Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20260217Decision Memo.pdf DECISION MEMORANDUM TO: COMMISSIONER LODGE COMMISSIONER HAMMOND COMMISSIONER HARDIE COMMISSION SECRETARY COMMISSION STAFF LEGAL FROM: CURTIS THADEN, COMMISSION STAFF ERIKA K. MELANSON,DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL DATE: FEBRUARY 17, 2026 RE: AVISTA UTILITIES TARIFF ADVICE NO.AVU-TAE-26-01 REVISION TO IPUC TARIFF NO. 28, SCHEDULE 58 (TAX ADJUSTMENT SCHEDULE—IDAHO); CASE NO. AVU-TAE-26-01. On January 28, 2026, Avista Corporation d/b/a Avista Utilities ("Company") submitted to the Idaho Public Utilities Commission("Commission") a revised Tariff Advice. STAFF ANALYSIS In the January 28, 2026 filing, the Company requested to revise Tariff No. 28 to increase the percentage of the franchise fee being collected for the City of Kellogg ("City") found in Schedule No. 58 (Tax Adjustment Schedule— Idaho) ("Schedule No. 58"). The City's franchise fee will increase from one percent (1%) to three percent (3%) that is imposed on gross revenue from the sale of electricity to customers within the city limits. The increase is the result of Ordinance No. 644, which amends Ordinance No. 557, being passed on January 14, 2026. Application at 12. A copy of the 1) City Ordinance No. 644, and the 2) the proposed revisions to Schedule No. 58 are attached (Attachment A). The Company is requesting an effective date of March 1, 2026. Idaho Code § 50-329A allows cities to establish franchise fees assessed upon a public service provider up to one percent without the consent of the public service provider or the approval of a majority of voters of the city voting on the question at an election. Franchise fees up to three percent are allowed with the consent of the public service provider or the approval of a majority of voters of the city voting on the question at an election. DECISION MEMORANDUM - 1 - FEDBRUARY 17, 2026 STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff has reviewed the Company's proposed tariff change, Ordinance No. 644, and the franchise fee requirements of Idaho Code § 50-329A(a). Staff recommends that the Commission accept the Company's proposed revision to Schedule No. 58 as filed, with an effective date of March 1, 2026. COMMISSION DECISION Does the Commission wish to accept the Company's proposed revision to Schedule No. 58, as filed, with an effective March 1, 2026? Curtis Thaden Commission Staff I:\Utility\UDMEMOS\AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memo.docx DECISION MEMORANDUM - 2 - FEDBRUARY 17, 2026 ORDINANCE NO.644 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF KELLOGG, SHOSHONE COUNTY IDAHO, AMENDING ORDINANCE 557 WHICH GRANTS AVISTA CORPORATION, D/B/A AVISTA UTILITIES, A WASHINGTON CORPORATION,A NONEXCLUSIVE FRANCHISE TO LOCATE,CONSTRUCT, INSTALL, OWN, MAINTAIN, REPAIR, REPLACE, EXTEND, OPERATE AND USE ELECTRIC FACILITIES AND APPURTENANCES IN, UPON, OVER, UNDER, ALONG, AND ACROSS THE PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY UNDER THE JURISDICTION OF THE CITY OF KELLOGG FOR PURPOSES OF THE TRANSMISSION, DISTRIBUTION, AND CONTROL OF ELECTRICITY; INCREASING THE FRANCHISE FEE; ESTABLISHING DURATION; PROVIDING SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR THE REPEAL OF CONFLICTING ORDINANCES;AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, Avista Corporation dba Avista Utilities ("Avista"), a Washington Corporation, which Is authorized to do business within the state of Idaho, has filed with the City of Kellogg, State of Idaho (the "City") a written application for renewal of its Franchise to locate, access, construct, operate, maintain and use such plants, works poles, elevated wires, underground cables, equipment and appurtenances over, under, along and across all of City's rights-of-way and public property in the City for the purposes of the transmission,control,distribution,and sale of Electricity;and the City has determined it is in the interest of persons and businesses in this jurisdiction to have access to Avista's services; THEREFORE,THE CITY OF KELLOGG DOES ORDAIN: SECTION 1.0 DEFINITIONS For the purposes of this Franchise the following terms, phrases, words and their derivations shall have the meaning given In this Section.When not inconsistent with the context, words used In the present tense include the future,words in the plural include the singular, and words In the singular include the plural. Words not defined shall be give their common and ordinary meaning. 1.1 Avista. "Avista"means Avista Corporation,dba Avista Utilities,a Washington corporation, and Its respective successors and assigns, agents and contractors. 1.2 City. "City" means the City of Kellogg, a municipal corporation of the State of Idaho, and tis respective successors and assigns. 1.3 Commission. "Commission" means the Idaho Public Utilities Commission, or such successor regulatory agency having jurisdiction over investor-owned public utilities in the State of Idaho. 