90 $75.00 14 - $0.28
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 64.71 $175.00 14 - $0.29
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 13.44 $42.00 12 - $0.37
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 26.85 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.35
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 90.52 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.33
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 39.00 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 56.13 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.07
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 77.93 $218.00 20 - $0.25
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 100.32 $695.00 20 - $0.61
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 39.06 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 85.15 $198.00 22 1.05 $0.20
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 86.08 $198.00 22 - $0.19
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 107.36 $352.00 22 - $0.28
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 52.24 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 75.19 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 104.39 $218.00 20 - $0.18
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 134.38 $695.00 20 - $0.46
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.29 $121.00 20 0.91 $8.24
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.27 $580.00 20 0.67 $11.98
Appliances Stove Induction 23.99 $898.00 20 0.57 $3.30
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 273.96 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 13.56 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 46.34 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 91.33 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 97.93 $0.03 11 1.06 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-21
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 12.68 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 258.60 $300.00 5 1.02 $0.26
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 154.64 $85.00 15 0.98 $0.06
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 618.56 $579.00 15 0.78 $0.10
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 3,984.80 $2,550.00 15 0.82 $0.07
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 142.50 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.22
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 190.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.19
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 198.57 $110.00 10 0.92 $0.07
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 19.30 $769.00 18 0.20 $3.70
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Table B-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — Multi Family, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost
Lifeti
me B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 90.87 $581.49 20 0.93 $0.56
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 178.42 $1,453.72 20 0.82 $0.72
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 252.06 $1,526.41 20 0.83 $0.53
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 314.74 $5,124.38 20 0.54 $1.44
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 464.03 $4,942.66 20 0.57 $0.94
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 18.25 $6.13 10 1.05 $0.04
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 21.49 $100.71 10 0.92 $0.62
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 29.11 $308.68 10 0.73 $1.41
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 36.11 $516.66 10 0.61 $1.90
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 87.53 $727.80 20 0.95 $0.73
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 171.67 $3,084.42 20 0.78 $1.59
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 242.26 $3,207.67 20 0.78 $1.17
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 302.68 $6,005.30 20 0.53 $1.75
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 133.91 $66.61 20 1.09 $0.04
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-22 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost
Lifeti
me B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 148.99 $177.64 20 1.09 $0.11
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 384.61 $399.68 20 1.25 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 87.64 $1,223.41 12 0.89 $1.64
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 223.76 $6,117.03 12 0.59 $3.22
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 233.07 $1,041.79 20 0.95 $0.39
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 427.55 $4,415.11 20 0.78 $0.91
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 587.34 $4,591.52 20 0.78 $0.69
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 717.13 $13,469.43 20 0.53 $1.66
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 396.13 $68.23 20 1.09 $0.02
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 606.59 $181.94 20 1.09 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 1,243.85 $409.36 20 1.25 $0.03
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 82.24 $67.00 15 0.97 $0.08
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 950.94 $1,614.00 15 0.48 $0.17
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 130.29 $26.80 15 1.02 $0.02
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 973.89 $2,865.00 15 - $0.30
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 14.55 $110.67 4 - $2.10
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 525.18 $110.67 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 654.99 $46.90 6 1.64 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 711.40 $1,324.80 15 0.25 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 767.81 $424.87 15 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 8.05 -$2.66 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 13.62 $483.00 20 0.13 $3.13
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 24.11 $21.30 10 0.77 $0.12
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 24.46 $36.53 10 0.61 $0.20
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-23
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost
Lifeti
me B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 26.29 $316.57 20 - $1.06
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 83.16 $112.23 4 - $0.37
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 255.78 $112.23 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 299.66 $47.56 6 1.13 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 318.73 $1,343.54 15 0.12 $0.43
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 337.80 $430.88 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 20.00 $25.21 4 - $0.35
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 123.73 $25.21 4 - $0.06
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 142.82 $10.04 6 1.74 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 154.29 $216.80 15 0.30 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 174.37 $88.66 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 26.65 $80.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 32.86 $75.00 14 - $0.24
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 37.46 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.33
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 37.46 $115.00 14 - $0.33
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 40.23 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.56
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.05 $52.00 14 0.92 $0.92
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 28.90 $75.00 14 - $0.28
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 64.71 $175.00 14 - $0.29
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 13.44 $42.00 12 - $0.37
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 26.85 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.35
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 90.52 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.33
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 39.00 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 56.13 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.07
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 77.93 $218.00 20 - $0.25
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 100.32 $695.00 20 - $0.61
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 39.06 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 85.15 $198.00 22 1.05 $0.20
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 86.08 $198.00 22 - $0.19
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 107.36 $352.00 22 - $0.28
Appliances Second Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-24 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost
Lifeti
me B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigerator
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 52.24 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 75.19 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 104.39 $218.00 20 - $0.18
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 134.38 $695.00 20 - $0.46
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.29 $121.00 20 0.91 $8.24
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.27 $580.00 20 0.67 $11.98
Appliances Stove Induction 23.99 $898.00 20 0.57 $3.30
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 273.96 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 13.56 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 46.34 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 91.33 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 97.93 $0.03 11 1.06 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 12.68 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 116.10 $11.04 5 1.02 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 154.64 $85.00 15 0.98 $0.06
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 618.56 $579.00 15 0.78 $0.10
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 3,984.80 $2,550.00 15 0.82 $0.07
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 142.50 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.22
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 190.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.19
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 198.57 $110.00 10 0.92 $0.07
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 19.30 $769.00 18 0.20 $3.70
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-25
Table B-7 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — Mobile Home, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 85.55 $150.66 20 0.99 $0.16
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 111.85 $376.66 20 0.93 $0.30
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 133.98 $395.49 20 0.93 $0.26
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 152.91 $1,327.73 20 0.71 $0.77
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 320.35 $1,280.65 20 0.77 $0.35
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 39.73 $3.10 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 46.84 $50.87 10 1.04 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 63.40 $155.94 10 0.96 $0.33
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 78.75 $261.00 10 0.90 $0.44
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 83.84 $188.19 20 0.99 $0.20
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 109.61 $797.56 20 0.88 $0.64
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 131.30 $829.43 20 0.89 $0.56
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 149.85 $1,552.84 20 0.67 $0.91
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 153.63 $141.38 20 1.03 $0.08
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 177.26 $377.01 20 1.01 $0.19
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 445.29 $848.26 20 1.02 $0.17
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 82.33 $316.99 12 0.96 $0.45
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 210.20 $1,584.93 12 0.74 $0.89
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 479.70 $424.15 20 0.99 $0.08
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 833.87 $1,797.55 20 0.88 $0.19
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,092.57 $1,869.37 20 0.89 $0.15
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,273.47 $5,483.88 20 0.67 $0.38
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 995.69 $322.96 20 1.03 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,594.06 $861.23 20 1.01 $0.05
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 3,170.90 $1,937.77 20 1.02 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-26 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 125.02 $67.00 15 0.99 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,444.50 $1,614.00 15 0.60 $0.11
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 198.05 $26.80 15 1.03 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,479.57 $2,865.00 15 - $0.20
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 19.08 $139.96 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 688.80 $139.96 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 859.05 $59.31 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 933.04 $1,675.41 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,007.03 $537.31 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 11.64 -$3.72 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 19.70 $673.75 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 34.88 $29.71 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 35.38 $50.95 10 0.62 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 38.04 $441.59 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 143.70 $187.01 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 441.98 $187.01 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 517.81 $79.25 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 550.77 $2,238.63 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 583.72 $717.94 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 28.78 $34.98 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 178.03 $34.98 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 205.51 $13.94 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 222.01 $300.80 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 250.90 $123.01 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 26.92 $80.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 33.19 $75.00 14 - $0.24
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 37.84 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.32
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-27
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 37.84 $115.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 40.64 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.55
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.11 $52.00 14 0.93 $0.91
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 29.19 $75.00 14 - $0.27
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 65.36 $175.00 14 - $0.29
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 13.58 $42.00 12 - $0.36
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 27.13 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.35
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 91.44 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.33
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 39.39 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 56.70 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.07
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 78.72 $218.00 20 - $0.24
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 101.33 $695.00 20 - $0.61
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 39.46 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 86.01 $198.00 22 1.06 $0.19
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 86.94 $198.00 22 - $0.19
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 108.45 $352.00 22 - $0.27
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 52.77 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 75.95 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 105.44 $218.00 20 - $0.18
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 135.74 $695.00 20 - $0.45
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.31 $121.00 20 0.91 $8.16
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.31 $580.00 20 0.67 $11.86
Appliances Stove Induction 24.23 $898.00 20 0.57 $3.27
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 265.98 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 11.85 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 44.99 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 79.80 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 85.57 $0.03 11 1.05 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-28 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 12.31 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 112.72 $11.04 5 1.02 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 154.64 $85.00 15 0.98 $0.06
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 618.56 $579.00 15 0.78 $0.10
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 3,984.80 $2,550.00 15 0.82 $0.07
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 142.50 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.22
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 190.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.19
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 161.07 $110.00 10 0.90 $0.09
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 50.84 $769.00 18 0.28 $1.41
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Table B-8 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Mobile Home, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 124.05 $74.05 20 1.04 $0.05
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 155.06 $185.11 20 1.02 $0.11
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 180.02 $194.37 20 1.03 $0.10
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 201.96 $652.53 20 0.89 $0.29
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 448.61 $629.39 20 1.03 $0.12
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 41.33 $3.10 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 48.68 $50.87 10 1.04 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 65.86 $155.94 10 0.97 $0.32
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 81.71 $261.00 10 0.90 $0.43
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 98.77 $92.49 20 1.03 $0.08
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 122.86 $391.97 20 0.98 $0.28
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 143.34 $407.63 20 1.00 $0.25
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 160.81 $763.16 20 0.84 $0.42
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 139.68 $69.48 20 1.07 $0.04
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-29
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 155.41 $185.28 20 1.07 $0.11
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 401.16 $416.89 20 1.16 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 97.71 $155.79 12 1.02 $0.19
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 249.46 $778.93 12 0.92 $0.37
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 603.80 $208.45 20 1.03 $0.03
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 1,107.64 $883.40 20 0.98 $0.07
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,521.62 $918.70 20 1.00 $0.05
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,857.85 $2,695.03 20 0.84 $0.13
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 921.55 $158.72 20 1.07 $0.02
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,411.18 $423.26 20 1.07 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 2,893.71 $952.33 20 1.16 $0.03
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 125.02 $67.00 15 0.99 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,444.50 $1,614.00 15 0.60 $0.11
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 198.05 $26.80 15 1.03 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,479.57 $2,865.00 15 - $0.20
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 21.68 $159.01 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 782.56 $159.01 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 975.98 $67.38 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 1,060.04 $1,903.45 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,144.10 $610.44 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 13.23 -$4.22 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 22.38 $765.45 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 39.63 $33.75 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 40.20 $57.89 10 0.62 $0.19
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-30 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 43.21 $501.69 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 179.62 $233.76 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 552.48 $233.76 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 647.26 $99.06 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 688.46 $2,798.29 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 729.65 $897.42 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 32.69 $39.74 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 202.26 $39.74 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 233.48 $15.83 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 252.23 $341.74 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 285.05 $139.76 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 26.92 $80.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 33.19 $75.00 14 - $0.24
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 37.84 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 37.84 $115.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 40.64 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.55
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.11 $52.00 14 0.93 $0.91
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 29.19 $75.00 14 - $0.27
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 65.36 $175.00 14 - $0.29
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 13.58 $42.00 12 - $0.36
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 27.13 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.35
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 91.44 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.33
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 39.39 $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 56.70 $0.00 20 1.24 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 78.72 $0.00 20 - $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 101.33 $0.00 20 - $0.00
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 305.43 $72.79 22 1.03 $0.02
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 86.01 $0.00 22 1.06 $0.00
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 86.94 $0.00 22 - $0.00
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 108.45 $0.00 22 - $0.00
Appliances Second Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-31
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigerator
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 52.77 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 75.95 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 105.44 $218.00 20 - $0.18
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 135.74 $695.00 20 - $0.45
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.31 $121.00 20 0.91 $8.16
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.31 $580.00 20 0.67 $11.86
Appliances Stove Induction 24.23 $898.00 20 0.57 $3.27
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 265.98 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 11.85 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 44.99 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 79.80 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 85.57 $0.03 11 1.05 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 12.31 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 112.72 $11.04 5 1.02 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 154.64 $85.00 15 0.98 $0.06
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 618.56 $579.00 15 0.78 $0.10
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 3,984.80 $2,550.00 15 0.82 $0.07
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 142.50 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.22
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 190.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.19
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 161.07 $110.00 10 0.90 $0.09
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 50.84 $769.00 18 0.28 $1.41
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-32 www.enernoc.com
Table B-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 155.03 $273.04 20 0.99 $0.16
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 202.70 $682.60 20 0.93 $0.30
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 242.80 $716.73 20 0.93 $0.26
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 277.10 $2,406.16 20 0.71 $0.77
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 580.55 $2,320.84 20 0.77 $0.35
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 25.93 $2.02 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 30.57 $33.20 10 1.04 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 41.38 $101.76 10 0.96 $0.33
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 51.39 $170.32 10 0.90 $0.44
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 151.93 $341.05 20 1.00 $0.20
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 198.65 $1,445.37 20 0.90 $0.64
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 237.94 $1,503.12 20 0.91 $0.56
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 271.56 $2,814.10 20 0.71 $0.91
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 278.42 $256.21 20 1.05 $0.08
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 321.23 $683.22 20 1.03 $0.19
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 806.97 $1,537.25 20 1.06 $0.17
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 169.00 $650.69 12 0.96 $0.45
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 431.49 $3,253.46 12 0.74 $0.89
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 497.45 $439.85 20 1.00 $0.08
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 864.72 $1,864.06 20 0.90 $0.19
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,133.00 $1,938.54 20 0.91 $0.15
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,320.59 $5,686.79 20 0.71 $0.38
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 1,032.54 $334.91 20 1.05 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,653.04 $893.10 20 1.03 $0.05
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 3,288.22 $2,009.47 20 1.06 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-33
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 167.89 $67.00 15 1.00 $0.04
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,939.72 $1,614.00 15 0.70 $0.09
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 204.75 $26.80 15 1.03 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,529.62 $2,865.00 15 - $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 21.33 $156.42 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 769.84 $156.42 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 960.11 $66.29 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 1,042.81 $1,872.51 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,125.50 $600.52 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 13.01 -$4.15 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 22.01 $753.01 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 38.98 $33.20 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 39.54 $56.95 10 0.62 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 42.51 $493.54 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 160.60 $209.01 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 493.98 $209.01 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 578.73 $88.57 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 615.56 $2,502.00 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 652.39 $802.40 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 32.16 $39.09 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 198.97 $39.09 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 229.69 $15.58 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 248.13 $336.19 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 280.42 $137.49 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 28.27 $80.00 14 - $0.30
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 34.85 $75.00 14 - $0.23
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 39.73 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.31
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-34 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 39.73 $115.00 14 - $0.31
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 42.67 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.52
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.42 $52.00 14 0.93 $0.87
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 30.65 $75.00 14 - $0.26
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 68.63 $175.00 14 - $0.27
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 14.26 $42.00 12 - $0.35
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 28.48 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.33
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 96.01 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.31
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 41.36 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 59.53 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.06
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 82.65 $218.00 20 - $0.23
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 106.40 $695.00 20 - $0.58
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 41.43 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 90.31 $198.00 22 1.06 $0.19
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 91.29 $198.00 22 - $0.18
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 113.87 $352.00 22 - $0.26
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 55.41 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 79.75 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 110.71 $218.00 20 - $0.17
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 142.53 $695.00 20 - $0.43
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.37 $121.00 20 0.91 $7.77
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.53 $580.00 20 0.67 $11.30
Appliances Stove Induction 25.44 $898.00 20 0.57 $3.11
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 273.96 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 13.56 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 46.34 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 91.33 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 97.93 $0.03 11 1.06 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-35
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 12.68 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 116.10 $11.04 5 1.02 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 154.64 $85.00 15 0.98 $0.06
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 618.56 $579.00 15 0.78 $0.10
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 3,984.80 $0.00 15 0.82 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 304.36 $134.19 15 0.93 $0.05
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 392.32 $335.47 15 0.92 $0.09
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 200.36 $110.00 10 0.92 $0.07
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 49.84 $769.00 18 0.27 $1.43
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Table B-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 161.86 $134.19 20 1.03 $0.07
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 202.32 $335.47 20 1.00 $0.15
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 234.89 $352.24 20 1.00 $0.13
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 263.52 $1,182.53 20 0.84 $0.40
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 585.35 $1,140.60 20 0.95 $0.17
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 27.66 $2.02 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 32.59 $33.20 10 1.05 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 44.08 $101.76 10 0.97 $0.31
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 54.69 $170.32 10 0.91 $0.41
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 159.72 $167.61 20 1.03 $0.09
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 198.68 $710.34 20 0.98 $0.32
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 231.79 $738.72 20 1.00 $0.28
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 260.04 $1,383.02 20 0.85 $0.47
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 253.13 $125.92 20 1.09 $0.04
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-36 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 281.63 $335.78 20 1.09 $0.11
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 727.00 $755.50 20 1.22 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 176.50 $319.79 12 1.01 $0.21
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 450.64 $1,598.94 12 0.89 $0.42
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 523.68 $216.16 20 1.03 $0.04
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 960.67 $916.09 20 0.98 $0.08
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,319.72 $952.69 20 1.00 $0.06
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,611.33 $2,794.75 20 0.85 $0.15
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 955.65 $164.59 20 1.09 $0.02
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,463.40 $438.92 20 1.09 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 3,000.78 $987.57 20 1.22 $0.03
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 167.89 $67.00 15 1.00 $0.04
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,939.72 $1,614.00 15 0.70 $0.09
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 204.75 $26.80 15 1.03 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,529.62 $2,865.00 15 - $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 24.23 $177.72 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 874.62 $177.72 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 1,090.80 $75.31 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 1,184.75 $2,127.39 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,278.70 $682.26 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 14.78 -$4.72 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 25.01 $855.51 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 44.29 $37.72 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 44.92 $64.70 10 0.62 $0.19
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-37
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 48.30 $560.72 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 200.75 $261.26 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 617.48 $261.26 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 723.41 $110.71 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 769.45 $3,127.50 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 815.49 $1,003.00 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 36.54 $44.41 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 226.06 $44.41 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 260.95 $17.70 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 281.91 $381.95 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 318.59 $156.20 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 28.27 $80.00 14 - $0.30
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 34.85 $75.00 14 - $0.23
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 39.73 $115.00 14 1.07 $0.31
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 39.73 $115.00 14 - $0.31
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 42.67 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.52
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 6.42 $52.00 14 0.93 $0.87
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 30.65 $75.00 14 - $0.26
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 68.63 $175.00 14 - $0.27
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 14.26 $42.00 12 - $0.35
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 28.48 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.33
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 96.01 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.31
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 41.36 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 59.53 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.06
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 82.65 $218.00 20 - $0.23
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 106.40 $695.00 20 - $0.58
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 41.43 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 90.31 $198.00 22 1.06 $0.19
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 91.29 $198.00 22 - $0.18
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 113.87 $352.00 22 - $0.26
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-38 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 55.41 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.03
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 79.75 $43.00 20 1.25 $0.05
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 110.71 $218.00 20 - $0.17
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 142.53 $695.00 20 - $0.43
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.37 $121.00 20 0.91 $7.77
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 4.53 $580.00 20 0.67 $11.30
Appliances Stove Induction 25.44 $898.00 20 0.57 $3.11
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 273.96 $72.79 5 0.96 $0.06
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 13.56 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 46.34 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 91.33 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 97.93 $0.03 11 1.06 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 12.68 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 116.10 $11.04 5 1.02 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 154.64 $85.00 15 0.98 $0.06
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 618.56 $579.00 15 0.78 $0.10
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 3,984.80 $2,550.00 15 0.82 $0.07
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 142.50 $300.00 15 0.93 $0.22
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 190.00 $350.00 15 0.92 $0.19
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 200.36 $110.00 10 0.92 $0.07
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 49.84 $769.00 18 0.27 $1.43
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-39
Table B-11 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Multi Family, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 49.64 $353.28 20 0.92 $0.63
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 97.18 $883.21 20 0.82 $0.80
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 137.11 $927.37 20 0.82 $0.60
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 171.05 $3,113.31 20 0.53 $1.61
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 252.68 $3,002.91 20 0.55 $1.05
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 17.49 $6.48 10 1.05 $0.05
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 20.61 $106.50 10 0.91 $0.69
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 27.93 $326.46 10 0.72 $1.56
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 34.62 $546.41 10 0.59 $2.10
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 60.85 $552.72 20 0.94 $0.80
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 119.05 $2,342.42 20 0.78 $1.74
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 167.97 $2,436.02 20 0.78 $1.28
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 209.64 $4,560.65 20 0.53 $1.92
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 111.59 $102.68 20 1.06 $0.08
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 128.74 $273.82 20 1.04 $0.19
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 323.42 $616.10 20 1.11 $0.17
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 47.83 $743.28 12 0.88 $1.83
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 122.13 $3,716.40 12 0.58 $3.58
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 137.46 $715.58 20 0.94 $0.46
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 238.96 $3,032.60 20 0.78 $1.12
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 313.09 $3,153.77 20 0.78 $0.89
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 364.93 $9,251.72 20 0.53 $2.24
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 290.45 -$1.69 20 1.06 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 465.46 $307.12 20 1.04 $0.06
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 924.00 $13.54 20 1.11 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-40 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 113.67 $57.56 15 0.97 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 952.43 $57.56 15 0.45 $0.01
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 112.52 $26.80 15 1.01 $0.02
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 841.09 $2,865.00 15 - $0.35
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 9.96 $75.78 4 - $2.10
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 359.63 $75.78 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 448.52 $32.11 6 1.64 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 487.15 $907.20 15 0.25 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 525.79 $290.94 15 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 5.12 -$1.69 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 8.66 $307.12 20 0.13 $3.13
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 15.33 $13.54 10 0.77 $0.12
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 15.55 $23.23 10 0.61 $0.20
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 16.72 $201.30 20 - $1.06
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 42.64 $57.56 4 - $0.37
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 131.17 $57.56 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 153.67 $24.39 6 1.13 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 163.45 $688.99 15 0.12 $0.43
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 173.23 $220.96 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 12.52 $15.78 4 - $0.35
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 77.46 $15.78 4 - $0.06
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 89.42 $6.29 6 1.74 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 96.60 $135.73 15 0.30 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 109.17 $55.51 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 21.27 $80.00 14 - $0.40
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 26.22 $75.00 14 - $0.31
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 29.89 $115.00 14 1.06 $0.41
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-41
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 29.89 $115.00 14 - $0.41
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 32.11 $209.00 14 0.96 $0.70
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 4.83 $52.00 14 0.92 $1.15
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 23.06 $75.00 14 - $0.35
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 51.64 $175.00 14 - $0.36
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 10.73 $42.00 12 - $0.46
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 21.43 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.44
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 72.23 $255.00 12 0.83 $0.42
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 31.12 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.06
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 44.79 $43.00 20 1.23 $0.08
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 62.19 $218.00 20 - $0.31
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 80.05 $695.00 20 - $0.77
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 31.17 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 67.95 $198.00 22 1.03 $0.25
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 68.69 $198.00 22 - $0.24
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 85.67 $352.00 22 - $0.35
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 39.58 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 56.96 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.07
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 79.08 $218.00 20 - $0.24
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 101.81 $695.00 20 - $0.60
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 0.98 $121.00 20 0.90 $10.88
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 3.24 $580.00 20 0.66 $15.81
Appliances Stove Induction 18.17 $898.00 20 0.55 $4.36
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 226.08 $72.79 5 0.95 $0.07
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 11.19 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 38.25 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 70.93 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 76.06 $0.03 11 1.05 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-42 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 10.47 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 90.18 $11.04 5 1.01 $0.03
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 115.98 $85.00 15 0.96 $0.08
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 463.92 $579.00 15 0.71 $0.13
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 2,988.60 $2,550.00 15 0.72 $0.09
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 106.88 $300.00 15 0.92 $0.29
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 142.50 $350.00 15 0.91 $0.25
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 188.64 $110.00 10 0.91 $0.08
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 19.30 $769.00 18 0.20 $3.70
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Table B-12 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Multi Family, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 55.08 $352.42 20 0.93 $0.56
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 108.13 $881.04 20 0.82 $0.72
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 152.77 $925.10 20 0.83 $0.53
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 190.75 $3,105.68 20 0.54 $1.44
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 281.23 $2,995.55 20 0.57 $0.94
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 18.25 $6.13 10 1.05 $0.04
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 21.49 $100.71 10 0.92 $0.62
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 29.11 $308.68 10 0.73 $1.41
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 36.11 $516.66 10 0.61 $1.90
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 66.31 $551.37 20 0.95 $0.73
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 130.05 $2,336.68 20 0.78 $1.59
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 183.53 $2,430.05 20 0.79 $1.17
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 229.30 $4,549.47 20 0.54 $1.75
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 101.45 $50.47 20 1.10 $0.04
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-43
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 112.87 $134.57 20 1.10 $0.11
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 291.37 $302.79 20 1.27 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 53.11 $741.46 12 0.89 $1.64
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 135.61 $3,707.29 12 0.59 $3.22
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 155.38 $694.53 20 0.95 $0.39
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 285.03 $2,943.41 20 0.78 $0.91
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 391.56 $3,061.02 20 0.79 $0.69
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 478.08 $8,979.62 20 0.54 $1.66
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 264.08 $45.48 20 1.10 $0.02
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 404.39 $121.29 20 1.10 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 829.23 $272.90 20 1.27 $0.03
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 71.03 $67.00 15 0.97 $0.10
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 821.27 $1,614.00 15 0.45 $0.20
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 112.52 $26.80 15 1.01 $0.02
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 841.09 $2,865.00 15 - $0.35
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 12.73 $96.84 4 - $2.10
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 459.53 $96.84 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 573.11 $41.03 6 1.64 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 622.47 $1,159.20 15 0.25 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 671.84 $371.76 15 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 6.54 -$2.17 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 11.06 $392.44 20 0.13 $3.13
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 19.59 $17.30 10 0.77 $0.12
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 19.87 $29.68 10 0.61 $0.20
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-44 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 21.36 $257.21 20 - $1.06
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 55.44 $74.82 4 - $0.37
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 170.52 $74.82 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 199.77 $31.71 6 1.13 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 212.48 $895.69 15 0.12 $0.43
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 225.20 $287.25 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 16.00 $20.17 4 - $0.35
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 98.98 $20.17 4 - $0.06
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 114.26 $8.04 6 1.74 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 123.43 $173.44 15 0.30 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 139.50 $70.93 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 21.27 $80.00 14 - $0.40
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 26.22 $75.00 14 - $0.31
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 29.89 $115.00 14 1.06 $0.41
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 29.89 $115.00 14 - $0.41
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 32.11 $209.00 14 0.96 $0.70
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 4.83 $52.00 14 0.92 $1.15
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 23.06 $75.00 14 - $0.35
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 51.64 $175.00 14 - $0.36
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 10.73 $42.00 12 - $0.46
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 21.43 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.44
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 72.23 $255.00 12 0.83 $0.42
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 31.12 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.06
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 44.79 $43.00 20 1.23 $0.08
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 62.19 $218.00 20 - $0.31
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 80.05 $695.00 20 - $0.77
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 31.17 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 67.95 $198.00 22 1.03 $0.25
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 68.69 $198.00 22 - $0.24
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 85.67 $352.00 22 - $0.35
Appliances Second Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-45
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigerator
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 39.58 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.04
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 56.96 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.07
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 79.08 $218.00 20 - $0.24
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 101.81 $695.00 20 - $0.60
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 39.23 $0.01 20 0.90 $0.00
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 3.24 $0.00 20 0.66 $0.00
Appliances Stove Induction 18.17 $0.00 20 0.55 $0.00
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 226.08 $72.79 5 0.95 $0.07
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 11.19 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 38.25 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 70.93 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 76.06 $0.03 11 1.05 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 10.47 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 90.18 $11.04 5 1.01 $0.03
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 115.98 $85.00 15 0.96 $0.08
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 463.92 $579.00 15 0.71 $0.13
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 2,988.60 $2,550.00 15 0.72 $0.09
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 106.88 $300.00 15 0.92 $0.29
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 142.50 $350.00 15 0.91 $0.25
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 188.64 $110.00 10 0.91 $0.08
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 19.30 $769.00 18 0.20 $3.70
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-46 www.enernoc.com
Table B-13 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 99.47 $175.19 20 0.99 $0.16
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 130.06 $437.98 20 0.93 $0.30
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 155.79 $459.88 20 0.93 $0.26
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 177.80 $1,543.87 20 0.71 $0.77
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 372.50 $1,489.13 20 0.77 $0.35
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 46.20 $3.60 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 54.47 $59.15 10 1.04 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 73.72 $181.32 10 0.96 $0.33
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 91.57 $303.49 10 0.90 $0.44
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 97.49 $218.83 20 1.00 $0.20
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 127.46 $927.40 20 0.89 $0.64
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 152.67 $964.46 20 0.89 $0.56
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 174.24 $1,805.62 20 0.68 $0.91
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 178.64 $164.39 20 1.04 $0.08
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 206.11 $438.38 20 1.02 $0.19
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 517.78 $986.35 20 1.03 $0.17
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 95.73 $368.59 12 0.96 $0.45
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 244.42 $1,842.94 12 0.74 $0.89
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 459.71 $406.48 20 1.00 $0.08
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 799.12 $1,722.65 20 0.89 $0.19
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,047.05 $1,791.48 20 0.89 $0.15
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,220.41 $5,255.39 20 0.68 $0.38
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 954.21 $309.51 20 1.04 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,527.64 $825.35 20 1.02 $0.05
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 3,038.78 $1,857.03 20 1.03 $0.05
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-47
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 112.52 $67.00 15 0.99 $0.06
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,300.05 $1,614.00 15 0.57 $0.13
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 178.24 $26.80 15 1.02 $0.02
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,331.61 $2,865.00 15 - $0.22
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 18.41 $135.02 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 664.49 $135.02 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 828.73 $57.21 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 900.11 $1,616.28 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 971.49 $518.35 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 11.23 -$3.59 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 19.00 $649.97 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 33.65 $28.66 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 34.13 $49.15 10 0.62 $0.19
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 36.69 $426.00 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 135.24 $176.01 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 415.99 $176.01 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 487.35 $74.58 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 518.37 $2,106.95 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 549.38 $675.71 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 27.08 $32.92 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 167.56 $32.92 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 193.42 $13.12 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 208.95 $283.10 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 236.14 $115.78 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 24.23 $80.00 14 - $0.35
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 29.87 $75.00 14 - $0.27
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 34.05 $115.00 14 1.06 $0.36
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-48 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 34.05 $115.00 14 - $0.36
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 36.58 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.61
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 5.50 $52.00 14 0.92 $1.01
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 26.27 $75.00 14 - $0.31
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 58.82 $175.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 12.22 $42.00 12 - $0.40
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 24.41 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.39
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 82.29 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.36
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 35.45 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.05
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 51.03 $43.00 20 1.23 $0.07
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 70.84 $218.00 20 - $0.27
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 91.20 $695.00 20 - $0.67
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 35.51 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 77.41 $198.00 22 1.04 $0.22
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 78.25 $198.00 22 - $0.21
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 97.60 $352.00 22 - $0.30
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 47.49 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.04
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 68.35 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.06
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 94.90 $218.00 20 - $0.20
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 122.17 $695.00 20 - $0.50
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.18 $121.00 20 0.90 $9.07
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 3.88 $580.00 20 0.66 $13.18
Appliances Stove Induction 21.81 $898.00 20 0.56 $3.63
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 239.38 $72.79 5 0.95 $0.07
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 11.19 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 40.50 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 75.37 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 80.82 $0.03 11 1.05 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-49
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 11.08 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 101.45 $11.04 5 1.01 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 115.98 $85.00 15 0.96 $0.08
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 463.92 $579.00 15 0.71 $0.13
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 2,988.60 $2,550.00 15 0.72 $0.09
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 106.88 $300.00 15 0.92 $0.29
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 142.50 $350.00 15 0.91 $0.25
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 153.02 $110.00 10 0.89 $0.10
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 165.69 $107.55 18 0.28 $0.06
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Table B-14 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Central AC SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Central AC SEER 14 (Energy Star) 144.24 $86.10 20 1.04 $0.05
Cooling Central AC SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 180.30 $215.25 20 1.02 $0.11
Cooling Central AC SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 209.33 $226.01 20 1.03 $0.10
Cooling Central AC Ductless Minisplit 234.83 $758.75 20 0.89 $0.29
Cooling Central AC SEER 21 521.64 $731.85 20 1.03 $0.12
Cooling Room AC EER 9.8 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Room AC EER 10.8 (Energy Star) 48.05 $3.60 10 1.08 $0.01
Cooling Room AC EER 11.0 56.61 $59.15 10 1.04 $0.14
Cooling Room AC EER 11.5 76.58 $181.32 10 0.97 $0.32
Cooling Room AC EER 12.0 95.01 $303.49 10 0.90 $0.43
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 114.85 $107.55 20 1.03 $0.08
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 142.87 $455.78 20 0.98 $0.28
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 166.68 $473.99 20 1.01 $0.25
Cooling Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 186.99 $887.39 20 0.85 $0.42
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 162.41 $80.79 20 1.08 $0.04
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-50 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 180.70 $215.45 20 1.07 $0.11
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 466.47 $484.75 20 1.18 $0.09
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.00
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 113.61 $181.15 12 1.02 $0.19
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 290.07 $905.73 12 0.92 $0.37
Space Heating Electric Room
Heat Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 13 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 14 (Energy Star) 578.64 $199.76 20 1.03 $0.03
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 15 (CEE Tier 2) 1,061.49 $846.59 20 0.98 $0.07
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump SEER 16 (CEE Tier 3) 1,458.22 $880.42 20 1.01 $0.05
Space Heating Air-Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,780.44 $2,582.74 20 0.85 $0.13
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14.1 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 16 883.15 $152.11 20 1.08 $0.02
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 18 1,352.38 $405.62 20 1.07 $0.03
Space Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 30 2,773.13 $912.65 20 1.18 $0.03
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.9 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 0.95 112.52 $67.00 15 0.99 $0.06
Water Heating Water Heater <=
55 Gal EF 2.3 (HP) 1,300.05 $1,614.00 15 0.57 $0.13
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.86 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 0.92 178.24 $26.80 15 1.02 $0.02
Water Heating Water Heater > 55
Gal EF 2.0 (HP) 1,331.61 $2,865.00 15 - $0.22
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (14
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 20.91 $153.40 4 - $2.02
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 754.94 $153.40 4 - $0.06
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 941.53 $65.00 6 1.67 $0.01
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 1,022.63 $1,836.27 15 0.25 $0.18
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 1,103.72 $588.90 15 - $0.05
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 12.76 -$4.07 10 1.13 -$0.04
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2011) 21.59 $738.44 20 0.14 $3.02
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 38.23 $32.56 10 0.77 $0.11
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 38.78 $55.84 10 0.62 $0.19
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-51
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 41.69 $483.99 20 - $1.02
Interior
Lighting Specialty Incandescent - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen 169.06 $220.01 4 - $0.36
Interior
Lighting Specialty Infrared Halogen (2020) 519.98 $220.01 4 - $0.12
Interior
Lighting Specialty CFL 609.19 $93.23 6 1.15 $0.03
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED 647.96 $2,633.69 15 0.12 $0.42
Interior
Lighting Specialty LED (2020) 686.73 $844.63 15 - $0.13
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent (16
lm/watt) - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.00
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (17
lm/watt) 30.77 $37.40 4 - $0.34
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Infrared Halogen (45
lm/watt) 190.36 $37.40 4 - $0.05
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL (63 lm/watt) 219.75 $14.90 6 1.77 $0.01
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (97 lm/watt) 237.40 $321.64 15 0.31 $0.14
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (197 lm/watt) 268.28 $131.54 15 - $0.05
Appliances Clothes Washer Standard (1.26) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (1.72) 24.23 $80.00 14 - $0.35
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 1.72) 29.87 $75.00 14 - $0.27
Appliances Clothes Washer Energy Star (MEF 2.0) 34.05 $115.00 14 1.06 $0.36
Appliances Clothes Washer AHAM (MEF 2.0) 34.05 $115.00 14 - $0.36
Appliances Clothes Washer Compact (MEF 2.79) 36.58 $209.00 14 0.97 $0.61
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (EF 3.01) - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (EF 3.17) 5.50 $52.00 14 0.92 $1.01
Appliances Clothes Dryer Baseline (AHAM 2015+) 26.27 $75.00 14 - $0.31
Appliances Clothes Dryer High Efficiency (AHAM
2015+) 58.82 $175.00 14 - $0.32
Appliances Dishwasher Standard (EF 0.63) - $0.00 12 - $0.00
Appliances Dishwasher Energy Star (EF 0.73) 12.22 $42.00 12 - $0.40
Appliances Dishwasher AHAM (EF 0.73) 24.41 $80.00 12 1.00 $0.39
Appliances Dishwasher Ultra Efficient (EF 1.1) 82.29 $255.00 12 0.84 $0.36
Appliances Refrigerator Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Refrigerator Energy Star 35.45 $19.47 20 1.00 $0.05
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency 51.03 $43.00 20 1.23 $0.07
Appliances Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 70.84 $218.00 20 - $0.27
Appliances Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 91.20 $695.00 20 - $0.67
Appliances Freezer Standard - $0.00 22 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Freezer Energy Star 35.51 $4.00 22 1.03 $0.01
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency 77.41 $198.00 22 1.04 $0.22
Appliances Freezer AHAM (2014) 78.25 $198.00 22 - $0.21
Appliances Freezer High Efficiency (2014) 97.60 $352.00 22 - $0.30
Appliances Second Standard - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-52 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigerator
Appliances Second
Refrigerator Energy Star 47.49 $19.47 20 1.01 $0.04
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency 68.35 $43.00 20 1.24 $0.06
Appliances Second
Refrigerator AHAM (2014) 94.90 $218.00 20 - $0.20
Appliances Second
Refrigerator High Efficiency (2014) 122.17 $695.00 20 - $0.50
Appliances Stove Baseline - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.00
Appliances Stove Convection 1.18 $121.00 20 0.90 $9.07
Appliances Stove Halogen Burner 3.88 $580.00 20 0.66 $13.18
Appliances Stove Induction 21.81 $898.00 20 0.56 $3.63
Appliances Microwave Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Personal
Computers Energy Star 239.38 $72.79 5 0.95 $0.07
Electronics Monitor Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Monitor Energy Star 11.19 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Laptops Energy Star 40.50 $0.01 4 1.01 $0.00
Electronics TVs Standard - $0.00 11 1.00 $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (4.1) 75.37 $0.02 11 - $0.00
Electronics TVs Energy Star (5.1) 80.82 $0.03 11 1.05 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Printer/Fax/Copier Energy Star 11.08 $0.01 5 1.01 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Electronics Set-top
Boxes/DVR Energy Star (2011) 101.45 $11.04 5 1.01 $0.02
Electronics Devices and
Gadgets Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 115.98 $85.00 15 0.96 $0.08
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Two-Speed 463.92 $579.00 15 0.71 $0.13
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Electric Resistance - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump (COP = 5.0) 2,988.60 $2,550.00 15 0.72 $0.09
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Efficient Pumps 106.88 $300.00 15 0.92 $0.29
Miscellaneous Hot Tub / Spa Improved Controls and
Pumps 142.50 $350.00 15 0.91 $0.25
Miscellaneous Well Pump Baseline (40% EF) - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Well Pump High Efficiency (60% EF) 153.02 $110.00 10 0.89 $0.10
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan Standard - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Furnace Fan ECM 50.84 $769.00 18 0.28 $1.41
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.00

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-53
Table B-15 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Single Family, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 36.1% 90.0% 20 $594.00 375.8 0.19 $0.139
Insulation - Ducting 0.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 628.1 0.58 $0.045
Insulation - Infiltration Control 24.2% 100.0% 12 $266.00 1,070.9 0.77 $0.029
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 90.0% 12 $922.68 706.3 0.17 $0.154
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 11.8% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,877.2 1.56 $0.018
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 61.3% 100.0% 25 $7,500.00 2,558.6 0.09 $0.235
Windows - Install Reflective Film 5.0% 45.0% 10 $895.39 943.4 0.67 $0.126
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.0% 100.0% 12 $320.00 144.8 0.10 $0.260
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 10.0% 15 $1,549.61 211.1 0.10 $0.753
Attic Fan - Installation 3.8% 50.0% 18 $115.80 15.8 0.10 $0.680
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 13.0% 100.0% 19 $350.00 15.8 0.04 $2.001
Whole-House Fan - Installation 7.7% 25.0% 18 $200.00 445.6 1.71 $0.042
Ceiling Fan - Installation 20.6% 100.0% 10 $160.00 277.8 1.10 $0.077
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 52.0% 85.0% 12 $114.42 1,460.5 3.15 $0.009
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 40.0% 20 $600.00 1,277.9 0.54 $0.041
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.4% 80.0% 15 $2,895.00 274.7 0.07 $1.081
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 41.0% 100.0% 4 $125.00 271.0 0.78 $0.127
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $430.31 794.9 0.74 $0.048
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.0% 100.0% 5 $75.00 393.4 4.30 $0.043
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 12.0% 90.0% 10 $12.70 148.2 2.16 $0.011
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 48.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 675.1 4.64 $0.005
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 38.1% 15 $180.00 261.1 0.32 $0.071
Water Heater - Timer 17.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 419.7 0.40 $0.062
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 20 $6,500.00 3,458.2 0.13 $0.166
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 24.0% 50.0% 15 $750.00 467.8 0.12 $0.164
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 24.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 26.0 0.03 $0.541
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 38.5 0.00 $7.927
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 10.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 26.0 0.04 $0.433
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 0.0% 100.0% 13 $1,203.00 136.8 0.02 $0.983
Refrigerator - Maintenance 37.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 151.9 0.38 $0.071
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 1,062.3 1.35 $0.018
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 714.6 0.95 $0.036
Freezer - Early Replacement 0.0% 100.0% 13 $484.00 107.2 0.04 $0.505
Freezer - Maintenance 37.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 125.7 0.78 $0.034
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 91.4 0.43 $0.063
Pool Pump - Timer 59.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 213.7 0.32 $0.077
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 363.4 0.30 $0.110
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-54 www.enernoc.com
Table B-16 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Single Family, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 54.2% 90.0% 20 $415.80 568.5 0.42 $0.065
Insulation - Ducting 3.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 571.2 0.52 $0.049
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 25.0% 100.0% 12 $922.68 210.5 0.07 $0.516
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 50.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,707.5 1.40 $0.019
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 92.9% 100.0% 25 $2,200.00 3,070.4 0.40 $0.057
Windows - Install Reflective Film 2.0% 45.0% 10 $577.67 568.1 0.63 $0.135
Doors - Storm and Thermal 13.0% 100.0% 12 $180.00 209.9 0.30 $0.101
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 90.0% 15 $516.54 218.1 0.32 $0.243
Attic Fan - Installation 3.8% 50.0% 18 $96.50 14.7 0.12 $0.611
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 4.0% 25.0% 19 $200.00 14.7 0.06 $1.233
Whole-House Fan - Installation 7.7% 25.0% 18 $200.00 402.8 1.58 $0.046
Ceiling Fan - Installation 20.6% 100.0% 10 $160.00 292.9 1.18 $0.073
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 74.3% 85.0% 12 $114.42 970.4 2.49 $0.014
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 60.0% 20 $600.00 1,210.6 0.54 $0.044
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 41.0% 100.0% 4 $125.00 225.0 0.66 $0.153
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $430.31 674.8 0.63 $0.056
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 3.0% 90.0% 10 $7.12 135.1 3.65 $0.007
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 50.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 616.8 4.40 $0.006
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 41.3% 15 $50.00 238.7 1.11 $0.021
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 392.1 0.39 $0.066
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 20 $6,500.00 3,158.9 0.12 $0.182
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 24.0% 30.0% 15 $500.00 571.1 0.23 $0.090
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 13.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 27.5 0.04 $0.511
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 41.4 0.00 $7.366
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 16.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 27.5 0.05 $0.409
Refrigerator - Maintenance 24.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 83.0 0.22 $0.130
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 667.4 0.92 $0.028
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 419.8 0.44 $0.061
Freezer - Maintenance 24.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 73.8 0.49 $0.058
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 84.3 0.39 $0.069
Pool Pump - Timer 55.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 216.4 0.32 $0.076
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 329.2 0.27 $0.122

