Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20250703Reply to Staff Comments.pdf RECEIVED July 03, 2025 Michael P. Lawrence (ISB #7288) IDAHO PUBLIC GIVENS PURSLEY LLP UTILITIES COMMISSION 601 W. Bannock St. P O Box 2720 Boise, ID 83701 Telephone: (208) 388-1200 Facsimile: (208) 388-1300 mpl@givenspursley.com Attorneys for Flying H Trailer Ranch, Inc. BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF CAPITOL WATER CASE NO. CAP-W-24-03 CORPORATION'S PETITION REQUESTING AN INVESTIGATION FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC INTO FLYING H TRAILER RANCH, STAFF COMMENTS INC. Flying H Trailer Ranch, Inc. ("Flying H" or"Company"),by and through its attorneys of record, and pursuant to the Commission's June 3, 2025 Notice of Modified Procedure, Order No. 36625, submits this reply to the June 6, 2025 Comments of the Commission Staff("Staff Comments"). Flying H agrees with the Staff Comments'recommendation that the Commission find that Flying H is not a public utility and is not subject to the Commission's regulatory jurisdiction pursuant to Title 61, Idaho Code. Flying H does not intend to modify its ownership structure or undertake water system upgrades that would alter that recommendation. Flying H submits this reply in support of the Staff Comments'recommendation and to provide further factual and legal support for that recommendation.' First, however, Flying H 1 Certain Exhibits are attached to this reply for the convenience of the Commissioners. Flying H provided some of these documents to IPUC staff in response to discovery requests or otherwise in aid of their investigation. Flying H requests that the attached Exhibits and all documents reviewed or relied upon by IPUC staff in conducting FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-1 points out that this investigation was initiated through a petition filed by Capitol Water Corporation("Capitol Water"). Capitol Water did not submit any comments to the Commission and has not otherwise participated in this matter aside from filing its petition and providing Flying H with minimal information in response to discovery requests. I. Additional Factual Background The Staff Comments accurately describe Flying H's ownership and operation of its mobile home park. Staff Comments at 2. In addition, Flying H notes that the mobile home park's first phase was constructed in 1955, at which time domestic water was provided to tenants under water rights appropriated under state law. See attached Exhibit A(affidavit of original owner) and Exhibit B (water right decree no. 63-30206).2 This predates the formation of Capitol Water Corporation in 1959. See attached Exhibit D (certificate of incorporation for Capitol Securities Water Corporation).3 In short, the provision of water to tenants in Flying H's mobile home park began prior to the existence of Capitol Water Corporation. Flying H and Capitol Water have entered into at least one agreement for Capitol Water's provision of water to a portion of Flying H's property. See attached Exhibit F. Flying H has no information that, prior to filing the petition initiating this matter, Capitol Water ever objected to Flying H providing water to its other tenants. The Staff Comments indicated the length of tenancy was unclear for Flying H tenants. Flying H's leases,pursuant to Idaho Code, do not exceed 12 months. See I.C. § 55-2005. its investigation and preparing the Staff Comments,including without limitation Flying H's and Capitol Water's responses to discovery requests,be made part of the Commission's official record in this proceeding. Flying H reserves the right to provide additional evidence. z Water right decree no. 63-30206 has a 1955 priority date. An additional water right(no. 63-7291)was later developed with a 1970 priority date. See attached Exhibit C. This 1970 water right was acquired when the owner added a third well to the system,but the use was developed by 1958. See Exhibit A,p. 1¶2. s The entity's name was changed from"Capitol Securities Water Corporation"to"Capitol Water Corporation"in 1990. See attached Exhibit E(articles of amendment). FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-2 II. Additional Legal Analysis Flying H agrees with the Staff