Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDirect StewardPage 1 of 2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this day, I caused to be served, via email, a true and correct copy of Settlement Stipulation Testimony in Case No. PAC-E-25-14 to the following: Service List Commission Staff Jeffrey R. Loll Deputy Attorney General Idaho Public Utilities Commission 11331 W. Chinden Blvd., Bldg. No. 8 Suite 201- A 83714 PO Box 83720 Boise, ID 83720- 0074 jeff.loll@puc.idaho.gov PacifiCorp, dba Rocky Mountain Power Jana Saba 1407 West North Temple, Suite 310 Salt Lake City, UT 84116 jana.saba@pacificorp.com Ajay Kumar 1407 West North Temple, Suite 320 Salt Lake City, UT 84116 aiay.kumar@pacificorp.com Adam Lowney McDowell Rackner Gibson, PC 419 SW 11ffi Ave., Suite 400 Portland, OR 97205 adam@mrg-law.com Data Request Response Center PacifiCorp datarequest@pacificorp.com Anna DeMers 315 W. 27th St. Cheyenne, WY 82001 Anna.demers@pacificorp.com Idaho Irrigation Pumpers Association Eric L. Olsen Echo Hawk & Olsen, PLLC P.O. Box 6119 505 Pershing Ave., Suite 100 Pocatello, ID 83205 elo@echohawk.com Lance Kaufman, Ph.D. 2623 NW Bluebell Place Corvallis, OR 97330 lance@aegisinsight.com Page 2 of 2 Bayer Corporation Ethan Waltermire P4 Production, LLC P.O. Box 816 Soda Springs, ID 83276 ethan.waltermire@bayer.com Thomas J. Budge Racine Olson, PLLP P.O. Box 1391 201 E. Center Pocatello, ID 83207 tj@racineolson.com Greg Meyer Brubaker & Associates 16690 Swingley Ridge Rd # 140 Chesterfield, MO 63017 gmeyer@consultbai.com Brian C. Collins Brubaker & Associates 16690 Swingley Ridge Rd # 140 Chesterfield, MO 63017 bcollins@consultbai.com Dated this 9th day of November, 2026. _____________________________ Carrie Meyer Manager, Discovery & Regulatory Operations BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION FOR APPROVAL OF THE 2026 INTER-JURISDICTIONAL COST ALLOCATION PROTOCOL ) CASE NO. PAC-E-25-14 ) ) SETTLEMENT STIPULATION ) SUPPORTING TESTIMONY OF ) JOELLE R. STEWARD ) ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER CASE NO. PAC-E-25-14 November 2026 Steward, STIP 1 Rocky Mountain Power I. INTRODUCTION 1 Q. Are you the same Joelle R. Steward who previously 2 submitted direct testimony in this proceeding on behalf 3 of PacifiCorp, d/b/a Rocky Mountain Power (“Rocky 4 Mountain Power” or the “Company”)? 5 A. Yes, I presented direct testimony on behalf of Rocky 6 Mountain Power (Steward, Di). 7 Q. Who is sponsoring this testimony? 8 A. This testimony is sponsored by Rocky Mountain Power in 9 support of the Settlement Stipulation (“Stipulation”) 10 executed by the Company, Staff of the Idaho Public 11 Utilities Commission, Idaho Irrigation Pumpers 12 Association, and Ruveon LLC f/k/a Bayer Corporation 13 (collectively, the “Stipulating Parties”) and filed with 14 the Idaho Public Utilities Commission (“Commission”) on 15 October 13, 2026, in this docket. 16 Q. Was the Stipulation executed by stakeholders from other 17 states as well? 18 A. Yes. The Stipulation was also signed by: 19 • From Oregon – Staff of the Public Utility Commission 20 of Oregon, Oregon Citizens’ Utility Board, Alliance 21 of Western Energy Consumers, and Sierra Club; 22 • From Utah – Utah Division of Public Utilities, Utah 23 Office of Consumer Services, Utah Association of 24 Energy Users, Utah Large Customer Group, Nucor Steel-25 Steward, STIP 2 Rocky Mountain Power Utah a Division of Nucor Corporation, Utah Clean 1 Energy, Western Resource Advocates, and Sierra Club; 2 and 3 • From Wyoming – Wyoming Office of Consumer Advocate, 4 and Wyoming Industrial Energy Consumers. 5 One intervening party in Oregon—Renewable Northwest—6 takes no position and does not oppose the Stipulation. 7 In total, this represents all of the intervening parties 8 in Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming. 9 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony? 10 A. My testimony describes and supports the Stipulation, 11 which recommends a temporary extension of certain 12 elements of the 2020 PacifiCorp Inter-Jurisdictional 13 Allocation Methodology (2020 Protocol) through December 14 31, 2028, and outlines the process for developing a 15 Successor Allocation Methodology (“SAM”) to be effective 16 January 1, 2029. The Stipulation resolves all the 17 Stipulating Parties’ issues in this proceeding. 18 Q. Have all parties that have intervened in this proceeding 19 participated in settlement conferences? 20 A. Yes. 21 Q. Has any party to this proceeding objected to the 22 Stipulation? 23 A. No, all parties to this proceeding have signed the 24 Stipulation and are therefore Stipulating Parties. 25 Steward, STIP 3 Rocky Mountain Power II. BACKGROUND 1 Q. What is the inter-jurisdictional allocation protocol? 2 A. The Company’s inter-jurisdictional allocation protocol 3 is the cost allocation methodology used by the Company 4 to allocate costs among its state jurisdictions to set 5 fair, just, and reasonable rates. The Idaho Public 6 Utilities Commission has separately approved Rocky 7 Mountain Power’s allocation methodologies for use in 8 Rocky Mountain Power’s ratemaking proceedings. 9 Q. What is the 2020 Protocol? 10 A. The 2020 Protocol is the latest Commission-approved 11 allocation methodology for use in Rocky Mountain Power’s 12 rate proceedings before the Commission. The 2020 13 Protocol was originally approved for use through 14 December 31, 2023, in Case No. PAC-E-19-20.1 It was 15 subsequently extended for use through December 31, 2025, 16 in Case No. PAC-E-23-13.2 Rocky Mountain Power filed the 17 2026 PacifiCorp Inter-Jurisdictional Allocation 18 Protocol (“2026 Protocol”) in the current proceeding to 19 replace the expiring 2020 Protocol. 20 1 In the Matter of Rocky Mountain Power’s Application for Approval of the 2020 PacifiCorp Inter-Jurisdictional Allocation Protocol, Case No. PAC- E-19-20, Order No. 34640 (Apr. 22, 2020). 2 In the Matter of Rocky Mountain Power’s Application for Approval of an Extension of the 2020 PacifiCorp Inter-Jurisdictional Allocation Protocol, Case No. PAC-E-23-13, Order No. 35984 (Nov. 2, 2023) Steward, STIP 4 Rocky Mountain Power Q. What was the intent of the 2026 Protocol? 1 A. As mentioned above, Rocky Mountain Power intended the 2 2026 Protocol to supersede the 2020 Protocol for 3 California, Idaho, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming, and align 4 with the changes in the Washington 2026 Protocol, 5 approved by the Washington Utilities and Transportation 6 Commission.3 Rocky Mountain Power envisioned the 2026 7 Protocol as the first phase in a multi-phase process to 8 transition the Company’s cost-allocation methodology to 9 accommodate diverging resource portfolios and changes to 10 operations needed to address individual state energy 11 policies.4 12 Q. Have subsequent events raised new considerations 13 regarding the allocation of costs among Rocky Mountain 14 Power’s jurisdictions? 15 A. Yes. The Company originally filed for approval of the 16 2026 Protocol in Oregon on August 1, 2025. Soon after, 17 Rocky Mountain Power filed for approval of the 2026 18 3 Wash. Utils. & Transp. Comm’n v. PacifiCorp, Docket No. UE-250224, Order 08 ¶ 18 (Dec. 22, 2025). 4 Case No. PAC-E-25-14, Application at 4 (Aug. 6, 2025). Steward, STIP 5 Rocky Mountain Power Protocol in Wyoming on August 4, 2025;5 in Utah on August 1 5, 2025;6 and in Idaho on August 6, 2025.7 2 Subsequently in Oregon, on April 1, 2026, the 3 Company filed an application for approval of the sale of 4 the Company’s Washington service area and certain of the 5 Company’s Washington-based generation, transmission, 6 and distribution assets to Gem Sub LLC, an affiliate of 7 Portland General Electric Company (the “Washington 8 Service Area Transfer”).8 Rocky Mountain Power followed 9 suit, filing applications for the Washington Service 10 Area Transfer in Wyoming on April 3, 2026, and in Idaho 11 and Utah on April 6, 2026.9 12 5 In the Matter of the Application of Rocky Mountain Power for Approval of the 2026 Inter-Jurisdictional Cost Allocation Protocol, Docket No. 20000-690-EA-25 (Record No. 17937), RMP Exhibit 1.0 Application (Aug. 4, 2025). 6 Application of Rocky Mountain Power for Approval of the 2026 Inter- Jurisdictional Cost Allocation Protocol, Docket No. 25-035-47, Application (Aug. 5, 2025). 7 In the Matter of the Application for Approval of the 2026 Inter- Jurisdictional Cost Allocation Protocol, Case No. PAC-E-25-14, Application (Aug. 6, 2025). 8 In the Matter of PacifiCorp dba Pacific Power, Application for an Order Authorizing the Sale of Washington-Based Asset, Docket No. UP 441, Application (Apr. 1, 2026). 9 For Idaho – In the Matter of the Application of PacifiCorp d/b/a Rocky Mountain Power for Approval of Sale of Washington Service Area and Accounting Order, Case No. PAC-E-26-04, Application (Apr. 6, 2026); for Utah – In the Matter of the Application of PacifiCorp d/b/a Rocky Mountain Power for Approval and Report of the Sale of Washington Service Area and an Accounting Order, Docket No. 26-035-20, Application (Apr. 6, 2026); and for Wyoming – In the Matter of the Application of Rocky Mountain Power for Authority to Sell the Washington-Based Assets and Accounting Order, Docket No. 20000-706-EA-26 (Record No. 18110), Exhibit 1.0 Application (Apr. 3, 2026). Steward, STIP 6 Rocky Mountain Power Q. How does the Washington Service Area Transfer raise 1 additional allocation implications? 2 A. The Washington Service Area Transfer, if approved, would 3 result in the Company serving customers in, and 4 allocating costs among, five states, rather than 5 allocating costs among the six states currently served 6 by the Company. Accordingly, Rocky Mountain Power must 7 reassign or reallocate system costs and benefits amongst 8 its remaining states. 9 Q. Are Rocky Mountain Power and the other Stipulating 10 Parties in agreement on how to reassign or reallocate 11 the Company’s system costs previously allocated to 12 Washington load? 13 A. Not at this time. 14 Q. Do Rocky Mountain Power and the other Stipulating 15 Parties recognize the need for an allocation methodology 16 to address ongoing or upcoming ratemaking proceedings? 17 A. Rocky Mountain Power does and while I can only speak for 18 the Company, I believe the other Stipulating Parties 19 agree, as evidenced by the provisions in the 20 Stipulation. The Company has an obligation to submit 21 periodic rate filings, which requires the use of an 22 allocation methodology to appropriately allocate costs 23 and benefits to customers in each jurisdiction. 24 Steward, STIP 7 Rocky Mountain Power Q. What was the solution agreed to by the Stipulating 1 Parties in the Stipulation? 2 A. The Stipulating Parties agreed to recommend a temporary 3 extension of elements of the 2020 Protocol, while 4 allowing the Stipulating Parties to develop arguments 5 and take positions on other elements of the 2020 Protocol 6 regarding the sale of certain Washington-based or 7 allocated assets. 8 Q. Does the Stipulation address how a new allocation 9 methodology will be developed? 10 A. Yes. The Stipulation outlines a new process for 11 developing a SAM to replace the 2020 Protocol. 12 III. 2020 PROTOCOL EXTENSION 13 Q. Did the Stipulating Parties agree to extend the 2020 14 Protocol? 15 A. Yes, with the modifications described in the Stipulation 16 and in this supporting testimony. 