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-55
Table B-17 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Multi Family, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 27.5% 40.0% 20 $215.00 150.3 0.26 $0.126
Insulation - Ducting 0.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 15.3 0.03 $1.838
Insulation - Infiltration Control 10.1% 100.0% 12 $266.00 303.3 0.23 $0.103
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 40.0% 12 $922.68 239.0 0.09 $0.454
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 11.8% 90.0% 20 $375.00 418.4 0.28 $0.079
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 60.5% 100.0% 25 $2,500.00 548.1 0.08 $0.366
Windows - Install Reflective Film 5.0% 45.0% 10 $186.32 155.1 1.09 $0.160
Doors - Storm and Thermal 17.0% 100.0% 12 $320.00 - - $0.000
Roofs - High Reflectivity 3.0% 10.0% 15 $1,549.61 54.3 0.05 $2.931
Attic Fan - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 19 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Whole-House Fan - Installation 1.6% 25.0% 18 $150.00 63.3 0.66 $0.220
Ceiling Fan - Installation 12.7% 100.0% 10 $80.00 52.4 0.86 $0.203
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 28.6% 85.0% 12 $73.33 179.6 1.00 $0.048
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 40.0% 20 $600.00 1,080.0 0.58 $0.049
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.0% 80.0% 15 $2,895.00 81.3 0.02 $3.653
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 33.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 80.3 0.28 $0.344
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $100.00 211.1 0.89 $0.042
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.0% 100.0% 5 $75.00 195.9 2.31 $0.087
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 8.0% 90.0% 10 $12.70 79.6 1.10 $0.021
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 24.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 363.2 2.35 $0.010
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 38.1% 15 $180.00 100.2 0.12 $0.184
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 161.2 0.15 $0.160
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 1,532.7 0.04 $0.564
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 6.0% 20.0% 15 $256.00 209.0 0.15 $0.126
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 7.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 15.9 0.02 $0.888
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 41.1 0.00 $7.430
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 6.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 15.9 0.03 $0.711
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 2.7% 100.0% 13 $1,203.00 119.7 0.02 $1.124
Refrigerator - Maintenance 27.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 132.9 0.32 $0.081
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 929.5 1.18 $0.020
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 625.3 0.64 $0.041
Freezer - Early Replacement 2.7% 100.0% 13 $484.00 93.8 0.04 $0.577
Freezer - Maintenance 27.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 110.0 0.71 $0.039
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 81.8 0.38 $0.071
Pool Pump - Timer 50.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 - - $0.000
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 196.6 0.17 $0.203
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-56 www.enernoc.com
Table B-18 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Multi Family, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 41.3% 40.0% 20 $150.50 190.1 0.51 $0.070
Insulation - Ducting 3.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 10.5 0.02 $2.668
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 100.0% 12 $922.68 67.1 0.02 $1.617
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 50.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 386.2 0.26 $0.086
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 93.0% 100.0% 25 $2,200.00 978.2 0.15 $0.180
Windows - Install Reflective Film 2.0% 45.0% 10 $218.97 131.5 0.81 $0.222
Doors - Storm and Thermal 19.0% 100.0% 12 $180.00 - - $0.000
Roofs - High Reflectivity 0.0% 90.0% 15 $516.54 35.9 0.11 $1.474
Attic Fan - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 19 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Whole-House Fan - Installation 1.6% 25.0% 18 $150.00 - - $0.000
Ceiling Fan - Installation 12.7% 100.0% 10 $80.00 60.6 1.02 $0.176
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 40.8% 85.0% 10 $73.33 111.8 0.68 $0.087
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 60.0% 20 $600.00 850.0 0.57 $0.062
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 33.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 65.7 0.24 $0.420
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $100.00 182.4 0.76 $0.048
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 4.0% 90.0% 10 $7.12 72.8 1.88 $0.013
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 30.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 332.3 2.26 $0.011
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 41.3% 15 $50.00 91.7 0.41 $0.056
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 150.9 0.14 $0.171
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 1,416.1 0.04 $0.611
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 6.0% 10.0% 15 $256.00 275.1 0.21 $0.095
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 1.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 20.0 0.03 $0.703
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 54.3 0.00 $5.622
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 11.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 20.0 0.04 $0.562
Refrigerator - Maintenance 9.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 72.6 0.19 $0.149
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 584.0 0.80 $0.032
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 367.3 0.38 $0.069
Freezer - Maintenance 9.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 64.6 0.43 $0.066
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 75.4 0.35 $0.077
Pool Pump - Timer 35.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 - - $0.000
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 177.1 0.15 $0.226

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-57
Table B-19 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Mobile Home, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 36.1% 95.0% 20 $707.00 299.1 0.14 $0.209
Insulation - Ducting 0.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 569.8 0.51 $0.049
Insulation - Infiltration Control 30.0% 100.0% 12 $266.00 905.7 0.73 $0.035
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 95.0% 12 $922.68 577.0 0.15 $0.188
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 10.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,703.5 1.37 $0.019
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 56.5% 100.0% 25 $7,500.00 2,096.8 0.08 $0.287
Windows - Install Reflective Film 5.0% 45.0% 10 $788.06 484.0 0.75 $0.217
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.0% 100.0% 12 $320.00 118.0 0.09 $0.319
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 10.0% 15 $1,549.61 108.3 0.10 $1.468
Attic Fan - Installation 2.3% 50.0% 18 $115.80 8.1 0.10 $1.326
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 13.0% 100.0% 19 $350.00 8.1 0.03 $3.900
Whole-House Fan - Installation 5.9% 25.0% 18 $150.00 228.6 2.25 $0.061
Ceiling Fan - Installation 17.9% 100.0% 10 $80.00 142.5 2.18 $0.075
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 32.4% 85.0% 10 $73.33 1,165.4 4.06 $0.008
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 40.0% 20 $600.00 1,313.4 0.58 $0.040
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.0% 80.0% 15 $2,895.00 221.3 0.06 $1.342
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 25.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 218.3 0.78 $0.126
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $393.00 705.1 0.69 $0.049
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.0% 100.0% 5 $75.00 880.3 9.63 $0.019
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 12.0% 90.0% 10 $12.70 99.2 1.45 $0.017
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 33.4% 100.0% 10 $27.00 452.1 3.11 $0.008
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 38.1% 15 $180.00 174.8 0.22 $0.106
Water Heater - Timer 17.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 347.4 0.33 $0.074
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 2,315.8 0.07 $0.373
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 67.0% 80.0% 15 $750.00 421.1 0.11 $0.183
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 23.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 23.4 0.03 $0.601
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 34.7 0.00 $8.808
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 10.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 23.4 0.04 $0.481
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 4.9% 100.0% 13 $1,203.00 125.4 0.02 $1.073
Refrigerator - Maintenance 35.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 139.3 0.34 $0.078
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 973.8 1.24 $0.019
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 655.1 0.65 $0.039
Freezer - Early Replacement 4.9% 100.0% 13 $484.00 98.3 0.04 $0.551
Freezer - Maintenance 35.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 115.2 0.72 $0.037
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 81.8 0.38 $0.071
Pool Pump - Timer 50.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 194.3 0.29 $0.085
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 297.7 0.27 $0.134
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-58 www.enernoc.com
Table B-20 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Mobile Home, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 54.2% 95.0% 20 $494.90 440.6 0.35 $0.099
Insulation - Ducting 3.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 497.0 0.45 $0.056
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 100.0% 12 $922.68 158.9 0.08 $0.683
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 50.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,486.3 1.20 $0.022
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY
STAR 88.0% 100.0% 25 $2,200.00 2,409.6 0.38 $0.073
Windows - Install Reflective Film 2.0% 45.0% 10 $576.18 350.5 0.77 $0.219
Doors - Storm and Thermal 13.0% 100.0% 12 $180.00 163.0 0.29 $0.130
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 90.0% 15 $516.54 134.6 0.38 $0.394
Attic Fan - Installation 2.3% 50.0% 18 $96.50 9.1 0.14 $0.991
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 4.0% 25.0% 19 $200.00 9.1 0.07 $1.998
Whole-House Fan - Installation 5.9% 25.0% 18 $150.00 248.5 2.56 $0.056
Ceiling Fan - Installation 17.9% 100.0% 10 $80.00 180.7 2.87 $0.059
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 46.3% 85.0% 10 $73.33 740.2 3.67 $0.013
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 60.0% 20 $600.00 1,332.0 0.64 $0.040
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 25.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 176.8 0.65 $0.156
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $393.00 577.5 0.59 $0.060
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 3.0% 90.0% 10 $7.12 90.6 2.46 $0.010
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 35.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 413.4 2.96 $0.009
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 41.3% 15 $50.00 160.0 0.75 $0.032
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 328.5 0.33 $0.079
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 2,117.2 0.06 $0.409
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 67.0% 80.0% 15 $500.00 514.0 0.21 $0.100
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 13.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 24.8 0.04 $0.568
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 37.3 0.00 $8.185
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 16.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 24.8 0.05 $0.455
Refrigerator - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 76.1 0.20 $0.142
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 611.8 0.84 $0.030
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 384.8 0.40 $0.066
Freezer - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 67.7 0.45 $0.063
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 75.4 0.35 $0.077
Pool Pump - Timer 35.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 196.7 0.29 $0.083
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 267.6 0.25 $0.149

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-59
Table B-21 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, Existing
Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 36.1% 90.0% 20 $594.00 317.0 0.14 $0.165
Insulation - Ducting 0.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 602.5 0.54 $0.047
Insulation - Infiltration Control 24.2% 100.0% 12 $266.00 945.1 0.66 $0.033
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 90.0% 12 $922.68 610.9 0.14 $0.178
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 2.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,801.3 1.45 $0.018
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 61.3% 100.0% 25 $7,500.00 2,219.7 0.07 $0.271
Windows - Install Reflective Film 5.0% 45.0% 10 $895.39 525.6 0.37 $0.227
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.0% 100.0% 12 $320.00 125.0 0.08 $0.301
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 10.0% 15 $1,549.61 117.6 0.06 $1.352
Attic Fan - Installation 3.8% 50.0% 18 $115.80 8.8 0.06 $1.221
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 13.0% 100.0% 19 $350.00 8.8 0.02 $3.591
Whole-House Fan - Installation 7.7% 25.0% 18 $200.00 248.3 0.95 $0.075
Ceiling Fan - Installation 20.6% 100.0% 10 $160.00 154.8 0.61 $0.138
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 52.0% 85.0% 10 $114.42 1,235.1 2.19 $0.012
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 40.0% 20 $600.00 1,139.9 0.46 $0.046
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.4% 80.0% 15 $2,895.00 234.1 0.06 $1.269
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 41.0% 100.0% 4 $125.00 231.0 0.66 $0.149
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $430.31 745.6 0.67 $0.051
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.0% 100.0% 5 $75.00 335.3 3.67 $0.051
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 12.0% 90.0% 10 $12.70 136.8 2.00 $0.012
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 41.7% 100.0% 10 $27.00 623.1 4.28 $0.006
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 38.1% 15 $180.00 241.0 0.30 $0.077
Water Heater - Timer 17.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 387.5 0.37 $0.067
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 3,192.2 0.09 $0.271
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 24.0% 50.0% 15 $750.00 491.2 0.13 $0.157
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 24.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 27.3 0.04 $0.515
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 40.4 0.00 $7.549
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock Installation 10.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 27.3 0.05 $0.412
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 0.0% 100.0% 13 $1,203.00 125.4 0.02 $1.073
Refrigerator - Maintenance 37.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 139.3 0.34 $0.078
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 973.8 1.24 $0.019
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 655.1 0.65 $0.039
Freezer - Early Replacement 0.0% 100.0% 13 $484.00 98.3 0.04 $0.551
Freezer - Maintenance 37.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 115.2 0.72 $0.037
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 84.9 0.40 $0.068
Pool Pump - Timer 59.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 194.3 0.29 $0.085
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 323.0 0.25 $0.124
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-60 www.enernoc.com
Table B-22 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Single Family, New
Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 54.2% 90.0% 20 $415.80 477.4 0.32 $0.077
Insulation - Ducting 3.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 527.4 0.47 $0.053
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 25.0% 100.0% 12 $922.68 169.3 0.05 $0.641
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 50.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,577.1 1.26 $0.021
Windows - High
Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 92.9% 100.0% 25 $2,200.00 2,629.7 0.32 $0.067
Windows - Install Reflective
Film 2.0% 45.0% 10 $577.67 321.2 0.36 $0.239
Doors - Storm and Thermal 13.0% 100.0% 12 $180.00 176.7 0.23 $0.120
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 90.0% 15 $516.54 123.3 0.18 $0.430
Attic Fan - Installation 3.8% 50.0% 18 $96.50 8.3 0.07 $1.081
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic -
Installation 4.0% 25.0% 19 $200.00 8.3 0.03 $2.181
Whole-House Fan - Installation 7.7% 25.0% 18 $200.00 227.7 0.89 $0.082
Ceiling Fan - Installation 20.6% 100.0% 10 $160.00 165.6 0.67 $0.129
Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable 74.3% 85.0% 10 $114.42 794.1 1.63 $0.019
Home Energy Management
System 2.0% 60.0% 20 $600.00 1,083.0 0.45 $0.049
Central AC - Maintenance and
Tune-Up 41.0% 100.0% 4 $125.00 191.7 0.56 $0.180
Central Heat Pump -
Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $430.31 633.6 0.57 $0.060
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 3.0% 90.0% 10 $7.12 124.7 3.38 $0.008
Water Heater - Low-Flow
Showerheads 50.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 569.3 4.07 $0.006
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 41.3% 15 $50.00 220.4 1.03 $0.023
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 362.0 0.36 $0.071
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 2,915.9 0.09 $0.297
Interior Lighting - Occupancy
Sensors 24.0% 30.0% 15 $500.00 599.6 0.24 $0.086
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor
Control 13.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 28.9 0.04 $0.487
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 43.5 0.00 $7.016
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 16.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 28.9 0.06 $0.390
Refrigerator - Maintenance 24.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 76.1 0.20 $0.142
Refrigerator - Remove Second
Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 611.8 0.84 $0.030
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 384.8 0.40 $0.066
Freezer - Maintenance 24.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 67.7 0.45 $0.063
Electronics - Smart Power
Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 78.2 0.36 $0.074
Pool Pump - Timer 55.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 196.7 0.29 $0.083
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 294.4 0.23 $0.136

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-61
Table B-23 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Multi Family, Existing
Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 27.5% 40.0% 20 $215.00 172.8 0.24 $0.110
Insulation - Ducting 0.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 15.3 0.03 $1.838
Insulation - Infiltration Control 10.1% 100.0% 12 $266.00 335.7 0.24 $0.093
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 40.0% 12 $922.68 277.5 0.08 $0.391
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 2.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 418.4 0.28 $0.079
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 60.5% 100.0% 25 $2,500.00 627.2 0.08 $0.320
Windows - Install Reflective Film 5.0% 45.0% 10 $186.32 238.7 0.79 $0.104
Doors - Storm and Thermal 17.0% 100.0% 12 $320.00 - - $0.000
Roofs - High Reflectivity 3.0% 10.0% 15 $1,549.61 83.5 0.04 $1.904
Attic Fan - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 19 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Whole-House Fan - Installation 1.6% 25.0% 18 $150.00 - - $0.000
Ceiling Fan - Installation 12.7% 100.0% 10 $80.00 80.6 0.62 $0.132
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 28.6% 85.0% 10 $73.33 212.3 0.79 $0.046
Home Energy Management System 5.0% 40.0% 20 $600.00 1,214.4 0.55 $0.044
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.0% 80.0% 15 $2,895.00 81.3 0.02 $3.653
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 33.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 80.3 0.28 $0.344
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $100.00 211.1 0.94 $0.042
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.0% 100.0% 5 $75.00 195.9 2.31 $0.087
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 8.0% 90.0% 10 $12.70 79.6 1.10 $0.021
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 24.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 363.2 2.35 $0.010
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 38.1% 15 $180.00 100.2 0.12 $0.184
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 161.2 0.15 $0.160
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 1,512.9 0.04 $0.572
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 6.0% 20.0% 15 $256.00 209.0 0.15 $0.126
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 7.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 15.9 0.02 $0.888
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 41.1 0.00 $7.430
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock Installation 6.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 15.9 0.03 $0.711
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 2.7% 100.0% 13 $1,203.00 119.7 0.02 $1.124
Refrigerator - Maintenance 27.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 132.9 0.32 $0.081
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 929.5 1.18 $0.020
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 625.3 0.64 $0.041
Freezer - Early Replacement 2.7% 100.0% 13 $484.00 93.8 0.04 $0.577
Freezer - Maintenance 27.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 110.0 0.71 $0.039
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 81.8 0.38 $0.071
Pool Pump - Timer 50.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 - - $0.000
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 199.5 0.16 $0.200
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-62 www.enernoc.com
Table B-24 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Limited Income Multi Family, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 41.3% 40.0% 20 $150.50 210.7 0.43 $0.063
Insulation - Ducting 3.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 10.5 0.02 $2.668
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 100.0% 12 $922.68 72.8 0.02 $1.492
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 50.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 376.6 0.25 $0.088
Windows - High
Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 93.0% 100.0% 25 $2,200.00 1,068.0 0.14 $0.165
Windows - Install Reflective Film 2.0% 45.0% 10 $218.97 178.2 0.52 $0.164
Doors - Storm and Thermal 19.0% 100.0% 12 $180.00 - - $0.000
Roofs - High Reflectivity 0.0% 90.0% 15 $516.54 48.7 0.07 $1.088
Attic Fan - Installation 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic -
Installation 0.0% 0.0% 19 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Whole-House Fan - Installation 1.6% 25.0% 18 $150.00 - - $0.000
Ceiling Fan - Installation 12.7% 100.0% 10 $80.00 82.1 0.66 $0.130
Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable 40.8% 85.0% 10 $73.33 127.3 0.51 $0.077
Home Energy Management
System 2.0% 60.0% 20 $600.00 932.5 0.48 $0.057
Central AC - Maintenance and
Tune-Up 33.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 65.7 0.24 $0.420
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $100.00 182.4 0.78 $0.048
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 4.0% 90.0% 10 $7.12 72.8 1.88 $0.013
Water Heater - Low-Flow
Showerheads 30.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 332.3 2.26 $0.011
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 41.3% 15 $50.00 91.7 0.41 $0.056
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 150.9 0.14 $0.171
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 10 $6,500.00 1,399.1 0.04 $0.618
Interior Lighting - Occupancy
Sensors 6.0% 10.0% 15 $256.00 275.1 0.21 $0.095
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor
Control 1.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 20.0 0.03 $0.703
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 54.3 0.00 $5.622
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock
Installation 11.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 20.0 0.04 $0.562
Refrigerator - Maintenance 9.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 72.6 0.19 $0.149
Refrigerator - Remove Second
Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 584.0 0.80 $0.032
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 367.3 0.38 $0.069
Freezer - Maintenance 9.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 64.6 0.43 $0.066
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 75.4 0.35 $0.077
Pool Pump - Timer 35.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 - - $0.000
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 177.5 0.14 $0.225

Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting B-63
Table B-25 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, Existing
Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 36.1% 95.0% 20 $707.00 184.5 0.08 $0.338
Insulation - Ducting 0.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 374.4 0.36 $0.075
Insulation - Infiltration Control 30.0% 100.0% 12 $266.00 565.1 0.44 $0.055
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 95.0% 12 $922.68 358.7 0.09 $0.303
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 10.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 1,118.5 0.96 $0.030
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 56.5% 100.0% 25 $7,500.00 1,304.8 0.05 $0.461
Windows - Install Reflective Film 5.0% 45.0% 10 $788.06 249.0 0.39 $0.421
Doors - Storm and Thermal 38.0% 100.0% 12 $320.00 73.3 0.05 $0.514
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 10.0% 15 $1,549.61 55.7 0.05 $2.854
Attic Fan - Installation 2.3% 50.0% 18 $115.80 4.2 0.05 $2.577
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 13.0% 100.0% 19 $350.00 4.2 0.02 $7.581
Whole-House Fan - Installation 5.9% 25.0% 18 $150.00 117.6 1.16 $0.118
Ceiling Fan - Installation 17.9% 100.0% 10 $80.00 73.3 1.13 $0.145
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 32.4% 85.0% 10 $73.33 719.5 2.35 $0.014
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 40.0% 20 $600.00 911.1 0.38 $0.058
Central AC - Early Replacement 0.0% 80.0% 15 $2,895.00 182.3 0.05 $1.630
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 25.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 179.8 0.64 $0.153
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $393.00 484.4 0.52 $0.072
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0.0% 100.0% 5 $75.00 725.0 7.93 $0.024
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 12.0% 90.0% 10 $12.70 86.8 1.27 $0.019
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 33.4% 100.0% 10 $27.00 395.5 2.72 $0.009
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 38.1% 15 $180.00 153.0 0.19 $0.121
Water Heater - Timer 17.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 303.9 0.29 $0.085
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 20 $6,500.00 2,026.3 0.08 $0.283
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 67.0% 80.0% 15 $750.00 467.8 0.12 $0.164
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 23.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 26.0 0.03 $0.541
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 38.5 0.00 $7.927
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock Installation 10.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 26.0 0.04 $0.433
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 4.9% 100.0% 13 $1,203.00 119.7 0.02 $1.124
Refrigerator - Maintenance 35.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 132.9 0.33 $0.081
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 929.5 1.18 $0.020
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 625.3 0.62 $0.041
Freezer - Early Replacement 4.9% 100.0% 13 $484.00 93.8 0.04 $0.577
Freezer - Maintenance 35.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 110.0 0.69 $0.039
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 78.1 0.37 $0.074
Pool Pump - Timer 50.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 194.3 0.29 $0.085
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 253.1 0.21 $0.158
Residential Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
B-64 www.enernoc.com
Table B-26 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Limited Income Mobile Home, New
Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 54.2% 95.0% 20 $494.90 265.5 0.18 $0.164
Insulation - Ducting 3.0% 9.5% 25 $350.00 325.5 0.31 $0.086
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 100.0% 12 $922.68 92.8 0.04 $1.169
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 50.0% 90.0% 20 $375.00 972.7 0.84 $0.034
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 88.0% 100.0% 25 $2,200.00 1,471.6 0.21 $0.120
Windows - Install Reflective Film 2.0% 45.0% 10 $576.18 151.2 0.33 $0.507
Doors - Storm and Thermal 13.0% 100.0% 12 $180.00 98.4 0.15 $0.215
Roofs - High Reflectivity 5.0% 90.0% 15 $516.54 58.0 0.17 $0.913
Attic Fan - Installation 2.3% 50.0% 18 $96.50 3.9 0.06 $2.296
Attic Fan - Solar 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 4.0% 25.0% 19 $200.00 3.9 0.03 $4.632
Whole-House Fan - Installation 5.9% 25.0% 18 $150.00 107.2 1.11 $0.130
Ceiling Fan - Installation 17.9% 100.0% 10 $80.00 77.9 1.24 $0.137
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 46.3% 85.0% 12 $73.33 438.0 2.02 $0.020
Home Energy Management System 2.0% 60.0% 20 $600.00 933.4 0.40 $0.057
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 25.0% 100.0% 4 $100.00 145.6 0.54 $0.190
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 25.0% 100.0% 20 $393.00 396.3 0.44 $0.087
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 3.0% 90.0% 10 $7.12 79.3 2.15 $0.012
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 35.0% 100.0% 10 $27.00 361.7 2.59 $0.010
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 42.0% 41.3% 15 $50.00 140.0 0.65 $0.037
Water Heater - Timer 5.0% 100.0% 10 $194.00 287.4 0.29 $0.090
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Solar System 5.0% 50.0% 20 $6,500.00 1,852.6 0.07 $0.310
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 67.0% 80.0% 15 $500.00 571.1 0.23 $0.090
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 13.0% 100.0% 8 $90.00 27.5 0.04 $0.511
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 10.0% 45.0% 15 $2,975.00 41.4 0.00 $7.366
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock Installation 16.0% 100.0% 8 $72.00 27.5 0.05 $0.409
Refrigerator - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $39.18 72.6 0.19 $0.149
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 3.0% 85.0% 9 $130.00 584.0 0.80 $0.032
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 2.0% 85.0% 6 $130.00 367.3 0.38 $0.069
Freezer - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $15.57 64.6 0.43 $0.066
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 1.4% 100.0% 4 $21.00 72.1 0.33 $0.080
Pool Pump - Timer 35.0% 100.0% 15 $160.00 196.7 0.29 $0.083
Pool Heater - Solar System 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 1.00 $0.000
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0.0% 100.0% 1 $40.00 228.3 0.19 $0.175

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-1
APPENDIX C
COMMERCIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE
DATA
This appendix presents detailed information for all commercial energy-efficiency measures
(equipment and non-equipment measures per the LoadMAP taxonomy) that were evaluated in
this study.
Measure Descriptions
Table C-1 and Table C-2 provide brief narrative descriptions for all equipment and non-
equipment measures that were assessed for potential.
Measure Data
Table C-3 through Table C-27 list the detailed unit-level data (including economic screen results)
for commercial equipment measures in existing and new buildings. The column headings and
units are the same as described for the corresponding residential sector tables above, with the
exception that savings and incremental costs are expressed on a per square foot basis.
Table C-28 through Table C-49 provide data for the non-equipment measures.

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-2 www.enernoc.com
Table C-1 Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment Measure Descriptions
End Use Technology Measure Description
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller
A central chiller plant creates chilled water for distribution throughout the
facility. Because of the wide variety of system types and sizes, savings and cost
values for efficiency improvements represent an average over screw,
reciprocating, and centrifugal technologies. Under this simplified approach,
each central system is characterized by an aggregate efficiency value (inclusive
of chiller, pumps, and motors), in kW/ton with a further efficiency upgrade
through the application of variable refrigerant flow technology.
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller
A central chiller plant creates chilled water for distribution throughout the
facility. Water source chillers include heat rejection via a condenser loop and
cooling tower. Because of the wide variety of system types and sizes, savings
and cost values for efficiency improvements represent an average over screw,
reciprocating, and centrifugal technologies. Under this simplified approach,
each central system is characterized by an aggregate efficiency value (inclusive
of chiller, pumps, motors, and condenser loop equipment), in kW/ton with a
further efficiency upgrade through the application of variable refrigerant flow
technology.
Cooling RTU
Packaged cooling systems, such as rooftop units (RTUs), are simple to install
and maintain, and are commonly used in small and medium-sized commercial
buildings. Applications range from a single supply system with air intake filters,
supply fan, and cooling coil, or can become more complex with the addition of
a return air duct, return air fan, and various controls to optimize performance.
For packaged RTUs, varying Energy Efficiency Ratios (EER) are modeled, as well
as a ductless mini-split system.
Cooling /
Heating
Air-Source Heat
Pump
For heat pumps, units with increasing EER and COP levels are evaluated, as well
as a ductless mini-split system.
Cooling /
Heating
Geothermal Heat
Pump For heat pumps, units with increasing EER and COP levels are evaluated.
Cooling Evaporative AC Evaporative air conditioning, sometimes called swamp cooling, uses the cooling
effect produced when water evaporates to provide space cooling.
Cooling Other Cooling
Other cooling encompasses any remaining cooling technologies such as
packaged terminal air conditioning units. Higher efficiency options for these
devices are similar to those for standard air conditioning units.
Heating Electric Furnace
Resistive heating elements are used to convert electricity directly to heat. The
heat is then delivered by a supply fan and duct system to the regions that
require heating.
Heating Electric Room Heat
Resistive heating elements are used to convert electricity directly to heat.
Conductive fins surrounding the element or another mechanism is used to
deliver the heat directly to the surrounding room or area. These are typically
either baseboard or wall-mounted units.
Ventilation Ventilation
A variable air volume ventilation system modulates the air flow rate as needed
based on the interior conditions of the building to reduce fan load, improve
dehumidification, and reduce energy usage.
Water
Heating Water Heater
Efficient electric water heaters are characterized by a high recovery or thermal
efficiency (percentage of delivered electric energy which is transferred to the
water) and low standby losses (the ratio of heat lost per hour to the content of
the stored water). Included in the savings associated with high-efficiency
electric water heaters are timers that allow temperature setpoints to change
with hot water demand patterns. For example, the heating element could be
shut off throughout the night, increasing the overall energy factor of the unit.
In addition, tank and pipe insulation reduces standby losses and therefore
reduces the demands on the water heater. This analysis considers conventional
electric water heaters and heat pump water heaters.
For natural gas hot water heating, the most common type is a storage heater,
which incorporates a burner, storage tank, outer jacket, insulation, and
controls in a single unit. Efficient units are characterized by a high recovery or
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-3
End Use Technology Measure Description
thermal efficiency and low standby losses (the ratio of heat lost per hour to the
content of the stored water). A further efficiency gain is available in condensing
units, which condense the water vapor produced in the combustion process
and also use the heat from this condensation.
Interior
Lighting Screw-in This measure evaluates higher-efficiency alternatives for screw-in interior
lamps including halogen, CFL, and LED.
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures
With the exception of screw-in lighting, commercial lighting efficiency changes
typically require more than the simple purchase and installation of an
alternative lamp. Restrictions regarding ballasts, fixtures, and circuitry limit the
potential for direct substitution of one lamp type for another. Also, during the
buildout for a leased office space, management could decide to replace all
lamps, ballasts, and fixtures with different configurations. This type of decision-
making is modeled on a stock turnover basis because of the time between
opportunities for upgrades. For High-Bay fixtures, alternatives include mercury
vapor, metal halides, T5 fluorescent high output, and high-pressure sodium.
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent
With the exception of screw-in lighting, commercial lighting efficiency changes
typically require more than the simple purchase and installation of an
alternative lamp. Restrictions regarding ballasts, fixtures, and circuitry limit the
potential for direct substitution of one lamp type for another. Also, during the
buildout for a leased office space, management could decide to replace all
lamps, ballasts, and fixtures with different configurations. This type of decision-
making is modeled on a stock turnover basis because of the time between
opportunities for upgrades. For linear fluorescent fixtures, alternatives include
T12, T8, Super T8, T5, and LED.
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in This measure evaluates higher-efficiency alternatives for screw-in interior
lamps including halogen, CFL, and LED.
Exterior
Lighting HID Alternatives modeled include metal halides, T8 and T5 high output, high
pressure sodium, and LEDs
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent For linear fluorescent fixtures, alternatives include T12, T8, Super T8, T5, and
LED.
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator
These refrigerators can be designed to perform at higher efficiency through a
combination of compressor equipment upgrades, default temperature settings,
and defrost patterns. Standard refrigeration compressors typically operate at
approximately 65% efficiency. High-efficiency models are available that can
improve compressor efficiency by 15%. Analysis assumes unit with: 140 square
feet, Cooling capacity of 26,230 BTU/hr.
Refrigeration Reach-in
Refrigerator
A significant amount of energy in the commercial sector can be attributed to
"reach-in" units. These stand-alone appliances can range from a residential-
style refrigerator/freezer unit in an office kitchen or the breakroom of a retail
store, to the larger reach-in units in foodservice applications. As in the case of
residential units, these refrigerators can be designed to perform at higher
efficiency through a combination of compressor equipment upgrades, default
temperature settings, and defrost patterns. Analysis assumes unit with: 48
cubic feet, Cooling capacity of 3000 BTU/hr.
Refrigeration Glass Door Display,
Open Display Case
These refrigerators can be designed to perform at higher efficiency through a
combination of compressor equipment upgrades, default temperature settings,
and defrost patterns. Standard refrigeration compressors typically operate at
approximately 65% efficiency. High-efficiency models are available that can
improve compressor efficiency by 15%. Analysis assumes unit with: Cooling
capacity of 20,000 BTU/hr
Refrigeration Icemaker By optimizing the timing of ice production and the type of output to the
specific application, icemakers are assumed to deliver electricity savings.
Refrigeration Vending Machine High-efficiency vending machines incorporate more efficient compressors and
lighting.
Food
Preparation
Cooking Equipment,
High Efficiency
This set of measures includes high-efficiency fryers, ovens, dishwashers, and
hot food containers. Less common equipment, such as broilers and steamers,
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-4 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Measure Description
and assumed to be modeled with the other more common equipment types.
Office
Equipment
Desktop Computer,
Laptop, Monitors
ENERGY STAR labeled computers automatically power down to 15 watts or less
when not in use and may actually last longer than conventional products
because they spend a large portion of time in a low-power sleep mode.
ENERGY STAR labeled computers also generate less heat than conventional
models.
Office
Equipment Server
In addition to the "sleep" mode a reductions, servers have additional energy-
saving opportunities through "virtualization" and other architecture solutions
that involve optimal matching of computation tasks to hardware requirements
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax
ENERGY STAR labeled office equipment saves energy by powering down and
"going to sleep" when not in use. ENERGY STAR labeled copiers are equipped
with a feature that allows them to automatically turn off after a period of
inactivity.
Office
Equipment POS Terminal
Point-of-sale terminals in retail and supermarket facilities are always on.
Efficient models incorporate a high-efficiency power supply to reduce energy
use.
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors
Includes motors for a variety of non-HVAC uses including vertical
transportation. Premium efficiency motors can provide savings of 0.5% to 3%
over standard motors. The savings results from the fact that energy efficient
motors run cooler than their standard counterparts, resulting in an increase in
the life of the motor insulation and bearing. In general, an efficient motor is a
more reliable motor because there are fewer winding failures, longer periods
between needed maintenance, and fewer forced outages. For example, using
copper instead of aluminum in the windings, and increasing conductor cross-
sectional area, lowers a motor’s I2R losses.
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High-efficiency motors and two-speed pumps provide improved energy
efficiency for this load.
Miscellaneous Pool Heater
Efficient pool heaters can make use of heat pump technology to achieve
significantly higher coefficients of performance in the COP=5.0 range.
Gas pool heaters have a burner to heat water in a loop. Efficiency
improvements can include: exhaust fan controls, electronic ignition (no pilot
light), compact size and lighter weight to reduce cycling losses, and sealed
combustion. Very high efficiency units, or condensing units, condense the
water vapor produced in the combustion process and also use the heat from
this condensation.
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous
The miscellaneous category within the miscellaneous end use accounts for
energy consumed by a wide range of otherwise uncategorized plug loads in
commercial buildings. This can include medical equipment, switching units
in rail yards, telecommunications equipment, and so on. No efficiency
measure is modeled for these uses.
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-5
Table C-2 Commercial Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Measure Descriptions
End Use Measure Description
HVAC (All) Insulation - Ceiling
Thermal insulation is material or combinations of materials that are used to
inhibit the flow of heat energy by conductive, convective, and radiative transfer
modes. Thus, thermal insulation can conserve energy by reducing the heat loss
or gain of a building. The type of building construction defines insulating
possibilities. Typical insulating materials include: loose-fill (blown) cellulose;
loose-fill (blown) fiberglass; and rigid polystyrene.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Ducting
Air distribution ducts can be insulated to reduce heating or cooling losses. Best
results can be achieved by covering the entire surface area with insulation.
Insulation material inhibits the transfer of heat through the air-supply duct.
Several types of ducts and duct insulation are available, including flexible duct,
pre-insulated duct, duct board, duct wrap, tacked, or glued rigid insulation, and
waterproof hard shell materials for exterior ducts.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Radiant
Barrier
Radiant barriers are materials installed to reduce the heat gain in buildings.
Radiant barriers are made from materials that are highly reflective and have
low emissivity like aluminum. The closer the emissivity is to 0 the better they
will perform. Radiant barriers can be placed above the insulation or on the
roof rafters.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Wall
Cavity
Thermal insulation is material or combinations of materials that are used to
inhibit the flow of heat energy by conductive, convective, and radiative transfer
modes. Thus, thermal insulation can conserve energy by reducing the heat loss
or gain of a building. The type of building construction defines insulating
possibilities. Typical insulating materials include: loose-fill (blown) cellulose;
loose-fill (blown) fiberglass; and rigid polystyrene.
HVAC (All) HVAC - Duct Repair
and Sealing
Leakage in unsealed ducts varies considerably because of the differences in
fabricating machinery used, the methods for assembly, installation
workmanship, and age of the ductwork. Air leaks from the system to the
outdoors result in a direct loss proportional to the amount of leakage and the
difference in enthalpy between the outdoor air and the conditioned air. To
seal ducts, a wide variety of sealing methods and products exist. Each has a
relatively short shelf life, and no documented research has identified the aging
characteristics of sealant applications.
HVAC (All) Doors - High
Efficiency
Like other components of the shell, doors are subject to several types of heat
loss: conduction, infiltration, and radiant losses. High efficiency doors have
exceptional thermal insulation properties and tight-fitting, weather-stripping
on the doorframe to reduce air leakage.
HVAC (All) Windows - High
Efficiency
High-efficiency windows, such as those labeled under the ENERGY STAR
Program, are designed to reduce a building's energy bill while increasing
comfort for the occupants at the same time. High-efficiency windows have
reducing properties that reduce the amount of heat transfer through the
glazing surface. For example, some windows have a low-E coating, which is a
thin film of metallic oxide coating on the glass surface that allows passage of
short-wave solar energy through glass and prevents long-wave energy from
escaping. Another example is double-pane glass that reduces conductive and
convective heat transfer. There are also double-pane glasses that are gas-filled
(usually argon) to further increase the insulating properties of the window.
HVAC (All) Roof - High
Reflectivity
The color and material of a building structure surface will determine the
amount of solar radiation absorbed by that surface and subsequently
transferred into a building. This is called solar absorptance. By using a living
roof or a roofing material with a light color (and a lower solar absorptance), the
roof will absorb less solar radiation and consequently reduce the cooling load.
Living roofs also reduce stormwater runoff.
Cooling
Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature
Reset
Resetting the condenser water temperature to the lowest possible setting
allows the cooling tower to generate cooler water whenever possible and
decreases the temperature lift between the condenser and the evaporator.
This will generally increase chiller part-load efficiency, though it may require
increased tower fan energy use.
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-6 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
Cooling Chiller - Economizer
Economizers allow outside air (when it is cool and dry enough) to be brought
into the building space to meet cooling loads instead of using mechanically
cooled interior air. A dual enthalpy economizer consists of indoor and outdoor
temperature and humidity sensors, dampers, motors, and motor controls.
Economizers are most applicable to temperate climates and savings will be
smaller in extremely hot or humid areas.
Cooling Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage
This measure uses energy at off-peak times to create a chilled media, typically
cool water or ice, and then stores it in an insulated chamber until peak hours.
During peak hours, it uses the cooling energy stored in the media by running
the chiller loop through a heat exchanger in the thermal storage chamber,
thereby reducing energy and peak demand from the grid.
Cooling Chiller - VSD on Fans Variable speed drives, which reduce chiller energy use under part load, are
modeled for both air-cooled and water-cooled chillers.
Cooling Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset
Chilled water reset controls save energy by improving chiller performance
through increasing the supply chilled water temperature, which allows
increased suction pressure during low load periods. Raising the chilled water
temperature also reduces chilled water piping losses. However, the primary
savings from the chilled water reset measure results from chiller efficiency
improvement. This is due partly to the smaller temperature difference
between chilled water and ambient air, and partly due to the sensitivity of
chiller performance to suction temperature.
Cooling
Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow
System
The part-load efficiency of chilled water loops can be improved substantially by
varying the flow speed of the delivered water with the building demand for
cooling.
Cooling
Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans
High-efficiency cooling fans utilize efficient components and variable frequency
drives that improve fan performance by adjusting fan speed and rotation as
conditions change.
Cooling Chiller -
Maintenance
Filters, coils, and fins require regular cleaning and maintenance for the heat
pump or roof top unit to function effectively and efficiently throughout its
years of service. Neglecting necessary maintenance leads to a steady decline in
performance while energy use increases.
Water
Heating
Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery
Capturing the waste heat from the cooling tower of a chiller by means of a heat
exchanger in order to meet water heating loads.
Cooling RTU - Evaporative
Precooler
Evaporative precooling can improve the performance of air conditioning
systems, most commonly RTUs. These systems typically use indirect
evaporative cooling as a first stage to pre-cool outside air. If the evaporative
system cannot meet the full cooling load, the air steam is further cooled with
conventional refrigerative air conditioning technology.
Cooling RTU - Maintenance
Regular cleaning and maintenance enables a roof top unit to function
effectively and efficiently throughout its years of service. Neglecting necessary
maintenance leads to a steady decline in performance while energy use
increases. Maintenance can increase the efficiency of poorly performing
equipment by as much as 10%.
Heating Space Heating - Heat
Recovery Ventilator
Heat recovery ventilation uses a counter-flow, air-to-air heat exchanger
between inbound and outbound air flow to selectively transfer heat and reduce
space heating loads.
Cooling /
Heating
Heat Pump -
Maintenance
Regular cleaning and maintenance enables a heat pump to function effectively
and efficiently throughout its years of service. Neglecting necessary
maintenance leads to a steady decline in performance while energy use
increases. Maintenance can increase the efficiency of poorly performing
equipment by as much as 10%.
Ventilation Ventilation - ECM on
VAV Boxes
ECM motors are well suited to the variable flow rates of VAV boxes. ECMs are a
higher efficiency option for the air blowers and maintain efficiency better over
a wide range of loads.
Ventilation Ventilation - Variable Variable speed controls adjust ventilation fans for part-load conditions to
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-7
End Use Measure Description
Speed Control reduce energy use.
Ventilation Ventilation – CO2
Controlled
Ventilation air is controlled and supplied as needed by measuring the
concentration of carbon dioxide in the space, which correlates with occupancy
levels.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Drainwater Heat
Recovery
Drainwater Heat Recovery is a system in which drain water is used to preheat
cold water entering the water heater. While these systems themselves are
relatively inexpensive, upgrading an existing system could be unreasonable
because of demolition costs. Thus they are modeled for new vintage only.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles
A faucet aerator or low flow nozzle spreads the stream from a faucet helping to
reduce water usage. The amount of water passing through the aerator is
measured in gallons per minute (GPM) and the lower the GPM the more water
the aerator conserves.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - High
Efficiency Circulation
Pump
A high efficiency circulation pump uses an electronically commutated motor
(ECM) to improve motor efficiency over a larger range of partial loads. In
addition, an ECM allows for improved low RPM performance with greater
torque and smaller pump dimensions.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Desuperheater
A desuperheater can be added to an existing geothermal heat pump system
(typically installed with the primary function of space heating and cooling) in
order to draw off a portion of the geothermal heat for water heating purposes.
The system can either supplement the building's water heater, or be a full-
demand water heater that meets all of the building's hot water needs.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - Solar
System
Solar water heating systems can be used in residential buildings that have an
appropriate near-south-facing roof or nearby unshaded grounds for installing a
collector. Although system types vary, in general these systems use a solar
absorber surface within a solar collector or an actual storage tank. Either a
heat-transfer fluid or the actual potable water flows through tubes attached to
the absorber and transfers heat from it. (Systems with a separate heat-
transfer-fluid loop include a heat exchanger that then heats the potable water.)
The heated water is stored in a separate preheat tank or a conventional water
heater tank. If additional heat is needed, it is provided by a conventional
water-heating system.
Water
Heating
Water Heater -
Install Timer
These measures use either a programmable thermostat or a timer to adjust the
water heater setpoint at times of low usage, typically when a home is
unoccupied.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - Pipe
Insulation
Insulating hot water pipes decreases the amount of energy lost during
distribution of hot water throughout the building. Insulating pipes will result in
quicker delivery of hot water and allows lowering the water heating set point.
There are several different types of insulation, the most common being
polyethylene and neoprene.
Water
Heating
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation
Insulation levels on hot water heaters can be increased by installing a fiberglass
blanket on the outside of the tank. This increase in insulation reduces standby
losses and thus saves energy. Water heater insulation is available either by the
blanket or by square foot of fiberglass insulation with R-values ranging from 5
to 14.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Daylighting Controls
Daylighting controls use a photosensor to detect ambient light and adjust or
turn off electric lights accordingly.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
LED Exit Lighting
The lamps inside exit signs represent a significant energy end-use, since they
usually operate 24 hours per day. Many old exit signs use incandescent lamps,
which consume approximately 40 watts per sign. The incandescent lamps can
be replaced with LED lamps that are specially designed for this specific
purpose. In comparison, the LED lamps consume approximately 2-5 watts.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Occupancy Sensors
The installation of occupancy sensors allows lights to be turned off during
periods when a space is unoccupied, virtually eliminating the wasted energy
due to lights being left on. There are several types of occupancy sensors in the
market.
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-8 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Timeclocks and
Timers
In many cases lighting remains on at night and during weekends. A simple
timer can set a schedule for turning lights off to reduce operating hours.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Task Lighting
Individual work areas can use task lighting instead of brightly lighting the entire
area. Significant energy savings can be realized by focusing light directly where
it is needed and lowering the general lighting level. An example of task lighting
is the common desk lamp. A 25W desk lamp can be installed in place of a
typical lamp in a fixture.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Fluorescent -
Bi-Level Fixture
Bi-level fixtures have the ability to reduce light output to a lower level, given a
control strategy that is based on a timer, occupancy sensor, motion sensor, or
manual switch.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Fluorescent -
Delamp and Install
Reflectors
While sometimes included in lighting retrofit projects, delamping is often
performed as a separate energy efficiency measure in which a lighting engineer
analyzes the lighting provided by current systems compared to the
requirements of building occupants. This often leads to the removal of
unnecessary lamps corresponding to an overall reduction in energy usage. In
addition, installing a reflector in each fixture can improve light distribution
from the remaining lamps.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting - Bi-
Level Fixture
Bi-level fixtures have the ability to reduce light output to a lower level, given a
control strategy that is based on a timer, occupancy sensor, motion sensor, or
manual switch.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Daylighting Controls
Daylighting controls use a photosensor to detect ambient light and adjust or
turn off electric lights accordingly.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Photovoltaic
Installation
Solar photovoltaic generation may be used to power exterior lighting and thus
eliminate all or part of the electrical energy use.
Refrigeration Refrigerator - Anti-
Sweat Heater
Anti-sweat heaters are used in virtually all low-temperature display cases and
many medium-temperature cases to control humidity and prevent the
condensation of water vapor on the sides and doors and on the products
contained in the cases. Typically, these heaters stay on all the time, even
though they only need to be on about half the time. Anti-sweat heater controls
can come in the form of humidity sensors or time clocks.
Refrigeration Refrigerator -
Decommissioning
Early retirement, removal, and recycling or older, little used refrigerators and
freezers removes the energy use of these inefficient, aging units.
Refrigeration Refrigerator -
Demand Defrost
Units can be designed to perform at higher efficiency with a sensing and
control system that runs defrost cycles based on demand/only when necessary.
Refrigeration Refrigerator - Door
Gasket Replacement
This measure involves replacing aging door gaskets that no longer adequately
seal reach-in refrigerators or glass door display cases.
Refrigeration
Refrigerator -
Evaporator Fan
Controls
Evaporator fan motor controls allow for part load use or demand scheduling
based on variable refrigeration load requirements, reducing energy
consumption.
Refrigeration
Refrigerator -
Floating Head
Pressure
Floating head pressure control allows the pressure in the condenser to "float"
with ambient temperatures. This method reduces refrigeration compression
ratios, improves system efficiency and extends the compressor life. The
greatest savings with a floating head pressure approach occurs when the
ambient temperatures are low, such as in the winter season. Floating head
pressure control is most practical for new installations. However, retrofits
installation can be completed with some existing refrigeration systems.
Installing floating head pressure control increases the capacity of the
compressor when temperatures are low, which may lead to short cycling.
Refrigeration Refrigerator - Strip
Curtain
Strip curtains at the entrances to large walk-in coolers or freezers, such as
those used in supermarkets, reduce air transfer between the refrigerated space
and the surrounding space.
Refrigeration Refrigerator - High
Efficiency
Standard compressors typically operate at approximately 65% efficiency. High-
efficiency models are available that can improve compressor efficiency by 15%.
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-9
End Use Measure Description
Compressor
Refrigeration
Refrigerator -
Variable Speed
Compressor
The part-load efficiency of drive systems can be improved by varying the speed
of the motor drive. An additional benefit of variable-speed controls is the
ability to start and stop the motor and process gradually, thus extending the
life of the motor and associated machinery.
Refrigeration
Refrigerator – Food
Temperature
Simulant
This device consists of a solid, waxy food simulant that is fitted around a
thermostat sensor that would otherwise measure air temperature. The
refrigeration controls therefore attempt to regulate the temperature of food,
which changes more slowly and gradually than air, thereby reducing the
frequency of refrigeration cycles.
Refrigeration Vending Machine -
Controller
Cold beverage vending machines usually operate 24 hours a day regardless of
whether the surrounding area is occupied or not. The result is that the vending
machine consumes energy unnecessarily, because it will operate all night to
keep the beverage cold even when there would be no customers until the next
morning. A vending machine controller can reduce energy consumption
without compromising the temperature of the vended product. The controller
uses an infrared sensor to monitor the surrounding area's occupancy and will
power down the vending machine when the area is unoccupied. It will also
monitor the room's temperature and will re-power the machine at one to three
hour intervals independent of occupancy to ensure that the product stays cold.
Office
Equipment
Office Equipment -
ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies
Power supplies with an efficient ac-dc or ac-ac conversion process can obtain
the ENERGY STAR label. These devices can be used to power computers,
phones, and other office equipment.
Office
Equipment
Office Equipment -
Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors
Occupancy sensors can control power strips and thus turn off energy used by
plug loads, such as task lights, when an office is unoccupied.
Miscellaneous Pool Heater - Solar This measure replaces a conventional pool heater with a solar system.
Miscellaneous Pool Pump - Timer A pool pump timer allows the pump to turn off automatically, eliminating the
wasted energy associated with unnecessary pumping.
Miscellaneous
Non-HVAC Motors -
Variable Speed
Control
The part-load efficiency of motors can be improved by varying the speed of the
motor drive. There are two major types of variable speed controls: mechanical
and electronic. An additional benefit of variable-speed controls is the ability to
start and stop the motor gradually, thus extending the life of the motor and
associated machinery. This analysis assumes that electronic variable speed
controls are installed.
HVAC (All) Energy Management
System
An energy management system (EMS) allows managers/owners to monitor and
control the major energy-consuming systems within a commercial building. At
the minimum, the EMS can be used to monitor and record energy consumption
of the different end-uses in a building, and can control operation schedules of
the HVAC and lighting systems. The monitoring function helps building
managers/owners to identify systems that are operating inefficiently so that
actions can be taken to correct the problem. The EMS can also provide
preventive maintenance scheduling that will reduce the cost of operations and
maintenance in the long run. The control functionality of the EMS allows the
building manager/owner to operate building systems from one central
location. The operation schedules set via the EMS help to prevent building
systems from operating during unwanted or unoccupied periods. This analysis
assumes that this measure is limited to buildings with a central HVAC system.
HVAC (All) Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable
A programmable thermostat can be added to most heating/cooling systems.
They are typically used during winter to lower temperatures at night and in
summer to increase temperatures during the afternoon. There are two-setting
models, and well as models that allow separate programming for each day of
the week. The energy savings from this type of thermostat are identical to
those of a "setback" strategy with standard thermostats, but the convenience
of a programmable thermostat makes it a much more attractive option. In this
analysis, the baseline is assumed to have no thermostat setback.
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-10 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
HVAC,
Lighting
HVAC - Occupancy
Sensors
Occupancy sensors turn off or adjust HVAC settings when a space is
unoccupied.
HVAC,
Lighting
Retrocommissioning
- HVAC, Lighting
In existing buildings, the retrocommissioning process identifies low-cost or no
cost measures, including controls adjustments, to improve building
performance and reduce operating costs. Retrocommissioning addresses
HVAC, lighting, DHW, and other major building systems.
Ventilation
Cooking – Exhaust
Hoods with Sensor
Control
Improved exhaust hoods involve installing variable-speed controls on
commercial kitchen hoods. These controls provide ventilation based on actual
cooking loads. When grills, broilers, stoves, fryers or other kitchen appliances
are not being used, the controls automatically sense the reduced load and
decrease the fan speed accordingly. This results in lower energy consumption
because the system is only running as needed rather than at 100% capacity at
all times.

