Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20251231Compliance Filing .pdf RECEIVED December 31, 2025 IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION Idaho Public Utilities Commission Brad Little,Governor P.O. Box 83720, Boise, ID 83702 Edward Lodge,President John R.Hammond,Jr.,Commissioner Dayn Hardie,Commissioner December 31, 2025 Via E-Mail: secretarykpuc.idaho._og_v Commission Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission P.O. Box 83720 Boise, ID 83702 RE: Case No. GNR-E-25-02, Compliance Filing Dear Commission Secretary, On September 30, 2025, the Idaho Public Utilities Commission ("Commission") issued Order No. 36774 directing Commission Staff("Staff') to hold two workshops to determine the required content of compliance reports. The topics required to be covered in the workshops included fire reporting, monthly compliance targets, expenditures, filing timelines, and establishing consistency in language and formatting in all Wildfire Mitigation Plans ("WMP"). Following the workshops,interested parties were ordered to either submit joint proposed standards by December 31, 2025, or individual proposals if consensus was not reached. Order No. 36774 at 20. On October 27,2025, Staff held the first virtual workshop with 46 participants representing 14 interested parties.' The first workshop covered a high-level discussion of the topics specified by the Commission's Order. On November 12, 2025, Staff sent a strawman proposal to all parties that incorporated items and language that were discussed during the workshop and a document describing Staff s rationale for each section for the proposed IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards. The purpose of the strawman was to encourage discussion during the second workshop. 1 Interested parties in attendance were Avista Corporation,Clearwater Power Company,CTIA—The Wireless Association,Idaho Consumer Owned Utilities Association,Idaho Department of Lands,City of Idaho Falls,Idaho Power Company,Kootenai Electric Cooperative,Lost River Electric Cooperative,Lower Valley Energy,Northern Lights Inc.,PacifiCorp dba Rocky Mountain Power,PotlatchDeltic Corp.,and Raft River Rural Electric Co-Op. 11331 W.Chinden Blvd.,Building 8 Suite 201-A,Boise ID 83714 Telephone:(208)334-0300 Facsimile:(208)334-3762 Commission Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission December 31, 2025 Page 2 On December 1, 2025, Staff held the second virtual workshop with 38 participants representing 16 interested parties.2 During the workshop, Staff and the interested parties discussed Staff s strawman proposal of the IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards. Incorporating the discussion about proposed language and topics from the workshops, Staff respectfully submits this filing in compliance with Order No. 36774. Workshop Discussion During the workshops, the topic of filing dates for the compliance reports festered discussion from the three large investor-owned utilities ("IOUs"). The IOUs requested to have a consistent filing date for compliance reports that provided adequate timing for the electric corporations to finalize year-end data. Other parties did not provide any input on this topic. Staff received either no comments or general support from interested parties on the proposed language for compliance reports for filing dates, the consistency in language, and consistency in formatting. The Commission ordered parties to discuss in the workshops"consistency in language and formatting for all WMPs." Order No. 36774 at 20. As the proposed standards were focused on compliance reporting, Staff did not include its two recommendations on the topics above for all WMPs. However, to address these topics, Staff has two recommendations to the Commission, in which the interested parties during the workshop either did not comment or provided general support. Therefore, Staff recommends the Commission to order that: (1)each electric corporation include a glossary within each WMP that defines the utility's terms, and those terms should be consistent with the Wildfire Standard of Care Act, Idaho Code § 61-1803 and with the IPUC Guidelines (Commission Order No. 36774, Exhibit B) and (2) the format of the WMP must be consistent with the Wildfire Standard of Care Act, Idaho Code § 61-1803 and IPUC WMP Guidelines. Details of the WMPs format will be left to each utility. 