1.4 Days. "Days" means business days. 1.5 Facilities. "Facilities" means, collectively, any and all electric transmission, and distribution systems and appurtenances owned by Avista, now and In the future In the Franchise Area, Including but not limited to poles, towers, overhead and underground wires and cables, Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17,2026 conduits, vaults, transformers, meters, meter-reading devices, communication and control systems and other equipment, appliances, fixtures, attachments, appurtenances and other Items necessary,convenient,or in anyway appertainingto any and all of the foregoing for the purposes of transmission, distribution, and control of electricity,whether the same be located above or below ground. 1.6 Franchise. "Franchise" means the grant by the City of rights, privileges and authority embodied in this Ordinance. 1.7 Franchise Area. "Franchise Area" means the surface and space above and below all rights-of- way for; • Public roads, streets, avenues, alleys, bridges, tunnels, easements, and highways of the City, as now laid out, platted, dedicated, acquired or improved within the present corporate limits of the City; • Public roads,streets, avenues,alleys,bridges,tunnels,easements, and highways that may hereafter be laid out, platted, dedicated, acquired or Improved within the present corporate limits of the City and as such limits may be extended by annexation of otherwise during the term of this Franchise; • All City-owned utility easements dedicated for the placement and location of various utilities,providing such easements would permit Avista to fully exercise the rights granted under this Franchise within the area covered by the easement; and • Any other specifically designated City-owned property. 1.8 Maintenance, maintaining, or maintain. The meaning of the terms "maintenance, maintaining, or maintain" includes, without limit, repairing, replacing, upgrading, examining, testing, Inspecting, and removing Avista Facilities, vegetation management, digging and excavating, and restoration of affected right-of-way surfaces. 1.9 Parties. "Parties" means City and Avista collectively. 1.10 Party. "Party" means either City or Avista individually. 1.11 Person. "Person" means a business entity or natural person. 1.12 Public Project. ""Public Project" means any Citty or other government-funded capital Improvement project on the rights-of-way or city property within the Franchise Area. 1.13 Right-of-way. "Right-of-way" means the surface of and the space along above, and below any street,road, highway, freeway, lane,sidewalk,alley, utility easement, and/or right-of-way now or hereafter held or administered by the City. 1.14 State. "State" means the State of Idaho. 1.15 Tariff. "Tariff" means the rate schedules, rules, and regulations relating to utility service, filed with and approved by the Commission during the term of this Franchise. SECTION 2.0 GRANT OF FRANCHISE Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 City hereby grants to Avista the right, power, privilege and authority to enter upon all roads, rights-of-way, streets, alleys, highways, public places, or structures, lying within the Franchise Area to locate, construct, operate, and maintain its Facilities for the purpose of controlling, transmitting, and distributing electricity, as may be necessary to provide electric service to Customers within the Franchise Area. 2.1 Effective Date This Ordinance is effective as of the date of approval,passage,and publication as required by law. 2.2 Term The rights, privileges, and Franchise hereby granted to Avista will remain for a term of 25 years from the Effective Date of October 1, 2012, and shall continue year-to-year thereafter,until It is otherwise renewed, or terminated by either Party,with not less than 180 days prior written notice to the other Party. 2.3 Non-Exclusive Franchise This Franchise is not,and will not be deemed to be, an exclusive Franchise.This Franchise shall not in any manner prohibit the City from granting other franchises within the Franchise Area that do not interfere with Avista's rights under this Franchise.This Franchise shall not prohibit or prevent the City from using the Franchise Area or affect the jurisdiction of the City over the same or any part thereof. City may not, however, award an electric franchise to another party under more favorable or less onerous terms than those of this Franchise without this Franchise being amended to reflect such more favorable or less onerous terms. 2.4 Notice of City's Intent to Compete With Avista inconsideration of Avista's undertaking pursuant to this Franchise, the City agrees that in the event the City Intends to engage in the business of providing Electric service during the life of this Franchise or any extension of this Franchise, In competition with Avista, the City will provide Avista with six months-notice of such action. 