Comments'conclusion that Flying H "has not dedicated itself to serving the public and has no additional connection(s) outside its privately owned property." Staff Comments at 3. In addition to the statutes and case law discussed in the Staff Comments, Flying H believes this conclusion is also supported by the Idaho Supreme Court's decision in Stoehr v. Natatorium Co., 34 Idaho 217, 200 P. 132 (1921) ("Stoehr"). The Stoehr Court analyzed the definitions of"public utility" and"water corporation" in Idaho Code Sections 61-129 and 61- 125, respectively. The relevant statutory language was enacted in 1913shortly before the Stoehr decision—and has not substantively changed since then. The Stoehr Court held that "[a] corporation becomes a public service corporation, and therefore subject to regulation as a public utility, only when and to the extent that the business of such corporation becomes devoted to a public use." Stoehr, 200 P. at 133. The Court explained that"[t]o hold that a water corporation is a public utility because it receives compensation for water owned by it and furnished to a limited number of the inhabitants of Boise within a limited area would be an unreasonable interpretation of the [statutory definitions of public utility and water corporation]." Id. Here, Flying H is not a"water corporation"because it does not own, control, operate, or manage a water system for compensation. See I.C. § 61-125. Instead, it owns, controls, operates, and manages a 152 unit mobile home park. Flying H has not devoted its provision of water to a public use. Rather, it provides water to itself for the purpose of supplying water to the tenants who pay rent for the privilege of staying within the privately-owned mobile home park owned and operated by Flying H. Flying H's water service is not dedicated to a public use, and no member of the public may demand service from Flying H. Only tenants of the mobile home FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-3 park who timely pay their rent may demand such service. More recently, the Commission listed factors that are relevant to the question of whether it has jurisdictional authority over a company, including: the primary purpose for the company's operation; whether the company intended or held itself out to be a utility; whether the company provides service to the public or some portion thereof that is larger than a single customer; whether the company's customers have any control over the operation management, and rates of the company; and whether customers have any alternatives or choice in their service provider. In Re Kootenai Heights Water Sys., Inc.,No. 30219, 2007 WL 1467299 (Jan. 10, 2007). Here, Flying H's primary purpose is operating a mobile home park, it has never intended or held itself out to be a utility, it provides service only to itself for purpose of supplying water to its tenants, and there are no water rates to be controlled. If Flying H's tenants are considered"customers," their choice is to rent mobile home space on someone else's private property if they believe they can rent a similar quality space (with amenities and services) for a better price. In short, Idaho's statutes and case law support the conclusion that the Flying H is not a public utility or water corporation subject to the Commission's jurisdiction. With respect to the non-Idaho cases discussed in the Staff Comments, Flying H wishes to provide a few additional details that support the conclusion that it is not a public utility subject to the Commission's jurisdiction. Two of those cases determined that the water providers at issue were public utilities subject to regulation. See Public Water Supply Company, Inc. v. DiPasquale, et al., 802 A.2d 929 (Del. Super. Ct., Jan. 15, 2002), affd sub nom. Tunnell Companies, L.P. v. Pub. Water Supply Co., 801 A.2d 11 (Del. Supreme Court, June 13, 2002) ("PWSC"), and Gosar's Unlimited Inc. v. Wyoming Pub. Serv. Comm'n, 2013 WY 90, 305 P.3d 1152 (Wyo. 2013) ("Gosar's Unlimited"). These cases are distinguishable from Flying H's FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-4 situation. In each of those cases, the water provider at issue individually metered each lot in the community it served and would pass on increased