Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20240731Schultz Workpapers.pdf 2024 Idaho PCA Case No. AVU-E-24-07 Avista Corporation Workpapers Kaylene J. Schultz AVISTA UTILITIES IDAHO ELECTRIC IMPACT OF PROPOSED SCHEDULE 66 PCA CHANGE PROPOSED RATE TO BE EFFECTIVE OCTOBER 1,2024 (000s of Dollars) (000s of kWh) Total Billed Percent Revenue Proposed change Line Type of Schedule Forecasted at Present Sch.66 on Billed No. Service Number Kilowatt-hours Rates Change Revenue (a) (b) (c)(1) (d) (e) (f) 1 Residential 1 1,362,736 $ 148,447 $ (9,594) -6.5% 2 General Service 11,12 591,380 $ 53,229 $ (4,163) -7.8% 3 Large General Service 21,22 492,856 $ 51,143 $ (3,470) -6.8% 4 Extra Large General Service 25 344,595 $ 22,608 $ (2,426) -10.7% 5 Clearwater 25P 377,883 $ 22,810 $ (2,660) -11.7% 6 Pumping Service 31,32 60,691 $ 7,173 $ (427) -6.0% 7 Street&Area Lights 41-49 10,014 $ 3,932 $ (70) -1.8% 8 Total 3,240,155 $ 309,342 $ (22,810) -7.4% check -7.4% 9 Proposed rate $ (0.00205) $ (6,642) 10 Present rate(AVU-E-23-08,Order No.35937) $ 0.00499 $ 16,168 11 Rate Change $ (0.00704) $ (22,810) Proposed rate 12 Total Amortization and Deferral Balance including interest thru 9/30/24 $ (6,604) 13 Conversion factor(Case No.AVU-E-23-01: Per Final Stipulation&Settlement) 0.996223 14 Revenue Requirement $ (6,629) 15 kWh's from above 3,240,155 16 Proposed rate: $ (0.00205) (1) Source: Calendar Load forecast for the twelve month period October 1,2024-September 30,2025 2024 Idaho PCA-Schultz Workpapers Exhibit KJS-1 Page 1 of 7 Avista Corporation PCA July 2023 through June 2024 IPUC Deferral Analysis AVU-E-21-01 AVU-E-23-01 Jul-23 thru Deferral for 2023-24 Deferral Period JulJul23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-2 4 Jun-24 Jun-24 BASE RATE RECOVERY-LOAD CHANGE ADJUSTMENT Idaho Actual Sales MWh 279,720 263,228 215,006 227,601 269,272 293,112 330,857 273,846 270,724 235,960 231,429 222,612 3,113,367 Idaho Base Sales MWh 245,017 250,933 218,497 235,421 260,464 297,899 304,450 275,917 276,088 250,222 227,023 225,845 3,067,776 Actual-Base Sales MWh 34,703 12,295 (3,491) (7,820) 8,808 (4,787) 26,407 (2,071) (5,364) (14,262) 4,406 (3,233) 45,591 LCAR $/MWh 25.43 25.43 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 24.41 Retail Revenue Adjustment-Under(+)/Over(-) $ (882,497) (312,662) 85,215 190,886 (215,003) 116,851 (644,595) 50,553 130,935 348,135 (107,550) 78,918 (1,160,814) Base-to-Actual Percent Difference % 14.16% 4.90% -1.60% -3.32% 3.38% -1.61% 8.67% -0.75% -1.94% -5.70% 1.94% -1.43% 1.49% NET POWER SUPPLY EXPENSE Actual Expense 555 Purchased Power $ 16,958,915 27,838,359 14,025,205 15,530,377 18,598,072 13,671,747 54,690,914 15,757,837 15,483,601 14,341,408 14,693,295 14,238,851 235,828,581 447 Sales for Resale $ (26,000,202) (22,956,191) (25,903,589) (18,891,771) (21,245,654) (18,129,690) (33,943,259) (26,569,719) (26,892,327) (16,036,987) (12,103,135) (17,187,526) (265,860,050) 501 Thermal Fuel $ 4,637,531 4,195,868 4,263,142 3,028,895 3,763,156 3,979,809 4,419,464 4,123,045 3,817,132 3,057,279 733,455 1,114,678 41,133,454 547 CT Fuel $ 10,398,260 9,852,495 8,996,101 12,524,452 14,838,485 17,119,650 21,574,355 12,617,001 13,274,499 