2,5 Assignment of Franchise Avista shall have the right to assign its rights, benefits,and privileges under this Franchise. Any assignee shall,within thirty(30)days of the date of any assignment,file written notice of the assignment with the City together with its written acceptance of all terms and conditions of this Franchise. As permitted by law and Commission regulation, Avista shall have the right, without notice to or consent of the City, to mortgage or hypothecate Its rights, benefits, and privileges In and under this Franchise as security for indebtedness. 2.6 Franchise Fees As compensation for the franchise granted by this Ordinance, Avista shall pay to the city an amount equal to three percent (3%) of the annual gross revenue collected by Avista from its customers for electricity consumed within the City. Gross revenue will be computed deducting from the total electric billings of Avista the total net write-off of uncollectible accounts. Avista Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 may offset against such compensation the amount of any license,permit or other fees paid to the City in connection with Avista's use of the rights-of-way within the Franchise Area, The City has the right to Increase its franchise fee pursuant to Chapter 3, Title 50, Idaho Code. Any such increase hereunder shall provide that the Increased franchise fee will apply to any electric service provider (other than the City) who utilizes the City's streets, alleys, or other public places to provide gas service within the City, during the term of this Franchise. SECTION 3.0 AViSTA'S OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE 3.1 Compliance with Laws, Regulations, Codes, and Standards In carrying out any authorized activities under the privileges granted by this Franchise, Avlsta shall meet accepted Industry standards and codes and shall comply with applicable laws, regulations, and ordinances of any governmental entity with Jurisdiction over Avista's Facilities in the Franchise Area.This Includes all applicable laws,regulations, and ordinances existing as of the Effective Date or may be subsequently enacted by any governmental entity with Jurisdiction over Avista's operation within the Franchise Area. The City shall have the right to make and enforce reasonable rules and regulations pertaining to the conduct of Avista's operations within the Franchise Area. Prior to the adoption of any new rule, procedure, or policy, Avista shall be provided a written draft document for comment with a response period of not less than thirty days.Service shall be supplied to the City and its inhabitants In accordance with Avista's rules and regulations and Tariffs currently or subsequently filed with and approved by the Commission. 3.2 Facility Location and Non-Interference Avista shall have the discretion to determine the placement of its Facilities as may be necessary to provide safe and reliable electric service within the Franchise Area, subject to the following non-interference requirement. Ali construction, installation, repair, relocation, or operation of Avista's Facilities performed by Avista in the Franchise Area will be done in such a manner s not to interfere with the existing facilities or construction and maintenance of other utilities (public or private) including drains, drainage ditches and structures, irrigations ditches and structures located therein, nor with the grading or improvement of the Franchise Area or vehicular use within the Franchise Area. 3.3 Facility Location Information Avista shall provide the City, upon the City's reasonable request, Facility location Information in electronic or hard copy showing the location of its Facilities at specific locations within the Franchise Area,to the extent such information is reasonably available.Avlsta does not warrant the accuracy of any such Facility location information provided and, to the extent the location of Facilities are shown,such Facilities may be shown in their approximate location. With respect to any excavations within the Franchise Area undertaken by or on behalf of Avista or the City, nothing stated In this Franchise Is intended (nor shall be construed) to relieve either party of their respective obligations arising under the State on-call law with respect to determining the Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 location of existing underground utility facilities in the vicinity of such excavations prior to commencing work. 3.4 Vegetation Management-Trimming/Removal of Trees State law requires electric utilities to comply with the national Electric Safety Code, Including the guidance in the Code for the trimming or removal of vegetation Interfering or potentially interfering with energized power lines.The right of Avista to maintain Its Facilities and appurtenances under this Franchise shall accordingly Include the right, as