Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20240816Staff 205-216 to PAC.pdf RECEIVED Friday, August 16, 2024 1.59.37 PM IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION ADAM TRIPLETT DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION PO BOX 83720 BOISE, IDAHO 83720-0074 (208) 334-0318 IDAHO BAR NO. 10221 Street Address for Express Mail: 11331 W CHINDEN BLVD, BLDG 8, SUITE 201-A BOISE, ID 83714 Attorney for the Commission Staff BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION ) OF ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER FOR ) CASE NO. PAC-E-24-04 AUTHORITY TO INCREASE ITS RATES ) AND CHARGES IN IDAHO AND APPROVAL ) ELEVENTH PRODUCTION OF PROPOSED ELECTRIC SERVICE ) REQUEST OF THE SCHEDULES AND REGULATIONS ) COMMISSION STAFF TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER Staff of the Idaho Public Utilities Commission,by and through its attorney of record, Adam Triplett, Deputy Attorney General, requests that PacifiCorp d/b/a Rocky Mountain Power ("Rocky Mountain Power" or the "Company")provide the following documents and information as soon as possible,but no later than FRIDAY,AUGUST 30, 2024.1 This Production Request is to be considered as continuing, and the Company is requested to provide, by way of supplementary responses, additional documents that it, or any person acting on its behalf, may later obtain that will augment the documents or information produced. Please provide answers to each question, supporting workpapers that provide detail or are the source of information used in calculations, and the name,job title, and telephone number of 1 Staff is requesting an expedited response. If responding by this date will be problematic,please call Staff s attorney at(208)334-0318. ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 1 AUGUST 16, 2024 the person preparing the documents. Please also identify the name,job title, location, and telephone number of the record holder. In addition to the written copies provided as response to the requests, please provide all Excel spreadsheets and electronic files with formulae intact and enabled. REQUEST NO. 205: Company witness McCoy's Exhibit No. 48, Page 8.5.3, Major Plant Detail lists the following three projects: 1) "Customer 27—UT—Trans"; 2) "Customer 22 —UT -Trans"; 3) "Customer 8—UT—Trans (1)". Please provide the following details for each of these three projects: a. Please provide a narrative description of each project scope; b. Please identify the Customer in each project, and the facilities that will be served by each project; c. Please specify if the Customer provided any Contribution in Aid of Construction ("CIAC") for this project, and if so,provide the amount and how it has been applied to the project; d. Please provide a map of the transmission line constructed by each project, showing how it interconnects with other transmission lines and/or generation resources in the vicinity; and e. Please provide a current project management Gantt chart for each project showing the major elements of work, their duration and dependencies, and their percent complete. Please highlight the project critical path. REQUEST NO. 206: Company witness McCoy's Exhibit No. 48, Page 8.5.3, Major Plant Detail lists the following project in the Transmission section: "Project Specialized" for a total plant-in-service amount of$72,681,510. Please clarify if this is truly a single project, or an umbrella project for several smaller ones. a. Please provide the project scope of work; b. Please explain why it has various in-service dates, what are the anticipated dates, and what scope of work is associated with each in-service date. If it is an umbrella project for several smaller projects, please provide the following: ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 2 AUGUST 16, 2024 i. Please provide a list of the subordinate projects with a unique identifier and title for each subordinate project; ii. Please include the estimated cost and completion date for each subordinate project; and iii. Please provide explanatory details for the need for each project. REQUEST NO. 207: Company witness McCoy's Exhibit No. 48, Page 8.5.3, Major Plant Detail lists the following project in the Transmission section: "OTP196 Nephi 2nd POD" for a total plant-in-service amount of$6,905,150. Please provide the following information regarding this project: a. Please provide an explanation of the need for the project including the analysis justifying the need; b. Please list all potential alternatives the Company considered and explain why the Company selected this solution; c. Please provide the approved Initial Project Plan including the following: i. Initial project scope, including maps and/or drawings depicting the scope; ii. Initial project