20240911PAC to IIPA 5 Attachment Verdict - Punitives.pdf

� s
I IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE STATE OF OREGON
2 FOR THE COUNTY OF MULTNOMAH
3 JEANYNE JAMES,ROBIN COLBERT, Case No. 20CV33885
JANE DREVO, SAM DREVO, BROOKE
4 EDGE AND BILL EDGE, SR.,LORI Case Assigned to: Hon. Steffan Alexander
FOWLER, IRIS HAMPTON, JAMES
5 HOLLAND, RACHELLE MCMASTER,
KRISTINA MONTOYA,NORTHWEST VERDICT FORM—
6 RIVER GUIDES, LLC, SHARIENE PUNITIVE DAMAGES
STOCKTON AND KEVIN
7 STOCKTON, VICTOR PALFREYMAN,
PALFREYMAN FAMILY TRUST, AND
8 DUANE BRUNN, individually and on behalf
9 of all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
10
V.
11
PACIFICORP,an Oregon corporation; and
12 PACIFIC POWER, an Oregon registered
electric utility and assumed business name
13 of PACIFICORP,
14 Defendants.
15
16 We, the jury, find:
17 PUNITIVE DAMAGES—PLAINTIFFS
18 QUESTION 24: Have the Plaintiffs within the boundaries of the fire areas below
19 proven an entitlement to punitive damages?
20
2 8 11 24 32 3w7l
21 Echo Mountain Complex fire YES NO ICJ y y y I v
44 48 61 69 83 96
22 y y y y y
23
2 8 11 24 32 37
24 Santiam Canyon fire YES �' NO N �� y y N
44 48 61 69 83 96
25 y N y
26
Page 1 of 6

1
,
2 South Obenchain fire YES V/ 2 NO N 8 11 24 32
44, 48, 61 69 83 96
3 Y V/
4
5 242 fire YES V NO 2H y 1 y 2 Y \y I�
44� 48 61 69 83 96
6
7
8 If"yes"for any of the fire areas go to question 25.
9 If"no"for any of the fire areas your verdict is against an award of punitive damages
10 for the plaintiffs for that fire area and for defendant for that fire area. Do not answer
11 question 25 for any fire area that you answered "no"for question 24. Do not answer
12 question 26 for any fire area that you answered "no"for question 24. If you answered
13 "yes"for at least one fire area proceed to question 25.
14 If you answered "no"for all four fire areas,please proceed to question 27.
15
16 QUESTION 25: Should punitive damages be awarded against the Defendant as to the
Plaintiffs within the boundaries of the fire areas below?
17
2 8 11 24 32 37
18 Echo Mountain Complex fire YES NO N y y y Y N
19 44, 48 61/ 69- 83 , 96
20 I
/ 2 11 24 32 37
21
Santiam Canyon fire YES V NO W y f j
22 4 y y 4� 6 6y 8 96
7 Y
23
2 8 11 24 32 37
24
South Obenchain fire YES V NO N y y y N
25
44� 48 61 69 83 96,
III V( y
26
Page 2 of 6

1
2 8 11 24 32 37
2 242 fire YES NO (�J
44 48 61 69 83 96
3
4 At least nine of you who answered "yes" to question 24 must also agree on the answer
5 to question 25 for that particular fire area. If you answered "yes" to any of the fire
6 areas,please proceed to question 26.
7 If you answered"no"for any of the fire areas, your verdict is against an award of
8 punitive damages for the plaintiffs for that fire area and for the defendant for that fire
9 area. If you answered "no"for all four fire areas,please proceed to question 27.
10
11 QUESTION 26: What amount of punitive damages, if any, do you award against
12 the Defendant as to the Plaintiffs within the boundaries of the fire areas below?
13
14 Echo Mountain Complex:
0
Z 2 8 11 2� 3
15 6 times the amount of economic and noneconomic N �// N
44 48 61 69 83 96
16 damages awarded. y y
17 Santiam Canyon fire:
18 .25 N Y 11 2v 32 N
times the amount of economic and noneconomic VI , y
44 48 61 69 83 96
19 damages awarded. y N y y y y
20 South Obenchain fire:
2 8 11 24 32 37
21 .25 times the amount of economic and noneconomic N 'Y y y V N
44 48 61 69 83 96
22 damages awarded.
23 242 fire:
N 8 11 24 32 37
24 ,Z 5 times the amount of economic and noneconomic y '�_ Y N
44 48 61 69 83 96
25 damages awarded. Y N y Y
26 At least nine of you who answered "yes" to question 25 must also agree on the answer
Page 3 of 6

1 to question 26 for that particular fire area. Please proceed to Question 27.
2
3 PUNITIVE DAMAGES—CLASS QUESTIONS
4 QUESTION 27: Has the entire class within the boundaries of the fire areas below
5 proven an entitlement to punitive damages?
6
2 8 11 24 32 37
7 Echo Mountain Complex fire YES NO t j y y y �_l N
44 48 61 , 69 83 96
8 ,
9
2 8 11 24 32 37
10 Sandam Canyon fire YES ✓ NO N y y 0
11
y N 61� 69 83 96
y
122 8/
13 South Obenchain fire YES V NO N � 1V z\/ 3Y (3�
44/ 48 61, 69� 83 , 96
14
15
11 , 24 32 37
16 242 fire YES N NO N N
17 44 48_ 61 69 83 96,
18
19 I.j`�"yes"for any of the fire areas go to question 28.
20 If"no"for any of the fire areas your verdict is against an award of punitive damages
21 for the entire class for that fire area and for defendant for that fire area. Do not answer
22 question 28 for any fire area that you answered "no"for question 27. Do not answer
23 question 29 for any fire area that you answered "no"for question 27.
24 If you answered "no"for all four fire areas, do not answer any more questions.
25
26
Page 4 of 6

I QUESTION 28: Should punitive damages be awarded against the Defendant as to the
2 entire class within the boundaries of the fire areas below?
3 / 2 8 11 24 32 37
Echo Mountain Complex fire YES NO N y y
4 44 69 8.3, 96
N 61
5 y y y
6 / 2 8 11 24 32 37
Santiam Canyon fire YES ✓ NO ►\I "I �/ l✓
7 44 48 61 69 83 96
8 N y
9 / V 8 11 24 32 37,
South Obenchain fire YES �/ NO t N
10 44 48 6� 69 83 9.6,
11 N �7/ Y /y
12 2 8 11 24 , 32- 37
242 fire YES NO
13 44 48 61 69 83 96
14 N Y y
15 At least nine of you who answered "yes" to question 27 must also agree on the answer
16 to question 28 for that particular fire area. If you answered "yes" to any fire area in
17 response to question 28,please proceed to question 29.
18 If"no"for any of the fire areas your verdict is against an award of punitive damages
19 .for the entire class for that fire area and for the defendant for that fire area. If you
20 answered "no" to all four fire areas,please do not answer any fiirther questions.
21
22 QUESTION 29: What amount of punitive damages, if any, do you award against
the Defendant as to the entire class within the boundaries of the fire areas below?
23
24
25 Echo Mountain Complex:
•25 times the amount of economic and noneconomic �
/ 1 7 3V 3N
26 44 48 61 69 83 96
damages awarded. y N y y y Y
Page 5 of 6

1 Santiam Canyon fire:
2 •25 times the amount of economic and noneconomic NJ 8 11 , zy 32 y N
44 48 61 69 . 83 ` 96
3 damages awarded. y N y Y y/
4 South Obenchain fire:
N 8 , 1� 24 32 • 3i
5 ,25 times the amount of economic and noneconomic �(/ I// N
44 48 61 69 83 96
6 damages awarded. y y Y y y
7 242 fire:
837
8 25 times the amount of economic and noneconomic N y 1y zy 32 , N
44 48 61 69 83 96
\,
9 damages awarded. 1 N" y y y y
10 At least nine of you who answered "yes" to question 28 must also agree on the answer to
11 question 29 for that particular fire area.
12
13
14 You are now done with this form. Your presiding juror should sign this verdict form and
15 notify the clerk.
16
17 Dated: I y 2 3 �oq
18 Presiding Juror Number and Initials
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Page 6 of 6