exercised in Avista's professional discretion,to utilize an integrated vegetation management program to minimize the likelihood that vegetation encroaching (either above or below the ground) on Avista's Facilities can lead to power outages and other threats to public safety and welfare.Avista or its agents may inhibit the growth of, prune, or remove any trees and vegetation which overhangs or encroaches upon its electric transmission and distribution corridors within the Franchise Area,whether such trees or vegetation originate within or outside the Right-of-way. Nothing contained in this Section shall prevent Avista,when necessary and with the approval of the record owner of the property on which they may be located,from pruning or removing any trees which overhang the Franchise Area and may Interfere with Avista's Facilities. 3.5 Right of Excavation For the purpose of implementing the privileges granted under this Franchise, and after any required notification is made to the City, Avista Is authorized to make any necessary excavations in, under,and across the street, alleys,roads,rights-of-way, and public grounds within the Franchise Area. Such excavation shall be carried out with reasonable dispatch and with as little Interference with or inconvenience to the public as may be feasible. Avista shall remove all debris stemming from excavation and construction.The Right-of-way surface shalt be restored by Avista after excavation, in accordance with applicable City and Avista specifications. 3.6 Emergency Work In the event of an emergency requiring Immediate action by Avista to protect the public health and safety or to protect its Facilities, or the property of the City or other persons Int eh Franchise Area,Avista may immediately proceed with excavation or other Right-of way work,with concurrent notice to the City to the extent possible. SECTION 4.0 RESERVATION OF CITY'S RIGHTS AND ROWERS The City, in granting this Franchise, does not waive any rights which it may now have or may subsequently acquire with respect to road rights-of-way of the City under this Franchise,and this Franchise shall not be construed to deprive the City of any such powers, rights, or privileges which it now has or may hereafter acquire to regulate the use of and to control the City's roads and rights-of-way covered by this Franchise. Nothing in the terms of this Franchise shall be Attachment A Case No.AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17,2026 construed or deemed to prevent the City form exercising at any time any power of eminent domain granted to it under the laws of this State. 4.1 Necessary Construction/Maintenance by City The construction, operation, and maintenance of Avista's Facilities authorized by this Franchise shall not preclude the City, its agents or its contractors, from grading, excavating, or doing other necessary road work contiguous to Avista's Facilities, provided that Avista shall be given not less than ten business days' notice of said work, and provided further that the City, Its agents and contractors, Shall be liable for any damages, including any consequential damages to third parties, caused by said work to any Facilities belonging to Avista. 4.2 Removal of Abandoned Facilities During the Term of this Franchise, or upon a revocation or non-renewal of this Franchise, the City may direct Avista to remove designated abandoned Facilities from the Franchise Area at its own expense and as soon as practicable, but only where such abandoned Facilities constitute a demonstrated threat to public health and safety. If it becomes necessary for the City to remove the designated Facilities the City shall be paid the reasonable and actual costs of removal by Avista. 4.3 Vacation of Properties By City If, at any time,the City shall vacate any road, right-of-way, or other public property which Is subject to rights granted by this Franchise, such vacation shall be subject to the reservation of a perpetual easement to Avista for the purpose of operating and maintaining Avista's Facilities on the affected property pursuant to Idaho Code 50-311. 4.4 Utility Pole Attachments By City City shall be permitted, upon reasonable notice to Avista and without charge by Avista, to attach its traffic control, street lighting, fire and police communications equipment to Avista's poles in the Franchise Area, but at the City's own risk and only in accordance with standard safety practices, codes and Avista specifications. If there is not sufficient space available on Avista's structures such structures may be changed, altered, or rearranged at the expense of the City so as to provide proper clearance and capacity for City facilities. Such City facilities shall be subject to removal or repositioning by Avista to the extent necessary for utility worker safety and proper construction, maintenance, operation, or repair of Avista's Facilities and appurtenances. City assumes all responsibility for the Installation and maintenance of City's facilities Installed on Avista's Facilities. 4.5 Change of Boundaries of the City Any subsequent additions or modifications of the boundaries of the City, whether by annexation, consolidation, or otherwise, shall be subject to the provisions of this Franchise as to all such areas.The City shall notify Avista of the scope of any change of boundaries not less than thirty(30) days prior to such change becoming effective. Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 SECTION 5.0 RELOCATION OF AVISTXS FACILITIES City acknowledges that Avista Is obligated to provide electric services and related line extension, relocation, or conversion of its Facilities forthe benefit of its Customers and to require compensation for such services on a non-preferential basis in accordance with applicable Tariffs. 5.1 Public Project Construction Whenever the City causes the construction of any Public Project and/or the alteration or Improvement of any road, highway, or Right-of-way within the Franchise Area, and such construction necessitates the relocation of Avista's Facilities from their existing location to another location within the Franchise Area,such relocation will be at no cost to the City. City shall notify Avista of any Intended or expected requirement or request to relocate Avista's Facilities as early as practicable, but will make reasonable efforts to provide not less than 120 days prior to any such relocation. After receipt of such notice,Avista shall complete relocation of its Facilities at least ten days prior to commencement of the project or an agreed upon date by both parties. If any relocation to accommodate the City forces Avista off of a Right-of-way then City will make a reasonable effort to accommodate said relocation on alternative public Right-of-way. 5.2 Public Project Related Relocation Costs The City shall have no responsibility for the costs of the relocations described In Section 5.1, however,the City agrees to provide reasonable advance notice to Avista in the event the City requires the subsequent relocation of any Avista Facilities previously relocated per Section 5.1 due to a Public Project. 5.3 Relocation of Facilities Request by Third Parties If Avista's Facilities within the Franchise Area are to be relocated at the request of or for the primary benefit of a third party (Including compliance by such party with any condition or requirement associated with approvals or permits to be obtained pursuant to any zoning, land use, construction or other development regulation), Avista is authorized to make arrangements with the benefited third party prior to relocation to receive reasonable compensation for such relocation costs incurred. Avista agrees to indemnify, defend, and hold City harmless for any disputes between Avista and such third parties regarding compensation.In the event the required move forces Avista off public Right-of-way,City will provide for proper easement or Right-of-way to accommodate said relocation. Nothin in this Section 5.3 shall require Avista to bear any cost or expense in connection with the location or relocation of any Facilities then existing pursuant to easement or such other rights not derived from this Franchise. 5.4 Temporary Relocation of Facilities Requested by Third Parties At the request of any Person holding a valid permit or other written permission from the City, and upon reasonable advance notice and payment by the permit holder of Avista's expenses of such temporary change, Avista will temporarily raise, lower, or remove its Facilities as Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 necessary to accommodate a permittee of the City desiring to move over-sized structures or equipment along or across the Right-of-way in the Franchise Area. 5.5 Conversion of Existing Overhead Electric Facilities City,subject to applicable laws, rules, regulations,and tariffs, may direct Avista to convert from above ground to below ground, wires for the distribution of electricity if such installation Is feasible, practical, and required for the public Interest,safety, and convenience. The Incremental cost of such conversion of existing overhead Facilities shall be borne and paid by the City or other party requesting the same, subject to law and such rules, regulations, and Tariffs of the Commission, 5.6 Availability of Funds In the event federal, state, or other funds are available in whole or in part for utility relocating purposes related to a Public Project as set forth in Section 5.1 above,the City in Its sole discretion, may apply for such funds and Avista will be reimbursed to the extent any such funds are actually obtained and designated for utility relocation costs. SECTION 6.0 INDEMNITY 6.1 indemnification of City Avista agrees to defend and indemnify the City, Its appointed and elected officers and employees, from any and all liabilities, claims, causes of action, losses, damages, and expenses, including costs and reasonable attorneys fees, that the City may sustain, incur, become liable for, or be required to pay, as a consequence of or arising from the construction, installation, maintenance, condition or operation of Avista's Facilities in the Franchise Area; provided, however, that this indemnification provision shall not apply to the extent that said liabilities, claims, damages, and losses were caused by or result from the negligence of the City, its employees or agents, 6.5 Indemnification of Avista City agrees to defend and indemnify Avista, Its officers and employees, from any and all liabilities, claims,causes of action,losses,damages and expenses, including costs and reasonable attorneys fees, that Avista may sustain, incur, become liable for, or be required to pay, as a consequence of or arising from the negligent acts or omissions of the City,Its officers,employees or agents In connection with City's obligations under this Franchise; provided, however, that this Indemnification provision shall not apply to the extent that said liabilities, claims, damages, losses, and so forth were caused by or result from the negligence of Avista, its employees or agents. SECTION 7.0 FRANCHISE DISPUTE RESOLUTION 7.1 Non-Waiver Attachment A Case No.AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17,2026 Failure of a Party to declare any breach or default of this Franchise immediately upon the occurrence thereof, or delay In taking any action in connection therewith, shall not waive such breach or default, but the Party shall have the right to declare any such breach or default at any time. Failure of a Party to declare one breach or default does not act as a waiver of the Party's right to declare another breach or default. In addition, the pursuit of any right or remedy by the City shall not prevent the City form thereafter declaring a revocation and forfeiture for breach of the conditions of the Franchise. 7.2 Revocation and Forfeiture of Franchise if Avista shall willfully violate or fall to comply with any of the provisions of this Franchise through willful and unreasonable neglect or willful and unreasonable failure to heed or comply with any notice given Avista under the provisions of this grant, this Franchise may be revoked by the City and Avista shall forfeit all rights conferred under the Franchise; provided, however, the City shall give 90-days' written notice of its intention to revoke the Franchise during which Period Avista shall have the opportunity to remedy any breach. 7.3 Dispute Resolution by the Parties Disputes regarding the interpretation or execution of the terms of this Franchise that cannot be resolved by Department counterparts representing the Parties,shall be submitted to the City's Attorney and a representative of Avista's Legal Department for resolution. If a mutually satisfactory or timely resolution cannot then be reached by the above process, prior to resorting to a court of competent jurisdiction,the Partis shall submit the dispute to a non-binding alternate dispute resolution process agreed to by the Parties. 7.4 Right of Enforcement No provision of this Franchise shall be deemed to bar the right of the City or Avista to seek judicial relief from a violation of any provision of the Franchise to recover monetary damages for such violations by the other party or to seek enforcement of the other Party's obligations under this Franchise by means of specific performance,injunctive relief or any other remedy at law or In equity.Any litigation between the City and Avista arising under or regarding this Franchise shall occur, If In the state courts, in Shoshone County, Idaho, a court of competent jurisdiction, and if in the federal courts, In the United States District Court for the District of Idaho. 7.5 Attorneys' Fees and Costs Each party shall pay for its own attorneys'fees and costs Incurred in any dispute resolution process or legal action arising out of the existence of this Franchise, SECTION 8.0 GENERAL PROVISIONS 8.1 Franchise As Contract, No Third-Party Beneficiaries This Franchise is a contract between the Parties and binds and benefits the Parties and their respective successors and assigns.This Franchise does not and is not intended to confer any rights or remedies upon any persons, entities,or beneficiaries other than the Parties. Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 8.2 Force Majeure in the event that Avista is delayed In or prevented from the performance of any of its obligations under the Franchise by circumstances beyond Avista's control (Force Majeure) including,without limitation, third party labor disputes,fire,explosion,flood, earthquake, power outage, acts of God,war or other hostilities and civil commotion, then Avista's performance shall be excused during the period of the Force Majeure occurrence. Avista will use all commercially reasonable efforts to minimize the period of the disability due to the occurrence. Upon removal or termination of the occurrence Avista will promptly resume performance of the affected Franchise obligations in an orderly and expeditious manner. 8.3 Prior Franchise Superseded As of the Effective Date this Franchise shall supersede all prior electric franchises for the Franchise Area previously granted to Avista or its predecessors by City, and shall affirm,authorize and ratify all prior Installations authorized by permits or other action not previously covered by Franchise. Termination of the prior Franchise shall not, however, relieve the Parties from any obligations which accrued under said Franchise prior to Its termination, including but not limited to, any outstanding indemnity, reimbursement or administrative fee payment obligations. 8.4 Severability The Franchise Is granted pursuant to the laws of the State of Idaho relating to the granting of such rights and privileges by City. If any article, section, sentence, clause, or phrase of this Franchise is for any reason held illegal, invalid, or unconstitutional, such invalidity shall not affect the validity of the Franchise or any of the remaining portions,The invalidity of any portion of this Franchise shall not abate, reduce, or otherwise affect any obligation required of Avista. 8.5 Changes or Amendments No change or amendment to this Franchise shall be effective until lawfully adopted by the City and agreed to by Avista. 8.6 Supremacy and Governing Law This Agreement shall be interpreted,construed,and enforced in all respects in accordance with the laws of the State of Idaho. In the event of any conflict between this Franchise and any City ordinance, regulation, or permit, the provision of this Franchise shall control. Notwithstanding the above, the City acknowledges that Avista is subject to Its Tariff with the Commission, and while this relationship is separate and not Minding between the Parties to this Franchise, in the event the terms of this Franchise create a conflict under Avista's Tariff, Avista may be required to suspend or abandon this Franchise if such conflict Is not capable to being resolved.Such suspension or abandonment shall be In accordance with Section 8.10 below.Avista agrees that it will not knowingly petition or persuade the Commission to amend or modify its Tariff to create a conflict. 8.7 Headings Attachment A Case No.AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17,2026 The headings or titles in this Franchise are for the purpose or reference only and shall not In any way affect the interpretation of construction of this Franchise. 8.8 Acceptance of Franchise Avista shall, within 30 days after passage of this Ordinance, file with the City Clerk, Its acceptance of the terms and conditions of this Franchise. 8.9 Franchise Effective Date The Effective Date of this Franchise shall be October 1, 2012 after passage, approval and legal publication of this ordinance as provided by law, and provided that it has been duly accepted by Avista as specified above. 8.10 Abandonment or Suspension of Franchise Rights and Obligations Avista may at any time abandon the rights and authorities granted hereunder, provided that six (6) months' written notice of intention to abandon is given to City. in addition, pursuant to Section 8.6 and In the event a conflict exists between the terms of this Franchise and Avista's Tariff with the Commission that cannot be resolved, Avista may suspend or abandon the rights and obligations of this Franchise upon reasonable notice to the City. PASSED under suspension of the rules upon which a roll call vote was taken and duly enacted an Ordinance of the City of Kellogg, Shoshone County, Idaho at a convened meeting of the City of Kellogg City Council held on the 141h day of January 2026. M or Rod Plank ATTEST: City Clerk/Treasurer Lindsy Strobel Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17,2026 Twenty-fourththird Revision Sheet 58 Canceling I.P.U.C. No.28 Twenty-ihirdsesond Revision Sheet 58 58 AVISTA CORPORATION dlbla Avista Utilities SCHEDULE 58 TAX ADJUSTMENT SCHEDULE- IDAHO The rate schedules of the Company for electric service furnished in Idaho do not include any portion of municipal occupation, business,excise or use of the streets, taxes,or charges. In order to reimburse the Company for such taxes or charges, amounts equivalent to such taxes or charges where now imposed,or which may hereafter be imposed,will be billed by the Company to its Customers as set forth below. APPLICABLE: To all charges for electric service rendered pursuant to tariff 28 within the jurisdiction imposing a tax or charge, as provided in Rule 3 of the Rules and Regulations included in this tariff. TAX ADJUSTMENT: The rates and charges named in this tariff shall be proportionately increased by an adjustment equivalent to the amount of the tax or charge imposed by the jurisdiction and effective as listed below: Idaho Municipality Ordinance or Resolution Date Ordinance Effective Charge' City of Clark Fork Ord. No.268 May 1,2017 1%franchise fee City of Coeur d'Alene Ord. No.2517 July 1, 1993 5%franchise fee City of Dalton Gardens Ord. No. 168 February 1,2005 1%franchise fee City of Deary Ord.No.405 January 1,2026 1%franchise fee City of Dover Ord. No. 54 October 1,2000 1%franchise fee City of Elk River Ord. No.209 February 5,2018 1%franchise fee City of Feman Lake Village Res No. 195 Ord, No. 166 March 1,2024 1%franchise fee City of Grangeville Ord. No. 972 January 1,2024 1%franchise fee City or Hayden Ord.391 October 1, 2005 1%franchise fee City of Hayden Lake Ord. No. 14B June 1, 1998 1%franchise fee City of Kamiah Ord. No. 97-2 January 1, 1997 1%franchise fee City of Kendrick Ord. No.739 January 1,2013 1%franchise fee City of Kellogg Ord. No. 557 as amended by 644 March 1,2026€+ctaber 1,2042 34%franchise fee City of Kooskia Ord.No. 172 March 1,2013 1%franchise fee City of Kootenai Ord.No. 113 August 1, 1996 1%franchise fee City of Lapwai Ord. No. 300 January 1, 2001 1%franchise fee City of Lewiston Ord. No.4256 January 1,2000 1%franchise fee City of Moscow Ord. No.2005-34 April 1,2006 3%franchise fee City of Mullan Ord.No.310A May 1, 1997 1%franchise fee City of Oldtown Ord. No.2010-2 June 1,2010 1%franchise fee City of Orofino Ord.No.707 January 11,2002 3%franchise fee City of Osburn Ord. No.234 June 1,2001 1%franchise fee City of Pierce Res, No. 136 May 1, 1999 1%franchise fee City of Pinehurst Ord. No.2022-239 July 1,2022 1%franchise fee City of Ponderay Ord, No.3-16 November 1, 1996 1%franchise fee City of Post Falls Res. No.2002-17 June 1, 2002 1%franchise fee Issued January 28,202614overnber 7 2025 Effective March 1. 2026Jarm. 1,-2126 Issued by Avista Utilities By Patrick Ehrbar, Director of Regulatory Affairs Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 gcx* - Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026 f Twenty-fourththird Revision Sheet 58 Canceling I.P.U.C, No.28 Twenty-thirdsesorad Revision Sheet 58 58 AVISTA CORPORATION d/b/a Avista Utilities SCHEDULE 58 TAX ADJUSTMENT SCHEDULE- IDAHO The rate schedules of the Company for electric service furnished in Idaho do not include any portion of municipal occupation, business, excise or use of the streets, taxes, or charges. In order to reimburse the Company for such taxes or charges, amounts equivalent to such taxes or charges where now imposed,or which may hereafter be imposed, will be billed by the Company to its Customers as set forth below. APPLICABLE: To all charges for electric service rendered pursuant to tariff 28 within the jurisdiction imposing a tax or charge, as provided in Rule 3 of the Rules and Regulations included in this tariff. TAX ADJUSTMENT: The rates and charges named in this tariff shall be proportionately increased by an adjustment equivalent to the amount of the tax or charge imposed by the jurisdiction and effective as listed below: Idaho Municipality Ordinance or Resolution Date Ordinance Effective Charge* City of Clark Fork Ord_ No. 268 May 1,2017 1%franchise fee City of Coeur d'Alene Ord. No.2517 July 1, 1993 5%franchise fee City of Dalton Gardens Ord. No. 168 February 1,2005 1%franchise fee City of Deary Ord. No.405 January 1,2026 1%franchise fee City of Dover Ord. No. 54 October 1,2000 1% franchise fee City of Elk River Ord. No. 209 February 5, 2018 1%franchise fee City of Fernan take Village Res No. 195 Ord. No. 166 March 1, 2024 1%franchise fee City of Grangeville Ord. No. 972 January 1,2024 1%franchise fee City or Hayden Ord. 391 October 1,2005 1%franchise fee City of Hayden Lake Ord. No. 148 June 1, 1998 1%franchise fee City of Kamiah Ord. No. 97-2 January 1, 1997 1%franchise fee City of Kendrick Ord. No. 739 January 1,2013 1%franchise fee City of Kellogg Ord. No, 557 as amended by 644 March 1, 20260eteboer 1,2012 34%franchise fee City of Kooskia Ord. No. 172 March 1, 2013 1%franchise fee City of Kootenai Ord. No. 113 August 1, 1996 1%franchise fee City of Lapwai Ord. No. 300 January 1,2001 1% franchise fee City of Lewiston -Ord. No.4256 January 1,2000 1% franchise fee City of Moscow Ord. No.2005-34 Apri; 1, 2006 3%franchise fee City of Mullan Ord. No. 310A May 1, 1997 1%franchise fee City of Oldtown Ord. No.2010-2 June 1, 2010 1%franchise fee City of Orofino Ord. No. 707 January 11, 2002 3%franchise fee City of Osburn Ord. No. 234 June 1, 2001 1%franchise fee City of Pierce Res. No. 136 May 1, 1999 1%franchise fee City of Pinehurst Ord. No.2022-239 July 1, 2022 1%franchise fee City of Ponderay Ord. No.3-16 November 1, 1996 1%franchise fee City of Post Falls Res. No. 2002-17 June 1,2002 1%franchise fee Issued January 28, 2026Nevembep-7,2026 Effective March 1, 2026January-1-2026 Issued by Avista Utilities By Patrick Ehrbar, Director of Regulatory Affairs Attachment A Case No. AVU-TAE-26-01 Decision Memorandum February 17, 2026