Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20261116Comments_3.pdf Name: John Katovich Submission Time: Nov 14 2026 10:19PM Name of Utility Company: Avista Case ID: AVU-E-26-10 Comment: "ID the project proposed byAvista is concerning on several fronts. From a safety aspect, it puts all the residents in the vicinity at risk of loss of life and property by fire directly caused by elevated power lines through thick timber. The secondary risk to the area residents is related to the policy the power company has to shut off power during storms. I suppose that's an admission of their guilt to the causes of some of the significant fires the country has suffered the past fewyears. ( Maui , California etc)The fix is simple to me. Bury Lines Through Timbered Regions. This fix is noted byAvista itself, its plan to bury existing elevated lines in the Spokane area that are already in place. It seems that all new lines should be buried especially in timbered areas. A second point is from an economic concern of all the residents affected by the proposed lines. The negative effect on property values which can't be underestimated.The real possibility of the loss of fire insurance which has happened in several areas of the country. There is also the negative effect on the environment, looking at power poles and lines through your property and across the beautiful north Idaho terrain. It seems development of north Idaho is pushed by the almighty dollar for the few developers that have no concerns for the water table `which is very poor' in the area of concern. Many of the homesites along this proposed area have very Little water. With some residents with very expensive dry wells. Maybe the answer is to pull back on the reins, evaluate the devastation that this project may cause to those that live here along the route,with no benefit since the power here is not supplied by Avista.The bottom line to me is that all power lines from this day forward should be buried in timbered regions of a state that's main industry is timber. Too simple?John" -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Angie Morrow Submission Time: Nov 15 2026 9:28PM Name of Utility Company: Kootenai Electric Case ID: AVU-E-26-10 Comment: "To whom it concerns (mostly land owners): As a landowner whose property right-of-way is being taken over, I have many complaints. When we purchased our property, we had all of our power lines buried; a costly process, but one that kept the beauty of our place, and kept us out of fire danger, caused by power Lines. Avista is now bringing that fire danger back to our land, (which raises our property insurance rates;you've seen all the fires power companies have started all over California and other states!)Avista has publicly stated that they will be turning power off during 1 windstorms, so as not to start fires. They KNOW their lines start fires. And then, the ugliness of making lines visible after the fact. Unfair and a waste of the costs we originally paid. We also have many old trees,which are trees the owls prefer.We have seen many different owls on our property and by removing these for a seventy-five foot easement, we will lose much of that.We consider our property a preserve for wildlife as we don't hunt, nor allow any hunting on our land. These power-line easements allow easy access to hunters who trespass through private properties that otherwise don't exist. That is also unfair and invites more problems for us landowners. Also, in case people are unaware, every extra line placed on Avista power poles below the actual"power lines"are lines used by companies who pay Avista to run telecommunications lines, internet providers and cable services. The landowner should receive fair value for money being made on the use of property being taken for ANY purpose. Avista is also requesting use of entire property to access right-of-way. Their access should ONLY BE UNDER THEIR POWER LINES.They should be required to put up locked gates at every ingress and egress site. Our property is PRIVATE property we pay taxes for. They are already taking property under the easement to cross our beautiful land, isn't this enough? How would you like this in your yard? No one but us drives our roads, rides horses on our roads, bicycle on our roads, walks our dogs on our roads, now we have to watch for traffic coming and going on our roads ?Who will pay to maintain our roads from use of vehicles coming and going over our dirt roads? Pot holes we now maintain will be worse due to their equipment and who pays to fix?We do. The easements Avista wants will also run through our hayfield. Do you know how impossible it would be to run hay equipment around power poles to fertilize and cut and bale hay?We will lose hay yearly, and as hay prices go up, our intake of hay will be lost to feed our animals.Who compensates us for this expense? Avista should be using the right of way following Highway 97. They already have power lines on it, and no one else has to suffer from all this hassle. A much better fix for all involved, and since the lines run there already, they can manage their lines without introducing more Lines for fire danger. And finally, the easements Avista wants us to sign states"MUTUAL BENEFIT", I'd like to know how this benefits us?We don't even use Avista power, we use Kootenai Electric, and we receive no free power for taking our property!There should be benefits to land owners who lose property and their rights. I know if you are negotiating a new easement, you can 2 request compensation for the full value of the property to which the easement is requiring access. Now pay a lawyer to fight for these rights. Angie Lee Morrow" -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Philip Acosta Submission Time: Nov 16 2026 8:26AM Name of Utility Company:Avista Case ID: AVU-E-26-10 Comment: "As a landowner in the Black Lake area of Kootenai County I would like to comment against the current alignment of the planned Carlin Bay-O'Gara transmission Line. My family has been on this land for approximately one hundred years. We love this lake property for the memory's through the generations from my great grand father passing it along and now to me the current family elder. It is private and reserved, our own little sanctuary in paradise and we have always been good stewards carefully thinning and allowing game to run free with no hunting allowed on this approximately 120 acres The alignment that Avista has chosen appears to be the shortest between two points but certainly not the most community or environmentally friendly. It comes down off Harrison Flats makes a ninety degree turn down through two heavely wooded canyons with environmentally sensitive streams cutting a huge swath which would cause significant spring runoff with the potential of flooding our property down below. The unsightliness of the huge transmission poles and draping humming power lines being a constant irritant especially during precipitation and this is not temporary situation. The alignment of this transmission line, once approved, will affect this area for many lifetimes. Avista could very easily follow the corridor Highway 97 takes which travels between Carlin- Bay and O'Gara without needing many if any easements and no unsightly lines or poles dropped across residents properties. Another option would be to bury the cable which in today's world of climate change would provide protection from wind and fire, lower property values unsightliness and higher insurance rates. Avista has already paid multiple property owners for easements which is a bit surprising as one would think they would wait to have your blessings for the route they have chosen. In our case we've had to hire counsel to assist us with the legalese of all the documents that were put before us.The compensation offered for a full easement across our 37 1/2 acre lot was beyond lowballing and wouldn't cover the cost of our attorney. 3 Pease allow yourself the opportunity to examine the route of this transmission line and its long term effects on current and future residents and ask yourself if this route is the best solution for all involved Respectfully Philip N Acosta Parcel#47NO3W029700 LT 9 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4