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-11
Table C-3 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Small Office, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.73 $0.33 20 1.04 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.88 $0.43 20 1.05 $0.044
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.82 $0.53 20 1.19 $0.026
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.93 $0.63 20 1.19 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 1.18 $0.13 20 1.16 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1.34 $0.26 20 1.16 $0.017
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.58 $0.32 20 1.19 $0.018
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.89 $0.49 20 1.20 $0.023
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.97 $0.54 20 1.21 $0.024
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 2.13 $0.60 20 1.22 $0.025
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.58 $0.46 16 - $0.078
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.16 $0.88 16 1.00 $0.075
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.51 $1.68 16 0.93 $0.110
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 2.27 $5.52 16 0.67 $0.241
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.73 $0.69 16 - $0.093
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 1.30 $1.00 16 1.00 $0.077
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.66 $3.09 16 0.91 $0.184
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.94 $5.17 16 0.87 $0.263
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.96 $0.00 16 0.75 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.14 $0.34 16 0.98 $0.246
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.62 $0.48 16 0.90 $0.030
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.42 $2.23 15 0.87 $0.550
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 1.06 $11.14 15 0.57 $1.076
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.17 $0.69 14 0.89 $0.419
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.41 $1.00 14 0.86 $0.260
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.49 $3.09 14 0.63 $0.679
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.66 $5.17 14 0.49 $0.840
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.09 $0.34 16 - $0.356
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.13 $0.48 16 1.00 $0.357
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-12 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.16 $1.24 16 0.91 $0.792
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.16 $1.62 16 0.87 $1.004
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.13 $3.11 16 0.75 $2.397
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.15 16 0.98 $0.336
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.56 $1.36 16 0.90 $0.086
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 2.43 -$0.04 10 1.61 -$0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.00 $0.028
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.48 $0.01 15 1.96 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.54 $0.01 15 2.21 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.55 $0.01 15 2.29 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.11 $0.05 4 - $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.70 $0.07 4 1.36 $0.012
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.18 $0.04 4 3.06 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 3.44 $1.15 4 0.45 $0.092
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.95 $0.32 4 - $0.023
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.13 $0.26 6 0.24 $0.387
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.13 -$0.01 6 1.91 -$0.010
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.14 $0.00 6 1.62 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.16 $0.00 6 1.69 $0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.17 $0.00 6 2.17 -$0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.25 $0.07 6 - $0.052
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.85 $3.86 10 0.25 $0.607
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.88 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.22 $0.03 10 1.48 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.42 $0.04 10 1.58 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.58 $1.07 10 - $0.055
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.08 $0.00 4 - $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.13 $0.01 4 1.33 $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.24 $0.00 4 2.96 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.26 $0.09 4 0.41 $0.092
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-13
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.30 $0.02 4 - $0.023
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.20 $0.93 6 0.16 $0.902
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.21 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.007
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.33 $0.00 6 1.56 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.33 $0.03 6 1.19 $0.019
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.34 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.62 $0.25 6 - $0.079
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.02 $0.10 10 0.23 $0.607
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.02 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.03 $0.00 10 1.47 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.04 $0.00 10 1.56 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.06 $0.03 10 - $0.055
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 0.95 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.04 12 0.90 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.04 12 0.90 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.05 12 0.97 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.03 $0.02 10 0.97 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.05 $0.06 10 0.82 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.03 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.05 $0.01 10 1.09 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-14 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.09 $0.02 10 1.09 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.27 $0.01 12 1.29 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.39 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.18 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.13 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.05 $0.03 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.04 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.05 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-15
Table C-4 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Small Office, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.66 $0.43 20 1.02 $0.058
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.79 $0.56 20 1.01 $0.063
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.64 $0.69 20 1.12 $0.037
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.74 $0.82 20 1.11 $0.042
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 1.07 $0.18 20 1.13 $0.015
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1.21 $0.36 20 1.11 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.42 $0.43 20 1.13 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.71 $0.66 20 1.13 $0.034
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.78 $0.73 20 1.13 $0.036
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.92 $0.81 20 1.14 $0.037
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.55 $0.48 16 - $0.085
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.11 $0.92 16 1.00 $0.082
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.45 $1.76 16 0.93 $0.120
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 2.17 $5.78 16 0.65 $0.263
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.52 $0.50 16 - $0.094
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.83 $0.71 16 1.00 $0.085
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.10 $1.83 16 0.91 $0.165
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.21 $2.39 16 0.87 $0.196
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.84 $4.57 16 0.77 $0.246
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.33 16 0.98 $0.857
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.34 $2.97 16 0.90 $0.219
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.39 $1.70 15 0.88 $0.450
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.99 $8.51 15 0.58 $0.882
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.16 $0.71 14 0.88 $0.464
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.38 $1.03 14 0.85 $0.288
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.45 $3.18 14 0.61 $0.751
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.61 $5.32 14 0.48 $0.929
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.31 $0.31 16 - $0.098
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.53 $0.44 16 1.00 $0.082
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-16 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.76 $1.14 16 0.91 $0.149
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.85 $1.49 16 0.87 $0.172
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.53 $2.85 16 0.77 $0.184
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.17 16 0.98 $0.416
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.44 $1.54 16 0.90 $0.106
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 2.22 -$0.03 10 1.63 -$0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.00 $0.025
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.45 $0.01 15 1.97 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.51 $0.01 15 2.23 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.52 $0.01 15 2.31 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.11 $0.05 4 - $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.70 $0.07 4 1.36 $0.012
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.18 $0.04 4 3.06 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 3.44 $1.15 4 0.45 $0.092
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.95 $0.32 4 - $0.023
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.33 $0.93 6 0.24 $0.549
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.34 -$0.01 6 1.91 -$0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.47 $0.00 6 1.62 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.49 $0.03 6 1.69 $0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.51 $0.00 6 2.17 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.87 $0.25 6 - $0.057
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.87 $0.10 10 0.25 $0.015
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.90 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.25 $0.00 10 1.48 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.45 $0.00 10 1.58 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.64 $0.03 10 - $0.001
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.08 $0.00 4 - $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.13 $0.01 4 1.33 $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.24 $0.00 4 2.96 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.26 $0.09 4 0.41 $0.092
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-17
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.30 $0.02 4 - $0.023
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.20 $0.93 6 0.16 $0.902
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.21 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.007
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.33 $0.00 6 1.56 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.33 $0.03 6 1.19 $0.019
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.34 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.62 $0.25 6 - $0.079
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.02 $0.10 10 0.23 $0.607
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.02 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.03 $0.00 10 1.47 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.04 $0.00 10 1.56 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.06 $0.03 10 - $0.055
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 0.95 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.04 12 0.90 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.04 12 0.90 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.05 12 0.97 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.03 $0.02 10 0.97 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.05 $0.06 10 0.82 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.03 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.05 $0.01 10 1.09 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-18 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.09 $0.02 10 1.09 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.27 $0.01 12 1.29 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.39 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.18 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.13 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.05 $0.03 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.04 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.05 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-19
Table C-5 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Large Office, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.65 $0.26 20 1.05 $0.035
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.78 $0.34 20 1.06 $0.038
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.62 $0.41 20 1.21 $0.022
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.72 $0.49 20 1.21 $0.025
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.96 $0.09 20 1.16 $0.008
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1.09 $0.19 20 1.17 $0.015
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.28 $0.22 20 1.20 $0.015
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.54 $0.35 20 1.22 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.61 $0.38 20 1.23 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.73 $0.42 20 1.25 $0.021
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.43 $0.32 16 - $0.075
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.86 $0.62 16 1.00 $0.072
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.13 $1.20 16 0.93 $0.105
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.69 $3.94 16 0.67 $0.230
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.41 $0.37 16 - $0.089
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.66 $0.54 16 1.00 $0.081
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.88 $1.38 16 0.91 $0.156
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.96 $1.80 16 0.87 $0.185
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.47 $3.45 16 0.75 $0.233
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.25 16 0.98 $0.773
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.11 $2.21 16 0.91 $0.197
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.31 $1.59 15 0.87 $0.524
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.79 $7.95 15 0.57 $1.027
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.13 $0.51 14 0.89 $0.419
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.31 $0.75 14 0.86 $0.260
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.36 $2.31 14 0.62 $0.679
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.49 $3.87 14 0.49 $0.840
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.08 $0.27 16 - $0.356
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.11 $0.39 16 1.00 $0.357
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-20 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.13 $1.00 16 0.91 $0.792
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.13 $1.31 16 0.87 $1.004
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.10 $2.50 16 0.75 $2.397
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.02 16 0.98 $0.053
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.29 $0.18 16 0.91 $0.014
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 3.03 -$0.08 10 1.41 -$0.003
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.028
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.53 $0.01 15 1.98 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.59 $0.01 15 2.25 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.61 $0.01 15 2.33 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.86 $0.03 4 - $0.011
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.32 $0.05 4 1.48 $0.010
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.47 $0.03 4 3.43 $0.003
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2.67 $0.71 4 0.74 $0.073
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.07 $0.20 4 - $0.018
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.05 $0.08 6 0.35 $0.308
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.05 $0.00 6 1.85 -$0.008
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.05 $0.00 6 1.70 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.06 $0.00 6 1.85 $0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.06 $0.00 6 2.19 -$0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.09 $0.02 6 - $0.042
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.12 $4.07 10 0.36 $0.482
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 1.17 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.62 $0.03 10 1.51 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.88 $0.04 10 1.63 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 3.42 $1.13 10 - $0.044
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.07 $0.00 4 - $0.011
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.10 $0.00 4 1.39 $0.010
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.19 $0.00 4 3.17 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.20 $0.05 4 0.51 $0.073
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-21
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.23 $0.02 4 - $0.018
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.12 $0.42 6 0.19 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.12 $0.00 6 1.37 -$0.005
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.19 $0.00 6 1.58 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.19 $0.01 6 1.26 $0.015
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.19 $0.00 6 1.58 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.36 $0.11 6 - $0.063
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.01 $0.03 10 0.28 $0.482
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.01 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.01 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.01 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.02 $0.01 10 - $0.044
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.94 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.94 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.04 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.02 12 0.88 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 0.85 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.11 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-22 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.14 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.09 $0.01 12 1.13 $0.021
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.97 $0.00 12 1.03 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.10 $0.00 12 1.34 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.07 $0.01 12 1.26 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.95 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.15 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.11 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.11 $0.00 6 1.08 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.02 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-23
Table C-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Large Office, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.59 $0.38 20 1.02 $0.056
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.71 $0.49 20 1.01 $0.061
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.48 $0.61 20 1.12 $0.036
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.57 $0.72 20 1.11 $0.040
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.81 $0.13 20 1.13 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.92 $0.26 20 1.11 $0.025
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.08 $0.31 20 1.13 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.30 $0.49 20 1.13 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.35 $0.54 20 1.13 $0.035
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.46 $0.59 20 1.14 $0.036
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.41 $0.38 16 - $0.093
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.81 $0.74 16 1.00 $0.089
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.06 $1.41 16 0.92 $0.131
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.60 $4.64 16 0.64 $0.287
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.39 $0.37 16 - $0.094
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.62 $0.53 16 1.00 $0.085
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.82 $1.37 16 0.91 $0.165
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.90 $1.78 16 0.88 $0.196
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.38 $3.42 16 0.77 $0.246
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.26 16 0.98 $0.936
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.99 $2.38 16 0.89 $0.239
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.29 $1.40 15 0.88 $0.492
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.75 $7.02 15 0.57 $0.963
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.12 $0.53 14 0.88 $0.464
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.29 $0.77 14 0.85 $0.288
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.34 $2.38 14 0.61 $0.751
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.46 $3.98 14 0.47 $0.929
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.25 $0.25 16 - $0.098
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.43 $0.36 16 1.00 $0.082
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-24 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.61 $0.92 16 0.91 $0.149
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.69 $1.20 16 0.88 $0.172
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.23 $2.30 16 0.77 $0.184
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.02 16 0.98 $0.052
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.15 $0.15 16 0.89 $0.013
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 2.64 -$0.07 10 1.39 -$0.003
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.025
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.52 $0.01 15 1.99 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.58 $0.01 15 2.26 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.60 $0.01 15 2.35 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.86 $0.03 4 - $0.011
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.32 $0.05 4 1.48 $0.010
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.47 $0.03 4 3.43 $0.003
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2.67 $0.71 4 0.74 $0.073
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.07 $0.20 4 - $0.018
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.05 $0.08 6 0.35 $0.308
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.05 $0.00 6 1.85 -$0.008
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.05 $0.00 6 1.70 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.06 $0.00 6 1.85 $0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.06 $0.00 6 2.19 -$0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.09 $0.02 6 - $0.042
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.12 $4.07 10 0.36 $0.482
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 1.17 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.62 $0.03 10 1.51 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.88 $0.04 10 1.63 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 3.42 $1.13 10 - $0.044
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.07 $0.00 4 - $0.011
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.10 $0.00 4 1.39 $0.010
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.19 $0.00 4 3.17 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.20 $0.05 4 0.51 $0.073
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-25
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.23 $0.02 4 - $0.018
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.12 $0.42 6 0.19 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.12 $0.00 6 1.37 -$0.005
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.19 $0.00 6 1.58 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.19 $0.01 6 1.26 $0.015
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.19 $0.00 6 1.58 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.36 $0.11 6 - $0.063
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.01 $0.03 10 0.28 $0.482
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.01 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.01 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.01 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.02 $0.01 10 - $0.044
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.94 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.94 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.04 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.02 12 0.88 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 0.85 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.11 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-26 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.14 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.10 $0.00 12 1.34 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.07 $0.01 12 1.26 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.95 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.15 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.11 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.11 $0.00 6 1.08 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.02 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.74 $0.24 15 1.00 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.89 $0.32 15 1.00 $0.037
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 1.03 $0.09 15 1.00 $0.009
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-27
Table C-7 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Restaurant, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.74 $0.24 20 1.08 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.89 $0.32 20 1.10 $0.032
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.85 $0.39 20 1.29 $0.019
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.96 $0.46 20 1.30 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 1.03 $0.09 20 1.19 $0.008
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1.17 $0.18 20 1.20 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.37 $0.22 20 1.24 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.65 $0.33 20 1.28 $0.018
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.72 $0.37 20 1.29 $0.019
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.86 $0.41 20 1.32 $0.019
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.69 $0.38 16 - $0.055
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.39 $0.74 16 1.00 $0.053
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.81 $1.42 16 0.97 $0.077
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 2.72 $4.64 16 0.77 $0.169
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.64 $0.30 16 - $0.046
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 1.02 $0.42 16 1.00 $0.041
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.35 $1.09 16 0.96 $0.080
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.48 $1.42 16 0.94 $0.095
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 2.26 $2.72 16 0.89 $0.119
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.05 $0.20 16 0.99 $0.416
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.71 $1.83 16 1.02 $0.106
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.50 $1.05 15 0.94 $0.216
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 1.27 $5.25 15 0.69 $0.423
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.22 $0.28 14 0.98 $0.141
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.51 $0.41 14 1.00 $0.087
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.60 $1.28 14 0.86 $0.228
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.81 $2.14 14 0.77 $0.282
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.21 $0.30 16 - $0.145
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.32 $0.44 16 1.00 $0.134
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-28 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.42 $1.12 16 0.96 $0.266
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.45 $1.47 16 0.94 $0.320
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.62 $2.81 16 0.89 $0.449
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.15 16 0.99 $0.494
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.07 $1.37 16 1.02 $0.126
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 5.17 -$0.06 10 1.95 -$0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.07 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.019
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 3.59 $0.03 15 2.00 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 4.03 $0.04 15 2.28 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 4.15 $0.04 15 2.37 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.81 $0.06 4 - $0.009
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.77 $0.08 4 1.50 $0.008
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 5.19 $0.05 4 3.49 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 5.62 $1.21 4 0.81 $0.060
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 6.46 $0.34 4 - $0.015
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.06 $0.07 6 0.38 $0.251
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.06 $0.00 6 1.84 -$0.007
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.71 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.87 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.20 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.11 $0.02 6 - $0.034
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.31 $0.90 10 0.39 $0.394
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.32 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.44 $0.01 10 1.51 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.51 $0.01 10 1.63 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.93 $0.25 10 - $0.036
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.10 $0.00 4 - $0.009
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.15 $0.00 4 1.44 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.28 $0.00 4 3.30 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.31 $0.07 4 0.61 $0.060
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-29
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.35 $0.02 4 - $0.015
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.43 $1.27 6 0.22 $0.586
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.44 -$0.01 6 1.37 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.69 $0.00 6 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.69 $0.04 6 1.31 $0.012
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.72 $0.00 6 1.60 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 1.31 $0.35 6 - $0.052
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.01 10 0.33 $0.394
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.50 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.61 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.01 $0.00 10 - $0.036
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.71 $0.28 12 1.01 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.86 $0.35 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 1.04 $0.63 12 0.96 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.13 $0.08 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.24 $0.15 12 0.93 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.26 $0.16 12 0.93 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.43 $0.17 12 1.02 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.52 $0.34 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 1.13 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 1.43 $0.34 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.22 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.23 $0.16 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.41 $0.16 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.09 $0.04 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.12 $0.06 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.18 $0.20 10 0.84 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.07 $0.01 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.19 $0.02 10 1.11 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-30 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.32 $0.06 10 1.13 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.97 $0.00 12 1.12 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.61 $0.13 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 2.40 $0.11 12 1.31 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 1.62 $0.37 12 1.19 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.08 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.06 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.09 $0.01 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.12 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.15 $0.01 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-31
Table C-8 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Restaurant, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.69 $0.36 20 1.05 $0.046
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.83 $0.47 20 1.06 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.73 $0.58 20 1.22 $0.030
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.83 $0.69 20 1.22 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.94 $0.14 20 1.16 $0.013
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1.06 $0.27 20 1.15 $0.023
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.25 $0.33 20 1.19 $0.023
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.50 $0.51 20 1.20 $0.030
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.56 $0.56 20 1.21 $0.032
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.69 $0.62 20 1.22 $0.032
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.64 $0.48 16 - $0.075
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.29 $0.93 16 1.00 $0.072
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.68 $1.79 16 0.95 $0.105
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 2.52 $5.87 16 0.71 $0.230
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.60 $0.45 16 - $0.075
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.96 $0.65 16 1.00 $0.067
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.27 $1.67 16 0.93 $0.130
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.39 $2.18 16 0.90 $0.155
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 2.12 $4.18 16 0.80 $0.195
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.29 16 0.98 $0.678
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.52 $2.65 16 0.93 $0.173
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.48 $0.92 15 0.94 $0.199
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 1.21 $4.61 15 0.70 $0.390
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.20 $0.26 14 0.98 $0.139
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.48 $0.38 14 1.00 $0.086
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.56 $1.18 14 0.87 $0.225
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.76 $1.97 14 0.78 $0.278
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.21 $0.30 16 - $0.142
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.32 $0.43 16 1.00 $0.131
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-32 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.42 $1.09 16 0.93 $0.258
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.45 $1.43 16 0.90 $0.310
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.64 $2.73 16 0.80 $0.425
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 6.20 -$0.06 16 0.98 -$0.001
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.96 $0.00 16 0.93 $0.000
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 6.18 -$0.06 10 2.14 -$0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.07 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.019
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 3.59 $0.03 15 2.00 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 4.03 $0.04 15 2.28 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 4.15 $0.04 15 2.37 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.81 $0.06 4 - $0.009
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.77 $0.08 4 1.50 $0.008
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 5.19 $0.05 4 3.49 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 5.62 $1.21 4 0.81 $0.060
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 6.46 $0.34 4 - $0.015
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.06 $0.07 6 0.38 $0.251
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.06 $0.00 6 1.84 -$0.007
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.71 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.87 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.20 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.11 $0.02 6 - $0.034
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.31 $0.90 10 0.39 $0.394
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.32 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.44 $0.01 10 1.51 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.51 $0.01 10 1.63 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.93 $0.25 10 - $0.036
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.10 $0.00 4 - $0.009
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.15 $0.00 4 1.44 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.28 $0.00 4 3.30 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.31 $0.07 4 0.61 $0.060
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-33
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.35 $0.02 4 - $0.015
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.43 $1.27 6 0.22 $0.586
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.44 -$0.01 6 1.37 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.69 $0.00 6 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.69 $0.04 6 1.31 $0.012
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.72 $0.00 6 1.60 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 1.31 $0.35 6 - $0.052
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.01 10 0.33 $0.394
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.50 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.61 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.01 $0.00 10 - $0.036
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.71 $0.28 12 1.01 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.86 $0.35 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 1.04 $0.63 12 0.96 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.13 $0.08 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.24 $0.15 12 0.93 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.26 $0.16 12 0.93 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.43 $0.17 12 1.02 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.52 $0.34 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 1.13 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 1.43 $0.34 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.22 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.23 $0.16 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.41 $0.16 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.09 $0.04 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.12 $0.06 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.18 $0.20 10 0.84 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.07 $0.01 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.19 $0.02 10 1.11 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-34 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.32 $0.06 10 1.13 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.97 $0.00 12 1.12 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.61 $0.13 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 2.40 $0.11 12 1.31 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 1.62 $0.37 12 1.19 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.08 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.06 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.09 $0.01 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.12 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.15 $0.01 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-35
Table C-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Retail, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.48 $0.11 20 1.10 $0.020
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.58 $0.14 20 1.12 $0.022
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.20 $0.18 20 1.33 $0.013
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.27 $0.21 20 1.35 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.67 $0.04 20 1.20 $0.006
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.76 $0.08 20 1.21 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.89 $0.10 20 1.26 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.07 $0.16 20 1.31 $0.013
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.11 $0.17 20 1.32 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.20 $0.19 20 1.36 $0.014
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.46 $0.15 16 - $0.033
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.92 $0.29 16 1.00 $0.031
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.20 $0.56 16 0.99 $0.046
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.80 $1.83 16 0.85 $0.100
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.44 $0.29 16 - $0.066
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.70 $0.42 16 1.00 $0.060
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.93 $1.09 16 0.94 $0.115
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.02 $1.42 16 0.91 $0.137
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.56 $2.71 16 0.82 $0.172
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.11 16 0.99 $0.338
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.18 $1.03 16 1.10 $0.086
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.33 $0.74 15 0.93 $0.229
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.85 $3.69 15 0.66 $0.448
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.14 $0.18 14 0.97 $0.141
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.33 $0.27 14 0.99 $0.087
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.39 $0.82 14 0.85 $0.228
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.52 $1.38 14 0.75 $0.282
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.08 $0.50 16 - $0.659
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.10 $0.72 16 1.00 $0.706
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-36 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.11 $1.85 16 0.94 $1.678
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.11 $2.42 16 0.91 $2.216
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.04 $4.63 16 0.82 $12.821
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.29 16 0.99 $0.712
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.40 $2.58 16 1.10 $0.182
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.85 -$0.03 10 1.28 -$0.005
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.46 $0.00 15 1.99 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.51 $0.01 15 2.26 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.53 $0.01 15 2.35 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.38 $0.06 4 - $0.012
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.12 $0.08 4 1.41 $0.011
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.97 $0.05 4 3.21 $0.003
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.30 $1.26 4 0.55 $0.081
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 4.94 $0.35 4 - $0.020
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.18 $0.31 6 0.28 $0.340
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.18 -$0.01 6 1.88 -$0.009
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.20 $0.00 6 1.65 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.23 $0.00 6 1.75 $0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.23 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.34 $0.08 6 - $0.046
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.77 $3.07 10 0.29 $0.533
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.80 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.11 $0.02 10 1.49 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.28 $0.03 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.34 $0.85 10 - $0.049
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.48 $0.02 4 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.73 $0.03 4 1.36 $0.011
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.37 $0.02 4 3.08 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.49 $0.44 4 0.46 $0.081
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-37
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.71 $0.12 4 - $0.020
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.08 $0.34 6 0.18 $0.793
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.09 $0.00 6 1.37 -$0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.14 $0.00 6 1.57 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.13 $0.01 6 1.23 $0.017
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.14 $0.00 6 1.57 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.26 $0.09 6 - $0.070
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.01 10 0.26 $0.533
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.48 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.58 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.01 $0.00 10 - $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.017
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.16 $0.02 12 0.95 $0.013
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 0.96 $0.029
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.01 12 0.92 $0.027
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.05 12 0.91 $0.078
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.00 12 0.99 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.16 $0.04 12 0.86 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 18 0.94 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.03 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.04 $0.05 10 0.83 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.04 $0.00 10 1.09 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-38 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.07 $0.01 10 1.11 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.17 $0.01 12 1.30 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.11 $0.03 12 1.16 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-39
Table C-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Retail, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.44 $0.20 20 1.06 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.53 $0.26 20 1.06 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.10 $0.32 20 1.22 $0.026
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.17 $0.38 20 1.22 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.61 $0.08 20 1.16 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.69 $0.16 20 1.16 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.81 $0.19 20 1.19 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.98 $0.29 20 1.21 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.02 $0.32 20 1.21 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.10 $0.35 20 1.23 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.44 $0.20 16 - $0.044
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.88 $0.38 16 1.00 $0.042
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.15 $0.72 16 0.97 $0.062
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.72 $2.37 16 0.79 $0.136
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.40 $0.21 16 - $0.053
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.64 $0.31 16 1.00 $0.048
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.84 $0.79 16 0.96 $0.093
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.92 $1.03 16 0.93 $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.41 $1.97 16 0.88 $0.138
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.13 16 0.99 $0.446
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.04 $1.20 16 1.04 $0.114
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.32 $0.66 15 0.93 $0.213
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.81 $3.28 15 0.67 $0.416
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.13 $0.17 14 0.97 $0.139
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.31 $0.25 14 0.99 $0.086
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.36 $0.76 14 0.85 $0.225
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.49 $1.28 14 0.75 $0.278
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.15 $0.25 16 - $0.166
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.25 $0.35 16 1.00 $0.139
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-40 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.36 $0.91 16 0.96 $0.249
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.41 $1.19 16 0.93 $0.288
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.76 $2.27 16 0.88 $0.296
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.20 16 0.99 $0.520
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.36 $1.82 16 1.04 $0.133
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.57 -$0.03 10 1.20 -$0.006
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.46 $0.00 15 1.99 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.51 $0.01 15 2.27 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.53 $0.01 15 2.35 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.38 $0.06 4 - $0.012
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.12 $0.08 4 1.41 $0.011
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.97 $0.05 4 3.21 $0.003
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.30 $1.26 4 0.55 $0.081
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 4.94 $0.35 4 - $0.020
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.18 $0.31 6 0.28 $0.340
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.18 -$0.01 6 1.88 -$0.009
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.20 $0.00 6 1.65 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.23 $0.00 6 1.75 $0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.23 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.34 $0.08 6 - $0.046
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.77 $3.07 10 0.29 $0.533
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.80 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.11 $0.02 10 1.49 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.28 $0.03 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.34 $0.85 10 - $0.049
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.48 $0.02 4 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.73 $0.03 4 1.36 $0.011
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.37 $0.02 4 3.08 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.49 $0.44 4 0.46 $0.081
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-41
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.71 $0.12 4 - $0.020
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.08 $0.34 6 0.18 $0.793
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.09 $0.00 6 1.37 -$0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.14 $0.00 6 1.57 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.13 $0.01 6 1.23 $0.017
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.14 $0.00 6 1.57 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.26 $0.09 6 - $0.070
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.01 10 0.26 $0.533
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.48 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.58 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.01 $0.00 10 - $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.03 12 1.00 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.09 $0.04 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.07 12 0.95 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.96 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.92 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.91 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 0.99 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.16 $0.04 12 0.86 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 18 0.94 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.03 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.04 $0.05 10 0.83 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.04 $0.00 10 1.09 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-42 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.07 $0.01 10 1.11 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.17 $0.01 12 1.30 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.11 $0.03 12 1.16 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.10 $0.02 3 1.02 $0.073
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-43
Table C-11 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Grocery, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.21 $0.05 20 1.07 $0.020
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.25 $0.06 20 1.08 $0.022
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.52 $0.08 20 1.26 $0.013
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.55 $0.09 20 1.26 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.29 $0.02 20 1.17 $0.006
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.33 $0.04 20 1.18 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.39 $0.04 20 1.21 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.46 $0.07 20 1.24 $0.013
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.48 $0.07 20 1.25 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.52 $0.08 20 1.27 $0.014
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.19 $0.49 16 - $0.250
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.39 $0.95 16 1.00 $0.240
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.51 $1.82 16 0.88 $0.353
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.76 $5.97 16 0.54 $0.772
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.18 $0.56 16 - $0.306
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.29 $0.80 16 1.00 $0.276
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.38 $2.05 16 0.86 $0.533
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.42 $2.68 16 0.81 $0.634
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.64 $5.13 16 0.64 $0.796
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.01 $0.38 16 0.97 $2.803
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.48 $3.46 16 0.83 $0.716
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.14 $2.49 15 0.84 $1.822
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.36 $12.45 15 0.51 $3.568
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.06 $0.08 14 0.94 $0.141
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.14 $0.12 14 0.94 $0.087
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.17 $0.36 14 0.75 $0.228
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.23 $0.60 14 0.63 $0.282
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.07 $2.16 16 - $2.916
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.11 $3.11 16 1.00 $2.836
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-44 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.13 $7.97 16 0.86 $6.046
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.14 $10.40 16 0.81 $7.555
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.12 $19.93 16 0.64 $15.781
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.95 16 0.97 $2.099
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.58 $8.58 16 0.83 $0.536
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1.73 -$0.06 10 1.27 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.17 $0.01 15 1.98 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 1.31 $0.01 15 2.25 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 1.35 $0.01 15 2.34 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.35 $0.04 4 - $0.008
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.08 $0.05 4 1.47 $0.007
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.90 $0.03 4 3.40 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.22 $0.82 4 0.71 $0.054
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 4.84 $0.23 4 - $0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.12 $0.14 6 0.35 $0.226
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.85 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.13 $0.00 6 1.70 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.16 $0.00 6 1.84 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.16 $0.00 6 2.19 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.24 $0.04 6 - $0.031
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.99 $5.31 10 0.36 $0.355
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 2.07 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 2.88 $0.04 10 1.51 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 3.33 $0.06 10 1.63 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 6.08 $1.47 10 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.13 $0.00 4 - $0.008
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.20 $0.01 4 1.45 $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.38 $0.00 4 3.35 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.41 $0.08 4 0.66 $0.054
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-45
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.47 $0.02 4 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.23 $0.61 6 0.24 $0.528
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.24 $0.00 6 1.36 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.36 $0.00 6 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.36 $0.02 6 1.33 $0.011
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.38 $0.00 6 1.61 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.70 $0.17 6 - $0.046
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.01 $0.03 10 0.35 $0.355
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.01 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.02 $0.00 10 1.51 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.02 $0.00 10 1.62 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.04 $0.01 10 - $0.032
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 1.13 $0.45 12 0.99 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 1.37 $0.57 12 0.99 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 1.67 $1.01 12 0.94 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 0.95 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.07 12 0.90 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.07 12 0.90 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.20 $0.08 12 0.98 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 2.36 $1.57 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 5.17 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 6.53 $1.57 12 0.85 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 1.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 1.05 $0.72 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 1.86 $0.72 18 0.93 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.03 $0.01 10 0.97 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.04 $0.05 10 0.82 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.03 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.08 $0.01 10 1.09 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-46 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.14 $0.03 10 1.09 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.10 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.06 $0.01 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.48 $0.02 12 1.28 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.33 $0.07 12 1.12 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.02 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-47
Table C-12 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Grocery, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.19 $0.09 20 1.02 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.23 $0.11 20 1.02 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.48 $0.14 20 1.13 $0.025
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.50 $0.16 20 1.12 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.26 $0.03 20 1.12 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.30 $0.07 20 1.11 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.35 $0.08 20 1.12 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.42 $0.13 20 1.12 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.44 $0.14 20 1.11 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.48 $0.15 20 1.12 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.33 $2.28 16 - $0.694
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.73 $11.40 16 1.00 $1.552
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.49 $0.00 16 0.87 $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.74 $0.00 16 0.53 $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.23 $0.07 16 - $0.032
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.41 $0.11 16 1.00 $0.026
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.52 $0.33 16 0.85 $0.063
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.61 $0.56 16 0.79 $0.090
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.61 $0.00 16 0.62 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.01 $0.48 16 0.97 $3.877
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.43 $4.34 16 0.81 $0.990
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.14 $2.28 15 0.84 $1.717
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.35 $11.40 15 0.52 $3.362
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.06 $0.07 14 0.94 $0.139
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.13 $0.11 14 0.94 $0.086
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.16 $0.33 14 0.76 $0.225
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.21 $0.56 14 0.64 $0.278
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.10 $3.12 16 - $3.139
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.15 $4.49 16 1.00 $2.995
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-48 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.18 $11.52 16 0.85 $6.207
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.19 $15.03 16 0.79 $7.661
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.21 $28.79 16 0.62 $13.646
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $1.42 16 0.97 $3.425
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.45 $12.80 16 0.81 $0.874
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1.21 -$0.05 10 1.20 -$0.006
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.14 $0.01 15 1.98 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 1.28 $0.01 15 2.25 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 1.32 $0.01 15 2.34 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.35 $0.04 4 - $0.008
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.08 $0.05 4 1.47 $0.007
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.90 $0.03 4 3.40 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.22 $0.82 4 0.71 $0.054
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 4.84 $0.23 4 - $0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.12 $0.14 6 0.35 $0.226
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.85 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.13 $0.00 6 1.70 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.16 $0.00 6 1.84 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.16 $0.00 6 2.19 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.24 $0.04 6 - $0.031
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.99 $5.31 10 0.36 $0.355
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 2.07 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 2.88 $0.04 10 1.51 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 3.33 $0.06 10 1.63 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 6.08 $1.47 10 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.13 $0.00 4 - $0.008
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.20 $0.01 4 1.45 $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.38 $0.00 4 3.35 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.41 $0.08 4 0.66 $0.054
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-49
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.47 $0.02 4 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.23 $0.61 6 0.24 $0.528
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.24 $0.00 6 1.36 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.36 $0.00 6 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.36 $0.02 6 1.33 $0.011
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.38 $0.00 6 1.61 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.70 $0.17 6 - $0.046
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.01 $0.03 10 0.35 $0.355
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.01 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.02 $0.00 10 1.51 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.02 $0.00 10 1.62 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.04 $0.01 10 - $0.032
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 1.13 $0.45 12 0.99 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 1.37 $0.57 12 0.99 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 1.67 $1.01 12 0.94 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 0.95 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.07 12 0.90 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.07 12 0.90 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.20 $0.08 12 0.98 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 2.36 $1.57 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 5.17 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 6.53 $1.57 12 0.85 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 1.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 1.05 $0.72 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 1.86 $0.72 18 0.93 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.03 $0.01 10 0.97 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.04 $0.05 10 0.82 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.03 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.08 $0.01 10 1.09 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-50 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.14 $0.03 10 1.09 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.10 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.06 $0.01 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.48 $0.02 12 1.28 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.33 $0.07 12 1.12 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.02 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-51
Table C-13 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— College, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.59 $0.45 20 1.06 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.70 $0.58 20 1.07 $0.073
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.46 $0.71 20 1.24 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.55 $0.85 20 1.24 $0.048
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.77 $0.16 20 1.17 $0.018
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.88 $0.32 20 1.17 $0.032
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1.03 $0.38 20 1.20 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.24 $0.59 20 1.23 $0.042
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.29 $0.66 20 1.23 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.39 $0.72 20 1.25 $0.046
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.40 $0.53 16 - $0.131
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.80 $1.02 16 1.00 $0.126
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1.05 $1.96 16 0.95 $0.185
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.57 $6.42 16 0.70 $0.404
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.38 $0.65 16 - $0.169
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.61 $0.94 16 1.00 $0.152
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.81 $2.41 16 0.92 $0.294
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.89 $3.15 16 0.88 $0.350
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.36 $6.04 16 0.78 $0.439
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.45 16 0.98 $1.531
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.03 $4.06 16 0.91 $0.391
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.29 $3.05 15 0.88 $1.085
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.74 $15.24 15 0.57 $2.124
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.12 $0.48 14 0.94 $0.419
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.29 $0.70 14 0.95 $0.260
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.34 $2.14 14 0.76 $0.679
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.46 $3.59 14 0.64 $0.840
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.50 $0.29 16 - $0.057
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.78 $0.41 16 1.00 $0.052
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-52 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.02 $1.06 16 0.92 $0.103
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.11 $1.38 16 0.88 $0.123
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.59 $2.65 16 0.78 $0.165
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.05 $0.15 16 0.98 $0.282
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.92 $1.39 16 0.91 $0.072
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 2.32 -$0.07 10 1.38 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.02 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.027
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.06 $0.01 15 1.99 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 1.19 $0.02 15 2.26 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 1.23 $0.02 15 2.35 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.43 $0.00 4 - $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.19 $0.00 4 1.55 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 4.10 $0.00 4 3.67 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.44 $0.03 4 1.12 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5.10 $0.01 4 - $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.22 $0.37 6 0.50 $0.328
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.23 $0.00 6 1.82 -$0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.32 $0.00 6 1.75 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.33 $0.01 6 1.96 $0.007
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.35 $0.00 6 2.21 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.60 $0.10 6 - $0.033
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.95 $2.32 10 0.50 $0.327
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.99 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.37 $0.02 10 1.53 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.59 $0.03 10 1.66 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.89 $0.64 10 - $0.030
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.05 $0.00 4 - $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.07 $0.00 4 1.48 $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.13 $0.00 4 3.43 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.14 $0.03 4 0.73 $0.049
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-53
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.16 $0.01 4 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.15 $0.37 6 0.26 $0.486
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.16 $0.00 6 1.36 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.24 $0.00 6 1.60 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.24 $0.01 6 1.36 $0.010
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.25 $0.00 6 1.62 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.46 $0.10 6 - $0.043
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.38 $0.327
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.51 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.63 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.030
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.01 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.98 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.95 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.95 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.06 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.01 12 0.89 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.97 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.02 10 0.86 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.12 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-54 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.16 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.03 $0.01 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.21 $0.01 12 1.34 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.14 $0.03 12 1.29 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.15 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 6 1.08 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.03 $0.02 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.01 $0.00 15 0.99 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-55
Table C-14 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data — College, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.50 $0.44 20 1.05 $0.078
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.60 $0.57 20 1.06 $0.085
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1.24 $0.71 20 1.21 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 1.32 $0.84 20 1.21 $0.056
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.68 $0.16 20 1.16 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.77 $0.31 20 1.16 $0.036
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.91 $0.38 20 1.19 $0.037
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1.09 $0.58 20 1.21 $0.047
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1.13 $0.65 20 1.21 $0.050
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 1.22 $0.71 20 1.23 $0.051
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.38 $0.55 16 - $0.145
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.75 $1.06 16 1.00 $0.139
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.99 $2.04 16 0.94 $0.205
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.48 $6.70 16 0.69 $0.448
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.36 $0.68 16 - $0.185
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.58 $0.97 16 1.00 $0.167
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.76 $2.50 16 0.91 $0.324
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.84 $3.26 16 0.87 $0.385
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.28 $6.25 16 0.76 $0.483
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.46 16 0.98 $1.684
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.95 $4.12 16 0.90 $0.430
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.27 $2.94 15 0.88 $1.109
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.69 $14.68 15 0.57 $2.173
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.11 $0.49 14 0.94 $0.464
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.27 $0.72 14 0.94 $0.288
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.31 $2.20 14 0.74 $0.751
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.42 $3.69 14 0.62 $0.929
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.46 $0.26 16 - $0.057
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.72 $0.38 16 1.00 $0.052
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-56 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.94 $0.97 16 0.91 $0.102
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.03 $1.27 16 0.87 $0.122
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.46 $2.43 16 0.76 $0.165
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.05 $0.14 16 0.98 $0.278
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.81 $1.30 16 0.90 $0.071
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 2.48 -$0.07 10 1.41 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.02 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.027
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.01 $0.01 15 1.99 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 1.13 $0.01 15 2.26 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 1.17 $0.02 15 2.35 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.38 $0.04 4 - $0.007
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.12 $0.05 4 1.55 $0.007
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 3.97 $0.03 4 3.67 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.30 $0.77 4 1.12 $0.049
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 4.94 $0.22 4 - $0.012
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.07 $0.08 6 0.50 $0.208
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.07 $0.00 6 1.82 -$0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.08 $0.00 6 1.75 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.09 $0.00 6 1.96 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.09 $0.00 6 2.21 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.14 $0.02 6 - $0.028
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.95 $2.32 10 0.50 $0.327
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.99 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.37 $0.02 10 1.53 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.59 $0.03 10 1.66 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.89 $0.64 10 - $0.030
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.05 $0.00 4 - $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.07 $0.00 4 1.48 $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.13 $0.00 4 3.43 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.14 $0.03 4 0.73 $0.049
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-57
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.16 $0.01 4 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.15 $0.37 6 0.26 $0.486
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.16 $0.00 6 1.36 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.24 $0.00 6 1.60 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.24 $0.01 6 1.36 $0.010
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.25 $0.00 6 1.62 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.46 $0.10 6 - $0.043
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.38 $0.327
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.51 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.63 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.030
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.01 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.98 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.95 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.95 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.06 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.01 12 0.89 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.97 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.02 10 0.86 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.21 $0.01 10 1.04 $0.006
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.12 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-58 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.16 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.18 $0.03 12 1.13 $0.021
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.03 $0.01 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.21 $0.01 12 1.34 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.14 $0.03 12 1.29 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.15 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 6 1.08 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.03 $0.02 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.01 $0.00 15 0.99 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-59
Table C-15 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— School, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.37 $0.28 20 1.09 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.44 $0.37 20 1.10 $0.073
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.93 $0.45 20 1.30 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.98 $0.53 20 1.31 $0.048
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.50 $0.10 20 1.19 $0.018
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.57 $0.20 20 1.20 $0.032
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.67 $0.25 20 1.24 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.80 $0.38 20 1.29 $0.042
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.83 $0.42 20 1.30 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.90 $0.46 20 1.33 $0.045
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.25 $0.33 16 - $0.131
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.51 $0.64 16 1.00 $0.125
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.66 $1.23 16 0.97 $0.184
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.99 $4.04 16 0.77 $0.402
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.25 $0.42 16 - $0.169
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.39 $0.60 16 1.00 $0.152
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.52 $1.54 16 0.94 $0.294
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.57 $2.01 16 0.92 $0.350
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.87 $3.85 16 0.84 $0.439
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.29 16 0.98 $1.531
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.65 $2.57 16 0.97 $0.391
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.18 $1.93 15 0.90 $1.086
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.47 $9.65 15 0.60 $2.127
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.08 $0.30 14 0.97 $0.419
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.18 $0.44 14 0.99 $0.260
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.21 $1.35 14 0.83 $0.679
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.29 $2.27 14 0.73 $0.840
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.38 $0.22 16 - $0.057
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.60 $0.32 16 1.00 $0.052
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-60 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.78 $0.81 16 0.94 $0.103
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.85 $1.06 16 0.92 $0.123
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.22 $2.03 16 0.84 $0.165
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.12 16 0.98 $0.282
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.47 $1.07 16 0.97 $0.072
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1.35 -$0.04 10 1.36 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.00 $0.027
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.63 $0.01 15 1.97 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.71 $0.01 15 2.23 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.73 $0.01 15 2.31 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.98 $0.06 4 - $0.018
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.51 $0.09 4 1.31 $0.016
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.82 $0.05 4 2.90 $0.005
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 3.06 $1.32 4 0.38 $0.119
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.51 $0.37 4 - $0.029
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.09 $0.22 6 0.21 $0.502
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.09 -$0.01 6 1.93 -$0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.09 $0.00 6 1.58 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.11 $0.00 6 1.62 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.11 $0.00 6 2.15 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.17 $0.06 6 - $0.068
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.30 $1.78 10 0.21 $0.786
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.31 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.43 $0.01 10 1.46 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.50 $0.02 10 1.55 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.92 $0.49 10 - $0.072
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.03 $0.00 4 - $0.018
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.05 $0.00 4 1.26 $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.09 $0.00 4 2.76 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.10 $0.04 4 0.33 $0.119
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-61
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.11 $0.01 4 - $0.029
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.13 $0.80 6 0.13 $1.170
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.14 -$0.01 6 1.39 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.22 $0.00 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.22 $0.03 6 1.11 $0.024
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.23 $0.00 6 1.52 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.41 $0.22 6 - $0.103
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.19 $0.786
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.45 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.53 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.072
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.01 12 1.01 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.03 12 0.96 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.02 12 0.93 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.93 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.03 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.02 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.85 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.11 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-62 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.03 $0.01 10 1.14 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.13 $0.01 12 1.28 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.09 $0.02 12 1.12 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.09 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.02 $0.01 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.31 $0.28 15 1.02 $0.091
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.38 $0.36 15 0.93 $0.098
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.00 $0.00 15 0.84 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-63
Table C-16 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— School, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.31 $0.28 20 1.08 $0.078
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.38 $0.36 20 1.09 $0.085
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.78 $0.45 20 1.28 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.83 $0.53 20 1.29 $0.056
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.43 $0.10 20 1.18 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.49 $0.20 20 1.19 $0.036
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.57 $0.24 20 1.23 $0.036
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.69 $0.37 20 1.27 $0.047
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.71 $0.41 20 1.28 $0.050
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.77 $0.45 20 1.31 $0.051
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.24 $0.35 16 - $0.145
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.48 $0.67 16 1.00 $0.139
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.62 $1.29 16 0.96 $0.204
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.94 $4.22 16 0.75 $0.446
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.23 $0.44 16 - $0.185
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.37 $0.63 16 1.00 $0.167
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.50 $1.62 16 0.94 $0.324
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.54 $2.12 16 0.91 $0.385
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.83 $4.05 16 0.82 $0.483
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.30 16 0.98 $1.684
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.63 $2.73 16 0.95 $0.430
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.17 $1.86 15 0.89 $1.111
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.44 $9.30 15 0.60 $2.176
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.07 $0.31 14 0.96 $0.464
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.17 $0.45 14 0.98 $0.288
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.20 $1.39 14 0.81 $0.751
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.27 $2.33 14 0.71 $0.929
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.35 $0.20 16 - $0.057
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.55 $0.29 16 1.00 $0.052
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-64 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.72 $0.75 16 0.94 $0.102
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.79 $0.97 16 0.91 $0.122
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.12 $1.86 16 0.82 $0.165
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.11 16 0.98 $0.278
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.39 $0.99 16 0.95 $0.071
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1.45 -$0.04 10 1.38 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.00 $0.027
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.60 $0.01 15 1.97 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.67 $0.01 15 2.23 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.69 $0.01 15 2.31 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.98 $0.06 4 - $0.018
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.51 $0.09 4 1.31 $0.016
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.82 $0.05 4 2.90 $0.005
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 3.06 $1.32 4 0.38 $0.119
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.51 $0.37 4 - $0.029
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.09 $0.22 6 0.21 $0.502
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.09 -$0.01 6 1.93 -$0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.09 $0.00 6 1.58 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.11 $0.00 6 1.62 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.11 $0.00 6 2.15 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.17 $0.06 6 - $0.068
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.30 $1.78 10 0.21 $0.786
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.31 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.43 $0.01 10 1.46 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.50 $0.02 10 1.55 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.92 $0.49 10 - $0.072
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.03 $0.00 4 - $0.018
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.05 $0.00 4 1.26 $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.09 $0.00 4 2.76 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.10 $0.04 4 0.33 $0.119
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-65
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.11 $0.01 4 - $0.029
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.13 $0.80 6 0.13 $1.170
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.14 -$0.01 6 1.39 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.22 $0.00 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.22 $0.03 6 1.11 $0.024
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.23 $0.00 6 1.52 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.41 $0.22 6 - $0.103
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.19 $0.786
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.45 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.53 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.072
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.01 12 1.01 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.03 12 0.96 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.02 12 0.93 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.93 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.03 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.02 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 0.99 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.85 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.11 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-66 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.03 $0.01 10 1.14 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.13 $0.01 12 1.28 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.09 $0.02 12 1.12 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.09 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.02 $0.01 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 0.93 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.00 $0.00 15 0.84 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-67
Table C-17 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Hospital, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 1.33 $0.89 20 1.00 $0.059
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 1.60 $1.16 20 1.00 $0.064
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 3.32 $1.43 20 1.09 $0.038
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 3.52 $1.70 20 1.08 $0.043
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 1.99 $0.33 20 1.12 $0.015
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 2.26 $0.66 20 1.10 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 2.66 $0.80 20 1.12 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 3.19 $1.24 20 1.11 $0.034
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 3.32 $1.37 20 1.11 $0.036
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 3.59 $1.51 20 1.11 $0.037
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.97 $0.73 16 - $0.074
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.95 $1.41 16 1.00 $0.071
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 2.55 $2.70 16 0.93 $0.105
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 3.83 $8.87 16 0.66 $0.229
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.94 $0.83 16 - $0.087
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 1.49 $1.19 16 1.00 $0.079
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.98 $3.05 16 0.92 $0.152
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 2.17 $3.98 16 0.88 $0.181
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 3.32 $7.63 16 0.76 $0.228
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.07 $0.58 16 0.98 $0.795
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 2.53 $5.19 16 0.91 $0.203
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.70 $3.71 15 0.87 $0.542
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 1.79 $18.57 15 0.56 $1.062
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.30 $1.16 14 0.88 $0.419
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.70 $1.70 14 0.85 $0.260
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.82 $5.22 14 0.61 $0.679
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 1.11 $8.74 14 0.48 $0.840
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.77 $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 1.22 $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-68 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.59 $0.00 16 0.92 $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 1.73 $0.00 16 0.88 $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 2.44 $0.00 16 0.76 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 6.50 -$0.15 16 0.98 -$0.002
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 3.08 $0.00 16 0.91 $0.000
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 6.41 -$0.15 10 1.41 -$0.003
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.05 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.013
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 2.32 $0.01 15 2.02 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 2.61 $0.02 15 2.30 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 2.69 $0.02 15 2.39 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.53 $0.04 4 - $0.008
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.35 $0.06 4 1.50 $0.007
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 4.40 $0.04 4 3.50 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.77 $0.94 4 0.82 $0.055
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5.48 $0.27 4 - $0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.02 $0.02 6 0.39 $0.230
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.02 $0.00 6 1.84 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.02 $0.00 6 1.72 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.03 $0.00 6 1.88 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.03 $0.00 6 2.20 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.04 $0.01 6 - $0.031
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.42 $3.85 10 0.40 $0.361
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 1.48 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 2.05 $0.03 10 1.52 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 2.38 $0.04 10 1.64 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 4.33 $1.07 10 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.02 $0.00 4 - $0.008
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.03 $0.00 4 1.45 $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.05 $0.00 4 3.36 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.05 $0.01 4 0.66 $0.055
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-69
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.06 $0.00 4 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.13 $0.35 6 0.24 $0.537
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.36 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.21 $0.00 6 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.21 $0.01 6 1.33 $0.011
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.22 $0.00 6 1.61 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.39 $0.10 6 - $0.047
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.35 $0.361
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.51 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.62 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.033
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.04 12 0.96 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.93 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.93 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.02 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.02 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.03 10 0.84 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.10 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-70 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.13 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.13 $0.00 12 1.12 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.08 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.65 $0.03 12 1.31 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.44 $0.10 12 1.17 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.18 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.06 $0.03 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.02 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.03 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 0.97 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.01 $0.01 15 0.89 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-71
Table C-18 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Hospital, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 1.20 $0.61 20 1.03 $0.045
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 1.44 $0.80 20 1.03 $0.049
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 3.00 $0.98 20 1.15 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 3.18 $1.16 20 1.14 $0.032
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 1.89 $0.24 20 1.14 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 2.14 $0.48 20 1.13 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 2.52 $0.57 20 1.16 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 3.02 $0.89 20 1.16 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 3.15 $0.99 20 1.16 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 3.40 $1.09 20 1.17 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.93 $0.42 16 - $0.045
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.85 $0.81 16 1.00 $0.043
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 2.42 $1.56 16 0.96 $0.064
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 3.64 $5.13 16 0.73 $0.140
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.91 $0.48 16 - $0.052
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 1.45 $0.69 16 1.00 $0.047
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 1.92 $1.77 16 0.94 $0.091
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 2.11 $2.31 16 0.92 $0.108
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 3.21 $4.42 16 0.84 $0.136
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.07 $0.32 16 0.98 $0.474
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 2.38 $2.90 16 0.99 $0.121
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.67 $3.22 15 0.87 $0.495
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 1.70 $16.11 15 0.56 $0.970
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.27 $1.19 14 0.87 $0.464
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.65 $1.75 14 0.84 $0.288
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.76 $5.37 14 0.59 $0.751
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 1.04 $9.00 14 0.46 $0.929
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.26 $0.39 16 - $0.150
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.44 $0.56 16 1.00 $0.125
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-72 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.63 $1.43 16 0.94 $0.225
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.71 $1.86 16 0.92 $0.260
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.33 $3.57 16 0.84 $0.266
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.08 $0.10 16 0.98 $0.123
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 2.96 $0.94 16 0.99 $0.031
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 7.92 -$0.13 10 1.56 -$0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.05 $0.01 15 1.01 $0.013
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 2.32 $0.01 15 2.02 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 2.61 $0.02 15 2.30 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 2.69 $0.02 15 2.40 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.53 $0.04 4 - $0.008
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.35 $0.06 4 1.50 $0.007
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 4.40 $0.04 4 3.50 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.77 $0.94 4 0.82 $0.055
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5.48 $0.27 4 - $0.013
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.02 $0.02 6 0.39 $0.230
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.02 $0.00 6 1.84 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.02 $0.00 6 1.72 $0.001
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.03 $0.00 6 1.88 $0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.03 $0.00 6 2.20 -$0.003
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.04 $0.01 6 - $0.031
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.42 $3.85 10 0.40 $0.361
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 1.48 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 2.05 $0.03 10 1.52 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 2.38 $0.04 10 1.64 $0.002
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 4.33 $1.07 10 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.02 $0.00 4 - $0.008
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.03 $0.00 4 1.45 $0.007
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.05 $0.00 4 3.36 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.05 $0.01 4 0.66 $0.055
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-73
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.06 $0.00 4 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.13 $0.35 6 0.24 $0.537
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.36 -$0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.21 $0.00 6 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.21 $0.01 6 1.33 $0.011
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.22 $0.00 6 1.61 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.39 $0.10 6 - $0.047
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.04 $0.02 10 0.35 $0.088
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.08 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.10 $0.02 10 1.51 $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.62 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.01 12 1.00 $0.017
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.01 12 0.96 $0.013
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.97 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.93 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.93 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 12 1.02 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.02 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 18 0.95 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.01 10 0.98 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.03 10 0.84 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.10 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-74 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.13 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.13 $0.00 12 1.12 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.08 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.65 $0.03 12 1.31 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.44 $0.10 12 1.17 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.18 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.06 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.06 $0.03 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.02 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.03 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.03 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 0.97 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.01 $0.01 15 0.89 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-75
Table C-19 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Lodging, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.22 $0.11 20 1.07 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.26 $0.14 20 1.08 $0.047
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.54 $0.17 20 1.26 $0.028
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.58 $0.20 20 1.27 $0.031
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.35 $0.05 20 1.18 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.40 $0.09 20 1.18 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.47 $0.11 20 1.22 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.57 $0.17 20 1.25 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.59 $0.19 20 1.26 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.64 $0.21 20 1.29 $0.029
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.06 $0.04 16 - $0.072
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.12 $0.09 16 1.00 $0.069
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.16 $0.17 16 0.99 $0.101
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.24 $0.54 16 0.92 $0.222
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.06 $0.05 16 - $0.085
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.10 $0.08 16 1.00 $0.077
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.13 $0.20 16 0.99 $0.148
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.15 $0.26 16 0.98 $0.176
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.22 $0.50 16 0.95 $0.221
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.04 16 1.01 $0.081
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.51 $0.32 16 1.56 $0.021
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.26 $0.31 15 0.99 $0.125
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.65 $1.56 15 0.82 $0.245
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.11 $0.45 14 0.92 $0.419
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.27 $0.65 14 0.91 $0.260
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.32 $2.01 14 0.70 $0.679
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.43 $3.37 14 0.58 $0.840
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.07 $0.04 16 - $0.064
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.10 $0.06 16 1.00 $0.061
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-76 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.12 $0.16 16 0.99 $0.125
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.13 $0.20 16 0.98 $0.153
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.16 $0.39 16 0.95 $0.241
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.01 16 1.01 $0.036
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.35 $0.12 16 1.56 $0.009
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1.36 -$0.04 10 1.38 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.04 $0.01 15 1.00 $0.038
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.96 $0.03 15 1.95 $0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 2.20 $0.04 15 2.21 $0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 2.26 $0.04 15 2.29 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 2.72 $0.13 4 - $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 4.19 $0.18 4 1.43 $0.012
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 7.84 $0.11 4 3.27 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 8.48 $2.82 4 0.59 $0.092
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 9.74 $0.80 4 - $0.023
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.04 $0.08 6 0.29 $0.387
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.04 $0.00 6 1.87 -$0.010
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.04 $0.00 6 1.66 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.05 $0.00 6 1.78 $0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.05 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.08 $0.02 6 - $0.052
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.18 $0.81 10 0.30 $0.607
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.19 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.26 $0.01 10 1.50 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.30 $0.01 10 1.60 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.54 $0.23 10 - $0.055
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.13 $0.01 4 - $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.20 $0.01 4 1.34 $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.37 $0.00 4 3.00 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.40 $0.13 4 0.42 $0.092
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-77
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.46 $0.04 4 - $0.023
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.12 $0.57 6 0.16 $0.902
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.38 -$0.007
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.20 $0.00 6 1.56 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.20 $0.02 6 1.20 $0.019
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.21 $0.00 6 1.56 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.38 $0.16 6 - $0.079
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.24 $0.607
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.48 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.57 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.055
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.03 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.09 $0.04 12 1.02 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.06 12 0.98 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.99 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.02 12 0.96 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.96 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.07 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.03 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.15 $0.03 12 0.89 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.02 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 18 0.97 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 1.00 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.87 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.05 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.04 $0.00 10 1.13 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-78 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.06 $0.01 10 1.17 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.03 $0.01 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.24 $0.01 12 1.33 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.16 $0.04 12 1.25 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 6 1.08 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.01 $0.01 15 1.02 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.06 $0.04 15 0.97 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-79
Table C-20 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Lodging, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.21 $0.10 20 1.08 $0.041
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.25 $0.13 20 1.09 $0.045
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.53 $0.16 20 1.27 $0.026
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.56 $0.19 20 1.28 $0.030
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.34 $0.04 20 1.18 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.38 $0.08 20 1.19 $0.019
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.45 $0.10 20 1.22 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.54 $0.16 20 1.26 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.56 $0.17 20 1.27 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.61 $0.19 20 1.29 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.04 $0.03 16 - $0.077
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.09 $0.07 16 1.00 $0.073
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.12 $0.13 16 0.99 $0.108
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.18 $0.42 16 0.93 $0.236
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.04 $0.04 16 - $0.090
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.07 $0.06 16 1.00 $0.081
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.09 $0.15 16 0.99 $0.157
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.10 $0.20 16 0.98 $0.186
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.16 $0.38 16 0.96 $0.234
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.05 $0.03 16 1.01 $0.066
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.60 $0.27 16 1.61 $0.017
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.21 $0.25 15 0.99 $0.121
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.55 $1.26 15 0.83 $0.238
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.11 $0.46 14 0.92 $0.464
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.25 $0.67 14 0.90 $0.288
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.29 $2.07 14 0.69 $0.751
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.40 $3.46 14 0.56 $0.929
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.09 $0.06 16 - $0.061
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.14 $0.08 16 1.00 $0.057
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-80 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.18 $0.21 16 0.99 $0.116
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.19 $0.27 16 0.98 $0.141
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.24 $0.52 16 0.96 $0.209
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.02 16 1.01 $0.046
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.31 $0.16 16 1.61 $0.012
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.94 -$0.04 10 1.27 -$0.005
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.04 $0.01 15 1.00 $0.038
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.90 $0.03 15 1.95 $0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 2.13 $0.04 15 2.21 $0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 2.20 $0.04 15 2.29 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 2.72 $0.13 4 - $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 4.19 $0.18 4 1.43 $0.012
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 7.84 $0.11 4 3.27 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 8.48 $2.82 4 0.59 $0.092
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 9.74 $0.80 4 - $0.023
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.04 $0.08 6 0.29 $0.387
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.04 $0.00 6 1.87 -$0.010
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.04 $0.00 6 1.66 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.05 $0.00 6 1.78 $0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.05 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.08 $0.02 6 - $0.052
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.18 $0.81 10 0.30 $0.607
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.19 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.26 $0.01 10 1.50 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.30 $0.01 10 1.60 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.54 $0.23 10 - $0.055
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.13 $0.01 4 - $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.20 $0.01 4 1.34 $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.37 $0.00 4 3.00 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.40 $0.13 4 0.42 $0.092
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-81
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.46 $0.04 4 - $0.023
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.12 $0.57 6 0.16 $0.902
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.38 -$0.007
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.20 $0.00 6 1.56 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.20 $0.02 6 1.20 $0.019
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.21 $0.00 6 1.56 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.38 $0.16 6 - $0.079
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.24 $0.607
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.48 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.57 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.055
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.03 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.09 $0.04 12 1.02 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.06 12 0.98 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.99 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.02 12 0.96 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.96 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.07 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.03 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.11 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.15 $0.03 12 0.89 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.02 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 18 0.97 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 1.00 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.87 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.05 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.04 $0.00 10 1.13 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-82 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.06 $0.01 10 1.17 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.05 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.03 $0.01 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.24 $0.01 12 1.33 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.16 $0.04 12 1.25 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.04 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 6 1.08 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.01 $0.01 15 1.02 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.06 $0.04 15 0.97 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-83
Table C-21 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Warehouse, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.24 $0.05 20 1.12 $0.020
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.29 $0.07 20 1.14 $0.021
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.61 $0.09 20 1.39 $0.013
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.64 $0.10 20 1.42 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.34 $0.02 20 1.21 $0.005
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.39 $0.04 20 1.24 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.46 $0.05 20 1.30 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.55 $0.08 20 1.37 $0.013
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.57 $0.09 20 1.38 $0.013
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.62 $0.10 20 1.43 $0.014
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.23 $0.08 16 - $0.033
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.46 $0.15 16 1.00 $0.031
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.61 $0.28 16 1.02 $0.046
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.91 $0.92 16 0.96 $0.100
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.22 $0.15 16 - $0.066
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.35 $0.21 16 1.00 $0.060
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.47 $0.55 16 0.97 $0.115
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.52 $0.71 16 0.96 $0.137
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.79 $1.37 16 0.91 $0.172
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.06 16 1.00 $0.338
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.59 $0.52 16 1.31 $0.086
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.17 $0.37 15 0.96 $0.228
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.43 $1.86 15 0.75 $0.447
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.07 $0.09 14 1.00 $0.141
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.17 $0.14 14 1.03 $0.087
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.19 $0.42 14 0.93 $0.228
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.26 $0.70 14 0.87 $0.282
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.11 $0.73 16 - $0.659
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.15 $1.05 16 1.00 $0.706
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-84 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.16 $2.68 16 0.97 $1.678
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.16 $3.50 16 0.96 $2.216
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.05 $6.70 16 0.91 $12.821
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.06 $0.42 16 1.00 $0.712
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 2.05 $3.77 16 1.31 $0.182
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.21 -$0.01 10 1.26 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.13 $0.00 15 1.98 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.15 $0.00 15 2.25 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.16 $0.00 15 2.33 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.36 $0.02 4 - $0.015
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.56 $0.03 4 1.29 $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.05 $0.02 4 2.87 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.13 $0.43 4 0.36 $0.104
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.30 $0.12 4 - $0.025
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.05 $0.12 6 0.20 $0.437
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.05 $0.00 6 1.94 -$0.011
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.57 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.61 $0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.15 -$0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.10 $0.03 6 - $0.059
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.58 $2.98 10 0.21 $0.685
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.60 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.84 $0.02 10 1.46 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.97 $0.03 10 1.55 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1.77 $0.83 10 - $0.062
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.00 $0.00 4 - $0.015
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.00 $0.00 4 1.29 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.00 $0.00 4 2.85 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 4 0.36 $0.104
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-85
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 4 - $0.025
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.13 $0.66 6 0.14 $1.019
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.38 -$0.007
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.20 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.20 $0.02 6 1.15 $0.021
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.21 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.39 $0.18 6 - $0.090
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.21 $0.685
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.55 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.062
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.24 $0.10 12 0.99 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.30 $0.12 12 0.99 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.36 $0.22 12 0.94 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.98 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.97 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.82 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.03 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.08 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-86 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.08 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.01 $0.01 4 0.94 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-87
Table C-22 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Warehouse, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.21 $0.10 20 1.09 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.25 $0.12 20 1.11 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.53 $0.15 20 1.31 $0.025
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.56 $0.18 20 1.32 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.29 $0.04 20 1.19 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.33 $0.07 20 1.20 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.39 $0.09 20 1.24 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.47 $0.14 20 1.29 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.49 $0.15 20 1.30 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.53 $0.17 20 1.33 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.22 $0.10 16 - $0.044
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.44 $0.19 16 1.00 $0.043
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.58 $0.37 16 1.00 $0.063
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.87 $1.20 16 0.89 $0.137
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.20 $0.11 16 - $0.053
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.32 $0.15 16 1.00 $0.048
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.42 $0.40 16 1.00 $0.093
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.47 $0.52 16 0.99 $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.71 $0.99 16 1.01 $0.138
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.01 $0.07 16 1.00 $0.446
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.52 $0.60 16 1.24 $0.114
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.16 $0.33 15 0.97 $0.214
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.41 $1.66 15 0.76 $0.418
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.07 $0.09 14 1.00 $0.139
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.15 $0.12 14 1.04 $0.086
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.18 $0.38 14 0.93 $0.225
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.25 $0.64 14 0.87 $0.278
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.21 $0.36 16 - $0.166
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.37 $0.52 16 1.00 $0.139
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-88 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.53 $1.33 16 1.00 $0.249
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.60 $1.74 16 0.99 $0.288
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 1.11 $3.33 16 1.01 $0.296
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.06 $0.30 16 1.00 $0.520
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.99 $2.67 16 1.24 $0.133
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.14 -$0.01 10 1.20 -$0.006
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.13 $0.00 15 1.98 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.15 $0.00 15 2.25 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.15 $0.00 15 2.34 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.36 $0.02 4 - $0.015
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.56 $0.03 4 1.29 $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.05 $0.02 4 2.87 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.13 $0.43 4 0.36 $0.104
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.30 $0.12 4 - $0.025
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.05 $0.12 6 0.20 $0.437
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.05 $0.00 6 1.94 -$0.011
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.57 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.61 $0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.15 -$0.005
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.10 $0.03 6 - $0.059
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.58 $2.98 10 0.21 $0.685
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.60 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.84 $0.02 10 1.46 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.97 $0.03 10 1.55 $0.004
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1.77 $0.83 10 - $0.062
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.00 $0.00 4 - $0.015
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.00 $0.00 4 1.29 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.00 $0.00 4 2.85 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 4 0.36 $0.104
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-89
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 4 - $0.025
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.13 $0.66 6 0.14 $1.019
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.13 $0.00 6 1.38 -$0.007
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.20 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.20 $0.02 6 1.15 $0.021
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.21 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.39 $0.18 6 - $0.090
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.21 $0.685
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.55 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.062
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.24 $0.10 12 0.99 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.30 $0.12 12 0.99 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.36 $0.22 12 0.94 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.98 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.97 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.02 10 0.82 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.03 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.08 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-90 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.08 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 5 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.00 $0.00 6 1.06 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 0.94 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-91
Table C-23 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.30 $0.07 20 1.13 $0.020
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.37 $0.09 20 1.16 $0.022
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.76 $0.11 20 1.42 $0.013
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.81 $0.13 20 1.46 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.41 $0.07 20 1.22 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1.11 $0.59 20 1.26 $0.047
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.52 $0.00 20 1.31 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.62 $0.00 20 1.39 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.65 $0.00 20 1.42 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.70 $0.00 20 1.46 $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.45 $0.42 16 - $0.092
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1.01 $2.10 16 1.00 $0.207
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.69 $0.00 16 1.04 $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.03 $0.00 16 1.03 $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.25 $0.17 16 - $0.066
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.40 $0.24 16 1.00 $0.060
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.53 $0.62 16 0.99 $0.115
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.58 $0.81 16 0.97 $0.137
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.89 $1.55 16 0.96 $0.172
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.07 16 1.00 $0.338
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.67 $0.59 16 1.31 $0.086
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.19 $0.42 15 0.99 $0.229
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.48 $2.10 15 0.83 $0.448
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.08 $0.10 14 1.01 $0.141
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.19 $0.15 14 1.06 $0.087
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.22 $0.47 14 0.99 $0.228
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.30 $0.79 14 0.95 $0.282
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.06 $0.38 16 - $0.659
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.08 $0.55 16 1.00 $0.706
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-92 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.08 $1.42 16 0.99 $1.678
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.08 $1.85 16 0.97 $2.216
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.03 $3.55 16 0.96 $12.821
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.22 16 1.00 $0.712
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.08 $1.99 16 1.31 $0.182
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.56 -$0.02 10 1.42 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.01 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.60 $0.01 15 2.01 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.68 $0.01 15 2.29 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.70 $0.01 15 2.38 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.87 $0.05 4 - $0.016
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.34 $0.07 4 1.43 $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.50 $0.04 4 3.29 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2.71 $1.07 4 0.61 $0.109
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.11 $0.30 4 - $0.027
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.06 $0.13 6 0.30 $0.458
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.06 $0.00 6 1.87 -$0.012
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.67 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.78 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.11 $0.03 6 - $0.062
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.74 $4.01 10 0.30 $0.718
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.77 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.07 $0.03 10 1.50 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.24 $0.04 10 1.60 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.27 $1.11 10 - $0.065
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.16 $0.01 4 - $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.25 $0.01 4 1.29 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.46 $0.01 4 2.87 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.50 $0.20 4 0.37 $0.109
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-93
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.58 $0.06 4 - $0.027
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.25 $1.35 6 0.14 $1.068
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.26 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.40 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.40 $0.05 6 1.15 $0.022
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.42 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.77 $0.37 6 - $0.094
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.21 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.55 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.065
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 0.98 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.99 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.09 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.02 12 0.90 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.98 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 1.00 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.87 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.05 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.13 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-94 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.18 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.11 $0.01 12 1.35 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.08 $0.02 12 1.30 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.09 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.09 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.02 $0.01 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 1.05 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-95
Table C-24 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.25 $0.11 20 1.11 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.30 $0.15 20 1.13 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.62 $0.18 20 1.36 $0.025
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.66 $0.21 20 1.38 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.34 $0.04 20 1.20 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.38 $0.09 20 1.23 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.45 $0.10 20 1.28 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.54 $0.16 20 1.33 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.56 $0.18 20 1.35 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.60 $0.19 20 1.39 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.25 $0.11 16 - $0.044
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.50 $0.21 16 1.00 $0.042
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.66 $0.41 16 1.02 $0.062
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.98 $1.35 16 0.98 $0.136
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.23 $0.12 16 - $0.053
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.36 $0.18 16 1.00 $0.048
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.48 $0.45 16 1.00 $0.093
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.53 $0.59 16 1.00 $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.80 $1.12 16 1.03 $0.138
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.08 16 1.00 $0.446
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.59 $0.68 16 1.23 $0.114
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.18 $0.37 15 1.00 $0.213
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.46 $1.87 15 0.84 $0.417
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.07 $0.10 14 1.01 $0.139
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.18 $0.14 14 1.06 $0.086
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.21 $0.43 14 0.99 $0.225
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.28 $0.73 14 0.95 $0.278
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.11 $0.19 16 - $0.166
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.20 $0.27 16 1.00 $0.139
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-96 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.28 $0.70 16 1.00 $0.249
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.32 $0.92 16 1.00 $0.288
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.59 $1.76 16 1.03 $0.296
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.16 16 1.00 $0.520
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.05 $1.41 16 1.23 $0.133
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.37 -$0.01 10 1.29 -$0.005
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.75 $4.01 15 1.01 $0.545
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.36 $0.00 15 2.01 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 1.74 $0.03 15 2.29 $0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 1.93 $0.04 15 2.38 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.03 $0.01 4 - $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.58 $0.01 4 1.43 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.96 $0.01 4 3.29 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 3.21 $0.20 4 0.61 $0.017
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.68 $0.06 4 - $0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.06 $0.13 6 0.30 $0.458
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.06 $0.00 6 1.87 -$0.012
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.67 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.78 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.11 $0.03 6 - $0.062
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.74 $4.01 10 0.30 $0.718
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.77 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.07 $0.03 10 1.50 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.24 $0.04 10 1.60 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.27 $1.11 10 - $0.065
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.16 $0.01 4 - $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.25 $0.01 4 1.29 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.46 $0.01 4 2.87 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.50 $0.20 4 0.37 $0.109
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-97
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.58 $0.06 4 - $0.027
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.25 $1.35 6 0.14 $1.068
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.26 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.40 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.40 $0.05 6 1.15 $0.022
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.42 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.77 $0.37 6 - $0.094
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.21 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.55 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.065
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 0.98 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.99 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.09 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.02 12 0.90 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.98 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 1.00 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.87 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.05 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.13 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-98 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.18 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.11 $0.01 12 1.35 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.08 $0.02 12 1.30 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.09 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.09 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.02 $0.01 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 1.05 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-99
Table C-25 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.25 $0.11 20 1.11 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.30 $0.15 20 1.13 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.62 $0.18 20 1.36 $0.025
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.66 $0.21 20 1.38 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.34 $0.04 20 1.20 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.38 $0.09 20 1.23 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.45 $0.10 20 1.28 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.54 $0.16 20 1.33 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.56 $0.18 20 1.35 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.60 $0.19 20 1.39 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.25 $0.11 16 - $0.044
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.50 $0.21 16 1.00 $0.042
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.66 $0.41 16 1.02 $0.062
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 0.98 $1.35 16 0.98 $0.136
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.23 $0.12 16 - $0.053
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.36 $0.18 16 1.00 $0.048
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.48 $0.45 16 1.00 $0.093
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.53 $0.59 16 1.00 $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.80 $1.12 16 1.03 $0.138
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.08 16 1.00 $0.446
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.59 $0.68 16 1.23 $0.114
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.18 $0.37 15 1.00 $0.213
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.46 $1.87 15 0.84 $0.417
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.07 $0.10 14 1.01 $0.139
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.18 $0.14 14 1.06 $0.086
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.21 $0.43 14 0.99 $0.225
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.28 $0.73 14 0.95 $0.278
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.11 $0.19 16 - $0.166
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.20 $0.27 16 1.00 $0.139
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-100 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.28 $0.70 16 1.00 $0.249
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.32 $0.92 16 1.00 $0.288
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.59 $1.76 16 1.03 $0.296
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.03 $0.16 16 1.00 $0.520
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.05 $1.41 16 1.23 $0.133
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.37 -$0.01 10 1.29 -$0.005
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.75 $4.01 15 1.01 $0.545
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 1.36 $0.00 15 2.01 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 1.74 $0.03 15 2.29 $0.002
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 1.93 $0.04 15 2.38 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1.03 $0.01 4 - $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.58 $0.01 4 1.43 $0.002
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.96 $0.01 4 3.29 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 3.21 $0.20 4 0.61 $0.017
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3.68 $0.06 4 - $0.004
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.06 $0.13 6 0.30 $0.458
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.06 $0.00 6 1.87 -$0.012
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 0.06 $0.00 6 1.67 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 0.07 $0.00 6 1.78 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 0.07 $0.00 6 2.18 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 0.11 $0.03 6 - $0.062
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.74 $4.01 10 0.30 $0.718
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.77 $0.00 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 1.07 $0.03 10 1.50 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1.24 $0.04 10 1.60 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 2.27 $1.11 10 - $0.065
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.16 $0.01 4 - $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.25 $0.01 4 1.29 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.46 $0.01 4 2.87 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.50 $0.20 4 0.37 $0.109
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-101
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.58 $0.06 4 - $0.027
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.25 $1.35 6 0.14 $1.068
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.26 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.40 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.40 $0.05 6 1.15 $0.022
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.42 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.77 $0.37 6 - $0.094
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.00 $0.00 10 0.21 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.00 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.00 $0.00 10 1.55 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.00 $0.00 10 - $0.065
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.02 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.04 12 0.98 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.99 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 0.97 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.05 $0.02 12 1.09 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.02 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.08 $0.02 12 0.90 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 0.98 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 1.00 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.01 10 1.00 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.87 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.05 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.02 $0.00 10 1.13 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-102 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.04 $0.01 10 1.18 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.13 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 12 1.03 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.11 $0.01 12 1.35 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.08 $0.02 12 1.30 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.09 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.09 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.02 $0.01 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.04 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 1.05 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.00 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-103
Table C-26 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Miscellaneous, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.32 $0.07 20 1.12 $0.020
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.38 $0.09 20 1.14 $0.022
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.79 $0.12 20 1.39 $0.013
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.84 $0.14 20 1.41 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.43 $0.03 20 1.21 $0.006
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.48 $0.05 20 1.24 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.57 $0.06 20 1.29 $0.010
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.68 $0.10 20 1.36 $0.013
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.71 $0.11 20 1.38 $0.014
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.77 $0.12 20 1.42 $0.014
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.29 $0.09 16 - $0.033
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.58 $0.18 16 1.00 $0.031
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.75 $0.35 16 1.02 $0.046
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.13 $1.15 16 0.95 $0.100
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.28 $0.18 16 - $0.066
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.44 $0.27 16 1.00 $0.060
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.58 $0.68 16 0.97 $0.115
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.64 $0.89 16 0.95 $0.137
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.98 $1.70 16 0.89 $0.172
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.07 16 0.99 $0.338
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.74 $0.65 16 1.22 $0.086
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.21 $0.46 15 0.96 $0.229
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.53 $2.31 15 0.74 $0.448
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.09 $0.11 14 1.00 $0.141
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.21 $0.17 14 1.03 $0.087
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.24 $0.52 14 0.93 $0.228
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.33 $0.87 14 0.86 $0.282
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.07 $0.48 16 - $0.659
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.10 $0.69 16 1.00 $0.706
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-104 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.10 $1.77 16 0.97 $1.678
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.10 $2.31 16 0.95 $2.216
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.03 $4.42 16 0.89 $12.821
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.28 16 0.99 $0.712
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.35 $2.48 16 1.22 $0.182
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.71 -$0.02 10 1.32 -$0.004
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.78 $0.01 15 2.00 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.87 $0.01 15 2.28 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.90 $0.01 15 2.37 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.76 $0.04 4 - $0.016
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.17 $0.06 4 1.35 $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.19 $0.04 4 3.04 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2.37 $0.93 4 0.44 $0.109
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 2.72 $0.26 4 - $0.027
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.95 $2.21 6 0.23 $0.458
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.96 -$0.06 6 1.91 -$0.012
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 1.03 $0.01 6 1.61 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 1.20 $0.03 6 1.68 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 1.23 -$0.04 6 2.17 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 1.81 $0.57 6 - $0.062
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.24 $1.29 10 0.24 $0.718
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.25 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.35 $0.01 10 1.48 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.40 $0.01 10 1.57 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.73 $0.36 10 - $0.065
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.23 $0.01 4 - $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.36 $0.02 4 1.28 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.67 $0.01 4 2.83 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.73 $0.29 4 0.35 $0.109
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-105
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.84 $0.08 4 - $0.027
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.15 $0.83 6 0.14 $1.068
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.16 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.25 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.25 $0.03 6 1.14 $0.022
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.26 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.47 $0.23 6 - $0.094
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.11 $0.60 10 0.20 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.12 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.16 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.19 $0.01 10 1.54 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.34 $0.17 10 - $0.065
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.03 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.09 $0.05 12 0.95 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.96 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.92 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.92 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.01 12 1.01 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.03 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.03 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 18 0.94 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.98 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.84 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.10 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-106 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.05 $0.01 10 1.12 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.13 $0.01 12 1.27 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.09 $0.02 12 1.10 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.03 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 0.99 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.02 $0.01 15 0.92 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-107
Table C-27 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Miscellaneous, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 0.27 $0.12 20 1.09 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 0.33 $0.16 20 1.10 $0.043
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 0.68 $0.20 20 1.30 $0.025
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 0.73 $0.23 20 1.31 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 0.37 $0.05 20 1.19 $0.011
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 0.42 $0.09 20 1.20 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 0.49 $0.11 20 1.24 $0.020
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 0.59 $0.18 20 1.28 $0.026
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 0.62 $0.20 20 1.29 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 0.66 $0.21 20 1.32 $0.028
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 0.28 $0.12 16 - $0.044
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 0.55 $0.24 16 1.00 $0.042
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 0.72 $0.45 16 1.00 $0.062
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1.08 $1.49 16 0.88 $0.136
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.25 $0.13 16 - $0.053
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.40 $0.19 16 1.00 $0.048
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.53 $0.49 16 0.99 $0.093
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.58 $0.64 16 0.97 $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.88 $1.23 16 0.97 $0.138
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.02 $0.08 16 0.99 $0.446
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 0.65 $0.75 16 1.15 $0.114
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 0.20 $0.41 15 0.96 $0.213
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 0.51 $2.06 15 0.75 $0.417
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 0.08 $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 0.19 $0.00 14 1.03 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 0.23 $0.00 14 0.93 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 0.31 $0.00 14 0.86 $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 10.3 0.14 $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.0 0.24 $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-108 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 11.7 0.35 $0.00 16 0.99 $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump EER 12.0 0.39 $0.00 16 0.97 $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat
Pump Ductless Minisplit 0.73 $0.00 16 0.97 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 0.04 $0.20 16 0.99 $0.520
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 1.31 $1.76 16 1.15 $0.133
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 0.45 -$0.02 10 1.22 -$0.006
Water Heating Water Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Water Heating Water Heating EF .98 0.02 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.020
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.0 0.78 $0.01 15 2.00 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.3 0.87 $0.01 15 2.28 $0.001
Water Heating Water Heating EF 2.4 0.90 $0.01 15 2.37 $0.001
Interior Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.76 $0.04 4 - $0.016
Interior Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1.17 $0.06 4 1.35 $0.014
Interior Lighting Screw-in CFL 2.19 $0.04 4 3.04 $0.004
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2.37 $0.93 4 0.44 $0.109
Interior Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 2.72 $0.26 4 - $0.027
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 0.95 $2.21 6 0.23 $0.458
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 0.96 -$0.06 6 1.91 -$0.012
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 1.03 $0.01 6 1.61 $0.002
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 1.20 $0.03 6 1.68 $0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 1.23 -$0.04 6 2.17 -$0.006
Interior Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 1.81 $0.57 6 - $0.062
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.24 $1.29 10 0.24 $0.718
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.25 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.35 $0.01 10 1.48 $0.003
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.40 $0.01 10 1.57 $0.005
Interior Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.73 $0.36 10 - $0.065
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 0.23 $0.01 4 - $0.016
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.36 $0.02 4 1.28 $0.014
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.67 $0.01 4 2.83 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 0.73 $0.29 4 0.35 $0.109
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-109
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 0.84 $0.08 4 - $0.027
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 0.15 $0.83 6 0.14 $1.068
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 0.16 -$0.01 6 1.38 -$0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 0.25 $0.00 6 1.55 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 0.25 $0.03 6 1.14 $0.022
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 0.26 $0.00 6 1.53 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 0.47 $0.23 6 - $0.094
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.11 $0.60 10 0.20 $0.718
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.12 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.16 $0.00 10 1.46 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.19 $0.01 10 1.54 $0.005
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.34 $0.17 10 - $0.065
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 14600 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10800 kWh/yr 0.06 $0.02 12 1.00 $0.046
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 10000 kWh/yr 0.07 $0.03 12 1.00 $0.049
Refrigeration Walk-in Refrigerator 9000 kWh/yr 0.09 $0.05 12 0.95 $0.071
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3800 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 3100 kWh/yr 0.01 $0.01 12 0.96 $0.070
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2500 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.92 $0.074
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 2400 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 12 0.92 $0.073
Refrigeration Reach-in Refrigerator 1500 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.01 12 1.01 $0.047
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 14480 kWh/yr - $0.00 12 - $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 11700 kWh/yr 0.04 $0.03 12 - $0.078
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 8400 kWh/yr 0.10 $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Glass Door Display 6800 kWh/yr 0.12 $0.03 12 0.87 $0.028
Refrigeration Open Display Case 6500 kWh/yr - $0.00 18 - $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5350 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.00 18 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Open Display Case 5300 kWh/yr 0.02 $0.01 18 - $0.064
Refrigeration Open Display Case 4330 kWh/yr 0.03 $0.01 18 0.94 $0.036
Refrigeration Icemaker 7.0 kWh/100 lbs - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.3 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.058
Refrigeration Icemaker 6.0 kWh/100 lbs 0.01 $0.00 10 0.98 $0.061
Refrigeration Icemaker 5.5 kWh/100 lbs 0.02 $0.02 10 0.84 $0.152
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3400 kWh/year - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Refrigeration Vending Machine 3000 kWh/year 0.01 $0.00 10 1.04 $0.013
Refrigeration Vending Machine 2400 kWh/year 0.03 $0.00 10 1.10 $0.013
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-110 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Refrigeration Vending Machine 1700 kWh/year 0.05 $0.01 10 1.12 $0.023
Food
Preparation Oven Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Oven Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 12 1.11 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Fryer Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 12 1.02 $0.026
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Dishwasher Energy Star 0.13 $0.01 12 1.27 $0.005
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Standard - $0.00 12 1.00 $0.000
Food
Preparation Hot Food Container Energy Star 0.09 $0.02 12 1.10 $0.027
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Desktop Computer Energy Star 0.07 $0.00 5 1.04 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Laptop Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.01 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Standard - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Server Energy Star 0.03 $0.00 3 1.03 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Monitor Energy Star 0.01 $0.00 4 1.02 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Standard - $0.00 6 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment Printer/Copier/Fax Energy Star 0.02 $0.00 6 1.07 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Standard - $0.00 4 1.00 $0.000
Office
Equipment POS Terminal Energy Star 0.04 $0.02 4 0.95 $0.156
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct) - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Standard (EPAct 2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.01 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors High Efficiency (2015) 0.00 $0.00 15 - $0.007
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA) 0.01 $0.00 15 1.02 $0.011
Miscellaneous Non-HVAC Motors Premium (NEMA 2015) 0.01 $0.00 15 - $0.009
Miscellaneous Pool Pump Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Pump High Efficiency 0.00 $0.00 15 1.03 $0.034
Miscellaneous Pool Pump
High Efficiency, Multi-
Speed 0.00 $0.00 15 0.99 $0.057
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Pool Heater Heat Pump 0.02 $0.01 15 0.92 $0.066
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-111
Table C-28 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Small Office, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.797 1.34 $0.029
Insulation - Ducting 14.7% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.445 0.49 $0.081
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.703 1.18 $0.033
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.34 0.532 0.60 $0.056
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 1.349 1.22 $0.029
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 66.5% 100.0% 20 $4.79 1.940 0.16 $0.218
Roof - High Reflectivity 41.6% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.587 2.24 $0.026
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.920 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.387 5.73 $0.011
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.881 1.11 $0.055
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 1.030 0.84 $0.074
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.239 0.13 $0.478
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $5.146
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 48.6% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.819 2.20 $0.027
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.094 0.31 $0.097
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.969 0.24 $0.245
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.843 7.64 $0.008
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.991 1.18 $0.052
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 1.085 0.89 $0.070
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.252 0.14 $0.454
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.011 0.13 $0.489
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 48.6% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.862 2.32 $0.026
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.094 0.31 $0.097
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 17.0% 20 $3.00 2.617 0.58 $0.101
RTU - Maintenance 48.6% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.750 1.99 $0.029
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.695 1.54 $0.022
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 1.129 6.38 $0.007
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.18 0.049 0.10 $0.343
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.8% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.428 0.52 $0.062
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.311 1.80 $0.018
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.084 0.28 $0.108
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 25.7% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.038 0.87 $0.038
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.655 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.187 9.70 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 0.702 18.04 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.187 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-112 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 67.5% 100.0% 15 $0.31 0.053 0.06 $0.597
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.047 172.6
0 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 21.1% 50.0% 8 $0.11 1.155 2.81 $0.015
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.092 29.53 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 27.7% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.462 0.62 $0.068
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 4.9% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.231 0.31 $0.135
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 17.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.173 0.10 $0.316
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.265 0.12 $0.295
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 15.1% 45.0% 11 $0.50 0.225 0.13 $0.277
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.105 0.08 $0.298
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.262 1.98 $0.012
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.315 0.03 $0.666
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.177 0.22 $0.115
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.20 0.020 0.03 $1.009
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.008 0.01 $1.995
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.04 0.020 0.05 $0.465
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.35 0.006 0.00 $6.103
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.020 6.01 $0.004
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 20 $0.01 0.029 1.10 $0.023
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.03 0.020 0.17 $0.155
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.030 0.02 $1.190
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.021 54.80 $0.001
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.228 0.34 $0.137
Pool Pump - Timer 2.0% 45.0% 10 $0.44 - - $0.000
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed Control 1.6% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.011 0.03 $1.161
Energy Management System 41.2% 75.0% 14 $0.35 3.129 3.70 $0.012
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 23.7% 40.0% 11 $0.13 1.535 3.88 $0.011
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.350 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 58.1% 7 $0.38 1.137 0.74 $0.057
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.7% 58.1% 5 $0.10 0.515 0.87 $0.044
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-113
Table C-29 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Small Office, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.696 1.22 $0.033
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.534 0.70 $0.068
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.081 0.15 $0.282
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.34 0.550 0.62 $0.055
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.800 0.72 $0.049
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 77.8% 100.0% 20 $3.38 1.693 0.20 $0.176
Roof - High Reflectivity 41.3% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.199 0.81 $0.077
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.730 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.248 5.29 $0.012
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.546 0.94 $0.067
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.809 0.67 $0.094
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.282 0.16 $0.406
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $4.425
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 41.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.471 1.28 $0.047
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.078 0.27 $0.117
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.654 0.17 $0.363
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.153 4.89 $0.013
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.392 0.85 $0.074
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.725 0.60 $0.105
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.253 0.14 $0.453
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.011 0.13 $0.494
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 41.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.423 1.15 $0.052
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.078 0.27 $0.117
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 19.0% 20 $3.00 2.064 0.49 $0.128
RTU - Maintenance 41.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.414 1.13 $0.053
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.600 1.33 $0.025
Heat Pump - Maintenance 1.6% 100.0% 4 $0.03 0.589 3.34 $0.014
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.18 0.298 0.63 $0.056
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 3.2% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.292 0.37 $0.091
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.243 1.47 $0.023
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.070 0.24 $0.130
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.031 0.75 $0.046
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.546 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.156 9.11 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.01 0.585 17.18 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.156 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-114 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 67.5% 100.0% 15 $0.29 0.044 0.05 $0.664
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.019 81.76 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 42.2% 50.0% 8 $0.09 0.919 2.88 $0.015
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.074 24.84 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 55.5% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.368 0.52 $0.085
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 21.8% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.184 0.26 $0.170
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 14.3% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.130 0.07 $0.422
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.229 0.10 $0.342
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 14.3% 45.0% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.064 0.06 $0.487
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.161 1.60 $0.019
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.193 0.03 $1.088
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.087 0.13 $0.234
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.010 0.41 $0.079
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.004 0.01 $4.042
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.03 0.010 0.04 $0.729
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.003 0.07 $0.430
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.010 3.67 $0.009
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.015 0.59 $0.055
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.03 0.010 0.10 $0.314
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.021 0.02 $1.695
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.020 55.03 $0.001
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.221 0.34 $0.142
Pool Pump - Timer 33.8% 45.0% 10 $0.44 - - $0.000
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed Control 1.6% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.012 0.03 $1.104
Energy Management System 49.5% 75.0% 14 $0.35 2.298 2.82 $0.016
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 78.0% 78.0% 11 $0.13 1.177 2.92 $0.014
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.051 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-115
Table C-30 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Large Office, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.278 0.41 $0.083
Insulation - Ducting 16.7% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.343 0.32 $0.106
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.247 0.37 $0.093
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.78 0.622 0.31 $0.111
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 1.241 1.07 $0.031
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 75.0% 100.0% 20 $2.57 1.814 0.27 $0.125
Roof - High Reflectivity 41.7% 100.0% 15 $0.04 0.138 1.28 $0.028
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.756 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.489 3.52 $0.010
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.507 0.53 $0.069
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.848 0.40 $0.089
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.201 0.30 $0.119
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $6.218
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 41.7% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.656 1.26 $0.025
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.104 0.35 $0.088
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.809 0.52 $0.061
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.591 3.82 $0.010
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.625 0.58 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.909 0.43 $0.083
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.215 0.32 $0.111
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.009 0.06 $0.580
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 41.7% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.703 1.36 $0.024
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.104 0.35 $0.088
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 3.0% 20 $3.00 1.957 0.26 $0.135
RTU - Maintenance 41.7% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.561 1.07 $0.030
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.532 1.16 $0.029
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.878 1.57 $0.019
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.454 0.99 $0.034
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 1.125 0.82 $0.040
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 15.0% 10 $0.04 0.389 2.29 $0.014
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.094 0.32 $0.097
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 41.7% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.042 0.33 $0.104
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.728 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.208 9.94 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 0.780 18.60 $0.002
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-116 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.208 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 67.5% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.059 0.25 $0.143
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.052 177.5
9 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 21.1% 25.0% 8 $0.29 1.231 1.06 $0.036
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.098 29.08 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 27.7% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.492 0.43 $0.089
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 21.8% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.246 0.30 $0.127
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 41.7% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.134 0.07 $0.408
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.40 0.351 0.19 $0.178
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 33.3% 67.5% 11 $0.50 0.299 0.17 $0.209
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.062 0.05 $0.508
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.154 1.14 $0.020
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.185 0.02 $1.134
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.029 0.04 $0.679
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.045 0.06 $0.455
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.005 0.68 $0.039
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.010 0.02 $1.518
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.01 0.005 0.07 $0.360
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.00 0.001 0.13 $0.212
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.005 6.20 $0.004
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.007 0.99 $0.027
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.005 0.18 $0.155
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.015 0.01 $2.350
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.032 80.24 $0.001
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.359 0.36 $0.122
Pool Pump - Timer 8.3% 45.0% 10 $0.13 - - $0.000
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 8.3% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.004 0.01 $3.018
Energy Management System 80.0% 100.0% 14 $0.35 2.596 2.45 $0.014
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 15.8% 20.0% 11 $0.13 0.988 1.99 $0.016
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.267 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 90.0% 7 $0.38 1.067 0.52 $0.061
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 66.7% 90.0% 5 $0.05 0.523 1.65 $0.022
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-117
Table C-31 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Large Office, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.250 0.38 $0.092
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.357 0.34 $0.101
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.135 0.20 $0.170
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.78 0.499 0.25 $0.138
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.800 0.70 $0.049
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 20 $1.84 1.160 0.24 $0.140
Roof - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.04 0.080 0.78 $0.048
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.500 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.894 2.20 $0.017
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.043 0.38 $0.099
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.563 0.27 $0.135
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.226 0.34 $0.106
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $6.765
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 50.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.318 0.62 $0.052
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.100 0.34 $0.091
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.490 0.32 $0.101
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 55.1% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.807 1.98 $0.019
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.028 0.38 $0.100
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.552 0.27 $0.137
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.221 0.34 $0.108
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.008 0.05 $0.690
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 50.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.312 0.61 $0.053
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.100 0.34 $0.091
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 1.0% 20 $3.00 1.516 0.22 $0.175
RTU - Maintenance 50.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.304 0.60 $0.054
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.465 1.00 $0.033
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.452 0.83 $0.037
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.479 1.09 $0.033
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 1.178 0.89 $0.038
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 8.7% 15.0% 10 $0.04 0.447 2.73 $0.012
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.090 0.31 $0.102
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.040 0.32 $0.108
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.699 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.200 10.61 $0.003
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-118 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 0.748 19.97 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.200 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 67.5% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.037 0.17 $0.218
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.050 190.1
5 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 42.2% 50.0% 8 $0.19 1.015 1.36 $0.029
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.081 24.92 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 55.5% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.406 0.41 $0.096
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 43.5% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.203 0.26 $0.154
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 50.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.101 0.06 $0.543
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.40 0.304 0.16 $0.206
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 100.0% 100.0% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.037 0.04 $0.841
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.093 0.93 $0.034
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.112 0.02 $1.878
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.026 0.05 $0.752
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.022 0.03 $0.922
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.002 0.41 $0.079
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.008 0.02 $1.842
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.01 0.002 0.04 $0.729
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.00 0.001 0.07 $0.430
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.002 3.68 $0.009
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.004 0.59 $0.055
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.002 0.10 $0.314
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.013 0.01 $2.695
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.032 82.09 $0.001
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.354 0.41 $0.111
Pool Pump - Timer 33.8% 45.0% 10 $0.13 - - $0.000
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 50.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.005 0.01 $2.871
Energy Management System 95.0% 100.0% 14 $0.35 1.926 1.88 $0.019
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 0.979 1.98 $0.017
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.065 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-119
Table C-32 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Restaurant, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.291 0.36 $0.079
Insulation - Ducting 10.7% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.399 0.35 $0.091
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 4.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.259 0.32 $0.089
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.34 0.329 0.33 $0.091
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.554 0.49 $0.070
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 53.6% 100.0% 20 $5.13 0.942 0.06 $0.480
Roof - High Reflectivity 35.7% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.271 0.71 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.969 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 26.2% 65.0% 15 $0.15 2.235 6.36 $0.007
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.903 0.78 $0.054
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 0.0% 75.0% 10 $1.73 1.080 0.20 $0.213
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.181 0.07 $0.631
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $5.038
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 64.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.824 1.43 $0.027
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.704 2.35 $0.013
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.931 0.15 $0.255
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 26.2% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.708 5.00 $0.009
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.833 0.78 $0.056
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 0.0% 75.0% 10 $1.73 1.038 0.19 $0.222
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.174 0.07 $0.657
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.010 0.08 $0.525
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 64.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.791 1.39 $0.028
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.704 2.35 $0.013
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 3.223 1.00 $0.000
RTU - Maintenance 64.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.918 1.56 $0.024
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.585 1.12 $0.026
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 1.009 4.06 $0.008
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.449 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 0.857 0.62 $0.053
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.644 3.75 $0.009
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.634 2.11 $0.014
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 28.6% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.282 6.53 $0.005
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 4.931 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 1.409 14.48 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.08 5.284 27.01 $0.001
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-120 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.409 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 18.1% 100.0% 15 $0.38 0.399 0.36 $0.097
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.352 258.15 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 2.2% 50.0% 8 $0.11 1.588 2.75 $0.011
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.127 28.15 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 75.0% 8 $0.30 0.635 0.40 $0.074
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 4.4% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.318 0.30 $0.099
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 3.6% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.527 0.24 $0.104
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.113 0.05 $0.691
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 7.1% 37.5% 11 $0.50 0.096 0.05 $0.648
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.191 1.00 $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 19.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.478 3.61 $0.007
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.573 0.06 $0.366
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.416 0.53 $0.048
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 4.139 5.19 $0.005
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.06 0.460 2.06 $0.012
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.331 0.51 $0.047
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.22 0.460 0.23 $0.111
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.09 0.138 0.38 $0.065
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.414 10.53 $0.002
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.460 18.72 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.06 0.690 3.00 $0.008
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.19 0.460 0.53 $0.048
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.109 0.08 $0.330
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.006 14.22 $0.003
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.30 0.064 0.06 $0.730
Pool Pump - Timer 0.0% 45.0% 10 $0.44 - - $0.000
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.036 0.10 $0.365
Energy Management System 0.2% 20.0% 14 $0.35 3.272 2.95 $0.011
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 30.2% 80.0% 11 $0.13 1.393 2.85 $0.012
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.412 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 0.0% 10.1% 0 $0.38 1.190 - $0.000
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 10.7% 15.0% 5 $0.10 0.731 0.95 $0.031
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.644 3.75 $0.009

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-121
Table C-33 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Restaurant, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.345 0.55 $0.066
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.423 0.44 $0.086
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 4.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.056 0.09 $0.409
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.34 0.321 0.37 $0.093
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.282 0.27 $0.138
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 0.0% 100.0% 20 $3.86 0.826 0.08 $0.413
Roof - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.138 0.38 $0.111
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.724 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 26.2% 65.0% 15 $0.15 2.134 6.24 $0.007
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.482 0.63 $0.070
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $1.73 0.851 0.16 $0.271
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.229 0.09 $0.500
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $5.157
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 100.0% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.449 0.79 $0.049
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.672 2.29 $0.014
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.582 0.10 $0.408
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 26.2% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.123 3.29 $0.013
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.192 0.51 $0.087
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $1.73 0.683 0.13 $0.337
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.184 0.07 $0.622
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.008 0.07 $0.642
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 100.0% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.361 0.64 $0.061
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.672 2.29 $0.014
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 2.276 1.00 $0.000
RTU - Maintenance 100.0% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.454 0.80 $0.049
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.506 1.12 $0.030
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 0.562 2.40 $0.015
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.193 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 0.410 0.31 $0.110
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.327 1.98 $0.017
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.605 2.06 $0.015
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.268 6.39 $0.005
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 4.702 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-122 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 1.343 14.09 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.08 5.038 26.59 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.343 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 18.1% 100.0% 15 $0.38 0.380 0.36 $0.101
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.168 126.4
8 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 4.4% 50.0% 8 $0.09 0.734 1.68 $0.019
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.059 14.24 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.294 0.24 $0.133
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 8.9% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.147 0.15 $0.213
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.211 0.10 $0.259
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.084 0.04 $0.932
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 0.0% 37.5% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.114 1.00 $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 19.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.284 2.84 $0.011
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.341 0.05 $0.615
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.375 0.68 $0.053
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 1.807 2.90 $0.011
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.06 0.201 1.28 $0.028
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.202 0.43 $0.078
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.22 0.201 0.12 $0.254
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.09 0.060 0.23 $0.150
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.181 5.89 $0.005
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.201 11.50 $0.003
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.06 0.301 1.84 $0.019
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.19 0.201 0.32 $0.109
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.079 0.06 $0.457
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.006 14.24 $0.003
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.061 0.07 $0.638
Pool Pump - Timer 33.8% 45.0% 10 $0.44 - - $0.000
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.038 0.10 $0.347
Energy Management System 5.0% 20.0% 14 $0.35 2.185 2.18 $0.017
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 0.897 1.94 $0.018
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.026 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.327 1.98 $0.017