4,996,584 2,934,591 4,030,212 133,156,685 456 Transmission Revenue $ (2,720,244) (2,730,714) (2,680,016) (3,085,232) (2,933,461) (3,189,820) (3,346,342) (3,343,315) (3,329,394) (3,554,069) (3,401,900) (3,022,063) (37,336,570) 565 Transmission Expense $ 1,585,031 1,498,269 1,475,607 1,482,065 1,402,141 1,450,677 1,782,206 1,735,976 1,687,036 1,659,166 1,611,410 1,578,466 18,948,050 537 MT.Invasive Species Expense $ 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 64,722 776,664 557 Expense Broker Fees $ (7,566) 153,632 196,190 6,777 9,001 5,574 6,131 30,209 7,090 1,627 9,261 40,256 458,182 557 Resource Optimization $ 210,313 809,212 890,798 399,237 1,637,183 2,347,018 3,021,411 1,851,473 228,377 151,774 406,169 329,822 12,282,787 Adjusted Actual Net Expense $ 5,126,760 18,725,652 1,328,160 11,059,522 16,133,645 17,319,687 48,269,602 6,267,229 4,340,736 4,681,504 4,947,868 1,187,418 139,387,783 Idaho Allocation Factor $ 34.36% 34.36% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% Idaho Actual Net Expense $ 1,761,555 6,434,134 457,817 3,812,217 5,561,267 5,970,097 16,638,532 2,160,314 1,496,252 1,613,714 1,705,531 409,303 48,020,733 Authorized Net Expense 555 Purchased Power $ 5,937,659 5,836,088 5,942,565 6,184,512 6,489,810 6,556,792 7,435,932 7,069,211 7,433,801 5,672,869 5,579,483 5,419,545 75,558,267 447 Sales for Resale $ (9,557,120) (4,493,194) (7,072,562) (3,997,529) (2,672,014) (4,453,080) (2,316,991) (1,936,564) (2,540,468) (4,230,873) (3,489,856) (5,862,698) (52,622,949) 501 Thermal Fuel $ 2,879,162 3,146,005 3,033,757 2,874,156 2,395,831 3,087,726 3,151,777 2,749,966 2,896,333 2,060,445 1,526,412 1,782,225 31,583,795 547 CT Fuel $ 6,693,265 7,977,571 8,729,385 8,223,214 8,133,493 10,790,239 8,942,104 7,474,530 5,068,911 4,095,763 2,284,385 3,117,887 81,530,747 456 Transmission Revenue $ (2,267,860) (2,209,469) (1,714,509) (1,711,129) (1,937,530) (2,146,621) (1,634,727) (1,811,669) (1,891,560) (1,715,927) (2,123,305) (2,306,697) (23,471,003) 565 Transmission Expense $ 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 1,439,897 17,278,764 90%Palouse Wind and Rattlesnake Flats $ 0 0 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 2,442,750 24,427,500 Remove Columbia Basin Hydro Transmission Project(embedd $ 0 0 (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (83,917) (839,170) Gas Liquids Revenue-456018 $ (524,310) (514,471) (290,007) (311,801) (548,421) (265,977) (633,351) (664,038) (880,329) (385,474) (657,028) (615,703) (6,290,910) Montana Invasive Species Expense $ 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 134,167 1,610,004 Settlement Adjustments $ 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 52,636 631,632 Authorized Net Expense $ 4,787,496 11,369,230 12,614,162 15,246,956 15,846,702 17,554,612 18,930,277 16,866,969 14,072,221 9,482,336 7,105,624 5,520,092 149,396,677 Idaho Allocation Factor $ 34.36% 34.36% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% Idaho Authorized Net Expense $ 1,644,984 3,906,467 4,348,102 5,255,626 5,462,358 6,051,075 6,525,266 5,814,044 4,850,695 3,268,561 2,449,309 1,902,776 51,479,263 RENEWABLE ENERGY CREDIT REVENUE Actual REC Revenue $ (121,260) (54,060) (93,740) (327,820) (529,574) (561,552) (331,704) (311,542) (333,892) (1,799,999) (1,129,608) (863,676) (6,458,427) Authorized REC Revenue $ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Actual-Authorized REC Revenue $ (121,260) (54,060) (93,740) (327,820) (529,574) (561,552) (331,704) (311,542) (333,892) (1,799,999) (1,129,608) (863,676) (6,458,427) Idaho Allocation Factor $ 34.36% 34.36% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% 34.47% Actual-Authorized Idaho REC Revenue $ (41,665) (18,575) (32,312) (113,000) (182,544) (193,567) (114,338) (107,389) (115,093) (620,460) (389,376) (297,709) (2,226,028) COST RECOVERY SUBJECT TO SHARING Actual-Authorized Net Expense(Idaho share) $ 116,571 2,527,667 (3,890,285) (1,443,409) 98,909 (80,978) 10,113,266 (3,653,730) (3,354,443) (1,654,847) (743,778) (1,493,473) (3,458,530) Retail Revenue Adjustment $ (882,497) (312,662) 85,215 190,886 (215,003) 116,851 (644,595) 50,553 130,935 348,135 (107,550) 78,918 (1,160,814) REC Revenue $ (41,665) (18,575) (32,312) (113,000) (182,544) (193,567) (114,338) (107,389) (115,093) (620,460) (389,376) (297,709) (2,226,028) 456030 ED ID-Sch 25P Transmission $ 13,750 13,750 13,750 13,750 13,750 13,750 13,750 13,750 14,536 14,587 14,730 15,090 168,943 456380 ED ID-Sch 25P REC Revenue $ (25,912) (28,254) (30,599) (26,827) (30,349) (31,591) (31,365) (70,300) (94,774) (89,991) (92,425) (95,186) (647,573) Sch 25P Net Cost (12,162) (14,504) (16,949) (13,077) (16,599) (17,841) (17,615) (56,550) (80,238) (75,404) (77,695) (80,096) (478,630) Energy Imbalance Market Incremental O&M Costs l'I $ 52,486 57,590 23,511 23,949 9,019 62,362 24,038 25,215 31,101 22,106 23,787 24,339 379,503 Total Cost(Subject to Sharing) $ (767,267) 2,239,516 (3,830,720) (1,354,651) (306,218) (113,173) 9,360,756 (3,741,901) (3,387,738) (1,980,470) (1,294,612) (1,768,021) (6,944,499) Sharing Percentage % 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% 90% $ (694,450) Total Cost Recovery Subject to Sharing $ (690,540) 2,015,564 (3,447,648) (1,219,186) (275,596) (101,856) 8,424,680 (3,367,710) (3,048,964) (1,782,423) (1,165,151) (1,591,219) (6,250,049) Total Power Cost Deferral with Adjustments $ (690,540) 2,015,564 (3,447,648) (1,219,186) (275,596) (101,856) 8,424,680 (3,367,710) (3,048,964) (1,782,423) (1,165,151) (1,591,219) (6,250,049) 2024 Idaho PCA-Schultz Workpapers Act-Auth-Proposed Page 2 of 7 Avista Corporation PCA July 2023 through June 2024 IPUC Deferral Analysis AVU-E-21-01 AVU-E-23-01 Jul-23 thru Deferral for 2023-24 Deferral Period JulJul23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-2 4 May-2 4 lun-24 Jun-24 Monthly Interest Rate % 0.16667% 0.16667% 0.16667% 0.16667% 0.16667% 0.16667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% 0.41667% PCA Ending Balances Account 182385 June 2023 Ending Balance $ 636,536 636,536 Account 182386 June 2023 Ending Balance S 16,017,001 16,017,001 Account 182387 June 2023 Ending Balance $ 0 0 2023-2024 Beginning Balance S 16,653,537 14,539,132 16,169,063 12,385,192 10,577,002 9,091,958 7,627,492 14,467,597 9,674,078 5,323,503 2,291,741 7,330 (2,712,886) (4,126,586) (5,480,520) 16,653,537 2023-2024 Incremental Deferral $ (690,540) 2,015,564 (3,447,648) (1,219,186) (275,596) (101,856) 8,424,680 (3,367,710) (3,048,964) (1,782,423) (1,165,151) (1,591,219) (6,250,049) RPS Compliance Adjustment S (1,058,163) (1,058,163) Amortization-Account 182385 $ (393,458) (409,865) (363,172) (609,647) (1,776,142) Amortization-Account 182386 S (1,227,077) (1,377,764) (1,616,355) (1,486,090) (1,341,921) (1,271,522) (1,128,809) (1,129,028) (10,578,566) Amortization-Projected $ (1,402,396) (1,336,740) (1,100,714) (3,839,850) 2023-24 Ending Balance w/out Current Month Interest $ 14,511,376 16,144,831 12,358,243 10,556,359 9,074,329 7,612,338 14,435,817 9,613,797 5,283,193 2,269,558 (2,219) (2,712,917) (4,115,282) (5,463,326) (6,581,234) (6,849,233) Interest $ 27,756 24,232 26,949 20,643 17,629 15,154 31,780 60,281 40,310 22,183 9,549 31 (11,304) (17,194) (22,836) 245,163 2023-24 Final Ending Deferral Balance $ 14,539,132 16,169,063 12,385,192 10,577,002 9,091,958 7,627,492 14,467,597 9,674,078 5,323,503 2,291,741 7,330 (2,712,886) (4,126,586) (5,480,520) (6,604,070) (6,604,070) I'I Per Avista ID General Rate Case,Case No.AVU-E-21-01,Order No.35156,section 6.Other Settlement Components,subpart E.Energy Imbalance Market("EIM") 202307 202308 202309 202310 202311 202312 202401 202402 202403 202404 202405 202406 $ 16,043697 $ 16,070,437 $ 16,097,222 $ 14,994,756 $ 13,782,654 $ 12,427,862 $ 10,863,290 $ 9,422,464 8,119,804 6,882,115 5,781,982 4,677,046 $ (1,748:704) $ 263,945 $ (3,183,263) $ (4,407,754) $ (4,690,696) $ (4,800,370) $ 3,604,307 $ 251,614 (2,796,301) (4,590,374) (5,774,652) (7,389,932) $ 244,139 $ (165,319) $ (528,767) $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 14,539,132 $ 16,169,063 $ 12,385,192 $ 10,577,002 $ 9,091,958 $ 7,627,492 $ 14,467,597 $ 9,674,078 5,323,503 2,291,741 7,330 (2,712,886) 2024 Idaho PCA-Schultz Workpapers Act-Auth-Proposed Page 3 of 7 Source: EREV June Mid-month 06.12.24,Bill Determ Tab Calendar Load(kWh)by Rate Schedule Oct 24 Nov 24 Dec 24 Jan 25 Feb 25 Mar 25 Apr 25 May 25 Jun 25 Jul 25 Aug 25 Sep 25 Total ID001 89,635,324 126,487,143 161,321,860 164,775,756 125,051,527 121,190,603 104,547,622 92,495,613 89,725,779 106,570,700 101,294,498 79,639,244 1,362,735,669 IDO11 43,985,633 47,712,475 51,187,592 53,925,621 45,599,569 45,359,295 42,407,000 41,610,075 43,124,809 49,253,666 46,992,450 40,858,115 552,016,300 ID012 2,532,299 3,794,725 4,604,453 5,126,506 4,032,974 3,801,486 3,026,929 2,538,344 2,368,179 2,733,089 2,583,562 2,220,885 39,363,431 ID021 42,259,253 44,098,847 44,815,482 44,111,493 38,115,478 38,059,706 37,468,439 37,728,048 39,498,038 43,928,852 39,571,932 35,583,396 485,238,964 ID022 571,992 636,249 815,810 866,712 718,300 654,179 559,776 524,753 517,217 609,535 595,207 547,183 7,616,913 ID025 30,783,187 26,726,710 28,862,523 29,217,676 26,794,250 30,251,423 26,978,231 29,712,240 28,017,855 29,814,511 29,858,091 27,577,925 344,594,622 ID025P 31,897,470 25,888,455 32,435,949 30,817,140 26,700,417 33,957,073 28,129,913 34,275,788 31,746,553 37,044,136 35,482,212 29,508,186 377,883,292 ID031 4,613,302 2,911,856 3,386,315 3,747,644 3,109,081 3,017,045 3,139,670 4,203,178 6,257,751 6,807,068 8,534,304 6,294,505 56,021,719 ID032 233,108 