budget; iii. Initial proposed schedule; and iv. Evidence that the plan and budget were approved at the appropriate level; and d. Please provide the latest project schedule showing the major elements of work, the duration and dependencies of those work elements, the percentage complete of each work element, and critical path for placing the plant in service. REQUEST NO. 208: Company witness McCoy's Exhibit No. 48, Page 8.5.3, Major Plant Detail lists the following project in the Transmission section: "Jackalope Bixby Transmission Upgrade" for a total plant-in-service amount of$7,034,353. Please provide the following information regarding this project: a. Please provide an explanation of the need for the project including the analysis justifying the need; b. Please list all potential alternatives the Company considered and explain why the Company selected this solution; ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 3 AUGUST 16, 2024 c. Please provide the approved Initial Project Plan including the following: i. Initial project scope, including maps and/or drawings depicting the scope; ii. Initial project budget; iii. Initial proposed schedule; and iv. Evidence that the plan and budget were approved at the appropriate level; and d. Please provide the latest project schedule showing the major elements of work, the duration and dependencies of those work elements, the percentage complete of each work element, and critical path for placing the plant in service. REQUEST NO. 209: Attachment IPUC 15 lists the following Transmission project: "TIUT/2020/C/012 - Q846 Horseshoe Solar, LLC" for a total plant-in-service amount of $8,645,796. Please provide the following information regarding this project: a. Please provide an explanation of the need for the project including the analysis justifying the need; b. Please list all potential alternatives the Company considered and explain why the Company selected this solution; c. Please provide the approved Initial Project Plan including the following: i. Initial project scope, including maps and/or drawings depicting the scope; ii. Initial project budget; iii. Initial proposed schedule; and iv. Evidence that the plan and budget were approved at the appropriate level; and d. Please provide a comparison of the actual expenditures to the budget, by budget line item. REQUEST NO. 210: Attachment IPUC 15 lists the following Transmission project: "DCED/2020/C/009 -Future Comp. LLC, 4.3 MW Load" for a total plant-in-service amount of $7,949,285. Please provide the following information regarding this project: a. Please provide an explanation of the need for the project including the analysis justifying the need; b. Please list all potential alternatives the Company considered and explain why the Company selected this solution; ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 4 AUGUST 16, 2024 c. Please provide the approved Initial Project Plan including the following: i. Initial project scope, including maps and/or drawings depicting the scope; ii. Initial project budget; iii. Initial proposed schedule; and iv. Evidence that the plan and budget were approved at the appropriate level; and d. Please provide a comparison of the actual expenditures to the budget, by budget line item. REQUEST NO. 211: Please provide the Company's procedures and policies documenting its capital project management controls. This should include required process steps, verifications, and approval levels for different types of expenditures and/or dollar thresholds. REQUEST NO. 212: From the Company's Response to Production Request No. 55, "Staff Attachment 55-2" (attached as Attachment No. 1) lists projects under$5 million for Wildfire projects. Please answer the following questions in regards to the projects listed in "Staff Attachment 55-2": a. Please explain what the term "Mandated Wildfire Mitigation"means. Please explain if each project with this term is mandated by a certain state or by the Company. b. For each project with the term"Mandated Wildfire Mitigation"in project description, please provide location of the project, narrative of the project, in-service date, and any benefits to Idaho customers. c. For each project with"Damage Repair", "Damage Rebuild", "Damaged Facilities", "Fire Damage" and "Fire Restoration" in the project description, please explain the cause of the damage, any associated names of the fire and the fire start date, the scope of the project, total project cost and if the Company expects any insurance funds for the project. d. For Ref#134 "RMP 2023 ID Fire Mitigation Vehicles",please provide a list of vehicles purchased,price, purpose, date and invoices. e. For Ref#79 "RMP 2023 UT Fire Mitigation Vehicles", Ref#211 "RMP 2022 UT Fire Mitigation Vehicles", Ref#531 "FHCA - 2021 UT Wildfire