Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20260311Direct Waites - Redacted.pdf RECEIVED MARCH 10, 2026 IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF IDAHO POWER ) COMPANY' S APPLICATION FOR ) CASE NO. IPC-E-26-04 CERTIFICATES OF PUBLIC ) CONVENIENCE AND NECESSITY FOR ) THE SOUTH HILLS AND PEREGRINE ) POWER PLANTS AND FOR AN ) ASSOCIATED ACCOUNTING ORDER. ) IDAHO POWER COMPANY DIRECT TESTIMONY OF COURTNEY WAITES 1 Q. Please state your name, business address, and 2 present position with Idaho Power Company ("Idaho Power" or 3 "Company") . 4 A. My name is Courtney Waites . My business 5 address is 1221 West Idaho Street, Boise, Idaho 83702 . I am 6 employed by Idaho Power as a Regulatory Consultant in the 7 Regulatory Affairs Department. 8 Q. Please describe your educational background. 9 A. In December of 1998, I received a Bachelor of 10 Arts degree in Accounting from the University of Alaska in 11 Anchorage, Alaska. In 2000, I earned a Master of Business 12 Administration degree from Alaska Pacific University. I 13 have attended New Mexico State University' s Center for 14 Public Utilities and the National Association of Regulatory 15 Utility Commissioners "Practical Skills for the Changing 16 Electric Industry" conference, the Electric Utility 17 Consultants, Inc . ' s "Introduction to Rate Design and Cost 18 of Service Concepts and Techniques for Electric Utilities" 19 conference, Edison Electric Institute' s "Introduction to 20 Public Utility Accounting" course, Edison Electric 21 Institute' s "Electric Rates Advanced" course, SNL Knowledge 22 Center' s "Essentials of Regulatory Finance" course, and the 23 Financial Accounting Institute' s "Utility Finance and 24 Accounting" seminar. WAITES, DI 1 Idaho Power Company 1 Q. Please describe your work experience with 2 Idaho Power. 3 A. I began my employment with Idaho Power in 4 December 2004 in the Accounts Payable Department. In 2005, 5 I accepted a Regulatory Accountant position in the Finance 6 Department where one of my tasks was to assist in 7 responding to regulatory data requests pertaining to 8 financial issues . In 2006, I accepted a Regulatory Analyst 9 position in the Regulatory Affairs Department where my 10 duties included providing support for the Company' s various 11 regulatory activities, including tariff administration, 12 regulatory ratemaking, and compliance filings, and the 13 development of various pricing strategies and policies . In 14 January 2014, I was promoted to Regulatory Consultant where 15 my responsibilities expanded to include the development of 16 complex cost-related studies and the analysis of strategic 17 regulatory issues . I was promoted to my current position, 18 Regulatory Projects Coordinator, in March 2025, providing 19 project management and coordination for regulatory cases 20 and issues, leading and coordinating regulatory activities . 21 Q. What is the Company' s request in this case? 22 A. Idaho Power is requesting the Idaho Public 23 Utilities Commission ("Commission") issue an order (1) 24 granting a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity 25 ("CPCN") for the South Hills Power Plant, a cost-effective WAITES, DI 2 Idaho Power Company 1 natural gas-fueled facility providing up to 222 megawatts 2 ("MW") of nameplate generation ("South Hills") to meet an 3 identified capacity deficit in 2029, (2) granting a CPCN 4 for the Peregrine Power Plant, a cost-effective natural 5 gas-fueled facility providing 430 MW of nameplate 6 generation ("Peregrine") to meet an identified capacity 7 deficit in 2030, and (3) confirmation of the Company' s 8 application of accrual of Allowance for Funds Used During 9 Construction ("AFUDC") for both the South Hills and the 10 Peregrine plants to coincide with initial procurement 11 activities for the natural gas-fueled facilities . The South 12 Hills and Peregrine plants are necessary for Idaho Power to 13 continue to provide safe, reliable electric service in 2029 14 and beyond. 15 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this 16 proceeding? 17 A. The purpose of my testimony is to describe 18 AFUDC and the commencement of its accrual as soon as funds 19 are expended and committed to a construction project. For 20 generation resources, this has typically occurred 21 subsequent to the request for a CPCN. However, because of 22 the long lead times associated with materials, Idaho Power 23 has incurred expenditures associated with the Peregrine 24 plant prior to filing the request for a CPCN, and 25 anticipates expenditures associated with South Hills within WAITES, DI 3 Idaho Power Company 1 the next two months, and therefore is requesting the 2 Commission approve the accrual of AFUDC for both projects 3 when expenditures are first incurred. 4 I . ALLOWANCE FOR FUNDS USED DURING CONSTRUCTION 5 Q. Please describe AFUDC. 6 A. A generally accepted accounting principle, 7 AFUDC represents the opportunity cost of funds used during 8 construction of utility projects . Idaho Power records the 9 accumulation of all costs associated with the construction 10 of an asset, including the cost of financing the 11 construction expenditures, or AFUDC, in Federal Energy 12 Regulatory Commission ("FERC") Account 107 - Construction 13 Work in Progress ("CWIP") . When the plant is completed and 14 placed in service, the total cost of the plant, including 15 AFUDC, is moved to FERC Account 101 - Electric Plant-in- 16 Service, placing the asset in rate base. In effect, during 17 construction, the Company is allowed to earn a return on 18 CWIP by accruing AFUDC, but typically the cash recovery 19 does not occur until the associated plant is placed in 20 service and authorized for recovery in a rate proceeding, 21 which strains the Company' s credit quality. 22 Q. When does the accrual of AFUDC begin on a 23 capital project? 24 A. Guidance from FERC suggests AFUDC shall begin 25 when (1) capital expenditures for the project have been WAITES, DI 4 Idaho Power Company 1 incurred, and (2) activities that are necessary to get the 2 construction project ready for its intended use are in 3 progress . Activities include all actions required to 4 prepare the construction project for its intended use, 5 including activities prior to physical construction, such 6 as the development of plans or the process of obtaining 7 permits from governmental authorities .' Accordingly, Idaho 8 Power commences accrual of AFUDC as soon as funds are 9 expended and committed to a construction project. 10 Q. How do these activities differ from 11 preliminary survey and investigation ("PS&I") activities 12 for which AFUDC does not accrue? 13 A. In accordance with Order No. 29904,2 costs 14 associated with investigation into the viability of 15 potential resources identified as part of the Integrated 16 Resource Plan are recorded to PS&I accounts . For example, 17 for benchmark bids prepared for submittal into a Request 18 for Proposals ("RFP") for new generation resources by the 19 Company' s Internal Bid Team, any consulting fees incurred 20 to aid in the development of an RFP bid submittal would be 21 charged to PS&I as the project' s viability as a least-cost, 22 least-risk resource has not yet been determined. 1 FERC: Capitalization of Allowance for Funds Used During Construction. 2 In the Matter of the Petition of Idaho Power Company for an Accounting Order Modifying the Accounting Procedures for Preliminary Survey and Investigation Charges, IPC-E-05-21. WAITES, DI 5 Idaho Power Company 1 Q. When does Idaho Power deem a project viable or 2 infeasible? 3 A. In the past, once selected on the final 4 shortlist having been identified as a least-cost, least 5 risk resource, and subsequently acknowledged by the Public 6 Utility Commission of Oregon ("OPUC") in accordance with 7 the competitive bidding rules, Idaho Power moves the 8 charges to FERC Account 107 - CWIP as the viability of the 9 project has been confirmed, and AFUDC commences . However, 10 as explained in more detail in the Direct Testimony of Mr. 11 Adam Richins, based on industry demand for long-lead 12 materials, and to ensure commercial operation dates are 13 met, the Company has been incurring capital expenditures 14 associated with resource procurements much earlier than 15 Idaho Power previously experienced. 16 II . PROPOSED ACCOUNTING TREATMENT 17 Q. When does the Company commence accrual of 18 AFUDC? 19 A. In the past, payment for procurement of 20 materials has typically not occurred until after Idaho 21 Power has filed a request for a CPCN with the Commission, 22 at which time the Company commences AFUDC accrual . 23 However, in order to secure a position in the queue to 24 purchase the turbine for Peregrine, Idaho Power was 25 required to make a down payment of approximately $_ WAITES, DI 6 Idaho Power Company 1 - in June 2025 . In addition, a payment for the 2 reciprocating internal combustion engines ("reciprocating 3 engines") for South Hills will be made in the next two 4 months . The reciprocating engines and turbine reservation 5 payments are necessary to ensure both plants would be 6 operational in time to meet the identified capacity needs . 