Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20260901Comment_1.pdf The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Ross Gibson Submission Time: Aug 312026 10:07PM Email: ross gibson@hotmail.com Telephone: 208-877-1428 Address: 1039 Helmer Lane Deary, ID 83823 Name of Utility Company:AVISTA Case ID: AVU-E-26-10 Comment: " REF: AVU-E-26-10 MUST READ Short answer: No — data centers do not "provide extra power"to Avista or lower other customers' bills. But yes —they must pay for their own transmission upgrades, and in some cases they pay so much that utilities claim it reduces pressure on general ratepayers. The rumor you heard is a distorted version of a real policy: Large-load customers (like hyper-scale data centers) must fund the new infrastructure they require, but they do not contribute power, and they do not directly lower residential bills. What a data center actually must provide to Avista 1.They must pay for their own transmission expansion Under Idaho and Washington utility rules, a "large load customer" (>_ 25 MW) must: • Pay for all new transmission lines needed to serve them • Pay for new substations • Pay for system upgrades • Pay for engineering studies • Provide financial guarantees (security deposits, construction prepayments)This is real, and Avista has publicly confirmed it. This is why Avista says the data center won't raise rates — because the customer pays for the new infrastructure. But this does not mean lower bills for everyone else. j What they do not provide 2.They do NOT provide electricity back to Avista Data centers are consumers, not generators. They do not: • Generate power • Sell power • Contribute surplus power • Lower grid load • Reduce other customers' bills The rumor that they"provide extra power" is false. L_c Why people think data centers lower bills (the kernel of truth) 3.They can reduce future rate pressure — indirectly Here's the real mechanism: • A 500-MW data center pays hundreds of millions for its own infrastructure. • Avista does not have to charge ratepayers for those upgrades. • Avista gets a huge new revenue stream from selling power to the data center. •That revenue can offset some future rate increases. This is not a bill reduction. It is simply a slower rate-increase trajectory — if the utility chooses to pass the benefit through; but utilities rarely pass through the full benefit. 1 Avista's new CPCN filing carefully avoids mentioning the real driver of regional transmission expansion — the 125-500 MW hyper-scale data center load — and instead frames the Carlin Bay line as purely for local reliability and population growth, even though their own prior public statements contradict this. Below is the precise, point-by-point breakdown of where Avista's language in this release conflicts with what they have already admitted about large-load customers and system-wide expansion needs. Where Avista's CPCN language contradicts their own prior statements 1. Avista claims the line is needed because "population and electricity demand continue to grow." But Avista has already publicly stated that: • The region's largest new load is a 125 MW --> 500 MW data center. • This load is orders of magnitude larger than residential growth. • It requires major new transmission, not distribution feeders. Conflict:Avista is presenting the Carlin Bay line as a response to local population growth,while the scale of the infrastructure matches large-load industrial demand, not residential expansion. This is classic utility framing — using a benign explanation to mask a controversial driver. 2. Avista says the line provides "dependable energy for existing and future customers." This wording is intentionally vague. It implies: • "Future customers" = normal households or small businesses. But Avista has already acknowledged that: • The "future customer" driving transmission planning is a hyper-scale data center. • The load is so large it affects regional transmission, not just local feeders. Conflict:Avista uses generic language ("future customers") to avoid admitting the real customer is a single massive industrial load. This is word manipulation —technically true, but misleading by omission. 3. Avista says the line is needed because two feeders have "reached their capacity." This is partially true — but incomplete. Distribution feeders reaching capacity is a local issue, normally solved by: • Adding a new feeder • Upgrading conductor size • Adding sectionalizing • Installing a new local substation But Avista is proposing a 115 kV transmission line, which is: • A regional infrastructure project • Far beyond what is needed for feeder relief • Exactly the voltage class required for large industrial loads Conflict: Avista is describing a distribution problem, but proposing a transmission solution — which only makes sense if the real driver is a major new load, not just local reliability. This is strategic framing — using a small problem to justify a a large project. 4. Avista claims the line will "create greater flexibility in delivering energy and reserve capacity." This is true — but again, incomplete. Transmission reserve capacity is only ne" -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2