Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20111208Settlement Stipulation.pdfORIGINAL Dean J. Miler (ISB No. 1968) McDEVITT & MILLER LLP 420 West Banock Street P.O. Box 2564-83701 Boise, Idaho 83702 Tel: 208-343-7500 Fax: 208-336-6912 ìoermmcdevitt-miler.com Attorneys for United Water Idaho Inc. r: 1-:¡ "- L,.. 201 I DEC -8 Pll 2: 25 10 Weldon Stutzan (ISB No. 3283) DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION P.O. Box 83720 Boise, ID 83720-0074 Tel: 208-334-03 Fax: 208-334-3762 weldon.stutzanrmpuc.idaho.gov mail to: Attorneys for Commission Staff BEFORE THE IDAHO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. FOR AUTHORITY TO INCREASE ITS RATES AND CHARGES FOR WATER SERVICE IN THE STATE OF IDAHO ) ) CASE NO. UWI-W-1l-2 ) ) SETTLEMENT STIPULATION ) ) This Settlement Stipulation (Stipulation) is entered into by and among United Water Idaho Inc., (United Water, Company), the Sta of the Idaho Public Utilties Commssion (Staff and Communty Action Parership Association of Idaho (CAPAI), the sole intervenor in ths case (colleètively, Paries). SETTLEMENT STIPULATION i INTRODUCTION The Paries agree the Stipulation represents a fai, just and reasonable compromise of the issues raised in United Water's Application for an increase in water service rates, and the Stipulation is in the public's interest. The Paries believe the Stipulation and its acceptace by the Idaho Public Utilties Commssion (Commission) represents a reasonable resolution of the several issues identified in ths matter. The Paries, therefore, recommend that the Commission, in accordace with Rule of Procedure (R) 274, approve the Stipulation and all of its terms and conditions without material change or condition. BACKGROUND . 1. On August 3, 2011, United Water filed an Application seekig authority to increase the Company's rates for water service in the State ofIdaho by an average, of 19.89%. If approved, the Company's revenues would increase by $7,616,015 anualy. The Company requested the new rates become effective September 2, 2011. 2. On August 18,2011, the Commission issued Order No. 32333, suspending United Water's proposed effective date for a period of30 days plus five (5) months from September 2,2011. On the same date, the Commssion issued Order No. 32334, granting CAP AI'S Petition for Intervention. 3. On October 5, 2011, the Commission issued Order 32376, establishing a procedural schedule, including a techncal hearng to commence on Febru 1, 2011. 4. After the filing of the Application, Commssion Sta conducted a thorough audit and investigation of the Company's Application. Commssion Sta propounded numerous SETTLEMENT SlIPULA TION 2 Audit Requests and Production Requests, to which United Water provided timely responses. 5. On November 16, 17 and 18,2011, representatives of the Paries met to engage in settlement discussions in accordance with RP 272, with a view toward resolving the issues in this case. 6. Based on the settlement discussions, as a compromise of the positions in this case, and for other considerations as set fort below, the Paries agree to the followig terms. TERMS OF THE STIPULATION 7. Fair Resolution. The settlement is reached as a fair resolution to several disputed issues between the paries, recognzing that neither par was likely to prevail on every issue at hearng. The settlement results in a revenue increase that is reasonable, but without resolving specific issues which were in dispute between the Company and Sta. 8. Revenue Requirement. Regarding United Water's revenue requirement, the Paries agree that United Water should be allowed to implement revised taff schedules, in the form atthed hereto as Exhbit A, to recover $3,050,000 in additional revenue effective Februar 1,2012, which is an overall increase of 7.96%, and to recovér an additional $950,000 effective Februar 1,2013, which is an additional increase of2.48%. The Paries have agreed to ths phased-in recovery of the tota agreed increase, to mitigate the rate impact on customers tht would otherwse occur in a single year, and spread the r increase durng the period the Company is precluded from fiing an additional rate case. SETTLEMENT STIPULATION 3 9. Rate Spread and Rate Design. As reflected by Exhbit A, the Pares agee that the additional revenue requirement should be recovered by implementig taffs which increase rates and charges on Febru 1,2012 and Febru 1,2013. 10. Rate Case Moratorium. United Water agrees that it will not fie a general revenue requiement rate case that results in an effective date for new rates prior to Janua 1, 2014. 