The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About20070817Deanhardt exhibits 58-72.pdfIdaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 58 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T RE' McleoC: ISDN Proposal l'I:F'3de Secret Data Begins Subject: RE: Mcteod ISDN Proposal Date: Man, 11 Jun 2001 07:13:43 -0600 From: "Shearburn Jim" -cJim,Shearburn0qwestcom:::. To: "'Patty Hahn'" -cphahn~uswest.com:::' , " McKenney, Audrey" -caxmcken~qwest.com:::' Shearburn, Jim" -cJim.Shearburn0qwestcom:::' , " Snider, Patricia" -cpsnider~qwestcom:::' CC: "Barto, Sandra" -csbarto~qwest.com? REC'O dUN i 1 2001 Thanks, Patty for getting this together. I had a few questions. What is the effective date of this proposal, Gary originally had asked for 5 -1--1. When it became apparent that this had been previous ly proposed in Feb. he wanted it ' back to then. What effective date had you and Skip discussed. has the 10% across the board discount been negated by the reference that noadditional discounts apply? Are we still required to discount this price component by an additional 10% in a monthly rebate per the B2B deal? Audrey, maybe you can weigh in on that issue. Other than those two questions, I think it is ready to go. This is a significant reduction for them. I am sure Gary will appreciate the proposal. I would like to get this to Gary today. am in the office, please call.Lets discuss ASAP this morning. Thanks ----Original Message----- From: Patty Hahn mailto:phahn~uswest.com Sent: Friday, June 08, 2001 8:30 PM To: axmcken~qwest. com; jim. shearburn~qwest. com; Cc: sbarto~qwest.com Subject: McLeod ISDN Proposal psnider~qwest. com Audrey, Jim and Patti, . I have attached two documents for the McLeod ISDN wholesale proposal. The first document is a written description of the offering. The second document is an excel spreadsheet detailing the services and rate elements by state that categorizes the current ISDN /DSS/OAS products McLeod purchases from Qwest. I apologize for the delay in getting this document to you today. I did want the go ahead from the retail product management team (SkipOlson) that I had included all the rate elements by product correctly. And I do want to thank Sandy Barto for helping me with this spreadsheet. Audrey and Jim, I hope this is what you were looking for. me know if you have questions or want to discuss further.Please let Have a great weekend Trade Secret Data Ends)421/C-02-197 DOC 08-212 Trade Secret Attachment Patty 303 896-0285 1 of I NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT caNT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA 6/11101 10:23 AM Idaho Public UtilitieE. ' . illssion Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 59 Case No. QWE-06- AT&T PRI proi0'Q1 ,. ,,.. ' . (Trade Secret Data Begins Subject: PRI proposal Date: Mon, 11 Jun 2001 14:16:51 -0600From: "Shearbum, Jim" -cJim.Shearburn~qwest.com:::' To: "'gdupler~cleodusa.com'" -cgduple~cleodusa.com;::''" ewi lkens(g)mcleodusa. com III -cewilkens~c leodusa, com?CC: "Hahn, Patty" -cphahn~qwest.com? , " Snider, Patricia" -cpsnider~qwest.com? McKenney, Audrey" ..::axmcken~qwest.com:::' Boone, Mark D." -cMark.Boone0qwestcom;:. lfee'b JfJN 1. CO07 Gary and Eric, as we discussed this afternoon, I am attaching for yourreview a proposal t~at will reduce your cost for PRr service to $ 667 perunit. There are ' some caveats, including effective date, eligibility for addi tional discounts, etc. but on the whole, this is an excell~nt deal foryou and we look forward to your approval. While not reflected in thisproposal, it is our intent to, address the PRI pricing conce=ns with thisproposal with the intent of moving on to other more fruitful revenue growingopportunities for both parties. To Patty Hahn and Audrey McKenney, r would like to say I appreciate the research and effort put forth in preparing this proposal. Your advocacy of this pricing schedule went a long way towards getting this done. Thanks Gary and Eric, please call me or Patty Hahn with questions or comments. There is another issue left open, that of the Portland Colo Augment, we aretrying to get a better date for you on that, but candidly I was informed late last week, that there does not seem to be a way to better the standardinterval. Todd was wanting to expedite the delivery of 20-25 coax DS3,part of the original 80 or so ordered. Our implementation group cannot come up with a guaranteed better date. Sorrywe cannot do better on that date. -;,. .. Hope the set back on the IROs we discussed and the lack of a better date for Portland are offset by the new PRI pricing enclosed. Two files are attached, a Word doc reviewing what we went over verbally and an Excel spreadsheet inventorying your PRIs as of April, the most recent info available. Please call with questions.Thanks James P. Shearburn Qwest Communications International, Inc.Vice President Central Region Wholesale Markets 314-918-7966 - direct888-370-6960 314-918-7968 fax j im. shearburn~qwest. com P -4 21 /C-02-197 DOC 08-212 Trade Secret Attachment -::-::rSDN PROPOSAL McLeod 06112001. doc~~-::-::rSDN Proposal 06082001. xls~~ '----...------.-.--..--...,..-.--. -...-- NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA lof2 6/1 1101 3:04 PM PRI proposal . . ISDN PROPOSAL McLeod 061 12001.doc Name: ISDN PROPOSAL McLeod 06112001.doc Type: Winword File (application/msword) Encoding: base64 Download Status: Not downloaded with message ISDN Proposal 06082001.xls Name: ISDN Proposal 06082001.xls Type: Microsoft Excel Worksheet ( application/vnd.ms-excel) Encoding: base64 . Download Status: Not downlqaded with message NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA 2 of2 6/11101 3:04 PM , . Gary Dupler GVP Network Planning- McLeodUSA 15 East 5th Street Tulsa, OK 74103 .-' ~';\ rIde the light ,;, Qwest June II , 2001 Attention: Gary Dupler Reference: Wholesale ISDN/DDS Pricing Proposal Background Information: McLeodUSA requested that the Qwest Wholesale organization review McLeodUSA' s current ISDN/DSS circuits and develop a proposal to transition them to the McLeodUSA wholesale bill. Qwest Wholesale is pleased to offer McLeodUSA the following Wholesale ISDN/DDS pricing proposal. (SEE A IT ACHED) Our proposed information is a preliminary pricing schedule based on data through April2001. Current ISDNIDSS Prices: Currently McLeodUSA is paying the following rates forISDN PRI,lDSS lines on average per state per circuit. Each Primary Rate ISDN serviceconsists of one Configuration, one T-l Facility, and one of the trunking options. Not included in the rates are the CALC charges, mileage or taxes. Each DSS service consistsof one T-l Facility, and one of the trunking options. Not included in the rates are the CALC charges, mileage or taxes. Following is a representative iHustration of the rate elements and current rates by state that McLeodUSA is billed for today. Additionally we have represented, by state, the number of ISDN PRl and DDS servicesthat McLeodUSA has ordered and the average elements billed for each circuit. The proposal of$677.00 per circuit is an approximate reduction of $1 271 794.00 permonth for McLeodUSA. NONPUBUC DOCUMEN1 CUN'l'AINS TRADE SECRET DAiA TERMS Product Pricing '" . Pricing/discounting is, in lieu of, and not in addition to, any discounts and/or credits'that Customer is or would otherwise be entitled to receive by application of discounts (i., Term Discount, SPR Field DiscOlmt and/or any Promotion(s)) unless otherwise noted in this SPR approval. '" For services not specified below, McLeodUSA will pay standard rates associatedwith the Service Tenn and monthly revenue tier for which McLeodUSA qualifies (as set forth in the Tariff or as referenced on the Q for non-tariffed services).. . Pricing/Discounts below DO NOT include charges for CPE The effective date of the contract will be either July 1 2001 or on thedate when both parties fully execute the agreement, whichever date is later. Access Pricing The monthly recurring charge (MRC) and non-recurring charge (NRC) for the Dedicated Local Access Circuit connecting each Customer premise are determined by the Customer's NP NNXX. and are set by the Service Term. . '" MRCs are based on mileage between Customer Serving Wire Center (SWC) and the nearest Qwest owned Point of Presence (POP) SWC. In addition to the above mentioned access charges, McLeodUSA shall beresponsible for the following unless otherwise noted in this SPR approval (i) all charges associated with the Central of Connection (COC), (ii) all charges associated with the local access interconnection and, (iii) access-related charges (including, without - limitation, installation charges, inside wiring charges, construction charges and distanceand termination charges assessed by Qwest or by the Local Exchange Carrier (LEC)). '" For Dedicated Local or Ethernet Access service not specified below Customer will pay standard pricing associated with the Service Term, whichCustomer qualifies (as set forth in the Tariff, or as referenced on the Q for non-tariffedservices). '" All pricing quotes are subject to availability of the Qwest POP, local access serviceprovider, and/or of specific SONET engineering at LEC SWCs NONPUBLlC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA General Clauses McLeodUSA MAY NOT be a member of an association or resell service. Approved Rates McLeodUSA is approved for the following: I) IfMcLeodUSA meets or exceeds 1000 spans (contributing spans can be either DSS or PRI) McLeodUSA will receive a price of $667 per span. 2) The $667 price is applicable to one way VAS only. 3) Please note that if McLeodUSA falls below a cumulative count of less 1,000 spans for 3 consecutive months, their pricing per span will revert to standard pricing 4) Please note "NO" Additional Reseller Discounts Apply to the $667 price. The rate for McLeod's ISDN/PRI services stated in this contract does not apply to any other discounts and specifically, that the 10% Business to Business reduction does not apply to the services addressed in this Contract. 5)The effective date of the contract will be either July 1 2001 or on the date when both parties fully execute the agreement, whichever date is later. We appreciate your continuing business with Qwest and are 10oking forward to detailed discussions regarding this proposal. Please do not hesitate to contact us. Sincerely Audrey McKenney SVP- Wholesale Business Development 303-896-5851 Jim Shearbum RVP - Sales QWEST Central Region 314-918- 7966 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS ~RADE SECRET DATA IT A CHMENT : NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA State Number Proposed Current MRCI MRC/Circui Present Total ProposedServiceCircuitsCircuitMRC'Total MRC'All ISDN 309 930.667.596,370.$ 206.103.DSS 554 160.667.196.640.$ 369.518.UAS 135 080.677.145,800.91.395.Total 998 938.810.$ 667.016. /'1 NONPUBLlC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA MRC's Revenue Yearly Rev&nu~ +/-+/- $ (390.267.00)$ (4 683,204.00) $ (827 122.00)$ (9.925,464.00) . (54,405.00)$ (652 860.00) $ (1 271 794.00)$ (15 261 528.00) NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT,)t . .. .. '. ,' " , '.O' ~:'. . "' , CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A State Number of Current Proposed Proposed Service Orcuits Revenue Revenue Revenue Arizona ISDN 930.667.263. Total 370.667.003. Revenue Loss (11 367.00) Arizona DSS 160.667.493. Total , $ 23,760.667.337. Revenue Loss (16 423.00) Arizona UAS 080.667.413. Total 667, Revenue Loss Colorado ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 38,600.667.13,340. Revenue Loss (25,260.00) Colorado DSS 126 160.667.493. . Total 272 160.667.042. Revenue Loss (188,118.00) Colorado UAS 080.667.413. Total 800.667.670. Revenue Loss 130.00) Idaho ISDN 930.667.263. Total 650.667.335. Revenue Loss 315.00) Idaho DSS 160.667.493. Total 080.667.671. Revenue Loss (19,409.00) Idaho UAS 080,667.413. Total 720.667.003. Revenue Loss 717.00) Iowa ISDN 930.667.263, Total 86,850.667.015, Revenue Loss (56,835.00) Iowa DSS 112 160.667.493. Total 241 920.667.704. Revenue Loss (167,216.00) NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A . . Iowa UAS 080,667,413. Total $ 87,480,667.027. Revenue Loss (33,453.00) Minnesota ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 69,480.667.24,012. Revenue Loss (45,468,00) Minnesota lOSS 177 160.667.493. Total 382 320.667.118 059. Revenue Loss (264 261.00) Minnesota UAS OBO.667.413, Total $ 21 600.667.340. Revenue Loss 260.00) Montana ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 25 090.667.671. Revenue Loss (16,419.00) Montana ass 160.667.493. ITotal 667. Revenue Loss Montana UAS 080.667.413, Total 667. Revenue Loss Nebraska ISDN 930.667.263. Total 667. Revenue Loss Nebraska ass 160.667.493. Total 800.667.335. Revenue Loss 465.00) Nebraska UAS 080.667.413. Total 667. Revenue Loss New Mexico ISDN 930.667.263, Total 370.667.003. Revenue loss (11 367.00) NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRA.DE SECRET DATA New Mexico DSS 160.667,493. Total 120.667.669. Revenue Loss (10 451.00) New Mexico UAS 080.667.413. Total 240.667.001. Revenue Loss 239.00) North Dakota ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 61 760.667,344.Revenue Loss (40,416.00) North Dakota DSS 160.667.493. Total 49,680.667.341.Revenue Loss (34 339.00) North Dakota UAS OBO.667.413. Total 667. Revenue Loss South Dakota ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 11 580.667.002. Revenue Loss 578.00) South Dakota DSS 160.667.493. Total 280.667.336. Revenue Loss (11 944.00) South Dakota UAS 080.667,413. Total 240.667,001.Revenue Loss 239.00) Oregon ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 52,110.667.18,009.Revenue Loss (34 101.00) Oregon DSS 160.667.493. Total 600.667.00 670.Revenue Loss (14 930.00) Oregon UAS 080.667.413. Total 667. Revenue Loss Utah IISDN 930.00 667.00 I 263.00 I .. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CaNT AINS TRADE SECRET DA T A Total $ 75.270.667.00 I $26.013. Revenue Loss (49 257.00) Utah DSS 160.667.493. Total 60,480.667.18,676. Revenue Loss (41 804,00) Uta!1 UAS 080.667.413. Total 667. Revenue Loss Washington ISDN 930.667.263. Total $106,150.667.36,685. Revenue Loss (69,465,00) Washington DSS 160.667.493. Total 680.667.15,341. Revenue Loss (34 339.00) Washington UAS 080.667.413. Total.560.667.669. Revenue Loss (2,891.00) Wyoming ISDN 930.667.263. Total $ 25.090.667.671. Revenue Loss (16,419.00) Wyoming DSS 160.667.493. Total 23,760.667.337. Revenue Loss (16,423.00) Wyoming UAS 080.667.413. Total 160.667.334. Revenue Loss (826.00) NONPu"BUC DOCUMENT CONTAINS ~RADE SECRET DA T A State Number Number of Rate Proposed Proposed Service oCCircuil.!elements Elements QtylPrice Rate Price Arizona ISDN 667.003. ZPAZD 400.600. ZPT1X 150.350. PR311 207 30.210. .. NDT 207 30.210. Total 17,370.003. Savings $11,367. Savings %65% Arizona DSS 667.337. D7W 360.960. T2DIX 264 30.920. NDT 264 45.11,880. Total 4~5.23,760.667.337. Savings 16,423. Savings 69% Arizona UAS D7W 360.667, T2DIX 30. Total 390.667. Savings $ Savings % Colorado ISDN 667.13,340. ZPAZD 400.000. ZPT1X 150.000. PR311 460 30.13,800. NOT 460 30.13,800. Total 600.13,340. Savings $25,260. ,:savings "/0 0::170 Colorado DSS 126 667.042. 07W 126 360.$ 45,360. .u J?D(.3024 30.$ 90,720. DID NOT 3024 45.$136,080. Total 435.$ 272,160.667.84,042. Savings $188,118. Savings %69% Colorado UAS 07W 360.600.667.670. T2DIX 240 30.200, Total 390.800.667.670. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRA.DE SECRET DATA Savings $129. Savings %38% Idaho ISDN 667.335. ZPAZD 400.000. ZPT1X 150.750. PR311 115 30.450. NDT 115 30.3,450. Total 650,. 3,335. Savings $315. Savings %65% Idaho ess 667.671. D7W 360.680. T2DIX 312 30.360. DID NDT 312 45.040. Total 435.28,080.667.671. Savings $19,409. Savings %69% Idaho UAS D7W 360.240.667.003. T2DIX 216 30.6,480. Total 390.720.667.003. Savings $716. Savings %38% Iowa ISDN 667.30,015. ZPAZD 400.$ 18 000. ZPT1X 150.750. PR311 1035 30.$ 31,050. NDT 1035 30.$ 31.050. Total $ 86.850.30,015. Savings $56,835. Savings %65% Iowa ess 112 667.74,704. D7W 112 360.$ 40,320. T2DIX 2688 30.$ 80,640. DID NDT 2688 45.$120,960, Total 435.$ 241,920.667.704. Savings $167,216. Savings %69% Iowa UAS D7W 360.$ 29,160.667.027, T2DIX 1944 30.$ 58.320. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA Total 390.87,480,667.54,027, Savings $33,453. Savings %38% IMinnesota ISDN 667.012. ZPAZD 400.$ 14,400. ZPT1X 150.400. PR311 828 30.$ 24 840. NOT 828 30.$ 24,840. Total $ 69,480.24,012. Savings $468. Savings %65% Minnesota ess 177 667.118,059. D7W 177 360.$ 63,720. T2DIX 4248 30,$127,440. DID NOT 4248 45.$ 191,160. Total 435.$ 382,320.667.$ 118 059. Savings $$ 264 261. Savings %69% Minnesota UAS D7W 360.200.667.13,340. T2DIX 480 30.14,400. Total 390.600.667.340. Savings $260. Savings %38% IMontana ISDN 667.671. ZPAZD 400.200. ZPT1X 150.950. PR311 299 30.970. NOT 299 30.970. Total 090.671, Savings $16,419. Savings %65% Montana ess 667. D7W 360. T2DIX 30. DID NOT 45. Total 435.667. Savings $ Savings %#DlV/O! IUAS D7WI 360.667.00 I $ NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A T20lX 30, Total 390,667. Savings $ Savings %#DIV/O! Nebraska ISDN 667, ZPAZO 400. ZPT1X 150, PR311 30, NOT 30. Total Savings $ Savings 'Yo Nebraska DSS 667.. 3,335. D7W 360.800. T20lX 120 30.600. DIO NOT 120 45.400. Total 435.10,800.667.335. Savings $7,465. Savings %69% Nebraska UAS D7W 360.667. T20lX 30. Total 390.667. Savings $ Savings 'Yo New Mexico ISDN 667.003. ZPAZD 400.600. ZPT1X 150.350. PR311 207 30.210. NOT 207 30.210. Total 17,370.003. Savings $367. Savings 0/.65% New Mexico DSS 667.669. D7W 360,520. T2D1X 168 30.040. DID NOT 168 45.560. Total 435.120.667,669. Savings $451, Savings %69% NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT caNT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA New Mexico UAS D7W 360.080.667.001. T2D1X.30.160. Total 390.240.667.001. Savings $239. Savings %38% North Dakota ISDN 667.344. ZPAZD 400.$ 12,800. ZPT1X 150.800. PR311 736 30.$ 22,080. NDT 736 30.$ 22,080. Total $ 61,760.344. Savings $416. Savings %65% North Dakota DSS 667.15,341. D7W 360.280. T2DIX 552 30.16,560. DID NDT 552 45.24,840. Total 435.49,680,667.15,341. Savings $34,339. Savings %69% North Dakota UAS D7W 360.667. T20lX 30. Total 390.667, Savings $ Savings % South Dakota ISDN 667.002. ZPAZO 400.2,400. ZPT1X 150.900. PR311 138 30.140. NOT 138 30.140. Total 11,580.002. Savings $578. Savings %65% South Dakota DSS 667.336. D7W 360.880. T20lX 192 30,760. NOT 192 45.640. Total 435.280.667,336. . NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA Savings $944.Savings %69% South Dakota UAS 07W 360.080.667.001.T20lX 30.160. Total 390.240.667.001. Savings $239.Savings %38% Oregon ISDN 667.009. ZPAZO 400.$ 10,800. ZPT1X 150.050. PR311 621 30.$ 18,630. NOT 621 30.$ 18,630. Total $ 52 110.18,009. Savings $101.Savings % Oregon DSS 667.670. 07W 360.600. T20lX 240 30.200. NOT 240 45.800. Total 435.21,600.667.670. Savings $14,930.Savings %69% UAS 07W 360.667. T20lX 30. Total 390.667. Savings $ Savings 0/. Utah ISDN 667.26,013. ZPAZD 400,$ 15,600. ZPT1 X 150.850. PR311 897 30.$ 26,910. NOT 897 30.$ 26 910, Total $ 75,270.26,013. Savings $49,257.Savings %65% Utah DSS 667.18,676. D7W 360.$ 10 080. T2DIX 672 30.$ 20 160. NDT 672 45.00 . $ 30 240. Total 435.$ 60,480.667.676, NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA . "~"'..""';"".."~ . . Savings $804, Savings %1 69% UAS 07W 360.667. T201X 30. Total 390,667. Savings $ Savings % Washington ISDN 667.36,685. ZPAZD 400.$ 22 000. ZPT1X 150.250. PR311 1265 30.$ 37 950. NOT 1265 30.$ 37 950. Total $106,150.685. Savings $69,465.Savings %65% Washington DSS 667.15,341. 07W 360.280. T20IX 552 30.16,560. DID NDT 552 45.24,840. Total 435,680.667.15,341. Savings $339.Savings %69% Washington UAS D7W 360.520.667.669.T2DIX 168 30,040. Total 390.560.667.669. Savings $891.Savings %38% Wyoming ISDN 667.671. ZPAZD 400.200. ZPT1X .150,950. PR311 299 30.970. NDT 299 30.970. Total 090.671.00 Savings $16,419.Savings %65% Wyoming DSS 667.337. D7W 360,960. T2DIX 264 30.920. NDT 264 45.11,880. Total 435.23,760.667,337. N'ONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA 423. 69% Wyoming UAS Savings % Number ISDN DSS UAS D7W T2DIX Total Savings $ 720.00 $ 667.00 $360.00 $ 30.00 $ 1 440.00 667. 00 $390.00 $ 2,160,00 $ 334. 334. 826. 38% ,:;' ;: NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T 1 p.z 1 CO 1 fA 1 10 1 MN 1 MT 1 NO 1 NE ' 1 NM 10R 1 SO 1 UT 1 WA 1 WY ISDN 309 OSS 126 112 177 5 ' 554 UAS , 0 135 t Data Ends)Trade Secre NO Np UBlI C DOCUMENT CONTAINS T~DE SECRET DATA Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise. Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 60 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T RE: (fwj: URGENT - Mcleod ISDN Proposal) , . , (Trade Secret Data Begins Subject: RE: (Fwd: URGENT - McLeod ISDN Proposal) Date: Wed, 13 Jun 2001 13 :21 :28 -0600From: "Shearburn, Jim" -cJim.Shearbum~qwest.com?To: "'Audrey McKenney'" -:::axmcken~swest.com?, Patty Hahn -cpha1m($uswest.com?CC: "Shearburn, Jim" -cJim.Shearbum~qwest.com?McKenney, Audrey" -:::axmcken~qwestcom?, j De. tomando~qwest. comSnider, Patricia" -cpsnider~qwest.com? RECV JUN 1 3 ,Om Additional input from Gary following a recent discussion, one of the dealpoint he would like to see, (perhaps we can substitute this for growth incentiv~), he would like flex~bility on the termina~ion liability if he discos a facility and orders like facility of equal or greater value in. another location. Facility portability under the PRI deal. Obviously thiswould be limited to in region access, I would think. Is that something we have done in the past? Your thoughts on being able to propose this? If we can do this, it is a big iss~e for him, we probably will not have to offer growth initiatives. have you socialized growth initiatives withStacey or Blake? As to the discount issue. What is not clear toOMR or product is that this10% across the board applies to all products. I asked that the "carve outlanguage be inserted in order to set the expectation that this is the bestand final price, candidly I do not think we need to go any lower, he ispretty happy with this, think. Please provide whatever language you want to see in this draft. Will thatcome from you or legal. On the switched minute deal we carved out therevenues with a clause prepared by legal, you should have a copy, if not Iwill get you one. The other option is to raise the rates, but Gary does not want to do that,because it goes against his budget Vs the general ledger.-----Original Message----- From: Audrey McKenney mail to: axmcken~uswest. comSent: Wednesday, June 13, 2001 12: 03 PMTo: Patty Hahn Cc: Shearburn, Jim; McKenney, Audrey; joe. tomando~qwest. com;PatriciaSubject: Re: (Fwd: URGENT - McLeod ISDN Proposal)Importance: High Snider, Jim and Patty - Thanks for the attached -- Why the July date -- why is effective date July they put in orderstomorrow, they can have the there are some typos, do you want us to correct? as opposed to once they reach 1000 spans?So if rate immediately. Patty, I believe there is a growth incentive by waiving the NRC and either one -two months ofrecurring. I think the question is this enough to incent the movement of the several hundred spans to us and it stays on net. but I not sure if we can put a minimum commitment of something greater than 1000 spans given thetiered pricing commitment of1000 spans. Product and SPR might have some other solutions lof5 );: NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT "'~.: ~ "." , 421/C-O2-197 DOC 08-212 Trade Secret Attachment """. . CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA 6/13/01 2:32 PM : ".,. .,. :::~'s ;i. :...:.,. R.E: (Fwc!: URG~ - McLeod ISDN Proposal) ... Jim, from a process stand point - how do you want to handle -- email,letter? Also, I need to get a copy to the people in Iowa. Than ks A Patty Hahn wrote: -~ ... Jill/ and Joe, ... ... I hav!! made the follo"ing revisions to '!e ISDN PRI proposal based Audrey ... input.process. ...... Jill/, Ron Keiter does not have term growth incentive nor do kno" theans"er for the migration of the services and ho" that is going to handled. ... I "ill check "i th Rose Harie Ferris and Skip Olson for their input Wednesday ... morning. ...... Patty ...... Sh!!arburn, Jim " "rote: ... ... ... I called Gary and indicated Ole have a fetl changes to discuss, fewterms ... ... and conditions associated "ith this pricing. I described the issuesbriefly ... ... and hav!! set the expectation that new revised proposal "ill be sentASAP. ... ... am sure that Ole can get that out today. ... ...... ... Audrey if you have any other issues to bring into the deal, Ole welcomeyour ... ... involvement. Thanks for advising on thes!!. ... ...... ... Please make sure that all parties have a chance to revie" prior to draft ... ... submission to th!! customer. ... ...... ... My thought is that the contract will be prepared by the legal team, ... ... inco~orating any issues approved by ~R. Standard dereg contractprocess, ... ... I "ould assume. ... ...... ... Patty Hahn, please draft ne" proposal inco~orating the comments you ... ... included as "ell as any other that Audrey or inserts. ... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ... Jim ... ...... ... I do not kno" ho" go about getting the right people involved to getAudrey ... ... her ans"ers. Joe,will you please revie" and approve them for the POM -----Original Message-----Froll/: Patty Hahn (mail to:phahn~us"est. com Sent: Monday, June 11, 2001 8:00 To: jIH.shearburn~qwest.com; psnider~qwest.colDSubject: (Fwd: URGE:NT McLeod ISDN Proposal) and Patti, I understand "hat she is asking for, but "ho makes thosetype ... ... of gro"th decisions and term decisions.who ... ... is responsible for the revenue objective When "e bring this acct over, and the product. ... ... still Ron Keiter, but his group did not "ant to be responsible for the... ... contract negotiation or the executive summary. ... ... ... ... I have a t tempted to answer Audrey question frolD responses recei ved assume it 2 of5 'eo. . ~.. _.'. .".. . NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT ........ -;4;;""":I '~:""'.:,;::,:-,'. : CaNT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA signed 6/13/01 2:32 PM Jli: lJ1wc!' URG~NT - McLeod ISDN Proposal) from ;. ;. Skip Olson.today: ;. ;. I assume I take these back to the POH group.these ;. ;. types of questions before they give us the approval? Aren theyresponsible ;. ;. to determine that the basic questions are answered? ;. ;.;. ;.;. ;);. ;. . In the proposed letter, the customer approved pricing section ;) ;. states that the $667 is applicable to one way UAS only -- the customer He informed me tha these sta tements are how they are Don t they research ;) ;. buying three' different products ass, iSDN, and UAS.all ;) ;. three products at the $667. ;) ;);) ;) . Spreadsheets' show Hhat's the quote for all three services?? products ;) ;) - I will have the PCH chg the language to state all three. products. ;) ;.;) ;) . If the customer is beloli the minimWl, ",hat price do the services ;) ;) revert to state specific month to month or a schedule? I thought our ;) ;) usually have had tiered pricing. ;) ;.;. ;. . for ;. ;. three months the schedule is: ;. ;.;. ;) .;. ;);) ;) .;) ;.;. ;. .;. ;.;. ;. .;. ;.;. ;. . contract? ;. ;.;. ;) .;) ;) 667. ;. ;);. ;. .;. ;);. ;) . Hhat is the incentive for growth? What are we doing in the ;. ;) proposal to move the PRIs that are off-net to on-net? They have stated ;. ;. that they ",ill move to Q and lie need commitment. (Todd's email) ;. ;) Hho has copy of this) Will we project manage the migration ofthose ;. ;) circuits? Do we have facilities available? ;) ;);) ;. .;) ;.;. ;. . RESPONSE Skip Olson and I put call into Ron toni te. Skip ;. ;. does not know how Ron wants to address this. Also we do not know howRon ;. ;. wants to address the migration chargeswaive ;. ;. some. ;. ;.;) ;) .;. ;);. ;) . Is there termination liability? If so, what are the terms and ;. ;. condi ti ons? ;. ;. When will we have a draft contract ready for the customer? ;. ;.;) ;. RESPONSE: ;. ;.;) ;.;. ;.;. :.;. :. RESPONSE:The quote of 667.00 is for all three types of RESPONSE Per Skip Olson If the customer drops below 1000 3 yr 500-999 790. 500 - 999 765. 3 yr 150-499 820. 5 yr 150-499 795. OOs Is there a contract term? If so, what is the term of the RESPONSE:Contract term is 3 yr or 5 yr same price if we ",ill charge all Per Skip Olson existing termination liability is lOOt for 1st year 80t second year 70t third year 65t fourth year NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT . ''-'.:-"'-"';'"~.:."'" CaNT AINS TRADE SECRET DA T A 6113/01 2:32 PM 3 of5 RE: (JIwd: URG!Mf - McLeod ISDN Proposal) ;:. ;) 451 flUh year. ;:. ;);:. ;);:. ;) RESPONSE:: My understanding ls the draft contract is wri tten by the ;:. ;) direction of the POH and that is the document that is edited and signedfor ;:. ;) review by the customer. ;:. ;) is not my understanding tha the acct team draws up the contractlanguage. ;:. .);:. ;) I put call ln to Joe tonite for feedback. Who does make the final ;:. ;:. decisions regarding this proposal? ;:. .);:. .)? .);:. ;:.;:. ;);:. ;:.;) ;);) ;) ------ Original Message --------;:. ;:.;:. .) Subject: URGENT McLeod ISDN Proposal ;:. .) Date: Mon, 11 Jun 2001 16:03:28 -0700 ;:. .) From: Audrey McKenney oCa1UJlckenf/uswest. COllI;:' ;:. .) Organization: U S ~ST Communications, Inc ;:. ;:. To: "Roger.Hoaglundl!qwest.com" oCRoger.Hoaglundl!qtlest.com;:., PattyHahn ;:. ;) oCphahnl!uswest. com;:.Patricia Snider oCpsniderl!uswest. com;)JamesShearburn ;:. ;) oCJim,Shearburnl!qwest.com;:. ;:. ;) CC: Dana Filip oCDana.Filipf/qwest.co18;), Greg Casey ;:. ;:. oCGreg.CaseYl!qwest.com;:.James Gallegos oCjhgallel!uSliest.cOlll;:', JosephDalton ;) ;:. oCjoe.daltonl!qwest.com;:. ;:. ;:.;) ;:. Patty, Patti, Jim, and Roger ;:. ;);:. ;) am not sure our proposal is "complete and clear . Some of these arethe ;:. ;:. same questions I raised over couple weeks ago ;:. ;:.;:. ;:. . In the proposed letter, the customer approved pricing section ;:. ;:. states that the $667 is applicable to one way UAS only -- the customer ;:. ;:. bUYing tllree different products DSS, ISDN, and UAS. Spreadsheets showall ;:. ;:. three products at the $667. ;:. ;:.;:. ;:. . If the customer is below the minimum, what price do the services' ;:. ;:. revert to --state specific month to month or schedule? I thought our ;:. ;) usually have had tiered pricing. ;:. ;:.;:. ;:. . contract? ;) ;);) ;:. . What is the incentive for growth? What are doing in theproposal to ;) ;) move the PRIs that are off-net to on-net? They have stated that theywill What'the quote for al~ three services?? Is there contract term? If so, what is the term of the ;:. ;:. move to 0 and we need colIIII/itment. (Todd's emailJmanage ;:. ;) the migration of those circuits? ;) ;);) ;) . Is there texmination liability? If so, what are the texms and ;) ;:. conditions? ;) ;:.;) ;:. .;:. ;);:. ;:. Jim, we can correct the grammer and typos in the proposed letter.Please ;:.;) let me know if I am missing something, but it appears that the basicsare ;:. ;:. still missing. Will we project Do we have facilities available? When will we have draft contract ready for the customer? 4 of5 :j~ . NONPUBLIC bOCuMENT """~:;' ~;~:1.i".,(.,"""...~.,;h. ",..-:;.",";"". CONTAINS TRADE SE~~~T 0 ATA 6/13/012:32 PM RE: (pwd: URG-2NT - Mcleod ISDN Proposal) ~ ~~ :. Please respond ASAP!! :. :. Thanks A - - - - -- -- ------ ---- ----- - - -- - - -------- ------ -- ------ - - --- - ---------- ----- 06112001. doc ISDN PROPOSAL McLeod 06112001.doc Type: MicrosoEt WordDocument (applica tion/rnsword) Encoding: base6f Download Status: Not downloaded withmessage Name: ISDN PROPOSAL McLeod Trade Secret Data EndsJ NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT 5 of5 caNT AINS TRADE SECRET DA 6113/01 2:32 PM Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 61 Case No. QWE-06- AT&T RE: f"'~od's ISDN PRI Proposal . . ITt~de Sec~t Data Begins Subject: RE: McLeod's IS ON PRI Proposal rn J UN .., 001Date: Mon, 18 Jun 2001 17:20:00 -0600 f: 1:/ .. From: "Shearburn, Jim" -cJim.Shearburn~qwest.com:::'To: "'Patty Hahn'" -Cphahn~uswest.com:::' , " Shearburn, Jim" -cJim_Shearburn~qwest.com:::'Snider, Patricia" -cpsnider~qwest.com;::', rkeiter~qwest.comMcKenney, Audrey" -caxmcken(g)qwestcom:::., jaolso~qwest.com here are my thoughts. ~udrey needs to come up with alternate langu?ge dealing with the 19% B2Bdeal. we should riot use the language we have in the proposal; toospecific. We either use alternate language, or reprice all components at arate 10% higher, and remove the paragraph entirely. If Audrey does nothave her language to you by tomorrow morning, 10: 00 Mountain, we will removethe para. and reprice all components by a multiplier or 1. the clause regarding McLeodUSA not being a member of an association or a reseller, needs to be removed. this is not appropriate. I understand this is a write down, candidly we are doing the dirty work that has been delayed for a while, no one else wanted to do it; We either reducethis and maintain a significant, albeit reduced revenue stream associated with PRIs from MCLD, or we lose it altogether later. it is a clear choice,we must reduce the price. Audrey, please provide feedback. Patti and Patty, yours as well. -----Original Message----- From: Patty Hahn mailto:phahn~uswest. comSent: Monday, June 18, 2001 5:38 PMTo: j im. shearburn~qwest. com; psnider~qwest. com;axrncken~qwest. com; j aolso~qwest. comSubj ect: McLeod's ISDN PRI Proposal rkeiter~qwest. com; I have attached a revised terms and conditions ISDN Proposal forMcLeod. Please review and state any conditions or terms that youwould like to see included or renegotiated in this proposal. Thisdocument is still in DRAFT . form and is not in Contract language.SOon as I receive the draft document I will have it revised withsuggested input and sent out again for review. Currently, I have gone back to the that he initiate a draft contract. and I received an initial go ahead pursue ( what do we need tochecking on this for me). POM org ( Joe Tomandao) and requested I had legal review it John Jones)to proceed with action items to file in the states - Skip Oslo I have made the following revisions based on feedback I recei ved; Mileage discrepancy Audrey - the mileage is not included in the667 price but I did delete the statement; " MRC' 5 are based on mileagebetween the customer SWC and Q POP. This only applies to out ofregion products and was included in the POM review. I discussed withJoe and informed him this is not appropriate for this contract. I included current contract language provided to me by Skip that detailsMoves. The customer will get a reduction in price but not aportability feature as stated in the access world. If the oneproposed is not accepted by McLeod, we will have to renegotiate withRetail. Skip was not willing to change at this time. 1 of2 ~:. . NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CaNT AINS TRA DE SECRET DATA P -4 21 /C-02-197 DOC 08-212 Trade Secret Attachment 6/19/019:05 AM RPMcLeod'ISDN PRI Proposal Growth incentives: Retail did not than the 667.00 price. renegotiate a lower incentive other Jim would like to share this revised DRAFT proposal with Gary Duplertomorrow morning. I realize this is short notice but any comments I receive from you would be appreciated Thank you all for your help with this proj ect.I appreciate it. Patty Hahn 303 896-0285 Trade Secret Data Ends1 - NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT . . CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA 1 ofl 6/19/01 9:05 AM Idaho P~lic Utilities Commission Office of the Secretary RECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 62 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T ' /"'. ". ;2;~2i~J t~;~;7:~c"' \"". --'-...:' Blake O. Fisher 03/28/2001 08:48 AM -""""--'-". - To: Stephen C. Gray/MCLEOD(g)MCLEOD cc: Subject: 02 (Owest 2) Steve, this is Ihe begin,:,ing of a concept for a term ~heet with Owest on the nex,t possible deal for us use with Roy and a potetial meeting With Joe N. 1. M agree with a on performance measures and remedies thaI M would support in their 271 proceedings.These would be pretty much in line with a's position. ( Owest is agreeable to parity) 2. a agrees with M in a private wholesale agreement to meet certain performance goals and remediesviewed as business critical to M such as 24 hour or better outage goals, instal/ation intervals, and repeatservice reports. (~O buys or enters into an IRU for fiber fromM in former CapRock territory and possibly some M's level~ r-network (assuming we have that right), structured .'