water costs in the rent charges paid by tenants. PWSC, 802 A.2d at 936; Gosar's Unlimited, 2013 WY at 90¶ 15, 305 P.3d at 1157. Flying H does not meter tenant water use and does not pass on increased costs based on water usage or water system operations. Flying H simply charges a flat rental fee to each tenant based on mobile home market conditions irrespective of tenants' water usage amount or the water system's operational costs. As noted in the Staff Comments, Flying H does not meter water usage. The other two cases discussed in the Staff Comments held that the water providers at issue were not public utilities. See Enberg v. Park City Mobile Home, Inc.,No. 93-0091, 1994 WL 120881 (Illinois Commerce Commission, Mar. 23, 1994) ("Enberg");In Re Complaints of Inscho,No. 90-182-WS-CSS, 1992 WL 937210 (F.E.D.A.P.J.P. Ohio, Feb. 27, 1992) ("Inscho"). As recognized in the Staff Comments, these cases support the conclusion that Flying H is not a public utility. Importantly, like the mobile home park owner in Enberg, Flying H only provides water to tenants within its privately owned property and not to the general public. And, like the mobile home park owner in Inscho, Flying H's provision of water to tenants is ancillary to its primary purpose of renting spaces to its tenants, it has never held itself as a water provider to the general public, and it does not separately charge tenants for water. III. Conclusion Flying H respectfully requests that the Commission adopt the Staff Comments' recommendation that Flying H is not a public utility and is not subject to the Commission's regulatory jurisdiction pursuant to Title 61, Idaho Code. FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-5 DATED this 3rd day of July, 2025. GIVENS PURSLEY LLP Michael P. Lawrence Attorneys for Flying H Trailer Ranch, Inc. FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-6 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on the 3rd day of July, 2025, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed and/or served upon the following individual(s)by the means indicated: Commission Staff Via Electronic Mail Monica Barrios-Sanchez, Commission Secretary monica.barriossanchez@puc.idaho.gov Idaho Public Utilities Commission 11331 W. Chinden Blvd., Bldg. 8, Suite 201-A Boise, ID 83714 H. Robert Price info@capitolwatercorp.com Capitol Water Corporation 2626 N. Eldorado St. Boise, Idaho 83704-5926 Michael P. Lawrence FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-7 EXHIBIT A ORIGINAL RECEIVED STATE OF IDAHO ) DEC 12 IN7 )s s. WATER RE600RCE8 County of Ada ) Wc3TFRNMG101J VERN HARDER, being first duly sworn under oath, deposes and says: 1. Myself and my wife Bernice are the persons who originally built the Flying H Trailer Ranch, Inc. (Ranch) , located at the intersection of Ustick and Cole Roads in the City of Boise, Ada County, Idaho. The first phase of the Ranch was built in 1955 and consisted of 85 spaces. To furnish water to the spaces, we constructed Well No. 1, located on the property. In 1955, the 85 spaces were constructed and were in use for domestic purposes using the water from Well No. 1. The water from Well No. 1 was delivered and was deliverable. The ground was developed by putting in spaces to be rented to owners of mobile homes who parked their homes on the rented space. Each space was provided with water to be used for domestic purposes and the wells were dug to furnish water to each of the spaces at the Ranch. 2. In phase 2 of the Ranch development, additional spaces were constructed so that I had a total of 126 spaces constructed. A second well was drilled. To the best of my recollection, this was in 1958. The second well and the first well were connected in a loop so that either well could furnish water to all 126 units. The same procedure was followed with the third well when we drilled it in 1970 for double-wide mobile home spaces. We then had a total of 126 spaces being supplied with water from the three wells. All of the wells at all times produced water for domestic purposes. The water for all wells was deliverable, and was delivered from FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-8 each of the three wells to all the spaces rented in the Ranch. I stress again that the wells were in tandem so that all wells furnished water to all spaces. VERN HARDER STATE OF IDAHO ) )ss. County of Ada ) On this kz+,_ day of. , 1992, before me, a notary public, personally appeared VERr HARDER, known or identified to me to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument, and acknowledged to me that he executed the same. 1992. SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this L• day of NOTARY PUBLIC FOR III O Residing at Beige, Zdaho VN (seal) My Commission Expires: FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-9 EXHIBIT B 2007 PRE 16 PH 02:00 DISTRICT COURT - BREA TWIN FALLS CO., IDAHO FILED IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF IDAHO, IN AND FOR THE COUNTY Of TWIN FALLS In Re SRBA 1 PARTIAL DECREE PURSUANT TO } I.R,C.P. 541b) FOR Case No. 39516 ] Water Right 63-30206 NAME AND ADDRESS: FLYING H TRAILER RANCH INC 7615 USTICI RD , BOISE, ID 93704 SOURCE: GROUND WATER QUANTITY: 0.60 CPS a5.00 APY USE OF THIS RIGHT WITH RIGHT NO. 61-7291 IS LIMITED TO A TOTAL COMBINED DIVERSION RATE OF 0 66 CPS AND TO A TOTAL COMBINED ANNUAL DIVERSION VOLUME OF 99 AF. PRIORITY DATE: 04/27/1955 POINT OF DIVERSION: T03H ROIR 801 LOT 1 (NEWS 1 Within Ada County LOT 1 4HENE ) LOT 1 (NINE ) i Three points of diversion are located within NENE, SOX, T03N, R018. PURPOSE AND PERIOD OF USE: PURPOSE OF USE PERIOD OP USE QUANTITY irrigation 01.01 TO I1.15 0.20 CPS 45.00 AFT ', Domestic 01-01 TO 12-31 0.40 CPS Domestic use is for 93 tones and does not include lawn, garden, landscape, or other types of irrigation. PLACE OF UStr Irrigation Within Ada County T03Y ROLE SOL I.OT 1 {NINI110.0 10.0 Acres Total Domestic Within Ada County T03M RO1R SOL LOT 1 (NINE) OTHER PROVISIONS NECESSARY FOR DEFINITION OR ADMINISTRATION OF THIS WATER RIGHT: The quantity of water decreed for this water right is not a determination of historical beneficial use. THIS PARTIAL DECREE IS SUBJECT TO SUCH GENERAL PROVISIONS NECESSARY FOR THE DEFINITION OF THE RIGHTS OR FOR THE EFFICIENT ADMINISTRATION OF TEE WATER RIGHTS AS MAY BE ULTIMATELY DETERMINED BY THE COURT AT A POINT IN TIME NO LATER THAN THE ENTRY OF A FINAL UNIPIED DECREE, I.C. SECTION 42-1412(6). SRSA PARTIAL DECREE PURSUANT TO I.R.^_.P. S41b1 PAGE 1 - Wacer Right 63-30206 Jen-OS-2007 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-10 SRSA Partial Decree Purevent to I.R.C.P. 54110) Icontinued) RULE 54(b) CERTIFICATE With respect to the issues determined by the above judgment or order, it Is hereby ccRritlED, in accordance With Rulo Sa(b), I.R.C.P., that the court has determined that there IS no 3ust reason for delay of the entry of a final judgment and that the court has and does hereby direct that the above judgment or order shall be a final judgment upon which execution may issue and an appeal may be teak—elaas provided by the Idaho Appellate Rules. John W. Kelanson Presiding Judge of the _ Snake River Basin Ad3udication SRBA PARTIAL DBCR£R PURSUANT To I.R.C.P. Se(b) PAGE 2 Water Right 43-30206 Jan-05-20e7 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-11 EXHIBIT C 2007 PER 16 PM 02:00 DISTRICT COURT - SRAA TWIN PALLS CO-, IDAHO PILED IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF IDAHO. IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF TWIN FALLS - In Re SRBA I PARTIAL DECREE PURSUANT TO I I.R.C.P. 54(b) FOR Case No. 39576 ) Water Right 63-01292 NA93 AND ADDRESS: FLYING H TRAILER RANCH INC 7615 USTICR RD BOISE, ID $3704 SOURCE: GROUND WATER QUANTITY: D.06 CPS . 44.00 AFY USE OF THIS RIGHT WITH RIGHT NO. 63-30206 IS LIMITED TO A TOTAL COMBINED DIVERSION RATE OF 0.66 CPS AND TO A TOTAL COMBINED ANNUAL DIVERSION VOLUME OF 99 AP. PRIOR.Ty DATE: 02/16/197G POINT OF DIVERSION. T03H ROTS S61 LOT 1 (HENS I Within Ada County PURPOSE AND PERIOD OF USH: PURPOSE OF USE PERIOD OF USE QUANTITY Domestic 01-01 TO 12-31 0.06 CTS 44.00 AFY Domestic use is for 43 homes. PLACE OF LSE: Domestic Within Ada County T03N ROLE S01 LOT 1 (NEWS) OTHER PROVISIONS NECESSARY FOR DEFINITION OR AUKINISTIA71ON OF THIS WATER RIGHT: THIS PARTIAL DECREE IS SUBJECT TO SUCH GENERAL PROVISIONS NECESSARY FOR THE DEFINITION OF THE RIGHTS OR FOR THE EFFICIENT ADMINISTRATION OF THE WATER RIGHTS AS MAY BE ULTIMATELY DETERMINED BY THE