Vehicles",please provide ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 5 AUGUST 16, 2024 a list of each vehicle purchased,price,purpose, date and invoices. Additionally, please explain how these costs were allocated to Idaho. f. For Ref#580 "RMP 2023 WY Fire Mitigation Vehicles",please provide a list of each vehicles purchased,price, purpose, date and invoices. Additionally,please explain how these costs were allocated to Idaho. g. For Ref#1705 "Purchase Firefighting Equipment",please provide a list of the equipment purchased, quantity,purpose, and cost of each item. Additionally, please explain how these costs were allocated to Idaho. REQUEST NO. 213: From the Company's Response to Production Request No. 55, Attachment 55-2 lists the following projects: 1) "Judge-Brighton 46kV Rebld for Wildfire"; 2) "Northeast-Medical 46kV Rbld for Wildfire"; 3) "Medical-Research 46kV Rbld for Wildfire"; 4) "El Monte-Eden 46kV Rebuild for Wildfire"; and 5) "Span Fk-Santaquin 46kV Rbld for Wildfire". Please provide the following details for each of these projects: a. Please provide a narrative description of each project scope and location; b. Please identify the facilities that will be served by each project; c. Plant in Service amount and date; d. Accumulated depreciation; e. CIAC associated with the line; f. Accumulated CIAC amortization; g. Please provide a map of the transmission line constructed by each project showing how it interconnects with other transmission lines and/or generation resources in the vicinity; and h. Please provide a current project management Gantt chart for each project showing the major elements of work, their duration and dependencies, and their percentage complete. Please highlight the project's critical path. REQUEST NO. 214: Company's Attachment 55-1 lists 18 transmission projects with no "Annual Actual Project Costs Placed in Service (by year)" from 2022 through 2024. For each,please answer the following: a. Please provide a narrative description of each project scope; and ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 6 AUGUST 16, 2024 b. Please provide a current project management Gantt chart for each project showing the major elements of work, their duration and dependencies, and their percentage complete. Please highlight the project's critical path. REQUEST NO. 215: Company's Attachment 55-1 lists project"Midpoint 500 kV Series Cap Bank Rpl (IDP)"with an in-service date of January 2024; however, it does not list any actual project costs placed in service. Please explain if this project is in service as of July 2024 and please explain this discrepancy. REQUEST NO. 216: Company's Attachment 55-1 lists project "Houston Lake— Ponderosa Add Second 115 kV Line"with an in-service date of May 2024; however, it does not list any actual project costs placed in service. Please explain if this project is in service as of July 2024 and please explain this discrepancy. DATED at Boise, Idaho, this 16th day of August 2024. CA Adam Yriplett Deputy Attorney General I:\Utility\UMISC\PRDREQ\PAC-E-24-04 PR#II.docx ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER 7 AUGUST 16, 2024 January 2022 through December 2023 plant additions-projects<$5 million (excludes non-Idaho distribution and projects>$5m included in Attach 55-1) Ref# Project Definition Project Description 2022 2023 Total Comment 20 TPAR/2019/C/001 Judge-Brighton 46kV Rebid for Wildfire 3,358,671 277,030 3,635,702 21 DORE/2023/C/DMW Oregon-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 3,545,915 3,545,915 31 TROS/2020/C/002 Archie Creek Fire Damage Repair 2,201,528 1,056,354 3,257,883 54 TMET/2019/C/004 Northeast-Medical46kV Rbld for Wildfire 2,542,479 2,542,479 79 DUTH/2023/C/005 RMP2023 UTFire Mitigation Vehicles 1,985,261 1,985,261 114 TCRE/2023/C/003 Smith River Fire Restoration 1,526,237 1,526,237 134 DIDA/2023/C/002 RMP2023 ID Fire Mitigation Vehicles 1,329,887 1,329,887 142 TORE/2019/C/003 Fire Mitig ORTransmission Protection 1,296,926 (426) 1,296,500 181 TMET/2019/C/005 Medical-Research46kVRbid for Wildfire 967,880 120,494 1,088,374 187 DIDA/2023/C/DMW Idaho-Dist Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 1,048,873 1,048,873 189 TCAL/2019/C/004 CA Wildfire MitigTrans Relays Phase 2 866,282 167,258 1,033,540 211 DUTH/2022/C/008 RMP2022 UTFire Mitigation Vehicles 11,978 938,642 950,620 281 TOGD/2019/C/003 El Monte-Eden 46kV Rebuild for Wildfire 744,188 744,188 293 DMTS/2022/C/006 Mill Fire Damage Rebuild 703,405 - 703,405 450 DCAL/2019/C/003 Calif Fire Mitigation CA-D Sub Relay 130,280 309,773 440,053 486 DWAS/2023/C/DMW Washington-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 401,686 401,686 531 DUTH/2021/C/001 FHCA-2021 UT Wildfire Vehicles 359,033 3,326 362,359 580 DWYO/2023/C/002 RMP 2023 WY Fire Mitigation Vehicles 325,725 325,725 601 TROS/2021/C/002 Jack Fire Damage Repair 306,996 1,732 308,727 774 TUTH/2021/C/TMW Utah-Tran Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 217,319 217,319 782 TCAL/2022/C/TMW California-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 215,075 215,075 798 DUTH/2020/C/002 ALERTWildfire Systems-Wildfire Cameras 205,119 205,119 1116 DUTH/2019/C/805 RMP Wildfire Mitigation-Distribution 115,614 115,614 General plant additions portion of project 1145 DCAL/2023/C/DMW California-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 109,951 109,951 1229 DYRE/2020/C/003 CA-Wildfire Mitig Dist Sub Relay Rpl Ph3 93,872 93,872 General plant additions portion of project 1282 DORE/2020/C/DMW Oregon-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 85,276 85,276 1542 DCAL/2020/C/003 CA-Fire Mitig Instl Weather Statns 2020 50,712 50,712 1544 DORE/2020/C/003 OR Fire Mitig Dist Sub Relay Rplc Phs 1 50,433 50,433 General plant additions portion of project 1581 DUTH/2022/C/DMW Utah-Dist Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 46,318 46,318 General plant additions portion of project 1586 DYAK/2020/C/002 WA-Fire Mitig lnst Weather Stations 2020 45,808 45,808 1675 TAME/2019/C/005 Span Fk-Santaquin46kVRbld for Wildfire 36,817 36,817 1700 DORE/2020/C/004 OR-Fire Mitig lnstlWeatherStatns2020 (156,236) 190,885 34,649 1705 SJIM/2023/C/050 Purchase Firefighting Equipment23 34,173 34,173 1821 DCAL/2021/C/DMW California-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 26,281 26,281 1882 DUTH/2020/C/DMW Utah-Dist Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 21,806 21,806 General plant additions portion of project 1937 TYRE/2020/C/001 Slater Fire(Happy Camp)Fire Damage 18,272 - 18,272 2032 DIDA/2022/C/DMW Idaho-Dist Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 13,082 13,082 2130 DORE/2021/C/DMW Oregon-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 8,999 8,999 2214 TPAR/2020/C/001 Cottonwd-Snyderville 138kV Rbld-Wildfire 5,268 5,268 2222 TMED/2020/C/001 Almeda Fire Damage Repair 5,090 5,090 2223 TZRB/2021/C/002 Winchester Sub Wildfire Mitigation Upgrd 5,086 5,086 2382 TYRE/2018/C/002 Delta Fire Damaged Facilities 1,186 1,186 2496 TCAL/2019/C/003 Calif Fire MitigTransmission Line Rebid 135,096 (135,096) - 2498 TORE/2022/C/TMW Oregon-Mandated Wildfire Mitigation 43,802 (43,802) - 2618 TCAL/2019/C/001 California Fire Mitigation CA-T Sub (1,877) 387 (1,490) 2825 TORE/2019/C/001 Calif Fire Mitigation OR-T Sub (7,029) (7,029) 3121 TUTH/2019/C/805 RMP Wildfire Mitigation-Transmission (595,091) 1,226 (593,864) 3126 TKLA/2020/C/001 Two FourTwo Fire Damage Repair (714,524) - (714,524) Attachment No. 1 Case No. PAC-E-24-04 Production Request No. 11 August XX, 2024 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE THIS A�VDAY OF AUGUST 2024, SERVED THE FOREGOING ELEVENTH PRODUCTION REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION STAFF TO ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER, IN CASE NO. PAC-E-24- 04, BY E-MAILING A COPY THEREOF, TO THE FOLLOWING: MARK ALDER JOE DALLAS ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER CARLA SCARSELLA 1407 WEST NORTH TEMPLE STE 330 ROCKY MOUNTAIN POWER SALT LAKE CITY UT 84116 825 NE Multnomah, Suite 2000 E-MAIL: mark.aldergpacificorp.com Portland, OR 97232 E-MAIL: joseqph.dallas&acificorp.com carla.scarsella(gpacificorp.com DATA REQUEST RESPONSE CENTER E-MAIL ONLY: datarequest&acificorp.com ERIC L OLSEN LANCE KAUFMAN PhD ECHO HAWK& OLSEN PLLC 2623 NW BLUEBELL PLACE PO BOX 6119 CORVALLIS OR 97330 POCATELLO ID 83205 E-MAIL: lance(a,aegisinsi t.com E-MAIL: elo _,echohawk.com MATTHEW NYKIEL BRAD HEUSINKVELD ID CONSERVATION LEAGUE ID CONSERVATION LEAGUE 710 N 6TH STREET 710 N 6TH STREET BOISE ID 83702 BOISE ID 83702 E-MAIL: matthew.Wkielggmail.com E-MAIL: heusinkveldgidahoconservation.org THOMAS J BUDGE BRIAN C COLILINS RACINE OLSON PLLP GREG MEYER PO BOX 1391 BRUBAKER& ASSOCIATES POCATELLO ID 83204-1391 16690 SWINGLEY RIDGE RD #140 E-MAIL: tj racineolson.com CHESTERFIELD MO 63017 E-MAIL: bcollinsgconsultbai.com gmeyergconsultbai.com Electronic Service Only: RONALD L WILLIAMS KEVIN HIGGINS BRANDON HELGESON NEAL TOWNSEND HAWLEY TROXELL ET AL ENERGY STRATEGIES LLC 877 W MAIN ST E-MAIL: khigginsgenergystrat.com BOISE ID 83701 ntownsendgenergystrat.com E-MAIL: rwilliams@hawleytroxell.com bhelgeson@hawleytroxell.com CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Page 1 of 2 Electronic Service Only: Electronic Service Only: BRADLEY MULLINS VAL STEINER MW ANALYTICS ITAFOS CONDA LLC E-MAIL: brmullinsgmwanalytics.com E-MAIL: Val.steinergitafos.com Electronic Service Only: KYLE WILLIAMS BYU Idaho E-MAIL: williamsk(kbyui.edu PATRICIA JORDAN, SECRETARY CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Page 2 of 2