~ po~enti~IIY give us reve~ue. :). ..ru!-- , "\ \o'7r -. ....~.. """' 'Z,%" .c.~ .~...-tOJ."O " ,...- ("- . -4 C" ,.., '.- "7"-~,,~ff'- ' GM buys wavelengths (or whatever Roy and Gary need) from a with _payme~ts spread out over a periodor time with possibly some level of take or pay (Note: we are researching the Impact- of 3 and 4 onaccounting treatment). I asume that this could offset potential nalional netwo(k cash requirement. 5. M gets revised pricing for voice mail, DSL, residential Une-M. and IMT's from O. (Note: a will need this10 be in a form that others Clecs can do). 'n__- ,- -- , p. 6. M gets reyised discount plan (probably in a form of amended take or pay.) (Note: Would likely be usefulif we could find additional services to sell to a such as resell of local services in out of region areas. Jim isresearch accounting treatmen "-- 7. Other considerations: ~. legislative agenda - -- - Securitization of receivables allowing M 10 treat part of monthly payment as amortization. . .:.. Highly questionable......- c. Wireless spectrum purchased by a from M d. Itelispan consent (Probably will be handled separately). e. T-1 pricing ~, f. AddilionallD to a 8. Carefully consider term of agreement. (I would like to get pricing term for a longer period without overcomminting on take or pay. Any other ideas for revenue? Comments? I think this agreement will have Ihe most value if we can get itfor Joe N. in time to make his 271 filings that I believe are targeted for this summer. ,+~:~/(~:' cc;~"::";1;-.F-i~~:,~~~';;~:;":~~,;;:; Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 63 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T ~?':~':,:' 7~"::'O""~;. :";:.:' .. " CONFIDENTIAL J\fcLeodUSA and Qwest Version 2 Business to Business Deal Proposed Term Sheet May 18tb, 2001 ...~ .. T;- '" 1. McLeodUSA will accept the Qwest P APIPID with the exception ofthe attached document incorporating a Parity with a Floor concept on the most important 5 measures for McLeod USA. The effective date of these measures will be November 1, 2000. ... .. "; "'" .. 2. Qwest will provide the remedies associated with the PAP plus the remedies for the 5I" 1'\ ~, I:.... Parity with the Floor measures in the attached document beginning with November 2000 performance. . "1-0 I~T 3. Qwest to provide McLeod USA with a resell voicemail offering that includes a ........ discount structure in exchange for a minimum commitment. See attached document. :t-\ ",It 4. Qwest to provide McLeod USA with a residential line program similar to our UNE- M offering. See attached analysis. 5. Qwest to provide McLeod USA with a Oat rate T-l offering similar to our UNE- offering. ,.,: "I.,.. 6. Qwest to provide a region-wide PRI rate of X to McLeod USA for all existing PRI' ..,\-~ and any future PRI. . 7. Qwest to offer McLeodUSA their DSL VDP program. 1". II/, r 8. Qwest to provide a X% discount on all intralata toll charges 9. Qwest will provide Wire CarelWire Maintenance to McLeodUSA region-wide withour state specific wholesale discount. (:-- 10. Qwest will provide a 'friendly' witness and testimony in support ofUNE-PfUNE-in the SBC markets in order to help facilitate and prove McLeodUSA's position tbatthis type of conversion activity can be a billing change and requires minimal effort on the part of the ILEC. See attached testimony. 11. In recognition of the proceeding, McLeodUSA will provide to Qwest an increasedcommitment of revenue and term. X tji(1"c....1)~.... ...,~ .J Jia -t...~~ .. r r(..f.... 12. MCLeodus l purchase from Qwest tbe following services: ~.,~ n.. r... J .H.. ",~ D Senices . P' 'ate Line sen'ices 13. McLeodUSA will support Qwest in their plans for 271 applications in all states within their ILEC footprint. 14. McLeod USA will encourage and participate in any settlement in Minnesota on , Wholesale Quality of Service proceedings. 15. Items to consider: ",H:.f......p;: 1.'1 ~ Ic.'\f I.... +:y~ (.0. ,.,+:.,."" - Ha\'ing we support killing TausinlDingell bill. : "., -,.~;~: ,:i":'~(-Support ore the FCC on multifunctional equipment collocations . .-.. ,- '.. ._-\- , -", '" " ~ompen t n for selling of exchanges?? Suppo ULS before the FCC(our plan) 1 1'\ ~ '" '" ""'1 . s I.,... q~.. .:1~"", s",... t"""I,T CONFIDENTIAL Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 64 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T DOC: . - ~t:dt:e Of t'i.lrll1esot:a De~artment of Commerce INfORNATION r,CQUEST P-~21/C-02-197 Inf~rmation Requested From:Qwest Corporation Information Requested By: Date Requested: Date Response Due: Ferguson, Sharon 06/05/2002 06/13/2002 REQUEST: (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS Admit that the June 22, 2001 wire transfer paymen~of $10,770,437.00 by Qwest to McLeodUSA was in payment for the discount o~lnedby Qwest to McLeodUSA for purchases by McLeodUSA from Qwest between October 2, 2000 and March 31, 2001. TRADE SECRET DATA ENDS) RESPONSE:: (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS Qwest did not owe McLeodUSA any monies for any type- .discount for purchases from Qwest by McLeodUSA. Qwest CommunicationsCorporation, a customer of McLeod , made a payment of $10,770,437 for acalculated shortfall in purchases made by Qwest from McLeod and associated Ilith terms and conditions set forth in the October 26 , 2000 Purchase Agreement:.TRADE SECRET DA T A ENDS). NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA 1'llIII,-=sotc; l--i)21/C-(J:::- ~,-: rJo::: ()'~ - ~ - I .; INTERVENOR:Department of Cornrn",-ccE: HEQUES'l' NO:17.., (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS l-\Jluit that October :., :::\101 I-Ijri~ (r:,:;.';;1,-': 1~:ii,0r.~630,879.00 by Qwest to McLeodUSA Iv as ln r:;ayment fur U"" d,:,,::,,\"e. :! Qwes!: to McLeodUSA was in payment for the discoun'~ o\:en Dy (1\.'("':; ,-. ":.:~- ,,"Co'!-'-for purchases by McLeodUSA from QWE5t betvken prj 1 ;".(J(J: cO:," i::!, :~- 2001. TRADE SECRET DATA ENDS) gESPONSE: (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS', Q;~'est did not owe McLeoc!US;!~ "rIY u;.:,nj co, rc.r an~' t Y!""~ "discount for purchases froril' ()west uy t--lcLeodUSl\. (:i"J;:"t: Conn:;un.l:, ;:',' i r:,n~Corporation , a customer of McLeod, made a pa~nent af $5, ri30, 67~ fo~ calculated shortfall in purchases, Iniide b~' QI-Iest fcom McLec."'".:: as::;:-J':::Cii'::f,d '1, " terms and conditions set forth in the October 26 , ~' (iOO Pur,-::',i'",C.. !''li--'--"'~e';II:-TRADE SECRET DATA ENDS) 1111 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT i'\.. CONTAINS TR,ADE SECRET DA DOC 17rj State Of Minnesota Department of Commerce INFORMATION REQUEST P-421/C-02-197 Information Requested From:Qwest Corporation Information Requested By: Da te Requested: Date Response Due: Ferguson, Sharon 06/05/2002 06/13/2002 REQUEST: (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS Admit that the January 18 2001 wire transferpayment of $5,649,513.00 by Qwest to McLeodUSA was a partial payment of thediscount owed by Qwest to McLeodUSA for purchases by McLeodUSA from Qwest between July 1, 2001 and September 30, 2001. TRADE SECRET DATA ENDS) RESPONSE: (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS Qwest. did not owe McLeodUSA any monies for any type ordiscount for purchases from Qwest by McLeodOSA. Qwest Communications Corporation, a customer of McLeod, made a payment of $$5,984,404. for calculated shortfall in purchases made by Qwest from McLeod and associated wi terms and conditions set forth in the October 26, 2000 Purchase Agreement..TRADE SECRET DATA ENDS) NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 65 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T McCleod & Cap Rock Current Charges & Payments 2001 Current Charges Manth December-!Trade Secret Data Begins November- October- September- August-O 1 July- June- May- April- March- February- January- Payments Mw1th December- November- October- September-O 1 August- July- June- May- April- March- February- January- Type of Service lisagf Private J.ine $ 90 241 $ 79 807 921 277 168 232 046 196 395 269 034 389,892 294 495 3:2 500 286 828 268 662 952 S 2,776,132 Type of Service lisagf Private IJne911 $ 79 644 578 274 203 227 886 193 974 297 960 352 497 327 134 321 595 286,132 268 077 507 S 2,787,454 197 595 208 186 240,564 241 "870 249 088 254 480 245,868 245 776 245 647 252 357 461,238 180 709 205 739 238 133 237 416 240 779 556 909 242 404 242,404 243 287 249,810 717,235 P-421/C-02-197 DOC 08-218 TRADE SECRET ATTACHMENT A Io1al $ 170 048 921 474 763 440 231 436 958 5 10 903 638 980 548 975 568 368 532,604 514 309 341 309 $ 5,237,370 Io1al $ 169 555 578 454 912 433 624 432 107 535 376 593,275 884 043 564 000 528 537 511 364 338 318 $ 5,504,690 NONPUIuc DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA McLeod Checks Check #Total Amount Check Date 4000866 362.42 01/23/2001 4001109 988.02/02/2001 4001356 221 821.02/08/2001 4001579 199.02/22/2001 4001950 243 286.03/06/2001 4002008 509.03/08/2001 4002211 515.03/13/2001 4002249 389.03/13/2001 4002397 148 342.03/15/2001 4002847 229 301.89 03/27/2001 4003186 120,095.04/05/2001 4003679 127 359.04/19/2001 4003680 673.39 04/19/2001 4003855 61.29 04/26/2001 4003943 814.04/26/200 1 4003944 26,290.31 04/26/2001 4003945 235,295.04/26/2001 4004209 003.05/03/2001 4004210 771.29 05/03/2001 4004423 555 230.43 05/08/200 I 4004869 109.05/17/2001 4004991 933.47 OS/25/2001 4005070 324 873.OS/25/2001 4005071 556,957.OS/25/2001 4005413 392.06/06/2001 4005415 61.41 06/06/2001 4005909 392.06/19/2001 4006160 523.06/26/2001 4006191 240 778.06/26/2001 4006440 1.48 07/02/2001 4007134 146,497.07/24/2001 4007254 527.07/26/2001 4007362 392.07/26/2001 4007363 041.23 07/26/2001 4007647 180,210.08/02/2001 4007648 237 416.08/02/2001 4007825 874.08/07/2001 4008017 295 459.08/09/2001 4008666 545.41 08/28/2001 4009194 238 133.09/06/2001 4009653 51.97 09/25/2001 4009810 138 871.79 09/25/2001 4010063 392.10/02/2001 4010064 29,464.10/02/2001 4010230 205,738.10/04/2001 NONPUBUC DOCUMENT4010390171723.06 10/09/2001 4011284 091.06 10/25/2001 4011285 232 324.10/25/2001 CONTAINS TRADB SECRET DATA 4011590 392.11/01/2001 4011591 445.11/01/2001 4011592 4012043 4012319 4012496 4012720 4012949 4013644 4013645 4013752 4013987 4014123 4014297 4014445 4014606 4015706 4015820 4015821 4016193 104 035. 514. 673. 453. 392. 200.38 201.43 16,552. 1,456.38 35,495.45 868. 405. 286.42 79,190. 340. 56. 458. 453. S 5,652,964. 11/01/2001 11/13/2001 11/16/2001 11/2012001 11/27/2001 12104/2001 12118/2001 12118/2001 12120/2001 1212712001 01103/2002 01/08/2002 01110/2002 01115/2002 0211412002 02115/2002 0211512002 02126/2002 -:: NONPUBUC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA A.C& Bill..Da1t:Load Date Total Current Cbal1:l!S Claim Amount Total Paid Check No Check Date INVOICE NO LOT 10/05/2001 10130/2001 347.347.4011592 11101/2001 9931414LOT09/05/2001 09/20/2001 351.13 347.46 4010230 10/04/2001 9572476LOT08/07/2001 08114/2001 113.109.4009194 09/06/2001 9226456LOT07/0612001 07/24/2001 113.109.4007648 08/0212001 8890774LOT06/051200 I 06/221200 1 347.237,109,4006191 06/261200 I 8564868LOT05/07/2001 OS/2312001 7,343.22,962.4005071 051251200 I 8252293LOT04/0512001 05/1612001 445.335.109.4004869 05/1712001 7941265 SPA 03/0612001 04/04/2001 445.335.109.4003186 04105/2001 7625000 SPA 02106/200 I 03/0512001 440.440.4001950 03/061200 I 7333433 SPA 01/0512001 0210712001 330.220,109.4001356 02108/200 I 7052257 69,276.141.S 83,754. NONPVBUC DOcuMENT CONTAINS !RADE SECRET DA T A .B1IlllaU Load Date Total Current Chal1!es Claim Amount Total Paid Check No Check Date INVOICE NO LTL 12131/2001 02121/2002 S 453,453.4016193 0212612002 CLEAN UP BAt LTL 12104/2001 01/11/2002 193,193,4014606 01/15/2002 733803 LTL 06/05/2001 06129/2001 1.76 1.48 4006440 07/0212001 8565035 LTL 05/07/2001 OS/29/2001 62.61.41 4005415 06/0612001 8252456 LTL 04/05/2001 OS/23/2001 48.48.4005071 OS/25/2001 7941425 761.2.59 758. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA AQiA Bill Date Load Date Total Current CharRe5 Claim Amount Total Paid Ch~k No Check Date IN OICE NO LTL 12104/2001 01/1112002 486.486.4014606 0 III 5/2002 733640 LTL 10/05/2001 11/13/2001 12,771.75 284.550,4012319 11/16/2001 9931419 LTL 09/05/2001 09/2012001 22,284.444,839.4010230 10/04/2001 9572481 LTL 08/07/2001 0811412001 426.437.988.4009194 09/06/2001 9226461 LTL 07/06/2001 07/24/2001 420.431.46 988.4007648 08/0212001 8890779 LTL 06/05/2001 06/22/2001 764.12 775.988.4006191 06/2612001 8564873 LTL 05/0712001 05123/2001 988.689.45 4005071 OS/25/2001 8252298 LTL 04/0512001 04/2412001 988.988.4003945 04/26/2001 7941265 LTL 03/0612001 04/0412001 988.988.4003186 04/05/2001 7625005 LTL 0210612001 03/05/2001 988.988.4001950 03/06/2001 7333438 LTL 01/05/2001 01/31/2001 988.988.4001109 0210212001 7052262 273,097.2,374.S 289,488.34 -:: NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA ACM Bill.Da.tc Load Dat~Total Curr~nt Cbar2e5 Claim Amount Total Paid Ch~rk No Check Date INVOICE NO LGT 10/05/200 I 101301200 I 587,307.21,280.4011592 11/0112001 9931423 LGT 09/051200 I 09/20/200 855.575.21,280.4010230 1010412001 9572485 LGT 08/0712001 08114/2001 812.15 566,31,245,4009194 09106/200 9226465 LGT 07/0612001 07/3112001 809,564.31,245.4007648 08/021200 8890783 LGT 06/0512001 0612212001 33.697.041.74 31,655.4006\9\061261200 I 8564877 LGT 05/0712001 OS/231200\33,924.132,\96.400507\05125/200 I 8252302 LGT 04/05/200 04/241200 747.45.522.46 224.4003945 04/261200 7941269 LGT 03/061200 03/261200\7\2.487.224.4002847 031271200 I 7625009 LTL 021061200\03/05/200 34,322.1,972.\9 32,349.400\950 03/06/200 7333442 LTL 011051200\021071200\293,943.32.349.4001356 021081200 I 7052266 312,762.12,979.$ 398,055. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA .." AC&Bill Date Load Date Total Current Cba~es Claim Amount Total Paid Check No Check Date INVOICE NO LTL 10/05/200 1 111\3/2001 72\.05 72\.36 4012319 11/16/2001 9931446 LTL 09/05/2001 09/20/2001 72\.05 721.05 4010230 10/04/2001 9572508 LTL 08/07/2001 081\4/2001 313.313.4009194 09/06/2001 9226488 LTL 07/06/2001 07/24/2001 313.566.4007648 08/0212001 8890806 LTL 06/05/2001 06/221200 I 72\.85 408.313.4006191 06/26/200 I 8564900 LTL 05/07/2001 OS/23/2001 124.217.4005071 OS/25/200 I 8252324 LTL 04/05/2001 04/24/200 I 853.556.296.4003945 04/26/2001 7941292 LTL 03/06/2001 04/04/2001 845,548.296.4003186 04/05/200 I 7625031 LTL 02/06/2001 03/05/200 I 685.388.296.4001950 03/06/200 I 7333464 LTL 01/05/2001 02107/2001 679.382.296.4001356 02/08/200 I 7052289 89,978.285.S t 02,040.33 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA ...., AC&Ili1l..Ilm Load Dat~Toul Current Charges Claim Amount Toul Paid rh~k No Chuk.,~vOlcr NO SPA 10/05/2001 11113/2001 73,820.401.34 4012319 III'9931490 SPA 09/0512001 09/20/200 I 73,820.73,820,4010230 9572553 SPA 08/07/2001 08114/2001 820.73,820,4009194 0';9226534 SPA 07/0612001 07/24/2001 820.73,527.4007648 .'01 8890851 SPA 06/05/2001 06/2212001 76,227.407.820.4006191 2001 8564944 SPA 05/0712001 05123/2001 700.160,500.4005071 G:' :512001 8252369 SPA 04/05/2001 04/24/2001 74,700.700.4003945 04126/200 I 7941337 SPA 03/061200 I 04/04/2001 700.700.4003186 04/05/2001 7625076 SPA 0210612001 03/05/2001 927.927.4001950 03/06/200 I 7333509 SPA 01/05/2001 0210712001 74,927.927.4001356 02108/200 I 7052333 745,464.407.51' S 819,145. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA A!J!!A .Bil1.lli.tc Load Dat~Total Current Charges Claim Amount Total PaId Ch~k No Ch~k Date INVOICE NO LGT 12104/2001 01111/2002 S 672.162.52 66,510.15 4014606 01115/2002 733730 LGT 10/05/200 I 10130/2001 78,347.939,407.4011592 11101/2001 9931509 LGT 09/05/200 I 09/20/2001 153.423.729.4010230 10/04/2001 9572571 LGT 08/07/2001 08/14/2001 078,422,89,655.4009194 09/0612001 9226552 LGT 07/0612001 0713112001 92,392.414.90,977.4007648 08/0212001 8890869 LGT 06/05/2001 06/22/200 1 94,325.435.91,890.4006191 0612612001 8564962 LGT 05/07/2001 OS/23/2001 100,335.162,341. 79 4005071 OS/25/2001 8252387 LGT 04/05/2001 04/24/2001 083.083,4003945 04/2612001 7941355 LGT 03/061200 I 03/2612001 90,083.083.4002847 03/27/2001 7625094 SPA 021061200 03/05/200 I 90,283.283.4001950 03/06/2001 7333526 SPA 01/05/2001 02107/2001 97,138.138.4001356 02108/2001 7052350 969,896.798.S 1,024,103. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA ACl':tA B.iJ.1.lli.U Load Date Total CurTent Cha~es Claim Amount Total Paid Check No Check Date INVOICE NO NWO 12/15/2001 01/08/2002 583.20.563.4014445 01/10/200209010037001349 NWO 11/15/2001 01/04/2002 638.629,4014297 01/08/2002 090loo37D013l9 NWO 10/1512001 0110412002 78\.12 776.4014297 01/08/200209010037001288 NWO 09/1512001 02113/2002 340.340.4015706 02/1412002 1227 2,344.34.37 $ 2.310. -:: NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CaNT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA AQ!A BilJ..D.a1.c Load Date Tot:al Current Charj!es Claim Amount Tot:al Paid Chuk No Chuk Date INVOICE NO LGT 1211512001 0110812002 S 97,97.4014445 01/1012002 09010432801349 LGT 11/1512001 01/0812002 128.128.4014445 01/1012002 09010432801319 LGT 10/1512001 1210712001 334.334.32 4013244 1211112001 09010432801288 LGT 09/1512001 1113012001 79,79,4012949 1210412001 09010432801258 LOT 0811512001 1113012001 646.63 646,4012949 1210412001 09010432801227 1.286.37 S 1.286.37 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA A.C& Blll..Dm l.o2d D2te Total Current Charges Claim Amount Total Paid Cb~k No Cb~k Date INVOICE NO LGT 1211512001 0110812002 23,980.980.4014445 0111012002 09010432DOI349 LGT 1111512001 01/0812002 516.26,516.4014445 0111012002 09010432DO1319 LGT 10/15/2001 1210712001 38,475.475,4013244 1211112001 09010432DO1288 LGT 09/1512001 11/3012001 001.95 001.95 4012949 12104/2001 09010432001258 LGT 08/1512001 1113012001 472.472.05 4012949 12104/2001 09010432001227 122.446.S 122,446. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA ...." .t\.QIA Blll.Da1c load Date Tobl Current CharJ!es Claim Amount Total Paid Cherk No Ch~k Date INVOICF NO LGT 1213112001 0211412002 56,56,4015820 02115/2002 CLEAN UP BAL LGT 12101/2001 1211412001 410,18.392.4013644 1211812001 120101 LGT 11/01/2001 11/2012001 409,17.392,4012720 11127/2001 110101 LGT 10101/2001 1013012001 412.20.48 392.4011590 11101/2001 100101 LGT 09/01/2001 09/25/2001 406.14.39 392.4010063 1010212001 90101 LGT 08101/2001 10/24/2001 595,14,58\.60 4011284 10/25/2001 80101 LGT 07/01/2001 . 07/17/2001 405.13.392.4007362 07/2612001 70101 LGT 06101/2001 06115/2001 410.18.55 392.4005909 06119/2001 60101 LGT 05/01/2001 OS/29/2001 410.18.27 392.4005413 0610612001 50101 LGT 04/01/2001 04/24/2001 434.28 42.28 392,4003943 04/2612001 30101 LGT 03/01/2001 03/2612001 395.39.356.4002847 03/27/2001 30101 SPA 0210112001 03/1212001 389.389.4002249 03113/2001 8100010400-2001 SPA 0110112001 0112.212 00 I 400.38.19 362.4000866 01123/2001 8100010400-0101 138.255.51 S 4.883.28 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA AQ!A B.i1l..Jl.m Load Date Total Current Cba~es Claim Amount Total Paid Cb.cdl.NtI Ch er k D at e INVOICE NO LGT 12110/2001 1212112001 S 15,213.253.959.4013987 12127/2001 08060432001344 LGT 11110/2001 1111612001 13,711.53 258.13,453.4012496 11/20/2001 08060432D-O1314 LGT 10/10/2001 1012312001 993.13 190,803.4011285 10/25/2001 08060432D-O1283 LGT 09/1 01200 I 0211412002 14,458.458.4015821 02115/2002 1253 LGT 08110/2001 09/2012001 650.369.8,280.4009810 09125/2001 08O6O432D-O1222 LGT 07/1012001 07/2012001 15,656.69.15,587.39 4008017 08109/2001 08O6O432D-O1I91 LGT 06/10/2001 07/2412001 890.220'2 19.670.35 4007363 07/2612001 08O6O432D-O1161 LGT 05/10/2001 OS/2212001 18,763.91' .852,4005070 OS/25/2001 08O6O432D-O1130 LGT 04/10/2001 05/0712001 25.960,812.25,147.4004423 05/0812001 08060432D-O1100 LGT 03/1 01200 1 04/24/2001 14,85\.69 580.14,271.32 4003943 0412612001 08060432D~1069 LGT 0211012001 04/24/2001 187.516.67\.65 4003943 04/2612001 08O6O432D-OIO41 LGT 01110/2001 04/2412001 886.406,480.4003943 04/2612001 08O6O432D-O I 0 I 0 173,222.4,587.S 168,635. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA --,: B11.I..D.a1J:: Load nale LGT 1211012001 1212812001LGT 10/1012001 1012312001LGT 09/1012001 10/3012001LGT 0811012001 0912112001LGT 0711012001 0712012001LGT 0611012001 0712012001LGT 04/1012001 05/0712001LGT 03/1012001 04/1812001LGT 0211012001 0411812001 Tot," Curreot Cb8l'~es Claim Amouol 1.10 S 41.51 121.18 249, 431.04 891.3 I 229. 143. 188. 2,296J1J S Total Paid 1.10 41.51 121.18 249. 431.04 89\.31 229. 143. 188. S 2,296.83 Cb.u.kliII Chei:k note INVOIrF. NO 4014123 01/0312002 0803432FGBOI344 4011285 1012512001 0803432FGBOl283 4011591 1110112001 0803432FGBOl253 4009810 091251200 1 0803432FGBO 1222 4008017 0810912001 0803432FGB-G119 4007134 0712412001 08O3432FGB-0116 4004423 05/0812001 0803432FGB-G110 4003679 0411912001 0803432FGB-0106 4003679 04/1912001 08O432FGB-01 04 I NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A AC& .B.il1...nm Load Dale Total CurreDI Char~es aaim AmouDtLGT 12110/2001 1212812001 S 27 867,81 SLGT 10/10/2001 10/23/2001 25,713.LGT 09/10/2001 1013012001 18 672,LGT 08/10/2001 09/2512001 15,615.LGT 06110/2001 07/24/2001 31,370,LGT 05/10/2001 OS/2212001 2,631.66LGT 04/10/2001 04/2412001 10,813.LGT 03/10/2001 04/2412001 7 130.LGT 02110/2001 04/2412001 8,347.LGT 01110/2001 04/1812001 6,706,S 154,869.72 S Total Paid S 27,867. 25,7\3. 18,672.96 15,615. 31,370. 631.66 10,813, \30. 8,347. 706. S 154.869. Cheo:k Dale INVOICE NO 4014123 01/03/2002 0803O432DO1344 4011285 10/25/2001 0803O432DO1283 401 1591 11/0112001 0803432FGDOI253 4010064 1010212001 0803432FGDO1222 4007363 07/2612001 0803432FGD-OI 16 4005070 OS/25/2001 0803432FGD-O1I3 4003944 04/261200 I 0803432FGD-O I 10 4003944 04/2612001 0803432FGD~ 4003944 04/2612001 0803432FGD-OI 4003679 0411912001 0803432FGD~IOI NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A -::-.: Bill.Jlatr Load Oat. Total Current Cbal"K.s Claim AmountLGT 1211012001 12121/2001 S 0.80 SLGT 1111012001 1211412001 0.LGT 1011012001 10123/2001 0.LOT 0911012001 10105/2001 34.LGT 0811012001 09125/2001 2,300,LGT 07/1012001 08103/2001 5,763.LGT 0611012001 08103/2001 5,874.LGT 05/1012001 0512212001 5 479.LGT 04/1012001 0413012001 6 771.29LGT 0311012001 04/1812001 7,673.LGT 0211012001 03/2612001 6,099.LGT 01/1012001 03/26/2001 5,646.S 45,644.31 S Total Paid S 0. 34, 2,300. 763. 874. 479. 771.29 673.39 099.11 646, S 45,644.31 Chetk No Chetk Oat. INVOICE NO 4013987 12127/2001 08O4O432BO1344 4013645 1211812001 08O4O432BO1314 4011285 10125/2001 08O4O432BOI283 4010390 10/09/2001 0804432FGB-0125 4010064 10/0212001 0804432FGBO1222 4008017 08109/2001 0804432FGB-0119 4007825 08/07/2001 0804432FGB-0116 4005070 05125/2001 0804432FGB-0113 4004210 05103/2001 0804432FGB-0IIO 4003680 04/19/200 1 0804432FGB-O 1 06 4002847 03/27/200 I 0804432FGBO 1041 4002847 03121/200 1 0804432FGBO 10 I 0 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A AC&B.l.U...IlI1I:Load Dalr Total Currrnt CbafJ:rs Claim Amount Total Paid Cb~k No Ch~k Datr INVOICE NO LGT 12110/2001 1212112001 20,535.20,535,4013981 1212112001 08040432001344 LGT 11/10/2001 1211412001 16,552.16,552.4013645 1211812001 08040432001314 LGT 10/1012001 10123/2001 816.15,816.4011285 1012512001 08040432001283 LGT 09/1012001 1013012001 116,10,651.30 4011591 11/0112001 0804432FGDO1253 LaT 08110/2001 0912512001 11,541,11.541,40 1 0064 1010212001 0804432FGoo1222 LGT 01/1012001 0112012001 692.48,112.4008011 08/091200 1 0804432FGD-O 119 95.980.S 123.874.83 NONPL :C DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A ..., AC& Billlla1r Load Date Total Current Charl!e5 Claim Amount LGT 10/10/2001 10/2312001 S 79721 SLGT 09/1012001 10/0512001 597,LGT 08/1012001 09/2112001 612, LGT 07/1012001 07/2012001 1 409.LGT 0611012001 07/2012001 1,225.LGT 05/1012001 OS/2212001 1 071.62 LGT 04/10/2001 05/07/2001 1,184.LGT 03/1012001 0411812001 127.LGT 02/1012001 03/14/2001 904. LGT 01/10/2001 03/14/2001 717.S 9,646.85 S Total Paid S 797. 597.11 612. 409, 1,225. 071.62 184, 127. 904. 717. S 9,646. Check No Check Oat! INVOICE NO 4011285 10125/2001 08000432B-O1283 4010390 10/09/2001 0800432FGB-0125 4009810 09125/2001 0800432FGB-OI22 4008017 08/0912001 0800432FGB-0119 4007134 07/24/2001 0800432FGB-01l6 4005070 OS/25/2001 0800432FGB.0113 4004423 05108/2001 0800432FGB-0110 4003679 04/19/2001 0800432FGB-0106 4002397 03/15/2001 0800432FGOOI041 4002397 03/1512001 0800432-FGBOIOI NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CaNT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA AC&Jli.l.I.llm Load Oa'.Total Curroat Charxes Claim Amouat Total Paid Chttk.1!isI ChHk Oa'.rNVOICF: NO LGT 10/1012001 1012312001 115 443.678,112.764.4011285 1012512001 0800432FGDO1283 LGT 09/10/2001 10/0512001 112.097.112.097.4010390 10/0912001 0800432FG~!25 LGT 08/1012001 09/2012001 81.150.1.994,156.4009810 09/25/2001 0800432FG~12: LGT 07/1012001 0712712001 142.138,965.139.173.4008017 08/09/200 1 0800432FG~ 11 9 LGT 06/10/2001 0712712001 183.879.668,180.210.4007647 08/0212001 0800432FG~I:" LGT 05/10/2001 0512212001 173,35\.27 ! ~3.35\.27 4005070 0512512001 0800432FGD~1 i . LGT 04/1012001 05/0712001 163.737.737.4004423 05/0812001 080O432FG~! ;. LGT 03/1012001 05/0712001 144 742.,44.742,4004423 05/0812001 0800432FG~ 106 LGT 02110/2001 03/1412001 146.720.146.720,4002397 03/15/2001 0800432FGDOIO41 LGT 0111012001 04/1812001 119.192.119.192,4003679 04/19/2001 080O432FGD~1O1 1.382.455.34 11.307.S 1,371.147. NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A ACNA B.i.Il..Da.1I Lold Dill! LOT 10/1012001 10/2312001LOT 09/10/2001 10/0512001LOT 08/10/2001 09/20/2001LOT 07/10/2001 07/2412001LOT 0611012001 07/20/2001LOT 05/10/2001 OS/2212001LOT 04/10/2001 05/0712001LOT 03/10/2001 05/07/2001LOT 02110/2001 03/2612001LOT 0\110/2001 0413012001 Total Currl!DI CblrJ:t!5 Claim AmouDIS 67 327.55 S 58.994. 50,573, 84,383. 144,380. 124,486. 111,409. 108,778. 94,890, 68,003. 913,228.11 S Total Plld S 67,327. 58.994. 50,573.46 84,383.09 144,380. 124 486. 111,409. 108,778, 94,890. 68.003. S 913,228.11 Cht!tk Dill! INVOICE NO 4011285 10/25/2001 0801O432~1283 4010390 10/09/2001 0801432FG~125 4009810 09/25/2001 0801432FGDOI222 4008017 08109/2001 0801432FGD-OI19 4007134 07/24/2001 0801432FGD-OI16 4005070 OS/25/2001 0801432FGD-OI13 4004423 05/0812001 0801432FGD~110 4004423 0510812001 0801432FGD-OI06 4002847 03127/2001 0801432FGDOIO41 4004209 05/03/2001 0801432FGD-OI01 NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT CaNT AINS TRADE SECRET DA T A ...., ACr!IA BilUlm Load DatrLOT 1210112001 12119/2001LOT 11/01/2001 11/09/2001LOT 10/01/2001 10/19/2001LOT 08/0112001 08114/2001LOT 07/0112001 07120/2001 LOT 0610112001 0612212001LOT 05/0112001 0512212001 LOT 04/01/2001 0512212001 LOT 03/0112001 03/1212001LOT 0210112001 03/07/2001 Total Currrnt ChurrsS 1,494. 1,495. 508. . 1,485. 486. 496. 480. 487. 490. 485. 14,910.71 S Claim Amount 38.42 39. 52, 28. 29. 40. 23. 31.33 33. 29. 346. Total Paid S 1,456. 456. 456. 456. 456. 456. 456. 456. 456. 456. $ 14,563. Chr~k No Chr~k DatrINVOICF. NO 4013752 1212012001 2766 4012043 1111312001 2675 4011084 1012312001 2579 4008666 08/2812001 2399 4007254 0712612001 2305 4006160 0612612001 2213 4004991 0512512001 2121 4004991 0512512001 2029 4002211 0311312001 1938 4002008 03/0812001 1849 -:: NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A AC& Bill.D.a1c Load nail!NIX 11101/2001 11/09/2001NIX 10/01/2001 10/19/2001NIX 09/01/2001 09/20/2001NIX 08/01/2001 08114/2001NIX 07/01/2001 07120/2001NIX 06101/2001 0612212001 NTX 05/01/2001 0512212001 NTX 04/01/200 I 04/24/200 INIX 03/01/2001 03/1212001NIX 02101/2001 03/07/2001NIX 01/01/2001 02120/2001 Total rurrl!nt Charg8 naim AmountS 57.91 S 53. 51.97 89. 70. 66. 61.70 61.29 59. 52. 199. 824.28 S Total Paid S 57. 53. 51.97 89. 70. 66. 20. 61.29 59. 52. 199. S 783. Cbl!rk No Chl!rk natl! INVOlcr NO 4012043 11113/2001 2717 4011084 10123/2001 2621 4009653 09125/200 2528 4008666 08/28/2001 2440 4007254 07/2612001 2346 4006160 0612612001 2253 4004991 OS/25/2001 2161 4003855 04/2612001 2070 4002211 03/13/2001 1976 4002008 03/08/2001 1888 4001579 02122/2001 671 Trade Secret Data Ends) NONPUBLJC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T A Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 BoIse, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 66 Case No. QWE- T -06- AT&T McCleod & Cap Rock Current Charges & Payments 2000 (TRADE SECRET DATA BEGINS Current Charges Mw1th December- November- October- Type of Service .Il1age Private l.ine $ 377 910 $ 414 517 286 167 410 392 341 192 660 S 1,056,418 S 607,588 Payments Mw1tb December- November- October- Type of Service .Il1age Private !.ine 377 635 $ 414 337 282 805 392 389 467 175 754 S 1,049,907 S 590,483 P-421/C-O2-197 DOC 08-21851 TRADE SECRET ATTACHMENT In1al $ 792 427 286 577 585 001 S 1,664,005 Io.taJ. $ 791 972 283 197 565 221 S 1,640.390 NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT - CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA .BAN lD.mi.tt1t BilI.Dau Curr~nt Cbary!!!Claim Amount Paid Amount Paid Dat~ChuU 81000104003 100101 Ol-Oct-Ol S 412.20,392.Ol-Nov-4011590 2803108 9931414 05-Oct-347,347.Ol-Nov-4011592 LITEL 9931419 05-0ct-12,77\.75 284,550,16-Nov-4012319 LITELIC 9931423 05-Oct-21,587.307.21.280,OI.Nov-4011592 LITELC 9931446 05-Oct-721.05 721.36 16-Nov-4012319 QWESTI 9931490 05-Oct-73,820.\0 64,401.34 16.Nov-4012319 QWESTI 9931509 05-Oct-347.939.407.Ol-Nov-4011592 3448O432D3 0817O432DO1283 I O-Oct-O I 72.72.II-Dee.4013244 7765003703 08030037D-01283 IO-Oc:t-OI 8.\ I II-Dee-4013244 73930037D3 08000037D IO-Oct-30.30.08-Jan-4014297 7393O432DI 1253 I O-Oct-O I 112,097.112,097.I 5-Feb-02 4015821 7407O432D3 0806O432D-01283 IO-Oct-993.190.803.25-Oct-4011285 7765432BMJ 0803432FGBOl283 IO-Oc:t-41.S1 41.S1 25-Oct-4011285 7765432DMJ 0803O432DO1283 IO-Oc:t-25,713.25,713.25-Oct-4011285 7767432BMJ 08O4O432BOI283 IO-Oct-25-Oct.4011285 7767432DMJ 08040432001283 IO-Oc:t-15,876.15,876.25-Oct-4011285 OFCO432BMI 08000432B-OI283 IO-Oc:t-797.797.21 25-0ct-4011285 OFCO432DMI 08OO432FGoo1283 IO-Oct-OI 115,443.678,112,764.25-0ct-4011285 OlN0432DMI 0801O432D-01283 IO-Oct-67,327.67,327.25-0ct.4011285 00377270DO 09010037001288 15-Oct-O1 781.12 776.08-Jan-4014297 O4327270BO O9O1O432BOI288 15-Oet-334.334.11-Dee-O1 4013244 0432727000 09010432001288 15-0et.38,475.38,475.II-Dee-4013244 81000104003 110101 Ol-Nov-409.17,392.27-Nov-O1 4012720 3448O432D3 1283 100Nov.73.73,I 5-Feb-02 401582177650037031314IO-Nov-26.26.15-Feb-02 4015821 7765O432B3 0803O432BO1314 IO-Nov-1.35 1.35 08-Jao-40J4297 7765043203 08030432001314 IO-Nov-26,595.26,595.08-Jan.4014297 7393O432BI 08000432BO1314 100Nov.939.939.08-Jao-4014297 7393O432DI 08000432001314 IO-Nov-127,601.95 094.124,507,08-Jao-4014297 7407043203 080604320-01314 IO-Nov-13,71 \.S3 258,13,453,20-Nov-4012496 . 7701O432B3 1314 I O-Nov.O I 37.37.15-Feb-4015821 7767432BM3 08O4O432BO1314 100Nov.18-Dee-4013645 7767432DM3 08O4O432DOI3 100Nov.16,552.16,552.18-Dee~01 40136456158O432DI 08010432001314 IO-Nov-OJ 73,344,73,344.08-Jao-O2 4014297 oo377270DO 0901 oo37DOI3 J9 15-Nov-638,629.08-Jao-O2 4014297 O4327270BO O9O1O432BOI319 1 5-Nov-128.128.IO-Jao-4014445 O4327270DO 0901 O432DO13 19 15-Nov-26,516.26,516.IO-Jan-4014445 81000104003 120101 Ol-Dee-410.18.392.18-Dee-4013644 2804064 733711 O4-Dee.786.786'\ 2 26-Feb-40161933205226733730O4-Dee-10,997.10,997.26-Feb-02 4016193 3319287 733803 O4-Dee-193.193.15-Jan-4014606 LlTEL 733640 O4-Dee-12,486,12,486.I 5-Jan-4014606 QWESTI 733730 O4-Dee-66,672.67 162.66,5 10. IS 15-1ao-4014606 3448O432D3 0817O432DO\344 IO-Dee-68,68.03-1an-40141237393oo37D31314IO-Dee-150.150,I4-Feb-4015706 7393O432BI 08OOO432B IO-Dee-778,778,01-Mar-4016305 7393O432DI 08OOO432D-0\344 10-Dee.127,308.127,308. 7407O432D3 0806O432DO\344 IO-Dee-15.213.253.959,27-Dec-4013987 7701O432B3 081OO432BO\344 I O-Dee-O I 1.56 03-Jao-4014123 7765432BM3 0803432FGBO1344 IO-Dee-1.10 1.10 03-Jao-4014123 7765432DM3 0803O432DO1344 IO-Dee-867.867.03-Jao-4014123 7767432BM3 08O4O432BOI344 100Dee.27-Dee-4013987 7767432DM3 08O4O432DO\344 10-Dee-535,20,535.27-Dee-40139876158O432DJ 080lO432DO\344 IO-Dee-72,891.67 72,891,12.Mar-4016789 00377270DO 0901 oo37DOI 349 15-Dee-583.20.563.10-1ao-4014445 O4327270BO O901O432BOI349 I 5-Dee-0 I 97.97.IO-Jao.4014445 O4327270DO O901O432DO1349 15-Dee-23,980,23,980.IO-Jao-4014445 81000104003 CLEAN UP BAL 31-Dee-56,56.15-Feb-4015820 MCLEOD OUT OF REGION 31-Dec-334 891.334 891.00 07-Mar-40165983319287 CLEAN UP BAL 3J-Dec-453.453,26-Feb-4016193 664,005.30 261.S 1,640,389. NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT - CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA Invoice Bill Date Current Charges Claim Amount Paid Amount Paid Date Chec:k 2803108 9931414 05-0ct-347.347.Ol-Nov-Ol 40115923448O432D3 0817O432DO1283 10-Oct-72.72.II-Dcc-QI 401324477650037D3 0803oo37D-01283 IO-Oct-QI 8.11 II-Dee-Ol 401324473930037D3 08000037D IO-Oet-30.30.08-Jan-02 40142977393O432D1125310-Oet-Q1 112 097.112,097.15-Feb-02 40158217407O432D3 0806O432D-01283 IO-Oet-993.190.803.25-0et-01 401128577654328M3 0803432FG801283 10-Oct-41.51 41.51 25-0ct-01 40112857765432DM3 0803O432DO1283 IO-Oct-25,713.54 25,713.25-0et-QI 401128577674328M308O4O43280128310-Oct-25-Oct-Q1 40112857767432DM3 08O4O432D01283 1 O-Oct-O I 15,876.31 15,876.25-0et-01 4011285OFCO4328MI 080004328-01283 IO-Oct-797.797.25-0ct-Q1 4011285OFCO432DMI 080O432FGDO1283 IO-Oct-115 443.678.112 764.25-0et-01 4011285OlNO432DMI 0801O432D-01283 10-Oct-67,327.67,327.55 25-0et-Ol 401128500377270DO 090loo37DOl288 15-Oct-781.12 776.08-Jan-Q2 4014297043272708009010432801288I 5-0ct-QI 334.334.II-Dee-QI 4013244O4327270DO 0901O432DO1288 15-0ct-38,475.11 38,475.11 II-Dcc-QI 40132443448O432D31283 IO-Nov-73.73.12 15-Feb-O2 401582177650037D31314 10-Nov-26.26.15-Feb-02 4015821776504328308030432801314IO-Nov-l.35 1.35 08-Jan-Q2 40142977765O432D3 0803O432DO 1314 IO-Nov-26,595.595.08-Jan-02 40142977393043281 08000432801314 IO-Nov-939.59 .939.08-Jan-Q2 40142977393O432D I 0800O432DO 1314 10-Nov-127 601.95 094.124 507.08-Jan-02 40142977407O432D3 0896O432D-0 1314 I O-Nov-O I 13,711.53 258.13,453.20-Nov-01 401249677010432831314 10-Nov-Q1 37.37.15-Feb-O2 401582177674328M3 08040432801314 IO-Nov-18-Dee-0l 40136457767432DM3 08O4O432DOI314 IO-Nov-552.16,552.18-Dee-01 40136456158O432DI 0801O432DO1314 IO-Nov-73,344.73,344.08-Jan-02 4014297oo377270DO 09010037DOl319 15-Nov-638.629.08-Jan-02 401429704327270800901043280131915-Nov-128.128.IO-Jan-Q2 4014445O4327270DO 090 I O432DO 1319 15-Nov-516.26,516.10-Jan-02 40144452804064733711 O4-Dcc-786.74,786.26-Feb-O2 40161933205226733730 O4-Dee-997.10,997.26-Feb-02 40161933319287733803 O4-Dee-193.193.15-Jan-02 40146063448O432D3 0817O432DO 1344 10-Dee-68.68.03-Jan-02 40141237393oo37D31314 10-Dee-15Q.41 150.14-Feb-02 40157067393043281 080004328 10-Dee-778.778.01-Mar-02 40163057393O432DI 080OO432D-O1344 10-Dee-127 308.127 308.137407O432D3 08060432001344 10-Dee-213.253.959.27-Dee-40139877701043283 08100432801344 IO-Dee-1.56 03-Jan-401412377654328M3 0803432FG801344 IO-Dee-1.\0 1.10 03-Jan-40141237765432DM3 0803O432DOI344 10-Dee-867.867.. 03-Jan-401412377674328M3 08040432801344 IO-Dec-27-Dee-40139877767432DM3 08O4O432DO1344 IO-Dee-535.535.27-Dee-40139876158O432DI 0801O432DO1344 IO-Dcc-891.67 72,891.67 12-Mar-401678900377270DO 0901oo37DO1349 15-Dee-583.20.563.10-Jan-Q1 4014445043272708009010432801349I 5-Dee-97.97.IO-Jan-401444504327270DO 0901O432DO1349 15-Dec-23,980.980.IO-Jan-40144453319287 CLEAN UP 8AL 31-Dee-453.453.26-Feb-4016193 056,417.6.510.S 1,049,907. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT. CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA BAN Invoice #Bill Date Current Char~es Claim Amount Paid Amount Paid Date Check #8.lE+1O 100101 01-0ct-412.48 20.48 392.01-Nov-4011590LITEL9931419 05-0et-771.75 284.550.16-Nov-4012319LITELIC9931423 05-0ct-587.307.280.01-Nov-4011592LITELC9931446 05-0et-721.05 721.36 I 6-Nov-O I 4012319QWESTI9931490 05-0et-820.401.34 16-Nov-4012319QWEST29931509 05-0et-347.939.407.01-Nov-40115921E+1O 110101 01-Nov-409.17.392.27-Nov-40127201E+1O 120101 01-Dee-410.18.392.18-Dec-0 I 4013644LITEL733640 04-Dee-486.486.15-Jan-4014606QWEST2733730 04-Dec-672.162.510.15-Jan-40146061E+1O CLEAN UP BAL 31-Dec-56.56.15-Feb-02 4015820MCLEOD our OF REGIOl'- 31-Dee-0 1 334 891.00 334 891.00 07-Mar-4016598607,587.750.S 590,482.58 TRADE SECRET DATA ENDS) NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT. CeNT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise. Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 67 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T DOC 358 State Of Minnesota Department of Commerce INFORMATION REQUEST P421/CI-01-1371 and P421/C-02-197 Information Requested From:Qwest :Corporation Information Requested By: Date Requested: Date Response Due: Ferguson, Sharon 07/12/2002 07/19/2002 REQUEST: Admit that the .Payments. listed on page 1 of Trade Secret Atachment A to Qwest's response to DOC 08-218 in this docket are payments that were made by Qwest to McLeodUSA. RESPONSE: Admit. Respondent:Terri Reddan Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 68 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T MINNESOTA DOCKET NO, P42L'CI-OI-1371AND P421/C-O2-I97 DOC-aJ-t(Z- ATTACHMENT: 'Trade secret data begins SmmryForA.Rchrds xls -----Original Message----- From: aibarra~qwest. com (mailto: aibarra~qwest. com) Sent: Friday, May 31, 2002 12:23 PM To: Anne Richardson Cc: Audrey McKenney Subj ect: Vendor Plan Summary Anne, Here s a synopsis of where we stand.Let me know if you have questions. Cheers,Arturo NONPUBLlC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA McLEOD VENDOR PLAN SUMMARY 4000 AI Wired 030 4000 Sttlemt 000 1001 740 2001 640 3001 984 364 01 0 Pymts 505 Total 2001 869 2001 Vndr Agrmt 840 01 Over/(Under) Pymt 029 4000 DoublePayment 000 Total Overpayment 12,029 2002 Est 0 Purch From M01 2002 Vendor Plan 02 Est. Over / (Under) 686 18,320 (10,634) Est. Post 2002 Residual 395 Trade secret data ends) NONPUBLlC DOCUMENT CONT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA " , P-42I1C-O2-197 DOC 08-212Trade Secret Attaclunent SUBJECT TO RULE OF EVIDENCE 408 CONFIDENTIAL BILLING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT ITrade Secret Data Begins This Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement ("Agreement"), is herebyentered into by Owest Corporation (ClOwest") and McLeod USA, Inc.McLeodUSAD) (hereinafter referred to as the "Parties" when referred to jointly)on this day of September, 2000. RECITALS 1. Owest is an incumbent local exchange provider operating in the states of Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Iowa, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, NewMexico, North Dakota, Oregon, South Dakota, Utah , Washington and Wyoming.2. McLeodUSA is a competitive local exchange provider that will soon operate in all fourteen states of Owest's operating region.3. Whereas both awest and McLeod USA have entered intointerconnection agreements pursuant to the federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 ("Acr) under Sections 251 and 252 of that Act, and those agreements havebeen approved by the appropriate state commissions where those agreementswere filed pursuant to the Act. Owest and McLeodUSA operate under those agreements in certain states, as well as various state and federal tariffs. 4. Disputes between the Parties have arisen regarding the provisioning of finished services through unbundled network elements, and theprovisioning of finished service through the UNE platform.5. In an attempt to finally resolve those issues in dispute and to avoid delay and costly litigation, the Parties voluntarily enter into this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement to resolve all disputes, claims and controversiesbetween the Parties, as of the date of this Agreement that relate to the matters addressed herein, and McLeodUSA releases Owest from any claims regarding the issue as described here. CONFIDENTIAL BILLING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT 1. The Parties enter into this agreement in consideration for the sum of money described below, and Owest's release of McLeodUSA's conversionand termination fees associated with the changes to a new platform which is currently being created by the Parties. As part of the new platform, Owest willprovide call origination, call termination , call duration , and call type information toMcLeodUSA. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA , ' 2. McLeodUSA shall pay to Qwest an amount of $38 500 000 no laterthan November 10, 2000. This amount represents the charges which Qwestclaims McLeodUSA owes it for conversion from resale to unbundled network elements, and for termination liability associated with existing contracts. 3. For valuable consideration mentioned above, the receipt andsufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, Qwest does hereby release andforever discharge the other and the other's associates, owners, stockholderspredecessors, successors, agents , directors, officers , partners, employeesrepresentatives, employees of affiliates, employees of parents, employees ofsubsidiaries, affiliates, parents, subsidiaries, insurance carriers, bondingcompanies and attorneys, from any and all manner of action or actions, causesor causes of action, in law, under statute, or in equity, suits, appeals, petitionsdebts, liens, contracts, agreements, promises, liabilities, claims, affirmativedefenses, offsets, demands, damages, losses, costs, claims for restitution, andexpenses, of any nature whatsoever, fixed or contingent, known or unknownpast and present asserted or that could have been asserted or could be asserted in any way relating to or arising out of the disputes/matters addressed herein. 4. The terms and conditions contained in this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement shall insure to the benefit of, and be binding upon, therespective successors, affiliates and assigns of the Parties. 5. Owest hereby covenants and warrants that it has not assigned or transferred to any person any claim, or portion of any claims which is released or discharged by this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement. 6. The Parties agree that they will keep the substance of the negotiations and/or conditions ofthe settlement and the terms or substance of the Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement strictly confidential. The Parties further agree that they will not communicate (orally or in writing) or in any way disclose the substance of the negotiations and/or conditions of the settlement and the terms or substance of this agreement to any person, judicial oradministrate agency or body, business, entity or association or anyone else forany reason whatsoever, without the prior express written consent of the other party unless compelled to do so by law. It is expressly agreed that this confidentiality provision is an essential element of this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement and negotiations, and all matters related to these mattersshall be subject to Rule 408 of the Rules of Evidence, at the federal and statelevel. 7. In the event either Party has a legal obligation which requires disclosure of the terms and conditions of this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement, the Party having the obligation shall immediately notify the other Party in writing of the nature, scope and source of such obligation so as to NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA T " . enable the other Party, at its option, to take such action as may be legally permissible so as to protect the confidentiality provided in this agreement. 8. This Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement constitutes an agreement between the Parties and can only be changed in a writing or writings executed by both Parties. Each of the Parties forever waives all right to assert that this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement was the result of a mistake in law or in fact. 9. This Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement shall be interpreted and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Colorado, and shall not be interpreted in favor or against any Party to this agreement. 10. The parties have entered into this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement after conferring with legal counsel. 11. If any provision of this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement should be declared to be unenforceable by any administrative agency or court of law, the remainder of the Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement shall remain in full force and effect, and shall be binding upon the Parties hereto as if the invalidated provisions were not part of this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement. 12. Any claim, controversy or dispute between the Parties in connect with this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement shall be resolved by private and confidential arbitration conducted by a single arbitrator engaged in the practice of law under the then current rules of the American Bar Association. The Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.C 991-, not state law, shall govern thearbitratibility of all disputes. The arbitrator shall only have the authority to determine breach of this agreement, but shall not have the authority to award punitive damages. The arbitrator's decision shall be final and binding and may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. Each party shall bear its owncosts and attorneys' fees and shall share equally in the fees and expenses of the arbitrator. 13. The Parties acknowledge and agree that they have a legitimate billing dispute about the issues described in this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement and that the resolution reached in this Agreement represents a compromise of the Parties' positions. Therefore, the Parties agree that resolutionof the issues contained in this agreement cannot be used against the other Party, including but not limited to admissions. 14. This Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement may be executed in counterparts and by facsimile. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA "'", ' IN WITNEESS THEREOF , the Parties have caused this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement to be executed as of this day of September2000. McLeodUSA Incorporated By: Title: Date: Qwest Corporation By: Title: Date: A,,~roved as to legal form ex( 2000 NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA . ' PRIVILEGED & CONFIDENTIAL - FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES Outline of Major Terms September 19, 2000 Q will provide billing tapes to allow M to bill access charges starting with usage for the month of October (or possibly September - Q to confirm) and going forward. M will not charge Q access rates on M platfonn lines at a rate higher than the rate Q charges M. Q will pay M (S18 million) to settle a past billing dispute over access charges for the (2d & 3d) quarter of 2000 and a release of claims for a new M platform from the date of M' s request.M will pay Q (S29 million) for conversion and termination fees associated with the changes to a new M platfonn created by the parties. (Judy and Stacey to work on platfonn issues and details) (Audrey needs to confinn:whether 2d quarter settlement is available). Q will offer v.m. & DSL (& .net - to be confinned by Q) to M region-wide at retail rates subject to paragraph 6. In addition, if any new products offered by Q the parties will meet to discuss product offerings through a business-to-business relationship. Q will develop state-by-state M local platfonn pricing for services (including & not limited to loops, ports, features, etc.) for a 36 month period (M to identify features it desires to sell and provide to Q by 9/22) (Q to provide pricing by 9/29). M will provide infonnation to allow Q to develop LO rates by 9/22 and Q will provide LO pricing by 9/29. Within 2 days after receipt of pricing, M will deliver a forecast based on the rate information and will propose a 36 month total revenue commitment to Q (including revenue :from allservices and products purchased by M :from Q, including & not limited to new M platform,resale, LD, Private line, v., DSL, OIA, etc.) with a firm, substantial portion of the total commitment in the fonn of "take or pay. '" In the event of significant competitive pressures, the parties agree to provide for a review of the pricing. The parties will address a review of the 'take-or-pay' amount in the event Q can not or does not provide services substantially in accordance with the agreement. Based on the proposed commitment by M, within 5 business days, Q will propose volumeand term discounts based on quarterly revenue targets, to be paid back to M by Q on aquarterly basis. As a condition to Q completing this transaction, M must take a neutral stance on Q 271 relief and agree to develop a joint press release with Q announcing this arrangement. M andQ will work jointly on service standards. This is a material provision of this agreement. The parties will continue to work on a program for securitization of receivables to allow capitalization by M (Audrey is working on these details and will provide input by 9/29). The parties will continue work on an agreement to address M trunking needs. (Audrey to investigate pricing issues and provide ideas for how M can help address these issues and Mneeds to update LIS forecast by 9/29). 10.The parties will develop a clear escalation process to address problems, issues, disputes andconcerns raised by the parties. NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA . ' IN WITNEESS THEREOF, the Parties have caused this Confidential Billing Settlement Agreement to be executed as of this day of September2000. Trade Secret Data Ends) McLeod U SA Incorporated By: Title: !PI/? /ertJ Date: 9/ZI1 lot) Title: Qwest Crror~lon /loration By: Evf W~Ck~"-ft 9/,:)..Qlob n1Q d=~ Date: NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA ...~ ':;;:;:"': . ~SS4 7C s..:;a:~=;.;.- L-N 24 2002 0S: 5S ;:; WHOL=:SAL..c '-'I,..,~ -..)r-. "kK .32 ~-- :: . e:.: " M~lAe~~. .._. .- P-421/C-O2-197 --. . 4~L~ _.- ~,,"Ct::;. .. - - -'-' ~~~- ~~~RET A TT ACHMENT ::~~ (Trade Secret Data Begi ~.:' J" 1" t.-f!v -; ! - ~:II- f'-' :t':o.i.l~S ~~~ . !:~r--=-~._t.~~+;~r ~~II~S ~ !L_~~r.w- -'0-I ~n'\ ~(t~ . .'' ': &\" W;l~" '-7~((~~~ ~~J,/V' ~~~ .kJ&-.-e, ~~ ~~U-D.J-. A1~)..t' ~~. , - ~I-V..r~ Q.r ". ~ ~.tiH"pY\ ! : --=-~~_.(~~ ~5 '~' I ~~~~ ~,~~~ I~ J" ~-'6 ,,~~ .;. if- :~ (7) 1.#- "--4 .-....~(JI : -.:.1I.d~~I ' ~~ ~ I\.~~ V'D i~..1- ~~ie-J do t\e ~~- k ~fi:ta."' ~~~~ r..Jt ;rs IY!! 6., ~ - ~r.. 1. ~) l' Q! "'" ...!""f2-~bt-- :~. -.-/- I\J p-' L- ----L-- IWw ~ftk~E2r. ... -CA.l.L.....~ . ~ (:~ r-~" ~" 55' ~-".. '- :bv~lc:l4Lu~~. ,- ., , I .--. --'--, :_-,--_... ';:'--. Q.- ~_..~~" !1;.J.~'P- I"':~S~il- _- .- ~l _. :.- -- C-fu?1 ~.. ~.$fs. .J- ~ rlt .CA1Y. ~1nJ "~~ f. .h?-D.~ 7NONPUBLIC DOCU ~ o_00 ~" Zf:.J;;(k/s "'0 CaNT AINS TRADE SEcKE DA T ~---'G-)-e-~~~, wi- '2 ! ~-'.--~~~' ~--S ~: -=-CiLii~~~~;t ~9 "--.. --', -, -~----- --, ";:':' 1;;:'-;-:3::: ;;..: _ ::::~ - .::." ,;:.....1'::"::'::'::. '::- - ~~ 2~:~= =~ ~~~~~'::~L~ - :: . J...; --.~~ . ' ( -u) I ~~. ~ ~.~~ (;.~~~ .fc~i._ ~_- if- +;;.. ~16- ~ 2-7- ~(.r!% i.b-~d. .K~) ~~ ~~- fuk---t-CAas.v-L!'-~ , ; ~ .- - '--r..Y.() -j I.1J~ i I ~~J.: -!!%~~ ~~L ~ -'~. L&....e.'..!'; !_- -:.b l.oI L~_ . - -- ;WOO CO ~P- 2$ ~ ~ .::; A.~ I'-~- to , ~. &"gg- ~--.~j~_._._~~~ /f-'k;o L) ItJPh~'~.J!L'-- ----'- -L$II -- '---- -. l#. ~~~~ I: ---l,/i-4-~'d( ;--- ----.-. ---: ;-~--,---~- f-- - -'- ..:... 11f;t, . -"" ~....... ll,. . ." .J... ' ~- -. L/:'3fI-:s.pb~4.d;~ (j;) 0h ~H= ==-=~- ~ -~~- L..V.: tM U:o "'.....-.0 --;i- .- - -- - - -- --- 1;-' !"" -r.-rtu- ~. . - ~dA ~ ~--- -- ---- -- -- -- U'1!~Y... - :;?';;-- ("U(.. ~ ~.-..- .-. ,- 2~ fhu.~_ &- '--'--==-. e;~~~~=~Fi /'7 'J,O _~~~J '" NONPUBLIC DOqpHENT '- '- '-, A.(: I-. INS TRADE S RET DAIA --'i-f - ..;..j... CaNT '--'-' --L:l -p---, ~~,-.. ~...~'-.- - -. .. CJ, tPS ..hl' 1';'" ~- --- ---- --2;~,,--~ d.OUl) ~'3Dl11t.. ~a.. i/l ---- puf ~~ --" rc:::,\.~ ?~ ::.c;;:.:- ~::::== =-::"JM':_ '::::':'':: ' l":'_ : ::;;;'== ==~ -=-==- -: .::.::.::.:::::===..::--. --.. ._--- - -_u.. - -.---- .'-- .--.. ---.- ----.. .u_--_. ---" "---'--' oI)...r" --"--'--- -. ~.u:: L;r'ICr- .---- --. --_u ...--... "--'-. _.. P"' ,:,_.. -- \ 'U)l):-1 1'rt~4.~ ~~ "1 .,"'- tJ9~ ~ ~ C=~. t"- ~ --. . -~ ~ f.4l I ~ . ---.. 1+ /.Id-I' u~- J 1'1-2 c.....r~ _.. -1Z5_- :3 4' P(~..._. UJUf -fL:.(1.'f~Ufa. r ub....€ I I - 4: ?-; c;: OJ .. -: fT J' ~~ r&.' ;+ r'-r;ie~ ~~ ILV.i.L E.*' ~ k ~YV'-l1-.ss jt ~~&i.pr~ UA (5 ~. ' 51Jk.. ~~~ ~ 'S"~1~f- tJ'&'\ ~~.~~._--. "--- ~~.I.( ~: "'- A-.l!U'i ~ M. -h..J-I ~-~:5 ._-=:. .iI:!l...J1&;.... .- r..----,-~ ~.:J i-,- ~._~_. -:J ~f?L:-. .. ~tJ ~~~ 4k ~:~- I r ~ ~ Jq~-;8:'a-, NONPUBLIC DOCU ~ ~ ~ r-L3~L- CONTAINS TRADE SEC tDATA ~. - ---- 76~ ---.. .. h (:).'- SCj ~ ;~: :~5~ ~C S~:2~~~~~. ," .::~ :: 3L~ '::);3: ~S -= .::; . J"", ':~'=':::":;,-"" - . w- ---: r;. kJ. -/y a. ~~~ ;.r;;:~L ~-- '&;~~,.~ 1~61t,~~1-- -- . _. ir~~ D.)~~~1~cb- ~_, --.-) '---: ~~_. .___.- '-- -.-.- ;1.-- 'M~ ~~-- - '. --- j i-- -.- '---"- I, -: I -- ---. ..~~ ~4.Aekrn,~ --a-'dA.-Y1... ~.d. --.lu.n/ t~d ~,.,., ). ----, (;,..b.. : I: "'" !:+t-.L ; /) S ~!.... rJ,...1vtz:- - . LUJ u.D-~ 1-1,..-.AJllA~ -=-=r~ A: I . ;.L "Iff i!)At ~Gt! €. -/..~ ~~SJ' ~....s ..--- -- '-..~~ ~~"lI, ~(... ~""'"~~ ~ arS~~~~ :. ~~~~-? ~s:~~~.. -- - !l51)d. y~---=-~~.( oj ~~~~.._-- IP f1),fi~""';~.t.. "i J'S' ~ c;, I.-.. ~ ~: ~ - r-" ;,--.- -------.---..-...--.--- i I :.JONPUBLIC DO~.t' I"!. II'- ad& ~' V.:. .J. -:-- CO NT A INS TRA D E SEC~ ..:b... ""14.~h.....-L.$~ G - .. ~~~ - .;-- -----A.J ~ p~ .k ,cur ;;~' P ...~ LrM-m ,""~-I..1 ..L-- -----i~~J t-L~ _...-----;;- -, .-=--"'-.. :: 0,:)-:" . ; 2 . - J ~i303~SSE!~, - - E'l 3:;::1- - . --... HOL i:"SRLE i1RJOR M C:::J - .--... ._.... . 24 2002 ~9: 59 t-R W - . --'-'-'.. .._. iC'Alt . ;~~. :-. .---..- ..- ~ ' '\!6 c:i ---"-- -.- - ~ i ~.:E (3) ---"- . 1_-.-_0_-.. +- W~ ":"#-~~- r-~ -" :f- ..71 ~~&-~ .b.~J .--- ' - t1!r...s :! -- - _.. . I(L, ~~S~: h-- ~ ~~/?~~~-- 1: iJL'tf !r- - .~""'-.:, !l===--_ ~ "'~~" II .t ~--~.- 0 - - ~J.5L-~. -fn..,.....L-l~.~.!oea -' ~I\ ~~~_.. . -;\ . ~- ~I.f:c;-,- ~-' ~~2- __._.~-,,~_.-' "-- . - ~s.k~v~ ~~~~~~oo: r--- -=~ -I~ D'o ,;;~ NONPUBLIC Do ~l\1EI~. 1."""'-~....,G ~_-I -1:0 k rt-Ir--'-'- CONTAINS TRADE S~fRE~ DATA -.--I L ----- !-.-:=-- --'-. ..... -- -- -. ~ --~. - ,.' ~- " /.,.-~ ==~ -:;~.: -:-.: =~::;a:~5S.::_i'~ 2--: 200..: J::J:::J::: ,CUH"'-t:.::JH'-::' "r-.~uk "RK,::o~ -- ~~ .- (f) ---,~- " - - --": ' QbK pe,.IN~- 0- .. ! ! ~~ "" ~1L-I' ~~S _-_. - .'\) iUl- .......J. qE5 L!.~-H..uf ~B'T ).,u,d . ..~~ ~LJ-~--J. reI ~, "'~ .. . . lulu-!'tJ.~ ~~1 ~; '--. J '" ~t~I' o ~-- - !...D i~. ~~~.~.- . 1- -. -tr ~.f- ~.a.-~~ -k .E. ~~ ~~ .JR. ~ It' ~~, & ,~~.)." ~~~----"'~~~~- ~~,;L ~,,~ ~-";- ~~ _ ~5 VIJ~ ~ ~I. :~..._.;~-, ~sb:v.~ . _ IL_ '" --"- . iNONPUBLIC DOCU~~~ -- ~.- J_. ~ L.L.: : ' t...l!!!L, ~~.L&....t)~- o-"lU. :b.~mJT AINS TRADE SEC 4-aJ1l. '$"-$O...kt~ ~~..: :: ~~.- A.J/1I ~p . : ~ . ~ ~ 'JI-../..o "\ !~- ~~.J-. .------ , I ...J".., , t' I ...... N ~, ?oe7 39 - ~C =~ ~HOLESAL~ MRjO~ ~RKTS2 ;03 J55~ ,0 913032366; ~_.o - - :"'~~---- '--- ..----.- -.--, .-.. ""-.. .----- 1~\J,i:: '- ..... ".--- ;:: - JS. i':: " .: ' Ji':I:';:~ --."--'-----. --:' '~~- 6) --'-r- J -r-- ; j- .~~ c:E.tJLf_LrW: -;- (. ~~~- r;1' 11 .-::; ~ .. " --..LL-. . ~ ~ ;;f ~~f1~ -I. 61.') ...A4L~M~G~Q0 I ~ ~~~~.~..- . "'oM .t!:!.$'(~ --/. - :::!iE. .. . .1 r;.... :-:~ 'de.,JAJN ~ 4GJ 12J&I-..s ~- ; - I Q ( """"" ""'r:./'I I ._ ~;;"....... -I "Y. " . ~..t:.- : - TLL.c -.r rd ~-LA I r- -::. i~ ~&kR~kd.I~-. :1 ~(~... 7H..r..i: i III-' ==:=: '-. i i , .--'-' ---'- !I --..---- i L __.- r J,1_- - ----- ---......--- ---: !---- I!-'- ----- -..--.-- 1:- '- ------ .---....-..---.- 1/-- --'._- NONPUBLIC DRcU~ENT - ~._-.._. r'ONTA!NS TRADE!$-E€~ --"----'-- ..-- -- _u --. .- -.--'-----.-. eN ~4 2002 J9: 59 =R ~HOLESRLE MAJOR MRKTS2 563 355~ ~c ~ l3032988l S::: . ~ -J. . ,~., ,~~ t!!i2--;L-~! i i i !L-)1 --.-- --. Ir-----' -- ---. I~.__ _._.- It-- J I !r---- .-- --- ir--- ---.- -- ;i-'-"--' ~'--- ,- --., i-'-" = =' -=, --'-.--'---'- I f--.- ,.-- ---- rl -. ------.-.-.-.- NONPUBLIC D#:UMENT -._---- '- :1--- CO"T-\INS TRADE ~ECRCT DAtA--- ~=--=--=-!- -- ~~~S\rC~~c.kJ... ",- Trade Secret Data Ends) .-. 00__ .___.---..---'-'----'-.,,-----------------,-----, -,----"------.. ITrade secret data begins MINNESOTA DOCKET NO. P421/CI-01-1371AND P421/C-02-197 DOC- ~.2J 2- ATTACHMENT: From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Hansen, Steven Q (steven.hansen(g)qwestcomj Thursday, January 17, 20028:10 AM Comelsen, Rodean Szeliga, Robin; Berman, Scott; McKenney, Audrey; Ibarra Jr, Arturo; Reed , StacyFW: McLeod Payment Scott, Please use this as authorization for the release of the payment to ~cLeod. Questions, please call me at 303-294-4543. Thank you. Steve Steven Q. HansenVice President CFO - Wholesale Markets Phone: 303-294-4543 Cell: 720-312-7798 ~ -----Original Message-----~ From: Szeliga, Robin~ Sent: Wednesday, January ~ To: Hansen, Steven Q~ Subject: RE: McLeod Payment ;:,;:,;:, ;:, Robin, ;:,;:,;:,;:,;:,;:,;:.;:.;:,;:.;:.;:,;:,;:,;:,;:.;:.;:.;:.;:,;:.;:, 16, 2002 10: 19 Thanks for keeping me informed I am good to go Could we look at whether they would like to renegotiate this given their financial status Maybe they could use something else and we could structure a better deal -----Original Message-----From: Hansen, Steven QSent: Wednesday, January To: Szeliga, Robin Cc: McDermet t, Kr is; Graham, Subj ect: McLeod Payment 16, 2002 4:00 PM Grant The request for the $5. 9M payment to McLeod is a result of a take or pay commi tment made in conjunction with service agreement between Qwest andMcLeod. Originally McLeod had signed a $480M 3-year deal for services with Qwest in October of 2000. We enlisted there support on regulatory, legal, 271 and other matters of consulting for a $48M take or payment commitment over the same period. This payment is for the time period of July through September. We will make similar payments on a quarterlybasis. We have a similar deal with Eschelon. These commitments are allpart of the partnership known as UNE-Star. It is my understanding that you are to be informed on all payments over $lM before treasury will process. Would I be correct then in assumingthat the best way to handle these going forward would be to submit the explanation to you for e-mail approval, have Grant sign on these once you have agreed and then process to treasury? I will ensure we followwhatever procedure you have outlined. Steven Q. HansenVice President CFO - Wholesale Markets Phone: 303-294-4543 Cell: 720-312-7798 Trade secret data ends) NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DA : ...-,- , Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 69 Case No. QWE-06- AT&T II. ill. VI. SummarY of Owest 3ereement packa2e A series of four agreements running through 12/31/03, which provide a special unbundled platform to MCLD. The new platfonn is considered and unbundled loqp and switch port combination. The agreement included a one-time conversion payment of$43.5 million (capitalized) to searnlessly converts aU existing business and Centrex (ihcl. Res) lines to the new UNE-M platform. There is no requirement to discormect or reconnect customers. We are actually converting our existing platfonns to a new platfonn in name only. The new UNE-M Platform allows MCLD to collect access revenues starting October I , 2000 on its business and Centrex-residcntiallines. These revenues are estimated to be _. The Platfonn also provides new state rates approximately 25% below IFB levels and is similar to UNE-P rates. The estimated savings arc approximately $500 000 per month. .The rates are flat for the first average 525 minutes, with additional fees for additional avera e us~~ there is risk of hi er rates de endin on local usa e. . l&.' ' ~~.- . . .. The agreement has no rates or specified discounts for residential service other than in existing Centrex common blocks. Under a hh~hlv confidential 31!reement,we also receive a revenue/purchase commitment from Qwest based on the following: Year MCLD expenditures with 0 2001 $178-188 million $188-198 million over $199 million 2002 $199-230 million over $230 million 2003 $199-250 million over $250 million 0 expenditure with MCLD 5% oftotal MCLD e"penditures 8% of total MCLD expenditures 10% oftotal MCLD expenditures 8% of total MCLD expenditures 10% of total MCLD expenditures 8% oHotal MCLD expenditures 10% of total MCLD expenditures The platfonn includes the offering of the resale of voice messaging and DSL at retail rates. The package includes a settlement of our claims for conversion to a UNE- platform during Q2 and Q3 2000 by .Qwest paying us Includes a 3 year, $480 million take-or-pay commitment by MCLD. The commitment is spread over 3 years and has annual commitments but total MCLD expenditures over 3 are cumulative. 480 million of revenue to VIT. VIII. IX. We forecast about $750 million over expenditures over the same period and includes in-region and out-or-region, local and long distance purchases. The agreement provides that the parties will meet to establish an implementation process including service levels and metrics for service. Until the implementation process is established, e,osting DMOQs under existing interconnection agreements eontinue in force. If disputes arise the parties will utilize and agreedescalation process including three levels of management (up to CEO level) and arbitration. If escalation is not successful. MCLD may bring an action in federal court to recover its actual damages. If Qwest perfonns, McleodUSA agrees not to object to Qwest applications for 271 approval. EBITDA for 2001 +$40 million. (Excludes possible impact of treating this as a lease of assets) Additional sales in Qwest region in about 700 CO' Incremental out-or-region opportunities (SplitRock and CapRock) and LD Reduced capital - Not yet quantified Beginning of improved relationship with Qwest - not yet quantified Risks: Local usage substantially higher than a 525 minutes per line per month average drives rates up quickly. We will do not have traffic exchange agreements with other CLECs who may attempt to collect recip comp from us. Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 70 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T JUL 24 20~2 l~: 11 FR QWESi 612 672 8911 :;M .. ,... ~ TO 914155850443 P.02/09 fJ.~2 IC-U2- j-)7 DOC 08-Trade Secret Attachmenr ITrade Sacrat Dlta Dclia! 1h.is Service and E:JiUina l\irecment ("'SBA") is made and entuecl into by ItncfberwccnMcLeoduSA Jnc:(J'JIorued and its subsidiaries (UMcLeodUSA") and Owen CommunJca.honsJrncm.uional Inc. and its subsidiaries IFDr' IIW doculIVfIIl GSJIImft tltis Hl'1U the QwUl "Itimat'pllnllllUJd is all "1U'~1I11IlU DIIiJy.Qw~t") (~oUec:tively, the "Partie.s ) on this iW.day or October, 2000 (I J",,~, we dal, this ~'1f1 one d4y II/ter rhe A~II~nr to b"~(J"1:rmrsj Senrice and BiUio! A2r~menrlUsea in lic" q( II sidt! ICtt!Tj E,T~'1i'Vc OC\ob=r , 2000 the Parties entered into an Amendment to allInll'.rr.nnMrfi"ft ~8I'-1n."'c b":;-.." 'ft....., ..~.. iu I;~' ur =ne.rea 11110 pncr to December 312003 (the "Amendmen1 ). Based on the Parties ability 10 rxgotiace 4tld emer intO thatAmendment 10 a.l1lncercoMection Agreements, the Parties cleaed to neeotiue and erl1er into thisSBA. Tht Piirties hilvlB entered in to enter into this SBA to ucilitate and improve their businessand operational aCtivities, agreements and rclltioruhips. In consideration of the COVeJ1lntsagreements and promises contained below the Parties alU" to the followil'\~: 'fhj;) SBA IS entered into between the Panics b~ued aD Ibe fol1owing conditions. whichare a materia) pan of this agreelTlent. j, 1 Md .t'lnllll ~.... hac p"'rc~cod . \'10 of.h.. cnd ur IiGI,;J. ur LhC' J&S1 1. Cllenaar years, atIus! .lCX,OOO local c"chanlc lines for ruaJe from Qwe5t (throughout the 14.statc area whereQwest is an incumbent local ~cRanse tInier). QwCSi arI(J McLeodlJSA CUJrtml)' hive an asreemen1, on a region-wide basis, toenter into agreements for the e:ICchanBc ofloca! traffic On a "bill and k:e~" basis, which providesfer uu:: mutuat reco"ery of cons through the offsetting ofreciprocaJ obligations , for localcx~hl"Be traffic which origjnatcs with a CUstomers of one company and terminates to I customerof the olher company j , The Panie.s wish 10 establish a busiaess.to. busines5 relationship and have 88!'eedthat the)" will attemp1 to resolve all djff'l'!tJII"r~ I"r ;U"8' ,..lWeft InA)' .rioo 'Incl.". d~.. !IDA., ~ \Yell&5 any other agreement between any McLeodUSA company and ny QweSt compU1)', under rneescaJa.cion pro~5S in this section. Th~ Panies agree to utiJjz~ tbe following escalation processand time lTames to resolve all differences or issues which may ari5e und~r any aereement between an)' McLeodUSA COmpany and any QweSt company, and not proceed to a higher levelof dl.spute resolUtion until compleriOIl of1he prior level. and to complC1e all Jevels before filing aproceed ins before any ooun or administrative or governmental body I. 3. J LeveJ I - Vice Presidems (Staccy SteWanlJ udy Tinkham or successor! \I (I busil"~~s day. J .i: Lcvell. GrOup/Sernar Vice Presidents'D:&/.r:.I,.., 0"'5 (.".~e'~ UI :ltU\;&;csSOrSI 10 business ds\'s NON PUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SEelEr DATA' JUL 24 2002 10: 12 FR QWEST 612 672 8911 TO 914155850.:14:1 a3.109 :::'..J''..J ' ; .: ~ ':. . '" ~ \.; , I 3.L-.weIJ. CEOsiPre.!idents (Steve Gray/Joe Nacchio Of' 5ucCe'SOr$) 5 b\lsJncs~ days :; Level 4 . Arbimuion accordin!!! to the provisions of the Agre~ment. Lfthese Steps do not resolve the di.sputc, tlIen either party may initiatelitiA:uion in federal cowt. The Panics isree the exclusive venUe for civil court actio~ byMcLeodUSA islhe Un~ SUtCI District Coun in Denver and the exclusive venue for civil COUI\ "lion" h\l Owrou i; ,h,a' '";'81'4 ~I'I"'CI Di....i.. c.w't i,~ C...J... J\at'I~~. rr GU1lin&! order of disrni ISing I ~se is entered the COUrt, and nOT reversed, then the pinybringing the aCtion shall be re3ponsiblc for the reimbursement of reasonable attorneysfees incurred by the oTher pany, Ifany (mal summaryjudgmcrn is entered by the courttbell the pany asaiost whom the judsment is entered shan be responsible for thereimbursement of reasonable anomeys fees ineumd by the pany who obtained such judgnaeot. In the event that eitl'1cr pany tiles an action in coun, the Partics waive primaryj~risdiction il) any IWe utility or servicl! commission and aU contractual or tarifflinlitlHion, on cbmases, and Ehe Agreements are hereby IJnencfcd aecorcfingly. Neitherpany, however, waives ita right 10 lake d.ispu1cs unresolved ~Aer Ihe arbitration levellaIn., IipprClpri.:uQ :Jtate 0," (C.:lCI'~ IO~I.IIa~UI~ body rer reSOlUtion 1.-1 Thl~ S.t:JA shaJJ be bindiJiS on Qwest and MC'l..ccdUSA and each of theirn:spec:tive subsidiaries, affiliated corporations, SUccessors and Is$il1ns This SBA may be ameaded OT altered only by writtl'n instrument uecutcd by anauthorilcd represc:I1tative of bOTh Parties, I () Tne Parties, intending to be legally bound, nave eXe~1:ed trus SBA effective as Oc:tober I , 2000, in multiple counu:rpans, each of wllich is deemed "11 original. but all of whi chshall constitute one al1d the same in51T\Jmen~ 1, The tenn or tbis sa... wiJl be the $line as the term of the Amendment and bothlIilrf"""'~rI't \I,ill '8r"',aue oanOU""'lul J'. TI.i:lo S!lA -",-, me I\JTIcnameln can only be tcrmiMtedin the evem of 1 a 0111&::11111 chAnge in the CUlTenl percentlge aflines purchase byi\-lcLeodUSA j, each ofthc variou:I pdcinit zones ofQwen: 2 , the averl8e retail business rates across IIIJ Qwen nates fall to within 20%arLh(: "overage oftnc rales altered to McLeodUSA Oft Attacbment 3,2 to the Amendment: 1.1.3 .1 mllleri.J breach ofrhe tcmu of the A81eemenl.S or Ihis Amendmentwhich remainJ unresolved and unc:ompensated following appliCAtion of the disputer~.solutiQn provisions of this agrcem~nt: NONPUBlIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA " ' JUL 24 2002 10:13 FR QWEST 612 672 8911 TO 91415585e44~~4d~9 7. "c'';'~M" ;':'~;; a rnllcriil ctwJgl: in the \elecommWlicatiol'ls industry not ~ultin8 fr~many ~Ctions within th. control of either "arty; or I. 7.eilher pany giving MUten notice oftemination at least six (6) mO"t~S'prior 1.0 the end of the InniaJ Term or any Successi\le Term, All factual preconditions and duti8i see forth in this SBA arc, Ire inr~nded to beand are considered by the Panies to be. reasonably reltted to, and depcndern upon eoach otherI. 'i Jf either pany s performance of this SBA or any chliwinn Ilnrl~r 'hie ~~ 4. ir",""'cu"=~, rcsrnCtea or aMcrtered with by causcs beyond such Panics reuonable controlincluding bul not limited 10 ACts of Gcd, fire, explosion. vandalism which reasonable precautionscould not protect against, storm or other similar occurrence. lAy law, order. rcaullLtion, directionaCtion or request of any unit of federal, state or locil government, or of lay civil or milituyauthority, or by nuional emergeneic:!, jruwrections, riors. wars, SUpplier flilures , shonil8es,hrcach or delays, then such PIIITY sb&J1 be o:ltQJ.sed from such per(ormaac:e on II day-ro-da)' basis . . ' ,e .e'Ctent of such prevention, rcmiaion or inlerferel1c:e (I "Force Majeul'1: l. J 0 Provision of ProduCts under thc Amendment in accordance with lections 3,2 and3.4 of the Amendment will be \Oiewed by McL.eodt1~A 111"1 in """"1"'.-. ,..i.h &h. r.,~ircrt'W.IU~or ::.ectlon l71 crlbe Telecommunications Act of 1996 and McuodUSA wiJl not object to lI1yfiling by Qwest for aU1hority to proYide in.region imcrlAT A long distances s8rVices. Thisprovi!ion doelnot prevent McI..eodUSA fi-om plU'ticipwns in rcgulatory proccedinas rclatiq teservice quality Dr service standards for wholesaJe or reaajl services; or relating to pricing. termsand condi1ions for related to resale SCJ'\lices, unbundled network elements, or inurConncctiol'l orcal)ocation services : 11 This SBA is nor, and i. not inteflded 10 be, an amencfment 10 an intercoMcctionagreement; however', onher pany may, It iIty lime, demlnd that the olher party make 111)'provision Or!mS SBA thai is contruy to, or in any way inconsistent wUh, &D)' IntercOMtctionAsr..m.nt bOlWC48 V\c ""'Lie.., u& ..uy orthetr NbSiOllnCS, an amendment to each of suchInterl:Onnectjon Asreemcnh and tht other pany will immediAtely eause the appropriate corporueentity to =c.ccule such an amendment. Tb. ParUe:. that time is of the encnce in compliance withtlUs section and that failure to comply would cause immediate and severe d&mlse to the otherpan)' acknowledge that money darnasc. can not adequately remedy and . therefore, upon failure10 e)(ecutc such 8n amendmenl within 1.5 days ifter WTittm demand, the PIny makin, demandmay. upon 48 hours notice to the other patty, obtain a judgmem of injunctive relief in the (orm ofan order for gpecific J)erfonnance efchc obligation ofthis section. In the eVent either pany ;srtquired to bring an aCtion (or specific: performance artfUs section, the ather party will pay aU"..ale ""II -p..,~.a. ;'I",lu"'ijl~ leuunlOle attorneys toes, il'1C\U'1'cd in conneaion with such flc~ion ... 1.11 consideration of the IIsrec:ments and COvenants set fon" above and the entire group ofcu'llenants provided in section 3, aJl taken as a whole, with such consideration only beingad~qua!e if all su!:h agreements and covenantS are made and are cnforce.able , McLeodUSAui;rees to !he rolll)u.in NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA JUL 24 2002 10: 13 FR QWEST 612 672 8911 TO 914155850443 P .05/09 :;.~~ :y'(J~I ':.'::,~; ' :r: $7,~7:'\~,N\:, .,~~,,;:;~,.. 2. J ' To pay Qwest the $38.million for conversion fees and termination charg,8srequired by the Amendment. 10 purcha.se aolD QweSt. or one of its a.fflliate corporations, during the InitialTerm ofthh SBA, It lUSt $480 million worth (excl\Jdinglny amounts paid to McLeodUSAputliuanr to Seetin 32) otrelecommunil;annnl; "'n".1nr:~.1 nr iftForrl13tion D_"iu8, neo!..",...elc:ments. interconnection or collocation service.. or eJcmOllu. capacity, tcsmjnltion ororigination services, and switching or fiber ngbts (" the ProduCtS ), , ax prict;s provided inAttachmcl\t 3.2A lQ tbe Amendment, including tbe best ayulabJt prjcing for wholesale longdi.u.Jlc~ 5ervices, subject to the terms ofrhi, secriot! 2. . J Subject to the Pro\iisioDS oftfUs section 2.2, by December 3 I , 200 J McLaodUSA wiU purchase a miaimum o'SI50 million ofPloduc:u and in the eventpurchases by McLeodUSA do nor meet this minimum, McLcodUSA igTCe$ to make apayment to Qwcn, no later than January J 5, 2001, in an ID1ounr equal to tne differen~bec~cn ao:uaJ purchues and rh~ minimum :Z '&w"jo.,...be. tJA",..j~iu":I ul'tNS 'ectlon :.!'~I by Ucc;anbcr J 1 2002M.:LcodUSA wj)J purchase a minimum of SJ J 0 million of Products, and in the cventpurchases by McLcodUSA do not meet tJUs minimum. McLeodUSA agrees to make &payment to Qwest, 110 later than January IS, 2003, ill an amount equal to the differencebet'We=u IIc.:tUa! purc:hascs and the minimum: J;. ,; Subject 10 the provisions oflbjs seaion 2., by December J 1 2003~cLc:odUSA will purthlse a minimum Of$480 milIioD of ProduCts, and in the eve"tpurchases by McLeodl1SA do nat meet this minimum, McleodtJSA agrees to make apayment to Qwesr. no later than Januuy \5, 20004, in an IUI'IOUDt equal to the differencebetWeen actUal pur,hascs and the minimum. ... "'T A. UI; Iwuunum pUTcnue requirementS provided in this Attac:hment shall bereduced proponionaJJy for "cn otthe (oUowin,. which Occ:ur' 22.4. or otherwise Ally oflhe ProlSucti are no longer offered Any "Ie OfCUrTenr ()west exchanges4.4 Any deJ.~ in the t1eljvery of an ordered Product (which shftll redu~ the iTUnjmum dol/ar for dolJlT' for ProducEs ordered but 110t delivered)2..Any outase ot Stare DC'out ofse:rvic:e" when ProduCts havebeen ordered or reqlleS't~d 2.4.6 Release. ,Ila/c, trans2er or relinquishment of an)' c:urrCnIcoHocarion back 10 C)weSI.l.4 , i Mc:Leod(J. ~", ' A ml~lnen: i, pr'8v.nt.d. rODtrioI(1d or jnteri~, t;Jwith by a Foret! Majeure IS described i" scc:t;l\n 1 9.~2,Chanses in technology eliminating the need fer certain servicesNONPUBLIC DOCUMENT A reauCtion in the rUes tor any oftl1e ProduCts, by agreement CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA JUL 24 2002 lB:14 FR QWEST 612 672 8911 TO 91~155850443 P. ~5/e9 '~~. :~::I:'i:. ...:.;:,; .:i ,~' :.o;~O. ':;:j:.,:, provided uy QweSt :!. Ib~ take or pay purcnue requiremems of this section &re ccnditiom:d Oll the approval of the AmendmenT in each of the 14 stites where Qwest is an incIJmbentlow e~c:hange carrier. To nwintain, throughout rcrm ofthis SBA, no kwcr than xx,OOQ local exchangelines per year purchasi:d from Qwt:St throuRhout tht tcnirnri,.\ wh",~ QUIIIrt 'II O\lrT'1I",1), .1...Jucumccm lOcal ~C:l1anse service provider. for the purpose of pro vi dins service toMcLeodUSA's CUStomer:!. For purposes of chis provision, local exchange lines purchasedinclude lines purchased for resale and unbundled loops. whether purchased alone or in combinaeion witb other nerwork clements.. 'Ibis minimum line commitment win be reduced proportionally in Ihe even Qwesl sells any exchanges where it is currently the incumbent localeJCchange .seMce provider To Juaintain, OwlQ8 tbe terna ofrhis SBA no fewer than x OOO local exc:h.ang:lines purchased lTom Qwest in each !late where Qwest 1$ I;UrnntJy the incumbent local exchanseservice provider. fer the purpose of' providing Jervice te McLeodUSA r s customers. !hi sminim,,", Ii... eoolft_ia.......1 ......ill boO ...,J",\ow Io'I\ljJUlLlunauy In me even ~west sells any exchangeswhere it is currently the incumbent loca.) exchanse servic:e provider. 2.4 'fa place orders for the produ= offered in Utis SBA. and for features associated with the product. using (at McLeocItJSA's oJllioa) ~ithcr IMA Or EDI electronic imenaccsoffered by Qwest. to the ext~t that those intaflces adequately suppon the produa. Ordersplaced elecuonicl.Uy through a third pany acting on behalf of Mc:LeodUSA u, il'l ~rnplilnccwilh ttUs requirement 1'0 remain on a .bm and keep" basis for the =xchange of' locil traffic: with Owes'throughout the territories where Owest is cunendy d.e incumbent leeal exchange service:provider until December J 1 , ,QQ~I 1'0 i!nlOl' into and maimain interconnection agreemenrs. or one lcsionalagreerncat, toverinS the provision ofProc:lucrs throughout the entire territory wh~ Qwesl iscurrenll)' the incumbent loc:aJ exchanse service provider, except in those exchanges sold byQwut. .). In consideration olene agrecmenu and c:ovcnanu set forth .bave and the en\ire group ofcovcnants provided in seclion 2, all taken IS a wbole, with such consideration onJy beingadequate if &11 such "sreerncnts and covenants are made and ue enforceable, QweSt agrees to thef':1l!owing: To W4Uves and reJeue all ~barl~ "nrt 'I"hi lit)" t:lth.r than theca dQOcriD~ inSeCtion Z., associated resale produCls purl:hased fTgm Qwest prior to the etrecrive dale ofthi!SBA or for convening or terminating Mcl.cadLJSA se1\'ices purchased Uom Qwcst for resale (he UNE/5witch pon and loGS' combination produCt described in this SBA NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CO NT AINS TRADE SECRET DATA JUL 24 2~O2 10: 14 FR QWEST 612 672 8911 TO 914155850443 07/09 "ON '~O";I:,'":' j(j ~:2'1 !iT':'Jf,NC."6~o)"r.':l'~ ' To increase iu purchases &em McLeodUSA, or one Dries affiJjatc corporations.Q~JriD8 the term of this SBA., to the minimum amount of telecommunications, erthanC:ed orInformation services, netWork elements. iDterCOMecrion or coJJcCltion services or elements.c:i1pllciry, termination or orisination serviOCI, switchiJ'l,!' or fiber r;~h1s (lI lhl: ProduCts ) asdt:.liCl1bed lJ1., and aubjecl1.o tn. tenns. 8ftachmern 3.J"'o To remain on I "bill and keep" basis for tne exchange cf)ocal traffic with QwCSI.lbroughoUt the territories where Qwcn IS currcctly the incumbent JoeaJ exchange serviceprovider unti i Dcecmber ) I , 2002. Made and entered inco on the date written abave by Mc:LeodtTSA and Qwest I\IcLeodUSA 18cot'pOrared QWfSt - -----..----.---- "uth(Jr~ed S &gnature Authorized SignatUr-e --.---- "--~-_.. -----...--.- --.. ...- -._- --.-- Nlime Printedf! ;'Pcd Name PrintcdlT)-pcd --~ -- '-- ----- Tille -.--.-----------'--. Tille D.Jl~ -. --- - Cat.: NONPUBLJC DOCUMENT CONTAJNS TRADE SECRET DATA . ~ . JUL 24 2002 ~: 14 FR QWEST I',,:JM 612 672 8911 TO 914155850443 P. \38/13:3 :"'~I\. ;. ",,;.'. ," ''~' NO,t,;;,.Il""' .....__&._--. ...... SUO)ect to the provuioo, OrafUS Attachment. the amounr of Qwest'a commitme:nt to InCTC"!SC It purc;b.ues. based on prices set by McLeodl1SA in Ic:cordanoe with Jaw and my Other agreemem between the PlntC$, will be thu amount required to produd ~rginsior McLeodUSA in tile amcunUi described below: McLeod-USA p~baW ManOn Produ~G.Q.!l'I.mirm~m 2001: S 1784181 million S I !S8.) 98 mjUion over $198 miBion 5% artOtalamount of McLeod USA purchases 8% Of10taJ amount of McLeodUSA purchas~s 10% oftoral amount o(McLeadUSA purchases ~U,,~. c,1.?,?a:tO luUUvn over $230 miUion 078 UI IUW Imoum or MCL..eoOU~A p\Jrchas:l!~ I ()6/. cftoraJ amount oC McLeodUSA purchases 2003: 5 1 99.:Z50 milJion o~er SZSO million 8% oftoltl amount of"McLeodUSA nurch8!1es 1(J8/o oftatal amount of McleodUSA purC'.h.~e$ In thv event pW';hue~ by Qwes1 arc no1 in,reased to the proportionate quanerly level oftile commitmcm ciescribed above, based on the proponiorllte purchases ofMdeodUSAunder this S8A. Qwesl wiU pay the difference between make its actual increasedpul'cha.ses and committed increase by the end of each calendar quaner. In the even' of1.:h4n"cl durin IE 1hc counc oft"e Y~Jfr. ,h... r,n",minP'liI'l"t"l"'.hu., Vld qu1l18rly pD~'mO"UIwjJI be balanced .at the end of the Y"" baled on the annual figures provided .bove iiI.If McLeodliSA does not reach the purchase levels provided above men there is no lO~reut:d purcha~ commitment by Qwest NONPUBLIC DOCUMENT CONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA JUL 24 2002 10: 14 FR QWE5T 6L2 672 8911 TO 914155850443 99/09 :' ,c~!v.t'",~ ':'::-":.... \JC. ".-:. A tJ . - I ." H""'"~TERCONNEcrION AGREEMENT AMENDMENT n:RM~ . ,1 t~Y1J~ ~(MIUIO't subj~ ID ~/=ry,.."i4w can 'tIC/lAded i" IlItJ 1UMNl,,"1Ic./ or. \M' . . f'" O,,:.LJhnus Amecdmcn1 Agcement ("Amendment ) is made and entered into by and b=tween j tY1\.fc:.Leodt.:'SA Tcl=o~catiDns S~ces, Inc. ("McLeod") and Qwe$I Corpotlioon IF., .l.......w..-.. I'C ~ - - f&~ .I'NIIR! ~€'~I"" M"I)' ,It. ,..11 '~\kk 11t tHft .teP't'jMIJ ",. ~ ;~:/';';( Qwcst ) (collc;tivcly, the "Panies ) on tlris 1i!P:day of October.2000, (1 'f!CO~n4 ad,., tlris lire d4y b~o,~ tJ.e Snvit:1! tlfld Billlwt: A/(Ht!ltWrftl 11: l"1J11CS agree to dfd asd--fiJethis An2endment 115 IJ1lJ11endment ant!! it is jl'Meflsed\.;. ~ftcl'ld, ail )nlcrConn~eni- ("Aareetnel1t$" and, sinsuJarly, "Agreement ) bctw~n\11I:m, no\\, in effect or~~~ma prior 0 DCCCJnb~ 31 , 2003 , with rhe Amendment containingih!:! folluwif1g f1r"vis;ons , k ~ ~ --1.~We; ~.'\ +0 ~ ~ 'fl" c.J- ' tk;.J #J... 'Chi.:i Amendment IS mItred MltO bc:E\1icen tnc Panies bLSe4 on rhe followinQ c:onditi('n s , p.., ICJ 'f-"'."-41 ,.-.1 _.I'::-':;'~' _..... ) 77 1::I.w\~ c:..h1~lJd;t.4 " 1-, G1 rJ " ' ~- (Vt\I.l~.~ (flJ~ McL.eodliSA has purch~ed,1S oftbe end ofeacb ofth ca.lcnctaryears, 4T lo/i/otJ~",. M ,",chanS' Jules tOr resale !Tom Qwe51 h!voua/lou''hc 1.-5111' are. who.. .." 1"13'/..I..l...r:u I~.... UlcumOcnt local exchange carTIer) ,/. L,~ /'\ .., .:L. ,CW,. ,r' - ~ '-t' .. Qwest and Mcleod USA cwnntJ)' hive an a ment, on a resion.wide basis, ff' "'Rtoi!!l' UULJ agrcerncftts--for tb; exchange of Jocal triffic on I "bilJ ADd keep" basis, which provide~lur tht m1.ltU.&l recovery at'COStS through the offsetting ofreciproc:af obliBations. Cor local ~~ e)(ch8J'lj;~ cr.-We: which OriSinal1S with I CUS1oma-s of one compilUJY ..imlJ1.I.~Q.m.QA~~~T~wjrcb for men DUmOie\and terminates to a C\lSlomer of (he other COmpany. ~~ .:J'- I, "l'ha pan;.. ,.;sb to CStobIiG. ...i.....,o-....i.." ,c',.o",Np and have 'S'ecd .v-~ tn~ they will ancrnpr lO resolve all differences or issue! that may arise unde~ the Agreements or :::J?im ~~ I;~::; I ~~~=~;':::=:~~~~, ~ ~ = Ie ~ ~ ;~=~=:. ;~: :-;::. .lil;.. lhe ~.~,;::.~ ~;.;:;; :~. :~ Io ~~ ..; ~~ ?h ;:;= =: '- ...s......,..,......, 0"" or ""...."..." . 0' g . "" *"'" D(...t I !4~I y.~l. IS .,.t . ' ~~",,;~~i.8'0 '" ~",vi,i.". or,.. .\ole"!'.., ~ ~,.1.tCONTAINS TRADE SECRET DATA ru.i)~ " "de Sm.~~~5 ** TOTAL PAGE, as ** ~: ~l t ~~!r~~8(ns\~lIaeey e.t ~'. 8:A.'JwaJ' 'J tM"ll'R Sf .~eeeii9r~)i f'. ~!!::'\; rli.I.o8 .---- -.- t , : ~ "I!J.a ('fSttp!i;eRLJ.f Vi.. P,uiseflts. - ,-. --'- ~i~r8 7i:the'/~re~ ( llSe, ~r ~eee5!'""'" ):I I Q bu1i"~~5 611\.'$ Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise, Idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 71 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T P421/C-O2-197 Exhibit No. WCD- Serrlemenr Agreement This Settlement :\greemen! (rhis "-\~reemem ) is dared \lJrch 1. 200: (rhe Effecri'"e Dare ). and is bet\\een Q\\es! CorporaTIon. a Colorado corporarioll ("!. JllC Eschelon Teiecom. Inc.. a Delaware coflJorarlon (Eschelon ), Q'\"esr and Escheion are rer"erred to col!ecri,'e!\' as the "Panie," and indi,idualh' as the "Pam. ---= '\\- nereas. Q\\'esi IS 311IIlcumbem local exchange caITJer operatll1f ill 1i1~ SlJtes or" Arizona. Colorado. .Idaho. 10'\'a. \'1lI1J1esqrJ. .\Ionrana. \"eoraska. e\\ .\IeXICO. \"onh OJI-.:O(;':.Oregon. South Dal-.:ota. Lrah. \\"ashlIlgron. and Wyoming: \\' hereas. Eschelon is a comperiri'"e local exchange catTier operating 111 the stares of .-\rizona. Colorado. .\1innesota. Oregon. L'rah. and Washington. as well as \"e'"ada: Whereas. each of the Panle:s seeks ro a"oid delay and costly litigation and ro resohe cenall1 issues in dispute" Q\\esr and Eschelon therefore agree as follows: I. Definitions \\' ha, used in this Agreemen!. the follo\\'ing terms ha\'e thefollo\\'ing meanings: -\CI " means the T ekCOmil1UnlC3rlons .-\cr of J 996. CABS " means C!ITJer ;)'::::S::- billll1g system. Claims " means. II1dl\lduJII: ;)nd collecti\'ely. each and every claIm. action. causes of action. sui!. demand. damage. -,uJ~'Tllen!. execu!lon. cos!. expense. liability. conrro'ersy. setoff. omission. ;)nd los5 ("If ;111: kind whatsoever. whether known or unknown. whether in Ja\\ or In equit:-. Incjudln~ ;111: rcbted Interest expenses that may ha\'e :1ccrued inconnection rhere\\'llh. from the b~gll1n1n~ l,f lime through February 28. 2002. that Eschelon or Qwest has. had or may ha\"e agJlI1s! tn;: ("Ither Pan: arising out of the Disputes throughFebruary 28.2002, Disputes" me:Ins. for Ih:: tlm:: renod through February 28. 200~: (I) disputesconceming ser'\"ice credits: (2 I Jlsrutt:.s- ~~)I1i:::ml!1g consulting and network-related services provided by Eschelon to Qwes!. (.~ I C.-\B:::' dlsrutcs concerning switched access minutes of use;(4) disputes concerning pa~Jnenr of L'\"E.E Ime and L~E-E Non-Recurring Charge credits; and 15) disputes concerning Eschelon s Cl:1II11:. at" :Inti-competitive conduct and unfair competition. Inrerconnectlon .-\~reemc:nt". means the interconnection agreements and all amendments thereto filed wllh the PL'C In ~ach stare in which Eschelon obtaInS services andfacilities from Owes!. PUC means stare public utility commission. 03/06/02 10:40 AM SertJemerll Agreemerll Page I of 6 Q110653 IDC" 6696J,"5" '1.8567~ d Tenmnated-\!?reemerm" has the meaning set forth In paragraph ~(b) belo\\ l"-" means l'nbundled \"et\\"ork Element - Eschelon. J product purch.1sedby Eschelon under ItS Interconnecrion Agreemenr. as amended in \o\"ember of '::000 J.nd Julyand Augusr of 2001. '\E-P" means l'nbundJed \"em"ork Element - Plarfoml" .., Release of Claims " (a) For \"aluable consideration to be paid by Qwest toEschelon as pro\"ided in Paragraph .3(.1) below. Eschelon hereby fuJly waives. releases. acquits.and discharges Qwest and its associates. owners. stockholders. Successors. assigns. parrners.parents. Jnsur:mce can-iers. bonding companies. affiliates and subsidiaries. and each of their respeCIl\ e dlreclOrs. officers. agem5. employees and representatives from any and all Claimsarising out or the Disputes through February ~S. ~OO~" Inl In consideratIon Mthe waiver and release described in Paragraph 2(.1)abo\"O\\ cst hL'reby fully Wal\"es, reJeases, acquits. and discharges Eschelon and its associates. owners. stodholders. successors. asslgllS. p:mners. parents. insurance can-iers. bonding comp:m Je5. J fti II ates and 5ubsldl:m ::'5. Jna e:.!ch 0 their respecti \"e directors. 0 fficers. agents.employees :mJ rcpresent.:J.ti\"es from aJ1~ and all ClaJnlS arising out of the Disputes throughFebruar~ ~S" ~()U~" -\C!lom te"' h;:" TJ~en The Panies sh.:J.JI undertake the foJlowing actions: (a I On the EffecIl\"c Date. Qwest shall provide paymenr. using creditsto Eschelon In.:J.n amount equal to"91~.(JOO. with offsets as follows: (i) apply 56.380.000against l'?\E-E charges and assocIated chJrges that are not disputed by the Parries as of February ~8. 2002: and (ii) apply and credl! 51.53':.00(1 whIch sum represents 57 912.000 less56.3S0.00(j against all cun-ent and non,dlsputed in\"oicesrhat are payable by Eschelon toQwesl. Eschelon shall deteml1ne how the ofiset amounts in each of clauses (i) and (ii) will be applied and shall so designate In wntln~ (('I OWesI wlIhin ten days of the Effective Date. (b) For COI1\ enlCI1CC and \"arious reasons. the Parries hereby tenninatethe follo\\lng agreements ("TermlnJ!ed-\\.:r~emenrs ). as oflhe Effective Date: (J) 1:2) ( .3 ) (~) (5 ) Feature Let!er dated ~o\"emher 15" '::UUU.Implementa!lon Plan Leiter dated ~o\emher 15.2000;EscaJa!lon procedures and buSIncSS solu!lon let!er dated November j 5 2000;Confidential Purchase Agreement daled So\"ember 15. 2000;Confidential Amendment 10 ConfidentIal Trade Secret Stipulation daled November 152000: Third Amendment to ConfIdentIal Trade Secret Agreement dated July , 2001;Status of switched access mJnule reponing lener dated July 3 2001; andImplementation Plan dated July 31. 2001/August 1 2001. (6) (i) (8 ) 03/06/02 1040 AM Serrlemen.! Agreemen.c DC - 669831.3" 01.88679 ,. Page 2 of 6 Q II 0654 Ic I Attachment 3 to the Implementation Plan dated July 3!. 1001 AU!2:Ust I. 2001 relatim: to L""\"E-E will continue to bind the Parties unless the PartJes at:-'Tee otherwis; in a \\Tjun~ execu;ed b\' both Parties, Eschelon as::rees that Owest wiJl file thIS Attachment 3 as an amendment to the Interconnection Agreement, Id) The BdlIng t"Sage letter dated \o\'ember J 5. :000 \\dl t'1;:- tem1inated \\'hen the Parties agree the manual process is tem1inated and Eschelon n10\'eS ((1 themechanized process described in Paragraph 3tgJ below (e) Q\\'est shaIl make the LT1\E-E offering and existing. business processes related to the L:-iE-E offering anilabJe to EscheJon through the current tem1 of the , Interconnection Agreement Amendment T ems dated November 15. 1000. (fj \\"Ithin ten days of the Effective Date. the Parties shall form ajoint leam, The purpose of the join! team shall be to de\'eJop a mutuaIly acceptable plan (the "Plan ) tocom'en L "):E-E lines to L '?\E - p, Q\\'est and Eschelon shal1 use best effol1S to cooperate convening L -:\E-E lines to L ~'P In accordance with the Plan.. (g) Qwest and Eschelon shall work closely together in movingEsche!on from a manual to a mechanized process so that Eschelon can bil1 for access on UNE-The Panies shall work closely for b(1 days t(1 \'aJjdate working telephone numbers and associated minutes of use. and wiJl termInate the manual process after these 60 days with the consent of both Parries. I r the partJes are unable to a~ree on the date of the termination of the manual process. then the Panies shall folio\\' the procedures described in paragraph 8 below (h) Le\el ~ EscalatIon , Lpon execUtion of this Agreement. Eschelon February S. 2002 request for a Le\'el .3 escalation will be deemed permanently withdrawn. ~, Successors and ASSIL'TlS , The terms and conditions contained in this Agreement shall inure to the benelit of and be binding upon. the respective successors. affiliates and assi gns f the Parties, 5, Assi!2:nment 0f C'la1n1S \0 Pany has assigned or transferred to any personany ClaIm. or ponion of any Claim. releJscd or discharged by this Agreement. 6, Filin~ of AIITeement.The Parties agree that negotiation of this Agreement is subj ect to Ru Ie 408 of the Federal R u \es 0 f Evidence. and similar rules at the state level.Notwithstanding the foregoing. nothing In this Agreement shalJ prevent a Party from asserting aclaim agaInst the other Party to enforce thIs Agreement and nothing herein shall bar a Party from filing this Agreement as it deems necessary and appropriate in order to comply with state or federal law . or in connection wllh a relevant legal or regulatory proceeding in which Qwest or Eschelon is a party. Qwest and Eschelon expressly contemplate that this Agreement will be filed 03/06/02 1040 AM Serf/erneI'Ll Agreernel'Ll Pag!: 3 of 6 Q 11 0655\\\DC .66983'.5. -'"B867Q\'2 \\" irh the Pl'Cs In its region In states \\here Eschelon is certiiied and has an interconnec!lol1 a2:reement" Entire ,-\!2Teement: Amendments " This Agreement constitutes the eIl!ire a!2Teemem between the Parties, This A!2Teement can be amended or changed only in a \\Tilin~ or ritings executed by both of the Parties~ except that this Agreemem must not be Jmended or modified in any \\-ay by electronic message or e-maiJ "communications, s" - DISDute Resolu!lon " Each Pany-reserves its rights to resort to all remedJes. Including seeking resolution by a PLT or a court. agency. arbitrator. or regulatory authority of competent jurisdiction C)" \"otices, Except as otherwise pro\'idedin this Agreement. every notice other communication to a Pany required. pern1irred or contemplated under this Agreement must be in \\TI!ln~ Jnd 13) ser."ed personall~, In which case delivery will be deemed to Occur at the time and on rhe day of delivery: (b) dell\ered by certified mail or registered mail. postage prepaid. rctum rt:celpt requested. In \\"hlch case delivery will be deemed to occur the day it isofficIally rc:corJt:U by the l'.S, PostJ! Ser."lce as deli\"ered to the intended recipient: or (c)delivered b~ ne\t-day deli\"ery \0 a L"S address by recognized o\'ernight delivery service such asFederal E\jlrL'ss. In \\"hlch case Jeli\er~ \\ ill be deemed to occur upon receipt. upon prioragreement ot'thc Panles ' designated reCIpients identified below. notice may also be provided by facsimile" E\ccrt 3S Dlher.\lse pro\lded In thIs Agreement. every notice or other communication must be dell\"ered US1n~ oneofthe alremJtl\es mentioned in this paragraph and must be directedto the applicJbk address Indicated hcl(1\\ or such address as the Pany to be notified has desIgnated by gJ\"mg \\Tllten notice In compilJnce \\"lIh this paragraph: If 10 O\\"est I f to Eschelon: Qwest Corporallon Anention: General Counsel 801 California Street. Sulle 520(1 Denver. Colorado 80202 Tel: (303) 6-:-:-2700 Fax: (303) 295- 70-t6 Esthelon Telecom. Inc, Allention: General Counsel 730 2"..J Avenue. Suite 1200 \1mneapolis. M?\ jj402 Tel: (612) 436-6692 Fax: (612) 436-6792 10, \0 \"31\ Tht..' PJnlCS ;Jgree that their entering into this Agreement is without prejudIce to. and does nOI \\ JI\:':, ;Jn~ positions they may have taken previously. or may take in the future. in any legIslJtl\ c. rc~uIJtor~. Judicial. or other forum addressing any matters other than the Claims, II, \:0 AdmissIon The P;mles acknowledge and agree that they have legitimate disputes relatIng to the Issues desCrIbed in this Agreement. and that the resolution reached in this Agreement represents a compromise of the Parties ' positions. Therefore , thePanies deny any wrongdoIng or IlabJiny and expressly agree that resolution of the Issues 03;06;02 1040 AM Setliemenl Agreemenl Pag~ 4 of Q 11 0656'-IDC" 66983/"5 - 01.88679..2 contained in this A.greemenr cannot be used against th~ other Pany in any manner or In Jn~forum (exc~pt for cJairns related to breaches of this .-\greemenrL 1':. Counternans . This Agreement may be executed by facsimile and in counterpans. each of which is an original and aIJ of which together constitute one and the sameInstrument. EXECl"TlO.'\ PAGE FOLLOWS 03/06/02 1040 AM Setllement Agreement Pag~ 5 of 6 QII06S7DC "bb98Ji"S . 01-88679," Counrerpart Execution Page Settlement Agreement The undersigned are executing this Senlement .-\greement on th;;- OJt;;' stJted III the introductory clause, Q\\'EST CORPOR-\ TIO!" , ----.., \- B\" Ii:" - ' , ! L - \ ~ame: Dana Filip Title: Senior Vice President ESCHELO:\ TELECOM. I!'\c. B\' :\ame: Cli ford D, Williams Title' Chief Executi\'e Officer 03/06/02 10:40 AM Serzlemen.! Agreemerll Pag~ 6 of 6 Q 11 0658 \ \ IDC - 6698J/"5 . .1"88679 '. Idaho Public Utilities Commission Office of the SecretaryRECEIVED AUG 1 6 2007 Boise. idaho Deanhardt, C. - Exhibit 72 Case No. Q WE- T -06- AT&T - ,- "::-~"'~_ ~:r $:- c:~~ -- --'.- 1---'-, :.. :~~' ;L, Lyle Patrick 07/231200005:03 PM To: James T. BalvanzlMCLEOD~MCLEOD, Joseph P. TerflerIMCLEOD(g)MCLEOD. Jamie J. LochINorthlMCLEOD~MCLEOD - - --- cc: Joseph H. CeryaneclMCLEOD(g)MCLEOD Subject: Re: Overview of Owest Mtg FYI, and it looks like some Rassistance work- coming your way. ____ Forwarded by Lyle PalricklMCLEOD Ol\ 07/2312000 05:19 PM , - --.-..:-.;:~ '- ~~~~/ ~~;O ~~l6 To: Clark E. McLeodIMCLEOD(g)MCLEOD, Roy A. WilkenslMCLEODC9)MCLEODcc: Lyle PatricklMCLEOD(g)MCLEOD Subject: Re: Overview of Owest Mtg Net, neL..., A very good meeting with O. TIme will tell how effective....... SCG Forwarded by Stephen C. GraylMCLEOD on 07/21/2000 05:06 PM - , ,.";-,-../,;"'-:" L.-- BlakeO. Fisher 07/2012000 12:21 PM To: Stacey D, StewartlMCLEOD(Q)MCLEOD, Randall E. RingslMCLEODrg)MCLEODcc: Stephen C. GrayIMCLEOD~MCLEOD Subject: Re: Overview of Owest Mtg Stacy, I think your recap is good. I have the following additional observations and recommend we get a joint plan together covering the what by when by who. I have copied Steve for his information. Business Philosophy: Go forward transactions make good business sense for both parties (win win)Work toward a long-term relationship Quest is primarily focused on wholesale. McleodUSA on retail market share. Phase 1 Activities 1. Make clear to Quest that the Une -P platform is partially of interest because of access revenue. 2. Identify CO's assuming Une-P economics that we could add (also assume DSL and voice messaging would be available). I estimate that 80 to 85 ales people could replace the revenue loss to Quest of lowering our resale prices to Une-P in twelve months. 3. Identify CO's that we would consider leaving on -switch for Quest with Une-P pricing. 4. Talk with Quest next week about moving to a proposal that could include volume discounts. ~:::":"""'~";"~: ::":.:.--,,- Phase 2 Activities CONFIDENTIAL . .."_.""'..? 1. Get commitment on trunking needs. 2. Get cage delivery schedule based on 45 day time frame rather than 90. 3. Establish clear process and escalation procedures within both network orgs. Phase 3 Activities 1. Out of region LD opportunities 2. Joint build possibilities. 3. Splitrock needs. Maybe they could help with in-region IMT's Phase 4 Activities 1. Randy to contact Steve Davis. 2. Identify filings that are -anticompetive' and escalate 3. Understand go forward pricing and regulatory agendas. 4. Possible 271 discussions. Stacey D. Stewart .' . .'. ..........:.....-.. .., " L:.. L- Stacey D. Stewart 07120/2000 10:12 AM To: Blake O. Fisher/MCLEOD(Q)MCLEODcc: Stacey D. StewarVMCLEOD(Q)MCLEOD Subject: Overview of Owest Mtg Blake,Randy Below is a recap of what we discussed yesterday along with a list o~ action items. Can you review andgive me some feedback. Attendees: Greg Casey, Executive Vice President Wholesale, Owest Judy Tinkham, Vice President (regulated) Wholesale Services Joe Dalton, Vice President (unregulated) Wholesale Services Audrey McKenney, Vice President Wholesale Markets Finance Blake FIsher Randy Rings Stacey Stewart Openings Comments: - Casey expressed Owest's desire to 1everage' the wholesale markets much more going forward- He said he wanted McLeodUSA to be 'flagship' wholesale carrier in their footprint- They want to provide additional services at reasonable rates - They want us to be successful, since there belief is that 'j( McLeodUSA is successful then Owest wouldbe successful' . - He declared that USWest is dead and Owest is in charge and their mind set is not as an RBOe- They clearly understand the importance of wholesale business - They want to leverage McLeod across their footprint especially in smaller markets - To help prove that they re serious, they have dropped 17 of 21 pending commission complaints across the region and the rest soon. - They want to form a business to business relationship or more like it should be a vendor to customer - relationship in region. . - :f='.fi,,~ If they r~ ,still issues lingering, he wanted them identified and detailed (product, pricing, functionality) . . ~ He wants to 'cut a deal' on line cost, period.- They re impatient, they want results so they want to begin taking action CONFIDENTIAL ". -. . .~~:,~;~' ::f;,i.~: '::~~.-~":-- r~. ~;,. ':: '~ . Other discussion items: --- ..--. - Opportunities for co-construction - Network sharing - Delivery issues - Out of region desires, SplitRock specific - Open discussions, unless both parties agree it's 'on the record' Assessment: - Cautiously optimistic - Same conversation we had with Kelley months ago (but this was during Sol reign) - They seemed sincere about writing down their revenue for the prospect of added revenue in region and especially out of region - We need to be sure we ask for exacUy what we want, because we may just get it and then we have nobody to blame but us. - DSL and VM resale would be a great addition to the mix. - Even though it appears that we ll get some nice bones, we need to negotiate on every detail It would sure be nice working business to business without every ~oncem being regulatory.- Only time will prove their claims Plan: - Phased approached recommended (could happen in parallel) - Phase 1- CentrexlUNE-Z Pricing proposal - Phase 2- Network to Network discussions - Phase 3- Joint Planning Meeting Phase 4- Legal to Legal meeting ,_. Action Items: - Line Cost Proposal - Need to establish pricing target (with access rev) (Stacey/Jim Balvanz) - Need to determine platform (UNE-P, CTX, UNE-Z) (all) - How many lines can we commit to and for what period (Balvanz) - How do features add in. (Balvanz and marketing) - What's the differential by state In UNE-L(colo) and UNE-Z if we were going to not deploy addedcolos (Balvanz) . - Colocation Assessment - What stage are we in where (LochlNovakiGraham) - What price would we need to delay or abort (BalvanzILoch) - How do we reprioritize based on new keeping UNE-Z (BalvanzILoch)- Forecast - co level, lines on-switch vs. resale lines (StaceylLoch) - potential feature mix (Stacey/marketing) : u c:-S~-;:-:'i~:::~~~~;:;J;t' :~' .~ .. ! CONFIDENTIAL