214,535 253,579 282,652 219,440 209,881 196,563 286,412 480,569 891,534 949,878 451,248 4,669,399 I D04X 831,823 832,878 830,887 851,788 812,683 861,811 810,877 841,538 832,122 835,246 836,544 835,626 10,013,823 Total 247,343,391 279,303,873 328,514,450 333,722,988 271,153,719 277,362,502 247,265,020 244,215,989 242,568,872 278,488,337 266,698,678 223,516,313 3,240,154,132 3,240,154 Calendar Loads Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 ID001 108,312,152 101,011,808 77,394,173 IDO11 48,378,248 46,209,101 40,093,929 ID012 2,678,291 2,506,620 2,160,032 ID021 47,379,612 42,208,326 38,247,220 ID022 604,662 584,352 545,023 ID025 29,242,241 30,811,253 26,436,726 ID025P 36,583,865 35,113,026 29,219,813 ID031 7,188,585 8,661,116 6,029,826 ID032 896,178 950,028 451,077 I D04X 843,061 843,864 842,458 Total 282,106,895 268,899,494 221,420,277 772,426,666 Present Rate $0.00499 $0.00499 $0.00499 $1,407,713 $1,341,808 $1,104,887 Present RCF* 0.996223 0.996223 0.996223 $1,402,396 $1,336,740 $1,100,714 $3,839,850 *Case No.AVU-E-23-01:Per Final Stipulation&Settlement 2024 Idaho PCA-Schultz Workpapers KWh Forecast Page 4 of 7 AVISTA UTILITIES Settlement Revenue Conversion Factor Idaho - Electric System TWELVE MONTHS ENDED JUNE 30, 2022 Line No. Description Factor 1 Revenues 1.000000 Expenses: 2 Uncollectibles 0.001795 3 Commission Fees 0.001982 4 Idaho Income Tax 5 Total Expenses 0.003777 6 Net Operating Income Before FIT 0.996223 Case No. AVU-E-23-01: Per Final Stipulation &Settlement 2024 Idaho PCA- Schultz Workpapers Conversion Factor Page 5 of 7 Bill Determinants 2024 Idaho Annual PCA Filing Present Proposed Basic Charge $ 15.00 $ 15.00 Block 1 $ 0.09207 $ 0.08503 Block 2 $ 0.10379 $ 0.09675 Present Proposed Bill Bill Basic Charge $ 15.00 $ 15.00 Block 1 $ 55.24 $ 51.02 600 Block 2 $ 33.94 $ 31.64 327 Total Bill $ 104.18 $ 97.66 927 Total Bill Impact $ (6.52) -6.3% 2024 Idaho PCA- Schultz Workpapers Bill Impact Page 6 of 7 Avista Utilities Idaho Jurisdiction 2024 PCA Electric Service (000s of Dollars) (000s of kWh) PCA Present Present Proposed Proposed Proposed Incremental Type of Schedule Billing PCA PCA PCA PCA PCA Rate Service Number Determinants Rate Revenue Decrease Revenue Rate change (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) Residential 1 1,362,736 $ 0.00499 $ 6,800 $ (9,594) $ (2,794) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) General Service 11/12 591,380 $ 0.00499 $ 2,951 $ (4,163) $ (1,212) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) Large General Service 21/22 492,856 $ 0.00499 $ 2,459 $ (3,469) $ (1,010) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) Extra Large General Service 25 344,595 $ 0.00499 $ 1,720 $ (2,426) $ (706) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) Clearwater 25P 377,883 $ 0.00499 $ 1,886 $ (2,661) $ (775) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) Pumping Service 31/32 60,691 $ 0.00499 $ 303 $ (427) $ (124) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) Street&Area Lights 41-49 10,014 $ 0.00499 $ 50 $ (71) $ (21) $ (0.00205) $ (0.00704) Total 3,240,155 $ 16,169 $ (22,811) $ (6,642) 2024 Idaho PCA- Schultz Workpapers Bill Impact for Staff Page 7 of 7