HomeMy WebLinkAboutAnswer to ComplaintANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 2 OF 8
BACKGROUND
5.The Company incorporates and restates its responses to Paragraphs 1 through 4.
6.The Company admits the allegations in Paragraph 6 of the Complaint.
7.In response to Paragraph 7, the Company admits only that Staff issued NOPV
Report No. I202405 relating to alleged violations of Title 49 CFR Part 192 on or about April 16,
2024, that Staff accepted the Company’s corrective response, and that Staff closed Report No.
I202405 on August 15, 2024.
8.The Company admits the allegations in Paragraph 8 of the Complaint.
9.In response to Paragraph 9, the Company admits only that Staff issued NOPV
Report No. I202504 relating to alleged violations of Title 49 CFR Part 192 on or about June 17,
2025, that Staff accepted the Company’s corrective response, and that Staff closed Report No.
I202504 on August 4, 2025.
10.The Company admits the allegations in Paragraph 10 of the Complaint.
11.The Company admits the allegations in Paragraph 11 of the Complaint.
12.The Company admits the allegations in Paragraph 12 of the Complaint.
13.In response to Paragraph 13, the Company admits only that Staff issued NOPV
Report No. I202608 relating to alleged violations of Title 49 CFR Part 192 on or about June 2,
2026.
14.The Company admits the allegations in Paragraph 14 of the Complaint.
VIOLATIONS
15.The Company incorporates and restates its responses to Paragraphs 1 through 14.
16.Paragraph 16 states legal conclusions to which no response is required. To the
extent a response is required, the Company denies the allegations.
ANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 3 OF 8
PROPOSED ACTION
CIVIL PENALTY UNDER 49 CFR 190.223
17.The Company incorporates and restates its responses to Paragraphs 1 through 16.
18.Paragraph 18 states a legal conclusion to which no response is required. To the
extent a response is required, the Company denies the allegations.
19.In response to Paragraph 19, the Company admits that Staff accepted the
Company’s corrective actions in response to NOPV Report Nos. I202405 and I202504.
Otherwise, the Company is without sufficient information or knowledge of Staff’s reasons for
accepting the Company’s corrective actions and therefore denies the same.
20.The Company is without sufficient information or knowledge to admit the
allegations in Paragraph 20 and therefore denies the same.
21.The Company denies that the maximum allowable civil penalty is warranted or
authorized in this case.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
1.In response to Paragraph 1 of the Prayer for Relief, the Company denies that the
maximum allowable civil penalty is warranted or authorized in this case.
2.In response to Paragraph 2 of the Prayer for Relief, the Company denies that the
Commission Staff is entitled to any other or further relief.
THE COMPANY’S PROCEDURAL REQUEST, FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS, AND AFFIRMATIVE
DEFENSES
Under Commission Rules of Procedure 54, 57, 201–204, and 241–260, the Company
makes the following procedural request and alleges the following facts and affirmative defenses.
ANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 4 OF 8
PROCEDURAL REQUEST
3.The Company understands that Staff has requested that this case be deemed fully
submitted upon Staff’s filing a reply to this answer.1
4.Staff requests more than $2.7 million in penalties in a Complaint that involves
technical issues, including proper operation of a pipeline and potential approaches for safely
removing lubricating oil introduced by a third party from an operating pipeline.
5.The Company submits that Staff’s proposed procedure does not comply with the
Commission’s Rules and is not adequate to resolve this proceeding.
6.Staff has indicated a willingness to work with Intermountain on an appropriate
procedure, whether by modified procedure, technical hearing, or other procedure.
7.The Company intends to work with Staff and file with the Commission a motion
or stipulation requesting a particular procedure within thirty days of this Answer.
8.The Company requests that the Commission not adopt Staff’s proposed procedure
at this time and allow thirty days for Intermountain and Staff to meet, confer, and file a
stipulation or motion regarding the proper procedure for this case.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
9.The Company alleges the following to support its affirmative defenses. These
allegations do not amount to all relevant facts, but are instead facts appropriate at the pleadings
stage of a case to support affirmative defenses under Rule 57. The Company reserves the right to
present evidence regarding all relevant facts as this case proceeds.
1 Staff made this request in its October 13, 2026 decision memorandum. It is the Company’s understanding
that the Commission approved Staff’s decision memorandum. The Commission does not appear to have issued a
written order reflecting any decision or a schedule in this proceeding.
ANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 5 OF 8
10.The Company acknowledges that lubricating oil was introduced to its pipeline.
Based on its inquiries and experience, Intermountain believes the lubricating oil was introduced
by the Williams Northwest Pipeline (Williams) compressor station.
11.Since discovering the presence of lubricating oil, Intermountain has worked in
good faith to identify the source of the oil and possible approaches to address it.
12.Intermountain’s efforts have included working with Williams to facilitate
Williams’s installation of a coalescent filter between Williams’s compressor station and
Intermountain’s pipeline.
13.Intermountain believes the filter will prevent additional lubricating oil from being
introduced into its pipeline.
14.Williams has indicated that it has secured the permits and other authorizations
necessary to begin work in November 2026. Based on current projections, filter installation is
expected to be completed in January 2027.
15.Projects on interstate pipelines require extensive engineering, permitting, and
contracting procedures. Intermountain believes that its actions, and Williams’s response times,
have been reasonable under the circumstances.
16.As it was working with Williams on a technical solution, the Company
implemented in good faith responsive actions that included increased inspections and oil
remediation. Although the Company has on occasion discovered lubricating oil in its facilities,
each time oil has been discovered, the Company has cleaned the affected facilities and left them
in good order.
17. The Company’s responsive actions were repeatedly accepted as adequate by
Staff, as indicated by the closure letters issued on or about May 23, 2024 and August 4, 2025.
ANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 6 OF 8
18.The Company’s responsive actions did not remove all lubricating oil from its
system, so the lubricating oil continued to accumulate periodically. However, ultimate removal
of the lubricating oil is not possible without installation of the coalescent filter.
19.The Company believes the filter will significantly limit the introduction of new oil
into its system. However, existing lubricating oil is likely to remain and, as such, oil is likely to
be periodically discovered at IGC facilities downstream of Williams’s custody transfer point.
20.The Company has backup systems in place, and the configuration of the system is
such that the Company does not believe the lubricating oil currently presents, or has ever
presented, a significant safety risk.
21.The Company has at all times responded to the presence of oil in an appropriate
and reasonable way that maintains the safety of its pipeline.
22.The Company is willing to work with Staff to identify and implement additional
responsive measures. However, based on the nature of the system, the Company does not believe
there is an existing technical solution that will immediately or swiftly remove all lubricating oil
from the system.
AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
23.“[T]he Commission is not empowered to assess a civil penalty.” Case No. MSW-
W-08-01, Order No. 30628 at 16 (Aug. 26, 2008). Under Idaho Code sections 61-701 and 61-
712, an action to recover penalties must be filed in district court rather than the Commission. The
Commission lacks jurisdiction to assess the civil penalty sought in the formal complaint.
24.Pursuant to Idaho Code § 61-712B, the appropriateness of the civil penalty
imposed against the Company must take into account “the gravity of the violation” and “the
good faith of the person charged in attempting to achieve compliance.” Because the Company
has, at all times, worked in good faith to remediate the presence of lubricating oil, to identify the
ANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 7 OF 8
cause of oil accumulation, and to work with the originating party to identify and implement
solutions, assessment of the maximum penalty is not appropriate. Likewise, assessment of the
maximum penalty is disproportionate to the actual safety considerations actually implicated by
accumulation of lubricating oil.
25.Idaho Code § 61-712A was revised in March 2025 to provide for increased civil
penalty amounts. The Company cannot be subject to civil penalties in excess of what was
permissible under the law in effect at the time of the alleged violations.
26.Lubricating oil is introduced by the independent actions of a third party that
Intermountain does not control. The solution needed to prevent the continued introduction of oil
is likewise within the control of an independent third party. Intermountain has reasonably
undertaken the responsive actions that are within its control.
27.Staff is estopped from imposing the maximum civil penalty, or any civil penalty,
with regard to alleged violations for which Staff accepted the Company’s responsive actions.
28.In seeking the maximum penalty Staff assumes a violation occurred every day
between inspections. However, Intermountain remediated lockup issues after every inspection
that identified oil in the system. Staff has not alleged facts supporting daily violations.
Dated: November 11, 2026
GIVENS PURSLEY LLP
By /s/ Preston N. Carter
Preston N. Carter
Megann E. Meier
Attorneys for Intermountain Gas Company
ANSWER TO FORMAL COMPLAINT PAGE 8 OF 8
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on November 11, 2026, I caused to be served a true and correct copy
of the foregoing document to the person(s) listed below by the method indicated:
Commission Staff
Monica Barrios-Sanchez, Commission Secretary
Idaho Public Utilities Commission
11331 W. Chinden Blvd., Bldg. 8, Suite 201-A
Boise, ID 83714
secretary@puc.idaho.gov
monica.barriossanchez@puc.idaho.gov
Via: IPUC eFile portal
/s/ Preston N. Carter
Preston N. Carter