Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20251119Comments_21.pdf From: Kelley Filbin <carefree208@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 18, 2025 5:05 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 comment I submitted a comment on your online form but when I clicked submit I did not get any confirmation that my comment was received. Please see a copy of my comment below: I recently learned about the proposed kWh rate increase and $15/mo service charge that has been proposed by Idaho Power. I am strongly opposed to these increases. I find it interesting that Micron was involved in the decision making process. These large companies that are taxing the electric grid need to pay for the upgrades to the infrastructure that are required due to the draw on the systems that their businesses are creating. It is not right to charge every day families for something that would be unnecessary if the businesses such as Micron and Facebook and data centers were not placing such a demand on the system. The kWh increase is bad enough but to also tack on a $15/mo service charge irrelevant of consumption is completely unacceptable. Our cost of living has done nothing but go up. Idaho Power has routinely been raising their rates. It has to be reigned in. Please confirm receipt. Thankyou, Kelley -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From:Terrence Johnson <terrencej321 @icloud.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 18, 2025 5:23 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: Power My name is Terrence Johnson, and I am an Idaho Power customer living in Fort Hall. I am submitting this comment in opposition to the proposed rate increase in Case No. IPC-E-25- 16. As an everyday residential customer, I am extremely concerned about the financial impact this increase will have on families like mine. The average increase of$12.13 per month may not seem like much to Idaho Power, but for many households it matters a lot. especially with the rising cost of groceries, gas, housing, and everything else we rely on. Many people are already stretching their paychecks to cover basic needs. I am also concerned that this rate increase is being used to cover infrastructure upgrades that are not caused by regular households, but by the growth of large companies, industries, and new energy projects connecting to the grid. It does not feel fair that 1 everyday Idaho families are being asked to subsidize the business needs of much larger corporate customers.Those who create the strain on the grid should pay a proportional share of the cost, not the people who are already struggling. This especially impacts low-income families, elders, and rural communities. Many people in our region simply cannot afford higher utility bills, and Idaho Power needs to explain how it plans to protect customers who are already behind or barely keeping up. I am respectfully asking the Commission to: 1. Reevaluate whether residential customers should be paying for infrastructure growth driven by large commercial users. 2. Provide clear transparency about what is included in this $110 million revenue increase. 3. Consider the burden on regular families, especially those on fixed or lower incomes. 4. Require Idaho Power to expand assistance programs so people are not pushed into disconnection or debt. Please consider the real people who will feel this increase the most. Families like mine are trying to stay afloat, and higher power bills will make life harder for many Idahoans. Thank you for taking the time to listen to my concerns. Sincerely, Terrence Johnson Idaho Power Residential Customer -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: mark_knutson <mark_knutson@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 18, 2025 5:47 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov>; dwalker@idahopower.com Subject: Letter of Opposition Idaho Power Rate Case Case No. IPC-E-25-16 Order No. 36832 Hello, Mark Knutson and Robyn Berry, strongly OPPOSE the proposed rate hike increase to consumers. Any rate hikes should be imposed on the large scale businesses that are here and also being approved and built all over the Treasure Valley(i.e.: the current and forthcoming Data Centers including the new$800M Meta Data Center in Kuna, &to Micron who is expanding and building a $200B Semiconductor plant), and NOT to the citizens. 2 Thankyou, Mark Knutson and Robyn Berry ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Carol Christensen <cchristensen211 @msn.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 18, 2025 6:24 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 (Idaho Power Rate Increase) I am discouraged and frustrated by rate increases, price increases,yet decrease in quality service, especially as 1, and so many other Idahoans, are on fixed incomes. Even my retirement"increases" do not match the increases in utilities, medical insurance and bills, food prices, etc. Enough already! Many citizens are working hard to make do with what we have; can we please ask the same of our public entities? I have watched my electric rates continue to increase the past few years, despite my actions to conserve electrical use in my home. It seems like a useless attempt anymore. We all need to tighten our belts during these hard times, Idaho Power included! Thank you for your listening ear. Sincerely, Carol Christensen -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Rick Rice (rickrice@frontier.com) Sent You a Personal Message <rickrice@grsdelivery.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 18, 2025 6:36 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, 3 that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Rick Rice 1444 STONERIDGE DR POCATELLO, ID 83201 rickrice@frontier.com (208) 237-3493 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Deborah McCarthy(corlieshouse@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <corlieshouse@p2a.co> Sent:Tuesday, November 18, 2025 7:28 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, There are so many other ways to help your customers. Please be creative. Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Deborah McCarthy 211 Fulton St Salmon, ID 83467 corlieshouse@gmail.com (208) 768-7704 4 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.carePsierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ From: Nancy Landon (nancyLandon06@gmaiL.com) Sent You a Personal Message <na ncyla ndon06@advocatefor.me> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 6:43 AM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, I am writing to formally request any more increases to electric power be denied immediately. If they want to continue to provide power to the data centers let the centers pay the billions they are sucking out of the sytem Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Nancy Landon 12930 w engelmann Boise, ID 83713 nancyLandon06@gmaiL.com (208) 890-1487 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5 The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Katie Olivier Submission Time: Nov 18 2025 6:02PM Email: tandlmom2(@gmail.com Telephone: 530-333-3329 Address: 143 E Lake Fork Rd McCall, ID 83638 Name of Utility Company: Idaho Power Case ID: IPC-E-25-16 Comment: "I don't agree with the huge price hike or monthly service fee. I can see charging a fee for hook up, but not a monthly service fee. I have never gotten a cost of living increase of 7.5% in one year. I think it is reasonable for a 3 or 4% increase and charging only for new hookups. I also would like the companies building all the Al hardware to pay for the equipment needed to power it.That should not be on the residential customer. Thank you for your time:' ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Sarai Bowen (saraibowen@isu.edu) Sent You a Personal Message <saraibowen@sendgrassroots.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 7:04 AM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, Please take your pound of flesh from those who can afford it. Raise businesses rates, not us, who are the poorest Idaho has to offer!You know better. You know the less fortunate are going to be harmed over everyone else. The rate hikes and fees are absolutely ridiculous! Do the right thing for a change! Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. 6 Sincerely, Sarai Bowen 1255 W. Quinn Rd., Apt A Pocatello, ID 83202 saraibowen@isu.edu (208) 220-3235 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Ralph Cavalieri Submission Time: Nov 19 2025 7:06AM Email: rpcavalieri@gmail.com Telephone: 208-336-0012 Address: 16250 S Curtis Rd Kuna, ID 83634 Name of Utility Company: Idaho Power Case ID: IPC-E-25-16 Comment: "It is my understanding that Idaho Power is seeking to increase the base charge per meter to $25 per month.This represents a 250% increase in just a few years, with this rate being$5 per month not too long ago. As a rural resident with meters on three buildings, this would mean an increase to$75 per month for my electrical service without any additional consumption on my part. I cannot imagine what argument can be made to justify this increase. All three meters are included on a single bill, so overhead for accounting cannot be the reason. No additional base load is required whether I have one or three meters, so that cannot be the reason. Perhaps the electrician that designed my residence's electrical layout is to blame? But that was ten years ago when the charge per meter was $5 per month. I want Idaho Power to make a reasonable profit, but this proposed new meter charge is simply being greedy. I encourage the PUC to deny the request and maintain the per meter charge at the present$10 per month. Thank you:' -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7 The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name:Willow Abrahamson Submission Time: Nov 19 2025 8:29AM Email: willow.abrahamsonCcbgmail.com Telephone: 208-339-9559 Address: PO Box 40 Ft Hall, ID 83203 Name of Utility Company: Idaho power Case ID: IPC-E-25-16 Comment: "I am an Idaho Resident, born and raised, I am also Indigenous and reside on my own Indian Reservation. This rate increase is to appease the super wealthy programs, institutions, and corporations that are putting these constraints on costumers, INL is nearby and these mining operations, as well as more big-business related infrastructure coming into Idaho should not be on all of us, real true residents that are not benefiting from those big businesses. Those big business or communities who USE so much should experience the rate increase. Rural Idaho does not use what Boise or INL or Melaleuca or Dairy/Cattle or others use. In fact, this increase harms the elderly, those on low-income, fixed income, and the prices for anything are insane. I do not agree with this rate increase and ask Idaho Power to do better. Send those companies and businesses, and YES churches the bigger bills, not us. Theres no reason to have temple lights all over these Idaho towns then passing the cost of those non-tax paying groups onto the residents. Idaho Power, I say NO and I do not agree and on behalf of Shoshone Bannock Tribe's residents I say no. Otherwise offer us more infrastructure in rural areas, keep our water clean, and honor our treaty. Heck, we don't even have high speed internet in rural communities, and the rate increase is out of touch. Do Better. " ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Kirby Ortiz (kortiz1976@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <kortiz1976@forgrassroots.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 10:19 AM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, This is simply an attempt to hide rate increases without the public being made aware. Shame. Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the 8 Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Kirby Ortiz 6191 W Winstead Place Boise, ID 83704 kortiz1976@gmail.com (208) 608-8931 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From:Alex Todd (todd.alexander910@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <todd.alexander910@grassrootsmessages.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 10:32 AM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, There's no need to raise the rate. Switch to nuclear. It's hundreds of times more efficient and it is much cleaner. Because people are seeing the electricity bill rise, they will likely get their own panels (which can be tax write-offs in this state) and exit the grid system which is fraudulently raising their prices. If done in mass, this would remove a large amount of funding to the infrastructure very quickly. And once someone produces their own energy, they likely won't plug back in. For the sake of competitive capitalism, please don't tempt people into a position where they withdraw from utilities. That will leave many people that need utilities with underfunded programs that exponentially increase in cost. It could become a total collapse for the living quality of the low and middle class with the flick of this domino. Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the 9 Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Alex Todd 2529 s barrington lane Boise, ID 83706 todd.alexander910@gmail.com (986) 230-4580 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Eric Davis <davis@retailwest.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 12:06 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Cc: rmccandless@idahopress.com Subject: Case Number IPC-E-25-16 Idaho Power Rate Increase Dear Commissioners Lodge, Hammond and Hardie While Idaho Power rate increases are to be expected in our growing state, you are wise to consider carefully the specific reasons leading to rate increase justification with particular focus on DATA CENTER DEMAND. Meta, Google, Microsoft, Open Al...the list goes on, are giant entities that are worth trillions of dollars and have more cash on hand than most countries in the world. They have been building server barns all along the Columbia River basin for two decades, in search of cheap hydropower. Now, they are reaching out in Idaho in search of transmission and MORE power. Their demand for grid infrastructure and electricity is directly tied to their products and services, storage and compute, the latter of which is growing at lighting speed due to the advent of Al. How much of the Idaho Power increase can be attributed to this demand that is growing exponentially? Are residential electricity rates increasing to subsidize Al profitability? 10 THE TOP Al COMPANIES, DATA CENTER OWNERS, SHOULD PROVIDE THEIR OWN POWER! Why not?The irony is that even the entire $199.1 Million initially requested by Idaho Power could be absorbed by Meta, alone, as a capital expenditure in one year with almost zero impact on their bottom line or shareholder value. Word is that these Al companies are becoming concerned about the rate increase objections they are getting from the public, nation-wide. Certain insiders are suggesting the Al companies should step up to help pay for the power they need. NOW is the time for Idaho to push back as official confirmation that they need to participate. P. Eric Davis RETAIL WEST PROPERTIES, LLC 199 N. Capitol Blvd, Suite 300 Boise, Idaho 83702 (o) 208-331-0110 www.retaiLwest.com P R O P E R T I F -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Paul Hancock(pocatellopaul177@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <pocatellopaul177@advocatesmessage.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 11:40 AM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, Think longterm Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any 11 increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Paul Hancock 2750, Kootenai Pocatello, ID 83201 pocatellopaul177@gmail.com (208) 244-1483 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.carePsierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Corey Bade (cbadezz@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <cbadezz@advocatesmessage.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 11:43 AM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, More fees are not what Idahoans need right now! Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Corey Bade 333 W Avenue K Jerome, ID 83338 cbadezz(a-)gmail.com 12 (503) 329-4869 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care(a)sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Creighton Hardin (hardcrei2@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <hardcrei2@yourconstituent.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 12:30 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Creighton Hardin 6078 old ranch rd pocatello, ID 83204 hardcrei2@gmail.com (208) 604-4730 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 13 The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Christopher Ross Submission Time: Nov 19 2025 1:48PM Email: rosseagleidahoCcbgmail.com Telephone: 208-371-9126 Address: 1198 N Echohawk Way Eagle, ID 83616 Name of Utility Company: Idaho Power Case ID: IPC-E-25-16 Comment: "This is a rate hike to cover for the big data centers moving into the valley. You could raise their rates and not ours.Why should the people of Idaho pay more so Meta and others can make a few extra bucks. This is not an Idaho first policy, this is a money first policy." -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The following comment was submitted via PUCWeb: Name: Pine Irwin Submission Time: Nov 19 2025 2:44PM Email: feed.on.lightning@gmail.com Telephone: 208-863-8708 Address: 1728 N Crestmont Dr Meridian, ID 83646 Name of Utility Company: Idaho Power Case ID: IPC-E-25-16 Comment: "I want to understand why the rate hike for residents is so much higher than that for businesses. Why is it the responsibility of working Idahoans to subsidize big businesses operations?We are already subsidizing their tax breaks, and now we are expected to pay more for power-while also paying higher prices across the board for all necessities- and yet once again big businesses are getting a pass on shouldering the burden they are responsible for generating? No one is asking for this data center, so why are residents being asked to give them welfare off our money?" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 14 From: Christopher Ross (rosseagleidaho@gmail.com) Sent You a Personal Message <rosseagleidaho@grass roots messages.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 1:48 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: IPC-E-25-16 Rate Case Public Comment Dear Idaho Public Utilities Commission, Maybe you could raise the rates of the big energy sucking data centers that are moving into the valley. Please don't approve any Fixed Service Charge fee increases for residential customers, small businesses, or farmers—in this case or future rate cases. Idaho Power has already increased that fee on homeowner power bills from $5 to $15, and going up to $25 or more would make it one of the highest in the nation. Idaho Power's ongoing attempts to raise the Fixed Charge fee seem to be motivated by greed and maximizing profit, not by facts or the best interests of its customers. This is where you come in. As our utility regulators, your job is to stop this kind of excessive profit-seeking and rein in our monopoly utility to ensure Idahoans are being charged fair prices. Please do everything in your power to ensure that these Fixed Charge fees remain reasonable, particularly for low energy users, such as low- income and energy conscious households, who will be disproportionately harmed by any increases. Also, please explore the creative rate designs, such as tiered Fixed Charge fees, that other states are looking at. Thank you. Sincerely, Christopher Ross 1198 N Echohawk Way Eagle, ID 83616 rosseagleidaho@gmail.com (208) 371-9126 This message was sent by KnowWho, as a service provider, on behalf of an individual associated with Sierra Club. If you need more information, please contact Member Care at Sierra Club at member.care@sierraclub.org or (415) 977-5673. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 15 From: STEVEN Hall<stghall@msn.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 19, 2025 3:22 PM To: secretary<secretary@puc.idaho.gov> Subject: Rate increase for Idaho Power Hello, My name is Steven Hall; my wife and I live in Meridian. We met after I returned home from the Air Force. I returned home in Mar. after spending 4 years in the service, we met and were married Dec 1970, we both worked until we are both retired and in the meantime, we raised two children who are now both productive members of society. Now are only income is a SSA checks each month. I'm not complaining but we are not flush with a lot of money either. I am writing this letter in regard to the rate increase that Idaho Power wants. I am not against companies making money but, in my research, I find that Idaho Power just had a rate increase the It of Jan. 2024. 1 have lived my whole live in the Boise Valley, with the exception of the 4 years in the Air Force, I was born in Caldwell in 1947 and Graduated from High School in 1965 from Notus. I have seen the valley explode with people, homes, and businesses. So, if you find that hard to believe justjump in your car and try driving almost anywhere in the valley and you'll soon see the results of all the people moving in. That fact alone is a big increase in Idaho power's revenue. I remember when Idaho Power shutdown their coal fired plants in Wyoming,why should the public be required to cover that lose of power generation? It wasn't our decision. It is my contention that if Idaho Power can't keep up with all the new construction without putting the bill on the ones who are already here, then they need to add new power generation paid for by the newcomers. After this last election my property taxes are going up and no doubt almost every thing else, so please consider the taxpayers and especially the ones like me living on a fixed income, I can't go to my employer and ask for a pay increase. Thank You for your time and consideration in this matter, Steve Hall -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 16