11. Deferrals. The Paries agree that the Commssion's Final Order in ths matter may also approve the following deferrals and amortization periods. a) Deferred Power Expense: There remains an unamortized balance of deferred Idaho Power Company PCA electrc power expense from the deferral and amortization authorized by Order No. 31029, Case No. UWI-W-09-01 in the amount of $365,570 as of Janua 31,2012, which shal be re-amortized over a period of thirty-six (36) months, commencing Febru 1, 2012. It is estimated that the pending deferred power balance as of Janua 31, 2012, will be approximately $185,000, which balance shall be amortzed over a period of thiry-six (36) months, commencing Februar 1,2012. The Company shall continue to defer for later amortization all amounts biled by Idaho Power Company under its PCA. The carng charge on the unamortized balances shall be the interest rate determined by the Commission as the interest rate on customer deposits pursuat to Rule 106 of the Commission's Customer Relations Rules, IDAPA 31.01.21. b) Rate Case Expense: There remais an unamortized balance of deferred rate case expense from the deferral and amortization authorized by Order No. 31029, Case No. UWI-W-09-01, which balance shall be re-amortized over a period of thrty-six (36) SETTLEMENT STIPLA nON 4 months. The Company shal defer and amortize its actu rate case expense incured in ths proceeding over a period of th-six (36) months, commencing Febru 1, 2012. c) Tan Paintings: Expense incured by the Company for the paiting and rehabiltation of the Hilcrest water storage reservoir amounting to $230,134 may be deferred and amortized over a twenty (20) year period beginnng Februar 1,2012. d) Pension Expense: The actu cash contrbutions to the Company's ERISA pension plan for the plan year 2010 was $1,300,769. In subsequent plan years, should the actu cash contributions exceed, or be less than, the 2010 plan year contrbution, the Company is authorized to record a deferred asset or liabilty for the difference between the actu cash contrbution in each of the subsequent years and the 2010 plan year amount. Such amounts so deferred will be presented by the Company for amortization in its next general rate proceeding and, if prudently made as determined by examination by the Commssion, United Water can expect, in the ordinar course of events, to amortize the deferred asset or liabilty over a period not to exceed three (3) years in its next general rate filing. The Company is also authorized to apply the Commission authorized interest rate on customer deposits, pursuant to Rule 106 of the Commission's Customer Relations Rules, IDAP A 31.01.21, as a caring chage/accrued interest to the deferred asset or liabilty until such time as the deferral is incorporated into the revenue requirement of the general rate case. e) Relocation Expense: The Company may defer the actul expenses incured up to the $125,000 included in ths case related to the item labeled relocation expense in Adjustment 11 in Exhibit No. 11, accompanyig the Direct Testiony of Jarila SETTLEMENT STIPULATION 5 Car. The deferred amount shall not be subject to a caring charge. Such amounts so deferred will be amortized over sixty (60) month beging the later of the month afer the deferral is booked or Febru 1, 2012. The unortized amount may be presented by the Company for inclusion in its next general rate proceeding and, if prudently made as determined by examination by the Commission, United Water can expect, in the ordinar course of events, to include the anua amortization in its next general rate filing. f) Redundant Power: The Company may defer and amortize over a period of five (5) years beginnng Februar 1,2012, the $74,272 expense item labeled redundat power expense, in Adjustment No. 16 in Exhibit 11, accompanying the Direct Testimony of Jarila Car. g) Other Deferrals: Except as modified by ths Stipulation, the Company may continue to amortize other deferrals previously authorized in Case No. UWI-W-04-04, Case No. UWI-W-06-02 and Case No. UWI-09-01. 12. Depreciable Life of Customer Care and Biling System (CC&B). For the purose of calculating book depreciation expense on the CC&B system, the usefu life of the system shall be considered to be a period of ten (10) years, commencing November 1, 2011. 13. Per Meter Charges and Cost of Service Study. The adjustments to the Company's Bi- Monthy Per Meter Charge as shown on Exhbit A does not reflect a unform percentage increase to all rate elements. Instead the adjustments reflect a movement toward recovering appropriate customer costs in the Per Meter Charge, as supported by the Cost of Service Study sponsored by Company witness Herbert. In its next general rate proceeding, the Company will not seek fuer adjustment to the Per Meter Charge, SETTLEMENT STIPULATION 6 except on a uniform percentage increase basis. Accordingly, with respect to its next general rate proceeding, the provision ofRP 121(01)(e), requirng that a cost of servce study be submitted with an Application for a chage of rates, may be waived. 14. Issues for Furer Discussion. Withn a reasonable time after the entr of a Final Order in this matter, the Commission Sta and the Company shall convene a conference, or series of conferences, to discuss potential rate makng mechansms aimed at addressing revenue and earings instabilty associated with the observed trend of decling per capita consumption by United Water's customers. 15. Low Income Issues. United Water and CAPAI have agreed on the following matters with respect to low income customers: a) The curent anua per customer cap of$50 for receipt of benefits under the UW Cares Program shall be increased to $65 per customer, per year, for quaified customers; b) The anual "matching cap" of $20,000 contrbuted by United Water to the UW Cares shall be removed; c) With a reasonable time, United Water will provide to CAP AI an analysis of water consumption patterns of a representative sample of customers who have received benefits from the UW Cares Program; d) Within a reasonable time, United Water will provide to CAP AI the other information requested in CAPAI's First Production Requests to United Water, filed in ths case; e) In order to enhance water conservation opportties for low income customers, United Water will make available to requesting CAPAI agencies residential water conservation devices for distrbution to low income customers. Withi a reasonable SETTLEMENT STIPATION 7 time United Water and CAP AI wil meet and confer with a view toward developing protocols for insurg kits are delivered only to United Water customers and appropriate record keeping is maitaed. 