Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20261112Staff Comments - Redacted.pdf RECEIVED November 12, 2026 IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION JEFFREY R. LOLL DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION PO BOX 83720 BOISE, IDAHO 83702 (208) 334-0357 IDAHO BAR NO. 11675 Attorney for the Commission Staff BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF IDAHO POWER ) COMPANY'S APPLICATION FOR ) CASE NO. IPC-E-26-24 APPROVAL OF THE THIRD AMENDMENT ) TO THE POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENT ) BETWEEN IDAHO POWER COMPANY AND ) REDACTED COMMENTS OF TELOCASET WIND POWER PARTNERS, ) THE COMMISSION STAFF LLC ) COMMISSION STAFF ("STAFF") OF the Idaho Public Utilities Commission ("Commission"), by and through its attorney of record, Jeffrey R. Loll, Deputy Attorney General, submits the following comments. BACKGROUND On August 25, 2026, Idaho Power Company ("Company") applied to the Commission requesting an order approving the Third Amendment("Third Amendment")to the Power Purchase Agreement ("PPA") between the Company and Telocaset Wind Power Partners, LLC ("Seller") (collectively, "Parties"), which would extend the term of the PPA and update the pricing schedule ("Application"). The Commission approved the original 20-year PPA between the Company and Seller for the purchase and sale of energy generated at the Elkhorn Wind Park ("Facility") in 2007. Order No. 30259. The PPA is scheduled to expire on December 31, 2027. The PPA contains Post-Operation Date Pricing and Post-Operation Date Alternative Pricing. Since February 2012, the Company has been using the Post-Operation Date Alternative STAFF COMMENTS 1 NOVEMBER 12, 2026 Pricing. The Parties agreed to extend the Post-Operation Date Alternative Pricing for five years based on negotiated prices, with an option to extend the PPA for an additional five years under terms to be negotiated prior to the expiration of the Third Amendment. STAFF ANALYSIS To determine whether the Third Amendment is reasonable, Staff focused on the following areas in its analysis: • whether the Company has adequately justified the need for the extension of the PPA from 2028 through 2032; • whether the expense of purchasing energy from the Facility is prudent; and • whether the provisions of the Third Amendment accurately reflect the Parties' intentions. As a result of its review, Staff recommends that the Commission approve the Third Amendment to the PPA. Capacity Needs Since this Facility is not a qualifying facility under the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act, it is not mandatory for the Company to purchase the energy from the Facility. However, the Company's capacity deficits in 2028 and beyond prompted the Company to acquire resources to meet its capacity needs. Application at 3. Table No. 1 below shows the Company's most recent capacity positions from 2028 through 2032 without the extension of the PPA. Response to Staff Production Request No. 1. Staff believes that the Company's need for new resources from 2028 through 2032 is justified. [REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK] STAFF COMMENTS 2 NOVEMBER 12, 2026 Table No. 1: The Company's Most Recent Capacity Positions' Year Capacity Positions (megawatts) 2028 -177 2029 -166 2030 -120 2031 -415 2032 -614 The Facility has a nameplate capacity of 101 megawatts. 2025 Integrated Resource Plan at 41. Table No. 2 below lists the Facility's capacity contribution factor each year and how much capacity the Facility can reliably provide to the system each year. Table No. 2: Capacity Contribution Factors and Capacity Contribution Amounts Year Capacity Contribution Factor? Capacity Contribution Amounts (megawatts) 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 Prudence Analysis Staff evaluated whether the expense of purchasing energy from the Facility under the Third Amendment is prudent based on four comparisons: (1) a comparison with the Jackalope wind project, (2) a comparison with other wind projects in the Company's recent Request for Proposals ("UP"), (3) a comparison with other alternatives that could come online in 2028 that were included in the Company's 2028 RFP Final Shortlist, and(4) a comparison between the Facility's 'These annual capacity positions are calculated based on the inclusion of the Bluebird solar-plus-storage project in pending Case No.IPC-E-26-20 and a new large load anticipated to come online in 2029 that will ramp up to full load in 2032. Response to Staff Production Request No. 1. 2 Response to Staff Production Request No.3. STAFF COMMENTS 3 NOVEMBER 12, 2026 value relative to its cost. Based on these four comparisons, Staff believes that the cost of purchasing energy from the Facility is prudent. Comparison with Jackalope Although the Jackalope project was never constructed, Staff believes the price of the project represented a recent market alternative that was likely to be built, had it not experienced permitting issues.3 From 2028 through 2032, Jackalope's annual price was- higher than the Facility's annual price under the Third Amendment. Response to Staff Production Request No. 6. The Jackalope project consisted of two parts: (1) a PPA, and (2) a Build Transfer Agreement. Id. The annual price of the Jackalope project reflected the all-in price inclusive of both contracts. Id. Since the Jackalope project represented a recent market alternative that was likely to be built, Staff believes it provides a good comparison to the proposed annual price under the Third Amendment. Comparison with Other Wind Projects Staff also compared the Facility with other wind projects in the 2028 RFP Final Shortlist, the 2032 RFP Initial Shortlist, and the 2032 RFP Final Shortlist. Staff believes that wind projects in these lists represent market alternatives that are possible to be built to meet the Company's capacity needs in the near future. The bids in these lists range fron=�to-higher than the Facility's price. Response to Staff Production Request No. 5. Because the price of the proposed annual price under the Third Amendment was least-cost among all these wind projects, Staff believes that the price of the Facility is competitive compared to other wind projects. Comparison to Other Alternatives with 2028 Online Dates In addition, Staff compared the prices of projects of other energy-generating technologies included in the Company's 2028 RFP Final Shortlist that were available to come online in 2028. Company Witness Hackett Direct Testimony Exhibit No. 2 (Case No. IPC-E-26-20). Among all 3 Staff recommended approval of the Jackalope project in Case No. IPC-E-24-46,and the Commission approved the project in Order No.36659. Subsequently,the Company requested withdrawal of the project in Case No.IPC-E-25- 28,because the planned commercial operation date could not be met due to permitting delays and uncertainty around federal land use policies. On December 31,2025,the Commission approved the withdrawal in Order No.36893. STAFF COMMENTS 4 NOVEMBER 12, 2026 the energy-generating projects of various types of technologies included in the 2028 RFP Final Shortlist, a solar project is the only remaining project with an online date in 2028. Since the solar project is the last alternative in the 2028 RFP Final Shortlist that could be acquired by the Company in 2028, Staff believes it serves as a meaningful comparison to evaluate the proposed price under the Third Amendment. The comparison shows that the proposed Facility's annual price is 8.8% lower than the solar project's annual price. Because of the lower cost, Staff believes this additional comparison provides further evidence that the proposed price under the Third Amendment is competitive. Comparison Between Values and Costs Lastly, Staff compared the cost of the Third Amendment to the value of energy, capacity, and renewable energy credits ("RECs") that the Company will receive from the Facility. If approved,the Company will incur a total cost of abou while receiving a total value from the Facility of about from 2028 through 2032. Response to Staff Production Request No. 7. Given the difference between the value and the cost, Staff believes that purchasing energy from the Facility is prudent. The total value of the Facility is the sum of the value of energy, capacity, and RECs generated from the Facility over the proposed term. The value of energy i , which is calculated based on the Mid-Columbia market price forecast from the 2025 Integrated Resource Plan ("IRP") multiplied by the Facility's generation amounts. Id. The value of capacity is - which is calculated based on a simple cycle combustion turbine plant, the least-cost capacity resource in the preferred portfolio of the 2025 IRP. Id. The value of RECs is - which is calculated based on a REC price forecast multiplied by the Facility's generation amounts. Id. The cost of the Facility is calculated based on its contract price multiplied by the Facility's generation amounts. Id. Provisions of Third Amendment Staff reviewed the provisions of the Third Amendment, with a focus on the provisions related to Article 4.1.1, Article 4.1.2, and Appendix A of the original PPA. Staff believes that the provisions accurately reflect the Parties' intention to extend the PPA for five years using the STAFF COMMENTS 5 NOVEMBER 12, 2026 negotiated prices, with an option to extend the PPA for another five years beyond the first five- year extension to December 31, 2032, at rates, terms, and conditions to be negotiated at that time. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends that the Commission approve the Third Amendment to the PPA between the Company and the Seller. Respectfully submitted this 12th day of November 2026. Jeffrey R. Loll Deputy Attorney General Technical Staff. Yao Yin I:\Utility\UMISC\COMMENTS\IPC-E-26-24 Comments.docx STAFF COMMENTS 6 NOVEMBER 12, 2026 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE THIS 121h DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026, SERVED THE FOREGOING REDACTED COMMENTS OF THE COMMISSION STAFF, IN CASE NO. IPC-E-26-24, BY SENDING VIA FED EX (Per IDAPA 31.01.01 Sec. 063., due to Microsoft Outlook Worldwide Global Outage) A COPY THEREOF, TO THE FOLLOWING: DONOVAN E. WALKER AND IPC DOCKETS IDAHO POWER COMPANY 1221 West Idaho Street BOISE ID 83702 - o' z t PATRICIA JORDAK, SECRETARY CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE