20060928Motion to dismiss Part II.pdf

"""'--'--'U_'--'-------------""..---.
"...-...... .
EXHIBIT
Appendix 1
Form A-
CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
accordance wi th the terms and conditions of the License Agreement No. -I-901C. thi s
duit Occupancy License Number 88-is hereby granted this 11 th dayJuly19~. This license allows Li'censee to occupy Licensor conduitsystem as indicated on the attached Form A-3. with cable. equipment and facilitiesspecified on the attached Forms A-4 an6 A-
This l1cense shaH continue for an initial term of twenty (20) years commencing on thelicense date first written above. This license sha11 continue after the initial term forsuccessive terms of five (5) years unless terminated by either party hereto.
Licensor estimates completion of the make-ready work hereunder to be on or before
, 1 988
FEES AND CHARGES
A) General
1) Occupancy fees commence on the first day of the calendar month during which AT&T begins
the placement of their facilities in the llcensed innerduct. or June 1 . 1990, whichever date comes fi rst.
2) The total occupancy fees due hereunder. sha 11 be based upon the number ofductllnnerduct feet of duct for whlch licenses have been issued.
81)
For the purpose of determining the duct feet, chargeable, the duct considered occupied
~'
sha 11 be measured from the:
center to center of adjacent manholes. or
(i1) center of manhole to the end of a duct not terminated in a manhole.
B) Charges applicable under this license are as follows:
Recurring Charge(s):F or one (l) i nnerduct
From Birch toFi 1 more Street in Jerome , Idaho.
652 feet ~ 3.25/ft./yr. $15.119.00/yr.
Nonrecurring Charge(s). (such as make-ready fees. supervision fees):
None
THE AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND
TiLEGRAPH COMPANY
(Li censee)
SIGNED:
THE MOUNTAIN STATES TELEPHONE
AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY
(L censor)
SIGNED: \
NAME:
TITLE:
Chuck Mei er NAME:
TITLE:Executi ve Di rector
Network ties
-": 1f
OHE:
OJ stri ct Manager
Pt' "
... ""'"
:",UL .
;'.'.)
DATE:
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page I of20
Appendix 1
Form A-
APPLICATION FOR CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
In accordance with the terms and conditions of the L1 cense Agreement No.
OOIC, dated May 28. 1988 application is hereby made for alicense to occupy the conduit system shown on Form A-3. with the cable andequipment detailed on Forms A-4 andA-5. This request will be designated as:
Conduit System Occupancy Appl ication No. 88-
From Birch to Filmore Street in Jerome, Idaho.
(1) (hereinafter C.O. No.
li censee hereby reque s ts L1 censor to spec i fy the fees and charges as soci a tedwith the above request. Such fees and charges shall be specified on Form A-
Spec; fy party that wi 11 perform:
J) Installation of Ucensee communi.cation facilities in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Const. Dept.
2) Modifications to Licensee communication facllaies in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
3) Mal ntenance
conduit system:
Licensee communication facilities in Licensor
American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
4) Removal services of Llcensee s communication facnities in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Const. Dept.
American Telephone and Telegraph Company
(Licensee)
Signed:
Pri nt Name:Chuck Me; er
Title:District Mana
Date:UUrt2 1985
(1) Individual applications to be numbered in sequential ascending order by
Licensee for each License Agreement. Licensor will process applications insequenti al ascendi ng order accordi ng to the app 1 i cati on numbers as signed the Li censee.
. ;
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 2 of20
. ,, ;
Fi lmore
Street
, '
American Telephone and Tele~ph Company
(Licensee)
, (C.s.O. Application No.
Idaho - Birch to Filmore Street in Jerome.
Appendix I
Form A-3
CONDUITIINNERDUCT SYSTEM DIAGRAM
(Ll censee will provi de d\agram of requested condui t system route)
652"
B'rch
Tel CoO
Telco Site
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 3 of20
Appendix 1
Form A-
American Telephone and Tele~aph Company
(Licensee)
(C.s.O. Application No.
CABLE TO OCCupy CONDmT SYSTEMS
Idaho - Birch to Ftlmore Street in Jerome.
Meta lli c
Cab 1 e Ht. lbs.Sheath Type Max.Max.TypeDesignationinchesperVol tage CurrentFootSh i e 1 d Cable . to Gnd.in any Jacket
~T no
AC ,
I DC
Conductor.(a)(b)(c)(d) (d)(e)(f) (f)
SM-
042 X-P1 36 F N/A Poly
(a) Cable Designation AssIgn letter , alphabetically,of cable to be installed.
(b) 0. Inches Outside diameter of the cable.
(c) Ht. lbs. per foot self explanatory.
(d) Metallic Sheath or Shield self explanatory.
(e) TYDe of Cable Show size and gauge,(e.g.. 16-22),
(f) Mox. Voltage to Gnd.self explanatory
, (g)
Max. Current in any Conductor Indicate ~oltage.
(h) Type of JacKet Enter type of ma teri a 1 of the
(poiyethylene, PVC, or lead. etc.
to each different type
outer jacket or sheath
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 4 of20
Appendix 1
Form A-
; .
erican Telephone arid Telegraph Company
~eDSee)
(C.O. Application No.\II
EQUIPMENT HOUSINGS TO BE PLACED IN MANHOLES
Idaho - BI rch to Filmore Street in Jerome.
Location Hei Wi dth We; aht uanti t
1 C.O. + 9,800 Splice Case 2S"25 1 bs .
O. + 19.6000 and every 9800 I to end condui t run.
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 5 of20
Appendix I
Form A-
CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
accordance with the terms and conditions of the License Agreement No. I-OO1C. thi s, ju it Occupancy Li cense Number , 88-1 s hereby granted thi s 11 th dayJuly19~. Thi s 1 i cense allows Licensee to occupy li censor I s conduitsystem as ind1cated on the attached Form A-3, with cable equipment and facilitiesspecified on the attached Forms A-4 and A-
This license shall continue for an inithl term of twenty (20) years commencing on theli cense date fi rst written above. Thi s license shall continue after the i nHi a 1 term forsuccessive terms of five (5) years unless terminated by either party hereto.
Licensor estimates completion of the make-ready work hereunder to be on or before
, 1
FEES AND CHARGES
A) General
1) Occupancy fees commence on the first day of the calendar month during which AT&T beginsthe placement of their facilities in the licensed innerduct . or June 1, 1990. wMchever date comes fi rst.
2) The total occupancy fees due hereunder shall be based uponduct/innerduct feet of duct for which licenses have been issued.the number
8)
For the purpose of determining the duct feet chargeable. the duct considered occUpied~ sha 11 be measured from the:
(i) center to center of adjacent manholes. or
(i i) center of manho1 e to the end of a duct not termi nated 1n a manhol
B) Charges applicable under this license are as follows:
Recurring Charge(s):For one (1) i nnerduct
From 619 Bannock (Boise Main) to Federal Way & Amity
2S.S26 feet ~ 3.Zs/ft./yr. $82.959.S0/yr.
Nonrecurring Charge(s) , (such as make-ready fees. supervision fees):
None
THE AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND
TELEGRAPH COMPANY
(l i censee)
THE MOUNTAIN STATES TELEPHONE
AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY
. ::::
~~n:7 :.:G.t
TITLE: Executive Director
Netwqrk acll i ti es
DI-."iE: IS Cri
SIGNED:
NAME:
TITLE:
Chuck Me
DATE:
District Manager
irur f 2 KJRS
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 6of 20
Appendix 1
Form A-
APPLICATION FOR CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
In accordance wi th the terms and conditions of the Li cense Agreement No.
OO1C. dated May 28. '1988 application is hereby made for alicense to occupy the conduit system shown on Form A-3. with the cable andequipment detailed on Forms A-4 and A-5. This request will be designated as:
Conduit System Occupancy Application No. 88-(1) (hereinafter C.O. No.From 619 Bannock (Boise Main) to Federal Way & Amityft.,
Licensee hereby requests Licensor to specify the fees and charges associatedwith the above request. Such fees and charges shall be specified on Form A-
Specify party that will perform:
1) Installation of licensee communication facilities in licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Const. Dept.
2) Modifications to Licensee communication facilities in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
3) Maintenance of
condui t system:
licensee communication facUities in UcensorAmerican Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Opr,ns. Dept.
.in Removal services of Licensee s communication facilities in licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Const. Dept.
Ameri can Te 1 ephone and Telegraph Company(ll censee)
Signed:~~lL-
Print Name:Chuck Mei er
Tt tl e:Di stri ct Mana
Date:Uor 1 2 1988
(1) Individual applications to be numbered in sequential ascending order byL1 censee for each 11 cense Agreement. Li censor wi11 process appl i cations sequenti a 1 ascendi ng order accordi ng to the app 11 cation numbers assigned bythe licenseE.
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 7 of 20
American Telephone and Tele~aph Company
(Licensee)
(C.s.O. Application No.
Idaho - 619 Bannock (Boise Main) to Federal Way & Amity.
Appenmx 1
Form A-
CONDUITIINNERDUCT SYSTEM DIAGRAM
(Licensee wi 1l provide diagram of requested conduit system route)
25,526'
Federal Hay
& Ami ty
Boise Main
619 Bannock
Telco Site
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 8 of20
tt:
Appendix 1
Form
American Telephone and Telegraph Company
(Licensee)
(C.O. Application No.
CABLE TO OCCUpy CONDUIT SySTEMS
Idaho - 619 Bannock (Boise Main) to Federal Way & Amity.
Meta 11 i c
Cab 1 e Wt. 1 bs .Sheath Type Max.Max.TypeDes i gnation inches per Vol tage CurrentFootShieldCab 1 e to Gnd.i n any Jacketye ~I no AC I DC Conductor(a)(b)(c)Cd) (d)(e)(f) (n
SM-042 P 1 Y 36 F N/A Poly
(a) Cable. Designation Assign letter , alphabetical1y,
of cable to be installed.
(b) D. Inches Outside diameter of the cable.
(c) Wt. lbs. per foot self explanatory.
(d) Metallic Sheath or Shield self explanatory.
(e) Type of Cable Show size and gauge (e.. 16-22).
(f) Max. Voltage to Gnd.self explanatory
(9) Max. Current in any Conductor Indicate voltage.
(h) Type of Jacket Enter type of ma teri a 1 of the
(polyethylene. PVC. or lead. etc.
to each different type
outer jacket or sheath
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 9 of20
Appendix 1
Form A-
erican Telephone and Tele~aph CompanyW:ensee)
, (C.s.O. Application No.
EQUIPMENT HOUSINGS TO BE PLACED IN MANHOLES
Idaho - 619 Bannock (Boise Main) to Federal Way & Amity.
Location He i Wi dth He i uanti
1 C.O. + 9.800 Splice Case 25"25 1 bs.
2 C.O. + 19.6000 and every 9800' to end conduit run.
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT- T-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 10 of20
'-:
Appendix 1
Form A-
CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
accordance with the terms and conditions of the license Agreement No. I-001C. this~ui t Occupancy License Number 88-is hereby granted thi s 11 th dayVl July 19~. This license allows Licensee to occupy Licensor s conduitsystem as indicated on the attached Form A-3. with cable. equipment and facilitiesspecified on the attached Forms A-4 and A-5.
Thh license shall continue for an initial term of twenty (20) years comencing on theJicensedate first written above. This license shall continue after the initial term forsuccessive terms of five (5) years unless terminated by either party hereto.
Licensor estimates completion of the make-ready work hereunder to be on or before
, 19
FEES AND CHARGES
A) Genera 1
1) Occupancy fees commence on the first day of the calendar month during which AT&T beginsthe placement of their facilities in the licensed innerduct. or June 1 . 1990, whichever date comes first.
2) The total occupancy fees due hereunder shall be basedduct/i nnerduct feet of duct for whi ch 1 i censes have been issued.upon the number of
3) For the purpose of determining the duct feet chargeable. the duct considered occupied) shall be measured from the~
, -
(i) center to center of adjacent manhol es, or
(ij) center of manhole to the end of a duct not terminated in a manhole.
B) Ch~rges app 1 i cab 1 e under th is 1 i cense are as follows:
Recurring Charge(s):For one (1) i nnerduct
From Boise Main to Mer1dan. Linder Rd. & Pine.
64.129ft ~ $3~2S/ft./yr. $208 419.2s/yr.
Nonrecurring Charge(s), (such as make-ready fees, supervision fees):
None
THE AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND
TELEGRAPH COMPANY
(Licensee)
THE MOUNTAIN STATES TELEPHONE
AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY
(Licensor)
SIGNED:
NAME:Chuck Me i er
TITLE:Di stri ct Manaaer
DATE:nUL 1 2 198
NAME:
TITLE:Executive Director
Netwo~ %i1 ities
'i RDATE:
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-AT &TComplaint, Page II of 20
, ~.::,
American Telephone and TeleJ?;I'8ph Company
(Licensee)
(C.s.O. Application No.
Idaho - Boise Main to Meridan. Linder Rd. 'Pine.
Appendix 1
Form A~
CONDUITIINNERDUCT SYSTEM DIAGRAM
(Licensee will provide diagram of requested conduit system route)
1291
Mer1 dan Li nder Rd.
& Pine
Bo1se Main
619 Bannock
Tel co SHe
AT&T SUe~
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 12 of 20
Appendix 1
Form A-4
American Telephone and Tele~aph Company
(Licensee)
(C.s.O. Application No.
CABLE TO OCCUpy CONDUIT SySTEMS
Idaho - Boise Main to Meridan, Linder Rd. & Pine.
Meta lli c
Cab 1 e Wt. 1 bs.Sheath Type Max.Max.TypeDesignationnchesperVol tage CurrentFootShieldCableto Gnd.in any Jacket
~1 no
AC I DC Conductor(a)(b)(c)(d) (d)(e)(f) (f)
SM-
042 P 1 Y 36 F N/A Poly
(a) Cable Designation Assign letter, alphabetically,of cable to be installed.
(b) D. Inches Outside diameter of the cable.
(c) Wt. .tbs. per foot self explanatory.
(d) Metallic Sheath or Shield self explanatory.
(e) Type of Cable Show size and gauge (e., 16-22).
(f) Max. Voltaae to Gnd.self explanatory
(g)
Max. Current in any Conductor Indicate voltage.
(h) Type of Jacket Enter type of material of the
(polyethylene, PVC. or lead. etc.
to each different type
outer jacket or sheath
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 13 of20
Appendix 1
Form A-5 tit
III8i.. "lerican Telephone and Telel!:I'aph Company
:ensee)
(C.5.0. Application No.
EQUIPMENT HOUSJNGSTO BE PLACED IN MANHOLES
Idaho -Boise Main to Meridan, L1nder Rd. & P ne.
Location Hei W, dth Wei uant, t
1 C.O. + 9.800 Sp 11 ce Case 25"25 lbs.
2 C.O. + 19.6000 and every 00' to end con duit run.
.--."
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 14 of20
tJ)
Appendix I
Form A-
APPLICATION FOR CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
In accordance with the terms and conditions of the License Agreement No.
OO1C, dated May 28, 1988 application is hereby made for a11 cense to occupy the conduit system shown ' on Form A-3, with the cabl e andequipment detailed on Forms A-4 and A-5. This request will be designated as:
Conduit System Occupancy Application No. 88-(1) (hereinafter C.O. No~)
~rom Boise Main to Meridan . Linder Rd. & Pine.
Li censee hereby requests Li censor to specify the fees and charges associatedwith the above request. Such fees and charges shall be specified on Form A-
Specify party that wi II perform:
1) Installation of Licensee communication facilities in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Const. Dept.
2) Modifications to Licensee communication facilities in Licensor
conduit system. American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
3) Maintenance of Licensee communication facilities in Licensor
conduit system: American TeleOhone & Telegraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
4) Removal services of Licensee s communication facil1ties in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & TeleQraph Co. (Const. Dept.
Ameri can Telephone and Te egraph Company(L i censee)
Si gned:C1~d-
Pr i nt Name:Chuck Me i er
n tle:Di stri ct Mana
Da te:1J1Jl 1 ? 1988
(1) Individual applications to be numbered in sequential ascending order byLicensee for each license Agreement. Licensor will process applications insequential ascending order according to the ' application numbers assigned by
the Licensee.
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 15 of 20
i.J"Appendix 1
Form A-
iI~CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY LICENSE
r" accordance with the terms and conditions of the License Agreement No. I-001C, this..ndui t Occupancy U cense Numbe,88-i s hereby granted thi s 28 th dayof May 19~. This licen-se a11ows Licensee to occupy Licensor'conduitsystem, as indicated on the attached Form A-3, with cable, equipment and facilitiesspecified on the attached Forms A-4 and A-
This license sha11 continue for an initial term of twenty (20) years commencing on thelicense date first written above. This license shall continue after the initial term forsuccessive terms of five (5) years unless terminated by either party hereto.
Licensor estimates completion of the make-ready work hereunder to be on or before
October l., 1 988
FEES AND CHARGES
A) General
1) Occupancy fees commence on the first day of the calendar month during which AT&T beg1ns
the pl acement of thei r facl1 iti es in the 1i censed i nnerduct, or June 1 , 1990, whi ever date comes first.
2) The total occupancy fees due hereunder shall be based uponduct/i nnerduct feet of duct for wh1 ch li censes have been i ssued.
Jl:!iR
For the purpose of determining the duct feet chargeable, the duct considered occupied
..,
shall be measured from the:
the number
(1 )center to center of adjacent manholes, or
(11) center of manhole to the end of.a duct not terminated in a manhole.
B) Charges appl1cable under this license are as follows:
Recurring Charge(s):For one (1) i nnerduct
From Pocatel1o Junction to Darby Road
300 feet ~ 2.75/ft./yr. $l2l 825.00/yr.
Nonrecurri ng Chargee s). (such as make-ready fees, supervi s ion fees):
None
THE AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND
TELEGRAPH COMPANY
(Licensee)
THE MOUNTAIN STATES TELEPHONE
AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY
(L i censor)
SIGNED:
NAME:
U/'iJw-
Chuck Me i er NAME:
TITLE:Executi ve Di rector
Network ities
TITLE:Di stri ct Manager
DATE: :t. tt APPROVED
JITN 2 2 19& TO fORM
1NLf(
DATE:
Exhibit 3,
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 16 of 20
, .. ,: '..~
Appendix 1
Form A-
APPLICATION FOR CONDUIT SYSTEM OCCUPANCY UCENSE
In accordance with the terms and conditions of the li cense Agreement No.001C , dated May 28.1988 appHcation is hereby made for alicense to occupy the conduit system shown on Form A-3, with the cable andequipment detailed on Forms A-4 and A-5. This request will be designated as:
Conduit System Occupancy Application No.(1) (hereinafter C.O. No.
Licensee hereby requests licensor to specify. the fees and charges associatedwith the above request. Such fees and charges shall be specified on Form A-
Specify party that will perform:
1) Installation of Licensee communication facilities in licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & TeleGraph Co. (Canst. Dept.
2) Modifications ' to Licensee l s conul1I.inicatlon facilities in Licensor
conduit system: American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
3) Ha i ntenance of
conduit system:
Ucensee communication fat; lit1es in Licensor
American Telephone & TeleGraph Co. (Oprns. Dept.
4) Removal services of licensee s communication facilities in Licensor
conduit system:' American Telephone & Telegraph Co. (Con st. Dept.
American Telephone and Teleqraph Company
(ll censee)
Signed:
Print Name:
~'~.L
Chuck Meier
Title:Oi stri ct ManaQer
, 6 -11 'e;; "JUN 22 1988Date:
(11 Individual applications to be numbered in sequential ascending order byL1 censee for each L1 cense Agreement. li censor will process appl1 cations i sequential ascending order according to the application numbers assigned bythe Licensee.
_..
J..
;;:;
J ;'(),~:vj
Attorney Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-T-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 17 of 20
American Telephone and Tele~ph, Company(Licensee)
Pocatello Junction to Darby Road.
Appendix 1
Form A-
CONDUIT/INNERDUCT SYSTEM DIAGRAM
(Licensee will provide diagram of requested conduit system route)
300'
(C.s.O. Application No.
Pocatel1o. Junction
Pocatel10 Matn
Telco Site
AT&T Site
Darby Road
(End Conduit)
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 18 of20
Appendix I
FormA-4
American Telephone and Tele~ph Company(Licensee)
(COS.O. Application No.
CABLE TO OCCUpy CONDUIT SYSTEMS
Idaho - Pocatel1o Junction to Darby Road
Meta 11i c
Cable Wt. lbs.Sheath Type Max.Max.TypeDesignationinchesperVol tage Current
Foot Sh1e 1 d Cab 1 e to Gnd.in any Jacket
~ I
AC 1 DC Conductor(a)(b)(c)(d) (d)(e)(f) (f)
SH-
042 Ply 36 f N/A Poly
(a) Cable Designation Assign letter. alphabetically,of cable to be installed.
(b) 0. Inches Outside diameter of the cable.
(c) Ht. 1bs. per foot self explanatory.
Cd) Metallic Sheath or Shield self explanatory.
(e) Type of Cable Show size and gauge (e.g.. 16-22).
(f) Max. Voltage to Gnd.self explanatory
(9) Max. Current in any Conductor Indicate voltage.
(h) Type of Jacket Enter type of materla1 of the
(polyethylene, PVC, or lead, etc.
to each di fferent type
outer jacket or sheath
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 19 of 20
Appendix I
Form A-5t '
1lerican Telephone and Tele~ Company
...
icensee)
(C.O. Application No.
EQUIPMENT HOUSINGS TO BE PLACED IN MANHOLES
Idaho - Pocatello Junction to Darby Road.
Location Hei Wi dth Wei uantit
1 C.O. + 9,800 Splice Case 25"25 .1 bs .
O. + 19.6000 and every 9800' to end conduit. run.
, j
Exhibit 3
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 20 of 20
..
EXHIBIT
AGREEMENT FOR TERMS AND CONDmONS FOR INTERCONNECTION,
UNBUNDLED NETWORK ELEMENTS, ANCILLARY SERVICES,
AND RESALE OF TELECOMMUNICATION SERVICES
BETWEEN
aWEST CORPORATION
AND
AT&T COMMUNICATIONS OF TIfE MOUNTAIN STATES, INC.
IN TIff STATE OF IDAHO
;. '
OwestlAT&T-
CD5-040129-0006 - i-
Exhibit 4
~ase # ATT-T~O4-AT&T Complaint, Page 1 of 19
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION 1.0 - GENERAL TERMS/NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT .............................................