16. Just and Reasonable: Best Efforts. The Paries agree that ths Stipulation is in the public's interest and that all ofits terms and conditions are fair, just and reasonable. The Paries agree to use their best efforts to obtan Commission approval of the Stipulation in order to have new rates implemented by Febru 1,2012. 17. No Acknowledgement. No Pary shall be bound, benefited or prejudiced by any position asserted in the negotiation of this Stipulation, except to the extent expressly stated herein, nor shall ths Stipulation be constred as a waiver of the rights of any Pary uness such rights are expressly waived herein. Execution of ths Stipulation shall not be deemed to constitute an acknowledgement by any Pary of the validity or invalidity of any paricular method, theory or principle of regulation or cost recovery. No Par shall be deemed to have agreed that any method, theory or principle of regulation or cost recovery employed in ariving at ths Stipulation is appropriate for resolving any issues in any other proceedig in the futue. No findings of fact or conclusion oflaw other th those stated herein shall be deemed to be implicit in ths Stipulation. 18. Commssion Approval. The obligations of the Paries under this Stipulation are subject to the Commssion's approval of ths Stipulation in accordance with its terms and conditions. 19. Confidentiality. The Paries agree tht this Stipulation represents a compromise of the positions of the Paries. Therefore, other than any testimony filed in support of the approval of ths Stipulation, and except to the extent necessar for a Pary to explain SETTLEMENT STIPULATION 8 before the Commission its own statements and positions with respect to the Stipulation, as directed by RP 272, all statements made and positions taen in negotiations relatig to ths Stipulation shall be confdential and will not be adissible in evidence in ths or any other proceeding. 20. Best Efforts. The Paries submit ths Stipulation to the Commission and recommend approval in its entirety. Paries shall support this Stipulation before the Commission, and no Pary shall appeal a Commission Order approving the Stipulation or an issue resolved by the Stipulation. If this Stipulation is challenged by any person not a pary to the Stipulation, the Paries to this Stipulation reserve the right to fie testimony, cross- examne witnesses, and put on such case as they deem appropriate to respond fuly to the issues presented, including the right to raise issues that are incorporated in the settlements embodied in this Stipulation. Notwthstading this reservation of rights, the Pares to ths Stipulation agree that they will continue to support the Commssion's adoption of the terms of ths Stipulation. 21. Right to Withdraw. If the Commission rejects any par or all of ths Stipulation, or imposes any additional material conditions on approval of ths Stipulation, each Pary reserves the right, upon wrtten notice to the Commission and the other Paries to ths proceeding, withn foureen (14) days of the date of such action by the Commission, to withdraw from ths Stipulation. In such case, no Par shall be bound or prejudiced by the terms of ths Stipulation, and each Pary shall be entitled to seek reconsideration of the Commission's Order, fie testimony as it chooses, cross-examine witnesses, and do all other thngs necessar to put on such case as it deems appropriate. SETTLEMENT STIPULATION 9 22. Counteroars. This Stipulation may be executed in counterpars and each signed counterpar shall consttute an origi document. t~ Respectfuly submitted ths T day of December, 2011. By ) Weldon B. S an Deputy Att mey General Attorney for Commission Staf Brad Purdy Law Ofce B SETTLEMENT STIPULTION 10 Sheet NO.3 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.1 GENERAL METERED SERVICE Availabilty: To all metered customers not served under a separate schedule. Customer Charges:Bi-Monthly Bi-Monthly Per Meter Per Meter Meter Size Charge Charge 5/8"-3/4 $~$20.10 1"$~$25.70 1-114" and 1-1/2"$3&$44.00 2" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity $ãã $68.20 3" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity $102.23 $133.10 4" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity $162.71 $248.20 6" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity $313.15 $414.50 8" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity $472.3Q $542.20 10" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity $660.37 $780.30 Volume Charge:Winter Winter Rates Rates For all water used less than 3CCF (100 cubic $1.3521 $1.4388 Feet) (CCF)(1 CCF=748 gallons): For all water used greater than 3CCF $1.3521 $1.4388 Volume Charge:Summer Summer Rates Rates For all water used less than 3CCF (100 cubic $1.3521 $1.4388 Feet) (CCF)(1 CCF=748 gallons): For all water used greater than 3CCF $1.6Q02 $1.7985 Conditions of Contract: The customer shall pay the total of the customer charge plus the volume charge. The volume charge is based on all metered water for the billng period. Consumption is expressed in hundred cubic foot units or thousand gallon units as determined by the meter installed by the Company. The customer charge wil be prorated whenever the customer has not been a customer for the entire biling period. Summer Period: The summer rate wil apply to water consumed between May 1 and September 30. Meter readings straddling these dates wil be prorated. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective -February 1, 2012 through Januar 31, 2013. STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 1 OF 10 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID Sheet NO.5 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.1 B FLAT RATE SERVICE Availability: To non-metered residential customers pursuant to Residential or Multi-Family Housing Non-Contiguous Water Systems Agreement Paragraph 11 (a) addressing flat rate systems. Customer Charges: Based on United Water Idaho residential consumption for the year ending June 1998 of 208.75 ccf, the average residential bill, assuming a %" meter and 65% / 35% summer/winter split, is $434.16/ $468.90. Biled bi-monthly, equals $72.36/ $78.15. Bi-Monthly Charge:$ 72.36 $78.15 Conditions of Contract: The monthly charge wil be prorated whenever the customer has not been a customer for the entire billing period. The Company or the customer may convert to metered service pursuant to Subparagraphs (b) or (c) of Paragraph 11 as follows: (b) If Company should determine that a flat rate customer is using water in excess of the average residential customer, the Company wil provide a meter setting and meter. Customer will then pay Company's metered tariff rates as approved by the IPUC, which rates may be amended from time to time. (c) If a customer prefers to pay Company's approved metered tariff rates, the customer shall pay the installation and material costs associated with the installation of a meter setting. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2012 through January 31,2013. STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 2 OF 10 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID Sheet NO.3 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.2 PUBLIC HYDRANTS AND STREET SPRINKLING Availability: To the City of Boise and Ada County Highway District. Rates: Street Sprinkling Service Flat Charge $239.9SlMonth $268.78/Month Miscellaneous: Bils wil be rendered monthly, bi-monthly, or at other intervals upon mutual agreement of the Company and the customer. Hydrants and service pipes from the fitting on the Company main to the hydrants are to be installed and maintained by and at the expense of the City of Boise or Ada County Highway District. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2012 through January 31,2013. Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 3 OF 10 Sheet NO.4 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.3 PRIVATE FIRE SPRINKLER AND SERVICE Availabilty: To all customers who have sprinkler systems and/or inside hose connections for fire fighting purposes. Rate: For service through a separate line for fire fighting purposes. For 3" service or smaller, per month For 4" service per month For 6" service per month For 8" service per month For 10" service per month For 12" service per month $15.84 $24.01 $59.63 $97.98 $152.80 $228.87 $17.74 $26.89 $66.79 $109.74 $171.14 $256.33 Miscellaneous: Provided that if the installation of a private fire service shall require an extension of the existing mains of the company, the cost of such extension shall be borne by the customer. All private fire services shall be equipped with sealed gate valves or thermal automatic openings. Meters may be placed on fire services by the utility at any time; however, metered rates wil not apply unless improper use of water is disclosed, and if such be the case, usage wil be biled to the consumer under Rate Schedule NO.1. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2012 through January 31, 2013. Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 4 OF 10 Sheet NO.5 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.4 PRIVATE FIRE HYDRANT SERVICE Availabilty: To all customers having private fire hydrant installations. Rate: For fire hydrants installed and maintained by the customer at customer's expense: Each fire hydrant, per month $9 $10.75/Month Miscellaneous: Service pipe from the fitting on the company water main to the fire hydrant is to be installed and maintained by the customer. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2012 through January 31,2013. Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 5 OF 10 Sheet NO.3 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.1 GENERAL METERED SERVICE Availability: To all metered customers not served under a separate schedule. 1" Bi-Monthly Per Meter Charge$~$~$~$~ $133.10 $248.20 $414.50 $542.20 $780.30 Bi-Monthly Per Meter Charge $20.80 $26.60 $45.50 $70.60 $137.70 $256.90 $428.90 $561.10 $807.40 Customer Charges: Meter Size 5/8"-3/4 1-1/4" and 1-1/2" 211 or multiple meters of equivalent capacity 3" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity 4" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity 6" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity 811 or multiple meters of equivalent capacity 10" or multiple meters of equivalent capacity For all water used less than 3CCF (100 cubic Feet) (CCF)(1 CCF=748 gallons): Winter Rates $1.4388 Winter Rates $1.4647 Volume Charge: For all water used greater than 3CCF $1.4388 $1.4647 For all water used less than 3CCF (100 cubic Feet) (CCF)(1 CCF=748 gallons): Summer Rates $1.4388 Summer Rates $1.4647 Volume Charge: For all water used greater than 3CCF $1.7985 $1.8310 Conditions of Contract: The customer shall pay the total of the customer charge plus the volume charge. The volume charge is based on all metered water for the biling period. Consumption is expressed in hundred cubic foot units or thousand gallon units as determined by the meter installed by the Company. The customer charge wil be prorated whenever the customer has not been a customer for the entire billng period. Summer Period: The summer rate wil apply to water consumed between May 1 and September 30. Meter readings straddling these dates wil be prorated. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2013 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 6 OF 10 Sheet NO.5 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.1 B FLAT RATE SERVICE Availabilty: To non-metered residential customers pursuant to Residential or Multi-Family Housing Non-Contiguous Water Systems Agreement Paragraph 11 (a) addressing flat rate systems. Customer Charges: Based on United Water Idaho residential consumption for the year ending June 1998 of 208.75 ccf, the average residential bil, assuming a %" meter and 65% / 35% summer/winter split, is $468.90 ,1$479.34. Biled bi-monthly, equals $78.15'1 $79.89. Bi-Monthly Charge:7&$79.89 Conditions of Contract: The monthly charge wil be prorated whenever the customer has not been a customer for the entire billing period. The Company or the customer may convert to metered service pursuant to Subparagraphs (b) or (c) of Paragraph 11 as follows: (b) If Company should determine that a flat rate customer is using water in excess of the average residential customer, the Company wil provide a meter setting and meter. Customer wil then pay Company's metered tariff rates as approved by the IPUC, which rates may be amended from time to time. (c) If a customer prefers to pay Company's approved metered tariff rates, the customer shall pay the installation and material costs associated with the installation of a meter setting. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1 i 2013 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 7 OF 10 Sheet No.8 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.2 PUBLIC HYDRANTS AND STREET SPRINKLING Availability: To the City of Boise and Ada County Highway District. Rates: Street Sprinkling Service Flat Charge $268.78lMonth $277.90/Month Miscellaneous: Bils wil be rendered monthly, bi-monthly, or at other intervals upon mutual agreement of the Company and the customer. Hydrants and service pipes from the fitting on the Company main to the hydrants are to be installed and maintained by and at the expense of the City of Boise or Ada County Highway District. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2013 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt; Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 8 OF 10 Sheet NO.9 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.3 PRIVATE FIRE SPRINKLER AND SERVICE Availability: To all customers who have sprinkler systems and/or inside hose connections for fire fighting purposes. Rate: For service through a separate line for fire fighting purposes. For 3" service or smaller, per month For 4" service per month For 6" service per month For 8" service per month For 10" service per month For 12" service per month $17.74 $26.89 $66.79 $109.74 $171.14 $256.33 $18.34 $27.80 $69.05 $113.46 $176.94 $265.03 Miscellaneous: Provided that if the installation of a private fire service shall require an extension of the existing mains of the company, the cost of such extension shall be borne by the customer. All private fire services shall be equipped with sealed gate valves or thermal automatic openings. Meters may be placed on fire services by the utilty at any time; however, metered rates wil not apply unless improper use of water is disclosed, and if such be the case, usage wil be biled to the consumer under Rate Schedule NO.1. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2013 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 9 OF 10 Sheet No. 10 Replacing all Previous Sheets UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. SCHEDULE NO.4 PRIVATE FIRE HYDRANT SERVICE Availability: To all customers having private fire hydrant installations. Rate: For fire hydrants installed and maintained by the customer at customer's expense: Each fire hydrant, per month $10.75 $11.12/Month Miscellaneous: Service pipe from the fitting on the company water main to the fire hydrant is to be installed and maintained by the customer. UNITED Issued Per IPUC Order No. Effective - February 1, 2013 Issued by UNITED WATER IDAHO INC. Gregory P. Wyatt, Vice President 8248 West Victory Road, Boise, ID STIPULATION EXHIBIT A PAGE 10 OF 10