2 Interested parties in attendance were Avista Corporation,Clearwater Power Company,CTIA—The Wireless Association,Idaho Consumer Owned Utilities Association,Idaho County Light and Power,Idaho Department of Lands,City of Idaho Falls,Idaho Power Company,Kootenai Electric Cooperative,Lost River Electric Cooperative, Lower Valley Energy,Northern Lights Inc.,PacifiCorp dba Rocky Mountain Power,PotlatchDeltic Corp.,Raft River Rural Electric Co-Op,and United Electric Cooperative. 11331 W.Chinden Blvd.,Building 8 Suite 201-A,Boise ID 83714 Telephone:(208)334-0300 Facsimile:(208)334-3762 Commission Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission December 31, 2025 Page 3 In the first workshop,parties discussed the reasoning for and against the fire reporting topic to be included within a compliance report. Parties believed there were other ways to show implementation and performance of a WMP. Following the input of most of the parties, the fire reporting topic was not included in the Staff strawman. In the second workshop,the discussion of not including fire reporting received support from parties. Although it is not included within the proposed standards, Staff believes fire reporting is a more appropriate topic to ask within a case while evaluating a WMP through different performance metrics during the Commission's review.3 While agreeing to exclude this topic in compliance reports, two parties encouraged Staff to consider the size of an electric corporation and encouraged Staff to develop performance metrics with collaboration of all electric corporations.4 Monthly Compliance Targets and Expenditures The two topics that had the most discussion were monthly compliance targets and expenditures. Idaho Code § 61-1803(5) requires the compliance report to include documentation describing "...wildfire mitigation expenditures, and the work taken to adopt wildfire mitigation components and measures. " In the first workshop, the electric municipalities and cooperatives expressed the burden of breaking yearly goals into monthly goals and requested further explanation how the granular data was necessary. Additionally, a party suggested the language shift from monthly to seasonal. In Staff s strawman, there was language incorporated for the suggested seasonal option. In the second workshop, further discussion of Staffs rationale was requested. Staff believes it is necessary for the compliance reports to include granular data beyond a yearly target/goal or annual cost forecast to exemplify the electric corporation's progress made towards the goals set within the approved-WMP throughout the year. Also, the granular data will aid with Staff s and other stakeholders'understanding of the feasibility of the approved WMP and will help inform any changes to the next WMP. Further, Staff believes granular data provided as either monthly, quarterly, or meteorological season rather than yearly would be a benefit to the electric 'Idaho Code§ 61-1804 requires the Commission to consider the degree to which the plan adequately minimizes wildfire risk. 4 City of Idaho Falls and Kootenai Electric Cooperative. 11331 W.Chinden Blvd.,Building 8 Suite 201-A,Boise ID 83714 Telephone:(208)334-0300 Facsimile:(208)334-3762 Commission Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission December 31, 2025 Page 4 corporations that wish to file WMPs, as granular data would help with explanations of any differences between an approved-WMP and actual results. Idaho Code § 61-1806 provides utilities with an approved WMP with a "rebuttable presumption that the electric corporation acted without negligence if, with respect to the cause of the wildfire, the electric corporation reasonably implemented a commission approved wildfire mitigation plan." To meet the intent of the law, Staff believes it is necessary for electric corporations to exemplify how its WMP was implemented throughout the year, as compared to showing only an annual check off. Staff believes the proposed language would also comply with the legislative requirements of Idaho Code § 61-1803(5). Proposed Compliance Report Standards Following the second workshop, on December 4, 2025, Staff sent the interested parties its proposal of IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards. Staff requested each party sign the proposal if they agreed with the proposed standards. Attached as Exhibit No. 1 is the proposed IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards that Staff recommends being adopted by the Commission with the signatures from five of the parties. As of December 18, 2025, Avista Corp, PacifiCorp, Idaho Power Company, Lost River Electric Cooperative, and Northern Lights, Inc. have signed the proposed standards, intending to show support of the proposed IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards. PotlatchDeltic provided a letter of agreement with Staff s proposed IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards; however, the party did not wish to sign the document at this time. See Exhibit No. 2. Staff respectfully recommends the Commission adopt the proposed IPUC WMP Compliance Report Standards in Exhibit No. 1 and order the following: (1) Each electric corporation include a glossary within each WMP that defines the utility's terms, and those terms should be consistent with the Wildfire Standard of Care Act,Idaho Code § 61-1803 and with the IPUC WMP Guidelines (Commission Order No. 36774, Exhibit 13); and 11331 W.Chinden Blvd.,Building 8 Suite 201-A,Boise ID 83714 Telephone:(208)334-0300 Facsimile:(208)334-3762 Commission Secretary Idaho Public Utilities Commission December 31, 2025 Page 5 (2) The format of the WMP must be consistent with the Wildfire Standard of Care Act, Idaho Code § 61-1803 and IPUC WMP Guidelines. Details of the WMPs format will be left to each utility. Sincerely, Chris Burdin Deputy Attorney General for Commission Staff 11331 W.Chinden Blvd.,Building 8 Suite 201-A,Boise ID 83714 Telephone:(208)334-0300 Facsimile:(208)334-3762 Proposed IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Report Standards EXHIBIT NO. 1 Proposed - IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Case No. GNR-E-25-02 12/31/25 Compliance Filing December 31, 2025 I.C. § 61-1803(5) "An electric corporation with a commission-approved wildfire mitigation plan shall submit a report to the commission updating the commission on the electric corporation's compliance with its wildfire mitigation plan on an annual basis or on such other basis as the commission may prescribe by rule or order. The report shall include documentation describing the development and adoption of the wildfire mitigation plan's components and measures, the wildfire mitigation expenditures, and the work taken to develop and adopt the plan's components and measures." Filing Requirements Beginning in 2027, each electric corporation must file its compliance report of a Commission- approved Wildfire Mitigation Plan ("WMP") no later than June 1 each calendar year. The compliance report should be filed under the most recently approved-WMP docket. Format for the Compliance Report The format of the Compliance report must be consistent with the Wildfire Standard of Care Act and IPUC Guidelines. Additionally, each compliance report should contain the following: (1) a table of contents, (2) an introduction section, (3) dedicated sections for each category of the WMP, and (4) any other sections at the discretion of the electric corporation. The introduction section should include: (1)high-level descriptions of the WMP's development, adoption, and expenditures and(2) a crosswalk table for each I.C. §§ 61-1803(3) and 61-1803(5)requirements and IPUC Guidelines is met within the compliance report. Each dedicated section should include detailed information on categories of the WMP such as metrics, actual expenses, explanations for any discrepancies between WMP goals and actuals, and explanations of which I.C. §§ 61-1803(3) and 61-1803(5) requirements and IPUC Guidelines is met within each section.Any measurable data should be included within each section. EXHIBIT NO. 1 Case No. GNR-E-25-02 Proposed -IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Compliance Filing 12/4/25 December 31, 2025 Laniune for Compliance Reports • Language to be consistent with: o The Wildfire Standard of Care Act(I.C. § 61-1803); o The IPUC Guidelines (Commission Order No. 36774, Exhibit B); and o The electric corporation's Commission-approved WMP glossary. Compliance Targets I.C. § 61-1803(5): "The report shall include...the work taken to adopt wildfire mitigation components and measures." The electric corporation must include within its compliance reports actual progress toward goals set within the approved WMP with explanations for any delays or modifications to electric corporation-planned and commission-approved goals. The data should be tracked relative to the WMP category with sufficient granularity to show substantial compliance with the approved WMP throughout the year. The data could be broken down monthly or quarterly. Expenditures Commission Order No. 36774 ordered cost forecasts to be included within WMPs, included in Exhibit B page 8. Wildfire mitigation expenditures are required to be reported by I.C. § 61-1803(5). The electric corporation must include within its compliance reports actual expenditures spent towards the approved WMP components. The expenditures should be tracked relative to the WMP category with sufficient granularity to show substantial compliance with the approved WMP throughout the year. The data could be broken down monthly or quarterly. EXHIBIT NO. 1 Proposed - IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Case No. GNR-E-25-02 12/4/25 Compliance Filing December 31, 2025 Party Agreement Atlanta Power Company Avista Corporation 12/09/2025 Date Date Bennet Lumber, IFG, MIM, Molpus Clearwater Power Company Woodlands Group, and Stimson Lumber Date Date City of Bonners Ferry City of Idaho Falls Date Date CTIA—The Wireless Association Idaho County Light and Power Date Date Idaho Department of Lands Idaho Power Company Date Date EXHIBIT NO. 1 Staff Proposal-IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Case No. GNR-E-25-02 12/4/25 Compliance Filing December 31, 2025 Party Agreement Atlanta Power Company Avista Corporation Date Date Bennet Lumber,IFG,MIM,Molpus Clearwater Power Company Woodlands Group, and Stimson Lumber Date Date City of Bonners Ferry City of Idaho Falls Date Date CTIA—The Wireless Association Idaho County Light and Power Date Date Idaho Department of Lands Id ho Pow r Company Date Date 12/11/2025 EXHIBIT NO. 1 Staff Proposal-IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Case No. GNR-E-25-02 12/4/25 Compliance Filing December 31, 2025 Fall River Rural Electric Cooperative Kootenai Electric Cooperative Date Date Lost River Electric Cooperative Lower Valley Energy Date Date Northern Lights, Inc. PacifiCorp,dba Rocky Mountain Power 12/11/25 Date Date PotlatchDeltic Corp. Raft River Rural Electric Co-Op Date Date United Electric Cooperative U.S.Telecom—The Broadband Association Date Date EXHIBIT NO. 1 Staff Proposal-IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Case No. GNR-E-25-02 12/4/25 Compliance Filing December 31, 2025 f R i, Fall River Rural Electric Cooperative Kootenai Electric Cooperative Date Date Lost River E ectric Cooperative Lower Valley Energy 12 ]CEc— 2U25-- Date Date Northern Lights, Inc. PacifiCorp, dba Rocky Mountain Power Date Date PotlatchDeltic Corp. Raft River Rural Electric Co-Op Date Date United Electric Cooperative U.S.Telecom—The Broadband Association Date Date Staff Proposal-IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards 12/4/25 EXHIBIT NO. 1 Case No. GNR-E-25-02 Compliance Filing December 31,2025 Fall River Rural Electric Cooperative Kootenai Electric Cooperative Date Date Lost River Electric Cooperative Lower Valley Energy Date Date Northern 6 ,Inc. PacifiCorp,dba Rocky Mountain Power � I � Date Date PotlatchDeltic Corp. Raft River Rural Electric Co-Op Date Date United Electric Cooperative U.S.Telecom—The Broadband Association Date Date Staff Proposal-IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards EXHIBIT NO. 1 12/4/25 Case No. GNR-E-25-02 Compliance Filing December 31,2025 Chris Burdin Commission Staff December 31, 2025 Date EXHIBIT NO. 1 Case No. GNR-E-25-02 Staff Proposal - IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Reports Standards Compliance Filing 12/4/25 December 31, 2025 A T T O R N E Y S A T L A W 515 N.27th Sheet.Boise.ID 83702 Tel-208-398-1900 Fax-'-08-398-7904 richardsonadams.com December 12, 2025 VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL Kimberly Loskot Utilities Analyst Adam Triplett, Esq. Deputy Attorney General Idaho Public Utilities Commission Kimberly.loskot@puc.idaho.gov Adam.tripleti@puc.idaho.gov Re: GNR-E-25-02—Staff Proposal for WMP Compliance Ms. Loskot and Mr. Triplett: I write on behalf of my client,PotlatchDeltic