The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About200408311st Response of IPC to Staff.pdfBARTON L. KLINE ISB #1526 MONICA B. MOEN ISB #5734 Idaho Power Company O. Box 70 Boise, Idaho 83707 Telephone: (208) 388-2682 FAX Telephone: (208) 388-6936 Attorney for Idaho Power Company Street Address for Express Mail 1221 West Idaho Street Boise , Idaho 83702 ""' \ n: P,#1-V f;:1t::J F\ E. t.J\ 1.. """ 11""f\ """"'I ""'"'-"" H.,\" iJJU'1 ML \. ; .. ; : ~: c ,... -~'(';~, Aj"€ '-.. \ON " . .". '1 ' , . \- '- . v \ II i I .JU\\L\\\\-..J v BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION S. GEOTHERMAL, INC. an Idaho corporation Complainant vs. IDAHO POWER COMPANY, an Idaho corporation Respondent. BOB LEWANDOWSKI and MARK SCHROEDER Complainants, vs. IDAHO POWER COMPANY, an Idaho corporation Respondent. Case No. IPC-04- Case No. IPC-04- IDAHO POWER RESPONSE TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST, Page COMES NOW , IDAHO POWER COMPANY ("Idaho Power" or lithe Company ), and in response to the First Set of Production Requests of the Commission Staff received by Idaho Power, herewith submits the following information: Request No.1: On page 16 , lines 9-11 of Kip Runyan s rebuttal testimony on behalf of U.S. Geothermal , he states, On May 21 2004 , two months after U.S. Geothermal filed its Complaint, Idaho Power sent a letter to U.S. Geothermal that, for the first time in negotiation, denied entitlement to the published rates for the U. Geothermal project. ) Using the AURORA model , consistent with the methodology as described in the attached document as accepted in the Settlement Stipulation in Case No. IPC-95-9 and using assumptions consistent with Idaho Power s 2002 IRP please compute an avoided cost rate for the proposed U.S. Geothermal project. Also attached for reference is a document previously prepared by Idaho Power with its own description of the same methodology. ) Please provide Staff in an AURORA format all input and output files used in the foregoing analysis. Response 1 a): Upon receipt of this production request, Idaho Power contacted the Idaho Public Utility Commission (IPUC) staff (Rick Sterling) and discussed the portion of the request that asks Idaho Power to utilize assumptions consistent with Idaho Power s 2002 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP). The 2004 IRP was filed with the IPUC on Friday August 27 2004. Idaho Power recognizes that the 2004 IRP has not yet been accepted by the IPUC. However, in preparing the 2004 IRP considerable amount of time was spent updating the forecasts and assumptions IDAHO POWER RESPONSE TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST, Page 2 that were utilized in the 2002 IRP. In order to produce a timely, and more accurate response to this production request, Idaho Power requested that it be allowed to use assumptions consistent with the 2004 IRP rather than the assumptions used to prepare the 2002 IRP. IPUC Staff agreed with this approach and Idaho Power has proceeded accordingly. Like the 2002 IRP , the 2004 IRP considers a 10-year planning horizon and the resources identified in the 2004 IRP Long-Term Action Plan are those resources intended to satisfy Idaho Power s forecast requirements through 2013. Idaho Power expects that additional resources will be required, and built, after 2013. Since US Geothermal is seeking a 20-year PURPA contract , and since the AURORA model will be utilized to establish avoided costs over a 20 year horizon , new long-term AURORA analyses were run to determine the timing, quantity and cost of new resources to add after 2013. Two long-term (L analyses were run. The first L T run includes the resources identified in the 2004 IRP plus the AURORA generated resource additions through 2030. This analysis identified in the attached documents and files as the "Base Case" and incorporates the resources identified in the first L T run. The second L T run includes the resources identified in the 2004 IRP, the assumed energy and capacity to be purchased from the US Geothermal project and the AURORA generated resources through 2030. This second analysis is identified in the attached documents and files as "Base Case with USGeoRR Project On-Line and incorporates the resources identified in the second L T run. The calculation IDAHO POWER RESPONSE TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST, Page 3 of the cost avoided by including the US Geothermal project at zero cost, was based on 50th percentile load and hydro conditions. The difference between the present values of the revenue requirements associated with each case is 42.635 million dollars (2006 dollars). Given the generation that the US Geothermal project has indicated it will deliver, beginning in 2006, this difference in revenue requirements will result in a 20-year levelized purchase price of $46.13/MWh. Idaho Power acknowledges that there are aspects of this response that require additional analysis. If the Commission determines that AURORA should be used to determine the avoided costs attributable to the U.S. Geothermal Project, the AURORA analysis should , and could be refined. However, given the time constraints and Idaho Power s desire to respond to this request in a timely manner, this response is generally representative of costs the Company would avoid in 2006 based on an AURORA analysis. Response 1 b): Attached to this response is an electronic copy of the AURORA input and output files associated with this production request. The response to this request was prepared by Karl Bokenkamp, Manager Thermal Production, Idaho Power Company, in consultation with Barton L. Kline , Senior Attorney, Idaho Power Company. Dated at Boise, Idaho this 30th day of August, 2004. BARTON L. KLINE IDAHO POWER RESPONSE TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST, Page 4 Attorney for Idaho Power Company IDAHO POWER RESPONSE TO FIRST PRODUCTION REQUEST, Page 5 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day of August, 2004 , I served a true and correct copy of the within and foregoing IDAHO POWER COMPANY RESPONSE TO FIRST PORDUCTION REQUEST upon the following named parties by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following: Scott Woodbury Deputy Attorney General Idaho Public Utilities Commission 472 W. Washington Street O. Box 83720 Boise, Idaho 83720-0074 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX Don Reading Ben Johnson Associates 6070 Hill Road Boise, I D 83702 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX Peter J. Richardson Richardson & O'Leary 99 East State Street, Suite 200 O. Box 1849 Eagle, ID 83616 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX Dan Kunz, President S. Geothermal , Inc. 1509 Tyrell Lane , Ste. B Boise, ID 83706 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX James F. Fell Stoel Rives LLP 900 S.W. Fifth Avenue, Ste. 2600 Portland , OR 97204 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX Bob Lively PacifiCorp One Utah Center, 23rd Floor 201 S. Main Street Salt Lake City, UT 84140 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE, Page R. Blair Strong Paine, Hamblen, Coffin , Brooke & Miller LLP 717 W. Sprague Ave., Ste 1200 Spokane, WA 99201-3505 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX Clint Kalich, Manager of Resource Planning and Analysis Avista Corporation - MSC- O. Box 3727 Spokane, W A 99220-3727 Hand Delivered S. Mail Overnight Mail FAX ~3J8-~ BARTON L. KLINE CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE , Page 2 US Geothermal Raft River Project IPCo Response to IPUC Staff First Production Request Case No. IPC-E-O4-8/IPC-E-O4-10 August 30, 2004 DAHO POWER An IDACORP company Levelized Avoided Cost Calculations Discount Rate:2002% Portfolio Power Production Costs ($ x 1.000) Case 1: Base Case 20 Year Net Present Value (Year 2006 $)418 168 Case 2: Base Case with US Geothermal Online (Q) Online at Zero Cost 20 Year Net Present Value (Year 2006 $) Difference Case 1 - Case 2 (Year 2004 $) 375 533 635 40,580 Difference Case 1 - Case 2 (Year 2006 $) Monthlv Avoided Costs ($/MWh) 20 Year Monthly PV of Avoided Costs (Year 2006 $):841.74 20 Year Monthly Levelized Cost (Year 2006 $):46. 20 Year Monthly Levelized Cost (Year 2004 $)43. Statistics from Portfolio Analvsis Average: Median: Maximum: Minimum: 46. 46. 290. (146.92) Page 1 of 1 AURORAxmp Ver. 7.1.0. n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w w ~ w w w w w w w ~ w ~ w w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1-1 ::I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 Z 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 Z 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ro c c w ~ w ro w ro 0 ro c c w ~ w ro w ro 0 ro c c w ~ w ro w ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cr ~ n c ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cr ~ n C ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ cr ~ ~I 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d g g g ~ g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g g ~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~W~~~NONN~W~~N~~~ NO~~WW~~N~~~~O~~W ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ro 0 W 0 ro ~ ~ 00 ~ N ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ro ~ ~ W ~ W W ~~ ~ ~~~~~~ ~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ 0 ~ N N ~ N W 0 ~ W N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ W w ro ~ ~ ~ ~ a w ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ 0 ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ro w ~ ~ ~ ~ aro ~ ~ N ~ N ~ N ~ W ~ ro ~ 0 N N ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ N N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ NN~~WN ~ NNNNNWWN~ ~ ~NNNNWWN~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ro N ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ W N ~ ~ 0 ~~~~W~~~~~N~~NW~O~O~ N~OO~ O~~ ~~N~~~~~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ W W N ~ ~ ro ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ro ro ~ ro ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ~ 0 W ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro 0 0 ~ ~ 0 N 0 ro 0 ~ N ro ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ aN ~ ~ a W ~ W ~ 0 a W 0 ~ W ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 ~ 0 W ro W ~ ro ~ 0 ):. ~n"""'afI) n ;:a tD 0Z::aW 0 $'. fI)N .... "'a 0on:::::l fI) ,...,... ::T .... 00 "'a ....... c:.... n .., "'a ,....... ~:n .., fI):;a ,....... "'a ::I ;::p):.,... :;aII( :::::I ::a II( .., fI) ,.........,....,... ::I :IE j:1:::r "1:1""I 18) ""I n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Cro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro :JN N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N NI 1-1 ...... "1:1 -ICD -.:I. 3~~ ~~~~~~OZ ~~ ~~~~~~OZo~~ ~~~~~~ ro c ~c w~ ro w ro 0 n ro c ~c w~ ro w ro 0 n ro c ~c w~ ro w ~~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ cr ~ n c ~~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ cr ~ n c ~~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ cr ~000 a 00000000000000000 a a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000ro ro ro ro ro 00 ro ro ro ro ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1-1W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W ~ W W ~ W ~ W W W ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~W~~~NONN~ w~~ N~~~ NO~ ~ WW~~N~~~ ~ o~ ~ W ~~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ro 0 W 0 ro ~ ~ ro ~ N ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ro ~ ~ W ~ W w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ N N ~ N W 0 ~ W N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ W W ro ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 W ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ 0 ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ro W ~ ~ ~ ~ aro ~ ~ N ~ N ~ N ~ W ~ ro ~ 0 N N ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ N N ~ ~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~~~~ ~ NN~~WN ~ NNNNNWWN~ ~ ~NNNNWWN~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ro ~ W W 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ NOW ~ ~ W 0 ~ ~ ~ ro ~ W ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~N~OOOO~ ~O~OO~~ O~ W~ ~ ~ OONWNOW~ OO~ ~ 0~W~~W~~~~~WOW~~~~~~~w~~ro~~~ro~w~~~ro ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ~ ro W ~ N ~ W W ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro N ro ro ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ W ~ ~ N ~ ~ a~ ~ N N N ~ ~ a ro ~ W ro ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W W ~ ~ ro ~ WNW ~ ~ c: 0';tnc m ... ""~:Jc::: .. 't:I c:;""I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~ ~~~OONO~O~~~~~~~roNO~O~~~~~~~roNO~O~~ ~~~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ro ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ N N ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ N ro ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ N ro ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1:) c::::: c: m ctn n -.G) I ~ CD m ~ 0NNWnCD~~~~c :J ~~~ro""c::; nu,o~C:j:1:CD ~~~ ::r ..-.. ..-.. ~ WNW NNW W ~ W W W N N N N ~ W ~ W W ~ W W N ~ N N N N ~W ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ro N 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N NN ro ~ 00 ro 0 0 ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro W a ro ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ W ~ 0 aNN ~ 0 ~ ~ a ro ~ ~ ro ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~~ W ~ 00 ~ N ~ ~ N ~ 0 N ~ N N ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ro ro N ~ '-' '-'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ...... -. 3: g.Ww~:E~~~~::rntv a 0- 00 0 ~ ..-.. ..-.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ W N ~ ~ W ~ ~ W ~ W N ~ ~ W W ~~ 0 0 a ~ ro ro N N 0 0 N ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ ~ N W N ro ~ ~~ ~ ~ 0 ~ N W ~ ~ ~ ro ~ ~ tv ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ N ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ro ~ W ro W ~ ~ ~ N ~ W ~ W N ro ~ '-' '-' 'tJ oe:: US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e l No v - 08 T o t a l 20 2 51 3 $ 00 7 . 4 1 Ca s e l De e - 08 T o t a l 41 5 63 2 $ 55 4 . Ca s e l Ja n - 09 T o t a l 43 5 19 5 $ 94 7 . Ca s e l Fe b - 09 T o t a l 22 0 63 8 $ 09 0 . Ca s e l Ma r - 09 T o t a l 23 0 41 1 $ 26 2 . Ca s e l Ap r - 09 T o t a l 11 2 14 2 $ 98 4 . Ca s e l Ma y - 09 T o t a l 28 2 35 9 $ 63 4 . Ca s e l Ju n - 09 T o t a l 54 0 88 0 $ 95 6 . Ca s e l Ju l - 09 T o t a l 80 3 25 8 $ 40 4 . Ca s e l Au g - 09 T o t a l 69 1 17 6 $ 65 4 . Ca s e l Se p - 09 T o t a l 34 5 44 8 $ 51 0 . Ca s e l Oe t - 09 T o t a l 20 5 41 5 $ 80 9 . Ca s e l No v - 09 T o t a l 23 0 49 2 $ 31 3 . 3 0 Ca s e l De c - 09 T o t a l 44 6 42 6 $ 77 8 . Ca s e l Ja n - l0 T o t a l 46 5 , 88 5 $ 97 7 . Ca s e l Fe b - l0 T o t a l 24 7 05 9 $ 13 0 . 3 8 Ca s e l Ma r - l 0 T o t a l 25 7 44 2 $ 25 7 . Ca s e l Ap r - l 0 T o t a l 13 6 33 3 $ 42 9 . Ca s e l Ma y - l0 T o t a l 30 9 40 5 $ 02 6 . Ca s e l Ju n - l0 T o t a l 57 2 95 7 $ 12 7 . Ca s e l Ju l - l 0 T o t a l 84 2 65 5 $ 48 6 . Ca s e l Au g - l0 T o t a l 72 9 72 2 $ 55 8 . Ca s e l Se p - l0 T o t a l 37 5 26 1 $ 74 0 . Ca s e l Oe t - lO T o t a l 23 2 63 7 $ 27 3 . Ca s e l No v - lO T o t a l 25 7 56 2 $ 34 5 . Ca s e l De e - lO T o t a l 47 6 36 8 $ 97 5 . Ca s e l Ja n - 11 T o t a l 49 5 63 7 $ 45 2 . Ca s e l Fe b - 11 T o t a l 27 2 65 5 $ 32 3 . 4 7 Ca s e l Ma r - 11 T o t a l 28 3 59 7 $ 20 8 . Ca s e l Ap r - 11 T o t a l 15 9 77 0 $ 51 0 . 4 1 Ca s e l Ma y - 11 T o t a l 33 5 , 76 9 $ 65 9 . Ca s e l Ju n - 11 T o t a l 60 4 51 9 $ 46 0 . 4 7 Ca s e l Ju l - l l T o t a l 88 1 65 0 $ 97 9 . Ca s e l Au g - 11 T o t a l 76 7 80 9 $ 62 6 . 4 2 Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R P r o j e c t On l i n e (Q J Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 No v - 08 T o t a l 20 2 51 3 $ 67 2 . 7 4 Ca s e 2 De e - 08 T o t a l 41 5 63 2 $ 13 6 . 4 8 Ca s e 2 Ja n - 09 T o t a l 43 5 19 5 $ 56 0 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 09 T o t a l 22 0 63 8 $ 68 3 . 3 5 Ca s e 2 Ma r - 0 9 T o t a l 23 0 , 41 1 $ 86 3 . 3 8 Ca s e 2 Ap r - 09 T o t a l 11 2 14 2 $ 67 8 . 3 4 Ca s e 2 Ma y - 09 T o t a l 28 2 35 9 $ 35 2 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 09 T o t a l 54 0 88 0 $ 67 1 . 8 6 Ca s e 2 Ju l - 09 T o t a l 80 3 25 8 $ 06 4 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 09 T o t a l 69 1 17 6 $ 32 0 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 09 T o t a l 34 5 44 8 $ 14 1 . 7 7 Ca s e 2 Oe t - 09 T o t a l 20 5 41 5 $ 45 4 . Ca s e 2 No v - 0 9 T o t a l 23 0 49 2 $ 02 4 . Ca s e 2 De e - 09 T o t a l 44 6 42 6 $ 36 9 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - l 0 T o t a l 46 5 88 5 $ 63 4 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - l0 T o t a l 24 7 05 9 $ 21 2 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - l 0 T o t a l 25 7 44 2 $ 74 1 . 8 3 Ca s e 2 Ap r - lO T o t a l 13 6 33 3 $ 26 2 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - lO T o t a l 30 9 40 5 $ 60 9 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - l0 T o t a l 57 2 95 7 $ 39 , 87 7 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - l0 T o t a l 84 2 65 5 $ 17 6 . Ca s e 2 Au g - l 0 T o t a l 72 9 72 2 $ 21 8 . Ca s e 2 Se p - l 0 T o t a l 37 5 , 26 1 $ 42 3 . Ca s e 2 Oe t - l 0 T o t a l 23 2 63 7 $ 96 4 . Ca s e 2 No v - l0 T o t a l 25 7 56 2 $ 93 6 . Ca s e 2 De e - l0 T o t a l 47 6 36 8 $ 56 6 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 1 1 T o t a l 49 5 63 7 $ 99 6 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 11 T o t a l 27 2 65 5 $ 98 1 . 2 7 Ca s e 2 Ma r - 1 1 T o t a l 28 3 59 7 $ 84 2 . 3 2 Ca s e 2 Ap r - 1 1 T o t a l 15 9 77 0 $ 08 5 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 11 T o t a l 33 5 , 76 9 $ 51 6 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 11 T o t a l 60 4 51 9 $ 15 3 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 1 1 T o t a l 88 1 65 0 $ 66 2 . 3 0 Ca s e 2 Au g - 11 T o t a l 76 7 80 9 $ 31 3 . 7 8 Pa g e 2 o f 8 lD A l t O P O W E An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 9 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h Av o i d e d C o s t US G e o R R ) ($ / M W h ) 33 4 . 41 . 9 0 41 8 . 48 . 38 6 . 4 2 44 . 40 7 . 4 2 53 . 39 8 . 49 . 30 6 . 40 . 28 2 . 4 2 39 . 28 4 . 45 . 34 0 . 58 . 33 4 . 5 1 55 . 36 8 . 56 . 35 4 . 46 . 28 8 . 36 . 40 8 . 47 . 34 3 . 39 . (8 2 . 18 ) $ (1 0 . 69 ) 51 5 . 64 . 16 6 . 22 . 41 7 . 59 . 25 0 . 39 . 31 0 . 53 . 33 9 . 56 . 31 7 . 48 . 3 3 30 8 . 40 . 40 9 . 51 . 2 4 40 8 . 47 . 45 6 . 4 0 53 . 34 2 . 44 . 36 6 . 4 7 45 . 42 4 . 56 . 14 2 . 20 . 30 6 . 48 . 31 7 . 54 . 31 2 . 52 . 3 2 AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e l Se p - 11 T o t a l 40 4 46 3 $ 92 0 . Ca s e l Oc t - l l T o t a l 25 9 06 7 $ 72 3 . Ca s e l No v - 11 T o t a l 28 3 75 5 $ 80 4 . Ca s e l De c - 11 T o t a l 50 5 29 5 $ 40 4 . Ca s e l Ja n - 12 T o t a l 52 4 60 5 $ 47 7 . 4 3 Ca s e l Fe b - 12 T o t a l 34 2 20 7 $ 20 3 . Ca s e l Ma r - 12 T o t a l 30 9 02 7 $ 91 5 . Ca s e l Ap r - 12 T o t a l 18 2 57 0 $ 59 5 . Ca s e l Ma y - 12 T o t a l 36 1 53 9 $ 20 3 . Ca s e l Ju n - 1 2 T o t a l 63 5 60 3 $ 84 2 . Ca s e l Ju l - 12 T o t a l 92 0 26 0 $ 31 2 . Ca s e l Au g - 12 T o t a l 80 5 48 4 $ 07 5 . Ca s e l Se p - 1 2 T o t a l 43 3 12 3 $ 74 7 . Ca s e l Oc t - 12 T o t a l 28 4 82 2 $ 00 9 . Ca s e l No v - 12 T o t a l 30 9 22 7 $ 91 1 . 3 9 Ca s e l De c - 12 T o t a l 53 3 89 9 $ 91 8 . Ca s e l Ja n - 13 T o t a l 55 3 85 1 $ 40 5 . 3 8 Ca s e l Fe b - 13 T o t a l 32 2 71 5 $ 20 5 . Ca s e l Ma r - 13 T o t a l 33 4 69 8 $ 70 2 . Ca s e l Ap r - 13 T o t a l 20 5 60 1 $ 66 7 . Ca s e l Ma y - 13 T o t a l 38 7 61 3 $ 29 , 89 4 . Ca s e l Ju n - 13 T o t a l 66 7 13 7 $ 49 , 88 8 . Ca s e l Ju l - 13 T o t a l 95 9 51 0 $ 62 5 . Ca s e l Au g - 13 T o t a l 84 3 76 6 $ 09 2 . Ca s e l Se p - 1 3 T o t a l 46 2 15 9 $ 66 6 . Ca s e l Oc t - 13 T o t a l 31 0 84 3 $ 88 5 . Ca s e l No v - 13 T o t a l 33 4 88 9 $ 28 0 . Ca s e l De c - 13 T o t a l 56 2 12 3 $ 29 7 . 3 6 Ca s e l Ja n - 14 T o t a l 58 2 47 6 $ 71 9 . Ca s e l Fe b - 14 T o t a l 34 7 38 7 $ 71 3 . 4 8 Ca s e l Ma r - 14 T o t a l 35 9 96 9 $ 63 6 . Ca s e l Ap r - 14 T o t a l 22 8 41 3 $ 87 4 . Ca s e l Ma y - 14 T o t a l 41 3 52 1 $ 92 0 . Ca s e l Ju n - 14 T o t a l 69 8 54 6 $ 40 0 . Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R P r o j e c t On l i n e (Q ) Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 Se p - 11 T o t a l 40 4 46 3 ' $ 51 7 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 11 T o t a l 25 9 06 7 $ 34 7 . 4 6 Ca s e 2 No v - 11 T o t a l 28 3 75 5 $ 35 9 . 4 9 Ca s e 2 De c - 11 T o t a l 50 5 29 5 $ 96 9 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 12 T o t a l 52 4 60 5 $ 09 3 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 12 T o t a l 34 2 20 7 $ 64 6 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 12 T o t a l 30 9 02 7 $ 61 8 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 12 T o t a l 18 2 57 0 $ 29 7 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 12 T o t a l 36 1 53 9 $ 92 0 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 1 2 T o t a l 63 5 60 3 $ 48 8 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 12 T o t a l 92 0 26 0 $ 00 2 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 12 T o t a l 80 5 48 4 $ 74 2 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 12 T o t a l 43 3 12 3 $ 14 1 . 1 2 Ca s e 2 Oc t - 1 2 T o t a l 28 4 82 2 $ 63 9 . 5 7 Ca s e 2 No v - 12 T o t a l 30 9 22 7 $ 59 0 . Ca s e 2 De c - 12 T o t a l 53 3 89 9 $ 46 6 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 13 T o t a l 55 3 85 1 $ 97 8 . 4 3 Ca s e 2 Fe b - 13 T o t a l 32 2 71 5 $ 70 8 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 13 T o t a l 33 4 69 8 $ 27 4 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 13 T o t a l 20 5 60 1 $ 38 6 . 7 6 Ca s e 2 Ma y - 13 T o t a l 38 7 61 3 $ 59 3 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 13 T o t a l 66 7 13 7 $ 70 9 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 13 T o t a l 95 9 , 51 0 $ 27 0 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 13 T o t a l 84 3 76 6 $ 92 7 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 13 T o t a l 46 2 15 9 $ 32 3 . 4 0 Ca s e 2 Oc t - 13 T o t a l 31 0 84 3 $ 40 2 . Ca s e 2 No v - 13 T o t a l 33 4 88 9 $ 75 4 . 3 9 Ca s e 2 De c - 13 T o t a l 56 2 12 3 $ 82 3 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 14 T o t a l 58 2 47 6 $ 14 4 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 14 T o t a l 34 7 38 7 $ 13 7 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 14 T o t a l 35 9 96 9 $ 33 7 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 14 T o t a l 22 8 41 3 $ 33 9 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 14 T o t a l 41 3 52 1 $ 73 9 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 1 4 T o t a l 69 8 54 6 $ 16 9 . Pa g e 3 o f 8 II 1 I U - I O PO W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 96 2 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 3 59 9 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h Av o i d e d C o s t US G e o R R ) ($ / M W h ) $ 4 0 2 . 95 61 . 3 9 $ 3 7 5 . 78 49 . 4 5 $ 4 4 5 . 12 $ 5 5 . $ 4 3 5 . 93 $ 5 0 . $ 3 8 3 . 66 $ 4 4 . $ 5 5 6 . 50 $ 6 9 . $ 2 9 6 . 84 $ 3 6 . $ 2 9 8 . 74 ' I $" " " ,I i 3 9 : 9 9 $ 2 8 3 . 24 $ 4 0 . 35 4 . 4 1 $ 5 6 . $ 3 1 0 . 06 53 . 4 5 33 2 . 3 6 $ 5 5 . $ 6 0 5 . 95 92 . 3 2 37 0 . 4 2 $ 4 8 . $ 3 2 0 . 65 $ 4 0 . 45 1 . 9 6 $ 5 2 . $ 4 2 6 . 95 $ 4 9 . $ 4 9 7 . 04 $ 6 4 . 42 7 . 5 7 $ 5 3 . 28 0 . 4 9 $ 3 7 . $ 3 0 0 . 22 $ 42 . 4 5 $ 1 7 9 . 68 $ 2 8 . $ 3 5 5 . 71 61 . 3 2 $ 1 6 4 . 90 $ 2 7 . 34 3 . 4 1 $ 52 . 3 2 48 2 . 3 9 $ 63 . 4 8 $ 5 2 6 . 50 $ 6 5 . $ 4 7 3 . 75 $ 5 5 . $ 5 7 4 . 60 $ 6 6 . $ 5 7 6 . 33 $ 7 4 . $ 2 9 8 . 85 $ 3 7 . $ 5 3 5 . 10 $ 71 . 6 3 18 1 . 8 3 $ 2 5 . $ 2 3 0 . 32 $ 3 6 . AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ($ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e l Ju l - 14 T o t a l 99 8 , 63 6 $ 46 2 . Ca s e l Au g - 14 T o t a l 88 1 90 5 $ 44 2 . Ca s e 1 Se p - 1 4 T o t a l 49 1 06 9 $ 25 5 . Ca s e 1 Oe t - 14 T o t a l 33 6 64 5 $ 45 3 . Ca s e 1 No v - 14 T o t a l 36 0 17 7 $ 96 5 . Ca s e 1 De e - 14 T o t a l 58 9 88 1 $ 95 7 . Ca s e l Ja n - 15 T o t a l 61 0 78 5 $ 35 6 . Ca s e l Fe b - 15 T o t a l 37 1 80 6 $ 12 2 . Ca s e l Ma r - 15 T o t a l 38 5 01 3 $ 29 9 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 15 T o t a l 25 1 08 2 $ 64 5 . Ca s e l Ma y - 15 T o t a l 43 9 , 36 8 $ 66 4 . Ca s e l Ju n - 15 T o t a l 73 0 01 7 $ 83 3 . Ca s e l Ju l - 15 T o t a l 03 7 92 7 $ 93 3 . Ca s e 1 Au g - 15 T o t a l 92 0 16 8 $ 96 7 . 3 6 Ca s e 1 Se p - 15 T o t a l 51 9 96 3 $ 14 9 . 4 6 Ca s e l Oe t - 15 T o t a l 36 2 30 5 $ 91 8 . Ca s e 1 No v - 15 T o t a l 38 5 24 6 $ 10 2 . Ca s e 1 De e - 15 T o t a l 61 7 81 0 $ 91 6 . Ca s e l Ja n - 16 T o t a l 63 9 56 3 $ 84 1 . 1 5 Ca s e 1 Fe b - 16 T o t a l 44 4 77 4 $ 13 2 . Ca s e 1 Ma r - 1 6 T o t a l 41 0 45 5 $ 35 , 87 6 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 16 T o t a l 27 4 11 7 $ 23 , 34 2 . 4 7 Ca s e 1 Ma y - 16 T o t a l 46 5 68 7 $ 84 0 . Ca s e 1 Ju n - 1 6 T o t a l 76 2 15 5 $ 52 1 . 6 6 Ca s e 1 Ju l - 16 T o t a l 07 8 12 2 $ 67 9 . Ca s e 1 Au g - 16 T o t a l 95 9 27 9 $ 13 3 . Ca s e 1 Se p - 1 6 T o t a l 54 9 40 2 $ 18 2 . Ca s e l Oc t - 16 T o t a l 38 8 37 0 $ 78 5 . Ca s e 1 No v - 16 T o t a l 41 0 68 2 $ 96 0 . Ca s e 1 De e - 16 T o t a l 64 6 10 4 $ 49 6 . Ca s e 1 Ja n - 17 T o t a l 66 8 57 4 $ 45 7 . Ca s e 1 Fe b - 1 7 T o t a l 42 1 64 8 $ 29 5 . 4 3 Ca s e 1 Ma r - 17 T o t a l 43 6 , 13 1 $ 09 4 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 17 T o t a l 29 7 38 1 $ 74 9 . Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R P r o j e c t On l i n e (g ) Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ($ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 Ju l - 14 T o t a l 99 8 63 6 $ 01 9 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 14 T o t a l 88 1 90 5 $ 17 3 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 14 T o t a l 49 1 06 9 $ 91 1 . 0 9 Ca s e 2 Oc t - 14 T o t a l 33 6 64 5 $ 00 0 . Ca s e 2 No v - 1 4 T o t a l 36 0 17 7 $ 47 7 . Ca s e 2 De e - 14 T o t a l 58 9 88 1 $ 53 1 . 1 2 Ca s e 2 Ja n - 15 T o t a l 61 0 78 5 $ 87 3 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 15 T o t a l 37 1 80 6 $ 89 3 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 15 T o t a l 38 5 01 3 $ 28 , 89 3 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 15 T o t a l 25 1 08 2 $ 56 6 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 15 T o t a l 43 9 36 8 $ 48 0 . 3 9 Ca s e 2 Ju n - 15 T o t a l 73 0 01 7 $ 54 0 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 1 5 T o t a l 03 7 92 7 $ 62 7 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 15 T o t a l 92 0 16 8 $ 78 0 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 15 T o t a l 51 9 96 3 $ 56 5 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 15 T o t a l 36 2 30 5 $ 62 3 . Ca s e 2 No v - 15 T o t a l 38 5 24 6 $ 79 5 . Ca s e 2 De e - 1 5 T o t a l 61 7 81 0 $ 49 8 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 1 6 T o t a l 63 9 56 3 $ 52 2 . 4 6 Ca s e 2 Fe b - 16 T o t a l 44 4 77 4 $ 49 6 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 16 T o t a l 41 0 45 5 $ 50 2 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 1 6 T o t a l 27 4 11 7 $ 32 1 . 1 6 Ca s e 2 Ma y - 1 6 T o t a l 46 5 68 7 $ 49 0 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 16 T o t a l 76 2 15 5 $ 28 2 . 7 0 Ca s e 2 Ju l - 16 T o t a l 07 8 12 2 $ 21 7 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 16 T o t a l 95 9 , 27 9 $ 60 1 . 5 5 Ca s e 2 Se p - 16 T o t a l 54 9 40 2 $ 06 3 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 16 T o t a l 38 8 37 0 $ 26 9 . Ca s e 2 No v - 1 6 T o t a l 41 0 68 2 $ 92 2 . Ca s e 2 De e - 1 6 T o t a l 64 6 10 4 $ 08 7 . 4 5 Ca s e 2 Ja n - 17 T o t a l 66 8 57 4 $ 95 7 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 1 7 T o t a l 42 1 64 8 $ 12 1 . 5 2 Ca s e 2 Ma r - 17 T o t a l 43 6 13 1 $ 78 0 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 17 T o t a l 29 7 38 1 $ 71 1 . 9 0 Pa g e 4 o f 8 lD A l t O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 9 98 6 59 6 59 6 96 2 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h Av o i d e d C o s t US G e o R R ) ($ / M W h ) 44 2 . 76 . 26 8 . 44 . 34 4 . 52 . 45 2 . 59 . 48 7 . 61 . 0 9 42 6 . 4 4 49 . 48 3 . 56 . 22 9 . 3 4 29 0 . 40 6 . 50 . 4 7 79 . 10 . 18 4 . 26 . 29 3 . 46 . 30 6 . 3 7 52 . 18 6 . 31 . 2 7 58 3 . 88 . 29 5 . 38 . 30 6 . 38 . 4 2 41 7 . 48 . 31 8 . 37 . 63 5 . 79 . 37 4 . 46 . 4 6 21 . 3 1 34 9 . 49 . 4 7 23 8 . 38 . 46 2 . 79 . 53 2 . 4 0 89 . 11 9 . 18 . 51 6 . 67 . 38 . 40 9 . 47 . 50 0 . 58 . 17 3 . 22 . 31 4 . 39 . 37 . AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US Ge o t h e r m a I R a f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e l Ma y - 17 T o t a l 49 2 26 2 $ 48 1 . 8 4 Ca s e l Ju n - 17 T o t a l 79 4 62 3 $ 32 9 . Ca s e l Ju l - 17 T o t a l 11 8 78 0 $ 96 8 . Ca s e l Au g - 17 T o t a l 99 8 85 6 $ 01 1 . 3 9 Ca s e l Se p - 17 T o t a l 57 9 15 6 $ 11 5 . Ca s e l Oc t - 17 T o t a l 41 4 70 0 $ 97 8 . Ca s e l No v - 1 7 T o t a l 43 6 34 3 $ 91 4 . Ca s e l De c - 17 T o t a l 67 4 56 3 $ 93 6 . Ca s e l Ja n - 18 T o t a l 69 7 84 1 $ 13 0 . 4 3 Ca s e l Fe b - 18 T o t a l 44 6 88 7 $ 32 7 . Ca s e l Ma r - 1 8 T o t a l 46 2 01 1 $ 36 2 . 4 1 Ca s e l Ap r - 18 T o t a l 32 0 84 0 $ 38 7 . Ca s e l Ma y - 1 8 T o t a l 51 9 11 6 $ 55 , 46 9 . Ca s e l Ju n - 18 T o t a l 82 7 54 0 $ 09 0 . Ca s e l Ju l - 18 T o t a l 16 0 09 6 $ 41 3 . Ca s e l Au g - 18 T o t a l 03 9 04 9 $ 64 4 . Ca s e l Se p - 18 T o t a l 60 9 26 5 $ 83 8 . Ca s e l Oe t - 18 T o t a l 44 1 25 4 $ 93 8 . 5 9 Ca s e l No v - 18 T o t a l 46 2 18 3 $ 71 7 . Ca s e l De e - 18 T o t a l 70 2 95 9 $ 35 2 . 3 6 Ca s e l Ja n - 19 T o t a l 72 6 79 8 $ 95 2 . Ca s e l Fe b - 19 T o t a l 47 1 87 0 $ 79 6 . Ca s e l Ma r - 19 T o t a l 48 7 64 3 $ 87 6 . Ca s e l Ap r - 19 T o t a l 34 4 11 0 $ 80 9 . Ca s e l Ma y - 19 T o t a l 54 5 82 8 $ 57 3 . 3 2 Ca s e l Ju n - 1 9 T o t a l 86 0 40 3 $ 57 9 . Ca s e l Ju l - 19 T o t a l 20 1 46 2 $ 86 7 . 4 1 Ca s e l Au g - 19 T o t a l 07 9 27 0 $ 18 4 . Ca s e l Se p - 19 T o t a l 63 9 27 3 $ 33 1 . 0 9 Ca s e l Oe t - 19 T o t a l 46 7 61 0 $ 12 6 . Ca s e l No v - 19 T o t a l 48 7 75 8 $ 15 3 . Ca s e l De e - 19 T o t a l 73 1 31 3 $ 87 4 . Ca s e l Ja n - 20 T o t a l 75 6 06 8 $ 76 8 . Ca s e l Fe b - 2 0 T o t a l 54 8 86 6 $ 73 8 . Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R Pr o j e c t O n l i n e (g ) Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 Ma y - 1 7 T o t a l 49 2 26 2 $ 10 7 . 3 6 Ca s e 2 Ju n - 17 T o t a l 79 4 62 3 $ 85 8 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 17 T o t a l 11 8 78 0 $ 41 2 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 17 T o t a l 99 8 85 6 $ 82 0 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 17 T o t a l 57 9 15 6 $ 00 5 . Ca s e 2 Oe t - 1 7 T o t a l 41 4 70 0 $ 92 2 . Ca s e 2 No v - 17 T o t a l 43 6 34 3 $ 64 0 . Ca s e 2 De e - 17 T o t a l 67 4 56 3 $ 69 5 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 1 8 T o t a l 69 7 84 1 $ 36 2 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 18 T o t a l 44 6 88 7 $ 14 3 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 18 T o t a l 46 2 01 1 $ 22 4 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 18 T o t a l 32 0 84 0 $ 69 4 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 18 T o t a l 51 9 11 6 $ 10 2 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 18 T o t a l 82 7 54 0 $ 00 6 . 3 3 Ca s e 2 Ju l - 18 T o t a l 16 0 09 6 $ 98 5 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 18 T o t a l 03 9 04 9 $ 28 9 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 1 8 T o t a l 60 9 26 5 $ 40 9 . Ca s e 2 Oe t - 18 T o t a l 44 1 25 4 $ 69 6 . Ca s e 2 No v - 1 8 T o t a l 46 2 18 3 $ 04 4 . Ca s e 2 De c - 18 T o t a l 70 2 95 9 $ 37 0 . 5 9 Ca s e 2 Ja n - 19 T o t a l 72 6 79 8 $ 53 , 47 5 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 1 9 T o t a l 47 1 87 0 $ 70 6 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 19 T o t a l 48 7 64 3 $ 64 8 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 19 T o t a l 34 4 11 0 $ 25 3 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 19 T o t a l 54 5 82 8 $ 23 2 . 3 9 Ca s e 2 Ju n - 1 9 T o t a l 86 0 40 3 $ 38 4 . 4 6 Ca s e 2 Ju l - 1 9 T o t a l 20 1 46 2 $ 15 4 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 19 T o t a l 07 9 27 0 $ 80 3 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 19 T o t a l 63 9 , 27 3 $ 50 7 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 19 T o t a l 46 7 61 0 $ 53 5 . Ca s e 2 No v - 19 T o t a l 48 7 75 8 $ 65 2 . 4 1 Ca s e 2 De e - 19 T o t a l 73 1 31 3 $ 65 2 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 20 T o t a l 75 6 06 8 $ 31 5 . 3 0 Ca s e 2 Fe b - 20 T o t a l 54 8 86 6 $ 93 8 . Pa g e 5 o f 8 EI U t O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 3 59 9 98 6 59 6 59 6 96 2 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h Av o i d e d C o s t US G e o R R ) ($ / M W h ) 37 4 . 4 8 52 . 47 0 . 75 . 55 6 . 95 . 19 0 . 31 . 9 4 11 0 . 16 . 56 . 7. 4 1 27 4 . 5 5 34 . 3 8 24 0 . 28 . 76 8 . 89 . 3 8 18 3 . 23 . 13 8 . 17 . 69 2 . 92 . 36 6 . 51 . 8 8 84 . 13 . 4 4 42 8 . 73 . 35 4 . 59 . 42 9 . 5 0 65 . 4 4 24 1 . 6 4 31 . 8 0 67 3 . 84 . 3 4 (1 8 . 23 ) (2 . 12 ) 47 6 . 55 . 4 8 90 . 11 . 8 1 22 7 . 28 . 55 6 . 5 3 74 . 34 0 . 48 . 19 5 . 3 8 31 . 1 9 71 2 . 12 2 . 38 0 . 5 6 63 . (1 7 6 . 3 0 ) (2 6 . 86 ) 59 1 . 5 6 77 . 50 0 . 62 . 22 1 . 4 2 25 . 45 3 . 52 . 79 9 . 10 0 . 4 6 AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 1 Ma r - 20 T o t a l 51 3 61 4 $ 05 6 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 20 T o t a l 36 7 75 8 $ 76 1 . 1 9 Ca s e 1 Ma y - 20 T o t a l 57 3 00 7 $ 37 8 . Ca s e 1 Ju n - 20 T o t a l 89 3 87 1 $ 24 8 . Ca s e 1 Ju l - 20 T o t a l 24 3 59 4 $ 42 0 . Ca s e 1 Au g - 20 T o t a l 12 0 22 1 $ 96 6 . Ca s e 1 Se p - 20 T o t a l 66 9 82 4 $ 42 7 . Ca s e 1 Oc t - 20 T o t a l 49 4 39 7 $ 32 7 . 4 3 Ca s e 1 No v - 20 T o t a l 51 3 66 8 $ 27 6 . Ca s e 1 De c - 20 T o t a l 75 9 80 8 $ 37 6 . Ca s e l Ja n - 21 T o t a l 78 5 36 3 $ 80 8 . 5 2 Ca s e 1 Fe b - 21 T o t a l 52 2 47 0 $ 62 8 . Ca s e 1 Ma r - 21 T o t a l 53 9 , 67 7 $ 34 5 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 21 T o t a l 39 1 56 3 $ 79 0 . Ca s e 1 Ma y - 21 T o t a l 60 0 41 0 $ 18 3 . 4 1 Ca s e 1 Ju n - 21 T o t a l 92 7 66 6 $ 70 1 . 6 9 Ca s e 1 Ju l - 21 T o t a l 28 6 17 5 $ 10 6 23 7 . 5 0 Ca s e 1 Au g - 21 T o t a l 16 1 59 2 $ 43 6 . Ca s e 1 Se p - 21 T o t a l 70 0 65 8 $ 90 9 . Ca s e 1 Oc t - 21 T o t a l 52 1 37 0 $ 68 9 . Ca s e 1 No v - 21 T o t a l 53 9 67 4 $ 54 4 . Ca s e 1 De c - 21 T o t a l 78 8 47 0 $ 37 4 . Ca s e 1 Ja n - 22 T o t a l 81 4 92 3 $ 18 0 . Ca s e 1 Fe b - 22 T o t a l 54 8 03 8 $ 53 1 . 2 8 Ca s e 1 Ma r - 22 T o t a l 56 6 01 7 $ 49 5 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 22 T o t a l 41 5 67 3 $ 44 7 . Ca s e 1 Ma y - 22 T o t a l 62 8 21 5 $ 33 3 . Ca s e 1 Ju n - 22 T o t a l 96 2 02 0 $ 10 1 47 9 . Ca s e 1 Ju l - 22 T o t a l 32 9 49 6 $ 11 2 52 3 . Ca s e 1 Au g - 2 2 T o t a l 20 3 65 6 $ 10 6 35 0 . 4 0 Ca s e 1 Se p - 22 T o t a l 73 1 96 5 $ 82 1 . 5 5 Ca s e 1 Oc t - 22 T o t a l 54 8 69 0 $ 21 7 . 3 4 Ca s e l No v - 22 T o t a l 56 5 93 8 $ 98 0 . Ca s e 1 De c - 22 T o t a l 81 7 04 1 $ 44 8 . Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R P r o j e c t On l i n e (Q ) Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 Ma r - 20 T o t a l 51 3 61 4 $ 77 2 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 20 T o t a l 36 7 75 8 $ 73 6 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 20 T o t a l 57 3 00 7 $ 91 9 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 20 T o t a l 89 3 87 1 $ 77 9 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 20 T o t a l 24 3 59 4 $ 14 0 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 20 T o t a l 12 0 22 1 $ 59 6 . 3 0 Ca s e 2 Se p - 20 T o t a l 66 9 82 4 $ 46 6 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 20 T o t a l 49 4 39 7 $ 21 2 . Ca s e 2 No v - 20 T o t a l 51 3 66 8 $ 95 2 . 4 5 Ca s e 2 De c - 20 T o t a l 75 9 80 8 $ 86 4 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 21 T o t a l 78 5 36 3 $ 91 9 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 21 T o t a l 52 2 47 0 $ 96 1 . 8 8 Ca s e 2 Ma r - 21 T o t a l 53 9 67 7 $ 10 8 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 21 T o t a l 39 1 56 3 $ 29 7 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 21 T o t a l 60 0 41 0 $ 87 8 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 2 1 T o t a l 92 7 66 6 $ 44 4 . 7 9 Ca s e 2 Ju l - 21 T o t a l 28 6 17 5 $ 10 5 , 88 5 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 21 T o t a l 16 1 59 2 $ 08 1 . 6 2 Ca s e 2 Se p - 21 T o t a l 70 0 65 8 $ 87 3 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 21 T o t a l 52 1 37 0 $ 40 8 . Ca s e 2 No v - 21 T o t a l 53 9 , 67 4 $ 18 6 . Ca s e 2 De c - 21 T o t a l 78 8 47 0 $ 85 8 . 3 8 Ca s e 2 Ja n - 22 T o t a l 81 4 92 3 $ 82 3 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 22 T o t a l 54 8 03 8 $ 29 8 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 22 T o t a l 56 6 01 7 $ 38 5 . 4 3 Ca s e 2 Ap r - 22 T o t a l 41 5 67 3 $ 41 5 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 22 T o t a l 62 8 21 5 $ 09 3 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 22 T o t a l 96 2 02 0 $ 10 1 19 0 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 22 T o t a l 32 9 , 49 6 $ 11 2 36 1 . 1 0 Ca s e 2 Au g - 22 T o t a l 20 3 65 6 $ 10 6 28 1 . 7 0 Ca s e 2 Se p - 22 T o t a l 73 1 96 5 $ 79 , 73 9 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 22 T o t a l 54 8 69 0 $ 24 6 . Ca s e 2 No v - 22 T o t a l 56 5 93 8 $ 76 7 . Ca s e 2 De c - 22 T o t a l 81 7 04 1 $ 94 5 . Pa g e 6 o f 8 lD A l t O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 9 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h Av o i d e d C o s t US G e o R R ) ($ / M W h ) 28 3 . 35 . 25 . 45 8 . 64 . 46 9 . 74 . 28 0 . 48 . 37 0 . 62 . (3 8 . 4 8 ) (5 . 86 ) 11 5 . 15 . 32 4 . 40 . 51 1 . 9 6 59 . 88 8 . 5 4 10 3 . 3 7 66 6 . 86 . 23 6 . 29 . 4 1 49 2 . 65 . 30 4 . 43 . 25 6 . 41 . 0 1 35 1 . 6 0 60 . 35 5 . 59 . 4 4 (9 6 4 . 3 1 ) (1 4 6 . 92 ) 28 1 . 5 3 37 . 35 8 . 44 . 51 5 . 60 . 35 7 . 41 . 5 9 23 2 . 5 8 30 . 10 9 . 13 . 32 . 24 0 . 34 . 28 8 . 4 0 46 . 16 2 . 4 0 28 . 68 . 11 . 5 0 82 . 12 . 5 0 (2 8 . 75 ) (3 . 78 ) 21 3 . 26 . 50 3 . 58 . AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US Ge o t h e r m a I R a f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 1 Ja n - 23 T o t a l 84 3 80 6 $ 04 2 . Ca s e 1 Fe b - 23 T o t a l 57 3 01 6 $ 27 3 . 4 8 Ca s e 1 Ma r - 23 T o t a l 59 1 74 2 $ 69 7 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 23 T o t a l 43 9 24 8 $ 52 1 . 7 2 Ca s e 1 Ma y - 23 T o t a l 65 5 51 0 $ 44 5 . 4 5 Ca s e 1 Ju n - 23 T o t a l 99 5 94 8 $ 10 5 21 0 . Ca s e 1 Ju l - 23 T o t a l 37 2 46 7 $ 11 7 86 8 . Ca s e 1 Au g - 23 T o t a l 24 5 35 8 $ 11 0 99 9 . Ca s e l Se p - 2 3 T o t a l 76 2 80 6 $ 04 4 . Ca s e 1 Oc t - 23 T o t a l 57 5 44 0 $ 31 2 . Ca s e 1 No v - 23 T o t a l 59 1 58 6 $ 34 4 . Ca s e 1 De c - 23 T o t a l 84 5 21 0 $ 01 9 . Ca s e 1 Ja n - 24 T o t a l 87 3 , 13 0 $ 44 4 . Ca s e 1 Fe b - 24 T o t a l 65 3 68 5 $ 92 8 . Ca s e 1 Ma r - 24 T o t a l 61 7 84 7 $ 48 0 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 24 T o t a l 46 3 18 2 $ 56 3 . Ca s e 1 Ma y - 24 T o t a l 68 3 28 6 $ 52 9 . Ca s e 1 Ju n - 24 T o t a l 03 0 57 0 $ 10 8 22 9 . 3 0 Ca s e 1 Ju l - 24 T o t a l 41 6 39 5 $ 12 1 39 1 . 0 0 Ca s e 1 Au g - 24 T o t a l 28 7 95 0 $ 11 3 73 4 . Ca s e 1 Se p - 24 T o t a l 79 4 20 6 $ 18 4 . Ca s e 1 Oc t - 24 T o t a l 60 2 58 8 $ 37 2 . Ca s e 1 No v - 24 T o t a l 61 7 58 2 $ 33 7 . Ca s e 1 De c - 24 T o t a l 87 3 74 8 $ 22 3 . Ca s e 1 Ja n - 25 T o t a l 90 2 58 4 $ 07 4 . 5 9 Ca s e 1 Fe b - 25 T o t a l 62 3 84 8 $ 73 5 . 3 0 Ca s e 1 Ma r - 25 T o t a l 64 4 09 7 $ 95 3 . Ca s e 1 Ap r - 25 T o t a l 48 7 28 0 $ 38 5 . Ca s e 1 Ma y - 25 T o t a l 71 1 28 4 $ 14 7 . Ca s e 1 Ju n - 25 T o t a l 06 5 52 5 $ 11 3 75 1 . 6 0 Ca s e 1 Ju l - 25 T o t a l 46 0 81 2 $ 12 8 13 6 . Ca s e 1 Au g - 25 T o t a l 33 1 01 3 $ 12 0 56 0 . Ca s e 1 Se p - 25 T o t a l 82 5 88 8 $ 65 5 . Ca s e l Oc t - 25 T o t a l 62 9 92 5 $ 40 3 . Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R P r o j e c t O n l i n e (Q ) Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ( $ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 Ja n - 23 T o t a l 84 3 80 6 $ 37 5 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 23 T o t a l 57 3 01 6 $ 89 8 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 23 T o t a l 59 1 74 2 $ 85 3 . 4 8 Ca s e 2 Ap r - 23 T o t a l 43 9 24 8 $ 60 8 . 5 9 Ca s e 2 Ma y - 23 T o t a l 65 5 51 0 $ 97 2 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 23 T o t a l 99 5 94 8 $ 10 4 76 0 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 23 T o t a l 37 2 46 7 $ 11 7 26 3 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 23 T o t a l 24 5 35 8 $ 11 0 46 4 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 23 T o t a l 76 2 80 6 $ 63 1 . 8 7 Ca s e 2 Oc t - 23 T o t a l 57 5 , 44 0 $ 22 0 . Ca s e 2 No v - 23 T o t a l 59 1 58 6 $ 66 4 . Ca s e 2 De c - 23 T o t a l 84 5 21 0 $ 33 9 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 24 T o t a l 87 3 13 0 $ 86 3 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 24 T o t a l 65 3 68 5 $ 80 5 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 24 T o t a l 61 7 84 7 $ 76 9 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 24 T o t a l 46 3 18 2 $ 99 2 . Ca s e 2 Ma y - 24 T o t a l 68 3 28 6 $ 12 9 . Ca s e 2 Ju n - 24 T o t a l 03 0 57 0 $ 10 8 13 7 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 24 T o t a l 41 6 39 5 $ 12 0 91 9 . Ca s e 2 Au g - 2 4 T o t a l 28 7 95 0 $ 11 3 48 4 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 24 T o t a l 79 4 20 6 $ 02 5 . 4 1 Ca s e 2 Oc t - 24 T o t a l 60 2 58 8 $ 96 8 . Ca s e 2 No v - 24 T o t a l 61 7 58 2 $ 15 7 . Ca s e 2 De c - 24 T o t a l 87 3 74 8 $ 55 6 . Ca s e 2 Ja n - 25 T o t a l 90 2 58 4 $ 79 9 . Ca s e 2 Fe b - 25 T o t a l 62 3 84 8 $ 42 6 . Ca s e 2 Ma r - 25 T o t a l 64 4 09 7 $ 28 9 . Ca s e 2 Ap r - 25 T o t a l 48 7 28 0 $ 40 1 . 3 4 Ca s e 2 Ma y - 25 T o t a l 71 1 28 4 $ 80 3 . 3 7 Ca s e 2 Ju n - 25 T o t a l 06 5 52 5 $ 11 3 62 3 . Ca s e 2 Ju l - 25 T o t a l 46 0 81 2 $ 12 7 76 0 . 4 0 Ca s e 2 Au g - 25 T o t a l 33 1 01 3 $ 12 0 36 4 . Ca s e 2 Se p - 25 T o t a l 82 5 88 8 $ 51 4 . Ca s e 2 Oc t - 25 T o t a l 62 9 92 5 $ 12 9 . 7 9 Pa g e 7 o f 8 lD A l t O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 98 6 59 6 59 6 96 2 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 3 59 9 98 6 59 6 59 6 68 8 05 2 47 1 07 2 26 5 80 1 97 6 56 4 59 8 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h Av o i d e d C o s t US G e o R R ) ($ / M W h ) 66 7 . 77 . 37 5 . 48 . 84 3 . 7 4 10 4 . (8 6 . 87 ) (1 1 . 6 3 ) 47 3 . 3 6 66 . 44 9 . 71 . 7 5 60 4 . 3 0 10 4 . 53 4 . 89 . 41 2 . 4 0 62 . 92 . 12 . 68 0 . 85 . 68 0 . 79 . 58 0 . 67 . 5 6 12 2 . 15 . 4 4 71 0 . 3 7 88 . 57 0 . 76 . 40 0 . 3 0 56 . 91 . 6 0 14 . 47 2 . 81 . 3 7 24 9 . 41 . 15 9 . 24 . 3 1 40 4 . 53 . 18 0 . 4 8 22 . 66 7 . 4 8 77 . 27 5 . 4 5 32 . 30 8 . 4 1 40 . 66 4 . 82 . (1 5 . 52 ) (2 . 08 ) 34 4 . 4 9 48 . 12 7 . 20 . 3 8 37 5 . 64 . 19 6 . 32 . 14 0 . 21 . 4 5 27 4 . 36 . AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US Ge o t h e r m a I R a f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 ID A H O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y AU R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o O u t p u t a n d Av o i d e d C o s t C a l c u l a t i o n s Ba s e C a s e w i t h US G e o R R P r o j e c t On l i n e (Q ) Ze r o C o s t Ti m e Co s t ($ x Ru n I D Pe r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 2 No v - 25 T o t a l 64 3 , 69 5 $ 57 6 . Ca s e 2 De c - 25 T o t a l 90 2 03 6 $ 91 7 . Ba s e C a s e * Co s t ($ x Ru n I D Ti m e P e r i o d It e m En e r g y 00 0 ) Ca s e 1 No v - 25 T o t a l 64 3 69 5 $ 30 6 . Ca s e 1 De c - 2 5 T o t a l 90 2 03 6 $ 78 9 . No t e s : * Co n d i t i o n s : Si m u l a t i o n : Ab b r e v i a t i o n s : Re v i s e d : En e r g y Ou t p u t o f US G e o R R (M W h ) 98 6 59 6 Co s t Di f f e r e n c e (B C - B C w i t h U5 G e o R R ) $ 7 3 0 . $ 8 7 2 . Av o i d e d C o s t ($ / M W h ) 91 . 4 8 10 1 . 4 6 Al l v a l u e s a v e r a g e d o v e r a l l h o u r s o f s i m u l a t i o n Ba s e c a s e i n c l u d e s a l l e x i s t i n g a n d c o m m i t t e d r e s o u r c e s a s o f J a n u a r y 1 , 2 0 0 4 . Ba s e c a s e i n c l u d e s P o r t f o l i o 1 1 r e s o u r c e s a n d DS M p r o g r a m s a s o u t l i n e d i n I P C ' s 2 0 0 4 I n t e g r a t e d Re s o u r c e P l a n ( I R P ) . IP C L T re s o u r c e s a d d e d t o I P C a r e a s t a r t i n g i n 2 0 1 4 . EP I S d e f a u l t L T r e s o u r c e s u s e d f o r a l l o t h e r a r e a s . Fo r L T r u n s ( a s r e c o m m e n d e d b y EP I S t o a v o i d d e m a n d s i d e c u r t a i l m e n t i n po r t f o l i o a n a l y s i s ) , t h e f i x e d c o s t s o f n e w r e s o u r c e o p t i o n s w e r e r e d u c e d b y $ 6 0 0 j M W j W e e k . Th e f i x e d c o s t s o f e x i s t i n g r e s o u r c e s w e r e r e d u c e d b y $ 2 5 0 j M W j W e e k . Al l f i x e d c o s t s w e r e r e t u r n e d t o o r i g i n a l v a l u e s f o r p o r t f o l i o r u n s . Po r t f o l i o a n a l y s i s w a s f o r y e a r s 2 0 0 6 t h r o u g h 2 0 2 5 . L T ru n w a s f o r y e a r s 2 0 0 6 t h r o u g h 2 0 3 0 a s r e c o m m e n d e d b y EP I S . Th e a d d i t i o n a l f i v e y e a r s a l l o w s f o r a d e q u a t e r e s o u r c e b u i l d - ou t t h r o u g h t h e p o r t f o l i o p l a n n i n g pe r i o d . Al l c o s t s n o m i n a l . 50 t h p e r c e n t i l e h y d r o c o n d i t i o n s , 5 0 t h p e r c e n t i l e l o a d s . Ev e r y 3 r d h o u r , M W F S u , e v e r y w e e k , J a n . 2 0 0 6 - De e . 2 0 2 5 BC - B a s e c a s e IR P - I n t e g r a t e d R e s o u r c e P l a n L T - L o n g T e r m US G e o R R - U S G e o t h e r m a l R a f t R i v e r Pr o j e c t Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 Pa g e 8 o f 8 AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . ... . . . . . $( 1 0 0 ) $( 1 5 0 ) $3 0 0 $2 5 0 $2 0 0 $1 5 0 US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r A v o i d e d C o s t V a l u e s b y M o n t h Fr o m A U R O R A x m p Po r t f o l i o A n a l y s i s "- ~ - - - - - - - - ~ _ . - -- - - -- - - - " ~ -" - , .- - - - - - - . .-. -- - - . - -- - - - - - - - -- n - - -. - . - - - - . _ _ _m _ .n _ - - - - - -_ _ _ . _ . m _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ n . _ __ _ _ .- - - - - - - - - u - -- - - - - - . - - - -- - - - . - -- . - . _- - - - _ . . . . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . -- . - - - -. .- . . - - . . $1 0 0 $5 0 - i -- - - ~~ o o o o o o ~ ~ ~ O O - - - N N N M M M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ O O O O O O ~~ 00 0 - - ~M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ i 50 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ N N N N N ~ N N N N N N N N N N N N i I , ~~ ~~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~~ C ~ ~~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ C ~ ~ , ro ~~ ro ~ ro r o ~ r o ro ~ ro r o ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ ro r o ~ r o r o ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ ro r o ~ r o ro ~ r o ro ~ ! ~~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ $( 5 0 ) - - n n _ n _ _- - _ - - - d . .. . n - - - - - - - - _ m __ _ nn - n - ._ . _ m . . . _ _ - u_ _ _.m n o _ _ n - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - . . - . - -- - .n . - _ - - -- - - .._ n n . . - ._ _ _ . n . - - un _ - - - - - - - _ n_ m n _ _ __ _ _ - _~ - nn _ _ _ _ n _ _ _ _ n _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ n . n _ _m _ m n - .- - . - - - - -- ~ " ~ - - " - - ~ / _ - - " " - - _ / ~ _ / ~ - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - Mo n t h / Y e a r ._ - - - - - ~ ~ ~ - - - - _ / _ - " - - ~ - - ~ - - - - ~ - - - _ / _ - " - - - - - - - _ / _ - - " - - " - - - - - -- 1 IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f Fi r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - 0 4 - 8 / I P C - E - 04 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 . A v o i d e d C o s t ($ / M W h ) Id a h o P o w e r C o m p a n y AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1. 0 . US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f F i r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 ID A H O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y AU R O R A x m p L o n g - T e r m R u n : Re s o u r c e O n l i n e D a t e s f o r I P C Ca s e 1 - U S G e o t h e r m a l R R OF F - L I N E Re s o u r c e O n l i n e D a t e s Ye a r Re s o u r c e 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 To t a l Co a l 2 5 0 M W 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 75 0 CC C T 2 7 0 M W Ge o t h e r m a l 5 0 M W 85 0 Wi n d 1 0 0 M W 10 0 10 0 10 0 30 0 CH P 6 M W SC C T 4 4 M W SC C T 1 6 2 M W 16 2 16 2 To t a l f o r Y e a r 40 0 40 6 40 6 30 6 30 0 30 0 30 0 21 2 08 0 Re s o u r c e R u n n i n a T o t a l s Ye a r Re s o u r c e 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 Co a l 2 5 0 M W 25 0 50 0 75 0 10 0 0 12 5 0 15 0 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 CC C T 2 7 0 M W Ge o t h e r m a l 5 0 M W 10 0 15 0 20 0 25 0 30 0 35 0 40 0 45 0 50 0 55 0 60 0 65 0 70 0 75 0 80 0 85 0 Wi n d 1 0 0 M W 10 0 20 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 CH P 6 M W SC C T 4 4 M W SC C T 1 6 2 M W 16 2 Su m o f R u n n i n g T o t a l s 40 0 80 6 21 2 51 8 81 8 11 8 41 8 46 8 51 8 56 8 61 8 66 8 71 8 76 8 81 8 86 8 08 0 Lo n g T e r m R e s o u r c e T o t a l s Ca s e 1 - U S G e o t h e r m a l R a f t R i v e r OF F - L I N E 50 0 25 0 - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - 00 0 - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - 2, 7 5 0 50 0 25 0 00 0 ~ 1 75 0 - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -- - - -- - - - - 50 0 25 0 00 0 75 0 50 0 25 0 ~~ ~ ~ ~~ - . ~ - - =- ~ - =- . SC C T 4 4 M W . S C C T 1 6 2 CH P 6 M W . W i n d 1 0 0 Ge o t h e r m a l 5 0 M W II C C C T 2 7 0 M W I: C o a l 2 5 0 M W 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 Ye a r AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1.0 . US G e o t h e r m a l Ra f t R i v e r P r o j e c t IP C o R e s p o n s e t o I P U C S t a f f F i r s t P r o d u c t i o n R e q u e s t Ca s e N o . I P C - E - O 4 - 8 / I P C - E - O 4 - 1 0 Au g u s t 3 0 , 2 0 0 4 ID A H O P O W E R An I D A C O R P Co m p a n y AU R O R A x m p L o n g - T e r m R u n : R e s o u r c e O n l i n e Da t e s f o r I P C Ca s e 2 - US G e o t h e r m a l R R O N - L I N E Re s o u r c e O n l i n e D a t e s Ye a r Re s o u r c e 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 To t a l Co a l 2 5 0 M W 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 25 0 75 0 CC C T 2 7 0 M W Ge o t h e r m a l 5 0 M W 85 0 Win d 1 0 0 M W 10 0 10 0 10 0 30 0 CH P 6 M W SC C T 4 4 M W SC C T 1 6 2 M W To t a l f o r Y e a r 40 6 40 6 40 0 30 6 30 0 30 0 30 0 91 8 Re s o u r c e R u n n i n a T o t a l s Ye a r Re s o u r c e 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 Co a l 2 5 0 M W 25 0 50 0 75 0 10 0 0 12 5 0 15 0 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 17 5 0 CC C T 2 7 0 M W Ge o t h e r m a l 5 0 M W 10 0 15 0 20 0 25 0 30 0 35 0 40 0 45 0 50 0 55 0 60 0 65 0 70 0 75 0 80 0 85 0 Win d 1 0 0 M W 10 0 20 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 30 0 CH P 6 M W SC C T 4 4 M W SC C T 1 6 2 M W Su m o f R u n n i n g T o t a l s 40 6 81 2 21 2 51 8 81 8 11 8 41 8 46 8 51 8 56 8 61 8 66 8 71 8 76 8 81 8 86 8 91 8 Lo n g T e r m R e s o u r c e T o t a l s Ca s e 2 - US G e o t h e r m a l R a f t Ri v e r O N - L I N E 50 0 -- - - - , 25 0 - - - - - - , - - - - - 00 0 - - -- - . _ _ _ . __ n -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 75 0 - - - _ - - - - _ n -_ - _ , _ . _ - - . - . - - - -- - - - -, - - 50 0 - -- - 25 0 - - - - - - 00 0 -- - - - - - - ~ 1 75 0 - - - - - - - - -- - - - 50 0 - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - _. . . . 25 0 00 0 75 0 50 0 25 0 -- - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - SC C T 4 4 M W . S C C T 1 6 2 CH P 6 M W . W i n d 1 0 0 Ge o t h e r m a l 5 0 M W II C C C T 2 7 0 M W :: : C o a l 2 5 0 M W 20 1 4 20 1 5 20 1 6 20 1 7 20 1 8 20 1 9 20 2 0 20 2 1 20 2 2 Ye a r 20 2 3 20 2 4 20 2 5 20 2 6 20 2 7 20 2 8 20 2 9 20 3 0 AU R O R A x m p V e r . 7 . 1.0 .