SECTION 2.0 -INTERPRETATION AND CONSTRUCTION ..................................................... 5
SECTION 3.0 - CLEC INFORMATION .......................................................................................
SECTION 4.0 - DEFINITIONS.................................................................................................... 9
SECTION 5.0 - TERMS AND CONDITIONS ............................................................................ 29
GENERAL PROVISIONS ....... .....
........,.. """""""
................................................ ............ 29
TERM OF AGREEMENT .......:......................................................................................." 30PROOF OF AUTHORIZATION .................................................................,........................ 30
PAYMENT AND DEPOSIT ............................................................................................." 31
TAXES """"""""""" ......,..... ......................................... ....."....... ... ............................ 32
INSURANCE ................................................. ....... ..."................. ................................... 33
FORCE MAJEURE..
....................... ...... ...................... ............. ..... ......... ............
............. 34
LIMITATION OF LIABILITY.........................................................................;..................... 34
INDEMNITY
............ ..................................... """"""""""""""'" """"""""""
.............. 3510 INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ............................................................................................ 36
11 WARRANTIES
.......... ..... ...............
......................... .................... .............. .............. ....." 3812 ASSIGNMENT.. ........................... """'" .................................... ............" .......... ..........." 3913 DEFAULT.......................... ...........
........................................................ ......... ...............
14 DISCLAIMER OF AGENCY ....................:......................................................................... 3915 SEVERABILITY
..,........ ..................... ..........................
................................................... 4016 NON-DISCLOSURE......... .............. """'" ................................ ...... .................................. 4017 'SURVIVAL....................... ..............
............................................................... ................
18 DISPUTE ReSOLUTION
............................ ......... ............................ ...............
"""""""'" 4219 CONTROLLING LAw............... ........... ................................................................... ......... 4520 RESPONSIBILITY FOR ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINATION................................................ 4521 NOTICES """""""
... .......;.. ......".... ....
...........................,........... ...... ............................. 4622 ReSPONSIBILITY OF EACH PARTY ................................................................................. 47
23 No THIRD PARTY BeNEFICIARIES ................................................................................. 4724 RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE. ...................................................................................... 4725 PUBLICITY........
...................... ..... """ ........... .......
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 4726 exECUTED IN COUNTERPARTS ..................................................................................... 4727 COMPLIANCE..
................. .................... ......................
............................................, ...,. 4728 COMPLIANce WITH THE COMMUNICATIONSASSISTANCE LAw ENFORCEMENT ACT
OF 1994................... ........ ...............
..................... ....... ..... ........
..... ............................" 4829 COOPERATION.
......... ........................... """""""'" ...
:.... ..................... ................ ........" 4830 AMENDMENTS; W AlVERS...
~.............. ..............................................................
:::........... 4831 ENTIRE AGREEMENT .................................................................................................... 48
SECTION 6.0 - RESALE """"""""""""""
""""""""""""""""""""""""'"..........................
DESCRIPTION .................. ....................... ........... ....................... ........................ ........... 49
TERMS AND CONDlTlorIIS..............................................
................................................
RATES AND CHARGES .....................................................................................
;............. ,
ORDERING PROCESS .............,......................................................... ............................ 55
BILLING
........... ........................... """"""'" .........
................ ................... ........ ............" 56
MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR .........
...;.............................................................................
SECTION 7.0 - INTERCONNECTION......................................................................................
Owest/AT&T-
CDS-040129-0Q06
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 2 of 19
, ~ .. ':", .
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTERCONNECTION FACILITY OPTIONS .......................................................................... 57
MUTUAL exCHANGE OF TRAFFIC """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'" 63
RECIPROCAL COMPENSATION """""""""""""""""'...................................,............... 75
ORDERING ........................................... ........................ ..................... .......................... 81
JOINTLY PROVIDED $WITCHED ACCESS SERVICES ........................................................
TRANSIT RECORDS .....................".......................................,..........,............................ 83
SECTION 8.0 - COLLOCATION .........., ......................... ..................... .............. .............. .......... 84
DESCRIPTION
..................................... "'" ................ .....
............................................... 84TERMS AND CONDITIONS.......................,......................................................................
RATE ELEMENTS ................................................. .................. .................................... 119
ORDERING ,.....................:...................,....................,....................... ....................... 129
BILLING....
"""""""""'"
....................... ................... ............ ...................................... 145
MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR ......... ...................,.... .................... ........... ........................ 147
SECTION 9.0 - UNBUNDLED NETWORK ELEMENTS ......................................................... 148
GENERAL TERMS """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""'" .......................... 148'
UNBUNDLED Loops ........................................,........................................................... 153
SUBLooP UNBUNDLING....................... ""'..............................,.............. ........"........... 170
LINE SHARING
.................... ..... ........... ..........,...... ...................................,..................
181
NETWORK INTERFACE DEVICE (NID)........................................................................... 189
UNBUNDLED DEDICATED INTEROFfiCE TRANSPORT (UDIT) ..........;.............................. 192
UNBUNDLED DARK FIBER
.................... ..... """""""".......................
:.......................... 199
SHARED INTEROFFICE TRANSPORT............................................................................. 207
UNBUNDLED CUSTOMER CONTROLLED REARRANGEMENT ELEMENT (UCCRE)............. 208
10 LOCAL TANDEM SWITCHING ....................................................................................... 210
11 LOCAL SWITCHING .....
.......... ........,...................... ............ ..... ......................................
212
12 CUSTOMIZED ROUTING .............................................................................................. 221
13 ACCESS TO SIGNALING .............................................................................................. 22214 AIN SERVICES
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""......."...................................
225
15 INTERCONNECTION TO LINE INFORMATION DATABASE (LlDB) ....................................... 227
16 8XX DATABASE QUERY SERVICE ............................................................................... 232
17 INTERNETWORK CALLING NAME (ICNAM)................................................................... 23418 ADDITIONAL UNBUNDLED
...
ELEMENTS..................................................................
......
236
19 CONSTRUCTION CHARGES ..............
:....................................................
;..................... 237
20 UNBUNDLED PACKET SWITCHING .
....................................................
;......................... 237
21 UNE-P LINE SPUlTlNG .........~.................................................................................. 24022 RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE. .................................................................................... 244
23 UNBUNDLED NETWORK ELEMENTS COMBINATIONS (UNE COMBINATIONS) .......m......... 244
24 Loop SPLITTING....
...................... ........... .............. ...~....................... .........
"""" ......... 260
SECTION 10.0 - ANCILLARY SERVICES.............................................................................. 264
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
RESERVED FOR FUTURE USE ..................................................................................... 264
LoCAL NUMBER PORTABILITY ..........................................
........................................
264911/E911 SERVICE ............................................................................................
.'......
271WHITE PAGES DIRECTORY LISTINGS...........................................................................275
DIRECTORY AsSISTANCE ......................
:............................ ..... .... ... ..................
,......... 279
DIRECTORY ASSISTANCE LIST ..............
.................................;...................
................. 282
TOLL AND ASSISTANCE OPERATOR SERVICES ............................................................. 285
ACCESS TO POLES, DuCTS, CONDUITS,AND RIGHTS OF WAY..................................... 289
QwesVAT&T- 10
CDS-040129-QOO6 - ii-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 3 of 19
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION 11.0 - NETWORK SECURITY ............................................................................... 301
SECTION 12.0 - ACCESS TO OPERATIONAL SUPPORT SYSTEMS (OSS) ....................... 306
12.DESCRIPTION
........................ ............... ..................... ....................... ,......
.... .............. 30612.2 ass SUPPORT FOR PRE-ORDERING, ORDERING AND PROVISIONING ........................... 30612.MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR ...........................................,.....................................,...... 321
SECTION 13.0 - ACCESS TO TELEPHONE NUMBERS....................................................... 332
SECTION 14.0 - LOCAL DIALING PARITY............................................................................ 333
SECTION 15.0 - QWEST OFFICIAL PUBLISHER ................................................................. 334
SECTION 16.0 ~ REFERRAL ANNOUNCEMENT .................................................................. 335
SECTION 17.0 - BONA FIDE REQUEST PROCESS............................................................. 336
SECTION 18.0 - AUDIT PROCESS ....................................................................................... 339
SECTION 19.0 - CONSTRUCTION CHARGES .........................................
,...........................
342
SECTION 20.0 - RESERVED.................................................................................................343
SECTION 21.0 - BILLING....... ............. ................ ....... ........ ................... ........... .............. ........ 344
SECTION 22.0 - PRICING .....................................
:..................................~............................
358
SECTION 23.0 - NETWORK STANDARDS ........................................................................... 360
. '. :
SECTION 24.0 - SIGNATURE PAGE................................................................................... 364
OwestlAT&T-ID
CO8-O40129-0006 - iii-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 4 of 19
TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR EXHIBITS
. ' ~:.
APPENDIX 1 To Section 21 - Billing
EXHIBIT 1
EXHIBIT 2
Owest Transfer Authorization Agreement
Owest Services Transfer Agreement
EXHIBIT A Rates
EXHIBIT B Service Pertonnance Indicators
EXHIBIT C Service Interval Tables
EXHIBIT D Owest Right of Way, Pole Attachment and/or Innerduct Occupancy
General Information Document
EXHIBIT E Vertical Switch Features for UNE Switching
EXHIBIT F Special Request Process
EXHIBIT G Change Management Process (CMP)
EXHIBIT H UNE-P Call Flows
EXHIBIT I
EXHIBIT J
Individual Case Basis (ICB)
Election of Reciprocal Compensation Option
EXHIBIT K Reserved
EXHIBIT L Advice Adoption Letter
EXHIBIT M Interim Advice Adoption Letter
' ,
QwestlAT&T- 10
COS-040129-0006 Iv -
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-AT&T Complaint, Page 5 of 19
Section 10
Ancillary Services
originating from coin telephones where the computer requests deposit of coins,
additional End User Customer key actions, recording of End User Customer
voice, etc.
' '
10.Call Branding Non-recurring Charge. Owest will charge to ClEC a non-recurring setup and. recording fee for establishing Call Branding and loading each Switch
with ClEC's branded message. ClEC must pay such non-recurring charges prior to
commencement of the service. The non-recurring set-up and recording charge will applyeach time the ClEC's brand message Is changed. The non-recurring charge to load the
Switches with the CLEC's branded message will be assessed each time there is any
change to the Switch.
10.4 Ordering Process
ClEC will order Operator Services by completing the "Owest Operator Services/DirectoryAssistance Questionnaire for Local Service Providers." Copies of this questionnaire may beobtained from ClEC's designated Qwest account manager.
10.5 Billing
10.Qwest will track usage and bill ClEC for the calls placed by CLEC's EndUser Customers and facilities.
10.Qwest will compute CLEC's invoice based on both Option A (Price PerMessage) and Option B (Price Per Work Second and Computer Handled Calls). Owest
will charge ClEC whichever option results in a lower charge.
10.If, due to equipment malfunction or other error, Owest does not have
available the necessary infonnation to compile an accurate Billing statement, Owest mayrender a reasonably estimated bill ' but shall notify ClEC of the methods of suchestimate and cooperate in good faith with ClEC to establish a fair. equitable estimate.
Qwest shall render ,a bill reflecting actual billable quantities when and If the infonnation
necessary for the Billing statement becomes available.
10.Access to Poles, Ducts, Conduits, and Rights of Way
1 0.8. 1 Description
10.Pole Attachments - Where it has owne~hip or control to do so, Owest will
provide CLEC with access to available pole attachment space for the placing of facilities
for the purpose of transmitting Telecommunications Services. ,
10.1 The teRn pole attachment means any attachment by CLEC to a pole
owned or controlled by Qwest.
10.Ducts and Conduits - Where it has ownership or control to do so, Owest will
provide CLEC with access to available ducts/conduits for the purpose of placing facilities
for transmitting Telecommunications Services. A spare duct/conduit will be leased for
copper facilities only, and an innerduct for the purpose of placing fiber. , ClEC may place
innerduct in an empty duct/conduit. Control of CLEC-installed spare innerduct shall vestin Qwest Immediately upon installation; ownership of such Innerduct shall vest to Owest
~..
QwestlAT&T- 10
COS-O40129-0006 289-
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 6 of 19
Section 10
Ancillary Services
if and when CLEC abandons such innerduct.
, ,
10.1 The terms duct and conduit mean a single enclosed raceway for
conductors, cable and/or wire. Duct and ' conduit may be in the ground, may
follow streets, bridges. public or private ROW or may be within some portion of a
multi-unit building. Within a multi-unit building, duct and conduit may traverse
building, entrance facilities, building entrance links, equipment rooms, remote
terminals, cable vaults, telephone closets or building riser. The terms Duct and
Conduit include riser conduit.
10.2 The term innerduct means a duct-like raceway smaller than a
duct/conduit that is inserted into a duct/conduit so that the duct may typicallycarry three cables.
10.8;1.Rights of Way (ROW) - Where it has ownership or control to do so. Owest
will provide to CLEC, via an Access Agreement in the form of Attachment 4 to Exhibit D,
access to available ROW for the purpose of placing telecommunications facilities. ROW
includes land or other property owned. or controlled by Owest and may run under, on,
above, across, along or through public or private property or enter multi-unit buildings.
c .
10.1 ROW means a real property interest in privately-owned real property,
but expressly excluding any public. governmental, federal or Native American, or
other quasi-public or non-private lands, sufficient to permit Owest to place
telecommunications facilities on such real property; such property owner may
permit Owest to install and maintain facilities under, on, above, across, along or
through private property or enter multi-unit buildings. Within a multi-unit building,
a ROW includes a pathway that is actually used or has been 'specifically
designated for use by Owest as part of its transmission and distribution network
where the boundaries of the pathway are clearly defined either by Written
specifications or unambiguous physical demarcation.
10.Intentionally Left Blank.
10.The phrase .ownership or control to do so. means the legal right, as a matter
of State law, to (i) convey an interest in real or personal property. or (Ii) afford access to
third parties as may be provided by the landowner to Owest through express or implied
agreements, or through Applicaple Rules as defined in this Agreement.
10.2 Terms and Conditions
Owest shall provide CLEO non-discriminatory access to poles, ducts, conduit and ri!!Jhts of way
on terms and conditions foun~ in the Revised Owest Right of Way, Pole Attachment and/or
DuctllnnerductOocupancy General Information Document, attached hereto as Exhibit D. Owest
will not favor itself over CLEO when Provisioning access to poles, ducts, conduits and rights of
way (ROW). Owest shall not give itself preference when assigning space.
10.Subject to the provisions of this Agreement, Owest agrees to issue to CLEO
authorization for CLEC to attach, operate, maintain, rearrange, transfer and remove at
its sole expense its facilities on poleslductlinnerduct or ROW owned or controlled in
whole or in part by Owest, subject to Orders placed by CLEO. Any and all rights granted
to CLEC shall be subject to and subordinate to any future local, State and/or federal
OwestlAT&T-
CDS-04Q129-0006 290-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-AT&T Complaint, Page 7 of 19
Section
Ancillary Services
requirements.
10.Owest will rely on such codes as the National Electrical Safety Code (NESC)
to prescribe standards with respect to capacity, safety, reliability, and general
engineering principles.
10.Federal requirements. such as those imposed by Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission (FERC) and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), will
continue to apply to the extent such requirements affect requests for attachments or
occupancy to Owest facilities under Section 224(1)(1) of the Act.
\; ,
10.CLEC shall provide access to a map of the requested
poleslductlinnerductlROW route, InQluding estimated distances between major points,
the Identification and location of the poles/ductlinnerduct and ROWand a description of'
CLEC's facilities. Owest agrees to provide to CLEC access to relevant plats, maps,
engineering records and other data within ten (10) business days of receiving a request
for such infonnation. except In the case of extensive. requests. extensive requests
Involve the gathering of plats from more than one (1) . location, span more than fIVe (5)
Wire Centers, or consist of ten (10) or more intra-Wire Center requests submittedsimultaneously. Responses to extensive requests will be provided within a reasonable
, interval, not to exceed forty-five (45) Days.
10.Except as expressly provided herein, or in the Pole Attachment Act of 1934
as amended and its regulations and rules, or in any applicable, State or municipal laws,nothing herein shall be construed to compel Owest to construct, install, modify or place
any poles/duct/innerduct or other facility for use by CLEC.
10.Owest retains the right to detennine the availability, of space on
poteslductlinnerduct, duct, conduit and ROW consistent with 47 USC ~ 224 and FCC
orders, rules and regulations pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224. In the eventOwest detennines
that rearrangement of the existing facilities on poles, innerduct. duct/conduit and ROW is
required before CLEC'facilities can be acoommodated, the actual cost of such
modification will be included in CLEC's nonrecurring charges for the associated Order
(Make-Ready fee). When modifications to a Owest spare duct/conduit include the
placement of innerduct. Owest or CLEC will install the number of innerduct required to fill
the duct/condUit to its full capacity.
10.Owest shall make manhole ingress and egress for ductJinnerduct accessavailable to CLEC. Owest will perfonn a feasibility study to determine whether to
provide a stub out via the pre-constructed knock out Within the manhole, or to perfonn a
core drill of the manhole.
10.8 'Where such authority does not already exist, CLEC shall be responsible for
obtaining the . necessary legal authority to occupy ROW, and/or poleslduct/innerduct on
governmental. federal, Native American, and private rights of way. CLEC shall obtainany penn its, licenses, bonds. or other necessary legal authority and permission, at
CLEC's sole expense, in order to perform its obligations under this Agreement. CLEC
shall contact' all owners of public and private rights-of-way to obtain the permission
required to perfonn the work prior to entering the property or starting any work thereon.
See Section 10.4. CLEC shall comply with all conditions of rights-of.way and permits.
Once such permission is obtained, all such work may be perfonned by Owest or CLEC
OwestlAT&T-
CD5-040129-0006 - 291 -
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 8 of 19
Section 10
Ancillary Services
, ' ~,
at the option of CLEC.
10.Access to a Owest Central Office manhole will be permitted whereTechnically Feasible. If space is available, Owest will allow access through the Central
Office manhole to the, POI (Point of Interconnection). There shall be a presumption that
there shall be no fiber splices allowed in the Central Office manhole. However, whereCLEC can establish the necessity and technical feasibility of splicing in the Central
Office manhole, such action shall be permitted.
10.10 Replacement/Modification/Installation -If CLEC requests Owest to replace or
modify existing poles/ductllnnerduct to increase its strength or capacity for the sole
benefit of CLEC, CLEC shall pay Owest the total actual replacement cost, Owest'actual cost to transfer its attachments to new poleslductlinnerduct, as necessary, and
the actual cost for removal (including actual cost of destruction) of the replacedpoleslductllnnerduct, if necessary. Ownership of new poleslductlinnerduct shall vest to
Owest.
10.10.Upon request, Owest shall permit CLEC to installpoleslductlinnerduct. Owest reserves the right to reject any non-conformingreplacement pole/ductlinnerduct installed by CLEC that do not conform, to the
NESC, OSHA or local ordinances.
10.10.To the extent that a modification is incurred for the benefit of
multiple parties, CLEC shall pay a proportionate share of the total actual cost
based on the ratio of the amount of new space occupied by the facilities of CLEC
to the total amount of space occupied by all parties including Owest or its
Affiliates participating In the modification. Parties who do not, initiate;' request or
receive additional space from a mQdification, are not required to share in the cost
of the modification. CLEC, Owest or any other party that uses a modification as
an opportunity to bring its facilities into compliance with applicable safety or other
requirements will be deemed to be sharing in the modification and will be
responsible for its share of the modification cost. Attaching entities will not be
responsible for sharing in the cost of governmentally mandated pole or other
facility modification.
. i
1 0.1 0.The modifying party or parties may recover a proportionate share
of the modification costs from parties that later are able . to obtain access as aresult of the modification. The proportionate share of the subsequent attacher
will be reduced to take account of depreciation to the pole or other facility that
has occurred since the modification. The mOdifying party or parties seeking to
recover 'modification costs from parties that later' obtain attachments shall be
responsible for maintaining all records regarding modification costs. Owest shallnot be responsible for maintaining records regarding modification costs on behalf
of attaching entities.
10.11 Notification of modifications initiated by or on behalf of Owest and at Qwesfs
expense shall be provided to CLEC at least sixty (60) Days prior to beginningmodifications. Such notification shall include a brief description of the nature and scope
of the modification. If CLEC does not respond to a requested rearrangement of itsfacilities within sixty (60) Days after receipt of written notice from Owest requesting
rearrangement, awest may perform or have performed such rearrangement and CLEC
QwestlAT&T- ID
CDS-040129-OO06 292-
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 9 of 19
Section 1 0
Ancillary Services
shall pay the actual cost thereof. No such notice shall be required in emergencysituations or for routine maintenance of poleslductlinnerduct completed at Owest's
expense.
t '
." :'
10.12 owest reserves the right to make an on-sltelfinal construction inspection of
ClEC's facilities occupying the poleslduct/innerduct system. CLEC shall reimburse
owest for the actual cost of such inspections except where specified In this Section.
10.13 When final construction inspection by owest has been completed,CLECshall correct such non-complying conditions within the reasonable period of timespecified by owest in its written notice. If corrections are not completed within thespecified reasonable period, occupancy authorizations for the ROW,
poleslduct/innerduct system where non-complying conditions remain uncorrected shall
suspend forthwith, regardless of whether CLEC has energized the facilities occupying
said poleslductlinnerduct or ROW system and CLEC shall remove its facilities from said
polesfduct/innerduct or ROW in accordance with the provisions of this Section, provided,
however, if the corrections physically cannot be made within such specified time, and
CLEC has been diligently prosecuting such cure, CLEC shall, be granted a reasonable
additional time to complete such cure. Owest may deny further occupancy authorization
to CLEC until such non-complying conditions are corrected or until CLEC's facilities are
removed from the polesJduct/innerduct system where such non-complying conditions
exist. If agreed between both Parties, owest shall perform or have performed suchcorrections and CLEC shall pay owest the actual cost of performing such work.
Subsequent inspections to determine if appropriate corrective actions have been taken
may be made by owest.
10.14 Once CLEC's facilities begin occupying the poleslduct/innerduCt or ROW
system, owest may perform a reasonable number of inspections. owest shall bear the
cost of such inspections unless the results of the inspection reveal a material violation or
hazard, or that CLEC has in any other way failed to comply with the provisions of
Section 10.20; in which case CLEC shall reimburse Owest the costs of inspections
and re-inspections, as required. CLEC's representative may accompany Owest on such
field inspections. The cost of periodic inspection or any special inspections found
necessary due to the existence of sub-standard or unauthorized occupancies shall be
billed separately.
10.15 The costs of inspections made during construction and/or the. final
construction survey and subsequent Inspection shall be billed to CLEC upon completion
of the inspections.
, \
10.16 Anal construction, subsequent, an~ periodic inspections or the" 'failure to
make such inspections, shall not relieve CLEC of any responsibilities, obligations, or
'liability assigned under this Agreement.
10.17 CLEC may use IndiVIdual workers of its choice to perform any work
necessary for the attaching of its facilities so long as such workers have the same
qualifications and training as Owest's workers. CLEC may use any contractor approved
by OweSt to perform Make-Ready Work.
10.18 If Owest terminates an Order for cause, or if CLEC terminates an Order
without cause. subject to 1 0.4, ClEC shall pay termination charges equal to the
QwestlAT&T-
CD8-040129-0006 -293-
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT~T-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 10 of 19
Section 10
Ancillary Services
amount of fees and charges remaining on the terminated Order(s) and shall remove its
facilities from thepoleslductlinnerduct within sixty (60) Days, or cause Owest to remove
its facilities from the poles/ductlinnerduct at ClEC's expense; provided, however,that
ClEC shall be liable for and pay all fees and charges provided for in this Agreement to
Owest until ClEC's facilities are physically removed. "Cause" as used herein shall
include ClEC's use of its facilities in material violation of any applicable law or in aid of
any unlawful act or making an unauthorized modification to Qwesfs
poles/ductlinnerduct, or, in the case of ROW, any act or omission that violates the terms
and conditions of either (a) the Access Agreement by which Owest conveys a right of
access to the ROW to ClEC, or (b) the instrument granting the original ROW to Owest
or its predecessor.
10.19 Owest may abandon or sell any poles/innerduct, duct/conduit or ROW at any
time by giving written notice to ClEC. Any poles, innerduct, duct/conduit or ROW that is
sold, will be sold subject to all existing legal rights of CLEC. Upon abandonment of
poles/innerduct, duct/conduit or ROW, and with the concurrence of the other joint
user(s). if necessary, ClEC shall, within sixty (60) Days of such notice, either. 1)
continue to occupy the poleslinnerduct, duct/conduit or ROW pursuant to its existing
rights under this Agreement if the poles/innerduct, duct/conduit, or ROW is purchased by
another party; 2) purchase the poles/innerduct, duct/conduit or ROW from Owest at the
current market value; or 3) remove its facilities therefrom. Failure to explicitly elect one
of the foregoing options within sixty (60) Days shall be deemed an election to purchase
the poleslinnerduct, duct/conduit or ROW at the current market value if no other party
purchased the poleslinnerduct, duct/conduit or ROW within this sixty (60) Day period.
10.20 ClEC's facilities shall be placed and maintained in accordance with the
requirements and specifications of the current applicable standards of Telcordia Manual
of Construction Standards, the National Electrical Code, the National Electrical Safety
Code, and the rules and regulations of the Occupational Safety and Health Act, all of
which are Incorporated by reference, and any governing authority having jurisdiction.
Where a difference In specifications exists, the more stringent shall apply.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, ClEC shall only be held to such standard as Owest, its
Affiliates or any other Telecommunications Carrier Is held. Failure to maintain facilities
in accordance with the above requirements or failure to correct as provided in Section
10.13 shall be cause for termination of the Order. ClEC shall ina timely manner
comply with all requests from Owest to bring its facilities into compliance with these
terms and conditions.
.. I
1 0.21 Should Owest under the provisions of this Agreement remove ClEC'
facilities from the poleslductllnnerduct covered by any Order, Owest will deliver the
facilities removed upon payment by CLEC of the cost of removal, storage and delivery,
and all other amounts due Owest. If CLEC removes facilities from poleslductllnnerductfor other than repair or maintenance purposes, no replacement on the
poles/ductlinnerduct shall be made until all outstanding charges due Owest for previous
occupancy have been paid In full. CLEC shall advise Owest. in writing, as to the date on
which the removal of facilities from the poleslductlinnerduct has been completed.
10.22 If any facilities are found attached to poleslductlinnerduct for which no order
is in effect, Owest, without. prejudice to its other rights or remedies under this
Agreement, may assess a charge and CLEC agrees to pay the lesser of (a), the annual
fee per pole or per innerduct run between two (2) manholes for the number of years sine
OwestlAT&T- 10
COS-040129-0006 294-
Exhibit 4
Case # A TT - T -04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 11 of 19
Sectiol110
Ancillary Services
the most recent inventory, 'or (b) five times the annual fee per pole or per innerduct run
between two (2) manholes. In addition. CLEC agrees to pay (a) interest on these fees ata rate set for the applicable time period by the Internal Revenue Service for individualunderpayments pursuant to Section 6621 of the Internal Revenue Service Code (25
C. ~ 6621, Rev. Ru!' 2000-30, 2000~25 IRS 1262), and (b) the cost of any audit
required to identify unauthorized CLEO attachments. Owest shall waive half theunauthorized attachment fee if the following conditions are met: (1) CLEO cures such
unauthorized attachment (by removing it or submitting a valid Order for the attachment in
the form of Attachment 2 of Exhibit D). within thirty (30) Days of written notification from
Owest of the unauthorized attachment; and (2) the unauthorized attachment did not
require Owest to take curative measures itself (e., pulling additional innerduct) prior to
cure by CLEO, (3) CLEO reimburses Owest for cost of audit, or portion thereof, which
discovered the unauthorized attachment. Owest shall also waive the unauthorizedattachment fee if the unauthorized attachment arose due to error by Owest rather thanCLEO. CLEC is required to submit in writing, within ten (10) business days after receipt
of written notification from Owest of the unauthorized occupancy, a poleslduct/innerduct
application. If such application is not received by Owest within the specified time period,
CLEC will be required to remove its unauthorized facility within thirty (30) Days of the
final date for submitting the required application, or Owest may remove CLEC's facilities
without liability, and the cost of such removal shall be borne by CLEC.
10.23 No act or failure to act by Owest with regard to an unauthorized occupancyshall be deemed as. the authorization of the occupancy. Any subsequently,lssued
authorization shall not operate retroactively or constitute a waiver by Owest of any of its
rights or privileges under this Agreement or otherwise. CLEO shall be subject to . allliabilities of the Agreement in regard to said unauthorized occupancy from its inception.
10.24 Owest will provide CLEO non-discriminatory access to poles, innerducts,ducts/conduits and ROW pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224 and FCC orders, rules and
regulations pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224. In the event of a conflict between thisAgreement, on one hand, and 47 USC ~ 224 and FCC orders, rLiles and regulations
pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224, on the other, 47 USC ~ 224 anca FCC orders, rules andregulations pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224 shall govern. Further, in the event of a conflict
between Exhibit D. on one hand. and this Agreement or 47 USC ~ 224 and FCC orders,
rules and regulations pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224. on the other, this Agreement or 47 use~ 224 and FCC orders, rules and regulations pursuant to 47 USC ~ 224 shall govern,
provided however, that any. Access Agreement that has been duly executed,
acknowledged and recorded in the real property records for the county in which theROW is located shall govern in any'event pursuant t~ its terms.
10.25 Nothing in this Agreement shail require Owest to exercise eminent"domain onbehalf of CLEC.
10.26 Upon CLEC request. Owest will certify to a landowner with whom Owest hasan ROW agreement, the following:
10.26.that the ROW agreement with Owest does not preclude the
landowner from entering Into a separate ROW agreement with CLEC; and
10.26.that there will be no penalty under the agreement between thelandowner and Owest if the landowner enters into a ROW agreement with CLEC.
QwestlAT&T-
CD5-040129-0006 295-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 12 of19
' " ," ':" ." "\:;':" :,
Section 1 0
Ancillary Services
10.27 For purposes of permitting CLEC to determine whether Owest has ownership
or control over duct/conduit or ROW within a specific multi-dwelling unit, If CLEC
requests a copy of, an agreement between Owest and the owner of a specific multi-
dwelling unit that grants Owest access to the multi-dwelling unit, Owest will provide the
agreement to CLEO pursuant to the terms of this Section.' CLEC will submit a completedAttachment 1.A from Exhibit D that identifies a specific multi-unit dwelling or route for
each agreement.
10.27.Upon receipt of a completed Attachment 1.A, Owest will prepare,
and return an MDU information matrix, within ten (10) Days, which will identify (a)
the owner of the multi-dwelling unit as. reflected in Owesfs records, and (b)
whether or not Owest has a copy of an agreement that provides Owest access to
the multi-dwelling unit in its possession. OWest makes no representations or
warranties regarding the accuracy of Its records, and CLEO acknowledges that
the original property owner may not be the current owner of the property.
10.8.2.27.Owest grants a limited waiver of any confidentiality rights it mayhave with regards, to the content of the agreement, subject to the terms and
conditions In Section 10.27.3 and the Consent to Disclosure form. Owest will
provide to CLEO a copy of an agreement listed in the MDU information matrix
that has not been publicly recorded after CLEC obtains authorization for such
disclosure from the third party owner(s) of the real property at issue , by
presenting to Owest an executed version of the Consent to Disclosure form that
is included in Attachment 4 to Exhibit D of this Agreement. In lieu of submission
of the Consent to Disclosure form, CLEC must comply with the indemnification
requirements in Section 10.
10.27.As a condition of its limited waiver of its right to confidentiality Inan agreement that provides Owest access to a multi-dwelling unit that Owest
provides to CLEO or that CLEO obtains from the multi-dwelling unit owner or
operator. Owest shall redact all dollar figures from copies of agreements that
have not been publicly recorded that Owest provides to CLEC and shall require
that the multi-dwelling unit owner or operator make similar redaction s prior to
disclosure of the agreement.
10.27.In all Instances, CLEO will use agreements only for the. following
purposes: (a) to determine whether Owest has ownership or control over duct,
conduits, or rights-of-way within the property described in the agreement; (b) to
determine the ownership of wire within the property described in the agreement;
or (c) to determine the Demarcation Point' between Owest facilities and the
Owner's facilities in the property described in the agreement. C~EC furtheragrees that CLEO shall not disclose the contents, terms, or conditions of any
agreement provided pursuant to Section 10.8 to any,CLEC agents or employees
engaged in sales, marketing, or product management efforts on behalf of CLEO.
10.3 Rate Elements
Owest fees for attachments are in accordance with Section 224 of the Act and FCC orders.
rules and regulations promulgated thereunder, as well as the rates established by the
Commission including the following rates, are reflected in exhibit A.
, QwestlAT&T-
CDS-O40129-0006 -296-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 13 of 19
Section
Ancillary Services
10.Inquiry Fee. A non-refundable pre-paid charge used to recover the costs
associated with performing an internal recOrd review to determine if a requested routeand/or facility is available, or with respect to ROW, to determine the informationnecessary to create the ROW matrix, which identifies, for each ROW, the name of the
original grantor and the nature ' of the ROW (i.e., publicly recorded and non-recorded)
and the MDU matrix, which identifies each requested legal agreement between Qwest
and a third party who has a multi-unit building in Qwest's possession that relates to
Telecommunications Services provided to or through real property owned by the third
party (MDU Agreement) and, for each such MDU Agreement, the name of the third
party. Separate Inquiry Fees apply for ROW, poles and ductlconduitlinnerduct.
10.Field Verification " Feel Access Agreement' Preparation Fee. In the case of
poles and ductllnnerduct, the Field Verification Fee is a non-refundable pre-paid charge
which recovers the estimated actual costs for a field survey verification required for aroute and to determine scope of any required Make-Ready work. Separate FieldVerification Fees apply for poles and manholes. In the case of ROW, the AccessAgreement Preparation Fee Is a non-refundable, pre-paid charge which recovers the
estimated actual costs for preparation of the Access Agreement for each ROWrequested by CLEC. Field Verification and Access Agreement Preparation Fees shall be
billed in advance.
10.3 Make-Ready Fee. A pre-paid non-refundable (other than true-up) chargewhich recovers the cost of necessary work required to make the requested facility/ROW
available for access. For Innerduct, this could include, but is not limited to, the placing ofinnerduct in conduit/duct systems or core drilling of manholes. For pole attachment
requests. this could include, but is not limited to, the replacement of poles to meet
required clearances over roads or land. For ROW, this Make-Ready could iilclude. but
is 'not limited to, personnel time, including attorney time. With respect to ROW. Make-Ready work refers to legal or other investigation or analysis arising out of CLEC's failureto comply with the process described in Exhibit 0 for, ROW, or other circumstancesgiving rise to such work beyond the simple preparation of one or more Access
Agreements. The estimated pre-paid fee shall be billed in advance.
10.Pole Attachment Fee. A pre-paid fee which is charged for the occupancy,
including during any Make-Ready period, of one (1) foot of pole space (except forantenna attachment which requires two (2) feet). This fee shall be annual unless CLEC
requests that it be semi~nnual..
10.Innerduct Occupancy Fee. A pre-paid fee which is charged for the
occupancy, Including during any Make-Ready period: of an innerduct on a per foot basis.
This fee shall be annual unless CLEC requests that it be semi-annual.
10.Access Agreement Consideration. ,A pre-paid fee which constitutes
consideration for conveying access to the ROW to CLEC. This fee shall be a one-time
(i.e. honrecuning) fee.
10.4 Ordering
There are two (2) steps required before placing an Order for access to ROW. Ductllnnerductand Pole Attachment: Inquiry Review and Field Verification.
OwestlAT&T- 10
COS-()40 129-0006 297-
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 14 ofl9
" ', ,. ,
Section 10
Ancillary Services
10.8.4.Inquiry Reviews. Upon receipt of an inquiry regarding ROW access, PoleAttachment or Ductllnnerduct Occupancy. Owestwill provide CLEC with Exhibit D.
CLEO will review the documents and provide Owest with maps of the desired area
indicating the routes and entrance points for proposed attachment,proposed occupancy
or proposed. CLEO construction on Owest owned or controlled poles, ductlinnerduct and
ROW as well as the street addresses of any multi-unit buildings upon or through which
CLEO proposes constru~ion on ROW owned or controlled by Owest. CLEC will include
the appropriate Inquiry Fee with a completed Attachment 1.A from Exhibit D.
10.8.4.Inquiry Review - DuctlConduitllnnerduct. Owest will complete the
database inquiry and, prepare a duct/conduit structure diagram (referred to as a
Flatline ) which shows distances and access points (such as manholes). Along
with the Flatllne will be estimated costs for field verification of available facilities.
These materials will be provided to the CLEO within ten (10) Days or within the
time frames of the applicable federal or State law. rule or regulation.
10.Inquiry Review - Poles. Owest will provide the name and contact
number for the appropriate local field engineer for joint validation of the poles and
route and estimated costs for field verification on Attachment 1.8 of Exhibit D
within ten (10) Days of the request.
10.Inquiry Review - ROW. Owest shall, upon request of CLEO.
provide the ROW matrix, the MDU matrix and a copy of 'all publicly recorded
agreements listed in those matrices to CLEO within ten (10) Days of the request.
Owest will provide to CLEO a copy of agreements listed in the matrices that have
not been publicly recorded if CLEO obtains authorization for such disclosure from
the third party owner(s) of the real property at issue by an executed version of
the Consent to Disclosure form. which is included in Exhibit D, Attachment 4.
Owest may redact all dollar figures from copies of agreements listed in the
matrices that have not been publicly recorded that Qwest provides to CLEC. Any
dispute over whether terms have been redacted appropriately shall be resolved
pursuant to the dispute resolution procedures set forth in this Agreement.
Alternatively, in order to secure any agreement that has not been publicly
recorded, a CLEC may provide a legally binding and satisfactory agreement to
indemnify Owest in the event of any legal action arising out of Qwesfs provision
of such agreement to CLEC. In that event, CLEO shall not be required to provide
an executed Consent to. Disclosure form. Owest makes no warranties concerningthe accuracy of the information provided to CLEC; CLEO expressly
acknowledges that Qwesfs files contain only the original ROW instruments,and
that the current owner(s) of the fee estate may not be the party identified in thedocument provided by Owest.
(',
10.Reid Verification - Poles Ductllnnerduct and Access Agreement Preparation
(ROW). CLEC will review the inquiry results and determine whether to proceed with fieldverification for poles/ducts or Access Agreement preparation for ROW. If field
verification or Access Agreement preparation is desired, CLEC will sign and retum
Attachment 1.B of Exhibit D along ' with a check for the relevant verification fee (Field
Verification Fee or Access Agreement Preparation Fee) plus $10.00 per Access
Agreement as consideration for the Access Agreement. Upon payment of the relevant,
fee and Access Agreement consideration, if applicable, Owest will ' provide, asapplicable: depending on whether the request is for ductlinnerductlconduit, ROW or
OwestlAT&T-ID
CDS-040129-0006 298-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page IS of 19
Section 10
Ancillary Services
poles: (a) in the case of innerductlductlconduit, a field survey and site investigation ofthe innerductlductlconduit, including the preparation of distances and drawings, to
determine availability of existing innerductlductlconduit; identification of Make-Ready
costs required to provide space; the schedule in which the Make-Ready work will be
completed; and, the annual recurring prices associated with the attachment of facilities;(b) in the case of ROW, the completed Access Agreement(s) , executed and
acknowledged by Owest Upon completion of the Access Agreement(s) by CLEC, in
accordance with the instructions, terms and conditions set forth in Exhibit D, the Access
Agreement becomes effective to convey the Interest identified in the Access Agreement
(if any). Any dispute regarding whether a legal agreement conveys a ROW shall be
resolved between CLEC am;! the relevant third party or parties, and such disputes shall
not involve Owest; and/or (c) In the case of poles, estimates of Make-Ready costs and
the annual recurring prices associated with the attachment of facilities shall be provided
on Attachment 2 of Exhibit D and shall be completed not later than forty-five (45) Days
after CLEC's submission of the inquiry request. Make-ready time, if any, and CLEC
review time, is not part of the forty-five (45) Day interval. The Attachment 2 quotation
shall be valid for ninety (90) Days.
10.1 CLEC-Perfonned Reid Verification. At the option of CLEC, it may
perform its own field verification (In lieu of Owest pertonnlng same) with the
following stipulations: 1) Verifications will be conducted by a Owest approved
contractor; 2)A Owest contractor will monitor the activity of CLEO contractor
and a current labor rate will be charged to CLEC; 3) CLEO will provide Owest
with a legible copy' of manhole butterfly drawings that reflect necessary Make-
Ready effort; and 4) Owest will use CLEC-provided butterfly drawings and
documentation to check against existing jobs and provide a final field report of
available ductlinnerduct. CLEC will be charged standard rates for Tactical
Planner time.
10.Order - Poles and Ductllnnerduct. The review, signing and return of
Attachment 2 of the General Information Document along with payment of the Make-
Ready and prorated recurring access charges for the current relevant period (annual or
semi-annual) shall be accepted as an Order for the attachment or occupancy. Upon
receipt of the accepted Order from CLEC and applicable payment for the fees identified.
Owest will assign the requested space and commence any Make-Ready work which
may be required. Owest will notify CLEC when poleslductlinnerduct are ready.
10.Make-Ready - Estimates of Make-Ready are used to cover actual Make-
Ready costs.
10.If Owest requests, CLEC will be responsible for payment of the
actual Make-Ready costs determined if such costs exceed the estimate. Such
payment shall be made within thirty (30) Days of receipt of an invoice for the
costs that exceed the estimate.
10.Within fifteen (15) business days of a request, Owest will provide
CLEC copies of records reflecting actual cost of Make-Ready work; provided,
, however, that, If Owest does not possess all such records at the time of the,
request, then Owest will provide copies of such records within fifteen (15)
, business days of receipt of such records. CLEC must request such records; If at
all, within sixty (60) Days after written notification ofthe completion of the Make-
QwestlAT&T-
CDSH04012~O6 299-Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 16 of 19
.. ,\. ":..
i, ..
Section 1 0
Ancillary Services
Ready work.
10.8.4.If the actual Make-Ready costs are less than the estimate, an
appropriate credit for the difference will be Issued upon request. Such. request
must be received within sixty (60) Days following CLEC's receipt of copies of
records if CLEC has, requested records under this paragraph. or within sixty (60)
Days after written notification of the completion of Make-Ready work if CLEC has
not requested records under this paragraph. Such credit will issue within ten (10)
business days of Owest's receipt of either all records related to such actual costs
or CLEC's request for credit, whichever comes last, but in no event later than
ninety (90) Days follo!'ing the request for credit.
" '
10.If CLEC cancels or if, due to circumstances unforeseen during
inquiry/verification, Owest denies the request for poles, ducts or. ROW, upon
CLEC request, Owest will also refund the difference between the actual Make-
Ready costs incurred and those prepaid by CLEC, If any. Such request must be
made within thirty (30) Days of ClEC's receipt of written denial or notification of
cancellation. Any such refund shall be made within ten (10) business days of
either receipt of CLEC's request or Owest's receipt of all records relating to the
actual costs, whichever comes last, but In no event later than ninety (90) Days
following the denial.
10.5 Billing
CLEC agrees to pay the following fees in advance as specified In Exhibit A: Inquiry Fee, Field
Verification Fee, Access Agreement Preparation Fee, Make-Ready Fee, Pole Attachment Fee,
Ductllnnerduct Occupancy Fee and Access Agreement Consideration. Make-Ready Fees will
be computed in compliance with applicable local, State and federal guidelines. Usage fees for
poleslductlinnerduct (i.e., Pole Attachment Fee and Ductllnnerduct .Occupancy Fee) will be
assessed on an annual basis (unless CLEC requests a semi-annual basis). Annual usage fees
for poleslductlinnerduct will be assessed as of January 1 of each year. Semi-annual usage fees
for poleslductlinnerduct will be assessed as of January 1 and July 1 of each year. All fees shall
be paid within thirty (30) Days following receipt of invoices. All fees are not refundable except
as expressly provided herein.
10.6 Maintenance and Repair
, In the event of any service outage affecting both Owest and CLEC, repairs shall be effectuated
on a non-discriminatory basis as established by local, State or federal requirements. Wheresuch requirements do not exist, repairs shall be made ' In the following order. electrical,
telephone (EASIIocal), telephOne (long distance). and cable television, or as mutually, agreed to
by the users of the affected poleslductlinnerduct.
~ .
QwestlAT&T-
CD$-040129-0006 300-
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 17 of 19
Exhiblrt A . Idaho
ATT
10.6.1 InitlalDa18blloeload.DerUsUna $.02610.82 Reload of Database,$.02
10.8.3 .. D8r Using $0.02510.8.4 One-1me8el-tJoFee $82.2210,6.& Media file
10.e.s.1 E1ecIJonIc TRlnsmIssIon 002
lapel
10.6.5.2 T- (dlarges only apply IIIIs Is seIeckId as the normal delivery meclum 10' dally updates) (per
$30.10.e.s.deliverY)1GB
10,7 Toll and AssI- 008I8IDr Services, FacIIItv IIa8ed PruvIders,RecurrIng Non-RtlQlnlnO NOles10.1 OpIionA-PeI'Messalll
10.7,1 OII8t8IOtHlIKIedcaRinaCard lIAS10.7.2 MachIne Handled calling Card $.601 0.7.1.3 StBIIon Cd 51.5010,1A Parson ""'I $3.5010.7.1.5 ComecIIio DlnlcIOlV -lance $.7610,6 IlUSvUleV8tW,perCall $.721 0.7,7 BUsv UIe InI8RUoI
10.7,1.8 00818lOI' Assistance, P4II' S.&O10.7.2 00I0n B-Per Work Second and COmDUler Handled Calls
10.7.2.1 OPerII\OrHllndlecl,Work Second 02810.7.2.2 MachIn. HencIed, per Call $.260.7.2,3 Call Branclna. SeI-w & RecoRIIng $10,500.00
10.7.lDBclna Hr.-., SwIIc:h $600,
10.6 AccesB to Poles, DucIB, COnduII8 and Rfgh1s of WIN RBCIIII1na Noles10.8.1 PoI.IIVIUIfVFee,DB,MlIe 1335.9210.8.2 InneRfUC11nau1ry Fee, per MIle 03.7910.8.3 ROW inquiry Fee $149.2310.8.4 ROWDocPrBpFee 5149.2310.8.5 field V- Fee, per Pole SS7.3110,8.6 FiBldV~5465,10.8,7 PlBMer V Per Manhole $16.6410.8.8 ManholeV """""""PerMBIIhoIe $298..4710.8.9 ManholeM '1""""'*"',D8rM-
10.8.10 Pole -Ment Fee, per FOOl, Year $2.77
10.8,11 InnenIUCIOccupancy Fee, per Foot, oerYear $0.3110.&.12 -A!IJBI!IIIBtIICcInaIdenIIIon $10.0010.8.13 ICB
12 Opera1Ionel Support "'1/SI8ms RBcurt1no Non-Recurrlna Noles
12.1 DevlllODmBl11 and Enhencements, per Order $5.
12.2 OnooInn MUlIBII8_, per CRIer $1.
12.3 DeIly Useae RBCOIII file, POr $0.000419
12.4 TroubIel&olsllonChero.SBe9.:!O17 Bona fide Rsou8sI PAtC8SS
17,-Fee $1851.
NOTES
. .......
0IhBIwt&e 1ndIc8I8d," raI8s ... pulSlllntlO lie Qwest end AT&T InIBfOO!1llBClion
"-"'"
lIIJIIIOVed \Iv \heIdBho PublIc UUIIIIBs Conwnlsslon In DocI!8I Nu..w usw- T -416-15, COmmIssIon Order IUnber 27738, BI!GcIIve17,11196..
B: Cost Dock8IaNE-T-ot.11 PhBsB 1 OtWNo.29408 (Janu8JV5, 2004) el!ecllveJeI1UlllY S. 2004-
Denotes VDluntaIV fa," reoiJc1Ion,
II AddItIonBI reoiJc1Ion 10 ... voluntary recb:llons refIBcIed In ... MIIUSI6. 2002 BXfIIbII,
1) ReM -111 Cost DockeItBOtlmony1llBd on 6/29/01 & 11/1612.001, m:LRIC)
Merfc8I.b8sed......
3) Ice. IncMIuaI Case IIBsIs III1CrIa.
4) 11Ie SlId. of IdBho hIIII retaNd lite oversight IX! \hese l81li8. These l81li1 are IlOl under (he Iw1sdIoIIon of lite FCC.
iii RBles notaddnlssBd In Cost DockeIITB.RICI
6) -nelTELRlCbBIBCI~1'IIOIJIood.:1 reqll8llls. reqll8ll \Iv the CU-to peotonn someIIIIng \hat Is IBchnlcally IBBS!bIB bullhe pl'QC8SS and1m ... not mln DIBc8.
8 Rates kMndln FCCT8llfltl
, '
ExhIJft A - Idaho
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 18 of 19
Exblbirt A-Idaho
ATT
9) The preJlmllI8Iy engI.-tng and planning COSIs aralncwed In the caged and cagel8sa space construdIon c:h1lJll8lL
These 8Itg1oo8tng and pIennkIg charges arv &IsO lnc:ludIId to the C8Q8d and cagel888 quOOt pI8p8I8IIan f88S. Upon
01 ilia coIIoc8IIan COII8IIIII)tIon,Ih8 quoI8 preperauon fee (QPf) wII beCf8dll8CI to tile an&! spaC8 COII8Iruction
....rge for ilia Jab. Tha CItIdIt wllllpply 10 OPF Is oppIio!d. 1Ne 81111l1li1 culTellfty lists nQ1IpI8 QPfa
WI lias b88n prIIpOI8d on the cost cIocIaIIand was epprowd to the AT&T InI8rconriectlan agl'88m8111.CLEO rney choosa QPF at thIa Ime.
10) 0we8I wi no! Charge lor ilia 8I8m8nI1fIIII1I1e CommIssIon has an CJI'POI\UnIty 10 and IIppIOV8 a 1818 In a cost
III Allachn1c8IIy fa8BIbI8 V_I SwItch Faaluras are awIabI8 with unbundled IIWItc:h ports. No monthlyracunIng charge applies larBaslc Var11c81 SWIIc:h F88IIIras. Only bull: V8111C8/ SWIc:h FeaIU188 willi nonrecurring charges8f81~ Nonreculllng c:harg8s are 8jII)Ik:abI8
--
a tealure Is 8dd8d . wh8II1er on nawlnstall8llon, -skin, orc:han1l6. order acIvIIy, V8111C81 SWkh not listed 8J81ncb18C11n 1118 cost of Ita swIIch port and have a rela of zerolor boIh lacurrtna and non,
12-18 I Latt Blank
19) Agreed let raI8, 0w88t Is voIIIlI18rIy 18CIucktg In onI8r to kII8p 1818 reJallanshlp wI1h Ih8 FIb8r Trenspart "par Pair" rate8I8mant.
. :
, EJd\tbIt A . IdaM
Exhibit 4
Case # ATT-04-AT&T Complaint, Page 19 of 19
, -'-"-----.'.'--"'.,............-..,
EXHIBIT
"",~_,,'...-_..-~--~--,..~.._..._......--.
c.._..
~..,.....
,c..."
..,. ",
_..n__,..
"....~~-_"...._"~,---..,,,-,,, .........' """..,' ............,....,....,_..,,'......_--'........,..,...,.., .:..,'. ',', ,,':_.. "," ,"""\~~--
AGREEMENT
FOR LOCA~.WIRELINE NETWORK INTERCONNECTION, AND
SERVICE RESALE
Between
AT&T Corp.
and
U S WEST Communications, Inc.
in the State of Idaho
'"-,, " .
"t!:"'...;."'.-VSWclAT&T Interamnection Agreement -Idaho 07127/98
Exbibit 5
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 1 of 10
" -- -..-.., ..
TABLE OF CONTENTS
, '
RE C ITA LS
........ ...................... ~......... .... ..... ..... ....... ..... ........ ......... ..... ........ .............. ....... ........... ...
SCOPE OF A G REEM ENT........ ...
................. ......................................................... .... .................
D EFI N ITIO NS
.................................................. ..... ........ .... .... ....... ........ ............ .................. ........ ..
1. General Provisions ..............
................................................... .............................. ... ..
2. Most Favored Nation Terms and Treatlnent...........................................................
3. Payment ............... ........................ ........................ .......................................
........ ........
4. Taxes ........ ............ ...............................
.......................... ..................................... .........
5. I ntellectual Property
............................................................ ............... .... ...................
6. S everabi I ity
..................... ........... ... . .......... ............ .................. ............ .... ... ......... .... ....
7. Responsibility for Environmental Contamination .................................................
9. Independent Contractor Status.......................................
~........................................
1 O. Refe renced Docu m ents .... ......................
.... ... ....... .... ....... ..
......... ...................... ...... 20
11. Publicity and Advertising................... ............. ........................................................
12. Executed in Counterparts. ... ..
........................ ....................... ....... ................ ...........
13. Headings Not Controlling .......................................................................................
14. Joi nt Work Prod ucl..... .......... ....
...... ..... ......... ................ .............. ........... .. .............. .
15. S u rviva I.............
.................. ................... .......... .......... ...... .... ....... .................. ........... .
16.Effective Date .... .......................... ....
:................................ ................... ............ .........
17. Amendment of Ag reement....................
.......,........................... ............. ..................
18. I n dem n ificati on
....... .... ......... ,...... ............ ..... ......... .... .. ..... ............... .................... .... .
19. Lim itation of Liability........ .... ............... ...................... .................... ..........................
20. Term ofAg reement............................... .............................
............ ....~.. ...................
21. Governing ,Law................................... ..................... .........
................. .......................
22. Cancellation C ha rges
.. .......... ................ .......... ...... ........................ .... ....... ...... .... ....., ,
23. Regulatory Approvals. .........
...... ............................... ............... .........~.............~.. .....
24. Com p I iance...... ........... ......... ................... ............ ........... ......... ....
................ ......... .....
25. Force Majeu fe.................
................ ........... ..... ..... .. ........... ..... .......... .. ............ .... ...... .
26. Escalation Proced ures ..
.... ....... ...... ........ ... ......... ...... ......~. .-..... ~....... ........... ........... .
27. Dis pute Resolution. .....
..... ............. ..-........... ............... .... ....... ............. ........ ............ ..
28. No nd Isclos u re .... .....
....... .......... ......... .... .................. ............... ........... ................ ... ....
29. ,Notices....... ........... ..................... .......
... ........ .............. ............ ..... ................. ........... ..
30. Ass ig nment . ........................... ........... ....
... ............. ....... ...... ... ... .... ..~..... ................... .
31. Warranties.. ........
....... ..... . ....... .,.... ....~.. ...... .~....................... ........... ..... ......... ...... ...... .
32. Defau It ...... .... ..............
.... ..... .... ...... .. ........... ........... ..... .... ............ ....... ................ ....... .
33. Remed les .... ....... .............
.... ........... ....... ...... .... .............. ...... ....... .. .......... ............ .... ...
30 '. 34. Waivers ...... .....
...... ............. ......... ............ ......... ....... ........... .... ......... .... ................... ...
35. No Third Party Beneficiaries ..................................................................................
36. P hysi ca I See u rity ......... ... ..... .....
.... .... .... ..........,........ ............. ......... ................... ...... .
37. Network Secu rlty
..... ............... . ............ .......
"""""'0""'" .... .......
..... ........ ................. .~~)
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 2 of 10
....".. ..,_..
38. Reven ue .p rotection ....... .......... .
~......... ........... .......... ... .................... .... ............ ........ .
39. Law Enforcement I nterfa ce....... .... .......... ..... ....... ...........
................. ........ ............. ...
40. Collocation......
~................... ... ............. ...... ........ ......... .... ..... ........ ...................... ..... .. .
41. Technical References . Coliocatiol'L......................................................................
42. Num ber Portability........ .......... ........
...... ..... ......... .......... ...... ......... .................. ........ ..
43. Dial i ng Parity.... .......... ';
. .... ...... ............... ............. .................... ... .. .......... ... . ............. .
44. Oi rectory Listi ngs
.................... ......... ......... ...... ..... ... ....... ........................ .......... ...... .
46. U S WEST Dex Issues..............................................................................................
47. Access to Poles, Ducts, Conduits, and Rights of Way.......................................
48. Bona Fide Request Process for Further Unbundling..........................................
49. Audit Process.. ....
..... ........ ........... ............. ....... .... .................. ...,...... ......... ................
50. Miscellaneous Services..... ....
........... ..................... .... ................ .............................
51. Unused Transmission Medla...
~..............................................................................
52. Service Standa rds ...........
... ................ ........ ....... ... ....... ... . ... ................. .............. .... ..
53. Entire Ag reement........ .......
.... .... .. .... . ..... ... ....... ..... .............. ... .... ....... ........ .... ...........
54. Reservation of Rights..
......... .................... ............ ......... .. ......... ................... ..... ..... ..
ATTACHMENTS
Attachment 1
Attachment 2
Attachment 3
Attachment 4
Rates and Charges
Resale
Unbundled Access/Elements
Interconnection
Attachment 5
Attachment 6
Business Process Requirements
Electronic Interfaces
Implementation ScheduleAttachment 7
USWCIAT&T Interconnection Agreement . Idaho 07fJ.7198
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 3 of 10
. ,;'.::':')
(c)
44.3
U S WEST shall be entitled. to retain all revenue. associated with any
sales pursuant to subparagraphs (a) and (b) above.
WEST Wf71 take reasonable steps In accordance with industry practices to
accommodate non-publlshed and non-listed Ustings provided that A T& T has supplied
S WEST the necessary privacy Indicators on such Ustings.
44A AT&T Responsibilities
44.4.AT&T agl8eS to provide to U SWEST its end user names, addresses and
telephone numbers In a standatd mechanized fonnat as utilized by U WEST.
44.4.AT&T will supply its ACNA/C/C or CLCCIOCN. as appropriate, with each Older to
provide U WEST the means of identifying listings ownership.
, 44.4.AT&T represents the end user Information provided to US WEST Is accurate and
conect. A T& fulther I8presents that It has teviewed all listings provided to
S WEST, Including end user requested I8str/ctions on use such as non-published
and non-listed.
44.AT&T Is responsible for dealings with, and on be half of, A T& Ts end users on the
following subjects:
a) All end U$9r account activity, g., end user queries and complaints.
b) All account maintenance activity, e.g., additions, changes, issuance of OIders
fOr Ust/ngs to U WEST.
c) Determining privacy requitements and accurately coding the privacy indicators
for A T& Ts end user information. If end user information provided by A T& T
S WEST does not contaIn privacy Indicator, no privacy testrictions will
apply.
45. (Intentionally left blank for numbering consistency.
46.U S WEST Dex Issues
46.US WEST and AT&T agree that certain issues, such as yellow page advertising,
directory disbibution, access to call guide pages, and yellow page listings, may be the
subject of negotiations between AT&T and U SWEST Dex. U SWEST acknowledgesthat AT&T may request U S WEST to facilitate discussions between AT&T' andU S WEST Dex.
47.Access to Poles, Ducts, Conduits, and Rights of Way
25 Third Order, at p. 4.
USWCIA T& T Interconnection Agreement - I~ho 07/27/98
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 4 of 10
.. ,. ".. " '" "" '
47., U S WEST shall provide AT&T nondiscriminatory access to poles, ducts, rights-of-
way and conduits it owns or controls on tenns, conditions and priceS comparable to
those offered to any other entity.
47.(Intentionally left blank for numbering consistency)
Definitions47.3
Poles, duCts, Conduits and ROW' refer to all the physical facilities and legal rights which
provide for access to pathways across public and private property. These include poles,
pole attachments, ducts, Inoerducts, conduits, building entrance fac17ities, buUding entrance
links, equipment rooms, remote tenninats, cable vaults, telephone Closets, buUding risers,
righ~f-way, or any other requirements needed to Cleate pathways. These pathways may
fUn over, under, across or through streets, traverse private property, or enter mult/-Unit
buildings. AR/ght-of-Way rROW) is the right to use the land or other property owned,
leased, or controlled by any means by U S ~ST to place poles, ducts, conduits and ROW
or to provide passage to access such poles, ducts, conduits and ROw. A. ROW may fUn
under, on, or above public or private property (including air space above pubftC or private
property) and shan Include the right to use discrete space in buHdings, building complexes,
or other locations.
47A Requirements
47.4. 1 ~ST shall make poles, duct. conduits and ROW available to A T& T upon
receipt of a request for use within the time periods provided In this SectIon,
providing aU information necessary to implement such use and containing rates,
terms and conditions, Including, but not limited to, maintenance and use
accordance with this Agreement and at least equal to those which it affords itself. its
Affiliates and othelS. U S WEST may reserve the space in its poles, ducts,
conduit and rights-of-way in order to meet jts.resldentialservice obligations
under Idaho Iaw,Z7 Other users of these facJ7ities, including U ~ST, shalf not
interfere with the a,vaOability or use of the facilities by A T& T.
47.4,Within ten (10) Business Days of AT&T~ request for specific poles. ducts, conduits,
or ROw, U ~ST shaff provide any Information In its possession or available to
tegarding the environmental conditions of such requested poles, ducts, conduits
ROW route or location Including, but not Bmiled to, the existence and condition
asbestos, lead paint. hazardous substance contamination, or radon. Information
considef8d &vaNable- under this Agreement if It is In U S WESrs possession or
files, or the possession of an agent contractor; employee, lessor; or tenant of~srs that holds such information on U WESTs behalf. If the poles, ducts,
conduits or ROW contain such environmental contamination, making the placement
of equipment hazardous. U S WEST shaff offer alternative poles, ducts, conduits
ROW for AT&rs cons/deration.S WEST shall sHow AT&T to perfonn any
fPtvlronmentaJ site Investigations, /ncluding, but not limited to, Phase I and Phase II
environmental site assessments, as A T& T may deem to be necessary.
28 Per Third Order, at 5.27 Per First Order at 41
USWCIA T& T Inten:onnection Ag..ment - Idaho 07/27/98
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 5 of 10
"""..,.""..., .,,""', ", "'".'" .",.. ,..,, .,--"...., ,
47.4.US WEST shall not prevent or delay any third party assignment of ROW to A T&
47.4.4 US WEST shaH offer the use of such poles, ducts, oonduits and ROW it has
obtained from a third party to A T& 1, to the extent such agreement does not prohibit
US WEST from granting such rights to AT&T. US WEST shan not be required
to act as the agent of AT&T in A T& 1"s efforts to secure license form third
parties for the access of third parties' poles, ducts, conduit and rights of way.However, US WEST shaH provide to AT&T the necessary Information as to
the ownership of such space and where necessary and appropriate, provide
assurance to the third party that U S WEST does not object to the granting of
any required rights. The Parties shall jointly develop a document Introducing
AT&T to third party property owners.2I They shall be offered to AT&T on the
same tenns as 818 offe1'eQ to S WEST. A T& T shall reimburse U S WEST for
WESTs reasonable costs, if any, incurred as a result of the exercise of its
eminent domain authority on behalf of AT&T in accordance with the provisions
this paragraph.
,. "
47.4.US WEST shall provide AT&T equal and nOlHliscriminatory access to poles
ducts, conduit and ROWand any other pathways on terms and conditions equal
that provided by U WEST to itself or to any other Person. Further, U WEST
shall not preclude or delay allocation of these facilities to AT&T because of the
potential needs of Itself or of other Person, except maintenance spare may be
retained as described below and except for TesetVations in existence made prior
the request of A T&T in accordance with the Act.
47.4.US WEST shall not attach, or permit other entities to attach facHities on, within
overlashed to existing A T& T facif'fIies without A T& T's prior written oonsent
47.On timely basis, U WEST agrees to provide immediately necessary
information, on a case-specilic route basis, cunent detaRed engineering and other
plant records and drawings for specific requests for poles, ducts, oonduit and ROw,
including facBity IOUte maps at'city level, and the fees and expenses incurred in
providing such records and drawings on the' earlier of twenty (20) Business Days
from A T& Trequest or the time within which U WEST provides this infonnation
itself or any other Person. If U S WEST is unable. to provide this information within
the twenty (20) day period, it shall immediately advise AT&T of the expected delay,
the rfiason for such delay, and the expected date on which A T& T wilt teeeive the
information requested. T& T may request an earlier response time. Suchinformation shall be of eqUal type and quality as that" which is available
WESTs own engineering and operations staff. WEST shag also allow
personnel designated by T& T to jointly examine with U WEST personnel, at
cost to A T& T for such personnel, such engineering records and drawings for
specific routing at S WEST Central Offices andU S WEST Engineering Offices
upon ten (10) days' written notice to WEST. US WEST acknowfedgesthat the
request for information and the subject matter related to the request made under
this Section shall be treated as Proprietary Information
28 Per First Order at42
USWCIAT&T Interconnection Agreement -Idaho 07/27/98
Exhibit
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 6 of 10
.., " , ,
0..
' ",.-. .. .. '....... ., ,, .. ,,~.' .. ,""'" .. .'. .., ,..
47.4.US WEST shall provide to AT&T Single Point of Contact for negotiating all
structure lease and ROW arrangements.
47.US WEST shaff provide information regarding the avai/ab/7ity and condition
poles, ducts, conduit and ROW within five (5) Business Days of A T& Ts request if
the information then exists in U S WESTh records (a records based answer) and
within twenty (20) Business Days of AT&Th request if US WEST must physically
examine the poles, ducts, conduits and ROW (a field based answer) ("Requesr,.
A T& T shan have the Option to be present at the field based survey and U S WEST
shall provide AT&T at least twenty-four (24) hours notice prior to the start of such
field sulV9y. During and after this pelfod, U WEST shall affow A T& T personnel
enter manholes and equipment spaces and view pole structures to inspect such
structures in order to corifirmusability or assess the condition of the structure.
US WEST shall send AT&T a written notice confirming avaiJabHity pursuant to the
Request within such twenty (20) day period ("Confumation'.
47.10.
For the period beginning at the time of the Request and ending sixty (60)
days following Confirmation, U S WEST shall reserve such poles, ducts,
conduits and ROW for AT&T ,and shall not allow any use thereof by any
Party,lncludlng U S WEST. AT&T shall elect whether or not to accept such
poles, ducts, conduits and ROW within the sixty(60) day period following
Confirmation. AT&T may accept such facilities by sending written notice to
U S WEST ("Acceptance ). From the time of the Request pursuant to
Section 47 above until sixty (60) days after Confirmation, U S WEST
shall reserve any such requested poles, ducts, conduits andlor ROW for
AT&T's use, provided, however, that If another party makes a bona fide
request In writing to use any such requested poles, ducts, conduits andlor
ROW,lncludlng US WEST, U S WEST shall so Inform AT&T. US WEST
shall not allow the requesting party, Including Itself, to use the requested
, poles, ducts, conduits andlor ROW without first giving AT&T the right to
continue Its reservation of such poles, ducts, conduits andlor ROW by
paying U S WEST a reservation fee In an amount to be mutually agreed for
the right to continue Its reservation.