Corporation, in response to your email dated December 5, 2025,regarding the above-referenced Staff proposal for establishing standards that are applicable to electric corporations' WMP compliance reports. The PUC Staff is to be commended for their tenacity and comprehensive efforts in drafting the proposed WMP Compliance Report Standards. Your principled adherence to both the intent and the letter of the Wildfire Standard of Care Act's requirements—particularly with respect to reporting progress and expenditures—is commendable. You are authorized to report to the Commission that, as of this writing, PotlatchDeltic Corporation agrees with Staff s proposed compliance reporting standards referenced above. However, PotlatchDeltic Corporation specifically reserves its ongoing ability and obligation to recommend variances or additions to the Standards as new issues and nuances (will inevitability) arise during implementation of the WMP reporting process—hence we will not be signing onto the "Proposed IPUC Wildfire Mitigation Plan Compliance Report Standards"report dated 12/4/25. Please feel free to give me a call if you have any questions or would like to discuss PotlatchDeltic's position in more detail. Sincerely, EXHIBIT NO. 2 Case No. GNR-E-25-02 Compliance Filing December 31,2025 PotlatichDeltic Corporation Page 2 Peter J. Richardson RICHARDSON ADAMS, PLLC CC: Parties of Record EXHIBIT NO. 2 Case No. GNR-E-25-02 Compliance Filing December 31,2025 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 31' day of December 2025, I served the foregoing STAFF'S COMPLIANCE FILING, in Case No. GNR-E-25-02, via Electronic Mail to the following: Idaho Power Company: PacifiCorp d/b/a Rocky Mountain Power: Megan Goicoechea Allen maoicoecheaallenkidahopower.com Joe Dallas joseph.dallas@pacificorp.com Donovan Walker dwalker e,idahopower.com Mark Alder mark.alder(kpacificorp.com Lisa C. Lance llance e,idahopower.com datarequest(cr�pacificorp.com Matt Larkin mlarkin@idahopower.com Connie Aschenbrenner caschenbrenner@idahopower.com Tim Tatum ttatum(kidahopower.com Riley Maloney rmaloney@idahopower.com docketskidahopower.com Avista Corporation: Atlanta Power: Anni Glogovac anni.glo og vac@avistacorp.com Nick Jones AtlantaPower23@outlook.com Elizabeth Andrews liz.andrews(cr�,avistacorp.com avistadockets(kavistacorp.com Raft River: Lower Valley Energy: Chad Black cblack(krrelectric.com Jim Webb jim( ivenergy.com City of Bonners Ferry: Idaho County Light& Power: Mike Klaus mklaus(kbonnersferry.id.gov Max Beach mbeach(kiclp.coop Fall River Electric: Idaho Falls Power: Bryan Case bryan.casekfallriverelectric.com Jacob S. Beck jbecknidahofalls.gov Linden Barney linden.bamey(kfallriverelectric.com Zachary H. Jones zjones e,idahofalls.gov Randy Wakefield randy.wakefield@fallriverelectric.com Stephen Boorman sboormankifpower.org David Peterson dave.petersonkfallriverelectric.com Northern Lights,Inc.: Kootenai Electric Cooperative: Annie Terracciano annie.terraccianoknli.coop Michael G.Andrea mandrea@kec.com Kristin Burge kristin.burge(knli.coop Thomas Maddalone tmaddalone(kkec.com Trevor Kelly trevor.kelly(knli.coop Lost River Electric Cooperative: Clearwater Power: Brad Gamett brad(klrecoop.com Tell Stanger tstanger(kclearwaterpower.com United Electric: Idaho Consumer-Owned Utilities Association: Michael Darrington mdarrin ton e,uec.coop Will Hart whart(kicua.coop Idaho Department of Lands: CTIA—The Wireless Association: J.J.Winters jwinterskidl.idaho.gov Matthew DeTura MDeTura@ctia.org Tyre Holfeltz tholfeltz(kidl.idaho.gov Benjamin Aron Baron e,ctia.org PAGE 1 OF 2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE PotlatchDeltic Corp: Bennett Lumber Products,Inc.,Idaho Forest Peter J. Richardson peter ckrichardsonadams.com Group,Manulife Investment Management, Michele Tyler michele. , lerki2otlatchdeltic.com Molpus Woodlands Group,and Stimson Anna Torma anna.torma(crpotlatchdeltic.com Lumber Company: Wade Semeliss wade.semelisskpotlatchdeltic.com Pendrey P.Trammell service(cr�,smithmalek.com Brian Schlect brian.schlectkpotlatchdeltic.com Jeremy Pisca jpiscagrischpisca.com US Telecom—The Broadband Association: B. Lynn Follansbee lfollansbee(kustelecom.org Kathleen Slatterly Thompson ksthompson e,ustelecom.org PATRICIA JORDA , SECRETARY PAGE 2 OF 2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE