Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutReply CommentsNORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 2 documentation explaining its wildfire risk modeling methodology and materials addressing the Commission’s requested WMP updates. On October 21, 2026, IDL filed its Responsive Comments after reviewing NLI’s supplemental submissions. IDL expressly agreed that the wildland-urban interface (“WUI”) is sufficiently captured in NLI’s risk modeling, withdrew its previous recommendation that the WMP be rejected, and affirmatively recommended Commission approval. IDL Responsive Comments at 1. Commission Staff has not filed additional comments on reconsideration, and its original recommendation for approval remains part of the record. The supplemented record therefore presents the Commission with a materially different basis for evaluating NLI’s application. The additional documentation addresses the matters identified in Order No. 37120, and the State Forester’s recommendation now supports approval. As discussed below, approval on reconsideration is also consistent with the Commission’s treatment of supplemental WMP information in its proceedings concerning Kootenai Electric Cooperative, Inc. (“KEC”). NLI respectfully requests that the Commission approve its 2026–2028 WMP as supplemented by its October 2, 2026 submissions. II. THE SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD SUPPORTS APPROVAL OF NLI’s WMP The Commission granted reconsideration to permit NLI to supplement the record concerning its wildfire risk modeling and the additional materials identified in Order No. 37120. Order No. 37174 at 3–4. NLI’s October 2, 2026 submissions address those matters. After reviewing those submissions, IDL withdrew its prior recommendation to reject and now affirmatively recommends approval of the WMP. NORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 3 A. IDL’s Revised Recommendation Confirms That Its Principal Concern Regarding NLI’s Wildfire Risk Modeling Has Been Resolved. In its original comments, IDL expressed concern that NLI’s wildfire risk modeling did not sufficiently identify the wildland-urban interface (“WUI”). That concern formed the basis of IDL’s recommendation that the Commission reject the WMP. NLI’s October 2 submissions explain the data and methodology used by Athena Intelligence (“Athena”) in evaluating geographic wildfire risk. Specifically, the supplemental materials establish that Athena incorporated SILVIS WUI data into its analysis, including WUI boundary information and measures of WUI density and proximity. These data were included in the geographic wildfire risk analysis used to prepare NLI’s 2026 WMP. Response to IDL Recommendations at 1; WMP Update Materials, Item 2. The supplemental materials do not describe a modification of NLI’s original risk model to add WUI information. Rather, they explain how WUI data were incorporated into the existing analysis and make that component of the modeling expressly identifiable. After reviewing NLI’s supplemental submissions, IDL stated: “When considering the additional details, IDL has a clearer understanding of the risk modeling completed by Northern Lights and agrees based on the provided details that the wildland urban interface (WUI) is sufficiently captured in the risk modeling.” IDL Responsive Comments at 1 (October 21, 2026). IDL then expressly withdrew its previous recommendation for rejection and recommended that the Commission approve NLI’s WMP. Id. IDL’s revised recommendation is significant not because it dictates the Commission’s ultimate decision, but because it reflects the State Forester’s technical assessment of the very modeling concern that prompted IDL’s original objection. The WSCA assigns the State Forester NORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 4 an express role in the Commission’s review of wildfire mitigation plans. I.C. § 61-1804(3). Here, the State Forester has reviewed the supplemental information requested on reconsideration and concluded that the WUI is sufficiently captured in NLI’s wildfire risk modeling. The supplemented record therefore resolves the principal concern underlying IDL’s original recommendation for rejection. The Commission now has both a fuller explanation of NLI’s risk modeling and IDL’s affirmative recommendation for approval. B. The Supplemental Record Demonstrates How NLI Uses Wildfire Risk Information in Its System Operations and Mitigation Decisions. Order No. 37174 also invited NLI to explain how its wildfire risk modeling accounts for its electrical infrastructure and how the WMP demonstrates approaches and methods designed to avoid and minimize wildfire risk. Order No. 37174 at 3–4. NLI’s supplemental submissions explain that Athena’s Landscape Wildfire Risk analysis evaluates geographic wildfire risk, while NLI separately maintains and evaluates information concerning its electrical infrastructure. NLI’s geographic information system, system records, inspection and testing programs, maintenance records, and operational experience provide information concerning the type, age, condition, and performance of its electrical facilities. NLI overlays its mapped electrical facilities with Athena’s geographic wildfire risk information and considers the resulting information in its system planning, maintenance, inspection, and mitigation decisions. Response to IDL Recommendations, Item 2(a). The supplemental record also provides examples of the practical application of that information. NLI used geographic wildfire risk information to identify higher risk portions of its Idaho electrical system for its 2026 drone inspection program and to identify portions of the system warranting heightened protection settings during Red Flag conditions in August 2026. Response to Order No. 37174. These examples demonstrate that NLI’s wildfire risk assessment is not NORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 5 confined to a geographic model considered in isolation. The geographic analysis informs operational decisions when evaluated together with NLI’s knowledge of its electrical system. The distinction is important. The absence of facility-specific information as a direct input into Athena’s landscape model does not mean that NLI excludes that information from its overall wildfire risk evaluation or mitigation decisions. The supplemental record explains how NLI uses both sources of information in implementing its WMP. The Commission also identified seven categories of WMP Update Materials and additional recommendations from IDL in Order No. 37120. In response to Order No. 37174, NLI submitted materials addressing each of those categories, together with a separate response to IDL’s recommendations. The submissions provide additional documentation of existing practices, incorporate information developed during Staff ’s review, and address recommendations concerning future wildfire risk evaluations. IDL reviewed these materials before withdrawing its rejection recommendation and recommending approval. The distinction between supplementing the documentation of existing practices and implementing additional measures in future WMPs is significant. The Commission has previously recognized that a WMP may satisfy the statutory requirements for approval notwithstanding recommendations for further refinement or additional information in future filings. As discussed below, the Commission’s orders concerning Kootenai Electric Cooperative and Avista provide a framework for evaluating NLI’s supplemented WMP and determining the appropriate disposition on reconsideration. III. THE COMMISSION’S PRIOR WMP DECISIONS SUPPORT APPROVAL OF NLI’S SUPPLEMENTED WMP The Commission’s recent decisions concerning Avista Corporation (“Avista”) and Kootenai Electric Cooperative, Inc. (“KEC”) provide guidance regarding the treatment of NORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 6 supplemental information and recommendations for future improvements to wildfire mitigation plans. A. The Avista Reconsideration Order Distinguishes Present Compliance from Future Improvements. In Order No. 37200, the Commission reaffirmed its approval of Avista’s 2026 WMP and rejected the argument that I.C. § 61-1804(3) required implementation of the State Forester’s recommendations as a condition of approving the current WMP rather than directing their incorporation into future filings. The Commission reasoned that requiring utilities to revise otherwise approvable plans whenever the State Forester made recommendations would impose requirements inconsistent with the statutory text and legislative intent. Order No. 37200 at 14–15. The Commission further observed that when IDL considers implementation of its recommendations necessary before approval, its comments expressly say so. Id. at 15–16. Here, IDL initially recommended rejection but, after reviewing NLI’s supplemental submissions, expressly withdrew that recommendation and recommended approval. The Commission also recognized that Staff’s recommendations for future improvements must be considered in the context of its overall recommendation for approval. Id. at 17. Commission Staff likewise recommended approval of NLI’s WMP while identifying additional information for future filings. B. The KEC Orders Establish a Procedure for Addressing Supplemental WMP Information. In Order No. 37081, the Commission determined that KEC’s 2026–2028 WMP, together with information supplied through discovery, satisfied the minimum statutory requirements of the Wildfire Standard of Care Act (“WSCA”) and the Commission’s guidelines. Because certain supplemental information had not been incorporated into the WMP itself, the Commission NORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 7 conditionally approved the plan and directed KEC to file an updated WMP incorporating that information within 14 days. The Commission separately directed KEC to incorporate IDL’s recommendations into future WMP filings. Order No. 37081 at 13–14. KEC subsequently submitted its amended WMP, and the Commission granted final approval in Order No. 37118. The KEC orders demonstrate that the Commission distinguishes between substantive compliance with the WSCA and formal incorporation of supporting information into a WMP. Where supplemental information establishes compliance, the Commission has permitted conditional approval followed by a compliance filing. NLI’s procedural posture differs because the Commission initially denied its WMP. However, the Commission subsequently granted reconsideration and expressly authorized NLI to supplement the record concerning the matters identified in Order No. 37120. NLI has now submitted that information. C. The Commission Can Approve NLI’s WMP on the Supplemented Record. NLI has supplied the additional information requested on reconsideration, addressed the Commission’s identified WMP Update Materials, and responded to IDL’s recommendations. IDL has withdrawn its previous recommendation for rejection and now recommends approval. Commission Staff ’s original recommendation for approval also remains part of the record. Under these circumstances, NLI respectfully submits that the Commission has a sufficient basis to approve its 2026–2028 WMP as supplemented. If the Commission determines that additional formal incorporation of the supplemental materials is necessary, conditional approval consistent with the procedure employed in the KEC proceeding provides an appropriate alternative. NORTHERN LIGHT INC.’S REPLY TO RECONSIDERATION ORDER NO. 37174: 8 IV. CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, NLI respectfully requests that the Commission reconsider Order No. 37120 and approve its 2026–2028 Wildfire Mitigation Plan as supplemented by its October 2, 2026 submissions. Alternatively, if the Commission determines that formal incorporation of the supplemental materials is necessary, NLI requests conditional approval with an opportunity to submit an amended WMP consistent with the procedure established in Order No. 37081. DATED this 25th day of October, 2026. JAMES, VERNON & WEEKS, P.A. /s/ Susan P. Weeks SUSAN P. WEEKS Attorneys for Northern Lights, Inc. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was served by email on the following persons this 25th day of October, 2026: Idaho Public Utility Commission Staff Erika K. Melanson, Deputy Attorney General Kelsea E. Ross, Deputy Attorney General EMAIL: secretary@puc.idaho.gov /s/ Susan P. Weeks SUSAN P. WEEKS