HomeMy WebLinkAboutReply CommentsIDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 1
DONOVAN E. WALKER (ISB No. 5921)
LISA C. LANCE (ISB No. 6241)
Idaho Power Company
1221 West Idaho Street (83702)
P.O. Box 70
Boise, Idaho 83707
Telephone: (208) 388-5317
Facsimile: (208) 388-6936
dwalker@idahopower.com
llance@idahopower.com
Attorneys for Idaho Power Company
BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
IN THE MATTER OF THE IDAHO
HYDROELECTRIC POWER PRODUCERS
TRUST’S PETITION FOR IDAHO POWER
COMPANY TO REDUCE ITS OPERATION
AND MAINTENANCE CHARGES
APPLICABLE TO SCHEDULE 72,
GENERATOR INTERCONNECTIONS TO
PURPA QUALIFYING FACILITY SELLERS
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
CASE NO. IPC-E-26-15
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S
REPLY COMMENTS
COMES Now, Idaho Power Company (“Idaho Power” or “Company”), and,
pursuant to Idaho Public Utilities Commission’s (“Commission”) Rules of Procedure 201-
204; the Notice of Modified Procedure, Order No. 37145, entered August 31, 2026; and
the Notice of Modified Schedule, Order No. 37192, entered October 2, 2026, hereby
respectfully submits the following Reply Comments to the Initial Comments filed by
Commission Staff (“Staff”) on October 15, 2026.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 2
I. BACKGROUND
On May 19, 2026, Idaho Hydroelectric Power Producers Trust (“IdaHydro”) filed a
Petition, based upon the same allegations, complaints, and requests made by IdaHydro
in Case No. IPC-E-25-22, asking the Commission to re-examine the system-average
methodology and update Idaho Power’s Schedule 72, Generator Interconnections to
Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (“PURPA”) Qualifying Facility Sellers
(“Schedule 72”), Operations and Maintenance (“O&M”) charges from the currently
approved system-average methodology to an actual cost methodology. On October 15,
2026, Idaho Power and Staff submitted initial comments in response to IdaHydro’s
Petition.
II. STAFF COMMENTS
Of the issues being examined in this proceeding, Staff focused primarily on
whether the current system-average methodology used to determine Schedule 72’s O&M
charges is fair, just, and reasonable, and whether IdaHydro’s proposed actual cost
method (“Actual Cost Method”) is a reasonable alternative.1 To answer these questions,
Staff evaluated whether the published avoided costs determined by the Surrogate
Avoided Resource (“SAR”) model include the O&M interconnection cost of the surrogate
resource, thereby making it valid for the Company to charge a Qualifying Facility (“QF”)
for the full O&M cost of their interconnection, and whether Schedule 72’s currently
approved system-average methodology is reasonably based on actual costs
representative of the Company’s system.2 Although both of Idaho Power’s Commission-
1 IPC-E-26-15 Staff Comments at 3.
2 Id.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 3
approved avoided cost rate methodologies3 include interconnection and O&M costs in the
rates paid to QFs for their generation, Staff limited its assessment of whether the
surrogate resource’s O&M interconnection costs are reflected in the SAR model’s
published avoided cost rates given Staff’s role in the development of such rates.4
Staff concluded that the avoided cost rates in the SAR model include the
interconnection O&M cost of the surrogate resource and, therefore, charging QFs the full
O&M cost to maintain their interconnection is needed to ensure the Company’s customers
are not harmed. Additionally, Staff determined that the existing system-average
methodology used by Schedule 72 is based on the Company’s actual O&M cost of its
transmission and distribution system and can reasonably be anticipated to capture the
expected actual O&M cost of a QF interconnection. As such, Staff found the existing
system-average methodology used by the Company to assess O&M costs to QFs
(through Schedule 72) to be fair, just, and reasonable.5
Despite its findings with respect to the existing system-average methodology, Staff
noted that it is not opposed to the Actual Cost Method proposed by IdaHydro, if
implemented to ensure that customers are not harmed.6 To keep customers indifferent,
Staff highlighted that billing QFs based upon IdaHydro’s proposed Actual Cost Method
would require billing actual O&M costs as they occur, as well as billing for ongoing fixed
charges for O&M overhead costs such as management and maintenance labor,
replacement equipment inventory costs, and any other ongoing costs the Company incurs
3 The SAR methodology is utilized by Idaho Power for QF projects that are below the published rate
eligibility thresholds, and the Incremental Cost Integrated Resource Plan methodology is utilized by Idaho
Power for QF projects that are over the published rate thresholds.
4 Staff Comments at 3
5 Id.
6 Staff Comments at 7
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 4
to maintain its system at a high level of reliability.7 Additionally, Staff stated that because
Idaho Power does not track costs in the manner needed to accommodate IdaHydro’s
proposed Actual Cost Method, the cost associated with implementing such a billing
construct should be amortized and recovered from QFs and not the Company’s general
body of customers. Finally, Staff raised concern as to whether every QF is able to pay its
actual O&M costs if a major repair is required and recommends that, if the Commission
orders the Company to implement an Actual Cost Method on a facility-by-facility basis,
methods to mitigate risk of a QF’s inability to pay be developed.
III. COMPANY REPLY
Idaho Power appreciates Staff’s thorough review and analysis of the Petition and
their acknowledgement that, with respect to their review of the SAR method, the
interconnection O&M cost of the surrogate resource is included in published avoided cost
rates and QFs using these rates should therefore be required to pay the full O&M costs
of their interconnection.8 Additionally, the Company appreciates and agrees with Staff’s
findings that the system-average methodology used by Schedule 72 is fair, just, and
reasonable and that, because the method is based on average costs, Idaho Power will
likely recover interconnection costs from QFs as a whole, thereby holding the Company’s
general body of customers harmless.9
With respect to IdaHydro’s proposed Actual Cost Method, Staff stated it was not
necessarily opposed to such a change, but only if additional requirements could be
implemented to protect customers. Idaho Power shares the same concerns expressed by
7 Id.
8 Staff Comments at 3.
9 Staff Comments at 6.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 5
Staff and agrees that, should the Commission determine to implement a different O&M
methodology or an Actual Cost Methodology as suggested by IdaHydro on a facility-by-
facility basis, it is critical that such a change be accompanied by measures designed to
hold the Company’s body of retail customers neutral, or not harmed, by the addition of
the QF to the Company’s system. This is more complex than simply changing the current
methodology to one that assigns and collects actual costs. At a minimum, Staff’s
recommended customer protections would need to be implemented along with the
methodological change. The Company also notes that even with these added protections,
the Actual Cost Method proposed by IdaHydro does not guarantee that Idaho Power’s
general body of customers will be insulated from the ongoing O&M cost imposed upon
the Company’s system by the addition of a QF. As suggested by Staff, if a QF is unable
to pay its actual O&M costs, there is risk that such costs could ultimately be shifted to the
Company’s general body of customers.
As confirmed by Staff, the currently approved methodology, which has been in
place as directed by the Commission for more than two decades, is fair, just, and
reasonable; based on the Company’s actual O&M cost of its transmission and distribution
system; and, because it is based on average costs, holds customers harmless. Moving
to a new and different system of collecting O&M costs from QFs would require the
implementation and administration of several new systems that do not exist today, and
as acknowledged and conditioned by Staff, would require additional measures to ensure
that customers are not harmed by the addition of the QF to the Company’s system. As
such, and as acknowledged by Staff, the Company believes the system-average
methodology, as approved by the Commission and currently used by Schedule 72, is the
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 6
best way to mitigate the risk of retail customers paying for O&M costs associated a QF
interconnecting to the Company’s system.
Accordingly, and in recognition that this approach helps mitigate the
aforementioned risk of cost shifting, Idaho Power believes the Commission should
maintain Schedule 72’s currently approved system-average methodology, consistent with
Staff’s recommendation.
IV. CONCLUSION
Idaho Power appreciates Staff’s review of and comments on IdaHydro’s Petition in
this matter. The Company respectfully requests the Commission issue an order
dismissing IdaHydro’s Petition and affirming the lawfulness, appropriateness, and
reasonableness of Schedule 72 and its associated system-average methodology as it
exists today. Staff also supports and “recommends that the Commission maintain the
currently approved Average Cost Method used by the current Schedule 72.”10
Although Staff states alternatively that it is not opposed to IdaHydro’s proposed
method, this comes with a significant condition: that additional measures be developed
to protect customers and hold them harmless to the PURPA transaction and addition of
the QF to the Company’s system, as required by PURPA. The current methodology
already does this well, and abandoning the current approach risks unnecessary cost shifts
to Idaho Power’s retail customers. Idaho Power respectfully requests that the
Commission maintain the currently approved Schedule 72 O&M methodology and reject
IdaHydro’s alternative proposal.
10 Staff Comments at 7.
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 7
Respectfully submitted this 5th day of November 2026.
DONOVAN WALKER
Attorney for Idaho Power Company
IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS – 8
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 5th day of November 2026 I served a true and
correct copy of IDAHO POWER COMPANY’S REPLY COMMENTS upon the following
named parties by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following:
Commission Staff
Erika K. Melanson
Deputy Attorney General
Idaho Public Utilities Commission
472 West Washington (83702)
P.O. Box 83720
Boise, Idaho 83720-0074
Hand Delivered
U.S. Mail
Overnight Mail
FAX
X Email erika.melanson@puc.idaho.gov
IdaHydro
C. Tom Arkoosh
Nicholas J. Erekson
ARKOOSH LAW OFFICES
913 W. River Street, Suite 450
P.O. Box 2900
Boise, ID 83701
Hand Delivered
U.S. Mail
Overnight Mail
FAX
X Email tom.arkoosh@arkoosh.com
nick.erekson@arkoosh.com
erin.cecil@arkoosh.com
________________________________
Christy Davenport
Legal Administrative Assistant