20150615Comment1.pdf

Jean Jewell
From:[e-mail]
Sent:Saturday,June 13,2015 4:32 PM
To:Beverly Barker;Jean Jewell;Gene Fadness
Cc:rj_rogers @ q.com
Subject:Case Comment Form:Richard Rogers
Name:Richard Rogers
Case Number:uwi-w-15_15-02/LWI-cJ_/Q/
Email:rj rogers(g.com
Telephone:[phone]
Address:1066 E.Saratoga Dr.
Boise id,83706
Name of Utility Company:united water idaho Acknowledge public record:True
Comment:I am against the proposed rate increase for this case and for the general rate
increase petition on file with(uwi-w-15-01)The transfer of the fire hydrants from the city
of Boise Back to United Water does not justify an increase in costs to the consumer.
Boise city took over the maintenance of fire hydrants just recently maybe 10 but less than 15
years ago.I know it was after 9-1-11 as security requirements increased after that date.
Any money associated in United Waters budget for fire hydrant operation and
maintenance/replacement at the time of the transfer to the city of Boise should be returned
to UWI current budget.
Fire hydrants are an integral part of the distributions system as they are used to flush the
system when there is cloudy water or after main repair and disinfection,measuring water
pressure,collection of water samples and semi annual flushing of the system to remove
chemical deposits such as iron and manganese.Fire protection is an important function but
these hydrants are used more often to maintain water quality and to meet DEQ5 standards.The
rate application doesnt discuss these important functions.This insignificant rate increase
should be part of the uwi-w-15-01 rate application increase package which is also out of
line/too much.Fire hydrants are part of the distribution system plain and simple I do not
understand the referenced franchise date of 1995 as the franchise has existed for maybe 100
years.
I think the PUC should review the documents of a few years ago when the fire hydrants were
taken over by the city of Boise and ask some hard questions of both parties
Richard Rogers retired professional engineer(3033)
1066 E.Saratoga Dr.
Boise,ID 83706
Unique Identifier:65.129.124.92
1