47A.10.RIght of First Refusal. During the Reservation Period, If
another party,lncludlng US WEST, makes a bona fide
request for the actual use which would commence during
the reservation periOd of any poles, ducts, conduits or
ROW that AT&T has previously reserved, AT&T shall have a
right of first refusal" over these facilities. If AT&T chooses
to exercise this right, AT&T must do so within fIVe (5)
calendar days prior to the expiration of the Reservation
Period, whichever OCCUIS first.
47.4. 11 Reservation. After Acceptance by A T& T, AT&T shall have six (6) months to begin
attachment and/or insta/Jation of its facUlties to the poles ducts,. conduit and ROW
or request U S WEST to begin make ready or other construction activities. Any
29 Per First Order at 40.
USWC!AT&T Interconnection Agreement -Idaho 07/27/98
..' "
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-
AT&T Complaint, Page 7 of 10
""""'__
"0"",
"""'-"",'""" '
such construction, installation or make ready by AT&T shall be completed by the
end of one (1) year after Acceptance. AT&T shaH not be in default of the 6-month
or 1-year requil8ment above if such default is caused in any way by any action,
Inaction or delay on the part of WEST or its Affiliates or subsidiaries.
47.12 Make Ready. U WEST shalll8arrange, modify and/or make ready existing poles,
ducts, conduit and ROW where necessary and feaSIble to provide space for A T& 1's
tequil8ments. However. U S WEST shall not be required to undertake any
modification if AT&T requeSts a modification that U S WEST would not
undertake for Itself to Increase capacity. In addition, U S WEST may offer
AT&T an economically competitive alternative to modification to meet A T&
request in lieu of actual modlflcation.SUbject to the requirements above, the
Parties shan endeavor to mutually agree upon the time frame for the completion
such work within five (5) days following A T& 1's request; provided, however, that
any such worlc required to be p81formed by U WEST shall be completed within
sixty (60) days or reasonable period of time based on standard construction
intervals in the industry, unless otherwise agreed by A T& T in writing.
' '
47.4. 13 New Construction. After Acceptance, U WEST shall. complete any new
constnJctlon, relocation or installation of poles, ducts; conduits or ROW required
be performed by U WEST or any U lIVEST construction, 19Iocation or
Installation requested by A T& T within reasonable period of time based on
standard construction intetVais in the industry or sixty (60) days after obtaining all
governmental authority or permits necessary to complete such construction,
relocation or installation. "U WEST anticipates that construction, relocation or
instailation wHl go beyond standanl industry intervals or the sbcty (60) day period,
WEST shan immediately notify A T& T a nd ,the Parties shaH mutually agree on
completion date.
47.4.14 AT&T shaH begin payment for the use of newly constructed poles ducts, conduit,
and ROW upon completion of such construction and installation and confirmation
by appropriate testing methods that the faeDities are ins condition ready to operate
in A T& 1's network or upon use (other thEm for testing) by A T& T, whichever is
earlier.
47.15 AT&T shall make payment for construction, relocation, rearrangements,
modifications and make teady in accordance with Section 3.5 of Attachment 1 of
this Agreement
47.4.16 (Intenlionally left blank for numbering consistency)
47.4.17 AT&T may, at its option, install its facDities on poles, ducts, conduit and ROWand
use AT&T or AT&T designated personnel to attach its equipment to such
WEST poles, ducts, conduits and ROw.
47.4, 18 "avaHable, U WEST shaH provide A T& T space in manholes for racking and
stotage of cable and other materials as requested by A T& T.
30 Per First Order at 41.
U8'NCIAT&T Interconnection Agreement - Idaho aT 127/98
0 ")
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-O4-
AT &T Complaint, Page 8 of 10
"......, ,' . "
47.4.19 US WEST shall rearrange, modify and/or make ready any conduit system or poles
with retired cable by removing such retired cable from conduit systems or poles
allow for the efficient use of conduit space and pole space. Before denying access
based on a lack of capacity, U S WEST must explore potential accommodations
with AT&T.
47.4.20 Where U S WEST has innerducts which are not, at that time, being used or are not
reserved as emeTgenc;y or maintenance spare in aCCOldance with FCC rules and
regulations, U S WEST shall offer such ducts for A T& T's use.
47.4.21 Whet8 a spare innerduct does not exist, US WEST shall allow AT&T to instal/an
innerduct in US WEST conduit, at AT&T's cost and expense. US WEST must
review and approve any installation of innerduct in any U WEST's duct prior to
the start of construction. SUch approval shall not be unreasonably delayed,
withheld or conditioned. A T& T shall provide notice to U S WEST of any work
activity not less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to the start of construction
47.22 Where U S WEST has any ownership or other rights to ROW to buildings
building complexes, or within buildings or building complexes, U S WEST shall offer
such ROW to AT&T.
(a)Subject to the approval of the buHdingowner, if required, the right to use
any available space owned or controlled by U S WEST in the building
building complex to install A T& T equipment and facUities;
(b)SUbject to the approval of the buDding owner, if required, ingress and
egress to such space; and
(c)Subject to the approval of the building owner, if required, the right to use
electrical power at parity with U WEST's rights to such power.
47.23 Whenever U S WEST Intends to modify or alter any poles, ducts, conduits or ROW
which contain A T& rs facUities, U S WEST shan provide written notification of such
action to AT&T so that AT&T may have reasonable oppoTtunityto acid to
modify its facRities, A T& T shall advise U S WEST, in writing, of its intentions to add
or modify the facHities withinfifleen(15) Business Days of U S WEST's notffication.
If A T& T adds to or modifies its facJ71ties according to this paragraph, A T& T shaN
bear proportionate share of the costs Incufflld by US WEST in making such
facilities accessible.
47.24 A T& T shall not be required to bear any of the costs of rearranging or replacing its
facilities, if such rearrangement or rep,acement is, required as a result of
additional attachment or the modification of an existing attachment sought by any
entity other than A T& T, including U S WEST.
, 47.4.25 U S WEST shall maintain the poles, ducts, conduits and ROW at its sole cost.
T& shall maintain its own facifdies installed within the poles, ducts,' conduits and
ROW at its sole cost. In the event of an emergency, U S WEST shaH begin repair
of its facilities containing A T& T's facilities within reasonable time frame based
industry standards or a time frame requested by A T& T. If U WEST cannot begin
USWCIAT&T Interconnection Agreement-Idaho 60 07/27/98
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-04-
AT &T Complaint, Page 9 of 10
""""""""""-"'--"-"'----"", ", \, , ,~, ., , ". ":,.,,"., " "
repair within the requested time frame. upon notice and approval of S WEST,
which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld, A T& T may begin such repairs
without the presence of U S WEST personnel. AT&T may climb poles and enter
the manholes, handholds, conduits and equipment spaces containing U S WESrs
faeRities in order to perform such emergency maintenance, but only until such time
as qualified personnel of U WEST arrives ready to continue such repairs. For
both emetgency and' non-emergency repairs, A T& T may use spare innerduct or
conduits, including the innerduct or conduit designated by U WEST
emetgency spare for maintenance purposes; prOvided, however, that A T& T may
only use such spare conduit or innerduct for a maximum period of ninety (90) days.
47.4.26 In the event of a relocation necessitated by govemmental entity exercising the
power of eminent domain, when such relocation is not reimbursable, all parties shall
share pro tata in costs for relocating the base conduit or poles and shall each pay
its own cost of cable and installation of the faCl7ities In the newly rebuilt U WEST
poles, ducts" conduits and ROw.
48.Bona Fide Request Process for Further Unbundling
48.Any request for Interconnection or access to an unbundled Network Element not already
available via price lists, tariff, or as described herein shall be treated as a Request under
this Section.
48.U S WEST shall use the Bona Fide Request Process iBFR' process as described in this
Section 48. to determine the technical feasibility of the requested interconnection or Network
Bement(s) and, for those items found to be technically feasible, to provide the terms and
timetable for providing the requested items. Additionally, elements, services and functions
which are materially or substantially different from those services, elements or functions
already provided by U WEST to itself, its Affiliates, CUstomers, or end users may, at the
discretion of A T& T, be subject to this BFR process.
48.A Request shall be submitted in Writing and, at a minimum, shaH include: (a) a complete and
accurate technical description of each requested Network Element or Interoonnection; (b)
the desired interface specifications; (e) a statement that the Interconnection or Network
Element will be used to provide Telecommunications Service; (d) the quantity requested;
(e) the location(s) requested; and (f) whether A T& T Wants the requested item(s) and terms
made generaUyavanable. A T& T may designate Request as Confidential.
48.Within forty-eight (48) hours of receipt of a Reques~ U WEST shall acknowledge IBCeipt
of the Request and review such Request for initial compliance with Subsection 48. 3 above.
In its acknowledgment, U WEST shall advise A T& T of any missing information reasonably
necessary to move the Request to the preliminary analysis descnbed in SUbsection 48.5
below.
48.Unless otherwise agreed to by the Parties, within thirty (30) calendar days of its I8C8ipt
the Request and all infarmationnecessary to process It, US WESt shaH provide to AT&T
preliminary analysis of the Request. As reasonably requested by A T& T, WEST agrees
to provide status updates to A T& T. WEST will notify A T& T if the quote preparation fee,
if any. will exceed $5,000. A T& T wHI approve the continuation of the development of the
USWCIAT&T Interconnection Agreement - Idaho 61 07/27/98
Exhibit 5
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 10 of 10
"""-'---"--'-""""""----_.'-" -"" ".....,._,-,"'.,.
_, ,..u
EXHIBIT
Qwest:--~\'~' ~~i8I--_:
. '. ,~~ - ~
BR'Jl~
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO027
INVOICE DATE: 01-2B-200~
INVOICE NO: A831695-
PREVIOUS
BALANCE
PAYMENTS + CURRENT
CHARGES
+ LATE
CHARGE
= NEW
BALANCE
AMOUNT
DUE
PAYMENT
DUE DATE
121.825. DO 121.825.121.825.D2-28-2DD~
CONDUIT RENTAL LICENSE AGREEMENT I-OOOIC APPLICATION' 88-1 (ID)ONE INNERDUCT FROM POCATELLOJUNCTION TO DANBY ROAD IN POCATELLO. ID~4. 300 FEET ~ $2.75 PER FOOT
FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY 1. 2004 THRU DECEMBER 31. 2004
PREVIOUS BANI BJOO125E
REFER BILLING QUESTIONS TO
JERI ROGAN [phone]
SUMMARY OF CURRENT CHARGES
CHARGES
CURRENT CHARGES 121.825.
TOTAL CURRENT CHARGES 121.825.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS. PLEASE CALL [phone]
'ife f u;.~ -this -
;;;-
.:1 i ;-n -;'1 ~iii -you,: - payment- -:- ;;Ye;;;-;'--;;;'1-t;-'rh;- 1 n;o1 i;- i- -(j n -y(j~;.- ch;;c k .
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO027
INVOICE DATE: 01-28-2004 INVOICE NO: A831695-050102 11902132
, AMOUNT ENCLOSED:
~~r~~II&I~~il!~i:~~~~~: ~~:~;i~!~~llilljfil~~~~~1 m1iltlli!!:~:~lj
RETURN PAYMENT TO:
QWEST
O. BOX 2348
SEATTLE. WA 98111 2348
ATTN: ATTN: GRE LEASE ADMIN
AT&T
55 CORPORATE DRRM 21C70
BRIDGEWATER. NJ 08807
! .
'20501021 D 18 J I D 0 027 A 8 31 b '5012 8 20D~ aDD 012182 50DD7US wel
Exhibit 6
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 1 of 5
_. .. -,
Qwest.--~f"~J-
.....
ACCOUNT NO I ID BJIDO028
INVOICE DATE: 01-28-2004 INVOICE NO: A831696-
::r D COil/)) AA 8 ~().6l)lJ
PREVIOUS - PAYMENTS + CURRENT + LATE =: NEW AMOUNT PAYMENTBALANCECHARGESCHARGEBALANCEDUEDUE DATE
82,959.82,959.82,959.02-28-2004
CONDUIT RENTAL LICENSE AGREEMENT I-OOlC APLICATION I 88-3 (ID)
ONE INNERDUCT FROM 619 BANNOCK (BOISE MAIN) TO FEDERAL WAY AND AMITY25,526 FEET a $3.25 PER FOOT
FOR tHE PERIOD JANUARY I, 2004 THRU DECEMBER 31, 2004
PREVIOUS BANI BJOO126E
REFER BILLING QUESTIONS TO
JERI ROGAN [phone]
SUMMARY OF CURRENT CHARGES
CHARGES
CURRENT CHARGES 82,959.
TOTAL CURRENT CHARGES 82,959.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL [phone]
if; t ~ ,:n- t ii is -;;0- rt i o-n -with - y-
;~ ,,- -
;;;-;;ii:t -::- ;;Y;; 5"8-- ;;::r.f; - 7fti;-in v ;;'i" -on - y Our-- ~ heck.
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO028
INVOICE DATE: 01-28-2004 INVOICE NO. A831696-050102 11902132-_D
111~~~!jj!~I~K~:~:::. :Ji~I!:ji~i 1t~~~m~~~:1iitlll~;~~~~~1 i~~~gl~lil~~
AMOUNT ENCLOSED:
RETURN PAYMENT TO:
QWES1
O. BOX 2348
SEATTLE, WA 98111 2348
ATTN: ATTN: GRE LEASE ADMIN
AT&T
55 CORPORATE DR RH 21C70
BRIDGEWATER, NJ 08807
CJ2DSD1D2ID /BJIDDD28A831bl:JbD1282DD4SDDDD82~ r;q cnnAII't"I.lr
Exhibit 6
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 2 of 5
1.: Qwest~.FEB 2004
1)..-
- -.
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO026
INVOICE DATE: 01-28-2004 INVOICE NO: A831694-
'XD ColV~R. 86~ilJa
PREVIOUS - PAVMENTS + CURRENT + LATE = NEW AMOUNT PAVMENTBALANCECHARGESCHARGEBALANCEDUEDUE DATE
-111506.151119.612.612.02-28-2DG'"
CONDUIT RENTAL LICENSE AGREEMENT I-OOOIC APPLICATION I 88-2
ONE INTERDUCT FROM BIRCH TO FILMORE STREET IN JEROME IDAHO
652 FEET a $3.25 PER FOOT PER VEAR
FOR THE PERIOD JANUARV 1, 2004 THRU DECEMBER 311 2004
PREVIOUS BANI BJOO124E
REFER BILLING QUESTIONS TO
JERI ROGAN [phone]
SUMMARV OF CURRENT CHARGES
" ,.
CHARGES
CURRENT CHARGES 15,119.
TOTAL CURRENT CHARGES 15,119.
IF VOU HAVE ANV QUESTIONS I PLEASE CALL [phone]if; of u~n.thi-s ;~-rtio n -wi-ih-you;,--pBYmen :r-;Yeasewrrte-t"he-invol.cei'-on-y aur-ch e~k .
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO026
INVOICE DATE: 01-28-2004 INVOICE NO: A831694-087318 11902132I_"
il~i~~j~l i~j~f~1i~~lfii_l~ lli1~~I~ilt~~lti
AMOUNT ENCLOSED:
RETURN PAVMENT TO I
QWEST
O. BOX 2348
SEATTLE, WA 98111 2348
ATTN: GRE LEASE ADMIN
AT&T
55 CORPORATE DR RM 21C70
BRIDGEWATER I NJ 08807
CJ208 7318ID IBJIDOD2bA83JrbCW40Jr2820D4:1. DDDOD4J.' ::111 an r......... .
Exhibit 6
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 3 of 5
, ,
Qwest~'
~--
ACCOUNT NO : ID BJIDO026
STATEMENT DATE: 01-28-2004
CUSTOMER ID I 087318
O~IVJA\e Zb~6l
BILLING AUTHORITY NUMBER ACCOUNT STATEMENT
DATE INVOICE PREVIOUS PAYMENTS + CURRENT + LATE = NEWBALANCE& CREDIT CHARGES CHARGES BALANCE
01-28-04 A831694 15,119.15,119.
06-04~02 A716837 -10,506.-10,506.
TOTAL 612.
Exhibit 6
Case # ATT-O4-AT&T Complaint, Page 4 of 5
Q w e s t-----t~ . lllil ~t iiI. 4 IUU4
I~~jr-' - ~m 1m ~~ij;"...~r;rmlli ~.III " ",?-~S/,i,.;,t'
:\/:
O';\l ";;':;'2';;-;'
;\;;) ,
;:;;r':',W.';!~'!:Wf';:'
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO029
INVOICE DATE:' 01-28-2004
INVOICE NO: A831697-
./'.
J-D&JIUDA A3' ;)700
PREVIOUS - PAVMENTS + CURRENT'+ LATE = NEW AMOUNT PAVMENTBALANCECHARGESCHARGEBALANCEDUEDUE DATE
208.419.208.1t19.208.419.02-28-2014
CONDUIT RENTAL LICENSE AGREEMENT I-0001C APPLICATION NUMBER 88-4 (10)
ONE INNERDUCT FROM BOISE MAIN TO MERIDAN. LINDER ROAD & PINE
64,129 FEET a $3.25 PER FOOT
FOR THE PERIOD JANUARV 1. 2004 THRU DECEMBER 31. 2004
PREVIOUS BANI BJOO127E
REFER BILLING QUESTIONS TO
JERI ROGAN [phone]
SUMMARY OF CURRENT CHARGES
CHARGES
CURRENT CHARGES 208.419 .
TOTAL CURRENT CHARGES 208.419.
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CALL [phone]
if e iu rn--i h 1-
p~-
;H~-
;,'
r ili -Y-ou r- p-;ym-;nF- :-pYea;;- - ;r1- i;- th; in v;; 1""i ;-.- 0 n - you .,.-- c he c-k" .
ACCOUNT NO: ID BJIDO029
INVOICE DATE: 01-28-2004 INVOICE NO: A831697-050102 11902132
AMOUNT ENCLOSED:
RETURN PAYMENT TO I
, QWEST
O. BOX 2348
SEATTLE WA 98111 2348
ATTN: ATTN: GRE LEASE ADMIN
AUT
55 CORPORATE DR RM 21C70
BRIDGEWATER. NJ 08807
'120501021)) IBd 1 0029A831b'1701282004 20002084 ).1:I;ll;;n 1;;1I~ldr /
Exhibit 6
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 5 of 5
EXHIBIT
exhibit A
Idaho.
--_j!
lr'~~~III Jl\~i.i1~i.!~;ljl,i~~I~1.0'ReN. Ie'Wholesale WhoI888Ie
DIscount DIScount
Percenlage Pen:entage
RecurrIng ,Nonrecurring
Charges Charges
Wholesale Discount Rates
Sou1hem Idaho
BasIc ExChanae Residential line Service 18.25%11.25%BasIc ExChanae Business Une SefVIce 18,25%18.25%IntraLATA Toll 18.25%18.25'ICPackagelSpecial Servi""" (e.9-, Centrex, DIscounted LlnelFealure Packages,18.25%18.25'11ISON, PBX-TNnks, DSS & UAS, Frame Relay Service, LAN, MegaBit and other
ACS)
UstI""". CO Features & InIOrmaIIon S8fVIces 18.25%18.25%PrIva1e line 18,25%18.25%0ltemItIr Services Dlrectorv AssIs1ance IOSIDAI 18.25%18,25'110Volume PIICkaIIed SenIIces . Hlah Volume Customel$65%65%1.8 Public Access LIne PALl Service 00%oo'!ll
Nollhem Idaho
2.1 Basfc Excnsnaa Residential Une Service 19.37%19,37%1.2.2 Basic Exchanae Bualness Une ServIce PBX 19,37%19.37%2.3 InlraLATA TOIl 19.37%19,37%2.4 Package/Speclal Servfcea (e.g" Centrex, Discounted UnelFeature Packages,19.37%19.37%ISON, PBX- TNnke, DSS & OAS, Frame Relay Service. LAN, MegaBit and oilierACSI
2.5 UstInns CO Features & Information Services 19.19.37%2.5 Private Une 19.87%19.37%2.7 OrIsrator Services Dlrectorv Assfstance OSIDAI 19,37%19,37'!C1.2.8 Volume PaCKaaIKI Services - Hloh Volume CusIDfI1IIIII 67%87'1112.9 Public Access Una (PAL ServIce 00%00%
6.2 Customer Transfer Cham. lercl
62.1 erc for POTS Service
2.1.Manual
FRSt Line ~16,Each Additional Una 52.27
6.2.1.MeChanized
6.2.2.1 FirstUne SO.Each Additional Une SO.
2.2 CTC for Private Une TrenSMrt Services
62.2. 1 First CIrcuit $36.6.2,2.2 Additional CIrcuit. D8I' clrcul same CSR $33.
erc for Advanced Convnunicatians Se~ oer CIrcuit iHtI.
InterconnecUon
7.1 Entrance Faclities
Left Blank
OSI 1103.S208,1.3 DS3 1524.42 5Zf7.
7.2 USEICT
2.1 PerDSI SO.SO.2.2 Per DS3 SII SO.
7.3 erred Tranked T.........."
intentionallY Left Blank
7.3,DS1
3.2.1 Over 0 to 8 MBes .35 $1.3.2.2 Over 8 to 25 Miles 7.35 $1.827.3.2.3 Over 25 to 60 MIles 7.35 11.89Over 60 MUes 7.35 51.90
DS3
Over 0 to 8 Mias $2S7,119,3.3.Owr8 1025 Miles S26Q,524,Over 2510 60 MBes 1260.$26.4SOver 60 MIles 5259.128.35
7.4 MulUalexlnn
DSIIo DSO 12&3.88 $193.30
Qwest Idaho SGAT Third Revision ExhJbI A 5th Amended Aprt1 28, 2004 Exhibit 7 ,
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 1 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho
1...:111
7.5 Trunk Non
Irmnflnn..uv left Blank
5.2 DS11n1erface
F"U8t Trunk
2.2 Each Additional Trunk
DS3 Interface
3.1 First Trunk $235,Each Addttlonal Trunk $11.
Ellchanaa Service tEASILocan TraffIC
End Office Call Termination ~er Minute of Use $0.001343 l1li#Tandem SwItched TRIllS""" Per Minute of Use $0.000890
Tandem Transmission nAr Minute of Use
6.3,Over 0 to 8 Mles SiiOOO4564 OIIOO3878.3.2 Over 8 \0 25 MBea OOO4584 $0.l1OOO867Over 25\0 50 Miles $0.0004584 OOOO387Over 50 MIles . ItnOOO4280 $0.0000144
L0C81 Traffic-FCCfSP Rate Cane
MOU June 14 2OQ3.June 13 2004 $0,0007
Miscellaneous Chllnles
7.8,Expedite Charge (LIS Trunks)Qwests Idaho
Acceaa S8IVIce
Caialog
8.2 Cancellation Charge (US Trunks)0Nesfs Idaho
Access ServIce
Catalog
AddItIonal Testing (US Trunks)0west'8 Idaho
Accesl SeIYIce
CaIaIog
Transit Traffic
Local Transtt (Local Transit Assumed Mleage = 7 Mias)Sea TIItICIem S. Tandem
Switching and SwItching and
Tandem TlIt1dem
Transmission Transmission
Rates NKNe.Rates Above.