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-123
Table C-34 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Retail, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.403 0.67 $0.057
Insulation - Ducting 20.5% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.290 0.28 $0.125
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 1.052 1.62 $0.022
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.34 0.645 0.75 $0.047
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.398 0.38 $0.098
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 45.2% 100.0% 20 $1.18 1.029 0.35 $0.101
Roof - High Reflectivity 57.5% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.284 1.64 $0.027
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.631 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.5% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.861 5.92 $0.008
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.238 0.57 $0.083
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.86 0.720 0.30 $0.159
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.089 0.04 $1.285
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $7.155
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 45.2% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.540 1.07 $0.041
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.090 0.30 $0.102
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.604 0.11 $0.393
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.5% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.944 2.98 $0.016
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 1.189 0.54 $0.087
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.86 0.689 0.28 $0.166
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.085 0.03 $1.343
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.007 0.06 $0.748
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 45.2% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.516 1.02 $0.043
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.090 0.30 $0.102
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 13.0% 20 $3.00 2.083 0.36 $0.127
RTU - Maintenance 45.2% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.597 1.17 $0.037
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.579 1.32 $0.026
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 0.711 3.45 $0.012
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.388 0.83 $0.041
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.250 0.31 $0.107
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.277 1.63 $0.020
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.081 0.27 $0.113
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 23.3% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.036 0.82 $0.040
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.629 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.180 13.45 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.01 0.674 25.10 $0.001
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-124 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.180 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 76.6% 100.0% 15 $0.05 0.051 0.31 $0.110
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.045 239.94 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 7.0% 50.0% 8 $0.11 1.469 2.90 $0.012
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.118 30.27 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 16.9% 75.0% 8 $0.30 0.588 0.42 $0.080
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 16.0% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.294 0.32 $0.107
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 12.3% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.313 0.15 $0.175
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.243 0.10 $0.322
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 9.6% 30.0% 11 $0.50 0.207 0.11 $0.302
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.096 0.08 $0.326
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 17.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.240 2.00 $0.013
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.288 0.03 $0.728
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.046 0.06 $0.433
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.455 0.58 $0.045
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.051 2.09 $0.012
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.036 0.06 $0.430
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.051 0.23 $0.111
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.015 0.39 $0.065
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.046 10.52 $0.002
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.051 19.01 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.076 3.04 $0.008
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.051 0.54 $0.048
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.024 0.02 $1.498
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.005 11.87 $0.004
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.30 0.054 0.05 $0.873
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.001 0.00 $13.035
Energy Management System 46.8% 75.0% 14 $0.35 2.713 2.72 $0.014
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 17.1% 25.0% 11 $0.13 1.652 3.40 $0.010
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.081 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 60.9% 7 $0.38 0.911 0.50 $0.071
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 31.5% 75.0% 5 $0.10 0.636 0.91 $0.036
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.028 0.16 $0.202

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-125
Table C-35 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Retail, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.318 0.52 $0.072
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.275 0.27 $0.132
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.833 1.25 $0.028
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.34 0.498 0.57 $0.060
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.212 0.21 $0.184
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 72.7% 100.0% 20 $0.77 1.072 0.54 $0.063
Roof - High Reflectivity 63.6% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.153 0.95 $0.050
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.448 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.5% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.090 3.57 $0.014
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 0.917 0.43 $0.113
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 10.0% 75.0% 10 $0.86 0.479 0.20 $0.239
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.187 0.08 $0.611
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $8.580
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 45.4% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.280 0.56 $0.079
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.085 0.29 $0.107
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.355 0.07 $0.669
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.5% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.276 0.90 $0.054
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 0.727 0.34 $0.142
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 10.0% 75.0% 10 $0.86 0.379 0.16 $0.302
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.148 0.06 $0.772
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.005 0.04 $1.084
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 45.4% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.221 0.45 $0.100
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.085 0.29 $0.107
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 13.0% 20 $3.00 1.596 0.29 $0.166
RTU - Maintenance 45.4% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.320 0.64 $0.069
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.506 1.12 $0.030
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 0.331 1.67 $0.025
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.286 0.63 $0.056
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.193 0.25 $0.138
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.200 1.21 $0.028
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.077 0.26 $0.119
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.034 0.81 $0.042
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.597 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-126 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.171 13.20 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.01 0.640 24.95 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.171 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 76.6% 100.0% 15 $0.06 0.032 0.19 $0.184
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.021 118.5
8 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 14.0% 50.0% 8 $0.09 0.972 2.45 $0.014
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.078 21.07 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 33.8% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.389 0.35 $0.101
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 32.0% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.194 0.22 $0.161
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 18.2% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.161 0.08 $0.339
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.214 0.09 $0.365
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 9.1% 30.0% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.095 0.09 $0.329
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 17.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.238 2.35 $0.013
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.286 0.04 $0.734
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.041 0.08 $0.479
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.199 0.32 $0.102
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.022 1.26 $0.028
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.022 0.05 $0.706
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.022 0.12 $0.254
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.007 0.23 $0.150
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.020 5.89 $0.005
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.022 11.33 $0.003
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.033 1.81 $0.019
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.022 0.31 $0.109
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.017 0.01 $2.134
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.005 11.88 $0.004
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.051 0.06 $0.762
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.001 0.00 $12.397
Energy Management System 56.2% 75.0% 14 $0.35 1.913 1.96 $0.020
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 1.265 2.61 $0.013
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.814 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-127
Table C-36 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Grocery, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.603 0.97 $0.038
Insulation - Ducting 33.3% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.453 0.49 $0.080
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 0.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 1.301 2.33 $0.018
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.34 0.822 1.13 $0.036
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.415 0.39 $0.094
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 33.3% 100.0% 20 $0.88 1.131 0.62 $0.069
Roof - High Reflectivity 66.7% 100.0% 15 $0.15 1.169 2.39 $0.013
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.274 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 45.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.260 0.67 $0.058
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 0.539 0.20 $0.192
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.37 0.313 0.24 $0.157
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.039 0.01 $2.954
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.02 $1.779
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.233 0.36 $0.095
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.229 0.76 $0.040
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.263 0.04 $0.903
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 45.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.482 1.23 $0.031
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 0.517 0.19 $0.200
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.37 0.300 0.23 $0.164
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.037 0.01 $3.087
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.02 $1.859
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.223 0.34 $0.099
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.229 0.76 $0.040
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 18.0% 20 $3.00 0.906 0.12 $0.292
RTU - Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.258 0.39 $0.085
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.624 1.76 $0.024
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 0.822 2.90 $0.010
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.18 0.055 0.11 $0.309
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 0.984 0.72 $0.046
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.545 3.21 $0.010
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.206 0.68 $0.044
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 22.2% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.092 2.12 $0.016
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.603 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.458 13.19 $0.002
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-128 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.03 1.717 24.83 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.458 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.12 0.130 0.38 $0.093
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.114 236.47 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 2.5% 50.0% 8 $0.11 2.350 4.79 $0.007
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.188 50.50 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 5.8% 75.0% 8 $0.30 0.940 0.70 $0.050
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 22.1% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.470 0.53 $0.067
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.314 0.15 $0.174
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.609 0.25 $0.129
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 44.4% 49.4% 11 $0.55 0.517 0.26 $0.133
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.123 0.09 $0.255
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 31.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.306 2.24 $0.010
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.368 0.04 $0.570
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 1.895 2.44 $0.010
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 6.604 8.57 $0.003
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.06 0.734 3.33 $0.008
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.848 1.36 $0.018
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.23 0.734 0.37 $0.071
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 17.9% 37.5% 15 $0.09 0.220 0.62 $0.042
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.660 16.38 $0.001
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.734 30.26 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.06 1.101 4.84 $0.005
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.19 0.734 0.86 $0.031
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.050 0.04 $0.723
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.000 0.82 $0.051
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.30 0.038 0.03 $1.241
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.007 1.00 $0.000
Energy Management System 30.0% 40.0% 14 $0.35 3.330 3.24 $0.011
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 39.8% 65.0% 11 $0.13 2.518 5.81 $0.006
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.292 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 40.0% 7 $0.38 1.088 0.55 $0.060
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 55.6% 75.0% 5 $0.10 1.001 1.46 $0.023
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.055 0.32 $0.103

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-129
Table C-37 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Grocery, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.338 0.52 $0.068
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.312 0.30 $0.116
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 0.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.873 1.29 $0.026
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.34 0.607 0.70 $0.049
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.192 0.17 $0.203
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 33.3% 100.0% 20 $0.66 1.116 0.64 $0.052
Roof - High Reflectivity 66.7% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.216 0.55 $0.071
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.194 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 45.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.204 0.54 $0.074
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 0.397 0.15 $0.260
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.37 0.207 0.16 $0.238
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.081 0.03 $1.413
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.00 $19.266
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.120 0.19 $0.184
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.220 0.74 $0.041
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 4 $0.86 0.165 0.02 $1.436
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 45.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.319 0.84 $0.047
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.5% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0.0% 0.0% 20 $1.17 0.339 0.13 $0.305
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.37 0.177 0.14 $0.279
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow System 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.86 0.069 0.02 $1.657
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.002 0.02 $2.259
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.103 0.16 $0.215
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.220 0.74 $0.041
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 14.0% 20 $3.00 0.651 0.10 $0.407
RTU - Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.08 0.130 0.20 $0.170
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.5% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.528 1.17 $0.028
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.03 0.264 0.97 $0.031
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.18 0.004 0.01 $4.641
Ventilation - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 0.782 0.59 $0.058
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.427 2.59 $0.013
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.198 0.66 $0.046
Water Heater - Faucet
Aerators/Low Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.01 0.088 2.07 $0.016
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.539 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-130 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.440 12.79 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.03 1.649 24.23 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.440 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.12 0.081 0.24 $0.148
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 40.4% 50.0% 10 $0.00 0.093 195.5
2 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 5.0% 50.0% 8 $0.09 1.784 4.57 $0.008
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.143 39.49 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy
Sensors 11.5% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.714 0.66 $0.055
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 44.2% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.357 0.41 $0.088
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.160 0.08 $0.341
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level
Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.546 0.23 $0.143
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 44.4% 49.4% 11 $0.55 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.073 0.07 $0.429
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 31.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.182 1.81 $0.017
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.219 0.03 $0.958
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 1.710 3.11 $0.012
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 2.891 4.72 $0.007
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 10.0% 75.0% 16 $0.06 0.321 2.03 $0.018
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.623 1.33 $0.025
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 10.0% 7.5% 5 $0.23 0.321 0.19 $0.163
Refrigerator - Floating Head
Pressure 22.9% 37.5% 15 $0.09 0.096 0.37 $0.096
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 10.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.289 9.18 $0.003
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 30.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.321 18.30 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 30.0% 37.5% 15 $0.06 0.482 2.93 $0.012
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.19 0.321 0.50 $0.070
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.035 0.03 $1.030
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.003 8.26 $0.005
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 7.1% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.036 0.04 $1.087
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.007 0.02 $1.802
Energy Management System 36.0% 40.0% 14 $0.35 1.943 1.84 $0.019
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 1.352 2.74 $0.012
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.759 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with
Sensor Control 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.043 0.26 $0.131

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-131
Table C-38 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— College, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.531 0.89 $0.043
Insulation - Ducting 55.5% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.829 0.89 $0.044
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 2.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.473 0.80 $0.048
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.09 0.317 1.49 $0.025
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 2.173 2.03 $0.018
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 44.5% 100.0% 20 $1.33 0.623 0.20 $0.189
Roof - High Reflectivity 22.2% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.551 1.58 $0.028
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 0.605 1.05 $0.041
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 67.8% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.159 0.48 $0.097
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 1.362 0.61 $0.076
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.513 1.98 $0.023
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.151 0.58 $0.079
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $7.816
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.591 1.53 $0.028
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.208 0.70 $0.044
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 0.591 1.02 $0.042
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 67.8% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.163 0.50 $0.094
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 1.331 0.60 $0.078
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.501 1.94 $0.024
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.148 0.57 $0.081
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.007 0.06 $0.801
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.577 1.50 $0.029
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.208 0.70 $0.044
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 5.4% 20 $3.00 1.814 0.31 $0.146
RTU - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.520 1.34 $0.032
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 73.4% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1.111 2.58 $0.014
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.132 2.50 $0.015
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.464 0.97 $0.034
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.480 0.58 $0.055
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.191 1.10 $0.029
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.187 0.63 $0.049
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 55.5% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.083 0.65 $0.052
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.457 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-132 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 0.416 10.24 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.03 1.561 19.02 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.416 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 100.0% 100.0% 15 $0.11 0.118 0.38 $0.093
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.104 182.10 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.6% 20.0% 8 $0.29 1.200 1.05 $0.038
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.096 29.26 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 42.4% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.480 0.43 $0.091
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 4.8% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.240 0.30 $0.130
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 11.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.181 0.10 $0.302
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.289 0.31 $0.108
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 55.5% 60.5% 11 $0.50 0.245 0.14 $0.254
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.073 0.05 $0.427
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 6.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.183 1.30 $0.017
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.220 0.02 $0.954
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.016 0.02 $1.219
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.162 0.20 $0.126
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.018 1.39 $0.018
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.014 0.02 $1.115
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.01 0.018 0.15 $0.166
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.005 0.26 $0.098
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.016 7.01 $0.003
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.018 12.64 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.027 2.02 $0.012
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.018 0.36 $0.072
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.009 0.01 $4.219
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.007 17.24 $0.003
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 41.7% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.077 0.08 $0.572
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 11.1% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.001 0.00 $17.867
Energy Management System 76.7% 85.0% 14 $0.35 3.911 4.05 $0.010
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 26.6% 30.0% 11 $0.13 1.617 3.78 $0.010
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.763 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 80.9% 7 $0.38 1.486 0.80 $0.044
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 66.7% 80.9% 5 $0.05 0.517 1.65 $0.022
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.038 0.22 $0.147

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-133
Table C-39 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— College, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.414 0.65 $0.055
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.580 0.59 $0.062
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 2.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.226 0.36 $0.101
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.09 0.287 1.26 $0.028
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 1.265 1.10 $0.031
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 44.5% 100.0% 20 $1.00 0.495 0.20 $0.179
Roof - High Reflectivity 22.2% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.177 0.55 $0.087
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 0.456 0.81 $0.054
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 67.8% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.005 0.02 $3.014
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 1.033 0.48 $0.100
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.369 1.47 $0.032
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.139 0.55 $0.086
Air-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.001 0.01 $9.315
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.314 0.83 $0.053
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.194 0.67 $0.047
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Condenser Water Temperature
Reset
60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 0.500 0.88 $0.050
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Economizer 67.8% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.117 0.37 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on
Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 1.133 0.53 $0.091
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.404 1.61 $0.030
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.152 0.60 $0.079
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.006 0.06 $0.850
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.344 0.91 $0.048
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller
Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.194 0.67 $0.047
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 3.2% 20 $3.00 1.498 0.27 $0.177
RTU - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.301 0.80 $0.055
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 73.4% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.976 2.11 $0.016
Heat Pump - Maintenance 33.3% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.510 1.08 $0.032
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.310 0.69 $0.052
Ventilation - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.373 0.47 $0.071
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.150 0.91 $0.037
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.174 0.60 $0.052
Water Heater - Faucet
Aerators/Low Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.077 0.62 $0.056
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-134 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.356 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 0.387 9.76 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.03 1.453 18.37 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.387 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 100.0% 100.0% 15 $0.11 0.072 0.24 $0.153
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.048 87.46 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 3.3% 20.0% 8 $0.19 1.072 1.46 $0.028
Interior Lighting - LED Exit
Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.086 26.87 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy
Sensors 84.8% 86.0% 8 $0.25 0.429 0.45 $0.091
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks
and Timers 9.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.214 0.28 $0.146
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 11.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.162 0.09 $0.337
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level
Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.265 0.29 $0.118
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp
and Install Reflectors 55.5% 60.5% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level
Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.041 0.04 $0.763
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 6.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.103 1.02 $0.031
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.123 0.02 $1.704
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.015 0.03 $1.351
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.070 0.11 $0.289
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.008 0.84 $0.041
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.008 0.02 $1.861
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.01 0.008 0.08 $0.381
Refrigerator - Floating Head
Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.002 0.15 $0.225
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.007 3.94 $0.008
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.008 7.59 $0.005
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.012 1.21 $0.029
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.008 0.21 $0.164
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.007 0.00 $5.511
Office Equipment - ENERGY
STAR Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.007 17.34 $0.003
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 41.7% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.074 0.09 $0.528
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable
Speed Control 11.1% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.001 0.00 $16.993
Energy Management System 80.6% 85.0% 14 $0.35 2.630 2.63 $0.014
Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 1.128 2.47 $0.014
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.252 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with
Sensor Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.030 0.18 $0.187
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-135
Table C-40 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— School, Existing Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.406 0.84 $0.056
Insulation - Ducting 26.9% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.629 0.84 $0.057
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 2.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.362 0.75 $0.063
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.78 0.243 0.16 $0.283
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 1.653 1.81 $0.024
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 73.1% 100.0% 20 $1.33 0.473 0.18 $0.248
Roof - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.421 1.70 $0.037
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.383 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.101 0.45 $0.153
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.862 0.56 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.325 1.87 $0.037
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.096 0.28 $0.250
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.01 $12.673
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 73.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.374 1.51 $0.044
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.124 0.39 $0.074
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.374 0.51 $0.133
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.112 0.50 $0.138
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.841 0.56 $0.123
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.317 1.85 $0.038
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.093 0.27 $0.257
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.05 $1.298
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 73.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.365 1.49 $0.045
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.124 0.39 $0.074
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.5% 20 $3.00 1.147 0.28 $0.231
RTU - Maintenance 73.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.329 1.32 $0.050
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.852 2.27 $0.018
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.830 2.66 $0.020
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.19 0.311 0.59 $0.056
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.280 0.34 $0.095
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 15.0% 10 $0.04 0.111 0.64 $0.050
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.111 0.35 $0.082
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 30.8% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.050 0.36 $0.087
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.866 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-136 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.248 9.61 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 0.928 18.11 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.248 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 89.0% 90.0% 15 $0.11 0.070 0.21 $0.157
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.062 172.39 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 8.1% 25.0% 8 $0.29 0.590 0.44 $0.076
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.047 12.05 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 30.0% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.236 0.18 $0.186
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 4.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.118 0.12 $0.265
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 3.9% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.129 0.07 $0.425
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.40 0.092 0.05 $0.683
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 19.2% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.078 0.04 $0.800
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.063 0.05 $0.497
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 6.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.157 1.14 $0.020
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.189 0.02 $1.110
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.021 0.03 $0.948
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.208 0.26 $0.098
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.023 1.39 $0.018
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.018 0.03 $0.867
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.023 0.15 $0.166
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.007 0.26 $0.098
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.021 7.03 $0.003
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.023 12.64 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.035 2.02 $0.012
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.023 0.36 $0.072
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.011 0.01 $3.281
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.005 11.13 $0.003
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.061 0.05 $0.723
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 3.9% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.001 0.00 $15.663
Energy Management System 70.0% 85.0% 14 $0.35 2.872 3.59 $0.013
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 27.0% 30.0% 11 $0.13 1.233 3.61 $0.013
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.326 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 77.5% 7 $0.38 1.117 0.75 $0.058
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 30.8% 77.5% 5 $0.05 0.268 0.70 $0.043
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.011 0.06 $0.503

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-137
Table C-41 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— School, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.312 0.54 $0.073
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.432 0.49 $0.084
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 2.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.170 0.29 $0.135
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.78 0.218 0.12 $0.316
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.958 0.86 $0.041
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 66.5% 100.0% 20 $1.00 0.372 0.16 $0.238
Roof - High Reflectivity 33.5% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.122 0.56 $0.126
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.288 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 56.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.003 0.01 $4.774
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.652 0.45 $0.158
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.233 1.39 $0.051
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.087 0.26 $0.274
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.01 $14.225
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 66.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.198 0.82 $0.084
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.115 0.37 $0.079
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.315 0.43 $0.157
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Economizer 56.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.082 0.38 $0.188
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on
Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.715 0.49 $0.144
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.255 1.52 $0.047
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.096 0.28 $0.250
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.05 $1.300
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Maintenance 66.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.217 0.90 $0.076
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller
Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.115 0.37 $0.079
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 2.6% 20 $3.00 0.947 0.25 $0.279
RTU - Maintenance 66.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.190 0.79 $0.087
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.749 1.63 $0.021
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.397 1.07 $0.042
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.19 0.244 0.49 $0.072
Ventilation - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.217 0.28 $0.123
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 8.7% 15.0% 10 $0.04 0.087 0.53 $0.064
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.104 0.33 $0.088
Water Heater - Faucet
Aerators/Low Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.046 0.35 $0.093
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-138 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.806 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.230 9.16 $0.003
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 0.864 17.49 $0.002
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.230 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 89.0% 90.0% 15 $0.11 0.043 0.13 $0.258
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.029 82.81 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 16.2% 25.0% 8 $0.19 0.511 0.59 $0.058
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.041 10.97 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Occupancy
Sensors 60.0% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.205 0.18 $0.191
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 8.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.102 0.11 $0.306
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.116 0.06 $0.473
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level
Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.40 0.084 0.04 $0.745
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 66.5% 71.5% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.036 0.04 $0.879
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 6.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.089 0.89 $0.035
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.107 0.01 $1.963
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.019 0.03 $1.050
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.091 0.14 $0.225
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.010 0.84 $0.041
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.011 0.02 $1.447
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.010 0.08 $0.381
Refrigerator - Floating Head
Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.003 0.15 $0.225
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.009 3.92 $0.008
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.010 7.57 $0.005
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.015 1.21 $0.029
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.010 0.21 $0.164
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.008 0.01 $4.286
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.005 11.12 $0.003
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.058 0.06 $0.670
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable
Speed Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.001 0.00 $14.896
Energy Management System 77.0% 85.0% 14 $0.35 1.860 2.01 $0.020
Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable 71.5% 71.5% 11 $0.13 0.843 2.07 $0.019
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.924 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with
Sensor Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.009 0.05 $0.641

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-139
Table C-42 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Hospital, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.616 0.92 $0.037
Insulation - Ducting 9.8% 90.0% 20 $0.41 1.316 1.27 $0.027
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.518 0.78 $0.044
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.09 2.272 9.76 $0.003
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 3.435 2.99 $0.011
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 65.9% 100.0% 20 $0.30 0.935 1.20 $0.028
Roof - High Reflectivity 39.0% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.474 2.24 $0.016
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.425 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 81.0% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.432 1.03 $0.036
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 3.094 1.10 $0.033
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.30 1.460 1.31 $0.027
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.456 1.36 $0.026
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.002 0.01 $3.173
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 48.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.344 2.60 $0.012
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.456 1.51 $0.020
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 1.466 1.90 $0.017
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 81.0% 90.0% 15 $0.15 1.199 2.89 $0.013
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 3.188 1.15 $0.032
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.30 1.502 1.36 $0.027
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.469 1.41 $0.026
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.017 0.12 $0.309
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 48.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.382 2.69 $0.012
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.456 1.51 $0.020
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 2.0% 20 $3.00 4.422 0.59 $0.060
RTU - Maintenance 48.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.267 2.44 $0.013
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 73.4% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1.686 3.69 $0.009
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 2.006 3.61 $0.008
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.454 0.97 $0.034
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 2.4% 90.0% 10 $0.34 1.495 1.06 $0.030
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.570 3.28 $0.010
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.410 1.35 $0.022
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 19.5% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.182 1.40 $0.024
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 3.189 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-140 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 0.911 20.17 $0.001
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.04 3.417 38.00 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.911 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 93.8% 100.0% 15 $0.10 0.258 0.84 $0.042
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.228 361.77 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 0.9% 20.0% 8 $0.29 1.574 1.26 $0.029
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.126 35.19 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 30.3% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.630 0.52 $0.070
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 14.9% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.315 0.37 $0.099
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 9.8% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.199 0.10 $0.275
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.433 0.45 $0.072
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 12.2% 25.0% 11 $0.50 0.368 0.20 $0.169
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.056 0.04 $0.556
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 11.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.141 1.05 $0.022
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.169 0.02 $1.243
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.029 0.04 $0.689
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.286 0.36 $0.071
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.032 2.10 $0.012
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.023 0.04 $0.684
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.032 0.23 $0.111
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.010 0.39 $0.065
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.029 10.56 $0.002
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.032 19.06 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.048 3.05 $0.008
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.032 0.54 $0.048
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.015 0.01 $2.385
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.009 21.44 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 41.7% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.096 0.10 $0.456
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 2.4% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.007 0.02 $1.840
Energy Management System 60.0% 85.0% 14 $0.35 5.762 5.36 $0.006
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 15.7% 20.0% 11 $0.13 2.938 5.94 $0.006
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 2.950 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 72.5% 7 $0.38 2.485 1.20 $0.026
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 12.2% 80.0% 5 $0.05 0.658 1.97 $0.017
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.114 0.66 $0.049

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-141
Table C-43 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Hospital, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 2.874 4.29 $0.008
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 1.110 1.09 $0.033
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 1.858 2.77 $0.012
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.09 0.706 3.16 $0.011
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 2.055 1.80 $0.019
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 90.9% 100.0% 20 $0.18 2.365 5.10 $0.007
Roof - High Reflectivity 45.5% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.384 1.89 $0.020
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.209 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 81.0% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.599 1.49 $0.026
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 2.637 0.98 $0.039
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 50.0% 75.0% 10 $0.30 1.149 1.06 $0.035
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.415 1.28 $0.029
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.002 0.01 $2.957
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 72.7% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.802 1.59 $0.021
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.446 1.49 $0.020
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 1.297 1.71 $0.019
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 81.0% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.755 1.87 $0.020
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 73.4% 81.0% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 2.836 1.05 $0.036
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 50.0% 75.0% 10 $0.30 1.234 1.14 $0.032
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.09 0.446 1.37 $0.027
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.019 0.13 $0.275
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 72.7% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.861 1.70 $0.019
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.446 1.49 $0.020
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 1.0% 20 $3.00 3.684 0.53 $0.072
RTU - Maintenance 72.7% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.739 1.46 $0.022
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 73.4% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1.433 3.12 $0.011
Heat Pump - Maintenance 9.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.160 2.16 $0.014
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.334 0.76 $0.047
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.34 1.486 1.12 $0.030
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.494 3.02 $0.011
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.402 1.34 $0.023
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.179 1.39 $0.024
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 3.124 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-142 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 0.893 20.53 $0.001
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.03 3.347 38.92 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.893 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 93.8% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.165 0.69 $0.051
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.112 184.7
9 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.7% 20.0% 8 $0.19 1.406 1.76 $0.021
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.113 32.23 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 60.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.563 0.53 $0.070
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 29.9% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.281 0.33 $0.111
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 27.3% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.177 0.09 $0.309
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.390 0.41 $0.080
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.2% 25.0% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.033 0.03 $0.959
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 11.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.082 0.82 $0.038
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.098 0.01 $2.142
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.026 0.05 $0.764
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.125 0.20 $0.163
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.014 1.26 $0.027
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.013 0.03 $1.207
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.014 0.12 $0.253
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.004 0.23 $0.149
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.013 5.92 $0.005
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.014 11.35 $0.003
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.021 1.82 $0.019
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.01 0.014 0.31 $0.109
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.011 0.01 $3.305
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.008 21.46 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 41.7% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.092 0.11 $0.423
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.008 0.02 $1.750
Energy Management System 71.9% 85.0% 14 $0.35 4.575 4.35 $0.008
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.8% 86.8% 11 $0.13 2.794 5.65 $0.006
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 2.524 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.099 0.60 $0.057

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-143
Table C-44 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Lodging, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.370 0.54 $0.062
Insulation - Ducting 4.8% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.359 0.36 $0.101
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.308 0.45 $0.074
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.78 0.087 0.05 $0.787
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.824 0.70 $0.047
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 61.9% 100.0% 20 $2.53 0.278 0.04 $0.801
Roof - High Reflectivity 33.3% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.165 0.86 $0.047
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.233 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 31.8% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.056 0.14 $0.275
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.505 0.19 $0.204
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.05 0.198 1.16 $0.034
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.071 0.12 $0.337
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.00 $16.716
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 14.3% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.049 0.10 $0.338
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.400 1.26 $0.023
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.267 0.19 $0.186
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 31.8% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.075 0.19 $0.206
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.581 0.22 $0.178
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.05 0.228 1.34 $0.029
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.082 0.13 $0.294
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.03 $1.456
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 14.3% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.056 0.12 $0.295
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.400 1.26 $0.023
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 8.0% 20 $3.00 1.702 0.25 $0.155
RTU - Maintenance 14.3% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.109 0.23 $0.152
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.381 0.79 $0.040
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 0.47 $0.064
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.18 0.049 0.10 $0.343
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.251 0.31 $0.106
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.295 1.75 $0.019
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.360 1.14 $0.025
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 33.3% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.160 1.17 $0.027
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 2.803 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-144 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 0.801 7.09 $0.004
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.09 3.003 13.14 $0.003
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.801 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 89.8% 100.0% 15 $0.07 0.227 1.12 $0.029
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.200 125.96 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 0.0% 25.0% 8 $0.29 1.368 0.91 $0.033
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.109 24.44 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 7.0% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.547 0.37 $0.080
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 5.0% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.274 0.26 $0.114
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 9.5% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.495 0.23 $0.111
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.061 0.02 $1.290
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 0.0% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.052 0.03 $1.209
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.077 0.05 $0.406
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 20.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.193 1.35 $0.016
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.231 0.02 $0.906
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.042 0.05 $0.469
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.420 0.53 $0.048
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.047 2.05 $0.012
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.034 0.05 $0.466
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.047 0.23 $0.111
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.014 0.38 $0.065
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.042 10.53 $0.002
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.047 18.67 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.070 2.99 $0.008
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.047 0.53 $0.048
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.022 0.02 $1.624
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.002 4.80 $0.009
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.022 0.02 $1.982
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.003 0.01 $4.612
Energy Management System 59.0% 75.0% 14 $0.35 2.050 1.85 $0.018
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 39.8% 50.0% 11 $0.13 0.675 1.32 $0.024
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.797 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 67.0% 7 $0.38 0.671 0.34 $0.097
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 42.8% 67.0% 5 $0.05 0.586 1.49 $0.019
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.030 0.17 $0.189

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-145
Table C-45 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Lodging, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.408 0.62 $0.056
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.287 0.30 $0.126
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 5.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.097 0.16 $0.236
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.78 0.111 0.06 $0.621
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.480 0.42 $0.081
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 74.9% 100.0% 20 $1.90 0.282 0.06 $0.595
Roof - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.08 0.123 0.66 $0.063
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.179 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 31.8% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.001 0.00 $10.707
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.391 0.16 $0.264
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 10.0% 75.0% 10 $0.05 0.149 0.90 $0.045
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.070 0.12 $0.341
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.00 $15.390
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 25.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.027 0.06 $0.624
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.365 1.20 $0.025
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.188 0.14 $0.264
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Economizer 31.8% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.032 0.09 $0.484
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on
Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.411 0.17 $0.251
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset 10.0% 75.0% 10 $0.05 0.156 0.95 $0.043
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.074 0.12 $0.325
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.03 $1.468
Water-Cooled Chiller -
Maintenance 25.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.028 0.06 $0.595
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller
Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.365 1.20 $0.025
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 8.0% 20 $3.00 1.395 0.22 $0.190
RTU - Maintenance 25.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.062 0.14 $0.265
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.317 0.69 $0.049
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.139 0.26 $0.119
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.18 0.327 0.69 $0.051
Ventilation - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.193 0.25 $0.138
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.250 1.52 $0.022
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.328 1.08 $0.028
Water Heater - Faucet
Aerators/Low Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.146 1.13 $0.030
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-146 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 2.553 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.01 0.729 6.75 $0.004
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.09 2.735 12.83 $0.003
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.729 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 89.8% 100.0% 15 $0.07 0.206 1.09 $0.032
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.182 121.7
1 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 0.0% 25.0% 8 $0.19 0.878 0.94 $0.034
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.070 16.93 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy
Sensors 14.0% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.351 0.28 $0.111
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 10.1% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.176 0.18 $0.178
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.309 0.15 $0.177
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level
Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.049 0.02 $1.604
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 0.0% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.044 0.04 $0.713
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 20.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.110 1.09 $0.029
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.132 0.02 $1.591
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.038 0.07 $0.520
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.184 0.29 $0.111
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.020 1.25 $0.027
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.020 0.04 $0.765
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.020 0.12 $0.253
Refrigerator - Floating Head
Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.006 0.23 $0.149
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.018 5.91 $0.005
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.020 11.26 $0.003
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.031 1.80 $0.019
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.020 0.31 $0.109
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.016 0.01 $2.250
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.002 4.85 $0.009
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.021 0.02 $1.824
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable
Speed Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.003 0.01 $4.386
Energy Management System 64.9% 75.0% 14 $0.35 2.421 1.49 $0.015
Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable 100.0% 100.0% 11 $0.13 1.002 1.28 $0.016
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.831 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with
Sensor Control 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.025 0.15 $0.223
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-147
Table C-46 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Warehouse, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 1.022 6.28 $0.022
Insulation - Ducting 15.3% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.681 1.12 $0.053
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 1.957 12.10 $0.012
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.78 1.124 0.83 $0.061
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.906 7.96 $0.043
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 46.9% 100.0% 20 $1.33 0.607 0.84 $0.194
Roof - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 2.314 76.18 $0.007
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.627 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.235 30.28 $0.012
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.761 5.32 $0.059
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 1.027 3.76 $0.074
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.183 3.12 $0.131
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.07 $1.728
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.768 16.02 $0.020
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.038 0.09 $0.239
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.604 5.96 $0.082
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.307 27.02 $0.012
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.702 5.12 $0.061
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.993 3.60 $0.076
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.177 2.99 $0.136
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.005 0.63 $1.010
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.741 15.21 $0.022
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.038 0.09 $0.239
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 6.0% 20 $3.00 2.722 3.28 $0.097
RTU - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.780 17.18 $0.021
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1,411.84
8 2.17 $0.000
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.895 49.58 $0.009
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.13 0.203 0.26 $0.061
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 4.2% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.209 0.12 $0.128
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.072 0.19 $0.077
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.037 0.08 $0.245
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 19.5% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.017 0.08 $0.260
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.184 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-148 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.083 13.77 $0.001
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.00 0.272 25.82 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.083 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 43.7% 100.0% 15 $0.05 0.023 0.09 $0.239
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.021 246.28 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 1.344 0.34 $0.033
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.056 15.65 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 22.2% 75.0% 8 $0.28 1.547 0.23 $0.028
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 2.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.285 0.16 $0.110
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 6.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.120 0.04 $0.456
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.223 0.19 $0.140
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.3% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.189 0.08 $0.329
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.124 0.04 $0.252
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.441 0.59 $0.007
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.373 0.02 $0.562
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 1.948 1.63 $0.010
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.159 3.70 $0.006
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.063 0.09 $0.247
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.04 0.159 0.42 $0.055
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.02 0.048 0.68 $0.033
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.143 20.82 $0.001
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.159 33.66 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.238 5.39 $0.004
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.03 0.159 0.96 $0.024
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.200 0.01 $0.180
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.011 6.10 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.125 0.03 $0.350
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.002 0.01 $5.458
Energy Management System 21.4% 25.0% 14 $0.35 4.370 26.53 $0.009
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 71.9% 85.0% 11 $0.13 1.485 5.65 $0.011
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.632 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 25.0% 7 $0.38 1.665 7.06 $0.039
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.6% 75.0% 5 $0.05 0.633 0.92 $0.018
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-149
Table C-47 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Warehouse, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.644 2.15 $0.036
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.550 0.52 $0.066
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 1.046 5.17 $0.022
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.78 0.817 0.43 $0.084
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.368 1.67 $0.106
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 77.8% 100.0% 20 $1.00 0.450 0.45 $0.196
Roof - High Reflectivity 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.779 17.53 $0.020
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.454 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.655 12.44 $0.023
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.357 3.85 $0.076
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.612 2.50 $0.124
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.217 3.81 $0.110
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.005 0.53 $1.123
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.454 8.06 $0.036
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.036 0.09 $0.253
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.450 4.15 $0.110
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.529 9.28 $0.029
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal
Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.381 3.55 $0.075
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.624 2.29 $0.122
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.217 3.49 $0.110
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.005 0.49 $1.155
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.464 7.38 $0.036
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.036 0.09 $0.253
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 2.095 2.52 $0.126
RTU - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.459 8.87 $0.036
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1,411.741 1.60 $0.000
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.788 8.54 $0.021
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.13 0.163 0.21 $0.075
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.169 0.10 $0.158
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.058 0.16 $0.096
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.035 0.08 $0.260
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.016 0.08 $0.276
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.177 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-150 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.078 13.47 $0.001
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.00 0.258 25.40 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.078 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 43.7% 100.0% 15 $0.06 0.014 0.06 $0.406
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.013 120.8
4 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.919 0.43 $0.032
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.045 13.13 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 44.4% 75.0% 8 $0.25 1.022 0.22 $0.038
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 5.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.204 0.14 $0.153
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.081 0.02 $0.673
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.205 0.17 $0.153
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.7% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.080 0.03 $0.392
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.294 0.45 $0.011
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.240 0.01 $0.874
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 - - $0.000
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 1.144 1.03 $0.018
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 10.0% 75.0% 16 $0.01 0.069 2.68 $0.014
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 10.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.028 0.06 $0.565
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan
Controls 10.0% 7.5% 5 $0.04 0.069 0.24 $0.127
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 22.9% 45.0% 15 $0.02 0.021 0.49 $0.075
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 10.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.062 11.88 $0.003
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 30.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.069 24.15 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 30.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 0.104 3.86 $0.010
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 10.0% 100.0% 12 $0.03 0.069 0.66 $0.055
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.137 0.00 $0.263
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.011 6.08 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.122 0.03 $0.320
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.003 0.01 $5.191
Energy Management System 22.4% 25.0% 14 $0.35 2.515 8.06 $0.015
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.3% 86.3% 11 $0.13 1.219 5.18 $0.013
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.996 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-151
Table C-45 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data, Electric—Assembly, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.225 0.37 $0.102
Insulation - Ducting 55.5% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.236 0.25 $0.153
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.202 0.33 $0.113
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.09 0.497 2.34 $0.016
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.864 0.81 $0.045
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 44.5% 100.0% 20 $4.79 1.385 0.12 $0.305
Roof - High Reflectivity 22.2% 100.0% 15 $0.04 0.096 1.10 $0.040
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 0.354 0.64 $0.070
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.697 2.20 $0.022
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 0.708 0.33 $0.146
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.397 0.25 $0.191
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.094 0.19 $0.254
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.00 $15.033
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.307 0.84 $0.054
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.118 0.39 $0.077
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.09 0.339 0.62 $0.073
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 90.0% 15 $0.15 0.083 0.27 $0.185
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 3.0% 100.0% 20 $1.17 0.680 0.32 $0.152
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.380 0.24 $0.199
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.090 0.18 $0.266
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 25.0% 73.7% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.03 $1.571
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.294 0.81 $0.056
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.118 0.39 $0.077
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 5.4% 20 $3.00 1.187 0.21 $0.223
RTU - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.340 0.92 $0.049
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 0.448 1.06 $0.034
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.672 1.55 $0.025
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.17 0.217 0.48 $0.074
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.224 0.29 $0.119
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.078 0.47 $0.072
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.107 0.36 $0.086
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 55.5% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.047 0.37 $0.091
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.829 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.237 13.60 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.01 0.888 25.57 $0.001
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-152 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.237 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 70.3% 98.9% 15 $0.08 0.067 0.28 $0.126
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.059 243.6
7 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 12.6% 20.0% 8 $0.29 0.963 0.78 $0.047
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.077 21.77 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 18.4% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.385 0.32 $0.114
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 26.7% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.193 0.23 $0.163
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 11.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.145 0.08 $0.377
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.232 0.24 $0.135
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 15.1% 67.5% 11 $0.50 0.197 0.11 $0.317
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.122 0.10 $0.257
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.304 2.38 $0.010
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.365 0.04 $0.574
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.024 0.03 $0.817
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.241 0.30 $0.084
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.027 1.39 $0.018
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.021 0.03 $0.747
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.027 0.15 $0.166
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.008 0.26 $0.098
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.024 6.98 $0.003
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.027 12.59 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.040 2.01 $0.012
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.027 0.36 $0.072
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.013 0.01 $2.826
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.004 10.77 $0.004
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 41.7% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.049 0.05 $0.898
Pool Heater - Solar 0.0% 45.0% 20 $0.00 0.001 0.13 $0.280
Pool Pump - Timer 11.1% 45.0% 10 $0.44 0.001 0.00 $83.052
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed Control 11.1% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.000 0.00 $70.668
Energy Management System 66.8% 80.0% 14 $0.35 2.076 2.16 $0.018
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 20.3% 35.0% 11 $0.13 0.769 1.67 $0.021
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.814 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 73.4% 7 $0.38 0.686 0.39 $0.095
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 66.7% 73.4% 5 $0.05 0.446 1.32 $0.026
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 0.016 0.09 $0.360

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-153
Table C-46 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data, Electric— Assembly, New Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation
Applicabilit
y Lifetime Cost
Savings
(kBtu)
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.435 0.47 $0.053
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.446 0.25 $0.081
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.894 1.19 $0.026
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.78 0.560 0.24 $0.123
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.318 0.18 $0.123
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 77.8% 100.0% 20 $3.38 1.329 0.12 $0.224
Roof - High Reflectivity 33.3% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.155 0.37 $0.099
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.454 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.167 2.77 $0.013
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.279 0.34 $0.081
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.698 0.25 $0.109
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.217 0.30 $0.110
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.002 0.01 $2.988
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 36.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.412 0.62 $0.040
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.180 0.52 $0.051
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.418 0.29 $0.119
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.001 1.70 $0.015
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.199 0.30 $0.086
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.658 0.22 $0.115
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-
Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.202 0.27 $0.119
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.005 0.05 $0.992
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 36.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.388 0.54 $0.043
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.180 0.52 $0.051
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 2.083 0.23 $0.127
RTU - Maintenance 36.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.441 0.69 $0.038
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1,411.488 1.05 $0.000
Heat Pump - Maintenance 8.3% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.624 0.69 $0.027
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.19 0.372 0.45 $0.046
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 2.8% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.316 0.19 $0.084
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.266 0.94 $0.021
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.176 0.46 $0.052
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow
Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.078 0.48 $0.055
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation
Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.020 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.391 13.90 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 1.343 25.99 $0.001
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-154 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation
Applicabilit
y Lifetime Cost
Savings
(kBtu)
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.391 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 70.3% 100.0% 15 $0.06 0.071 0.34 $0.081
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.059 124.0
8 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 25.1% 25.1% 8 $0.19 1.221 0.80 $0.024
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.054 14.62 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 36.9% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.449 0.24 $0.087
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 53.5% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.224 0.15 $0.140
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 16.7% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.152 0.05 $0.361
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.115 0.03 $0.680
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 11.1% 67.5% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.186 0.10 $0.169
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.677 2.50 $0.005
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.557 0.04 $0.377
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.040 0.06 $0.495
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.673 0.24 $0.030
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.023 1.26 $0.020
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.029 0.04 $0.532
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.018 0.12 $0.237
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.014 0.23 $0.056
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.020 5.90 $0.004
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.026 11.32 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.034 1.81 $0.014
Refrigerator - Food Temperature Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.017 0.31 $0.109
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.023 0.01 $1.577
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power
Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.007 11.33 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy
Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.083 0.06 $0.470
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.002 0.01 $6.720
Energy Management System 70.1% 80.0% 14 $0.35 2.230 1.66 $0.017
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 1.638 2.46 $0.010
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.855 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-155
Table C-48 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Miscellaneous, Existing Vintage
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.26 0.610 0.72 $0.038
Insulation - Ducting 17.8% 90.0% 20 $0.41 0.513 0.28 $0.070
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 1.135 1.70 $0.020
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0.0% 15.0% 20 $0.78 0.773 0.34 $0.089
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.588 0.39 $0.066
Doors - High Efficiency 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 63.0% 100.0% 20 $4.79 1.240 0.09 $0.341
Roof - High Reflectivity 36.3% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.353 0.91 $0.044
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.649 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 2.060 4.45 $0.007
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.645 0.44 $0.063
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 1.109 0.35 $0.068
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.124 0.14 $0.193
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.045 0.47 $0.119
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.716 1.14 $0.023
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.189 0.53 $0.048
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.622 0.43 $0.080
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.471 2.65 $0.010
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.579 0.42 $0.065
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 1.065 0.33 $0.071
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.119 0.13 $0.201
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.042 0.45 $0.127
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.688 1.09 $0.024
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.189 0.53 $0.048
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 10.0% 20 $3.00 2.703 0.28 $0.098
RTU - Maintenance 44.5% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.775 1.25 $0.021
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1,411.55
9 1.33 $0.000
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.402 2.05 $0.012
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.19 0.476 0.56 $0.036
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 1.4% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.392 0.23 $0.068
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.340 1.19 $0.016
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.187 0.48 $0.049
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 27.4% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.084 0.49 $0.052
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.070 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-156 www.enernoc.com
Measure
Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.416 14.19 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 1.422 26.21 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.416 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 70.3% 100.0% 15 $0.05 0.118 0.56 $0.048
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.104 251.53 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 12.6% 25.0% 8 $0.29 1.968 0.71 $0.023
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.090 19.46 $0.001
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 18.4% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.726 0.29 $0.060
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 26.7% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.363 0.20 $0.086
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 17.8% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.220 0.07 $0.249
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.129 0.03 $0.604
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 15.1% 67.5% 11 $0.50 0.110 0.03 $0.567
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.228 0.11 $0.138
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.823 2.68 $0.004
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.683 0.04 $0.307
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.044 0.05 $0.446
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.870 0.44 $0.023
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.053 2.04 $0.009
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 5.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.048 0.04 $0.323
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.042 0.23 $0.103
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.032 0.38 $0.024
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.046 10.44 $0.002
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.059 18.58 $0.001
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.078 2.97 $0.006
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 5.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.039 0.53 $0.048
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.032 0.01 $1.126
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.008 11.36 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.086 0.05 $0.507
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.7% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.002 0.01 $7.066
Energy Management System 66.8% 80.0% 14 $0.35 3.523 2.74 $0.011
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 20.3% 25.0% 11 $0.13 2.007 3.46 $0.008
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.239 3.00 $0.000
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 73.4% 7 $0.38 1.329 0.54 $0.049
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 34.2% 73.4% 5 $0.10 0.840 0.61 $0.027
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting C-157
Table C-49 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Miscellaneous, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.26 0.435 0.47 $0.053
Insulation - Ducting 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.41 0.446 0.25 $0.081
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 7.0% 12.5% 20 $0.26 0.894 1.19 $0.026
Insulation - Wall Cavity 95.0% 95.0% 20 $0.78 0.560 0.24 $0.123
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.318 0.18 $0.123
Doors - High Efficiency 100.0% 100.0% 0 $0.00 - 3.00 $0.000
Windows - High Efficiency 77.8% 100.0% 20 $3.38 1.329 0.12 $0.224
Roof - High Reflectivity 33.3% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.155 0.37 $0.099
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.454 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.167 2.77 $0.013
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.279 0.34 $0.081
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.698 0.25 $0.109
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.217 0.30 $0.110
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.002 0.01 $2.988
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 36.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.412 0.62 $0.040
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.180 0.52 $0.051
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.418 0.29 $0.119
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 62.9% 65.0% 15 $0.15 1.001 1.70 $0.015
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy
Storage 44.3% 48.8% 15 $0.15 - - $0.000
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 1.199 0.30 $0.086
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.658 0.22 $0.115
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.202 0.27 $0.119
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.005 0.05 $0.992
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 36.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.388 0.54 $0.043
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.180 0.52 $0.051
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 2.083 0.23 $0.127
RTU - Maintenance 36.1% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.441 0.69 $0.038
Space Heating - Heat Recovery
Ventilator 44.3% 75.0% 15 $0.15 1,411.488 1.05 $0.000
Heat Pump - Maintenance 8.3% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.624 0.69 $0.027
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0.0% 0.0% 18 $0.19 0.372 0.45 $0.046
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 2.8% 90.0% 10 $0.20 0.316 0.19 $0.084
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 11.5% 20.0% 10 $0.04 0.266 0.94 $0.021
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat
Recovery 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.04 0.176 0.46 $0.052
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low
Flow Nozzles 75.0% 100.0% 9 $0.03 0.078 0.48 $0.055
Water Heater - High Efficiency
Circulation Pump 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 1.020 1.00 $0.000
Commercial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
C-158 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0.0% 50.0% 5 $0.00 0.391 13.90 $0.002
Water Heater - Solar System 0.0% 50.0% 20 $0.02 1.343 25.99 $0.001
Water Heater - Install Timer 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.391 1.00 $0.000
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 70.3% 100.0% 15 $0.06 0.071 0.34 $0.081
Water Heater - Tank
Blanket/Insulation 0.0% 0.0% 10 $0.00 0.059 124.0
8 $0.000
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 25.1% 25.1% 8 $0.19 1.221 0.80 $0.024
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.054 14.62 $0.002
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 36.9% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.449 0.24 $0.087
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and
Timers 53.5% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.224 0.15 $0.140
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 16.7% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.152 0.05 $0.361
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.50 0.115 0.03 $0.680
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 11.1% 67.5% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.186 0.10 $0.169
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.677 2.50 $0.005
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.557 0.04 $0.377
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 10.0% 100.0% 16 $0.20 0.040 0.06 $0.495
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 50.0% 51.7% 8 $0.13 0.673 0.24 $0.030
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0.0% 75.0% 16 $0.00 0.023 1.26 $0.020
Refrigerator - Door Gasket
Replacement 15.0% 100.0% 8 $0.10 0.029 0.04 $0.532
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0.0% 7.5% 5 $0.02 0.018 0.12 $0.237
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 38.0% 45.0% 15 $0.01 0.014 0.23 $0.056
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 5.0% 56.3% 4 $0.00 0.020 5.90 $0.004
Refrigerator - High Efficiency
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.026 11.32 $0.002
Refrigerator - Variable Speed
Compressor 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.00 0.034 1.81 $0.014
Refrigerator - Food Temperature
Simulant 15.0% 100.0% 12 $0.02 0.017 0.31 $0.109
Vending Machine - Controller 2.0% 10.0% 10 $0.27 0.023 0.01 $1.577
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR
Power Supplies 10.0% 100.0% 7 $0.00 0.007 11.33 $0.002
Office Equipment - Plug Load
Occupancy Sensors 12.6% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.083 0.06 $0.470
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed
Control 0.0% 75.0% 10 $0.10 0.002 0.01 $6.720
Energy Management System 70.1% 80.0% 14 $0.35 2.230 1.66 $0.017
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 50.0% 50.0% 11 $0.13 1.638 2.46 $0.010
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.855 3.00 $0.000
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor
Control 1.0% 0.0% 10 $0.04 - - $0.000

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-1
APPENDIX D
INDUSTRIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE
DATA
This appendix presents detailed information for industrial energy-efficiency measures (equipment
and other measures per the LoadMAP taxonomy) that were evaluated in this study.
Measure Descriptions
Table D-1 and Table D-2 provide brief narrative descriptions for the measures.1
Measure Data
Table D-3 through Table D-12 list the detailed unit-level data (including economic screen results)
for industrial energy-efficiency equipment measures in existing and new buildings. The column
headings and units are the same as described for the corresponding residential sector tables
above, with the exception that savings and marginal costs are normazlized to a per employee
basis.
Table D-13 through Table D-22 list the detailed unit-level data (including economic screen results) for
industrial energy-efficiency non-equipment measures in existing and new buildings.

1 Measure Description Sources: Global internal databases. Also, for several measures: Northwest Power & Conservation Council, 6th
Plan, "Systems Whole Plant Optimization Overview"
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-2 www.enernoc.com
Table D-1 Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment Measure Descriptions
End Use Technology Measure Description
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller
A central chiller plant creates chilled water for distribution throughout the
facility. Because of the wide variety of system types and sizes, savings and cost
values for efficiency improvements represent an average over screw,
reciprocating, and centrifugal technologies. Under this simplified approach,
each central system is characterized by an aggregate efficiency value (inclusive
of chiller, pumps, and motors), in kW/ton with a further efficiency upgrade
through the application of variable refrigerant flow technology.
Cooling Water-Cooled
Chiller
A central chiller plant creates chilled water for distribution throughout the
facility. Water source chillers include heat rejection via a condenser loop and
cooling tower. Because of the wide variety of system types and sizes, savings
and cost values for efficiency improvements represent an average over screw,
reciprocating, and centrifugal technologies. Under this simplified approach,
each central system is characterized by an aggregate efficiency value (inclusive
of chiller, pumps, motors, and condenser loop equipment), in kW/ton with a
further efficiency upgrade through the application of variable refrigerant flow
technology.
Cooling RTU
Packaged cooling systems, such as rooftop units (RTUs), are simple to install
and maintain, and are commonly used in small and medium-sized commercial
buildings. Applications range from a single supply system with air intake filters,
supply fan, and cooling coil, or can become more complex with the addition of
a return air duct, return air fan, and various controls to optimize performance.
For packaged RTUs, varying Energy Efficiency Ratios (EER) are modeled, as well
as a ductless mini-split system.
Cooling /
Heating
Air-Source Heat
Pump
For heat pumps, units with increasing EER and COP levels are evaluated, as well
as a ductless mini-split system.
Cooling /
Heating
Geothermal Heat
Pump For heat pumps, units with increasing EER and COP levels are evaluated.
Cooling Evaporative AC Evaporative air conditioning, sometimes called swamp cooling, uses the cooling
effect produced when water evaporates to provide space cooling.
Cooling Other Cooling
Other cooling encompasses any remaining cooling technologies such as
packaged terminal air conditioning units. Higher efficiency options for these
devices are similar to those for standard air conditioning units.
Heating Electric Furnace
Resistive heating elements are used to convert electricity directly to heat. The
heat is then delivered by a supply fan and duct system to the regions that
require heating.
Heating Electric Room Heat
Resistive heating elements are used to convert electricity directly to heat.
Conductive fins surrounding the element or another mechanism is used to
deliver the heat directly to the surrounding room or area. These are typically
either baseboard or wall-mounted units.
Ventilation Ventilation
A variable air volume ventilation system modulates the air flow rate as needed
based on the interior conditions of the building to reduce fan load, improve
dehumidification, and reduce energy usage.
Interior
Lighting Screw-in This measure evaluates higher-efficiency alternatives for screw-in interior
lamps including halogen, CFL, and LED.
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures
With the exception of screw-in lighting, industrial lighting efficiency changes
typically require more than the simple purchase and installation of an
alternative lamp. Restrictions regarding ballasts, fixtures, and circuitry limit the
potential for direct substitution of one lamp type for another. Also, during the
buildout for a leased office space, management could decide to replace all
lamps, ballasts, and fixtures with different configurations. This type of decision-
making is modeled on a stock turnover basis because of the time between
opportunities for upgrades. For High-Bay fixtures, alternatives include mercury
vapor, metal halides, T5 fluorescent high output, and high-pressure sodium.
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-3
End Use Technology Measure Description
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent
With the exception of screw-in lighting, industrial lighting
efficiency changes typically require more than the simple
purchase and installation of an alternative lamp. Restrictions
regarding ballasts, fixtures, and circuitry limit the potential for
direct substitution of one lamp type for another. Also, during
the buildout for a leased office space, management could
decide to replace all lamps, ballasts, and fixtures with different
configurations. This type of decision-making is modeled on a
stock turnover basis because of the time between
opportunities for upgrades. For linear fluorescent fixtures,
alternatives include T12, T8, Super T8, T5, and LED.
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in This measure evaluates higher-efficiency alternatives for screw-in interior
lamps including halogen, CFL, and LED.
Exterior
Lighting HID Alternatives modeled include metal halides, T8 and T5 high output, high
pressure sodium, and LEDs
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent For linear fluorescent fixtures, alternatives include T12, T8, Super T8, T5, and
LED.
Process Process
Electrochemical
Electrochemical processes deal with chemical reactions in solution driven by
electricity applied at a cathode and anode.
Process Process Other This category is a "catch all" for the many unique process applications in the
broader industrial sector.
Process Process Cooling Industrial process where cooling is applied
Process Process
Refrigeration Industrial refrigeration process
Process Process Heating Industrial process where heating is applied
Process Other Process This category is a "catch all" for the many unique process applications in the
broader industrial sector.
Motors
Pumps, Fans &
Blowers,
Compressed Air,
Matl Handling, Matl
Processing
Premium efficiency motors reduce the amount of lost energy going into heat
rather than power. Since less heat is generated, less energy is needed to cool
the motor with a fan. The initial cost of energy efficient motors is generally
higher than for standard motors, however their life-cycle costs can make them
far more economical because of savings they generate in operating expense.
The fact that energy efficient motors run cooler than their standard
counterparts also results in an increase in the life of the motor insulation and
bearing. High efficiency units use copper instead of aluminum in the windings
and increased conductor cross-sectional area to lower a motor’s I2R losses.
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Improvement of miscellaneous electric uses.
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-4 www.enernoc.com
Table D-2 Industrial Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Measure Descriptions
End Use Measure Description
HVAC (All) Insulation - Ceiling
Thermal insulation is material or combinations of materials that are used to
inhibit the flow of heat energy by conductive, convective, and radiative
transfer modes. Thus, thermal insulation can conserve energy by reducing
the heat loss or gain of a building. The type of building construction defines
insulating possibilities. Typical insulating materials include: loose-fill (blown)
cellulose; loose-fill (blown) fiberglass; and rigid polystyrene.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Ducting
Air distribution ducts can be insulated to reduce heating or cooling losses.
Best results can be achieved by covering the entire surface area with
insulation. Insulation material inhibits the transfer of heat through the air-
supply duct. Several types of ducts and duct insulation are available,
including flexible duct, pre-insulated duct, duct board, duct wrap, tacked, or
glued rigid insulation, and waterproof hard shell materials for exterior ducts.
HVAC (All) Insulation - Wall
Cavity
Thermal insulation is material or combinations of materials that are used to
inhibit the flow of heat energy by conductive, convective, and radiative
transfer modes. Thus, thermal insulation can conserve energy by reducing
the heat loss or gain of a building. The type of building construction defines
insulating possibilities. Typical insulating materials include: loose-fill (blown)
cellulose; loose-fill (blown) fiberglass; and rigid polystyrene.
HVAC (All) HVAC - Duct Repair
and Sealing
Leakage in unsealed ducts varies considerably because of the differences in
fabricating machinery used, the methods for assembly, installation
workmanship, and age of the ductwork. Air leaks from the system to the
outdoors result in a direct loss proportional to the amount of leakage and the
difference in enthalpy between the outdoor air and the conditioned air. To
seal ducts, a wide variety of sealing methods and products exist. Each has a
relatively short shelf life, and no documented research has identified the
aging characteristics of sealant applications.
Air-Cooled
Chiller Chiller - Economizer
Economizers allow outside air (when it is cool and dry enough) to be brought
into the building space to meet cooling loads instead of using mechanically
cooled interior air. A dual enthalpy economizer consists of indoor and
outdoor temperature and humidity sensors, dampers, motors, and motor
controls. Economizers are most applicable to temperate climates and savings
will be smaller in extremely hot or humid areas.
Air-Cooled
Chiller
Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout
Improvements to layout and placement of chiller equipment, for example to
enable unobstructed access to cooling tower airflow or minimize the length
of refrigerant run between cooling tower and chiller head unit.
Air-Cooled
Chiller
Chiller -
Maintenance
Filters, coils, and fins require regular cleaning and maintenance for the heat
pump or roof top unit to function effectively and efficiently throughout its
years of service. Neglecting necessary maintenance leads to a steady decline
in performance while energy use increases.
Air-Cooled
Chiller
Chiller - Chilled
Water Reset
Chilled water reset controls save energy by improving chiller performance
through increasing the supply chilled water temperature, which allows
increased suction pressure during low load periods. Raising the chilled water
temperature also reduces chilled water piping losses. However, the primary
savings from the chilled water reset measure results from chiller efficiency
improvement. This is due partly to the smaller temperature difference
between chilled water and ambient air, and partly due to the sensitivity of
chiller performance to suction temperature.
Air-Cooled
Chiller
Chiller - Chilled
Water Variable-Flow
System
The part-load efficiency of chilled water loops can be improved substantially
by varying the flow speed of the delivered water with the building demand
for cooling.
Air-Cooled
Chiller
Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature
Reset
Resetting the condenser water temperature to the lowest possible setting
allows the cooling tower to generate cooler water whenever possible and
decreases the temperature lift between the condenser and the evaporator.
This will generally increase chiller part-load efficiency, though it may require
increased tower fan energy use.
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-5
End Use Measure Description
Air-Cooled
Chiller
Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling
Tower Fans
High-efficiency cooling fans utilize efficient components and variable
frequency drives that improve fan performance by adjusting fan speed and
rotation as conditions change.
Air-Cooled
Chiller Chiller - VSD on Fans Variable speed drives, which reduce chiller energy use under part load, are
modeled for both air-cooled and water-cooled chillers.
Cooling RTU - Maintenance
Regular cleaning and maintenance enables a roof top unit to function
effectively and efficiently throughout its years of service. Neglecting
necessary maintenance leads to a steady decline in performance while
energy use increases. Maintenance can increase the efficiency of poorly
performing equipment by as much as 10%.
Cooling /
Heating
Heat Pump -
Maintenance
Regular cleaning and maintenance enables a heat pump to function
effectively and efficiently throughout its years of service. Neglecting
necessary maintenance leads to a steady decline in performance while
energy use increases. Maintenance can increase the efficiency of poorly
performing equipment by as much as 10%.
Cooling Roofs - High
Reflectivity
The color and material of a building structure surface will determine the
amount of solar radiation absorbed by that surface and subsequently
transferred into a building. This is called solar absorptance. By using a living
roof or a roofing material with a light color (and a lower solar absorptance),
the roof will absorb less solar radiation and consequently reduce the cooling
load. Living roofs also reduce stormwater runoff.
All Energy Management
System
An energy management system (EMS) allows managers/owners to monitor
and control the major energy-consuming systems within a commercial
building. At the minimum, the EMS can be used to monitor and record
energy consumption of the different end-uses in a building, and can control
operation schedules of the HVAC and lighting systems. The monitoring
function helps building managers/owners to identify systems that are
operating inefficiently so that actions can be taken to correct the problem.
The EMS can also provide preventive maintenance scheduling that will
reduce the cost of operations and maintenance in the long run. The control
functionality of the EMS allows the building manager/owner to operate
building systems from one central location. The operation schedules set via
the EMS help to prevent building systems from operating during unwanted or
unoccupied periods. This analysis assumes that this measure is limited to
buildings with a central HVAC system.
HVAC (All) Thermostat -
Clock/Programmable
A programmable thermostat can be added to most heating/cooling systems.
They are typically used during winter to lower temperatures at night and in
summer to increase temperatures during the afternoon. There are two-
setting models, and well as models that allow separate programming for
each day of the week. The energy savings from this type of thermostat are
identical to those of a "setback" strategy with standard thermostats, but the
convenience of a programmable thermostat makes it a much more attractive
option. In this analysis, the baseline is assumed to have no thermostat
setback.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Occupancy Sensors
The installation of occupancy sensors allows lights to be turned off during
periods when a space is unoccupied, virtually eliminating the wasted energy
due to lights being left on. There are several types of occupancy sensors in
the market.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Skylights
Addition of transparent windows/fixtures in the roof to allow daylight to
enter and reduce the need for powered lighting.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Time Clocks and
Timers
In many cases lighting remains on at night and during weekends. A simple
timer can set a schedule for turning lights off to reduce operating hours.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
LED Exit Lighting
The lamps inside exit signs represent a significant energy end-use, since they
usually operate 24 hours per day. Many old exit signs use incandescent
lamps, which consume approximately 40 watts per sign. The incandescent
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-6 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
lamps can be replaced with LED lamps that are specially designed for this
specific purpose. In comparison, the LED lamps consume approximately 2-5
watts.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Lighting -
Daylighting Controls
Daylighting controls use a photosensor to detect ambient light and adjust or
turn off electric lights accordingly.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Screw-in -
Task Lighting
Individual work areas can use task lighting instead of brightly lighting the
entire area. Significant energy savings can be realized by focusing light
directly where it is needed and lowering the general lighting level. An
example of task lighting is the common desk lamp. A 25W desk lamp can be
installed in place of a typical lamp in a fixture.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Fluorescent
- Bi-Level Fixture
Bi-level fixtures have the ability to reduce light output to a lower level, given
a control strategy that is based on a timer, occupancy sensor, motion sensor,
or manual switch.
Interior
Lighting
Interior Fluorescent
- Delamp and Install
Reflectors
While sometimes included in lighting retrofit projects, delamping is often
performed as a separate energy efficiency measure in which a lighting
engineer analyzes the lighting provided by current systems compared to the
requirements of building occupants. This often leads to the removal of
unnecessary lamps corresponding to an overall reduction in energy usage. In
addition, installing a reflector in each fixture can improve light distribution
from the remaining lamps.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting - Bi-
Level Fixture
Bi-level fixtures have the ability to reduce light output to a lower level, given
a control strategy that is based on a timer, occupancy sensor, motion sensor,
or manual switch.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Daylighting Controls
Daylighting controls use a photosensor to detect ambient light and adjust or
turn off electric lights accordingly.
Exterior
Lighting
Exterior Lighting -
Photovoltaic
Installation
Solar photovoltaic generation may be used to power exterior lighting and
thus eliminate all or part of the electrical energy use.
Process
Process -
Conductivity
Controls
Automated control of conductivity levels in a process solution, for example
by variably injecting CO2 into a stream of rinse water, can maintain an
optimal solution that increases process effectiveness, decreases impurities,
reduces scaling or corrosion, and minimizes required rinse time.
Process Process - Controls on
Fume Hoods
Improved fume hoods involve installing sensors and variable-speed controls
to provide ventilation based on actual demand. When the relevant
equipment or process is not active, the controls automatically decrease the
fan speed accordingly.
Process Process - Timers and
Controls
Significant energy savings can frequently be attained from processes by
adding a timer or altering their control algorithms.
Process
Refrigeration
Refrigeration -
Floating Head
Pressure
Floating head pressure control allows the pressure in the condenser to
"float" with ambient temperatures. This method reduces refrigeration
compression ratios, improves system efficiency and extends the compressor
life. The greatest savings with a floating head pressure approach occurs when
the ambient temperatures are low, such as in the winter season. Floating
head pressure control is most practical for new installations. However,
retrofits installation can be completed with some existing refrigeration
systems. Installing floating head pressure control increases the capacity of
the compressor when temperatures are low, which may lead to short cycling.
Process
Refrigeration
Refrigeration -
System Controls
Refrigeration System Controls would include measures such as temperature
sensors, flow/float controls, and pressure controls. These work to improve
the refrigeration system by limiting demand and improving overall system
efficiency.
Process
Refrigeration
Refrigeration -
System Maintenance
This measure includes repairing and recharging refrigerant lines, cleaning
condenser coils, and replacing the oil. This reduces energy consumption by
improving the rate at which the system can compress and cool refrigerant as
it moves through the system.
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-7
End Use Measure Description
Process
Refrigeration
Refrigeration -
System Optimization
Refrigeration system optimization is a thorough overhaul of the refrigeration
system which involves the resizing, sequencing, and controlling of
compressors in order to optimize load.
Compressed
Air
Compressed Air - Air
Usage Reduction
This measure involves a process audit of the facility to determine if the actual
application of compressed air can be reduced, reconfigured, consolidated, or
otherwise optimized.
Compressed
Air
Compressed Air -
Compressor
Replacement
This measure is the replacement of existing air compressor equipment with
more efficient compressors and motors in order to improve energy
efficiency.
Compressed
Air
Compressed Air -
System Controls
Compressed Air System Controls would include measures such as VSDs,
centralized controls, and system performance monitoring. These measures
work in tandem to reduce energy usage by lowering system demand.
Compressed
Air
Compressed Air -
System Maintenance
This measure includes repairing holes in air lines, replacing failed nozzles, and
lubricating the compressors. This reduces energy consumption by improving
compressor efficiency and reducing line loss as gas moves through the
system.
Compressed
Air
Compressed Air -
System Optimization
and Improvements
System optimization is a thorough overhaul of the compressed air system
which involves the resizing, sequencing, and improving control over all
compressors in a system in order to reduce energy consumption to a
minimum. This measure may include those from Controls and Maintenance.
Pumps Pumping System -
Controls
Significant energy savings can frequently be attained from processes by
adding a timer or altering their control algorithms.
Pumps Pumping System -
Maintenance
This measure includes clearing traps, repairing impellers, and repairing
broken seals or valves. This reduces energy consumption by reducing losses
incurred by moving fluids through the system.
Pumps Pumping System -
Optimization
Optimization integrates best practices of system analysis, equipment
improvements, and operational improvements into a sustaining energy
program. A facility that implements such a practice treats its energy program
in a similar manner to safety or quality control programs: an individual or
team is tasked with developing and enforcing standards, goals are set,
regular reports are generated and reported to management, and all plant
employees are engaged and held accountable.
Pumps Pumps - Variable
Speed Control
The part-load efficiency of drive systems can be improved by varying the
speed of the motor drive. An additional benefit of variable-speed controls is
the ability to start and stop the motor and process gradually, thus extending
the life of the motor and associated machinery.
Pumps Pump Equipment
Upgrade
Improved design of flow, housing, control valves, impeller trimming, proper
sizing, etc to increase productive output per energy input. Moreover, these
improved systems could be assessed and managed in accordance with
recognized standards such as ASME EA-2-2008.
Fans &
Blowers
Fan Equipment
Upgrade
Improved design of airflow, blades, housing, sizing, etc to increase productive
output per energy input. Fans are widely used in industry for conveyance,
drying and ventilation. For example, relatively inefficient centrifugal-radial
fans, with efficiency as low as 22%, are commonly used in industry. These
fans could be replaced with more efficient centrifugal backwardly inclined
fans that increase overall fan efficiency by 20% to 30%. The savings potential
for premium-efficiency fans is high, and the costs are relatively low.
However, premium-efficiency fans are sometimes not chosen for industrial
applications because of concerns about reliable operation in dirty
environments.
Fans &
Blowers
Fan System -
Controls
Significant energy savings can frequently be attained from processes by
adding a timer or altering their control algorithms.
Fans &
Blowers
Fan System -
Maintenance
This measure includes repairing holes in ducts, replacing clogged filters, and
lubricating the motors. This reduces energy consumption by improving fan
efficiency and reducing system loss as gas moves through the ductwork.
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-8 www.enernoc.com
End Use Measure Description
Fans &
Blowers
Fan System -
Optimization
Optimization integrates best practices of system analysis, equipment
improvements, and operational improvements into a sustaining energy
program. A facility that implements such a practice treats its energy program
in a similar manner to safety or quality control programs: an individual or
team is tasked with developing and enforcing standards, goals are set,
regular reports are generated and reported to management, and all plant
employees are engaged and held accountable.
Fans &
Blowers
Fans - Variable
Speed Control
The part-load efficiency of drive systems can be improved by varying the
speed of the motor drive. An additional benefit of variable-speed controls is
the ability to start and stop the motor and process gradually, thus extending
the life of the motor and associated machinery.
Motors
Motors - Magnetic
Adjustable Speed
Drives
To allow for adjustable speed operation, this technology uses magnetic
induction to couple a drive to its load. Varying the magnetic slip within the
coupling controls the speed of the output shaft. Magnetic drives perform
best at the upper end of the speed range due to the energy consumed by the
slip. Unlike traditional ASDs, magnetically coupled ASDs create no power
distortion on the electrical system. However, magnetically coupled ASD
efficiency is best when power needs are greatest. VFDs may show greater
efficiency when the average load speed is below 90% of the motor speed,
however this occurs when power demands are reduced.
Motors Motors - Efficient
Rewind
When a motor burns out or is in need of repair, the owner may elect to
either replace the motor or have it rewound. A typical motor rewind costs
less than a replacement motor, but at the cost of efficiency. An efficient
rewind, however, attempts to improve the efficiency of the motor by
reducing stator losses. If the manufacturer has left stator slots open, or not
entirely filled, additional copper wire can be included to reduce resistance
and increase efficiency.
Motors Motors -
Synchronous Belts
Synchronous belts offer higher efficiency compared with standard belts due
to reduced slipping, as well as less maintenance and retensioning.
Motors Motors - Variable
Frequency Drive
The part-load efficiency of drive systems can be improved by varying the
speed of the motor drive. An additional benefit of variable-speed controls is
the ability to start and stop the motor and process gradually, thus extending
the life of the motor and associated machinery.
HVAC,
Lighting
Retrocommissioning
- HVAC, Lighting
In existing buildings, the retrocommissioning process identifies low-cost or no
cost measures, including controls adjustments, to improve building
performance and reduce operating costs. Retrocommissioning addresses
HVAC, lighting, DHW, and other major building systems.
Ventilation Ventilation - CO2
Controlled
Also known as Demand Controlled Ventilation, this measure uses carbon
dioxide (CO2) levels to indicate the level of occupancy in a space. Sensors
monitor CO2 levels so that air handling controls can adjust the amount of
outside air the system needs to intake. Ventilation rates are thereby
controlled based on occupancy, rather than a fixed rate, thus saving HVAC
energy use.
All Transformer - High
Efficiency
All electric power passes through one or more transformers on its way to
service equipment, lighting, and other loads. Currently available materials
and designs can considerably reduce both load and no-load losses. The new
NEMA TP-1 standard is used as the reference definition for energy -efficient
products. Tier-1 represents TP-1 dry-type transformers while Tier-2 reflects a
switch to liquid immersed TP-1 products. More efficient transformers with
attractive payback periods are estimated to save 40 to 50 percent of the
energy lost by a "typical" transformer, which translates into a one to three
percent reduction in electric bills for commercial and industrial customers.
Cooling RTU – Evaporative
Precooler
These systems use an efficient evaporative precooler to supplement
conventional rooftop cooling systems.
All Strategic Energy
Management
Strategic Energy Management is a systematic approach to integrating energy
management into an organization’s business practices and creating lasting
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-9
End Use Measure Description
energy management processes that produce reliable energy savings.
Miscellaneous Engine Block Heater
An engine block heater preheats an engine, for example on farm equipment,
to facilitate faster starting. High-efficiency options can reduce energy used in
this application.

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-10 www.enernoc.com
Table D-3 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Agriculture, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 1,252.74 $654.29 20 1.14 $0.046
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 1,503.27 $850.58 20 1.17 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 3,131.81 $1,046.87 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 3,319.70 $1,243.15 20 1.50 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 1,840.97 $243.82 20 1.24 $0.012
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 2,086.84 $487.64 20 1.27 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 2,456.11 $585.17 20 1.34 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 2,946.48 $910.26 20 1.43 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 3,069.66 $1,007.79 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 3,316.14 $1,105.31 20 1.51 $0.029
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 997.10 $969.65 16 - $0.096
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1,998.18 $1,864.71 16 1.00 $0.092
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 2,611.06 $3,580.23 16 1.05 $0.136
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 3,919.70 $11,747.64 16 1.12 $0.297
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 1,074.99 $1,193.45 16 - $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 1,711.09 $1,715.58 16 1.00 $0.099
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 2,271.20 $4,400.84 16 1.03 $0.192
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 2,491.24 $5,743.47 16 1.04 $0.228
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 3,800.06 $11,002.10 16 1.13 $0.286
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $314.39 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 3,193.10 $2,829.54 16 1.70 $0.088
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 399.66 $40,277.63 14 0.87 $10.770
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 1,020.42 $201,388.15 14 0.55 $21.091
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 381.35 $5,271.92 14 0.98 $1.477
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 900.45 $7,722.25 14 1.01 $0.916
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 1,061.11 $23,760.76 14 0.88 $2.393
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 1,437.94 $39,799.28 14 0.79 $2.958
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 180.81 $1,454.53 16 - $0.796
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 244.37 $2,090.88 16 1.00 $0.846
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 265.15 $5,363.57 16 1.03 $2.001
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-11
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 262.72 $6,999.91 16 1.04 $2.636
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 81.15 $13,408.92 16 1.13 $16.347
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 290.55 $10,299.88 16 1.00 $3.507
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 10,242.4
6 $92,698.88 16 1.70 $0.895
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1,101.05 -$42.94 10 1.25 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1,513.66 $57.15 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2,325.52 $78.60 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 4,353.48 $45.52 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4,713.36 $1,209.03 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5,414.12 $341.11 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 224.29 $340.96 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 228.32 -$9.07 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 242.95 $1.62 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 267.92 $96.18 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 284.31 $5.27 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 291.42 -$5.44 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 428.58 $87.94 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 2,464.89 $8,658.06 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 2,564.53 $3.54 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 3,557.80 $57.84 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 4,124.51 $93.25 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 7,515.95 $2,402.07 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 2.33 $0.09 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 3.57 $0.12 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 6.69 $0.07 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 7.24 $1.86 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-12 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 8.32 $0.52 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 472.68 $1,676.37 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 492.12 -$12.67 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 762.29 $56.54 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 762.55 -$0.69 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 796.57 $4.84 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 1,458.46 $455.43 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 16.74 $10.03 15 0.32 $0.061
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.19 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.27 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.31 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.56 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 113.37 $20.04 10 0.99 $0.024
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 77.50 $74.03 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 16.55 $10.03 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 19.07 $20.04 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF .98 37.63 $9.80 15 1.00 $0.027
Process Process Heating EF 2.0 1,902.86 $23.93 15 1.95 $0.001
Process Process Heating EF 2.3 2,136.54 $28.08 15 2.21 $0.001
Process Process Heating EF 2.4 2,201.54 $30.73 15 2.29 $0.001
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-13

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-14 www.enernoc.com
Table D-4 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Agriculture, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 1,155.72 $815.05 20 1.14 $0.062
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP 2.8 1,386.93 $1,059.56 20 1.17 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 2,889.45 $1,304.08 20 1.45 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP 3.6 3,062.70 $1,548.59 20 1.49 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP 4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP 5.9 1,145.67 $205.97 20 1.23 $0.016
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP 6.1 1,298.71 $411.93 20 1.27 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP 6.4 1,528.32 $494.32 20 1.33 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP 6.9 1,832.65 $768.94 20 1.42 $0.037
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP 7.0 1,909.22 $851.33 20 1.45 $0.039
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP 7.3 2,062.56 $933.71 20 1.50 $0.040
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 667.02 $598.10 16 - $0.089
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1,336.80 $1,150.18 16 1.00 $0.085
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1,746.70 $2,208.35 16 1.06 $0.125
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 2,622.20 $7,246.15 16 1.14 $0.273
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 811.89 $831.37 16 - $0.101
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 1,293.93 $1,195.10 16 1.00 $0.091
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 1,715.41 $3,065.69 16 1.04 $0.177
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 1,884.33 $4,000.99 16 1.06 $0.210
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 2,878.25 $7,664.23 16 1.19 $0.263
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 - $278.03 16 1.01 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 2,144.77 $2,502.31 16 1.68 $0.115
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 267.36 $12,535.49 14 0.90 $5.010
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 682.62 $62,677.44 14 0.60 $9.812
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 370.03 $5,044.03 14 0.98 $1.457
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 873.92 $7,388.44 14 1.01 $0.903
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 1,029.48 $22,733.65 14 0.88 $2.360
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 1,395.00 $38,078.86 14 0.80 $2.917
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 2,416.34 $1,708.75 16 - $0.070
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 4,084.06 $2,456.33 16 1.00 $0.060
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 5,735.41 $6,301.01 16 1.04 $0.109
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 6,430.10 $8,223.35 16 1.06 $0.127
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 11,060.0
4 $15,752.53 16 1.19 $0.141
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-15
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 14 2,729.30 $6,286.43 16 1.01 $0.228
Heating Geothermal Heat
Pump EER 27.8 12,523.9
1 $56,577.88 16 1.68 $0.447
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 882.63 -$62.76 10 1.16 -$0.009
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 1,513.66 $57.15 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2,325.52 $78.60 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 4,353.48 $45.52 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4,713.36 $1,209.03 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5,414.12 $341.11 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 224.29 $340.96 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 228.32 -$9.07 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure Sodium 242.95 $1.62 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 267.92 $96.18 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting Plasma 284.31 $5.27 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 291.42 -$5.44 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 428.58 $87.94 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 2,464.89 $8,658.06 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 2,564.53 $3.54 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 3,557.80 $57.84 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 4,124.51 $93.25 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 7,515.95 $2,402.07 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-38 2.33 $0.09 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 3.57 $0.12 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 6.69 $0.07 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 7.24 $1.86 20 1.11 $0.023
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 8.32 $0.52 20 - $0.006
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-16 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 472.68 $1,676.37 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 492.12 -$12.67 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting Plasma 762.29 $56.54 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure Sodium 762.55 -$0.69 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 796.57 $4.84 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 1,458.46 $455.43 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.19 $0.65 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.19 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.27 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.31 $0.01 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.56 $0.18 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 94.30 $77.99 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 77.50 $74.01 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 16.55 $10.03 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 19.07 $20.04 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF .97 - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF .98 33.43 $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF 2.0 1,686.87 $0.00 15 1.96 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF 2.3 1,893.99 $0.00 15 2.21 $0.000
Process Process Heating EF 2.4 1,951.55 $0.00 15 2.29 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-17
Table D-5 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Electronics, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP 2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP 2.7 553.66 $289.17 20 1.14 $0.046
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 664.38 $375.92 20 1.17 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP 3.5 1,384.12 $462.67 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 1,467.16 $549.42 20 1.50 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 813.62 $107.76 20 1.24 $0.012
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 922.29 $215.51 20 1.27 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 1,085.49 $258.62 20 1.34 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 1,302.21 $402.29 20 1.43 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 1,356.65 $445.40 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 1,465.59 $488.50 20 1.51 $0.029
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 440.67 $428.54 16 - $0.096
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 883.11 $824.12 16 1.00 $0.092
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1,153.97 $1,582.30 16 1.05 $0.136
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1,732.33 $5,191.93 16 1.12 $0.297
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 475.10 $527.45 16 - $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 756.23 $758.21 16 1.00 $0.099
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 1,003.77 $1,944.97 16 1.03 $0.192
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 1,101.02 $2,538.36 16 1.04 $0.228
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,679.46 $4,862.44 16 1.13 $0.286
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $138.95 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 1,411.21 $1,250.53 16 1.70 $0.088
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 176.63 $17,800.91 14 0.87 $10.770
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 450.98 $89,004.54 14 0.55 $21.091
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 168.54 $2,329.95 14 0.98 $1.477
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 397.96 $3,412.89 14 1.01 $0.916
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 468.96 $10,501.19 14 0.88 $2.393
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 635.51 $17,589.50 14 0.79 $2.958
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 79.91 $642.84 16 - $0.796
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 108.00 $924.08 16 1.00 $0.846
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 117.18 $2,370.46 16 1.03 $2.001
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-18 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 116.11 $3,093.65 16 1.04 $2.636
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 35.87 $5,926.14 16 1.13 $16.347
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 128.41 $4,552.08 16 1.00 $3.507
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 4,526.71 $40,968.75 16 1.70 $0.895
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 486.61 -$18.98 10 1.25 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 209.60 $7.91 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 322.02 $10.88 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 602.84 $6.30 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 652.67 $167.42 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 749.71 $47.23 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 31.06 $47.21 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 31.62 -$1.26 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 33.64 $0.22 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 37.10 $13.32 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 39.37 $0.73 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 40.35 -$0.75 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 59.35 $12.18 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 341.32 $1,198.91 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 355.12 $0.49 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 492.66 $8.01 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 571.13 $12.91 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1,040.75 $332.62 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 0.32 $0.01 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.49 $0.02 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.93 $0.01 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.00 $0.26 20 1.11 $0.023
Exterior Screw-in LED (2020) 1.15 $0.07 20 - $0.006
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-19
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Lighting
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 65.45 $232.13 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 68.15 -$1.75 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 105.56 $7.83 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 105.59 -$0.10 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 110.30 $0.67 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 201.96 $63.07 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.03 $0.09 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.03 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.04 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.04 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.08 $0.02 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 2.44 $2.02 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 2.51 $2.40 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 1.07 $0.65 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 0.74 $0.78 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 3.71 $3.90 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency 4.94 $5.19 10 0.99 $0.140
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-20 www.enernoc.com
Table D-6 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Electronics, New Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 510.78 $360.21 20 1.14 $0.062
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 612.96 $468.28 20 1.17 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 1,277.01 $576.34 20 1.45 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 1,353.58 $684.41 20 1.49 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 506.34 $91.03 20 1.23 $0.016
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 573.97 $182.06 20 1.27 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 675.45 $218.47 20 1.33 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 809.95 $339.84 20 1.42 $0.037
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 843.79 $376.25 20 1.45 $0.039
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 911.56 $412.66 20 1.50 $0.040
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 294.79 $264.33 16 - $0.089
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 590.81 $508.33 16 1.00 $0.085
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 771.96 $975.99 16 1.06 $0.125
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1,158.90 $3,202.47 16 1.14 $0.273
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 358.82 $367.43 16 - $0.101
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 571.86 $528.18 16 1.00 $0.091
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 758.14 $1,354.90 16 1.04 $0.177
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 832.79 $1,768.26 16 1.06 $0.210
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,272.06 $3,387.25 16 1.19 $0.263
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $122.88 16 1.01 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 947.89 $1,105.91 16 1.68 $0.115
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 118.16 $5,540.12 14 0.90 $5.010
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 301.69 $27,700.62 14 0.60 $9.812
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 163.54 $2,229.23 14 0.98 $1.457
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 386.23 $3,265.36 14 1.01 $0.903
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 454.98 $10,047.25 14 0.88 $2.360
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 616.53 $16,829.15 14 0.80 $2.917
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 1,067.92 $755.19 16 - $0.070
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 1,804.97 $1,085.59 16 1.00 $0.060
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-21
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 2,534.80 $2,784.76 16 1.04 $0.109
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 2,841.81 $3,634.35 16 1.06 $0.127
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 4,888.04 $6,961.91 16 1.19 $0.141
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 1,206.23 $2,778.32 16 1.01 $0.228
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 5,535.01 $25,004.89 16 1.68 $0.447
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 390.08 -$27.74 10 1.16 -$0.009
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 209.60 $7.91 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 322.02 $10.88 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 602.84 $6.30 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 652.67 $167.42 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 749.71 $47.23 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 31.06 $47.21 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 31.62 -$1.26 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 33.64 $0.22 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 37.10 $13.32 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 39.37 $0.73 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 40.35 -$0.75 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 59.35 $12.18 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 341.32 $1,198.91 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 355.12 $0.49 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 492.66 $8.01 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 571.13 $12.91 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1,040.75 $332.62 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 0.32 $0.01 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.49 $0.02 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 0.93 $0.01 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.00 $0.26 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-22 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.15 $0.07 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 67.96 $2.40 15 0.29 $0.004
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 68.15 $0.00 10 1.21 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 105.56 $0.00 15 1.22 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 105.59 $0.00 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 110.30 $0.00 10 1.45 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 201.96 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1.10 $0.65 15 0.32 $0.061
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.03 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.04 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.04 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.08 $0.00 15 - $0.000
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 2.44 $2.02 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 2.51 $2.40 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 1.07 $0.65 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 0.74 $0.78 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 3.71 $3.89 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency 4.94 $5.19 10 0.99 $0.140
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-23
Table D-7 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Manufacturing Food, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 1,203.93 $628.80 20 1.14 $0.046
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 1,444.70 $817.44 20 1.17 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 3,009.78 $1,006.08 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 3,190.36 $1,194.72 20 1.50 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 1,769.23 $234.32 20 1.24 $0.012
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 2,005.53 $468.64 20 1.27 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 2,360.41 $562.37 20 1.34 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 2,831.67 $874.79 20 1.43 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 2,950.06 $968.52 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 3,186.93 $1,062.25 20 1.51 $0.029
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 958.25 $931.87 16 - $0.096
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1,920.32 $1,792.05 16 1.00 $0.092
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 2,509.32 $3,440.74 16 1.05 $0.136
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 3,766.98 $11,289.91 16 1.12 $0.297
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 1,399.59 $5,066.51 16 - $0.358
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 2,509.79 $7,421.36 16 1.00 $0.293
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 3,202.47 $22,834.96 16 1.03 $0.705
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 3,776.09 $38,248.56 16 1.04 $1.002
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 3,651.99 $0.00 16 1.13 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 173.76 $1,397.85 16 1.00 $0.796
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 3,303.53 $2,009.41 16 1.70 $0.060
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 384.09 $38,708.27 14 0.87 $10.770
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 980.66 $193,541.34 14 0.55 $21.091
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 366.49 $5,066.51 14 0.98 $1.477
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 865.36 $7,421.36 14 1.01 $0.916
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 1,019.76 $22,834.96 14 0.88 $2.393
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 1,381.92 $38,248.56 14 0.79 $2.958
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 173.76 $1,397.85 16 - $0.796
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 234.84 $2,009.41 16 1.00 $0.846
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-24 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 254.82 $5,154.58 16 1.03 $2.001
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 252.48 $6,727.17 16 1.04 $2.636
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 77.99 $12,886.46 16 1.13 $16.347
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 279.23 $9,898.56 16 1.00 $3.507
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 9,843.38 $89,087.00 16 1.70 $0.895
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 1,058.15 -$41.27 10 1.25 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 944.79 $35.67 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1,451.54 $49.06 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 2,717.34 $28.42 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2,941.97 $754.65 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3,379.37 $212.91 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 140.00 $212.82 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 142.51 -$5.66 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 151.64 $1.01 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 167.23 $60.04 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 177.46 $3.29 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 181.89 -$3.40 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 267.51 $54.89 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1,538.53 $5,404.16 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 1,600.72 $2.21 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 2,220.69 $36.10 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 2,574.42 $58.20 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 4,691.28 $1,499.31 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 1.45 $0.05 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.23 $0.08 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 4.17 $0.04 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.52 $1.16 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-25
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5.19 $0.33 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 295.03 $1,046.35 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 307.17 -$7.91 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 475.81 $35.29 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 475.96 -$0.43 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 497.20 $3.02 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 910.34 $284.27 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.12 $0.41 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.12 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.17 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.19 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.35 $0.11 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 67.49 $55.83 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 49.86 $47.64 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 24.01 $14.55 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 41.82 $43.95 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 59.39 $62.41 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-26 www.enernoc.com
Table D-8 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Manufacturing Food, New Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 1,110.69 $783.29 20 1.14 $0.062
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 1,332.89 $1,018.28 20 1.17 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 2,776.87 $1,253.27 20 1.45 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 2,943.37 $1,488.25 20 1.49 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 1,101.03 $197.94 20 1.23 $0.016
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 1,248.11 $395.88 20 1.27 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 1,468.77 $475.06 20 1.33 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 1,761.24 $738.98 20 1.42 $0.037
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 1,834.83 $818.16 20 1.45 $0.039
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 1,982.20 $897.33 20 1.50 $0.040
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 641.03 $574.79 16 - $0.089
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 1,284.72 $1,105.37 16 1.00 $0.085
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1,678.64 $2,122.31 16 1.06 $0.125
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 2,520.03 $6,963.82 16 1.14 $0.273
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 780.25 $798.98 16 - $0.101
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 1,243.51 $1,148.53 16 1.00 $0.091
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 1,648.58 $2,946.24 16 1.04 $0.177
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 1,810.91 $3,845.09 16 1.06 $0.210
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 2,766.10 $7,365.60 16 1.19 $0.263
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $267.20 16 1.01 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 2,061.20 $2,404.81 16 1.68 $0.115
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 256.94 $12,047.06 14 0.90 $5.010
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 656.02 $60,235.30 14 0.60 $9.812
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 355.61 $4,847.49 14 0.98 $1.457
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 839.86 $7,100.56 14 1.01 $0.903
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 989.37 $21,847.86 14 0.88 $2.360
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 1,340.64 $36,595.17 14 0.80 $2.917
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 2,322.19 $1,642.17 16 - $0.070
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 3,924.94 $2,360.62 16 1.00 $0.060
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-27
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 5,511.94 $6,055.50 16 1.04 $0.109
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 6,179.56 $7,902.94 16 1.06 $0.127
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 10,629.10 $15,138.75 16 1.19 $0.141
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 2,622.95 $6,041.49 16 1.01 $0.228
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 12,035.93 $54,373.40 16 1.68 $0.447
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 2,386.77 $5,404.16 10 1.16 $0.301
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 944.79 $35.67 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 1,451.54 $49.06 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 2,717.34 $28.42 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 2,941.97 $754.65 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 3,379.37 $212.91 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 140.00 $212.82 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 142.51 -$5.66 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 151.64 $1.01 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 167.23 $60.04 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 177.46 $3.29 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 181.89 -$3.40 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 267.51 $54.89 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 1,538.53 $5,404.16 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 1,600.72 $2.21 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 2,220.69 $36.10 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 2,574.42 $58.20 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 4,691.28 $1,499.31 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 1.45 $0.05 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 2.23 $0.08 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 4.17 $0.04 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 4.52 $1.16 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-28 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 5.19 $0.33 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) - $1,046.35 15 0.06 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 - -$7.91 10 4.84 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma - $35.29 15 1.16 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium - -$0.43 6 1.86 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 - $3.02 10 2.29 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) - $284.27 15 - $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.12 $0.41 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.12 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.17 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.19 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.35 $0.11 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 67.49 $55.82 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 49.86 $47.62 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 24.01 $14.55 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 41.82 $43.94 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 59.39 $62.39 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-29
Table D-9 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Water and Wastewater, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 444.65 $232.23 20 1.14 $0.046
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 533.57 $301.90 20 1.17 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 1,111.60 $371.57 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 1,178.29 $441.24 20 1.50 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 653.43 $86.54 20 1.24 $0.012
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 740.70 $173.08 20 1.27 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 871.77 $207.70 20 1.34 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 1,045.82 $323.09 20 1.43 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 1,089.54 $357.70 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 1,177.03 $392.32 20 1.51 $0.029
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 353.91 $344.17 16 - $0.096
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 709.23 $661.86 16 1.00 $0.092
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 926.77 $1,270.77 16 1.05 $0.136
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1,391.26 $4,169.70 16 1.12 $0.297
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 381.56 $423.60 16 - $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 607.33 $608.93 16 1.00 $0.099
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 806.14 $1,562.03 16 1.03 $0.192
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 884.24 $2,038.58 16 1.04 $0.228
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,348.79 $3,905.08 16 1.13 $0.286
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $111.59 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 1,133.36 $1,004.31 16 1.70 $0.088
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 141.86 $14,296.12 14 0.87 $10.770
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 362.19 $71,480.58 14 0.55 $21.091
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 135.35 $1,871.21 14 0.98 $1.477
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 319.60 $2,740.93 14 1.01 $0.916
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 376.63 $8,433.63 14 0.88 $2.393
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 510.38 $14,126.33 14 0.79 $2.958
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 64.18 $516.27 16 - $0.796
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 86.74 $742.14 16 1.00 $0.846
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-30 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 94.11 $1,903.74 16 1.03 $2.001
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 93.25 $2,484.54 16 1.04 $2.636
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 28.80 $4,759.35 16 1.13 $16.347
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 103.13 $3,655.83 16 1.00 $3.507
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 3,635.45 $32,902.48 16 1.70 $0.895
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 390.81 -$15.24 10 1.25 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 380.65 $14.37 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 584.81 $19.77 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1,094.80 $11.45 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1,185.30 $304.04 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1,361.52 $85.78 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 56.40 $85.74 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 57.42 -$2.28 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 61.10 $0.41 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 67.38 $24.19 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 71.50 $1.33 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 73.28 -$1.37 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 107.78 $22.11 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 619.86 $2,177.29 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 644.92 $0.89 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 894.70 $14.54 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1,037.21 $23.45 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1,890.08 $604.06 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 0.58 $0.02 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.90 $0.03 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.68 $0.02 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.82 $0.47 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-31
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 2.09 $0.13 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 118.87 $421.57 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 123.76 -$3.19 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 191.70 $14.22 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 191.76 -$0.17 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 200.32 $1.22 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 366.77 $114.53 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.05 $0.16 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.05 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.07 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.08 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.14 $0.05 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 157.93 $130.66 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 34.58 $33.03 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 11.82 $7.16 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 40.85 $42.92 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 34.31 $36.05 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency 37.44 $39.34 10 0.99 $0.140
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-32 www.enernoc.com
Table D-10 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Water and Wastewater, New Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 410.21 $289.29 20 1.14 $0.062
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 492.27 $376.08 20 1.17 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 1,025.58 $462.87 20 1.45 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 1,087.07 $549.66 20 1.49 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 406.64 $73.11 20 1.23 $0.016
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 460.96 $146.21 20 1.27 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 542.46 $175.45 20 1.33 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 650.48 $272.93 20 1.42 $0.037
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 677.66 $302.17 20 1.45 $0.039
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 732.08 $331.41 20 1.50 $0.040
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 331.65 $4,449.34 16 - $1.327
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 716.77 $22,246.69 16 1.00 $3.071
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 619.97 $0.00 16 1.06 $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 930.72 $0.00 16 1.14 $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 419.51 $1,790.32 16 - $0.422
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 769.45 $2,622.45 16 1.00 $0.337
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 974.27 $8,069.07 16 1.04 $0.819
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 1,163.96 $13,515.68 16 1.06 $1.149
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,021.60 $0.00 16 1.19 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $98.69 16 1.01 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 761.26 $888.17 16 1.68 $0.115
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 94.90 $4,449.34 14 0.90 $5.010
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 242.29 $22,246.69 14 0.60 $9.812
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 131.34 $1,790.32 14 0.98 $1.457
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 310.19 $2,622.45 14 1.01 $0.903
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 365.40 $8,069.07 14 0.88 $2.360
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 495.14 $13,515.68 14 0.80 $2.917
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 857.66 $606.50 16 - $0.070
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 1,449.60 $871.85 16 1.00 $0.060
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-33
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 2,035.72 $2,236.48 16 1.04 $0.109
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 2,282.29 $2,918.79 16 1.06 $0.127
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 3,925.64 $5,591.19 16 1.19 $0.141
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 968.73 $2,231.30 16 1.01 $0.228
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 4,445.23 $20,081.71 16 1.68 $0.447
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 313.28 -$22.28 10 1.16 -$0.009
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 380.65 $14.37 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 584.81 $19.77 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1,094.80 $11.45 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1,185.30 $304.04 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1,361.52 $85.78 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 56.40 $85.74 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 57.42 -$2.28 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 61.10 $0.41 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 67.38 $24.19 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 71.50 $1.33 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 73.28 -$1.37 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 107.78 $22.11 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 619.86 $2,177.29 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 644.92 $0.89 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 894.70 $14.54 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 1,037.21 $23.45 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1,890.08 $604.06 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 0.58 $0.02 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.90 $0.03 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.68 $0.02 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.82 $0.47 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-34 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 2.09 $0.13 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 118.87 $421.57 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 123.76 -$3.19 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 191.70 $14.22 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 191.76 -$0.17 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 200.32 $1.22 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 366.77 $114.53 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.05 $0.16 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.05 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.07 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.08 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.14 $0.05 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 157.93 $130.62 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 34.58 $33.02 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 11.82 $7.16 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 40.85 $42.91 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 34.31 $36.04 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency 37.44 $39.33 10 0.99 $0.140
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-35
Table D-11 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Other Industrial, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 525.67 $274.55 20 1.14 $0.046
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 630.79 $356.91 20 1.17 $0.050
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 1,314.15 $439.28 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 1,392.99 $521.64 20 1.50 $0.033
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 772.49 $102.31 20 1.24 $0.012
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 875.67 $204.62 20 1.27 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 1,030.61 $245.54 20 1.34 $0.021
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 1,236.38 $381.96 20 1.43 $0.027
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 1,288.07 $422.88 20 1.46 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 1,391.49 $463.80 20 1.51 $0.029
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 418.40 $406.88 16 - $0.096
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 838.46 $782.45 16 1.00 $0.092
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 1,095.63 $1,502.31 16 1.05 $0.136
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1,644.76 $4,929.46 16 1.12 $0.297
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 451.08 $500.79 16 - $0.110
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 718.00 $719.88 16 1.00 $0.099
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 953.02 $1,846.65 16 1.03 $0.192
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 1,045.36 $2,410.03 16 1.04 $0.228
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,594.55 $4,616.62 16 1.13 $0.286
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $131.92 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 1,339.86 $1,187.31 16 1.70 $0.088
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 167.70 $16,901.00 14 0.87 $10.770
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 428.18 $84,505.02 14 0.55 $21.091
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 160.02 $2,212.16 14 0.98 $1.477
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 377.84 $3,240.35 14 1.01 $0.916
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 445.25 $9,970.32 14 0.88 $2.393
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 603.38 $16,700.28 14 0.79 $2.958
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 75.87 $610.34 16 - $0.796
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 102.54 $877.36 16 1.00 $0.846
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-36 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 111.26 $2,250.62 16 1.03 $2.001
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 110.24 $2,937.25 16 1.04 $2.636
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 34.05 $5,626.55 16 1.13 $16.347
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 121.92 $4,321.96 16 1.00 $3.507
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 4,297.87 $38,897.62 16 1.70 $0.895
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 462.01 -$18.02 10 1.25 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 319.61 $12.07 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 491.04 $16.60 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 919.25 $9.61 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 995.24 $255.29 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1,143.20 $72.03 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 47.36 $71.99 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 48.21 -$1.92 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 51.30 $0.34 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 56.57 $20.31 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 60.03 $1.11 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 61.53 -$1.15 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 90.50 $18.57 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 520.47 $1,828.17 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 541.51 $0.75 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 751.24 $12.21 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 870.90 $19.69 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1,587.01 $507.20 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 0.49 $0.02 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.75 $0.03 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.41 $0.01 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.53 $0.39 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-37
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.76 $0.11 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 99.81 $353.97 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 103.91 -$2.68 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 160.96 $11.94 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 161.01 -$0.15 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 168.20 $1.02 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 307.96 $96.17 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.04 $0.14 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.04 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.06 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.07 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.12 $0.04 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 5.03 $4.16 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 6.21 $5.93 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 4.29 $2.60 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 2.11 $2.21 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 8.35 $8.77 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency 0.18 $0.00 10 0.99 $0.000
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-38 www.enernoc.com
Table D-12 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data— Other Industrial, New Vintage
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.5 kW/ton, COP
2.3 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.3 kW/ton, COP
2.7 484.95 $342.00 20 1.14 $0.062
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.26 kW/ton, COP
2.8 581.97 $444.61 20 1.17 $0.067
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 1.0 kW/ton, COP
3.5 1,212.45 $547.21 20 1.45 $0.040
Cooling Air-Cooled Chiller 0.97 kW/ton, COP
3.6 1,285.15 $649.81 20 1.49 $0.045
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.75 kW/ton, COP
4.7 - $0.00 20 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.60 kW/ton, COP
5.9 480.74 $86.43 20 1.23 $0.016
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.58 kW/ton, COP
6.1 544.96 $172.85 20 1.27 $0.028
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.55 kW/Ton, COP
6.4 641.30 $207.42 20 1.33 $0.029
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.51 kW/ton, COP
6.9 769.00 $322.66 20 1.42 $0.037
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.50 kW/Ton, COP
7.0 801.13 $357.23 20 1.45 $0.039
Cooling Water-Cooled Chiller 0.48 kW/ton, COP
7.3 865.48 $391.80 20 1.50 $0.040
Cooling Roof top AC EER 9.2 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Roof top AC EER 10.1 279.89 $250.97 16 - $0.089
Cooling Roof top AC EER 11.2 560.94 $482.63 16 1.00 $0.085
Cooling Roof top AC EER 12.0 732.94 $926.65 16 1.06 $0.125
Cooling Roof top AC Ductless Minisplit 1,100.31 $3,040.58 16 1.14 $0.273
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 340.68 $348.86 16 - $0.101
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 542.95 $501.48 16 1.00 $0.091
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 719.81 $1,286.40 16 1.04 $0.177
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 790.69 $1,678.86 16 1.06 $0.210
Cooling Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 1,207.75 $3,216.01 16 1.19 $0.263
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 - $116.67 16 1.01 $0.000
Cooling Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 899.97 $1,050.00 16 1.68 $0.115
Cooling Evaporative AC Direct - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect 112.19 $5,260.05 14 0.90 $5.010
Cooling Evaporative AC Indirect/Direct 286.44 $26,300.25 14 0.60 $9.812
Cooling Other Cooling EER 9.8 - $0.00 14 1.00 $0.000
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.2 155.27 $2,116.54 14 0.98 $1.457
Cooling Other Cooling EER 10.8 366.71 $3,100.28 14 1.01 $0.903
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11 431.98 $9,539.33 14 0.88 $2.360
Cooling Other Cooling EER 11.5 585.36 $15,978.37 14 0.80 $2.917
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 9.3 - $0.00 16 - $0.000
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 10.3 1,013.93 $717.01 16 - $0.070
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.0 1,713.73 $1,030.71 16 1.00 $0.060
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-39
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 11.7 2,406.65 $2,643.98 16 1.04 $0.109
Heating Air Source Heat Pump EER 12.0 2,698.15 $3,450.62 16 1.06 $0.127
Heating Air Source Heat Pump Ductless Minisplit 4,640.93 $6,609.96 16 1.19 $0.141
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 13.8 - $0.00 16 1.00 $0.000
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 14 1,145.25 $2,637.87 16 1.01 $0.228
Heating Geothermal Heat Pump EER 27.8 5,255.19 $23,740.79 16 1.68 $0.447
Heating Electric Room Heat Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Heating Electric Furnace Standard - $0.00 25 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Constant Volume - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Ventilation Ventilation Variable Air Volume 370.36 -$26.33 10 1.16 -$0.009
Interior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 319.61 $12.07 3 - $0.013
Interior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 491.04 $16.60 3 - $0.012
Interior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 919.25 $9.61 6 3.09 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 995.24 $255.29 20 1.24 $0.023
Interior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1,143.20 $72.03 20 - $0.006
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2010) 47.36 $71.99 15 0.45 $0.156
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T8 48.21 -$1.92 10 1.74 -$0.005
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures High Pressure
Sodium 51.30 $0.34 6 1.68 $0.001
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Induction 56.57 $20.31 15 0.99 $0.037
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures Light Emitting
Plasma 60.03 $1.11 15 1.78 $0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures T5 61.53 -$1.15 10 2.09 -$0.002
Interior
Lighting High-Bay Fixtures LED (2020) 90.50 $18.57 15 - $0.021
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 520.47 $1,828.17 15 0.35 $0.360
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 541.51 $0.75 10 1.34 $0.000
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 751.24 $12.21 10 1.50 $0.002
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 870.90 $19.69 10 1.60 $0.003
Interior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 1,587.01 $507.20 15 - $0.033
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in Incandescent - $0.00 2 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 90W Halogen PAR-
38 0.49 $0.02 3 - $0.013
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in 70W HIR PAR-38 0.75 $0.03 3 - $0.012
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in CFL 1.41 $0.01 6 2.97 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2010) 1.53 $0.39 20 1.11 $0.023
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-40 www.enernoc.com
End Use Technology
Efficiency
Definition Savings
Incremental
Cost Lifetime
B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Exterior
Lighting Screw-in LED (2020) 1.76 $0.11 20 - $0.006
Exterior
Lighting HID Metal Halides - $0.00 3 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2010) 99.81 $353.97 15 0.29 $0.364
Exterior
Lighting HID T8 103.91 -$2.68 10 1.21 -$0.003
Exterior
Lighting HID Light Emitting
Plasma 160.96 $11.94 15 1.22 $0.008
Exterior
Lighting HID High Pressure
Sodium 161.01 -$0.15 6 1.54 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting HID T5 168.20 $1.02 10 1.45 $0.001
Exterior
Lighting HID LED (2020) 307.96 $96.17 15 - $0.032
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T12 - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2010) 0.04 $0.14 15 0.32 $0.360
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T8 0.04 $0.00 10 1.33 $0.000
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent Super T8 0.06 $0.00 10 1.49 $0.002
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent T5 0.07 $0.00 10 1.59 $0.003
Exterior
Lighting Linear Fluorescent LED (2020) 0.12 $0.04 15 - $0.033
Motors Pumps Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Pumps High Efficiency 5.03 $4.16 10 0.99 $0.110
Motors Fans & Blowers Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Fans & Blowers High Efficiency 6.21 $5.93 10 0.99 $0.127
Motors Compressed Air Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Compressed Air High Efficiency 4.29 $2.60 10 1.00 $0.081
Motors Matl Handling Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Handling High Efficiency 2.11 $2.21 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Matl Processing Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Matl Processing High Efficiency 8.35 $8.77 10 0.99 $0.140
Motors Other Motors Standard - $0.00 10 1.00 $0.000
Motors Other Motors High Efficiency 0.18 $0.18 10 0.99 $0.140
Process Process Heating Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Process Cooling and
Refrig Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process
Electro-Chemical
Processes Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Process Other Process Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Miscellaneous Miscellaneous Standard - $0.00 5 1.00 $0.000

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-41
Table D-13 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Agriculture, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.390 1.64 $0.059
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.278 0.46 $0.130
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.615 0.46 $0.112
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.693 2.38 $0.056
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.514 19.97 $0.030
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.304 2.33 $0.249
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.080 1.94 $0.300
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.320 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.04 $14.136
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.624 3.70 $0.165
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.459 18.91 $0.034
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.291 2.36 $0.261
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.076 1.96 $0.314
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.306 3.65 $0.162
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.42 $1.477
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.600 3.79 $0.172
RTU - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.301 8.63 $0.055
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.012 19.13 $0.016
Roofs - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 1.699 20.75 $0.009
Energy Management System 21.4% 75.0% 14 $0.35 3.251 8.69 $0.012
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 71.9% 85.0% 11 $0.13 1.187 3.48 $0.014
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 22.2% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.245 0.19 $0.179
Interior Lighting - Skylights 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 2.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.123 0.13 $0.255
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.049 13.32 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 6.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.062 0.03 $0.888
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.173 0.21 $0.181
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.3% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.147 0.10 $0.424
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.052 0.04 $0.606
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.077 0.65 $0.040
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.155 0.02 $1.354
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.26 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-42 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.23 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.67 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 0.88 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.38 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.34 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 2.89 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 3.71 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 4.74 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.26 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.49 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.54 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.46 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.70 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.12 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.25 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.45 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.54 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.79 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 34.09 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.02 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.83 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.35 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.25 $0.002
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 90.0% 7 $0.38 0.596 1.49 $0.109
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.6% 80.0% 5 $0.05 0.271 0.70 $0.042
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.032 0.25 $0.172
Custom Measures 0.0% 0.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 6.0% 20 $3.00 1.050 1.87 $0.252
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.64 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 52.46 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 10.0% 90.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-43
Table D-14 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Agriculture, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.253 1.50 $0.090
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.226 0.41 $0.160
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.467 0.37 $0.147
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.224 1.53 $0.174
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.211 11.42 $0.073
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.203 2.16 $0.374
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.097 3.29 $0.246
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.233 1.00 #DIV/0!
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.758
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.452 3.74 $0.229
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.158 9.26 $0.098
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.186 2.15 $0.409
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.089 3.27 $0.268
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.213 3.63 $0.233
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.919
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.416 3.74 $0.248
RTU - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.152 6.49 $0.109
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.292 12.97 $0.057
Roofs - High Reflectivity 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.297 15.64 $0.052
Energy Management System 100.0% 75.0% 14 $0.35 1.777 7.59 $0.021
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.3% 86.3% 11 $0.13 0.836 4.97 $0.019
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 44.4% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.203 0.20 $0.192
Interior Lighting - Skylights 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 5.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.102 0.12 $0.308
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.041 12.31 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.042 0.03 $1.289
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.157 0.20 $0.200
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.7% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.030 0.04 $1.032
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.045 0.53 $0.069
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.091 0.01 $2.305
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.26 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-44 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.23 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.67 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 0.88 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.38 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.34 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 2.89 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 3.71 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 4.74 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.27 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.49 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.54 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.46 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.70 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.12 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.26 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.45 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.54 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.79 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 34.10 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.02 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.83 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.35 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.26 $0.002
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.026 0.23 $0.214
Custom Measures 10.0% 90.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 0.756 2.23 $0.350
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.78 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 56.10 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 10.0% 90.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-45
Table D-15 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Electronics, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.390 1.64 $0.059
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.278 0.46 $0.130
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.615 0.46 $0.112
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.693 2.38 $0.056
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.514 19.97 $0.030
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.304 2.33 $0.249
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.080 1.94 $0.300
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.320 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.04 $14.136
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.624 3.70 $0.165
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.459 18.91 $0.034
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.291 2.36 $0.261
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.076 1.96 $0.314
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.306 3.65 $0.162
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.42 $1.477
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.600 3.79 $0.172
RTU - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.301 8.63 $0.055
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.012 19.13 $0.016
Roofs - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 1.699 20.75 $0.009
Energy Management System 21.4% 75.0% 14 $0.35 3.251 8.69 $0.012
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 71.9% 85.0% 11 $0.13 1.187 3.48 $0.014
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 22.2% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.245 0.19 $0.179
Interior Lighting - Skylights 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 2.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.123 0.13 $0.255
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.049 13.32 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 6.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.062 0.03 $0.888
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.173 0.21 $0.181
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.3% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.147 0.10 $0.424
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.052 0.04 $0.606
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.077 0.65 $0.040
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.155 0.02 $1.354
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.28 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-46 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.44 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.69 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 1.06 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.46 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.35 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 3.35 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 4.07 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 5.20 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 45.43 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.54 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.69 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.03 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.78 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.23 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.75 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.78 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.12 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.95 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.45 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.70 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.91 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.49 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.75 $0.002
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 90.0% 7 $0.38 0.596 1.49 $0.109
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.6% 80.0% 5 $0.05 0.271 0.70 $0.042
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.032 0.25 $0.172
Custom Measures 0.0% 0.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 6.0% 20 $3.00 1.050 1.87 $0.252
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.77 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 53.09 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-47
Table D-16 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Electronics, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.253 1.60 $0.090
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.226 0.42 $0.160
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.467 0.37 $0.147
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.224 1.62 $0.174
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.211 11.42 $0.073
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.203 2.16 $0.374
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.097 3.29 $0.246
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.233 1.00 #DIV/0!
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.758
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.452 3.74 $0.229
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.158 9.26 $0.098
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.186 2.15 $0.409
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.089 3.27 $0.268
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.213 3.63 $0.233
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.919
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.416 3.74 $0.248
RTU - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.152 6.49 $0.109
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.292 12.97 $0.057
Roofs - High Reflectivity 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.297 16.57 $0.052
Energy Management System 100.0% 75.0% 14 $0.35 1.777 7.83 $0.021
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.3% 86.3% 11 $0.13 0.836 4.97 $0.019
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 44.4% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.203 0.20 $0.192
Interior Lighting - Skylights 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 5.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.102 0.12 $0.308
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.041 12.30 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.042 0.03 $1.289
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.157 0.20 $0.200
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 18.7% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.030 0.04 $1.032
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.045 0.53 $0.069
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.091 0.01 $2.305
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.28 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-48 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.44 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.69 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 1.06 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.46 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.35 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 3.35 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 4.07 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 5.20 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 45.44 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.54 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.69 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.04 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.78 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.23 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.76 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.78 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.12 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.95 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.46 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.70 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.91 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.49 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.76 $0.002
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.026 0.23 $0.214
Custom Measures 10.0% 90.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 0.756 2.23 $0.350
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.91 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 56.76 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-49
Table D-17 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Manufacturing Food, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.390 1.64 $0.059
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.278 0.46 $0.130
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.615 0.46 $0.112
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.693 2.38 $0.056
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.514 19.97 $0.030
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.304 2.33 $0.249
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.080 1.94 $0.300
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.320 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.04 $14.136
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.624 3.70 $0.165
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.459 18.91 $0.034
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.291 2.36 $0.261
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.076 1.96 $0.314
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.306 3.65 $0.162
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.42 $1.477
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.600 3.79 $0.172
RTU - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.301 8.63 $0.055
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.012 19.13 $0.016
Roofs - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 1.699 20.75 $0.009
Energy Management System 21.4% 75.0% 14 $0.35 3.251 8.68 $0.012
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 71.9% 85.0% 11 $0.13 1.187 3.48 $0.014
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 22.2% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.245 0.18 $0.179
Interior Lighting - Skylights 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.27 $0.121
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 2.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.123 0.13 $0.255
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.049 12.95 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.27 $0.121
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 6.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.062 0.03 $0.888
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.173 0.21 $0.181
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.3% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.147 0.10 $0.424
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.052 0.04 $0.606
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.077 0.65 $0.040
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.155 0.02 $1.354
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.28 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-50 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.44 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.69 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 1.06 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.46 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.35 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 3.35 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 4.07 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 5.20 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 45.43 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.54 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.69 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.03 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.78 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.23 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.75 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.78 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.12 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.95 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.45 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.70 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 10.9% 12.1% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.91 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.42 $0.030
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.75 $0.002
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 90.0% 7 $0.38 0.596 1.49 $0.109
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.6% 80.0% 5 $0.05 0.271 0.69 $0.042
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.032 0.25 $0.172
Custom Measures 0.0% 0.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 6.0% 20 $3.00 1.050 1.87 $0.252
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.13 1.000 3.22 $0.017
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 57.61 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-51
Table D-18 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data—Manufacturing Food, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.253 1.50 $0.090
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.226 0.41 $0.160
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.467 0.37 $0.147
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.224 1.53 $0.174
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.211 11.42 $0.073
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.203 2.16 $0.374
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.097 3.29 $0.246
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.233 1.00 #DIV/0!
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.758
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.452 3.74 $0.229
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.158 9.26 $0.098
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.186 2.15 $0.409
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.089 3.27 $0.268
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.213 3.63 $0.233
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.919
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.416 3.74 $0.248
RTU - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.152 6.49 $0.109
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.292 12.97 $0.057
Roofs - High Reflectivity 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.297 15.64 $0.052
Energy Management System 100.0% 75.0% 14 $0.35 1.777 7.59 $0.021
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.3% 86.3% 11 $0.13 0.836 4.97 $0.019
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 44.4% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.203 0.20 $0.192
Interior Lighting - Skylights 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 5.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.102 0.12 $0.308
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.041 12.31 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.042 0.03 $1.289
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.157 0.20 $0.200
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.7% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.030 0.03 $1.032
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.045 0.51 $0.069
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.091 0.01 $2.305
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.28 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-52 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.44 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.69 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 1.06 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.46 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.35 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 3.35 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 4.07 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 5.20 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 45.44 $0.001
Compressed Air - System
Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.54 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.69 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.04 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.78 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.23 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.76 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.78 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 29.12 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.95 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.56 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.46 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.70 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 10.9% 12.1% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.91 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.42 $0.030
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 25.76 $0.002
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.026 0.23 $0.214
Custom Measures 10.0% 90.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 0.756 2.23 $0.350
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.13 1.000 3.32 $0.017
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 61.41 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-53
Table D-19 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Water and Wastewater, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.390 1.64 $0.059
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.278 0.46 $0.130
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.615 0.46 $0.112
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.693 2.38 $0.056
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.514 19.97 $0.030
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.304 2.33 $0.249
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.080 1.94 $0.300
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.320 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.04 $14.136
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.624 3.70 $0.165
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.459 18.91 $0.034
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.291 2.36 $0.261
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.076 1.96 $0.314
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.306 3.65 $0.162
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.42 $1.477
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.600 3.79 $0.172
RTU - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.301 8.63 $0.055
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.012 19.13 $0.016
Roofs - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 1.699 20.75 $0.009
Energy Management System 21.4% 75.0% 14 $0.35 3.251 8.69 $0.012
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 71.9% 85.0% 11 $0.13 1.187 3.48 $0.014
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 22.2% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.245 0.19 $0.179
Interior Lighting - Skylights 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 2.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.123 0.13 $0.255
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.049 13.32 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 6.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.062 0.03 $0.888
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.173 0.21 $0.181
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.3% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.147 0.10 $0.424
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.052 0.04 $0.606
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.077 0.65 $0.040
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.155 0.02 $1.354
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.26 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-54 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.23 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.67 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 0.88 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.38 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.34 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 2.89 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 3.71 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 4.74 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.26 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.49 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.54 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.46 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.70 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.12 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.25 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.45 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.54 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.79 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 34.09 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.02 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.83 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.35 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.25 $0.002
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 90.0% 7 $0.38 0.596 1.49 $0.109
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.6% 80.0% 5 $0.05 0.271 0.70 $0.042
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.032 0.25 $0.172
Custom Measures 0.0% 0.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 6.0% 20 $3.00 1.050 1.87 $0.252
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.68 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 52.65 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-55
Table D-20 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Water and Wastewater, New Vintage
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.253 1.50 $0.090
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.226 0.41 $0.160
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.467 0.37 $0.147
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.224 1.53 $0.174
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.211 11.42 $0.073
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.203 2.16 $0.374
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.097 3.29 $0.246
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.233 1.00 0
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.758
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.452 3.74 $0.229
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.158 9.26 $0.098
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.186 2.15 $0.409
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.089 3.27 $0.268
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.213 3.63 $0.233
Water-Cooled Chiller - High
Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.919
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.416 3.74 $0.248
RTU - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.152 6.49 $0.109
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.292 12.97 $0.057
Roofs - High Reflectivity 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.297 15.64 $0.052
Energy Management System 100.0% 75.0% 14 $0.35 1.777 7.59 $0.021
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.3% 86.3% 11 $0.13 0.836 4.97 $0.019
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 44.4% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.203 0.20 $0.192
Interior Lighting - Skylights 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 5.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.102 0.12 $0.308
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.041 12.31 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.042 0.03 $1.289
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.157 0.20 $0.200
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.7% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.030 0.04 $1.032
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting
Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.045 0.53 $0.069
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.091 0.01 $2.305
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-56 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.26 $0.121
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.23 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.67 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head
Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 0.88 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.38 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.34 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 2.89 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage
Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 3.71 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 4.74 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.27 $0.001
Compressed Air - System
Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.49 $0.012
Compressed Air - System
Optimization and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.54 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.46 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.70 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.12 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.26 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.45 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.54 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.79 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 34.10 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.02 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.83 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.35 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.26 $0.002
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.026 0.23 $0.214
Custom Measures 10.0% 90.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 0.756 2.23 $0.350
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.79 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 56.11 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-57
Table D-21 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Other Industrial, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.390 1.64 $0.059
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.278 0.46 $0.130
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.615 0.46 $0.112
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 5.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.693 2.38 $0.056
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.514 19.97 $0.030
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.272 10.56 $0.057
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.304 2.33 $0.249
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.080 1.94 $0.300
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.320 1.00 $0.000
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.000 0.04 $14.136
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.624 3.70 $0.165
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.459 18.91 $0.034
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.260 9.31 $0.064
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 5.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.291 2.36 $0.261
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.076 1.96 $0.314
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser
Water Temperature Reset 30.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.306 3.65 $0.162
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.004 0.42 $1.477
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.600 3.79 $0.172
RTU - Maintenance 62.2% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.301 8.63 $0.055
Heat Pump - Maintenance 20.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 1.012 19.13 $0.016
Roofs - High Reflectivity 50.0% 100.0% 15 $0.15 1.699 20.75 $0.009
Energy Management System 21.4% 75.0% 14 $0.35 3.251 8.69 $0.012
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 71.9% 85.0% 11 $0.13 1.187 3.48 $0.014
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 22.2% 75.0% 8 $0.28 0.245 0.19 $0.179
Interior Lighting - Skylights 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 2.6% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.123 0.13 $0.255
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 50.0% 90.0% 10 $0.00 0.049 13.32 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 1.2% 40.6% 8 $0.29 0.368 0.28 $0.121
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 6.1% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.062 0.03 $0.888
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.173 0.21 $0.181
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and
Install Reflectors 18.3% 56.3% 11 $0.50 0.147 0.10 $0.424
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.052 0.04 $0.606
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.077 0.65 $0.040
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.155 0.02 $1.354
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.26 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-58 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.23 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.67 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 0.88 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.38 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.34 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 2.89 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 3.71 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 4.74 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.26 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.49 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.54 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.46 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.70 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.12 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.25 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.45 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.54 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.79 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 34.09 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.02 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.83 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.35 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.25 $0.002
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 10.0% 90.0% 7 $0.38 0.596 1.49 $0.109
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 25.6% 80.0% 5 $0.05 0.271 0.70 $0.042
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 1.0% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.032 0.25 $0.172
Custom Measures 0.0% 0.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 6.0% 20 $3.00 1.050 1.87 $0.252
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.61 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 52.32 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting D-59
Table D-22 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Other, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Insulation - Ceiling 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.26 0.253 1.50 $0.090
Insulation - Ducting 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.41 0.226 0.41 $0.160
Insulation - Wall Cavity 7.0% 13.0% 20 $0.78 0.467 0.37 $0.147
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 25.0% 50.0% 15 $0.38 0.224 1.53 $0.174
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.211 11.42 $0.073
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical
Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.138 6.47 $0.120
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.203 2.16 $0.374
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.097 3.29 $0.246
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 0.0% 0.0% 0 $0.00 0.233 1.00 0
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.758
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.452 3.74 $0.229
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 43.3% 65.0% 15 $0.15 0.158 9.26 $0.098
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient
Mechanical Layout 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.126 6.45 $0.131
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Reset 25.0% 75.0% 10 $0.57 0.186 2.15 $0.409
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water
Variable-Flow System 30.0% 75.0% 10 $0.18 0.089 3.27 $0.268
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water
Temperature Reset 60.0% 100.0% 4 $0.18 0.213 3.63 $0.233
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency
Cooling Tower Fans 15.0% 43.5% 10 $0.04 0.003 0.46 $1.919
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 15.0% 88.2% 20 $1.17 0.416 3.74 $0.248
RTU - Maintenance 62.8% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.152 6.49 $0.109
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0.0% 100.0% 4 $0.06 0.292 12.97 $0.057
Roofs - High Reflectivity 55.9% 100.0% 15 $0.15 0.297 15.64 $0.052
Energy Management System 100.0% 75.0% 14 $0.35 1.777 7.59 $0.021
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 86.3% 86.3% 11 $0.13 0.836 4.97 $0.019
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 44.4% 75.0% 8 $0.25 0.203 0.20 $0.192
Interior Lighting - Skylights 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and
Timers 5.3% 75.0% 8 $0.20 0.102 0.12 $0.308
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 100.0% 100.0% 10 $0.00 0.041 12.31 $0.003
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 2.4% 40.6% 8 $0.19 0.305 0.39 $0.097
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 0.0% 100.0% 5 $0.24 0.042 0.03 $1.289
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.157 0.20 $0.200
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install
Reflectors 18.7% 56.3% 11 $0.50 - - $0.000
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 10.0% 30.0% 8 $0.20 0.030 0.04 $1.032
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 18.0% 37.5% 8 $0.02 0.045 0.53 $0.069
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic
Installation 0.0% 12.5% 5 $0.92 0.091 0.01 $2.305
Process - Conductivity Controls 20.0% 100.0% 5 $0.53 1.000 0.26 $0.121
Industrial Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
D-60 www.enernoc.com
Measure Base
Saturation Applicability Lifetime Cost Savings Ratio Levelized
Cost
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 30.0% 100.0% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.23 $0.018
Process - Timers and Controls 40.0% 100.0% 5 $0.42 2.000 0.67 $0.048
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 30.0% 90.0% 18 $0.57 1.000 0.88 $0.053
Refrigeration - System Controls 40.0% 56.0% 18 $1.33 1.000 0.38 $0.123
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 30.0% 72.0% 3 $0.24 1.000 0.34 $0.086
Refrigeration - System Optimization 40.0% 56.0% 15 $0.15 1.000 2.89 $0.015
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 20.2% 25.9% 10 $0.08 1.000 3.71 $0.011
Compressed Air - Compressor
Replacement 14.6% 17.1% 10 $0.06 1.000 4.74 $0.009
Compressed Air - System Controls 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.01 1.000 39.27 $0.001
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.03 1.000 2.49 $0.012
Compressed Air - System Optimization
and Improvements 24.8% 35.6% 10 $0.20 1.000 1.54 $0.027
Pumping System - Controls 22.8% 31.0% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.46 $0.001
Pumping System - Maintenance 5.0% 33.8% 3 $0.02 1.000 3.70 $0.008
Pumping System - Optimization 22.4% 30.0% 10 $0.28 1.000 1.12 $0.037
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.26 $0.002
Pump Equipment Upgrade 24.0% 33.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.017
Fan Equipment Upgrade 18.6% 23.2% 10 $0.09 1.000 3.45 $0.012
Fan System - Controls 20.9% 27.2% 10 $0.01 1.000 26.54 $0.001
Fan System - Maintenance 10.0% 37.5% 3 $0.01 1.000 7.79 $0.004
Fan System - Optimization 22.2% 29.6% 10 $0.13 1.000 2.33 $0.018
Fans - Variable Speed Control 10.0% 37.5% 15 $0.01 1.000 34.10 $0.001
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed
Drives 5.0% 15.0% 20 $0.19 1.000 3.02 $0.016
Motors - Rewind 14.9% 17.4% 10 $0.35 1.000 0.83 $0.047
Motors - Synchronous belts 17.3% 21.0% 10 $0.22 1.000 1.35 $0.029
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 5.0% 33.8% 15 $0.02 1.000 22.26 $0.002
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 5.9% 10.0% 10 $0.04 0.026 0.23 $0.214
Custom Measures 10.0% 90.0% 15 $0.67 - - $0.000
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0.0% 7.0% 20 $3.00 0.756 2.23 $0.350
Transformers 8.6% 9.4% 10 $0.11 1.000 3.77 $0.014
Strategic Energy Management 0.0% 20.0% 10 $0.02 1.000 56.06 $0.003
Engine Block Heaters 0.0% 0.0% 5 $0.30 1.000 0.46 $0.069

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting E-1
APPENDIX E
IRRIGATION ENERGY EFFICIENCY EQUIPMENT AND MEASURE
DATA
This appendix presents detailed information for irrigation energy-efficiency measures (equipment
and other measures per the LoadMAP taxonomy) that were evaluated in this study. Because
irrigation loads are almost exclusively due to pumps, efficiency motors were the only equipment
measure evaluated for this sector. Table E-3 through Table E-18 list the detailed unit-level data
(including economic screen results) for energy-efficient motors. Table E-19 through Table E-26
list the detailed unit-level data (including economic screen results) for irrigation energy-efficiency
non-equipment measures. These include a variety of measures for replacing nozzles, sprinklers,
hubs, goosenecks, gaskets, wheel levelers, and other hardware to distribute water more
efficiently and thus reduce pumping hours of use. Also included are motor rewinds to improve
motor efficiency and variable speed drives to reduce part-load use. Scientific irrigation practices,
which use moisture-sensing soil probes to determine when irrigation is required, can potentially
reduce irrigation time. The multiple pumps, proper flow design, and proper pressure design
measures optimize irrigation system design to reduce energy use.

Irrigation Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
E-2 www.enernoc.com
Table E-1 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Irrigation, Existing Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings Incremental Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio Levelized Cost
Motors 5 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 5 HP High Efficiency 10.29 $17.17 15 0.98 $0.171
Motors 10 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 10 HP High Efficiency 21.92 $80.90 15 0.96 $0.379
Motors 15 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 15 HP High Efficiency 1.11 $59.23 15 0.95 $5.481
Motors 20 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 20 HP High Efficiency 32.20 $146.84 15 0.95 $0.468
Motors 25 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 25 HP High Efficiency 19.10 $125.36 15 0.96 $0.674
Motors 30 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 30 HP High Efficiency 14.54 $90.67 15 0.96 $0.640
Motors 40 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 40 HP High Efficiency 29.02 $146.84 15 0.96 $0.519
Motors 50 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 50 HP High Efficiency 7.82 $125.36 15 0.96 $1.644
Motors 60 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 60 HP High Efficiency 3.01 $84.96 15 0.97 $2.897
Motors 75 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 75 HP High Efficiency 37.13 $112.68 15 0.98 $0.311
Motors 100 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 100 HP High Efficiency 73.95 $123.15 15 0.99 $0.171
Motors 125 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 125 HP High Efficiency 60.68 $81.26 15 0.99 $0.137
Motors 150 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 150 HP High Efficiency 53.27 $86.64 15 0.99 $0.167
Motors 200 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 200 HP High Efficiency 89.44 $126.61 15 0.99 $0.145
Motors 250 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 250 HP High Efficiency 55.34 $74.33 15 0.99 $0.138
Motors 300 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 300 HP High Efficiency 61.29 $96.71 15 0.99 $0.162
Motors 350 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 350 HP High Efficiency 6.25 $90.52 15 0.98 $1.486
Motors 400 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 400 HP High Efficiency 13.67 $86.04 15 0.98 $0.646
Motors 450 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 450 HP High Efficiency - $53.93 15 0.98 $0.000
Motors 500 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 500 HP High Efficiency - $50.88 15 0.98 $0.000
Motors 600 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 600 HP High Efficiency - $53.75 15 0.98 $0.000
Motors > 600 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors > 600 HP High Efficiency - $113.92 15 0.98 $0.000

Irrigation Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting E-3
Table E-2 Energy Efficiency Equipment Data—Irrigation, New Vintage
End Use Technology Efficiency Definition Savings Incremental Cost Lifetime B/C Ratio Levelized Cost
Motors 5 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 5 HP High Efficiency 10.29 $16.57 15 0.99 $0.165
Motors 10 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 10 HP High Efficiency 21.92 $78.00 15 0.96 $0.365
Motors 15 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 15 HP High Efficiency 1.11 $57.37 15 0.95 $5.308
Motors 20 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 20 HP High Efficiency 3.18 $72.43 15 0.95 $2.338
Motors 25 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 25 HP High Efficiency 11.28 $86.94 15 0.96 $0.791
Motors 30 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 30 HP High Efficiency 14.54 $88.50 15 0.96 $0.625
Motors 40 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 40 HP High Efficiency 29.02 $144.00 15 0.96 $0.509
Motors 50 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 50 HP High Efficiency 7.82 $123.11 15 0.96 $1.615
Motors 60 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 60 HP High Efficiency 3.01 $83.68 15 0.97 $2.854
Motors 75 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 75 HP High Efficiency 37.13 $111.45 15 0.98 $0.308
Motors 100 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 100 HP High Efficiency 73.95 $121.31 15 0.99 $0.168
Motors 125 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 125 HP High Efficiency 60.68 $80.38 15 0.99 $0.136
Motors 150 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 150 HP High Efficiency 53.27 $85.62 15 0.99 $0.165
Motors 200 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 200 HP High Efficiency 89.44 $125.34 15 0.99 $0.144
Motors 250 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 250 HP High Efficiency 55.34 $73.47 15 0.99 $0.136
Motors 300 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 300 HP High Efficiency 61.29 $95.51 15 0.99 $0.160
Motors 350 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 350 HP High Efficiency 6.25 $89.59 15 0.98 $1.470
Motors 400 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 400 HP High Efficiency 13.67 $52.67 15 0.98 $0.395
Motors 450 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 450 HP High Efficiency - $111.64 15 0.98 $0.000
Motors 500 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 500 HP High Efficiency - $49.86 15 0.98 $0.000
Motors 600 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors 600 HP High Efficiency - $52.67 15 0.98 $0.000
Motors > 600 HP Standard - $0.00 15 1.00 $0.000
Motors > 600 HP High Efficiency - $111.64 15 0.98 $0.000
Irrigation Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
E-4 www.enernoc.com
Table E-3 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Irrigation, Existing Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Nozzle Replacement - Flow-Control Type 4.0% 1.0% 4 $5.67 30.000 1.50 $0.052
Nozzle Replacement - Same Flow Rate or
Less 92.0% 20.0% 4 $1.60 39.000 6.92 $0.011
Rebuilt or New Brass Impact Sprinklers 30.0% 8.0% 5 $12.33 30.000 0.86 $0.094
Rebuilt or New Wheel Line Levelers 15.0% 3.0% 5 $3.25 2.000 0.22 $0.370
Rotating-type or Low-Pressure Pivot
Sprinklers 55.0% 15.0% 5 $11.88 28.000 0.83 $0.097
Low Pressure Regulators 53.0% 15.0% 5 $6.13 38.000 2.19 $0.037
Gasket Replacement 75.0% 8.0% 5 $8.80 24.000 0.97 $0.084
Hub Replacement 8.0% 2.0% 10 $50.00 69.000 1.00 $0.096
New Goose Necks 55.0% 45.0% 10 $10.67 14.000 0.95 $0.101
Pipe Repair 75.0% 7.0% 8 $18.00 48.000 1.54 $0.059
Center Pivot Base Boot Gasket 10.0% 2.0% 8 $250.00 1,282.000 2.96 $0.031
Multiple Configuration Nozzle 5.0% 28.3% 5 $4.57 44.864 3.48 $0.023
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 25HP 11.2% 85.0% 20 $176.33 236.659 1.89 $0.066
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 30HP 11.2% 85.0% 20 $193.67 254.325 1.85 $0.067
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 40HP 11.2% 85.0% 20 $236.67 297.309 1.77 $0.070
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 50HP 9.8% 85.0% 20 $262.00 322.492 1.74 $0.072
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 60HP 9.8% 85.0% 20 $309.00 327.829 1.50 $0.083
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 75HP 9.8% 85.0% 20 $334.00 340.654 1.45 $0.086
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 100HP 10.9% 85.0% 20 $414.33 584.848 2.00 $0.062
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 125HP 10.9% 85.0% 20 $465.33 727.397 2.22 $0.056
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 150HP 10.9% 85.0% 20 $518.33 866.822 2.37 $0.053
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 200HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $624.00 1,148.813 2.62 $0.048
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 250HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $802.00 1,434.009 2.54 $0.049
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 300HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $810.67 1,718.370 3.01 $0.042
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 350HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $849.67 2,004.765 3.35 $0.037
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 400HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $949.00 2,284.735 3.42 $0.037
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 450HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $1,037.33 2,563.188 3.49 $0.036
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 500HP 10.4% 85.0% 20 $1,120.67 2,847.987 3.58 $0.035
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 600HP 10.4% 85.0% 20 $1,651.45 3,417.539 2.92 $0.043
Green Motors Program Rewind: > 600
HP 10.4% 85.0% 20 $2,375.10 5,695.899 3.38 $0.037
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 4.0% 15.0% 10 $0.10 11,800.878 85,808.2
5 $0.000
Scientific irrigation practices 20.0% 85.0% 1 $9.45 190.000 1.44 $0.050
Multiple Pumps 15.0% 25.0% 25 $6,000.00 4,720.351 1.35 $0.102
Proper Flow Design 85.0% 100.0% 25 $3,000.00 4,720.351 2.69 $0.051
Proper Pressure or Head Design 75.0% 100.0% 25 $15,000.00 14,161.054 1.61 $0.085
Irrigation Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting E-5
Table E-4 Energy Efficiency Non-Equipment Data— Irrigation, New Vintage
Measure Base
Saturation
Applica-
bility Lifetime Cost Savings B/C
Ratio
Levelized
Cost
Nozzle Replacement - Flow-Control
Type 4.0% 1.0% 4 $5.67 30.000 1.50 $0.052
Nozzle Replacement - Same Flow Rate
or Less 92.0% 20.0% 4 $1.60 39.000 6.95 $0.011
Rebuilt or New Brass Impact Sprinklers 30.0% 8.0% 5 $12.33 30.000 0.87 $0.094
Rebuilt or New Wheel Line Levelers 15.0% 3.0% 5 $3.25 2.000 0.22 $0.370
Rotating-type or Low-Pressure Pivot
Sprinklers 55.0% 15.0% 5 $11.88 28.000 0.84 $0.097
Low Pressure Regulators 53.0% 15.0% 5 $6.13 38.000 2.21 $0.037
Gasket Replacement 75.0% 8.0% 5 $8.80 24.000 0.97 $0.084
Hub Replacement 8.0% 2.0% 10 $50.00 69.000 1.01 $0.096
New Goose Necks 55.0% 45.0% 10 $10.67 14.000 0.96 $0.101
Pipe Repair 75.0% 7.0% 8 $18.00 48.000 1.55 $0.059
Center Pivot Base Boot Gasket 10.0% 2.0% 8 $250.00 1,282.000 2.98 $0.031
Multiple Configuration Nozzle 5.0% 28.3% 5 $4.57 44.864 3.49 $0.023
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 25HP 11.2% 85.0% 20 $176.33 236.659 1.92 $0.066
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 30HP 11.2% 85.0% 20 $193.67 254.325 1.88 $0.067
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 40HP 11.2% 85.0% 20 $236.67 297.309 1.80 $0.070
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 50HP 9.8% 85.0% 20 $262.00 322.492 1.76 $0.072
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 60HP 9.8% 85.0% 20 $309.00 327.829 1.52 $0.083
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 75HP 9.8% 85.0% 20 $334.00 340.654 1.46 $0.086
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 100HP 10.9% 85.0% 20 $414.33 584.848 2.02 $0.062
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 125HP 10.9% 85.0% 20 $465.33 727.397 2.24 $0.056
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 150HP 10.9% 85.0% 20 $518.33 866.822 2.39 $0.053
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 200HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $624.00 1,148.813 2.64 $0.048
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 250HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $802.00 1,434.009 2.56 $0.049
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 300HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $810.67 1,718.370 3.03 $0.042
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 350HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $849.67 2,004.765 3.38 $0.037
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 400HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $949.00 2,284.735 3.45 $0.037
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 450HP 8.9% 85.0% 20 $1,037.33 2,563.188 3.54 $0.036
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 500HP 10.4% 85.0% 20 $1,120.67 2,847.987 3.64 $0.035
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor
size 600HP 10.4% 85.0% 20 $1,651.45 3,417.539 2.96 $0.043
Green Motors Program Rewind: > 600
HP 10.4% 85.0% 20 $2,375.10 5,695.899 3.43 $0.037
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 4.0% 15.0% 10 $0.10 11,621.475 85,192.5 $0.000
Scientific irrigation practices 20.0% 85.0% 1 $9.45 190.000 1.44 $0.050
Multiple Pumps 15.0% 25.0% 25 $6,000.00 4,648.590 1.34 $0.104
Proper Flow Design 85.0% 100.0% 25 $3,000.00 4,648.590 2.68 $0.052
Proper Pressure or Head Design 75.0% 100.0% 25 $15,000.00 13,945.770 1.61 $0.086
Irrigation Energy Efficiency Equipment and Measure Data
E-6 www.enernoc.com

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-1
APPENDIX F
MARKET ADOPTION FACTORS
A set of market adoption factors are applied to Economic potential to estimate Achievable
Potential. These estimate customer adoption of economic measures when delivered through
efficiency programs under realistic market and customer preference conditions. They reflect
expected program participation given barriers to customer acceptance and program
implementation. These adoption rates generally increase over time, reflecting an increasing
awareness and willingness to adopt energy-efficient measures. However, in some cases, where a
new technology is introduced, the adoption rates drop to reflect that the new technology may
not yet be accepted in the market. For mature measures, information channels are assumed to
be established for marketing, educating consumers, and coordinating with trade allies and
delivery partners. For evolving measures, this is not the case and thus the factors start at a
lower level.
The market adoption rates for the Idaho Power study were developed using the ramp rates from
the Northwest Power & Conservation Council’s Sixth Plan as a starting point. The ramp rates
were then adjusted based on actual Idaho Power program history and information from program
evaluations. These adjustments mainly set the potential in the first years of the study to match
with recent program achievements and thus show continuity of results.
Table F-1 through Table F-2 present the Achievable Potential market adoption factors for the
residential sector, first for equipment measures and then for non-equipment measures. Table F-4
through Table F-8 present the market adoption factors for the commercial, industrial, and
irrigation sectors.

Market Adoption Factors
F-2 www.enernoc.com
Table F-1 Residential Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
End Use Fuel Technology 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Cooling Electric Central AC 0% 7% 14% 22% 30% 32% 33% 34% 35% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Cooling Electric Room AC 0% 7% 14% 22% 30% 32% 33% 34% 35% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Cooling Electric Air-Source Heat Pump 0% 7% 14% 22% 30% 32% 33% 34% 35% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Cooling Electric Geothermal Heat Pump 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Cooling Electric Evaporative AC 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Heating Electric Electric Room Heat 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Heating Electric Electric Furnace 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Heating Electric Air-Source Heat Pump 0% 7% 14% 22% 30% 32% 33% 34% 35% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Heating Electric Geothermal Heat Pump 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Water Heating Electric Water Heater <=55 gal 0% 0% 1% 1% 1% 2% 4% 6% 8% 9% 10% 12% 13% 14% 16%
Water Heating Electric Water Heater > 55 gal 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Int. Lighting Electric Screw-in 0% 21% 24% 27% 31% 35% 38% 42% 46% 11% 13% 16% 20% 23% 27%
Int. Lighting Electric Linear Fluorescent 0% 8% 13% 19% 24% 28% 32% 35% 38% 41% 44% 46% 48% 51% 53%
Int. Lighting Electric Specialty 0% 12% 14% 16% 19% 21% 23% 26% 29% 7% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16%
Ext. Lighting Electric Screw-in 0% 21% 24% 27% 31% 35% 38% 42% 46% 11% 13% 16% 20% 23% 27%
Appliances Electric Clothes Washer 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Clothes Dryer 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Dishwasher 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Refrigerator 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Freezer 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Second Refrigerator 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Stove 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Appliances Electric Microwave 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Electronics Electric Personal Computers 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Electronics Electric Monitor 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Electronics Electric Laptops 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Electronics Electric TVs 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Electronics Electric Printer/Fax/Copier 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Electronics Electric Set-top Boxes/DVR 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Electronics Electric Devices and Gadgets 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Misc Electric Pool Pump 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Misc Electric Pool Heater 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Misc Electric Hot Tub / Spa 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Misc Electric Well Pump 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Misc Electric Furnace Fan 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 13% 15% 17% 20% 22% 24% 27% 30% 32%
Misc Electric Miscellaneous 0% 4% 7% 11% 15% 19% 23% 28% 33% 36% 37% 37% 38% 39% 40%
Market Adoption Factors
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-3
Table F-2 Residential Non-Equipment Measures— Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Insulation - Ceiling 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Insulation - Ducting 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Insulation - Foundation 0% 35% 46% 52% 54% 56% 54% 53% 54% 55% 56% 58% 60% 61% 63%
Insulation - Infiltration Control 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0% 35% 46% 52% 54% 56% 54% 53% 54% 55% 56% 58% 60% 61% 63%
Insulation - Wall Sheathing 0% 35% 46% 52% 54% 56% 54% 53% 54% 55% 56% 58% 60% 61% 63%
Ducting - Repair and Sealing 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Windows - High Efficiency/ENERGY STAR 0% 24% 34% 40% 42% 43% 45% 47% 50% 52% 51% 51% 51% 52% 53%
Windows - Install Reflective Film 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Doors - Storm and Thermal 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Roofs - High Reflectivity 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Attic Fan - Installation 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Attic Fan - Photovoltaic - Installation 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Whole-House Fan - Installation 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Ceiling Fan - Installation 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Home Energy Management System 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Central AC - Early Replacement 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Central AC - Maintenance and Tune-Up 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Central Heat Pump - Maintenance 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Room AC - Removal of Second Unit 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators 0% 24% 34% 40% 42% 43% 45% 47% 50% 52% 51% 51% 51% 52% 53%
Water Heater - Low-Flow Showerheads 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 0% 24% 34% 40% 42% 43% 45% 47% 50% 52% 51% 51% 51% 52% 53%
Water Heater - Timer 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Water Heater - Solar System 0% 18% 23% 28% 32% 35% 41% 43% 45% 47% 49% 51% 53% 55% 57%
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Exterior Lighting - Photosensor Control 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Exterior Lighting - Timeclock Installation 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Refrigerator - Early Replacement 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Refrigerator - Maintenance 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Refrigerator - Remove Second Unit 0% 10% 11% 13% 15% 17% 19% 21% 23% 26% 28% 31% 34% 37% 40%
Market Adoption Factors
F-4 www.enernoc.com
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Freezer - Remove Second Unit 0% 10% 11% 13% 15% 17% 19% 21% 23% 26% 28% 31% 34% 37% 40%
Freezer - Early Replacement 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Freezer - Maintenance 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Electronics - Smart Power Strips 0% 12% 20% 26% 30% 34% 36% 39% 41% 43% 46% 48% 51% 55% 58%
Pool Pump - Timer 0% 22% 30% 33% 35% 37% 39% 41% 43% 45% 46% 47% 47% 48% 49%
Pool Heater - Solar System 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
ENERGY STAR Home Design 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Advanced New Construction Design 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%
Behavioral Feedback Tools 0% 20% 31% 39% 42% 44% 46% 48% 49% 50% 50% 51% 52% 54% 56%

Market Adoption Factors
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-5
Table F-3 Commercial Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
End Use Fuel Technology 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Cooling Electric Air-Cooled Chiller 0% 49% 57% 66% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68%
Cooling Electric Water-Cooled Chiller 0% 49% 57% 66% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68% 68%
Cooling Electric Roof top AC 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Cooling Electric Air-Source Heat Pump 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Cooling Electric Geothermal Heat Pump 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Cooling Electric Evaporative AC 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Cooling Electric Other Cooling 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Heating Electric Air-Source Heat Pump 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Heating Electric Geothermal Heat Pump 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Heating Electric Electric Room Heat 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Heating Electric Electric Furnace 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Ventilation Electric Ventilation 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Water Heating Electric Water Heater 0% 8% 13% 16% 19% 22% 23% 25% 26% 27% 28% 29% 31% 31% 32%
Interior Lighting Electric Screw-in 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Interior Lighting Electric High-Bay Fixtures 0% 25% 33% 42% 51% 54% 56% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58%
Interior Lighting Electric Linear Fluorescent 0% 25% 33% 42% 51% 54% 56% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58% 58%
Exterior Lighting Electric Screw-in 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Exterior Lighting Electric HID 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Exterior Lighting Electric Linear Fluorescent 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Refrigeration Electric Walk-in Refrigerator 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Refrigeration Electric Reach-in Refrigerator 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Refrigeration Electric Glass Door Display 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Refrigeration Electric Open Display Case 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Refrigeration Electric Icemaker 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Refrigeration Electric Vending Machine 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Food Preparation Electric Oven 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Food Preparation Electric Fryer 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Food Preparation Electric Dishwasher 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Food Preparation Electric Hot Food Container 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Office Equipment Electric Desktop Computer 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Office Equipment Electric Laptop 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Office Equipment Electric Server 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Office Equipment Electric Monitor 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Office Equipment Electric Printer/Copier/Fax 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Office Equipment Electric POS Terminal 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Miscellaneous Electric Non-HVAC Motors 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Market Adoption Factors
F-6 www.enernoc.com
End Use Fuel Technology 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Miscellaneous Electric Pool Pump 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Miscellaneous Electric Pool Heater 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%
Miscellaneous Electric Miscellaneous 0% 12% 22% 32% 36% 41% 44% 47% 48% 50% 51% 52% 54% 55% 55%

Market Adoption Factors
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-7
Table F-4 Commercial Non-Equipment Measures — Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Insulation - Ceiling 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Insulation - Ducting 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Insulation - Radiant Barrier 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Doors - High Efficiency 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Windows - High Efficiency 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Windows - Install Reflective Film 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Roof - High Reflectivity 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water Temperature Reset 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-Flow System 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water Temperature Reset 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Thermal Energy Storage 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-Flow System 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chiller Heat Recovery 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
RTU - Evaporative Precooler 0% 39% 46% 52% 53% 54% 54% 55% 56% 56% 57% 57% 57% 57% 57%
RTU - Maintenance 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Space Heating - Heat Recovery Ventilator 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Ventilation - ECM on VAV Boxes 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Ventilation - Variable Speed Control 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Water Heater - Drainwater Heat Recovery 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Water Heater - Faucet Aerators/Low Flow Nozzles 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Market Adoption Factors
F-8 www.enernoc.com
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Water Heater - High Efficiency Circulation Pump 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Water Heater - Desuperheater 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Water Heater - Solar System 0% 11% 14% 16% 17% 17% 17% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18% 18%
Water Heater - Install Timer 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Water Heater - Pipe Insulation 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Water Heater - Tank Blanket/Insulation 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Interior Lighting - Timeclocks and Timers 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Interior Lighting - Task Lighting 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install Reflectors 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Refrigerator - Anti-Sweat Heater 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - Decommissioning 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Refrigerator - Demand Defrost 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - Door Gasket Replacement 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - Evaporator Fan Controls 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - Floating Head Pressure 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - Strip Curtain 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - High Efficiency Compressor 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator - Variable Speed Compressor 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Refrigerator – Food Temperature Simulant 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Vending Machine - Controller 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Office Equipment - ENERGY STAR Power Supplies 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Office Equipment - Plug Load Occupancy Sensors 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Pool Heater - Solar 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Pool Pump - Timer 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Non-HVAC Motors - Variable Speed Control 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%
Energy Management System 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
HVAC - Occupancy Sensors 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Commissioning - HVAC 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Commissioning - Lighting 0% 46% 59% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72% 72%
Market Adoption Factors
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-9
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 0% 14% 16% 17% 18% 19% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 23% 23% 24% 24%
Advanced New Construction Designs 0% 39% 46% 52% 53% 54% 54% 55% 56% 56% 57% 57% 57% 57% 57%
Custom Measures 0% 26% 31% 35% 36% 36% 37% 38% 38% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39% 39%
Cooking - Exhaust Hoods with Sensor Control 0% 19% 21% 22% 24% 26% 27% 28% 30% 31% 31% 32% 33% 33% 34%

Market Adoption Factors
F-10 www.enernoc.com
Table F-5 Industrial Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
End Use Fuel Technology 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Cooling Electric Air-Cooled Chiller 0% 49% 61% 63% 65% 66% 68% 69% 70% 71% 71% 72% 73% 74% 75%
Cooling Electric Water-Cooled Chiller 0% 49% 61% 63% 65% 66% 68% 69% 70% 71% 71% 72% 73% 74% 75%
Cooling Electric Roof top AC 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Cooling Electric Air-Source Heat Pump 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Cooling Electric Geothermal Heat Pump 0% 14% 19% 24% 30% 36% 42% 43% 44% 45% 46% 46% 47% 47% 48%
Cooling Electric Evaporative AC 0% 14% 19% 24% 30% 36% 42% 43% 44% 45% 46% 46% 47% 47% 48%
Cooling Electric Other Cooling 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Heating Electric Air-Source Heat Pump 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Heating Electric Geothermal Heat Pump 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Heating Electric Electric Room Heat 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Heating Electric Electric Furnace 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Ventilation Electric Ventilation 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Interior Lighting Electric Screw-in 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Interior Lighting Electric High-Bay Fixtures 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Interior Lighting Electric Linear Fluorescent 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Exterior Lighting Electric Screw-in 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Exterior Lighting Electric HID 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Exterior Lighting Electric Linear Fluorescent 0% 28% 39% 51% 64% 71% 75% 76% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77% 77%
Motors Electric Pumps 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Motors Electric Fans & Blowers 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Motors Electric Compressed Air 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Motors Electric Matl Handling 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Motors Electric Matl Processing 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Motors Electric Other Motors 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Process Electric Process Heating 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Process Electric Process Cooling and Refrig 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Process Electric Electro-Chemical Processes 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Process Electric Other Process 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%
Miscellaneous Electric Miscellaneous 0% 18% 25% 32% 40% 48% 56% 58% 59% 60% 61% 62% 62% 63% 64%

Market Adoption Factors
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-11
Table F-6 Industrial Non-Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Insulation - Ceiling 0% 55% 61% 67% 68% 67% 67% 66% 66% 65% 65% 64% 63% 63% 62%
Insulation - Ducting 0% 55% 61% 67% 68% 67% 67% 66% 66% 65% 65% 64% 63% 63% 62%
Insulation - Wall Cavity 0% 55% 61% 67% 68% 67% 67% 66% 66% 65% 65% 64% 63% 63% 62%
HVAC - Duct Repair and Sealing 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical Layout 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-Flow System 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water Temperature Reset 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Air-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Economizer 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Efficient Mechanical Layout 0% 42% 51% 55% 60% 63% 63% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Maintenance 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Reset 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Chilled Water Variable-Flow System 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - Condenser Water Temperature Reset 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - High Efficiency Cooling Tower Fans 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Water-Cooled Chiller - VSD on Fans 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
RTU - Maintenance 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Heat Pump - Maintenance 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Roofs - High Reflectivity 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Energy Management System 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Thermostat - Clock/Programmable 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Interior Lighting - Occupancy Sensors 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Interior Lighting - Skylights 0% 8% 24% 36% 45% 47% 49% 50% 51% 51% 52% 51% 51% 51% 50%
Interior Lighting - Time Clocks and Timers 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Interior Lighting - LED Exit Lighting 0% 61% 69% 72% 72% 72% 71% 71% 70% 69% 69% 68% 67% 67% 66%
Interior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Interior Screw-in - Task Lighting 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Interior Fluorescent - Bi-Level Fixture 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Interior Fluorescent - Delamp and Install Reflectors 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Exterior Lighting - Bi-Level Fixture 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Exterior Lighting - Daylighting Controls 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Exterior Lighting - Photovoltaic Installation 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Market Adoption Factors
F-12 www.enernoc.com
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Process - Conductivity Controls 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Process - Controls on Fume Hoods 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Process - Timers and Controls 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Refrigeration - Floating Head Pressure 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Refrigeration - System Controls 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Refrigeration - System Maintenance 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Refrigeration - System Optimization 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Compressed Air - Air Usage Reduction 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Compressed Air - Compressor Replacement 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Compressed Air - System Controls 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Compressed Air - System Maintenance 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Compressed Air - System Optimization and Improvements 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Pumping System - Controls 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Pumping System - Maintenance 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Pumping System - Optimization 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Pumps - Variable Speed Control 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Pump Equipment Upgrade 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Fan Equipment Upgrade 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Fan System - Controls 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Fan System - Maintenance 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Fan System - Optimization 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Fans - Variable Speed Control 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Motors - Magnetic Adjustable Speed Drives 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Motors - Efficient Rewind 0% 18% 37% 50% 55% 58% 61% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
Motors - Synchronous Belts 0% 35% 43% 52% 57% 59% 59% 58% 58% 58% 57% 56% 56% 55% 55%
Motors - Variable Frequency Drive 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Retrocommissioning - HVAC 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Retrocommissioning - Lighting 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Commissioning - HVAC 0% 61% 69% 72% 72% 72% 71% 71% 70% 69% 69% 68% 67% 67% 66%
Commissioning - Lighting 0% 61% 69% 72% 72% 72% 71% 71% 70% 69% 69% 68% 67% 67% 66%
Ventilation - CO2 Controlled 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Custom Measures 0% 42% 51% 55% 60% 63% 63% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%
RTU – Evaporative Precooler 0% 55% 61% 67% 68% 67% 67% 66% 66% 65% 65% 64% 63% 63% 62%
Transformer - High Efficiency 0% 20% 37% 45% 49% 52% 55% 56% 55% 55% 54% 54% 53% 53% 52%
Strategic Energy Management 0% 11% 15% 18% 20% 20% 21% 21% 22% 22% 22% 23% 23% 23% 23%
Engine Block Heaters 0% 42% 51% 55% 60% 63% 63% 62% 62% 61% 61% 60% 59% 59% 58%

Market Adoption Factors
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting F-13
Table F-7 Irrigation Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
End Use Fuel Technology 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Motors Electric 5 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 10HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 15 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 20 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 25 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 30 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 40 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 50 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 60 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 75 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 100 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 125 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 150 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 200 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 250 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 300 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 350 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 400 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 450 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 500 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric 600 HP 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%
Motors Electric > 600 0% 6% 12% 19% 26% 34% 42% 50% 59% 65% 66% 68% 70% 71% 73%

Market Adoption Factors
F-14 www.enernoc.com
Table F-8 Irrigation Non-Equipment Measures—Achievable Potential Market Adoption Factors
Measure 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Nozzle Replacement – Flow-Control Type 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Nozzle Replacement – Same Flow Rate or Less 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Rebuilt or New Brass Impact Sprinklers 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Rebuilt or New Wheel Line Levelers 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Rotating- or Low-Pressure Pivot Sprinklers 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Low Pressure Regulators 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Gasket Replacement 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Hub Replacement 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
New Goose Necks 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Pipe Repair 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Center Pivot Base Gasket 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Multiple Configuration Nozzle 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 25HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 30HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 40HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 50HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 60HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 75HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 100HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 125HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 150HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 200HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 250HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 300HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 350HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 400HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 450HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 500HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: Motor size 600HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Green Motors Program Rewind: > 600HP 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Motors – Variable Frequency Drive 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Scientific Irrigation Practices 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Multiple Pumps 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Proper Flow Design 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%
Proper Pressure or Head Design 0% 6% 10% 17% 22% 26% 29% 31% 33% 35% 38% 40% 42% 45% 48%

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting G-1
APPENDIX G
ANNUAL SAVINGS
This section presents the estimates of annual savings, both cumulative and incremental. Selected years are shown in Chapter 5 of the report. Table G-1
shows the overall annual savings across all sectors, while the remaining tables show the annual savings for each sector.

Table G-1 Annual Electric Energy Savings, All Sectors (1,000 MWh)
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Baseline Forecast (1,000 MWh) 12,869 12,987 13,136 13,358 13,521 13,726 13,945 14,144 14,343 14,539 14,715
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 128 214 308 411 505 595 699 795 875 955
Economic 732 1,002 1,266 1,476 1,599 1,734 1,895 2,053 2,290 2,515
Technical 1,178 1,587 1,992 2,330 2,586 2,850 3,131 3,417 3,749 4,073
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 1.0% 1.6% 2.3% 3.0% 3.7% 4.3% 4.9% 5.5% 6.0% 6.5%
Economic 5.6% 7.6% 9.5% 10.9% 11.7% 12.4% 13.4% 14.3% 15.8% 17.1%
Technical 9.1% 12.1% 14.9% 17.2% 18.8% 20.4% 22.1% 23.8% 25.8% 27.7%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 128 86 94 103 94 90 104 96 80 80
Economic 732 270 264 210 123 135 160 158 237 225
Technical 1,178 409 405 338 256 264 281 286 332 323
1. Includes street lighting sales of 23,879 MWh, 0.7% of commercial sales.
2. Excludes special-contract customers.

Annual Savings
G-2 www.enernoc.com
Table G-1 Annual Electric Energy Savings, All Sectors (1,000 MWh) (continued)
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032
Baseline Forecast 14,904 15,103 15,272 15,426 15,623 15,821 15,989 16,182 16,388 16,627 16,868
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 1,049 1,129 1,237 1,340 1,453 1,571 1,695 1,799 1,890 1,973 2,053
Economic 2,696 2,835 2,989 3,128 3,257 3,374 3,482 3,582 3,679 3,761 3,839
Technical 4,372 4,628 4,890 5,116 5,339 5,545 5,726 5,901 6,059 6,188 6,307
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 7.0% 7.5% 8.1% 8.7% 9.3% 9.9% 10.6% 11.1% 11.5% 11.9% 12.2%
Economic 18.1% 18.8% 19.6% 20.3% 20.8% 21.3% 21.8% 22.1% 22.4% 22.6% 22.8%
Technical 29.3% 30.6% 32.0% 33.2% 34.2% 35.0% 35.8% 36.5% 37.0% 37.2% 37.4%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 94 80 108 103 113 118 124 105 91 83 80
Economic 181 139 154 138 129 117 108 100 97 82 78
Technical 300 255 262 226 223 206 181 175 158 129 120

1. Includes street lighting sales of 23,879 MWh, 0.7% of commercial sales.
2. Excludes special-contract customers.

Annual Savings
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting G-3
Table G-2 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Residential (1,000 MWh)
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Baseline Forecast (1,000 MWh) 5,079 5,075 5,076 5,132 5,159 5,244 5,348 5,439 5,521 5,593 5,653
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 34 61 92 132 161 189 226 264 275 287
Economic 235 373 509 604 644 683 740 798 848 911
Technical 456 702 950 1,150 1,312 1,466 1,632 1,802 1,940 2,084
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 0.7% 1.2% 1.8% 2.6% 3.1% 3.5% 4.2% 4.8% 4.9% 5.1%
Economic 4.6% 7.4% 9.9% 11.7% 12.3% 12.8% 13.6% 14.5% 15.2% 16.1%
Technical 9.0% 13.8% 18.5% 22.3% 25.0% 27.4% 30.0% 32.6% 34.7% 36.9%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 34 27 31 40 28 29 37 38 10 12
Economic 235 138 136 95 41 39 57 58 50 63
Technical 456 246 248 200 161 154 167 169 138 144

Annual Savings
G-4 www.enernoc.com
Table G-2 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Residential (1,000 MWh) (continued)
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032
Baseline Forecast 5,718 5,794 5,853 5,904 5,980 6,058 6,116 6,188 6,266 6,359 6,462
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 297 308 337 373 420 473 529 573 619 662 701
Economic 939 951 1,006 1,063 1,107 1,149 1,184 1,219 1,257 1,286 1,313
Technical 2,200 2,304 2,427 2,543 2,664 2,781 2,880 2,977 3,074 3,146 3,212
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 5.2% 5.3% 5.8% 6.3% 7.0% 7.8% 8.7% 9.3% 9.9% 10.4% 10.8%
Economic 16.4% 16.4% 17.2% 18.0% 18.5% 19.0% 19.4% 19.7% 20.1% 20.2% 20.3%
Technical 38.5% 39.8% 41.5% 43.1% 44.6% 45.9% 47.1% 48.1% 49.0% 49.5% 49.7%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 10 10 29 36 47 54 56 44 46 42 40
Economic 28 12 55 57 44 42 35 34 39 29 27
Technical 116 104 123 116 122 117 99 96 97 73 66

Annual Savings
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting G-5
Table G-3 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Commercial (1,000 MWh)
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Baseline Forecast (1,000 MWh) 3,436 3,472 3,529 3,592 3,649 3,709 3,761 3,820 3,883 3,950 4,012
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 51 77 106 136 165 194 225 252 286 319 357
Economic 303 390 469 541 568 613 658 703 829 932 1,015
Technical 485 596 696 782 821 872 926 982 1,111 1,227 1,340
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 1.5% 2.2% 2.9% 3.7% 4.5% 5.2% 5.9% 6.5% 7.2% 8.0% 1.5%
Economic 8.7% 11.1% 13.1% 14.8% 15.3% 16.3% 17.2% 18.1% 21.0% 23.2% 8.7%
Technical 14.0% 16.9% 19.4% 21.4% 22.1% 23.2% 24.3% 25.3% 28.1% 30.6% 14.0%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 51 26 28 30 29 29 31 27 35 33 51
Economic 303 88 79 72 27 45 45 45 127 103 303
Technical 485 112 100 86 39 52 54 55 130 116 485
1. Baseline includes street lighting sales of 23,879 MWh, 0.7% of commercial sales.

Annual Savings
G-6 www.enernoc.com
Table G-3 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Commercial (1,000 MWh) (continued)
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032
BaselineForecast 4,077 4,135 4,177 4,217 4,262 4,306 4,348 4,395 4,441 4,499 4,555
CumulativeSavings(1,000MWh)
Achievable 357 387 425 455 484 512 544 570 593 613 634
Economic 1,015 1,081 1,122 1,153 1,187 1,216 1,243 1,269 1,292 1,313 1,331
Technical 1,340 1,429 1,509 1,568 1,619 1,663 1,705 1,745 1,771 1,796 1,818
CumulativeSavings(%ofBaseline)
Achievable 8.8% 9.4% 10.2% 10.8% 11.4% 11.9% 12.5% 13.0% 13.4% 13.6% 13.9%
Economic 24.9% 26.2% 26.9% 27.3% 27.9% 28.2% 28.6% 28.9% 29.1% 29.2% 29.2%
Technical 32.9% 34.6% 36.1% 37.2% 38.0% 38.6% 39.2% 39.7% 39.9% 39.9% 39.9%
IncrementalSavings(1,000MWh)
Achievable 38 30 38 30 29 28 31 27 23 21 18
Economic 82 66 40 31 35 29 27 26 22 21 18
Technical 113 89 80 59 51 44 42 40 26 25 22
1. Baseline includes street lighting sales of 23,879 MWh, 0.7% of commercial sales.

Annual Savings
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting G-7
Table G-4 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Industrial (1,000 MWh)
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Baseline Forecast (1,000 MWh) 2,585 2,651 2,741 2,830 2,895 2,959 3,010 3,046 3,086 3,127 3,168
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 40 70 98 123 151 175 202 223 247 270
Economic 145 178 213 241 281 314 352 388 427 467
Technical 185 225 268 303 342 381 420 460 503 545
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 1.5% 2.5% 3.5% 4.2% 5.1% 5.8% 6.6% 7.2% 7.9% 8.5%
Economic 5.5% 6.5% 7.5% 8.3% 9.5% 10.4% 11.6% 12.6% 13.7% 14.7%
Technical 7.0% 8.2% 9.5% 10.5% 11.5% 12.6% 13.8% 14.9% 16.1% 17.2%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 40 30 28 25 28 23 27 21 24 23
Economic 145 33 35 28 40 33 39 36 40 39
Technical 185 40 42 36 38 39 40 40 43 42

Annual Savings
G-8 www.enernoc.com
Table G-4 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Industrial (1,000 MWh) (continued)
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032
Baseline Forecast 3,210 3,262 3,316 3,366 3,429 3,493 3,547 3,608 3,675 3,745 3,812
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 302 328 355 376 397 416 434 450 464 476 488
Economic 517 560 603 639 676 711 746 778 806 830 858
Technical 596 639 682 717 754 788 819 849 877 901 928
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 9.4% 10.1% 10.7% 11.2% 11.6% 11.9% 12.2% 12.5% 12.6% 12.7% 12.8%
Economic 16.1% 17.2% 18.2% 19.0% 19.7% 20.4% 21.0% 21.5% 21.9% 22.2% 22.5%
Technical 18.6% 19.6% 20.6% 21.3% 22.0% 22.6% 23.1% 23.5% 23.9% 24.1% 24.3%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 32 26 26 21 21 19 18 16 14 12 13
Economic 50 43 43 36 38 35 35 31 28 25 28
Technical 51 43 42 35 37 34 30 30 28 25 26

Annual Savings
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting G-9
Table G-5 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Irrigation (1,000 MWh)
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Baseline Forecast (1,000 MWh) 1,769 1,789 1,790 1,805 1,819 1,814 1,825 1,840 1,854 1,869 1,881
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 3 6 13 20 28 36 46 56 67 79
Economic 50 61 75 90 106 124 145 165 185 205
Technical 52 63 78 94 112 131 152 174 195 216
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 0.2% 0.3% 0.7% 1.1% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 3.6% 4.2%
Economic 2.8% 3.4% 4.1% 4.9% 5.8% 6.8% 7.9% 8.9% 9.9% 10.9%
Technical 2.9% 3.5% 4.3% 5.2% 6.2% 7.2% 8.3% 9.4% 10.4% 11.5%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 3 3 7 7 8 9 10 10 11 12
Economic 50 11 14 15 16 19 20 20 20 20
Technical 52 12 15 16 17 19 21 21 22 21

Annual Savings
G-10 www.enernoc.com
Table G-5 Annual Electric Energy Savings, Irrigation (1,000 MWh) (continued)
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032
Baseline Forecast 1,900 1,912 1,925 1,939 1,952 1,964 1,978 1,991 2,005 2,023 2,038
Cumulative Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 92 106 121 136 153 170 188 207 214 222 230
Economic 225 242 259 273 287 298 308 317 324 332 337
Technical 237 255 272 288 301 312 322 330 337 344 349
Cumulative Savings (% of Baseline)
Achievable 4.9% 5.5% 6.3% 7.0% 7.8% 8.6% 9.5% 10.4% 10.7% 11.0% 11.3%
Economic 11.8% 12.7% 13.4% 14.1% 14.7% 15.2% 15.6% 15.9% 16.2% 16.4% 16.6%
Technical 12.5% 13.4% 14.1% 14.8% 15.4% 15.9% 16.3% 16.6% 16.8% 17.0% 17.1%
Incremental Savings (1,000 MWh)
Achievable 13 14 15 16 16 17 18 19 8 8 8
Economic 20 18 16 15 13 11 10 9 8 7 6
Technical 21 19 17 15 13 11 10 8 7 7 5

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting G-1

EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting
500 Ygnacio Valley Road, Suite 450
Walnut Creek, CA 94596
P: 925.482.2000 F: 925.284.3147
About EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting
EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting is part of EnerNOC Utility Solutions group, which
provides a comprehensive suite of demand-side management (DSM) services to
utilities and grid operators worldwide. Hundreds of utilities have leveraged our
technology, our people, and our proven processes to make their energy efficiency
(EE) and demand response (DR) initiatives a success. Utilities trust EnerNOC to work
with them at every stage of the DSM program lifecycle – assessing market potential,
designing effective programs, implementing those programs, and measuring program
results.
EnerNOC Utility Solutions delivers value to our utility clients through two separate
practice areas – Program Implementation and EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting.
• Our Program Implementation team leverages EnerNOC’s deep “behind-the-meter
expertise” and world-class technology platform to help utilities create and
manage DR and EE programs that deliver reliable and cost-effective energy
savings. We focus exclusively on the commercial and industrial (C&I) customer
segments, with a track record of successful partnerships that spans more than a
decade. Through a focus on high quality, measurable savings, EnerNOC has
successfully delivered hundreds of thousands of MWh of energy efficiency for
our utility clients, and we have thousands of MW of demand response capacity
under management.
• The EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting team provides expertise and analysis
to support a broad range of utility DSM activities, including: potential
assessments; end-use forecasts; integrated resource planning; EE, DR, and
smart grid pilot and program design and administration; load research;
technology assessments and demonstrations; evaluation, measurement and
verification; and regulatory support.
The EnerNOC Utility Solutions Consulting team has decades of combined experience
in the utility DSM industry. The staff is comprised of professional electrical,
mechanical, chemical, civil, industrial, and environmental engineers as well as
economists, business planners, project managers, market researchers, load research
professionals, and statisticians. Utilities view our experts as trusted advisors, and we
work together collaboratively to make any DSM initiative a success.