7 Because of current supply chain demands, our entire 8 industry, including Idaho Power, has been experiencing 9 longer lead times for the core components for generation 10 facilities (e .g. , turbines and transformers) and therefore 11 is seeking confirmation of the appropriateness to commence 12 the accrual of AFUDC once the necessary relatively large 13 expenditures for the resources are incurred to ensure 14 timely delivery. 15 Q. Does the Company believe accrual of AFUDC once 16 payments are made for materials is consistent with FERC' s 17 guidance? 18 A. Yes . A down payment for materials is evidence 19 that capital expenditures are being incurred and the 20 procurement is necessary to begin construction of the 21 project, which aligns with FERC' s guidance on the 22 commencement of AFUDC accrual . However, because Idaho 23 Power will incur costs associated with resource 24 procurements prior to receiving a CPCN, the Company is 25 requesting the Commission acknowledge it is appropriate to WAITES, DI 7 Idaho Power Company 1 begin the accrual of AFUDC once the South Hills and 2 Peregrine had been deemed viable and expenditures 3 associated with the resource procurements have been 4 incurred. This treatment would recognize the required 5 upfront investments made by the Company in pursuit of 6 cost-effective, necessary resources to safely and reliably 7 serve customers . 8 Q. Is this treatment similar to the treatment 9 sought in Case No. IPC-E-25-29, Idaho Power' s request for 10 a CPCN for the Bennett Mountain Gas Expansion Project? 11 A. Yes . In addition to the request for a CPCN, 12 the Company requested confirmation of the application of 13 the accrual of AFUDC for the Bennett Gas Expansion Project 14 to coincide with initial procurement activities . The 15 Commission approved Idaho Power' s request to commence 16 accrual of AFUDC to coincide with initial procurement 17 activities for the Bennett Gas Expansion Project with 18 Order No. 36958 . 19 Q. Is Idaho Power requesting the Commission deem 20 the accrued AFUDC amounts prudent at this time? 21 A. No. The Company is not seeking a prudence 22 determination of any project costs incurred at this time . 23 Rather, once the South Hills and Peregrine plants have 24 been completed and placed in-service, Idaho Power will 25 file a request with the Commission for a review and WAITES, DI 8 Idaho Power Company 1 approval of all prudently incurred project costs, 2 including any accrued AFUDC amounts . 3 III . CONCLUSION 4 Q. Please summarize your testimony. 5 A. Idaho Power records the accumulation of all 6 costs associated with the construction of an asset, 7 including AFUDC, in CWIP. When the plant is completed, the 8 total cost of the plant, including AFUDC, is moved to 9 Electric Plant-in-Service, placing the asset in rate base . 10 The Company commences accrual of AFUDC as soon as funds are 11 expended and committed to a construction project, which, 12 for generation resources, has typically occurred subsequent 13 to the request for a CPCN. Because of long lead times, 14 Idaho Power has incurred expenditures for South Hills and 15 Peregrine prior to receiving a CPCN for either plant. The 16 Company is requesting the Commission confirm Idaho Power' s 17 treatment of the accrual of AFUDC for both projects is 18 appropriate when expenditures are first incurred, which 19 occurred prior to a request for a CPCN. 20 Q. Does this complete your testimony? 21 A. Yes, it does . WAITES, DI 9 Idaho Power Company 1 DECLARATION OF COURTNEY WAITES 2 I, Courtney Waites, declare under penalty of perjury 3 under the laws of the state of Idaho: 4 1 . My name is Courtney Waites . I am employed 5 by Idaho Power Company as a Regulatory Projects Coordinator 6 in the Regulatory Affairs department. 7 2 . On behalf of Idaho Power, I present this 8 pre-filed direct testimony in this matter. 9 3 . To the best of my knowledge, my pre-filed 10 direct testimony is true and accurate. 11 I hereby declare that the above statement is true to 12 the best of my knowledge and belief, and that I understand 13 it is made for use as evidence before the Idaho Public 14 Utilities Commission and is subject to penalty for perjury. 15 SIGNED this loth day of March 2026, at Boise, Idaho . 16 17 - - 18 Signed: WAITES, DI 10 Idaho Power Company