COURT AT A POINT IN TIME NO :,A^.ER THAN THE ENTRY OF A FINAL UNIFIED DECREE. I.C. SECTION 42-141216). RULE 54(b) CERTIFICATE With respect to the issues determined by the above judgment or order, it is hereby CERTIFIED, in accordance With Rule 54(b), I.R.C.P., that the court has determined that there is no just reason for delay of the entry of a final judgment and that the court has and does hereby direct that the above judgment or order shall be a final judgment upon Which execution may issue and an appeal may be taken ae resided by the Idaho Appellate Rules. John M. Melanson Presiding Judge of the Snake River Basin Adjudication SRBA PARTIAL DECREE PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 54(b) PAOR 1 Water Right 63.07291 Jan-02-2007 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-12 EXHIBIT D a; XI r: 1 y? I • I - } CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION } 1 1, ARNOLD WILLIAMS,Secretary of State of the State of Idaho,and legal custodian of i the corporation records of the State of Idaho do hereby certify that the original of the articles of incorporation of CAM& O1312IT ld IAMB ATM 1 was filed in the office of the Secretary of State on the "stY day 111 t of April, A.D.One Thousand Nine Hundred f1[tlr•It1M, a duly recorded on Film No. 106 of Record of Domestic Corporations,of the State of Idaho, ( and that the said articles contain the statement of facts required by Section 30.103.Idaho Cade. l! I FURTHER CERTIFY. That the persow executing the articled and their associates and E' su,et•ssors are hereby constituted a corporation, by the name hereinbefore stated. for r parpetaal adstaiM from the dale hereof, with its registered office in this State located at 1a1lNa in the County of Ads. j 1 t!\ IN TESTIMONY WNF.RP:OF. I have hereunto � set my hand and affixed the Great Seal or the State. Done at 1lioise City,the Capital of Idaho, ' J this sass► day of April A.D., 19 4 � i �• Secretary of State. `i Domestic aaraar.;;sit••. 1r. :�..' :.-5�''t". Cam" y; ;, FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-13 ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION OF CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION w • tr KNOW ALL K94 BY THESE PRESENTS: That we, the undersigned, J. B. DOLLARD, R. C. PAULEY and NASH BIDEGANETA, being persons of full age, residents of the State of Idaho, and citizens of the United States, desiring to form a general business corporation under and by virtue of the provisions of Chapter 1 of Title 30 of the Idaho Code, and we do hereby certify, declare and adopt the following articles of incorporation: I The name of the corporation is CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION. II The nature, objects and purposes of this corporation shell be to do any and all of the things hereafter sat forth to the same extent as natural persons might or could do in any part of the world, namely: (a) To own by purchase, drilling or otherwise, to lease, rent or in any other manner lawfully acquire, water for domestic or irrigation b purposes; (b) To own by purchase or otherwise, loose, rent or in any other manner lawfully acquire, and to sell, rent, lease or assign to any other parson, firm, corporation, county or municipality, pipelines and mains for the transportation, delivery and sale of water; and to construct, build, maintain and operate the same; to buy and sell water and water rights from and to individuals, firms, corporations, counties or municipalities; to own, operate, maintain and control such motors and other appliances as may be necessary in conducting it■ business afore- said; to buy, own, sell, lease or rent all such property, real, personal or mixed, as may be FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS- 14 I necessary in the conduct of its business afore- said, and not contrary to law; (c) To manage, lease, purchase or otherwise acquire, and to hold, own, sell or dispose of real estate, and do such things In connection therewith as shall be convenient, necessary or required by this corporation in the conduct of its business and at such places so the board of directors may determine; (d) To borrow money for its corporate purposes, and to make, accept, endorse, execute and issue promissory notes, bills of exchange, bonds, debenture■ or other obligations from time to time, for the purpose of purchasing property or for any other purpose in or about the business of the corporation and, if deemed proper, to secure the payment of any such obligation by mortgage, pledge, deed of trust or otherwise; (a) To acquire and take over a■ a concern and thereafter to carry on the business of any person, firm or corporation engaged in any business which this corporation is authorized to carry on, and in connection therewith to acquire the good will and all or any of the assets and to assume or otherwise provide for all or any of the liabilities of any such business; (f) To @all, improve, manage, develop, lease, mortgage, dispose of or otherwise turn to account or deal with all or any part of the property of the corporation; (g) To carry on business at any place or places within the Jurisdiction of the United States, and in any and all foreign countries, and to purchase, hold, mortgage, convoy, lease or other- wise dispose of and deal with rag and personal property at any such place or places; (h) To enter into, make, perform and carry out contracts of every sort and kind which may be necessary or convenient for the business of the corporation, or business of a similar nature, with any person, firm, corporation, whether private, public or municipal, body politic or under the government of the United States, or any state, territory or colony thereof or any foreign government, so far as and to the extent that the some may be done and performed by corporations organized under the general corpo- ration law; a ARTICLES, P. 2 - FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS- 15 - I (i) To do all and every thing necessary, suitable or proper for the accomplishment of any of the purposes, the attaiument of say of the objects or the furtherance of any of the powers, herainbefore not forth, either alone or in f connection with other corporations, firma or individuals, and either as principal or agent, and to do every other act or thing incidental or appurtenant to or growing out of or connected with the aforesaid objects, purposes or powers or any of then; (J) The foregoing enumeration of $pacific powers of the corporation shall not be deemed to limit or restrict in any manner the general povers of the corporation, and the enjoyment and exercise thereof, as conferred by the laws of the State of Idaho upon corporations organised under the provisions of Cm Idaho Code. III This corporation shall have an authorised capital of Twenty-five Thousand and no/100 ($25,000.00) Dollars, divided into 250 shares of the par value of $100.00 per •hare. IV The office of the corporation shall be located at Boise, Idaho, V The duration of the corporation shall be perpetual. VI The number of directors shall be not less than three nor more than seven in number. The directors need not be stockholders. VII The names and postoffics addresses of each subscriber and the number of shares subscribed by each are as follows: Mama Address No. Shares J. B. Dollard 900 Jefferson Street- 1 Boise, Idaho R. C. Paulay 900 Jefferson Street 1 Boise, Idaho Nash Bidegansts 900 Jefferson Street 1 Boise, Idaho i ARTICLES, P. 3 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS- 16 VIII No contract or other transaction of the corporation with any other person, firm or corporation or in which this corpora- tion is interested shall be affected or invalidated by the fact that any one or more of the directors of this corporation is interested in or is a director or officer of another corporation, or the fact that any director either individually or jointly with others may be a party to or may be interested in any such contract or transaction, and each and every person who may become a director of the corporation is hereby relieved from any liability that might otherwise arise by reason of his contracting with the corporation for the benefit of himself or any firm or corporation in which he may be in any way otherwise interested. IN WITNESS WHEREOF. We have hereunto set our hands and a sale this r day of April, 1959. J. S. Dal-lard R. C. Paulay Nash Bidogana a STATE OF IDAHO ) County of Ada On this day of April, 1959, before me, the under- signed, a Notary Public in and for said State, personally appeared J. B. DOLLARD, R. C. PAULEY and NASH SIDEGANITA, known 1 to me to be the persons whose names are subscribed to the within instrument, and acknowledged to me that they executed the tams. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my official seal the day and year in this'certificate first above written. Notary Public for Idah0 Residence: Boise, Idaho ARTICLES, P. 4 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS- 17 EXHIBIT E IM _IIIIIIIIUIIpIUIIII�IIIUIIIIIIUIIIIIIIIHIIWIIIIIIII1111111111111111111IIIIlUIIIIIIIIIIIIIHIl��II ,"Itf"���I �: ' '� � � r' ,Il��tu�ii r Al` Department or state. CERTIFICATE OF AMENDMENT OF -- _ eStreL ■ecer:zlTirt r+�Ttt co�tpEATIO� _ —___ - I PFTE T. CETIARRUSA, Secretan of State of the State of Idaho hcreh%. ccrtll% that duplicate originalsof Articles of Amendment to the Article%of Incorporation of CAPITOL WATER CORPORATION duly signed and verified pursuant to the provisions of the Idaho Business Cotpotahon Act, ha%c been received in this office and are found to conform to law. ACCORDINGLY and by%irtue of the authority%e%ted to me b%la%►.I issuethi%Ccrtdreatc Amendment to the Articles of Incorporation and attach herein a duplicate ori}mal of the %Iti.I. of Amendment. Dated -- July 26 - - - to 90 SFCR1-1 ARY UI 1 \1 1 y .:. >`. 4Q Corporation Clok 11111111HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIllllllllllllllllllllllllllllliildllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll{IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII{Illlllllllllllllllllq{IIIHMIIIIIIINIIIdIIa{IIIIIII;IIIIIIIWIIdlllli. i CAM 779 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-18 kcf.C: C ARTICLES OF AMENDMENT • . ti Ji.G. to the 30 JUL 26 F 9 26 ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION of CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION Pursuant to the provisions of Section 30-1-61 of the Idaho Business Corporation Act, the undersigned oorporation adopts the following Articles of Amendment to its Articles of Incorporation: FIRST: The name of the corporation is CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION. SECOND: The following amendment to the Articles of Incorporation was adopted by the shareholders of the corporation on the 20th day of July, 1990 in the manner prescribed by the ' Idaho Business Corporation Act: The name of the corporation is amended to ' CAPITOL WATER CORPORATION THIRD: The number of shares of the corporation outstanding at the tree of such adoption was one hundred ( 100) , all of which shares were entitled to vote thereon and all of which are of the same class. FOURTH: The number of shares voted for such amendment was one hundred ( 100) . No shares voted against such amendment. FIFTH: The manner in which any exchange, reclassification or cancellation of issued shares shall be effected is as follows: Stock certificates bearing the name "CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION" shall be delivered to the corporation and exchanged for stock certificates representing the same number of shares bearing the amended name "CAPITOL WATER CORPORATION". SIXTH: The amendment does not effect a change in the amount of the stated capital of the corporation. 1 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS- 19 e IN WITNESS WHEREOF, �th�/�j�President and Secretary have set their hands and seals the �� - July, 1990. CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION by T PRICE, HT ATTEST: by y 71 _-- BIUNNIE R. PRICE, STATE OF IDAHO ) ss County of Ada ) a H. Robert Price and Bonnie R. Price, being first duly sworn, depose and say that they are the President and Secretary of the said corporation and that they have read the foregoing ARTICLES OF AMENDMENT TO THE ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION OF CAPITOL SECURITIES WATER CORPORATION, know the contents thereof, and bellevP the facts therein stated to be true. W—i(,Ie�z ,1 SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this day of July", 1990. 1 t o a y c rifr Ydaho -- Res_141ng in Boise, Idaho f 7 2 A 1 5 FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS—20 EXHIBIT F 2caf !S MAIN EXTENSION CONTRACT Subdivisions, Tracts Housing Projects, Industrial Develo ments or Organized Commercial Districts This Agreement, made and entered into this ict day of nil 11 by and between Capitol Water Corporation, (hereinafter referred to as "Corporation"), and _ lair ova,- - Clyin') 'r.. _ Trailer anc;; of Boise, Idaho (hereinafter referred to as "Applicant"), mutually agree as follows: 1. Applicant hereby applies for a water main extension to be constructed in accordance with the Corporation's standard specifications and is generally described as follows: i-lyinq H. Trailer Park A`11 Installation of 1,140 6" Class 150 C-900 P.V.C. Water PiDe 24D' 3/4" Tyoe K Copper Water Tube to serve 15 Services in the Flying H. Trailer Park 2. Applicant will advance an amount of $6,564.36 to cover the estimated cost of facilities generally described in paragraph 1 above. Any difference between the actual cost and the amount advanced shall be shown as a revision of the amount of advance and shall be payable within thirty days of submission. 3. At the time the water main extension is connected to the Corporation's water system, the ownership of the pipeline shall belong to the Corporation and shall thereafter be maintained and operated by the Corporation. 4. The amount advanced, in paragraph 2 above, shall be subject to refund by the Corporation, in cash, without interest, to the Applicant as follows: (a) The Corporation shall determine the annual revenue received from each customer, other than residential supplied by service pipes connected directly to the extension for which the cost was advanced and the refund shall be 22% of the revenue so received. (b) For Residential Customers connected directly to the extension for which the cost was advanced, the refund shall be 2211% of the average revenue per residential customer of the entire system for the immediately preceding 12 month period. (c) The total amount refunded shall not exceed the total of the amount advanced. Refunds will be made in annual payments for a period not to exceed 20 years after the date of this contract, except as provided in Section C-2-d R e, Page 20E & 20F i.A.. 1n 4nar, ototlnn the nnntra Ct neriod can continue FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-21 for refunds for 25 years. 5. This Contract is entered into pursuant to the requirement of and in accordance with the various applicable provisions of the Corporation's main extension rule in effect and on file with the Idaho Public Utilities Commission, a copy of which is available on request and is made a part hereof. All service rendered from the Corporation's water system shall be in accordance with the rates, rules and regulations applicable to said service under approval and authority of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission. FLYING HIS REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-22 6. Applicant shall provide a water main stake-out, on the property line on the same side of the street on which the main is to be laid. Said stake-out shall indicate the, off-set distance from the stake to the center line of pipeline, the cut required from the top of stake to the invert of the pipeline. (the minimum cover from finished grade to the top of pipe is 4'-0"), the location of valves, fitting, fire hydrants, and meters. Exact grade for meter boxes shall also be furnished to Water Company by Appli- cant. Stakes are to be set no further apart than lo0 feet on straight runs and 50 feet on all curves. Any adjustments of Water Company's facilities which may be necessitated due to changes in grade or due to damage by others will be done by Water Company, or Water Company's contractor at developer's expense. If any valve boxes, curb boxes, or meter boxes are covered up or damaged by others, these facilities will be located and brought to proper grade by Water Company or Water Company's contractor at developer's expense. 7. For labor in lieu of cash construction, applicant guarantees both material and workmanship for a period of one year after date of pressure tests of installed system. CAPITOL WATER CORPORATION ATTEST: By: �iLC-C Manager Capitol Water Corporation WITNESS: II, Robert Price v Applicant Bonnie R. Price Blaine Evans FLYING H'S REPLY TO IPUC STAFF COMMENTS-23