Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20261117Petition for Rulemaking - Memo to Open Case.pdf RECEIVED November 17, 2026 DECISION MEMORANDUM IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION TO: COMMISSIONER LODGE RUL-U-26-03 COMMISSIONER HAMMOND COMMISSIONER HARDIE COMMISSION SECRETARY COMMISSION STAFF LEGAL FROM: CHRIS BURDIN DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL DATE: NOVEMBER 17, 2026 SUBJECT: IN THE MATTER OF GREEN RECURSIVE UTILITY SERVICE LLC'S PETITION FOR RULEMAKING On October 29, 2026, Green Recursive Utility Service LLC ("Green Recursive"), a Texas limited liability company,filed a Petition for Rulemaking with the Idaho Public Utilities Commission ("Commission")pursuant to Idaho Code § 67-5230. Green Recursive requests that: the Commission adopt a rule, in a new section of its rules (numbering to be assigned by the Commission), designating GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001, incorporated by reference, as the measurement and reporting method for large-load electric service under Idaho Code § 61-335 that is, the method by which the quantities the § 61-335 framework requires to be filed,tested, and reviewed are measured and stated. . . . Petition at 2. RECOMMENDATION Counsel for the Commission recommends that the Commission process the Petition under a Rulemaking case designation, consider the matter fully submitted, and deliberate upon the Petition as convenient to issue an order either granting or denying the Petition within the 28 day schedule provided under Idaho Code § 67-5230. COMMISSION DECISION Does the Commission wish to process the Petition under a Rulemaking case designation, consider the matter fully submitted, and deliberate upon the Petition as convenient to issue an order either granting or denying the Petition within the 28 day schedule provided under Idaho Code § 67- 5230? Chris Burdin Deputy Attorney General DECISION MEMORANDUM 1 Nick Cordova,Principal Green Recursive Utility Service LLC 205 E 3rd St,Weatherford,TX 76086 management@greenrecursiveutilityservice.org • 817-404-6379 Representative for Petitioner Green Recursive Utility Service LLC BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION In the Matter of the Petition of GREEN RECURSIVE UTILITY SERVICE LLC for Rulemaking to Adopt a Measurement and Reporting Method for Large-Load Electric Service (Idaho Code §§ 67-5230, 61-335) Case No. (to be assigned by the Commission Secretary) PETITION FOR RULEMAKING OF PETITIONER GREEN RECURSIVE UTILITY SERVICE LLC Under § 67-5230 of the Idaho Code TO: The Idaho Public Utilities Commission, submitted to the Commission Secretary, Idaho Public Utilities Commission,P.O. Box 83720,Boise,ID 83720-0074(secretary@puc.idaho.gov) I. THE PETITIONER Petitioner: Green Recursive Utility Service LLC ("GRUS" or "Petitioner"), a Texas limited liability company. Address: 205 E 3rd St,Weatherford, TX 76086 Email: management@greenrecursiveutilityservice.org Telephone: 817-404-63 79 Representative for service (IDAPA 31.01.01, Rule 41): Nick Cordova, Principal, at the address, email, and telephone above. Service of all notices and orders on the named representative is requested. This petition is filed for Petitioner by its Principal as an officer of the company, as IDAPA 31.01.01, Rule 43.01 provides for filings in administrative proceedings,which expressly include rulemaking. GRUS is the publisher of GRUS-STD-60084, a measurement standard for data center and large-load water and energy consumption, published in the public domain under a CCO dedication, and performs facility consumption audits in the standard's audit form (GRUS-AUD). GRUS petitions in its own name as a person under § 67-5230(1) of the Idaho Code. Its interest is that of the standard's publisher and of a practitioner whose audits apply the method proposed: Idaho has now enacted a large-load framework in which contract approval, ratepayer protection, and cost recovery all turn on measured quantities, and every one of those instruments is only as sound as the measurement underneath it the layer this petition supplies. Petition for Rulemaking of Petitioner GRUS LLC Page 1 Identifiers:ISNI 0000 000E 3033 4084 •Ringgold ID 851161 •IANA PEN 65876•FERC CID C013240 •SAM UEI JGT4J9QKGCQ3 II.THE SUBSTANCE AND PURPOSE OF THE REQUESTED RULEMAKING—§ 67-5230(1); IDAPA 31.01.01,Rule 53 Petitioner requests that the Commission adopt a rule, in a new section of its rules (numbering to be assigned by the Commission), designating GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001, incorporated by reference, as the measurement and reporting method for large-load electric service under Idaho Code § 61-335 that is,the method by which the quantities the § 61-335 framework requires to be filed,tested, and reviewed are measured and stated, including: 1. The threshold quantities —contracted demand and the increase in cumulative power requirement (§ 61-335(1)(b), (1)(c)), measured and stated in megawatts at the service entrance, so that whether a load is a"new large load"is determined from metered and contracted figures stated in one form; 2. The no-harm quantities — the energy quantities (demand, energy consumption, and load profile over time) from which the impact of a new large load on the rates of existing customers is assessed under the no harm test(§ 61-335(l)(d), (3)); 3. The full-cost-of-service quantities — the measured load and consumption figures from which a new large load's full cost of service, including its share of generation, transmission, substation, and distribution investment, is computed for contract approval (§ 61-335(4)(b)) and re-examined in each general rate case(§ 61-335(7)); and 4. The water quantities — the water withdrawal, consumption, and evaporation attributable to the large load's operations, stated by source, which the reporting under the large-load framework carries with the energy figures and on which the facility's consumption classification under the Standard rests. Proposed regulatory text is set out in Annex A. Purpose: one measurement method, adopted once, underneath every instrument the § 61-335 framework creates — contract filings, no-harm tests, cost-of-service computations, and rate-case reviews—so that the figures those instruments produce are stated in a common, verifiable form instead of in each filing utility's own convention. There is no respondent to this petition (Rule 53.02.d): it is addressed to the Commission, and it charges no act or omission by any utility or person. III.LEGAL AUTHORITY 1. § 67-5230(1), Idaho Code—any person may petition an agency requesting the adoption of a rule; the agency shall deny the petition in writing stating its reasons or initiate rulemaking proceedings in accordance with the Idaho Administrative Procedure Act; § 67-5230(4) prescribes action within twenty-eight(28) days after submission, and § 67-5230(6)makes a denial a final agency action. 2. § 61-335,Idaho Code(added 2026, ch. 335)—the new-large-load framework this rule implements: commission-approved service contracts (§ 61-335(2)—(3)), the no harm test (§ 61-335(1)(d), (3)), full cost of service (§ 61-335(4)(b)),rate-case review of cost recovery(§ 61-335(7)), and the Commission's duty to "issue orders setting forth guidance or other requirements necessary to implement the provisions of this section" (§ 61-335(8)(a)),with jurisdiction over all disputes arising under the section (§ 61-335(8)(b)). Petition for Rulemaking of Petitioner GRUS LLC Page 2 3. Title 61, Chapters 1 through 7,Idaho Code—the Public Utilities Law,the general legal authority under which the Commission's Rules of Procedure are promulgated (IDAPA 31.01.01, Legal Authority) and under which the Commission regulates the service of public utilities, including the measurement of the service they furnish. 4. §§ 67-5220 and 67-5221, Idaho Code—the rulemaking procedure (notice of intent and negotiated rulemaking;public notice of proposed rulemaking)by which an initiated rulemaking proceeds. IV.FACTS AND ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT—IDAPA 31.01.01,Rule 53.02.a A. Idaho has ordered the determinations; it has not adopted a method for making the measurements they rest on. Section 61-335, effective July 1, 2026, conditions electric service to every new large load — 50 megawatts or more of increased cumulative power requirement within 60 months, under a contract entered into on or after that date—on a sequence of measured determinations. A utility may not serve except under a Commission-approved contract, filed before service with a no harm test (§ 61-335(2)—(3)). The Commission must decide within 270 days, on demonstrations about reliability and about the load's full cost of service, stated down to its share of generation, transmission, substation, and distribution investment (§ 61-335(4)). Approval is conditioned on financial security measured against the contracted power requirement (§ 61-335(6)). And in every later general rate case, the Commission must re-review the contract's rates and cost recovery "to ensure the new large load is assigned its full cost of service"(§ 61-335(7)). Each of those determinations is arithmetic performed on measured quantities—contracted and metered demand, energy consumed and its profile, and the water the load's operations consume — and no statute or rule states how any of those quantities is to be measured or reported. The first § 61-335 contracts are, by the statute's own terms, being entered into now;their filings will fix,by practice,the conventions every later filing follows. B. The Commission is deciding large-load cost methodology in IPC-E-26-07 on the same missing foundation. In Case No. IPC-E-26-07, Idaho Power has asked the Commission to evaluate class cost-of-service methodology and to determine cost-of-service considerations for new large-load customers. The Commission's schedule (Order No. 37170) takes public comment through December 14, 2026, party testimony January 13, 2027, and a technical hearing January 19-21, 2027, with intervenors including industrial customers, irrigation pumpers, the City of Boise, and Micron Technology. Whatever methodology that case adopts will allocate costs computed from measured load quantities.A designated measurement method, adopted by rule, gives that methodology—and the § 61-335 filings that will be judged under it inputs stated in one verifiable form, instead of a different convention embedded in each utility's model. C. The proposed method exists,is published,is free, and has been demonstrated under scrutiny. GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U does three things. First, it classifies each facility by measured characteristics — a consumption classification (water-use categories W-1 through W-3 crossed with consumption classes C-1 through C-5) computed from the facility's filed load and site conditions, not from the facility's own description of itself. Second, it accounts granularly for the quantities the framework reports—energy by demand, consumption, and profile; water as withdrawal, consumption, Petition for Rulemaking of Petitioner GRUS LLC Page 3 and evaporation, by source and by use — at the granularity a no-harm test and a full-cost-of-service computation require if either is to be checked rather than credited. Third, it carries its own verification protocol in audit form (GRUS-AUD), under which a reported figure is checked against metered records, so a filing is a verifiable document rather than an attestation. The method is not theoretical. It has been applied in full form to a real facility: the granular consumption audit of the Circle T facility in Texas (GRUS-AUD-CTDC-Rl, September 2026), performed under the standard, submitted to the City of Keller and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, and sworn into the record of that proceeding,with third parties standing on it. Its reproducibility has therefore already been tested in the setting that matters—a contested proceeding in which the numbers had to survive scrutiny. D. Timing is the substance. Section 61-335 has been in effect since July 1, 2026; every service contract it governs is necessarily a contract of the framework's first years, and the 270-day approval clocks on the first filings are already running or about to run. The Commission's § 61-335(8)(a)implementation guidance has yet to issue. A measurement rule adopted now can be built into the first contract filings,the first no-harm tests,and the methodology record in IPC-E-26-07;the same rule offered after those filings have set their conventions arrives as a request to displace settled practice. The petition is therefore made now, while every instrument it serves is still open. E.Record elsewhere(one line). GRUS-STD-60084 is of record in Texas PUC Project No. 58317 (Item 96), Ohio PUCO Case No. 24-0508-EL-ATA, Arizona Corporation Commission Docket No. E-01773A-26-0123, and New Jersey BPU Docket No. E026080463; a pleading presenting the Uniform Edition was filed October 30, 2026 in Kansas Corporation Commission Docket No. 25-EKME-315-TAR. V.EFFECT ON EXISTING RULES AND ORDERS The requested rule supplements, and does not amend in substance or repeal, any existing rule, tariff, or order. Section 61-335's duties stand exactly as enacted; the requested rule prescribes the measurement method by which the quantities those duties turn on are produced and reported. It does not disturb the procedural schedule or any party's rights in Case No. IPC-E-26-07, which will be decided on its own record; it supplies the measurement layer that case's methodology, and the § 61-335 filings to come, will compute from. No provision of the proposed text conflicts with the Commission's Rules of Procedure (IDAPA 31.01.01)or with any utility's filed tariff; tariffs and contracts would continue to be filed as they are now,with their quantities measured and stated under the designated method. VI.PERSONS AND CLASSES LIKELY TO BE AFFECTED • Public utilities serving or contracting with new large loads the quantities in their § 61-335 contract filings, no-harm tests, and rate-case cost studies gain a defined measurement method: metered demand and energy, water by source, a stated derivation, and a facility classification. The rule imposes no fee and no new category of filing. • New large loads, including data centers the threshold determination, the contract quantities, and the cost responsibility attributed to them are stated in one auditable method rather than in each utility's Petition for Rulemaking of Petitioner GRUS LLC Page 4 convention. • Existing utility customers—the ratepayer-protection purpose of§ 61-335 is served in the form the statute intends: a no-harm determination and a full-cost-of-service assignment that rest on figures produced by a stated method, defensible on the record that produced them. • The Commission — § 61-335(8)(a) implementation guidance, contract approvals, and dispute resolution under § 61-335(8)(b) conducted on comparable, verifiable quantities across utilities and across cases. • Petitioner — its published standard would become the designated method; Petitioner states this interest openly, and notes the standard is dedicated to the public domain under CCO, so designation creates no royalty, license fee, or proprietary dependency for any party. ANNEX A—PROPOSED REGULATORY TEXT New section, IDAPA Title 31 (numbering to be assigned by the Commission): Measurement and reporting method for large-load electric service. 1. Definitions.New large load a new large load as defined in Idaho Code § 61-335(1)(c). Standard — GRUS-STD-60084 v2.0-U (Uniform Edition), published by Green Recursive Utility Service LLC, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001, dedicated to the public domain under CCO 1.0, incorporated by reference. 2. Measurement method. The quantities filed, tested, or reviewed under Idaho Code § 61-335 shall be measured and stated in accordance with the Standard, including: (a) contracted demand and the increase in cumulative power requirement at the service entrance, in megawatts, as defined in § 61-335(1)(b)—(c); (b)the metered energy quantities—demand, energy consumption, and load profile—from which the no harm test under § 61-335(3) and the full cost of service under § 61-335(4)(b) and (7) are computed; (c) the water quantities attributable to the new large load's operations—withdrawal, consumption, and evaporation, stated by source — reported with the energy quantities; (d) a statement accompanying each filing of the metered quantities and the measurement method from which each reported figure is derived; and(e)the consumption classification of the facility under the Standard. 3. Verification. A filing stating quantities measured under this section is subject to verification in the audit form of the Standard(GRUS-AUD),under which reported quantities are checked against metered records. 4.Availability. The Standard is available to the Commission,to utilities, and to the public at no cost at DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23246001. Incorporation by reference creates no license fee or royalty obligation. VII.REQUESTED ACTION(PRAYER)—IDAPA 31.01.01,Rule 53.02.c Petitioner respectfully prays that the Commission grant this petition by initiating rulemaking proceedings in accordance with the Idaho Administrative Procedure Act to adopt the rule proposed in Annex A or, if the Commission declines, deny the petition in writing, stating its reasons — in either case within twenty-eight (28) days after submission of this petition, as § 67-5230(4) of the Idaho Code requires; and, in the alternative, if the Commission prefers to carry the designation into the Petition for Rulemaking of Petitioner GRUS LLC Page 5 guidance and requirements it issues under§ 61-335(8)(a),that it state that course in its written action on this petition. Petitioner further requests that the Commission Secretary assign a docket number to this petition, confirm the date of its receipt(the date from which the 28-day period runs), and give notice of any meeting, negotiated rulemaking, or hearing at which it is considered, directed to the representative named in Part I. VIII. SIGNATURE Respectfully submitted, /s/Nick Cordova Nick Cordova,Principal Green Recursive Utility Service LLC 205 E 3rd St,Weatherford, TX 76086 management@greenrecursiveutilityservice.org • 817-404-6379 Dated: October 30,2026 Petition for Rulemaking of Petitioner GRUS LLC Page 6