IntraUt.TA Transit Tol (IntralATA Transit ToU Assumed Mlea9a = 7 Mles)a--. Idaho QweaI's Idaho
Access SeMce Aa:as SenIk:e
CaIaIog Calalog
JoinUy PIVVIdecI SwIIched Access aWS'e kI8ho Qwest's awest'8ld8hoAcce8a SeMce Ac:cess S8Mce Acceu 8eMce
CaIIIog Catalog Catalog
Cats""'" 11 Mechanized Record~. -rRecord 1tn0014877
CoIIoc8Uon
All CoIlocaUon
Plannlno and
IntenIIa~... Left Blank
1.2 Cable Quole Pre""- Filii S1 ""'.30
EnItance FaciiiU
1.2. 1 Standard Shared. "'" Fiber 5818.328.1.2.2 Cross eon- -- fiber $5.~852.3 Cable 1A8,1il009.
Callie Snlkft1
3.1 fiber. Per Set~~$389.1.8,""r Fiber Snllced $37.
Power U""""
-48 Volt DC PowerU reo """Month
Power Plant
1.4,Power Plimt - Leas than 80 $10.
Qwest Idaho SGATThlrd RevIsIon Exhibit A , 5th Amended Apt1125, 2004 Page 2 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 2 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho
1lIr((1it1I1~~jJ~!i ~: B!1~_lli~~'11111.4,1.1.Power Plant - Equal1D or GIeater Than 60 Amps $8,
Power USa\18
1.4.1.2.1 Power Usaae 611 Amos or Less, ller Ama $2.471.4.1.2.2 Power U....... Mare Than 60 $4.113
N:; Power Feed
1.5.N:; Power Feed Month
5.1.120 V S18.1.5.1.2 208 V SinGle Phase $27,1.5.1,208 V Th- Phase 548,
8.1.6,240 V SlIXI1e Phase $32.19240 V Three
_..
5!I!leB
1.6 480 V Three Phase &111.
N:; Power FIHIII. aer FoaL ner Month
5.2.1 20 AmP. SInGle Phase 00841.5.2.2 20 Arne. Three Phase 0105 $8,1.5.2.311 Arne. SInaIe Phase .GO911.5,311 AII1b. Three Phase 0125 11,1.5.2.5 40 AII1D, SIIKIIB Phase $0.0107 2.8 40 ARID. Three Phase 0147 12.5.2.7 50 ARID, Sina18 Phase 10,0127 11.1.5.2.8 50 Anm. Three Phase $0.0177 15,5.2.9 60 Ama, Sinale Phase 10.0144 12,1.5.2.10 60 Arne. Three Phase $0,0204 $17,5.2.11 100 AmP. Slno/e Phase 10.0178 :li15.5.2,100 AmD. Three Phase 0277 $24.
1.8 Insoectar Lebar. oer Half Hour
:m~1.8.Remdar Haws Rate
6.2 After HaulS Rate minimum 3 hOUlS
Channel Reaeneratian
1.7.OSI $0,7.2 OS3 Reaeneratlon so.OO
Collocation TennInatians
Shared Access
OSO
Cable PIaaImBnt. oar 100 PaIr Black 50.2262 S2IIII.81.Cable Placement. oerTarmInaIIon $O.G0901.3 Cabl... 081' 100 PaIr Block 10.3304 $304.1.4 Ca"" -TermlnaUan 0066 54.50
1.5 Black&. oer 100 Pair Block 5730 $528,1.8,Blocks -TennInaIIan 0116
Block r 100 PaIr Block .2381 5219.1.8 Block PI TermlnaUan 0048 $3,
1.2 OS1
1.8,1.2.Cable PlacemenL - 28 DS18 .111 ~141.8,1.2.2 Cable Termnatian ;0442
1.8.1.2.3 Cable 28 DSI..3!193 5351.
1.2.4 Cable Tennination 0429 1.8,1.2.5 Panel 28 OSI. ..2742 1.691.2.8 Panel Tennloelion cO33O1.8.1.2.7 Pm1eI 211 OS1.0847 4.681.2.8 Panel PI TennInaIIoo .GO91 $8,
1.3 OS3
Cable P rTermIn8IIon 1521
too
1.3.Cable -Tennlnatfon 50.25781.8,Canriactor. nerTerminatton SII.21125 1.211.3,Canneclor Placement. ller T ermINIIIan $0.0204 18.
FiberTennInaIIon
8.1.1.4,TemIInatIons. oor 12 FIbers S21L24 11.513,1.8.AddiIIonaI ConnecCar (If aDOlIcabIe 10.S811.1.8.Cable Rackino. ShaIed. OBI 12 F'obenI S26
1.8.1.4.Cable Ractdng . Oedlcaled $1.63 $1.433.96
Securllv Ch:mIA
PerE Card SII9.2 Card Office $7,
Qwest Idaho SGAT ThIrd Revision ExhIbIt A 5th Amended ApII 28, 2004 Page3af18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 3 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho
Camoos~e Clock Cenllal OIliCl!SVnchronizalion
1.10.Svm:hronaatfon - Comooslte Clock. Iier Port 51.
IntentionallY Left Blank
Saace AvaDabIIltv Chame 1313,
Collocation Space ReSIIIVaIion Fee Tho cIIaIge wi ..
25% the
NonreamfngFe
Collocation Soao& Oction Administration Fee $1107,
Collocation S Fee, oer 5aUare Foot ili2.0Q
8.2 VIrtual Colloca1lon
Plannl.... and Fees
8.2.1.Quote Pr&OaratJon Fee 13 148.B 7
8.2.2 MaInIenance Labor. IHY'HalfHour
8.2.2.1 Reaular HourI Rate $29.012.2.2 Aller Hours lImA $39,
Traln!na Labor. IHY'HalfHour
8.2.3,ReouIar HoulB Rate
2.4 IbvSo:II!A
8.2.4.Eoul Shelf
2.4.2 VIrtual SD8C8 Constlllctlon Inftfal Bav Provided $20.S17749.Each Addillonal Bay SDaC8 $3.24 52.854.33V1r1uaf Cable Raddltll. per Shelf 50,$384.
EMineerina Labor. per Half Hour
2.5.Reoular Hours Rate 532.942.5.AJtar HouI1l Rate $43.
Instanatfon Labor. ner Half Hour
8.2.6.ReouJar Hours Rate 131.8.2,6.2 Atfer HouI1l Rate 541.32
8.2.7 Rent
8.2.Floor Space Leaae. D8f 5011818 Foot 52.702.7.2 Rent. "'" Shelf
2.8 IntenUonaIIv l8II Blank
Power Plant
2.9,~8 DC Power Cable
8.2.9.20 Arm Power FefId $4.52 985.8.2.9.1.2 30 ArnD Power Feed SII $4.1i37.878.2.9.40 Amp Power Feed 81.22 $Ii 1te0,8.2.9.eo MID Power Feed 511-708.038.2.9,1.5 100 AmD Power Feed 18,1018.370.518.2.9.200 AmD Power Feed $30"'73.2.9,300 ArnD Power Feed 1047917.2.8.400 AIm Power Feed 037.
PhVIIlcal CoIIDCatlon
PllII1nln" end ~lneerIna Fee
8.3,Quale P'--Fee 103.148.41
Soam ConstJuctlon and S1Ie
2.1 Site PnlDaratlon Fee ICE2.2 2 BaIIR 523.$20 803.402.3 I-HIt l8II 81ank
2.4 l8II Blank
2.5 SD8C8 Construclon for Each Additlonallbv $3.24 52 854.33
8,3,2.8 Adloslmenl for BaY - ChanOB 10 S1andard Deslon 153.24 1li2 854,
8.3.2.7 DC Power Cable
8.3,2.7.20 AmD Power Feed $4.52 53.985.2.7.2 30 ArnD Power Feed 1iS $4637,8.3.2.7.3 . 40 Amn Power Feed SB,111480.42
Qwest Idaho SGA T Third RevisIon ExhIbit A 5Ih Amended ApriI2fI, 2004 Page 4 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 4 of 18
exhibit A
Idaho
~t~!~J~~t,j~n~i~'~11~~IJ~'~B~~; ~
~'j
8.3. . .2,eo. Power Feed 11.$9 708.1ooAm Power Feed S16J170.613.2.7,200 Am Power Feed S30.473.11,3.2.7.300 AIr PO\Y8I' Feed 5471117,11711.400 Am PawIll'Feed 77.S6II 037,02
3.3 Floor SDaC8 Lease. IIer SlllJare Foot 12.
can.d -leal Collocation
Plannlna and
Quote Prenanollnn Fee S3.185.
SNIt!A ConslnJctlon and SRe Preaaration
Site PreoaraUon Fee JCI'4.2,Intentionally l.el Blank
2.3 Intentionally Left Blank
4.2.4 Soaae ConstnJcIIDn
4.2.4.r- Unto 100 80, Fl
161
133,927,4.2.4.2 C- -101 Sa. A. la 200 50. Fl $30 113.
~ .
201 80, Fl to 300 Sa. Fl 2.18 537154,2.4,CaD. . 301 So. Fl to 400 So. R.$44.$38,922.82
4.2,IntenIIOIIBIIY Left Blank
8.4.2.8 IntanllonaAv Left Blank
4.2.DC Power Cable
2.7,20 Arm Power Feed $5,54.854.852.7.2 30 .6"", Power Feed S6.20 $5457.4.2.7,40 Amn Pawer Feed M.5262.7.60 Am.. Power Feed 12.23 $10772.11.4.2,~Pawer Feed 1.2911."'.2.7.
11.4.2.7.300 Amn Power Feed
11,2.7.. 400 Amn Power Feed 8J!.1.29
Soace ConsInJcIIDn - FencIn Credit
c.mo. Uato 100 , R.10.071 58723.124.3.caae 101 . 200 G. Fl 12.70 trr 135.89
11,4.3.~2O1 -300 . Fl 14.471 ft6.2811.4.3.L;aae 301 -400 ill. FI,18,1.38
FIODr SallC8 Lease, DOr 5aUaJ'B Foot 52.70
Inl8nlionallv Left Blank
IntentionallY Left Blank
IntentiDnallv Left Blank
Groundlna
2/0AWG r Foal 00978.2 1/0AWG Foot $0.0170 S14,8.3 4/0AWG ...Foot 0200 $17.84350 kI:miI rFDDt
8.6 500 kcIriI FDDt 0299 750 Foal 0468 S40,
8.5 Adw..nt Colloc8tion
Re- ~nlloc:aIIon
Phvslcal &. VorIuBI Remote CoIIoca1Ion
11,11.SDIICB tiler Standard Ununtlnn Un.!1It'J $665,11.1.2 FDI~2S PAIr!10.35 1.3 Power U""'"
11,1.3,Power Usa... 80 or Leas. IIer Amn $2.47
11,8.1.3.Power Usaoe More Than 80 $4.9311.1.4 Quote S1 JIII4.62
6.2 Ad'-nt Remota CoUocaIIon
11,2.1 AdIal:snI R8I1IOIe Collocation New'ICB11,2.2 Adiacent RentDIII Collocation lExIsIIno!
11.6.2.2.1 SDaC8 ,...., Standard MountIna Una
11.2.2.2 FDI Termina1klns tD8f25 Pair!$0.35 8.2.2.3 Power Usa-
QwetlldahoSGA T ThIrd RevIsIon ExhIbR A 5th Amended Aprl 28, 2004 P8ge5of18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 5 rift8
Exhibit A
Idaho
8.2.2,3.2 Power Usa"" Mare Than 60
2.2.4 QuoI8 -ration Fee 11:1 064.52
8.3 Additional VIrtual R.......... CoI1acaIIon Bernera
8.3.Flat Cha~ Job
8.3.Rate -Half Hour
8.3.3 HalfHaur
8.3.1nstaI1- -Half Hour
Tralnlftn -- Half Hour $29.40
ClI't". '" CLEC
Deslan E~"""""'" & InS1aUation
Flat C n ~nnlneerinn . No Cables\
FIber Flat C"s_S1 """.81
7.2 Cable "-""",, Per Foot
DSO n;r FtW er Cable 118482.2 DS1 -rF"'"- Cable 130767.2.DS3 ruwFoot ... Cable 10234FIber-Fnot """ Fiber 83313
7.3 VII1uel ConnectIona ""'"""lcable - Connections onIv; No cables
DSO 100 Connections 11:184,3.2 DS1tPer 28 ConnedIoni\11:01,
3.3 DS3 II2cw 1 CoI1lll!Gllon
7.3.Fiber ConnectIons:- Mr FIber SnUMtt 11:.'17
Cable Hole If AnnIlcabIGY
CLEC to CLEC Cross Connection 11:-
Inten:onnecllon Distribution Frame "CD~ Colloc.oUon ICE
8JI A-cation 10 Reauest C.ncellaUon NoCh
Microwave CoIocaUon -c-Under
D8II8I-111
IntentJonaDv Left Blank
8.12 Intentl""~11v left Blank
= P-r Reduction
13.1 QuOte PnI""ratJon Fee 5703,13.2 Power Reduc:Iion Less than 6O AiiiiHo~
IAS
13.Power Reduction ........ to 80
13,Power Reduction Greater than 60 Arn-=
13.Power On Off $821.0913.IbIMIv DIstributIon F\I8e SoardTBDFBI Rent $84,
8.14 Collocation Transfw of R.siiwiCibliiiV
14.Left Blank
14.~Fee S1 038.0014.3 Network AdmInIsIraIIon Fee 1.1 588.00
L18 IntentIonaIIv Left Blank
8.J1 Unbundled Ne_rk Elements tUNES'
Intefconn P.Ir8/ITD' - Par Tennlnlltlon
DSO !.n
1.2 DS1 S1.
1.3 DS3 11:14,
8.2 Unhun
2.1 Analoa Loo""See 9.2.42.1.2-Wire Voice
8.2.1,Zone 1 115,88 8,2,1.2 Zone 2 "'23.78 9.2.1.1.3 Zone 3 S4a.60
Intentional'" Left Blank
2.1.3 ..we Voice Grade Looo
9.2.1.3.1 Zone 1 70
Qwesf Idaho SGA T ThInI RevIsIon ExhIbIt A 5th Amended Ap1t12S, 2004 Page 8 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-AT&T Complaint, Page 6 of 18
ExhibIt A
Idaho
2.1,ZOne 2 83 2.1.3,Zone 3 47
2.2 Nonloaded looM See &.2.4&.2.2.2-'dlnn"
2.2.ZOne 1
185
8.2.2,1.2 ZOne 2 till2.2.1.3 ZOne 3
""""tiMaUv I .... Blank
&.2.2.3 4-WIre NanIoacIed lMft
&.2.2.3.1 Zone 1 S3O.2.2.3.2 Zone 2 548,83 2.2.3.3 Zone 3 S79.47
8.2.2.4 Loon Un/nsuRnn 59.2.2.5 Looo Concrollonlna S22.oo A.8
&.2.3 DitlItaJ
2.3.Basic Rate ISDN / xDSL-I ('--able / ADSL S-'I,2.49.2.3,1.1 Zone 1
166
2.3.Zone 2
2.3.1.Zone 3 .50
9.2.3.2 Intention""" Left Blank
9.2.3,DS1 Cariable LooD See-9.2.68.2.3.Zone 1 586.48 8.2.Zone 2 $68.48 2.3.Z"""3 $99.98
DS3 Canable Lnnrt Se&4I.2.67n_'
"'"
2.3,4.2 ZOne 2 04
Zone 3 S1 264,till
2.3.OC-nCs"""'elnnn See-8.2.72.3.OC-S1124,
OC-12 , S1314m2.3.5.OC-46 53.528.
2.3.WInt Extension TAclwonIntN S22,
8.2.4 =..,":IIIIlation CIIa
~~: ~
4 win! Analog / d~ed. ADSl CompatiIIIe. ISDN BRI See 8.2. 1 &and xDSL -I Ca e Loons where cond . Is not Mnufred.9.2.28.2.4.BasIc Inslallation
2.4,FIrst S11,2.4,1.2 Each Additional 1A07
9.2.4.BaaIc Installation with Pedoonance TAIIIIna
8.2.4,2.1 Fnt LooD ~7,8.2.4.2.2 Each Additional 58,
8.2.4.3 CoordInated InsIaIatIon with CooperatIve Testing I PnIject CoonIinated InsIaIIaIIon
8.2.4.3,FirslloDD 5171.872.4.3.2 Each Additional SD4
9.2.4,CcIonIinaIed Installation without Coopemllve T88Ik1g / PItIject Coordinated
lnsIIIIIation
9.2.4,FIrst LooD $69.812.4,4.2 Each AddIttDnaI 5""".32
9.2.4.6 Bask: III&IaUatlDn wfth
2.4.5.FIrst .........5142.1092""7 E"""A"""""'a'SAI.
2.5 DSt LOOD Installation ChamAs See 9.2.3.39.2.5.1 BasIc Installallon
9.2.6.Find LooD 5128.&.2.5.1.2 Each'Addltlonai 5911
9.2.5.2 Basic: InsIaIlalion with Performance Testi""
Qwest Idaho SGAT ThIrd Revl&lonlExlibiC A lith Amended AprI28, 2004 PIIge 7 at 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 7 of
Exhibit A
Idaho
8.2.5.2.2 Each Addlllonal 2.5T
8.2.5.3 CoonI1nated InstaIation wlthCooperaIive Testing PIOje!:t Coordinated Installation
9.2.First UXID 5318.5.3.2 Each Additional S~40
2.5.4 CooIdInated Installation without Cooperative Testing Project CoordinatedInstallation
9.2.Find: Loco 8135.2.5.4.2 Each Addlllonal 108.
9.2.5.5 Basic: Installation with Coo-lYe Tm:l1nn
Fht UXID 5272.24
Each Adcfdlonal :&195,
9.2.8'DS3 l.ooD Installelion aJames See 9.2.3,2.8.Basic installation
2.8,FIrst Loop 5128,2.8.1.2 Each Additional 5119.
9.2.8.Basic Installation with Perfonnance TestIno
2.8,FIrst L.oop $279.372.8.2.2 ElICh Additional $212.57
9.2.8.3 Coordinated Installation with Cooperallve Testing Projeel Coordinated Installation
2.6.3.FIrst LooD 15318.8.2.6.Each Additional S222.4O
9.2.Coordinated Ins1ell8tlon wilhout CooperaIive Testing Project CoordlnaledIns1aIation '
9.2.8,Find lJxID $135.Each Additional 108.
9.2.6.5 Basfc InstaUatIon wllh CooIIIII'atiWI TeBIInD
FIf&! Looo S272.24
Eech ACldillonal 195.l1li
aC-3 12,48 LooplnsialationChames See 9.2.3.2.7.Basic Instanelion
9.2.7.FInIt Loop S128.2.7.1.2 Each AddIIionaII..OOo 599,
9.2.7.2 Basic Installation with P8Ifonnanoe T
2.7.2,Firat loaD $279.37E- AddlUlIII81 Loon :&212.
2.7.Coordinated JnsIaUaIIan willi Tesllna
9.2.7.Find: LooD 18.9.2.7,Each AddItIonal Loon S222.4O
2.7.Coordinated IlI8IaIIeIion wIIhcIuI TestIno
2.7.~Lnnn $135,'7.4.2
BasIc Installation with Teallna
9.2.7,FIrst UXID
8.2.7,5.2 Each AddHIonaII..OOo $195.
2.8 Privale line to Unbundled loaD Conv8I1ion8 $34.110
1.3 SuIII-
3.1 Wire DisIribuUon Loop (Applies to both AnIIkta end NonIoaded
8.3,Fht 107.82
Each Addllonal 1i2II.113
FIrst & Each Add'1IIonaI 2.Wire DisIdbutIon l.ooD
1.3,Zone 1 511.001.3.Zone 2 :&16.701.3.Zone 3 527.5'1
IrdenUonallY Left Blank
Intra-Buildinn Cable LoaD, Per Pair $0.
Qwest IdahO SGAT ThIrd RevIsIon ExhIbIt A 5th Amended AprI 28. 2004 Paee8of18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 8 of 18
Exhibit A
ldaho*
9.3,3.2 No DlsDBICIL Each Addllfonal &21 9.3.3.CIs- First
' -
9.3.DlsDaICIL Each Addllfonal SUe:
3.4 Feeder LoaD
OS I caMbia Feeder loon
9,3,4,t,FIIst S310,9,3,1.2 Each Additional 5221,FInit & Each Addllfonal OS1 CaMbie Feeder LaOD
3.4.1.3.Zone 1 571.20
D:3A. 1 ,3.2 Zone 2 ST1, tiff.1.3,Zone 3 590,
MTE T enrinal SubJooo Access
3.5.SublooD MTE - POI Site Invent uestl
MTE . POI Rea""""""'" of Faclllles
MTE . POI CoiIstruc:Ifon of New SPOt Ice
IntenI!onatlv Left Blank
9.3.7 FIeld Connection PoIntlFCPI
FeaslbliIY Fee Quote --on Fee $1197.9,3,7.2 FCP Reclassification _.2111
IntenllOnallv Left Blank
lntenIIonanv Left Blank
Intentionally Left Blank
Construc:tIon Fee lei'
Shared Services
ShanId LaoD. ,per Looo SO.$3S.
8.4.2 UNE - P Line SDliIIIDa
2.1 Basic Installation for UNE-P Line SDIiIIino $33.
LaOD Solillina
Basic Instanallon CIuImA for LaoD Snl1tllnn $33
ass, Une. Del'Mon\I1 U.23
Reclass1fication Chams ICBSDiIter Shelf CharlIe $503.
8A.Snlitler TIE Cable ComectIons
S IIIIIBr in the Common Area-Dala 10 410 block 06 ' s 889,. S Utter In the Conmm Ar8a-Data direct ID ClEC 3.248A,Iller an the IDF. Data 10 410 Block
S Iter on the IDF - Data dInIct 10 CLEC 1 823.S liter on the MDF-Oata ID 410 block SO,5881,9.4.S Iftteran the MDF - Data dliectto CLEC !I:"S1 822.42
Ennlneertnn 51 079.85
1.5 Networtllnterr- DevIce !NIDI !I:O.51 ~76
Unbundled Dedicated Interom.... TransDort UDm
8:6,DSO UDIT n41,0-0 to 8 MDes .211.2 0-61D25Mlas $24..231.3 0- 2510 50 Mias 524
Over 50 MIas 524.
OS1 UOIT 1i2II4.5262.0vRr01o8 Miles s:!8 S3.20Over 8 to 25 MItes !l:37.26 $3,. B6.2.Over 25 to 50 Mias,$38,51.6.2.4 Over 50 Miles U7,$0,
DS3 UDIT S284.52Over 0 10 8 Mles $238,$54,3.2 Over81D 25 MItes 5242.03 516,0- 25 10 50 Miles 1223.90 521.34
Qwest Idaho SGAT ThInI Revlston Exhibit A 5th Amended AprIlS, 2004 Page 9 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 9 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho
6.4 oc-s UDIT
0.- 0 to 8 MRea ot703.S38
Over 8 to 25 Mles $763.S38.Over 25 to 50 MnBS *763.70 $38,Over 50 Miles $763.70 $86.83
&.5 oc.12 UDIT $295.086.6.Over 0 to 8 Miles "" 163.&1 S72.685.2 Over 8 to 25 MIles ,,? 103,S72J!8Over 25 to 50 Mlea "" 163.*72.88Over 50 Miles "2 163,5135.97
0C48 UDIT *""".08Over 0 to 8 Miles !U. 420,*183,Over 8 to 25 Mies 54~2O,5183.75
8.8.Over 25 to 50 Mles $4 420,911 $183.75
Over 50 MOBS u,42O.-28
11.UDIT DSO Channel Performance
DSO UDIT Low SIde Channelization "13,7.2 DS11 DSO Muv Law SIde ChannellzalJon rf.7.rf.191.93
UDIT MulliDlexi~
DS1 to DSO -,86 52S8.D38.2 DSStoDS1 S3M.22 51 996.
Extended Unbundled Dedicated Interoffice Tnm.'IfItVt
8.9.DS1 E-UDIT $80,DS3 E-lJDIT ~1,5347.84QC..3 E-lJDIT 12.63OC-12 E-lJDIT S427.8904:0"ni- -::Ail E-UD
....'
1"n.,
Remote Node I Remote Port
10.QC..3 Remote Node
10,Remote Node !U.78,
10.DS1 Remote Port S3.65 "198.10,1.3 DS3 Remote Port u9.$198.88
10.OC-12 Remote Node
10,2.1 Remota Node ""94,10.2.2 DS1 Remote Port 112.87 $198.8810.DSS Remote Port rr..""OQ rf.198.88
10.2.4 oc-a Remote Port $103.198.
10.QC..48 Remote Node
10.Remote Node $3'Jt1'710.3.2 DS3 Remote Port $22.34 198.88
10.QC..3 Remote Port rf.121,rf.198.88
10.3,OC-12 Remote Port 'U79.98.88
UDIT ReeIl1l-
11.DSO S"""" 0tIice 184.408.6.11.2,DSO Dual 0IIIcIJ
11.3 SI""'" Office
8.11.Dual 0IIIce
1.7 Unbundled Darte FIber RJnR
11.initial ~s IMuiN RRI'
Simnle rf.1118.02
Comnlex -1.
7.2 Field Vedlica1lon and Quote PAI"""'1Ion IFVOP1 7.28
Field VerfficatIon n:~I"""""" VerlicaIIon\'7.
UDF-Strand
UDF -Interoffice Fadiitu 'UDF"~. SlnnIA Strand
7.4,Older Strand I Route I Order 2.801.2 Order Cha~ Each Adcf&tlonalSlrand I Same
-...
$266.881.3 Fiber T Strand I MIle SIIO
7.4,1.4 Termination Fixed """ Strand I Office I Temdnallon u,.80
7.4,1.5 fiber Strand I Office S2.M 19,
QwBst Idaho SGA T ThIrd Revision Exhibit A 5th Amended AprI28, 2004 Page 10 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT8d Complaint, Page 10 of 18
, i
2.1 OnIerOl"""".......FlratStrancl/RcuIe/OrcIer 60 4.2.2 0nI00r Charae. Each Additional StnInd / Same Route $255.86 4.2.3 FIber lmn. ""r StIwid / Rcuta S8II98 '7A.2.4 Termnalion FIxed -Strand/Office 14.83 TennlnaUon fixed. "'" StnInd / PremIse $3.94 fiber r Strand / 0III0e 52.71 11:19.38 B
Extended Unbundled Calk fiber IE-UI)F\. Slnme SItand
OrcIerCha- """FlrstStnlnd/Rauta/Order
11.Order ChaIU8. Each A~dftlonal Sltand I Same RouteFiberTrana r"~""/Strand
1I.7A,TermkiatIon Fixed .u.rStrancl/OfIIce
Terminallon Fixed. niorStrand/Prerrise
4.3.FlberCroas-Conneci """Pair
exhIbit A
Idaho
$98.
14,
S3.94
12.71 11:19,38 B
UDF - DBr P8Ir
UDF-tOF Chant8!l. ...... Pair
7.5.Order75.1.2 Order
11,1.3 FlberT Pair/Mia
Termlnatfon FIxBd,""" PaIr / OIIIce / TarminBlionFIber rPaIr/OIIice
r First Pair / Route I Older
/ 5am8 Route
"'"
588
57,
11:4,43 519.38 B
5.2 UDF.I """ Chounes . oar Pair2.1 OrderCh........ ner first Pair/ Route/Order
2.2 0n1ar Charue. Each MdilionsI-PBIr / Same Route
5.2.3 FiberLMD, oerRcuta/-PaIr2.4 TennInation Fixed,-Palr/OIIice5.2.5 TeminaIIon. FIXed PaIr/ PnuriIlB5.2.6 FlberClo PaIr/Oftice
Extended Unbundled Dark Fiber tE..UDFf
Order ChB""""" First PaIr/Route / Order
7.5.Order DuInte. Each AddilonaJ.Par / Same Route7.6.:U F'lIIer ouI8/PerPair
TennInaUon FIxBd Per Pair / 0IIice
7.6,TennlnaIIon Fixed Per Pair / Premise
7.6,fiber CIoas-Connect. rIM PaIr
lI:i~1M
57,
$8,
~::
519.38 B
2.60
5131.32
57,
l1:li
53,92 519.38 B
7.5,
, .
bar
Shared Trans"""
ParMlnu!eo so.
1.9 Unbundled Customer Controlled Rearranaement Element IUCCREI
DS1 Port
DS3 Port
DIBI Uo Access
AIIendant Access
VIr1ueI Ports ICI!
ICB
1C8
1C8
ICB
ICI! 3
ICB 3
10 Local Tandem Switc""'"
10.DS1Loc81MessaneTrunkPM """Oilier10.2 DS1TrunkGrmm
10.2.1 FJrstTnlnk-Order
10.2.2 Each AddIUonal Trunk. ...... Order10.3 Per Mlnu\e of Use so.oootl9O
S187AC
lI:2nA
$21.11!
Local Swltchlna
11,Ports
11,Analoo Una Side Port
11,1;1 FIrstPnrt
11,1.2 Each AddlUonal Port 11:10.21 A
11:549 A
11:1.34
51.34
11.1.2 DioItaJ Una SIde Port SuDDDlllna BRlISDN1 FIr8I& EechAdditional 512.53 S21J5..70 B
11;1.D/ol1a/ Trunk Ports
11.1.3.PBX/DID Trunk Port, perDSO $213.14 B$2.43
11.1.3.
11.1.3.3
DS1loc81-eTnmkPOIt
M88S8ge Trunk Gnlup, first Trunk
M- Trunk Gmom: Each Additional
DS1 PRIISON Trunk Port
5'111,:5""'33
$178.18
11.3.4
11.1.3,51118,
$37,~11,49 B
Qweat Idaho SGAT Third Revf&1on ExhIbit A 5th Amended April 26, 2004 Page 11 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-AT&T Complaint, Page II of 18
exhibit A
daho
.ilitllll(iii~~Jllj!r&1fi~I!~1~~II i~.Ifi~
11.1,4 DSO Arudna Trunk Port
111.4,first Port S14.56 1115.11,Each Additional Port S14.58 , 1
11.1.5 Local U""",,- ...... MlnuIa of Use 511001343
11.2 V8llical Fealums
8.1 1.2.BasIc l'ubt...
11.2.1.Account Codes-$77.4111.2.1.Altendanl Access line. ...... Station Une !l1.1211.2.1,Audible Me_"" Waltlna SU811.2.1.AuthorfzaIIon Codes . Dt!!r svstam 1,0811.2,Automatic Line
11.2.1,Automatic Route Selection . Common En..)6.2111,CaU Dmn .2311.2.1.Call Exclusion - Automallc
11.2.1.Call Exdusion . M&nWII .4811,1.10 Call FnlWanllnlI; BURV lIn..' Don' Answer '7711.2.1.11 Call Fmwanllnn: Don' hwwer' Call Forw:mIfnn B""" Customer
11,2.1.Cd Wallna Indication - 1181' TIm/no Stale
11,2.1.CenInIx Conunon EttuI-
11.2.1,CaD Forwanllna BuSY line . I On'"20,11.2.1,can F-- Don't Answer I $20.11.2.1.ClASS - ContInuous Redial 11.2811,2.1.ClASS - last Call ReIUm 1.1.2911.2.CLASS -11.2111.2,ClASS -Selective Call Forwardina S1.2811.2.1.CLASS - Selective Call Rele 1.1.2111,Direct S ' 8w Lamn FIeld 50.2411.2,1.22 DInIcted Call with lIB 18-11 18.0111.2.1.23 Dllected Call without larlle-In 13.8711,2.1.DIs6nc:ttve Rlnntnl8llnctlve Call W
11.2.1,25 EtrnenslveRou1BWamlnnTone -S-11.2.1,F- RestricIion
11.2.1.GRHlO Int8rmm
11.2.1.28 Hot LkIe .- line !11M11.2.1.29 Hunllna;Hunt Queulna 5211.2511.2.1.Hun&1'"MuItiIlMlllnn with Announcement In Queue 591,11.2.1.31 with Music in QUeue $28,11.2.1.ISON ShoItHunt S1.1711.2.1,LoudsDl!8I1er Trunk GrolID 5183.6011.2,Make Bu ms. -Grn.."50.5311,2.1.Make 8uRv Ana line .5S11.2.1.36 -""""" Center. OBI' Main StatIon line .3111.2.1.37 L4AuMeWaftlnaVlaual
11.1.38 Music On Hold. ...... SVSII!m
11.P- Release .4211.2.1.40 QuelY TIme
11.2.StaIIon Camo.On SefYIce. per MaIn StatIon .3111.2.1,TIme of n.u Control for ARS
11.2.1.43 111118 of Dav NCOS
11.2.1.TIme of D line11.2.1.Tnmk Verification S1aIIDn .3511.2.1,UCD in Hunt Grouo. D8I' line
11.2,SUDR.p . SeMce Establishment CIIa-. InIIeIlnstaIIaIü
11.2.1,SMDR.p - An:hfved Data !l1
9.1 1.2.2 Pnomlum Port. Additional Chelae ~.42 8.111.z.z.1
".... "
b- .lnlllallMIJIIletlon11,2.2.2 CMS. ~1nsIaI1atIon11.2.2.3 CMS - Packet ConInII
11.2.2.4 ConfereiIce Cal
fi" Meet 11,2.2,6 Confel1ll1C8 CaD . Preael
11.2.2.8 Con . S1atIon DIal fR.W_1 1.48
11.2.3 ClASS CaB Tra"'"- ..... Occurr81tC8 51.43
11.Subselluent Order Cha-!l12.11
11.4 Local SwitchIng - Market Based Rates The8e I8Ies
.. only
.........
In Zone 1 in Zone 11Mn1
Centeno Centers
8.12 Cuslamized RouUnll
Qwest Idallo SGAT ThIrd RevIsion ExhIbit A 6th Amended AprIl 25, 21104 . Page12of18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT~T-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 12 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho_5if ~~~ililll.II~Ilmr~'1I ll'l~r;I~13i~lljl~'11 ~~ 12.1
12.2
12.
DsveI', - o. pme
. .
rot. of. Custom line. . Class
, .
Code. - DInIctory A88I8Iance or Operator SeNIcea RoutIng .
on.vInsiaRation ch - DltRnfrvv AssIstance or nn."""r Service Routine OnlYAU Other Custom
$235.89
ICB ICB 3
Common Channel SlanalllttllSS7.
13,CCSACSTPPort
11,
13.2
13.
13.
13.6
13.6
13,
52l1li.05
CCSAC OoIIDns Adfvation Charue
13.2.1 BasicTransIaIIonB
13.2.1,FIIst Activation. OBr Older
13.2.1,Each Additional AdivaIIon. -r Older
5100,
$8.
13.2.CCSAC 00IIItns Database Translallon813.2.2.1 first Order
13,2.2 Each Addlfonal ActIvation, Del' Order
SianaI Fol111J!atlon ISUP. oerCall est
S"'nalTransa. ISUP.-CalISet-U..R-
51ana! Tru..... TCAP. IIer Data Reauest
Sinnal Switchi ISUP- "",,Call 5et-U" ReauestSlansl Swftch TCAP. -Data ReauesI
1118.
$53,
50,000524
000178
000019
$O,0D0983
$0.000837
Advanced Intell/aent Network lAIN!
14.AlN Customized Selllicea ACS\
14.AIN Platfonn Access APAI
14.AIN QueN Process lOB
ICB
IC8
1C8 3
9.15
15.
Una Infonnatkm Det~"".... LlDB
15.LlDB Storaae
Une Validation AdmlnlstraUon SvdRm A....""" ILVAS
15.
15.
15.2.LlDB line Record Initial Load
15.2.1.U.. to 20.000 line Recorda
15.2.1.2 Over 20 000 UneRecords 52601.
ICB
15.2.2 MechanImd Service Account UDdate, OBI' Addition or UrvI"'" PIOC8S8ed15.2.3 Individual line Record Aud"1!
15.2.4 Account Groun Audit15.2.5 exned1ted RemJest Chame tor Manual
LlDB Querv ServIce. ...... QueN 10.0008230
Fraud Alert r Alert No Ghame
8)0( Datab- Ououv Service
18.1 Bas/cOIlAl"- -rQuery
18.2 POTS Translation
18.ea. Handllna & Destination
_....
$0,0130355
$O,OOOOOO4a
$0.I10OOO145
11.18
11.17 I~u Pei'DuelY 000788
IntantktnaDv Left Blank
Constnrction Charaes IC8 ICB 3
Misce.neous CIIanI8s
20,Additional Enol Half Hour or fracIIon II8eof
20,AddIIIon8I Enlllne&rlna- BasIc
9.20,1.2 Addlional -0wrtIme 131.
139
20.2
20.3
9.20,
AdditlonailaMr InstaIIation- NIl' Half Hour or -n thereof9.20.2. 1 AddItIonal labor Instalatlon - OvertIme9.20.2.2 Add"""""llabor Installalion - Plemlum
Addlllonal LaborOlher. --Half Hour or fraeIIon thereof
20,3.1 Additional UIbOI' Other Basic20.3.2 AddIttonaI Labor Other..;, Overtime
20.AddItional Labor Other - Pnlrrium
$18.
:m;29
TestinD and Mal Half Hour or fraction thenlOf
20,TesIIna and Malnlenance- Basic
20.2 T- and MaIntenance - Overtime
20.Testina and Maintenance PremIum
S2II
ISS.57
549,
Qwest Idaho SGAT ThIrd Revision ExhIIItA 5th Amended Apd 28. 2004 Pag813of18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-O4-
AT&T Complaint, Page 13 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho
20.Maintenance of HalfHouror fradIon Iher8af
20.6,Malnlen8nce Of Service - BasIc $28.20.MaIntenance Of Service - OvertIme
20.Maintenance of SeIVIc8 - PnImIum
20.Additional r--1IIIfve PDca"'- Testfnn. """ Half Hour or fraction thllAlDf
8.20.AddiIIon8I Coo T..otbvo - BasIc
8.20.8.2 AddlUonal Coo lance T- - Overtime
20.Addlllonal Coo....ratfve Acce""""'" Testino - PremIum
8.20.Nonscheduled Co"""""- T-.. ...... Half Hour or fraction 1her8of
8.20,NOI18CIieduled Coonmmlu.loTMKM - Basic 529,8.20.7.2 Nol18Checluled r.........raIJve T..- - Overtime s""
8.20,7.3 Nonscheduled TestInn - PnIriIm $49,
8.20.Nonscheduled Manual T-"n ...... Half Hour or fnIcIIon thenIof
20.Nonscheduled MaIM!! T"""'" - Basic
20.Nonscheduled Manual TMI/nn- OvertIme $38,20.Nonscheduled Manual T""""" - Premium
20,InIentionallv Left Blank
8.20.Il'IIentIonallv Left Blank
8.20,Add1IfonaI 587,20,Date Channe "10.20.n-Inn ChannA
20.
CanC8Ra6on ICB9.20.IC8
8.21 Channel R."...-allon
21,OSI $0.21.DS3 $0.
8.22 Intentionallv Left Blank
8.23 UNE CombJnaUons
23.IntentionaDv left Blank
23.UNE-P Conversion Nonrecurri"" Chato8S
23.2. 1 UNE-P POTS CenIr8x AnaIM PBX Mechanized
23.2.1.First
9.23.2.1.Each Adcflllonal
8.23.UNE-P POTS CenJrex p,\I Ana"'" PBX Manual
9.23,2.2.1 FIrst 1118.22
23.2.2.2 Each Additional
23,2.3 UNE-P PBX DID Trunks
8.23.2.3,Finst S28"Ji'23.2.3.Each AddItIonal $2,
8.23.2.4 UNE-P ISDN BRI
8.23.2.4.Rrst S90 8I!
8.23.2.4.2 .Each Additional
8.23.2.5 UNE-PISDNPR OSS""'-OS1 FIIItiv
23.2.8 UNE-PISDNPRI OSS.-Trunk
8.23.2.8.1 Arst
23.2.8.2 Each Additional S2.
23.3 UNE-P New ComecJlon NonI8cun123.3.1 UNE-P POTS Mechanized
9.23,FIrst $5723,Each Additional 515
23.3.UNE-P POTS r...- p.o.. Anal"'"
-"
Manual
8.23,3.2.1
"'...
8.23.3.2.2 Each Additional 518.2
23.3,UNE - P PBX 010 . -r Trunk 515.2
23.3,UNE - P ISDN SRI 272,'"
Qwest Idaho SGA T Thkd RevIsIon ExhIbit A 5th Amended ApIII 26, 2004 Page 14 of18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 14 of 18
exhibit A
Idaho.
23.3.UNE-PTnmIaI
8.28.3.11.DSS Basic TRInk-in Onlv. Out Only: or1\vo2-Wav 574.218.28,3.5.2 Dss,1SDN PRI Advanced Trunk - In only w DID & Hunting, or 2-$73,Way w DID, HunIk1g & ArIfter Supervision
9.23.3.DSS. ISDN PRI Advanced Trunk - OUt Only w/AMNet SupeNlsJon $74,
23.3.FacAl6esforUNE-P DSS UNE-P ISDN PRI
23.3,DS1lNvo 5279,23.3.6.2 DS31.JJon FaoiIitv S27II
23.UNE-PPRI lIS
=III
23.UNE.fO PRI DedIcated PRl23 + D
8.28,7.2 UNE.fO PRI DIIdIcaIBd PRI 24B
9.28.3.7.3 UNE.fO PAl PRI 23B + Back-Un D Cnnfinllration - 6E
23.U-aneGus UNE.fO DID Trunks Ch8m..
8.23.UNe.P Como/ex Translations Dlalls IJUlDUIsed Chanae SI..nallna $158.23.UNe.P DID Coma/ex TransIaIfons S
23,UNE.fO DID Block Cormronise
23.UNe.fO DID Groll.. 0120 Numbers 531.323,UNe.P DID Seauential # Block
23.UNE.fO DID Re8eMI Nons""'lAtllial Teleohone Numbers23,UNE.fO DID NoMlHluential T-ne Numbers $33,
9.28.5 UNE - P Qwest DSL See applicable
QwesI RaI8II
Tariff, Catalog,
or Price Uat
23.UNE Combinations. Loo.. MUX Combinatione fLMC
8.23.InterconnecIIon Toe Pair IlTPt .- T8/1RlnaUon
8.23.6.1.DS1 11.248.23,8.1.2 DS3 514.
8.23.6.2 Lnnn MUX 2-WinI AnaInn
9.23.6.2.1 we 2..wJ.. Installation
8.23,6.2.1.First $226.23.8,2.1.2 Each AddIUanaI $146.1118.23.2.2 WIrB AnaIOa Loo..
8.23.6.2.2.1 Zone 1 $15,23,6.2.2.2 ZnnA 2 ~~7623.8.2.2.Zone 3 $40.50 111#
, ,
23.LOOD MUX 4-Wore AnaIoa
23.6.3.1 LMC 4-Wire lnatalalion
8.23,8.3.FirIt 5225.23.Each Additional 5148.1123.3.2 4-WIre Analoa loaD
23.8.3.2.1 Zone 1 ~7023.3.2.2 Zone 2
9.28.6.3.2.3 Zone 3 78.47
8.23.OS1 Looo MUX
23,8.4.LMC DS1loaD Installatian
9.23.6.First 12115.08
8.23.6.Each AdditIanaI ' 52l1li,8.23,6.4.2 DS1
23,8.4.2.1 Zone 1 $30,23.6.4.2.2 Zone 2 $48.838.23.6.4.2.3 Zone 3 579,
23.Private line to loaD MUX Conversion 534.
23,
23,8.6,LMC OS1 to DSO 1183.3023,LMC DS3 to DS1 183.30
23.OSO Channel
23.6.DS1/ DSO L1ux. Low Slda Channelization
23,Enhanced Extended
9.23.7,EEL DSO 2-WinI AmInft
23,EEL 2..wJre I..mD InstaIIatfan
23.7,F'II'III $245,
Owe8tklaho SGATThird Revision Exhibit A 5th Amended AprI 28, 2004 page 15 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case it ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 15 of 18
Exhibit A
Idaho
lili_IIIt ;~$li_li~f~t~~lt1~~1~llr.l~jlffJI~&hj'I~~I
",' n'23.1.2 2-WInI AnaI- "",,"
23,2.1 Zone 1 "15.23,Zone 2 ~789.23.7,1.2.Zone 3 50
9.23.7.2 EEL DSO 4-W118 Analntl
23,EEL 4-W1re Loo" Installation
23,2.1.FinIt S245
23.2.1.2 Each Additional $182.923,7.2.2 4-Wn Anal"" I ......
23.2.2.1 Zone 1 -:I.~70
23.2.2.2 Zone 2 ""8,9.23.2.2.3 Zone 3 !ITA
23.EELOS1
9.23.7.3.1 EEL OS1 I ...... Inslallalion
23.7.first
9.23.7,1.2 Each Additional
23.7.3.DS1 CRneble I..tinft
23.2.1 Zone 17.....,
23 '7"".3
23.EEL OS3
23,EEL DS3 I ...... Inslalatlon
23.7.4.first
23.Eech Addlttonal
23.4.2 DS3 ~ble Loon
23.4.2.Zone 1 $941.9.23.2.2 Zone 2 !tQ!;"
9.23.2.3 Zone 3 &1 284.
23.7,InIenlional~ Left Blank
23.7,Private Une to EEL ConversIon
23.InIentionaHv Left Blank
23.EEL T"'n..nNf
23.OSO
9.23.Over 0 to 8 Miles 1.?I..67 SO,29
23.Over 8 to 25Uiles &24,50.239.23.7.8.1.3 Over 25 to 50 Miles "24.$0.9.23.7.8.Over 50 MHes $24,5O.G5
9.23.8.2 OS1
23.7.8.2.1 Over 0 10 8 MIles 13.
23.78.2.2 Over 8 ID 25 MDes .28 $3.1923,8.2.3 Over 2510 50 MIles $1.819.23.7.8.2.4 Over 50 Miles
9.23,8.3 DS3
23.7.8,Over 0 ID 8 Miles
""""
$54,8.23.7.8.3.2 Over 81D 25 MI1es $242.03 1:18,
9.23.3.3 Over 251D 50 Ulea 121.9.23,7.8.3,Over50MDes !1:?\\6 "14.
9.23.Left Blank
23,EEL MuIliiilSinon
9.23.7,10.OS1 toOSO $2&3.869.23.10.2 OS31D OS1 !I:AA.I..22 $246.9
23.DSO Channel Pedonnance
9.23.11,DSO LcM Side Channelization 113.
9.23.11.2 OS1 , DSO M\.fx Low SIde Channellza1lon $7.
23.ConcenIraIion c..n..IiIHV ICB
1.24 Unbundled Packet SwltdtllIlII
24.Unbundled Packet SwIch Customer Channel
9.24,DSlAM 'and
~\
FuncIfonaIHv 1:21,
24,VIrtual Trans"'-
24.2 Cu8tomer ChaMeI ShanId DlsIrIbuIIon SubIaon ""1,
"-'
9.237112 Each Addlllo aI 182.9
Qwest Idaho $GAT TI*d RevIaIon ExhIbIt A 5th AmIInded Aprl 26, 2004 Page 16 of 18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 16 of 18
ExhIbit A
Idaho
8.24.3 Unbundled PadtAf !':wIfr.h InI8Iface Port
9.24,DSI
24,3.2 DS3
10,0 Ancillarv Services
10.LacaI Numller Portabilitv
10,LNP Queries
10.2
10.1.2 lNPM
10,2.1
10,
10,
Standard MAIISItIM Cuts Half Hour
OvertIme Msnsoed Cuts. ...... Person. OSt Half Hour
Premium Mananed Cuts ""r Pel8Ol1. Del' Half Hour
911/E911
10.2.IJ1l1E911
10.3 WhIte Panes Dlnctorv UsUna. FacUltv Based Providers10.3.1 P
10.Premium PIIvacy UstInge
10..4 Dr-""" Assistance Facilltv Based ProvIde"
10.4.Local Direolnrv Assislance. ..... CaD
10.4.2 National DlI1ICIDrv AssIsIance. Call
10.4.3 CaR Brandinn. Set- UD and Recordinn10.4.4 loadtna Brand.oerSwilch
10.4.5 CaR ComaIetion link. """CaD
10.5 Dlrectorv Assistance Ust information
10.InImI D
10.5.Reload of Database
10.5.DaDv U UsIlna
10.5.Qne.&ne Set-UD Fee
10.5.Media Charaes for fie DelIvAtv
10.5.5,E1ectmn1c: Transmission
10.5.2 T
~~
analv if this Is selected as the normal delivAnt medklm for
10.&,3 Shio~for
10,TolI.nd Assistance OD8rator Services Facilitv Based ProvIdllnL10.lhtllon A - Per M""""""
10.ODeratafHandledCallinnCard
10.8:1.2 Machin. Handled CaDInn Card
10,1.3 SIaIIon Call
10,Person Cau
10.CGnn8cIIo DlntdDrv Assistance
10,8.1.BuavLhtV-' -CaD
10,1.7 Busv line InIenuDl .
10,6.1,ooerator Assistance """CaI
10,8.2 0nfIftn B - Per n.......tnr Work Second and SIdled Calla
10,8.2.1 IJIM!mkIt Handled. """ a-Work Second
10,8.2.2 Machk1e Handled. ""r CaD
10.8.2.3 CaI Brandlna, s~ & RecordIna
10.8.2.4 Uladlna BrandIPer SwItch
10.'1' Access to .......... Duc:b Conduits and RI"hts ofWav 'ROW!
10.1 PoIelnqullyFee,perlnquky
10.
10.
10,
10.
10.
10.
10.7.8
10.
10.
Innenluct Inquiry Fee. per inquiry
ROW Inquiry Fee, per Inquiry
ROW Documont P~n Fee
Field Verllicalion Fee -Pole
Field VedftcaIIon Fee Manhole
PfannerVeriftcaIIan..... Manhole
Manhale Vsrtllcallon Ins-. !tAI'ManhclsManhole I \SO8CIor. ...... Manhole
Transfer of ResDOll8lbW
Owes! Idaho SGATThird Revision ExIu'bitA 5th Amended April 28, 2004
$158,
$272.7".
$210.3!
5210,
See FCC Tariff
1111 SedIon 13 &
$34.
542.21
No Chamo No ChamS
No Chams
~raI
Exchange TerilfReIII, La..
Wholesale
DJscaunl
No Coo"'"
Gens~~
ExdtengeT..ir
Rate, Less
Wholesale
DIsc:ounI
156
$0,
~:
0893
StI O25
SO,O2Q
SO.250
573,
SO,OO2O
$30.
lea
S1,
!!in
SI,
$3.50
$0,
$0.
$0.87
SII
$O.D2800
SII.25000
S10 !iOO.
SIKIO.OQ
$341,
$233,
$378,
S122.9
flO
1190.8
$18
$92.1
. $245,
$108.
Page 17of18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT- T-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 17 of 18
exhibit A
Idaho
12.4 Trouble Isolation Cha
$10.
.00
1.40
000419
Sell 9.20
1 851,
12,rational Su stems
12.1 DeveIo nt and Enhancemenls Order
12.2 Malnlenance Order
12.3 ReconJ Fie.Record
17.0 Bona FIde est Process
17,Processl Fee
NOTES:
Unle5S oth4!rwise Indicatud, all mtea are "pul&U8l1t to Idaho Public UtiDtl811 CorrmIss/on DockeIa:
A AT&T ArbItration Docket USW-T-96-15, Order No 27738, eII'ecIIve SepteniJer 17, 1988.
B Cost Docket OWE-.01-11, Order No. 29408 (J8IIUaIy 5. 21104) raIe8 elreclive J8IIUaIy 5,2004,
, Voluntary Rate Reductton, Docket USW. T~. etrecllve 1111 0102. Reductions reIIecIed In the 5/2W2 ExhIbit A.
till- Second VoIunIary Rate Reduction. Docket USW-T.oo-3, eIfecIive 611102. Reductions reflected In the 7/10102 ExhIbiI A.11## Third Voluntary Rate Reduction, Docket USW-T.oD-3, elYective 12/18102, Reductions reflected In the 10118102 exhibit A
(1)1ELRIC mtea proposed in Cost Docket testimony filed on NIW8TI1ber 12, 2003
(2) Market-based ratBs.
(3) ICB, Individual Case Beals pricing,
(4) The Stale otklaho hBs retained the owraighton these rates, These rates are notunclarthejurisd'lCtion otthe FCC.
(5) FCC ordered rates pursuanlto the FCC'. Older on Remand and Report and Order (lnteraurier fer ISP-8ound Traffic) CC Docket 01-131 (FCCISP Order), effective June 14,2001.
(6) Efi'ecUve Augus11, 2003, Qwest WIll no longer blithe recunlng and nDI1IBCII'I1ng charges for Channel Regenenlllon. Qw8&t I'888MIS the IIghIltlleVeIt back tothe contracutaI rate only after aplJRlPllalB notice Is given.
(7) The preliminary Quote Preparation F- (QPF) are Included In the apace COII5trucIIon charges. Upon c:ompIetion otthe collocation construcUon, the QPFwIIbe c:n!Cfded to the final space consInIction charge roribe virtual, caged or cage(1I&S coIocation job, These engineering and plamlng charges 88 alto IndudedIn the VIrIuaI, Caged and CageIess Quote Preparation Feas.
(8) The Cable Unloading / Bridge Tap Removal chaIga does not apply unW further notice.
(9) Qwast Is valuntarily raducIng this rete In Older to keep rate reIaIionahIp with the FiberTransporl "per Pair" rate element.(10) Owest hBs nul Implemented lids UNE rate or charge In lis bif'1I1II system but reserves the right to
--
such a chatge In the future.(II) All technicaI1y l'easlble Vertical SwItch Features are 8vaIIabIe with compatible unbundled awitch polIS. No manIhIy reaming charge applies for Basic V8IticaI
Switch FeaIIn8, Only b8s1c Vertical SwItch FeBllna with I1OI1/'BCI.II'I c:hargeallrB II$ted, Nonrecunfng charges are applicable whenever a fe8IunI Is added -whalher on new InsIaJlatIon, conversion, or change order actMIy. Vertical SWItch FeatUlUS not listed are Included In the cost of the switch port and have a rateof Z8lO for both recurring and nonl1lCUn1ng charges.
(12) The PremIum Port J:IIOnthly reamtng chaIge applies k1 addition to the Analog or DIgital Una Side Pori recurring chaJges when Pnm1Ium Featuraa 818 orderedwith analog or digital ports.
Qwest Idaho SGA T Third Revision ExhibH A 5th Amended Aprl 26, 2004 Page 18 ar18
Exhibit 7
Case # ATT-04-
AT&T Complaint, Page 18 of 18
BEFORE THE MINNESOTA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
Gregory Scott
Edward A. Garvey
Marshall Johnson
LeRoy Koppendrayer
Phyllis A. Reha
Chair
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner
In the Matter of the Complaint of the
Minnesota Department of Commerce Against
Qwest Corporation Regarding Unfiled
Agreements
ISSUE DATE: March 12 2002
DOCKET NO. P-421/C-02-197
NOTICE AND ORDER FOR HEARING
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On February 14, 2002, the Minnesota Department of Commerce (DOC) filed a Complaint against
Qwest claiming Qwest had violated state and federal law by not submitting for Commission
approval numerous agreements with Competitive Local Exchange Cwers (CLECs). Among
. other things, the Complaint requested an expedited hearing and temporary relief, pursuant to
Minn. Stat. ~ 237.462.
On March 1 , 2002 Qwest filed its Answer to the Complaint of the DOc. As part of its answer
Qwest joined the DOC in its request for an expedited proceeding in this case.
On March 1 , 2002, Qwest filed its Opposition to Temporary Relief.
On March 1 2002, Qwest also filed its Conditional Application for Approval of certain negotiated
agreement provisions between Qwest and Eschelon Telecom, Inc" Covad Communications
Company, Small CLECs, McLeod USA, US Link, InfoTel and Advanced Telecommunications, Inc,
Pursuant to Minn. Stat. ~ 237.462, Subd. 7, when there is a request for temporary relief, the
Commission has 20 days from the filing of the complaint to issue a decision on such a request.
March 6, 2002, is the twentieth day from the date of filing.
Further, pursuant to Minn. Stat. ~ 237.462, Subd. 6 (t), when there has been a request for an
expedited hearing, the Commission has 15 days from the receiving an answer to determine
whether an expedited hearing is warranted. March 16, 2002 is the fifteenth day from the filing of
Qwest's answer.
These matters came before the Commission on March 5, 2002,
Qwest Motion to Dismiss
Exhibit E
FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS
Background
Summary ofthe Complaint
The complaint alleges, among other things, that Qwest has entered into numerous! secret
agreements with Competitive Local Exchange Carriers (CLECs) to provide interconnection
access to network elements, resale, number portability, dialing parity, access to rights-of-way,
reciprocal compensation and collocation to the CLEC. Further, the complaint alleges that Qwest
has not submitted these agreements for Commission approval, as required by statute? As a result
the terms of these agreements are unknown to CLECs not a party to these agreements and are not
available for adoption by other CLECs, as required.
The complaint requests expedited proceedings, temporal)' relief and penalties.
II.Jurisdiction
The Commission has jurisdiction over this complaint pursuant to 47 V.C. ~ ~ 252( e) and 251 (c )(2),
(authority of state commissions to enforce interconnection agreements, and duty of incumbent
carriers to interconnect with CLECs, respectively) and Minn. Stat. ~ ~ 237.08 I (Commission
investigations) and 237.462 (competitive enforcement).
III.The Request for Temporary Relief and Expedited Hearings
The DOC requested that the Commission order Qwest to immediately make any and all of the
specified terms or conditions of interconnection or service public, and also make the specified
terms and conditions immediately available to any other CLEC that wishes to adopt these
provisions.
Both the DOC and Qwest requested expedited proceedings.
Approximately thirty-three provisions in eleven agreements.
47 V.C. ~ 252(e).
3 47 V.C. ~ 252(i).
IV.Parties Positions on the Issue of Temporary Relief
DOC
Inits Complaint the DOC argued that temporary relief was necessary to protect the public
interest in fair and reasonable competition. It argued that Qwest was offering terms and conditions
of interconnection in a discriminatory manner. If Qwest were not required to make the specified
terms or conditions of interconnection immediately available to all CLECs, Qwest would be
continuing to limit competition and to provide access to its network and its services in a
discriminatory manner.
At the hearing before the Commission, the DOC did indicate that a Commission decision to
resolve the Complaint under expedited time lines would significantly mitigate the need for
temporary relief.
Qwest
Qwest argued that the relief the DOC is requesting is not temporary relief but is, in fact
immediate, complete and permanent relief. Qwest further argued that it has submitted the terms of
the agreements to the Commission without a request for confidential treatment and in doing so has
made the terms public.
Qwest also argued that the DOC has not met the statutory requirements4 for such relief. The DOC
has made assertions but has not adequately shown that there has been any effect on competition
from the non-filing of the agreements. Further, Qwest argued, the DOC is unlikely to succeed on
the merits because the terms at issue were not properly the subject of interconnection agreements.
Commission Action
The Commission recognizes that there are contested issues of material fact arising from this
. complaint that the Commission cannot satisfactorily resolve on the basis of the parties' filings.
For this reason the Commission will refer this matter to the Office of Administrative Hearings
(OAH) for contested case proceedings. The Commission will request that the OAR hear this
matter on an expedited time schedule following the guidelines for expedited hearings set forth in
Minn. Stat. 9237.462, Subd. 6. Hearing this matter on an expedited schedule will address the
concerils of both parties that this issue be quickly resolved.
4 See Minn. Stat. 237.462, Subd 7(c) requiring: (1) the party seeking relief will likely
succeed on the merits, (2) the order is necessary to protect the public s interest in fair and
reasonable competition, and (3) the relief sought is technically feasible.
Further, the Commission recognizes that to make a determination on whether temporary relief
should be granted, the merits of the case would necessarily need to be addressed. Since the merits
of the case will be addressed on an expedited basis, and the complainant has indicated its
agreement, the Commission will not award temporary relief at this time.
VI.Issues to be Addressed
The scope of the issues to be addressed in the contested case hearing are as follows:
whether the agreements or any portion thereof needed to be filed with the
Commission for review;
if the agreements needed to be filed whether they were filed under other settings;
whether there were any exculpatory reasons why they were or were not filed;
recommendations as to whether disciplinary action/penalties are appropriate.
VII.Procedural Outline
Administrative Law Judge
The Administrative Law Judge assigned to this case is Allan W. Klein. His address and telephone
number are as follows: Office of Administrative Hearings, Suite 1700, 100 Washington Square
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401-2138; [phone].
Hearing Procedure
Controlling Statutes and Rules
Hearings in this matter will be conducted in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act, Minn.
Stat. ~~ 14.57-14.62; the rules of the Office of Administrative Hearings, Minn. Rules, parts 1400.5100
to 1400.8400; and, to the extent that they are not superseded by those rules, the Commission s Rules of
Practice and Procedure, Minn. Rules, parts 7829.0100 to 7829.3200.
Copies of these rules and statutes may be purchased from the Print Communications Division of the
Department of Administration, 117 University Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55155; [phone].
These rules and statutes also appear on the State of Minnesota's website at
www.revisor.leg.state.mn.us.
5 The Commission clarified that this included terminated agreements.
The Office of Administrative Hearings conducts contested case proceedings in accordance with the
Minnesota Rules of Professional Conduct and the Professionalism Aspirations adopted by the
Minnesota State Bar Association.
Right to Counsel and to Present Evidence
In these proceedings, parties may be represented by counsel, may appear on their own behalf, or
may be represented by another person of their choice, unless otherwise prohibited as the
unauthorized practice oflaw. They have the right to present evidence, conduct cross-examination
and make written and oral argument. Under Minn. Rules, part 1400.7000, they may obtain
subpoenas to compel the attendance of witnesses and the production of documents.
Parties should bring to the hearing all documents, records, and witnesses necessary to support their
positions.
Discovery and Informal Disposition
Any questions regarding discovery under Minn. Rules, parts 1400.6700 to 1400.6800 or
informal disposition under Minn. Rules, part 1400.5900 should be directed to Kevin O'Grady,
Public Utilities Rates Analyst, Minnesota Public Utilities Commission, 121 Seventh Place East
Suite 350, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101-2147, [phone]; or Karen Hammel, Assistant Attorney
General, 1100 NCL Tower, 445 Minnesota Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 , [phone].
Protecting Not-Public Data
State agencies are required by law to keep some data not public. Parties must advise the
Administrative Law Judge if not-public data is offered into the record~ They should take note that
any not-public data admitted into evidence may become public unless a party objects and requests
relief under Minn. Stat. ~ 14., subd. 2.
Accommodations for Disabilities; Interpreter Services
At the request of any individual, this agency will make accommodations to ensure that the hearing
in this case is accessible. The agency will appoint a qualified interpreter if necessary. Persons
must promptly notify the Administrative Law Judge if an interpreter is needed.
Scheduling Issues
The times, dates, and places of public and evidentiary hearings in this matter will be set by order
of the Administrative Law Judge after consultation with the Commission and intervening parties.
Notice of Appearance
Any party intending to appear at the hearing must file a notice of appearance (Attachment A) with
the Administrative Law Judge within 20 days of the date of this Notice and Order for Hearing.
Sanctions for Non-compliance
Failure to appear at a prehearing conference, a settlement conference, or the hearing, or failure to
comply with any order of the Administrative Law Judge, may result in facts or issues being
resolved against the party who fails to appear or comply.
Parties and Intervention
The current parties to this case are Qwest and the Minnesota Department of Commerce. Other
persons wishing to become formal parties shall promptly file petitions to intervene with the
Administrative Law Judge. They shall serve copies of such petitions on all current parties and on
the Commission. Minn. Rules, part 1400.6200.
Prehearing Conference
A prehearing conference will be held in this case on Wednesday, March 20, 2002, at 9:30 a.m. in
Conference Room B of the Public Utilities Commission, 121 Seventh Place East, Suite 350
St. Paul, Minnesota 55101. Persons participating in the prehearing conference should be prepared
to discuss time frames, scheduling, discovery procedures, and similar issues. Potential parties are
invited to attend the pre-hearing conference and to file their petitions to intervene as soon as
possible.
Time Constraints
The Commission requests that this matter be heard on an expedited time schedule following the
guidelines in Minn. Stat. 237.462, Subd. 6 for expedited hearings.
VIII. Application of Ethics in Government Act
The lobbying provisions of the Ethics in Government Act, Minn. Stat. ~~ lOA.Ol et seq , may
apply to this case. Persons appearing in this proceeding may be subject to registration, reporting,
and other requirements set forth in that Act. All persons appearing in this case are urged to refer to
the Act and to contact the Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board, telephone number
[phone], with any questions.
IX.Ex Parte Communications
Restrictions on ex parte communications with Commissioners and reporting requirements
regarding such communications with Commission staff apply to this proceeding from the date of
this Order. Those restrictions and reporting requirements are set forth at Minn, Rules, parts
7845.7300- 7845.7400, which all parties are urged to consult.
ORDER
The Commission hereby refers this case to the Office of Administrative Hearings for
contested case proceedings as set forth above,
A preheaTing conference shall be held on Wednesday March 20 2002, at 9:30 a.m. in
Conference Room B, Public Utilities Commission, 121 Seventh Place East, Suite 350
St. Paul, Minnesota 55101.
This Order shall become effective immediately.
BY ORDER OF THE COMMISSION
Burl W. Haar
Executive Secretary
(S E A L)
This document can be made available in alternative formats (i., large print or audio tape) by
calling [phone] (voice), [phone] (TTY), or 1-800-627-3529 (TTY relay service).
ATTACHMENT A
BEFORE THE MINNESOTA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
1O0Washington Square, Suite 1700
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401-2138
FOR THE MINNESOTA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
121 Seventh PI8;ce East Suite 350
St. Paul, Minnesota 55101-2147
In the Matter of the Complaint ofthe
Minnesota Department of Commerce
Against Qwest Corporation Regarding
Unfiled Agreements
MPUC Docket No. P-421/C-02-197
OAH Docket No.
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
Name, Address and Telephone Number of Administrative Law Judge:
Allan W. Klein, Office of Administrative Hearings, Suite 1700, 100 Washington Square
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401; [phone].
TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE LAW WDGE:
You are advised that the party named below will appear at the above hearing.
NAME OF PARTY:
ADDRESS:
TELEPHONE NUMBER:
PARTY'S ATTORNEY OR OTHER REPRESENTATIVE:
OFFICE ADDRESS:
TELEPHONE NUMBER:
SIGNATURE OF PARTY OR ATTORNEY:
DATE: