Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20261102APPLICATION.pdf RECEIVED November 02, 2026 IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION Preston N. Carter, ISB No. 8462 GIVENS PURSLEY LLP 601 West Bannock Street P.O. Box 2720 Boise, Idaho 83701-2720 Office: (208) 388-1200 Fax: (208) 388-1300 prestoncarter@givenspursley.com Attorneys for Intermountain Gas Company BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION Case No. INT-G-26-06 OF INTERMOUNTAIN GAS COMPANY FOR A DETERMINATION OF 2025 APPLICATION ENERGY EFFICIENCY EXPENSES AS PRUDENTLY INCURRED Intermountain Gas Company("Intermountain"or"Company"), a subsidiary of MDU Resources Group, Inc. with general offices located at 555 South Cole Road, Boise, Idaho, pursuant to the Rules of Procedure of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission("Commission"), 1) submits its 2025 Energy Efficiency Annual Report and 2) applies to the Commission for an order designating $4,464,533 of 2025 Energy Efficiency expenditures as prudently incurred. Please address communications regarding this Application to: Preston N. Carter Michael Parvienen Givens Pursley LLP Director—Regulatory Affairs 601 W. Bannock St. Intermountain Gas Company Boise, Idaho 83702 PO Box 7608 prestoncarter@givenspursley.com Boise, Idaho 83707 stephaniew@givenspursley.com michael.parvinen@cngc.com igcregulatory@intgas.com APPLICATION PAGE I OF 8 In support of this Application, Intermountain alleges and states as follows. I. INTRODUCTION Intermountain is a gas utility,subject to the jurisdiction of the Commission,engaged in the sale of and distribution of natural gas within the State of Idaho under authority of Commission Certificate No. 219, issued December 2, 1955,as amended and supplemented by Order No. 6564, dated October 3, 1962. Intermountain provides natural gas service to the following Idaho communities and counties and adjoining areas: Ada County-Boise,Eagle,Garden City,Kuna,Meridian,and Star; Bannock County-Arimo,Chubbuck,Inkom,Lava Hot Springs,McCammon,and Pocatello; Bear Lake County- Georgetown and Montpelier; Bingham County-Aberdeen,Basalt,Blackfoot,Firth,Fort Hall,Moreland/Riverside,and Shelley; Blaine County-Bellevue,Hailey,Ketchum,and Sun Valley; Bonneville County-Ammon,Idaho Falls,Iona,and Ucon; Canyon County-Caldwell,Greenleaf,Middleton,Nampa,Parma,and Wilder; Caribou County-Bancroft, Grace,and Soda Springs; Cassia County-Burley,Declo,Malta,and Raft River; Elmore County-Glenns Ferry,Hammett,and Mountain Home; Fremont County-Parker and St. Anthony; Gem County-Emmett; Gooding County-Gooding and Wendell; Jefferson County-Lewisville,Menan,Rigby,and Ririe; Jerome County- Jerome; Lincoln County-Shoshone; Madison County-Rexburg and Sugar City; Minidoka County-Heyburn,Paul,and Rupert; Owyhee County-Bruneau and Homedale; Payette County-Fruitland,New Plymouth,and Payette; Power County-American Falls; Twin Falls County-Buhl,Filer,Hansen,Kimberly,Murtaugh,and Twin Falls; Washington County-Weiser. Intermountain's properties in these locations consist of transmission pipelines,liquefied natural gas storage facilities, compressor stations,distribution mains,services,meters and regulators, and general plant and equipment. APPLICATION PAGE 2 OF 8 II. BACKGROUND Intermountain's Energy Efficiency Program(the "Program") began in April 2017. See Case No. INT-G-16-02, Order No. 33757, at 35-37. Since then, Intermountain has continuously evaluated and revised the program based on orders from the Commission, conversations with Staff, input from the stakeholder committee, in response to recommendations from consultants, and from other sources. The Commission recently required Intermountain to provide an EM&V with a billing analysis covering Whole Home Tier I and Furnace measures, and to separate savings for new construction, retrofit, and replacement for the 95% AFUE furnace rebates in its next application for a prudency determination. Case No. INT-G-24-05, Order No. 36797. The Commission later rescinded its requirement that Intermountain provide a billing analysis for the Whole Home Tier I measure, since Intermountain retired that measure. Case No. INT-G-26-02, Order No. 37030. Intermountain has complied with the remaining directives of Order No. 36797. The billing analysis for the Furnace measure is attached as Exhibit 2,with the savings for the 95%AFUE furnace rebate separated by new construction, retrofit, and replacement applications. III. 2025 PRuDENCY FILING The Company's 2025 Energy Efficiency Annual Report ("Annual Report")is included as Attachment 1 to this Application and incorporated by reference. The Annual Report of the Company's eighth program year provides a review of the Company's Energy Efficiency Portfolio, which consists of the Residential Program and the Commercial Program. The report outlines revenues, expenditures, cost-effectiveness, and performance by measure for each Program. A review of outreach and educational activities, and discussion of future plans complete the Annual Report. APPLICATION PAGE 3 OF 8 IV. REVENUES The EE Program expenditures are funded through collections from customers via Energy Efficiency Charges. The current EEC-RS of$0.01149 was effective October 1, 2024. Total Residential Program revenues for calendar year 2025 were $3,085,314. Attachment 1 at 5. Due to an over-collected balance, Company decreased the EEC-GS collection rate to zero effective October 1, 2024. The revenue for January through December 2025 was $151. Attachment 1 at 23. V. EXPENDITURES Expenditures for the Residential and Commercial Programs combined for January 1, 2025, through December 31, 2025, were $4,464,533. Of this amount, $3,542,212, or approximately 79%, is for energy efficiency rebates paid directly to residential and commercial customers. Residential rebates accounted for$3,508,480 and Commercial rebates accounted for$33,732 of the total. Attachment 1 at 5 and 23. In addition to the amount spent on energy efficiency rebates, the Company incurred $922,321 of administrative expenses for labor,program delivery, direct expenses, and special studies. As a Portfolio, this was approximately 3 percent less than 2024 expenditures. The Company also spent $142,722 on an Evaluation, Measurement and Verification study ("EM&V") in 2025. Labor expenses as a percent of rebate dollars paid decreased by 3 percent from 2025. Beginning in 2025, the Company modified its expense assignment process for Energy Efficiency Program costs by discontinuing the use of a general allocation methodology between the Residential and Commercial Programs. Instead, expenses are now assigned directly to the applicable program at the time they are incurred, except in limited circumstances where an APPLICATION PAGE 4 OF 8 expense is appropriately characterized as shared between both programs. This approach provides a clearer separation of Residential and Commercial Program costs and supports more precise tracking of program-specific expenditures. For example, when the Company places a single order for promotional giveaway items to be used equally by both programs, such as 1,000 pens for customer outreach, inventory is allocated to each program and the associated expense is assigned to the requisite program, Residential or Commercial. VI. DEFERRAL BALANCE The Residential Program began the year with an over-collected deferral balance of $1,027,286 and ended 2025 with an over-collected balance of$37,300. The 2025 program year closed out with an exceptionally high number of rebate payments, drawing down the deferral balance. This was due to the "last chance" opportunity to apply for smart thermostats, storage water heaters, Tier II tankless water heaters, and Whole Home Tier II rebates before they were retired on December 31, 2025. As of June 30, 2026, the residential deferral balance was $286,774. The Commercial Program began the year with an over-collected balance of$1,037,285 and ended 2025 with an over-collected balance of$645,503. VII. COST EFFECTIVENESS Intermountain reports the cost-effectiveness of its Portfolio based on two industry standard metrics:the Utility Cost Test("UCT")and the Total Resource Cost("TRC"). The UCT measures cost-effectiveness from the utility company's perspective and takes into consideration avoided supply costs,program administration costs,and incentives paid by the utility. The TRC measures cost-effectiveness from the customer's perspective and focuses on avoided supply costs,program administration costs,and net participant costs. Although both are common industry metrics for measuring cost-effectiveness,the Company relies more on the UCT because it measures the cost- APPLICATION PAGE 5 OF 8 effectiveness of items directly under the Company's control. Exhibit No. 1, attached and incorporated by reference, outlines the cost-effectiveness for the programs and for each individual rebate offered. The Company acknowledges the Commission's rejection of the Company's request to use the deemed savings approach for evaluating the cost effectiveness of the Company's EE Program, and"the Commission has directed that utilities use a billing analysis where appropriate," in Order No. 36797. This order was received on October 14, 2025,more than halfway into the implementation of the 2025 program year. For that reason, the Company conducted cost- effectiveness testing using both the evaluated savings results from the deemed savings and modeling evaluation methods since that was in place at the time of 2025 Program planning. To comply with using billing analysis where appropriate, cost-effectiveness testing based on the available billing analysis was also conducted. The 2024 EM&V billing analysis results were applied to the Whole Home I and II, and the smart thermostat,the most current information for these measures. In compliance with Order No. 36767, a furnace billing analysis was conducted, separating savings by three furnace categories: new construction,retrofit, and replacement. The 2026 furnace billing analysis results were applied to the cost-effectiveness testing, and the full report on the furnace savings analysis is available as Exhibit 2. Cost-effectiveness testing results based on billing analysis is available in Exhibit 1,page 19. VIII. MODIFIED PROCEDURE Intermountain requests that this matter be handled under modified procedure pursuant to Rules 201-204 of the Commission's Rules of Procedure. Intermountain stands ready for immediate consideration of this matter. APPLICATION PAGE 6 OF 8 IX. REQUEST FOR RELIEF Intermountain respectfully petitions the Idaho Public Utilities Commission as follows: a. That the Commission issue an order designating $4,464,533 of 2025 Energy Efficiency expenditures as prudently incurred; b. That this Application be heard and acted upon without hearing under modified procedure c. For such other relief as the Commission may determine just and proper. Dated: November 2, 2026 GIVENS PURSLEY LLP By /s/Preston N. Carter Preston N. Carter Givens Pursley LLP Attorneys for Intermountain Gas Company APPLICATION PAGE 7 OF 8 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on November 2, 2026, I caused to be served a true and correct copy of the foregoing document to the person(s) listed below by the method indicated: Commission Staff Monica Barrios-Sanchez, Commission Secretary Via: IPUC eFile portal Idaho Public Utilities Commission 11331 W. Chinden Blvd., Bldg. 8, Suite 201-A Boise, ID 83714 secretary@pue.idaho.gov monica.baffiossanchez@puc.idaho.gov Preston N. Carter Preston N. Carter APPLICATION PAGE 8 OF 8