HomeMy WebLinkAboutD201801 NOPV Response Colleen Larkin Bell � Dominion
Vice President and General Manager-Western Distribution
Gas Infrastructure Group / Ene gye
333 South State Street,Salt Lake City,UT 84111
Mailing Address:
P.O.Box 45360,Salt Lake City,UT 84145-0360
DominionEnergy.com
3/1/2019
Mr. Joe Leckie
Executive Director
Idaho Public Utility Commission
PO Box 83720
Boise, Idaho 83720
Dear Mr. Leckie,
Dominion Energy Idaho (DEI) has received your letter dated November 16, 2018 and appreciates the
opportunity to respond. DEI acknowledges its delayed response to the letter due to internal issues
receiving the paper copy of the letter. DEI Compliance thanks the Idaho PSC for forwarding the letter
through e-mail. The following probable violations were described in your letter:
Item 1: 49 CFR 192,739(a)and 192.740(b)- `During the inspection it was noted that 1 regulator
(FC0001)failed to lock-up when tested and 6 other reg stations(FR0001, FC0001, FC0003,
FC0004, FC0005, and FC0006)being inspected were not plumbed for lock-up. Measurement and
Control Technicians were unable to demonstrate that the regulators were functioning properly
and were able to lock-up when the necessity arrives."
Item 2:49 CFR 192.479(a)(b)- `During the inspection it was noted that 3 regulating stations
(FC0001, FC0004, and FC0005)had some coating issues/corrosion concerns."
During the inspection and testing of FC0001, the monitor regulator did not perform a complete lock-up.
There was some pressure bypassing due to a defective regulator boot. Our technician was able to
replace the boot during the inspection and demonstrate that the station was operating properly prior to
leaving the site. The worker regulator and the relief device functioned properly during the test.
49 CFR 192.739 outlines inspection and testing requirements for pressure limiting and regulating stations.
Under 192.739(a)(3)the code states"...except as provided in paragraph (b)of this section, set to control
or relieve at the correct pressure consistent with the pressure limits of 192.201(a)". DEI Standard Practice
5-55-02, Pressure Limiting and Regulating Station Inspection and Testing, documents two acceptable
methods for inspection of regulators: (1) disassembly and inspection of regulators or(2) performing a
lock-up test. During the annual inspection, DEI Technicians will either dis-assemble and inspect a
regulator and/or perform a lock-up test. If only dis-assembly is performed, the regulator(s) are thoroughly
inspected for any debris or other material that may prematurely fail or cause the regulator to operate
irregularly. Once placed back into service after disassembly or a lock-up test, the regulator is carefully
adjusted,while monitoring downstream pressure, to ensure it is regulating at the correct pressure—
consistent with the requirements of 192.739(a)(3). In addition to the pressure regulator, Company
standard configurations will have either a secondary regulator or a full-size relief valve for over-pressure
protection in the event a primary regulator does not lock-up.
There are station designs in the Company system where lock-up tests are not achievable due to piping
configuration and the necessity to maintain supply to downstream customers. These stations are
periodically reviewed and assessed for replacement. The current Company station standards (revised
September of 2017), have additional pressure taps and configurations that make it possible to perform
lock-up tests on all standard station assemblies.
In response to Item 2, Company's Standard Practice 5-55-02, Pressure Limiting and Regulating Station
Inspection and Testing, documents the processes used by Measurement and Control Technicians to
complete the inspections. Inspection for signs of atmospheric corrosion is part of the annual inspection of
the FC0001, FC0004, and FC0005 regulating stations (Section 6.19 and 6.20 of SP 5-55-02).
Additionally, if atmospheric corrosion was encountered, Technicians would complete a Corrosion
Detection Report and denote the issue on the annual inspection form. Annual Inspection Reports from
2017 and 2018 do not denote atmospheric corrosion as an issue. However, DEI acknowledges there may
be signs of light surface oxide at the above mentioned regulating stations. Company will ensure that the
regulating stations are cleaned and painted during the 2019 annual inspection to protect against
atmospheric corrosion. Any signs of existing corrosion will be documented in accordance with our
Standard Practice.
Respectfully,
Colleen Larkin Bell
VP and General Manager, Western Gas Distribution
Dominion Energy Idaho
cc:
Matt Bartol
Reid Hess
Chris Noble
Lauren Skufca
Darrin Ulmer