HomeMy WebLinkAbout20261106Comment_1.pdf From: Barry Galen
Sent: Friday, November 6, 2026 7:52 AM
To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov>
Cc: Mary Galen
Subject: Public Comment—Case No. AVU-E-26-10 (Carlin Bay Transmission Line)
Commission Secretary,
My name is Barry Galen. My wife Mary and I own 8099 East Bridger Trail, Harrison, Idaho
83833, an Avista customer on the east side of Lake Coeur d'Alene. I'm submitting this
comment on Case No. AVU-E-26-10. I also have a complaint pending with Commission
Staff(Investigator Kevin Maxwell), who let me know about this case.
Avista's application says the east side of the lake is served by two distribution feeders that
have had sustained outages and have reached capacity. Our part of that system has had a
safety problem since this summer, and I'm asking the Commission to consider it as part of
this case.
Since July 2026 there has been measurable strayvoltage in the lake water along Bridger
Trail. Rental guests have been shocked climbing onto our dock. A licensed Idaho electrical
contractor measured about 4 volts between the dock and the water. The voltage stayed in
the water after Avista pulled our meter and ran a new service line. It also stayed after power
was fully shut off at four neighboring properties. Other testing found a steady 5 volts along
roughly 1,000 feet of shoreline, and a sixth property outside that group reads 5.6 volts. Five
houses have been ruled out as the source, and nobody has found the real source yet.We've
stopped all swimming at our property because strayvoltage in fresh water can cause
electric shock drowning. But this is public water, and families and children swim along this
whole stretch.
Avista sent technicians in July and August and said its equipment was working properly.
Since then it has stopped looking into it. As far as we know, nobody is investigating the
source now.
I'm not opposed to the Carlin Bay project. Better reliability for the east side of the lake is
good for all of us. I'm asking the Commission to:
1. Have Avista look at the condition of the existing distribution system serving the
Harrison/ Bridger Trail shoreline as part of this case. That includes the neutral and
grounding, and any buried or underwater lines near the shore.
1
2. Require Avista to find and fix any stray voltage problem on its facilities in this area
before or along with the new construction, and to report what it finds.
3. Make sure that when loads are moved between feeders or onto the new line, Avista
checks that it doesn't create or worsen stray voltage at the shoreline.
I can provide the full documented timeline, the contractor's statement and invoice, and
photos if they would help.
Respectfully,
Barry Galen
2