17 Q. In what proceedings and for how long will the 2020 18 Protocol be used? 19 A. The Stipulating Parties agree that the 2020 Protocol, as 20 modified by the Stipulation, should be adopted for use 21 in all Rocky Mountain Power ratemaking proceedings that 22 are filed on or before December 31, 2028. For net power 23 cost filings, the 2020 Protocol, as modified, will also 24 be used in net power cost filings involving costs and 25 Steward, STIP 8 Rocky Mountain Power revenues incurred through December 31, 2028. Such 1 filings may occur after December 31, 2028, to align costs 2 and benefits of net power costs. For example, actual 3 power cost adjustment filings, such as Idaho’s Energy 4 Cost Adjustment Mechanism, made after December 31, 2028, 5 but addressing net power costs incurred before January 6 1, 2029, will use the 2020 Protocol, as modified by the 7 Stipulation. 8 Q. What modifications did the Stipulating Parties make to 9 the 2020 Protocol proposed by the Company? 10 A. The Stipulation continues, with certain limited 11 modifications, the Interim Period Allocation Method 12 articulated in the 2020 Protocol. This would continue 13 the use of the allocation method used to set Rocky 14 Mountain Power’s current rates until December 31, 2028. 15 The provisions of the 2020 Protocol associated with the 16 planned Post-Interim Period allocation method would not 17 be extended and would be replaced by the SAM process 18 articulated in Paragraph 4 of the Stipulation. 19 Q. Are there any provisions of the 2020 Protocol Interim 20 Period Allocation Method that apply currently that will 21 not be continued under the terms of the Stipulation? 22 A. Yes. Table 1 of the Stipulation addresses each section 23 of the 2020 Protocol and whether it has been extended or 24 not. Importantly, Sections 4.1.3 and 4.1.4 of the 2020 25 Steward, STIP 9 Rocky Mountain Power Protocol would not be extended. Those provisions address 1 the originally contemplated Oregon Exit Dates and 2 Washington Exit Orders regarding coal-fueled Interim 3 Period Resources, meaning the Company’s existing 4 resources. Those provisions are now largely out of date 5 given updated resource decisions and planning 6 assumptions. 7 Q. Does the Stipulation address updating decommissioning 8 costs similar to Section 4.3 of the 2020 Protocol? 9 A. Yes. The Stipulating Parties agree Rocky Mountain Power 10 will file a new depreciation study that includes a 11 contractor-assisted engineering study of 12 decommissioning costs by June 30, 2027. 13 IV. WASHINGTON SERVICE AREA TRANSFER 14 Q. Please explain the Stipulating Parties’ agreement 15 regarding the Washington Service Area Transfer. 16 A. The Stipulating Parties agree that the extension of the 17 2020 Protocol will not apply to any reassignment or 18 reallocation of all or portions of the generation and 19 transmission facilities due to the Washington Service 20 Area Transfer. Any reassignment or reallocation of 21 generation and transmission facilities will be 22 considered in each state separately and outside of this 23 proceeding. This agreed-upon process for addressing the 24 Washington Service Area Transfer is consistent with 25 Steward, STIP 10 Rocky Mountain Power Section 3.1.9 of the 2020 Protocol, which leaves the 1 reallocation of resources resulting from a change in 2 load greater than five percent to be determined on a 3 case-by-case basis by the respective state regulatory 4 commissions. 5 As part of the Stipulation, Rocky Mountain Power 6 submitted supplemental filings in the Washington Service 7 Area Transfer proceeding, presenting a counterfactual 8 analysis that assumes the unallocated costs and benefits 9 for resources and transmission facilities subject to the 10 Washington Service Area Transfer are not reassigned to 11 the remaining five states.10 12 Q. Did the Stipulating Parties agree on the specific 13 proceedings that will address any reassignment or 14 reallocation of all or portions of the generation and 15 transmission facilities due to the Washington Service 16 Area Transfer? 17 A. Yes. In Idaho, the reassignment or reallocation of 18 generation and transmission facilities will be 19 considered in the pending Washington Service Area 20 Transfer proceedings. 21 10 Case No. PAC-E-26-04, Supplemental Testimony of Joelle R. Steward (Steward, Supp), Michael G. Wilding (Wilding, Supp), Ramon J. Mitchell (Mitchell, Supp), and Shelley E. McCoy (McCoy, Supp) (Oct. 22, 2026). Steward, STIP 11 Rocky Mountain Power Q. How long will cost allocation decisions made in the 1 Washington Service Area Transfer proceeding be used for 2 ratemaking purposes? 3 A. Since this 2020 Protocol extension is only in effect 4 through December 31, 2028, any cost allocation decisions 5 made in the individual Washington Service Area Transfer 6 proceedings in each state will be used for ratemaking 7 purposes until December 31, 2028. 8 Q. Does the Stipulation limit any Stipulating Party’s 9 ability to argue how any proceeds from the Washington 10 Service Area Transfer should be treated? 11 A. No. The Stipulating Parties agreed that the Stipulation 12 does not limit any Stipulating Parties’ ability to argue 13 how any proceeds from the Washington Service Area 14 Transfer should be treated.11 15 V. SUCCESSOR ALLOCATION METHODOLOGY 16 Q. Given that this is a temporary extension of aspects of 17 the 2020 Protocol, what is the plan for replacing the 18 2020 Protocol? 19 A. As discussed above, Rocky Mountain Power intends to 20 establish a new multi-state negotiation process to 21 establish a SAM to replace the 2020 Protocol to be 22 effective beginning January 1, 2029. The process by 23 11 Stipulation ¶ 2(d). Steward, STIP 12 Rocky Mountain Power which the SAM will be established is included as part of 1 the Stipulation. 2 Q. Please explain how the SAM process will begin. 3 A. As part of the Stipulation, the Stipulating Parties have 4 agreed to recommend that each state commission open 5 investigative or other appropriate dockets to serve as 6 a repository for information and to provide appropriate 7 confidentiality provisions during the SAM process.12 8 Q. How frequently will the Company meet with interested, 9 intervening parties? 10 A. Starting no later than April 1, 2027, Rocky Mountain 11 Power will schedule monthly meetings in 2027 in which 12 Stipulating Parties and any other interested, 13 intervening parties may participate.13 14 Q. Will the Stipulating Parties communicate with the 15 Commission during the course of the negotiations? 16 A. Yes. The Stipulating Parties will update the Commission 17 on SAM progress no less frequently than every four 18 months.14 19 12 Stipulation ¶ 4(a). 13 Stipulation ¶ 4(c). 14 Stipulation ¶ 4(b). Steward, STIP 13 Rocky Mountain Power Q. Has the Company agreed to provide any data or analyses 1 in the SAM process? 2 A. Yes. Paragraph 4(e) of the Stipulation outlines specific 3 data and analyses that will be provided by Rocky Mountain 4 Power to stakeholders as part of the SAM.15 5 Q. Does the Stipulation impose any discovery limitations? 6 A. Yes, the Company and the other Stipulating Parties have 7 endeavored to identify the data desired now in order to 8 support their own analysis and more efficiently work 9 through the negotiations over the next year. 10 Accordingly, the Stipulation limits discovery and data 11 sharing in this proceeding to data provided in the above-12 mentioned analyses unless otherwise agreed to during the 13 SAM process.16 14 Q. Does the Stipulation bind the Stipulating Parties to any 15 position regarding the appropriate allocation 16 methodology for the SAM? 17 A. No. The Stipulation specifically states that “[n]o 18 Stipulating Party, by agreeing to these factors or 19 participating in this case, concedes that the 2020 20 Protocol methodology is the appropriate basis for the 21 SAM.”17 The Stipulating Parties reserve the right to 22 propose an entirely different allocation framework in 23 15 Stipulation ¶ 4(e). 16 Stipulation ¶ 4(a). 17 Stipulation ¶ 6. Steward, STIP 14 Rocky Mountain Power the future SAM negotiations, and the Company agrees to 1 provide timely analysis of a reasonable number of 2 alternative allocation approaches.18 3 VI. REASONABLENESS OF THE STIPULATION 4 Q. How did the Stipulating Parties arrive at the 5 Stipulation? 6 A. The Company and the other Stipulating Parties met in 7 numerous multi-state discussions over the past several 8 months to discuss allocation issues and exchange 9 potential settlement offers. Non-Company parties also 10 met on several occasions to separately discuss issues. 11 Q. Please explain why Rocky Mountain Power supports 12 Commission adoption of the Stipulation. 13 A. The Stipulation provides an opportunity for the 14 Stipulating Parties to address specific allocation 15 concerns regarding the Washington Service Area Transfer 16 while providing a common allocation methodology that 17 will result in just and reasonable rates for use in the 18 ratemaking process in each jurisdiction. The intent in 19 identifying specific elements of the 2020 Protocol that 20 would not be extended is narrowly focused to allow 21 parties to develop positions in a contested proceeding 22 on resources that will be under-allocated if the 23 Washington Service Area Transfer is approved and the 24 18 Stipulation ¶¶ 4(e), 6. Steward, STIP 15 Rocky Mountain Power transaction closes. The agreement by all of the 1 Stipulating Parties, in all jurisdictions, reflects the 2 importance of a common allocation methodology, while 3 providing the Stipulating Parties with a process to 4 establish a SAM. 5 Q. Does the Company believe the Stipulating Parties have 6 evaluated the overall fairness of the Stipulation? 7 A. Yes. Each Stipulating Party participated in the current 8 proceeding and the negotiation of the Stipulation. The 9 Stipulating Parties agree that the Stipulation is in the 10 public interest and is consistent with applicable 11 standards in each respective state.19 12 Q. By adopting the Stipulation to resolve all issues in the 13 current proceeding, is the Commission limited in its 14 determination of just and reasonable rates? 15 A. No. Nothing in the Stipulation is intended to prejudge 16 the prudence of any costs or the extent that any costs 17 may be reflected in rates. Further, the Stipulation does 18 not require the Commission to abrogate its rights and 19 obligations to: (1) determine fair, just, and reasonable 20 rates based upon applicable laws and the record 21 established in rate proceedings conducted by the 22 Commission; (2) consider the impact of changes in laws, 23 regulations, or circumstances on inter-jurisdictional 24 19 Stipulation ¶ 9. Steward, STIP 16 Rocky Mountain Power allocation policies and procedures when determining 1 fair, just, and reasonable rates; or (3) establish 2 different allocation policies and procedures for 3 purposes of allocating costs and revenues within each 4 state to different customers or customer classes. The 5 Stipulation dictates how the Company will allocate 6 costs, which will then be subject to Commission review. 7 VII. 2026 PROTOCOL DEFERRAL APPLICATIONS 8 Q. Rocky Mountain Power has separately filed applications 9 for deferred accounting treatment of the differences 10 between the 2020 Protocol and 2026 Protocol starting 11 January 1, 2026, until implementation of the rate 12 revisions incorporating allocation pursuant to the 2026 13 Protocol. Does the Stipulation address those filings? 14 A. Yes. The Company has agreed to withdraw those 15 applications as part of the Stipulation given the 16 continued use of the 2020 Protocol for allocations.20 17 VIII. CONCLUSION 18 Q. What action do you recommend the Commission take with 19 respect to the Stipulation? 20 A. For the reasons discussed above, I recommend that the 21 Commission find that the Stipulation is in the public 22 interest and would produce rates that are fair, just, 23 reasonable, and sufficient. Accordingly, I recommend 24 20 Stipulation ¶ 7. Steward, STIP 17 Rocky Mountain Power that the Commission adopt the Stipulation and include 1 the terms and conditions in its order in this case. 2 Q. Does this conclude your testimony? 3 A. Yes. 4